BI THU HOCH DIN N

H S HNH S S 04/DA2
V n Phm Thnh Trung cp ti sn
I. TM TT NI DUNG V N:
1.

Nhng ngi tham gia t tng

- B co: Phm Thnh Trung, L Vn o.
- Ngi b hi: Bi Vn Cng, Nguyn i Dng.
-

2.

Ngi lm chng: V nh Khim, ng Trng ng.

Tm tt ni dung v n

Do nghi ng anh Bi Vn Cng v Nguyn Di Dng em bo sang

Thy Nguyn bn, tranh khch ca ch Nguyn Th H (d rut ca Trung), ti
ngy 02/5/x, Trung n r o sng hm sau sang Thy Nguyn e
nh.
Sng ngy 3/5/x Trung v o n ch sn nh cu Bnh. Khong 8g,
khi thy anh Cng v anh Dng ang dt xe p ch bo t chn cu i ln,
anh Dng i trc pha lng ng, anh Cng i sau pha trong lan can cu,
Trung v o xng ra chn nh anh Cng, anh Dng. Sau khi nh xong,
Trung c xin anh Cng 30.000 ng i xe m v c anh Cng cho 20.000
ng. Nhng sau , nghe li ca o, Trung tr li 20.000 ng cho Cng.
Trung v o yu cu anh Dng, anh Cng khng c tip tc sang bn bo
Thy Nguyn.
Sau , o yu cu Dng thu xe m ch o v Trung v. Dng
thu ng ng Trng ng ch o v Trung i v a cho ng ng
100.000 ng. ng ng ch Trung v o n ca hng xng du Hng An
th nh ng V nh Khim ch gip mt ngi. Lc , o ly li 100.000
ng m Dng a cho ng ng v ln xe ng Khim ch i; Trung tip
tc i xe ca ng ng v n nh Hng ri v nh.
Ngy 25/8/x, Vin Kim st nhn dn qun Hng Bng, tnh Hi Phng
ra Co trng truy t Phm Thnh Trung v L Vn o ra trc TAND

qun Hng Bng v ti Cp ti sn theo im d khon 2 iu 133 B lut

Hnh s.
Ngy 05/9/x, TAND qun Hng Bng quyt nh a v n ra xt x
vo ngy 21/9/x.
II. K HOCH XT HI:
-

T cch tham gia xt hi: Lut s bo cha cho Phm Thnh Trung.

nh hng bo cha: Khng phm ti.

nh hng, mc ch hi: Lm sng t mc ch ca Trung l ngn

chn khng cho Cng v Dng sang Thy Nguyn bn bo, khng c
mc ch chim ot ti sn; khng dng dao e da Cng v Dng.
-

1.

Hi b co Phm Thnh Trung:

- Hi v l do Trung chn nh Cng v Dng.
- Hi lm r vic Trung c ly tin t ti qun v gi xe ca

Cng khng.
- Hi xc nh li vic Trung c chim ot s tin 20.000 do

Cng a hay khng.

- Hi lm r vic Trung c s dng dao e da Cng v Dng

khng.
- Hi v thi v hnh ng ca Dng khi thu xe m, nhm xc

nh vic Dng a 100.000 thu xe l t nguyn v khng phi v b

Trung v o e da.
2.

Hi anh Bi Vn Cng
- Hi xc nh s tin Cng khai l b Trung cp l c tht hay

khng?
V d:
Mi ngy anh bn khong bao nhiu t bo? Thu nhp c
bao nhiu tin? Sng ngy 03/5x, anh ly bao nhiu t bo i bn? Bao
nhiu tin?

Tin anh bn bo c, anh b trong r xe hay d trong ti?

Ti no?
Sng ngy 3/5/x, trc khi b chn nh, anh bn c bao
nhiu t bo? (Anh c th c lng?)

- Hi lm r Cng c nhn thy Trung ly tin ca mnh khng.

Hi v v tr ng ca Dng (ng trc hay sau Cng)

- Hi lm r Trung c dng dao e da Cng v Dng khng?

Hi v v tr ng ca Dng lc ny.
V d:
Anh ni Trung c cm dao e da anh, vy t th, v tr ca
anh, anh Dng, Trung, o lc cm dao e da anh nh th no?

Anh cho bit Trung cm dao tay no? Ly dao u ra? Sau
khi e da xong, Trung ct giao u?

Anh khai l hong s khng nh r Trung ly dao u, cm

tay no( Bt lc 64), ti sao li nh r c im con dao?

c im con dao m anh khai l c im con dao ca anh

dng ch khng phi l dao ca Trung v thc t l Trung khng c cm
dao e da anh, c phi khng? (Bt lc 73, li khai ngy 27/7: V ti
s dng loi dao ny nn ti bit).

3.

Hi anh Nguyn i Dng:

- Hi lm r Dng c thy Trung ly tin ca Cng khng?
V d:

Sng ngy 03/5/x, khi dn xe p ln nh cu Bnh th anh i

trc, anh Cng i sau c phi khng?

khng?

Khi b o nh th anh nhn i din (trc din) vi o phi

Anh khai r anh ch thy Trung thc tay vo ti qun ca anh

Cng hay thy Trung thc tay vo ti qun ca Cng v ly tin ra?

Anh i trc anh Cng v b o chn nh trc u xe ca

anh, anh i din vi o th tt nhin quay lng v phi anh Cng, t th
nh vy lm sao anh c th thy Trung nh Cng v ly tin ca Cng
c?

- Hi lm r vic Trung c cm dao e da Cng v Dng khng?

Hi v c im con dao tm ra mu thun trong li khai.
V d:
Anh ni Trung c cm dao e da anh, vy t th, v tr ca
anh, anh Cng, Trung, o lc cm dao e da anh nh th no?

Anh cho bit Trung cm dao tay no? Ly dao u ra? Sau
khi e da xong, Trung ct giao u?

Anh khng h nhn thy con dao no m ch on v khai nhn

c im con dao theo con dao m anh dng c phi khng? (Bt lc 96
Li khai ngy 27/7: V ti thy cn dao ging loi dao bm Trung Quc
nn ti xc nh nh vy, V ti s dng loi dao ny nn qua nhn
c im th ti on nh vy (cn rng khong 2cm), cn thc t th ti
khng khng nh chc chn).

- Hi v c ch, li ni ca Trung v o khi yu cu Dng gi xe

m. Hi v li ni ca Dng khi gi xe m. Nhm xc nh Trung v o
khng c hnh ng uy hip, e da Dng thu xe m.
V d:
o v Trung c ai c hnh ng g e da, uy hip anh v
Cng khi yu cu anh thu xe m khng?

(Bt lc 93 Li khai ngy 18/5: Khi a tin cho ng xe m th

ti ch ni: Chu tr tin cho hai anh ny. Lc ny th bn chng khng
e da g ti c)

4. Hi b co L Vn o:
- Hi v l do chn nh Cng v Dng.
- Hi lm r Trung c ly tin t ti qun v gi xe ca Cng

khng?
V d:

Khi chn nh anh Dng, t th ca anh v anh Dng nh

th no?
Anh c nhn thy Trung mc ti ca anh Cng khng? (Bt
lc 155 Li khai ngy 26/5: Trong lc nh th ti khng nhn thy
Trung th tay vo ti mc tin hoc xin tin cc em bn bo).

- Hi lm r Trung c dng dao e da Cng v Dng khng.

5. Hi ngi lm chng ng Trng ng

- Hi lm r thi ca Dng khi thu xe.

V d:
C phi sng ngy 03/5/x, anh Dng thu ng ch Trung
v o? Dng ni g vi ng v tr ng bao nhiu tin?

Khi thu xe m, ng thy thi ca Dng nh th no?

- Hi v hnh ng c ch ca Trung v o lm r Trung vo

o khng c hnh vi e da.

V d:
Trung v o c li ni, c ch hay hnh ng g i vi
Dng v Cng khng?

III. BN LUN C BO CHA CHO B CO PHM THNH TRUNG

CNG HA X HI CH NGHA VIT NAM

c lp T do Hnh phc
TP. H , ngy

thng

nm

Knh tha Hi ng xt x;
Tha i din Vin Kim st;
Tha cc v Lut s ng nghip;
Ti l Nguyn Vn A, l Lut s thuc Vn phng Lut s X, on
Lut s TP. H Ch Minh. Nhn li yu cu bo cha ca b co Phm
Thnh Trung v c s chp thun ca Qu Ta, ti c mt ti Phin
ta ngy hm nay vi t cch l Lut s bo cha cho thn ch ti l b
co Phm Thnh Trung.
Qua nghin cu h s v n v phn xt hi cng khai ti Phin ta
ngy hm nay, ti xin nu li mt s nt chnh v din bin v n nh sau:
Do nghi ng anh Bi Vn Cng v Nguyn Di Dng em bo sang Thy
Nguyn bn, tranh khch ca ch Nguyn Th H (d rut ca Trung), ti
ngy 02/5/x, Trung n r o sng hm sau sang Thy Nguyn e
nh. Sng ngy 3/5/x Trung v o n ch sn nh cu Bnh.
Khong 8g, khi thy anh Cng v anh Dng ang dt xe p ch bo t
chn cu i ln, anh Dng i trc pha lng ng, anh Cng i sau
pha trong lan can cu, Trung v o xng ra chn nh anh Cng,
anh Dng. Sau khi nh xong, Trung v o yu cu Cng v Dng
khng c tip tc sang Thy Nguyn bn bo v vt bo xung sng.
Sau , o yu cu Dng thu xe m ch o v Trung v. Dng
thu ng ng Trng ng ch o v Trung i v a cho ng ng
100.000 ng. ng ng ch Trung v o n ca hng xng du Hng
An th nh ng V nh Khim ch gip mt ngi. Lc , o ly li
100.000 ng m Dng a cho ng ng v ln xe ng Khim ch i;
Trung tip tc i xe ca ng ng v n nh Hng ri v nh. Theo li
khai ca Dng th Trung c th tay vo ti qun ca Cng v ly tin
trong r xe ca Cng. Cng khai s tin b mt l khong 360.000 ng.
Dng v Cng cng khai Trung dng dao e da mnh.
Theo Co trng ca Vin Kim st nhn dn qun Hng Bng v li lun
ti ca v i din Vin Kim st ti Phin ta ngy hm nay, hnh vi ca

Trung b truy t v ti Cp ti sn theo quy nh ti im d khon 2

iu 133 B lut Hnh s.
Ti khng ng vi truy t ca Vin Kim st v lun ti ca v
i din Vin Kim st. Vic truy t, lun ti Phm Thnh Trung phm
ti cp ti sn vi tnh tit nh khung tng nng dng hung kh nguy
him l hon ton khng c c s.
Theo quy nh ti khon 1 iu 133 B lut Hnh s, mt ngi b
coi l thc hin hnh vi cp ti sn nu dng v lc, e do dng v lc
ngay tc khc hoc c hnh vi khc lm cho ngi b tn cng lm vo
tnh trng khng th chng c c nhm chim ot ti sn. Mc ch
chim ot ti sn l yu t bt buc cu thnh ti phm ny. thc
chim ot ca ngi phm ti phi c trc khi thc hin hnh vi dng
v lc, e da dng v lc ngay tc khc hoc c hnh vi khc lm cho
ngi b tn cng lm vo tnh trng khng t v c.
i vi v n ny, t u n cui Trung khng h c mc ch
chim ot ti sn ca Cng hoc Dng. Trung ch mun e nh Cng
v Dng Cng v Dng khng sang Thy Nguyn bn bo tranh
khch vi d ca Trung l ch Nguyn Th H. y chnh l mc ch duy
nht ca Trung trong v n ny.
Vic buc Trung c mc ch v hnh vi chim ot ti sn ca
Cng l 360.000 ng, Vin Kim st ch da vo li khai ca Dng v
li khai ca Cng. Vic buc ti nh vy l phin din, khng c c s.
Theo h s v n cng nh li khai ca Bi Vn Cng ti phin ta ngy
hm nay, Cng ph nhn vic Trung xin tin ca Cng v tha nhn
khng nhn thy Trung ly tin ca mnh. Anh o cng xc nhn:
Trong lc nh th ti khng nhn thy Trung th tay vo ti mc tin
hoc xin tin cc em bn bo (Bt lc 155 Li khai ngy 26/5). Chnh
Dng cng khng chc chn v li khai ca mnh: Thc t ti ch nhn
thy ngi nh Cng mc tay vo ti qun, cn c th ti khng r
(Bt lc 90 Li khai ngy 11/5). Trong v n ny ch c 04 ngi, ch c
Dng l khai nhn nhn thy Trung c th tay vo ti qun ca Cng v
cng khng chc chn Trung c ly tin ca Cng v ly bao nhiu. Trong

phn xt hi cng cho thy, lc Cng b nh, Dng cng ang b o

chn trc u xe v b o nh, Dng hng i din vi o v quay
lng v pha Cng. Vy lm sao Dng nhn thy Trung ly tin ca Cng
c?! Vic xc nh s tin m Cng b mt l 360.000 ng ch da vo
li khai v tnh ton ca Cng m khng c c s no chng minh. Mt
thanh nin bn bo, ch mi bt u y xe i bn n khong 8g sng m
bn c 360.000 ng liu c l con s ng tin, xc thc hay khng?!
Nh vy, khng c s s xc nh Trung c mc ch, hnh vi chim
ot ti sn ca Cng, hay ni cch khc Trung ch ch c hnh vi e nh
Cng vi mc ch duy nht ca Trung l yu cu Cng v Dng khng
c sang Thy Nguyn bn bo, khng h c mc ch chim ot ti
sn.
V vic thu xe m ca ng ng v tr cho ng ng 100.000 ng,
Trung khng yu cu vic ny. Trung v o cng khng c hnh vi e
da, uy hip g i vi Cng v Dng buc Dng thu xe m cho
mnh. Vic thu xe m v tr tin cho ng ng 100.000 ng l do Dng
hon ton t nguyn. Li khai ca Dng ti bt lc s 93 Li khai ngy
18/5 xc nhn: Khi a tin cho ng xe m th ti ch ni: Chu tr tin
cho hai anh ny. Lc ny th bn chng khng e da g ti c. ng
ng cng xc nhn anh Dng t thu xe v a tin cho ng, Trung v
o khng c hnh vi g uy hip hay e da, ng cn nhm tng rng h
l ch quen bit: anh Dng ni: Bc ch 2 anh chu i, ht bao tin
bc ly, cn bao nhiu a li cho anh chu tiu; khi anh Dng thu xe
ti, ti thy hai thanh nin trn khng ni g vi anh Dng nn ti ngh
h l ch quen bit nhau (Bt lc 111 Li khai ngy 18/5). Cng theo
li khai ca ng ng trong h s v ti phin ta ngy hm nay, Trung
cng khng c ly li 100.000 ng ny m o yu cu ly li: Khi
dng xe th thanh nin ci trn (o) bo ti a li s tin ca Dng
nn ti a li ton b s tin trn cho bn chng.
Vin Kim st cng truy t Trung dng hung kh nguy him l dao
bm e da Cng v Dng cp ti sn. iu ny cng hon ton
khng c c s. Ton b h s v n khng c vt chng no l dao bm!
Vin kim st ch da vo li khai ca Dng v Cng cho rng Trung

 dng dao e da h l khng c s thuyt phc v khng m

bo s tht khch quan ca v n. Hn na, li khai ca Cng v Dng
cn c nhiu mu thun. Lc Cng khai dao di khong 7cm, rng
khong 1cm(Bt lc 62 Li khai ngy 03/5 ti Cng an Phng
Thng L), lc li khai: l con dao nhn, loi dao bm, c li dao
v cn dao di khong 20 cm, bn rng khong 2cm, u dao nhn, cn
dao mu nht (Bt lc 64 Li khai ngy 06/5/x ti Cng an qun
Hng Bng). Hn na, Cng cn khai ti khng nh tn e da ti cm
dao tay no, ly dao u ra v lc ti hong s khng (Bt lc
64 Li khai ngy 06/5/x ti Cng an qun Hng Bng). ni l hong
s khng d , khng bit con dao t u ra li bnh tnh d v m t
chi tit c im con dao nh vy th c hp l khng? Cng khai dao
bt li nhng Dng li khai dao cha bt li. Thc t, Cng v Dng
ch m t c im con dao m h s dng ch khng mt t c im con
dao ca Trung v khng xc nhn Trung cm dao tay no, ly dao u
ra: ti bt lc 73, li khai ngy 27/7, Cng xc nhn V ti s dng
loi dao ny nn ti bit. Ti bt lc 96 Li khai ngy 27/7, Dng
cng xc nhn: V ti s dng loi dao ny nn qua nhn c im th
ti on nh vy (cn rng khong 2cm), cn thc t th ti khong khng
nh chc chn. Nh vy, khng c c s xc nh Trung c dng dao
e da Cng v Dng.
T nhng phn tch nu trn, cn c vo ton b h s v n v
din bin phin ta ngy hm nay, Trung ch c hnh vi e nh Cng vi
mc ch yu cu Cng v Dng khng c sang Thy Nguyn bn
bo. Trung khng h c mc ch chim ot ti sn ca Cng hoc
Dng v thc t cng khng c chim ot ti sn no ca Cng v
Dng. Vin kim st ch cn c vo li khai ca Dng v Cng xc
nh Trung dng dao e da Cng v Dng trong khi v n khng c vt
chng nh vy v Vin Kim st cng ch da vo li khai ca Dng v
Cng xc nh Trung ly s tin 360.000 ng ca Cng m khng
c c s chng minh l khng c c s v khng m bo s tht khch
quan ca v n, khng m bo nguyn tc suy on v ti theo tinh
thn ca php lut Hnh s. Khng c mc ch chim ot ti sn th

khng th cu thnh ti cp ti sn theo quy nh ti iu 133 B lut

Hnh s.
T nhng phn tch nu trn, ti knh ngh Hi ng xt x:
- Cn c khon 2 iu 107 B lut T tng Hnh s, tuyn b co
Phm Thnh Trung khng phm ti (hnh vi khng cu thnh ti phm);
- Cn c khon 1 iu 227 B lut T tng Hnh s, tuyn b tr t
do cho b co.
Knh mong Hi ng xt x cn nhc, xem xt c phn quyt
cng minh, khng lm oan ngi v ti.
Ti xin chn thnh cm n.
Trn trng,

IV. NHN XT V BUI DIN N

1. Nhn xt v cng vic chun b:
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
2. Ch ta phin ta:
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
3. Hi thm nhn dn:
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................

2. Th k phin ta:
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
3. i din Vin kim st:
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
4. B co:
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
5. Ngi lm chng:
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
6.

Lut s ca b co:

...............................................................................................................................

...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
7. Lut s ca b hi:
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................

...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
8. Nhn xt chung:
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................