Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Effect of Foster Care on Childrens Emotional, Social Development, and Education
Derrick Daniels, Caroline Fletcher, and Claire Palermo-Re
Bridgewater College
Abstract
This paper explores the effects that foster care has on a childs emotional development,
brain development, social development, and education. Children who have a secure attachment
to their foster parent were found to have better outcomes than those who had a weaker
attachment. When children form this attachment early in their childhood, they are able to
socially interact with other children regardless of their background. A childs educational
attainment tends to improve once they are in a stable foster home. Overall, foster care homes
provide a safe, caring environment where children who were previously in a worse situation are
able to overcome these problems and have a better life.
The Effect of Foster Care on Childrens Emotional, Social Development, and Education
Introduction
Many different aspects such as stability at home, resources such as shelter and food,
social interactions, and quality of life can impact the development of a child. From previous
research, it is clear that foster care can have a large impact on a child. This impact can range
from troubles in school to language acquisition (Stock & Fisher, 2006). In 2009, there were
542,000 children in foster care in the United States (Bruskas, 2009). That is a large number of
kids who are seeing the benefits of foster care. Requirements for becoming a foster parent differ
from state to state. According to the Virginia Department of Social Services [VDSS], in the state
of Virginia, there is no minimum income for an adult to apply to be a foster parent (2013). While
this means that anyone can apply, many questions for foster parents will likely be centered on if
the adult can financially support someone else in their family. In addition, it is not necessary for
there to be two married adults to apply. Single parents can be foster parents as well (VDSS,
2013). The Virginia Department of Social Services says Children who need foster families have
been removed from their birth family homes for reasons of neglect, abuse, abandonment, or other
issues endangering their health and/or safety (2013). These children have been taken away from
their parents for their own good. Often times they are very confused and do not always
understand why they are being taken away from their home.
Compared to being in an institution or in a home with kin, being placed in a foster family
can improve the life for these children (Font, 2014). Through our research we have found that
kids placed in a foster care home do better than kids who are in an institution or even kids who
are in the care of a relative. Research has also found that the age kids are when placed in foster
care can affect their education. The earlier a child is placed in foster care, the better these
children do on language tests (Windsor et al., 2011). This has also been proven true for the
reading scores of these children. This shows how beneficial foster care can be for these children
who end up in foster homes.
Readers will benefit from this study because they will see the importance of foster
homes. If people are unsure about the benefits of the foster care system this study will help show
how helpful they can be for a child in a troublesome situation. Taking a child out of a bad
situation and placing them in foster care can greatly benefit their lives and help improve their
emotional and brain development, educational and literacy outcomes, and social development.
This research is important because it will highlight the impact that becoming a foster family or
parent can have on the lives of these children.
Review of Literature
Emotional/Brain Development
One concern people have with foster care is they worry that it will affect the children's
emotional development. They worry that the children will not be able to bond with their
caregivers. However, infants that are placed in foster care still bonded with their caregivers
(Dozier, Stovall, Albus, & Bates, 2001). These babies knew that if they cried and needed
something, they could rely on their caregiver to provide for them. Research has also examined
how children in foster care compare to children who have been placed in institutions. In most
cases children in foster care were more emotionally developed than kids in institutions. One
study took kids who were institutionalized and randomly selected a group of them to be put into
a foster care home. Then they compared them to the kids who were randomly chosen to stay in
the institutions. They were also compared to kids who had never been in an institution. A study
of children placed into a foster care home indicated that foster children showed a more positive
reaction and more attention in the two episodes of a television program they were shown (Ghera
et al., 2009). The short time they spent in foster care had already positively affected them. The
kids were tested at 30 and 42 months. At the 42 month test, kids who were placed in foster care
paid better attention to emotion-eliciting tasks (Ghera et al., 2009). They did better than kids who
had never been in foster care and the kids who were institutionalized.
Children in foster care compared to children who are institutionalized have better brain
development. Institutionalized children have smaller brain volume (Nelson, Fox, & Zeanah,
2013). This may be due to various reasons. Children in institutions are surrounded by many
children and not as many adults. The amount of words they are exposed to is probably
significantly less than kids in a foster care which could be a reason their brain volume is smaller.
Kids in institutions also have more other emotional problems that kids in foster care do not have.
One study found that 62 percent of kids in institutions by the time they were 5 years old had
diagnoses that ranged from anxiety disorders, which was 44 percent, to attention deficit
hyperactivity disorder or ADHD, which was 32 percent (Nelson et al., 2013).
Researchers have also looked to see how time can affect a childs emotional
development. They determined that kids have about two years to receive intimate physical and
emotional contact or else their personal development will be hindered (Nelson et al., 2013). If
when they are upset they are not comforted or when they need something someone does not
provide for them, they will have trouble forming a secure attachment. Kids who have a secure
attachment know that when they need something their caregiver will be there for them. This
relates to attachment theory. According to attachment theory there are three types of attachment:
the child start feeling more secure and begin to grow in their emotional development. They begin
to have a secure attachment with their caregiver. One study has shown how long-term foster
caregivers can provide a secure base for kids who were mistreated and can help the kids feel like
they belong (Frey et al., 2007).
Education
Movement of Foster Children between Schools
Some research looks into the impact that moving frequently has on a childs education.
By moving so frequently, children in foster cares education is incredibly inconsistent (Bruskas,
2008). Between moving into new houses and adjusting to new families, these children are
constantly being forced to adapt to new situations and scenarios. These children are missing days
of school during moves and transferring to different schools all too often (Bruskas, 2008). This
can create a sense of stability for children in the foster care system. For many of them, their life
has been a series of changes and moving. By ensuring that they are given the opportunity to stay
at the same school, they can have a sense of normalcy in their lives. Their friends may be the
only constant in their lives during turmoil, so ensuring that they can remain in one place will be
reassuring for the children.
Language Development
Differences in language development can also be seen in children in the foster care
system. Typically, there seems to be a delay in these childrens acquisition and development of
language (Stock & Fisher, 2006). Compared to infants in institutions, infants in foster care had
significantly better language development outcomes (Windsor et al., 2011). When placed in a
more stable home by the age of 24 months, children and infants were more likely to use a variety
of words and phrases to communicate than those that were in an institution (Windsor et al.,
2011). By finding a home for these children in the foster care system, it can really benefit their
education in the future. Predictors at a young age such as the age of placement can impact their
education for the future. Fisher and Stock (2006) argued that little differences in early language
development of an infant can impact a childs education into the future. Research has shown
that language delays have negative long-term effects on social competence and mental health, as
well as IQ and academic achievement (Fisher & Stock, 2006, p.447). With a limited language
background, children in the foster care system tend to be less successful in the classroom.
According to a study, 35% to 73% of children in the foster care system exhibit signs of language
delays (Fisher & Stock, 2006). This statistic shows that it is an extremely prevalent problem, but
also one that is hard to measure accurately.
Legal Responses
The Education Initiative Project is attempting to help foster children in their problems
with school. Many studies have compared foster children to children not in foster care and their
educational differences. Based on the research, it is found that the children in foster care tend to
be falling behind with attendance, having discipline problems, not performing up to grade level
in academics, and an increased number placed with special education services (Zetlin, Weinberg,
& Shea, 2006). This initiatives goal is to help advocate for these students to get the help and
assistance they need while in school. A study done by this group found that the children that
received their services showed an increase in their educational outcomes than those that were not
served by someone from the group (Zetlin, et al., 2006). By providing services and focusing on
each child as an individual, the children in foster care showed an improvement in their
educational attainment that will hopefully continue to benefit them throughout their years in
school.
With so many difficulties in these childrens lives, there have been significant strides in
attempting to improve their experience with the education system. National and state
governments have passed laws that are keeping the best interests of these children in mind. There
is one federal law in particular that was passed in 2008 that really benefits children in the foster
care systems education. Congress passed the Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing
Adoptions Act which was the first time anything like this was passed that looked into benefiting
the children (Chambers & Palmer, 2010). This law allows children to stay at the same school
after they enter or leave different foster care homes. In addition, if staying in the same home
would hurt the child more than benefit them, the student will be switched to another school right
away so that they do not miss too much instruction at their new school (Chambers & Palmer).
New York and Texas are two states that have passed statewide legislation to alleviate the
problems the children in foster care are experiencing in their schools. The state of Texas has
taken a stand against this problem and is focused on ensuring that these children do not
experience problems in their education. The Texas Blueprint suggests ways in which we can
improve the education for these children while in the foster care system (Chiamulera, 2015). A
child in foster care has a right to remain in the same school regardless of whether the child
enrolled in school before or after entering foster care and the child is entitled to remain in that
school through the highest grade offered even if the child exists foster care while enrolled
(Chiamulera, 2015). This is just one example of states that have identified the problem and are
attempting to make the educational system better for these children that are struggling with
11
unorganized attachment with one or many caregivers. 66% of children who have been adopted
by 4 months of age, show secure attachment to their new guardians (Dozier et al., 2001). This is
because the children are able to develop an attachment with their new guardian at such an early
age. On the other hand only 37% of children showed secure attachments with their new guardian
after 8 months or more in a foster care system (Dozier et al., 2001). This shows that there is a
small window of opportunity to make sure the child will develop a secure attachment. With an
insecure attachment, the child will struggle to listen to authority and may lash out at other
children. A healthy and successful attachment will make sure the child has the best opportunity to
develop their social and behavioral skills.
Procedures/Methods
In order to determine what effect foster care has on a childs development, specific
questions were formed to ask the parents how they viewed their child. To begin with, the first
section asked for basic information about the child in the foster care system and their foster
family. Dozier, Windsor, Nelson, Ghera, Bruskas, and Font all used questions that gained insight
into the background of the foster care family. We wanted to know about the familys income and
the makeup of them (Dozier et al., 2001). Based on the number of siblings a child has in their
foster home, it could affect their ability to form relationships with others in social situations
(Ghera et al., 2009). We also asked if the child has been diagnosed with any behavioral,
attentional, or other disabilities that could affect their emotional development, social
development, or educational attainment. The questions that came from Ghera looked into if there
were any biological siblings for the foster child and if they lived together. Dozier researched the
adults and family life scenario that this foster child is experiencing.
Survey Instrument
Survey of Effectiveness of Foster Care
NAME:________________________________
Instructions: Primary caregiver, please indicate the extent to which you agree with each
statement below (in relation to your own experiences) by darkening the circle in the appropriate
column.
Emotional and Brain Development:
Disagre
Neutra
Agre
Strongly
Agree
Strongly
Disagree
himself/herself.
9. The child appears comfortable in
your home.
10. Do you include your child in making
family decisions?
Social Development
11. My child interacts well with other
children around him/her.
12. My child responds well to
authoritative figures including teachers,
parents, etc.
13. My child has many friends who
he/she interacts with at home, school,
etc.
14. My child spends more than three
hours straight alone a day.
Strongly
Disagre
Neutra
Agre
Strongly
Disagree
Agree
Education
Science:
Social Studies:
English:
Math:
References
Almas, A. N., Degnan, K. A., Walker, O. L., Radulescu, A., Nelson, C. A., Zeanah, C. H., & Fox,
N. A. (2015). The Effects of Early Institutionalization and Foster Care Intervention on
Children's Social Behaviors at the Age of Eight. Social Development,24(2), 225-239.
doi:10.1111/sode.12089
Bass, S., Shields, M., & Behrman, R. (2004). Children, Families, and Foster Care: Analysis and
Recommendations. The Future of Children, 14(1), 4-29. Retrieved September 26, 2015,
from JSTOR.
Bruskas, D. (2008). Children in Foster Care: A Vulnerable Population at Risk. Journal Of Child
& Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing,21(2), 70-77. doi:10.1111/j.1744-6171.2008.00134.x
Chambers, C., & Palmer, E. (2010). Educational Stability for Children in Foster Care. Touro Law
Review, 26(1). 1103-1130.
Chiamulera, C. (2015). The Texas Blueprint -- A Model for Improving School Experiences for
Children in Foster Care. Child Law Practice, 34(8), 113-121.
Dozier, M., Stovall, K., Albus, K., & Bates, B. (2001). Attachments for Infants in Foster Care:
The Role of Caregiver State of Mind. Child Development, 72(5), 1467-1477.