Heatwheel Comparison

James Lee
Introduction
y BryAir
y Enventus
y Heatex
y Seibu
 Basic Comparison
Bry Air Enventus Heatex Seibu
Origin India Sweden Sweden Japan
Make China China China China
Maximum Rotor 5000mm 5000mm 2500mm 4600mm
diameter
Performance report Eurovent / ARI Eurovent Eurovent / ARI Eurovent
Fire Report Yes N/A Yes Yes
Anti-bacteria report N/A N/A Yes Yes
Anti-mold report Yes N/A N/A Yes
Leakage report Yes Yes Yes Yes
Lead time 8~10 weeks 4 ~6 weeks 3 weeks 6~8 weeks
HK Agent Glory / Paul N/A N/A Carrier
Chan
 Construction Comparison
Bry Air Enventus Heatex Seibu
Construction Frame Frame Frame Frame
Casing Painted GI Painted GI Painted GI Painted GI
Rotor Aluminum Aluminum Aluminum Aluminum
Rotor thickness SG – 200 mm 200 mm 200 mm 200 mm
MS – 200 mm/
270 mm
Well Height N/A Extra Low / Low 1.5/1.7/2.0 mm N/A
/ Normal / High
Coating SG – silica gel HX1 – silica gel Silica gel HI-PANEX-ION
MS – 3A HM1 – 3A
Motor 3Ph / 380V / 3Ph / 380V / 3Ph / 380V / 3Ph / 380V /
50Hz 50Hz 50Hz 50Hz
Clean sector Option 5° Option 6°
Performance Comparison
y Example
10,800 CMH / 3 CMS
OA condition (DB/WB): 33/28oC
RA condition (DB/WB): 24/18oC
Performance Comparison
Brand Model Total Load Sensible Latent Efficiency
Load Load
SG200-1500 92 23 69 69.3%

BryAir MS200-1500 89 25 64 67%

MS270-1500 101 26 75 76.3%

HX1-Nor-1500 78.9 22.4 56.5 56.6%

HX1-Low-1500 85.5 23.8 61.7 61.3%

Enventus
HM1-Nor-1500 98.8 22.3 76.5 70.9%

HM1-Low-1500 104.5 23.8 80.7 74.9%

BD-015-1500 88.2 24.6 63.7 64%

Heatex BD-017-1500 85.6 23.8 61.8 61%

BD-020-1500 79.4 22.4 57.0 57%

Seibu PAC-1500 87.95 24.49 63.46 68.4%

 Performance Comparison
Brand Model Claimed Calculated Calculated
Efficiency Efficiency Efficiency
Based on kW Based on
Condition
SG200-1500 69.3% 65.6% 68.7%

BryAir MS200-1500 67% 63.5% 65.9%

MS270-1500 76.3% 72.0% 76.1%

HX1-Nor-1500 56.6% 56.3% 67.6%

HX1-Low-1500 61.3% 61.0% 74.0%

Enventus
HM1-Nor-1500 70.9% 70.5% 67.1%

HM1-Low-1500 74.9% 74.5% 70.9%

BD-015-1500 64% 62.9% 62.9%

Heatex BD-017-1500 61% 61.1% 61.1%

BD-020-1500 57% 56.6% 56.6%

Seibu PAC-1500 68.4% 62.7% 63.0%

 Rating
Brand Model Price Cooling Load Price / Saving
Saving
SG200-1500 74,466 96.3 773

BryAir MS200-1500 78,604 92.3 852

MS270-1500 106,652 106.6 1000

HX1-Nor-1500 43,750 94.7 462

HX1-Low-1500 48,516 103.8 467

Enventus
HM1-Nor-1500 49,706 94.0 529

HM1-Low-1500 55,664 99.4 560

BD-015-1500 83,744 88.2 949

Heatex BD-017-1500 72,572 85.6 848

BD-020-1500 61,424 79.4 774

Seibu PAC-1500 51,040 88.3 578