Professional Documents
Culture Documents
klickpharma.com
Jay Goldman Pharma speaker and Klicks Mobile and Social Media expert
Brian ODonnell Eye for Pharma chair and Klicks lead on Digital Strategy
klickpharma.com
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
2011 will go down in history as the year of the smartphone. There has never been a better time for your organization to make the dive into mobile and to leverage the considerable consumer and HCP interest in smartphone and mobile web platforms. This guide aims to provide pharma marketers with an overview of the key issues and challenges surrounding mobile marketing, as well as some potential solutions for effectively leveraging this channel within the complex regulatory environment. Employing real data and pharma case studies, this guide will explore the common challenges faced with the core strategies most frequently deployed in mobile: optimized websites, native apps, and advertising. This guide will provide an overview of each tactic, the associated legal/regulatory issues, and potential approaches to help marketers implement programs successfully. In reviewing each tactic, we will address concerns and questions commonly cited by pharma marketers. Mobile Optimized Websites Introduction to mobile testing and optimization Overview of mobile browsers Driving traffic Mobile challenges Native Mobile Apps Overview of the mobile app opportunity Understanding hardware vs. operating system vs. ecosystem Apps for pharma and healthcare Design considerations Mobile Advertising In-app advertising Mobile ad networks Fair balance and ISI When youve finished reading this guide, you will hopefully have a much clearer picture of the major challenges facing pharma marketers in mobile, understand what other brands are currently doing in the marketplace, and get some ideas on what you can potentially do to better leverage mobile within the regulatory framework. While not exhaustive, it should at least provide a starting point for discussion with your internal regulatory teams.
A note on recommendations
Recommendations appear throughout this document in the following format: This is a strong recommendation.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION & OVERVIEW . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 MOBILE OPTIMIZED WEBSITES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 MOBILE APPS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 MOBILE ADVERTISING . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 SUMMARY & CONCLUSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
DISCLAIMER The Mobile Marketing guide is provided by Klick Pharma as an informational reference and subject to change without notice. Any opinions published here are those of the author(s) and are not meant to be exhaustive guidelines for online marketing compliance. The recommendations cited here have been developed based on Klick Pharmas interpretation of what is currently happening in the marketplace and where the category appears to be going. Every effort has been made to present accurate and reliable information, but Klick Pharma assumes no responsibility or liability for any errors or inaccuracies that may appear in this document. Furthermore, this guide was not reviewed or developed in consultation with the FDA, and therefore all suggested approaches should always be vetted by your internal regulatory/compliance teams and receive appropriate FDA approvals. All brand names used are the trademarks of their respective owners. All of this information is provided as is and Klick Pharma disclaims any express or implied warranty, relating to the use of this information including warranties relating to fitness for a particular purpose, compliance with a specification or standard, merchantability or non infringement.
klickpharma.com
DEFINING MOBILE
It is well worth defining some important terms before we dive into the practical aspects of mobile marketing. Even the word mobile has different connotations depending on who you speak to. These definitions are provided in broad terms with specific deviations noted throughout the document. Mobile (device): a battery-powered handheld computing and telephony device. Desktop: a traditional, desktop-based computer. This term can also refer to a laptop, in the sense that laptops run software written for the desktop rather than for mobile devices (e.g. its useful to draw a distinction between desktop and mobile web browsers). Featurephone: an older mobile device consisting primarily of a phone with a limited data connection (generally at EDGE speed), and sometimes with the ability to run primitive third party applications (generally written in Java). Featurephones generally fall into either the candybar or flip hardware formats and almost never have a full keyboard (most featurephones include a system like T9 for inputting text using the keypad without having to laboriously repeat keys to type each letter). Smartphone: a modern mobile device consisting of a phone, an always-on data connection (generally at least 3G speed and increasingly 4G), and the capability to install and run third party applications. Smartphone web browsers are increasingly quite sophisticated and rival their desktop counterparts for speed and the ability to render complex, interactive websites. Smartphones generally fall into either touchscreen (e.g. iPhone) or keyboard (e.g. BlackBerry Bold) devices, with some hybrids (e.g. BlackBerry Torch) becoming increasingly popular. Older touchscreen smartphones dont support multitouch, meaning that only one finger is recognized by the display at any time (Apples iPhone pioneered the use of multitouch for gestures like pinching to zoom, which is now a widely accepted standard). Tablet: can refer to either a first generation or second generation tablet device. The first generation are generally Microsoft Windows-based laptops with screens that can be rotated into tablet position. These devices often require a stylus for use on the touchscreen and are considerably bulkier and more limited than their newer cousins. Second generation devices were defined by the launch of the Apple iPad in April 2010, which eschewed the laptop format for a much lighter device built entirely around a touchscreen with no physical keyboard or stylus. 2011 will see the release of more than a hundred Android-based tablets, as well as the much anticipated BlackBerry Playbook from RIM.
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
20 08
86%
84%
83%
81%
79%
76%
73%
69%
10%
Q2
13%
Q3
14%
16%
17%
19%
21%
24%
Q4
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
Q1
20 08
20 08
20 09
20 09
20 09
20 09
20 10
20 10
20 10
20 10
20 11
20 11
02
Feature Phone
Smartphone
2011 also represents a significant shift in the way that consumers are accessing online information. Some key statistics: According to Google, 75% of consumers research symptoms online first and then go see their doctor, while 70% research online after being prescribed a med.1 Yahoo! and Nielsen report that 48% of respondents to their study on The Role of Mobile Devices in the Shopping Process are interested in seeing healthcare or medical-related content on their internet-enabled mobile devices in the next 12 months.2 The Pew Internet and American Life Study on The Social Life of Health Information likewise found that six in ten patients (61%) use the Internet to search for health information.3 Perhaps more critically for marketers, the study found that these searches had an impact on the users decisions and actions.
1 2 3
Google & OTX, Health Consumer Study, December 2009. http://bit.ly/klick-googleOTX eMarketer: Consumers Eager for Mobile Shopping Info. http://bit.ly/klick-healthinfo Pew Internet: The Social Life of Health Information, 2009. http://bit.ly/klick-pewsocial
20 11
Q3
klickpharma.com
These trends are only going to continue as broadband penetration increases, but will differ from the reported numbers in the manner in which the content is accessed. Google reports that searches on mobile phones have grown more than five times in the last two years and surged 130% in the third quarter of 2010.4 They expect to see 250 billion+ searches from mobile in 2011, matching the same levels of search seen on desktops in 2007. The difference is in the trend line, showing an accelerated rate of mobile search that will cross desktop searches in the next few years.
450
400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Desktop searches Smartphone searches
Source: Google
We are at the beginning of a move away from desktop computers toward a mobile-focused world, and pharma/healthcare will be no exception. Morgan Stanley estimates that 50% of all web traffic will come from mobile devices by 2013.5 The Global Mobile Health Market Report estimates that 500 million people will be using healthcare smartphone applications by 2015.6 Innovators and early adopters are there now, as seen in the 3500+ healthcare apps already available for download on iPhone and Android. Depending on the target for your campaigns, the early majority may already be there as well, particularly for younger audiences (29% of 18-29 year olds already use their mobile devices to access health information online).7 Finally, we see an expanded future for mobile as the world adopts tablet devices with open arms. The trend started by the iPad will continue solidly over the next five years, with Forrester Research calling for tablets to grow as quickly as MP3 players.8
4 5 6 7 8
Google Mobile Searches Soar as Thumb Shopping Gains Steam. http://aol.it/klick-mobilesearch Morgan Stanley: Mobile Internet Report, December 2009. http://bit.ly/klick-morgan Global Mobile Health Market Report 2010-2015. http://bit.ly/klick-globalmobile Pew Internet: Mobile Health 2010 report. http://bit.ly/klick-pewhealth Forrester Research: US Tablet Sales Will More Than Double This Year. http://bit.ly/klick-tablets
Millions
50.7
42.3
44.0
10.3
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
Source: Forrester Research Report Tablets Will Grow As Fast As MP3 Players
Forrester expects sales of nearly 25 million tablets in 2011, with the lions share going to Apple (and continuing to do so through 2012). They expect 82 million American consumers one third of the total online audience to have a personal tablet by 2015. This trend has definitely started to take root in the pharma world, with a growing movement toward arming sales reps with tablets (iPads for the most part).
klickpharma.com
MOBILE WEBSITES
Mobile tested and optimized websites are the simplest way to get involved in mobile marketing. At the most basic level, this involves testing your existing website on the most popular mobile devices and browsers to ensure that it displays and functions correctly what we refer to as a mobile-tested website. At a more complex level, this can involve rethinking your existing website to produce a mobileoptimized website, which presents a presentation layer laid out and designed for the mobile experience on top of your existing content. Given the sharp increase in traffic from mobile devices, a mobiletesting plan should be considered a basic requirement for all digital campaigns. Our own klickpharma.com website demonstrates best practice for mobile sites. Visiting the site from your desktop browser delivers a rich media experience suitable to browsing on a large screen, fast connection, and focused environment. Visiting the same URL from a mobile browser automatically delivers a mobile-optimized version of the site that omits the Flash video and focuses on a simplified menu offering direct access to the content visitors are most likely seeking. Always provide a link from mobile-optimized sites to the full version of your site. Not all mobile users want a simplified experience and browser detection technology is not a perfect science. The basic concept is an important one to understand. Think of your existing website as a series of stacked layers:
Presentation Content
Dynamic websites often use a Content Management System (CMS) to make the content easily editable and manageable by non-technical team members. The Presentation layer sits on top of that and defines what the website actually looks like and how the content gets displayed. The best approach to building mobile-optimized sites is to add additional Presentation layers:
Presentation
Presentation
Presentation
Content
Think of this as a book thats available in different editions: the underlying text doesnt change but each
10
edition looks very different from its peers. Two hardcover editions are more similar than a hardcover and paperback a fairly accurate way to think about the difference between a big, heavier desktop version and a much lighter, smaller, mobile version. It is important to note, from a pharma perspective, that the FDA DTC regulations (especially those related to branded vs. unbranded sites) still very much apply in the mobile world. Some of those regulations, like fair balance, are made more challenging when dealing with smaller screen sizes, so it is especially important that your mobile campaigns go through the same rigourous review process as your desktop sites. That may prove to be a challenge in and of itself as many MRL reviewers will want to see the site in context of the devices it is designed for, so you should plan to have some sample devices available during the review process.
Mobile Browsers
Web browsers on mobile platforms are not significantly different than they are on desktops like Windows or Mac OS. The major mobile operating systems iPhone, Android, and BlackBerry all ship with their own default browser, the latest versions of all three being nearly as fully featured as their desktop cousins. Users of Android and Maemo (the operating system used by some Nokia smartphones and tablets) have the option of installing Firefox Mobile on their devices, while users of Android, Maemo, Windows Mobile, BlackBerry, and iOS have the option of installing Opera.
An important note on mobile browser compatibility: the underlying technology that handles actually rendering websites in the iPhone, Android, and BlackBerry (starting with BlackBerry OS 6) web browsers is called WebKit, and is the same technology that powers Safari and Chrome on the desktop. This makes testing considerably simpler since a site that displays correctly on one platform is very likely to display correctly on the other two (though you should still test across all three since this is not a guarantee).
klickpharma.com
11
for example, is a link to the Klick Pharma website. Most smartphones (with the notable exception of iPhones) include the ability to scan QRCodes automatically.
12
MOBILE APPS
Apps are at the more complex end of the mobile marketing spectrum, requiring development of custom software for each platform. The numbers alone attest to the importance of this opportunity: Gartner expects mobile users to download 17.7 billion apps in 2011, a 117% year-over-year increase, and are calling for an astounding 185 billion apps by 2014.9 As of January 2010, Apple has more than 400,000 apps available in the iTunes App Store, with over 10 billion downloads across the iPhone, iPod touch, and iPad.10 The Google Android Market has more than 200,000 apps available in 34 countries worldwide.11 86% of mobile users aged 35-44 report having downloaded an app, followed by 85% of those aged 18-24.12
Truly understanding the mobile app opportunity means understanding the underlying technology and marketplace. Mobile apps really apply to the smartphone market. In North America, the market is divided between Apple, RIM, and Android, with RIM historically enjoying the largest share but now facing a continued decline as it loses ground to the other players (Android specifically).
40%
38% 39% 35% 35% 37%
36%
36%
30%
Market Share
28%
29%
28%
27%
28%
27%
27% 23%
28%
20%
19% 18% 16% 12% 10% 7% 2% 4% 8% 8% 13%
22%
10%
0% Oct 2009
Nov 2009
Dec 2009
Jan 2010
Feb 2010
Mar 2010
Apr 2010
May 2010
Jun 2010
Jul 2010
Aug 2010
Sep 2010
Oct 2010
Nov 2010
RIM BlackBerry
Apple iOS
Google Android
The worldwide market is less evenly divided, with Nokia still owning a significant share in some markets
9 10 11 12 Gartner: Forecast: Mobile Application Stores, Worldwide, 2008-2014. http://bit.ly/klick-gartner Apples App Store Downloads Tops 10 Billion. http://bit.ly/klick-appstore Wikipedia: Android Market. http://bit.ly/klick-androidmarket eMarketer: How Mainstream are Mobile Apps? http://bit.ly/klick-appsbyage
Dec 2010
klickpharma.com
13
(notably Asia, Africa, and Eastern Europe). Players outside of the big three have yet to really capitalize on the app opportunity, and so the decision for marketers rests on which one of those platforms best match your target audience. We expect to see the Android trend very much continue this year as the number of available devices expands. Several carriers and manufacturers, including T-Mobile in the US, have committed to releasing sub $100 Android handsets before the end of the year, which will drive considerable adoption across all market segments. It is our expectation that Android will become the dominant smartphone platform by market penetration, but that Apple and RIM will continue to hold sizeable portions of the consumer and enterprise markets respectively. It can be difficult enough to design and build the right app without having to worry about getting it right across three platforms. We recommend releasing your app as a pilot for one operating system, refining, and then releasing across the platforms with highest penetration in your target audience.
14
Google Android Android is an Open Source13 operating system made by Google and available on a very wide variety of hardware options. Although Google has partnered with HTC to design and market two of their own phones (the Nexus and Nexus S), Android handsets are mostly produced by other device manufacturers. Samsung and HTC have been leading the way to date, with some very promising announcements from Motorola suggesting that they will become much more involved in this market. Given the number of manufacturers and model numbers, building applications for Android is more complicated than building for iOS since your app has to account for more screen sizes, hardware features, and manufacturer/carrier customizations. Google has recently announced a new operating system, called Chrome OS, which will power netbooks and laptops. It is far too early in the lifetime of that product to make any solid recommendations toward it, and so marketers should plan on Android releases with an eye toward evaluating Chrome OS at a later date. The app ecosystem for Android has been relatively strong since launch, lagging behind Apple but showing genuine promise. The Android Market has recently been relaunched to provide a much more robust shopping experience and to offer developers additional flexibility with regard to international customers and in-app purchasing two options Apple has had for some time now. Developers are much freer on Android and can build almost anything they can imagine without needing to go through an approval channel to distribute their apps. RIM BlackBerry OS RIM has recently launched BlackBerry OS version 6, a much improved version of their popular offering that fully integrates touchscreen devices into the BlackBerry experience. Most of their older devices still in market are running BlackBerry OS version 5, with 6 now available on the Torch, Bold, and Curve. RIM has also recently announced a new operating system called QNX, which will power their forthcoming PlayBook tablet. They have committed to QNX gradually replacing OS 6 across all of their future devices, but have yet to provide a timeline. Apps written for BlackBerry OS 6 should run correctly on QNX, and so we recommend that marketers not wait for the next generation of hardware if BlackBerry use is high in their target audience. Developing apps for the BlackBerry platform brings a unique set of challenges. There have been a significant number of BlackBerry devices, many of which have different input options (e.g. scroll wheels, track balls, track pads, and touchscreens). The different devices have very different screen sizes, some
13 Open Source means that Google provides the source code for the software at no charge so that other companies and
people can use it on their devices as well as to contribute fixes and improvements back to Google.
klickpharma.com
15
in portrait orientation and others in landscape. Each major release of BlackBerry OS has also brought new functionality into the mix, meaning that apps have to be planned and tested for a very specific set of supported hardware from the outset. Although it is well worth making these decisions given the size of the market, it should be factored into any BlackBerry app plans. App distribution on BlackBerry OS has traditionally been achieved through the use of third party websites and app catalogs. RIM released the App World store in April 2009, providing a subset of the features found in Apple and Googles offerings. BlackBerry users are starting to install more apps as the concept becomes familiar, though the size of the store and richness of the offerings lags behind the other platforms. Cross-Platform App Development There are a few third party toolkits available that claim to allow you to build your application once and have it run on multiple platforms (particularly iOS and Android). The market leader in this field is Phone Gap14, which supports iOS, Android, BlackBerry OS 4.6 and higher, HP WebOS, Microsoft Windows Phone 7, and Nokias Symbian. Your app developers build your app using standard HTML, JavaScript, and CSS as though they were building a website and the toolkit wraps the app into a native package for distribution through the various app stores. This may be a viable alternative for some apps, though it is important to note that mobile users are notoriously fickle, insisting on apps that match their expectation for the platform. It is very difficult to achieve a platform native look and feel when not actually writing code for that platform. You will also be dependent on the third party toolkit to keep up to date with the latest features of each platform in order to use them in your app, which will be a limiting factor for particularly advanced apps.
16
available to American radiologists since shortly after its release. MIMvista released the app in the safe harbour of non-diagnostic use, a regulatory grey zone that precludes FDA review for products that will never be used for diagnosis. Realizing that radiologists were likely to use the app for that exact purpose, MIMvista submitted a 510(k) application to the FDA under the belief that it was sufficiently equivalent to their existing products to not require additional approval. The FDA responded with a Not Substantially Equivalent (NSE) letter in January 2010, stating your device has new technological characteristics that could adversely affect safety and effectiveness and raise new types of safety and effectiveness questionsTherefore, this device is classified by statute into class III (Premarket Approval). The decision was based on the fact that your device has a new indication for displaying medical images for diagnostic use on a mobile/portable device. Mark Cain, MIMvistas Chief Technology Officer, believes this applies to any mobile or portable device, including tablets and laptops, and that the FDA will view all of those devices as class III. Their emphasis was purely on portable and mobile devices, he said. The way I read this, laptops, iPads, anything that is carried around and used for diagnosis has no predicate and, therefore, is a class III device. The FDA granted 510(k) clearance for Mobile MIM on February 4th, 2011, clearing the app for sale in the US.15 Getting to Medical Regulatory Legal Approval Every companys MRL process will differ enough to make generalizations difficult. Some important considerations as your pursue approval for your mobile app campaigns: Mobile apps are uncharted territory for many pharma and healthcare companies. It is well worth involving your review panel as early as possible, ideally seeking their pre-approval at early, conceptual milestones rather than waiting to show them the finished product. Your approvers are likely reviewing one of their first mobile apps, and will therefore need a fair amount of background information to consider the context of use. If allowable, consider having your development partner present during the MRL process to help answer questions. Reviewers are likely to want to see the application running on the devices it is built for rather than in the abstract context of screenshots and documentation. You may therefore need to convene in-person meetings of your review panel and consider how to document that process for archiving in your electronic review process. Reviewers may not have access to the hardware required to complete their reviews, particularly for multi-platform apps. This will also be true during the User Acceptance Testing (UAT) phase of development, during which your staff will need to test the app.
15
klickpharma.com
17
You may therefore need to have some example devices available during the review and testing process, which you should budget for at the outset of your program. Pharma companies will want to consider the impact of app store reviews on their Adverse Event (AE) SOPs. The three major app stores (as well as the third party Android stores operated by Samsung and Amazon) provide a free form field for anyone to provide a review of your app. There is no way to disable this functionality or to require pre-approval before publication. Although it is highly unlikely that anyone would use this space as an opportunity to report an AE (especially one that met the FDAs reporting criteria), it is well worth noting and preparing a policy to handle.
Design Considerations
Designing a mobile app can be a very foreign experience for those marketers who are new to the field. There are many parallels to designing other types of digital campaigns that will feel familiar, but there are a number of new considerations that need to be accounted for. Confidentiality and Privacy Marketers should consider the type of information their app is going to collect and ensure that the app is properly designed to protect it. Many pharma and healthcare apps take advantage of the omnipresent nature of mobile devices, designing experiences around data collection and logging (e.g. food/symptom/ weight logs). The general best practice is to have apps launch without requiring any form of password protection, but you should consider offering that functionality if users are likely to want to keep their information secure. Take Full Advantage of the Device Rebuilding your website as a mobile app is a costly expenditure that delivers little additional value. Mobile devices have many properties that set them apart from the desktop world, including being omnipresent in users lives, having always on data connections, including phones for tap-to-call16 functionality, being able to deliver push notifications, and being filled with sensors like microphones, cameras, GPS, accelerometers, gyroscopes, etc. Take full advantage of these properties to deliver an experience that users couldnt have elsewhere and they will make repeated use of your app.
16
Tap-to-call involves tapping a button in your app and having a sales or customer service rep place an immediate call to
18
MOBILE ADVERTISING
Mobile advertising is a relatively new field, emerging as the mobile platforms have gained higher and higher penetration rates. There are two significant opportunities available to marketers aimed at promoting your product, driving traffic to your mobile site, and leading would-be users to download your app. In-App Advertising: there are four major networks offering in-app advertising, reselling the inventory provided by other app developers. Although we would not recommend providing inventory within pharma and healthcare apps, purchasing media within other very targeted apps can be an excellent way to attract users to your own app. Look to Millennial Media and Apple iAd as the premier networks in this space, both offering the richest capabilities for dynamic ad formats. Both are familiar with the DTC regulations and can provide ad formats that allow for the inclusion of Important Safety Information (ISI). Some networks may provide inventory on a Cost-Per-Acquisition model (CPA), which will be higher than their CPM rates but may ultimately be more cost effective as you only pay when someone clicks and ultimately installs your app. Mobile Ad Networks: all of the major ad networks now provide the ability to target webbased ads at mobile users, displaying them only to mobile devices that meet specified criteria. CPM rates are quite similar to those you would find for desktop inventory. This can be an excellent method to reach consumers outside of the desktop, as this graph illustrates:
11pm
Traffic
1pm 8pm
7am Time
Desktop use
Source: Google
Smartphone use
Your media partner should have relationships in place with vendors of both types of ads and be in a position to advise you on the best strategy for your campaign.
klickpharma.com
19
How to Embrace the Mobile Revolution with Open Arms 1. Make mobile website testing a mandatory step in every web-based campaign you undertake going forward. 2. Develop a mobile-optimized version of your site in parallel with the desktop version or as a second phase. Make sure to keep the considerations listed in the Mobile Websites section of this document in mind as youre planning it. 3. Build an app for iOS as a pilot, followed closely by Android when it has matured to version one. Build a BlackBerry app at the same time if BlackBerries are prominent in your target audience.
20