Professional Documents
Culture Documents
On this page I will tell you about the pros and cons of the rotary screw compressor, what to look for when buying one and common breakdowns that might occur during operation The rotary screw compressor uses two rotors (helical screws) to compress the air. There's a 'female' rotor and a 'male' rotor. The rotors are of different shape, but fit each other exactly. When the rotors start turning, air will get sucked in on one side and gets 'trapped' between the rotors. Since the rotors are continuously turning, the air gets pushed to the other end of the rotors (the 'pressure side') and new fresh air gets sucked in.
Compressor element (oil-free type). Photo: Atlas Copco Because this is a continuous process, this kind of compressor doesn't make a lot of noise; it runs quiet and smoothly. Compared to piston-type reciprocating compressor, the rotary screw compressor is much more expensive, but it will use a lot less energy over the years, resulting in a lower overall cost.
Oil-free or lubricated
The rotary screw compressor is available as oil-injected and oil-free versions. The basic principle is the same (the rotors 'push' the air to one side), but they are quite different machine.
Oil-inject models are by far the most common oil-injected screw-type compressors. When you need a lot of air in your workshop or factory, this type of compressor is usually the best choice! Oil-free models are used for specific special applications. I've mostly seen them on big factories like oil/gas or chemical refineries, big food factories or other places where the compressed air must be 100% oil-free (otherwise it could contaminate the food, product or chemical process).
Quiet operation High volume of air, steady flow. Low energy cost
Cons:
Expensive compared to piston compressors. More suitable for continuous operation only
Cons:
More expensive than oil-injected type Servicing/repairing more difficult, and more expensive than oil-injected type More noise than oil-injected compressors
Example of big rotary screw compressor (old fashioned oil-free type). Photo: Atlas Copco
Failures:
Rotary screw compressors can fail in a number of ways. The most common problem is oil in the compressed air. Most of the times this happens because the oil separator is not doing its job properly. The chances are that the separator element is saturated with oil (read: you didn't service the compressor in time! There's a fixed time limit (running hours) to change the element! ;). Another problem often encountered is water in the compressed air. Since the compressor takes in a huge amount of air (with water vapor), and compresses it to 7 times a smaller volume, a lot of water will be produced. Normally this water is drained using an electronic or mechanical automatic drain. If this drain is broken, the water will stay in your compressed air and fill up your air receiver and piping. If the problem is 'it just won't give me any pressure' .. the problem will most probably be a defective pressure switch (which will start/stop, load/unload the compressor), or a defective inlet valve (which opens and closes the air inlet of the compressor). If it's closed, the compressor is running in 'unloaded' condition and wont supply any air.
OR
Concept:
If you have ever used an electric drill in a piece of wood or metal, you may have noticed that the chips or spirals of metal follow the contour of the flutes up and out of the hole. Most of them, at least. A similar sort of phenomenon occurs inside the rotary screw compressor housing. At the wide end of the screw (sometimes there is one screw operating against a housing, sometimes more than one) an inlet valve allows free air into the screw housing when there is a demand. Free air flows into the housing from the outside as there is a partial vacuum formed inside the rotary screw housing as the screw(s) rotate. Inside the screw housing are the screws in a bath of oil. The oil is there to provide a viscous, flowing, sealing method to help trap the air in the rotary screw flutes. The air / oil mixture in the screw housing moves along the flutes from the wide end of the screw towards the narrow, pulling a vacuum behind, this drawing more air into the screw housing. As the air / oil blend is pulled along the flutes of the screw the space in which the air is contained gets smaller and smaller. The diameter of the screw is larger at the inlet end, and smaller at the discharge end - thus compressing the air. The amount of air trapped in the screw flutes does not change as the air is moved along the narrowing path, but the volume that air is in gets steadily smaller, thus compressing the air. Manufacturers of rotary screw compressors, have their own ideas of what constitutes the ideal geometry of the screw within their air compressor. Rotary screw compressors may have just one screw (also sometimes known as augers) or there may be two or more. Single screw compressors function the same way as multiple screw units, with the air being compressed between the housing of the screw compartment and the screw itself, rather than between two or more screws.
This drawing is to give you an idea of how the rotary screw concept works with two screws. The actual guts of the rotary screw compressor will vary depending on the designs of the company that manufactured that particular compressor. The drawing shows two screws. They would be housed inside the screw compartment of the compressor, in a bath of oil.
At the narrow end there would be an outlet valve which feeds the compressed air /oil mixture from the screw compartment and into a separator. The separator has the job of removing as much oil from the compressed air as possible, and then to release that compressed air into the compressor receiver or into the plant main air lines.
Features / Comments
Although rotary screw compressors are available in lower horsepower ratings, it would appear that it is in the 20-25 horsepower and-higherrange that many industrial compressor applications tend to move towards
using a rotary screw compressor solution from other types of compressors. One major manufacturer states that the rotary screw air compressor has become the most popular source of compressed air for industrial applications. That may be because of the need for a compressor with a continuous duty cycle. Some rotary screw compressor manufacturers claim a duty cycle of 24/7/365, which is pretty incredible for any electromechanical device. Rotary screw compressors are available with a direct motor-toscrew drive, others are belt driven. Each have their benefits, their own drawbacks, and the details of which are best obtained from the actual compressor manufacturer.
Less Maintenance
The perception may be, and one that is claimed by some manufacturers, is that rotary screw units have the least maintenance issues of all types of air compressors and are touted as being the easiest to maintain both in terms of regular maintenance and unscheduled downtime.
Oil Carryover
Others suggest their oil carryover from the compressor into the compressed air supply of the plant is calculated in parts per million per day, that rather than the ounces or more of oil that can enter the plant air-stream from older reciprocating models and some well-used vane models.