Professional Documents
Culture Documents
/f /3
^1 I
2007
witii
IVIicrosoft
funding from
Corporation
littp://www.arcliive.org/details/cliristiansocialrOOIauxuoft
Christian Social
Reform
ELECTION AS BISHOP.
(
(Hjjrtjsttan S^nrtal
Program outlined by
its
Pioneer
Preface by
HIS
U-f^uTLl
pbiladelpbia
Hbe
SJolpbln iprees
1912
1R.
&
Z. TIDlagbbourne, Xt&.
-*
<
f H-
9m|tnmatur
Edmond
F.
Prendergast
Archbishop
May,
1912.
Copyright.
1912
of Philadelphia
CONTENTS
PAGE
Preface
Bibliography
Introduction
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
VI.
VII.
iii
OF Poverty, 1850
VIII.
70
76
FACE
179
stag, 1868-1871
185
XV.
181
194
203
216
226
233
still
241
PREFACE.
whole
Baron Von
THEenergetic
and intrepid Bishop
life
of
modern
apostle
who wrought
He was
action.
It is
Ketteler,
of Mainz,
the
is
the record of a
a Christian bishop
who
believed
of action.
He
realized, as no other
new order
man
only
of conditions the
act,
standing firm.
He was a living proof of what
one resolute mind can accomplish in the face of
enormous
difficulties.
pagan system
obstacles.
(iii)
PREFACE
iv
He was
social
upon
principles
Thomas was
his
Catholic
He
based
all his
doctrine.
St.
practical
Germany
he
death.
We
Leo found
in
Von
Pius X has placed a loving tribute upon his honored tomb. What greater
glory could he have than this? Germany and the
whole world may well preserve in eternal memory
and grateful recognition the words and works of
one of the very greatest men of our age, Bishop
lofty consideration.
Von
And
Ketteler.
REFORM MOVEMENT*
Bibliography.
A.
KETTELER
Soziale Predigten.
Ed. Raich.
Arbeiterfrage und
Christ entum.
Mainz, 1878
Fourth edition,
with an Introduction by Windthorst.
Mainz,
1890.
(French Transl. Liege, 1869.)
Die Katholiken im deutschen Reiche. Fifth ediMainz, 1873.
tion.
Mainz, 1869.
1869.
(Italian
die
Fuldaer
Transl.
Venice,
fiir
Two
Pastoral Letters,
1876-77.
B.
Mainz, 1862.
und Kirche.
Seventh edition.
BISHOP KETTELER.
Kann
gldubiger
ein
Fifth edition.
Freiherr
v.
Ketteler.
Mainz, 1904.
Hirtenbriefe.
C.
W. E.
WORKS ON KETTELER
Pfiilf,
Eine
Bischof von Ketteler.
3 volumes. Mainz:
Otto, S.J.
geschichtliche Darstellung.
Kirchheim.
1899.
Goyau, Georges. Ketteler, W. E. in La Pensee
Paris, 1908.
Chretienne series.
Also article on
Ketteler in Catholic Encyclopedia.
De Girard. Ketteler et la Question Ouvri^re.
Avec une introduction sur le mouvement social
Berne, 1896.
catholique.
Decurtins,
CEuvres
Gaspar.
Ketteler.
Choisies
de Mgr.
Basle, 1892.
Kannengieser.
Ketteler et
en Allemagne.
Liesen, Bernard.
I'
Organisation sociale
Paris, 1894.
Frankf. 1888.
Greiffenrath, Dr.
zialreform.
Ketteler
und
Frankfort, 1893.
Wenzel, Johannes.
Berlin, 1893.
Mumbauer, Johannes.
Ketteler's Schriften.
Kemp ten,
1911.
INTRODUCTION.
OLD
1184
far
beyond
"
thousand " knights of labor
came to do homage, not to earthly liege, but to
Christ the King, and to honor th^. memory of the
its
borders
fifty -two
Emmanuel von
Ketteler.
The
Wilhelm
Fifty-eighth Katho-
workingmen's
parade was the prelude, was Catholic Germany's
tribute to one of her greatest sons, a mighty echo of
the popularity which he enjoyed during his lifetime.
The record of what Bishop von Ketteler did for
his own diocese and for the Church at large, the
great debt of gratitude Germany owes to him as the
renewer of religious life, as the pioneer of the Catholic social reform movement and its scientific exponent, as the champion of the religious and politilikentag,
of
which
this
splendid
is
written in indelible
letters
BISHOP KETTELER.
bless
A church consecrated
Sacred Heart was erected in the workingmen's colony of Mainz the shrine of Our Lady of
Sorrows in Dieburg, where Ketteler preached so
often and prayed so much, was completely renovated; and a Ketteler Society was founded to raise
funds for the erection of a free sanatorium for poor
from
to the
children in
It is the
Bad Nauheim.
purpose of the following sketch to treat
Ketteler, p. xxxi.
SOCIAL REFORM.
my
He was
great predecessor!"^
He knew
must begin
The
answer
at
home.
life-story of a
man
who have
poor
man and
stood by the
by Bebel and Liebknecht at the members of the German Reichstag, 31 May, 1881, during the debate on
the Accident Insurance Bill " When did you begin
When did you
to take notice of the workingman?
begin to study the Social Question? Not until the
Socialists reminded you of your duty."
:
XIII
Rerum Novarum,
of 15
May, 1891.
No
less
To
'
M. Gasp. Decurtins.
BISHOP KETTELER,
view on the social question and the clearest presentation of the defects and the one-sidedness of
the
last
century,
Decurtins,
Kannengieser,
CHAPTER
I.
8i
i - i
844.
1,
who ascended
Born at Miinster, on Christmas Day, 181 1, Wilhelm Emmanuel ^ inherited more than a baron's
title and rank
ardent love of the Catholic Church,
noble independence of mind, deep manly piety
traits for which his ancestors were ever distinguished
these were the better portion of his
:
heritage.
Carlyle speaks somewhere of the " ail-but omnipotence of early culture and nurture
".
The
influ-
life,
who was filled with inexhaustible love and solicitude for the Christian training of her children, surrounded by respectful and respected domestics
whose years of service were as a rule measured by
^
day of
his birth.
in
BISHOP KETTELER.
life,
tenant,
the industrious
his
own
und
SOCIAL REFORM.
But it must be remembered that in those days student duels with rapiers or broadswords were fought
by Catholic students without the least scruple. The
ecclesiastical prohibitions were either not known
or mildly interpreted, and very few indeed saw in
such " little affairs of honor," which seldom took a
Bonn
had seen for many years. In later years these men
became outspoken opponents of dueling both in the
army and in the universities.
BISHOP KETTELER.
lO
He who
of duty.
and
its
has learned to
know
Christianity
which Christ
calls
who has
His peace,
in the
will pluck
which
life
may
hurl him.
He who
happen
to
his life.
SOCIAL REFORM.
mixed
marriages to Protestantism.
This so-called Cologne Event {Kolner Ereignis)
made a deep impression on Ketteler. He had not
buried his chivalry and his love of Holy Church in
law books nor bartered his independence of mind
for Government favor.
When his kinsman Ferdinand von Galen was dismissed from his diplomatic
post in Brussels for declining to
make
com-
official
munication of the false charges against the imprisoned Archbishop to the Belgian Court, he
handed in his resignation, having become convinced
that he could not serve a Government that de-
manded
conscience.^
"
One
drew
Catholic
8
leaders,
Briefe, p. 8.
Gorres,
Windischmann,
and
BISHOP KETTELER.
12
vowing
and
selbst aufgezeichnet
Mainz, 1877.
CHAPTER
Curate and Pastor.
WHEN
II.
1844- 1849.
was
Ketteler
genial duties as
The following
to let siip
even one.
BISHOP KETTELER.
14
Home
are a lasting
in
monument
same time
them
stories,
couraging them.
1
Briefe, p. 227.
^Vmi,
I,
p.
128.
SOCIAL REFORM.
15
piece of bread.
said
"
'
BISHOP KETTELER.
its
second
One
realized in 1846,
some
whole
life
pastor of
was
Hop-
sten,
parish
Throughout
his
shepherd.
The baptismal
side," Ketteler
SOCIAL REFORM.
much
of his
teler spent
own and
17
of his relatives'
money KetWagonloads
the
and no one
bills.
last
und
Rome,
in 1877.
BISHOP KETTELER,
masonry
is
dependent for
its
membership on dock-
We
joy-
is
of as
much moment
to us as
Ketteler,
Kann
CHAPTER
III.
THE
social
and
1848.
political tempest,
to
of the
his Catholic
and
tal-
cussed.
Briefe,
p.
157.
BISHOP KETTELER.
20
when, by accident, as it were, his name was suddenly heralded throughout the length and breadth
On the
of Germany and far beyond its confines.
eighteenth of September the streets of Frankfort
were the scene of bloody encounters between the
and the Government troops. Totwo of the ablest and most aggressive of the conservative deputies, Fiirst Lichnowski
and General von Auerswald, as they were riding
out of the city in the direction of Bockenheim,
where the Regent of the Empire resided, were fol-j
lowed by a band of rioters. As the two deputies
were unarmed they took refuge in a nearby wood,
but were discovered by their pursuers, set upon,
and literally torn and slashed to pieces. Auerswald
died on the spot, but Lichnowski succumbed to his
wounds during the night, in the Holy Ghost Hospirevolutionaries
ward
nightfall
tal.
When
morning
Ketteler
at his usual
came
to
The
lasting.
impression
"
it
saw these
a sermon
in its report
SOCIAL REFORM.
21
" It
is to be printed and
buted broadcast throughout the country."
of the obsequies.
distri-
was
August Reichwas powerful;
the very marrow," he told his
It
penetrated to
brother Peter.^
Beside the open graves, facing the
speaker and his jaws working with ill-suppressed
rage, stood Robert Blum, the radical deputy and
demagogue who was court-martialed and shot a
few weeks
later in
at the
head
The
oration,
and
in Leipsic
" It
few extracts
will
was not
show that
Who
those
is
who have
not they.
Is
it
It is the
indeed
No,
it
August Reichensperger,
I, p.
264.
BISHOP KETTELER.
22
people
who
set
On
may
fall
them.
and
whose soul would not joyfully join in the cry? and I
see men ever more and more divided against themselves,
all sides I
sister,
among men, an
and before me
see
men murdered
word;
me
with horror.
hear
fills
SOCIAL REFORM.
23
its
sublime ideas
depths to-day; in
my
off as their
own
inven-
He
lying,
Through
and death.
out.
May we
take
it
to heart!
was on the same fateful eighteenth of Septemwhose evening hours, as Pfiilf says, were polluted by the massacre of Auerswald and LichIt
ber,
first
parliamen-
BISHOP KETTELER.
24
liberty
cracy
may demand
citizen,
lutism."
'
74.
CHAPTER
At the
IV.
TWOmanweeks
1848.
it
BISHOP KETTELER.
26
goods of humanity
its truth.
social
The most
conditions.
which no
legislation,
is
me
difficult
question,
urgency of
The
diffi-
this question
fills
SOCIAL REFORM.
2^
Works
When men
tall,
the
its
Catholicism
...
still
lives
on
in the freshness
own
hearts.
Report, p. 51.
still
onfinished
when
these
BISHOP KETTELER.
28
When
of
him
as of
Mainz he became a
draw the attention of
the Catholic world to the supreme importance of the
social question and to the only means of solving it.
Since this memorable fourth of October the social
question has formed one of the principal topics of
discussion at the Catholic Congresses, which have
become the rallying-point of all the Catholic socioIf Ketteler had done
logical work of Germany.
nothing else, this fact would suffice to render his
of his
fame
prophet.
as
an orator;
He was
the
in
first to
name immortal.
splendid banquet brought the first Katholikentag to a close. The Pope, the German nation, the
German hierarchy were toasted amid loud acclama-
tion.
guests to drink to the health of the honest tradesof Germany; a " democrat " from Treves arose
and pleaded for a remembrance of the people,
" the people who are ready to die for liberty and
for the Holy Faith " last of all, Ketteler arose and
proposed three cheers for ^the poor. He reminded
the banqueters of the many poor men and women of
" God's
the city debarred from joys like theirs.
Providence doles out to the one more, to the other
men
SOCIAL REFORM.
in response to this
29
unexpected
toast,
CHAPTER
The
V.
WHEN
November,
1848.
SOCIAL REFORM.
To my
31
taverns, quite
At
difficulties.^
possess property
* Official
XXIII,
p. 336.
BISHOP KETTELER.
32
political questions,
life,
the foregrormd
them from
new form
of
propose to
SOCIAL REFORM.
33
faith, traced for
itself, it
seeks
inquiry.
St.
Thomas
lays
and consequently
down
all
This proposition
dogma
that
God drew
is
a neces-
forth all
God
'
ship,
God
God
man
none.
St.
Thomas
re-
right of using
purpose of
all
earthly things
is
and
words addressed by God to the first of mankind
after creation " Behold, I have given you every herb-
'
BISHOP KETTELER.
34
esirth,
To God
own
and
belongs,
therefore
have in
conclude
with
St.
man
Two
In the
first
place,
common with
man
private
the conception
looks
on
of property pertains to
God
gard to
by God.
viz. that
alone, that
man's right is
boimd, in re-
is
there
who
living faith in
is
God.
is
It is
possible only
its
ruin,
and
where
men
although
from God, they set up sensual pleasures and the enjoyment of life as the end of their existence, and worldly
*
Gen.
29.
SOCIAL REFORM.
35
The
theory which
man
God
two ways.
Men
is
in this
from them.
BISHOP KETTELER.
36
Thomas
Now,
organization of labor
is
SOCIAL REFORM.
termining as
the
members
37
it
of the family
Commandment
of
God
enjoyment of the
the administration of
down
very
Thou shalt
Communism
"
principle.
of our day.
fruits derived
earthly goods,
different
St.
irrec-
But
from
Thomas
lays
Man, according
to
common
need.
5 I
Summa
&
2.
BISHOP KETTELER.
38
of ownership,
We
have now
ideas of St.
justified
him
lies,
in order to con-
Thomas on
and we felt
them the doctrine of the
recognizing in
in
all,
ir-
The
ownership
is
no injustice
in using for the gratification of the most insatiable
avarice and the most extravagant sensuality what God
intended to be food and clothing for all men; because
it kills the noblest sentiments in the human heart and
it
sees
Scorn and derision will not dismust destroy the truth that is in it, in
may become all lie again. As long as it
pose of
order that
We
it.
it
' St.
In his
Basil, it seems, is the author of this phrase.
Constitutiones Monasticae, C. 34, I, he says in regard to private
property in a monastery : K%onii yap fj l6L&C,ovaa KT^aig, " personal property is theft."
Proudhon very likely took it from Jean
Pierre Brissot who wrote in 1780: "La propriete exclusive est
nn vol dans sa nature." (Pfeiffer in Caritas, Vol. 16, no. 12,
P-
347-)
SOCIAL REFORM.
contains even a particle of truth,
the whole order of the world.
it
39
As deep
Out of
munism was
nature,
for,
the
Com-
begotten..
bring upon mankind the prof oundest misery, destroy industry, order, and peace on earth, turn the hands of all
against all and thus sweep away the very conditions of
human
existence.*
man
Man
is
With
his
man
This
is
man
acts hvimanly
and
God
his
1896, p. 19.
BISHOP KETTELER.
40
acts
God on
eeu-th
it
if
self -determining
as a free,
liberty of
away even
if
agent.
man and He
God
does not
it
to his
own undoing.
Let us apply these principles
right of property.
God
from
it.
God
to
man might
it
derive sustenance
He
us,
men
for the welfare of their fellow-men, the most beautiful fountain of the noblest feelings of mankind would
be dried up.
For assuredly a life devoted to the works
is a divine life.
Consider the life of a Sister of Charity and tell me
whether there are not more courage, more beauty, and
love, in such a life than perhaps in the life of a whole
city.
SOCIAL REFORM.
41
faith
In the second sermon Ketteler continues the development of the Christian theory of private property and shows in the first place that it is a postulate
of right reason.
God
has
We
by the exercise
that
He
all
As both
these
we apply
If
which
ff.
BISHOP KETTELER.
42
The preacher
The two
find in the
to share
ask you,
how
is
it
which so
How
and wide?
is it
one hand we see rich men, in the face of the most elementary laws of nature and without a qualm of conscience, wasting their substance riotously, while the poor
are starving and children degenerate?
sible
for us
to
relish
superfluities
How
is
it
pos-
tion
men
hand, how is
to
become
inhuman?
How
is
it
pos-
sible for
so
SOCIAL REFORM.
and look to it for salvation, though
it would drag all humanity down to
To
is
43
it is
its
so evident that
ruin?
it is
con-
him to
men and
and
Eph.
i: lO.
have
set forth.
BISHOP KETTELER.
44
and
its
conse-
As
diffusion of so-called
ment, so also
it
would
way
nature on the
suffice to
from the
general culture.
its
develop-
human
and forth-
own
But
If
it
were
true,
it
would
deprived
of
general culture,
than
ures
statistical
upon
when
tables?
treasures
is
the
who heaps
and
sacrifices
treas-
traverses the
knows
SOCIAL REFORM.
^5
on
his
that
fills
is
God,
And
poor
man
stretches
command
".
Guided by their sinful passions, men are
no longer able to apprehend even the simplest natural
truths that run counter to these passions. Apostasy from
Christianity is the cause of our wretched state if we shut
not steal
our eyes to this truth we are undone. Just as the individual can make true progress only if he recognizes that
he cannot fulfil the high purpose of his existence unless
aided from without, so the world will not raise itself
BISHOP KETTELER.
46
out of
its
it is convinced that,
cannot solve the great problems
solve at any cost or relapse into
which
it
must
it
barbarism.*'
Social
says]
made by
onward
march of pauperism, and I admit I have found none that
would answer the purpose. As long as the authors do
not venture beyond the commonplaces in which they
clothe their proposals, one would almost believe them to
ing the proposals
i Cf.
Goyau, Ketteler,
p.
131.
SOCIAL REFORM.
more or
less value,
47
Whether we shall ever put this prowe cannot foresee, but one thing is cerwould not make the poor rich, but the whole
bution of property.
posal to the test
tain, that it
In fact, whoever looks at things with unclouded vision will frankly recognize that all the wisdom of the world is powerless and silent in the presence
world poor.
tianity.
of
its
power
is
manifested.
An
Jesus, related
Him:
Master, speak to
my brother
He said
hath appointed
But
to
Me
laid
up
for
many
rest, eat,
drink,
make
good cheer. But God said to him Thou fool, this night
do they require thy soul of thee and whose shall those
things be which thou hast provided?
So is he that layeth up treasures for himself, and is not rich toward
God." "
You see, my brethren, what answer Christ gives to
those who, like the man in the Gospel, wish to become
:
**
Lake
12: 13-21.
BISHOP KETTELER.
48)
rich
to better their
social condition
He
also in
is
tianity
which
is
ruption of heart,
terial evils
the
is
human
heart.
Not
Ma-
would be easy
its
were
are,
its
its efforts
shall
ishness.
treas-
ures
^^
" The Communists disdain to hide their views and aims.
They openly declare that their ends cannot be attained except by
a world to gain
!"
Kommun.
Manx}., p. 32.
SOCIAL REFORM.
49
Name's
shall receive
sake,
wounds of the
man
made
soul
^^
To
My
in the lives of so
And
again
we
many
of her saints.
and with thy whole soul, and with thy whole mind. This
is the greatest and the first commandment.
And the
second
is
like to this:
Thou
BISHOP KETTELER.
50
And
thyself." ^*
He
if
brings us to the
O my
day and
chantment; let
single
us, rich
But what
Saviour:
shall
"Amen
My
it
to
least brethren,
in them.
\
how
turned
He knew
it, and
what violent efforts would be needed to eradicate them.
Hence He confronts those who do not wish to be influenced by higher motives with the day of judgment and
eternal pimishment.
He rehearses for them a scene that
will be enacted in that awful hour when He shall come
1* Matth. 22 37-39.
i Matth. 25:40.
:
'^
Matth.
10
40,
4a.
SOCIAL REFORM.
His majesty and glory
51
from
them that shall be on His
" Depart from Me, you accursed, into everleft-hand
lasting fire, which was prepared for the devil and his angels.
For I was hungry and you gave Me not to eat ; I
was thirsty and you gave Me not to drink I was a
stranger and you took Me not in
naked and you covered Me not; sick and in prison, and you did not visit
Me. Then they shall answer Him, saying: Lord, when
did we see Thee hungry or thirsty, or a stranger, or
naked, or sick, or in prison, and did not minister to Thee?
in all
when He
the goats,
shall say to
Then He
may
my
am
tongue,
2^ Matth. 25:41-46.
Luke 16:19-^6.
BISHOP KETTELER.
52
Such
is
and
He
avarice.
him Dives
He
takes
in the
him
to
Judgment and shouts the words into his ears " Depart from Me, you accursed one, into everlasting fire "
He takes him to the rich man, who, when he has amassed
many treasures and is about to enjoy them, hears the
the
words
of thee
"
Thou
".
fool, this
He shows him
He
He
teaches
holds up to him
him
to love
men owe
to
man and
his
man He
;
transfers
Him,
It is
own
the
hearts.
Instead of
SOCIAL REFORM.
53
Maxims and
To
this
end we must
extend our search for poverty and the poor into their
most hidden recesses, discover the soiirces of their misery,
share their pains and their tears; no degradation, no
squalor must
make us
we must bear
be misBorne
up by charity, we must renew our attacks tmtil we have
broken the thick ice-crust under which the heart of the
poor is often buried and flood it with love.
Just as God does not treat the sinner and we are all
sinners
only according to His justice, but overcomes his
indifference by the superabundance of His love, so we,
imitating God, must vanquish our fellow-men by exThis is, according to my conviction and
cess of charity.
experience, the only way to change the heart of the great
masses of the poor.*'
recoil;
to
ff.
BISHOP KETTELER.
54
people Jesus
",
Christ,
who
practised
what
He
all
soul
and one
life for
into
Ketteler
dew
man
to
waken
it
to
divine life and divine love, such a cold-blooded, diabolical doctrine has not
man.^*
^* Predigten, II, p.
i63.
SOCIAL REFORM.
55
And how beautifully he speaks of the soul's testimony of its own immortality in the sermon on
" Man's Destiny "
:
is
an
illusion,
how
dumb
cattle
all
the
is
dream
below
I
hear
it
is
to disappear
and that
all
who are burdened with mental and bodily diswho are confined to the sick-room for years, or even
of those
eases,
we
give
^^ Predigten, II, p.
176.
BISHOP KETTELER.
56
man
amidst the most excruciating and uninterNo more palpable proof of the divine
mitting sufferings.
he
is
made
that she
is
From Mainz,
CHAPTER
VI.
WITH
restless
toral
1849- 1850.
was gradually changing. The old indifference in religious matters was giving place to earnest zeal in
the service of God. The last touches to this work of
renovation were given by the mission preached by
the well-known Jesuit Father, Henry Behrens, in
the spring of 1849.
Father Behrens had been engaged for many years in teaching and missionary
work in Switzerland when the storm of radical intolerance that swept over free Helvetia in 1847 set
him adrift. After conducting a band of fathers
and brothers
to the
re-
sidence in Miinster.
struck by his
BISHOP KETTELER.
58
first
rector of
from 1856
When
to i860.
as a zealous missionary
October, 1895.^
After Frankfort and Mainz it was vain for Kethe would be permitted to end his
days as a " Bauernpastor " in an out-of-the-way
Westphalian borough. When the Provostship of
St. Hedwig's in Berlin became vacant in 1849, this
important post was offered to Ketteler, who accepted it only after repeated insistence on the part
of the Prussian Government, the Prince- Bishop of
Breslau, and his own Ordinary.
In the middle of the last century the state of
teler to think that
"A
to church.
I,
p.
173.
and
all
are
filled
morning
SOCIAL REFORM.
59
fulfil
It
were sterling children of the Church, ready to profess their faith before the world and to make heroic
sacrifice, if need be, to help on a good work.
A
Catholic hospital, absolutely necessary as
it
was,
dream never
No one could remember when a nun
as a pious
be realized.
last appeared on the streets of Berlin.
To attempt to introduce them was regarded as presumptuous temerity.
But the nuns and the hospital did
to
had
come
after
Early
ladies
all.
in the
who
'forties
felt called to
eight
young Westphalian
the religious
life,
finding
I, p.
l86.
BISHOP KETTELER.
6o
money was
sent
When
arrived,
they had
build a
fire
with.
wood
to
them
Two
years
first
night.
by the
Berliners, but
to the
small tradesmen, the journeymen, day-laborers, and
*
Thaler
* Cf.
= 75
cents.
Mainz, 1848.
SOCIAL REFORM.
6l
tions lately
which affected
sum
.
received until
practice.
One
Briefe, p. 199,
Briefe, p. 228.
BISHOP KETTELER.
62
factor in
Mainz
".
The
Ketteler.
old Protestant
woman. ^
Hedwig's was of
sowed brought
" His forceful, impresforth fruit a hundredfold.
sive sermons
there's something peculiarly authem,'
Savigtiy, one of the future
thoritative about
were universally
leaders of the Centre, used to say
praised," wrote Prince Bishop Forster of Breslau
after Ketteler's death " so were also his inexhaustible love and solicitude for the poor of the parish.
One day he brought a pillow concealed in the folds
of his paletot to a poor family and found his
proteges doing full justice to a fried goose, which
they had bought with the money he had sent them
the day before.
To a friend, who had expressed
Ketteler's
incumbency
at St.
'
Wenzel, Ketteler
to
"
Of
u. die sob.
Frage, p. 50.
money
I
was
SOCIAL REFORM.
63
many of
The one on Almsgiving,
sermons.
Berlin
his
a beautiful com-
is
St.
Thomas on
this
subject.
People are only too often disposed to look on almsgiving as a good work indeed, but not as a strict obligation.
Such a conception
Christian soul.
Thomas and
strict
a fundamental error in a
almsgiving in general
obligation,
obligation
is
the
as
is
fulfilment
of
which
is
necessary
for
salvation.
number
Summa
of Scripture texts
to love
almsgiving."
If
sel
it is
but a
Summa
tkeol.,
5,
is
does
8; James 3:13.
BISHOP KETTELER.
64
The
demand
Ketteler answers
is
the assistance
an obligation
is
not in-
mean
that
the
distribution
of
is
the
superabundance
of
the
rich
gation of almsgiving
is,
It can be realized by an
appeal to conscience only, not by coercion.
He who
breaks a law binding in justice is a thief, or a defrauder,
or a robber; he
less
a sinner:
who
violates the
for the
Not
law of charity
precept of
the spirit of
charity
is
occupies
no
a
SOCIAL REFORM.
65
actions.
and
in this the
be thus on the
world
Day
is
altogether wrong.
of Judgment.
It will
not
This must be
when we
and
into detail
."
known
it
to us.
sufficed to help
But
such as
made
their
province
of
the
Church
wound upon
also,
thereby
inflicting
deep
the
BISHOP KETTELER.
66
The
As
is
a favorite topic
manner
of determining
an affair of each
one's conscience, but that we must beware of applying the standard of the world, which fails to see
of controversy.
it,
to the
is
superfluity
Riches
it
is
certain that,
Thomas
we
says,^
and no one
is
by
These
and our
station in life.^^
obligation of almsgiving.
minimum
in the
institutions.
its
spirit ani-
Without wishing to
universalize the vow of evangelical poverty, without pretending to make a commandment of what is
only a counsel, without attempting to force on the
generality of
10 II, II,
men an
q. 32, a. 5,
^^ Predigten,
I,
ad
ideal that
3.
pp. 35-44.
would be equivalent
SOCIAL REFORM.
to a practical realization of
Qj
Communism,
preaches
it
Communism.
He
says
munism
Hence
of the Apostles.
had
it
him
lied to
remained, did
St.
And
who
" Whilst
after
it
sold,
*' Girard,
"Acts
KeiteUr
5:4.
et
BISHOP KETTELER.
68
up only by
Christian community.
We
who wrought
must
first
in the first
again,^*
temporal
Brandenburg and Pommerania, Ketteler was sumthe Supreme Head of the Church to undertake a still more onerous and responsible work.
On 7 December, 1849, Pius IX rejected the nomination of Professor Schmid of Giessen as bishop by
After some hesitation and
the canons of Mainz.
opposition the chapter proposed three names to the
Pope, among them Ketteler's, and on 15 March,
1850, Pius IX named him Bishop: "To provide,"
as he wrote to Archbishop Reisach of Munich, " fof
Mainz, in the person of Baron Ketteler a Bishop
moned by
after God's
much
own
O how many
so
needs.
particular."
till
own Heart."
One of Ketteler's
last acts
Hedwig's was to lead a Corpus Christi procession for the first time since the Reformation
through the streets of Berlin to the neighboring
Spandau. " Last Sunday," the Berlin correspondent of the Allgemeine Zeitung wrote 4 June, "an
St.
^*Predigten,
I,
pp. 381-3.
SOCIAL REFORM.
gg
became
of
St.
'
fortunately
who
superfluous.
The
mounted
police-
CHAPTER
VII.
ON
His
Vow
in St,
as
unostentatiously as possible,
and out of the city, to whom the machinations of the Schmid party were well-known,
were of opinion that a gorgeous reception would go
far toward rallying the better Catholic element and
discomfiting the trouble-makers, and they prevailed
on him not to cross their plans. On 16 July, he
arrived in Bingen, where a steamer dressed with
flags from stem to stern and bearing the auspicious
name " Concordia," took him on board. The journey from Bingen to Mainz resembled a triumphal
procession.
Both banks of the Rhine were lined
leaders in
The whole
city
was
in holiday attire to
welcome the
SOCIAL REFORM.
71
parade brought
this
him
to
magnificent torch-light
memorable day
to a close.^
On
23 July, Ketteler proceeded to the Grandin Darmstadt to take the customary oath of allegiance. The words he addressed to
Ducal residence
his sovereign
my
down
my
he
to give unto
God
Non
The solemn
licet."
The
Hermann von
Blum of
saintly Bishop
oc-
ages of the
German Church.'
1850.
2 Pfiilf, I, p.
217.
Cardinal
BISHOP KETTELER.
72
pulpit.
The
eff'ect
of
Ketteler's
address,
**
his
consecration,
contains
famous
his
"
vow
of
with the deepest sorrow that I see him depart, for he is a minister
of God in the full sense of the word.
Among the successors
of St. Boniface he will hold a prominent place in the See which,
in former times, was of such high significance for the German
Church and the German Empire." Hochland, Oct., 191 1, p. 31.
.
Briefe,
p, 527.
SOCIAL REFORM.
73
is
Christ,
am and
all I
life.
have
of
my body and my
your
souls.
to fulfil this
God and of
God through His Church
obligation, and I beg you to pray to God
in His great mercy He may hasten to the
my weak
Elsewhere
have vowed to
in the
The trumpery
will.'
no
hut,
tiously
Hirtenbriefe,
p.
6.
''
Hirtenbriefe, p.
12.
BISHOP KETTELER.
74
reigned
his
in
household,"
says
Dr.
Liesen,
Ketteler's secretary.
half a dozen cane-chairs, a larger writingand an ordinary table made up the whole furniture
The little bed-room with its plain
of his sitting-room.
bedstead has caused more than one visitor to exclaim:
What? That was the bed-room of the noble Bishop of
Mainz! Silverware, Ketteler never possessed; even the
sofa,
table,
he allowed
Satmrday.
to
He was
a faithful
member
of the St.
Maimer
aire
Journal letorted: "If our multi-millionmanufacturers and all our other banknote-
Liesen,
Ketteler
u.
SOCIAL REFORM.
75
bristling
to the
workmen and
chari-
charity."
Beautifully in
harmony with
his
whole
life
is
of
my
house,
my
linen,
my
clothes,
shall
The same
Society was to dispose of the few valuhad been presented to him on various occasions, amongst others a cross valued at 1,200
marks, the gift of an Austrian Archduke.
ables that
foes,
the Liberal Kolnische Zeitung, was forced to con" It is almost literally true that the mighty
fess
:
CHAPTER
The
VIII.
Throne.
days
TWOanother
1850-1877.
previous to
Ketteler's
consecratioa
piece of
me
all
Diocese of Mainz. JosephinFrench domination, Rongeanism, had worked havoc with the ancient Catholic glories of Mainz. A strong anti-Catholic spirit
had gradually taken possession of the educated
classes of the episcopal city; in most of the other
cities and towns of the Diocese the Catholics were
in a helpless minority.
The number of really zealous pastors of souls had woefully decreased. Catholic aspirants to the priesthood were required to
set things right in the
Pfulf,
I, p.
221.
K U
HO
SOCIAL REFORM.
77
mere State
as
officials
excellent
staff
of
professors
Riffel,
Heinrich,
Moufang, HafTner, men who attained an international reputation for piety, zeal, and learning.
When all was ready for the opening, the Bishop
gave notice of his intentions to the Government in
Darmstadt and at the same time asked for financial
aid.
The Government thought that the most effective means of frustrating the Bishop's plans was
to wrap itself in profound silence.
But Ketteler
was not only a churchman, he was also a lawyer.
associations of
Germ-n
students.
BISHOP KETTELER.
78
calls
it,
'
Members of
SOCIAL REFORM.
yg
come good
priests ".
On Holy Thursday
he
waited on them at table and accompanied them on
celebrated in their midst.
window."
The
pastoral conferences
BISHOP KETTELER.
8o
He
the idea of a bad priest, so sublime was his conHe wept when he heard
ception of the priesthood.
young priest.
came to Mainz there were no Re-
of the apostasy of a
When
Ketteler
Brothers of
novelist,
House of the
Good Shepherd was opened; Franciscan nuns were
won for house-to-house attendance and care of the
ceived into the Church in Berlin, a
Day
were recalled
in
1858.
From
Easter Sunday one mission followed the other without interruption, for the Bishop
was of opinion that no parish should be without this
" The
blessing for more than six years at a time.
annual missions have just come to a close," wrote
a correspondent of the Historisch-Politische Blatter
in 1853 " the most zealous missionary of all was the
Right Reverend Bishop himself. In many places
he preached every day, and heard confessions from
four or five o'clock in the morning till nine or ten
in the evening almost uninterruptedly."
Periodical retreats and conferences for laymen, conducted
All Saints'
till
SOCIAL REFORM.
by
For the country people the Bishop's
frequent Confirmation tours he visited even the
smallest parish once every three years were nothderledy, kept alive the flame of zeal enkindled
the missions.
BISHOP KETTELER.
82
is
Grand-Duchy of Sisters of
down his program of prac-
reform
in a
younger generation,
consider
my
it
my
a duty of
calling t6
The
neglected children.
nual
for
the
care
of
poor-funds cannot be met by taxaa burden that will become heavy enough in time
deficits in the
tion
institutions
in any event.
to take
with enthusiasm
Not a few
to
an
in-
and inspired
cines,
but
who
and
who
their surroundings,
And
who
these
SOCIAL REFORM.
gj
poor,
hospitals
for
the
sick
and
institutions
for
the
is
well calculated to
summon
up, for in the hands of the Sisters each one will see his
alms multiplied."
Briefe,
p. 227.
BISHOP KETTELER.
84
Girls'
erected in
Neustadt and a Boys' Protectory in Klein-Zimmem. The latter institution still has the reputation of being one of the best organized of its kind
in Germany. Toward its maintenance Ketteler contributed thousands of florins from his own revenues
every year, and Countess Hahn-Hahn gave the proceeds of all her literary work.
Many
Ketteler founded a
home
were thought
of Chris-
for the
Pastoral in
of,
Protection
of
his diocesans
in his diocese.
He
journeymen, sup-
Hirtenbriefe, p. 248.
Gasteiger, Christ.-Soc.
Bewegung,
p.
13.
SOCIAL REFORM.
plied
gg
One
and benefactor
till
life.
solid
trial centres.
From
workingmen were
knew
either the
tle
whom God
Any
op-
work during the remainder of my life will be embraced by me with the greatest alacrity.
My
whole soul is taken up with the new forms which
BISHOP KETTELER.
86
human
depresses
me more and
wings of
my
persist
in
Church."
*
paralyzes, as
it
were, the
Briefe, p. 41 1.
who
the
CHAPTER
Liberty, Authority,
IX.
1862.
in the great
work
inactive.
They pressed
How
life
vile assaults?
BISHOP KETTELER.
88
No
away.
line of
bourgeoisie
Liberal
gave vent to its anti- Catholic instincts. Liberalism gave the order, and the proletariat carried it
out to suit
its
own
tastes.^
Neither
made him pause: he feared neither the clammob nor the frowns of kings. In him the
ors of the
propositi
Non
Non
to
"All these
men
off.
more."
of
is
Baden,
set
up the
SOCIAL REFORM.
89
When
Minister Jolly,
Lamey's successor, tried to force an archbishop of
his
own
who defended
it
was
the electoral
When a number
rights of the canons of Freiburg.
of " intellectuals " of Mainz disgraced a public
festival by insulting the Franciscan Order and
habit, Ketteler, in
of Mainz
an
"
Open
him and
to contribute
generously toward his support when the Piedmontese usurper robbed him of his patrimony.
It would take us too far afield to give even a
partial account of Ketteler's activity in defence of
the Church, for during the twenty-seven years of
his episcopate he wrote no less than ninety-two pastorals, brochures, pamphlets, and longer newspaper
articles of a controversial or apologetic nature, not
a few of the more important ones going through
three and four and even seven editions.
How, with
all this,
solicitude,
'
BISHOP KETTELER.
90
works on the
social question,
To
proper value
Bethe social program of the Liberal party.
fore joining issue with them on this question, however, he thought it advisable to clear the way by
a general settling of accounts. This he did in the
work entitled " Liberty, Authority, and the Church:
A Discussion of the Great Problems of the Day "
first to
estimate at
its
(1862).
The
was instantaneous.
Be-
the size
mod-
most 260 pages small octavo; short chapters; the arrangement of the parts simple; the diction clear, in short, smooth sentences with few and
always brief foot-notes; intelligible to all, never
fatiguing; not confusing, but illuminating; no unhealthy extremes, no appeals to the passions, but
clear, logical trains of thought, clothed in words
that could come only of a warm heart." *
Some one
has said of Ketteler that if he had not been one of
the greatest bishops, he would have been one of
the greatest journalists of all times."
This peculiar
erate, at
al-
SOCIAL REFORM.
91
talent of his
practical truth.
The
thority,
and
the
the Countess
Church
Hahn-Hahn
Au-
is
My
in
Briefe,
p. 273.
Ketteler
P- 347-
BISHOP KETTELER.
92
press,
therefore,
and
to
Catholic
publicists
the
Columbanus
Cognosce causam belli,
Fortem non nescias hostem
Et libertatem in medio arbitrii.
pugnam;
pugnam,
tollis et
coronam;
To
ness, Ketteler
the day
ity,
equality
of divine truth.
He
is
government and corporate rights; he combats absolutism and centralization, especially the absolutism practised by the Liberals under the guise of
liberty.
He claims for the Church liberty to ad-
own affairs, but protests against confounding with this autonomy of the Church athe-
minister her
Columbanus ad Fratrem
Epist. IV.
SOCIAL REFORM.
93
separation.
"
God
He
emphasizes the social significance of the Christian family founded on and hallowed by the Sacrament of Matrimony, and demands liberty and protection for it against the encroachments of absolutism, especially in the shape of a Godless compulsory educational system.
the
but the
social
question ia
social action
greatest
The
more
must be
built
warmth and
persuasiveness."
lays
in
says:
In the
first
place,
we regard
to
make people
believe
and
forms of other days, as inaccessible to improvement, or that we praise them unreservedly and hold
that
certain
institutions,
certain
social
political
BISHOP KETTELER.
94
we
live,
luminous truths
"to
thirdly,
all the
coiirse, we must,
with all the enthusiasm,
the energy of which we are capable,
endeavoring,
all these
With
how
in measuring his
little
slate,
human
race in all
its
flF.
SOCIAL REFORM.
In conclusion Ketteler, like another Paul, sumall the faithful to rise from sleep and
themselves for the battle.
mons
arm
the
this divine
of
spirit
the
men to the yoke of its own despotic law. It defrauds mankind of the sweet yoke of Christ and the
all
authority ordained by
Him, only
to lay
on
it,
with the
dress,
ocrisy of
plot to
ity.
modem
From
cussed, and these thoughts developed ; countless newspapers must spread them broadcast among the people.
What could we not do if we had but a small portion of
BISHOP KETTELER.
96
them
to rush breathlessly
infidelity
glorious,
to
our ancestors,
L. c, pp. 145
fF.
Matt. 20
6.
^^
"Why
CHAPTER
X.
1864.
the
KETTELER'S
not
made
in vain.
Edmund
was
pillars
on the
Frankfort, 21-24 September, 1863, under the presidency of Wilderich von Ketteler, adopted a resolution
brought
in
to
satis-
BISHOP KETTELER.
98
Finally, in the
corned and unanimously carried.
winter of 1863 Ketteler himself set to work to define the position of Christianity in regard to the
labor question and at the same time to supply the
nascent Christian social-reform movement with a
eral distress and famine of 1847, the natural consequence of the uncontrolled spread of Liberal Industrialism, and the Revolution of 1848, which was
as much a social as a political uprising, forced the
social question on Germany, the Liberals, thanks to
^ the banishment of the Socialist agitators, thanks
also to the listlessness of the Christian and conservative elements, as well as to the bold initiative
of Hermann Schulze-Delitzsch,^ got the start in the
jrace for the leadership of the masses.
Aiter several futile attempts had been made in Berlin and
other cities to help the workingman out of his
misery, Schulze-Delitzsch founded the first German
Loan Association in Eilenburg (1851). The experiment proved a success and served as a model
1
for
all
similar undertakings.
By
lecture courses
Hermann
Schulze,
bom
ir
1808.
In the civil service till
till his death in 1883.
Works
1852
SOCIAL REFORM.
by
tlie
restless
gg
gressist
at the
XV
be free
to exercise
any
craft,
to
settle
anywhere
made
protection.
possible only
By
Once
educated, the
to
BISHOP KETTELER.
lOO
life,
The whole
Herr
Even
Schulze's
theories,
believed
and
adored.
revolutionary
Young Germany.
first
interview
SOCIAL REFORM.
lOl
to
Many
years
Hatzfeld, fought
whose guiding
spirits
were Marx
102
and Engels.
BISHOP KETTELER.
Repeatedly imprisoned for exciting
(1857).
During the Italian War he tried to gain the goodBismarck and the Prussian Government by
a brochure entitled The Italian War and Prussia's
Mission, in which he demanded the restoration of
German unity under the hegemony of Prussia. In
1 861
he published his most ambitious work. The
System of Acquired Rights. In it he repudiates
every moral foundation of justice and rights, the,
will of
SOCIAL REFORM.
The two
are
IO3
program
manded universal,
More " revolutionary
associations
all
was
his
demand
indirect taxation.
Very few of
origin-
2 " The iron law of wages or the subsistence theory, was the
application to wages of the theory of price being due to the
cost of production.
Labor was likened to a commodity and thus
its price could be ordinarily no more than its cost of production,
namely, such wages as would enable the workman to live and
rear a successor."
Devas, Political Economy, 3rd ed., p. 473.
8 " The Iron Wage
Law," says Prof. Lujo Brentano, " was
formulated by Turgot, made the centre of a system by Ricardo
and shouted out into the world by Lassalle."
{Frankfurter
BISHOP KETTELER.
I04
salle
by the
But Lassalle, who said of
furiously attacked
all
with
interest, the
tion of the
May,
presidency.
Lassalle's
most important
Socialistic
work, Herr
blow
to the
opponent of Proudhon.
'Julian Schmidt (1818-86), whose uncritical History of GerLiterature Lassalle had handled very pungently in i860
Schmidt himself was relegated to the ranks of the " literary
man
mob".
SOCIAL REFORM.
I05
diners and soupers ranked with the most select affairs in Berlin.
There was no contradiction in this,
but rather a contrast such as we might look for in a
rich and complicated nature, in a Jacobin endowed
with a keen sense of the beautiful, in a revolutionary soldier fighting with gorgeously decorated
weapons, in a man who has not wholly put off the
child."
cratic, as is
lished in the
ever,
it
drew
closer to
He
Bismarck and the Kreuzzeitung. Beguiled by his vanity, he had hoped, for a while,
at the head of his labor party to be a match for
the all-powerful Chancellor; but he was soon undeceived."
What the daring demagogue's ulterior
plans were and what use he intended to make of his
tremendous influence, no one knows. He did not
live to see the disintegration of his party through
the incompetence of his successors and the intrigues of the Countess Hatzfeld, and its final absorption by the Socialistic Labor Party of Bebel and
Liebknecht.
He died in Geneva, 31 August, 1864,
of a wound received in a duel with the Wallachian
Bojar Racowitza, his rival for the hand of Helene
von Doenniges.^ His followers made a demigod
''
BISHOP KETTELER.
I06
of
him and
Socialists
still
make pilgrimages
to his
grave in
name
the
At
tions
asserted
that
Lassalle sent an
her penniless.
SOCIAL REFORM.
evasive answer and asked the
ent to reveal himself.
107
unknown correspond-
torian
No
further correspondence,
wise,
and
common
opposition to Liberalism,
political
social,
and depth of Christianity," as well as his just appreciation of the Middle Ages, resulted in Ketteler's
judging perhaps too favorably of his intentions and
aspirations.
2.
when
all
and
app ea red
To-day it is nothing unusual for the highest dignitaries of the Church to take an active part in the
discussion of the labor question.
It was not thus
fifty years ago.
In the introduction to his work
Ketteler deemed it advisable to set forth at length
the reasons which induced him to speak on this
tio n
BISHOP KETTELER.
I08
His apology
matter.
is
such a splendid
mind and
monument
Many
to
heart,
meddle
sufficient
that I
I
The
labor question
also
is
it
seems
to
Viewed
publicly.
it
a question of
me, gives
me
the right to
Christian charity.
What-
man
The
on
this principle.
Various
classes
this is the problem under discussion.
What is more important
means have been proposed.
than to examine these from the Christian point of view?
Can we approve of them? Can we lend, or must we
What special means has Chrisrefuse, our cooperation?
tianity to offer?
a bishop
When
the
am
Church
to be kind
entitled to pass
and merciful
judgment on them.
was about
name
of the
How
could
Lord?"
I after
And
and
an-
such a solemn
SOCIAL REFORM.
the welfare of
limits,
my
flock,
IO9
brothers in Christ.
After warning his readers not to expect an exhaustive treatment of the labor question it was too
Ketteler defines the term
early in the day for that
workingman. It applies not only to the laborer
properly so-called, that is the day-laborer and millworker, but to those also who, though conducting
a business of their own, possess so little capital that
their condition is no better than that of the man
forced to live on his daily wages.
In this sense
mechanics, small tradesmen and property-holders
must be classed as working-men.'
" The labor question is essentially a question of
subsistence.
Now there is no doubt that the material existence of almost the whole laboring class,
that
is
States,
bread necessary
children,
is
to the
workingman,
Ketteler
to his
wife and
1**
modem
all
p.
^.
7.
attributes the social distress of the wageearning classes to the action of the so-called Iron Law of Wages
(See above). So far he agrees with Lassalle and many other
" The theory of the Iron Wage
political economists of his day.
Law," H. von Scheel wrote in 1878, " is in fact irrefragable so
here
BISHOP KETTELER.
no
This
is,
question.
this
many
classes.
chandise.
workmen
hired
number of
human
de-
labor.^^
"
Ketteler then proceeds to examine the " Liberal
craft,
help
2.
3.
Self-
Work-
the text.
The
law theory
SOCIAL REFORM.
working
dition of the
Wages
it.
necessary,
classes,
who
difficulty
that the
Ill
and
is
will
be
intellectutal
powers."
equally ineffectual.
The
workingman
he
cannot,
properly speaking,
is
into
family, inculcated by
in the
practised
workshop of Nazareth.^*
" L.
c, p. 34.
i L. c,
pp.
37
flf.
BISHOP KETTELER.
112
it is
from the
flattest
men
to
be
satisfied
is
It is
make this
The Godless
man
fill
Ketteler's predictions
societies
rich
up the void
in his heart
true.
The
is
One
Bebel.
^* L. c, pp.
44
ff.
They were
the hotbeds of
SOCIAL REFORM.
At
113
in the third
have
loan
group
some
self-help
"
we
to-
The combination
relations
would
in-
BISHOP KETTELER.
114
variably be excellent.
this
The fact
the same
it rests.
bers of
is
that
value.
men
on which
numHerr Schulze-Delitzsch
are not merely
and
in
utter contradiction
to
is
non-
the natural
"
order."
make?
What
Lassalle formulates
them
as follows:
We
may
we must make a joint-proprietor,
a shareholder of him. To accomplish this, capital
is necessary.
The workingman therefore needs
share in
its
profits
i Op.
cit.,
pp. 33
and
57.
SOCIAL REFORM.
II5
of parliament will
vilest selfishness
gage
in
the deliberations
heart and
its
passions."
^^
amount
to
of capital required to
it out would necessitate a serious encroachment upon the rights of private property. Can such
carry
an encroachment be justified?
Ketteler answers:
with
all the
it,
man
and
is
man and on
The majority
property by will.
The
BISHOP KETTELER.
Il6
is
called the
modern
What
State.
If
it
supremely ridiculous
rooted to the spot,
of the millionaire.
Church and
away
the an-
who
will
take the same stand as they, and with the same right
will not only grant millions to subsidize labor-unions,
but for other things besides.
Viewed from the standpoint of the Liberals and the
principles taught in the name of the Government in so
many
The
case
is
who
believe in
God
Op.
cit.,
pp. 72-7.
SOCIAL REFORM.
117
Each
is
is
ism of the other; both are for the most part wrong
in the proposals they make to help the workingman. Both are right when they deny; both wrong
when they affirm. We are not surprised at this;
it is in harmony with the general character of the
spirit of the world, which can indeed criticize, pick
flaws, and tear down, but can not create, build up,
and shape, because it is cut off from all communication with the Truth and the Life." ^"
3.
After having thus shown that the remedies proposed by the Liberals and the Radicals are inadequate to solve the great problems of the day, and,
far from relieving the wretched condition of the
working clzisses, tend only to aggravate it, Ketteler
asks:
Is there
we
no
workingman?
down
as
Must
irre-
course?
ity
Certainly not.
God
is
agitated mankind,
shall
we
BISHOP KETTELER.
Il8
succeed.
is
in
fair
way
matter,
it
to
har-
(|
we
destroy
if
it
necessary,
we
kill the
When
old.
man dominion
he
is
Church
God gave
"
He
thy equal."
On
did not
as
man
1249,
SOCIAL REFORM.
The working
these
unhappy
Here
aberrations.
it is
119
whole weight of
again the mission
from
this
neo-pagan
new
He
and
says:
Christianity puts
ment of
his
all
man
in full possession
powers.
It
restored
to
and entire.
worth of man as an individual.
dividuality full
tion of the
For the
condition.
derstood.
of reasons.
citizen,
and
fulness
to
Nor was
It
'^
hardly be said to exist.
The enlightened Greeks, whose culture is still held up
to us as a model, despised manual labor.
The freeborn among them regarded the exercise of a trade as
.
** Op.
Griechenlands.
BISHOP KETTELER.
120
had no heart for the laborer and the slave. The Greek
philosophers taught that slavery was an institution
founded on the natural order, and as such could not be
They had not even the faintest idea that the
abolished.
great body of toilers could be elevated to the position
In their
they occupy under the Christian dispensation.
eyes the slave was a chattel like any other, a part of
their private property, in instrument at the service of the
free
man.
The most
world to-day, because the hearts of men have been refashioned by the breath of Christianity.
The sole reason
for a slave's existence was the satisfaction of the lusts of
his master.
And so it came to pass at
man knew no greater pleasure than
to
witness those
death-rattle,
this
SOCIAL REFORM.
121
lot
peoples,
the ancient
We
was
as a witness and a
monument
set in the
From
this
to the mercies of
men from
It
the bonds
Holy Writ,
the image of
"
man; and
forthwith they began to fall off from the hands and feet
BISHOP KETTELER.
122
More wonderful
was the manner of
still
it.
than the
Moehler
this,
that
it
brought about
made
by violent means.
Ec-
it
St.
new
Christian empire.
If the
Christians were
which He proclaimed.
The external
malady disappear in proportion as the body
recovers its health.
The same process took place in
humanity under the influence of Christianity. God has
placed a spiritual, a heavenly leaven in the world which
gradually raises and leavens the whole mass.
He heals
men from within, because all external ills have their
eternal
truths
traces of a
SOCIAL REFORM.
source within;
is
He
Thus
23
flicted.
ills
process.
its
Christian workingmen
What
centuries of
handed on
reign,
its
plish to-day.
to
it
still
it
It
of slavery, by informing
ideas
and infusing
into
it its
spirit of charity.
It
" Op.
cit.,
25 " I
am
pp. 149-156.
BISHOP KETTELER.
124
What
first
filial
this burden.^^
SOCIAL REFORM.
25
ish
The
secularization
was a
benefit
of the
To
Christian
it is
built,
preserve to the
ily,
is
an indispensable
others, call
28
Op.
cit., p.
15.
BISHOP KETTELER.
126
serves
dreadful consequences of
In times of dis-
vice.
want of work, what can replace the inexhaustible love and spirit of sacrifice
tress,
of sickness,
o*f
ment
to
who
is a
^*
command-
divine com-
he
life,
is
man and
teach
is
stewardship
his
over
the
goods
entrusted
to
on earth " to
eat and to drink and be drunk," and nothing more,
" shall be beaten with many stripes," that, whether
he have five pounds or only one pound, he must
make the most of his opportunity. In season and
out of season she strives to impress on him the supreme necessity of temperance, self-denial, continence, and all those other virtues whose observance
cannot but be conducive to his temporal as well as
his eternal well-being and without which " selfhelp " is a hollow phrase.'"
In the fourth place the Church offers her power-
him
that the
man who
thinks he
is
SOCIAL REFORM.
127
The fundamental characteristic of the labor movements of our day, that which gives them their importance and significance and really constitutes their essence,
is the tendency, everywhere rife among the workingmen,
to organize for the purpose of gaining a hearing for their
just claims by united action.
To this tendency, which is
not only justified but necessary under existing economic
Church cannot but gladly give her sancand support.
It would be a great folly on our part if we kept aloof
from this movement merely because it happens at the
present time to be promoted chiefly by men who are
hostile to Christianity.
The air remains God's air though
breathed by an atheist, and the bread we eat is no less
the nourishment provided for us by God though kneaded
by an unbeliever. It is the same with unionism: it is an
idea that rests on the divine order of things and is essentially Christian, though the men who favor it most do
not recognize the finger of God in it and often even turn
it to a wicked use.
Unionism however is not merely legitimate in itself
and worthy of our support, but Christianity alone comconditions, the
tion
mands
erly
and making
it
and vigor
BISHOP KETTELER.
128
of an association
terial,
may be
if
purely ma-
the elements of
their
own
inmiediate objects.
Supply-associations furn-
ish their
common
object.
combine in a Christian
the earth;
it
is
this
The
The
men
are
still
zealously at
work trying
to
remove the
last
new
building
hut
is
^built
cit.,
^^
pp. 130-136.
SOCIAL REFORM.
29
The
associations especially
teler to the
Associations.
fancy, were
lack of
latter,
Father Kolping
question,
them."
In the
fifth
means
of
He
placed the greatest hopes in the ultimate sucby ChrisAt the same time he did not shut his
tian charity.
^es to the very serious difficulties standing in the
way
of
its realization.
It is superfluous
of Productive Associations of
Workingmen.
We
can-
But there
it
is
something so grand in
est degree.
So far as it is realizable it holds out the
most palpable solution of the problem under discussion,
assuring as it does to the workman, over and above his
daily wages, which competition has practically reduced
to a
Lassalle wishes
BISHOP KETTELER.
I30
funds.
The
is,
command.
workingmen with little or no
capital will be literally crushed and trampled upon by
the giant business concerps which are becoming more numerous every day. Where can the workingmen get the
necessary capital to compete with them?
If Lassalle's
plan is unjustifiable and impracticable, as we are convinced it is, and if there are no other means available
talists
The
As often
as I
weigh these
difficulties,
up within me
and realize
Vast sums will be required, and I
grand
scale.
it
on a
am
far
"
There is an excellent sketch of this eminent Christian economist in Janssen's Zeit und Lebensbilder, Vol. I cf. Goyau,
;
L'Allemagne religieuse ;
le
Protestantisme,
pp.
191-193.
SOCIAL REFORM.
the foundations for
Christianity
is
it,
now
in
I3I
It
grovmd
to
program a
salle's
trial.
The
disastrous
consequences
directed
is
it
vince
that the
it
cure
less to
it
by unscrupulous demagogues,
(Social-) Democrats are just
of
its ills
will con-
as power-
human
We
cannot, therefore,
tell
Christianity
realize
It
is
true,
do most
at the present
moment
'^
BISHOP KETTELER.
132
ered Italy with institutions for the poor, and even sacrificed their lives for the love of Christ.
Christianity
is
wonderful
Its enemy of yesterday falls down today at the foot of the Cross, and the son gives his blood
for the love of the God whom his father blasphemed
so
The
God
Christians to these
systems of taxation.
other by Christianity.
assessors
and
it
the
science.
asteries,
human
money
all this
is
up
it still is
What
to-day.
If
Christianity
we were
life-
was
to count
SOCIAL REFORM.
years '*
alone
twenty million
Catholics
the
florins to the
of
Holy
the
33
How
Father.
can we,
men who
It
seems to
feel impelled to
me
do good
is
no dearth
fellow-men.
to their
more pleasing
more
to
Above
all things, it is
when
their
For only
importance for the working-classes shall have
been recognized on
people themselves,
all
and
feasibility
all
by the
demonstrated,
treat of the
work) he
,
insists
to the
** 1859-1864.
Ketteler was one of the most zealous promoters
of the collections for the papal treasury. Cf. Pfulf, II, pp. 4 ff.
Op.
BISHOP KETTELER.
134
demand
all
security for a
permanent
moral right
livelihood.
to
All
Why
'
80
Op.
cit.,
pp. 26
if.
SOCIAL REFORM.
Later on, as
we
135
found occasion
urgent reforms which the
to particularize certain
We
cannot
bring
this
imperfect
analysis
of
a more
to
fitting close
would be easy to solve if it were not for the unhappy schisms that divide Christendom. May God
restore to us what we all still profess when we
pray
'
:
Church.' "
The
Catholic Apostolic
'
publication of Christianity
'^
Op.
* It
cit, p.
160.
was translated
" Introduction
into
BISHOP KETTELER.
136
won
its
es-
We
among
among
many
re-
his pro-
war against
Liberalism so open, that comparatively few even in
the Catholic camp had the courage to follow his
lead then and there.
Some looked upon the labor
question as " the question of the future," and preferred not to wrestle with it just then.
To others
posals so daring and his declaration of
away.
*o Pfulf, II, p.
189.
SOCIAL REFORM.
137
Letters
Bishop from
the
him
less
for
all
sides,
..." A
He ought to know;
had struggled for twenty years to keep above
water, but had gone down in the end without any
much
for he
to save him.
His sad
social
misery.
We
are
living
very much like heathens: we do not fulfil the purpose for which God created us; therefore we must
perish.
If I cannot see you in this world, I wish
.
BISHOP KETTELER.
138
to visit
you
in the next
lover of men."
These and numerous other heartfelt effusions indemnified Ketteler for the vile abuse heaped upon
him from other quarters. Thus the Liberal journals persistently accused him of inflaming the masses
with hatred and contempt for the existing order of
things and of championing the cause of Socialistic
Radicalism.
In 1871 this charge was openly repeated in the German Reichstag by a spokesman
of
the
National-Liberals.
Ketteler
replied
" I
'
'
'
'
i Pfulf, II, p.
196.
SOCIAL REFORM.
139
away by
his eloquence.
'
Two
men
of
** The passages were Ketteler's criticism of Economic Liberalism and his description of the degradation of labor.
*
op.
cit.,
flF.;
Goyau,
BISHOP KETTELER.
I40
Though
forts that
The
SOCIAL REFORM.
I4I
some
He
service."
workmen are
at the
of the business.
He
sole proprietors
all obstacles.
He
of capital."
BISHOP KETTELER.
142
The promotion
of this quadruple system of assoby adopting the good features of each, is,
in the Bishop's eyes, " one of the most important
tasks of the age, one of the most beautiful tasks of
ciation,
He
is
determined
to
make
From
his
point of mentioning a
willing to
make
workingmen's
is ready
own revenues he
am
off".
still
He
began
He was
support any undertaking that would assure to the workmen an income over and above their
daily wages.
This would at any rate solve the subsistence question, he thought, and the social question
too, in so far as it was a " stomach question ".
From his letter to Lassalle we see that he had
50,000 florins on hand with which he intended to
start a number of such associations for the GrandDuchy of Hesse. A combination of untoward circumstances prevented him from carrying out his
plan at the time; the necessity of employing almost
ready
to
SOCIAL REFORM.
43
they
to organize the Catholic workingmen
did not seem to think it necessary.
No one did
more to enlighten them on this point than Ketteler.
little
Organization was the magic word on which he cenall his hopes for the solution of the labor
question
organization supported by the Church
and the State. In sermons, occasional addresses,
talks to his seminarians, he reverted to this theme.
tred
protection
jotted
down by
for them.
The
following notes
A rbeiterfrage
BISHOP KETTELER.
144
Who
help.
Many must
What can
I.
tions
awaken
in employers
1.
help.
2.
in
What can
II.
vision
The
3.
do?
the State
prohibitive measures
State should
1.
Associations;
2.
super-
4. occasional subventions.
make laws
to facilitate organization
exceptionally;
provide
factory-
inspectors.
III.
IV.
What the
What can
do?
"
few,
if
any,
German
socio-
classes.
the
all
workmen must
belong.
members
*
Pfaf,
its
The
SOCIAL REFORM.
45
These
various Unions form district federations.*^
members;
the
federations are courts of appeal for
they administer the common funds and form the
connecting-link between the State and the Union.
Recognition of the district federations by the
State.
The
..."
" pulverization
Can we
and professions? he asks. Study and experience had taught him that there was no hope of
carrying them out for the present.
But as he wjis
no mere social theorizer, no mere dreamer of Utopian dreams, and as the distress of the workingclasses was growing worse from day to day, the
Bishop quietly pigeonholed his grand plans of universal reform and looked about him to see where
the need was greatest and what could be done to
classes
relieve
*''
it.
CHAPTER
XI.
1866.
marked a turning-point
in
of the Catholic
Prussian
War
many
made
Church
in
Germany,
it
of Catholicity
of
in the
unenviable position of a
SOCIAL REFORM.
man
147
do
to
so.
to give it;
He had
and he
felt
carefully
Germany
after the
War
modern
Crown was
political
tell
12 February. 1867.
BISHOP KETTELER.
148
place
among
If ever a
it
this
who imputed
Ketteler
ed., p.
15.
SOCIAL REFORM.
149
'^
deed
not
we
because
we
sincerely love
are
it.
We
..."
land.
The war
lowed
in its
as a violation
ciple of the
in so
many
Austria's politics
knowledge
all
that
system of Cjrovernment, especially the liberty enjoyed by the Church under the Constitution, which
he does not hesitate to call " a real Magna Charta
of religious peace for a religiously divided country
like
'
Germany."
Op.
cit, p. 44.
Ibid.
' Ibid.,
pp.
57-58.
BISHOP KETTELER.
ISO
was
Politically Ketteler
many under
was
Ger-
in favor of a united
the leadership of
Prussia.
Austria
to
many
hold of so
fellow
Catholics
of his
fellow
regard
in
to
countrymen and
aims of the
the
government.
We
ever injustice
triumphs,
life
which, when-
retributive justice of
just
German who
is
but another
of finding a
way out
of the
threatening destruction.
No
single action of
every
respect
calamity
is
disastrous.
to
be in
great
" Prussia
own advantage,
make
it
would
be to
its
Op.
cit.,
pp. 67-68.
to
this
SOCIAL REFORM.
finger of
God,
We
151
and indulging
in lamentations, or to
folded arms.
However painful
sit
down
faces
sovir
idly with
workingman's
interests.
The
last
title "
Antichrist,"
Christ
sets
and
He
writes
State no
Christ Jesus,
All economic efforts not based on religion and moralgulf that separates capital from
from the poor, and bring that vast mass
of men who live by the labor of their hands to a state
in which they will be in want of the most indispensable
necessaries of life, a state which is not only in itself
barbarous, but which must necessarily end in frightful
social conflicts between poverty and riches such as we
ity
BISHOP KETTELER.
152
number
is
of those
their daily
labor
The
share
in
the
benefits
resulting
from the
co-
of life;
daily market-value of
workingman
is
forced
any price no
matter what the supply or demand may be, unless he
cares to face the prospect of perishing with hunger;
hence the tendency among workmen to underbid one
to deliver his goods, that
is,
his labor, at
which
When
is
his circumstances
SOCIAL REFORM.
153
Such for the majority of workingmen are the necessary consequences of the principles of economic Liberal-
this point.
The
over-population
may
is
The Government
has a right
much
as possible.
BISHOP KETTELER.
^54
right
the
to
police force
ages
and
yet
how widespread
men
they are
The
very lan-
disorder.^^
To
this
we
pass,
repeat,
has
irreligious
and
anti-
In
China.^^
of
^ 1
Ketteler
Ansichten
scientific
treatises
iiber
in
support
for
1865,"
p.
128.
SOCIAL REFORM.
the abomination of impurity
155
unblushingly held up as
is
word
that of itself
horrors of
their
God-like
are
souls
the
choicest
tian
benediction
of'
life,
from the
first
moment
of
its
exist-
This
is
still
",
or im-
its
frankly
sjrmpathize
with
the
working-classes
in
their
BISHOP KETTELER.
156
distress.
For the rest, their systems too are nothing
but doctrinarian experiments of no real value for the
We are therefore justisolution of the labor problem.
fied in maintaining that, on the one hand, the difficulties
resulting
fill
up the abyss
is
from
life
and death.
cial life,
and htunanity
will
If he seeks to fulfil
them
humanity,
in
destiny.
realize
its
supreme
in defiance of Christ
^that is
the alternative." ^
CHAPTER
A
^<
XII.
1869.
/"^AST
V^
it
again."
Labor Question;
many
and he used
to
add
facetiously
" In Ger-
and views
BISHOP KETTELER.
158
".
The
v.
Geissd,
Pfiilf, II, p.
II, pp.
569
s.
SOCIAL REFORM.
59
ment of
his
report.
He had
busy days
visitation tours
mo-
Before returning
to
Mainz he
in-
lic
point of view."
legitimate and
course
is
audience
;,
BISHOP KETTELER.
l6o
continues
We
will
all relig-
a commodity, but looked on man himself, with his capacity for work, simply as a machine bought as cheaply as
possible and driven until it will go no more.
To combat
the dreadful consequences which resulted from the application of such principles the Trade Unions arose in
England and, in time, spread into other countries. They
are beginning to take root in Germany too, and not a
few of you belong to them. The chief weapon of the
Trade Unions against capital and the grande Industrie
is the Strike, by means of which, in spite of many reverses
and seeming defeats, they have succeeded, as the English-
SOCIAL REFORM.
l6l
man Thornton
wages
and 15 per
50, 25,
cent.
make
this clear.
first
place,
possible.
far
more
in evidence.
BISHOP KETTELER.
62
One
this
respect
nothing but a base speculation for cheating the workingman out of his hard-earned wages. A few brief months
given up to intemperance amply suffice to absorb the
biggest pay.
who
is
Of what
And
yet,
on the other
on earth
is
down without
How
easy for a
man who
is
importance not to exaggerate this demand: the workingcan be only too easily imposed upon and the power
man
The
object of
SOCIAL REFORM.
'
63
the labor
man and
tween both.
treat the
It
is
work-
a crime
It fits in
it degrades them.
with the theory of those who would trace man's descent
But the impiety of labor must also be
to the ape.
guarded against. If the movement in favor of higher
justice, catastrophes
must
on the working-classes.
for lucrative investments.
workman
is
When
it
government
securities.
ness in which he
is
employed comes
to
When
the busi-
a standstill, un-
cannot
district
BISHOP KETTELER.
64
it
to
undermine
his
The
of
third
soul,
constitution,
and
simply
It will
to
the
disfigure
wages
to dissipate his
all
surely.
demand
of the working-classes
is
for days
rest.
This claim,
also,
is
perfectly legitimate.
Religion
it
God
is
vindicated
Law
"
Re-
mitted,
and
that cries to
men
to
still
Heaven
SOCIAL REFORM.
65
and
To
this the
means of securing
be to give him as
six days'
receives for
to the laborer
Who
as he
now
would
sacrifice his
re-
human
If the capitalists
work
The immense
workman even
profit
to
the indulgence of
work could be demonstrated to you with the same hypocritical mien as the benefit of Sunday work.
Just as
man has need of a certain number of hours out of the
twenty-four which make up the day for repose, so also
has he need of one day of rest out of the seven which
make up the week. He has a right to this for the sake
of his soul, in order that he
his relationship to
a son of
toil,
God,
may have
leisure to think of
to recollect that
but a child of
God
as well.
is
not merely
He
has a right
he
BISHOP KETTELER.
l66
Just as a master
is obliged to give
for
up
the
SOCIAL REFORM.
whom
from
67
no
workman and
his
Church.
family.
What
is
Monday
"
is
nothing else
rest is spent in
harmony with
the prin-
is
a curse.
fourth
demand
of the working-classes
is
the prohibi-
demand
is
not as general as
it
come.
It
would be more correct to say that it is a decertain spokesmen of the labor organiza-
mand made by
BISHOP KETTELER.
68
regard child
in
The
a factory.
fifth
women,
working
demand made by
the working-classes
is
that
from
in factories.
Jules
Simon
instructive
mean
Paris, 1863.
many
After de-
industrial districts
SOCIAL REFORM.
of France repeatedly visited by him, where
in the factories
and family
life is
69
women work
life.
do not
in France,
exist to so
wide an extent
in
Germany,
Two
in
more and
more the supreme importance of the family for their
own prosperity, and the close connexion between religion
and the urgent reforms demanded by the working-classes
the workpeople are beginning to understand
reforms
dren.
workman have
the family,
is
infinitely surpassed
in
still
BISHOP KETTELER.
170
Various reasons have been urged in favor of this deThus it has been pointed out that, as a general
rule, girls can work for far lower wages because they
require less to live on, and that therefore wholesale girl
labor must of necessity have a damaging effect on the
wages of men.
mand.
is
the
working-girls and
conse-
Workmen them-
sequences.
many
cents a day.
The dangers of factory life to the
morals of the young working- girls and therefore to the
family of the workman are beginning to be recognized
more and more even by the factory-owners themselves.
This is a happy symptom and shows once more that the
Op.
Here Ketteler
and morality."
SOCIAL REFORM.
I7I
After a soul-stirring appeal to fathers and brothers to leave no stone unturned to safeguard the
virtue of their daughters and sisters, Ketteler lays
down a few short, pregnant rules for distinguishing
the true social reformer from the sham one, the true
friend of the
workman from
his deadliest
enemy
who wish
we have seen,
workman is accom-
panied by religion and morality. Hence, if any one prohe is anxious to help you and at the same time
attacks your religion, you may be sure he either knows
tests that
and progress,
their patriotism,
their
all is metamorphosed, in
men, into blasphemy, into slanders
case
of
these
Beware of
these
men
"
Op.
cit.,
pp. 2i-aa.
girls
BISHOP KETTELER.
172
perfectly,
warm
my
you and my
You see from them
your welfare.
you can take a large share in
the labor movements of to-day without detriment
But you see
to the principles of your holy faith.
also that all your efforts will be vain if they are
^
not based on religion and morality."
On 5 August the Liebfrauenheide Address appeared in print dedicated " to all the Christian
workmen of the diocese of Mainz ". A fourth edition became necessary before the end of the month.
that,
interest in
as Catholics,
The Kolnische
Volksseitung, the
Christlichsoziale
Blatter,
Op.
cit, p. 24.
SOCIAL REFORM.
173
Only a brain which has subjected itself with incomparable military subordination to the dogmas of
the Roman Church and is withal endowed with un-
common
labor
meeting
in
Eisenach
for
the
purpose of
" uniting
the
cieties."
various
German workingmen's
so-
this
To
II, p. 439.
BISHOP KETTELER.
174
effected,
work
rest
from
should in
future take place on Sundays or holidays) and
both anticipated by Ketteler,
for factory laws ^^
(but
insisted
that
all
elections
we
as
shall
have occasion
to refer to again.
be looked up to
on the
social question.
The Protestant sociologist Dr.
Huber sent him a number of his writings with the
request to make their contents known, through some
" The
qualified person, at the next Katholikentag.
"
deep reverence," he wrote,
which I have for years
entertained for your Lordship in every respect, but
especially on account of your vigorous and dignified
championship of the interests of our poor people,
gives me ground to hope that my request will be
Ketteler
to
granted.
of the world."
Dr.
"
Hermann
Economy
"
Pfiilf, II, p.
187.
ss.
SOCIAL REFORM.
75
and
^^
studied.
articles,
of the noble
Lord
in this matter.^*
II,
p.
432.
u.
p. 433.
CHAPTER
XIII.
Social Question.
Social Program for the Clergy. 1869.
THE
sions on
The
the
is
the so-
to solve.
1.
4.
What can
the
Church do
to apply
them?
After a vivid description of the wretched condition of the working-classes in the great industrial
centres of Europe, especially of England, " the
classical
descrip-
I.
DOES THE SOCIAL QUESTION CONCERN GERMANY?
As regards Germany, the social evil is not so widespread
as in England, though the danger grows from day to day.
SOCIAL REFORM.
77
world.
II.
all
not her duty to concern herself directly with capital and industrial activity, but it is her duty
at stake.
it is
men by
and true
charity.
if
The
Chiirch
must help
dissolubly
it
is
in-
guiding mankind.
{a)
herself at
and did she not for dogmatic reasons proscribe usury and
the taking of interest on accoimt of the social conditions
of the time?
Why should not the Church occupy herself
with similar questions at present?
{b) The social question touches the deposit of faith.
Even if it was not evident that the principle underlying
BISHOP KETTELER.
178
is
mind and
of Christianity,
is
we wish
to look for-
battle
tion of the
workingman, according
to
which he
is
no
Church
Paul
it
is
to impress
" If
St.
es-
and
is
{d)
worse than an
To
infidel."
^*
workmen
entrusted
^^ Roscher,
175-
iI Tim. 5:8.
I,
p.
SOCIAL REFORM.
179
thing
else.
(/)
By
is
God
for,
according to His
known by
shall be
III.
Here
it
WHAT
their
its
handle it thoroughly, calmly and with any wellfounded hope of success. This objection is altogether
unfounded. The question is ripe. All parties admit the
existence of the evils of which I have spoken, and these
evils will go on increasing indefinitely unless something is done to check them.
No power on earth can
to
arrest
the
economy.
We
modem
system
of
BISHOP KETTELER.
l8o
tern,
as
and
we
it
and
it,
mend
to
make
end,
would be
we
if
most
part,
parties;
difficult
left the
sterile
indeed to
as
much
the
workman
it offers.
know how
to attain this
if
we
appears
much
and promote
simpler
and
it
associations
who
zealously es-
men have
and
ing population.
If
institutions
of
among
this
the labor-
kind existed
and purposes.
working- classes
of Europe."
To
2.
welfare.
and
intellectual
SOCIAL REFORM.
l8l
3.
4.
5.
6.
Sunday
7.
rest.
8.
our present industrial system and bring real reour workpeople. Let this system of associations
evils of
lief to
ASSOCIATIONS AND
INSTITUTIONS FOR WORKPEOPLE?
IV.
1.
It
sociations
and
institutions for
couragement and approbation, by instruction and spiritual cooperation, she can further their development in
the highest degree.
2.
classes especially
arouse
amongst the
intere,st
clergy,
in the laboring
who
evil,
be-
medies to be applied.
The
BISHOP KETTELER.
82
direction
induced
if
to
make a
and
to gain personal
The
institu-
would be communicated
to their
4.
word, to
fill
workman
trust in
God,
must be used
^'^
ment of the
many
and
if
there are so
and practical
this is due in the
sociologists
among them
at present,
^''
Ketteler's Fulda Report was first published in the Christlichsoziale Blatter, 6 Nov., 1869
Italian translation appeared in
Venice, 1870. It has been repeatedly reprinted since. " In the
history of the social question and of the social action of the
Catholic Church," Prof. Hitze wrote in 1886, " this report will
always retain a prominent place." {Arbeiterwohl, 1886, no. 7.)
;
SOCIAL REFORM.
first
83
Mainz and the other princes of the Church assembled at Fulda on the eve of the Vatican Council.
An immediate result of the Fulda deliberations
was the appointment in each diocese of a commisof
joint report
was
to
be drawn up and
German
bishops,
social
question stood
in
the fore-
ground.
ature."
The
social reform.
Vis-
"
The
Christian- Social
their
of thousands.
BISHOP KETTELER.
84
be treason.
The
and
drew the minds of men from the workmine and the iron mill to the school
room, the pulpit and the altar. " We must first win
the Church
when approached on
lation, "
social
1* "
The
into the
Catholic clerical party," the Sozialdemokrat comconvention, " especially the clergy, shows more
clearly every day that it is determined to interfere in the labor
movement." (1870, no. 13.)
^* Wenzel, Arbeiterschutz und Zentrum, p. ai.
mented on
this
CHAPTER
XIV.
in
the Reichs-
1 869- 1 87 1.
ALTHOUGH
mitting a Catholic social reform program to the assembled Fathers, it will not be out of place to say
The nearer, however, the date set for the opening of the Council approached, the fiercer became
the storm of opposition to the Church and her
visible Head, artificially aroused by the anti-
BISHOP KETTELER.
86
minded,
restive, Catholic
clerical
and
lay.
It
(in
was
name only)
especially
savants,
against the
infallibility of the
to the
the politicians
five
German-speaking
Written in his characteristically clear, impressive style, it could not fail to set the minds of
all honest inquirers at ease and keep them from
wandering dangerously astray. It was above all
the Bishop's own unequivocal profession of faith
in the divine guidance of the Church and in the
infallible teaching authority of her Head, the Vicar
of Christ on the throne of Peter, that encouraged
clergy and people to look with confidence and cheerfulness into the future, however dark the prospect
world.^
might appear.*
^ French, Italian, and
prepared.
' Cf.
Das
VI Die Frage
:
aller
Fragen.
SOCIAL REFORM.
87
his ex-
He never had the slightest sympathy with Gallicanism and he deeply deplored the stand taken by
" Shortly before his
Dollinger and his school.
departure for the Council," says Dr. Heinrich, " I
spoke to him about the violent attacks directed
against the doctrine of Papal Infallibility and the
new objections daily urged against it. At the end
of our conversation he said with great earnestness
Nothing can shake my faith in this doctrine '." '
On 23 May, he declared in a plenary meeting,
that he had always believed in Papal Infallibility,
but he insisted on a thorough examination of the
theological proofs put forward to justify its dogmatic definition as well as of the arguments advanced by the opposition. Though he circulated
in the Council a pamphlet, ad instar manuscripti,
of the learned and pious Jesuit Quarella, which in
'
S.J.,
my
special
'
examined
'
'," *
* Briefe, p. 557-
BISHOP KETTELER.
88
It is true
he wrote
to
practical
decrees
for
the
the
of
sanctification
Church, with the application of the practical principles of Christianity to the lives of the faithful.
he erred in
his heart
this, it
was
Church, and
filled
all
If
intellect, for
were
'
right
wing
'
ultramontane of the
To
find
himself in, or at any rate to be regarded as belonging to, another camp in Rome certainly meant no
small sacrifice to him, but he made it because his
demanded it of him, and later on he demore than once that he never even for a
single moment regretted the stand he had taken."
After the Council, when his enemies made his
conscience
clared
**
number
'^
SOCIAL REFORM.
to
igg
his
stay
in
Rome,
ments.
He
all
his
move-
he openly before
all
men walked
the
way
his con-
When
fallibility
way
it
became
make
its
reception
all
the
Ketteler,
555.
BISHOP KETTELER.
190
and special,
arrangements were made with the clergy of St.
Christopher's Church, so that the six hundred officers quartered in the town might have Mass regularly. On Whit Monday 1 50 soldiers were solemnly
confirmed in the Cathedral.*
As soon as it became known that the question of
at Versailles,
s.
to
SOCIAL REFORM.
brought freedom
to the
191
it
seemed, per-
had already
proved abortive.
Pressure of business,
Bismarck
first
Reichstag.
On
13
February,
made a deep
About the same time it became known that five electoral districts had requested him to become their
candidate for the Reichstag.
After some hesitation
he decided
Pfulf,
in favor of
Tauberbischofsheim in
II, p. 253.
ss.
BISHOP KETTELER.
192
and of
entitled
religious liberty.
In a splendid
little
the First
work
German
Reichstag, Ketteler gave his constituents a faithful account of his parliamentary activity,
exposed
body
SOCIAL REFORM.
and made no
him
to resign
the Bishop
193
which induced
Before bidding farewell to Berlin
two more attempts to convince
made
Aug. Reichensperger,
II, pp.
49
s.
CHAPTER
XV.
1871.
of
pseu do- Liberalism which held the
THEpower
Germany and which the Bishop had
reins
in
had occasion to study in action on the floor of parwas the subject of Ketteler's famous discourse before the thousands of his countrymen
whom the twenty-first Catholic Congress had asliament,
sembled
in
While there is nothing so necessary for the development of the new German Empire as religious peace [he
began], nearly all the parties have set upon us and are
determined at all costs to conjure up a religious conflict.
We must not be surprised at this. It is nothing
new. There never was a time when truth and justice
ruled unopposed in the world.
The great men of every
age have always been the great fighters for justice and
.
right.
must be
therefore,
Since,
we must
To
to fight well.
fight,
this
who
He
time and
is
satisfied
to act
of his contemporaries.
too frequently
made by
us.
SOCIAL REFORM.
and
which
all
we
whole human
95
race,
easily that
it
giving
may
be best
how
they
To
way
to ulti-
descent."
There
is
of
38
BISHOP KETTELER.
196
trial.
We
Christians
Outside of
nothing but experimenting, and, if
I were a Liberal, I should experiment with Socialism.
Liberalism makes a present God of the State.
The
Liberals speak none the less of religion and Church.
This is the plainest nonsense. Socialism steps up and
" If the State is God, the historical development
says
ing by far
all
Christianity there
is
I, for my part,
a colossal imposition.
do with religion. Church or liturgy."
Liberalism wishes to rob matrimony of its religious
of Christianity
is
it
Our
on us?
will
is
as a civil contract.
" If God has not
man
mam
has
is
inviolable.
The
SOCIAL REFORM.
relating
to
live
At present the
good things of
of men
human
igy
state of things.
The
title to
property
is
God,
if
the law
is
absolute,
who can
is
derived
to the
the present
The
Socialists
we
eternity;
answer
"
We
also
priestcraft.
with
this life
There-
BISHOP KETTELER.
198
there
that
says
an
is
eternity,
is
when
right
sensual
that
enjoy-
its
men
and
classes
promise,
has
it
than any
set
estates.
But instead of
up a more brutal distinction
known
more
till
then
This
^money.
not
counterbalanced by distinction of rank as in former
times, nor toned down by the spirit of Christianity and
distinction
is
all the
hvuniliating because
it
is
day
to day.
idle
phrase.
acquisition
it
it
de-
this life;
it
is
controlled by
money;
it
who
man
man;
it
Government
excluded
it
will dare to
offices
who
service.
SOCIAL REFORM.
which
is
rich,
199
word,
all equality in
It destroys, in a
regard to the enjoyment of material
world.
which
Away
is
it is
because Christianity
is
BISHOP KETTELER.
200
sequently set
as necessary condi-
all the
order.
is
The
a fatal illusion.
doc-
certain
into
strata
of
the people,
but
incapable of un-
itself so utterly
it is,
its
No
it
lives in
its
its
hollow phrase.
When
people,"
translate
it
is
it
" Everything
through
Liberalism
is
it
people.
we who are
You represent
who
work
in the sweat of
our brow.
we
we workmen,
If
true.
we
sistent.
The
it is
we who
are
God
Socialism
who
the
of
possess
is
little
right.
Modern Liberalism
manoeuvre which
is
incon-
consists, in theory,
SOCIAL REFORM.
people,
etc.,
201
and, in practice, of
This
is
wrong
the situation
lies in their
Their power
and the
them with
their
We
elections.
own weapons.
single
must fight
good organiza-
tion
is
tions,
that
is
The
future belongs to
self-evident
how
consists solely
'
* Liberalistnus,
third edit
Socialismus,
und Christentum.
Mainz,
1871,
BISHOP KETTELER.
202
Mainz.'
that
it
can accept
looks on those
it
tion.
I
Briefe, p. 532.
CHAPTER
XVI.
1873.
ON
10 March, 1873, Bismarck delivered his famous Kulturkampf speech in the Prussian
House of Lords.
After proclaiming his divorce
from the Conservatives and his Liberal predilec-
tions,
lics to
The work
The
is
Ket-
Catholics in
BISHOP KETTELER.
204
framers of
its
of
its
This dis-
Programm
Decem-
of 13
my
since 1848,
"
The program itself, however, is the most crushing answer to Bismarck's ravings about political
dualism and Papal intrigues.
The Catholics,
though streams of Catholic blood had helped to bind
together the foundation stones of the new empire,
were calumniated as enemies of the empire {Reichsfeinde), as ultramontanes, as spies of a foreign
Ketteler,
who was
in
gram
1
to
Quoted by Pfulf,
III, p. 265.
SOCIAL REFORM.
ness to the real aims
205
proposals.
In the public
life of
how
to get
Numbers
it.
we have
we have
in the past.
so often
If,
there-
edit., p. vii.
BISHOP KETTELER.
2o6
alone can
are entitled.
German empire,
demand with equal candor for the other religious
The principles laid down by me can be acbodies.
rights I claim for the Catholics in the
I
who
all
Germany.
in
There
is
gram from becoming the program of all believing Christians, and I could call it a program for all right-minded
Christian men.*
its
significance,
PROGRAM.
I.
II.
Op.
cit.,
pp. 2-3.
in 1878.
SOCIAL REFORM.
III.
207
This
is
This
is
Art
Art.
abrogated in
1873.
Cf. Art.
workmen,
etc.
BISHOP KETTELER.
2o8
and
and
state ad-
ministrations.^"
management of
c.
State
d.
e.
Exemption of the
railways.^'
necessaries
of
from
life
taxation.
workmen
Protection of
the workman's
strength by laws
rest.
XIII. Prohibition of
all
secret
societies,
especially of
Freemasonry.^*
10 This
ii
April,
1877,
with
its
seat in
Leipsic.
"^^
1885,
1894,
1900, 1905.
" Law
of 27 July, 1885.
18 Realized at the end of the 'seventies.
SOCIAL REFORM.
The Program
209
commentaries
is
in
The
to
legislative
1.
The
protect
the
workingman and
enactments against
all
his
demand from
give back to
it
family by
unjust exploitation.
them what
it
deprived them
It is
afiEected.
The
labor question
social question
entirety.
Hence
dissolution
is
that
we have
and reorganization of
its
society in general
and
under
authorities,
4. that the
the
surveillance
of
the
ordinary
administrative
BISHOP KETTELER.
2IO
The
ing-classes.^^
and
The
phases as the old State and the old social order.
Physiocrats of the last century made the organization
of labor responsible for all the economic evils of the
people, instead of looking for their true origin in
degeneration,
egotistical
its
ossification,
in
the
its
patent
it
were
excluded from
still
tion
of
their
They applied
working-classes.
State vested
^' See
Art.
in
VIII
commentary.
^* Englaender,
I,
pp. 17-20.
the
Geschichte
Program
and
der franzos.
the
corresponding
Arbeiterassociationen,
SOCIAL REFORM.
211
side,
National Assembly
Such too
volution.
merely the
politics
its
spirit of its
and of
its
the
spirit
of
not
being a product of Liberalism, is on the contrary a reaction against the unnaturalness of its pretended natural
law.
ing-classes
'.
he
to
tries to get
allows the
workman
to
combine with
him a means
of escape
way
his
affords
Empire
BISHOP KETTELER.
classes are
to
the future.
2.
demand from
not only
made a
ment with
his employer.
when
These
entering on an agree-
is
niunerous unsuccessful strikes and their deplorable consequences, to say nothing of the fact that coalitions are
in
no right
to
it
By
wise
We
Trade-
SOCIAL REFORM.
213
States.
Hence new
wants the age of employment for children in facand away from home to be raised to fourteen.
But even this age does not seem to him to be advanced enough, " as children of fourteen cannot do
without the pure atmosphere of the family and
have not yet acquired the moral strength necessary
to resist the influence of bad environment."
Married women must be forbidden to work in
factories or at other employment away from home.
Girls may be permitted to work in factories only
on condition that their workshops are completely
" Unless the
separated from those of the men.
Christian family is restored to the working-classes
all other remedies will be vain.
But if the mother
is snatched from her sacred home duties and turned
into a wage-earning workwoman, there can be no
tories
rea-
sons
to
work
in
factories
and
BISHOP KETTELER.
914
spectors as
visors
^*
" If this
movement was
still
The
in its begins
SOCIAL REFORM.
215
were
needed,
'^
DU
p. riii.
CHAPTER XVI
I.
of his activity.
full
linckrodt's speeches,
position invited the poisoned shafts of his adverit also drew toward him the loving venerand unfaltering trust of his fellow com" In the best room of my father's house,
batants.
saries;
ation
'
'
High
Mumbauer,
SOCIAL REFORM.
217
graved
'
years
tive
The Champions
Many
Justice.'
when
of Truth,
left to
Freedom and
it
na-
was
my
and when
man
my father,
whom the
Church
is
preserved to us in
me
be-
'
'
BISHOP KETTELER.
and
their rights
works:
"The
it.
Two
years
he defended the Jesuits against the silly accusation that their superiors can command what is
later
sinful.
Ketteler's
struggle in Germany.
The
1873,
"The
Prussian
Law
Catholic majority, now, on the contrary, the Protestant majority arrogated to itself the right to de-
Catholic Church.
The only way to secure a lasting peace, he said, was to return to the old wellapproved principle of allowing each religious body
SOCIAL REFORM.
to regulate its
the question, "
own
affairs.
Why
In 1876 he discussed
appeared
title "
The
May
Laws."
It
The
bears the
On
219
Church."
much
man and
Kulturkampf
when the
Germany vied with one another to do
" The amount of work done by the
Catholics of
him honor.
dom.
the State
is
Church from
BISHOP KETTELER.
220
if
liberty
is
and
and
thrive.
On
An
Duke was
mics.
as ineffec-
SOCIAL REFORM.
221
fact that
The
Old Catholics, the fines and threats of imprisonment, the bereavement of so many parishes, the
banishment of devoted nuns and brothers from the
schools and hospitals, the ruin of innumerable
works he had spent himself to rear and bring to
perfection, Ketteler's interest in the social question
never abated. With keen and penetrating glance
he followed every phase of its development. The
latest sociological works were always to be found
on his table, and on his journeys he invariably
carried such works with him.
His secretary had
to collect and arrange all the important newspaper
articles dealing with the subject, no matter from
what point of view Catholic, Protestant, Conservative, Liberal or Socialistic.
Among his papers
Father Pfiilf found numerous sketches with head-
Working
Question," "
the
Red
International,"
Marriage and
Consequences for the Working Classes," " The
BISHOP KETTELER.
222
Woman,
Christian
Children."
By a beautiful
Pastorals
On my episcopal visitation
tours last year," he begins the one for 1876, " I
tions
of his
pen.
"
We
rightly
but perhaps
we
that they are also the right road to temporal happiness, nay, that, for the generality of
mankind, they
below."
After explaining the true meaning of the term
" welfare of the people " as contained in the words
of Holy Writ: " Give me neither beggary, nor
riches give me only the necessaries of life," ^ he
treats of the virtues of temperance, economy, and
chastity, to which he adds, as being of the highest importance for the public welfare, " the Chris:
"
Of
all
the re-
medies required to solve the so-called social question," he says, " the first and most indispensable
by far is the promotion of family life. The philanthropist who does not see this is a fool and with
all his well or ill-meant remedies only beats the air."
which
Prov. 30
8.
is
dated
February, 1877.
" It
is
with
SOCIAL REFORM.
223
world,
but
also
He
law
whose observance became painful only when imposed as a punishment for sin as a law for all
men, but directly and immediately laid on the male
portion of mankind; as a law the observance of
which alone entitles us to eat, to enjoy the things
of earth.
He next describes the manifold ways in
which this law is violated by men and women in
every station in life and the sad consequences of
such transgressions.
In conclusion he lays down
",
^to
work because
it
the will of
God;
to
BISHOP KETTELER.
224
In the closing sentences Ketteler sums up the experiences of his whole life in the field of social
They read
like
his
social
testament.
The most
is
asunder, because
God
there
is
no
Among
these
knowledge of
knowledge of God is not, there morality succumbs in
the struggle with sin, with selfishness and sensuality,
with the lust of the eyes, the lust of the flesh, and the
pride of life.
But where morality is not, there is no
means left of making the people happy and prosperous.
In such a state men are ruled by their passions. They
are the slaves of the tyrants of avarice and lust, in whose
service the powerful oppress the weak, and the weak, in
up against the powerful, and, if they conbecome the willing tools of the selfsame tyrants
their passions; war without end will be waged between
the rich and the poor ; peace on earth among them is imtheir turn, rise
quer,
possible.
Intimately, inseparably
is
per-
God
God
whom
but in a truly
poor will
manner.*
^
always
be
Hirtenbriefe, p. 923.
adjusted
in
the
best
possible
i
CHAPTER XVIIL
The Christian Workman and the
Labor Party.
the
IN new
member
Socialistic
1877.
from
It
Now
in
it
begins
that the Socialistic
numbers and
Labor Party
is
daily growing
workingman
invitation
to act as
a serious
* Pfiilf,
interest in the
BISHOP KETTELER.
226
feel
more
the
all
obliged to discuss
it
called
upon and
in
a measure
pletely.
movement national
in character
and confined
the amelioration of labor conditions has been succeeded by one that relegates practical reform proposals
to the background and aims at the transformation of
existing social conditions in regard to the acquisition
at the
inauguration of
apply to present
in order to be able to answer the question,
whether a Catholic workman can join the Socialistic
Labor Party, we must acquaint ourselves with the aims
fair to
But
it
really want.
in this matter
To make
is
his
To
answer
such
as are only in
SOCIAL REFORM.
227
to
those
who
'
lasts.
.'
"
The
words,
" for
s)rstem
lasts ",
as
the
time
that
the
present
social
new
State, described in
BISHOP KETTELER.
228
There
is
danger
too
of
the
workman
aside
and
ask
laboring
If
him
we were
what he
confidentially
three heads
organization
Only the
The
classes, State
first
of these
demands
is
fully treated.
same as
Labor Question.
Absolutism, the French Revolution, and
Liberalism, economic and political, were according
to Ketteler the progenitors of the labor question and
line of
argument
is,
of Socialism.
and
the
Socialism, he says,
is
right in de-
SOCIAL REFORM.
229
Modern Socialism
changed.
In
its
a legitimate
is
is
it
men
child
of
no room
knows but one me-
is,
is
Hence
itself.
dif-
has never
all
ing
is
it
is
not
instead of bring-
them
into
scribes,
it
But
this
at all
all
forced union
is
species
We
in depriving
them of
It is the
same
with men.
ture does.
as thoroughly as na-
own
all
established by
No
all
God?
dissolution of
class stands so
much
man
in
No
give to
help and protection.
The help
and protection given to man by organization enable
him to develop his whole personality, to make full use
He who
of the powers and faculties within him.
On
has wealth finds help and protection in his wealth.
zations
the
BISHOP KETTELER.
230
have arisen.
afiiicted
workman is only
movement that promises
lessness, the
every
himself into the arms of every fool or lying demagogue.
To
basis
is
have
will
to
am
efforts
To
insure
The
(1)
desired
organizations must be
growth {naturwiichsig)
that
is,
of
natural
and
its faith,
Middle Ages.
The
Social-
(4)
same
all
class.
in
it
If,
SOCIAL REFORM.
231
far
pressed in the
first
article of the
for he jotted
down a remark
Labor Party
is
labor
to
its
attain
Gotha platform,
end by
unjustifiable
it
wants
means
^the
Marxian Socialism,
is
based, viz.
of
enjoyment
{consumption
goods),
whilst
all'
IX
of the present
BISHOP KETTELER.
232
should, for
to
to
by
is
men
in all
He
alone
able to vanquish
is
In the name of the Christian Workingmen's Associaof Augsburg, the undersigned express to Your
Lordship their deepest veneration and at the same time
their most heartfelt thanks for the warm sympathy Your
Lordship has on so many occasions manifested for the
tion
interests of
the working-classes.
The Bishop
Your
replied,
friendly
me
under date of
appreciation
my
of
May, 1877:
endeavors
has
touched
in your
deeply.
jotted
a
E"
-tift-J
>
CL,
o
a
m
pq
C^
O
Q
pq
H
<
cj
a o
03
00
SOCIAL REFORM.
233
and with
Christ.
It is
last
harmony and
we
can establish
fraternity, of true
humanity."
On
St.
1877.
Joseph, 21
ought
to celebrate
it.
"
and
and
suffering.
Except-
Briefe, p. 536
Hirtenbriefe, p. 925.
s.
BISHOP KETTELER.
234
He
had,
it
drawing
to
is
represent
his
true, repeatedly
and he wished
to take leave of
him, little suspecting that his own end was so near.
He arrived in Rome on 1 1 May and took up his
" I cannot tell you," he
residence in the Anima.
said to the Rector on their first walk to St. Peter's,
"
to a close
how happy
feel
when
am
in
Rome."
The
"
love
from church
before.
to church,
To
and
My
SOCIAL REFORM.
235
Shortly
with the rest of the pilgrims from Mainz.
into
the
after twelve o'clock the Pope was carried
After
the
hall and took his place on the throne.
Archbanished
Latin address had been read by the
bishop of Cologne, the leaders of the various depuWhen the jubilee gift of the
tations advanced.
diocese of Mainz was about to be presented and the
word " Mainz " struck the ears of the Pope, he said
in a loud voice: " But where is the Bishop of
Mainz?" Told that the Bishop was present but
BISHOP KETTELER.
236
"
Dei."
Vestrae,"
tatis
Ketteler
replied.
moned to
who was
Holy
On
the
way from
and
resisted,
He
broke out
in
had
",
SOCIAL REFORM.
237
bed.
break his
what God
maxim
spirit or
intellect.
earth "
Heaven on
mother he had made
wills
of his
cloud his
is
and he remained
faithful to
it
his
in death.
"
To
will
this favorite
own
in life
When
one
Death
is
be done."
prayer
the hand
Heaven,
of death
had
dying hours. ^
When
Church
Germany was
just
entering upon
its
ray of light
Thousands
Letzte
BISHOP KETTELER
238
The
at his feet.
Latin inscription
tells
the visitor
that "
39
15.
issued,
but
SOCIAL REFORM.
239
champion
When the
il rogo non vive ira nemica."
voice of the " fighting Bishop " was hushed and
" Oltre
to
"
The
fight-
is
The
a silent corpse.
Ecclesia militans
she will not easily forget and whose place she will
to
flags at half-mist
who have
lost
fill.
Well may they hang their
and chant funeral hymns, they
him.
And
if
come home
did
it
to them, if they
days when they
trembled for his life, they will realize it when, as
the battle proceeds, this warrior of indomitable will
and piercing vision shall be missing from the lines.
Germany had had few bishops who can compare
in knowledge and practical wisdom with this Westphalian nobleman."
Of all the eulogies bestowed
on him that of our gloriously reigning Pontiff is
not
experience
in
the
BISHOP KETTELER.
240
"
We
1,
were rejoiced
to
to the president of
Ketteler's
men whose
his
works
adopt
re-
and
to
fence of religion."
10 Official
191 1.
p. 521.
in the practice
and de-
^^
For Latin
CHAPTER
"
XIX.
Dead, yet
Speaks."
^^"1^7"
HEN
VY
lics
death
Goyau,
" the
surprised
German
Ketteler,"
says
^
He could have
added And the social reforms demanded by Ketteler have been for the most part realized.
We have seen how the hands of the Catholic representatives in the German parliament were tied by
the Kulturkampf. The Liberals had an overwhelming majority in the Imperial Diet and in the various State Legislatures, and every bill brought in
by the Centre, no matter what its nature might be,
was a priori doomed to be voted down. The legpislative mills were so busy turning out anti- Catholic
laws that there was no time for social work, even
if the Government had been minded
which it was
not to promote it.
As soon, however, as an opening appeared, the
Centre came forward with a Labor Protection Bill,
It was the first bill of the kind
19 March, 1877.
ever placed on the table of the Reichstag ^ and bore
the name of Count Ferdinand von Galen, a nephew
of Bishop Ketteler.
In scope it was identical with
Goyau, Ketteler,
The
first
II April, 1877.
p. xlvii.
Social-Democratic
Labor
Bill
was introduced on
BISHOP KETTELER.
242
Art.
XII
debate showed
The
One
Herr
was
as a sealed book to him that he could not see what
" the Christian social order of the world " had
Liberal, a certain
To another it looked
medieval chronicle, a
story of Franks and Burgundians."
Bebel wanted
to know " whether the Christian social order of the
world dated from the time when Gregory VII ruled
supreme, or when Leo X squandered indulgence
money in Rome; from the Peasant War, or from
that epoch of Christianity when the first Christians
lived a communistic life?"
Lasker called the Bill
" a piece of folly ", and Secretary of State Hoffman regarded it as a " provocation of the Government, as a serious attack on the economic policy
heretofore pursued by the Chancellor."
The same
statesman was at a loss to know where, in a rational
factory law, a place could be found for the demand
for rest on Sundays and Feast Days.
For these
and other equally weighty reasons he asked that the
Bill be killed then and there without doing it the
honor of committing it. As the majority of the
House did not think it advisable to quash in so
brutal a manner a Bill behind which stood lOO representatives of the people, this suggestion was not
acted on.
The Bill was accordingly referred to a
committee of 21 members
10 Liberals, 10 Conservatives and Centrists, and one Socizdist.
The
ten Liberals and the solitary Socialist succeeded
to do with factory legislation.
like " a chapter from some
SOCIAL REFORM.
in
burying
it,
243
upon
it
satire.
Galen
Bill ?
Minister of
protection of the workingman's health, for the protection of youth, for the separation of the sexes,
tian
solved
II
Bill
July,
Worship and in the same month the Government made the first overtures to Windthorst.
The ship was being gradually cleared for action.
On 17 November, 1881, William I sent the famous message, known as " the great message ", to
istry of
(No. 172).
BISHOP KETTELER.
244
own
the
demand
made
its
This
is
not the
weak points of
the insurance laws enacted between 1883 and 1889.*
They are stamped with the stamp of Bismarck:
place to discuss the merits and the
and underrating
ture.
flattered
himself that
question with
morality.
in 1904
SOCIAL REFORM.
245
The Conference was still in session when Bismarck was dismissed from office (20 March). The
labor question was the rock upon which he finally
split.
as the
The
The
main
general elections,
issue,
with social
had broken up
reform
May was devoted to labor-protective legislation, and the Emperor expressed the firm hope that salutary laws
would, with the help of God, be enacted without
unnecessary delay. Thus urged on, the legislators
went about their task with energy and good will.
at the opening of the Reichstag on 6
The
is,
what was
left
we wish
BISHOP KETTELER.
246
Novarum.
the
working^an and
animated by Ketteler's
spirit.
his family
The
were
Catholic Con-
thousand
cities,
like
a net-
/
'<
V>