Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Table of Contents
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ................................................................................................................................... 3 Introduction: ................................................................................................................................................. 4 ANALYSIS OF BOILERS AND FIRED SYSTEMS ................................................................................................. 5 Boiler Energy Consumption ...................................................................................................................... 5 Balance Equations ..................................................................................................................................... 6 Heat Balance ......................................................................................................................................... 6 Mass Balance ........................................................................................................................................ 6 Efficiency ................................................................................................................................................... 7 Energy Conservation Measures ................................................................................................................ 9 KEY ELEMENTS FOR MAXIMUM EFFICIENCY ................................................................................................ 9 Excess Air ................................................................................................................................................ 12 Requirements to Effect Maximum Economy .............................................................................................. 13 Key Elements for Maximum Efficiency ....................................................................................................... 13 Instrumentation used for energy management ......................................................................................... 14 Measure: ................................................................................................................................................. 15 Optimize: ................................................................................................................................................. 15 Prove: ...................................................................................................................................................... 15 Save: ........................................................................................................................................................ 16 Energy saving opportunities in boilers........................................................................................................ 17 CONDENSING BOILERS ............................................................................................................................ 17 BOILER STACK ECONOMIZERS................................................................................................................. 17 FLUE GAS CONDENSERS .......................................................................................................................... 18 TURBULATORS ........................................................................................................................................ 18 BOILER RESET CONTROL ......................................................................................................................... 18 BLOWDOWN CONTROL........................................................................................................................... 19 BLOWDOWN HEAT RECOVERY................................................................................................................ 19 INSTALL INSULATION .............................................................................................................................. 19 CONSIDER MULTIPLE SMALL BOILERS INSTEAD OF ONE LARGE UNIT.................................................... 19 BOILER SEQUENCE CONTROL .................................................................................................................. 19
Energy Management
Page 1
Energy Management
Page 2
Energy Management
Page 3
Energy Management
Page 4
Similarly, the cost of operating a boiler or fired system can be determined as:
As such, the opportunities for reducing the energy consumption or energy cost of a boiler or fired system can be put into a few categories. In order to reduce boiler energy consumption, one can reduce the load, increase the operating efficiency, reduce the unit fuel energy cost, or combinations thereof. Of course above equations are not always that simple because the variables are not always constant. The load varies as a function of the process being supported. The efficiency varies as a function of the load and other functions, such as time or weather. In addition, the fuel cost may also vary as a function of time (such as in seasonal, time-of-use, or spot market rates) or as a function of load (such as declining block or spot market rates.) Therefore, solving the equation for the energy consumption or energy cost may not always be simplistic.
Energy Management
Page 5
A heat balance is used to determine where all the heat energy enters and leaves a system. Assuming that energy can neither be created nor destroyed, all energy can be accounted for in a system analysis. Energy in equals energy out. Whether through measurement or analysis, all energy entering or leaving a system can be determined. In a simple furnace system, energy enters through the combustion air, fuel, and mixed-air duct. Energy leaves the furnace system through the supply-air duct and the exhaust gases. In a boiler system, the analysis can become more complex. Energy input comes from the following: condensate return, make-up water, combustion air, fuel, and maybe a few others depending on the complexity of the system. Energy output departs as the following: steam, blow down, exhaust gases, shell/surface losses, possibly ash, and other discharges depending on the complexity of the system.
Mass Balance
A mass balance is used to determine where all mass enters and leaves a system. There are several methods in which a mass balance can be performed that can be useful in the analysis of a boiler or other fired system. In the case of a steam boiler, a mass balance can be used in the form of a water balance (steam, condensate return, makeup water, blow down, and feed water.) A mass balance can also be used for water quality or chemical balance (total dissolved solids, or other impurity.) The mass balance can also be used in the form of a combustion analysis (fireside mass balance consisting of air and fuel in and combustion gasses and excess air out.) This type of analysis is the foundation for determining combustion efficiency and determining the optimum air-to-fuel ratio.
Energy Management
Page 6
Efficiency
There are several different measures of efficiency used in boilers and fi red systems. While this may lead to some confusion, the different measures are used to convey different information. Therefore, it is important to understand what is being implied by a given efficiency measure. The basis for testing boilers is the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Power Test Code 4.1 (PTC-4.1-1964.) This procedure defines and established two primary methods of determining efficiency: the input-output method and the heat-loss method. Both of these methods result in what is commonly referred to as the gross thermal efficiency. The efficiencies determined by these methods are gross efficiencies as opposed to net efficiencies which would include the additional energy input of auxiliary equipment such as combustion air fans, fuel pumps, stoker drives, etc. For more information on these methods, see the ASME PTC-4.11964 or Taplin 1991. Another efficiency term commonly used for boilers and other fired systems is combustion efficiency. Combustion efficiency is similar to the heat loss method, but only the heat losses due to the exhaust gases are considered. Combustion efficiency can be measured in the field by analyzing the products of combustion the exhaust gases. Typically measuring either carbon dioxide (CO2) or oxygen (O2) in the exhaust gas can be used to determine the combustion efficiency as long as there is excess air. Excess air is defined as air in excess of the amount required for stoichiometric conditions. In other words, excess air is the amount of air above that which is theoretically required for complete combustion. In the real world, however, it is not possible to get perfect mixture of air and fuel to achieve complete combustion without some amount of excess air. As excess air is reduced toward the fuel rich side, incomplete combustion begins to occur resulting in the formation of carbon monoxide, carbon, smoke, and in extreme cases, raw unburned fuel. Incomplete combustion is inefficient, expensive, and frequently unsafe. Therefore, some amount of excess air is required to ensure complete and safe combustion.
Energy Management
Page 7
Theoretical flue gas analysis versus air percentage for natural gas
Energy Management
Page 8
steam lines and distribution system condensates lines and return system heat exchangers boiler or furnace Repair steam leaks Repair failed steam straps Return condensate to boiler Reduce boiler blow down Improve feed water treatment Improve make-up water treatment Repair condensate leaks Shut off steam tracers during the summer
Energy Management
Page 9
Utilize flash steam Preheat feed water with an economizer Preheat make-up water with an economizer Preheat combustion air with a recuperator Recover flue gas heat to supplement other heating system, such as domestic or service hot water, or unit space heater Recover waste heat from some other system to preheat boiler make-up or feed water Install a heat recovery system on incinerator or furnace Install condensation heat recovery system indirect contact heat exchanger direct contact heat exchanger
Efficiency Improvement
Reduce excess air Provide sufficient air for complete combustion Install combustion efficiency control system Constant excess air control Minimum excess air control Optimum excess air and CO control Optimize loading of multiple boilers Shut off unnecessary boilers Install smaller system for part-load operation Install small boiler for summer loads Install satellite boiler for remote loads Install low excess air burners
Energy Management
Page 10
Switch to alternate utility rate schedule interruptible rate schedule Purchase natural gas from alternate source, self procurement of natural gas Fuel switching switch between alternate fuel sources install multiple fuel burning capability replace electric boiler with a fuel-fired boiler Switch to a heat pump use heat pump for supplemental heat requirements use heat pump for baseline heat requirements Other Opportunities Install variable speed drives on feed water pumps Install variable speed drives on combustion air fan Replace boiler with alternative heating system Replace furnace with alternative heating system Install more efficient combustion air fan Install more efficient combustion air fan motor Install more efficient feed water pump Install more efficient feed water pump motor Install more efficient condensate pump Install more efficient condensate pump motor
Energy Management
Page 11
Excess Air
In combustion processes, excess air is generally defined as air introduced above the stoichiometric or theoretical requirements to effect complete and efficient combustion of the fuel. There is an optimum level of excess-air operation for each type of burner or furnace design and fuel type. Only enough air should be supplied to ensure complete combustion of the fuel, since more than this amount increases the heat rejected to the stack, resulting in greater fuel consumption for a given process output. To identify the point of minimum excess-air operation for a particular fired system, curves of combustibles as a function of excess O2 should be constructed similar to that illustrated in Figure 2. In the case of a gas-fueled system, the combustible monitored would be carbon monoxide (CO), whereas, in the case of a liquid- or solid fueled system, the combustible monitored would be the Smoke Spot Number (SSN). The curves should be developed for various firing rates as the minimal excess-air operating point will also vary as a function of the firing rate (percent load). Figure 2 illustrates two potential curves, one for high-fire and the other for low-fire. The optimal excess-air-control set point should be set at some margin (generally 0.5 to 1%) above the minimum O2 point to allow for response and control variances. It is important to note that some burners may exhibit a gradual or steep CO-O2 behavior and this behavior may even change with various firing rates. It is also important to note that some burners may experience potentially unstable operation with small changes in O2 (steep CO-O2 curve behavior).
Energy Management
Page 12
Energy Management
Page 13
Energy Management
Page 14
Optimize:
Optimize the combustion process by monitoring the flue gases. Only careful monitoring allows operators to strike a balance between supplying too much air, which carries heat away up the flue, and insufficient air, resulting in incomplete combustion. Make sure that boiler duty is at optimum efficiency. For example, dont use two boilers at 30% output if you can run one at 60 - 70% output. Check your instrumentation is up to scratch. Modern instruments are typically more robust and more accurate. They are also easier to maintain, and are less prone to problems such as drift
Prove:
The ability to readily access energy consumption data for a given period or piece of equipment is a key first step in helping to create an effective energy management strategy. Video-graphic data recorders offer an ideal tool for collecting and retrieving data as part of an energy management programme. Benefits include: immediacy of data, with operators able to quickly gain access to years of data; the ability to tie in associated data such as the date and time that an event occurred with specific information on that actual event; ease of use, interface and simple scrolling menus; and lower cost of ownership. Data recorders are helping a major food producer to identify areas for potential energy savings at one of its UK sites. Following a site survey, flow meters and data recorders were installed as part of a site energy monitoring and targeting programme.
Energy Management
Page 15
Save:
Instrumentation, by itself, will not directly save you energy. What it will do, however, is help you to identify the areas where measures can be taken that will help you to optimize your energy consumption.
Energy Management
Page 16
Energy Management
Page 17
TURBULATORS
Install turbulators in the boiler tubes of fire tube boilers to increase heat transfer between the combustion gases and the water. The result is relatively modest improved boiler efficiency. Turbulators are an option to a more costly economizer or air-pre-heater, but energy savings are less. They are simple, easy to install, and low cost. Their installed cost is about $10 to $15 per boiler tube.
Energy Management
Page 18
INSTALL INSULATION
All hot surfaces should be insulated for both worker safety and energy efficiency. Insulation must be in good condition to provide any benefits, for instance wet insulation is worse than no insulation. In general, any surface above 120F should be insulated, including boiler surfaces, piping and fittings. Removable insulating jackets are available for many fittings to allow easy access for maintenance.
Energy Management
Page 19
EFFICIENCY TERMINOLOGY
According to the Boiler Burner Consortium, there are many ways of measuring the efficiency of a boiler and it is important to know which type of efficiency is being used when comparing boilers.
Energy Management
Page 20
Thermal Efficiency
Thermal Efficiency is an indication of the ability of the boilers heat exchanger to transfer heat from the combustion process to the water or steam in the boiler. Thermal efficiency is exclusively a measurement of the effectiveness of the heat exchanger of the boiler and it does not include radiation and convection losses; therefore thermal efficiency is not a true measure of the boilers fuel usage.
Boiler Efficiency
Boiler Efficiency is a term often used interchangeably with the thermal efficiency.
Energy Management
Page 21
Energy Management
Page 22