You are on page 1of 8

Darrell Webb

UWRT 1103
Professor Campbell
3/31/15
Early Marriage: For Better or For Worse?
In the hierarchy of needs a desire for love, or belonging, falls in the third tier; right below
physiological needs in the first tier such as eating, sleeping, and breathing as well as safety needs
in the second tier such as shelter and heath (McLeod "Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs"). With a
need for love being so close to immediate priority in the hierarchy of needs it is strange to
witness American culture shift further and further away from settling down at a young age but
still people continue to get married at an early age. Now, it is more socially acceptable to have
sort of a trial phase where someone will hook up with, or date, any number of people before they
finally settle down with the right person. The dating relationships include sex, cohabitation, and
the converging of financial resources that boil right down to being on the cusp of marriage but
without the vows. Which I can understand, if a couple is already doing all of the things
traditional married couples do what is the point of getting married so soon? I can also see and
agree with the counter argument of not prolonging marriage because of the behaviors already
established. Early marriage which is defined by a study conducted and published in the
National Library of Medicine as anyone that marries under the age of 24 as opposed to a later
one, has its ups as well as its downsides as does a later marriage (Uecker & Stokes). An early
marriage allows couples to grow together as adults but also proves to be difficult because the
younger population tends to value their own wants and needs over the wants and needs of others.
The question posed is whether early marriage is still a healthy choice in the midst of this cultural
shift or is a later marriage actually the better choice?

In order to figure out whether early marriage was still a viable choice I explored the
demographics of people who marry early. With each ethnicity comes a separate culture of norms
that shapes the views of marriage. Ethnicity is also a factor for what time a person will get
married. Hispanics are at the top of the list when it comes to early marriage followed closely by
Whites. Asians are the third most likely to get married early but their likelyhood is distant from
Whites. Behind Whites on this list are Black people (Uecker and Stokes). Black people are the
least likely to get married early. Black men are over masculinized to the point where even Black
children are viewed as adults long before they are ready and able to be one. To be specific about
hypermasculinity I want to mention Tamir Rice, the 12 year old boy who was shot for playing
with a toy gun at a park. The police officer relayed to the dispatch that the child looked as if he
was 20 years old. ("Hypermasculinity" & Phillip). Within this hypermasculinity are their views
on marriage Black men are generally taught by their fathers and peers to not settle down until
later in life, if at all. Having a long list of women that youve slept with is something to be proud
of. Its like the drawing your kid brings home from daycare that you know really isnt that great
but you post it on the fridge anyway and tell them youre proud of it. Early marriage as a black
man is an oddity but it still happens. A young couple that has the capacity or the desire to settle
down early and experience life together can have a healthy marriage.
More factors considered in marital timing are value of religion, religious affiliation, and
educational attainment. There is no visible way to determine whether religion plays a role in
someones marital timing. Church attendance has shown no relevance in the marital timing on its
own but combined with self-reported religious values was thought to have a correlation in young
couples marital timing. The study also hypothesizes that the pledges of abstinence for religion
universally push younger couples to marriage much sooner (Uecker and Stokes). There are a

number of people who go to church but value all of the ideals spread by the church but the
church is a good place to find the foundations of a moral compass. That being said, thats where I
believe the influence of self-reported religion comes in considering my experience in a religious
community. It is determined by how much one person lets their spirituality affect their decision
making in relationships. The religious aspect also offers more compatibility within couples. Their
ideology influences friendships made, financial decisions, child care, and much more. Two
people that share the same ideals will have a much easier time making decisions and further
developing their marriage. Although, there are couples who do not share similar ideologies and
their path to an early marriage will be dependent upon both being accepting of each others
spirituality or lack thereof. Ultimately, the studies done by Uecker and Stokes show no large
variation in numbers for young couples marital timing due to religious values.
Instead, religious affiliation is what contained large numbers of variation. 42% of
Protestant women married under the age of 23. Jewish women and Black Protestant women were
the least likely to marry before 23: fewer than 1% of Jewish women and only 11% of Black
Protestant women. Conservative Protestants and Mormons were both the most likely to marry
before 23. Catholics, Black Protestants, and Jewish men all fell on the bottom of the spectrum for
early marriage (Uecker and Stokes). While experiencing both Black Protestantism and a general
Protestantism church I understand the numbers. In the Black churches it is common to hear
people teach boys and young men that they should enjoy their young age. Frequently I have
heard the phrase Dont do anything now that you cant make right with God later. That phrase
ultimately gives young men the mindset that they can do whatever they want and if they can
sleep at night with the decision they made then let that decision stand. While on the other hand,
the women are told to find themselves a nice man at about the same time the young men are

being taught to wait until later in life to marry. In White Protestant churches I see both women
being encouraged to marry early and men being encouraged to wait until after college if they end
up going. I have seen that White Protestant church communities are stricter about abstinence and
cohabitation before marriage while its not as big of a deal in Black Protestant churches.
Religious affiliation is a big factor in marital timing because the principles shape the views of
who it is being fed to.
Both men and women who have strong interests in attending college have shown, in the
study, low numbers in early marriage. This is understandable because a lot of money is tied up in
paying for college and having to pay for college as well as a wedding is too much of a stress for
some families. Couples that are on the track to getting married typically wait until right after they
have graduated college which is normally around ages 23 & 24. Both women and men with high
test scores and high goals for educational attainment have been shown to delay marriage. Men
who came from higher levels of income and educational goals were shown to be unlikely to
marry around the age of 19 but were more likely to marry around the age of 23, or right after
college (Uecker & Stokes).In an article written by Justin Deeter, A Case For Early Marriage:
Why Its A Good Idea To Get Married Young, he advocates for an early marriage but also
mentions how American society is moving away from this practice. He promotes it as a way for
young adults to learn how to grow up and handle responsibilities better. His belief is that
Marriage pushes young men out of the nest to spread their wings and fly under the windy
pressures of life. Religion is a major influence in marital timing and can also produce a stable
household. Even individuals who dont share similar ideologies can compromise on their ideals.
Another article entitled 9 Things Nobody Told Me About Getting Married Young, by
Kimanzi Constable, talks about early marriage and some of the things he and his wife had to

learn to overcome together. The first being arguments. He was shocked at some of the trivial
things they fought about when times were hard but they learned that effective and authentic
communication was key. Also,people that you are not married to do not stop being attractive
after marriage. Although, taking too much notice of these other people can hurt a marriage. For a
while everything is sunshine and rainbows but once that phase of the marriage is over both
parties will recognize that they need a bit of space. Combining lives is difficult. Marrying young
means that both parties are still getting to know themselves while committing to another person.
They either grow together or apart. Some single friends will bid their farewells. Interests stop
lining up and they will feel the need to move on. Make sure the relationship is about more than
just sex. In-laws will try to get deeply involved in your life. Pick and choose what you share with
them. Finally, falling in love will be an active, every day decision. Its choosing to stick with
your partner through the best and the worst. A wise counselor taught us that love isnt a feeling.
Its a decision. There will be days when you think youre falling out of love, there will be days
when you think about calling it quits. Love is a decision to stop listening to your emotions, and
choose to stay together through the tough times, (Constable). Constable gives his personal
truths about marriage, it is difficult to handle when young but it is possible if the couple will
work to maintain it.
The cultural shift that is happening is causing people to focus more on self-interests.
Individuals are less likely to be influenced by family (Uecker and Stokes). People used to get
married based on social or economic status. Wealthy families would marry into other wealthy
families to combine resources and to climb the social ladder. Either the unwed children were
restricted to certain families to marry into or their suitors were already chosen for them. Today,
family and demographics still influence marriage but nowhere near as much as it used to. The

focus now is more on the individuals wants and needs. Partners are found based on
compatibility as compared to financial or social opportunity. Couples whos parental figures have
high educational attainment, such as a Bachelors Degree or higher, typically delay marriage
because their parents can help to sustain them, financially, for a longer period of time. Couples
whos families originated in the South or other rural areas typically had a much higher rate for
early marriage than those originating in metropolitan areas. More than 30% of all women in the
South married before their 23rd birthday and 37% of women from rural areas married before that
time as well (Uecker & Stokes).
In the middle of this cultural shift of delaying marriage until the later 20s people are still
getting married in and right out of college. Religious affiliation, spirituality, family background,
educational attainment, and the capacity to learn together are just some of the thing that influence
couples to marry early. The studies and articles referenced did not give a finite answer as to
whether early marriage was a viable option but rather they presented it as a choice. If a person
has the capacity to commit to another and make it work then an early marriage is a viable option
for them. If not, it may be better for them to wait until their late 20s, possibly even longer than
that. For better or for worse is up to the individual who is considering marriage. To answer the
question originally posed, whether or not early marriage is still a healthy and viable option, I
believe it is. It will require a combination of cooperation, preparation, and support in order to
have the marriage succeed in the long run but I believe, ultimately, that it is a viable option. I
believe it is better to experience life with someone by my side than to figure it out all on my
own. If love is to live to its potential, it should continue to sprout new stories and new journeys,
sprinkling our lives with creativity and enjoyment rather than boredom, (Samudre "5 Reasons
Why I Got Engaged Before 23").

Constable, Kimanzi. "9 Things Nobody Told Me About Getting Married Young."
Contributors, Wikipedia. "Hypermasculinity." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 24 Mar. 2015.
Web. 26 Apr. 2015.
MindBodyGreen. MindBodyGreen, LLC, 28 Sept. 2014. Web. 31 Mar. 2015.
Deeter, Justin. "A Case for Early Marriage: Why It's a Good Idea to Get Married Young."
Justindeetercom. 7 May 2013. Web. 31 Mar. 2015.
McLeod, Saul. "Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs." Simply Psychology. Saul McLeod, 17 Sept.
2007. Web. 26 Apr. 2015.
Phillip, Abby. "Cleveland Cop Said He had No Choice but to Shoot 12-year-old Tamir Rice,
Father Says." Washington Post. The Washington Post, 2 Dec. 2014. Web. 26 Apr. 2015.
Samudre, Neal. "5 Reasons Why I Got Engaged Before 23." The Huffington Post.
TheHuffingtonPost.com, 4 Feb. 2014. Web. 26 Apr. 2015.
Uecker, Jeremy, and Charles Stokes. "Early Marriage in the United States." Journal of Marriage
and the Family. U.S. National Library of Medicine, 1 Nov. 2008. Web. 31 Mar. 2015.

You might also like