You are on page 1of 28

Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03

Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 131


21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Logistics Systems Design:
Material Handling Systems
13. Material Handling Systems
14. Material Handling Models
15. Warehousing Systems
16. Storage Models
17. Order Picking Models
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Material Handling Systems
Overview
^ Definition
^ Classifications
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Material Handling Definition
Material handling is concerned with the
Movement
Storage, and
Control
Of materials in a process
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Material Handling Is Expensive
^ 10 % to 80 % of product cost
^ Physical distribution costs 25 % of
product cost
^ More than 90 % of flow time in job
shop production systems
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 132
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Material Handling in Early
Automotive Assembly
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Traditional Versus Modern
View
^ Traditional
Not value adding, only cost adding
Minimize as much as possible
Support automation
^ Modern
Provides space and time utility
Maximize flexibility
Support integration
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Stages in M.H.S. Design
O Why ?
O What ?
O When and where ?
O How ?
O By whom ?
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Nine Rights of Material
Handling
O Uses the right
METHOD
O To provide the
right AMOUNT
O Of the right
MATERIAL
O To the right
PLACE
O At the right TIME
O In the right
SEQUENCE
O In the right
POSITION
O In the right
CONDITION
O At the right
COST
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 133
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Material Handling Systems
Overview
^ Definition
^ Classifications
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Classification of Material
Handling
O by Material
O by Method
O by Equipment
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Categories of Materials
^ Gasses
^ Liquids
^ Bulk materials
^ Discrete (unit) loads
^ Documents & money
^ Livestock
^ People
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load Definition
A collection of materials so
arranged and restrained that it can
be handled, stored, and controlled
as a single entity
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 134
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load Advantages
^ Standardized handling equipment
^ Standardized storage equipment
^ Reduced information & control burden
^ Efficient macro space utilization
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load Disadvantages
^ Cost of assembly and disassembly
^ Cost of container and wrappings
^ Cost of empty container handling &
disposal
^ Inefficient micro space utilization
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load Examples
^ Pallet
^ Drum
^ Truck
^ Ocean going intermodal container
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load Example: Ocean
Going Intermodal Container
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 135
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Classification of Material
Handling
O by Material
O by Method
O by Equipment
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Categories of Methods
^ Manual
^ Mechanized
^ Automated
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Labor And Control Providers
Capability
Labor Control
Type
Manual Human Human
Mechanized Machine Human
Automated Machine Machine
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Method Characteristics
Flexibility
Capacity
Project Job Shop Flow Shop
Manual
Hard
Automation
Mechanized &
Soft Automated
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 136
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Characteristics of Material
Handling Methods
Characteristic Type
Manual Mechanized Automated
Weight Low High High
Volume Low High High
Speed Low Medium High
Frequency Low Medium High
Capacity Low Medium High
Flexibility High Medium Low
Acquisition cost Low Medium High
Operating cost High Medium Low
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Manual Handling Illustration:
Postman and Farmer
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Manual Handling Equipment:
Wheelbarrow
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Mechanized Handling
Illustration: Forklift Truck
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 137
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Automated Illustration:
Deep Lane Storage Detail
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Classification of Material
Handling
O by Material
O by Method
O by Equipment
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
CICMHE-MHIA Taxonomy of
Material Handling Equipment
www.mhia.org/et/mhe_tax.htm
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Equipment Categories
O Conveyors
O Cranes and
hoists
O Industrial trucks
O Containers and
supports
O Storage
equipment
O Auxiliary
equipment
O Storage/retrieval
systems
O Robots
O Pipelines
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 138
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Pipeline Systems
^ Liquids, gasses, slurries, documents
^ High fixed cost, very low operational
cost, high volume
^ Slow transportation speed but
continuous movement
^ Dependable and low time variance
^ Larger diameters are more efficient
^ Water, waste, documents
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Pipeline Characteristics
^ Continuous movement
^ Fixed paths - ceiling suspended
^ Very limited access area
^ Very high hardware cost
^ Very high volume
^ Synchronous or asynchronous with
containers
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Conveyors Characteristics
^ Continuous movement
^ Fixed paths
^ Very limited access area
^ Very high hardware cost
^ Very high volume
^ Asynchronous versus synchronous
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Conveyor Examples
^ Synchronous
Belt
Roller
Power and free
^ Asynchronous
Automated electrified monorail (AEM)
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 139
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Bulk Belt Conveyor in Gold
Mining Leach Removal
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Bulk Belt Conveyor in Wood
Chip Removal
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Belt Conveyor in Electronics
Assembly
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Belt Conveyor With Diverter
Bar in Electronics Assembly
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1310
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Belt Conveyor in A-Frame
Order Picking System
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Conveyor Network in
Electronics Manufacturing
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Roller Conveyor With Diverter
in Electronics Manufacturing
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Roller Conveyor in Order
Picking
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1311
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Power and Free Buffer in
Automotive Assembly
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Power and Free in Automotive
Engine Assembly
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Power and Free in Automotive
Final Assembly
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Automated Electrified Conveyor
in Typewriter Manufacturing
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1312
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Cranes and Hoists
Characteristics
^ Overhead devices with vertical
movement
^ Intermittent movement
^ Limited access area
^ Medium hardware costs
^ Medium volume
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Bridge Crane Illustration
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Bridge Crane for Aircraft
Engine Transport
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Moveable Bulk Crane
Illustration
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1313
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Mobile Harbor Crane
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Gantry Cranes Unloading a
Container Ship
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Gantry Crane Example
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Cranes and Hoists Access Areas
^ Circular jib access
area
^ Rectangular bridge
crane access area
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1314
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Industrial Trucks
Characteristics
^ Moving vehicles on wheels
^ Intermitted movement
^ Variable paths
^ Very wide access area
^ Low hardware cost
^ Low volume
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Industrial Trucks Illustration:
Counterbalanced Lift Truck
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Pallet Jack and Tractor
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Tractor Trailer Example
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1315
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Straddle and Counterbalanced
Forklift Trucks
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Block Stacking Operation With
Counterbalanced Truck
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Order Picking Truck
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Stacker Cranes Example
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1316
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
AGV With Collision Bumpers
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
AGVS With Load Station
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
AGV Load Station
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
AGVS to ASRS Interface
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1317
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Multiload AGV in
Semiconductor Manufacturing
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Multiload AGV Interfacing With
Clean Room
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
AGVS and Gantry Cranes for
Intermodal Containers
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Stacker Cranes for Intermodal
Containers
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1318
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Containers Characteristics
^ To maintain a unit load
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Container Examples
^ Pallet
^ Tote box
^ Intermodal container
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Storage Equipment
Characteristics
^ To hold materials
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Storage Equipment Examples
^ Person-to-part
Block stacking
Pallet rack
Gravity flow rack
Bin shelving
^ Part-to-person
Carousels
Miniload
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1319
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Block Stacking Storage of
Household Appliances
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Bin Shelving
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Order Picking From Bin
Shelving
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Pallet Rack
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1320
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Shelves With Quantity Displays
(Pick-to-light)
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Small Parts Carousel Example
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Auxiliary Equipment Types
^ Bar code readers
^ Stretch wrappers
^ Palletizers
^ Lift tables
^ Measuring frames
^ Air film handling equipment
^ Radio frequency terminals
^ ..
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Pallet Positioners
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1321
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Voice Communications for
Hands-free Order Picking
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Radio Frequency
Communications Terminals
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Storage & Retrieval
Characteristics
^ Combined handling and storage
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load AS/RS Illustration
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1322
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Storage & Retrieval Types
^ Part-to-person
Unit load AS/RS
Miniload (storage drawer)
Microload (tote stacker)
Carousel with extractor
V and A frame order picking
Deep lane storage
^ Person-to-part
Person-aboard
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load Storage System With
Multiple Aisles
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load System Example
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load ASRS for Paper Rolls
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1323
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load ASRS for Thread
Coils
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Miniload Example
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Deep Lane Storage System
Detail
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Deep Lane Storage System
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1324
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Deep Lane Storage Example
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load, Deep Lane, Storage
Retrieval System Detail
Activ System Detail (Retrotech)
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Unit Load, Deep Lane,
Automated Staging Warehouse
Activ System
(Retrotech)
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
A-Frame Automatic Order
Picking Example Detail
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1325
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Person-aboard Example
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Person-aboard Example:
Inside the Aisle View
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Robot Characteristics
^ Programmable
^ Anthropomorphic (gripper)
^ General purpose (multifunctional)
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Robot Degrees of Freedom
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1326
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Six Degree of Freedom Robot
Example
Fanuc 710i
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Japanese Robot Classification
O Manual manipulator
O Fixed sequence robot
O Variable sequence robot
O Play back robot
O Numerically controlled robot
O Intelligent robot
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Robot Application Areas
^ 3 D areas
Dull
Dirty
Dangerous
^ 70 % automotive industry
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Robotic Processes
^ Spot and arc welding
^ Pick and place
^ Paint spraying
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1327
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Welding Robot Example
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Pick and Place Robot Example
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Robotic Assembly
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Robotic Machine Part Loading
Logistics Systems Design: Material Handling Systems 21-Jul-03
Copyright 1994-2003, Marc Goetschalckx, All rights reserved. 1328
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Pick and Place Palletizing
Robot Example
Motoman
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Pick and Place Clean Room
Robot
Motoman
K3crpic
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Robotic Part Unloading With
Vacuum
21-J ul-03 LogisticsSystemsDesign MarcGoetschalckx
Robotic Spray Painting in
Automotive Assembly

You might also like