Review Form

Submission ID: Paper 872

Submission Title: Authentication System for Smart Homes Based on ARM7TDMI-S and IRIS-Fingerprint
Recognition Technologies


SUBMISSION TITLE TO JOURANL TOPIC
Low
Moderate
High

TOPIC SIGNIFICANCE
Frontier
Hot
Fair
Not much


ORIGINALITY
Poor
Fair
High
Very high

NOVELTY
Poor
Fair
High
Very high

ACADEMIC VALUE
Poor
Fair
Good
Very Good


APPLICATION VALUE
Poor
Fair
Good
Very Good



PRESENTATION AND ENGLISH
Poor
Fair
Good
Very Good
Outstanding

REFERENCE TO RELATED LITERATURES
Poor
Fair
Good
Very Good
Outstanding

FIGURES AND TABLES
Poor
Fair
Good
Very Good
Outstanding


OVERALL VALUE
Poor
Fair
Good
Very Good
Outstanding




RECOMMENDATION
Reject: Content inappropriate to the journal or has little merit
Probable Reject: Basic flaws in content or presentation or very poorly written
Marginal Tend to Reject: Not as badly flawed; major effort necessary to make acceptable but content
well-covered in literature already
Marginal Tend to Accept: Content has merit, but accuracy, clarity, completeness, and/or writing should
and could be improved in time
Clear Accept: Content, presentation, and writing meet professional norms; improvements may be
advisable but acceptable as is
Must Accept: Candidate for outstanding submission. Suggested improvements still appropriate






DETAILED SUGGESTIONS ON HOW TO IMPROVE THE PAPER
For the benefit of the reader and publication, however, a number of points need clarifying and certain
statements require further justification. There are given below. (1) Equations should be numbered. (2) It just
needs using the abbreviation Fig. when a figure is cited. (3) The section of implementation should be
discussed in more details and more experimental results should be given. (4) Table 1is not well edited, small
font may be used in this table. (5) Some subheads are not well edited and aligned. (6)There is little content in
section6, which may be combined into section5.