Top 10 Things to Consider When Selecting a Digitizer/Oscilloscope

Publish Date: Dec 06, 2011 | 53 Ratings | 2.72 out of 5 | PDF

Overview
The modern day digital storage oscilloscope is dramatically different from the cathode ray oscilloscope German scientist Karl Ferdinand Braun invented in 1897. Technology advances continue to provide new features that make the oscilloscope more useful to engineers, but one of the most significant transformations of the oscilloscope was its transition into the digital domain, which enabled powerful features such as digital signal processing and waveform analysis. Digital oscilloscopes today include a high-speed, low-resolution (typically 8 bits) analog-to-digital converter (ADC), defined controls and display, and a built-in processor to run software algorithms for common measurements.

Digitizers, on the other hand, leverage the latest processing power and high-resolution display available from a PC, while providing all the other features that comprise an oscilloscope. Since digitizers are PC-based, you have the advantage of being able to define your instrument functionality in software. As a result, you can use a digitizer not just for oscilloscope measurements, but also for custom measurements, and even as a spectrum analyzer, frequency counter, ultrasonic receiver, or other instrument. With their open architecture and flexible software, digitizers provide several advantages over traditional stand-alone oscilloscopes. However, digitizers and oscilloscopes have many similarities and share a common set of considerations for selection.

This paper discusses the top 10 things you should keep in mind if you are considering a new digitizer/oscilloscope.

Table of Contents
1. Bandwidth 2. Sampling Rate

3. Sampling Modes 4. Resolution and Dynamic Range 5. Triggering 6. Onboard Memory 7. Channel Density 8. Multiple Instrument Synchronization 9. Mixed Signal Capability 10. Software, Analysis Capability, and Customizability 11. Conclusion

1. Bandwidth
Bandwidth describes the frequency range of an input signal that can pass through the analog front end with minimal amplitude loss - from the tip of the probe or test fixture to the input of the ADC. Bandwidth is specified as the frequency at which a sinusoidal input signal is attenuated to 70.7 percent of its original amplitude, also known as the -3 dB point.

In general, it is recommended that you use a digitizer with bandwidth at least two times the highest frequency component in your signal.

Oscilloscopes and digitizers are commonly used for measuring rise time of signals such as digital pulses or other signals with sharp edges. These signals are composed of high-frequency content. To capture the true shape of the signal, you need a highbandwidth digitizer. For instance, a 10 MHz square wave is composed of a 10 MHz sine wave and an infinite number of its harmonics. To capture the true shape of this signal, you must use a digitizer with bandwidth large enough to capture several of these harmonics. Otherwise, the signal is distorted and your measurements incorrect.

Figure 1: A high-bandwidth digitizer is important when capturing a waveform with high-frequency components

As a rule of thumb, use the following formula to figure out the bandwidth of your signal based on its rise time (defined as the time taken to transition from 10 to 90 percent of signal amplitude).

Figure 2: Rise time defines the time a signal takes to go from 10 to 90 percent of its full-scale value. Rise time and bandwidth are directly related, and one can be calculated from the other using the equation above.

Ideally, you should use a digitizer with three to five times the bandwidth of your signal as calculated in the equation above. In other words, your digitizers rise time should be 1/5 to 1/3 of your signals rise time to acquire your signal with minimal error. You can always backtrack to determine your signals real bandwidth based on the following formula:

= measured rise time,

Back to Top

= actual signal rise time,

= digitizers rise time

2. Sampling Rate
In the previous section, you learned about bandwidth, which is one of the most important specifications of a digitizer or oscilloscope. However, high bandwidth can be much less useful if the sample rate is insufficient.

While bandwidth describes the highest frequency sine wave that can be digitized with minimal attenuation, sample rate is simply the rate at which the analog-to-digital converter (ADC) in the digitizer or oscilloscope is clocked to digitize the incoming signal. Bear in mind that sample rate and bandwidth are not directly related. However, there is a rule of thumb for the desired relationship between these two important specifications: Digitizers real-time sample rate = 3 to 4 times digitizers bandwidth Nyquist theorem states that to avoid aliasing, the sample rate of a digitizer needs to be at least twice as fast as the highest frequency component in the signal being measured. However, sampling at just twice the highest frequency component is not enough to accurately reproduce time-domain signals. To accurately digitize the incoming signal, the digitizers real-time sample rate should be at least three to four times the digitizers bandwidth. To understand why, look at the figure below and think about which digitized signal you would rather see on your oscilloscope.

Figure 3: The figure on the right shows a digitizer with a sufficiently high sample rate to accurately reconstruct the signal, which will result in more accurate measurements. Although the actual signal passed through the front-end analog circuitry is the same in both cases, the image on the left is under sampled, which distorts the digitized signal. On the other hand, the image on the right has enough sample points to accurately reconstruct the signal, which will result in a more accurate measurement. Since a clean representation of the signal is important for time domain applications such as rise time, overshoot, or other pulse measurements, a digitizer with a higher sample is beneficial for these applications.
Back to Top

3. Sampling Modes
There are two main sampling modes real-time sampling and equivalent-time sampling (ETS).

Real-time sample rate is the one discussed above, which describes the clock rate of the ADC and indicates the maximum rate an incoming signal can be acquired in a singleshot acquisition. On the other hand, equivalent-time sampling is a method of

reconstructing a signal based on a series of triggered waveforms that are each acquired in single-shot mode. The advantage of ETS is that it offers a higher effective sample rate. The downside, however, is that it takes more time and is applicable only for repetitive signals. Note that ETS does not increase the digitizers analog bandwidth, and instead is only useful when you need to reconstruct the signal at a higher sample rate. A common implementation of ETS is random-interleaved sampling (RIS), which is available on most NI digitizers as listed in the table below.

Digitizer Channels Real-Time Equivalent- Bandwidth Resolution Model Sample Rate Time Sample Rate NI 5152 NI 5114 NI 5124 NI 5122 NI 5105 NI 5922 2 2 2 2 8 2 2 GS/s 250 MS/s 200 MS/s 100 MS/s 60 MS/s 500 kS/s to 15 MS/s 20 GS/s 5 GS/s 4 GS/s 2 GS/s 300 MHz 125 MHz 150 MHz 100 MHz 60 MHz 6 MHz 8 Bits 8 Bits 12 Bits 14 Bits 12 Bits 16 to 24 Bits UserDefined
Back to Top

4. Resolution and Dynamic Range

As described above, digital oscilloscopes and digitizers both have ADCs that convert the signal from analog to digital. The number of bits returned by the ADC is the digitizers resolution. For any given input range, the number of possible discrete levels

used to represent the signal digitally is 2b, where b is the digitizers resolution. The input range is divided into 2b steps and the smallest possible voltage that is detectable by the digitizer is denoted by (Input Range/2b). For example, an 8-bit digitizer divides a 10 Vpp input range into 28 = 256 levels of 39 mV each, while a 24-bit digitizer divides the same 10 Vpp input range into 224 = 16,777,216 levels of 596 nV (approximately 65,000 times smaller than in the 8-bit case).

One of the reasons for using a high-resolution digitizer is to measure small signals. The question is sometimes asked, why not just use a lower resolution instrument and a smaller range to zoom in on the signal to measure small voltages? However, many signals have both a small signal and a large signal component. Using a large range, you could measure the large signal but the tiny signal would be in the noise of the large signal. On the other hand, if you use a small range, then youd clip the large signal and your measurement would be distorted and invalid. Thus, for applications that involve dynamic signals (signals with large and small voltage components), you need a highresolution instrument, which has a large dynamic range (the ability of the digitizer to measure small signals in the presence of large ones).

Traditional oscilloscopes typically use ADCs with 8-bit resolution, which is not enough for many applications involving spectral analysis or dynamic signals such as modulated waveforms. Such applications may benefit from one of the several high-resolution digitizers highlighted in the table below. These include the NI PXI-5922 flexibleresolution digitizer, which was awarded 2006 Test Product of the Year by Test and Measurement World. This module uses linearization techniques to provide the industrys highest dynamic range of any digitizer or oscilloscope.

Digitize Resolutio Channels Real-Time r Model n Sample Rate

Bandwidth

NI 5922

16 to 24 Bits (UserDefined)

500 kS/s to 15 MS/s

6 MHz

NI 5122 NI 5124 NI 5105

14 Bits

100 MS/s

100 MHz

12 Bits

200 MS/s

150 MHz

12 Bits

60 MS/s

60 MHz

Back to Top

5. Triggering
Typically, oscilloscopes and digitizers are used to acquire a signal based on a certain event. The instruments triggering capability allows you to isolate this event and capture the signal before and after the event. Most digitizers and oscilloscopes include analog edge, digital, and software triggering. Other triggering options include window, hysteresis, and video triggering (featured on the NI 5122, NI 5124 and NI 5114). High-end digitizers feature fast rearm times between triggers, which enables a multirecord capture mode, where the digitizer captures the specified number of points upon a given trigger, quickly rearms and waits for the next trigger. A fast rearm time ensures that the digitizer does not miss the event or trigger. Multi-record mode is very useful in capturing and storing only the data that you need, thereby optimizing the use of the onboard memory as well as limiting the activity of the PC bus.
Back to Top

6. Onboard Memory

Often times, data is transferred from the digitizer or oscilloscope to the PC for measurements and analysis. Although these instruments can sample at their maximum rate, which can be in the several GS/s range, the rate which the data can be transferred to the PC is limited by bandwidth of the connecting bus such as PCI, LAN, GPIB, etc. While today none of these buses are able to sustain multi-GS/s rates, this may become a non-issue as PCI Express and PXI Express evolve to allow several GB/s data rates.

If the interface bus can not sustain continuous data transfer at the sample rate of the acquisition, onboard memory on the instrument provides the ability to acquire the signals at the maximum rate and later fetch the data to the PC for processing.

Deep memory not only increases acquisition time, but also provides frequency-domain benefits. The most common frequency-domain measurement is the fast Fourier transform (FFT), which shows a signals frequency content. If an FFT has finer frequency resolution, discrete frequencies are more easily detected.

In the equation above, there are two ways to improve the frequency resolution reduce the sample rate or increase the number of points in the FFT. Reducing the sample rate often is not the ideal solution because this will also reduce your frequency span. In this case, the only solution is to acquire more points for the FFT, which requires deeper onboard memory.

Figure 4: More onboard memory lets you sample at a high sample rate for a longer period of time to capture more points. Using more points when calculating an FFT results in greater frequency resolution.

Digitizer Channels Real-Time Model Sample Rate

Equivalent- Bandwidth Memory Time Sample Rate Options

NI 5152

2 GS/s

20 GS/s

300 MHz

16 MB, 128 MB, 512 MB, 1 GB

NI 5114

250 MS/s

5 GS/s

125 MHz

16 MB, 128 MB, 512 MB

NI 5124

200 MS/s

4 GS/s

150 MHz

16 MB, 64 MB, 512 MB, 1 GB

NI 5122

100 MS/s

2 GS/s

100 MHz

16 MB, 64 MB, 512 MB, 1 GB

NI 5105

60 MS/s

60 MHz

16 MB, 128 MB, 512 MB

NI 5922

500 kS/s to 15 MS/s

6 MHz

16 MB, 64 MB, 512 MB, 1 GB

Back to Top

7. Channel Density
An important factor in an oscilloscope or digitizer purchasing decision is the number of channels on the instrument or the ability to add channels by synchronizing multiple instruments. Most oscilloscopes have two to four channels, each simultaneously sampled at a certain rate. It is important to be wary of how sample rate is affected when using all the digitizer channels. This is because of a commonly used technique called time-interleaved sampling, which interleaves multiple channels to achieve a higher sample rate. If the digitizer or oscilloscope uses this method and you are using all the channels, you may not be able to acquire at the maximum acquisition rate.

The number of channels required entirely depends on your particular application. Frequently the traditional two to four channels may not be sufficient for a given application, in which case there are two options. The first one is to use a higher channel density product such as the eight-channel (simultaneous) NI 5105 12-bit, 60 MS/s, 60 MHz digitizer. If you are unable to find an instrument that matches your resolution, speed, and bandwidth requirements, you should consider using a platform that lets you scale your test system by providing tight synchronization and allows triggers and clocks to be shared. While its practically impossible to synchronize multiple boxed oscilloscopes over GPIB or LAN due to high latency, limited throughput and need for external cabling, PXI provides a superior solution. PXI is an industry standard that adds world-class synchronization technology to existing higher speed busses such as PCI and PCI Express.

Figure 5: Using synchronization technology, you can create high-channel-count digitizers. The picture above shows a system that can acquire up to 136 phase coherent channels. Multiple chassis can be synchronized for even higher channel counts. NI digitizers including the NI PXI-5105 and NI PXI-5152 provide a technology called TClock, which provides synchronization accuracy in the tens of picoseconds. For instance, using this technology, you can build a 34-channel (simultaneous), 1 GS/s oscilloscope usingNI PXI-5152 digitizers in a single 18-slot chassis. Likewise, multiple NI PXI-5105 digitizers can be synchronized to provide a system with 136 synchronized channels, each running at 60 MS/s with 12-bit resolution (see figure

above). For higher channel count, PXI also provides timing modules to scale to multiple chassis for up to 5000 channel count systems.
Back to Top

8. Multiple Instrument Synchronization

Almost all automated test and many benchtop applications involve multiple types of instruments such as digitizers, signal generators, digital waveform analyzers, digital waveform generators, and switches.

The inherent timing and synchronization capability of PXI and NI modular instruments allows you to synchronize all these types of instruments without the need for external cabling. For instance, you can integrate a digitizer (such as the NI PXI-5122) and an arbitrary waveform generator (such as the NI PXI-5421) for performing parameter sweeps, which is useful for characterizing the frequency and phase response of the device under test. The entire sweep can be automated, which obviates the need for manual setting of parameters on the scope and generator followed by offline analysis. A modular approach with PXI results in orders of magnitude improvement in speed and improves your efficiency by letting you focus on the results rather than the cumbersome steps needed to get those results.
Back to Top

9. Mixed Signal Capability

The same T-Clock technology that enables creating systems with up to 136 synchronized channels in a single PXI chassis or up to 5000 channels using multiple chassis (as described in the section above) also allows for synchronization of instruments of different types. For instance, an NI digitizer can be T-Clock synchronized with signal generators, digital waveform generators, and digital waveform analyzers for building mixed signal systems.

Figure 6: The VI above demonstrates an application that has been configured for mixed signal oscilloscope (analog and digital input) functionality. In addition, digital or analog output functionality could be added to the application and all instruments could still be synchronized.

Rather than settle for a mixed-signal oscilloscope with limited digital functionality, you can use a modular PXI digitizer with arbitrary waveform generators and digital waveform generator/analyzers to build a complete mixed-signal application with the benefits of both an oscilloscope and a logic analyzer.
Back to Top

10. Software, Analysis Capability, and Customizability

Determining software and analysis capabilities is very important when choosing a modular digitizer or a stand-alone oscilloscope for your application, and this factor may help you choose between the two instruments.

Stand-alone oscilloscopes are vendor-defined while digitizers are user-defined and

flexible in the applications they can solve. A boxed oscilloscope provides many of the standard functions that are common to the needs of many engineers. As you can imagine, these standard functions will not solve every application, especially for automated test applications. If you need to define the measurements your oscilloscope makes, you might select a modular digitizer, which leverages the PC architecture while letting you customize an application to your requirements, instead of the fixed functionality of a stand-alone oscilloscope.

NI digitizers are all programmed using the free NI-SCOPE driver software. This driver comes with more than 50 prewritten example programs that highlight the full functionality of any NI digitizer, and the included NI-SCOPE Soft Front Panel provides a familiar interface similar to an oscilloscope. The same hardware can also be programmed for both common and custom measurements in a broad range of applications using programming languages including NI LabVIEW, LabWindows/CVI, Visual Basic, and .NET. The driver also supports express configuration-based functions within LabVIEW.

Figure 7: Using preconfigured Express blocks lets you quickly set up your digitizer to quickly acquire data. NI LabVIEW SignalExpress is an interactive

environment that lets you acquire, analyze, and log your data with no programming required.

Back to Top

11. Conclusion
Although modular digitizers and stand-alone oscilloscopes are both used to acquire voltages, the instruments offer different benefits. However, the considerations discussed above are important when purchasing either instrument. Thinking ahead about application requirements, cost constraints, performance, and future expandability can help you choose the instrument that best meets all your needs.