You are on page 1of 65

TRIU LUN LC GII Tc Gi: Tng Triu i S - Lc Gii: Hm Sn i S

Vit Dch: T Kheo Thch Duy Lc ---o0o--Ngun http://thuvienhoasen.org Chuyn sang ebook 28-7-2009 Ngi thc hin : Nam Thin namthien@gmail.com Link Audio Ti Website http://www.phatphaponline.org Mc Lc
LI DCH GI BI TA CA PHP S THCH HU T I NH MINH, SA MN HM SN THCH C THANH KHUNG SN LC GII HU TN THCH TNG TRIU TRNG AN SNG TC TNG BN NGHA BI LUN TH NHT VT BT THIN BI LUN TH HAI BT CHN KHNG BI LUN TH BA BT NH V TRI TH CA TNG TRIU TR LI LU DI DN BI LUN TH T NIT BN V DANH l. KHAI TNG R NGHA 2. TM TH LP DANH 3. LP TH V DANH 4. TRCH VN LUN C 5. SIU CNH HU V 6. SU TM HUYN DIU 7. DIU O THNG TN 8. VN NN SAI BIT

9. GII P SAI BIT 10. TRCH S KHC BIT 11. DUNG THNG KHC BIT 12. CT VN NGHA TIM 13. SNG T NGHA TIM 14. CH V TM NG 15. NG TCH NHT NH 16. TRUY CU CN NGUYN 17. DUNG THNG KIM C 18. XT V S C 19. S C NHIM MU

---o0o--LI DCH GI Triu Lun l mt tuyt tc ca Ngi Tng Triu, t xa rt ni ting ti Trung Hoa, nay c dch sang ting Anh v ph bin trn th gii. Theo cn bn ca o Pht, bn th ca t tnh vn v hnh, v danh, chng th dng ngn ng vn t din t c. V vy, xa nay cc php s gio mn, tri qua nhiu i "y kinh gii ngha" thng b hn ch trong phm vi vn t, nn kh m din t ht gio l trong bin Pht. Nhng Ngi Tng Triu vi thin ti c bit, d dng vn t din t m vn siu vit ngoi vn t, nn gio l c thng sut v t n thm tm ca Pht. V li vn ngi xa thng ngn gn li qu sc tch nn ngi i nay kh hiu thu c. V li, tc gi phi dng hnh tng din t s v hnh, dng m thanh din t s v thanh, khin cho s lnh hi ca ngi thi nay cng thm kh khn bi phn. Nh li bt ca Php S Hu Tm ni: "Sau khi quyn Triu Lun ra i, c ngi cha thng sut ngha l, vit vn bi bc; nhiu ngi xem lun cm thy hoang mang hong s. Nhiu cuc bt chin ph bnh v kch ln nhau xy ra. n i Minh, Ngi Hm Sn, bc thng th bn Thin Tng, nh lun ny m ng o, thu r ngha thm su vi n ca Lun. V thy ngi i c nhiu li bn lun i chi nhau, lm cho k hu hc khng bit ch qui hng nn Ngi mi cm bt ch thch, hu gii quyt s kh hiu ca mi ngi vi mc ch lm sng t ch thm su ca Lun, gi l lc gii.

Nh m c kim khai m, u ui thng sut, mun ngn ng li qui v mt". Chng ti phi nh li ch thch ca Ngi Hm Sn lng vo chnh vn lm sng t ch thm su ca bn Lun. Chng ti c gi nguyn nhng li ch thch cn thit v lc b nhng ch khng cn. Quyn Lun ny gm : mt bi Tng Bn Ngha, bn bi lun v hai bc th ca Lu Di Dn hi v ca Ngi Tng Triu p. Trong cc bi Bt Nh V Tri, Nit Bn V Danh v hai bc th, chng ti lc b nhng phn xt thy khng phi Lun, cng nh phn ni v s tch ca Ngi Cu Ma La Thp v vua Tn. Trong bi Bt Nh V Tri, phn ni n Dch Trng ca Ngi Cu Ma La Thp c chng ti chn lm Tiu Dn cho bi, ngi i nay thu hiu c tm quan trng ca s dch Kinh. Qua bn Lun ny, tc gi t r mun cnh gic nhng ngi hc Pht m thnh ngoi o, v h hiu lm Pht, t ly mnh cho l ca Pht. Nh Ch Pht Ch T ni: Pht php l php bt nh, chng phi do li ni c nhiu khc bit m lm cho Pht php cng khc bit theo. Chng ti hy vng c gi nh Lun ny m ng nhp t tnh, ch nn dng n lm tng thm tri gii thnh chng ngi cho s chng ng. Mun tuyt i gi nguyn ca tc gi nn chng ti khng ch trng nhiu n vic trau chut li vn, xin qu c gi "c qun li", t bi hoan h cho. THCH DUY LC

---o0o--BI TA CA PHP S THCH HU T Sch ny do Php S Thch Tng Triu Trng An sng tc, gm bi Tng Bn Ngha v bn bi lun: Vt Bt Thin, Bt Chn Khng, Bt Nh V Tri, Nit Bn V Danh.

Tc gi lp lun rt hay, s din t siu vit ni nn, v phn ch th cn bn th mi cu u t n thm tm ca Pht; i vi s ging r u ui th mi li u thng sut gio l, Hu t ti may mn c sanh cng vo mt thi, gp chnh m ny (Triu Lun) mi ln c li u cm thy khch ng v cng, th nguyn i i kip kip ht lng hong dng. Pht o thn diu v hnh, du cho tm tr thng minh n mc no cng kh m t c. Bi v t tnh nhim mu, bit hiu l Bn V, nn trc tin phi dng phng tin, kin lp tng ch (Tng Bn Ngha), mn ng ngn ch by tht tng. Mun ging r php "KHNG" ca o, tm li khng ngoi hai ch "CHN" v "TC", nn k gii thch nh (Vt Bt Thin v Bt Chn Khng) hin by gio mn ca Pht. Nhng ci chnh nhn vin trn khng g hn Bt Nh, ci qu v cng tt ch c Nit Bn nn sau cng khai m tr hu trng huyn (Bt Nh V Tri) (trng huyn: huyn l nhim mu, trng huyn li thm nhim mu), sng t c qu nh ca ch Thnh (Nit Bn V Danh). D ly tnh khng lm cn bn gi, mun ni vn l tuyt ngn, chng phi ch tm tr suy lng c. Vy th tm cho bi Vt Bt Thin l tc , nhng "tc" cng chng sanh; bi Bt Chn Khng l chn , nhng "chn" ch l ngn thuyt. Nu c thm nhp vo o ny th chn tc nh u l v ngn. Nh vy, ci cng dng ca tch chiu hin hin th Bt Nh V Tri, ci c dng ca v danh khi ln th Nit Bn chng c tn gi. Hu hc ti cho rng ci thuyt ny rt l vin trn chu o, t ht gio l trong bin Pht, qung bc mnh mng cng tt th tng ca Pht Php, ch c bi Lun ny ca Ngi Tng Triu mi tht xng ng l nht m thi. Hu t ti qu ma km hc, nay lm bi ta ny gi li xin bc trit nhn tng lai ch dy cho. ---o0o--I NH MINH, SA MN HM SN THCH C THANH KHUNG SN LC GII GII : Triu l tn tc gi, gi l Tng Triu, (383-414), ngi thi y tn xng l Triu Cng, sch ny ly tn ngi lm tn Lun, nn gi l Triu Lun.

Ngi l t bc thng th ca Tam Tng Php S Cu Ma La Thp; tham hc vi Php S lu, thm nhp tht tng, theo Php S dch Kinh Dch Trng. Lc y Kinh Pht t n sang Trung Hoa rt t, i ngha cu cnh cha c thng sut; ngi thi by gi chung li h v ca Lo Trang, m bc Sa Mn Thch T phn nhiu cng ly li h v ging gii ngha l ca Pht, li t lp tn phi; nh o Hng th lp Tm V Lun, o Lm lp Tc Sc Du Huyn Lun, Trc Php Thi lp Bn V Lun, u ham thch li h v, a vo tng on dit. Ngi xt i o cha c sng t nn son bn Lun ny ph t chp ca nhng lun trn, l ca Ngi lp lun. ch "lun" l gi thit ch khch, phn tch l lun hin by chnh l, ph tan t chp vy. ---o0o--HU TN THCH TNG TRIU TRNG AN SNG TC GII : Ph Kin lp quc Quang Trung, quc hiu l i Tn, sau b Diu Trng cp ngi, quc hiu cng gi l Tn, nn s ly hai ch tin, hu phn bit. Diu Trng cht, con l Diu Hng k v, thnh Php S Cu Ma La Thp v nc dch kinh, Ngi Tng Triu cng thi y nn gi l Hu Tn. Theo tiu s ca Ngi rng: Php S Tng Triu l ngi x Kinh Triu, thu b nh ngho lm ngh vit mn nn c xem ht cc sch Ch T, B Gia, c ch ham thch h huyn, thng ly li Lo Trang lm tm yu. Sau li than rng: "Tt th tt lm, nhng cn tr ni h v, cha c cu cnh". K c xem Kinh Duy Ma Ct, rt hoan h lnh th, ni rng: "Nay mi bit c ch v". Nhn pht tm xut gia, lm bc Sa Mn, lc y tui hai mi, ting tm chn ng khp ni. Khi Php S La Thp cn C Tng, Ngi tm n y ch, Php S ni chuyn vi Ngi, kinh ngc rng : "Ngi l long tng trong Pht Php". n khi tr v Quang Trung, gip Php S La Thp khn nh Kinh Lun, hc gi bn phng tp np tm n, t ra th vn nn. Ngi gii p d dng, u vt ra ngoi tng ca mi ngi.

Ngi son bi Bt Nh V Tri Lun, Php S La Thp xem ri ni: "Kin gii ta khng hn ng, nn knh trng nhau vy". Bi Lun y truyn n L Sn, Lu Di Dn a cho Ngi Hu Vin (S T ca Tnh ) xem, c Ngi tn thn rng : "Xa nay cha tng c". Li son cc Lun kia, u tinh vi cu cnh; Vua Tn cng knh trng nhng tc phm y, cho truyn khp trong nc v ngoi nc. Ngi tch lc ba mi hai tui, ngi ng thi u than tic. ---o0o--TNG BN NGHA GII : Hai ch TNG BN l t r ci tng ch lp lun c cn bn. V bn Lun chng phi son cng mt lc, cc Lun son xong mi son bi Tng Bn Ngha ny thuyt minh bn Lun y u c h thng i vi cn bn. Bi v s lp tng ch u cn c vo tm truy cu ngun gc m ng, phm thnh v vn php. C php th phi c ngha, nn gi l Tng Bn Ngha. CHNH VN: Bn V, Tht Tng, Php Tnh, Tnh Khng, Duyn Hi, nm danh t trn vn ch c mt ngha. vch ra tng ch chnh php l cn bn ca bn Lun. Hai ch Bn V ch ngay tm tch dit vn khng mt php, la tt c tng, dt bt thnh phm, nn gi l BN V, chng phi c lm thnh v (1). V tt c php u do vng tm ty duyn bin hin m c, tm vn v sanh, ch do nhn duyn hi hp m sanh nn gi l DUYN HI. V duyn sanh ra cc php, vn khng c tht th, do nhn duyn sanh ra nn ni khng, nn gi l TNH KHNG, v php th l chn nh bin hin nn gi l PHP TNH. Do chn nh php tnh m thnh cc php, chn nh khng c tng, nn bn th cc php tch dit, nn gi l THT TNG. V bn v l th ca tm, duyn hi l dng ca tm, tht tng, php tnh, tnh khng, u l ci ngha do tm to thnh vn php nn ni l mt ngha

vy. Y theo tm php lp bn Lun ny, ly bi Vt Bt Thin lm tc , bi Bt Chn Khng lm chn , nh l cnh s qun, Bt Nh l tm nng qun, ba bi Lun trc l nhn, Nit Bn l qu, nn trc tin ly bi Tng Bn Ngha lm Tng th (tng ch ca bn th) chung cho c b lun. Ti sao vy? Tt c cc php u do nhn duyn hi hp m sanh, duyn hi m sanh th khi cha sanh khng c, duyn la th dit, nu m tht c, c th chng dit. Theo m suy ra th bit, d nay hin ra c, ci c y tnh thng t khng, v tnh thng t khng, nn gi l TNH KHNG, bi v tnh khng nn gi l PHP TNH, php tnh chn thc nh th nn gi l THC TNG,tht tng vn khng c t th, chng phi do suy lng m cho l khng, nn gi l BN V. Ni n "chng c chng khng" l ni ci c chng ging nh "ci c" ca ngi thng kin chp "tht c"; cn ni n "ci khng" cng chng phi nh ngi on kin, chp "tht khng". Nu ngi ly ci c lm c, th ly ci khng lm khng, nn chng ly "c khng" qun cc php mi c th gi l bit c tht tng ca cc php vy. D qun "c" m chng chp ly tng c, d qun "khng" m chng chp ly tng khng, vy th cc php tng l ci tng ca v tng, nn tm ca bc thnh tr ni v s tr vy. Tam tha u cng qun tnh khng m c o, tnh khng l tht tng ca cc php nn gi l chnh qun, nu thy c khc bit tc l t qun. Gi s nh tha chng thy l ny th in o ging nh phm phu ri. Cho nn tam tha qun php chng c khc nhau, ch do tm chp c ln nh m hnh thnh sai bit. Phng tin phi i i vi Bt Nh th mi c gi l i hu, tht tng ca cc php gi l Bt Nh. qun c tht tng m khng th chng l nh cng dng ca phng tin; ty theo cn c thch ng ca chng sanh m , gi l phng tin. D ra vo trong sanh t m chng nhim trn lao l nh sc tr hu ca Bt Nh; vy th ci ca ca Bt Nh l qun "khng", ci ca ca phng tin l vo "hu". Vo "hu" m cha tng m chp nn thng ni "hu" m chng nhim, chng chn "hu" m qun "khng" nn qun "khng" m khng th chng, y gi l sc lc ca mt nim, tc l quyn tr v tht tr u vy. Ngi dng cng tham cu th trong mt nim, quyn tr v tht tr u c, do , tm cnh c hin r rng.

Ni "Nit Bn Tn " tc l ci tri buc ca phin no ht, th sanh t vnh vin tiu dit, nn gi l TN thi, ch chng phi cn c ch no tn vy. GHI CH : (1) C ngha l chng phi t hu m bin thnh v, v BN V ny vt ngoi ci c v khng tng i. ---o0o--BI LUN TH NHT VT BT THIN GII : Lun ny ni tc tc chn, l cnh s qun. Ch VT l ch VN PHP, hai ch BT THIN l chng bin i, cng c ngha ch ngay th tnh tht tng ca cc php. Phm phu vng thy cc php hnh nh c lu ng v bin i; nu ly Bt Nh m qun th lin thy ngay tht tng ca cc php ngay th tnh tch dit chn thng, chng c cht tng lu ng hay bin i, nn ni chng c mt php c ng chuyn l vy. V duyn sanh nn tnh khng, nn mi php ngay vn khng bin i, chng phi tng bin i m tnh chng bin i (ngha l tnh vi tng chng khc). Thy c mi php khng bin i, nn tc vt tc chn, chn th chng c mt php no dnh dng n tnh cm, theo m qun tc th tc tc chn vy. V do ton l thnh s, s s u chn, th tht tng ca cc php ngay u c hin hin ri. LC GII Tc gi cn c vo Kinh Duy Ma Ct v Php Hoa ng nhp tht tng, nn ly bi Vt Bt Thin lm tc , tc tc m chn th ch ca Bt Thin r rng trc mt. ---o0o--CHNH VN

S sanh t lun hi, ma ng ma h thay phin bin i, hnh nh c vt lu ng, y l s hiu bit ca ngi thng, nhng ti th ni chng phi vy. Ti sao? Kinh Phng Quang Bt Nh c ni : "Cc php chng c kh lai, chng c php no ng chuyn c". Cu xt ch ca bt ng, u phi ngng ci ng cu tnh! Cn phi cu tnh ni ng, cu tnh ni ng th du cho ng cch my cng l thng tnh; chng ngng ng cu tnh th du cho tnh cch my cng chng la ng. Vy th ng v tnh cha tng c khc bit m ngi m hoc cho l bt ng, thnh ra chn ngn ca bc thnh b kt khng c hin by bi nhng ngi ham tranh bin, lm cho o Nht Tha chn tng b chn vi bi nhng ngi ham chp d kin, cho nn s ng tnh n ch cng cc khng d g ni cho ngi tin c vy. Ti sao? V nu ni chn ngn ca bc thnh th nghch vi th tc, thun theo th tc th phn bi chn ngn. Phn bi chn ngn nn m lm khng tr v t tnh c; nghch vi th tc nn li ni lt lo, chng c mi v. Nu l ngi thng cn li tr, nghe xong tin lin; bc trung cn th cha phn bit c ch c hay khng; bc h cn th v tay ci to m b i. S ng tnh n ch cng cc cnh ni ngi m ngi chng bit c, nh th c phi l tnh ca vn vt ? Lng ti lun lun ray rt, xt thng k m lm nn mi ch by ci tm trong ng v tnh hu hin by l bt nh ca ng tnh, lm cho ngi m cht tnh, ra khi s rng buc ca ng tnh, nhng chng dm quyt on l tht ng, nay ch th lun bn m thi. Kinh o Hnh Bt Nh ni: "Cc php vn khng c ni xut pht, cng khng c ch n". Trung Qun Lun ni: "Nhn phng hng ca ngi i th bit hng ca h i, nhng ngi y khng n hng y c". (V chng c phng hng tht n). u l ngay trong ng m hin by tnh, nn chng t r rng l Vt Bt Thin vy. Ngi thng cho l ng v vt xa khng n nay, nn ni l ng m chng phi tnh (mt tr lc xa, nay bin thnh gi, c bin i th l ng ri, chng phi tnh). Cn ti cho l tnh, cng l vt xa khng n nay, nn ni tnh m chng ng (theo ti xem th mt tr tr lc xa, cha tng di n nay, nn ni tnh m chng ng). Ngi chp ng m chng tnh v n chng n (v mt tr chng n, t mt tr bin thnh gi nn cho l ng).

S tht, tnh m chng ng v n khng i (v mt tr lc xa khng n nay cng nh mt gi hin nay khng n xa, nn gi l tnh). Vy th hin tng cha tng khc, nhng s thy bt ng (cng ly "vt xa khng n nay" m thy c s ng tnh chng ng). Ngi m ly tnh nghch l nn b b tc, ngi ng th t l t s nn c thng sut. Nu ng o chn thng th u cn tng no c th chng ngi c! Tnh thc ca con ngi b m hoc lu, nn i vi cnh chn tht trc mt m chng bit, tht ng thng xt! bit vt xa chng n nay m li ni vt nay c i; vt xa chng n m vt nay lm sao i c? Ti sao vy? Tm vt xa ni xa, xa cha tng khng; tm vt xa ni nay, nay cha tng c. Nay cha tng c th r rng l vt khng n; xa cha tng khng, nn bit vt chng i. Ti ni vt xa tr ni xa, chng t nay n xa; vt nay tr ni nay, chng t xa m n nay. Nn Khng T ni vi Nhan Hi rng: "Ti vi Hi va bt tay nhau th s bt tay mt ri, nh th th r rng l vt khng qua li vi nhau" (Tc gi mn li ca Khng T ch by s bin i mau l n cng cc, mi thy r rng ch t by chn tht ca Vt Bt Thin). Kinh Lng Gi ni: "Tt c php chng sanh, l ngha st na, mi sanh lin c dit, chng v k ngu thuyt". Ngi Hin Th gii rng: "V st na lu chuyn nn khng c t tnh, nu vt c t tnh th vnh vin c nh, khng c sanh dit bin i; v khng c t tnh nn khng sanh. Nu khng sanh th khng lu chuyn, v th ngi kh ng php v sanh mi thy c ngha st na". Kinh Duy Ma Ct ni: "Bt sanh bt dit l ngha v thng" (Tc gi ng tht tng, mi c ngay trong php sanh dit bin i m trc thy s chn tht ca ngha "Bt Thin", cho nn mn li vn bin i lu ng m sng t ch ca "Bt Thin", nu khng phi ngi thng t ngha v sanh th rt kh m t c). khng c mt cht triu chng qua li th lm sao c vt g lu ng bin i? K tht, v khng gian th vt khng kh lai, v thi gian th khng c c kim. Cng nh trong chim bao thy tri qua nhiu nm, nhng tnh gic th bit ch c chc lt thi. Nu ly vic chim bao qun cc php th thi v c kim, php v kh lai r rng trc mt. Nu tc

phn bit th lin lt vo lu chuyn, ch ny chng phi phm tnh c th n c. Gi bo bay ni m thng tnh Nc sng gp m chng tri Bi trn lng xng m chng ng Trng qua bu tri m chng i. bn cu k ny u cn k l g na. LC GII Ti (Ngi Hm Sn) lc tr c Lun ny n bn cu trn, i vi ngha "Bt Thin" khi nghi tnh tri qua nhiu nm. Khi cng S Diu "kit ng" Ph Bn, khc li bn Lun ny; lc d n on ny, hot nhin tnh ng. Lng mng v hn, lin ng ln l Pht th thy thn mnh khng c tng l xung hay ng ln, m ca nhn ra ngoi cht thy gi thi, l cy ri l t m l no cng chng ng, mi tin cu "gi bo bay ni m thng tnh". K vo nh cu i tiu m chng thy tng lu chuyn ca nc tiu, tht l "nc sng gp m chng tri". Ngy xa v s nghi cu : "Th gian tng thng tr" ca Kinh Php Hoa lin nh y m tan r. Do mi bit ch ca Lun ny tht vi t su xa, nu chng phi chn tham tht ng, mun ly ci tri kin m t by, u chng khi b hoi nghi nhiu thm na. V s "ng tnh n cng cc" khng d g ni cho ngi tin c, nhng li y l mun ngi la ngn ng hiu , ng chp theo ngn ng m nh mt ch vy. ---o0o--CHNH VN

Bc thnh c ni "Mng ngi chng mt, mau hn nc chy", cho nn tha Thanh Vn ng "Phi Thng" m thnh o, Duyn Gic ng "duyn la" l "tc chn". Nu vn php chng phi "v thng" th bc thnh nh tha ti sao do nghe "v thng" m chng qu thnh? Tm li li ni ca bc thnh, tht l vi n kh hiu. Li ni ca bc thnh du ni v thng m mun hin by chn thng, cho nn vi n kh hiu. Hnh nh ng m tnh, nh i m , ch c th dng tht tr m hiu bit, ch khng th theo s tng m tm cu. Cho nn ni i chng cn cho l i, ch ph ci t tng chp "thng" ca ngi phm, ni khi cn cho l , ch ph ci chp tht c i ca ngi m thi. u phi ni i m c th ri ch, ni m c th li c. Nn Kinh Thnh C Quang Minh ni : "B Tt trong ch chp "thng" m ging gio php "phi thng". i Tha Lun ni: "Cc php khng ng, chng c ch kh lai". u l dn dt cho mi phng chng sanh c thng t , hai li trn ch l mt thi, u phi do li vn khc bit m c tri nghch nhau. LC GII on ny gii thch li ca bc thnh d khc nhau m ch l mt, cng nh hai php sanh t v Nit Bn, ngha u l khng c. Kinh Thnh C ni: "B Tt trong ch phm phu chp thng m ni v thng ph chp y, chng phi tht c tng sanh t; l mun ngi ngay trong v thng m ng "chn thng". Nh i Tha Lun ni: "Cc php trm nhin thng tr chng ng, vn khng kh lai". mun cho ngi ngay khi no ng m ng "Bt Thin", li ni THNG v V THNG u l ty c gio ha chng sanh, li tuy khc m l mt, u phi v vn khc m i chi nhau, vy th ngi chp theo ngn ng tranh bin, chng phi l m hoc ? ---o0o--CHNH VN Cho nn ni thng m chng tr, ni i m "Bt Thin". Chng v vi m khng b vn hnh, nn thng m chng tr; ni sanh t m chng la Nit Bn, nn i m "Bt Thin". V "Bt Thin" nn d thy c tng i m thng tnh, v chng tr nn d thy tng tnh m thng i. Tnh m thng i nn i m "Bt Thin", i m thng tnh nn tnh m chng tr vy. S giu ni ca Trang T (1) v s "n b sng" ca Khng T (2)l

vy, u l cm thy s i kh tr, u phi ni thy i m c i. Cho nn, ngi qun c tm ca bc thnh th chng ng vi s thy ca ngi thng. Ti sao? Ngi thng cho l: gi tr cng mt c th, n trm tui cng ch l mt bn cht, ngy thng tri qua, hnh th theo tng thi gian bin i m chng bit. cho nn ng Phn Ch lc tui tr xut gia, u bc tr v, ngi li xm thy hi :"Ngi xa kia cn sng sao? "Phn Ch p: "Ti ging ngi xa m chng phi ngi xa y! " Ngi li xm ngc nhin cho li ng y ni sai. Cng nh li vn trn ni "giu ni ni vng nc, ngi c sc mnh vc i m k m chng bit". l ch vic ging nh ngi li xm ca Phn Ch. GHI CH : (1) Trang T ni :"Giu ni, tng sn, ni vng nc cho l vng chc, nhng ngi c sc mnh c th vc i c m k m chng bit, nu giu thin h ni thin h th khng cn ch no m di i c". ni ngi cha qun hnh th hp vi o th d cho n giu ni ni rng m hnh th b to ha m thm bin i m k m chng bit, v c giu th c mt. Nu hnh th vi o hp lm mt ri th khng c ch giu, khng giu th khng mt, cng nh giu thin h ni thin h th chng th mt c vy. l ca Trang T. (2) Trong lun ng, Khng T trn b sng ni: " Nc chy qua mau nh th chng la ngy m", l li tn thn o-th nh nc sng chy chng ngng. l ca Khng T. Tc gi ly li vn trn dn chng s "Bt Thin", ni k m chng bit, d "Thin" m "Bt Thin", ni chng la ngy m th du cho i m chng i. Nn Lun ny gii thch rng hai li ni trn ch cm thy i m kh tr, chng phi ni i m tht c i, cho nn ni: d thy "Thin" m tht "Bt Thin", v cnh co rng : ngi qun c tm ca bc thnh, chng nn theo thng tnh chp ngn hi ngha th mi phi. LC GII Tc gi ly vic ca Phn Ch gii thch d "Thin" m "Bt Thin" sng t ci ngha k m chng bit. Ngi li xm ca Phn Ch ni " ngi xa cn sng y" l ly ci mt tr khi xa cho l ngi mt gi hin nay. Phn Ch p: " Ti ging ngi xa m chng phi ngi xa", l ni mt tr t tr khi xa m chng n nay, u c th ly mt gi hin nay m

i n khi xa c ? y l ngha ca "Bt Thin" r rng, nhng ngi li xm chng bit, nn ngc nhin cho l ni sai, mun ch r ra: k m chng bit vy. ---o0o--CHNH VN Nh Lai v tnh chp ca chng sanh nn dng li phng tin nh thc ngi m hoc, dng chn tm ca bt nh t ra nhiu li gio ha khc bit chng phi mt. D li ni tri nhau m chng c th cho l khc bit, ch c bc thnh mi ni c nhng li nh th. Tm li, li bc thnh c khc m tm chng khc. Ch Pht ra i vn chng c php thuyt, nhn v tnh chp ca chng sanh nn ty theo cn c ca chng sanh m thit lp li ni phng tin ph ci chp y. Li gio ha ca Pht mc d tri nhau m tm tht chng c khc, on trn ni vi n kh hiu l vy. Li ni v chn th c tn gi l "Bt Thin", cn dn dt v tc th c thuyt gi l "Lu ng", nh vy, d c ni ra mun ngn ng li khc nhau cng ch qui v ng vi mt m thi. LC GII on ny gii thch ci ngha tri nhau m chng khc. Ni v phn chn th gi l Bt-thin, m ni gio ha th tc ; ni v phn tc th c thuyt Lu ng m ni tr v chn tm, cho nn mun ngn ng li khc nhau m chng c th cho l khc bit vy. ---o0o--CHNH VN Ngi chp vn t th khi nghe ni "Bt Thin" cho rng vic xa khng n nay, nghe "Lu ng" th cho rng vic nay c n xa. ni c, kim, th c t tr ni c, kim t tr ni kim; m ti sao cn mun di kim n c vy? Cho nn, ni tr chng cn tr, c kim thng tn v n bt ng; ni i chng cn i, v c chng n kim th kim cng chng n c, khng n cho nn chng qua li ni c kim, bt ng cho nn cc tnh (tng tr v tng gi) tr ni mt thi. Vy th li vn khc bit ca cc Kinh, hc

thuyt sai bit ca Bch Gia, nu hi ng th lm sao cn b nhng li vn sai bit m hoc c? Cho nn ngi ta cho l th ti ni l i, ngi ta ni l i th ti cho l ; d cho i, khc nhau nhng ngha ch l mt m thi. Do , Lo T ni: "Li chnh ni ra ging nh li phn, ai m tin cho ni, song li y cng c l do vy". LC GII on ny hin by m, ng cng mt ngun gc. Ngi cho l "" v do vng tm chp thng; chp thng th lt vo v thng, nn ti ni "i" ph ci chp y, ni v tr, chng phi ni tht c i; ngi cho c "i" l chp sanh t v thng th ti ni "" ph ci chp y; ni vn khng c sanh t chp, chng phi ni "" m tht c li. Vy th hai li "i" v "" ch l li ph chp, hin by o nht chn thng tr thi, nn li khc m mt. Cng nh Lo T ni : "Li chnh ni ra ging nh li phn, ai m tin ni, song li y cng c l do vy". Li y ch r m, ng khng ngoi nht chn; th phi vn chng phi hai, nu chnh kin hin tin th chng ty theo b mt ca li ni hiu ngha vy. Ti sao? Ngi tm c ni kim, ni n chng , ti th tm kim ni c, bit n chng i. Kim nu n c, c phi c kim, c nu n kim, kim phi c c. Kim m khng c th bit chng n, c m khng kim th bit chng i. Nu c khng n kim, kim cng khng n c, c kim chng n vi nhau th cc tnh tr ni mt thi, vy u cn vt g cho kh lai na? Do , ngi ng l "Bt Thin" ni vi n, d cho t thi bin i mau l nh gi bay in chp, cng l bt ng nh nh. Cho nn cng c ca Nh Lai tri qua mun i m hnh li tha thng tn, o php thng n trm kip m hnh t li cng kin c vnh vin. Nh th, d mun i, trm kip, hnh nh thi gian bin i m hai hnh t li v li tha u bt h, l tht tng ca "Bt Thin" vy. ---o0o--CHNH VN Bng t p thnh ni phi nh ky t u tin, cng nh i n ni ngn dm phi nh bc u. Nn cng c thnh bc thnh m vn hnh vin

mn chng khc vi s tm, pht tm v cu cnh hai s chng khc, t nhn n qu m hnh hnh bt thin. Duy Ma Ct ni :" Nghip s tc cng chng qun, chng qun tc l bt h". Thin c u nh vy, qu tht chng t cng hnh v s nghip bt h. Cng nghip bt h nn d xa m chng bin i; chng bin i l "Bt Thin", bt thin th tht tng trm nhin r rng; cho nn Kinh ni "Ba th tai nn ln ca hoi kip (thy tai, ha tai, phong tai) cng khp php gii m hnh nghip trm nhin chng ng, chng hoi". Nh th ci ngha "cc thin" l "cc bt thin" th li y ng tin lm! Ti sao? Qu chng cng nhn, m v nhn thnh qu; v nhn thnh qu, nhn xa chng mt; qu chng cng nhn, nhn chng n nay; chng mt, chng n th ch ca "Bt Thin" r rng, u cn m lm ch i, m do d gia ng tnh vy. Nh th, tri t o ln ch cho l khng tnh, bo lt khp tri ch cho l c ng; nu kh ng c "tc vt tc chn" th trc mt u l tht tng thng tr, tt c vn php chng my may c th ng chuyn; nh vy chng cn tm cu ni xa m ngay bit c vy. LC GII Ti (Hm Sn) xem quyn Chnh Php Nhn Tng, Ha Thng Pht Gim th chng, k cng n "Tng hi Triu Chu: Th no l ngha "Bt Thin". Triu Chu dng hai tay lm th nh nc chy th Tng tnh ng". Cn mt cng n khc : " Tng hi Php Nhn : chng chp ly tng, nh nh bt ng, th no l chng chp ly tng, thy ch bt ng vy? Php Nhn p: Mt tri mc phng ng, ln phng ty. Tng cng tnh ng". Nu m thy c ch ny mi bit rng : gi bo bay ni m thng tnh, nc sng gp m chng tri. Nu khng th chng khi b ch l nhiu chuyn. ---o0o--BI LUN TH HAI BT CHN KHNG

GII : Lun ny ni "Chn Khng" bt "khng", t ra chn lm cnh s qun, "Bt Chn" c hai ngha : 1. L php hu vi: V php do duyn sanh l gi, gi m chng tht th th tnh vn khng, y l tc ; chng chn nn khng, gi l "Bt Chn Khng". 2. L chn tnh duyn khi thnh tt c php, th tnh chng phi on dit, nn chng phi tht khng, gi l "Bt Chn Khng". S "hu" l gi tm c, ni l "diu hu"; s "khng" chng phi l "on dit khng", ni l "diu khng"; th th phi hu phi khng l trung o nht ngha . Ly diu khng ph hai tng Tm V Lun v Bn V Lun; ly diu hu ph tng Tc Sc Du Huyn Lun; ch ba ch u bao gm ht diu dng ca chn , nu chng phi kh ng ch Trung o, u c s chiu soi huyn diu, linh ng nh th! ---o0o--CHNH VN Vic "Ch H V Sanh" l ch trung o nht ngha , chng phi cnh gii do thc phn bit, suy lng c. Bi v diu dng chiu soi nhim mu ca Bt Nh l tng th cn bn ca vn vt. Tht tr ca Bt Nh chiu soi chnh l, nn ni s chiu soi nhim mu; trung o l ch dng ca tht tr nn ni diu dng, th th khng m chng khng; vn vt ly Trung o lm cn bn ca tng th nn hu m chng hu; phi khng, phi hu l t ht th dng ca Trung o, y l kin lp tng th. Nu chng phi bc thnh c minh tr thng sut, u c kh ng gia ni "c" v "khng"! Cho nn, bc ch nhn thng t tm thn diu ni v cng; s v cng y khng vt no lm chng ngi c; s nghe thy cng tt ca tai mt, chng phi sc mnh ca thanh sc c th hn ch c. Bi v tnh th ca vn vt t khng, nn vn vt chng th lm lao nhc ci tm thn diu quang minh c. Cho nn bc thnh dng chn tm thun theo chnh l th khng c s chng ngi no m chng thng; dng tht tr qun st vn php, nn gp cnh no cng u t do t ti. Khng c s chng ngi no m chng

thng, nn c ln ln trong mun loi m bn th vn thun chn; gp cnh no cng t do t ti nn tip xc vn vt cng nh mt. Nh th th vn tng d cho khc nhau m chng th t thnh cch bit; chng th t thnh cch bit nn bit "tng" phi chn tng, v "tng" phi chn tng nn "tng" chng phi tng; vy th vt v ng ng mt gc, th (chn ) v phi (tc ) chng phi hai. Cnh gii vi n thm su ca bc thnh tht chng phi k m chp phm tnh c th hiu c. Nn ngi i m lun n ch H tng (ly h v lm tng) u mi mi chng ng, cc Lun ua nhau ra i, mi nh chp theo kin gii ca mnh m thnh s bt ng; ly s bt ng em vo l i ng th u cn vic g c th ng c na! Ti sao? Tng Tm V l v tm ni vn vt; vn vt cha tng v, ni v tm ch l khng c tm ui theo vn vt m vn vt cha tng khng; l cha thng t c vn vt th tnh t khng, nay c ni tm tnh, tht ni vt h. Tm chng ui theo vt th khng b ngoi cnh rung ng, nn c ni tm tnh; v khng hiu vn vt duyn sanh tnh khng, nn tht ni vt h. Bi v cn chp tm khng, cnh c, nn chng hp vi trung o (on ny ph Tm V Tng). Tc Sc Du Huyn Lun ch r c sc chng t sc, nn d sc m phi sc (1). Phm phu ni sc ch cho sc vn l sc, u phi ngi t tn ri mi thnh sc u? Cho nn li "Tc Sc Du Huyn" ch ni sc chng t sc m thi; cha hiu c bn th ca sc vn khng, v ch bit "y tha khi", tn l gi, chng bit "vin thnh tht", th l chn, nn khng phi chnh lun (on ny ph Tc Sc Du huyn Lun). Bn V Lun l c tnh cm ham thch s v, h gp vic g ni ra u tn sng ni "v", nn ni n phi hu th chp hu tc "v", ni n phi v th chp "v" cng "v"; "hu" vi "v" u v, cho l h huyn, chng bit a vo on kin, cha r chnh l. Nu hiu c bn lp ngn ca bc thnh, th ch cho li "phi hu" l chng phi tht c, li "phi v" l chng phi tht khng m thi, chng phi cho phi hu l khng c hu ny, cho phi v l khng c v kia; l li ca ngi ham "v", u phi ngi thun theo chnh l thng sut s tht m t n ch ch "Tc vt Tc chn"! (on ny ph Bn V Lun). Ly tn t tn cho vt l c vt tht t tn, ly tn t tn cho phi vt nh lng ra sng th, th ch c tn m khng c vt; cho nn vt chng

phi do tn m thnh vt thc, tn cng chng phi do vt m thnh tn chn. Vy th, chn c tnh (2) ngoi danh tng gio l, u phi vn t, ngn ng c th bin bit cho r c. Nay v cn ph m chp hin by chnh l m chng th nn ng, nn t ra ngn ng phng tin lun bn th. i Tha Lun ni : "Cc php chng phi c tng, cng chng phi khng c tng". Trung Qun lun ni: "Cc php chng c, chng khng, l nht Chn vy". Cu xt s chng c, chng khng, u phi ty sch vn vt, lp bt thy nghe, vng lng h v, c, khng u bt, ri mi cho l chn ? K tht, "tc vt thun thng chnh l" nn ngha chnh ca vn vt khng th phn nghch c, y l "phi hu", ni n "Tc ngy tc chn" th tnh vt khng th sa i, nu sa i hay phn tch tm chn th chng phi thit chn vy, y l "phi v". Tnh vt khng th sa i nn d "khng" m "c", chng phi tht "khng"; ngha chnh ca vn vt chng th phn nghch c, nn d "c" m "khng", chng phi tht "c". D c m khng, y l phi hu (bt chn nn khng); d khng m c, y l phi v (chng phi tht khng), nh th th chng phi tuyt i v vt, ch l vt y chng phi vt tht m thi! Vt chng phi vt tht (xng vi ngha "Bt Chn") th u m c vt gi? (xng vi ngha "khng"). GHI CH : (1) Sc chng t cho l sc, ch v ngi t tn n l sc, nu tm chng cho l sc th sc tc phi sc. (2) Chn c tnh rng khng, la tng, la danh, hin tng v s lng chng th gii thch, siu vit s hiu bit ca phm tnh, thc suy lng chng th n, nn gi l c tnh.

LC GII Tc gi ly phi hu phi v bn i bn li, gii thch ngha "Bt Chn Khng" ph nhng ngi chp "Vn khng". Bi v tc hu r ngha "khng", gi l "diu khng"; tc khng r ngha "hu", gi l "diu hu". Hai ch "Bt Chn" t ht ngha "khng" ca i tha, huyn diu n cc im ca gio l, chn u c hin by ni y.

---o0o--CHNH VN Nn kinh ni : "Tnh ca sc t khng", chng phi sc hoi ri thnh khng, ngha l sc khng bt nh, sng t bc thnh i vi vn vt, ngay ch vn vt thy tnh khng, v vn vt bn tnh t khng, chng i m x, phn tch ri mi thnh khng, vy k chp "vn khng" lt vo on dit ri. Cho nn Duy Ma Ct ni: "Bnh ca B Tt phi chn, phi hu", l li ni c ngha "Bt Chn". Kinh Siu Nht Minh Tam Mui ni: "Chng c th, chng bo mng, v t i chng tht vy" l li c ngha "Tt Khng". Vy th, vn vt ca Tam Tng khc nhau nhng u qui v mt hin by ch ca sc khng bt nh. Nn Kinh Phng Quang Bt Nh ni: " nht chn l chng c thnh, chng c c; th tc th c thnh, c c". V chn la duyn nn khng c thnh v c, tc duyn sanh nn c thnh v c. C c tc l ngy danh ca v c, v c tc l chn danh ca c c. Chn danh nn d chn m "phi hu", ngy danh nn d ngy m "phi v". Bi v s c l y chn kin lp nn "c" m "phi hu"; chn th ty duyn bin hin nn "khng" m "phi v"; cho nn ni chn cha tng c, ni ngy cha tng khng, hai li chng phi mt, hai l chng phi khc. Nn trong Kinh ni: "chn , tc , c khc ?" p rng: "khng khc". Kinh ny bin minh chn r "phi hu", bin minh tc r "phi v", u phi v c hai m vt cng c hai u! Vy th, vn vt qu tht c ci s d "chng c", c ci s d "chng khng". C ci s d "chng c" nn d c m "phi hu", c ci s d "chng khng" nn d khng m "phi v". D khng m phi v, "v" l khng tuyt h, d c m phi hu, "hu" l chng tht c. Nu hu chng chn tht, th v cng chng on dit, vy th hu v v tuy gi c khc nhau nhng l mt vy. Nn ng T than rng : "Thuyt php chng c cng chng khng, v nhn duyn nn cc php sanh". Kinh Anh Lc ni : "S chuyn php lun cng chng phi c chuyn, cng chng phi khng chuyn, nn ni chuyn v s chuyn". y l li vi n ca cc Kinh vy. Ni vt qu tht "khng" th ngi on kin chng phi l k m hoc; ni vt qu tht "c", th ngi thng kin cng l ng sao? V vt "phi v" nn on kin l m hoc; v

vt "phi hu" nn thng kin l chng ng. Nh th li "phi hu", "phi v" ng tin l chn vy. Nn Kinh o Hnh ni: "Tm cng chng c cng chng khng". Trung Qun Lun ni: "Vt do nhn duyn sanh, khi cha sanh l khng, nn chng c; c nhn duyn sanh khi th chng phi on dit, nn chng khng". Tm xt l o l ng nh th! S d nh th, s "c" nu tht c th "c" phi thng c, u cn i duyn hp ri mi c! V nh tht khng th s "khng" phi thng khng, u cn i duyn tan ri mi khng ? Nu "c" chng t c, i duyn hp ri mi c th bit s c chng tht c, s c chng tht c th d "c" chng th cho l c vy! Ni n ch chng khng, nu "khng" l tht khng, th trm nhin chng ng mi c cho l khng, vn vt nu "khng" th chng th sanh khi, c sanh khi th chng khng, y l t r duyn khi nn chng khng vy. Nn i Tha Lun ni: "Tt c cc php, do tt c nhn duyn sanh nn phi c; tt c cc php, do tt c nhn duyn sanh nn chng phi c. Tt c cc php "khng", do tt c nhn duyn sanh nn phi c, tt c cc php "c" do tt c nhn duyn sanh nn chng phi c". Cu xt li "c" v "khng" ni y, u phi l li Lun phn nghch nhau m thi u! Nu "phi c" tc l c, ch nn ni "khng"; nu " phi khng" tc l khng, ch nn ni c. Ni c ch l gi c, t "phi v", mn ch "v" bin bit "phi hu". y, vic tuy mt m gi thnh hai, xem vn hnh nh chng ng, nu lnh hi c ch ng th khng c s khc bit no m chng ng vy. Th th, vn php qu tht c ci s d chng c, khng c cho l "c"; c ci s d chng khng, chng c cho l "khng". Ti sao? Mun ni n c th ci "c" y chng phi tht sanh; mun ni n khng th s tng hnh thnh, c hnh tng th chng phi tht khng, c hai u chng chn tht, th th ngha "Bt Chn Khng" hin by y ri. Nn Kinh Phng Quang ni: "Cc php gi danh chng tht, v nh ngi huyn ha, chng phi khng c ngi huyn ha, ngi huyn ha chng phi ngi tht vy". V vic ly tn tm vt th vt chng c ch tht gn tn, ly vt tm tn, th tn y chng c cng dng c c vt. Vt chng c ch tht gn tn th chng phi vt; tn khng c cng dng c vt th chng phi tn, cho nn tn chng ng tht, tht chng ng tn. Tn v tht u chng ng th vn vt u?

Nn Trung Qun Lun ni: "Vt khng b th m ngi ny (th) ly th lm th, ly b lm b, ngi kia (b) th ly th lm b, ly b lm th. B, th chng nh vo mt tn m k m hoc m ly ci thnh kin nht nh. Cng nh hai ngi ng, ty i lp, cng xem mt vt gia, ngi bn ng cho vt hng ty, ngi bn ty th cho vt hng ng; s tht vt chng c ng ty, v k m c thnh kin chp s nht nh. Cho nn b, th vn chng c, k m vn chng khng. ng b th l chng c th u c vt g c th chp tht! Nn bit "vn vt chng chn, gi danh lu ri". Cho nn Kinh Thnh C ni: "Cc php chng c tht m cng lp danh gi". T Vt Lun ca Trang T ni : Ly "ngn tay" d cho ngn tay chng phi ngn tay, khng bng ly "phi ngn tay" d cho ngn tay chng phi ngn tay; ly "nga" d cho nga chng phi nga, khng bng ly "phi nga" d cho nga chng phi nga. Tri t l mt ngn tay, vn vt l mt con nga. Lun ni rng : vn vt chng t (khng bng nhau) bi do mi ngi kin chp th phi. Ngn tay v nga vn khng c th phi, m ngi vng chp nht nh cho l c b th, u chng phi l m hoc ? Vic trn th d tht tng ca cc php u c t, c tha, m ngi m chp lm c lm khng, l cng nh vy. Nu c qun li, kh l, th s tnh chp b-th u qun sch, li th-phi cng tiu lun c, th u cn c php no dnh dng n tnh cm. Nh th th li thm su ca kinh Lun ni no m chng c! Cho nn bc thnh chng sanh, thin b c ha thn m chng bin i; vo th gii c trc, sng chung vi chng sanh m chng b phin no chng ngi l v vn vt ngay t khng, chng cn nh s "khng" khng gim cho vt. Nn Kinh ni : "L qu Th Tn! Ngay ch bt ng chn tm m kin lp vn php, chng phi la chn tm m c ch kin lp, ngay ch kin lp tc l chn tm vy". Nh th, o c xa xi u! S tip xc no cng l chn o. Thnh c xa xi u! Th hi ngay vic trc mt tc l bc Thnh vy! ---o0o---

BI LUN TH BA BT NH V TRI TIU DN : Vua Tn Diu Hng (t nm 394-416 CN) l minh cha lc ng thi, triu tp cc php s gio mn hn 500 v, trong c nhng v S ngi n nh: Thin S Pht B La, hc thin vi Pht i Tin n sang Trung Quc vo thi Hong Thy, dy thin Nga Quang T (1). Ngoi ra, cn c Tam Tng Php S Pht Nh a La, v hai lun s T B Sa l m Ma Da X v m Ma Qut a, dch kinh vn ng uyn Tiu Dao Qun. Ngi Cu Ma La Thp c ngha ting Phn, vua Tn chnh tay vit ra Hn vn dch cc kinh i tha. Ti l ngi t hc, tng d vo dch trng, c nghe nhng iu tm yu khc thng v ch nhim mu ca Bt Nh bt u t lc y. GHI CH (1) Tc gi cng theo s hc thin v c ng. GII : Bt Nh dch l Tr Hu, l tht tr ca php thn do ch Pht kh ng. Trong kinh ni: Tr hu ca ch Pht thm su v lng, s nhim mu trong php gii phi nh tr ny chiu soi, nn gi l Cn bn tr. Tam tha u ly tr ny lm nhn m c chng qu, v tm chp ln nh bt ng nn s chng c cao thp, ch c Pht mi t n cng tt. Hai Lun Vt Bt Thin v Bt Chn Khng trc hin by chnh l bt nh ca Chn v Tc , y l cnh s qun. Nay ly Bt Nh lm tr nng qun, l dng s v tri ca Bt Nh chiu soi s bt nh ca trung o, tm lp Bt Nh lm nhn, chng c bt sanh bt dit ca Nit Bn lm qu, nn gi l Nh Lai vy. Nhng Bt Nh ch c mt m dng li c ba : l.- Tht tng Bt Nh: v Bt Nh l tht tng ca cc Php. 2.- Qun chiu Bt Nh : tc l tht tr nhim mu ca trung o chiu soi l nhim mu ca trung o. L v Tr ng mt, bnh ng nht nh, nn l v s song dung, quyn tr v tht tr cng hin by cng gi l nh tr.

3.- Vn t Bt Nh: v ngn gio ca ch Pht u xut pht t Bt Nh, nn mi vn t u hin by tng tr (tng nht thit php, tr nht thit ngha) y l mun nh vn t sng t Bt Nh. S "v tri" c hai ngha : l.- La vng : ni l vn chng c s tri m lm. 2.- Hin chn : c ba ngha : a) L bn gic la nim, linh tri t chiu, tri tc l v tri. b) L thy gic v tri (thy gic: gic u tin), ni thu sut nhim mu, qun c chiu soi, s i dng chng cn tc nn khng c s tri i i. c) L vn t tnh khng, chng phi tri v bt tri. D ni ngha c ba, nhng chng phi khc bit bi v chn v tng, bt tri kin, tuyt chiu soi, th dng ca chiu soi c lp, chng c i i, y l ngha v tri vy! ---o0o--CHNH VN S linh ng nhim mu ca Bt Nh l tng th (cn bn) cng cc ca tam tha. K thc chn tm bt nh, chng c sai bit, nhng v nhng k ham chp d kin, t lp tng phi lun bn, cho nn t lu nay lm cho t kin lan trn khp ni. Diu tr ca bc thnh nhim mu vi n, thm su kh hiu, v tng v danh, li ni chng th din t c, ti nay ly lng thnh c gan mn li ni lun bn thi, ch thc khng dm ni rng chn tm ca bc thnh c th t ra c. Kinh Phng Quang ni : "Bt Nh chng c tng s hu, chng c tng sanh dit". Kinh o Hnh ni: "Bt Nh v s tri, v s kin". y l mun t r s chiu dng ca diu tr. Ti sao li ni v tng v tri? V qu tht c ci tri ca v tng v c ci chiu dng ca v tri r rng. Ti sao vy? V c s tri th c s bt tri, m chn tm ca bc thnh v tri nn chng c ch bt tri, tri ca bt tri mi c gi l nht thit tri, nn kinh

ni: "chn tm ca bc thnh chng c ch tri, chng c ch bt tri" l ng tin vy. Li s chiu dng ca Bt Nh khng cn tc , cho nn chn tm ca bc thnh nu trng rng trong sch c chng no, th s chiu dng y chng ny, do sut ngy tri m cha tng tri l vy. Tht tr chng l bn trong, nh sng tim n m quyn tr lun lun hin ra s ng c ha bn ngoi. V v tri th tm c trng rng, t nhin t n chiu soi nhim mu, lp bt tm tr thng minh m s c gic li m thm cng khp ni, thnh ra chng c ch bt tri l ngha y vy. Nguyn tht tr c ci chiu soi nhim mu m v tri, quyn tr c cng dng ng c ha m khng qua s tc . Dng ca quyn tr chng cn tc nn c siu vit trn th tc, tht tr chng l m v tri nn c chiu soi nhim mu thu qua ngoi s vt. Tht tr d thu qua ngoi s vt chng phi l v s; quyn tr d siu vit th tc m sut ngy trong th gian. Cho nn quyn tr ty c ha v bin chng sanh m chng thy lao nhc; s chiu soi ca tht tr d sng t khp php gii m khng c cng chiu, v ci tri ca v tri l m thm dung hp vi tm thn diu ca bc thnh ri. Ci dng ca Bt Nh chn tht m bn th trng rng, bn th trng rng m s dng vn chng phi khng, s dng vn thng cn m khng th lun bn ngh ngi, y l diu tr ca bc thnh vy. Ti sao? Mun ni n c, th v hnh v danh; mun ni n khng th bc thnh chiu soi vn vt, s ng c nhim mu linh ng. Bc thnh ng c nhim mu linh ng nn trng rng m chng la chiu soi; v hnh v danh nn chiu soi m chng la trng rng. Chiu soi chng la trng rng nn quyn tr ln ln trong vn vt m bn th trm nhin chng bin i; trng rng m chng la chiu soi nn tht tr chng l tch dit m chng b chng sanh. Nh th, tr dng ca bc thnh chng bao gi tm ngng, m mun tm ra hnh tng th khng khi no c th c. Nn Kinh Bo Tch ni: "V v tm (chng tc ) m c s hin hnh". Kinh Phng Quang ni: "Bt ng ng gic m kin lp cc php". V th, s tch ca bc thnh d c mun iu nhng ngha ch l mt m thi. Nn Bt Nh c th trng rng m chiu soi, chn c th tch dit m hiu bit, vn vt c th no ng m ngay thng tch, s ng c ca

bc thnh c th trng rng m vn lm thnh, vy th chng bit m t bit, chng lm m t lm. Li cn mun bit ci g na? Mun lm ci g na? VN NN RNG :

Chn tm ca bc thnh t sng t nn c chiu soi vn vt, ng c gio ha khp ni, s hnh ng u thch ng vi cn c. Chiu soi vn vt nn s hiu bit chng c ch thiu st; hnh ng thch ng vi cn c nn s thch ng chng sai vi cn c. S thch ng chng sai vi cn c nn phi c cn c cho thch ng; s hiu bit chng c thiu st nn phi c ch hiu bit cho bit. C ch hiu bit cho bit nn s hiu bit ca bc thnh chng phi v tri; c cn c cho thch ng nn s ng c ca bc thnh chng phi trng rng. c tri c ng m ti sao li ni v tri v ng ? Nu ni qun tri qun ng th ch l v bc thnh khng ng chp, c tri c ng m khng cho l tri l ng ca mnh m thi! y ch c th ni : "Chng t cho l c ci tri", ch c phi l v tri u?

P RNG : Cng c ca bc thnh cao hn tri t m bt nhn (1), sng hn nht nguyt m li cng lu m (chng cn tc m hiu bit, nn ni l cng lu m), ch u phi v tri nh g ! K tht, khc vi phm phu bi do tr hu sng t thn diu nn chng th theo s tng tm cu vy. vn nn cho rng "bc thnh chng t khoe ci tri m bc thnh cha tng chng c tri" y l tri vi chn tm ca bc thnh, mt ht ch ca li vn. Ti sao? Trong kinh ni : "Chn Bt Nh thanh tnh nh h khng, v tri v kin, v tc v duyn", y th s tri t nhin v tri vy, u phi i tiu dit ci tm linh minh ri mi l v tri! Nu ni "Hu tri tnh khng" m gi l thanh tnh th chng phn bit c vi ci tri m hoc ca phm phu. Bi v phin no cng l tnh khng, cng u thanh tnh th u cn phi c tn ni Bt Nh? Nu ly s tri tn thn Bt Nh th s tri chng phi Bt Nh, v Bt Nh chng c nng s. Nu ni t tnh ca s tri lun lun thanh tnh, th Bt Nh cha tng thanh tnh. H c thanh tnh th phi c u, tc cn i i; thnh ra cng khng th ly s thanh tnh tn thn Bt Nh. Nhng kinh ni : "Bt Nh thanh tnh" l v th tnh ca Bt Nh chn tnh, vn chng ly ci tri m lm.

Vn chng c ci tri m lm nn chng th gn cho ci tn l "Tri" vy, u phi v tri mi gi l v tri, s chn tri t l v tri ! Cho nn bc thnh ly v tri ca Bt Nh chiu soi ci v tng ca chn , chn chng c du vt no thiu st, s chiu soi ca Bt Nh khng ch no chng cng tt. Do , ng c m chng sai, gp vic no cng ng l m chng c ch thy ng, nn trng rng v tri m chng c ch bt tri l vy. GHI CH : 1. i nhn bt nhn: nhn l thng mn, s thng mn ca bc thnh bnh ng, cng khp mi chng sanh, vy th u cn thy mt chng sinh no c thng mn na, cho nn ni "i nhn bt nhn" l vy. VN NN RNG : S vt vn chng t thng t c, nn phi lp danh s vt c thng t. S vt d chng phi danh m qu tht c s vt xng vi danh ny lp danh; cho nn theo danh m tm s vt, s vt chng th n du, m lun ni: "Chn tm ca bc thnh v tri", li cn ni "chng c ch bt tri", ni "v tri cha tng tri, tri cha tng v tri", y l s thng t ca ngn gio, v cng l bn ca lp ngn ri! Nhng Lun ni "chn tm ca bc thnh l mt m ch ca li vn th nhiu khc bit". Vy theo li vn tm s tht th cha thy c ch ng. Ti sao? Nu "Tri" l hp vi chn tm ca bc thnh th khi cn ni l v tri; nu "V tri" hp vi chn tm ca bc thnh th cng chng cn ni tri, nu c hai u chng hp th cn g u lun bn na? P RNG : Trong kinh ni : " ngha ca Bt Nh v danh v thuyt, phi hu phi v, phi thc phi h; h chng la chiu, chiu chng la h". Vy th gio php v danh, cho nn li ni chng th ni c. D li ni chng th ni, nhng khng c li ni th chng th truyn gio php c, cho nn bc thnh sut ngy ni m cha tng ni l vy! Nay v ng m ti c gan ni th : chn tm ca bc thnh vi diu v tng nn chng th cho l "c"; lun lun chiu dng nn chng th cho l "khng". Chng th cho l "khng" nn diu tr ca bc thnh thng cn, chng th cho l "c" nn ngn ng ca gio l dt bt, cho nn ni "Tri" chng ni l

tri, m ch mun thng t s chiu soi; "Bt tri" chng ni l bt tri, m ch mun t ci tng m lm. T tng m lm, chng phi l "khng", thng t chiu soi, chng phi l "c"; "phi hu" nn tri m v tri, "phi v" nn v tri m tri. Cho nn, tri tc l v tri, v tri tc l tri, ch nn v li ni khc bit m lm cho chn tm ca bc thnh cng khc bit theo. VN NN RNG : Chn thm su nhim mu, k v tr chng th suy lng c, ci nng lc ca thnh tr do y m hin by. Nn kinh ni : "Chng c Bt Nh th chng thy chn , chn l duyn ca Bt Nh". Ly duyn tm tr th tr l tri ri, ti sao ni v tri? P RNG : Ly duyn tm tr, tr chng phi tri. Ti sao? Kinh Phng Quang ni : "Chng duyn sc m sanh thc nn gi l chng thy sc". Li cn ni "V ng m thanh tnh nn Bt Nh thanh tnh". Bt Nh tc l nng tri, ng m tc l s tri. S tri tc l duyn, nng tri vi s tri i i nhau m "c", i i nhau m "khng". i i nhau m "khng" nn tm v cnh "chng c"; i i nhau m "c" nn tm v cnh "chng khng". "Tm v cnh chng khng" l cha qun c tm cnh, nn mi c nhn duyn sanh khi; "tm v cnh chng c" l tm cnh u qun, nn nhn duyn chng th sanh khi. Duyn chng th sanh khi v chn tr la duyn, nn chiu duyn m chng phi tri; v nhn duyn sanh khi nn bit nhn duyn i i m sanh; cho nn, tri vi v tri sanh ni s tri. Ti sao? Tr v tri s tri, chp tng nn gi l tri; chn vn v tng, chn tr lm sao tri? Nh th s tri chng phi s tri, v s tri sanh ni tri. S tri sanh tri, tri cng sanh s tri, nng s tng sanh vi nhau tc l nhn duyn; nhn duyn nn chng tht, chng tht nn chng phi chn vy! Trung Qun Lun ni : "Vt do nhn duyn sanh nn chng tht, chng do nhn duyn sanh nn tc l chn". Nay chn ni chn, chn th chng phi nhn duyn. Chn chng phi nhn duyn v khng c vt no do phi duyn m sanh c, nn Kinh ni "chng thy c php no khng duyn m sanh".

V th, chn tr qun chn cha tng ly s tri. Tr chng ly s tri, tr ny do u tri. Nhng tr chng phi v tri, v chn chng phi s tri nn chn tr cng chng phi tri, m ng mun ly duyn tm tr, nn cho tr l tri, duyn vn chng phi duyn, u m tm tri? VN NN RNG : Lun ni : "chng chp ly", l khi v tri chng chp ly hay l tri ri chng chp ly? Nu v tri nn chng chp ly th bc thnh ti m nh i chi m, chng phn bit c trng en c khc; nu tri ri mi chng chp ly th ci tri khc vi chng chp ly ri? P RNG : Chng phi v tri m chng chp ly cng chng phi tri ri mi chng chp ly, ngay ch tri tc l chng chp ly, nn c chng chp ly m tri. VN NN RNG : Lun ni chng chp ly, k tht v chn tm ca bc thnh chng chp ly vt ni vt, nn khng c s chp ly m lm. Chng chp ly th chng c tm nhn vt, chng c tm nhn vt th chng c c ng, vy th cn c c no ng vi chn tm ca bc thnh? Thnh ra on dit ri, m sao li ni chn tm ca bc thnh chng c ch bt tri. P RNG : Phi vy! Chng c tm nhn vt th chng c c ng; chng c c ng th khng c no chng c ng. ng l tm, c l cnh, nu c mt cnh ng vi tm th chn tm b kt m chng thng (c s tr), nu chng c cnh ng vi tm th cnh tch tm khng, chn tm c chnh bin tri (chng c ch bt tri) nn khng c c no chng c ng. Khng c tm nhn vt th tm khng, tm khng th cnh tch; tm khng cnh tch th mi php u chn, nn chng c vt no m khng nhn ra c. Chng c vt no khng nhn ra c, nn nhn m chng thy nhn, chng c c no khng c ng, nn ng m chng thy ng. V th Kinh ni: "Thy tt c cc php m chng c s thy" l vy. VN NN RNG :

Chn tm ca bc thnh chng phi khng th nhn vt, tht l khng c tm nhn vt m nhn c vt. D khng c tm nhn vt m nhn c vt, nn phi nhn vt ni khng c tm nhn (lm tng lt vo "khng"). Cho nn Kinh ni : "Chn v tng nn Bt Nh v tri", tht l Bt Nh chng c ci tri hu tng. Nu ly v tng lm v tng th u c tn hi ci ngha ca chn ? (1) GHI CH : (1) Ngi vn nn chng thng t c chn tri c chiu ca Bt Nh, nn cho s tuyt v l Bt Nh. P RNG : Bc thnh chng c s v tng (khng c tng v). Ti sao? Nu ly v tng lm v tng th v tng tc l tng, (chp v tng th v tng cng l tng). B "c" m vo "khng", cng nh trnh cht ui m nhy vo la, u chng khi tai ha. Chn tm ca bc thnh v tr, u c ging nh th! Cho nn ch nhn ni hu m "chng c", ni v m "chng khng"; d chng chp "c, khng", nhng cng chng la "c, khng" cho nn "ha quang ng trn" (thnh tr n trong trn lao), khng c chng sanh m chng sanh trong lc o; Tch nhin m i, chng ng bn th m ng hin tt c; trng rng m n, mun triu bin ha m tm v s tr. Bc thnh ly v tr lm tm, nn v vi m v s bt vi l vy. VN NN RNG : Chn tm ca bc thnh du v tri, nhng ci o ng c ha chng sai, cho nn ci c c th ng th ng, ci c chng th ng th li. Th th chn tm ca bc thnh c khi sanh, c khi dit, h c th c ? P RNG : Ni "sanh dit" l sanh dit ca phm phu, bc thnh v tm th sanh dit lm sao sanh khi c? Nhng chng phi v tm nh g , ch l v ci tm sanh dit m thi! Li cng chng phi khng c ng c, ch l ty duyn m ng, vn chng c tc mun ng c vy.

Cho nn ci o ng c ca bc thnh, cng nh ting di trong hang, ty theo tht cht ca t thi m ng c chng sai, v ly trng rng lm th nn chng th sanh, cng chng th dit vy. VN NN RNG : S v ca tht tr v s v ca quyn tr u chng sanh dit th u c ch no khc bit? P RNG : S "v" ca tht tr l "v tri", cn s "v" ca quyn tr l "tri v". Ni "v" d l ng, nhng ci ch ca v th khc. Ti sao? V chn tm ca bc thnh h tnh, chng c tri v, nn gi l "v tri", chng th ni "tri v"; quyn tr c tri, l c tri v, nn gi l "tri v", chng c ni "v tri" vy! V tri tc l ci v ca Bt Nh, tri v tc l ci v ca Chn . Cho nn, Bt Nh vi Chn ni v dng th ng m khc; ni v tch th khc m ng. V "ng" nn v tm (v tc ) ni tm v cnh, v "khc" nn chng mt ci cng dng chiu soi. Cho nn ni "ng" l ng ch chng ng; ni "khc" l khc ch chng khc; th th "khc" chng th cho l khc, "ng" cng chng th cho l ng vy. Ti sao? Bn trong c ci sng ca t chiu soi, bn ngoi c s chn tht ca vn php. Vn php du tht m khng chiu soi th chng c ci tht, trong v ngoi cng nhau mi thnh ci cng dng chiu soi, th th s dng ca bc thnh chng th ng l vy. Bn trong du chiu soi m v tri, bn ngoi du chn tht m v tng. Trong v ngoi tch nhin, c hai u khng, th th ci tch ca bc thnh chng th khc l vy. Cho nn Kinh ni : "Cc php khng c sai bit", u phi di ch g cao, lp bng trng thp ri mi cho l chng khc? K tht v chng khc ni khc nn d khc m chng khc vy. (1) Ch nn thy cnh khc m cho l tm cng khc. Nn kinh ni : "L thay, Th Tn! trong php khng khc m ni cc php c khc". Li cn ni : "Bt Nh ni cc php chng phi mt tng, cng chng phi khc tng" l ng tin vy. GHI CH : (1) T tnh bt nh. Nu c "ng" l nh; c "khc" cng l nh.

VN NN RNG : Lun ni : "Ni v dng th khc, ni v tch th ng", cha r trong Bt Nh c s dng v tch khc nhau chng? P RNG : Dng tc l tch, tch tc l dng; dng v tch th tnh l mt, cng xut pht t mt tm, nhng tn gi th khc nhau; tht ra th chng c ci tch ca v dng lm thnh s dng. Cho nn tht tr cng lu m th s chiu soi cng sng t; quyn tr cng vng lng th s ng c cng linh ng, u phi v li ni sng ti v ng tnh m sanh ra s khc bit? Nn Kinh Thnh C ni : "Chng lm m siu vit s lm". Kinh Bo Tch ni : "V tm v thc, nn chng c ch no chng c tri". y l quyn tr ng c n cng tt, tht tr chiu l n cu cnh. Qu tht l li ni din t thu sut ra ngoi hin tng vy. Da theo li vn sng t ca cc kinh th c th r c chn tm ca bc thnh ri. ---o0o--TH CA LU DI DN (Ngi Hu Vin, s t ca Tnh Tng, sau khi c bi Bt Nh V Tri Lun, c tn thn rng "xa nay cha tng c". Nhng cm thy trong Lun cn nhiu iu thc mc cha thng, nn c sai c s Lu Di Dn, l v t thng th vit th gi cho Ngi Tng Triu tham vn ng thi cng c vn nn). (Lc b phn thm hi, y ch dch phn vn nn). Chnh l tinh vi th li vn k him, m iu qu cao th ngi xng ha rt t, nu chng phi hng ngi siu vit ngn ng, qun li c th s chp vo li ni m tri ngc vi chnh l. Li p trong bi Lun Bt Nh V Tri, v on ly duyn tm tr, ngha t ra tht uyn chuyn cng tt, cc k tinh xo, chng c k h. Nhng k cha thu l th kh m hiu c, nay cn c mt hai ch cha hiu r, xin k ra trong th vit ring km theo y, nu Ngi c rnh ri th gii thch cho.

Trong Lun ni : "Th tnh ca Bt Nh phi hu phi v, h chng la chiu, chiu chng la h, nn ni chng ng ng gic m kin lp cc php". on sau c ni : "Khc vi phm phu l bi tm thn diu linh minh, nn chng th theo s tng tm cu m thi". Li cn ni : "Dng tc l tch, tch tc l dng, quyn tr cng vng lng th s ng c cng linh ng". Chn tm ca bc thnh tch dit, tht tr chng l cng tt ng vi trng rng. Quyn tr ng c chng mau m mau, chng chm m chm, cho nn tri chng la tch, tch chng la tri; cha phi l chng tch, cha phi l chng tri. Cho nn, o ng c ha c thnh cng trn th gian, d trong hu danh (quyn tr ng c ha ) m li ng vi v danh (tht tr chng l tch dit), l s nhim mu ca chnh l m k phm li cng cm thy m mui! Nhng nay ngi bnh phm c ch nghi i vi ch cao siu ca bi Lun, mun tm s khc bit ca thnh tr (quyn tr v tht tr), cho l tht tr linh minh cng tt, siu vit s lng, cc k vi diu, m thm ph hp nht th vi trung o ? Hoc cho l quyn tr tm th t nhin, linh minh trng rng, v tng c tn ? Nu ni linh minh cng tt, siu vit s lng, cc k vi diu, m thm ph hp nht th vi trung o th hai tn gi "Tch" v "Chiu" l th ca nh v hu m thi. nh v Hu l hai th tch v chiu cng l hai; dng l hai th th cng l hai, u c th ni tm v cnh hp thnh mt? Vy th hai tn gi chng nn cho l nht th. Nu ni tm th t nhin, linh minh trng rng, v tng c tn, tc l quyn tr cng vng lng th tr v mt m tiu dit du tch, c ci th m chng c ci dng, lm sao ni c c quyn tr? Nu c th chng c dng, th quyn tr ng c tuyt, lm sao ni l s ng c cng linh ng c? Chn tm nhim mu th tch nhin v tri, m li ni trng rng chiu soi, c chiu soi th l tri ri, ti sao ni v tri ? Ni quyn tr ng c ha thu qua ngoi vn vt, s ng c tuyt m linh minh trng rng c tn th chng nn c s ng c; c s ng c l c hai ci tri ri, tc l mt ci tri chiu soi chn , mt ci tri sng t tc , sao li ni l v tri? Ngi chng ng thm su, xin th gii thch cho.

Ngi bnh phm cn c ch nghi l : quyn tr ng c ha , khi ng c ha th phi bit v cn c trnh ca chng sanh, chng th cho l khng c, m ch trong Lun li ni : "Quyn tr vn chng c ci tri chp ly", m cha gii thch ti sao chng chp ly? Ni trc tin cn phi xc nh r o ng c ha ca thnh tr, vy cho l ch c chiu m chng c tng ? Hay cho l quyn tr qun c cn c sai bit ca chng sanh l c tng ? Nu qun c cn c sai bit ca chng sanh th khc vi v tng. Nu ch c chiu m chng c tng th chng c cn c no m ha ; chng c cn c no ha m li c cng dng ca s ng c ha , ny ti cha hiu, xin Ngi ch dy cho. Lun ni : "Chng c c ng th khng c c no chng c ng, chng c tm nhn vt th khng vt no m chng nhn ra c. Khng vt no m chng nhn ra, nn nhn m chng thy c ch nhn; khng c c no chng c ng, nn ng m chng thy c c no ng". S chng c c ng m khng c c no chng c ng th mi gi l chn ng; chng c tm nhn vt m khng vt no chng nhn ra c th mi gi l chn nhn; h c s chn nhn m chng thy nhn, s chn ng m chng thy ng, m li ni s ng m chng c c ng, s nhn m chng c vt nhn ? Nu ni s chn ng chng phi l s ng c ca phm tnh, s chn nhn chng phi l s nhn ca phm tnh, y l do s ni ca m v ng vn khc nhau m thi. Nh th th tn ch ca Lun khng c r rng, dm xin th d thm khi b nghi hoc na. Khi o Sanh Php s em bi Lun ny n L Sn, ti cng vi Hu Vin Php S xem xt tng tn, v S cng lnh hi c v tn thn, c th v tng phi c khc bit nn l th ca o php chng cn ng nht vi nhau chng? Ti c a cho cc v ng tu cng xem, cng c nhiu v khen ngi, nhng tic l khng c cng Ngi gp mt. ---o0o---

TH CA TNG TRIU TR LI LU DI DN (Lc b phn thm hi, nay ch dch phn gii p v vn nn). Th ng gi n c nm iu mun hi, rt uyn chuyn thit tha, ti tht chng dm cho l mnh c t cch gii p. Li ca bn o chng c nhp l, li km v vn t. V ch l th khng th ni, ni ra th tri vi l, d ni nhiu li m chng din t c trn vn l th th ni cng v ch. Nay ti c gan theo li dy tr li m thi. Th hi rng : "Ni thnh tr tch dit, tht tr chng l cng tt ng vi trng rng, d trong hu danh m li ng vi v danh, l s nhim mu ca chnh l m k phm li cng cm thy m mui". Nu ly iu ny lm tm th qun li ni bn ngoi m c bn trong. nh vo mt tm th u cn theo s khc bit ca phm tnh tm ci khc bit ca thnh tr. Th vit : Ngi bnh phm ni linh minh cng tt, siu vit s lng, cc k vi diu, m thm ph hp nht th vi trung o th "tn gi ca tch v chiu ch l th ca nh v hu m thi. Nu tm th t nhin, linh minh trng rng, v tng c tn th s ng c ha chng sanh dng nh chm dt ri. ni cc k vi diu, m thm ph hp nht th vi trung o, tc l tm v cnh hp mt, th tch v chiu u bt, chng th ly "nh" v "Hu" lm tn gi; ni linh minh trng rng, v tng c tn th chn tm khng c i i, cho nn ni s ng c ha chng sanh chm dt". Chng bit hai li ni tuy khc m diu dng lun lun l mt, v chp theo mnh thnh ra khc, nu theo ca bc thnh th chng khc. Ti sao vy? S tch chiu nhim mu ca thnh tr, tht tr chng l cng tt ng vi trng rng, ni l ng th khng c ch no m chng n cng cc, u c ci chnh l cng tt, ng vi trng rng li c hai tn gi "nh" v "hu"? Hai tn gi "nh" v "hu" vn cng mt th, u phi ngoi s ng cn c hai tn gi?

Nu hai tn gi "nh" v "hu" cng trong "ng" th phm ngn ng ni ra u chng c th tnh chn tht, tc l chng ng, nu ngoi s ng m gng t hai tn gi "nh" v "hu", l do s m chp, ch chnh ngay hai tn gi "nh" v "hu" chng c m chp. Li na, thnh tr trng rng, vi n thn diu, khc vi cnh phm, khng c c no chng thch ng, s ng c khng c ch no m chng thng? S nhim mu ca thnh tr m thm linh ng, nn diu dng ca quyn tr lun lun l nh th, th s ng c ha chng sanh lm sao chm dt c? Ci tm "c" ca phm phu l do nhn duyn m c; v c ci "c", c chng t c, phi i nhn duyn mi c. Ci chn tm ca bc thnh v la duyn nn chng c ci "c", nn s "c" chng c. S "c" chng c nn s "khng" cng chng khng, nn bc thnh chng c chng khng. Chng c chng khng th thnh tr trng rng c chiu, kh hp vi trung o. Ti sao? S c v s khng l bng v ting ca tm, ngn ng v s hin tng l s phan duyn ca bng v ting. S c v s khng tuyt, trong tm chng c bng v ting, bng v ting tiu th ngn ng v hin tng chng th suy lng c. Ngn ng v hin tng chng suy lng c th tm th la s lng. Tm th la s lng th o php trm khp mi phng m chng tr. o php trm khp mi phng m chng tr nn c linh minh cng tt, siu vit s lng. Linh minh cng tt, siu vit s lng nn chn vng u bt, gi l cc k vi diu. o php cc k vi diu vn l v tr, v tr do ni m thm tch dit, m thm tch dit th th tnh la tng, nn phi mn t "trng rng" t by. Cc k vi diu l bi siu vit s lng, siu vit s lng nn c v bin s lng thch ng vi mi cn c; v bin s lng thch ng mi cn c, nn s ng c chng sai. Mn t "trng rng" t by th la danh la tng, nn o php siu vit ngoi danh tng; o php siu vit ngoi danh tng nn gi l "khng" ch la danh tng, chng phi on dit, s ng c chng sai nn gi l "c" (ty duyn bin hin, chng phi tht c).

Ni v s "c" chng phi tht c, ch l gng gi nh th thi. Trung o tch dit, u phi v ng c m thnh c? Nn Kinh ni: "Thnh tr v tri m v s bt tri, v vi m v s bt vi". Ci o tch dit, v ngn v tng u phi ni c m tht c, u phi ni khng m tht khng; ni ng m tri vi tnh, ni tnh m ph b ci dng ? Nay ngi bnh phm chp theo ngn ng xc nh ch, mun ni tch dit trng rng ca Bt Nh tm s hu tri v v tri, dng thc phn bit ch by s nhim mu, ly ci thnh kin vng chp san c cho l phi c s nht nh ng hay khng ng. Cho nn nghe bc thnh hu tri th ni l hu tm, nghe bc thnh v tri th ni v tm ng nh h khng. Ci cnh "hu" v "v" u thuc v bin kin (chp v mt bn), u phi ni bt nh ca trung o! Ti sao? Vn vt d khc nhau m th tnh vn lun lun l mt, chng c tn gi, nhng chng phi khng c vt gi. C tm i vi cnh th danh tng khc nhau, l nng s cha qun; chng c tm i vi cnh th nng s u qun, tc vt tc chn. Cho nn bc thnh chng ly cnh ni tm, cng chng phi la tm ni cnh; chng ly cnh ni tm th cnh chng c, chng la tm ni cnh th tm chng khng; chng c cho nn chng ly, chng khng cho nn chng la; chng la nn mi php u chn, chng ly nn danh tng trng rng, danh tng trng rng chng phi hu tri, mi php u chn chng phi v tri; nn Kinh ni : "Bt Nh i vi cc php chng ly chng la, v tri v bt tri". Chng t Bt Nh nng s u qun hin by trung o. y l ch la tm thc, vt ra ngoi phan duyn m mun ly s c v khng ct vn, h chng phi xa la chnh l ri sao ? Ct vn v s "c" v "khng" th ci tr ct vn cng do thc phn bit sanh khi trong phm vi hu tng, m php vn v tng th thnh tr lm sao tri? Ngi i ni n v tri, cho l ng vi g , h khng v nhng vt v tnh.

S chiu soi linh minh m thm sng t ca Bt Nh, hin ra s dng trc khi mt nim cha sanh, nn o v n c (thp phng tam th u r rng trc mt, nn gi l o v n c), linh minh nh th l chnh bin tri, u th ni v tri nh g c! Li na, v tri sanh khi ni hu tri, tht chng c v tri, chng c hu tri. Chng c hu tri nn ni phi hu, chng c v tri nn ni phi v. Cho nn h chng la chiu, tch m thng chiu; chiu chng la h, chiu m thng tch; trng rng thng tr, chng chp chng x, u th do ng m lm cho c, do tnh m lm cho khng? Nn Kinh ni: "Chn Bt Nh phi hu phi v, chng sanh chng dit, chng th ly li ni t cho ngi bit". Ti sao? Ni v phi hu l ni chng phi tht c, chng phi ni tuyt khng c; ni v phi v l ni chng phi tht v, chng phi ni tht c. Ni phi hu chng phi phi hu, ni phi v chng phi phi v, la t c th tuyt bch phi; cho nn Tu B sut ngy thuyt Bt Nh m ni l v s thuyt. y l o tuyt ngn, chng phi cnh gii ca tri kin th s tri lm sao m truyn c? Vy ch c nhng ngi tham cu, thng t ch huyn diu, qun c ngn ng th tm mi lnh hi c m thi. Trong th li ni : "Trc tin cn phi xc nh ci o ng c ha ca thnh tr, cho l ch c chiu m chng c tng ? Hoc cho l quyn tr qun c cn c sai bit ca chng sanh ? "Ngi bnh phm hnh nh ni: V tng vi s qun c sai bit" ch chng phi l mt. Qun c sai bit th khc vi v tng, chiu soi v tng th mt s ng c ha . Vy th ci ngha "tc chn" hoc c sai lm Trong Kinh ni : "Sc bt d khng, khng bt d sc, sc tc th khng, khng tc thi sc". Nu nh ch ca ngi bnh phm th lc qun sc v khng, phi mt tm thy sc, mt tm thy khng.

Nu mt tm thy sc th ch c sc, chng thy khng; nu mt tm thy khng th ch c "khng" m chng thy sc, vy th "khng" v "sc" thnh hai, chng nh c ci bn "sc khng bt nh" trong kinh. Cho nn Kinh ni : phi sc, l ph s chp sc tht c ca phm hu, ch chng phi ly phi sc ph h khng, v h khng l phi sc ri. H khng khng phi l sc th d cho c ph c i na cng khng c g nhn bit. Nu ly phi sc ph sc th Kinh ni "khng bt d sc" l phi sc chng khc vi sc; "sc bt d khng" l sc chng khc vi phi sc, vy sc vi phi sc chng c khc nhau? Nn bit : qun c sai bit tc l v tng, v tng tc l qun c sai bit; ch v cn c ca chng sanh chng ng, nn gio php c s khc bit m thi. Xem xt cc kinh, cn c theo ch thuyt php ca ch Pht th u cn c s khc bit bi chn (tht tr) v ngy (quyn tr), i vi hai cnh "c" v "khng" m s chiu soi c khc bit ? Cho nn chiu soi v tng m chng mt ci cng dng ca s ng c ha , qun c sai bit m chng tri vi ch v tng, to "c" chng khc vi "khng", d ni sanh t m t tnh chng ng; to "khng" m chng khc vi "c", d chng Nit Bn m chng b chng sanh. Cha tng chng c, cha tng chng khng, nn ni "Bt ng ng gic m kin lp cc php". Theo m suy ra th hai php "tch" v "dng" u c khc nhau? Ti sao li ni ci tr qun c sai bit khc vi s chiu soi ca v tng? E rng ngi bnh phm hoc cho "khng" v "hu" l hai tm, "tnh" v "ng" l hai dng khc bit, nn mi ni ci tr qun c sai bit chng th cho l chng c! Nu x b c s ham chp d kin trong tm thc, tm chnh l nhim mu ngoi danh tng, ng qun vn php ni nht th, hiu r php thn v tng m chng phi khng, th phi ni "Bc ch nhn sut ngy ty cn c ca chng sanh ng c ha m cha tng cho l c chng sanh ". Chn tm ca bc thnh nh th, u c ch chp ly? M li hi : "Cha gii thch ci l chng chp ly". Li ni : "Chng c tm nhn vt mi cho l chn nhn, chng c c ng mi cho l chn ng". Cng c th ging nh li ni trong th vy.

Nu c v tm ni nhn vt th nhn vt ni chng c tm nhn, tc l chiu m thng tch; v tm ni ng c m ng c ni chng c c ng, tc l tch m thng chiu. Th th sut ngy nhn vt, chng tri vi "khng c tm nhn"; sut ngy ng c, chng tri vi "khng c c ng". Ch e rng tm chp cha qun, nn chp tht s nhn vt ni chng c tm nhn, chp tht s ng c ni chng c c ng, l v tnh chp cha qun nn mi c s sai vy. Ti sao? Nu chn nhn l nhn vt, chn ng l ng c, th tm v cnh cha qun, nn danh tng theo m hnh thnh, tt xu do m sanh ra, i i kip kip ui theo tm cnh th bnh chp trc n khi no mi ht? Cho nn bc thnh trng rng ni tm, v thc v tri, mun cnh u tch dit. V vy, ang lc linh ng chiu dng m ngng ngh ni cnh v vi; ang trong cn nh hu danh m li sng ni qu hng tuyt ngn, tch chiu trng rng, chng th theo danh tng m bit c. Chn tm ca bc thnh nh th m li cho : "Chn nhn l nhn, chn ng l ng". Ti cng cha r ch ca ngi bnh phm, nhng e rng s nhn vt ng c ca h l do vng chp ca phm phu m sanh khi, vy lm sao c th hiu c chn tm ca bc thnh. K thc chn tm ca bc thnh th chng phi nh vy. S din t ca ngn ng khi ln, v phm phu tm danh chp tng, theo li nhn ngha, t mi sanh ra nhiu s khc bit vy! Dng ngn ng hin by ci o tuyt ngn th din t cng chng phi l din t. Cho nn ngi kho ni m dng ngn ng th t by c nhng s m ngi ta khng th t by. Ngi kho din t th din t c nhng iu m ngi ta chng th din t. S ch l trng rng nhim mu h khi tm ng nim l sai tri ri, hung l c ngn ng din t! E rng bc th ch dy cha qun danh tng, mun n ch ch l cn rt xa xi, ch c ngi tm tr thng sut mi c th gp nhau ngoi vn t vy. ---o0o---

BI LUN TH T NIT BN V DANH GII : NIT BN V DANH LUN l Lun v Nit Bn. Hai ch Nit Bn l ting Phn, dch l vin tch. Ng tr (1) sch ht gi l vin, nh t (2) vnh vong gi l Tch, cng l bit danh ca nht tm tch dit, chn th ca thanh tnh php thn, chng phi nh ngi th gian hiu lm cho l cht. V tam th ch Pht tu nhn tri qua nhiu kip, chng c ci chn th ca nht tm ny, gi l Php thn; v p li ci nhn qung i, gi l Bo thn; ty c li ch chng sanh, gi l Ha thn. Tt c ch Pht u y tam thn: Php thn l th, Bo thn, Ha thn l dng, c cm ng th hin, khng cm ng th n; n m chng hin th vin qui nht tm, nhip dng tr v chn th gi l nhp dit, tc l Nit Bn chng phi l sanh t. V nht tm ny ng tr phin no chng che lp c nn gi l vin; hai th sanh t chng th b buc nn gi l "tch". Gio mn t v ch xut pht, ni c bn th: l. T Tnh Nit Bn: Tc l nht tm ny cng khp mi ni, l bn th ca cc php, t tnh vn tch dit. Cng nh ni : c Pht hay khng c Pht, tnh tng thng tr, tt c chng sanh vn dit , chng cn dit na, nn gi l "T Tnh Nit Bn". 2. Hu D Nit Bn: Ni s chng ca tam tha, v minh cha snh ht, bin dch sanh t cha dt, s chng l cha c cng tt, ngha l cn d mt khong ng cha gim n, nn gi l "Hu D Nit Bn". 3. V D Nit Bn: Tc l Pht tu thnh, vng ht, chn sch, th dng bt nh, cng l chng c qu V Thng i Nit Bn, nn gi l "V D Nit Bn". 4. V Tr Nit Bn : Tt c bc thnh chng ly hu vi, chng tr v vi, nh bin u bt tr, trung o cng chng lp, ng tnh bt nh, tng danh l Nit Bn, nn gi l "V Tr Nit Bn".

Bn th tn gi ny ch theo th v dng t tn, k tht trong nht tm danh tng u tch, nn gi l "V Danh", tc l sanh t v Nit Bn c hai u bt kh c, cho nn hai ch "V Danh" l ci tng danh ca nht tm thng tr, bt sanh bt dit. Hai bi Lun "Vt Bt Thin" v "Bt Chn Khng" trc l cnh s qun, "Bt Nh" l tr nng qun, ba lun y u l nhn, nay "Nit Bn" ny l qu s chng, nn ly lm lun. GHI CH : (1) Ng tr : l. Kin nht thit tr a phin no: tc l tt c kin gii m lm ca tam gii. 2. Dc i tr a phin no: tc l t tng m lm ca dc gii; trong t tng m lm, nng nht l ci li tham i, nn ra ci chnh bao gm tt c phin no khc. 3. Sc i tr a phin no: tc l tt c t tng m lm ca sc gii. 4. Hu i tr a phin no : l tt c t tng m lm ca v sc gii; v sc gii d chng c sc thn, nhng cn chp A Li Da thc lm ng, cn ng l cn c i, nn gi l hu i. 5. V minh tr a phin no : tc l ngun gc ca tt c phin no. Nm th phin no k trn gi tt l ng tr. Ni tr a v nm php ny l ch v sanh khi tt c ti li cng l ch da cn bn ca hng h sa s phin no. (2) Nh t : l. Phn on sanh t : l sanh t ca phm phu t on ny sang on kia, nh t thn ngi sang thn th. 2. Bin dch sanh t : cng l sanh t ca bc thnh chng qu tam tha, nh b A La Hn bin Bch Chi Pht, b Bch Chi Pht bin B Tt s a, b B Tt s a bin B Tt nh a v.v..

---o0o--BIU VN TRNH VUA TN (Lc b nhng phn tn thn vua Tn, ch dch phn nhn duyn lm Lun ny). Trc kia, vua Tn c ni : "o Pht ly V vi lm Tng". An Thnh Hu Diu Tung hi rng : "Chng r s v vi ca o ly g lm th"? Li p ca Vua Tn ch r : Nit Bn l tng th ca v vi, m tng kt li thnh hai ch "V Danh". y l nhn duyn ca tc gi lm lun ny. Theo li biu vn ca Ngi Tng Triu trnh cho vua c on nh sau : Ti sao ni l V Danh? V chng sanh t lu nay trong sanh t lun hi u do s chp trc i dc, nu i dc ngng ngh ni tm th chng cn sanh t lun hi. khng c sanh t th chn tm nhim mu vng lng, ci c dng m thm hp vi h khng, nn gi l "Nit Bn". ni l Nit Bn th u cn dung np ci tn vo trong y na! Nay ci bn lp lun ny l mun lm sng t chn th tch dit ca Nit Bn v danh bi xch nhng t kin ngoi o. V lc ng thi c mt hng ngi hc Pht, cho v vi l chng c bc thnh, lt vo on kin, xa b nhn qu; ch ci nhng ngi tu hnh, cho l chp tng, em t kin ny tuyn truyn khp ni; ly lm t c, nn chng th sa i cho ng vi chnh php c. Nay nh bc th ca vua Tn p Diu Tung rng : "Nu chng c bc thnh th ai bit s chng c?" Ch mt li ny lm cho bn t thuyt im lng, nn lp Lun ny din t thm gip cho gio php c sng t. Lun ny gm chn on vn nn, mi on din t, mn "hu danh" thay cho vn nn, mn "V Danh" thay cho gii p, hin by chnh l ca "V Danh".

---o0o--l. KHAI TNG R NGHA V Danh ni : Nh Kinh ni : "Hu D Nit Bn v V D Nit Bn dch l V vi, cng gi l Dit ". V vi l ly s trng rng tch dit, la danh la tng, cch tuyt vi hu vi. Dit l ni s tai ha ln ca sanh t vnh vin tiu dit, siu lc o lun hi. y l ch thc tnh ca m mt chim bao, cng l tuyt danh ca cn nh nhim mu. Ni hai tn "hu d" v "v d", y ch l tn khc bit ca xut x, gi danh ca ng c ha m thi. Ty duyn hin thn thuyt php gi l xut, duyn ht tr v n gi l x. Nay ti th Lun bn rng : Ci o ca Nit Bn tch dit trng rng chng th theo danh tng m tm, vi diu v tng chng th dng hu tm m tri ; cao siu tam gii, m hoc u dt, chng lng nh h khng, chnh l cng tt; mun ui theo th chng th tm ra tng tch (v lai v chung), mun tr li tm ch xut pht th chng thy bt u (qu kh v thy); lc o chng th lm cho sanh khi, sc mnh chng th lm cho bin i. Th tnh mnh mng chng c b bn, bc tr chng th nh danh. Nh tr th sanh m chng sanh, nh i th dit m chng dit. Ng nhn chng thy c dung mo, v la sc; nh thnh (nhc nh, thin nh) chng nghe c m thanh, v la thanh. Mt m thm su, ai thy ai hiu? Trm khp bao gm, khng c ch no chng tn ti, m li siu vit ni c v khng. Th th h ni c l mt ci chn, bit c th tr thnh k ngu; c "c" l tri vi t tnh, c "khng" l tn thng php thn. Cho nn khi Pht Thch Ca mi thnh o, t nht mnh trong phng m chng thuyt php; Vn Th hi v php mn bt nh th Duy Ma Ct ngm ming; Tu B tnh ta trong hang, Thch tn hoa cng dng cho l kho thuyt Bt Nh; khen ngi chng ni m ni, chng nghe m nghe, y u do chnh l l ci o tuyt ngn, ch c ngi chng mi c lnh hi, nn ming do m nn, u phi chng c bin ti. V bin ti chng th ni c.

Kinh ni : "S chn gii thot la ngn ng, tng s, tch dit vnh an, v th v chung, chng ti chng sng, khng lnh khng nc, trm nhin thng tch nh h khng, v danh v thuyt". Trung Qun Lun ni : "Nit Bn phi hu li cng phi v, con ng ca ngn ng chm dt, ch suy lng ca tm , tiu dit". Theo nhng li ca kinh lun trn, u phi chng ng s tht. Nh th, qu tht c ci s d chng c, nn chng th cho l c; c ci s d chng khng, nn chng th cho l khng vy. Ti sao? H truy cu cnh "c" th ng m vnh vin tiu dit (dit th la kh, gi l lc c); truy cu cnh "khng" th s nhim mu linh tri thng tn (gi l ng c) ; nhim mu linh tri thng tn nn du bt thy nghe m nht chn trm nhin thng tch (y l thng c); ng m vnh vin tiu dit th v bin phin no u sch (tnh c); v bin phin no u sch nn thng t vi o; nht chn trm nhin thng tch nn diu dng m chng thy cng dng. Diu dng m chng thy cng dng nn ch cng thng tn; thng t vi o nn thm su m chng bin i. Thm su m chng bin i nn chng th cho l c; ch cng thng tn nn chng th cho l khng. Th th "c, khng" tuyt bn trong, tn gi bt bn ngoi, s thy nghe chng th n, ngi ci T khng (v sc gii) m mui chng hiu bit. Bnh ng nht nh m v tr, trng rng chiu soi m khp ni, l qu hng ca tt c chng sanh, cng l ngun gc cu cnh ca ch Pht. y l ci cnh chng th thy nghe, x s ca thi huyn (nhim mu li thm nhim mu), m mun ly s "c" v "khng" gn tn ch by phm vi ca Nit Bn, dng li ni t ci o thn diu m t cho l c ch, h chng phi li cng xa xi ? ---o0o--2. TM TH LP DANH Hu Danh vn : Danh hiu chng phi khi khng m t ra, tn gi chng phi t mnh ng nhin m sanh khi. Trong Kinh ni : "Hu D Nit Bn v V D

Nit Bn l ci chn danh tr v t tnh, cng l tn gi ca o php thn diu". Nay ti xin trnh by th : Hai ch "Hu d" c ngha ni l ng thn ca Nh Lai mi hin ra, php thn bt u kin lp, l tm ra trong dng nc "Bt gii thot", ngh ngi trong vn an nhn ca "Tht gic chi", tch cha mun thin t nhiu kip, ra sch cu bn t v th. Tam minh chng ng bn trong, diu dng chiu soi bn ngoi. Pht th nguyn ni s tm, chng sanh cho n cui cng, trn cu qu Pht, di cu chng sanh, siu vit tam gii, c chng i gic. M ng bng phng ca Bt Chnh o, qut sch t kin ca cc phi t tng. Ci thn m ca lc thng, i xe yn n ca ng tha. Ra vo trong sanh t ty c ha chng sanh, o php sung mn, c dng khp ni, cng tt n ch to ha mi sanh khi, cc diu dng ca thnh tr. Tm cnh trng rng khp v tr, soi sng php gii bi nht thit tr. Nhn duyn ha ngng ni cu a, chm ni thi h m cn nhn duyn cha ht; s tch gio ha cha c vin trn, v minh cha ty sch, thnh tr vn cn, y l Hu D Nit Bn. Trong Kinh ni : "Tiu tan trn lao phin no, nh luyn vng tht, mun kh u ht m linh gic c tn". Hai ch "V d" l ni nhn duyn gio ha ca bc ch nhn xong, linh chiu vnh vin tiu dit v c cm u tuyt, nn gi l V d. Ti sao? Ha ln chng bng ni c thn, nn phi dit thn tr v "khng". Lao nhc chng bng ni c tr, nn phi bt tr vo ni trng rng. Th th tr bi hnh th m mt mi, hnh th bi tr m lao nhc, nhiu kip lun hi trong lc o l bi ci li ca thn tm. Trong Kinh ni : "Tm tr l ci gc ca tt c c, hnh th l ch ta ca gng cm" xa vi chnh l thm su vng lng, nn tai ha do m sanh khi, cho nn bc ch nhn tiu thn dit tr, b hnh th, tuyt suy t; bn trong khng c ci lao nhc ca ng c chiu soi, bn ngoi th ct t ci ngun gc ca tai ha. Siu nhin ni tam gii th s sanh t vnh vin ct tuyt, trng rng bao la, ng mt th vi h khng. Tch dit chng c s thy nghe, trng rng chng c du tch, m thm m mt chng c ch n; cng nh n tt, du cng vi nh sng u ht, y l V d Nit Bn.

Kinh ni : "Ng m vnh tn, cng nh n tt". Th th Hu D c th Hu Danh, V D c th V Danh. V Danh t ri th k tn sng h v ham thch vi s thm su vng lng, Hu Danh sanh khi th k nh n c cng ngng m cng lao ca bc thnh. y l li vn trong kinh in, l s gio ha hp l ca c Pht; m Lun li ni "c, khng" tuyt bn trong, tn gi chm mt bn ngoi, s thy nghe chng th n, ngi ci t khng m mui chng th hiu. Lm cho ngi nh n c t cch tuyt vi o, k tn sng h v chng c ch nng ta, chng khc g lp bt tai mt trn c th, che bt nh sng nht nguyt ni h khng, m li cn trch ngi chng phn bit c mu sc, m thanh, u c l nh vy? ng ch bit suy tn bc ch nhn, siu vit s c khng, t cho li vn vt ra ngoi danh tng, m ch trong Lun li lm cho ngi c chng bit ch quy hng, nn o ca Nit Bn t n m cha c hin by. Ti im lng suy ngh tm hiu, cm thy chng c ch nng ta, v th u c th cho l sng t ngha Nit Bn ni nh en ti, n ting nhc nhim mu ni t tuyt thnh ? ---o0o--3. LP TH V DANH V Danh p : Hu d, V d l tn gi bn ngoi ca Nit Bn, gi danh ca s ng c ha m thi, m k ui theo tn gi l chp danh, k ghi nh hnh tng l chp tng. Danh hiu hn ch ni mc, hnh tng phm vi trong vung trn. Cng c ch chng th ly vung trn din t, ly mc truyn nhau c, u c th ly tn gi gn vo ni v danh, ly hnh tng gn vo ni v hnh! Bi v th tnh ca Nit Bn la danh la tng, chng phi cnh gii ca phm tnh, vy ci o v hnh v tng y u c th ui theo hnh, danh m tm cu c. Li vn nn rng :"Hu d, V d l bn phng tin tch dit thit lp gio mn, cng l s tch "n v hin" ca Nh Lai. Nhng cha phi l s

thm su tuyt ngn ca nhim mu tch dit, cng chng phi l diu o cu th ca bc tr nhn. ng cha nghe c ci thuyt chnh qun ? Duy Ma Ct ni : "Ta qun Nh Lai v th v chung, vt qua lc cn, ra ngoi tam gii, chng ti phng, chng la phng, chng hu vi, chng v vi. Chng th dng thc bit, chng th ly tr hiu, v ngn v thuyt, ch suy lng ca tm tiu dit". Theo qun l chnh qun, nu qun theo cch khc th chng thy Pht c. Kinh Phng quang ni : "Pht nh h khng, v kh v lai, ng c m hin,, chng c phng s". Th th, bc thnh ni v tr tch dit trng rng, khng chp trc, khng tranh bin. C tranh bin l ni sanh t, khng tranh bin l ni Nit Bn; sanh t v Nit Bn c hai u bt kh c, dn dt n m chng i trc, cm thng ri sau mi ng c. T nh ting trong hang, hnh bng trong gng sng, i din m khng bit t u n, ui theo chng hiu ch i; chp nhong m c, mp m m khng, ng li cng tnh, n li cng t, ra vo ni c, khng; thm su m thm, bin ha v thng, chng th suy lng c. t ra tn gi l bi ng c ha , hin by s tch l sanh, ngng ngh s tch l dit; sanh gi l Hu d, dit gi l V d. Th th tn gi ca hu, v l sanh khi t v danh, m ci o v danh th ch no chng phi danh? Cho nn bc ch nhn ni vung th vung, ni trn th trn, ci tri th lm tri, ci ngi th lm ngi, bi v ci nng lc lm tri, lm ngi u phi hng tri, ngi c th lm c! Vy r rng chng phi tri, chng phi ngi nn mi lm tri, lm ngi c m thi. Do , khi ha chng sanh, ng c m chng c vic lm, v lm m chng qua s tc , v chng qua s tc nn s lm rng ln chng th ngh bn; chng lm m ng c nn s ng c ph bin, chng th suy lng. S lm rng ln chng th bn nn tr li ni vi n, s ng c ph bin chng th suy lng nn quy v V Danh. Kinh ni : "o B chng th suy lng, cao m v thng, rng chng b bn, thm su m khng y, xa xi chng c ch n. Ln bao gm tri

t, nh nhp vo ln h (bi trn cc nh), nn gi l o".Th th o ca Nit Bn chng th ly s hu, v tm r rng ri. Th m k m hoc thy s thn bin li cho l c, thy s dit lin cho l khng, ci cnh "c, khng" l trong phm vi ca vng tng, u c th lm tiu biu cho huyn o m din t chn tm ca bc thnh! ni bc ch nhn tch dit trng rng chng c du tch, n v hin cng mt ngun gc, "tn" chng cho l c, "vong" chng cho l khng. Ti sao? Pht ni : "Ta v sanh, v sanh bt sanh, d cho sanh m chng sanh; v hnh bt hnh, d hin hnh m chng thy hnh". Nn bit "tn" chng cho l c. Kinh ni : "B Tt nhp v tn tam mui, thy ht c qu kh ch Pht dit ". Li ni : "Nhp ni Nit Bn m chng thy Nit Bn". Nn bit "vong" chng th cho l khng. "Vong" (vong tc l mt, tri vi tn) chng th cho l khng, d khng m c; chng th cho l c, d c m khng. D c m khng nn gi l phi hu; d khng m c, nn gi l phi v. Th th, ci o ca Nit Bn qu tht vt ra ngoi phm vi c v khng, nn ng i ca ngn ng v tng s phi ct t. M ng li ni "Ci tai ha ca bc thnh l ti ni c thn, nn dit thn tr v khng; lao nhc chng bng ni c tr, nn bt tr chm ni trng rng". H chng phi tri vi chnh l cng tt ca php thn, tn thng ch nhim mu ca Nit Bn ? Kinh ni : "Php thn v tng, ng c m hin hnh; Bt Nh v tri, i duyn m chiu soi". V ng c ni v tm, nn d cho mun vic xy ra cng mt lc m chng thy lao nhc, ngn li vn nn khc bit m i ph chng cn suy t. V tm ni ng c nn ng nh my bay, tnh nh ting vang, u c tm ni b th, v tnh cm dnh dng ni ng tnh? v tm ni ng tnh, cng v tng ni kh lai. V kh lai chng c tng nn khng c vt no m chng hin hnh; v ng tnh chng c tm nn khng c cm thng no m chng ng c. Th th, tm sanh ni hu tm, tng xut ni hu tng; tng chng xut ni ta nn d kim thch chy m ta chng chy, tm chng sanh ni ta nn tuy ng dng hng ngy m chng ng; vn php t n lng xng, u c dnh dng vi ta ? Th th cn c tai ha g?

Cho nn tr hu cng khp vn vt m chng lao nhc, hnh th sung mn mi phng m chng tai ha, s li ch chng th thm, s tn hi chng th bt; u th ly s c Pht th hin nhp tch cho l nh n tt m gi l V d Nit Bn? Chng bit php thn thng tr, s th hin nhp tch y ch l phng tin ha chng sanh m thi. Th m k m hoc ni cnh gii thy nghe, tm kim s tch khc bit ca ng c ha ; cm ly cy thc k o lng h khng, mun ly tm tr lm lao nhc cho bc thnh, ly hnh th lm tai ha cho ch nhn, m b c vo khng, do t tn cho Nit Bn Hu d v V d; u phi l li ni tinh vi, siu vit thy nghe, hin by php thn ni trng rng! ---o0o--4. TRCH VN LUN C Hu danh vn : Thi hn mang s khai (kip khng) vn hu sanh khi, vn hu c ri th chng th cho l khng, khng chng t khng, phi do ni c; c v khng tng sanh vi nhau, y l l l t nhin, s lng ca hin tng th gii cng tt ni y. Theo m qun, to ha sanh ra vn vt, l l chng c n du v hin by, s ln nh, th yu, thnh tht v di tr u l c c. S c do bin i m tiu dit, dit ri tc l tht khng. Th th ci cnh "c, khng" trn th gian u thuc v chnh l ny. Kinh ni : "Hai php C, khng" gm tt c php, cng gi l tam v vi, l ba th v vi trong Duy Thc hc : l. H khng v vi : l d cho l ca chn nh ging nh h khng, th tnh thng tr. 2. Trch dit v vi : do s lng ca tr hu phn tch m chng qu tch dit, cng l Nit Bn nh tha. 3. Phi trch dit v vi : l chnh l ca "vin thnh tht", vn l tch dit, chng cn dit na, nn gi l phi trch dit, tc l V d Nit Bn vy.

M Lun ni : "Ngoi s c v khng, cn c ci o huyn diu khc, huyn diu hn s c v khng, gi l Nit Bn". Nhng ti suy xt ci bn th ca o huyn diu, nu qu tht l c, d cho huyn diu, chng phi l khng. D huyn diu chng phi l khng, tc l ch cnh tht c ri; nu qu tht l khng th phi tht khng, khng m tht khng tc l vo ni cnh tht khng. Ni tm li, chng c s khc vi c m phi v, chng c s khc vi khng m phi hu r rng ri. Theo gio l suy xt ngun gc, chng ra ngoi s c v khng, u phi khc vi s c m li ni chng khng, khc vi s khng m li ni chng c? M Lun ni : "Ngoi s c v khng cn c o huyn diu khc, l phi hu phi v, gi l Nit Bn", ti nghe li ny tht cha hp vi chn tm. ---o0o--5. SIU CNH HU V V Danh p : Tn gi ca "hu" v "v" d cho khng php no chng b bao gm, khng c l no chng b l thuc, nhng s bao gm l thuc ch l tc m thi. Trong Kinh ni : "Chn l g? L o ca Nit Bn vy. Tc l g? L php hu v v vy". Ti sao? Hu l hu ni v (1), V l v ni hu (2). Cho nn, hu ci s v gi l "hu", v ci s hu gi l "V"; "Hu" v "V" i i nhau m hnh thnh nn gi l Tc . Th th hu sanh ni v, v sanh ni hu : la hu chng v, la v chng hu; hu v v tng sanh vi nhau cng nh quay bnh xe; cao thp thay phin vi nhau, c cao th phi c thp, c thp th phi c cao. Nh th, hu v v d khc bit u chng th la ni hu vy. y l ch hnh thnh ca ngn ng, ch sanh khi ca th phi, l chng nht nh, u c th bao gm ht c s nhim mu cng tt m din t ci o thn diu ca Nit Bn? Cho nn Lun ni : "Siu xut hu v" l bi ci tn ca hu v ch hn ch trong cnh lc cn v lc trn. Trong cnh lc cn, lc trn chng phi l cn

nh nhim mu ca Nit Bn, nn mn ch "xut" qut tnh m chp m thi. Hy vng nhng ngi hc o, do li ni t lng din t s thm su ca Nit Bn, gi tm ni qun tnh tuyt chng, c qun li, kh ng s phi hu, phi v thi. u phi ngoi hu v v cn c mt ci hu gi vy, y l chp li ni m chng hiu ch, thit sai lm bit bao! Trong Kinh ni : "Tam v vi l bi chng sanh lng xng qua li trong sanh t". Bnh sanh t do ni tai ha ca cn trn, s tai ha ln nht ca cn trn trc tin l do ni hu. Mun xa b s hu, trc tin phi dng v, nn mn ch v sng t s phi hu, sng t s phi hu chng phi cho l tht khng vy. GHI CH (1) V vn chng c sanh t m nay thnh c, vn chng c thn tm m nay c, nn s "hu" l hu ni v m thi. (2) Bi hng tiu tha tiu dit thn tm gii thot sanh t m chng v vi, nn s "v" l v s hu m thi.

---o0o--6. SU TM HUYN DIU

Hu danh vn : Trong Lun ni : Nit Bn chng ra ngoi "c, khng", cng chng trong "c, khng". Chng trong c, khng, th chng th tm c ni c khng; chng ra ngoi c, khng, th chng th la c khng m tm c. Chng c ch tm th phi tt c u khng, m li ni "Diu o chng khng", nu diu o chng khng th ci ng li thm su c th tm; cho nn ngn thnh ng mt qu o, cha tng trng rng, chng c ch quy hng.

Diu o cn m li ni chng ra ngoi, chng trong, y th phi c ch khc thng, nay xin ni cho nghe c chng? ---o0o--7. DIU O THNG TN V Danh p : Ngn ng do danh hiu m khi, danh hiu do hnh tng m sanh, danh tng t vng tng by ra. Nu danh v tng c hai u qun th v danh v thuyt, ngn thuyt khng th t u m nghe? Trong Kinh ni : "Nit Bn phi php nn chng trong, phi phi php nn chng ra ngoi, khng ni khng nghe, v diu o la ngn ng, chng phi do tm m bit c". Ti u dm ni m ng mun nghe vy. Mc d nh th, Tu B ni : "Ta qun Bt Nh vn chng ngn thuyt, nu chng sanh c v tm lnh th, chng nghe m nghe th ta s chng ni m ni". Nay v trnh by li ca Pht gii ta s m chp, cng c th dng li ni ni vy. Duy Ma Ct ni : "Chng la phin no m chng c Nit Bn". Trong kinh Bu N S Vn c bi k ca Thin N rng : "Nh cnh gii ca ma V cnh gii ca Pht Bnh ng ng mt loi, Do Pht thy Pht". (1) Diu o chng ra ngoi, chng trong, nn kinh ni : "chng ra khi cnh gii ma m nhp cnh gii Pht". S y cn phi diu ng, u c th chp theo li ni m cu c. Th th, huyn o ni diu ng, diu ng ni "tc chn"; "tc chn" th "c, khng" cng qun mt lt, cng qun mt lt th ngi v mnh chng phi l hai, cho nn tri t vi ta ng mt gc, vn vt vi ta ng mt th; ng vi ta th chng cn s c khng, khc ta th tri vi

s dung thng; cho nn chng ra ngoi, chng trong, m ngay diu o thng tn. Ti sao? V bc thnh ni tm trng rng m m thm chiu soi, t l t s nn chng c ch no m chng bao gm; m v tr trong lng m linh minh chiu soi c d, hin vn hu ni tm m chn tm lun lun trng rng; do s diu ng nn c ty sch phin no, ph ci m chp t v th, chng c ngun gc nhim mu ca Nit Bn. ng c mi phng, ngay ni no ng m chn tm thng tnh, trng rng vng lng m kh ng t nhin. Tht tr chng l cng tt nn ni "c" m chng c; quyn tr ng c mi phng nn ni "khng" m chng khng; v chng khng nn chng kt ni "khng", v chng c nn chng chp ni "c"; ni "c" m chng c, nn chng c ni "c"; ni "khng" m chng khng, nn chng khng ni "khng". Nh th nn chng ra ngoi "c, khng" cng chng trong "c, khng", u c th cho nht nh phi tm cu ni "c" v "khng" vy. Th th, vn php chng c ci tng "c, khng" (cnh khng), bc thnh chng c ci tri "c, khng" (tm khng). Bc thnh chng c ci tri "c, khng" th chng tc bn trong, vn php chng c ci tng "c, khng" th chng c danh tng bn ngoi. Chng danh tng bn ngoi th cnh tuyt, chng tc bn trong th tr bt. Cnh v tm c hai u tch dit th vt v ng m thm hp mt, trng rng chng my lng, nn gi l Nit Bn. Nit Bn nu nh th th s suy lng ct tuyt, u cn c th chp s "c, khng" bn trong v tm cu s "c, khng" bn ngoi ? GHI CH : (1) Ch c ngi kin tnh thnh Pht mi thy c Pht tnh ca ma vi Pht khng khc.

---o0o--8. VN NN SAI BIT Hu danh vn : Nu tuyt ch suy lng ni Nit Bn th siu xut ngoi lc cn v lc trn, chng ra ngoi, chng trong m huyn o c tn; th th ci o cu cnh l cng, tnh tn, nhim mu hp mt, chng c sai bit l l d nhin ri. M Kinh Phng Quang ni : "o php ca tam tha u v v vi m c sai bit". Pht ni : "Xa kia lc ti lm B Tt tn l Nho ng, nhp Nit Bn thi Nhin ng Pht; lc y Nho ng B Tt mi chng c v sanh php nhn ni tht a, cn phi tin thm ba cp mi chng thp a". Nu Nit Bn l mt th chng nn c ba, nu c ba th chng phi cu cnh. ni l o cu cnh m li c s cao thp chng ng, theo s thuyt php khc bit trong cc kinh, phi ly ci no lm trung o? ---o0o--9. GII P SAI BIT V Danh p : Chnh l ca o cu cnh chng c sai bit. Kinh Php Hoa ni : " nht i o chng c hai chnh l, ta v nhng k gii i m kin lp phng tin, ni o php nht tha m phn ra ni thnh ba". Cng nh li th d "ra khi cn nh la c ba th xe" tc l l ny vy. V u c ra ngoi sanh t nn cng gi l v vi, v loi xe (tha) chng ng nn c ba tn, nu tr v ngun gc th ch l mt thi. Li vn nn rng "Ci o tam tha u v v vi m c s chng sai bit". y l do ngi c ba mi thnh ra ba loi ni v vi, chng phi v vi c ba loi. Nn Kinh Phng Quang ni : "Nit Bn c sai bit ? p rng : khng sai bit". Ch v Nh Lai tp kh phin no u tn, Thanh Vn tp kh cha sch m thi.

Nay ly th d sau y d cho ch xa xi : Nh ngi cht cy, cht i mt thc th mt ht mt thc, cht i mt tc th mt i mt tc, di ngn do ni thc tc chng do ni s mt vy. Mun iu sai bit ca chng sanh l do lc cn lc thc ca chng sanh chng ng, nn s chiu soi ca tr hu c su cn, c hnh c ln nh, nn Tam tha cao thp chng ng m u c n b bn kia. B bn kia u c khc bit, do ngi i t thnh ra khc bit m thi. Th nn vic ty c thuyt php ca cc kinh c sai bit m ch chng c tri nhau vy. ---o0o--10. TRCH S KHC BIT Hu danh vn : Cng ra nh la th s la tai ha l mt, ng ra khi sanh t th v vi cng l mt. M li ni : "B bn kia chng khc, do ngi t thnh ra khc". B bn kia tc l v vi, ngi tc l k chng v vi, xin hi "ngi v v vi l mt hay l khc"? Nu ngi tc l v vi, v vi tc l ngi th chng nn ni v vi chng khc, do ngi t thnh ra khc. Nu ngi khc vi v vi th ngi chng phi v vi, v vi t l v vi, ngi t thng l hu vi, th ci l "m thm dung hp" li mc kt m chng thng. Th th, ngi vi v vi nu l mt th cng chng phi l ba (Tam tha), nu khc cng chng phi l ba, vy ci tn "Tam tha" do u m sanh khi? ---o0o--11. DUNG THNG KHC BIT V Danh p : ni y l y, lc m Nit Bn tc l sanh t; ni kia l kia, lc ng sanh t tc l Nit Bn. Cho nn k ng ni c th s chng c ba tha cng ng c; k ng ni tht th s m hoc lc o cng ng m. Ngi vo ni v vi, ngi tc l v vi, v vi d l mt, u c tri vi s khc bit.

Th d nh ba loi chim ra khi li, cng vo ni chng c tai ha; s chng c tai ha d l ng m chim th mi loi khc nhau, chng th v chim mi loi khc nhau m ni ch chng tai ha cng khc; li chng v ch chng tai ha l mt m li cho nhiu loi chim cng l mt. Th th chim tc l chng tai ha, chng tai ha tc l chim; s chng tai ha u c khc, ch do mi loi chim t thnh ra khc m thi. Nh th chng sanh Tam Tha u ra khi lng vng tng, ng vo ch v vi; v vi d l ng m mi tha khc nhau, chng th v mi tha khc nhau li ni v vi cng khc, cng chng th v v vi l mt m ni Tam Tha cng l mt. Th th ngi tc l v vi, v vi tc l ngi, v vi u c khc, y l do ngi c ba loi, t thnh khc bit m thi. Cho nn ch chng tai ha d l ng m v con chim c ln nh th s bay c xa gn; v vi tuy l mt m m thm chiu soi c su cn. Vy v vi tc l tha, Tha tc l v vi, chng phi Tha c khc vi v vi, v cha n ch cng tt ca v vi, nn mi c s Tam Tha khc nhau vy. ---o0o--12. CT VN NGHA TIM Hu danh vn : Tt c au kh sanh ra u do ni vng tng, vng tng tr th tt c au kh u dt. Nh tha chng c tn tr, B Tt chng c v sanh tr, lc y vng tng u sch, s b buc vnh vin tiu tr; b buc tiu tr th chn tm v vi, tm v vi th chnh l chng my may chng ngi. Kinh ni : "Tr hu ca cc Bc thnh chng tri ngc vi nhau, bt xut bt sanh" (1). Cng ni : "i o v vi bnh ng bt nh". ni bt nh th chng cho tm c khc bit; chng chng th thi, nu chng th phi cng tt, m li ni "S chng cha c cng tt". y l ch ti cha hiu c. GHI CH : (1) V bn nhn chng sanh khi gi l bt xut, v bn duyn chng sanh khi gi l bt sanh, k tht c hai u khng.

---o0o--13. SNG T NGHA TIM V Danh p : V vi bt nh th nh ri, nhng tp kh phin no, nhiu lp m hoc t lu nay, m mun ngay lin dt sch, li ng ni ti cng cha hiu. Kinh ni : "Ba mi tn trng hng tm, ba con th qua sng, nc sng chng khc". Con th th nhy trn mt nc m qua sng; con nga th hoc l chm y sng, hoc l khng chm y sng; con hng tng th lc no cng chm y sng; m c s khc nhau ca su v cn y l do sc lc chng ng vy. Vn vt tuy nhiu, nhng mi loi u c s hn ch v s lng. Gi s tr hu nh X Li Pht, bin ti nh Di Lc, dng ht ti nng tr hu bin ti cng chng soi thu nhng s lng y, hung l ci nhim mu trng rng chng c s lng! Ci o th Nit Bn chng c b bn m mun cho ngi Tam Tha lin n cng cc ? T nh bin ln khng b m thuyn cho c s dm, h khng trng rng m bay ling c xa gn. Ngi Tam Tha i vi o th ca Nit Bn th cng nh th. Lo T ni :"S hc th ngy cng thm, ng o th ngy cng bt". K i ng o l vo ci v vi, vo ci v vi m ni ngy cng bt, s y u phi cho l thnh lnh c c? Cn phi bt ri li bt na, cho n chng cn c g bt na mi thi. Trong kinh c th d v om m v mt tri; tr hu ca Nh Tha ging nh om m, chng dm khi nim chiu khp Nam Thim B Chu; tr hu ca B Tt ging nh mt tri, chiu khp Nam Thim B Chu, th th c bit tr hu dng ra c sai bit ri. ---o0o---

14. CH V TM NG Hu danh vn : Kinh ni : "Ngi chng php thn th c vo ci v vi, chn tm chng th dng tr hu bit, hnh th chng th theo hin tng m suy, bn th ct tuyt ng m v lc cn, tm tr thy u tch dit". M cn ni "S tu tin thm ba cp th s tch cha cng c cng rng ln". S tu c tin trin l do ni tm c ham thch, s tch cha cng c l sanh khi ni c tm tm cu. Tm c ham thch th trong tnh cm hin ra s th x, tm c tm cu th s thm bt giao tranh trc mt. dng th x lm tm, thm bt lm th, m Kinh ni : "Bn th ct tuyt ng m v lc cn, tm tr tch dit", y l li vn tri nhau thnh s khc bit, m sao ng ni " trong mt ngi dng tm ng chng ly l tch"? Chng khc no mun ch li cho ngi lc ng m ch hng nam thnh hng bc? ---o0o--15. NG TCH NHT NH V Danh p : Kinh ni : "Bc thnh v vi m v s bt vi". V v vi nn d ng m thng tch, v v s bt vi nn d tch m thng ng. D tch m thng ng nn tm v cnh chng th l mt; d ng m thng tch nn tm v cnh chng th thnh hai. Tm v cnh chng th thnh hai nn cng ng cng tch, tm v cnh chng th l mt nn cng tch cng ng. Cho nn vi tc l v vi, v vi tc l vi, ng tch d khc nhau m chng th cho l khc c. Kinh o Hnh ni : "Tm cng chng c cng chng khng". Vy kinh chng t rng : chn tm ca Bc thnh chng dnh dng vi c khng. Th th s tu c tin trin v tch cha cng c chng phi c tm ham thch v tm cu, cng chng phi l v tm. Ni "chng c" l chng nh s c ca chng sanh hu tm, ni "chng khng" l cng chng nh s khng ca v tnh v tm.

Ti sao? Hu tm tc l chng sanh, v tm tc l h khng. Chng sanh ch c vng tng, h khng v tri chng c chiu soi, u c th ly s vng tng v v tri tiu biu cho o thn diu ca Nit Bn m ni chn tm ca Bc thnh l c hay l khng? Cho nn, chn tm ca Bc thnh chng c, cng chng th cho l tuyt khng; chn tm ca Bc thnh chng khng, cng chng th cho l tht c. Chng c nn tm thc u dit, chng phi phm phu; chng khng nn chnh l kh hp, chng phi h khng. Chnh l kh hp nn v bin cng c ngay c hong dng, tm thc u dit nn cng thnh chng phi ta chng. Nh th th u cn c s ham thch v tm cu? Cho nn ng c ha khp ni cha tng cho l hu vi, tch nhin bt ng cha tng cho l v vi. Kinh ni : "Tm v s hnh, v s bt hnh" l ng tin vy. B Tt Nho ng ni : "Xa kia ta ly ti sn, thn mng b th cho ngi tri qua v s kip, v dng tm vng tng b th, chng phi l chn b th, nn cu ng Ba La Mt chng c; nay dng tm v sanh, ch ly nm cnh hoa, b th cho Pht, mi c gi l chn th, nn lin c th k thnh Pht". Li, Khng Hnh B Tt vo c ca KHNG ca gii thot mi ni : "Nay ta ang lc hnh, chng phi lc chng", ni ch vo ca "khng" cn chng c chng, hung l tm ng ? Th th tm cng trng rng th hnh cng rng ln, sut ngy hnh m chng tri vi v hnh vy. Cho nn Kinh Hin Kip ni : "S b th chng c k th mi gi l chn b th". Kinh Thnh C tn thn s chng lm m hn lm. Kinh Thin ni : "T tm chnh nh c v duyn t, ng th bi". Kinh T ch ni : "S tri chng c th x mi gi l chn tri, gi l ci tri ca bt tri". Ngha bn Kinh trn ni r ch ca Bc Thnh trng rng nhim mu, li vn khc bit m ng mt ngha, u c th cho rng hu vi l hu vi, v vi l v vi! Kinh Duy Ma Ct ni : "C php mn Tn v Tn bnh ng, nh bc B Tt chng tn hu vi, chng tr v vi". C s gii rng : "Hu vi d ngy, nu b th Pht qu chng thnh; v vi d tht, nu tr th tm hu chng sng", tc l vic ny vy. M ng ly s nam bc lm th d, tht ra chng phi l li c lnh hi. ---o0o---

16. TRUY CU CN NGUYN Hu danh vn : Chng phi chng sanh th chng th tin vo Tam Tha, chng phi Tam Tha th chng th chng qu Nit Bn, vy trc tin phi c chng sanh, sau mi c Nit Bn. Vy th Nit Bn c s bt u (th), c bt u tt c cui cng (chung), m kinh ni "Nit Bn v th v chung, trm nhin nh h khng". Vy th Nit Bn c trc, chng phi do tu hc ri sau mi chng c, ti sao li ni chng sanh chng c Nit Bn? ---o0o--17. DUNG THNG KIM C V Danh p : Bc ch nhn trng rng v hnh m vn vt u do tm to. Ng c vn vt u qui v t k, y ch c Bc Thnh mi chng c. Ti sao? Chnh l ca vn php l nht chn, nu tr hu chng soi thu l y th chng thnh Bc Thnh. Chng phi tr hu Bc Thnh th chng soi thu l y. Vy chnh l tc l Bc Thnh, Bc Thnh chng khc vi chnh l vy. Nn trong kinh i Phm Bt Nh, Thch ni : "Bt Nh do u tm cu"? Tu B p : "Bt Nh chng th ni sc tm cu, cng chng th la ni sc tm cu". Cn ni : "Thy duyn khi tnh khng tc l thy php, thy php tc l thy Pht". y l ci l cnh v tm chng khc vy, th th u cn c s trc sau v th chung na? Cho nn bc ch nhn dng tht tr chiu soi chnh l, ngng ngh trc khi tch nhin chng ng, tim n trong ch ng gio ha chng sanh; v tr trn hin ni gng tm; kh

lai cng thnh mt bn th, thng c kim, ng th chung, cng tt ngn ngun, chng th thnh hai, mnh mng trng rng mi gi l Nit Bn. H c th no phn bit trc sau v th chung na ? Kinh ni : "Chng la cc php m chng c Nit Bn". Cn ni : "Vn php v bin nn b cng v bin". Do , c bit o ca Nit Bn ni diu ng, s diu ng do ni tm v cnh m thm hp lm mt. Th th cnh chng khc tm, tm chng khc cnh, tm cnh m thm dung thng, qui v v cc, tc l th tnh tch dit ca Nit Bn. Nh th tin chng trc, lui chng sau, tc l Tam Tha chng chng phi trc, lc o cn m chng phi sau, v c v kim, trc sau u dt, u c th cho s th chung ln ln trong ! Trong kinh duy Ma Ct, Thin N ni : "X Li Pht chng c gii thot, u c ty thuc thi gian lu hay mau"?. ---o0o--18. XT V S C Hu danh vn : Kinh ni : "Tnh ca chng sanh ch hn ch trong ng m". Li cn ni : "Chng c Nit Bn, ng m u sch v nh n tt". Th th tnh ca chng sanh bng dt trong ng m, o ca Nit Bn kin lp bn ngoi tam gii, r rng l Nit Bn v ng m l hai ci khc nhau th khng cn chng sanh chng c Nit Bn vy. Nu qu tht c s chng c th tnh ca chng sanh chng b hn ch trong ng m, nu b hn ch trong ng m th ng m chng phi "u sch", nu ng m u sch th cn ai chng Nit Bn na? ---o0o---

19. S C NHIM MU V Danh p : S "chn" l do la tnh cm v t tng m hin by; s "ngy" l do chp trc danh tng, c tht m sanh khi. Chp trc nn c c, la chp nn v danh. Cho nn php chn th ng vi chn, php ngy th ng vi ngy. ng cho c c l c, nn ch cu ni c c m thi. Ti cho v c l c, nn c ni v c vy. Theo s lp Lun, trc tin cn phi xc nh cn bn, nay Lun Nit Bn th chng th la Nit Bn m ni Nit Bn; nu ngay ni Nit Bn bn lun th u cn ai chng phi Nit Bn m ng mun c n ? Ti sao? Ci o ca Nit Bn tuyt c danh tng, dung ha tri t, ty sch vn hu, chng cn s lng; tri v ngi khng khc, mt v nhiu vn ng. V khng phi sc nn bn trong khng t thy, v khng phi thanh nn "phn vn" chng t nghe, trng rng tch dit nn cha tng c c, bnh ng bt nh nn cha tng v c. Kinh ni : "Nit Bn chng phi chng sanh, cng chng khc vi chng sanh". Duy Ma Ct ni : "Nu Di Lc c dit th tt c chng sanh cng c dit ". Ti sao vy? Tt c chng sanh bn tnh thng dit, chng cn dit na. Nay gi dit l ni chng dit vy. Nh th, u c th "ng m u sch" m cu c Nit Bn, cng u c th cn ng m m cu c Nit Bn! Th th, chng sanh chng phi chng sanh, ly ai lm k c c ? Nit Bn chng phi Nit Bn, ly g lm php c? Kinh Phng Quang ni : "B do ni hu m c c "? p rng : Chng phi. Do ni v m c c ?

p rng : Chng phi. Do ni hu v v m c c ? p rng : Chng phi. La ni hu v v m c c ? p rng : Chng phi. Th th tt c u v c ? p rng : Chng phi. Ngha ny nh th no? p rng : "V s c nn gi l c vy". Cho nn, c "v s c", "V s c" gi l c, vy th ai chng phi nh th? Do huyn o ni tuyt x (v s tr) nn chng c m c, diu tr tn bn ngoi vt nn chng tri m tri; i tng (l nht chn php gii) n ni v hnh nn chng thy m thy, i m (l m thanh tch dit trm khp) giu ni hy thanh (m thanh siu vit s nghe) nn chng nghe m nghe. Cho nn th tnh ca Nit Bn qung bc mnh mng, bao gm c kim, dn dt chng sanh n tuyt i, gio ha chng sanh khp mi ni, tuy xa m khng thiu st, u c g chng do y m kin lp! Nn Phn Ch ni : "Ta nghe Pht o ngha rng ln thm su, mnh mng chng c b bn, chng khng thnh tu vn php, chng khng ha chng sanh". Nh m ng li ca Tam Tha c khai thc, ng li chn ngy c phn bit, o ca Hin Thnh thng cn, ch ca V Danh c hin by r rng ri vy.

---o0o--HT

You might also like