Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sn xut sch hn
Ngnh: c kim loi
Phin bn: 09.2011
B CNG THNG
Mc lc
Mc lc ............................................................................................................2
M u ............................................................................................................5
1. Gii thiu chung .......................................................................................6
1.1
M t ngnh c kim loi ...................................................................6
1.2
Quy trnh c kim loi ........................................................................8
1.2.1
Chun b khun, rut (thao), mu ...............................................9
1.2.2
.....................................................................12
1.2.3
c kim loi ..............................................................................14
1.2.4
................................................................................14
2. S dng ti nguyn, tc ng n mi trng v an ton sn xut ........16
2.1
Tiu th nguyn nhin liu ...............................................................16
2.2
Cc vn mi trng v an ton sn xut ....................................17
2.2.1
Kh thi .....................................................................................17
2.2.2
Nc thi .................................................................................18
2.2.3
Cht thi rn .............................................................................18
2.2.4
Ting n ..................................................................................18
2.2.5
Nhit, chy n v an ton trong sn xut ..................................18
2.3
Tim nng p dng sn xut sch hn ............................................18
3. C hi sn xut sch hn.......................................................................19
3.1
.............................................19
3.1.1
Cc gii php qun l nguyn liu ............................................19
3.1.2
...........19
3.1.3
..................................................................21
3.1.4
.............................................21
3.1.5
...................22
3.2
.......23
3.2.1
Cc gii php p dng k thut - cng ngh tin tin ...............23
3.2.2
.....................................24
3.2.3
..........................27
3.2.4
............................27
3.3
..........................27
3.3.1
Lm sch..................................................................................27
3.3.2
X l nhit ................................................................................28
4. Thc hin sn xut sch hn .................................................................30
4.1
Bc 1: Khi ng ..........................................................................30
4.1.1
Nhim v 1: Thnh lp nhm nh gi SXSH...........................30
4.1.2
Nhim v 2: Phn tch cc cng on v xc nh lng ph ......34
4.2
Bc 2: Phn tch cc cng on sn xut .....................................39
4.2.1
Nhim v 3: Chun b s dy chuyn sn xut ....................39
4.2.2
Nhim v 4: Cn bng vt liu ..................................................40
4.2.3
Nhim v 5: Xc nh chi ph ca dng thi ..............................42
4.2.4
.........................................44
4.3
Bc 3: ra cc gii php SXSH .................................................45
4.3.1
Nhim v 7: xut cc c hi SXSH .....................................45
4.3.2
Nhim v 8: La chn cc c hi u tin trin khai ngay .........47
4.4
Bc 4: Chn la cc gii php SXSH ...........................................48
4.4.1
Nhim v 9: Phn tch tnh kh thi v k thut ..........................48
4.4.2
Nhim v 10: Phn tch tnh kh thi v mt kinh t ...................49
4.4.3
Nhim v 11: nh gi nh hng n mi trng .................50
4.4.4
Nhim v 12: La chn cc gii php thc hin .......................51
4.5
Bc 5: Thc hin cc gii php SXSH ..........................................52
4.5.1
Nhim v 13: Chun b thc hin .............................................52
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 2/61
4.5.2
Nhim v 14: Thc hin cc gii php......................................52
4.5.3
Nhim v 15: Quan trc v nh gi cc kt qu .....................53
4.6
Bc 6: Duy tr SXSH .....................................................................54
4.6.1
Nhim v 16: Duy tr SXSH ......................................................54
4.7
Cc yu t bt li cho vic thc hin SXSH ....................................54
4.8
Cc yu t thnh cng ca chng trnh SXSH ..............................55
5. X l mi trng ....................................................................................56
5.1
X l kh thi ...................................................................................56
5.1.1
X l bi trong kh thi l nu luyn ..........................................56
5.1.2
X l kh c hi trong kh thi .................................................59
5.2
X l nc thi ................................................................................60
5.3
X l cht thi rn ...........................................................................60
6. Ti liu tham kho ..................................................................................61
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 3/61
Danh mc cc bng
Bng 1. Sn lng cc hp kim c Vit nam giai on 2020 - 2025 ..........7
Bng 2. D tnh sn lng vt c ca Vit Nam giai on 2011-2020...........8
...........................16
Bng 4. Thnh phn ca than cc ti Nh my cc ha ................................20
............................................................21
.....................................................21
...........27
Danh mc cc hnh
Hnh 1. S dy chuyn c kim loi............................................................8
Hnh 2. Nguyn liu u vo v pht thi trong qu trnh c kim loi ...........16
Hnh 3. Cc loi bung lng bi .....................................................................57
Hnh 4 Cyclon lc bi .....................................................................................57
Hnh 5. Lc bi ti vi ....................................................................................58
Hnh 6. Lc bi kiu tnh in ........................................................................58
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 4/61
M u
Theo nh ngha ca Chng trnh Mi trng ca Lin hp quc (UNEP),
sn xut sch hn (SXSH) l vic p dng lin tc chin lc phng nga
tng hp v mi trng vo cc qu trnh sn xut, sn phm v dch v
nhm nng cao hiu sut sinh thi v gim thiu ri ro cho con ngi v mi
trng.
, sn xut sch hn l tip cn nhm mc tiu gim thiu
nhim ti ngun thng qua vic s dng nguyn nhin liu c hiu qu hn.
Vic p dng sn xut sch hn khng ch gip cc doanh nghip ct gim
chi ph sn xut, m cn ng gp vo vic ci thin hin trng mi trng,
qua gim bt chi ph x l mi trng.
Ti liu hng dn sn xut sch hn trong ngnh c kim loi c bin
son trong khun kh
Hp phn sn xut sch hn trong Cng
nghip (CPI), thuc chng trnh Hp tc Vit Nam - an Mch v Mi
trng (DCE), B Cng thng nhm cung cp nhng kin thc c bn cng
nh trnh t trin khai p dng sn xut sch hn trong ngnh c kim loi.
Tu thuc vo loi vt liu c, qui m mt hng sn phm, tim lc v ti
chnh v ngun nhn lc, cc doanh nghip c s la chn, p dng nhng
gii php SXSH ph hp vi n v mnh.
Cc chuyn gia dnh n lc cao nht tng hp thng tin lin quan n
hin trng sn xut ngnh c Vit nam, cc vn lin quan n sn xut v
mi trng cng nh nhng phng php vn hnh tt nht c th p dng
c trong iu kin nc ta.
Mc d Sn xut sch hn c gii hn trong vic thc hin gim thiu
nhim ti ngun, ti liu ny
thm mt chng v x l mi trng
tham kho khi tch hp
sn xut sch hn
nhng yu cu ca cng tc bo v
Hp phn Sn xut sch hn trong Cng nghip v Cng ty C phn T vn
EPRO xin chn thnh cm n s ng gp ca cn b Cng ty TNHH Nh
Cng ty C phn Cng ngh cao Sao
X
c bit l chnh ph an
Mch, thng qua t chc DANIDA h tr thc hin ti liu ny.
Mi kin ng gp, xy dng ti liu xin gi v: Vn Phng Hp phn Sn
xut sch hn trong Cng nghip, email: cpi.cde@hn.vnn.vn
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 5/61
H thng thit b hon chnh lm khun Furan cht lng cao, dy chuyn
c khun ti c nh c kh ha
; Cng ty
C phn C kh Luyn kim (SADAKIM);
Cng ngh c mu chy, mu chy cc chi tit phc tp cht lng cao
cho ngnh c kh, vi cng sut 600 tn/nm
Cng ty c phn c kh
& c kim loi Si Gn (SAMECO); Cng ty lin doanh VIDPOL v.v...
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 6/61
D
nh Yn Nam nh, Thy Nguyn Hi Phng, Phng c Hu).
/nm
Nm
2020
2025
Gang xm
Gang cu
Gang do
Thp c
HK nhm
103
Tn
950
1.250
103
Tn
570
625
103
Tn
19
50
103
Tn
114
200
103
Tn
190
250
%
50
50
%
30
28
%
1
2
%
8
8
%
10
10
HK mu
Tng
khc
103
%
103
Tn
Tn
19
1 1.900
50
2 2.500
D tho Quy hoch pht trin ngnh c Vit Nam giai on 2009-2020, c xt n
nm 2025.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 7/61
2011 2015
2016 2020
14,11
19,92
90
95
1,2 1,4
1,8 2,0
th
l/thnh phm
(
lng,
nghip.
c tim nng v ti ch
kim loi np
vn v
, v sinh mi trng cng
quay vng.
hn.
Nu
(gang, thp, ng, nhm) trong cc thit b ph hp (l
in h quang, l cm ng, l quibil, l cao, l ch v.v...);
, x l nhit nu cn.
mc
Nguyn nhin liu chnh
Cc cng on chnh
Cc vn mi trng chnh
ng
n
Khun,
Ba via
Sn phm
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 8/61
hun
thao
ct
t st, cht kt dnh v cc cht ph gia.
ca
ct l SiO2 (thch anh), t st l cao lanh (mAl2O3.nSiO2.qH2O). Cht kt
dnh lm tng do, bn ca hn hp lm khun, t
du thc vt
(du lanh, du tru, du bng); cht ha tan trong nc (ng, mt ma,
bt h), cc cht kt dnh ha cng (nha thng, xi mng, b hc n)
nc thy tinh. Cht ph gia
tng tnh ln, tnh thng kh, tng
bng b mt khun, thao v tng kh nng chu nhit ca hn hp.
ht
(bt graphit, bt than, nc thy tinh, bt thch anh).
cng ch ph hp
chi tit
P
Nhit sy khun
175 450 C. C th sy
trc tip trn nn nh xng bng
ci, rm, r hoc sy trong cc l sy than, du
o
Khun ct:
Khun ct vn gi mt vai tr quan trng trong ngnh c. Khun ct c
dng nhiu v d lm, r, vn u t thp. Hn na khun ct
c th dng c vt nh t 10 gram cho ti vt ln c khi lng
hng trm tn, dng c bt k hp kim no nh: thp, gang cu, gang
sm, ng thau, ng thanh, hp kim niken, hp kim nhm, magi, 90%
sn lng c ca th gii c sn xut bng khun ct, phn cn li c
c bng khun kim loi
sau:
-
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 9/61
Khun ct nha: s
c bc nha; c 2 loi l khun
(trn ct vi axit formaldehit) v k
(nung
);
Khun mu chy:
y l phng php c c bit, mu ch qua mt ln c. Thc cht ca
c trong khun mu chy l tng t nh c trong khun ct nhng c
nhng im khc bit sau:
-
Vt liu ch to khun bng cht liu c bit nn ch cn dy nh (6 8 mm) nhng li rt bn, thng kh tt v chu nhit;
Quy trnh ch to khun phi qua nhiu cng on nn nng sut khng
cao. Do vy, mun p dng phng php c mu chy cn c kh ho
hoc t ng ho mt s khu then cht;
Khun v mng:
c trong khun v mng l dng c trong khun ct c bit, c chiu dy
thnh khun mng 6 - 8 mm. Thng c ch to t hn hp 4 - 6% bt
thch anh, trn vi Punvebakelit (l hn hp ca Phenol v Uetropin). nhit
cao (200 - 250oC, cc phn t Fenol chy ra, dnh kt cc ht ct vi nhau
v ho cng to nn bn cao cho khun v mng.
c im ca khun c v mng l:
-
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 10/61
Khun v mng l dng khun kh, nhn bng, thng kh tt, truyn nhit
km, khng ht nc, bn cao nn thu c vt c t b r, nt v cc
dng khuyt tt khc;
Qu trnh c d c kh ho v t ng ho;
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 11/61
c ch to bng kim loi. Do khun kim loi c tnh cht c l cao, khc vi
vt liu lm khun ct nn c nhng c im sau:
-
Phng php c trong khun kim loi p dng thch hp trong sn xut hng
lot vi vt c n gin, trng lng vt c nh n trung bnh, di 2
tn/vt c.
sn phm n l
1.2.2
L ch nu gang hoc kim loi mu
y l loi l th cng, tiu tn nhiu nhin liu, nng lng. Thng nhng
doanh nghip u t loi l ny t c kh nng u t h thng lc bi gim
thiu tc ng ti mi trng do iu kin v sinh cng nghip, mi trng
lao ng ca cng nhn cng khng c m bo yu cu.
L ng/l Quibil
L loi l tin b hn l ch, dng nu gang vi nhin lu l than dng
cc/than cc hoc du. Loi l ny qua nhiu th h c nhng ci tin
ng k nhm tng nng sut l, tng hiu qu s dng nhit bng cch thu
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 12/61
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 13/61
rt vo
v a i c
c p lc
di
c
, chi tit phc tp.
c lin tc
20.000 tn/nm.
c li tm
1.2.4
Trn 90% c s c
ngt v u hi c th c
p nh
thng rt, u
ct.
km
theo bi lm sch
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 14/61
km theo
my mi 2 c nh, my mi lc
my mi di ng
X l nhit
theo
ca
i
mc vt liu:
cc
, thng ho, ti,
, thm Nit hoc cc hp cht,
kim loi khc, gi chung l x l nhit
c c cc ch tiu c, l, kim
tng theo yu cu. Dung dch ti thng dng l nc, du...
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 15/61
Ting n
Vt c
c kim loi
Nc
,
thao,
sn phm
Bng 3
g
m3
Ct ti sinh
700 1100
520 800
500 700
750 - 1300
1300 - 1800
0,76 - 0,90
-
4,0 - 5,0
3,7 20,4
312 349
94 96
126 - 1473
80 - 98%
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 16/61
:
-
2.2.1 Kh thi
Cc cht
Cc loi kh khc: CO, SO2, NO, hp cht Clorit, Florit, H2S, CH4, N,
Formaldehyde
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 17/61
2.2.2 Nc thi
Ngnh c kim loi s dng nc cho h thng lm mt cc thit b cng
ngh, lm ngui sn phm, x l kh thi, x l v lm mt nh xng bng
mnh nc trong qu trnh cNc
, ti
, ti s dng
qui nh v bo v mi trng.
theo cc
2.2.4 Ting n
khun, thit b lm sch,
d
nu
, lm sch
nhng
gy
v mt s khu
khc
cao
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 18/61
3. C hi sn xut sch hn
Chng ny dn ra mt s v d v gii php SXSH c th p dng thnh cng trong ngnh
c kim loi. Ni dung ny s tip tc c cp nht khi c thm cc doanh nghip p dng
SXSH.
3.1
3.1.1 Cc gii php qun l nguyn liu
tn tht
do b oxy ho trong qu trnh lu kho/bi
n ch nhim t, nhim nc
qun
l sau:
-
ra
c Philippine
lng
2.700 USD mi nm v
115 tn x thi.
ng (Quibil)
3.1.2
3.1.2.1
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 19/61
nhit
ph hp vi mc gang yu cu.
3.1.2.2
ca l ng, c bit
Hin nay Nh my luyn gang Cng ty C phn Gang thp Thi Nguyn
ang vn hnh l cao vi than cc sn xut ti Nh my cc ha, c thnh
phnh v cht lng nh bng di:
Bng 4. Thnh phn ca than cc ti Nh my cc ha
Thnh phn
Gi tr
tro
<15%
Cht bc
<1%
Lu hunh
<1,6%
C ht
15-40mm
Hm lng cacbon c nh
>80%
vo;
-
vo l
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 20/61
Bng 5
ng knh
trong ca l
(mm)
Phng php lm
giu oxy (lng
oxy thm vo %)
Nng sut nu
(tn/gi)
T l than cc (%)
Trc
Sau
Trc
Sau
1014
Lm giu (2,5%)
14
12
912
Lm giu (3%)
15
10
1166
Lm giu (4%)
10
12
12,5
9,4
1216
Bm oxy (3%)
12,5
9,4
811
Lm giu (2%)
2,5
2,5
17
14
3.1.3 G
ci tin
ng
L trc khi ci to
L sau khi ci to
1,4
1,4
1,4
1,7
6,5
140
115
3.1.4
3.1.4.1 L ng
Nhit kh thi ra khi l ng dao ng t 500 - 800oC tu thuc lng
than trong phi liu, t l H/D ca l (chiu cao/ng knh l). C th p
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 21/61
Lp b trao i nhit
nhit vt l ca kh thi
Kh thi
tn dng nhit n
tip CO
trong l gi nng gia nhit cho khng kh trc khi thi vo l ng.
u im
gi nng thi vo l:
;
.
3.1.4.2 L in (l cm ng, l h quang)
c l ht th 4 trn nc l).
3.1.5
Kh thi pht sinh t qu trnh nu luyn l cm ng v l in h quang
thng cha nhiu loi kh c hi, trong phi k n Dioxin v Furan
(PCDD/PCDF). cc nc cng nghip pht trin thng p dng cc bin
php sau gim pht thi (PCDD/PCDF) :
+ Loi tr n mc ti a nhng loi vt cht c tim nng gy nhim
ln nh nha, sn, du, m, linh kin in t/t in;
+ C gng loi b nhng kim loi mu trong thp ph v chng l nhng
cht xc tc thc y vic to thnh Dioxin/Furan;
+ S ch thp ph tng t trng ng, gim s ln m np l np
liu gy tn tht nng lng v pht thi kh, bi ra mi trng quanh l v
ton b nh xng;
+ Bi cha thp ph cn c btng ho trnh t ct ln vo l lm
tng ph gia to x, tng lng x v tiu hao in nhiu hn;
+ Lng d tr thp ph khng nn qu 45-50 ngy v thp ph
ngoi tri vi thi tit nng, m, ma, nng v.v... s thc y qu trnh to g
(b xy ho gy tn tht v trng lng v tiu tn nng lng, cht ph gia);
+ Nn tm mi cch c lp/ bt kn cc ngun pht tn bi d ht v
x l (EAF&LF). a s cc l in h quang EAF ca Vit Nam thng p
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 22/61
3.2
3.2.1 Cc gii php p dng k thut - cng ngh tin tin
Ci thin hiu qu sn xut c trn c s p dng cc gii php sau:
-
ng dng cng ngh CAD/CAM trong vic thit k khun, mu, tnh ton
h thng u ngt, rt, gim lng d gia cng, m bo kch thc hnh
hc cho cc vt c phc tp;
trang 448 Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Draft Reference Document
on Best Available Techniques for the Production of Iron and Steel Draft July 2009.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 23/61
Cht lng khun: kim tra, gii quyt v ngn nga khuyt tt khun;
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 24/61
3.2.2.2
Mt s li th ca
gc nc so vi keo gc ru:
Cho b mt vt c tt hn;
Chn cc khi hoc vt liu khc thay ct cho cc l rng trn hm khun
gim nhu cu s dng ct
gim 63 kg bentonit/tn vt c
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 25/61
Cng ty thp Shinhokoku Steel thc hin gii php thay th ct silic thng bng ct zircon
chu nhit v kt hp lp t thit b nung ti sinh ct (x l ct bng nhit)
Ti cng ty, sn phm thp hp kim v thp khng r yu cu nhit cao, thng ln qu
1500oC trong cng on c. Trong khi ct silic thng thng t c kh nng chu nhit cao
n 1500oC v dn n nhiu khuyt tt trong sn phm c. Do , cng ty p dng gii
php s dng ct zircon, l loi ct c c tnh chu nhit tt; v kt hp x l ct bng nhit
ti s dng (do gi ct zircon t gp 5 ln ct silic thng).
Chi ph u t: 8 triu Yn. Chi ph vn hnh trc khi thc hin gii php: 28 triu Yn/nm.
Chi ph vn hnh sau khi thc hin gii php: 2,5 triu Yn/nm (do gim khuyt tt trn sn
phm, d tng chi ph mua ct). Li nhun hng nm: 25,5 triu Yn.
Gim s dng ct: gim t 360 tn ct/nm v 330 tn ct/nm. Gim ct thi: T 360 tn
ct/nm v 30 tn ct/nm (gim 330 tn ct/nm).
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 26/61
Nguyn liu
98,0
Cng ngh c
dng hn hp ct
cht kt dnh
(kg)
98,0
30,0
30,0
38,1
68,0
68,0
58,0
256,8
122,0
233,0
150,7
1101,4
-
0,212
Cng ngh c
dng Khun ct
ti (kg)
Gang
Ph c ti s
dng
Trng lng vt
c
Khun ct
Li ct
Trng lng mu
xp v ng rt
Cng ngh c
khun mu chy
(kg)
96,1
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 27/61
Vic lm sch hon thnh trong thi gian ngn (10-40 giy) v tiu tn rt
t nng lng.
Gii php ny khng yu cu h thng thu bi, v do gim lng kh
thng gi cn lm sch khng kh.
Xung in pht sinh trong nc c th lm nng nc trong b, nc sau
lm sch c th tn dng s dng trong nh my.
3.3.2 X l nhit
3.3.2.1
Sn phm sau c v hon thin c nhit luyn theo mt trong hai phng
php: Ram () v ti. Trong cng on Ram, sn phm c c a v l
nhit nhm ng u cu trc sn phm sau lm mt t t. Cng on
ny s dng nhiu nng lng do cn duy tr nhit cao trong l nhit.
V d ci tin l nhit (h thng ram) nhm gim nng lng tiu th:
o
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 28/61
V d: trc nm 1998 c 3 l nhit luyn (ti Phn Lan) vi u t kim sot theo phng
php th cng. Nhin liu kh than c dn trc tip t l cc v c cht lng khng tt
(hm lng CO dao ng). Do cht lng kh than khng n nh nn trong qu trnh vn hnh
l kh nng kim sot cc thng s nhit km, pht sinh kh thi vi nng cht nhim
cao v c nguy c ng c kh than cho ngi vn hnh.
n nm 1998, 2 trong 3 l c lp u t mi vi h thng kim sot bng my vi tnh.
u t mi s dng nhin liu l kh t nhin. Ngoi ra, tng l cng c lm mi. Do ,
ngi vn hnh c th kim sot t ng thng s nhit l.
Hiu qu 2 l mi ci tin t c:
-
Gim chi ph mua nhin liu do gi kh t nhin r hn chi ph mua than v kh ha than.
Gim pht thi SO2, NOx, CO v hp cht hu c mch vng (bng di)
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 29/61
4.1 Bc 1: Khi ng
Mc ch ca bc ny nhm:
-
Thnh lp c i SXSH.
Tm kim cc bin php ci tin n gin nht, hiu qu nht v c th thc hin ngay.
Vic thnh lp nhm nh gi SXSH l rt cn thit khi trin khai chng trnh
nh gi SXSH. Cc thnh vin ca nhm nn l cn b ca doanh nghip,
c th c thm h tr trin khai ca chuyn gia bn ngoi. Quy m ca nhm
s ph thuc vo quy m ca doanh nghip. Vi doanh nghip ln, nhm
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 30/61
Tn v a ch doanh nghip
Nhm SXSH
Chc v - b phn
Tn
V tr trong nhm
1
2
3
4
5
CS thit k (tn/nm)
Kg/nm
Kg/nm
Kg/nm
Nguyn liu ph
Vt liu m l
Nc
Than
Gas
m /nm
kg/nm
kWh/nm
kg/nm
Kg/nm
Kg/nm
Cng sut
Thit b
Nc v nng
lng
Lng
Kg/nm
Kg/nm
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
tn/gi
tn/gi
tn/gi
tn/gi
Trang 31/61
Nhm SXSH
H v tn
Chc v - b phn
V tr trong nhm
1
2
3
4
Phng k thut
Phng k thut
6
Ngoi ra, nhm cn c cc thnh vin h tr l mt s cn b, cng nhn lm vic ti cc cng
on sn xut, ti v, chuyn trch an ton v sinh lao ng
CS thit k (tn/nm)
Bi nghin
148
ng trt
32
2.500
St thp ph
kg/nm
2.470.000
Ci
m3/nm
70
Gang
kg/nm
230.000
VL m l
kg/nm
30.672
mi nh
vin/nm
2.500
mi to
vin/nm
156
Vi amiang
kg/nm
625
Ph gia (Fer,
Al)
kg/nm
73.880
Ct
kg/nm
618.000
Nguyn liu ph
Lng
in
kwh/nm
750.000
t st
kg/nm
87.727
Than
kg/nm
100.000
m3/nm
20
Gas
kg/nm
5.760
Nc thy tinh
lt/nm
64.800
CO2
kg/nm
15.500
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 32/61
Nhn xt:
-
Nhm trin khai sn xut sch hn: c cc b phn lin quan. Tuy nhin, ban lnh o
doanh nghip cn m bo cc thnh vin trong i c thi gian trin khai chng
trnh. Vic c ra cc thnh vin h tr l mt tt nhng cc thnh vin ny nn c giao
cng vic mt cch chnh thc c trch nhim vi cng vic.
Cn mt s thng tin lin quan sn xut m nhm cn thu thp nh: danh sch thit b, s
gi lm vic, cng sut, s ngy sn xut mt nm c nh gi c bn v hin trng
sn xut ca doanh nghip.
C/khng
Ghi ch
S mt bng
Ti liu thit k
S liu thng k nguyn liu tiu th
S liu thng k tiu th nc, nng
lng
S cng ngh
Cn bng nng lng
Cn bng nc
H s bo dng thit b
H s hin trng mi trng
Cc thng tin cng ngh:
- Quy trnh cng on nu luyn
- Quy trnh cng on rt khun, d
khun v lm sch sn phm
- Quy trnh cng on nhit luyn
- Quy trnh cng on hon tt
- Quy trnh cng on lm khun
Lu : Rt nhiu doanh nghip khng c thng tin ban u v cc thnh vin trong nhm s
phi tho lun cch thc thu thp nhng thng tin ny. Ch c cc ti liu phn nh hin trng
sn xut mi c gi tr cao trong nh gi hiu qu kinh t, k thut v mi trng.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 33/61
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 34/61
Nguyn liu
chnh
Nguyn liu
ph
Nhin liu
CNG ON
1
Nguyn liu
Nhin liu
CNG ON
2
Nguyn liu
Nhin liu
CNG ON
3
Nguyn liu
Nhin liu
THIT B
PH TR
H THNG
X L
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 35/61
, nhin liu
ct
Fero
Khun
Than
Nhn xt:
-
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 36/61
Nhp liu
L in
Quan st
-
B tr mt bng
Ri vi nguyn liu
B tr mt bng
Bo dng thit b
Nhit mt mt / Kh thi
R r nc, du m
X l v lu tr bn sn phm
Ph tr
Nc chy trn
Nhit nc sau lm mt
l nhit
Sau khi quan st thc t v cch thc vn hnh cng nh qun l sn xut,
nhm nh gi c th a ra c rt nhiu gii php SXSH hin nhin
m cha cn s dng cc k thut phn tch tip theo. y l cc gii php
hin th r rng m trc y cha c lu tm trong sn xut hng ngy.
Vic mi cc chuyn gia bn ngoi tham gia, tham quan, kho st bc ny
l c bit c hiu qu.
Kim sot quy trnh vn hnh iu kin ti u v qun l mt bng trong
nh my thng b b qua v y cng l phn n gin nht, hp dn nht
bt u cc bc tip cn SXSH. Hn na, rt nhiu gii php SXSH
c xc nh l nhng gii php c th thc hin trong thi gian ngn, chi
ph thp, ch cn nhng thay i nh v thit b hoc ci thin v phng thc
v tn sut duy tr bo dng. Vic p dng nhng gii php ny chng
minh l mt khi u tt cho cc c gng SXSH ca nh my, khuyn khch
nh qun l cng nh cc cn b c gng hn na khi tin hnh nh gi
SXSH.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 37/61
n v
n gi
ng/n v
Lng s
dng
tn/nm
Lng s dng
n v/tn sn
phm
Chi ph
ng/tn sn
phm
Than
in
Nc
Gas
.
Vt liu m l
Ct
Lu : bng trn ch bao gm chi ph cho cc loi nguyn nhin liu s dng trong qu trnh sn
xut. y l c s dng xc nh hiu qu chng trnh, ng thi cng phn no ch ra t l
tng quan gia cc loi nguyn, nhin vt liu. Bc tranh chi ph sn xut tng th cn c
b sung bi chi ph nhn s, nng lng v vn hnh h thng x l mi trng. y c th
cn thiu chi ph ca mt s nguyn liu do c nhiu loi, nhiu gi khc nhau v lng s
dng nh hoc thay i. Vi cc loi ny ta c th ly gi tr trung bnh hoc b qua ty tng
trng hp.
n
v
n gi
Lng s dng
Lng s dng
ng/n v
n v/nm
n v/tn sn phm
193.742
1308
St thp ph
kg
12.000
Gang
kg
6.500
Ferro
kg
Al 35.000
1037
Fe 22.000
7
-
Ct
kg
88.132
595
Nc thy tinh
kg
2.410
9.850
66,5
in
Kwh
750
165.896
1120
Than
kg
4.520
37.030
250
Gas
kg
1.018.000
296
CO2
kg
130.000
4.592
31
Vt liu m l
Kg
30.000
30.672
17,2
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 38/61
Nhn xt:
-
Bng chi ph nguyn liu cng chi tit v y cng h tr vic xc nh chi ph dng thi
(phiu cng tc s 8) chnh xc.
Bng trn cn cho bit gi cng nh lng s dng mt s nguyn nhin liu, y l
nhng thng tin quan trng cho vic phn tch tip theo.
Khi doanh nghip c nhiu loi chi ph nguyn liu, ch lit k cc chi ph chnh trong bng
ny, phn cn li chuyn xung ph lc.
Lit k y cc dng vo ra, bao gm cc dng tun hon nguyn nhin vt liu, thu
hi v ti s dng. Dng vo ghi bn tri, dng ra ghi bn phi hp m t cng on.
Vi cc dng nguyn liu khng c s dng hng ngy cng nh dng pht thi khng
thng xuyn cn c ghi ch.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 39/61
u vo
Loi
Cng on 1
Nguyn liu
Nguyn liu
u ra
Lng
Loi
Sn
phm 1
Lng
Dng thi
Lng
Rn
Lng
1.1
Rn
2.1
Nhin liu .
Sn phm 1
Nguyn liu
Kh
3.1
Rn
2.2
Nhin liu
Cng on 2
Kh
Sn
phm 2
Nhin liu
Cng on .
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 40/61
Lu :
-
Khng c cn bng no l hon thin c. Khi ghp s liu ca tng cng on v s liu
tng th ca c dy chuyn s xut hin sai s do tnh chnh xc ca s liu, do tng ca
nhiu dng thi nh cha c k n nh bay hi, ri vi.... Mc ch ca cn bng vt
liu l tm ra cc dng thi lng ph ln nht tp trung gim thiu.
S liu dng trong cn bng vt liu c th c thu thp t s sch ghi chp hoc o c
trc tip. Cc s liu s dng cn quy i v cng mt n v sn phm.
S liu dng thi trong cn bng vt liu l tng nht l c km thm thng s v nguyn
liu hoc dng bin i mi ca nguyn liu b mt theo dng thi tin cho vic xc nh
chi ph dng thi bc tip theo.
Mi dng thi nn c nh s (v d L1, L2, L3 cho dng thi lng, K cho kh v R cho
rn) tin cho vic xc nh chi ph cng nh phn tch nguyn nhn tip theo.
Nu luyn
u vo
Loi
Lng
Thp ph
1308 kg
u ra
Loi
Lng
Thp
ph
1300 kg
Thp
lng
1227 kg
Thp ph
1300 kg
in
1.120kwh
VL m l
17.3 kg
Nc b
sung
20,96m3
Thp lng
1227 kg
SP c
Khun
660 kg
u hi 277 kg
liu
Dng thi
Lng
Rn (kg)
Kh (kg)
Tp cht
8 kg
Nc
tun
hon
1000 kg
X
l Bi
71,3kg
12,1kg
VL m kg
l 3.7kg
Khun
660kg
Ct
600 kg
Ghp
khun, sy
khun
BTP
662 kg
Gas
2 kg
BTP
662 kg
Khun
660
Nc thy 66 kg
tinh
Nc
thy
tinh ri
vi
Ct ri vi
4kg
Bavia 2kg
Nhn xt:
-
Bng cn bng vt liu nu trn phn tch chi tit cho tng cng on trong sn xut v
ch ra loi v lng ca cc dng thi.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 41/61
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 42/61
Tn dng thi
Thnh phn
trong dng
thi
Ngun gc
thnh phn
thi
n v
Lng
Nhn xt:
-
Vic tch thnh phn thi v ngun nguyn liu sinh ra dng thi gip cho vic p mc
gi tn tht nguyn liu c d dng hn.
Trong cng vic ny, c th xem xt n lng nguyn liu thu hi nh mt dng thi trong
mt bng ring c phn tch tip theo ring.
Vic chi tit ha s cng ngh v phn tch cn bng vt liu tt s nh hng n kt
qu xc nh chi ph cc dng thi trong cng vic ny.
Trong trng hp ca Cng ty c phn cng ngh cao Sao Xanh cng a ra c bng
c tnh dng thi ca cc cng on sn xut, tuy nhin s liu lng tn tht cn phi
quy ra lng tn tht tnh cho 1 nm.
Tin
Chi ph x l
Lng
TNG
Tin
Thc t nhiu doanh nghip cha xt n chi ph n l chi ph nguyn liu mt mt theo dng
thi m ch xt chi ph x l mi trng i vi cc dng thi lm nh hng n quyt nh u
t mi trng.
xc nh c tt nht tng gi tr dng thi v so snh mc quan trng ca cc dng
thi, cc s liu c xc nh trong phiu cng tc 5 (chi ph nguyn liu) v phiu cng tc s
6 (cn bng vt liu) ng vai tr quan trng.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 43/61
kg
12.000
15.696.000
Fero
Kg
30.000
210.000
VL m l
kg
10.000
173.000
750
840.000
Nc lm mt
in
kwh
Chun b
ph, np
ph
Nu luyn
Dng
thi
.gia Chi
ph
Tp cht
12.000 96.000
15.696.000
Khi bui
16.919
204.720
Hao
VLL
10.000
37.000
X l
16.919 1.206.325
Nhit thi
750
165.000
16.985
1.573.609
20
13.200
16.919.000
Khun cat
kg
20
13.200
Ra thep,
c
u
VL uc
16.932.200
4.2.4
C nhiu cch thc hin cng vic ny mt cch c h thng thng qua
vic r sot cc phm vi lin quan n tng dng thi. iu cn ch trong
phn tch nguyn nhn dng thi l lun ghi li cc nguyn nhn theo thc t
vn hnh hin ti/quan st c. Cc nguyn nhn xc nh khng mang tnh
ch trch hoc ph phn.
Nguyn nhn ca dng thi c xc nh mt cch c h thng v y
nht khi s dng phng php tho lun nhm v biu Ishikawa (hay cn
gi l biu xng c). Biu Ishikawa l mt trong by loi biu kim
sot cht lng, c coi l cng c ph bin nht thc hin phn tch
nhn- qu. xy dng biu ny cn dng phng php xem xt 4M1E,
bao gm con ngi (Man), phng php thc hin (Method), nguyn liu
(Material), my mc (Machine) v mi trng (Environment).
Cng c th xc nh nguyn nhn dng thi da trn cc cu hi c bn
sau: bn cht ca cng on l g? (vy dng thi sinh ra c phi p
ng mc ch ca cng on khng?); ti sao sinh ra nhim nhiu nh
th? (c phi do nh hng ca cng on trc hay do cng on ny dng
lng ph nguyn nhin vt liu?) v c th lm g c vi dng thi ny (c
thc hin tun hon ti s dng c khng) ? ...
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 44/61
D thc hin bng cch ny hay cch khc, cn tin hnh phn tch nguyn
nhn cho mi dng thi trong cng mt h thng v tm cc nguyn nhn
bng cu hi ti sao.
Lu :
Cch r sot nguyn nhn y nht l theo dng thi c nh s phiu cng tc 6.
Mi mt dng thi s c th c mt hoc mt vi nguyn nhn tng ng. Cc nguyn nhn
ny cng s c nh s th t theo s th t ca dng thi. Trong mt s trng hp cn
nh gi nhanh, nguyn nhn c xc nh theo nguyn nhin liu tiu th chnh (nh in,
nc... tiu th cao). y khng khuyn co xc nh nguyn nhn theo cng on m khng
bm theo dng thi v s khng m bo xem xt ht c cc nguyn nhn tim nng. Vic
a ra cc nguyn nhn cng chi tit th cc gii php c xut cng phong ph.
Cng on
Nguyn nhn
Ch quan
Khch quan
L1
L2
Nhn xt:
-
Vic phn tch mt cch c h thng s dn n nhiu nguyn nhn hn, qua c thm
c hi ci thin, gim dng thi.
Cc kha cnh phn tch nguyn nhn c th c tip tc khai thc thm.
Vic phn tch nguyn nhn ca Cng ty c phn cng ngh cao Sao Xanh khng i theo
tng dng thi m phn tch theo tng cng on sn xut. Tuy nhin cc nguyn nhn
c cng ty a ra kh y , c nhng nguyn nhn c a ra m khng phi t bt
k dng thi no c nu trn.
Cc c hi sn xut sch hn
Trang 45/61
C hi
1.1.1
QLNV
TDNL
KSQT
CTTB
TDCN
TH
SP
1.1.2
TNG
Ghi ch: QLNV: Qun l ni vi, TDNL: thay i nguyn liu, KSQT: Kim sot qu trnh, CTTB:
ci tin thit b, TDCN: thay i cng ngh, TH: tun hon, ti s dng, SP: ci tin sn phm
Lu :
-
Vic thc hin phn tch nguyn nhn l c bit quan trng i vi kt qu ca cng vic
xut c hi. Phn tch nguyn nhn cng chi tit v khch quan th s c cng nhiu c
hi c a ra.
ln
5. Kh
TT
1
1.1
1.3
2.1
4
5
2.2
3.1
3.2
4.1
5.1
6.1
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 46/61
10
7.1
11
7.2
12
13
14
15
7.3
7.4
8.1
8.2
16
9.1
17
9.2
18
19
10.1
10.2
20
10.3
21
22
11.1
11.2
23
11.3
24
11.4
25
14.1
26
15.1
27
15.2
Gia cng l
Khon than dng cho l trnh chy l khng
ti
Nghin cu tip
Loi b
1.1.1
1.1.2
TNG
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 47/61
M t gii php
Yu cu
C
u t phn cng
c sn
Khng
Thit b
Cng c
Cng ngh
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 48/61
2. Tc ng k thut
Lnh vc
Tc ng
Tch cc
Tiu cc
Nng lc sn xut
Cht lng sn phm
Tit kim ha cht
Tit kim nng lng
Tnh tng thch vi cc thit b trong h thng
An ton
Bo dng
Vn hnh
Khc
Lu : Mi phiu cng tc s dng phn tch cho mt gii php.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 49/61
M t gii php
u t phn cng
Tit kim
VND
VND
Thit b
Nguyn liu
Ph tr
Nng lng
Lp t
Nguyn liu ph
Vn chuyn
Chi ph x l v thi b
Khc
Khc
TNG
TNG
Chi ph vn hnh nm
Khu hao
VND
LI THUN
=
TIT KIM CHI PH VN HNH
Bo dng
Nhn cng
in
Khc
TNG
Lu vic in thng tin cho mi gii php SXSH vo mt phiu cng tc l l tng trc khi
tng hp danh mc cc gii php kh thi.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 50/61
M t gii php
Thng s
nh tnh
Kh
Nc
Rn
nh lng
Ngy nay, vic trin khai gii php SXSH c tc ng tch cc n mi trng ngy cng c
coi trng, thm ch c th c thc hin ngay c khi khng kh thi v mt kinh t.
Kh thi k thut
(25)
L
Kh thi kinh t
(50)
L
Kh thi mi
trng (25)
L
Tng
im
Xp hng
1.1.1
im cho cc mc thp (L: 0-5), trung bnh (M: 6-14), cao (H: 15-20)
Trng s 25 (kh thi k thut), 50 (kh thi kinh t), 25 (kh thi mi trng) ch l v d
V d: Hin ti cc doanh nghip Vit Nam thng trng s 30, 40, 30 cho tnh kh thi v k
thut, kinh t v mi trng
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 51/61
Gim st
Phng php
Giai on
Nhn xt:
-
Thi gian thc hin: nn ghi mc thi gian trin khai cng vic ny mt cch c th, v d
thng 1 n thng 5 nm 2009, tng ng ghi giai on gim st kt qu thc hin thng
6-10 nm 2009. Vic trin khai thng xuyn s c cp trong mc tip theo (duy tr
sn xut sch hn).
Ngi chu trch nhim: D l mt nhm ngi, nn c tn ngi chu trch nhim chnh
trin khai.
Cng ty c phn cng ngh cao Sao Xanh cha a ra c k hoch thc hin cc gii
php cng nh ngi chu trch nhim thc hin cc gii php .
Chi ph thc
hin
Li ch kinh t
D kin
Thc t
Li ch mi trng
D kin
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Thc t
Trang 52/61
n v
Li ch k thut
Trc
SXSH
Li ch kinh t
Sau SXSH
Li ch mi
trng
kg
CO2
Than
kg
CO2
%
Tng cng
SXSH
Sau
SXSH
1308
1300
17,2
10,3
30
50
1120
1100
660,8
649
250
232
510
473,28
0,6%
12.000
ng/kg
14.400.000
40,1%
10.000
ng/kg
10.350.000
1,8%
750
ng/kWh
2.250.000
1770 kg CO2
CO2/kWh
7,2%
1000
ng/kg
2.700.000
5508 kg CO2
CO2/kg than
200
190
20%
15%
5,0%
700.000
ng/kg
1.050.000.000
1.079.700.000
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 53/61
Khuyn khch nhn vin c nhng sng kin mi v nhng xut cho c
hi SXSH;
Ngay sau khi trin khai thc hin cc gii php SXSH, nhm SXSH nn bt
u thc hin t bc 2: Phn tch cng ngh, xc nh v chn la cng
on lng ph nht trong nh my. Tip tc trin khai tng bc nh c
m t trn.
duy tr c vic p dng thnh cng chng trnh SXSH, cha kha cho
thnh cng lu di l phi thu ht s tham gia ca cng nhiu nhn vin cng
tt, cng nh c mt ch khen thng cho nhng ngi c bit xut sc,
lm cho SXSH tr thnh mt hot ng lin tc, c thc hin thng
xuyn.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 54/61
mun;
-
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 55/61
5. X l mi trng
Mc ch ca chng ny nhm cung cp thng tin tm tt cc nguyn tc x l vn mi
trng c bn ca ngnh c kim loi. l x l kh thi, nc thi v cht thi rn.
SXSH h tr doanh nghip ci thin hin trng mi trng thng qua gim ti
lng pht thi ra mi trng, nng cao hiu sut s dng nguyn nhin liu.
Tuy nhin, c th p ng c tiu chun thi, trong nhiu trng hp
cn c thm cc gii php x l cui ng ng, c m t di y.
5.1 X l kh thi
Kh thi
v kh c hi.
90%.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 56/61
Kh thi sau
lm sch
Kh thi vo
Kh thi sau
lm sch
Kh thi
vo
5.1.1.2 Lc bi Cyclon
Kh thi sau
lm sch
Kh thi
vo
-95%.
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 57/61
, tng kh nng hp th kh
thi c hi v bi. Thit b lc bi nhiu
Hnh 5. Lc bi ti vi
tng bt cho hiu qu lc bi kh cao, t
99,7%, nng bi trong khng kh cn li kh thp, di 12 mg/m 3
5.1.1.5 Lc bi tnh in
Thit b lc bi tnh in nn p dng ti cc doanh nghip c cng nghip,
sn lng ln. Thi b lc tnh in s dng lc ht gia cc ht nh np in
m. Cc ht bi bn trong thit b lc bi ht nhau v kt li thnh khi c kch
thc ln cc tm thu gp. Thit b lc bi kiu tnh in rt hiu qu i vi
cc loi bi kch c t 0,5 n 8m. Khi cc ht bi c kch c khong 10m
v ln hn th hiu qu gim. Cn lu vn an ton v in th s dng
rt cao v nguy him n tnh mng con ngi.
B lc th
kiu trc quay
Dy ion ha
Ni t
Kh thi sau x
l
Kh thi + bi
Vng ion ha
Vng thu gp
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 58/61
Bung phun, thp phun: trong cht lng c phun thnh git nh
trong th tch rng ca thit b v cho dng kh i qua.
Vt liu ph bin nht thuc nhm 1 l than hot tnh. Ngoi ra, mt s vt
liu hp ph khc nh silicagel, alumogel
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 59/61
5.2 X l nc thi
cc thit b cng ngh trong
thng
luyn
ti s dng
V
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
c chc nng
Trang 60/61
Technologies for Sustainable Development European IPPC Bureau Reference Document on Best Available Techniques in the Smitheries and
Foundries Industry 2004;
http://oce.nrcan.gc.ca/cipec/newscentre/foundry/5/5_2.cfm
http://www.custompartnet.com
http://www.airbooster.com/
Ti liu hng dn Sn xut sch hn trong ngnh cng nghip c kim loi
Trang 61/61