Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Overview
This assessment identifies the major (not all) criteria that an investor will use to evaluate an investment opportunity in your business. By evaluating your business
against these criteria, you can determine your readiness to pursue outside investment. The criteria can also be used to develop benchmarks for improvement in various
aspects of your business.
Instructions
Step 1: Review the Investment Feasibility Assessment – Criteria Descriptions.
Review the criteria and descriptions on Sheet 2 of this worksheet. For each criterion, choose the description that most closely matches your situation. Mark that
description’s number (1 through 5) on the Scoring Page (Sheet 3 and Sheet 4 of this worksheet). The company and their coach have separate scoring pages.
In a comparison of an investment in your business against the model investment opportunity, no score guarantees an investment. A score of less than 4 for any
individual criterion indicates a weakness in the investment opportunity, which requires further consideration. Also, pay attention to any area (management, market,
technology, traction, business model) where your score was less than one-half of the possible points overall. The Analyses on Sheets 3a & 4a provide some additional
information based on the scores that the company received for each criterion.
Your coach will independently complete this assessment based upon his/her perspective on your business. Sheet 5 of this worksheet combines the results of the
company and coach score sheets and compares how each criertia was evaluated. Areas of agreement and divergence are highlighted, and the company should discusss
strategies to address any weak areas and identify why there is this difference in scoring.
2. Criteria and Descriptions
MANAGEMENT
Team is complete
MARKET
Market is growing
Technology is broad
BUSINESS MODEL
Ability and experience to leverage scarce resources. No Company Score Recorded Yet
Available market well defined and large. No Company Score Recorded Yet
Company based on unique or innovative use of technology. No Company Score Recorded Yet
Expertise in place to maintain and expand technology. No Company Score Recorded Yet
TRACTION
Customers have validated Company’s value proposition. No Company Score Recorded Yet
BUSINESS MODEL
Ability and experience to leverage scarce resources. No Coach Score Recorded Yet
Available market well defined and large. No Coach Score Recorded Yet
Company based on unique or innovative use of technology. No Coach Score Recorded Yet
Expertise in place to maintain and expand technology. No Coach Score Recorded Yet
TRACTION
Customers have validated Company’s value proposition. No Coach Score Recorded Yet
BUSINESS MODEL
MANAGEMENT
Great! This will definitely be an advantage moving forward and you should ensure that you take full advantage of
management team has had. Incorporate those portions that fit well with what you are doing and modify those tha
venture. Ensure that any hard lessons learnt are not repeated and pre-empt problems areas that were encountere
Transferable record of success.
Great! Having this ability and Experience can provide a competitve advantage and it should be a part of the compa
succeed.
Ability and experience to leverage scarce resources.
For a software or other technology company, relevant technical experience is critical to getting a good product ou
have strong technical experience, so it’s important to ask yourself whether you have good technical management
products shipped on time is important. If there is more than one technical member, you need to consider how the
divided/shared. Can founders communicate business "vision" in non-technical terms?
Appropriate functional and industry experience.
Good. Often a startup is formed when several colleagues leave a company because they want to collectively create
are familiar with each other's values, corporate culture gets established quickly and is one that the founding team
entrepreneurs can attract people who have worked for them in the past, that's a good sign. For one thing, it's an e
abilities. Perhaps more important, the trust that typically takes so long to build is there from the beginning.
Worked together previously.
Good. The management team is critical to the company, both operationally and in attracting outside investment.
in filling out the management team after the financing, you can increase valuation and attractiveness to investors
management team beforehand.
Team is complete.
MARKET
Be prepared to provide a thorough definition of your target market. Such a definition should include a description
problem that your product or service solves. Additionally, you should be prepared to define the customer, their be
can be capitalized upon to bring your venture to profitable and sustainable fruition. Your understanding of the ma
market size and demographics should be supported by thorough research through reputable sources such as Gart
associations, government research, and other sources. Investors are primarily interested in investing their money
growing markets. Absent such market characteristics, venture capitalists will probably not be interested. Your un
and penetration dynamics are critical to selling your venture to investors. Perform the necessary research to size
reference those research sources. Additionally, you must determine what portion of the market is realistically ach
aggressive in your assessments, but be prepared to defend your conclusions on your market penetration.
A demonstrated understanding of the market is critical. Be prepared to discuss the predicted (next five years) rat
segment. Are the markets regional, national, international? The more expansive the market, the more specialized
needed to capitalize on the markets. What factors will drive the market growth, and what is the likelihood that th
Market is growing.
A thorough understanding of the competition and a well constructed plan to compete and exceed is very importan
factors in the market: product performance, reliability, durability, styling, delivery, service, merchandising, price,
will react to changes in the market, and attempt to identify how the competition will react to your entry into the m
competition brings.
Competition has identifiable weaknesses.
It is imperative to know what factors will drive customers to your technology. What are the critical success facto
make his decision? Such factors may include performance, reliability, durability, availability, price, and service. E
relative to the others will determine where management should invest its time and money in the product developm
your product have different market segments, and do the customers in each segment buy for the same reasons? D
buying characteristics which should be considered, such as seasonality, cyclical patterns, or other industry trends
How have you determined the barriers, and how will you overcome them? If barriers exist ahead of you, investor
overcome them. Desirably, your product will not only overcome barriers, but will also create further barriers behi
A thorough understanding of the market barriers will help you justify your target market share.
Market entry by new competitors is difficult.
TECHNOLOGY
How unique is it and how sustainable is your position (sustainable competitive advantage)? Does the way in whic
to the customers? Will innovations be necessary to maintain market leadership? Have you planned for these?
Company based on unique or innovative use of technology.
Good. This will be important for the company to protect and expand upon their technology and keep competitors a
Expertise in place to maintain and expand technology.
This is good, but the company should exercise caution here. While there are many potential applications,markets,
should very carefully choose their targets. The company should conduct a strategic review in order to determine w
should be in order to maximize the benefit to the company and the customers that they choose to serve.
Technology is broad.
Good. Investors will require assurance that you have full rights to the technology as a condition to their investme
license, you'll want to make sure the scope of the license is sufficient and that any royalty obligations are reasona
royalties. Is your IP position well protected and defensible? Is it patented, and if so, how long does the patent las
Technology is exclusive to Company.
TRACTION
Is it unique/proprietary? Do you have a strategy for continued innovation? Have you packaged the technology in
your target market?
Product/service is ready to sell.
Good. This will provide focus for the business and should allow you to manage resources and conduct marketing e
Value proposition is quantifiable in customers’ terms.
Great! This puts your company in a good position going forward, but you should constantly engage and refine the
discretionary. If you do not create and continuously reinforce, the value of your company, products, services and
then you put your business at risk.
Customers have validated Company’s value proposition.
BUSINESS MODEL
Good. You should constantly be looking inside and outside of your industry to ensure you are using the best possi
you should not become complacent with a model that works today because it might not be the best model to get t
Business model is attractive and efficient.
Good. This will allow the company the flexibility to consider different options, although the company should consu
leader to seek guidance and feedback on their decision
Multiple exit opportunities exist.
This is good because it will bring many investors to the table, but ensure that you have not over promised and tha
company might not benefit from the success of the business
Favorable risk/return tradeoff for investors.
hat you take full advantage of the previous successes that your
are doing and modify those that would be useful in your current
ms areas that were encountered previously.
at are the critical success factors upon which the customer will
ailability, price, and service. Each factor and its importance
money in the product development phase. In addition, does
nt buy for the same reasons? Does your market have any special
terns, or other industry trends?
rs exist ahead of you, investors will want to see how you will
lso create further barriers behind you as you enter the market.
market share.
antage)? Does the way in which your product is unique MATTER
ave you planned for these?
re you are using the best possible model for your business and
not be the best model to get the company to the next level
ave not over promised and that the original founders of the
Things can Improve Responses
MANAGEMENT
Many investors base their entire investment decision on the management team behind a venture. Investors expect a well-rounded team of
professionals with experience in every function critical to the business. List past positions and responsibilities that directly relate to the current
position. Outline the companies you worked for, the duties, the successes, the experience gained, and how these skills transfer to your current
Transferable record of success. position. Industry experience is looked at favorably by investors as they size up your management team. Some investors consider industry
experience an absolute must, but if you lack direct industry experience, build on related and successful experiences from other fields. Describe your
abilities and experiences in previous management positions. The number of years you were in management roles? The number of people you
supervised? For how long? The goal here is to present a track record that predicts future success.
Should be able to leverage scare resources to maximize the impact those resources. In order to optimize the use of resources one must first
Ability and experience to leverage scarce resources.
understand the goals against which resource use should be optimized.
If you are lacking technical talent, this is an area you’ll need to expand. At many start-ups, management requires that all prospective engineers
take rigorous programming tests – the quantity of technical experience is not as important as the skill and ability. From a management team
Appropriate functional and industry experience. perspective, it’s more important to have engineering/technical management experience, and generally that person should be a much better
manager than technologist. However, this may not be important if technology is not required to develop your product or service. If it is important,
you need someone with experience in licensing deals and IP issues.
Often a startup is formed when several colleagues leave a company because they want to collectively create something new. Because they are
familiar with each other's values, corporate culture gets established quickly and is one that the founding team is comfortable with. When
Worked together previously.
entrepreneurs can attract people who have worked for them in the past, that's a good sign. For one thing, it's an endorsement of their leadership
abilities. Perhaps more important, the trust that typically takes so long to build is there from the beginning.
It is never too soon to get started. The management team is critical to the company, both operationally and in attracting outside investment. While
Team is complete. outside investors can help in filling out the management team after the financing, you can increase valuation and attractiveness to investors by
filling in gaps in the management team beforehand.
MARKET
Obviously, the lack of a clearly defined market will diminish your chances for success in both the short run and the long run. In the short run, you
will be unable to raise capital and may damage your reputation with the investment community. In the long run, your venture will most likely not
be successful. You should spend more time researching markets that your technology may enhance. Consider other applications/markets to which
your technology may be adapted. Limited market size limits the potential revenue and profits to be generated by your venture. Even dominant
penetration in a lesser market may not allow you to generate sufficient returns for your investors. However, investors are strategic, and your
Available market well defined and large. ability to demonstrate to the investors that you really know your market (although not as large as hoped) and how to tap its potential may get their
attention. They may be interested in smaller markets if they are experienced in the market and have established connections within the market that
may enable them to increase your penetration of the market. Additionally, strategic investors who already operate ventures within your market
may appreciate what your product can do for the market (including increasing the size of the market). Research the investment sources to
determine if there may be more strategic investors for your venture. Finally, consider whether there are other, larger markets that may benefit
from your product or service.
In a mature or declining market, your product or service must be an improvement or replacement for what is already available. Your key is to
realistically demonstrate that you understand the market and how your offering changes the dynamics of this market. You must demonstrate why
Market is growing. customers will abandon their current product in favor of your offering. What will be your competitive factors that will drive your success? Price?
Service? Quality? Innovation? Reliability? Also, have others tried to penetrate this market, and what were their results?
It will be difficult to raise money without a solid understanding of the market and its participants. One of the greatest temptations in the
development of the business plan is to overstate your own strengths and to understate the competition. This can be self-defeating, since you base
Competition has identifiable weaknesses. the actions on the directions charted in the business plan. Moreover, prospective investors are unlikely to back an entrepreneur who lacks a
realistic view of the competition. Show how the competition could deter your plans and how the venture can be adaptable to meet the changing
environment in these situations.
Investment of valuable management resources (including time and money) is largely dependent on management's understanding of the customers'
buying decisions. Research others in your market and determine what their key success factors are. Their knowledge of the customer should be
Customers receptive to early stage companies.
evident. Ensure that your research provides you with a clear understanding of what drives the customers' purchase decisions, considering
qualitative factors such as performance, quality, reliability, durability, and service and quantitative factors such as price and product availability.
Investors will quickly conclude that a management team unfamiliar with the market barriers to entry cannot predict the amount of funding
Market entry by new competitors is difficult.
necessary to achieve success in the market.
TECHNOLOGY
Company based on unique or innovative use of technology. What is your competitive advantage? Are those competitive advantages sustainable?
It is important for the company to protect and expand upon their technology and keep competitors at bay for as long as possible. Find a way to
Expertise in place to maintain and expand technology. ensure that the company is in charge of the technology that forms the core of the business because without this is will be difficult to create any
significant barriers to entry and your company might find itself losing market share to a competitor.
The company should spend some time and resources to ensure that alternative applications and uses for your product/services have been
Technology is broad. considered. Many times it will be one of these alternatives that find traction in the market place and it allows the company to establish themselves
and still be able to offer the orginal concept if the opportunity presents itself.
Without rights to use the technology, you can't move forward or expect to receive any outside investment. If a current or former employer or
Technology is exclusive to Company. anyone else owns the technology, you need to negotiate for the rights to the technology by assignment, license, or otherwise. The scope of the
license needs to be sufficient to achieve your goal, and any royalty obligations should be reasonable and in line with market royalties.
TRACTION
How long and how much money will it take to develop? What are the risks that you are not able to develop the technology as planned? Are there
Product/service is ready to sell.
others (competitors) developing similar technologies, and if so, how close are they to beating you?
A true value proposition is quantifiable with hard, tangible, grounded numbers framed within financial metrics CFOs quickly understand and use to
Value proposition is quantifiable in customers’ terms.
make decisions. Of course, all CFOs are not the same, and targeted analysis and perspectives will need to be shown around particular CFOs’ needs.
Value ultimately drives the decisions companies make when evaluating different products, services and bundled solution options, including internal
Customers have validated Company’s value proposition. options. The value of a product or service is the customers expectations of quality in relation to the amount paid for it and it is important that you
have some sort of indication from your target customers that validates the value you believe your product/service has.
BUSINESS MODEL
You should consult with industry experts and benchmarks against other players in your industry to determine what business model is most suitable.
You should also look outside of your industry to determine if there is a model that would work well for your business and might even provide a
Business model is attractive and efficient.
competitive edge. Once a suitable model is found, do not become complacent but rather you should continuously evaluate if the model is working
and to determine if it will get the business to the next level.
You should consider if there are alternative exit opportunities. This will provide you with some flexibility and the ablity to make an exit decision that
Multiple exit opportunities exist.
is right for you and for the business.
This might it difficult to raise sufficient capital to invest and grow the business and you should determine if there are any means to make the
Favorable risk/return tradeoff for investors. investment more favorable to investors while at the same time ensuring that the original founders are still able to benefit from any succes that the
business will have.
well-rounded team of
ectly relate to the current
transfer to your current
ors consider industry
om other fields. Describe your
number of people you
temptations in the
elf-defeating, since you base
repreneur who lacks a
able to meet the changing
he amount of funding
s possible. Find a way to
be difficult to create any
t or former employer or
herwise. The scope of the
arket royalties.