Professional Documents
Culture Documents
̸̸̸̸̺͎̺͉͉̺̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋́̈́̽́̾̈́́̓́͠
͉͇̺͇̺͇͉̹͌͊̾̽̾̓͆͊́́͢͠͠
4&3#*"/"$"%&.:0'4$*&/$&4"/%"354
*/45*565&'03#"-,"/456%*&4
41&$*"-&%*5*0/4
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
5)&$6-50')0-:36-&34"/%3&-*$4
*/.&%*&7"-4&3#*"
#FMHSBEF
̸̸̸̸̸̸͉͈͇͊͊̓̓̽̾́͆͌̓́͌̾͋͆͊͋́͠ͅͅ
̸̸̹͇͇̈́̓͆̈́͑̓́́͆͊͋́͋͌͋
̸̸̸͈͇̹͊̾͆́̀̽͢
%"/*$"10107*>
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̸̸̸̸̺͎̺͉͉̺̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋́̈́̽́̾̈́́̓́͠
͉͇̺͇̺͇͉̹͌͊̾̽̾̓͆͊́́͢͠͠
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
́Ͳͯͪͬͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪͶ͵ͳͳͼͽͳͽ;ͽ̸͊͆͌
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̓ͰͲͅͳͪͳͶͬͪ*7
ͰNBJMCBMLJOTU!TBOVBDZV
XXXCBMLBOJOTUJUVUDPN
̀ͪͳͲͯͪͬͪͪ
ͯͻ̽;̸̸̹͇̺ͪ͋͋̓́ͣ
ͯͳͻͰ͵ͽͻ
͉ͰͰͲͰͽͳ
͡;ͫͷͳͻ̸͇̺̓͊́́ͣͅͅ
ͯͺͳͼͳͶ̸ͪ͊͆͌
ͺͻͿͯͻ̹ͻͪͳͼͶ͇ͪͬ͋̽́ͣ
̻ͻͪͿͳ͵ͳͯͳͲͪΒ
̽ͪͳΒͰͶ̸̸͈͉ͪ͏̓́
̈́Ͱ͵ͽͻ
̸̻͇̺́ͬͪͪ́͋́ͣ͢
͋Ͱͳ͵ͳ;ͻͰͯͳ͵
̓ͻͪͳͼͶ̸̺͉ͪͬ͆́ͣ
͈ͻͰͬͯ;ͬͯͪ
ͪͅͻͳ̸̸͇̺ͪ̽́ͣͅњ͇̺̓͌̈́̾͆́ͣ
͑ͽͪͷͺͪ
̸̸̸͇̺̈́͋͆
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
͋ͳͻͪͱ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ͵ͪ
*4#/
ͭͅͻͪͿͳΒ͈ͪͯ͵ͻͳΓͰͷͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͽͪͷͺͪͪΒͰ;ͲͿͳͪͼͳΒͼ͵;ͺͯͻ͵;
ͅͳͳͼͽͪͻͼͽͬͪͲͪͪ;͵;ͳͲͪͽͳͽ;ͱͳͬͽͰͼͻͰͯͳͰ͉Ͱͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͊ ̸ ̽ ͉̿ ̸ ͠
̺͇͌̽ ]
̸̺͉͇͇͊̾͋́̽͆͐̾̈́͆́͏́ ]
͊ͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ ]
͈ͻͳͶͭͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔ;͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ
͇ͪͼͽͪ͵;͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ ]
ͅͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ ]
͐;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ ]
̸̺͇͉͇͊̾͋̽͆́͆͊̈́̾̽͆́͏̸̸͉́́͊͋̽̈́͆́͏́ ]
̓;Ͷͽ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪmͷͪͪ͋Ͱ͵ͽͳͼͽͪ ]
͊ͬͰͽͳ͵ͻͪΓ͊ͽͰͿͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ ]
̓ͽͳͽͻͅͻͪͰͳΔͰͭͬ͵;Ͷͽ ]
̸̸̸̸͉̺̺͉͇͇̻̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́̽͊̓́̽̾̈́́͠͠ ]
4BDSBFSFMJRVJBF͊ͺͪͼͬͰͻ͵ͬͰ;̿ͳͳ ]
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪUSBOTMBUJP͵ͪͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳBEWFOUVT ]
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ ]
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ(MPSJB#VMHBSJBFm(MPSJB4FSWJBF ]
ͅͽͳͼͬ̈́;͵Ͱmͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͰͺͳͲͯͪ ]
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5: ]
5)&$6-50')0-:36-&34"/%3&-*$4*/.&%*&7"-4&3#*"
̸͉͊̓ͣ̾͆́͏̾ ]
̸̸͇̹̺͉͇̺̾͆́̽́͠͡ ]
̺͇͌̽
̺͇͌̽
̸͈͉̾̽̾͋͊͋͌̽́͠ͅͼͪͫͻͪͳ;ͬΒ͵ΔͳͲͳΒͰͼ;ͯͪͫͻͪͳ͵;ͶͽͬͳͼͬͰͽͳ
ͽͰΓͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͵Βͳͼ;;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳͳͷͪͶͳͽͰͷͰΓ;;Ͷͭ;;
ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͷͲͪͼͳͬͪΔ;ͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰͳͯͻͱͪͬͰ̓ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰPͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͷͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪ
ͱͳͬͪͳͼ;ͪͳͪͶͳ͵;ͶͽͬͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͶͳͺΒͰͯͳͳͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͳͶͪͬͪ
ͺͻͯͳͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͑ͽͼͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͽͳͰ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͰͷͼ;ͫ;ͬͪΕͰͰ͵ͪ
͵ͰͲͪͷͰͳͽͰ
ͺͽͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͪ͵ͳͪͳͪͶͰmͷͽͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪm͵ΒͰͼ;ͰͼͪͷͲͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͳͳͷͰͳͽͰΓͬͰΕͳͼͷͳͼͪΒͰͲͭͻ
ͫͰͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͰͰͶͳͰ
͆ͰͽͻͰͫͪͺͼͰͫͪͭͶͪͪͬͪͽͳͯͪKFͼͬͰͽͼͽΒͰͯBͯ͵Γ;ͳ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͪ
ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͰͳͬͳͶͳͲͪͳΒͰͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ͊ͬͰͽͳͽͰΓΒͰ
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͺͻͪͬͳͰ
ͻΒͳͳͯͰͪͶͳͶͳ͵ͽͰͯͪͬͷͳ;ͶͰͰͺͰ͋ΒͰͶͳͼͽ͵ΒͪΒͰͬͰΕͲͪͼͬͭ
ͱͳͬͽͪ
ͺ ͺͻͪͬͳͶ; ͬͰͷͪ ͻͪ
ͺͻͰͺͲͪͽͪ ͵ͪ ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪ
tͼͬͰͽͳ ͬͰ͵i
͇ͯͼͽͪͶͳΓ;ͯͳͼͰͳͲͯͬͪΒͪͼͪͭͷͬͰͻͰͳΓ;ͫͪͬͳ
ͰͯΓͳͬͷͺͽͻͰ
ͫͷ Ͳͪ ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͰͷ ͬͻͶͳͰ
ͼͺͼͫΕ; ͽͻͺΓͰΔͪ
͵ͪ ͳ ͼͺͻͰͷΕ;
ͯͪͲͪͻͪͯͼͬΒͳͳͯͰͪͶͪͺͻͰͽͻͺͳͪΒͬͰΕͪ
ͺͪͳͼͷͻͽͪͳͼ͵;ͰΔ͈ͪͻͳͬͳͯͳ
ͺͪͻͪͯ͵ͼͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͼͪͼͽΒͳͼͰ;ͺͻͪͬ;ͽͷͰͽΒͰΔͰͭͬͪͺͻͪ
ͬͪͰͭͲͳͼͽͰͳΒͪͪͺͼͷͻͽͪ̀ͪͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳͱͳͬͽ;ͺͻͬͰͯͰͷ;ͬͻͶͳͳͳ
ͺͯͬͳͭ;
ͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳͼͽͳͰͪͻͳͽͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
͵ͪ͵;ͬͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͷͽͪ͵
ͳ;ͼͽͻͪͷͼͬͰͽ;͌ͺͻͬͷ
ΒͰͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͪΒͬͰΕͰͭͽͬͪΔͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͭ
͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͯ͵;ͼͿͰͻͳͽͻͪͼͰͯͰͽͭͳͷͪͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭͳΒ;ͯͪͼͰͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͳͻ;
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͵Βͳ͵ͻ;ͱ;Β;ͽͻ̻ͼͺͯΔͳ͋Ͱ͵ͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͼͺ;Δͪ
ͬͪͼͬΒ;ͼͬ;;Ͷͭ;mͺͼͻͰͯͳ͵ͪͳͲͷͰΌ;ͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͭͳͰͫͰͼ͵ͭ͡;ͯͳͷͪ
ͻͪͯͳͺͫͱͭͼͰΕͪΔͪͳͽͬͪΔͪ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͵ͪͲͪͶͭ;ͬͰͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰ
ͽͰͳͷͰͼͽͪͬͰͲͪͰͲͪͼͬΒ;ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ;ͰͭͲͳͼͽͰͳΒ;͋ͼ;
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͭͻͫͬͳ
ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͪͶͳͳͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͳͺͻͼͽͻͳ͵Βͳ
ͳͼͺ;ΔͰͳͫͱͪͼ͵ͷͼͳͶͷ
ͳͼ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺΓͪͬͪΒ;;ͯͰͼͰͷΕͳ̀ͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭͬͰ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓΒͰͫͳͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳ
ͯ;ͬͳͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽͳͺ;Ͳͯͪ;ͺͻͳͽͰͲͪͱͳͬͽͪͷ;ΒͰͺͻ;ͱͪͲͪͽͳͽ;
ͳͳͼͰΓͰΔͪ
ͳͼͺ;ΔͪͬͪͷͶͫͰ
ͪ͵ͼ;ͫͳͶͰͼͬͰͻͷ;ͺ;ΕͰͰ
ͪͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳ
ͯͰͶͽͬͻͭͪΒͰͲͪͼͽ;ͺͪͪ͊ͽͻͪͷͼ;ͯ;
͊ͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͼͰ
ͳΒͰͼͪͷͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͺΒͪͷͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͺͫ
ͱͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͻͳΕͪͪ͋͵ͷͳͽͪͬͭͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ́ͼͽ͵;
͵ͪͳͪ̀ͪ
ͺͪͯ;
ΒͰͫͳͶͳͲ;ͲͰͽͬͪͱͪͯͻ;ͽͬͰͪͳͳͯͰͶ͵ͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͪͺΒͪͬͪ͆ͳΒͰͯͪͼͬͰͽͪ
;͵ͻͪΒΔΒͶͳͳΒͳ
ͰͺͼͽΒͳͺͼͰͫͳ
ͳͽͳ
ͲͪͼͰͫͰΔͰͭͪͺͻͰͺͲͪΒ;ͳͺͻͳͲͪΒ;ͯͻ;ͭͳ
͵ͪͽͼ;ͳͯͫͻͫͳͽͳͼͺͪͼͰΔͰ
ͺΒͰͯͳͪ
ͪͶͳͳͳͽͪͬͰͯͻ;ͽͬͰͰͲͪΒͰͯͳͰ
͵ͻͪΒΔͪͼͬͻͪΔͰͭͬͭͯͰͶͪ
ΔͪͳͭͶͪͬͳͼͷͳͼͪͰͭͲͳͼͽͰͳΒͰ͌ͬͻͽͰΔͰͰ͵ͰͶͳͼͽͳ;ͻͰͯͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
;ͱ ΒͰ ͬͰͲͪ Ͳͪ ͯͻͰΌͰͳ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ ͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵ ͳ ͯͻ;ͽͬͰͺͶͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
͵Ͷͼͽͳ͇ΒͰͳͲͻͪͲͪΒͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳΒͳͺͽͻͰͫͪ
ͽͰΔͪͳͽͰͱΔͳͰ͵Ͱͼͳ
ΒͪͶͰͼ͵;ͺͳͰ͌ͽͪ͵ͬͷ͵͵ͻͰͽͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͼͽͪͶͳͼ;;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͳͲͪͳͲͫͻͯͻͰΌͰͭͼͬͰͪͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪmͯͻͱͪͬͰͳͭͻͪͯͪ
ͰͼͪͿͪ
ͳͺΒͰͯͳ͇ͪͳͼ;
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͳͷͪͶͳͺͻͰͼ;ͯͪ;ͽͳͪΒͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͽͳͺ͵Βͳ
ΒͰͺͻͰͬͶͪͯͪͬͪ;Ͱ͵ͷͺͰͻͳͯ;ͳͶͳͼͻͰͯͳͳmͷ;Ͱͳ͵
ͳͼͺͬͰͯͳ͵ͳͶͳ
ͻͪͽͳ͵
ͪͼ͵ͰͽͪͳͶͳͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓ́ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͪͯͳͷͰͲͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
ͽͪͳΒͰ
ΔͰͭͬͪͯͻ;ͽͬͰͪ;ͼͶͬΓͰͼͽͳͳͯͰͶ͵ͪͼͬͻͬͳͽͼͽ
ͪͻͳͽΒͰΒͪͼ
ͳͲͻͪͱͰͪ ͵ͪͯͪ ΒͰ ͻͰ ͬͶͪͯͪͻ; ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ; ͋ ͳΒͰ Ͱͫͳ ͪ͵ ͼͰ ͳͷͪ ;
ͬͳͯ;ͯͪΒͰΔͰͭͬͪͶͳͼͽͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͽͰͶͽͬͻͰΔͰͪΒͬͳͳ
ͪͰͶͪ ͳ ͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͪ ͯͻͱͪͬͰ ͳ ͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ ͇ͽ;ͯͪ ͺͽͳͰ ͳ ͼͬͪ ͼͶͱͰͼͽ
ͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͭͶͳ͵ͪͬͶͪͯͪͻÄͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓÄ͢ͳͬͪͪ;ͻͪͳͷͪͯͬΒͪ͵͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͼͳͷ
;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪ
ͲͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͳͼͬͳͷͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳͷͱͳͬͽͳͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͬͶͪͯͪ
ͻͳͷͻͪͶͳͼ;ͳͷͪͽͳͳͯͻ;ͭ;ͬͻͼͽ;ͲͪͼͶ;ͭͪ
͵ΒͰͼ;ͼͰͯͼͳͶͰͪͪΒ͵ͻ;ͺͳΒͪ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͪͺͳͽͪΔͪ
;ͬͰͲͳͼͪ;ͬͪΔͰͷ
;ͪͺͻͰΌͰΔͰͷͳͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͳͷ;ͽͰͷͰΓͰ
ΔͰͷͯͻͱͪͬͰͳͪͻͯͪ
͊ͬͰͽͼͽ
͵ͪͬͻ;ͼ͵ͼͽͬͪͻͰΔͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͪͳͪͱͳͬΓͰΔͪ
ͳͷͪͶͪ
ΒͰͭͻͷͪͲͪͪΒͲͪͭͻͪΌͰΔͰͶͳͭͳ͵ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬͭͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬ
ͭͬͰ͵ͪ͌ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪͳΒͳͫͳͽͯͻͰΌͰΒͰͼͪͽͶ͵ͳͷͺͭͶͰͯͷͪͼͬͰͽ
ͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳͱͳͬͽͳͫͳͶͳͼ;ͺͻͪͬͳͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͲͪ;ͭͶͰͯͳͼͷͪͽͻͪͳͼ;ͺͽͬͻͯͷ
ͷͭ;Εͼͽͳͳͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͳͳͼ͵;ͺΓͰΔ͇ͪͳͼ;ͺͯͼͽͳͪͶͳΓ;ͯͰͯͪͼͰ
Ͳͪͻͪͯ
ͼͺͼͽͬͰͭͼͺͪͼͰΔͪ
ͰͺͻͰͼͽͪ;ͺͯͫΓ;Β;ͳͯͰͪͶ;ͳ;ͼͪͬͻͪͬͪΒ;;ͬͻͶͳͳ
;ͬͪΒ;Εͳͽͪ͵tͺͻͪͬ;ͬͰͻ;iͳͼͺͻͬͯͰΕͳͲͪͯͪͽͰͰͽͳ͵ͰͻͷͰ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪ
Ͱ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͳ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ͵;ͶͽͪͫͳͶPKFͯͬͼͷͰͻͪͺͻͰͼ
]]
̺͇͌̽
mͰͼͪͷͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͻͰͰͺͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͼͽͳ
͵Βͪͽ͵ͻͳͬͪͷͭͰͼ;ͽͳͼ͵Ͱ
ͬͳͯͬͰͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͺͫͱͼͽͳͳͷͰͽͪͶͳͽͰͽ̸ͪ͵ͽͳͬͪͯͼͯͻ;ͽͬͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͯͶͪͲͳͯͺ;ͭͳͲͻͪͱͪΒͪ;ͺͻͰͼ;ͼͪ͵ͽͳͿͳ͵ͪͳΒͰ
ͽͪͳ
ΒͰ;ͼͶͱͰͷͳͼͰͽΓͳͬͷͺͼͽ;ͺ͵;͵ΒͳͼͰͷͱͰͲͪͳͽͳ͵ͪtͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰi
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͐ͳͳͭͪͳͲͻͪͯΔͳͳͫͻͰͯͪ͵ΒͳͼͰ
;ͻͭͪͳͲͪͳΒͳͳͺͯ͵ͽͻ
Ͷͷͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͪͻ͵ͬͰ
ͪͶͳ;ͲͼͪͯͰΒͼͽͬͪΒͳͻͳͼͶΒͰͬͪͪͻͯͪ
ͯͬͳΒͪΒ;;
ͬͳͰͰͽͪͺͪ͆ͪͰͶͺͼͷͪͽͻͪ
͵ͻͪΒΔͳͳΓ
͵ͪͳͳͼͯͽͭͺͻͰͼͪ
;ͬͰ͵
ΒͰͳͼͽͳ;ͬͻͽͰΔͰΒͰͯͰͶͳͼͽͳ
ͪͼͬ;ͽͪͺͻͺͳͼͪͳͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪ
;
ͻͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͋ͪt;ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶͼͽiͳtͪͳͼͽͻͳͼͽi
ͯͼͼͪͫͻͪͱͰͼͽ
;ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶͷͷͯͰͶ;
ͫͳͶͪΒͰͰͺͯͪ;ͼͶͬͯͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͫ;ͯͰ͵ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬ
ͺͻͰͺͲͪͽͳͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳͪͶͺͻͳͲͪͽ͇ͽΒͰͻͪͲͶͳͳͽ;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͺ
ΒͰͯͳͪͷͺͻͳͷͰͻ;
ͽͰͭͪͳͳΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͳͷ
ΒͰͼͽͰ͵͵ͻͰͽͳͷͰͪͳͲͪͷ
;ͬΌͰΔͪ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽ͇ͬΒͰͺͪ͵ͫͳ;ͼͶͬΓͰͼͶͱͰͳͷͼͺͶͰͽͷ͵͵ͻͰͽ
ͳ͵ͶͼͽͳmͯͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͳ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳͯͯͰͬͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳ͌ͽͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͺͻͳͲͬΌͰΔͰΒͰͯͰͶͳͼͽͳ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͽ͵ͻͳͬͪͺͻͪͬ;ͷͽͳͬͪͳΒ;
ͳͺ͵ͻͰͽͪ͵ͰͼͪͭͰ͵͵ͻͰͽͰͯͻ;ͽͬͰͰͲͪΒͰͯͳͰ͉ͪͲͽ͵ͻͳͬͪΔͰ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪ
ΔͰͳͽ;ͷͪͰΔͰͽͳͷͰͪͳͲͪͷͪͳͷͽͳͬͪͳΒͪmͪͻͪͬ;ͷͰͻͳ͵Β;ͯͺ;
ͽͪΒ;ͻͪͼͺͶͱͳͬͳͳͲͬͻͳmͭͶͪͬͳΒͰͲͪͯͪͽͪ͵ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͪ͵ΒͳͪͼͽΒͳͯͪ
ͼͺͲͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͪ
͐ͳͳͪͷͼͰͯͪͬͰΕͳͬͪΒͼͪͱͰͽͺ͵;ͪΒͯͪͼͰͳͽͪ;ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͳͽͰͷͪ
ͬͰͲͪͪͲͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵Ͱ͵;ͶͽͬͰͪͭͬͰͽͪͬͪͰͼͪͷͳͻͳ;ͳͼͶͱͰͼͽΔͰ
ͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ͵ͳ͵ͬͳͻͪͬͰΕͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͲͪͪΒ͵ΒͳͪͳͷͪͲͪͺͻͳͪΔͰ
;ͼͪͷ;ͼ;ͽͳ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭͯͻ;ͽͬͪͳ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ͆ͰͷͱͰͫͳͽͳͼͶ;ͪΒ
ͽͽΒͰ;ͺͻͪͬͬͪtͽͺͳ͵ͪi
ͻͪͲ;ΌͰͪ;ͳͲͺͼͰͫͳͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͯͱͳͬͰͶͪ;ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͯͬͰͯͰͰͳΒͰͺͻͪͬͳͺͻͬͪͽͳͯͪͶͪͬͰͷͪͬͻͰͯͰͻͰ
Ͳ;ͶͽͪͽͰ
͵ͪ͵;Ͱͬͻͺͼ͵Βͽͪ͵ͳ;ͪͷͰͻͳ͵ΒͷͰͯͳͰͬͳͼͽͳͳ͋ͪͭͶͪͰ
ͳͽͰͻͰͼͬͪΔͰͲͪͼͬͰͽͼͽ
ͪͪͻͳͽͲͪ͵Ͷͼͽͳ;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;ͪͼͽͪΒͪͶͳͳ
ͯͰͶͬͪͶͳΔͰͳͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͳ
ͷͭͶͫͳͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͶͭ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͳΒͰͯͳͷ
ͯͷͭ;ΕͳͯͭͬͻͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱͪ;͵ͰͪͺͻͰ͵;ͺͪͳΒͰͳͳͲͪͲͬͰͼͺͼͽͬͰͭ
ͬͻͰͷͰͪ
́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ͵;ͶͽͬͪͪͶͪͲͳͼͰ
ͪͯͷͪΕͰͷͽͰͻͰ
;
;ͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰͷͺͶͱͪΒ;ͳͼ;ͰͼͷͽͬͷͽͰ͵Εͪ͌ͲͰͰͶͰͷͰͽͪͻͰ
ͳ
ͪͱͪͶͼͽ
;ͫͳͪΒͰͰ
͵ͪͽΒͰͰͯͼͽͪͽͪ͵͵ͻͳͽͳ͵ͳͳͲͯͪΔͪͳͲͬͻͪͳͶͳ
͵ͻͺ;ͼͪͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͪ
ͽ;ͼ;ͳͺͻͫͶͰͷͳͷͰͽͯͶ͵ͰͺͻͳͻͯͰ͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͳͪ͵ͼ;
ͺΒͰͯͳͳͷͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ͵;ͶͽͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
] ]
̺͇͌̽
ͼ;Β;ͰͽͪͺͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͷͪͯͪ;ͼͽͪΓͰͳΒͯͷͰͽͪͿͻͪͼͽͬͼ͵Ͱ
͵ͯͳͿͳ͵ͪͳΒͰͳͺͻͳͬͳͯͼͶͳͳ
;ͱͳͽͳΒΒ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳ͵ͻͳͼͽͰͼͰͪͬͰ
ͷͪͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͪͳ͢ͳͬͪΒͰ;ͶͭͪͯͪͺͷΕ;ͼͷͳΓͰͳͪͭͶͪͼͪ͵ͪͽ
ͽͪͳΒͰͺͳ;͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͿ;͵ͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͭͱͳͬͽͪͳͺͯͬͳͭͪ̽ͻ;ͭͳͷͻͰ
ͳͷͪ
ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͽͰ͵ͼͽΒͰͰ͵ͪͬͻͼͽͪtͳͿͻͬͪͰͪͻͪͳΒͰi
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽͬͰΕ
ͯͪͬͳͼͽͪ͵ͪ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰ̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕt͇ͺͽͰͷͰͼͽΒͰ;ͼͶͬͳͳͲͻͪͲ
Ͳͪ͵
͵ΒͳͷͼͰͷͭ;ΕͪͬͪͺͽͰΔͰͳΒͰͫͪͪͶͼͽ
͵ͪͯͪͪͼ͊ͳͼͽͰͷͽͳͲͪ͵
ͬͪͳͿͻ;ΒͰ
ͪͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͯͰͳͿͻ;ΒͰΒͰͯͪͷͳͼͪͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͳͼͽͽͪ͵
;ͼͶͬΓͪͬͪΒͰͯͰͷͳͪͶͼͽͪΔͰi͊ͬͪͽͪΔͰͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͽͺͼͪ͵ͪ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪͲͪt͵ͯͳͻͪΔͰͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͳiͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ;ͷͯͰͻΒͪ;ͳͽͰͷͰΓ
ͷͰͽͯͶ͵ͪͰͶͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͽ;ͷͪͰΔͪͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳͱͳͽͳΒͪ͋ͪ͵ΒͰͳΒͰͯͪ
ͯͺͻͳͻͳͽͰͽͪͪͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͫͳͺ͵;ͪΒͯͪ;ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͺͻͰͺͲͪͺͻ;͵ͰͼͪͯͻͱͪͰ;ͪͳͲͭͶͰͯ;ͫͳͪΒͰͷͻͰͺͰͻ
ͽͪͻ;ͺͽͳͷͰͼͽͪ
͎ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪΒͰ
;ͲͼͶ;ͱͫ;
ͼͬͳͽͰ͵ͼͽ͵ΒͳͼͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;
ͲͪͺͽͻͰͫͰ
͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͪ͵ΔͰͭͬͭͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ͊ͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͽͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͪͰͳͲ
ͼͽͪͬͪΒͰ
ͲͪͬͻͪͰͽͪͺͪͺͻͰͼͪ͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͰ
ͽΒͰͼͽ;ͬΌͰΔͪ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ
ͼͽͬͅͰͽͯͲͪ͵ͻͳͽͳ͵;ͪͪͶͳͲ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͻͪͲͬͳͶͳ
ͫͶͪͯͳͼͽͳͻͪͯͰΕͳͪͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶΒͰͯͳͳΒͳ"DUB4BODUPSVN
ͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͯ
;ͲͻͭͫͶͳ͵ͪͯͬͰ́ͺͶͳͽ̽ͰͶͰΒͰ
ͳ;ͬͳΒͰͯͫͪͺͻ;ͱͪͺ;Ͳͯͪ;ͼ
ͬ;ͲͪͯͪΓͰͪͺͻͰ;ͽͷͺͻͪͬ;͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͬͰΕͯͪͬ
ͪͼͽΒͰͯͪͽΒͪͼͳΒͰͻͪͲͶ;ͰͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͰͺͶͪͲͰͼͬͰ
ͳΓͰͬͰͳͼͺͲͪΒ
Ͱͷͭ;Εͼͽͳ;ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷͯͰͶͳͷͪ͆ͪΒͳͻͰͺͼͷͪͽͻͪ
;Ͳ
ͽͰͶ͵ͳͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ
ͳͲͯͬΒͰͪͼ;ͯͬͪͼͬͪͪ;ͪͷͰͽͯͪmͶͳͽͰͻͪͻͿͳ
ͶͶ͵ͳͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ͈ͻͬͳͼͰͫͪͬͳͼͪͷͳͷ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͳͷͱͪͻͷ
ͺͰͽͼ͵ͷ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
] ]
̺͇͌̽
͌ͽ͵;ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͯͰͰͳΒͰͽͷͺͳͽͪΔ;ͪͺͳͼͪͪΒͰͳͽͪͬͪͷͪͶͪͫͳͫͶͳͽͰ͵ͪͻͪͯͬͪ̽
ͫͪͻ;ͬͳͯ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͳͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͰtͬͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰiͳtͬͰͪͭͳͶͭͳΒͰiͯ
ͼͰѮFJOWFOUJPOPGTBJOUMJOFTT
FE"#.VMEFS#BLLFS
-FJEFO-FTWJFTEFTTBJOUTÆ#Z[BO
DFWͷͰͽͯͶ͵ͳͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͬͪͱͰͳͼ͵ͻͪ͵Ͱ͵ͯ".5BMCPU
0ME8JOFJO/FX#PUUMFT
ѮF 3FXSJUJOH PG 4BJOUT-JWFTJOUIF1BMFPMPHJBO1FSJPE
JOѮF 5XJMJHIU PG #Z[BOUJVN "TQFDUT PG
$VMUVSBMBOE3FMJHJPVT)JTUPSZPGUIF-BUF#Z[BOUJOF&NQJSF
FE4ſVSǁJǀ
%.PVSJLJ
1SJODFUPO
m/FX+FSTFZ
m(%BHSPO
-PNCSFEVOEPVUF-IBHJPHSBQIJFFORVFTUJPO
97Fm9*F
TJÍDMF
%01
m+B-KVCBSTLJK
/FX5SFOETJOUIF4UVEZPG#Z[BOUJOF)JTUPSJPHSBQIZ
%01
m'-JGTIJU[
#FZPOE1PTJUJWJTNBOE(FOSFt)BHJPHSBQIJDBMiUFYUBT)J
TUPSJDBM/BSBUJWF
7JBUPS
m4$PVF
)BHJPHSBQIJFJN,POUFYU4DISFJCBOMBTTVOE
'VOLUJPOWPO#JTIPGTWJUFOBVTEFNVOEWPN"OGBOHEFT+BISIVOEFSUT
#FSMJO
̓ͪͺͯͼͽͳͪΒͰͺͻͳͷͰͻFͪͬͯͳͷ-FTTBJOUTFUMFVSTBODUVBJSFÆ#Z[BODF5FYUFT
JNBHFT
FUNPOVNFOUT
FE$+PMJWFU-FWZ
ͅ,BQMBO
+14PEJOJ
1BSJT-FTBDSÊFUTPOJOTDSJQUJPO
EBOTMFTQBDFÆ#Z[BODFFUFO0DDJEFOUUVEFTDPNQBSÊFT
FE.,BQMBO
1BSJT
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
] ]
̺͇͌̽
ͷͰͼͽͪ́ͼͽ͵ͪͳͶͳͼͳͽͰͽͳ͵ͳͻͪͯͺͼͬͰΕͰͪͼͽͪ͵;
ͺΒͪͬͳͷͫͶͳͳͷͪ
ͳͿ;͵ͳΒͳ͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;;ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͻͪͭͻͳΕͪͼͽͬͪ͌ͯͰͬͰͽΒͯͰͰ
ͳΒͳͲͪͳͷͪΔͰͲͪͽͰͷ;ͼͪͱͼ;ͺͯͼͽͪ͵ͶͰͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱͼͽ;ͯͳΒͼ͵ͰͳͲͶͱͫͰͺͼͬͰ
ΕͰͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪ͢ͳͬͪͽͻͪΒͪͽͰ͵ͬͳͪΒͰͼ;;Ͳͻ;ͻͪΌͰͳ͵ͪͽͪͶͲͳ
͵Βͳ
ͼͳͷͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͪ
ͫ;ͬͪͽͪΒ;ͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰͳͲͺͰͻͪͬͯͰΕͳͼͽͻ;Δͪ͵̸ͪ͵ͼͰͽͳͷͯͺͻͳͼͳͷͪͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͰͳ
ͲͪͪΒͳͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͳͺͼͽͳͭ;ͽͳ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔ;ͪͳͪͶͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ
͵;ͶͽͬͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͳͭͽͬͼͬͳͲͪͪΒͳΒͳͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͻͳͲͳͪ
Ͱ;ͯͳ
ͽͽΒͰͪͰͬͻͰͷͰͫͰͶͰͱͳͪͼͽͪͪ͵ͲͪͪΒͳͼͳͽͰͲ̺ͪͰΕͳͪΒͰͺͻ
ͳͲͪͶͪͳͲͰͷͪ͵Ͱͪ;ͰͼͻͰͯͳͰ̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͯΒͰ͵ͷͰΌ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͷͪ
Β
;ͬͰ͵ͱͳͬ
ͳͷͪͶΒͰ͵ͪͺͳͽͪͶͯͰͶ͎ͪͼ̹ͪͰͶͽͳͭͪ
͵ΒͰͺͻ;ͱͪͬͻͼͽͰͼͬͰ
Ͳͪͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͰͬͳͰͲͪͭͯͼͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͳͼͶͳ͵ͪ͆ͪͳͻ͵ͳͷͳͼͽͻͪ
ͱͳͬͪ͵ͳͷ͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪͳͼ;ͷͳͻͪΔ;ͯͼͪͯͪΔͳͲͪΔͪͺͳͬͪΒ;ͳ͵ΔͳͭͰ̸ͽ
ͪ̈́ͰͭͰͻͪͳ̸ͻͶ̸ͯͪͭͰͰͽͪͅͰΌ;ͬͪͱͰͺͯ;ͬͪͽͰͽͻͰͫͪͼͬͻͼͽͪͽͳ
ͳͼͽ;ͯͳΒ;
ͪͼͽͪͶ;ͳͼͽͳͭͯͳͪ
;͵ΒΒͼͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭͻͰ
ͶͳͭͳͲͭͷͰͽͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ
ͳͼͺͳͽ;ΒͰ͵;ͶͽͪͿ;͵ͳΒͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͵ͻͲͺͻͰΌͰΔͰ
ͼͰͬͪͻͳͼͽͳΒͷ̸͵ͽ;ͰͶͼͽͽͰͷͰ
͵ͪͳͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͷͭͳΔͰͳͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͳ
Βͳͼ;ͯͬΓͺͻ;Ͱͳ
ͺͼͬͰͯͰͪΒͰ;ͺͼͶͰͯΔΒͯͰͰͳΒͳ99ͬͰ͵ͪͳ
ͳͲͷͬͰͷͪͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͳͼ͵;ͺͬͪ͢ͳͬͳͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͳ
ͼͪͺͽͰͳ;Ͳͫͻͳ
ͳͷͪͻͪͯͬͪ
;͵ͪͲ;Β;ͪͽͯͪͼͰͳ;ͬΒͫͶͪͼͽͳͫͳͽͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ͵ͳͪͭͶͪ
ͼͳͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;ͪͺͳͽͪΔͪͯͻ;ͽͬͰͭ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ͵;ͶͽͪͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͰͿ;͵ͳΒͰ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͋ͻͰͫͪ
ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳͳͺͪͱΔͰͬͻͰͯͰͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͰmͳΒͳΒͰ
ͭͶͪͬͳͺ͵ͻͰͽ̸ͪͶͰ͵ͼͰΒ̈́ͅͳͯͬmͼͽͬͪͻͰͰ;ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰ;ͻ;ͼ͵Βͪ;
.. (BVUIJFS
-FT SPVUFT EF MB GPJT 3FMJRVFT FU SFMJRVBSJFT EF +ÊSVTBMFN Æ $PNQPTUFMMF
'SJCVSHm1BSJT1.BSBWBM
-JFVYTBJOUTFUQÊMFSJOBHFTE0SJFOU
1BSJT
%VWBM
"VQSÍTEFTTBJOUTDPSQTFUÄNF
͌ͺ;Ε;ΒͰͷͪͯͬͪ;ͲͻͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ0SOBNFOUB&DDMFTJBF,VOTUVOE,ÛOTUMFSEFS3PNBOJL
4DIOÛUHFO.VTFVN
,ÕMO 3FMJRVJFO 7FSFISVOH VOE 7FSLMÅSVOH
4DIOÛUHFO.VTFVN
,ÕMO
)#FMUJOH
#JMEVOE,VMU&JOF(FTDIJDIUFEFT#JMEFTWPSEFN;FJUBMUFSEFS,VOTU
.ÛODIFO
-FHOFS
3FMJRVJFOJO,VOTUVOE,VMU
"OHFOFOEU
)FJMJHFVOE3FMJRVJFO
(+$4OPFL
.FEJFWBM1JFUZGSPN3FMJDTUPUIF&VDIBSJTU
-FJEFO
1PMJUJL VOE )FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH JN )PDINJUUFMBMUFS
FE + 1FUFSTPIO
4JHNBSJOHFO -FT
SFMJRVFT
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ͌ͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͰͺͻͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͪͶͳͳͷͪͳͿͰͼͽͪͳ
Βͪͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭ;ͪΒͳͻͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ͻͰͳ
ͽ;ͼ;ͪͳΔͰͳͲͪͪΒͳͼͪͲͪΒͳͳ
ͷͰͽͯͶ͵ͳͳͼ͵ͻͪͳ
͋ͻͰΕͳͳͯͰΒͳͿ͵;ͼͪͰͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰͽͳͰͼͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͏ͰͶͬͳ
ͽͳͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͳͺͻͰͽͻͰͼͪΔͰͽͭͺͳͽͪΔͪ
ΒͰͯͭͯͪΒͼͶͱͰͳΒͳ;ͷͰͯͳͰ
ͬͳͼͽͳͳ
ͼͳͭ;ͻͼͺͪͯͪ;ͪͯͶͰͱͼͽͳͼͽͻͳͪͻͪͼͺͰͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͰ̹ͰͲͺͻͰͽͰ
ͲͳΒͪͯͪͯͼͳͷ͵ͻ;ͺͰͲͪ͵Γ;͵Ͱ
ͷͳͳͺͪ͵ͳͼͷͷͭͶͳͳͲͫͰΕͳͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͰ
ͷͭͳͽͰͷͪͳͲͽͰͫͶͪͼͽͳ
ͼͫͲͳͻͷͪͽͯͪͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶ
ͭͳΒͰ
;ͲͪͭͳͶ͵Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͰͳtͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͰi
ͳͰͰͻͪͲͶ;ͳͬͳͯͰͼͬͪ
͵ͭͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
ͫͪͬͰΕͳͼͰͽͳͷ͵;Ͷͽ
ͬͳͷͪ
ͫͳͶͳ ͼͷ ͼ;Ͱͳ ͼ ͷͭͳͷ tͳͯͰͶ͵ͳͷi ͺͳͽͪΔͳͷͪ
ͷͪͯͪ ͪ ͼͬͪ
ͳͼ;;ΒͰͯͪ͵ΒͷͰͻͳͲͪ͵;ͺΓͪͶͪͪ;ͺͪͱΔ;͆Ͱ͵ͪ
ͺͼͰͫͳͽͰͷͰΓͪm͵ͪ
ͽͼ;ͯͰͿͳͳͳΒͪͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ΔͰͭͺͻͰ͵ͶͪͳͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͳͽͰͽͪ
ͺͶͱͪΒͯͻͱͪͬͰ
;ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͷͺͻͰͽ͵;ͪͻͯͪ
ͽͰͶ͵ͳͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳ;Ͳͻͳmͳͼ;ͫͳͶͪ;Ͱͺ
ͼͻͰͯΒͿ;͵ͳΒͳͪͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͪͶͳͼ;ͲͪͽͰ͵ͪͯͻ;ͭͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͲͳ ͵ͬͳͻ ͪͳ ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪ ͌ ͺͻͬͷ ͺͶͪ;
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰ ͼͰ
ͫͳ ΒͰ
ͺͻ͵ͶͪͷͬͪͳͶͳ͵ͳͯͰͪͶͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͺͻͺͳͼͪͳͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪͳ
ͯ;ͱͼͽͳ
͵ͪͳΔͰͭͬͳͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͳͳΒͰͬͪΌͰͼ͵ͳ;Ͳͻ̺ͪͪͱͷͰͼͽ
ͳͷͪͶͪΒͰͳͽͳͺͶͭͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
͵ͪͺ͵ͪͲͪͽͰΓͪͳͪͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͼͬͰ
ͽͼͽͼͽͰͰͪ́ͼͽͬͪͱͳͳͲͪͼͬͪͺͳͽͪΔͪ͵ΒͪͼͰͽͳ;ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭͲͪͼͳͬͪΔB
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͯͼͼͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪͳͷͰͪͳͲͪͷͪ͵Βͳͼ;͵ͻͳΕͰͳͻͪͯͳͲͪͯͫͳΒͪ
Δͪͪ;ͻͰͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͅͰΌ;Δͳͷͪͼ;ͪͼͪͻͳͽͲͪ͵;ͺΓͪͶͪͺͳͽͪΔͪͺͻͳͻͯ
ͺͻͳͼͽͰ͵ͶͪͳͲͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͪ͵Βͪ
;ͪΒͳͻͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͻͰͳ
Ͳͪͯͳͻ;;ͯͻͱͪͬ;ͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵;
̀ͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯͺͻͰͽͯͳͺͻͫͶͰͷͼ͵ͳͫͶ͵ͬͪmͪͭͳͶͭͳΒͰͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳ
ΒͪͻͰͽͺͳ͵ͰmͭͯͰͼͷͳͷͪͶͳͼͶͪ;ͼͺͰͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͳ͵ͳͷͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪͷͪ
ͪͶͳͰ
ͳ;ͯͷͪΕͳͷͼͳͽͰͲͪͷͪ
ͻͪͯͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ΒͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͳͫͳͪͷΒͰ;ͽͷͺͭͶͰ
ͯ;ͲͪͽͶͪ͵ͪ͌ͼͪͼͬͳͷ͵ͻͪͽ͵ͷͬͻͰͷͰͼ͵ͷͻͪͲͷͪ͵;ͪ;ΒΒͪͬͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͯͰͰͼ;ͯͬͰͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰͺͼͬͰΕͰͰͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ΒͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͳ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷ
ͬͰ͵;͆ͪΒͬͰΕͪͲͪͼͶ;ͭͪ͵ΔͳͭͰ̹͵̹ͪΒͬͳΕͪΒͰ;ͽͷͰͽͳͼͽͻͪ;ͺ;ͫͶͳ
͵;;ͺͲͪΒͰͼͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͷͭͻͪΌͷ
ͪͯͷͪΕΒͪ;ΒΒͪͬͼͽͳͺͻͰͯͪͬͪͰ͵;
] ]
̺͇͌̽
ͬͻͼͽ;ͺͽͰͭËUBUEFSFDIFSDIÊͬͰͽͰͷͪͽͳ͵Ͱ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪ͊ͷͳΓͰ
ͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
ͷͰͽͯͼ͵ͳͳͻ͵ͲͪͼͬͪͪͳͺͻͫͶͰͷͼ͵ͳͯͫͻͺ
ͼͽͪͬΓͰͪ
ͺͻ;ͱͪͺ;ͲͯͪͰͺͶͪͲͰͼͬͰͲͪͼͬͪ͵ͯͪΓͰͳͺͯͻͫͳΒͰͳͲ;ͪ
ͬͪΔͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
͌ ͫͳΓ; ͺͽͰ ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ ͺͼͬͰΕͰͰ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Β ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͳ ͪΒͬͰΕͳ
ͼͶͪ
ͺͺͻͳͻͯͳͼͽͬͪͻͳ
ͺͻ;ͱͳͶͰͼ;ͪͷͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰͳΒͳͼͰͪ;ͽͻͳͼͻͪͲͶͳ
ͳͽͳͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͫͪͬͰͽ;ͷͪͰΔͰͷtͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪi
ͼͻͰͯͳΔͰͭͺͳͽͪΔͪͼͻͰͯ
ΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͌ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͼͽͲͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͪ
Β;ͬͰ͵ͳͼ;ͳͲͭ;ͫͳͶͰ͵ΔͳͭͰͪͺͳͼͪͰͺͻͰͷͭͯͰͰͳΒͪͼͽ;ͯͳΒ̻ͪͅ
͍ΒͯͽͬͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͷͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰ͉;ͼͳΒͰ
ͪͪͻͳͽͲͪͷͰͳͽͯͰ
Ͷͪͅͻ͵̹ͪͶͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ;;ͯͽͬͻ;
ΔͰͭͬͷͿͻͷͳͻͪΔ;ͳͯͰͶͬͪΔ;;
ͯͻͰΌͰͷ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͷ ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ; ͆ͪΒͬͳͰ ͼͷ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͫͳͶͳ ;ͺ;ΕͰͳ ͪ
ͫͳͷͰͼͳͽͰͲͰͪͼͽͪͶͰ;ͺͻͽͰ͵ͶͰͽͻͳͯͰͰͳΒͰ
͵ΒͰͼͪͱͳͷͪΒ;Ͱͼͪͷͷ
ͭͫͻΒͰͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͰͬͰΕͳͳͽͪͬͰͰͽͪͺͰͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔ͈ͪͷͳΔͰͷ͵Δͳͭ;͍ͻͪ
ͽͳͰ͵̻ͪͻͪ;ͼͪ
Ͳͪͼͬͪ;ͪͺ;ͲͯͪͷͫͶͪͯͳͼͽͳ͵ͷͷͰͽͯ;
͵Βͪ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͶͭ
ͯͼͳͪ͵ͻͳͫͳ;ͽͳͺͶͭͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳ
ͽΒͰͪͻͳͽͬͪͱ
ΒͪͼͳͲͯͬͪΒͪͳͽ;ͷͪͳͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͰͰͶͰͷͰͽͰ;Δͳͬͳͷ͵;Ͷͽͬͳͷͪ͊ͪͷ
Ͱͽ͵ͪͼͳΒͰ͵ͷͺͪͻͪͽͳͬ;ͽͳͺͶͭͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ;ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ̾ͬͻͺͰ
ͺ;ͯͳΒͰͳ̓ͪͻΓ̻ͻͼ͵ͳ͇ͼͪͷͯͰͼͰͽͰͭͯͳͰͺͻͶͭͬͰ͵ͪͫͰͶͰͱͳͶͰͼ;
##PKPWJǀ
-JEÊPMPHJFNPOBSDIJRVFEBOTMFTIBHJPCJPHSBQIJFTEZOBTUJRVFTEVNPZFOÄHFTFSCF
3PNB͵ΔͳͭͪΒͰͳͲͯͪͽͪͳͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͷΒͰͲͳ͵;̹̹ΒͬͳΕ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͼͽͬͳͼͬͰͽͼͽ͈
Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪͿͳͶͲͿͳΒͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
̹ͰͭͻͪͯͳͽͪͶͪͬͰ͵ΔͳͭͰ;Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵
ΒͰͲͪͽͰͰͳΔͰͳͷͯͪΒͰͳͻ͵ͪͫͪͬͰͽͰͼͽͪ;ͽͻͪͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͳͷͪ;ͳͷͽ͵ͬͳͷͪ
;ͼͬͰͽͼ͵Βͪ;ͳ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͪ;ͪ;ͷͪͺͪͻͪͽ;
ͼͽͪͬͳͶͪͬͰͷͪͷͪͶͽͻͪͭͪ;ͼͬͷͽͰ͵
ͼͽ;
͵ͪ͵ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪͷͰͽͯͶ͵ͳ͵ͬͳͻͪͽͪ͵ͳ;ͻͰͪͬͪΔ;ͺΒͰͯͳͳͺͳ
ͽͪΔͪ͠Ͱͯͪ͵;Ͱͯ;ͷͳ;ͳͲͪͲͳͬͪΒ;ͳͻͪͲͶͲͳͲͫͭ͵ΒͳͬͪΒͪ;ͽͻ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͪͭͳͶͭͳΒͳ
ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ΒͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͳͻͰ
ͲͪͰͷͪͻ;ΒͰͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͰͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͪ;ͳ͵ͪ
͵ͪ;
ͰͯͪͬͫΒͪͬΓͰΒͼͽ;ͯͳΒͳ##PKPWJǀ
&TIBUPMPHJFFUIJTUPJSF$BSBDUÊSPMPHJFEFMIBHJPHSBQ
IJFTVETMBWFEV.PZFO§HF
JO-FTWJFTEFTBJOUTÆ#Z[BODF
m
ͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͰBEFN
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͼͳͭͳΒͰͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵ͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳͯ9***ͯ97ͬͰ͵ͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̻͈͍ͯͽͬ
͊ͬΊͽΆͰͯͻͰͬͰʹ͉;ͼͳ 9m97**ͼͽ
1BSJT
.#MPDI
-FTSPJTUIBVNBUVSHFTUVEFTVSMFDBSBDUÍSFTVSOBUVSFMBUSJCVÊÆMBQVJTTBODFSPZBMF
QBSUJDVMJÍSFNFOUFO'SBODFFUFO"OHMFUFSSF
4USBTCPVSH
'(SBVT
7PML
)FSSTDIFSVOE)FJMJHFSJN3FJDIEFS.FSPXJOHFS4UVEJFO[VS)BHJPHSBQIJFEFS
.FSPXJOHFS[FJU
1SBIB
,(PSTLJ
-FSPJTBJOU6OQSPCMFNEJEÊPMPHJFGÊPEBMF
"OOBMFT&4$
m
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
"7BVDIF[
-BTBJOUFUÊFO0DDJEFOUBVYEFSOJFSTTJÍDMFTEVNPZFOÄHF%BQSÍTMFTQSPDFTTEF
DBOPOJTBUJPOFUMFTEPDVNFOUTIBHJPHSBQIJRVFT
3PNB
3'PM[
-FTTBJOUTSPJTEV.PZFO§HFFO0DDJEFOU 7*m9***FTJÍDMFT
#SVYFMMFT
+-F(PĒ
4BJOU-PVJT
1BSJT
(,MBOJD[BZ
)PMZ3VMFSTBOE#MFTTFE1SJODFTTFT%ZOBTUJD$VMUTJO.FEJFWBM$FOUSBM&VSPQF
$BNCSJEHF
] ]
̺͇͌̽
ΒͪͶͳͷmͳͼͪͷͼͺͻͬͰ;ͯͰͶͭͻͪͯͰΕͳ͵;Ͷͽͼͬͭͪ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
ͼͳ
ͬͪͪͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ͊;ͽͳ;ͷͯͰͶͪͳͳͶͰͼ;ͳͯͰΒͰͫͭͺͷͪͲͪͷͬͶͪͯͪͻ;
ͼͬͰͽͻͯͷ ͺͻͰ͵Ͷ; ͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ ͳ ͊ͻͫͳͷͪ ͵ͪ ͳͲͪͫͻͪͷ ͪͻͯ;
t͆ͬͷ
́ͲͻͪͳΓ;i
ͪͰͼ;
;ͰͶͳͳͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͰ
ͼͽͪͶͰͽͻͪΒͪͽͰ͵ͬͳͪͬͶͪͯͪͶͪ
͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ͊ͪͯͻͱͳͼ͵ΒͰͲͭͻͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͷͯͰͶͪtͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪi
ͳͳͶΒͰͽͻΒͼͽͬͬͶͪͯͪͻmͷͪmͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͈ͻͬͳͳͳͶͪ
;;ͱͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͻͰͳ
ͫ;ͬͪͽͪΒͰͳͲͺͻͺͳͼͪͳͬͻͶͳͪͳͯ;ͱͼͽͳ
͵ΒͰͼ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͯͻͰ
ΌͳͬͪͶͰ͵ͪͻͪͽͳ͵ͪͺͫͰͯͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪͻ͵ͬͰͳͺͻͪͬͬͰͻΒͪ
ͺͻͪͬͰͯͭ
ͼ;ͯͳΒ;
ͪͼͽͪͬͳ͵ͪͳͺͻͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͋ͪΔͰͭͬͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪͳͷͪͶͪͼ;ͯͬͼͽͻ;͵Ͱ
;ͲͻͰ;ͲtͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͰiͳͶͳͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͰ͵Βͳͼ;ͺͻͰͬͶͪΌͳͬͪͶͳ
͵Γ;;;Ͷ
ͭ;ͳͷͪͶͳͼ;ͳΒͰͬͪΌͰͼ͵ͳ
ͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪΒͰͼͺͪͼͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͪͷͳͼͳΒͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͺͻͳͼͽͳ
ͪͶͪͳͲͺͻ͵ͶͪͷͬͪͭͲͪͽͰͬͪͲͪͺͯͻͪͱͪͬͪΔͰͷͪΒͬͳͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ
;Ͳͻͪͳ
;͵ͻͪΒΔΒͳͼͽͪͳ
ͼͪͷ͎ͭͻͳͼͽͪ
ͪͅ͵ͪ͵ͷͺͰͽͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
;ͳͻͳͷͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ
ΒͰͯ;
ͯͪΒͳͲͻͪͲͳͽͳΒͳͼͫͰͼͽͳ͵;ͶͽͪtͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪiͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͭͻͪͲͯͫΓͪ
̿ͳͬͽͪͺͯͫͳΒͰtͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͳͪΌͰͶͪiͳͭͶͰͯΒͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͪΒͫΓͳͷͺ;
ͽͰͷͲͪͲͪͯͫͳΒͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͼͽͳ͇ͯͬͻͰͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳͰͪͫͯͳ͵ͪͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͷͪΔͪtͪ
ΌͰͼ͵ͭͫͻͪͲͪiͳͯͶͪͼ͵̸ͪͪͽͼͷͪ͵ͷͳͯͰͪͶ;;ͺͯͫΓ;Β;ͼͰͭͽͬ
ͼͬͳΔͰͭͬͳͺͽͷͳmͫͳͶͯͼͶͬ
ͺͻͰͯͼͷͻͽͳͷͷͪͰΔͰͷ
;ͺͻͪͱΔͪ
ͬͪΔͰͷͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵ͳͬͻͶͳͪͳͺͯͬͳͭͪ
ͫͳͶͫͪͻΔͳͬͳͷͺͻͭͻͪͷ
ͼ͵ͳͷͺͻ͵ͶͪͷͬͪΔͰͷ̀ͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͶͳ͵ͪ;;ͱͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ͻͰͳ
͵ΒͳΒͰͭͻͪΌͰͪͶͳͽͰͻͪͻͳͷͺͻͰͯͶͳͷͪ͵ͪͽͼ;ͪͻͼ͵ͳͰ͵ͷͳΒ;ͷͳ
ͳͶͳ͈ͻͳͰͬͼ͵ͪͭͶͰͯͪͶͪ
ͷͪ͵ͳͪͫͳͽ;ͼ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͼͽͬͪͻͪΒͰͪͼͬ;
ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͭͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͭͪͼͶͰΌ͇ͪͫͪͽͪͰͶͰͷͰͽͪ
;ͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͷͫͳͷ;
ͳͯͼ;
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰͪͼ;;Δͳͬͳͷͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͷͪ
͵ΒͳͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͼͫͰͷ
ͱͪͻ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͼͽͻͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰͪͅ͵ͳͳͯͰͪͶͳͳͬͻͶͳͰͺͻͰͯͰͳͼ;
;ͲͺͷΕ;ͼͽͪΓͰͭͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻͪͺͽͳͷͰͼͽͪ͵Βͪͺͳͼ;Β;ͺͻͺͳͼͪͰͰͽͪ
ͺͰͳ͵ͭͱͳͬͽͪͳͺͯͬͳͭͪt́ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͪiͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵Ͱͺͻͪ͵ͼͰ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͺͼͰͫͪΒͰͳͬͰͷͪͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͪͽͰͷͪ
ͪͺͼͽΒͰΕͳͺͻͳͷͰͻͳmͷͰΌ;
͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰͪͻͳͽͳͼͽͳͰͺͯͬͳͱͳ͵ͳͶͳ͵͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪmͺͻͪͬͳͼ;
ͳͲͪͲͬͲͪͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͰ;ͺͽͻͰͫͰ
ͺͻͪͬͭͲͪͰΔͪͳ͵ͻͪΒΔͰͼͬͻͰͪͭͳͭͻͪͿ
ͼ͵ͳͽͺͼͪ
̓ͰͺͽtͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪiͳͼͬͰͽͻͯͰͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
;ͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͳͯͰͶ
͵ͳͪͯͭͻͪΌͰ;Ͱͺͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒͰͬͻͰͷͰ;;ͼͺͪͳͳͻͰΔͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͯͻͱͪͬͰ͇ͽ;ͯͪͳΔͰͭͬͪͪͭͶͪͰͪͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͪͿ;͵
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͳΒͪͳͯͻͱͪͬͽͬͻͪͼͬͻͪ́ͲͷͰΔͰͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ͵Ͷͼͽͳ;ͺͼͶͰͯΔͳͷ
ͯͰͰͳΒͪͷͪ 9*7 ͬͰ͵ͪ
;Ͳͻ͵ͬͪͰ ͼͷͪͼ͵ͳͷ ͼͬͪΒͪΔͳͷͪ ͳ ͪͭͬͰͽͪΒͰͷ
ͫͶͳͼ͵Ͱͺͻͺͪͼͽͳ
ͳͷͪͶͰͼ;͵ͪͺͼͶͰͯͳ;ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͲͪ͵ͻͰͽ;ͯͷͰ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻ
ͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ ͌ ͺͼͽ͵ͼͬͼ͵Β ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ Ͷͳ͵ ͳͯͰͪͶͭ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ ͼͪͫͻͪͱͪͬͪ
ͼͰͫͻͪͼ;ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺͳ͵ͪͯ;ͬͭͪͰͶͪͳͼͳͪͯ;ͫ͵ͺͻͱͳ
ͬΓͰͭͰͼͪͽͶ͵ͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ͆ͬͼͳͼͽͰͷͬͻͰͯͼͽͳ
ͯ;ͬͳͳͷͻͪͶ
ͳ
ͳͼͺΓͳͼͰͳ͵ͻͲͬͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͼͽͳ͈ͻͪͬͳͳͲͻͪͲͯͫͳΒͰ;Ͷͳ͵;
͵ͰͲͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
͵ͼͬͼ͵ͭͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ͵ͪ
ͪͶͳΒͰͺͻͰͫͶͳ͵ͬͪͳͰ͵ͰͼͽͪͻͳΒͰͬͶͪ
ͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ͵;ͶͽͬͰ͋ͪ͵PΒͰͫͳͶͼͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͷ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ΒͳͺͰͽ͵ͷ97ͼͽ
ͶͰΕͪͼͽͳͰͬ
ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͳͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ͇ͯͽͳͬͳͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷ;Ͱͳ
͵ͪͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͰͳͻ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͰ͵ͳͬͪͰͼ;
ͳͲͪͯͼͬͰͭͪ
ͷͶͳͽͬͰͲͪͼͺͪͼ
tͽͪͪͼͽͬͪi͌ͰͶͼͽͳͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͪ
ͼͬͪͿ;͵ͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ;ͽͷ
ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;;ͯͼͶͬͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ΒͰͼͽͳͻͳͶ͵ͪ
̓;Ͷͽ ͼͬͰͽͳ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ ; ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ ͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ ΒͰ Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵
ͫͳͽͳͰͶͰͷͰͪͽͪ͵Βͳͼ;Ͳͪ͵ͻͪΒΔ;ͼͬͻ;ͳͷͪͶͳͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͲͪͼͳͬͪΔͰͯͻͱͪ
ͬͰ͇ͼͳͷͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͳͳͷͶ͵ͳ
ͪͷͰΔͰͳͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͷͺͻͼͶͪ
ͬΓͪΔ;
ͬͪͱ;;Ͷͭ;ͳͷͪͶͳͼ;ͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶͳ
ͽͰͳ͵ΒͳͼͰͷͭ;Ͳͪͳͽͳ͵ͪ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳ ͳͶͳ ͬͳͲ;ͰͶͳ ͉ͳͽ;ͪͶͳ ͰͶͰͷͰͽͳ
;ͽͰͷͰΓͰͳ ͪ ͫͻͪͼͳͷͪ
ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͰͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ͪͶͳͺͿ;͵ͳΒͳͫͶͳͼ͵ͳͲͪͺͪͯͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͺͻͳ
ͷͰͻͳͷͪ
ͯͼͳͶͳͼ;ͼͰͪͫͻͰͯͰͬͰͲͪͰͲͪͼͬͰͽͰͷͽͳͳͫ;ͬͪͽͪͶͳͼ;
Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵ͫͳͽͳͰͽͪͺͪFMFWBUJP
USBOTMBUJPͳEFQPTJUJPͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͋ͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ
ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͫͳͶͪΒͰͼͶͱͰͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪ
ͳΒͳΒͰͬͻ;ͪͫͳ
ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳBEWFOUVT͈͵ͻͪΒΔΒͼͬͻͼͳ
ͽͪΒͳͼͬͰͪͭͳΒͪͬͭͺͻͰͯͼͽͪ
ͬΓͪΔͪͬͭ
ͪͳͪͶͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒͰͰͼͪͷͼͿͰͻͳͺͫͱͰ
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͬͰΕΒͰͫͳͳͷΕͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͰͺͻͺͪͭͪͯͰ
ͪͅͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͰͶͰͷͰͽͳ͵;Ͷͽͪͼ;ͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͼͷͳΓͰͭͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ
Ϳ;ͰͻͪͻͭͳͶͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ
ͪͺͪΒͬͳͰΒͰͲͳ͵ͷͼͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͪͺ
ͽͪͬͪͶͳͪͰͶͪͳͺͻ;͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͶͪ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
ͪͪͺͼͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͺΒͪͷͼͬͰͽ
ͼͽͳͺͻͰͬͯͳͶͳ;͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͰͺͻͳΒͰͷͳͬͰͪΒͳͻͳͷͼͶΒͰͬͳͷͪͬͰͻͳͅͰΌ;
ͽͳͷͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͷͪͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ΔͳͳͷͪͶΒͰͪͻͳͽ;ͬͪͱͼͽͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͼͽͬͪͻͪ
Δͪ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ͋ͼ;
ͪͺͻͬͷͷͰͼͽ;
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰmͻͰͺͻͰ
ͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͳͭͻͫͳͻͪͷͬͳͼͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͳͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͭͻͫͬͳͷ͇ͪͳ
ͼ;ͳͷͪͶͳͳͪͻͳͽͺͻͭͻͪͷͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͪͭͶͪͰͭͰͼͪͽͶ͵ͭ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰ
ͻͪ
ͪͶͳͳͼΒͪͼͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͳͷͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͳͷͺͻ;͵ͪͷͪ͊ͪ͵ͻͪͶͼͻͰͯͳͽͰͬͶͪ
ͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͪ;ͲͶͰΒͪͫͳͶͰͼ;ͷͽͳ͵ͽͳͽͻͪ
ͼͬͰͽͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
͵ΒͰͼ;ͺͳͬͪͶͰ;
ͼ͵;ͺͰͳͷ͵ͳͬͽͳͷͪ
ͪͺͪͼͷͷͰͼͽ;
ͳͼͺͻͰͯͳ͵ͼͽͪͼ͈ͪͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
] ]
̺͇͌̽
ͼͬͰͽͰͷͽͳ;ͬͳͯ;ͪͻͳͽͺͽͬͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
tͰͶͳiͳtͫͶͪͭ;ͪ
ͳi ͽͰͶͪ m ͪ ͵ͪͯͪ ΒͰ ͻͰ ͼͬͰͽͷ ͊ͳͷͰ; ͆ͰͷͪΔͳ
; ͬͳͯ; ͷͳͻͽͳͬͭ
ͭͻͫͪmͫͳͶͰͼ;ͳͲͬͻ;ͯͽͬͻͰͫͱͪͼ͵ͰͼͳͶͰ͇Ͱͼ;ͺͻ;ͱͪͶͰͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͪ
ͳͼͰΓͰΔͪ
ͯͽͰͶͰͼͳͫͶͰͼͽͳͳtͯ;Ͱͬͳͼͽͻͪͼͽͳi
ͳͽͪ͵ͯͰͶͽͬͻͲͪ
ͯͬΓͪͬͪͶͰͺͽͻͰͫͰͪͻͯͰͺͫͱͼͽͳ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
͵ͪͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͪ
ͲͪͷͰΔͪͪΒͬͳͰͭͻͪͭͪ
ͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͺͼͰͯͬͪͶͰͼ;ͭͻͷ;ͼͳͷ
ͫͶͳ͵;ͼͪͭ;͇Ͱͼ;ͫͳͶͰͺͽͬͻͯͪͲͪͯͫͳΒͰͰͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͰͪ;ͻͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͻͰͳ
ͷͪͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͳͽͰͽͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͯͻͱͪͬͰ;ͬͪͼͰΓͰͼ͵ͷͺͻͰͽ͵;
ͳΒͰͷͼͽͬͰͫͰͼ͵ͭ
ͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪͪͯͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͷͳͪͻͯͷ
̓;ͶͽͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͳΒͰͯͰͳͻͰͭͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͭͺͻͭͻͪ
ͷͪ
ͪΒͰ;ͳͽͪͬͷͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;ͫͳΒͰͯͯͪΒͯͰͶͽͬͻͳΒͳͼͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬͪͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭͲͪͼͳͬͪΔͪͬͶͪͼͽͳ̽ͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰͳΒͰͫͳͶͳ͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ
͵ͯ͵
ΒͳͼͰ;ͺͽͻͰͫͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;ͽΒͿ;͵ͳΒͳͷͱͰͺͻͪͽͳͽͳͯͬͰͶͳ͵ͱ;ͺͪͼ͵ͳ
ͬͻͰͷͰͪ
ͯͺͼͶͰͯΔͳͯͰͰͳΒͪ9**ͬͰ͵ͪ͊ͳͭ;ͻͯͪͳΒͰͼͶ;ͪΒͽͽΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͲͪͷͰͳͽͳͷͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͷͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͪͲͪͼͬΒͰͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͳ
ͳͼͳͭͶ͵ͲͪͷͰΔͰͯͪͫͻͪ;ͺͻͪͬ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ
;͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͼͰͪͽͪΒͪ
ͳ;ͬͰͶͳ͵;ͺͻͯͳ;ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͼͬΒ;ͯͳͪͼͽͳΒ;ͳͯͻͱͪ
ͬ;ͼͽͪͬͳͶͳͺͯͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽ͈ͬͫͰͯͳ͵ͭ͵ͻͼͽ̺ͪͻ;ͼ͵ͳͯͷͰͽ;ͽͷ
ͺͻͪͬ;
͵ͪ͵;ͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͽͪ͵ͳ;ͼͽͬͪͻͰΔ;
ͺͼͽͳͭ;ͽΒͰͺͰͽ͵ͷ9***ͬͰ͵ͪ
;̿ͳͳ͌ͬͻͰͷͰ͵ͪͯͪͼͰ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳͫͻͪͲ;Β;ͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͰͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͰ
ͼͪͷͼͽͪͶ
ͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͳͻ͵ͬͪ
;͵ͻ;ͳͯͫͰͷͳ͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͷͻͪͷ;ͼͽͬͻͰΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳ
ΒͪͻͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͪΒͬͳͰͭͻ͇ͪͭͪΒͰͫ;ͬͪͽͪͪΒͲͪͷͰͳͽͳΒͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
ͺͻͰ͵ͶͷͳͲ͊ͬͰͽͰͲͰͷΓͰ
ͪͺͬͰͲͪͰͼͭͶͪͬͳͷͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ΒͰͬͪΌͰͼ͵ͳͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ͌ͯͪͽͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;Ͱͼ;ͳͳͶͰͬͪͱͪͰͶͰͷͰͽͯͻ
ͱͪͬͰͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͯ͵ͼ;
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͽͬͻͳͶͰͪͻͳͽ;ͬͻͼͽ;ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭ
ͺͻͼͽͻͪ
ͼ;ͺͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒ;͊ͬͰͽͰͲͰͷΓͰ̓ͪͳͯͻ;ͭͯͰ;ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;
ͽͪ
͵ͲͪͷͳΓͰUSBOTMBUJP)JFSPTPMZNJͫͳΒͰ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳͳͯͰΒͰUSBOTMBUJPJNQFSJJͳ
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͰͯͪͼͰ͊ͻͫͳ
͵ͪtͳͲͪͫͻͪͳͪͻͯi
ͪͺͻͺͳͼͪͪͳ
;͵Γ;Ͱ;ͽ͵ͬͰͼͬͰͽͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰ
̓ͪͳ ͵;Ͷͽ ͼͬͰͽͳ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
ͽͪ͵ ΒͰ ͳ ͵;Ͷͽ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ ͲͪͪΒ ͳͲͷͰͳ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ;ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͯͻͱͪͬͼͽͳ́ͪ͵ΒͰͬͻͰͯͪͯͬͻͼ͵ͪͻͳͲͳ
ͪͺͼͽΒͪͶͪͳ;ͯͫͪͯͰͼͺͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͽΒͰͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪ
ͺͰͪͽͰͺͳ
ͯͪͶͳͼ;ͺͻͰͼͳͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͳͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ
͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͪͷͰΔͰͪ
;ͶͭͪͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͯͰͼͺͽͬͳͰ͋ͳͼͬͰͪͳͫͻͰͯͳ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰͳͺͼͬͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬͳͶͳͷͪBEWFOUVTͪSFMJRVJBSVN
ͫͳͶͳͼ;ͳͲͻͪͲͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͪͯͰͳ;ͼͻͯͰͷ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͶͳͽͬͰͲͪ;ͬͪΔͰtͫͱΒͰͭͼͽͪͯͪi͈ͻͭͻͪͷͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭͲͪͼͳͬͪΔͪͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͬͰ
Ͷͳ͵ͭͳͯͰΒͭͿͻͷͪͽͪͳ;ͺͰͪͽΓͳͬͳͼͽͬͪͻͰΔͪ
͵ΒͰͷΒͰͼͬͰͺͶͱͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͫͳΒͰͼͪͫͻͪͱͰͺͽͻͰͫͪͷͪͳͷͭ;Εͼͽͳͷͪ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ;
ͯͫͪͼͬͰͽͻͯͰͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ͌͵ͶͼͽͳͷͪͺͻͰͯͯͻͱͪͬͳͼͶͷ
ͬͳͰͳΒͰͳͷͪ;ͺͻͳͽͪ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Βͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͳ͌ͼͽͪͶͷ
ͳͼͬͰͽͳͲͪ
ͽͳͽͳͳͽͭͻͪͲͯͫΓͪͺͻͺ;ͼͽͳͶͳͼ;ͯͪͳͼͺΓͰͼͬΒͰ;ͯͰͼͰͷΕͳ
͉ͪͯͬͳ͵ΒͰͺͻͰͯͪΒͰͷΒͪͬͼͽͳͺͳͼͪͳͼ;ͳͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪͳͽ͵ͷͺͼͶͰͯ
ΔͳͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵ͭͯͳͪ m
ͯ͵ͼͰͰ͵ͳͼͪͯͪͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽͺ;ͫͶͳ͵;Β;͵ͪ͵
ͫͳͼͰͲͪ͵ͻ;ͱͳͶͪͽͺͳ͵ͪͬͰ͵ΔͳͭͰ͇ͳͼ;ͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ͵ͭͺͻͰͼͪ
;ͼͷͰͻͰͭ͵ͪͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔ;ͳ͵;ͶͽͬͪmͪͺͻͬͷͷͰͼͽ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪm͵Βͳͼ;ͳͷͪͶͳͬͪͱ;;Ͷͭ;;ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͷͲͪͼͳͬͪΔ;
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͯͻͱͪͬͰ͊ͽ;ͯͳΒͰͼ;ͺͳͼͪͰͼͪͷͰͻͷͯͪͼͰͽΒͬͰͶͳ͵Β
ͽͰͷͳͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳͪͷͰͽͯͶ͵ͳͺͻͳͷͰͻͰͪͳ
ͳͯͪͼͰ
ͫͪͻ;ͳͲͬͰͼΒͷͰͻͳ
;ͼͺͼͽͪͬͰΔͰͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ͵ͳ͵ͬͳͻͳͳͺͻͰͺ
ͲͪΒ;ͭͶͪͬͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͼ͵ͪͽͰͱͳͽͪ́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͫͪͬΓͰͪͼ
ͬ;ͯͪͫͻͪͳ;Ͳͻͪ͵ͪ
ͫͰͲͪͷͫͳͳΒͰͯͪͼͰͼͳͽͰͽͼ͵ͳͲͪ͵ͻ;ͱͳ
ͪͶͳͼͪͯͷ
ͯͪΕͰͫͳͽͳͯ͵ͻͳͼͽͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͰ͵ͭͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͭ
ͼͬͰͫ;ͬͪͽͲͪͷͳΓͰͭ
ͺͻΒͰ͵ͽͪ͵ΒͳΕͰͼͰͯͼͳͽͳͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͭtͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪiͳ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;͈ͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͭͻ;ͺͳͼͪΔͪͻͪͯͬͪͻ;͵ͬͯͳͶͳͼͷͼͰΔͳͬͷ
ͺͻͫͶͰͷͼ͵ͷͺͬͰͲͪΕ;
ͪͰͼͶͰͯͷͪͼͽͪΒͪΔ̻ͪͯͳͰ;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;ͺΒͰ
ͯͳͰͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰͪͺͳͼͪͰͼͪͷͰͻͷͼ;ͯͯͪͽͪͲͪͰͰ
ͼͫͲͳͻͷͪͽͯͪ
͵ͯͬͳͰΔͳͺͼͽΒͳͲͪͪΒͪͻͪͲͷͪ͵ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͬͻͰͷͰͪͪͼͽͪ͵ͪͳͳͲͶͪͼ͵ͪͳͲ
ͽͪͷͺͰ͆ͪͽͪΒͪͳͪͼͽΒͪͶͳͼͷͯͪͺͻͰͯͳͷͻͪͲͶͭͰͳͲͼͽͪ͵ͪͰ͵ͳ
;ͷͰΌ;ͬͻͰͷͰ;ͫΒͪͬΓͰͳͪͼͶͬͪ̓ͪͯͪΒͰͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳͻͰ
ͽ͵ͷͻͪͯͪͪ
ͬͷͳͲͯͪΔ;ͯͶͳͼͷͯͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͯͪΔͰͬͰͶͳͻͪΔͰͳͲͬͳͰͻͪͲͶ
ͭͪͰͫͳͫͳͶͼͬͻͼͳͼͯ͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͼͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͷͬͳͰͭͯͳΔͰͭͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪ
ͳ ͪ ͼͪͯͪΔͰͷ ͼͽͰͺͰ; ͼͪͲͪΔͪ
ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͰ ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰ ͯͪͪͼ ͫͳͼͷ ͷͰͽͯͼ͵ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰ;ͫͶͳͳͶͳ
ͪͼͪͯͻͱͳͼ͵ͳͯͪͶͰ͵ͻͪͲ;ΌͰͳΒͰͳͲͶͱͳͶͳ͊ͽͭͪͼͷ
ͪ͵ͼͰͳͲ;Ͳͷ;ͷͪΔͰΒͰͲͳ͵ͰͳͻͽͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͰͳͽͰͻͬͰͳΒͰ
ͻͪͯͬͰͲͪͯͻͱͪͶͳ
;ͳͲͬͻͷͫͶͳ͵;͋ͪ͵ͬͪͯͶ;͵ͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭ
ͻ;͵ͬΌͰͪͪͷͰ
ͻͷͯͪ;ͳͳͷͬͳͯΓͳͬͳͷͼͪͷͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ͵ͳͺͻͰͼͳͰͽͪͺͰͺͻͰΌͰͭͺ;ͽͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͷͭͫͻΒͰͽͰ͵ΕͰͳͰͯ;ͷͳͰͼ͵ΒͳͷͪͼͷͼͰͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ
͵ͷͼ;ͪͬͪͶͳ
] ]
̺͇͌̽
̹͌Ͱͭͻͪͯ; Β;B
] ]
̸̺͉͇͇͊̾͋́̽͆͐̾̈́͆́͏́
̸̸̺͇͈͉͇̺͊̾͋́͋̾͊̓͊̈́̾͢͡͡
̸̸͇͊́̾͆͆̾̾͢ͅͅ
̸̸̺͇͈͉͇̺͊̾͋́͋̾͊̓͊̈́̾͢͡͡
̸̸͇͊́̾͆͆̾̾͢ͅͅ
̸̸̸͈͉͇̻͈͉͇̺́̈́͌͐͌̓͌̈́͋͢
̸͇͇͉̹͑͋́͌̓̽͊͠ͅ
̸̺͇̻͇̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͯͪͬͅΒͰͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͳͽͰͻͰͼͬͪΔͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͺͻͶͼͽͳ̀ͪͬͪΓ;Β;ΕͳͪͺͻͳͷͪͷͰͯͳͰͬͳͼͽͪͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳͪ;ͳ
ͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͪ
ΒͰͻͰͶͪͽͳͬͯͫͻͺͻ;ͰmͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ΒͯͳͷͰ
ͲͳΒͳ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͻͶͭͳΒͰͳ͵Ͷͼͽͳͪͼͽͪ͵ͪ
ͰͽͪͺͪͻͪͲͬΒͪͳͼͽͬͪ
ͻͪΔͪ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͪ;ΔͰͭͬΒͿ;͵ͳΒͳ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͼͽͪͶΒͰ;ͭͶͪͬͷͲͪͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰ͵ΒͰͫͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬ͊ͳͷͰ
ͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͶͳͶ͵ͻͲ͵͵ͻͰͽͰͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͳͺͼͽ;ͺ͵Ͱ
ͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͰͳͼ
ͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷͺͻͰͼ;͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͰ͋ͺͳͽͪΔͰͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;ΒͰ
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͺͼͰͫ;ͳͫͳͷ;ͼͽ;ͯͳΒ;͇ͬͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͫͪͬͳΕͰͷͼͰͼͪͷΒͰͯͳͷͬͳͯͷ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͻͫͶͰͷͪ
ͳͽͬͰͷͪͼͫͰͳͷmͫͶͳ͵ͷͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪmͳͪ
ͼͽΒͪΕͰͷͯͪ;ͽͬͻͯͳͷ͵ΒΒͼ;͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͰͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͶͰ
͇ͯ ͼͪͷͳ ͺͰͽͪ͵ͪ ͻͳΕͪͼͽͬͪ ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ ΒͰͲͭͻ ͳ ͯ;ͬͳ Ϳ͵;ͼ
ͬͳ͵;ͶͽͬͪͳͳͶͳͼ;ͭͻͫͬͳͼͽͰͶͰͼͳͷͼͽͪͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͈ͪͻͰͷͪ
ͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͰͼ;ͪΒ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͳ
ΒͷͺͽͬͻͯͷͫͭͽͬͻͰΔͪͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͰ
ͷͭ;ΕͰ͇ͭͬͪͺͶΕͰΔͰͷ
ͳ;ͯͽͬͻ
ͳͷͺͼͻͰͯͳͳͷͪͳͲͷͰΌ;ͬͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͭͳͽͻͪͼͰͯͰͽͭ͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ
ͺͫͱͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰ
ͽͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;
;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪ͵ͻͲͯͯͳͻͳͬͳΌͰΔͰ
ͫͳ
ͶΒͰͲͪͼͬͪͪͬͰͻͳ;ͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪ͊ͬͪͽͪΔͰͼͬͰ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽͼͽͳͪͶͳͳͰͯͰΓͳͬͼͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͬͯͳͶΒͰ;ͬͰͻͰΔ;ͯͪͼͰ
ͺͺͻͳ
ͳͺ;QBSTQSPUPUP
̹ͱΒͪͼͳͶͪΒͰͯͪ͵ͺͻΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰ͵ͻͲͰͶ͵;ͺͰ
ͰͽΓͰͰ
ͷͽͳ͵ͪͳ͵ͻͲΔͳͬ;ͪΒͷͪΔ;Ͱͼͽͳ;͋ͪͰͶͺͻͰͼ;ͯΒͰ;ͽͳͪͶ
ͪ͵;Ͷͽ;ͺͻͪ͵ͼ;͋ͪ͵ͬͰΕͻͪͪͰͭͲͰͭͰͲͪͺͻ;ͱͪͫͳΓͰͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͪͬͪͽͷͰ
ͯͪͼ;ͼͰͺͯͺͽͳͷͺΒͷͷͷͽͳΒ; SFMJRVJBF
le¿uana
ΒͰͯͪ͵ͺͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰ
ͬͪͶͪͳͰͶͪͫͪͶͼͪͷͬͪͪͽͰͶͪͳ͵ͼͽͳ
ͽΒͰͼͽͼ͵ͰͶͰͽͳͼͽͪͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͆ͪ
ͼͬ;ͻͪͼͺͶͱͳͬͳͳͲͬͻͪͷͱͰͼͰͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͯͪͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͰ͵ͳͯ
ͺͻͬͳͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͫͳͶͰ;ͬͳͯ;ͰͺͻͺͪͯΓͳͬͭͽͰͶͪ͌ͽͪ͵ͬͷ
ͼͽͪΔ;ͲͪͽͰͰͰͼ;
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͰ͠;ͶͳͽͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪͽͬͻΌͰΔ;̺ͪͼͳͶͳΒͪ
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͭ̀ͪͽͺͳͽͪΔͰͺͼͰͫΒͰͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͼͬͰͯͰΔͰͼͬͰͽ̸ͭͷͬͻͼͳΒͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ
ͺͻͪͪͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͷ;Ͱͳ͵̻ͪͰͻͬͪͼͳΒͪͳ͈ͻͽͪͼͳΒͪ
Ͳͪͺͳͼͪͯͪ
ͼ;ͰPNOJBPTTBJOUFHSB
TBOHVJOJTQMVSJNVNΔͰͭͬ;Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵͵ͽͻͬͰͻͲͪ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͳͳΒͪͼͳΒͳͷͽͬͻΌͰΔͰͼͬͰͽ̸ͭͬͭ;ͼͽͳͪ
͵ΒͳͲͪͽͰͷͽͳ͵ͪͱͰͯͪͼ;
] ]
̸̸̺͇͈͉͇̺͊̾͋́͋̾͊̓͊̈́̾͢͡͡
̸̸͇͊́̾͆͆̾̾͢ͅͅ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͽͳΒͳͼͷͳͼͪͼͬͰͯͳͼͺͳͼͼͬͰͽ͎ͭͳͶͪͻͳΒͪ;͵ΒͰͷͼͰͻͪͼͺͻͪͬΓͪͯͰͶ
ͽͬͻͼͽͳͷͽͳΒ;;ͲͪͽͳͽͳͯͯͰͷ͈ͪͯͺΒͷͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͽ;ͼͰͪͬͯͰ
TBODUVTVCJRVFCFBUPSVNNBSUZSVNTBOHVJTwFUWFOFSBOEBPTTB
́ͲͬͰͼKFͯͪͼ;ͳͯͳΒͰ
ͽ͵ͷͳͽͪͬͭͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
ͽͬͪͰͫͰ͵ͪ
ͽͰͭͻͳΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ̽ͪͻ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ
͵ͪͯ͵ͪͲͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽ̹ͬͪͱΒͰͫͶͪͭͯͪͽͳ
ͪͰͼͽͰͺͰΔͳͬͰ;ͬͪͼͽͳ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪΒͰͭͶͪͬͳͷͳͲͪͺͻͪͬΒͰͯͳͳͷͰͲͪ
ͫͳͶͪͲͳͷͲͪͷͰΔͰͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ͌ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;ͯͺͼͰͫͰΒͰͬͪͱͼͽͳ
ͫͭͪͽͪͻ;ͼ͵ͪͭͻͪΌͪ
;ͲͽΒͰͯͳͪ͵ΒͪΒͰͼͽͭͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͫͪͻͯͰͶͳͷͳͺͻ
;Ͱͪ͋ͪ͵ΒͰΒ͵ͻͪΒͰͷ9*9ͬͰ͵ͪ͠ͰͬͭͰͳΒ̻Ͷ;ͫͳͼ͵ͳͺ͵ͪͲͪͯͪͼ;;ͼͻͰͯ
ΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͉;ͼͳΒͳͽͬͪͰͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͰ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͰͷͽͳΒ;tͰͶͪiͽͰͶͪͳͷͪ
Ͷͳͼ;͵ͰͭͳΔ͇ͪͶͭͪ
͵ͰͲ̸ͯͻͰΒ̹ͭΓ;ͺͼ͵ͳ
͵ͪͳͬͳͰ͵ͳΒͰͬͺͰͰͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺͯͬͳͱͳ͵ͪ ͯͰͶͳͷͳ ͰͽΓͰ ͫͳͶ ΒͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͽͰͶ ͼͬͰͽͭ ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ
͉ͼͽͬͼ͵ͭ
ͪͶͳͼ;
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͷͽͳͰ͵ͳͯͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
mͺͺ;ͽ͵ͰͱͰͬͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵̹ͪͻͳͼͪͳ̻ΓͰͫͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒ͈ͪͰͰͻͼ͵ͭͳͶͳ̸ͯͻͰΒͪ
͊ͷͶͰͼ͵ͭmͫͳͶͰ;ͬͳͯ;ͼ͵ͰͶͰͽͳͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ͠Ͱͯ;ͯͻͰͽ͵ͳͳ;ͽͶͳ͵
ͯͻͪͭͰͳΒͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͺͽͬͻͯͪͽͪ͵ͬͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͺͻ;ͱͳͶͪͼ;ͳͼ͵ͺͪͬͪΔͪͳͲ
;͵ͻͳͺͽͳͻ͵ͬͰ͊ͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ;̹ͪͻͳΒ;͈ͯͶͽͪͻͷ
;ͷͰͻͷͰͻΒͺͯ
ͲͰͷΒͭͻͫͳͳ
ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰͳͼ;ͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͯͰͶͬͳͼ͵ͰͶͰͽͪm;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳ
ͯͶͳͼͪ;ͬͪ;ͶͫͪΔ;mͲͪͷͰͳͽͭͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪͳͲͅͳͻͰ
ͳΒͪΒͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳ
Βͪ;̹ͪͻͳͫͪͬΓͰͪͭͯͳͰ
͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͳ;͈ͻͪͬͼͶͪͬΒͳ;͉ͳͷ͵ͪͽͶͳ͵Βͻ͵ͬͳͰͽΓͰ
ͼͽ ͽͰͶͪ ͳΒͰ ͼͷͪͽͻͪͪ ;ͱͳͷ ;ͼͶͬͷ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ ͐ͳͳ ͼͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͯͪΒͰͽ͵ͷͬͻͰͷͰͪͼͬͰͳͲͻͪͱͰͳΒͪͫͳͶͪͽͰͱΔͪͯͪͼͰͽͰͶͪͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͳͺͯ
ͬͳͱͳ͵ͪͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳͫͪͶͼͪͷ;Β;͊ͫͲͳͻͷͪͽͯͪͬͪΒͺͻͫͶͰͷ;ͯͼͪ
ͯͪΔΒͪ;ͳͳΒͰͺͼͰͫͺͻ;ͪͬͪ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;ͳͼͰͲͪͼͪͯͪͷͭ;ͯͼͳͽͳ
ͼͪͷͺͼͻͰͯͳͷͺ;ͽͰͷ͆ͪͻͳͽͬͻͰͯͰͺͯͪͽ͵ͰͼͪͯͻͱͰͳͲͬͰͽͪΒͳͼͻͰͯΔ
1-59
m
̻Ͷ;ͫͳͼ͵ͳʹ
́ͼͽͻͳΊ͵ͪͳͲͪͳͳͼͬΊͽΆ·
mͳQBTTJNWͳ̻͍Ͱͯͽͬ
͊ͬΊͽΆͰͯͻͰͬͰʹ͉;ͼͳ
ͻͰͺͻͅͼ͵ͬͪ
m
7ͻͪͯͬͰͪͬͰͯͰͰ;ͺͻͰͽͯΒͪͺͷͰͳ ͼͪͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
'4DIFUUJOJ
-BCBTJMJDBEJ4BO/JDPMBEJ#BSJ
#BSJPͽ͵;ͳͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͳͷͪͳͼ͵ͺͪͬͪΔͪ
ͪͼͽͻm
ͼͶmͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͳͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰͺͽͺ;ͪͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
;ͪͺ
ͼͽͻm
͇ͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ͉ͳͷ͵ͪͽͶͳ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰW8%FPOOB
̾ȔȄȉ̸$SPZBODFTBOUJRVFTFUNPEFSOFT
MPEFVSTVBWFEFTEJFVYFUEFTÊMVT
(FOBWB97** (FOÍWF
m
] ]
̸̸̺͇͈͉͇̺͊̾͋́͋̾͊̓͊̈́̾͢͡͡
̸̸͇͊́̾͆͆̾̾͢ͅͅ
ͬͰ͵ͬͳͺͼͰͽͳͶͪͪ͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͪ
ͳͲ͵ΒͳΒͪͼͺͻͳͲͶͪͲͳͯͪͼ;ͺͻͰͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͻ͵ͬͰͫͳͶͬͪͶͰͰͽΓͰͳͷͷͽͳͷͪͭͫͅͻΒͳͻ;ͼ͵ͳͯͪͼͳͳͰ
ͺͻͺ;ͽͪΒ;ͯͪͳͼͽͪ͵;͵ͪ͵ͽͪ͵ͪͬͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓtͬͽFͶFͶͰͱͳͽ·i
ͽΒͰͯͼͶͬ
ͳͺͻͰͬͯ;ͫͳͪΒͰͰͭͻ͵ͰͼͳͽͪͭͷͰªn sÝmati ìgioi͆Ͱ͵ͳͯͽͳͺͳͼͪ
ͺͺ;ͽͭͽͭͪΒͰͼͪͼͽͪͬͳ́ͭΔͪͽͳΒͰͳͲ͊ͷͶͰͼ͵ͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͰͳͺͻͰͳͲͪ
ͽͰͻͷͳͶ͵ͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺΒͷͬͪͯͻͰΌͰΔͪ͆ͪͫͻͪΒͪΒ;ΕͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͰͺͻͰͼͽͳ
͵̸ͭͺͼͽͶͳͪ
́ͭΔͪͽͳΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭ
͵ͪͱͰt͋;Ͱͼͽ·ͬͺͻͳͯFͶFͼͬΊͽΆͳ
͊ͺͳͻͳͯͳ͈ͶͳͰ͵ͽ
ͫͪͬͽFͶFͼ;ͽ·
ͳͷ΄ͳͼͬΊͽͪͭ́ͪͪ̀Ͷͪͽ;ͼͽͪͭ
ͳͷ΄ͳͼͬΊͽ̻ͪͭͻͳͭͻͳ̹ͪͭͼͶͬͪͬ͵ͪͷͰΆ͵ͬͰͲFͲͪͺͰͪͽͪΆi͉;
ͼ͵ͳͯͪͼͳ͵ΒͰͳͭͶͰͯͺͻͪͬͳΒͪͼ;ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͳͲͷͰΌ;tͰͶͳi
ͰͽΓͰͳ
ͽͰͶͪͳtͷͽͳΒ;imͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͼ͵ͰͶͰͽͳͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ͵Βͳͼ;;ͬͪͳ;͵ͪͷͰͳͷ͵ͬ
ͰͱͳΕͳͷͪͭͅͶͫͳͼͰͺͷͳΓͪͽͳͪͽͯͪΒͰͳͻͪͺͻͳͷͰͪͫͳͪΒͪͫͪͶͼͪ
ͷͬͪΔͪͲͪͺͰͶͪͰͭͯͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ;ͽͬͻΌͰͳͯ
ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͻͪͲͻͪΌͰͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵FMFWBUJPͳUSBOTMBUJPͷͽͳΒ;͇ΒͰ
ͺͺͻͪ
ͬͳͶ;
͵ͪ͵ͻͪΒΔͳͳΓͳͷͪͼͬͰͪͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪm;͵ͪͷͰͳͷ͵ͬͰͲͳ
ͷͪͼͿͰͰͼͽͰͶͷͳͶͳ;ͯͻͬͰͳͷ͵ͳͬͽͳͷͪmͪͶͳ
;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
tͪͬͳΌͰΔͰi
ͬͰͻͳͷͪ͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪΒͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͪͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͪͰͶͳͽͰͶͪͼͬͻͰͷͰͷͯͫͳΒͪͶͪͪ
ͺͺ;Ͷͪͻͼͽͳ
ͼ;ͯͰΕͳͺͼͬͰ;ͰͼͽͪͶͳΒͳͷͺͷͰͳͷͪͽͪ͵ͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͪͻ
ͳͽ;ͺͲͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;͌Ͱ͵ͳͷͼͻͰͯͳͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͪΒͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͫͳͶͪͻ;ͼ͵ͪ
ͺͼͽͰͺͰͪ͵ͺͻͰͬͶͪͯͪͬͪͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͯͪͼͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͺͼͬͰ
ͯͪͬͪͳͼ͵Γ;ͳͬͰͽΓͰͳͷͷͽͳͷͪ͋ΒͺΒͪͬͳͻ͵ͬͪͼͰ;ͺͻͯ;ͺͳͻͪ
Ͷͪ
ͺͯͼͰΕͪΒ;ΕͳͪͳͲͬͻͼͬͰͽͽͪ͵ͺͻͰͯͪΔͰͳ;ͺͲͻͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪͰ
ͪͽͯͪͼͪ;ͬͪͽͰͶͷͱͰͫͳͽͳͳͲͪͷͰΔͰͶͳͼͽͳͺͻͰͷͳ;ͶͰ
ͺͯͺͻ͵ͶͰͽͼͽͬͷ̀ͪͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰͽͭͺͳͽͪΔͪͲͪͳͷΓͳͬΒͰͼͬͰͯͰΔͰ͈ͪ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͷͳΒͪ͊ͻͫͳͪ
;Ͱͭ͊ͬͰͽͭͻͪͳͺͶͯͭͺͳͼͪͻ;ͼ͵ͳͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͽͻͰΕΒͰͽͬͻͽͳͳ97ͬͰ͵ͪͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͱͳͽͳΒͰͷͼ͵ͬͼ͵ͭͷͳͽͻͺͶͳ
ͽ͈ͪͰͽͻͪͪ͵ͰͶͰͬͪͳΒͰΔͰͭͬͭͽͰͶ͇ͪ͵ͶͼͽͯͪΒͰ͈Ͱͽͻͬ;ͬͻͽͰΔͰ
;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰͯͬͰͯͰ;ͺͳͽͪΔͰͼͽͭͪͽͷͽͳͳͼ;ͺͻͪΌͰͰtͰͶͰi
ͺͯͼͽͪ͵ͶͪΒͰ͈ͪͷͳΒͪͪͽͯͪͫΒͪͼͳ͵ͪ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰͺͳͰtͲͫͭΓ;ͯͼ͵ͭͫͰͲ
ͬͰͻΒͪi
ΒͰͻt͵ʹͽͶ͵ͰͬͽFͶFͶͰͱͳͽ
ͽͽ;ͳ ͉;ͼͪ
ͰͼͬΊͽi͋ͪ͵ͬͼͬͪ
ͽͪΔͰͳͺͻͪ͵ͼ;ͺ͵;ͪΒͰͻͪͲͶͱͯͪͺͻͽ;ͷͪͳΒͰͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͳͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ
͆Ͱ͵ͽͪͻͳΒͰ †
͇͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰ;ͼͽͪͻͯͫͪ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;Γ;ͯͳΒ;ͬͰ͵ͫͳͶͳ
tͯͫͻͼͪͬͰͼͳi
;ͯͽͬͻͼͽͬͫͳͶͯͬΓͪͯ͵ͪͲͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
;ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰ
ͽΒͰͼͽ͆Ͱ͵ͽͪͻͳΒͰͬ
ͲͫͭͷͭͳͲͶ;ͺͽͻͰͫͪͺͽͻͰͫͪͼ;ͳ
ͯͯͪͽͪͲͪͷͰΔͪmͰͶͽͰͶͳͶͳͫͪͻͫͶͪͭ;ͪΔͰ͵ͼͽͳΒ;
͇ͬͪΒͺͽͳͼͬͻͽͳͳ;ͱͪ͵ͬͳͻͲͪͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͰͺͳͽͪΔͪͬͻͼͽͳ
ͽ
ΒͰͼͽ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰͼͷͲͪͼͬͪͶͳͪ
ͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔ;ͳͳͲͻͪͲͪͳͼͳͽͪͭͷͳ͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͷ
ͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͷͪͺͳͼ;Β;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵Ͱͷͽͳ͌ͫͲͳͻͼ;;ͲͰͽͳͳͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͲͪͬͪΒ
ͺͻͫͶͰͷͬͪͱͳͺͯͪͳΔͳͬͷͽͬͪΔ;
;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͼͰ
ͳͼͪͷͰ
ͼͪ;ͬͪͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ̓ͪͳ;ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͯͰͶͳͷͪͳͼͽͭͱͪͻͪ
ͽͪ͵ͼͰͳ;ͫͳͭͻͪ
ͿͳΒͪͷͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͷͽͳͷͪͭͬͻͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷΔͳͬͭͺͯͳͲͪΔͪͳͲ
ͭͻͫͪ
ͯͼͺͻͳͶ͵ͷͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ͆ͪΒͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͳΒͰͼͬͰͯͰΔͰͽͷ
ͯͭͪΌͪΒ;ͯͼͳ͊ͪͬͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕ
͵ΒͳΒͰͫͳͰͼͪͷͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͰͭͳͰͺ
ͼͻͰͯͳͳͲͬͻͳͶͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͰͰͶͰͬͪͳΒͰ͢ͰͭͬͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔͰ;ͺͻͬͳͷͪ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪΒͪͼͳͰͯͬͼͷͳͼͶͰ̓ͪͯͪΒͰ
ͼͪͷͭͯͳͪͪ͵ͰͬͰͼͷͻͽͳ
ͽͬ
ͻͳ ΔͰͭͬ ͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ ͭͻͫ
ΒͰ ͽͰͶ ͺͻͪͪ tͰͶ ͳ ͰͺͬͻͰΌͰi
wbrqtoh(2) y(2)st(2)noe tqlo ego cqlo i nevrqdimoͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬ
ͺ͵ͪͲ̻ͪͶ;ͫͳͼ͵ͳ
ͪͼͬ;;ͬͳͯͪ;ͫͳͷ;ͭͻͪΌ;
ͳͲͻͪͲtͰͶiͳtͰͺ
ͬͻͰΌͰͽͰͶiͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͽͺͼ͵ΒͳͼͪͷͺͼͰͫͳ
ͫͰͲͯͯͪͽͳͯͻͰΌͰΔͪ
Ͱ
] ]
̸̸̺͇͈͉͇̺͊̾͋́͋̾͊̓͊̈́̾͢͡͡
̸̸͇͊́̾͆͆̾̾͢ͅͅ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
] ]
̸̸̺͇͈͉͇̺͊̾͋́͋̾͊̓͊̈́̾͢͡͡
̸̸͇͊́̾͆͆̾̾͢ͅͅ
ͽΓͰͳͷͽͳΒ;͇ͯͯͪͽͯͫͳΒͪͪ;ͬͰͻΓͳͬͼͽͳͪ͵ͼͰͺͳͼ͊ͳͷͰ
ͬͭͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ;ͺͻͰͯͳͼͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰͷͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͳͶͳ
͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ
;ͽͶͳ͵ͺͻͰͽͼͬͳͷͪΔͳͷͪͼͬͰͯͰͳͼͽͳͺͳͼͳ
m̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͈ͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;ΕͳͽͬͪͻͪΔ;ͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭͭͻͫͪ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭͳ
ͺͻͰͼ;ΔͰͭͬͭͽͰͶͪ;̿ͳ;
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͯͼͽͪ;ͺͽͰ͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͰͬ
ͽͰͶͺͻͪΌͰtͰͶͳͰͻͪͲͻ;ͳͬisvet6e mo\ti ego cqli i nerazdrou\imi
obrqt̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͼͶͳͼͬͰͯͳ
ͪͶͳ;Ͳͫͳͽ;ͳͺͻͰͳͲ;ͯͳͼͽͳ͵ͳΒ;
mͯͪͳ;ΔͰͭͬͬͻͰͷͰ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͳ;̿ͳͳlejit2 tqlom2 nevrqdim2 v2s2
͆ͪͼͬ;ͬͰΕͪͬͰͯͰͳͪͪͶͭͳΒͪͼͪͳͻͰͭͺͯͻ;ΒͪͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͪΒͪ
ͼͺͻͳͲͶͪͲͳͯͪͼͰͽͪͿͻͷ;ͶͪͳΒͪmtͶͰͱͳͰͺͬͻͰΌͰͭͽͰͶͪimͯͼͳͪ
ͰͽΓͰͰͷͽͳͳͲͶͱͰͰ;͵ͳͬͽ;͋ͪ͵ͪͬͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵
ͼͻͰΕͳͷͼͽͳͪΒͰͷ͵Ͷ
ͼͽͳ
ͳͯͼͶͬͺͽͬͻΌ;Β;ͼͪͷͰͷͽͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ
ͼͪ;ͬͪͰ
ͯͪͳͯͪͪ
;ͺͻ͵ͼͼͬΒΒͰͫͳͯ;ͭΒͳͫ;ͻΒͳͼͽͻͳΒͳ͌ͬͰͲͳͼ
ͺͻͫͶͰͷͷ͵Βͳͳͼͺͳͽ;ΒͰͷͪͻͳͽͼ;;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͳͳͼͪͼͬͳͷͰͯͬͼͷͳͼͶͰͳ
ͺͳͼͳͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ̓ͪͯͪͷ;ΒͰͽͬͻͰͺͻͬͳ
ͽͻͬͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
͊ͪͬ;ͼ;
ͺͻͰͷͪ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ;
ͺͻͪͶͳpo istinq sveta pl2tiü i douhom2, xkoje i prqjde
v2 jivotq ögo vidim2 bq imiͯͷͪͲͪͽͳͷ
͵ͪͺͽͬͻͯͪͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͰ̹ͱΒͰͷͳͶ
ͼͽͳ
ͼͶͰͯͳͽͬͻΌͰΔͰ͵ͪ͵i po s2mr2ti zemlx ne prikosnou se bogonos2nqm2 tqle ögo
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͽͪ͵ΌͰͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪͯͪͼ;͊ͪͬ;ͺͻͪͶͳv2 istinnou sveta douhom2
i pl2t8ü, cqla vsego i nerazdrou\ena
ͪͭͶͪͪͬͪΒ;Εͳ
;Ͳͽ
tͺͻͳͻͯͳiͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͷͽͳΒ;i vlasi je glavn6e i bradn6e v2se svqtl6 i cql6 imou\ta, i xko spe\ta
v2zle\ta͊ͬͰͯͰΔͰͫΒͳͰ͊ͪͬͳͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪͪmͲͪͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͰͬͭ
ͺͻͫͶͰͷͪͽͪ͵ΌͰͬͰͷͪͬͪͱmͽͷͰͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͳͽͰͶͪ͵ͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͰͶͰͬͪͳΒͰͫͳͶͳͲͶͱͰ;͵ͳͬͽ;ͯͺ;Δ;Β;ͺͯͻͫͳΒͳͷͺͯͪͳͷͪͼͪͷͳͷ
ͷͽͳͷͪͷͭͳͺͼͰͽͳͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪͳͲ͵ͪͼͳΒͳͬͻͰͷͰͪ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
] ]
̸̸̺͇͈͉͇̺͊̾͋́͋̾͊̓͊̈́̾͢͡͡
̸̸͇͊́̾͆͆̾̾͢ͅͅ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͇͵ͶͼͽͯͪͷͽͳͺͻͬͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͳͼ;ͫͳͶͰ;ͫͶͳ͵;Ͱ
ͽΓͰͭͽͰͶͪmͪͽͪ;͵ͪͲ;Β;ͼͬͳͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͳͪͰͭͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͪmͳΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;
ͽͳͷ
ͺͻͰͷͪͬͪͱͰΕͳͷͷͰͻͳͶͳͷͪ
ͳͪ͵ΒͳͪͳͯͬͯͳͶͪ;ͺͳͽͪΔͰΔͳͬ;
ͼͬͰͽͼͽ̓ͪ͵ΒͰͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽ
ͭͶͪͬͳͷͲͪͷͰΔͰͷ̹ͱΒͰͫͶͪͭͯͪͽͳͼͷͪͽͻͪΒͰ
ͯͪͻ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ
ͪͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͳͷͰͯͶͳ͵ͬͪΒͰͳͷͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͷmͷͳͻͽͰ
ΔͰͷͅͳͻͽͳͬͰͷͽͳͬͪ̽ͪ͠ͷͪͼ͵ͳͪͲͳͬͪtͼͺͪͼͼͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪi
ͳͼͷͪͽͻͪͳͪΒͽͬͻΌͳͷͯ͵ͪͲͷͰͯ͵;ͳͬͰ̹ͱΒͰͼͳͶͰ͵ͪͽΒͰͳͲͺ;ͼͽͳΔ
ͼ͵ͰͼͽͰͰͺͽͰ͵Ͷͪͬͯͪ
ͽͪ͵ͼͰ
ͺͬΓͳ͊ͬͰͬͳΔͰͭ
ͷͱͰΒͪͬͳͽͳͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪ
ͪͫͶͪͭͯͪͽͪ;ͼͪͶΒͺͶͽͳΔͰͭͬͳ;ͭͯͳ͵ͪ̽ͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽͯͪΒͰͺ
ͽͷͼͬΒͼͽͬ;
͵ͪͳͺͰ͵ͳͷͯͻ;ͭͳͷͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͳͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͶͳ͵͊ͳͷͰͪ
͆ͰͷͪΔͰͭͻͪΌͰͺ;ͭͶͰͯ;ͪͼͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ͋ͷͰͼͰͷͱͰͺͻͳͯͯͪͽͳ
ͺͪͼ͵ͪͼͶͳͳͷ
ͪͲͬͳͷͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͷͼͬͪͷͪͫͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ͊Ͷ;ͼ͵
ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳͽͰ
ͲͪͼͰ
ͪ͵ͳΒͰͺͼͰͯͬͪͶͳͯͰͶͳΕͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳ
Βͪ
ͬͰΕͼͪͷ͵ͷͪͯͽ͵ͪͳͰͼͽͻͪͭͬͳͷͪ͵ͻͬͳ͋ͳΒͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳ͵ͪ
͵ͬ;ͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵;;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔ;͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͳͯͭͷͪͽͼ͵;ͳͺͻͪ͵ͽͳ;
ͼͫͲͳͻͷͪ
ͳͲͬͻ;ͼͬͰͽͽͪ͵;ͽͻͪͯͳͳΒ;ͶͳͰ;;ͼͽͪͬ;̻ͻͳͭͻͳΒͪ͆ͪͲͳΒͪͼ͵ͭͯͪͳ
Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵͵ͪͺͳ͵ͻͬͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳͷͪΒͰͯͪ͵;ͯͰͶͽͬͻͼͽ͵ͪͰͶ͵;ͺͽͰ
Ͷ̀ͪͽͺͳͽͪΔͰΒΒͰͺ;ͳΒͪͺͻͰͺͻ;͵ͪͬͪͪ̀͠Ͷͪͽ;ͼͽͭͬͰͻͳͷͪͯͪ
ͯͯͳͻ;ͳͫͭͻͶͰ͵ͬͰͭͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ΒͰͻͳͺͼͰͯ;Β;ͳͼͽ;ͷΕ͵ͪͳΔͳͬͰ
͵ͼͽͳ͈ͻͰͷͪͽͷͰ
ͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͳͷͰ
͵ͪͳͼͬͰͽͳ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰ
;Ͳͯͻ;ͭͰͷͳͻͽ
ͳͬͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰ
ͺͻͺͳͼΒͰͽͬͪͯͽͳͪΔͰͷͳͰͶͳͬͪΔͰͷͻͪ͵Ͱ
ͪͪͻͳ
ͽͲͪͬͪͽͪΔͰͷ;ͯͽͬͻͭͷͳͻͪ͋ͳͫͶͳͳ͵;ͶͽͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰ;ͺͽͺ;ͼͽͳͼ;
ͲͪͷͰͳͶͳtͬͳΌͰΔͰiΔͳͬͳͷͽͳΒ;
] ]
̸̸̺͇͈͉͇̺͊̾͋́͋̾͊̓͊̈́̾͢͡͡
̸̸͇͊́̾͆͆̾̾͢ͅͅ
͆ͪ͵ͻͪΒ;ͼͰͬͪΓͪͲͪͺͳͽͪͽͳ͵Βͳͼ;ͻͪͲͶͲͳ;ͽͳͪͶͳͪͽͯͪ͊ͪͬͪͰͬͰͷ
ͽͳͰ;ͳͳͰͽΓͰͳͷͪͅ͵ͪ͵ͼͶͱͰͳͼ͵;ͺ
ͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵ͫͪͶͼͪͷͬͪΔͪͼͬͪ
͵ͪ͵ͷ;ΒͰͫͳͺͲͪͽͳͯͼͽ;ͺͪ͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪΒͰͽͰͻͪͲͶͭͰͷͭ;ΕͰͯͬΒͪ͵
ͽ;ͷͪͳͽͳ͆ͪΒͺͻͰ
ͪ͊ͬͰͽΒ̻ͻͳ
ͪ͵ΒΒΒͰ͊ͳͷͰͺͻͰͷͳ;
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼ;
ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳͷͪͶͰͫͶͳ͵ͫͶͪͭ;ͪͳ͵ͼͽͳΒ;͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͰͽͻͰͫͪ
ͼͷͰͽ;ͽͳͼ;ͷͪͳͽͯͪͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͼͳͷͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͭͼͷͳͼͶͪ
Ͱͼͽͳͷͪ
ͶͰͰͺͼͻͰͯ;ͺͶͳͽͳ͵;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;
ͪͻͳͽͷͽͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͊ͽͭͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͷͽͳΒ;͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰͽͻͰͫͪͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͷ
͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
͵ͻͲͻͰͪͶͰ͵ͶͼͽͳͳͯͼͰͼͪͭͪ;ͽͪͯͪΔͰͷͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;̹;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪΒͰͻͰͶͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͻͯͪͰͶͳ͵ͼͪͱͰͯͳͪ
ͼͽͳΒͰ;;ͼͺ;
ΒͪͼΒͰͯͪͫͳͫͪͶͼͪͷͬͪΔͰmͻͪͬͺͻͭͶͪͰΔ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
mͫͳͶͼͺͻͪͬͷͺͻͽ;ͷͪͰ͵ͪͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͳ̓ͪͽͪ͵ͪͬ
ΒͰͫͳ;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͺͭͶͰͯ;ͰͺͻͳͬͪͽΓͳͬͳͫͰͲͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͭͳͲͭͶͰͯͪͪ;ͼͺͰ;
ͬͻͰͷͰ͊ͳͷͰͬͰͼͷͻͽͳͭͯͳͰ͋Ͱ͵ͪ͵ͻͪͼͺͪͯͪͯͽͪͯͪΔͰͭͺͻͰͽ
͵ͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ͊ͪͬͳͼͰͽͬͻͳͶͪͷͭ;ΕͼͽͯͪͺͼͽͰͺͰͳͷͳͺͻͷͳΓͰ
ͬΌͰͳͷͪ͵ͽͳͬͼͽͳͷͪm;͵ΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͼͺͪͯͪΒ;͊ͳͷͰͬͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ
ͳͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰm͊ͻͫͳΒͳͫͰͲͫͰͯͳͬͳͬͳͳͼͽͪͽ;ͼ;
ͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͳͪͻ̺ͯͪͰΕͭͯͳͰ
;ͳͲͷͰΔͰͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͼͯͻͱͪͬͷ
͵Βͪ ΒͰ ͫͳͶͪ ͷͰΌ;ͪͻͯ ͺͻͳͲͪͽͪ ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͪ
ͼ ͪ;ͽ͵ͰͿͪͶͷ ͻ͵ͬͷ ͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳͷͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͷͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͷͭͪͯͰͽͳͯͶ;͵;ͯͪͽͰͶͺͻͬͭ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͫͪͶͼͪͷ;ΒͰͳͼͬͰͪͳͲͶͱͳ;̿ͳͳ
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͷͳ͵ͻ;ͳͯ
ͫͰͷ ͻͪͷ; ̹ͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͪ ͽ;ͷͪͰΔͪ
͵Βͪ ͽͰͱͳͽͰ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ ͳ͵ͪͯͪ
ͳͼ;ͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪͪtͰͶ͵;ͺͼͽiͷͽͳΒ;
ͫͳͶͪͼ;
ͳͭͶͰͯΒͰ
ͺͻͰͬͶͪͯͪͪ
ͺͻͪͭͷͪͽͳͳΒͳͷͻͪͲͶͲͳͷ͇ͪͳͼ;ͺͪ͵ͺͳͬͪͶͳͪͼͬͰͼͽͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͷ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͲͪͪΒ;ͳͰͳͲͷͰͻΒͼ;ͭͰͼͽͳͬΒͷΕͳͽͪ͵ͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;Pͯͼ;ͪͺͺ;
Ͷͪͻ;ͺͫͱͼͽ
͵ͪͽͼ;ͳ͵ͳͬͽͳ;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;;ͬͪͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͳͪΒ;ͯ
ͽͬͻͳΒͷͬͻͼͽͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͪ͊ͽͰͽͪ͵ͰͭͶͰͯͳͽͪ
ͽͰ͵ΒͰͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰͷ
͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ͵ͪͳ;͵͵ͻͰͽͷͫͶͳΒ;;ͽͬͻΌͰ
ͫͻͪͲͪ
;ͼͪͭͶͪͼͼͽͳͼͪͼͽͪͯͪͻͯͳͷͪͬͻͰͷͰͪͳͯͬͰͶͳ͵ͭͲͪͪΒͪͲͪͺͽ
Δ;ͪͳͪͶ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒ;̹ͳΒͰͽͳͺͪ͵ͼͪͷͲͪͬͻͳͳͳ͵ͻ;ͪͳͻͰͭͳ
ͽͰͷͰΓͳͽͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΓͰͭͺͯ;ͬͪͽͪ͊ͺͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶͪͼ;ͽͳͪ͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;
ͪ
ͪͻͳͽΔͳͬͪͯͻͱͪͬͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͪͿ;͵ͳΒͪ
ͫͳͶͪΒͰͲͪͼͻͺͼ͵;ͼͻͰͯͳ;
ͪͽͻͪΒͪͽͰ͵ͬͳͪ͵ΒͪΒͰͺͻͳͼͽͰ͵ͶͪͳͲͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ͊ͳͷͰ
ͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
̸̸̸͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋
̸̺͇̻͇͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
̸͇͇̺͐́͆́͊̾̽̾͊͆͆́͠ͺͻͫͶͰͷͼ͵ΒͳͷͼͰͯͪͪͼͼ;ͪͬͪͺͻ;ͪͬͪͶͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ ͵;Ͷͽͬͪ Ͱͯ;ͷͳͪ ͵ ͳͲͫͻͪ ͺͻͳͷͰͻͰͭ ͷͰͽͯͪ ́ͼͽͳͪ
ͲͪͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳͯ;ͭΒͳͺͶͯͽͬͻΒͳͼͽͻͳΒͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͷͱͰͻͪ;ͪͽͳ
ͪͬͻͼͽͰͼͶͰmͰͼͪͷͪ͵ͻͳͽͳ͵ͪͳͲͯͪΔͪͳͲͬͻͪͬͰΕͳͪͽͰͷͰΓͰͼͽ;
ͯͳΒͰͅͰΌ;Δͳͷͪͼ;ͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͲͳ͵ͶͪͼͳͳͻͪͯͬͳͪͭͳͶͭͪͫͶͪͯͳͼͽͪ
ͪͶͳͳͯͺͻͳͼͳͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳͻ;ͼ͵ͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͪͼ͵ͻͪΒͪ9*9ͳͺͰͽ͵ͪ99
ͼͽͶͰΕͪ͌ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͯͬͰͯͽͻͳͯͰͰͳΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ
ͼ͵ͳ͵;ͶͽͬͪͫͰͶͰͱͰΒͰͬͳͯͳͷͲͪ͵ͻͰͽͷ͇ͼͰͳͼͺΓͪͬͪ͵ͻͲͳͻͰΔͰ
ͷͰͽͯͶ͵ͳ͵ͬͳͻͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͽͲͪͺͼͶͰͯͳ;ͳͷͪ;ͬΌͰΔͰͬͳ
ͳͺͻͰͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͰͬͰΕͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪͳͺͳͽͪΔ͈ͪͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳͳͺͻͯͻͳͽͰtͬͰͪ
ͭͳͶͭͳΒͰiͳͷͪΒ;ͼͬΒͰͺͶͪͲͳͽͰ;ͻͪͯͬͳͷ͈ͪ̾ͪͽͶͰͱͪ &WFMZO1BUMBHFBO
ͳΔͰΒ͵ͪ͵ͬͪΓͰΒͽͪ͵ͳͼͺͻͪͬͪΒͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪͶͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͪͪͶͳͲͳ
ͪ
ͪͻͳͽ;ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪͷ͈̹ͪͻͪ;ͪ 1FUFS#SPXO
͵ΒͳΒͰͽͰͱͳͽͰͼͬΒͳͳͼͺͳͽͳ
́ͼͻͺͪͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷ͵;Ͷͽͬͳͷͪ
͵ͶͪͼͳͿͳ͵ͬͪͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͼ͵ͳͳͽͰͻͳ
ͽͻͳΒͪͶ
JO4BJOUTBOEUIFJS$VMUT4UVEJFTJO3FMJHJPVT4PDJPMPHZ
'PMLMPSFBOE)JTUPSZ
FE4
8JMTPO
$BNCSJEHF
m ͭͯͰͼ;
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭ
ͪͬͰͯͰͳͳͻͪͯͬͳͫͶͪͯͳͼͽͪͪ
ͭͳͶͭͪ
̓ͪͽͪͶͭͳͲͯͪΔͪͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͱͳͽͳΒͪͺͻͳͻͰͯͳΒͰ')BMLJO
#JCMJPUIFLB)BHJPHSBQIJDB(SBFDB
WPM
#SVYFMMFTͲͪͺͽͪͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪPͺͻͫͶͰͷͳͷͪͳ
ͼͽͪΔ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͰͼͽͳJEFN
3FDIFSDIFTFUEPDVNFOUTEIBHJPHSBQIJFCZ[BOUJOF
#SVYFMMFT
́ͲͬͰͷͪͫͳͷͰͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰͬͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͳͲͯͬͪΒͪͷ̺̓ͶΉͰͬͼ͵ͳʹ
̽ͻͰͬͰͻ;ͼͼ͵JΊ
ͱͳͽͳΊDͬΊNΆ·͵ͪ͵΅ͳͼͽͻͳͰͼ͵ͳʹͳͼͽͳ͵·
ͅͼ͵̸͈ͬͪ̓ͪͯͶ;ͫͬͼ͵ͳʹ
͇Ͱͻ
͵ͳͺͳͼͽͻͳͳͯͻͰͬͰͻ;ͼͼ͵ʹͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻΆͱͳͽͳΊDͬΊͽΆ·
̺ͪͻͪͬͪ9̈́ͺͪͻͬ
̺ͳͲͪͽͳʹͼ͵ͳΊͱͳͽͳΊDͬΊͽΆ·7***m*9ͬͰ͵ͬ·
̺̺97**
97***
9*9
̻͈͍ͯͽͬ
͊ͬΊͽΆͰͯͻͰͬͰʹ͉;ͼͳ
1BSJT ͻͰͺͻͅͼ͵ͬͪ
1BUMBHFBO
"ODJFOOFIBHJPHSBQIJFCZ[BOUJOF
m̀ͪ͵ͻͳͽͳ͵;ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪͶͳͼͽͳ͵ͭͷͰͽ
ͯͪ;ͳͼͽͻͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
ͼͺͼͰͫͳͷͪͭͶͪͼ͵ͷͪͬͳͲͪͽͶͭͳΒͳ͠')BMEPO
͇ͺUIF4USVDUV
SBMJTU"QQSPBDIUPUIF4PDJBM͆JTUPSZPG#Z[BOUJVN
#Z[BOUJOPTMBWJDB
m
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͬͪΔͪ;ͼͷͰͻͳͪͯͻ;ͽͬͰͳ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;͵ΒͰͷͪͼͽͪΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͳ
͉ͪͲͶͭͰͲͪͳͲͷͰΔͰͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͺͻͫͶͰͷ;ͽͻͰͫͪͽͻͪͱͳͽͳ;ͺͬͷͯͻͰΌͰ
Δ;ͼͪͷͭͺΒͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ̀ͪͷͯͰͻͰͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͰͽΒͰͳͲ;ͲͰͽ
ͼͶͱͰͪͺΒͪͬͪmͯͻͰΌͰͪͼͺͼͽͬͰͷ
ͬͪͬͻͰͷͰͼ͵ͷͳͻͰͶͳͭͳͲͷͼ;
ͽͳͷ
ͪͶͳͳͰͺͼͻͰͯ;ͼͶͬΓͰͪͯͪͽͳͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷͽͻͰ;ͽ͵ͷ
͵ͪͳ
ͻͰͰͺͳΒͷͪΒͳͻͰͯͻ;ͽͬͰͰͲͪΒͰͯͳͰ͇ͫͶͳͳ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͪͳͳͼͺΓͪ
ͬͪΔͪ͵;Ͷͽͪͽͪ͵ΌͰͼ;ͷͭͼͽͻ;͵ͳ
ͺͪΒͰͽͪ͵ͪͬͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪͽͼ;
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͳ
ͪͭͳͶ͵ͳͳͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͪͶͳͳͯͻ;ͭͳͺͳͼͪͳͳͲͬͻͳ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͪͳ͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰͯͪͪͼͫͪͬͰͪͻͰͶͭͳΒͪͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͪ
;ͷͰͽͼͽͳ͈ͻͫͶͰͷ͵;ͶͽͬͪͰͺͼͻͰͯͲͪͯͳͻͰͳ;ͺͳͽͪΔͰͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰ
ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰͳͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͪ
ͪͶͳͳͭͷͰͽͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ͵ΒͳͼͰ͵ͬͳͻͲͪͪ
ͬͪͺΒͷͷͺͺ;ͶͪͻͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵Ͱͺͫͱͼͽͳ͇ͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͰͲͪͳͽͰͭͻͪͶͳ
ͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰͳͻ͵ͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ͵ͳ͵ͬͳͻͪͺͼͽͪͶͳͼ;ͽͪ͵
ͺͶͪͲͪͼͬͪͷͭͳͷͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͷͪͪ;ͽͻͳͷͪͳΒͳͼ;ͻͪͯͬͳ͵;ͺΓͰͳ
;Ͳͫͻͳ͵;ѮF #Z[BOUJOF 4BJOU1̓ͻͷͪ͵; 3PCJO$PSNBDL
͈̻ͳͻͳΒ; 1B
USJD(FBSZ
ͳͶͳ,̻ͪͶͪͽͪͻͳͽ; $BUJB(BMBUBSJPUPV
mͯͪͺͷͰͰͷͼͪͷͰ͵ͪ
ͯͳͷͰͪͳͳΒͳͼͰͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͳ;ͪ;ͳͬͳͰͰͷͭ;ͲͪͫͳΕͳ
͌ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͪ
͵ͻͪΕͪͳ
ͯͺͻͳͼͳͷͪͼ͵;ͯͳΒͪ
ͯͪͶͪΒͰͳͺͪ͵ͬͻͰͯͪͯͰͶͪΒ;ͻͪͯͬͳͷ͚ͪ;ͻͰ̽ͪͳ
ͳΕͪ
͈Ͱͽͻ͈ͪͻͽͳΕͪ
́Ͷͪͻͳ͉ͪ;ͬͪͻͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͪͅͳͻ͵ͬͳΕͪ
̺Ͷͪͯͳ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪͯͳͶͪͲͳͷͭ;ΕͼͽͳΒͰͯͭͻͪͯͪ
ͺͪͼͷͼͰͬͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͭͻͪͳͳͶͳͪ
ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͰͯͬͪͺͼͰͫͪͺͳͽͪΔͪͺͼͽ;ͺ͵ͪ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ;Ͳͻͪͳͽ;ͷͪͰΔͪΔͰͭͬͰͼͪͯͻͱͳͰͳͿ;͵ͳ
ΒͰͼͫͲͳͻͷͪ͵;ͶͽͷͽͳΒ;͉ͳͲͳͳͽͪ͵ͬͭͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪm͵Βͳͷͳͼ;ͫ;ͬͪ
ΕͰͳͼͬͳͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͳ͊ͳͷͰͬͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͪͻͳͽͳͽͳͰͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͯͰ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰͳΔͰͳͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳ;ͲͻͪmͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͳͼ;ͼͬͰͼ
;ͳͷͰ
ͺ͵;ͪΒͪͯͪͼͰͺͻͫͶͰͷͺͼͽͪͬͳ;ͳͻͰͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ͵Ͱ͵ͬͳͻͰͰͭͽΒͰͽ
ͯͼͪͯͳΔͰ
͊ͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ ͊ͳͷͰͪ ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ ;ͱ ΒͰ ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳ ;
ͼͺͼͽͬͰͷͬͻͰͷͰ;mͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͪͻͳͽ;Ͱͽͪͺ;;ͯ;ͭΒͳͼͽͻͳΒͳͳͼ
ͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͪ̽ͼͪͯͪΔͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͯͻͰͯͪͼ;ͼͪͭͶͪͼͳ;
Ͱͳͯͪͼ;9**ͳ9***ͬͰ͵;ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;ͯͫͪͳͲͻͪͲͳͽͰͼͰ͵Ͱ
͵ͪ͵ͺͫͻΒ;ͳ
;ͭͶͰͯ;ͬ;ͬͻͽͰͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͽͪ͵ͳͺͯͷͰͽͳͷͪͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ͵Βͪͳ
ΒͰͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪͶͪ͆ͪ͵ͺͶͰͽͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;
͵ͪͯͪͼͰΒͪͬΓͪ
ͳͲͲͪͪΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͳΒͪͼͰͱͳͽͳΒͪͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;ͺͻͰͷͪͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͷͷͪ
͵ͳͷͳͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵ͳͷͫͻͪͼͳͷͪ
ͪͼͽ;ͺͳͶΒͰͬͻͰͷͰͼ͵Ͱͺͽͳͭͳ͵ͻͳͽͳ͵ͭ
ͯͼͪ ͺͻͰͷͪ ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳͳͷͪ ͽ ͼ; ͺͻͰͽͰͯͬͪͶͳ ͪ ͼͬͰͽͼͽ ͈ͷͰͻͪΔͰ
ͽͰͱͳͽͪͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;ΒͰͬͰΕͼͪͷͪͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͬͰΕͳͪͬͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳΒͰͺͻͳ
ͺͪͯͪͶͪ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͳͺͯͬͳͱͳ͵ͪ͵ΒͪΒͰͻͪͳΒͰͺͻͰͬͶͪͯͪͬͪͶͪ
ͬͰΕͬͻͬͳͷͪ
ͯ;ͬͰ
ͺͪͳͼͬͰͽͬͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ͋ͻͪͲͯͫΓͰͯͼͳͳͷͭͰͺͻͷͰͰ
͵ΒͰͼͰͯͼͰͪͺͻͰͼ;ͼͽͪͬΓͰΔͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ́Ͳͬͻ;ͻͳΕͪͼ͵;ͺͻͪ͵ͼ;
mͭͶͪͪͬͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ;ͯͳͷͪͳͼͺͽͪͳͻͪͼͽͽͬͪΔͪ;;ͽͪͻͶ͵ͪͶ
ͰͲͪΒͰͯͳͰmͺͽͳͼ;ΒͰΒ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͯͫͪͲͪͽͼͶͱͰͳΒͳ
ͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵
ͳΒ;͵ͼͳ;ͳͰͺͻͪͶͪͱͰΔͰͷͽͳΒ;
ΔͳͬͪͼͬͰͪͪͽͻͪ
ͼͶͪͳΒͪͳ;ͯͪͽͼͰͲͫͳͬͪΒ;͵ͭͻ̹ͫͪͳͽͪͬͳͪ9***ͬͰ͵ͪͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ΒͰ
ͿͻͷͪͶ
ͼͪͫͻͺͻͭͶͪͰΔͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͋ͪ͵ͬͪͺͻͪ͵ͼͪ
ͻͪͳΒͰͰͺͲͪͽͪ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼ;ͷ;ͫͰͲͫͰͯͳͶͰͽͻͪΒͪͺͷͰ;ͺͽͷͼͽͬ;
ΒͰͷͭͪͫͳͽͳ;ͬͻͽͰ;͵ͪͽͰ
ͭͻͳΒ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͲͪ;͵ͪtͫͶͪͭͬͰͻͳͪͻͰͬͳͳ͵ͰͱͰͬͳi͆ͳΒͰ
ͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͻͳͫͰͭͶͽͪ͵ͬͷͻͰͰΔ;͌Ͳͯͻ;ͭͰͻͪͲͶͭͰ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽΒͰͻͰͪͶB
ͺͶͱͪΒ͊ͻͫͪ;ͽͪͯͪΔͰͷͺͻͰͽ͵;ͯͻͱͪͬͪͳͺͪ͵ͺͻͰͼ;ͯ;ͽͳͪͪͳͲͫͻ
ͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰͭ
ͲͪͽͼͶͱͰͳΒͰͭͺ;ͽͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͺͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͳͼͺ;ΔͰΔͰͬͳͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͬͪΌͰͼ͵ͳͻͷͳ͵ͻͲ;ͬͰͻΓͳͬͰͺͽͬͻͯͰͶͳͭͫͶͪͭͪΕ͈ͪͻͬͳͽͪ͵ͪͬ
ͯ͵ͪͲͫͳͶͳͼ;͆ͰͷͪΔͳͪͪͫͯͳ͵ͪͳΒͪͳͷͪͰΔͰͭͯͳͰ
ͫͻͪͲͶͱͰͳ
ͫͻͳͭͷͲͪͼͺͪͼͰΔͰͯ;ͰͳͺͻͳͬͷͯͪͺͼͶͰͯ;ΒͰ͎ͻͳͼͽ;͌ͼͶͰͯͳΒͰ
ͭͯͳ;
ͯͪͪ͵ͪͼͳΒͰ
ͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͪ͊ͬͰͽ;̻ͻ;̺ͰΕ;ͽͷͳ;ͫͳͶͪΒͰͼͪͯͻͱͪͪ͵ͻͪΒΔͪ
ͼͬͻͪ͵Β;
ͯͯ;ͰͯͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͳͲͯͻͰΌ;ΒͰ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͺͲͪͽͳͷ͊ͪͬͳ
ͳͷͻͰͳͷͪͯͪΕͰͼͰͯͶͪͼ͵ͷ̸ͪͽͼ͊ͳͷͰͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͽͳͳΒͪͬͳͽͳ͵ͪͺ
ͯͫͪͼͬͰͽͷ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒ;̽ͳͼͽͪ
ͺͻͬͳͳͺͼͽͰͺͰͳ͵ͻͪͳ;ͽͷͺͻͪͬ;
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͊ͳͷͰͬΒ;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͽͳͺͳ͵;
͵ͪͳͺͳͻͪͪͻͰ͎ͭͪͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͬͰΓͰ ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭ
͵Βͪ ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ ͼͰ ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͷͭͶͪ ͳͷͪͽͳ ;Ͷͭ;
ͼͬΒͰͬͻͼͭ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͭͱͳͽͳΒͪ͆ͪͻͳͽͲͪͪΒͲͪͪͼͽͪͪ͵͵;ͶͽͪͳͷͪΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵
͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͲͪͺͳͼͼͷͻͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
ͼͪ;ͬͪ;̓ͻͪͽ͵ͷͱͳ
ͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ͋ΒͰͺͼͰͫͪͼͪͼͽͪͬ
ͺͳͼͪͰͺͼͻͰͯͪ͵ͺͻͰͼͪ
͊ͳͷͰͬͳͷͽͳΒ;;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͰͼͪ;ͬͪͶͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͰͬͳ
ͪmͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͷͪͪm͊ͳͷͰͬΒͼͷͻͽͳͳͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔ;
͢Ͱͭͬͪͳͼ͵Γ;ͳͬͪͽͰͷͪΒͰtͼͬͰͽͪͼͷͻͽ
͵Βͪ͵ͬͪͶͳͿͳ͵;ΒͰͼͬͰͽͭͪͳͺͻͪͬͯͪͬͪ
͵;Ͷͽi̽ͻ;ͭͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ
;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͲͪͺͳͼ;ͯ͵;ͷͰͽͪͻͳ;ͬͰͻΓͳͬ
ͺͳͼͪͳͼ;;ͺͻͪͬͳͯͭͪΌͪΒͳ͵ΒͳͳͰͭͶͪͬͰͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͰͰͶͰͷͰͽͰͪͭͳ
ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ͽͰͼͽͭͪͳͷͪΒ;ͺͻͰͼ;ͯ;;Ͷͭ;;ͭͻͪΌͰΔ;͵;Ͷͽͪ
͊ͳͷͰͬͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;ͳͺͯͳͲͪΔͰͽͰͶͪ
ͫͪͬΓͰͼͪͷ
ͭͯͳͪͪ͵ͼͪͻͪͰ
ΒͰͼ;ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͬͪͱͪͯͭͪΌͪΒ;ΔͰͭͬͷͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔ;
̽ͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽͯͪͼ;ͭͪͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͺͳͼͪͶͳ͊ͪͬͪ͵ͻͪͽ͵ͼͬͰ
ͯͳͽͷͰ͵ͪ͵ΒͰ;ͺͯͰͼͷͽͻͰ;ͽ͵;ͽͬͻͳͭͻͫͳͺͻͪͪtͰͶͳ
ͰͺͬͻͰΌͰiͽͰͶ
ͯ͵͈ͻͬͬͰͪͳͽͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ;ͺͽͰͰͺͷͳΔͰ
ͭͅͺͯͻͫͳΒͰͳ;ͫͳͽͳͷͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰͳͼͽͷͯͭͪΌͪΒ;ͭ
ͬͻͰͺͲͳΒͳͺͳͼͳm̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ͇ͳͽͬͻͯͰͯͪΒͰͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ
ͫͳͶͺͻͪΕͰͫͳͶͳͷͽͰΔͰͷͷͳͻͪm͵ͪ͵ͳͲͼͪͷͭͭͻͫͪͽͪ͵ͳͳͲͪͼͶͳ
͵ͪͭͶͳ͵ͪ͊ͳͷͰ͎ͬͭͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͳͻͽͰΔͰ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰͺͻͰͯ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪͺͻͫͶͰͷ͵Βͳ;ͪ;ͳͳΒͰͲͫͳΓͺͻͰͽͻͰͼͪΒͯͬͻͰͷͰͪ͵ͪͯͪͭͪ
ΒͰͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪ̽̓ͼͽͳΕ̺ͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽ;ͯͪΒͰͼͺͻͪͬͪͳΔͰͳͷͯͪ
ͭͪͰͺͷͳΔ;ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳͫͳͭͻͪͿͳ
ͬͰΕͽͰ͵ͺͲͳΒͳͺͳͼͳ
ͪͰͼͪͭͶͪͼͼͽΔͳ
ͬͳͼͬͰͯͰΔͪͽ;ͷͪͳΒͰͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳͷͺͻͰ͵ͶͷͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͪ
ͽͪͳΒͰmͺͻͰ
ͳͷͳͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪͯͬͰΒ;ͼͻͰͯͳͪͲͪͳͳΒͰ͵ͪtͼͬͰͽͭͻͼ͵͵ͪͶ;ΌͰͻͼ͵ͳ
ͻͪͲͶͭi
ͼΒͰͯͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͳtͻͪ͵ͯͻͱͪͬͽͬͻͳi
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰ͐ͳͳͼͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͯͪ
ΒͰͺͳͽͪΔͰͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͷͳͻͽͰΔͪͲͪͽͼͶͱͰͳΒͰ͠ͰͯͪͯͭͶͪͬͳ̓
ͼͽͳΕͰͬͳͪͻͭ;ͷͰͪͽͪͭ;ͫͳͪͼͪͲͳ͵ͪͯͪͼͰͲͪͯͪͽͷ;ͯ;ͳͲͻͳ͵ͷͼͬͰͯ
ͳͰͬͳͯͪͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ
ͺͷͰ;ͽͳ͊ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͲͪͺͳͼͪͼͷͻͽͳ͊ͳͷͰͬΒ͊
ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͲͪͺͪͱͪΔͰͯͪ;ͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͳͷͪͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͳͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭ͵ΔͳͱͰͬ
ͭ͵ͻ;ͭͪͺͼͽΒͳͯͼͶͰͯͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ;ͺͳͼ;ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ͊ͳͷͰͬͭͺͻͬͭ
ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪͼͪͱ;ΒͰͳͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͳͻͽͰΔͰ
ͼͳͷ͊ͪͬͰ
ͳ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭ
ͰͺͷͳΔͰͳ͊ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͰͻͰͯͪ͵ͳΒͰ͈ͻͶ͵ͭ
ͱͳͽͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
ͪͼͽͪͶͰ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ͵mͭͯͳͰ
͈͵;ͪΒͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͪͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ;ΔͰͭͬΒͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ΒͻͰͪͶͼͽͳͫͳΒͰͯ
ͯͪͽͲͪͷͪͭΓͰͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͷ
;ͼͬͳͺͭͻͰͷ
ͯͪͫͳ
ͺͻͬ
ͪ;ͽͰͽͳ
ͼͽͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͷͳͻͽͰΔͪͪ;ͽͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͺͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶͪ;ͬͻͽͰΔͰ;ͼͬͰ
ͽͳͽͰΓͰͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ
ͯͪͫͳͯͪͷͻͪͶͫͳͽͳͫͪͬΓͰ;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;
͵ͪ͵
ͽͷͰͼͬͰͯͰ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ̓ͪͯͪΒͰͷͳͻͽͰΔ;ͻͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͪͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͪͺ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͯͪͽ;ͯͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͽͰ͵ͲͪͷͰ
ΔͰ
ͷͪͯͪΒͰͯͯͪΒͬͰΕͳ
͵ΒͳͷͼͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͭͶͪͪͬͪ
ͪͰͳͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰ
͇ΒͰͼͪͷΒͰͯͪ
ͳͪ͵ͬͰͷͪͬͪͱͪͰͽͪͺͪͼͶͱͰͭͺͼͽ;ͺ͵ͪ;ͬͻͽͰΔͪ;
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰ
Ͱͷ;ΕͰΒͫͳͽͳͻͰͳ͌ͰͺͼͻͰͯΒͬͰͲͳͼͽͳͷΒͰͳ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
ͬͼͬͰͯͰΔͰ
͵ΒͰ;ͺͭͶͰͯ;ͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽͳͺͼͽͪͬΓͪͺͻͰͯͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͰ
Ͱ͵ͪͽͰ͵ͻͰͳͬͪͺͳͽͪΔͪ͆ͪ͵ͷͳͻͽͰΔͪͳ;ͯͪͽͼ;;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪ
ͪ;
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
ͽͬͻͳͰͷ;ͺͻͪͲͳ͵i
ͪͯͪͬͅͰͷͪͼͶͪͫͪͺͻ;ͰͼͽͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭ
ͺͼͽ;ͺ͵ͪ t͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͰi Ͱ ͯͪΒͰ ;ͺͻͳͽͪ Ͳͪ ͳͶͰ ͺ;ͲͯͪͳΒͰ Ͳͪ͵Γ;͵Ͱ
ͼͽͪΒͰͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͽͪ͵ͬ
ͿͳͳΒͰͶ;ͬͻͽͰΔͰ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰmͫͰͲͫͲͳͻͪ
ͪͻͪͭͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͰ͵ΒͪͭͪΒͰͫͪͬͳͶͪmͳΒͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰ;ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͼͬͰ
ͽ;ͺͻͰͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͰͽͬͻͽͳͰ9***ͬͰ͵ͪ͊ͽͭͪΒͰͷͪͶͬͰͻͬͪͽͯͪΒͰͼͺͻͬͰ
ͯͰ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͳͷͰ;mͪͼͪͷͷͺͰͽ͵;9***ͼͽͶͰΕ͇ͪͼͳͷ
ͽͭͪ
ͻͰͳͽͪ ΒͰ ͵Ͷͼͽ ͯͪ ͬͪΒ ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬ ͳͼ͵ͪͲ Ͱ ͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰ ͳΒͰͯͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳͳͲͬͻ
;͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͳͺͷͰ;ͽͳ̀ͪͺͳͼͼͷͻͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
͵Βͳ
ͳͪͰͳͲͻͳͳͽͭͬͻͳͷͳͻͽͰΔ;͌ͽΒͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
Ͱͺͼͽ
ΒͳͼͪͭͶͪͼͼͽ;;ͽͪͻͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͪͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͭ͵ͻ;ͭͪ͊ͪͷͺͼͰͫͳ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬͺͳͼ͊ͳͷͰͬͰt͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͰiͳͷͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵
ͺͻͬͻͪͲͻͰͯͳ
ͲͪͪΒͲͪͽͽ
ͼ͵ͶͳͼͷͯͪͬͰͻ;ΒͰͷ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;ΒͰͺͻͪ͵ͼ;ΔͰͭͬͭͯͫͪ͊ͽ
ͭͪͫͳͼͰ
;ͲͽͻͰΕͳͽͻͺͪͻͯͰͬͰͽͰͺͰͼͷͰ;͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬΒ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳͼͬͰͽͷ͈Ͱͽͻ;
̓ͻͳ͵ͷ
ͷͭͪͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͻͰͽ͵ͳͷͳͯͻͪͭͰͳͷͺͯͪͽ͵ͷͽͷͰͯͪΒͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͼͻͰͯͳͪͫͳͶͪ;ͺͲͪͽͪͼͺͻͪ͵ͼͷͼͪͫͻͭͺͻͭͶͪͰΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
ͶͪͽͳͼͰͺͳͼͪΔͪͺͻͼͽͻͪͭͱͳͽͳΒͪͳͲͪͬͻͳͭͪͯͭͯͳͰ̀ͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;
ͯ͊ͪͬͳͭͱͳͽͳΒͪ
ͼͽͬͻͰͭ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳtͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭi͵;Ͷͽͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪͬ
ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪͻͯͪͰͶͳ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͻͯͰͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
ͪ͊ͳͷͰͬ͵;ͶͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͪtͼͬͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͰiͼͬͰ͆ͰͽͯͳΒͰͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͰΒͰͬͰΕͺͷͰ;ͽ͈ͻͶ
͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͳͷͰͬ
͵ΒͰΒͰͳͷͪͶ;Ͷͭ;͵ͻͪͽ͵ͭ
ͼͳͪ͵ͼͪͻͼ͵ͭͱͳͽͳΒͪ
͌ͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷͽͻͰΕͰͳͶͳͺͰͽ͵ͷͰͽͬͻͽͰͯͰͰͳΒͰ
ͪͼͽͪͶͪΒͰ
͵ͪ͵
ͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͳͲͪͬͻͪͻͰͯͪ͵ͳΒͪ͊ͪͬͳͰͼͶ;ͱͫͰ̽ͫͻΒͰͲͪͯͪͼͰ;ͼͪ
ͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͽͭ
ͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭ͵ͻ;ͭͪ
ͺͰͬͯ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰ
͊ͳͷͰͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽͲͪͪͬͪ
͵ͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͷͳͻͽͪ
ͪΔͰͭͬͰͷͽͳ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͰͳ;ͯͽͬͻͰ̹ͳ
ΒͰͽ͵ͻͪΒΔͳͳͼͯͯ;ͭͭͳͼͶͱͰͭͺͼͽ;ͺ͵͇ͪΒͰͳͲͬͰͯͰͼͪͼ;ͬͰͻͰͳͷ
ͺͲͪͬͪΔͰͷͪͭͳͶ͵ͳͫͻͪͲͪͪͳ;ͺͻͪͬͷͽͻͰ;ͽ͵;mͪ͵ͼͶͷͪͬͳ
ͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͭͺͻͰͽ͵ͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͭͯͳͰ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͼͽͬͻͰͺͻͼͽͻͲͪ;ͲͯͳͲͪΔͰ
ͬͭ
ͪͳͪͶͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͌ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͷͫͳͪΒͰͷ
ͭͻͪͳͪͽͪ͵ͪͺͻͰͶͪͼ͵ͪ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͽͰ͵ͼͰͷͱͰͯͻͰͯͳͽͳ͇ΒͰͪ
ͭͬͰͽͰͬͰΕ;ͺͰͽͳͷͫͶͳͳͷͪͽͬͪΔͪ
ͪͺͻͰͯͰͺͷΕ;ͫͻͪͲͪ
ͪ͵ΒͳͺΒͪͷͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͳͰͺͻͰͺͲͪͽΓͳͬͳͷ
ͷͭ;Ε;Β;ΔͰͭͬ;
ͺͼͽ;ͺ;ͻͰͰͺͳΒ;ͳͽͪ͵;ͽͳͻ;ͺ;ͽ͵;Ͷͽ;ͯΔͰͭͬͳͲͪͬͻͳ
ͳͷ
Ͷ͵Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͪͶͳͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͫͶͳ͵͈ͪͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ͊ͳͷͰͪ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭͳͷͪͶΒͰ
Ͳͪͳ
ͽͪͯͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰͫͶͳ͵͋ΒͰ ¢nagnÝrisivmͺͽͬͻ
ΌͳͬͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͷͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪͳͪͼͬ;ͬͰΕ
ͲͪͰͽͭͽͬͪΔͪͶͳͼͽͳ
ͲͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯͷͭͿͻͷͪͶͳΒͰ;ͼͽͻΒͰͭͺͻ
ͭͶͪͰΔͪm¢nak²ryzivmͬͰͷͪͫͶͳͼ͵ͭͻͳͷ͵ͪͽͶͳ͵ͷDBOPOJTBUJP
ͼ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͷͰͻͪΔͰͺͻͪͲͳ͵ͪ͵ͪͯͪͼͰͺ͵ͶͺͳͼͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͺͼͽͷ͊ͽͭͪΒͰͺͼͽ
ΒͪͶͪͷͭ;ΕͼͽͯͪͼͰ͊ͳͷͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͺͻͳ͵Γ;ͳ͊ͳͷͰ;̹ͭͺͻͳͷ; ͿͰͫͻ;ͪͻ
͵ͪ
;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͰͷͳ
;Ͳͽ
ͳͼͽͳͷͰͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;
W̓ͼͽͳΕ
PQDJU
m͋ͻͳͿ;ͬͳΕ
PQ
DJU
m
̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
̓ͻͪͽ͵ ͱͳͽͳΒͰ ͼͬͰͽͭ ͊ͪͬͰ
JEFN
́ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
m ͼͪ ͼͽͪͻͳΒͷ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
̓ͻͪͽ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
͆ͪͼͬ;ͺͯͻͫͰͪͪͶͳͲͰͻͪͼͺͶͱͳͬͰͭͻͪΌͰͽΒͰͺ͵ͪͲͪΒ̽̓ͼͽͳΕ
PQDJU
m
͇ͽͷͺͳͽͪΔ;ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬΓͪ͊(BMBUBSJPUPV
͋IF.BLJOHPGB4BJOU
m ͼͺͼͰͫͳͷͼͬͻ
ͽͷͪͺͻͪ͵ͼ;9**ͬͰ͵ͪ
5BMCPU
PQDJU
ͼͪͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͠Ͱͯͪ͵Ͳͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵ͳͲͬͰΒͰ͚͋ͻͳͿ;ͬͳΕ PQDJU
͵ΒͳΒͰͯͶ;ͯͫͪͳͷͳΓͰΔͰͺͻͭͶͪͰΔ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͭ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̀ͪͳͷΓͳͬͺͻͫͶͰͷ;ͬͰͲͳͼͽͳͷΒͰͼͽͰ;Ͷͭͪͻ͵ͬͰͳΔͰͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
̓ͪͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͪ͵ΒͪΒͰͼͳͶͪͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͭͺͻͪͲͬͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͻ͵ͬͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͺͻͳͻͯͳͼͽͬͪͻͳ
ͫͳͶͪͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͲͪͳͳͶͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ͋ͪ͵ͬͪ;Ͷͭͪ
ͷͰΌ;
ͽͳͷ
ͳΒͰͷͻͪͶͪͺͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͽͳͳͰͺͼͻͰͯ;ͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬ;͋ͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͪ
ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͪ ¢nagnÝrisiv͵ΒͪͽͰͱͳͽͰͼͽͪͬΓͪͪ;ͯͰͼ;ͳͷͻͪͶ;ͻͰͪͶ
ͼͽͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪmͪͼͽͬͪͻ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͪͰΔͰͭͬͳͼͽͳͽ;
ͳͪͶͲͬͪͳͰΔͰmͼͬͯͳͶͪΒͰͯͰͶͬͪΔͰͻ͵ͬͰ
;ͻ;ͽͳͼ͵ͳͷͼͶ;ͪΒͰͬͳ
ͷͪ
ͪSBUJIBCJUJPQPTUGBDUVN
ͺͻͳͲͪΔͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͺͫͱΒͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͬͰΕ
;ͬͪͽͳ͵ͻͰͪ̽ͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰΒͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷt͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͰiͶͳͼͽͳͳͲͬͻͬͪ
ͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͼͬͰͽͬͰ
͵ͪͳͯ;ͬͰ
͵ͪͯͪͼͰͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͪͻ͵ͬͰ
ͳͲͻͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬͳ
ͻͪͲͶͭͪ
ͳͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ͵ͪͺͻͰͼ;ͯͪ͊ͶͳΒͰͷͻͪͶͫͳͽͳͳ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͊ͳͷͰͬͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͰͺͻͺ;ͽͪΒ;ͯͪͳͼͽͪ͵;ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬtͼͬͰͽͰͭ
ͼͪͫͻͪi;ͼͬͳͷͬͪͱͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪͪͺ;ͽ;ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ͢ͰͭͬΒͰͲͪͯͪͽͪ͵
ͫͳͯͪͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳͷͻͳͽ;ͪͶͳͷͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪ͵;Ͷͽ;ͫͰͲͫͰͯͳͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͳ
ΒͪͬͳͫͶͳ͵́ͼͽͳͳͲͬͻͳ
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͰͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;ͳͷͪͶͼ;ͷΔͰ;ͽ
ͯͪΒͰͽ͵ͷͳͽͪͬͭͺͯ;ͬͪͽͪͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͪͫͳͶͪ;͊ͪͬͳͳͷͻ;͵ͪͷͪm͵ͪ͵;
͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;
;ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΒͰͽͪͺͳ
ͽͪ͵ͳΒͲͪͬͻΒ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ
͊ͪͬͪͬͰΕͫͳͻ;͵ͺͶͱͰͲͪͪͻͳͷͪͯͻͳͽͪͳͪͽͪΒͪͳͿͪ͵ͽͳ͵ͳͯͪ
ͪͰͶ͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰ
͆ͪͺͻͰͯͼͺͼͽ;ͺͳͷͽ͵ͷ͊ͳͷͰͬͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ;ͫͶͳͪͬͪͼͰͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒΔͰͭͬͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ͠ͰͲͭͻͷ;ͳͳͼͽ;ͺΔͰͬͳͽͭͻͪΌͰͪͳͯͰΒͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ;ͷ
ͪ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;
͵ΒͪͶͰͱͳ;ͼͪͷΒͼͬͳͺͽΔͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻ
ͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ
ͪͶͳͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͉ͪͪͲͬͳΒͪͪ͵ͻͲͺͷͰ;ͽͰ
͵;ͶͽͰͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͰ
ͪΒͰͯͬͻ;ͪͯͬͰͯͰͪͪ͵͊ͳͷͰͬͭ;ͬͻͽͰΔͪ;
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰ
ͪͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͳͲͻͪͲͯͫͳͶͪΒͰ;͊ͪͬͳΒͼͶ;ͱͫͳͳͲͪͬͻΒ͈ͬͪ
Ͷͳ;ͱͳͽͳΒ;͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭ͋;ͼͰ
ͳͼͽͳͪΔͰͷͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͳ
;ͺ;Β
ͷͰͻͳͽ͵ͻͳͬͪͼͶΒͰͬͳͽͼͽͳͯͰΒͰͬͶͪͯͪͻ;ͷͪ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;
͵ΒͪΒͰͼͺͻͬͰ
ͯͰͪ;ͯͬͪͼͬͪ͵ͬͳͻͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ͵ͷͳΒͪͼͽͳ͵ͷͳͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͷ
́ͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ͆ͰͷͪΔͰͯͻͱͪͬͳ͵ͪͽͰͷͰΓͳͼͰͪͺͽͳͷͪͰͶͳͷͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ
͵ͬͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͌ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰͽͺͳͽͪΔͰͺͯͻͫΒͰͻͪͲͷͽͻͰ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
;ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͳ͊ͷͳΓͰͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ͋;ΒͰͺ;ΌͰͪͳͯͫͻͲͪͼͬͪ
ͪͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͳͲͪͳΒͪ
ͪͼͬ;ͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪͳͯ;ͱͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ͵ΒΒͫͳͼͰtͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͳiͶͳ͵͆ͰͷͪΔͳmͪͺͽͷͳΔͰͭͬͳͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͪ
mͳͼͺΓͳ;ͯͬͪͼͬͪͬͳ͈ͯͪͻͬͳ
͵ΒͳͺͰͽͼ;ͬͯͳͺͻͰ͵ͶͳͲͪͻͪͳͰ
ͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͰ
ΒͰͼͽͰͺͫͰͯͼͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͻͪͽͳ͵͋ͪ͵ΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͪtͬΒͳ͵ͼͳͶ
ͳi
tͺͫͰͯͳͽͰΓͲͷͳΒͰͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͼ͵ͰiͳͽͰͶͬΓͰΔͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰ
ͽͪmtͼͬͳͷͪͯͳͬͪͳͼͽͻͪͪͬͶͪͯͪͻi
̽ͻ;ͭͳ
ͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͳ
ͯͻͰΌ;ΒͰ ͆ͰͷͪΔ; ͵ͪ ͫͭͳͲͪͫͻͪͭ ͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪ ͯͻ
ͱͪͬͰ
ͺ;ͭͶͰͯ;ͪͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͭͪ͠͵ͬͪ
ͬΌ;ͳͲͪͫͻͪͭͪͻ͉ͯͪͰΒͰ
ͽͰͷͰΓͷ͵Ͱͺͽ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰͳͫ;ͬͪͽͪͪΒ
ͬͪͱͳΒͰͬͶͪͯͪͶͪ͵ͰͬͻͶͳͰ͇͵ͬͳͻͷ;ͳͳͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͪͰͽͳ͵ͪ
ͺͪΒͰͽͪ͵
ͺͻͰͷͪ ͬͪͱͰΕͰͷ ͫͻͪͼ;
͆ͰͷͪΔͪ ͽͰͶͬΓͰΔͰ ͺͫͱͼͽͳ ͳ ͺͻͪͬͰͯͼͽͳ
̓ͪSͰJVTUVT
ΒͰtͲͪͼͽ;ͺͳ͵;ͯͬͳͪi
tͻͪͳͽͰΓͼͳͻͽͳͷͪi
tͺͽͺͻͪͫͰͲ
ͪͯͰͱͳͷͳͫͶͰͼͳͷi͊ͳͷͰΒͰͽͪ͵ΌͰͻͪUSPOVTFDDMFTJBFmtͻ͵ͬͰͫͱΒͰ
ͯͰͶͪͽͰΓiͳtͻ͵ͪͬͪͼͪͲͯͪͽͰΓi
tͪͻͳΒͰͻͰΒͳͷͪͯͫͻ;ͽͬͻΌͰΔͰi͈;ͭͶͰͯ;
ͪͺͻͻ͵ͪ̽ͪͬͳͯͪ
ΒͰSͰFUQSPQIFUB͆ͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͲ;ͯ;ͱͼͽͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ;
ͲͪͽͳͽͳͳͳͻͰΔ;ͺͻͪͬͬͰͻΒͪͳͼͺ;Δͪͬͪͳ͊ͳͷͰ
ͺͪͽͳͷͰͼͽͳͰͺͻͪͬͯͪ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͪͺͼͽͶͷ
ͪͼͽͪͬͳ͵ͷͳͺͻͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰͷ͆ͪͺͻͬͳͺͭͶͰͯͳͳ
ͼͰͯͪΒͰͰͫͳͪͳͫͰͲ;ͺͻͳͽͪ;ͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͳͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ͵Βͳͷ;
ͺͻͳͺͳͼ;ΒͰ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͳ͇
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͼͽͪΒͰΒͪͼͪͪ͵ͼͰͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪ;ͯ;;
ͼͬͪͽͪΔͪ͵ΒͪͺͼͽΒͰΒ;ͻͪΒͰͭͲͰͭͰͲͳmͪͻͳͽ;ͼͺͳͼͳͷ̺ͪͪͼͳͶͳΒ̺ͪͰ
Ͷͳ͵ͭͳͬͪͪ̀͠Ͷͪͽ;ͼͽͭ
͵Βͳͼ;ͺΒͪͷͷ;ͰͳͽͬͪͺͻͳͻͳͶͳ;ͬΌͰΔͰͷ
͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͪͬΓͰͳͼͪͬͰͼͽͳ͊ͪͼͬΒͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͽͪΒ͊ͳͷͰͬͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͰͼͪͷ
ͽΒͰͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͫͭͪͽͳΔͰͭͬ͵;ͶͽͬͰΕΒͰͳͺͻͬͭͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͺͻͳ
ͯͻ;ͱͳͬͰͷͪͺͽͬͪΒ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͳͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ
ͳΒͳΒͰ
ͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͺͻͽͽͳͺͼͪͷ͎ͻͳͼͽͼͱͻͽͬͪ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ
;;ͱͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ͻͰͳ
ΒͰͯͪͼ;ͯͯͬͰͫͳͽͰ
ͯͻͰͯͳͰΔͰͭͬͭͶͳ͵͇ͪΒͰͺͪ͵;ͪΒͬͰΕΒͷͰͻͳͭͻͪΌͰͺͻͰͷͪͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽ
ͳͷ;Ͳͻͳͷͪ͋ͪ͵ͪͬͳͲͫͻ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͺ͵ͪͲͪ
ͺͻͳͲͶͪͲͳΒͰͳͲͲͪͽͰͬͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ
ͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
ͪͶͳͳͳͲͺͽͻͰͫͪͺͻͪ͵ͽͳͰͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͱ;ͺͪͼ͵ͭͻͪͲ
ͯͫΓͪ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ͆ͪͳͷͰ
Ͱ͵ͳͯͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͳͳͯͰͶ͵ͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪ
͵ͪͽͼ;
ͺͻ͵ͶͪͷͬͪͳͺͶͳͰͽͻͳͲͪͷͬͪͼͰΓͰͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͳͯͰΒͪͳͲͪͫͻͪͷͪͻͯ;
ͳͺͫͰͯͳ͵ͷͬΌͳ
ͯͫͳͶͳͼ;ͪΒͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͳΒ;ͺͽͬͻͯ;ͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͷͪͯ
ͭͪΌͪΒͰͳͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͰ͊ͽͪͻͭͲͪͬͰͽͪmͅΒͼͳΒͪ
̽ͪͬͳͯͪ
ͪ͠͵ͬͪͳ͠ͼͳͿͪ
͉ͪͲ;ͷͰͼͰͯͪΒͰ
ͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰ
ͽͪ͵ͪͬͳͯͰͪͶͳͶͳ͵͆ͰͷͪΔͳͰͯͬΒͳͬͯΒͰͬͪ
ΌͰͼ͵ͳͬͻͰͯͼͽͳmͼͪͼͬͳͷ;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͪͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ͵ͪͺͯͻͪͱͪͬͪ
͎ͪͻͳͼͽͪͳt͌ͳͽͰΓͪͼͽͻͪͪͭͼͺͯΔͰͭi͋ͪͼͳͽͪͭͷͪ
ͳΒͳͼͰ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͳͺͻ
ͽͽͳͺͪͶͪͲͳ;ͺͻͳͺͬͰͼͽͳ̺ͪͻͶͪͪͷ;ͳͪ͠ͼͪͿ;mͬͰͷͪ;ͽͳͪΒΒ;ͼͻͺͼ͵Β
ͼͻͰͯͳͳͯͬͻͰͷͰͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰmͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪͳΒͪΒͰͬͪͱͭ;ͰΔͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ;
ͷͪ;͇ͳͳͯͻ;ͭ;͵ͼͳ;͆ͰͷͪΔͳͭͳͯͰͪͶͭͶͳ͵ͪͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
ͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͻͪͲͷͰΌͰ;ͯͼ;ͪͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ͵Ͱͺͽ̹ͭͷͯͪ;
ͪͻͳͲͷ;ͬͪͼͳͶͰͬͼͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͳͷͪΒͰͯͪͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳͳͬͳͰͼͽͻ;͵ͺͽͬͻͯͳ
͌ͽͷͳΓ;;ͫͶͳͰͪΒͰͳͼͺͻͬͰͯͰͪͲͪͷͳͼͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ;ͷͪ;
͵ͪͺͻͰͶͪ
ͲͪͰͽͪͺͪͲͪͬͻͭͫͶͳ͵ͪ͵;ͶͽͪͳΒͳΒͰͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͬͶͪͯͪͻͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ
͇͵ͬͳͻͽͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪͳͳͶͳͼ;;ͪΒͬͰΕΒͷͰͻͳͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͫͻͪͼͳ
ͳͽͳͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳͳͺͻͬͰͻͰͳ
;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷ
ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;͇ͯͪͽͶͰͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͪͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪͺͼͽͪΒ;ͭͶͪͬͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͺͻͳͺͬͰ
ͯͪΔͪͯͽͻͰ;ͽ͵ͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳͭͷͪͰΔͪmͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ͵ΒͳͲͪͪͬͪͺͻͰ͵ͻͰͽ;
ͱͳͬͽ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳͯͻͳͪΔͰͯͼͬͰͽͪͳͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͰͼͶͪͬͰͳ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
tͳͲͶͪͲͪ͵iͳͲͽͪͪͼͽͬͪͫͻͪͲͶͱͰͳͼ;;ͳͲͬͻͷͯ;;ͳͼͽͻͳΕͪ
ͼ͵ͰͪͭͳͶ͵ͰͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͰͽΒͰΒͰͬͪΌͰΓͰͷͺͻͺͳͼͪͳͫͶͳ͵tͽ;ΌͳͬͪΔͪi
ͽΒͰͼͽͼͽͻͪͼͽͬͬͪΔͪͺ;ͭͶͰͯ;͎ͪͻͳͼͽͪ
͵ͪͺͻͪͬͪͲͪͶͭͪͬͰͭͱͳͬ
ͽͪ͠Ͱͯͪ͵ͳͼͯͳͽͰͳͷͪΒ;͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͷͺͯͬͳͲͳͷͪͪ͊ͬͰͽΒ
̻ͻͳ
͵Βͳͷͪͯ;ͭ;ΒͰͰͺͳͽͰͽtͼͽͪͬͳ͵ͪͺ;ͼͽͳΔͰi͌ͪͭͳͶ͵Βͽͺͳͳ
ͺ;ͼͽͳΔͪΒͰͼͬͰΕͰͳͺͻͼͽͻͳͷͰͽͪͿͻͪͻͪΒͪ
ͪͫͻͪͬͪ͵;ΔΒͰͺͯͪ
ΒͰ;ͼͶͬͭ;;ͽͻͪΔͰͭͺͻͰͫͻͪͱͪΒͪ͵ΒͳΒͰ͊ͳͷͰ;ͷͭ;ΕͳͯͪͺͼͽͪͰ
tͬͰͽͬͰͻͰͰͫͰͼ͵ͭͬͳͭͻͪͯͪiͳtͶͰͼͽͬͳͪi
ͯͼtͷͼͽͽͺͻͰͬͯͳ
;ͬͰͳͱͳͬͽi̽ͪͫͳͼͰͼͪͫͻͪͲͳͳͯͰͪͶͷͷͯͰͶ;
͊ͳͷͰ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪ
ͬͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰͰͫͶͳ͵Ͱͪͼ͵ͰͲͰͳͳͳͯͰͶͪtͪͶͳ͵ͼͽͪͻͳͼͬͰͽͳ
ͪͰͶͳ͵ͪ
ͬͭͪͺͻͪͬͳͶͪi͊ͫͲͳͻͷͪͽͯͪͼͰͱͳͬͽͳͽ͵ͪͪͻͰͽͰͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪ;
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
ͯͼͳͼͪͷͪͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͳͰͺͳͲͯͰͬͰΕͪͰͶͳ;ͳͼ͵;ͺͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͶͪͪ
͋;ͼ;ͽͳͼ͵;ͳͯͰΒ;mͯͪ͊ͳͷͰ͵ͻͲͼͺͼͽͬͰͳͱͳͬͽͺͪͬΓͪͳ͵ͷͳΒ;
ͼͺͪͼͰΔͪmͫͻͪͲͶͪͱ;ͳ͊ͪͬͪͳ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͳ̹ͱΒͷͬΓͷ
ͽΒͰͼͽͰͬͷ
ͺͻͰͯͯͻͰΌͰΕ;Ͳͪͽͪ͵ͬ;
ͪΒͬͳ;ͷͳͼͳΒ;͇ͳͽͳͷͰͼͶͰͯͰͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͳͽ͵ͪ
ͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ9**ͳ9***ͬͰ͵ͪ
;͵ΒΒΒͰͫͭͳͲͪͫͻͪͼͽͺΒͰͯͳͪ
ͬͳͯͪ͵ͻͲ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ͊ͬͰͽͭ̽;ͪͳͲͪͷͰΔͪͺͻͰͷ;ͯͻͼͽͳ
;Ͳ;ͯͪ
ͭͶͪͬͳͺͻͰͯ;ͼͶͬ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ́ͼ͵ͪͲ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭͯͪΕͰ͊ͳͷͰtͪͻͰͬͪͽͳͪͲͰͷΓͳͪͪ
Ͱͫ;ͫͻͪͬͳͽͳͼͪΌͰͶͳͷͪiͪͼͬ;tͫͱΒͰͽͪΒͰͳͺ;ͳͰͷͳͶͼͻΌͪ͵ΒͪΕͰ
ͫͳͽͳͪΔͰͷ;iͪͯͳͶͪͲͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͼͷͳͼͶ;ͳͳΓ;
͵ͬͳͻͰͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
͋ΒͰͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͼͽͪͬ͵ΒͳͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͰͽͰͶͭͳΒͰͫͻͪͲͶͪͱͰͳͯͰΒ;
ͬͶͪͯͪͻ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;ͳͺͶͪͱͰͽͰͷͰΓͰͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͷͯͻͰΌͰΔ;ΔͰͭͬͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ
͊Ͷͳ ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ ͳͼͯͳͽͰ
ͪͶͳ ͯͪͶͰ͵ ͳͻͳ ͲͪͪΒ
ͳͷͪΒ; ͊ͳ
ͷͰͬͳ ͰͺͳͽͰͽͳ t;ͯͽͬͻͪi ͳ tͬͳ ͷͳͻͽͪi
͵Βͳ ͪ ͫͳͽͪ ͪͳ
ͯͻͰΌ;Β;ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒΔͰͭͬͭ͵;ͶͽͪͅΕ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͪͪΒͬͰΕͳͷͲͪ
ͷͰΔͰͷ̹ͱΒͰͷͳͶͼͽͳ
ͫͳͶͪΒͰͯͪΒͻͪͳΒͳͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͬͻͰͷͰͪͭͶͪͬͪ
ͺͽͬͻͯͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
ͪ;ͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;ͳΔͰͭͬͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͳ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͼͶͬ ͊ͳͷͰ ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͳΒͳ ΒͰ Ͷͳ͵ ;ͯͽͬͻͪ ͭͻͪΌͰ ͺ ;ͭͶͰͯ; ͪ
ͼͬͰͽͭ ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ ͊Ͷ;ͼ͵ͭ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ ΒͰ
;Ͳ ͽ
ͪͻͳͽ ͽͬͪΒ ͵ͪͽͰ
ͭͻͳΒͳͷͳͻͽͳͬͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ̺ͪͰͷͪΒͰͲͪͪΒͪͳΔͰͳͪͽͽͼ;;
ͱͳͽͳΒ;͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭmͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽ;ͼͻͺͼ͵Β͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳm͊ͳͷͰͬͪ;ͯͪ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͳͲͶͱͰͪ ͋ͪΒͼͬΒͰͬͻͼͳ͵ͪͽͪͶͭ;ͯͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͻͰͺͻͰͲͰ
ͽͪͽͳͬͳ;Ͳͻͪ͵͵ΒͳmͺͽͬͻͯͳͶͪͼ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪmͰͼͪͷͽ;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͪ
ͺͻͷͳΓͰͼͽͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͭͻͪΌͰΔͪ͵;ͶͽͪͬͰΕͳͯͪΒͰͽͪ;ͼͶͳ͵;ΔͰͭͬͷ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ;ͳ͵ͻͪΒΔͰͷͳΓ;͇ͯͯͰͬͰͽͺΒͰͯͳͪͺͳͼͪͳͼͪͷͯͬͪͺͻͳ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͪͯͪΒ;;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͷ;ͯͳͷͪΒͰͯΒͰͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵
ͪͯͻ;ͭͰͭͲͻͳͼͽͳ͵
͊ͬͪͼͽͪͶͪͯͼͰͼͰͪ͊ͳͷͰͬ;ͺͷΕ;ͯͫͻͪͳͳͽͰͻͰͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͰͳͯͳ
ͪͼͽͳΒͰͅͰΌ;Δͳͷͪ
ͽͪͬͳͰ
ͺͽͺ;ͺͻͰͬͶͪΌ;Β;ͽͪ͵ͲͬͪͪtͰͭͪͽͳͬ
ͪ;ͯͪi
͵ΒͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͳͽͪ͵ͽ͵ͪͱΔͪͬͪͳͶͳ;ͼͷͻΕ;ΒͰͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͰ
ͼͬΒͳͽͳΕͰͳ͵ͪ͋ͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ
ͯͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽ
ͫͳͶͪͼ;ͭͶͪͬͪͯͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͶ;ͼ͵ͭͷͳͻͽͪ͢ͳͷͪͼͰͷͭ;ͺͻͳͫͻΒͪͽͳͳͯͻ;ͭͪ͵ΒͪͼͰͽͳ;ͪ
ͳͪͯͰͶͬͪΔͪmͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͽͻBͺͷΕ;ͫͳͽ͵ͪͷͪ
;Ͳ;ͯͰͼͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ
ͼͪͷͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͯͪͬΒͰͺ͵ͪͲͪͯͪͼ;Ͱ͵ͳͯͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͳ͊ͳ
ͷͰͬͳͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͳͼ;tͽͪͪͼͽͬΓ;ͫͪiͳͶͳtͭͻͪͯͽͪͪͼͽͬͪͼͬΒͰͭͪi
ͰͺͼͻͰͯͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͳͯͼͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ͋ͪͳΔͰͳͪͳΒͰͬͪͱͪͼͪͷ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͪͿ;͵ͳΒͰ͵;Ͷͽ͇ͪͪͺ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͯͪΒͰͺͰͽ͵ͷ9***
ͼͽͶͰΕͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͼͻͰͯͳͪͫͳͶͪͼͺͻͰͷͪͯͪͺͻͳͬͪͽͳͬͪͱͪͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͪ;͵
ͷͰΌ;ͼͫΒͲͪͷͰΓͳͬͼͽͳͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪͳͿ;͵ͳΒͪ
͵ͪͳΔͳͬͳ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
;ͯͪ
͵Βͳͺͳͬͪͪ;ͰΔ;ͪͺͼͽͶ͈ͪͪͬͶͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͼͽͳͲͪΒͰͯͳͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰ
ΓͪΒͰͯͷͫ;ͬͪͽͷͽͰͶ;
͎ͻͳͼͽ;ͳͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͪͽͪΔͰͺͻͰͼͳͬͼͽͳͽͻͪ
ͼͰͯͰͽͰͼ;ͽͳͰͺͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͳ;ͬͰͻͰΔͰͬͻͼͽΒͬͰͲͳͼͬͰͽͳmͻͰSNZTUF
SJVNVOJVTDPSQPSJTmͪͽͰͶ͵ͳͺͻͪͬͯͪͬͪͷͭ;ΕͼͽͯͪͼͰͯͰͶͪͳ;ͯͪ
ΒͰͯͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͺͻͰ;ͲͳͷͪΒ;ͳͲͱͳͽͳΒͪͯͻ;͇ͭͭ͵Ͷͼͽͯͪͼ;;ͯͪͼͬͰͽͭ
̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪͺͼͽͪͶͪͳ͊ͳͷͰͬͪ;ͳͳͶͪΒͰͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͳͷΔͰͭͬͺͻͳ͵Γ;Ͱ
ΔͰͺͽͰͷͻ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͳͽ;ͬͳͼ͵ͷͼͽͪͽ;ͼ;ͬͭͷͳͻͽͪ
͊ͳͷͰͬͰͺͳͽͰͽ;ͯͽͬͻͪ;ͪΒͽͰΔΒΒͰͬͰͲͳͼΒΒͰͯͳͷ͵Γ;ͳͷ
ͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͷ ͵Βͳ ͼͰ ͯͼͳ ͪ ͼͬͰͰͬͰ ͷͽͳ ͊ͪͬͪ ͼͰ ; ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳ ͺͲͳͬͪ ͪ
ͺͽͰͬͪͱͰΕ;ͯͰͿͳͳͳΒ;ͬͪͪ̽ͪ͠ͷͪͼ͵ͳͪ͵ͪͯͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͰͷͽͳͪͲͳͬͪ
tͼͬͰͽͳͷͻͪͷͷi͋ͳͷͰͺͼͽͪͬΓͪͯ͵ͽͻͳͪͻͰͼͬͰ͵;ͶͽͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ
ͪ;ΒͰͯͳͷͯͻͰΌ;ΒͰͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳ͵ͬͳͻ͊ͽͳͬͳͳͻͷͼͪͼͰͯͷͰ
ͺͰͼͷͰ
͵Βͳ͵ͪͱ;ͯͪ͊ͳͷͰͼͽΒͳͺͻͰ̹ͯͭͷ
ͼͬͳΔͳͷͼͳͶͪͷͪ
ͯ͵ΒͰͪͲͰ
ͷΓͳt͵ͪͯͳͶͷͳͻͳͼͪͫͶͪͭ;ͪͪi
ͺ͵ͪͲ;Β;ͯͶͳ͊ͪͬͳͺͲͪͬͪΔͰͽͰ
Ͷ͵ͳͪͰͶͪ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͠ͰͯͪͯΔͰͭͬͳͫͳͽͳͺͼͽ;Ͷͪͽͪmͽ
ͺͻͳͲͶͪͲͳͳͲͬͰΕͺͷͰ;ͽͭ;ͰΔͪͬͻͼͽΒ
ͰͻͪͲͶ;ͳͬΒͬͰͲͳͲͪΒͰͯͳͰ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪmΒͰͼͽͰ;ͬͰͻͰΔͰͯͪ͵;ͶͽͰͷͱͰͫͳͽͳͰͶͬͳͽ;͵Ͷͳ͵ͰͫͰͼ͵ͪ
DPNNVOJPTBODUPSVNͰͷͪͯͻͪͲͪ;Γ;ͯͳͷͪͷͭͯͼͽ;ͺͳΒΒDPNNVOJPSFMJ
RVJBSVN
͈ͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͺͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͶΒͰͳͲͪͶͪͱͰΔͰͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;
ΕͳͫͶͳ͵ͪ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶͳͪͶͳͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳ
͵Βͳͼ;ͫͳͶͳͯͻͰΌͰͳͼͪͯͻͱͳ
ͷͳͺͽͻͰͫͪͷͪ͵;Ͷͽ͇ͪͼͳͷͬͰΕͺͷͰ;ͽͳ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͪͪͷͰΔͰͳ
Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͷͺͻͪͲͬͪΔ;
ͼͽͬͻͰͪͼ;
ͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ
ͷͭͪ
ͲͪͪΒͪ
ͯͪͪͼͫͳͼͷͻͰ͵ͶͳmͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͪͻͰͰΔͪ͆ͪͺͻͬͷͷͰͼͽ;
Ͳͪͼͬͪ
ͪΒͰͳͺͻͰͳͲͿͻͷ;ͶͳͼͪͪͪΒͳͻͪͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͪͰͶͳͪ
ͬͰͷͪͼͶͱͰͭ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪmͪͽΒͰͭͻͫͳͻͪͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͳΒͳΒͰͺͻͽͽͳͺ;ͼͽͪ
ͬΓͰ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ͇ΒͰͫ;ͬͪͽͪͳͲͺͼͰͫͳͻͰͰΔͪmͯͫͶͳ͵ͪͳͺ
̺ͪͱͪͽ;ͷͪͰΔͪͬͰͺΒͪͬͰͳͲͼͳ̓4DISFJOFS
;VN8BISIFJUTWFSTUÅOEOJTJN)FJMJHFO
VOE3FMJRVJFOXFTFOEFT.JUUFMBMUFST
4BFDVMVN
m DͪͬͰͯͰͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
͊ͺͳͼͳDͬ$BͬF
FEͣͻͬͳΕ
ͺͻͰͬͯ͊ͬͰͽͳ$BͬB͊ͪͫͻͪͳͼͺͳͼͳ
ͬͪ̽ͪ͠ͷͪ
ͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͰͷͽͳͲͪͪͬͪ͵ͪtͻͪͷͬͰͫͱΒͰi
ͯͼ͵ͪtͯ;ͬΓͰͪͽͰͶͰͼͪ
ͼͽͪͳͽͪͫͱΒͪi
ͬ͋ͰͳͲͶͱͰͳͰͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬʹͬͰQV
ͽͬͻͰͳͰ$F́ͪͪ̽ͪͷͪͼ͵ͳ
ͪ
͈͊ͰͽͰͻͫ;ͻͭ
ͻͰͺͻͅͼ͵ͬͪm͉ͼͽͬͪ̽;
͊ͺͳͼͳDͬ$BͬF
FEͣͻͬͳΕ
ͺͻͰͬͯ͊ͬͰͽͳ$BͬB͊ͪͫͻͪͳͼͺͳͼͳ
4DISFJOFS
PQDJU
ͼͪͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͶͱͪΒͪͭͻͫͭͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͪͯͼͶͳ͵ͪͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ;ΔͰͭͬΒͿ;͵ͳΒͳmͳͷͰ
ͼ;ͺͶͱͰͰͼͬͰͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͼͪͻͪͰ
ͪͶͳͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷͻͰͰΔͳͷͪͳͲͯͬͪΒͪΒ;ͼͰͳͰ͵ͪΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͪ
;͵Βͳͷͪ
ͼͰͭͶͰͯͪͼͫͰͼͽ͊ͳͷͰͬͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ͊ͫͲͳͻͷͪͽͯͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳͽͰͶ
ͳΒͰͺͯͬͻͭ;ͽͺͼͽ;ͺ͵;ͫͪͶͼͪͷͬͪΔͪ
ͯͼͯͪͷͽͳͳͼ;ͫͳͶͰͯͳͼͽͪ
tͰͽΓͰͰi
ͳͲͼͽͪͶͪΒͰͳͺͻͰͯ;ͻͪΔͳͬͭͺͻͰͰΔͪ;͵ͳͬͽͺͻͰͯͶͽͪ
ͻͷ
͵ΒͪΒͰ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
ͲͪͬͻͳͳͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͼͬͰͽͳ
ͽͰΓͪ̓ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͳͷͰ;
;Ͷͭ;͵ͳͬͽͪͲͪͯͻͱͪΒͰͼͪͷͭͻͫ
ͽ
ΒͰͼͽͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͳͷͰͻͷͰͻͳͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͺͯ͵ΒͳͷΒͰͽͰͶͺͳͬͪͶ͆ͰͺͼͻͰͯͪ
ͯͯͳͻͼͷͽͳͷͪ
ͬͰͷͪͬͪͱͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͲͪͷͰΔͰΒͰ
ͪͺͻͳͳͺͳΒͰͶΒͰͯͪ͵ͪͳ͵ͪ͵ͯ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ͊Ͷ;ͼ͵ͭmͲͪͬͪͽͪΔͰͷ
ͷͳͻͪ͵ΒͰͼͰͳͲͶͳͬͪͶͳͲͭͻͫͪͅͳͻͽͰΔͰΒͰͫͳͶͼͬͳͬͳͯ͊ͳͷͰ
ͬͭͺͼͷͻͽͭΒͪͬΓͪΔͪͳͭͶͪͬͳͪͭͰͼ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔ͈ͪͺ;ͽͷͳͻͪͳͲ
ͼͶ;ͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͳͶͳͽͪ
͵ΒͰͼͰͽͳͶ;ͳͲͫͳΓ;mͪͼͬͰͰͬͺͻͪͲͳ͵ͪ͵ͳͲ
Ͳͳͯͬͪͳͼͽ;ͫͬͪͻͪͷͪm;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳΒͰͳͼͽͳͪͶtͰͼͪͷΒͰͯͷͰ
ͭͳ;ͼͬͰͪͼͬͰi
ͪ;ΒͰͯΒͳͲ;ͲͰͽΒͺͻͳͶͳͳtͺͶͳͼͰͼͬͪͻ͵ͬͪ
ͯͪͳͲͰͷ
ͭͰͼͶ;ͱͳͳ͵ͯͼͬͰͽͭͪͭͻͫͪ
ͻͺ;ΕͳͼͬͰͽͷͳͻi͈;ͭͶͰͯ;ͪͷͳͻ
ͳͲͭͻͫͪͼͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ
ͪͻͳͽͰΔͰͭ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;;ͯͫͪ̓ͷͳͪ
ͳ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͷͪͶΒͰͼͽͪͽ;ͼtͼͰ͵;ͯͪͻͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰiΒͰͯͪ͵ͭ;ͯͽͬͻ
͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
7ͪͺ
͊Ͷ;ͼ͵ ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳͽͰ
͵ͪ͵ ΒͰ ͺͲͪͽ
ͳΒͰ ͺͼͰͯͬͪͶ ͷͽͳ ͼͬͰͽͭ ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ
ͬͰΕͼͪͷ͵ͷͪͯͽ͵ͪͳͰͼͽͻͪͭͬͳͷͪ͵ͻͬͳ
ͺͻͪΌͰ;ͷͪͶΒͼͽͪ͵ͶͰΒͺͼ;ͯͳ
W̻ʋʂʝ
Ȓʙʔʈʒʝʐʕ
ȇʃʂʓʊʌʊʋʜʔʐʕșʄʝʐʕȄʈʈʔʒʝʐʕȈʆʓʓʂʌʐʎʝʋʈʥ
șʉʜʎʂ
m͇ͭͻͫͳͳ;
ͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪͳͳͫͻͳΒ;ͷ;ͪͯΔͷ-FNFSMF
PQDJU
**
m ͼͪͼͽͪͻͳΒͷ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
Wͳ%*1BMMBT
-FDJCPSJVNIFYBHPOBMEF4BJOU%FNFUSJPTEFѮFTTBMPOJRVF
̀ͭͻͪͿ
m
͐;ͯͽͬͻ;ͷΕ
ͼͳͷͷͳͻͪ
ͳͷͪͶͳͼ;ͳͯͻ;ͭͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͳ͵Βͳͼ;ͫͳͶͳ;ͯͯͳͻ;ͼͪͼͬͰ
ͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷͷͽͳͷͪ;ΓͰͳͲ͵ͪͯͳͶͪͳͶͳͲͰͷΓͪͳͲͭͻͫͪ
ͪͶͳͳͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͰͬͻͼͽͰCSBOEFB
m ͪΒͰΕͰ ͵ͷͪͯͳΕͳ ͽ͵ͪͳͪ ͵Βͳ ͼ; ͺͽͳͪͶͳ ͯ ͼͬͰͰͬͭ ͯͰΒͪͳΒͪ
W %FMFIBZF
-FT
PSJHJOFTEVDVMUFEFTNBSUZST
m.BHPVMJBT
PQDJU#Z[BOUJPO
m$POOPS
PQDJU
8BMUFS
PQDJU
m
͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ
FEͣͻͬͳΕ
ͺͻͰͬͯ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ͊ͪͫͻͪͳ
ͼͺͳͼͳ
́ͲͬͻͰ͵ΒͳͺͷͳΔ;ͫͳͶͽͰΔͰͷͳͻͪͳͲͭͻͫͬͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳ
Ͱ͊-$POOPS
PQDJU
ͪͺ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
ͭͯͰΒͼͽͬͪ͵ͪͼͪͷͰͷͽͳ͋ͪ͵ͬΒͰͫͳͶͷͳͻ͵ΒͰΒͰ;ͼͽͪ͵ͶͰͳͳͯͰ
͊ͪͬͪ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;
͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳͺͼͶͪ;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ
̀ͪͰͶͬͳͽͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͰ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͳͪͳͪͪ͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͫ
ͶͳͰͬͰͷͪΒͰͬͪͱͪͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͯͪͼ;
ͼͳͷͭͻͫͪ
ͷͳͻͽͳͬͳͫͳͶͳͳΔͰͭͬͳ
ͺͻͽͻͰͽͳ̸͵ΒͰͬͰͻͬͪͽͳͼͬͰͯͰΔͳͷͪͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪm͊ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ;Ͳͪͺͳͼͪ
ͼͷͻͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͳ͊ͽͰͿͪ;͈ͻͬͬͰͪͷm͵ΒͪͺͽͷͺͪͬΓͪΒ;
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
ͷͳͻͼ;ͽͳͶͳͳͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͳͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͳtͫͻͪ
Ͳͳi͋ͳͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͺͻͽͻͰͽͳͷͭͶͳͫͳͼͰ;ͽͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;ͼͷͪ
ͽͻͪͽͳΔͰͭͬͳͷͺͻͬͳͷͳ͵ͪͷͪ͌ͳͼͽͷͼͬͰͽ;ͳ͵Ͱͼ;ͫͳͶͰͰͲͪͫͳͶͪ
ͲͪͳͳͶͪ ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ΔͰͭͬ ͬͳͲ;ͰͶͳ ͳ ͽͪ͵ͽͳͶͳ ͺΒͪͬͳ ͫͶͳ͵̀ͪͰͽ͵Ͱ
͊ͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪͪͻͳͽͼ;ͽͬͪͶͳͪͻͰͬͳ̸ͶͰ͵ͼͳΒͰ*ͳͪͅΒͶ̓ͷͳ
W8BM
UFS
PQ DJU
m ͼͪ ͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ ͳ ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͈ͻͰͷͪ ͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷ ͼͳͪ͵ͼͪͻ; 9**
ͬͰ͵
;ΒͰͯΒͯͺͻͰͼͽͳ͵ͳͻ͵ͪͬͪͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͼͶ;ͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;;ͬͪͶͼͰΔͰͭͬ
ͷͳͻ͵ͪͼͰ͵;ͯͪͻͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
W͆%FMFIBZF
4ZOBYBSJVNFDDMFTJBF$POTUBOUJOPQPMJUBOBF
#SVYFMMFT
͇ͬͪͼͬͰͯͰΔͪͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰͪͼ;ͼͪͷ͵ͯͺͲͳΒͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪͪ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
FE̽ͪͳ
ͳΕ
m ̿ͳͽͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
ͺͻͰͬͯ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
m5FPͯPDVKF
FE̽ͪͳ
ͳΕ
mͺͻͰͬͯ5FPͯPDVKF
͈ͻͰͷͪ͊ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ;Ͳͪͺͳͼͪ
ͪ͵ͳͼͽͳͪΔͪͷͳͻͪͳͲͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͭͻͫͪti pak6 wbraz2
simewn2 na z<i>dou ispousti muroi
W̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
̓ͻͪͽ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
ͼͬͰͯͰΔͰ
͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭͷͳͻͽͳͬͼͽͳ͊ͳͷͰͬͭͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭͶͳ͵ͪ tͳͳͲͳͼͺͳͼͪͭͪͶͳ͵ͪ
͊ͬͰͽͭͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͪͲͳͯ;ͻ͵ͬͰͷ
ͳͼͽͰͰͺͻͰ;ͯͪͻͰ͵ͪi
ͳͼͺͻͳͪΒͰ;ͼ͵Ͷͺ;ͺͻͳͺ
ͬͰͯͪΔͪ ΒͰͯͷ ͯ ͊ͳͷͰͬͳ ;ͯͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪ ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͳ
FE ͣͻͬͳΕ
ͺͻͰͬͯ
͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ͊ͪͫͻͪͳͼͺͳͼͳ
̀ͪͳͷΓͳͬΒͰͯͪ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪm;̿ͳͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ
͊ͳͷͰͪ
͵ͪͳ̿ͳͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰmͭͬͻͳͼͪͷͷͳͻͽͳͬͼͽͳͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭ
ͪͰ
ͳͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭͶͳ͵͈ͪͻͰͷͪͽͷͱͳͬͽͺͳͼ;
ͷͳͻΒͰ;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;ͳͼͽͳͪͶtͯͭͰ
ͼͬͰͽͰͼͶͳ͵ͰͪͺͳͼͪͰͪͼͽͰͳi
DG̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
FE̽ͪͳͳΕ
m
ͺͻͰͬͯ̽ͷͰ
ͽͳΒͪ
m
͈ͻͰͷͪ͋ͰͯͼͳΒ;
ͷͳͻͽͳͬͳͼ;ͫͳͶͳͳͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͳͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͳ
ͺͻͽͻͰͽ͇
ͽͪͬͳͰ
ͺͷͳΔͰͯͬͪͽͪ͵ͬͪͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͪͶͳ͵ͪm;ͻ͵ͬͳͳ;ͽͻͺͰͲͪͻͳΒͳ5FP
ͯPDVKF
FE̽ͪͳͳΕ
ͺͻͰͬͯ5FPͯPDVKF
m
͊ͳͷͰͬͺͻͽͻͰͽ;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;ͫͳΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͳͲͪͯΔͰͭͬͭͭͻͫͪ
ͪͷͰ
ͼͽ;ͪ͵ΒͰͷͼͰͯͪͪͼͪͶͪͲͰͺͻͽͻͰͽͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͳͲͬͻͰͷͰͪ͵ͻͪΓͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪ
W7͠ƄV
SJǀ
'SFTRVFTNÊEJÊWBMFTÆ$IJMBOEBS
JO"DUFTEV9**F$POHSFTJOUFSOBUJPOBMEFUVEFTCZ[BOUJOFT
0DISJEF
mͲͪ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͪͯͭͻͫͳͺͻͽͻͰͽ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳW͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
m ͼͪͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͊Ͷͳ͵ͪͰͺͻͽͻͰͽͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ͵ͪ
ͬͳͯ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͪΔͰͭͬͭ͵;ͶͽͪͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪͶͪΒͰ̽ͅͳͶͰͬͳΕ
͊ͻͫͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳ;ͼͽͪ
ͻͷͼͻͺͼ͵ͷͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ;
JO͇͊ͻͫΓͪ͵;
m
͊Ͷͳ͵ͪΔͰͳ͵Ͱ
;ͲͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͪͭͳͶ͵ͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͭͶͪͬͳͰͶͰͷͰͽͲͪͬͻͰͰͽͪͺͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ;͈ͻͪͬͼͶͪͬΒͻ͵ͬͳ͈ͻͬ
ͫͳͽͪͼͽͪͶͰ͵ͪͪͯͭͻͫͳͺͻͽͻͰͽͳ;ͺ͵ΒͰͭ
ͽͰͼͶͳ͵ͰͪΒͰΕͰͼ;ͫͳͶͰ;ͫͶͳ͵;
ͺͻͽͪͽͳͬͰͳ͵ͰͳͶͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͶͳ͵ͪͪͺ͵Ͷͺ;ΔͰͭͬͭͭͻͫͭͼͺ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͳͷͽͻͰͫͪͽͻͪͱͳͽͳ;ͪͯͭͻͫͳͷͺͻͽͻͰͽͳͷͪ
͵Βͳͼ;ͳͼͪͷͳͷͭͶͳͳͷͪͽͳ
;Ͷͭ;ͳ͵Ͱ͠Ͱͯͪ͵ͪ;ͯͽͬͻͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͷͽͳΒ;ͳtͳ͵Ͱi
;͵ͪͲ;Β;ͪͽͯͪͼ;͊ͻͫͳ͊ͪͬͳͭͯͫͪͲͪͶͳͲͪͪͰͶ;ͳͼͽͬͰͽͼͽΔͳͬͰ
ͼ;ͽͳͰͳͿ;͵ͳΒͰ
͵Β;ͰͼͽͺͯͬͶͪͰͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͫͭͼͶͬͳͪͅ
ͯͪ
;ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͽͬͪΔͰͳ͵ͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͺͳͬͪͪͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳͷͽͰ
Ͷ͵ͳͷͺͼͽ;ͶͪͽͳͷͪͳͬͰͲ;ΒͰͼͰ
͵ͪͯͷͳͪͽͪͫͶͳ͵ͺͫͱͼͽͳ
ͲͪͯͬͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͰͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͰm͵;Ͷͽͳ͵ͪͲͪͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳ
ͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͲͪͲͪ
ͺͪͯͳͼͬͰͽmͲͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͳͳͷΒͰͫͳͪͳͯͰͶͬͪΔͪ́͵Ͱ
͵ͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͰͼ;ͺͽͬͻͯͷͫͭͽͬͻͰΔͪͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͰ
ͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͷͳͼͽͳͳͷ
ͳ͵͵ͻͰͽͳͷͽͰͶͬΓͰΔͰͷͼͬͰͽͼͽͳ́ͲͪͯͼͬͰͭͪ
͵ͪͯ͵ͪͲͫͱͪͼ͵ͰͼͳͶͰ
ͳͷͳͶͼͽͳ
Ͱͼ;ͺͼͬͰͯͪͬͪͶͰͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪ
ͺͼͻͰ
ͯ;Β;ΕͳͪͽͪΒͪͳͳͲͷͰΌ;ͽͻͪͼͰͯͰͽͭͳͳͷͪͰͽͭ͋ͪͽͪ͵ͬͪͱͪ
QSBFTFOUJBͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͺͰ͵ͪͯΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͳͷͰ;
ͳͯͯͪͽ
ͪͭͶͪͪͬͪͪͻͰͪͶͳΒͪͷͪ͵ͪ͵ͬͰͼ;͵ͻͬ
ͼ;ͲͰͳͶͳͷͳͻ͆ͪͽͪΒͪͳͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͺͼͽͪΒͪͶͰͼ;ͳͲͬͻͪ͵ͽͳͬͰͼͳͶͰͽ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪͰͺͼͻͰͯͪͳ
ͳͽͰͲͳͬͪͯͼͬͰͻͳ͵ͪͼͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͷ̸ΒͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͫͳͽͪͿͻͷͪ
ͺͫͱͼͽͳͳͭͶͪͬͪͺ͵ͻͰͽͪ͵ͪͼͪͭͪͯͪΕͪ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͅͰͪͳͲͪͷ͊ͳͷͰͬͭͷͳͻͽͰΔͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒͰͼͿͰͻͳͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͲͪ
Δͪ͵Βͪͼ;
͵ͪͳͯͻ;ͭͯͰ
ͫͳͶͪͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭͳΒͪͯ;ͬͰͰͶͳͽͰ̓ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳͪ
ΒͰ͵ͶͼͽͯͪͼͰ;ͯ;ͬͰ͵ͯͰͪͬͪͶ;͊ͪͬͳͷͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ;ͳͶͳ;ͲΔͰͭͬ;
ͺͷΕ
ͽΒͪͼͼͶͰͯͳͳͲͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔͪͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪͪ͌ͬͰͲͳͼͽͳͷͺͳͽͪ
ΔͰͷͪͻͳͽΒͰͻͰͳͽͪͰͺͳͲͯͪͼtͺͼͶͪͳͷi͵Β;͊ͪͬͪ
ͪͷͶͫ;͊ͽͰͿͪ
ͬ;
ͪΓͰͳͲ͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻͪ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;ͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͪ́ͶͪͻͳΒͪͽͰ͵ͪ͵
ͽΒͰͺͻͳͽͪͪ;ͻ͵ͬͳ
ͺͻͰͼͪͶͳͭͻͫͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͺͬΒͰͺͼͽͪ
ͷͳͻͽͳͬ͌͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳΒͰͳͲͬͰͼͷͻͪͶͪͰ͵ͪͯͪͺͼͽΒͪͽͳͰ͵ͪͳͼͽͪ
ͶͪͳΒͪͺ;ͭͶͰͯ;ͪ;͵ΒͪΒͰͺͻͪΌͰͪ;ͼͬͰͽͳͶͳͽ;̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ͊Ͷ;
ͼ͵ͭ
ͪΒͲͪͷͰͳͽͳΒͰͭͷͰΌ;ͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͷͳͻͽͳͷͪ͊Ͷͳͪ
ͪͺͻͪͬͪ
ͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͪͼͰ
ͷͭͶͪͼͰͪͶͪͲͳͽͳͳ;Β;ͭͲͪͺͪͯͷͽͻͪͬͰΒ;͎ͳͶͪ
ͯͪͻͪ
ͺͯ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͷͭͻͫͷ̹;ͯ;Εͳͯͪͭͻͫͳͪ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͼͷͰͽͰͪ;Β;ͭͲͪͺͪͯͳ;ͭͪͻͪͷͪ
ͯͼͪͯͪͪͻͰͶ͵ͳͳΒͰͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪͪ
ΒͰͯͳͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͼͽͪͳͽͼͬͰͯͰͷͳͻͽͰΔ;ͯͪͪͼͼ;ͻͰͳͺͳΒͰͽͳ
ͪͺͼͽΓ;͊ͳͷͰͬͭͼͪͻ͵Ϳ̹ͪͭͪͳͶͫͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͳͺͭͻͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͯͪΒͰͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͽͪ͵ͬͭ
ͯͰ;ͺ;ΕͰͳͼ͵ͶΔͰͭͷͰͪͳͲͷͪ
ͷͭͶͯͪͯͬͰͯͰ;ͺͳͽͪΔͰͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽ;ͯͪ͐ͳͽͪͬͪΒͰͯͪͰͭͲͰͭͰͲͪͼͽͬ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
ͻͰͪΒͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͯͪͫͳͼͰͯͻͰͯͳͶͳͺΒͷͬͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͳͼ;WFSJUBTͳGBMTJUBT
́ͼͽͳͳͽͼͽͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ;ͯͪͳͼͪͷͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͺͪͽͳͷͰͳtͳͼͽͻͳͼͽi
ͯ͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͪͼͰ;ͲͺͷΕͽͰͶ͵ͭͻͪͲͶͭͪͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪΒͰ̹ͱΒͪͼͳͶͪͺͼͬΒΒ
ͺͻͳͻͯͳͫͰͼ͵ͪͪ
ͽ̹ͭͳ;ͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͳͳͳͰͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͬͪ;ͯͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͼͽͪͶͭm͵ͻͲͷͽͳͼͬΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ́ͲͽͭͪͰͶͭͼͬͪͽͪΔͪͯͰͯ;͵ͬͪ
ΒͰtͶͭͳ͵ͳiͺͼͽ;Ͷͪͽͯͪͼͬͪ͵͵ΒͰͼͬͰͽͳͼͺΓͪͬͪͼͬΒͰͼͪͬͻͰͼͽͬͳΔͰ
ΔͰͷ;͇ͯͪͼͳͷͽͭͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳ͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͳͼͽͳͳͽͼͽͳͰͲͪͼͳͬͪͼͰ
ͽͶͳ͵ͪͼͺΓͪΔΒͳͼͺͻͪͬͼͽͳͼͽͬͪͻͳ
ͬͰΕͷͭͬͳͰͪ;;ͽͻͪΔͰͷ
ͼ;ͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͬͷͪͰͶ;͋ͲͪͳmͳͼͽͳͳͽͪͬͰͻͪͳͺͫͱͰͪͷͰͻͰͺΒͰͯͳͪ
ͰͼͪͷͽͼͰ͵ͬͪͶͳͿͳ͵;Β;͵ͪͳͳͳͽͰͶͭͳΒͰͬͰΕͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪΒ;ͻͰͪͶ
ͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳͽͰͭͻͳͼͪͳͷ;ͼͪͷͫΒͰ͵ͪͽ͵;Ͷͽͪ͌ͺͻͪͬͽ;ͪͻͭ;ͷͰͽͪͳΒ;
ͺͯ;
ͺͻͽ;ͫͳͫͶͳΒͼ͵ͳͷͳͽͪͽͳͷͪ
͵ͻͳͼͽͰ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͯͪͫͳͫΒͪͼͳ
Ͷͳͺͻͳͻͯ;ͷͳͻͽͰΔͪͽͼͰͲͫͳͶͪ͵ͳͽͪΔͪtͺͼͶͪͳͰit̸ͬͪΒ
<͊ͳͷͰ>ͽͪ͵ΌͰͯͼͷͻͽͳ
ͪΒͳͳͲͪͯͼͳͶͰ
ͺͼͶͰͼͷͻͽͳ
ͼͪͽͬͻͳͺͼͶ;
ͪΔͰ͵ͪ;ͳͽͰΓ;ͼͬΒͰͷ;ͳͼͺ;Δ;Β;ΕͳͻͰ̻ͼͺͯΔ;̓ͬͰͻ;ΒͰ;ͷͰͰ
ͯͰͶͪ
͵Βͪͳͳͷ
ͳΕͰͳ;ͳͳͽͳ
ͪΒͳͬͰΕͪͯͬͳͼͪͽͬͻͳΕͰͪͺͬͪͶ;
ͷͰͳ
ΒͰͻͼͰͼͳͶͪͷΒͪͬͳͰͳͼͺ;Δͪͬͪ;ͰͷΕͷi͌ͽͷͼͬͰͽͶ;ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳͳ͊ͪͬͳ;;Ͷͭ;;ͼͽͬͪͻͰΔ;;͇ͯͪͼͰ
ͪͻͪͬ
ͷͭͶͲͫͳͽͳ
ͼͪͷͪͼͬ;tͯ;ͫͳͰͫͭͪͽͼͽͬͪͳͺͻͰͷ;ͯͻͼͽͳͳͲͪΔͪͫͱΒͰͭi
ͪͶͳ;Ͳ
ͼͪͯͰΒͼͽͬͬͰ͵ͪ͵ͪͪ͵ͽͳ̹ͬͭͱΒͰͭͳͼͽͻ;ͷͰͽͪ͵Βͳ;Ͱͼͽͬ;ΒͰ;ͷͳͼͽͰͻͳ
ΒͳͼͺͪͼͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͶͪͪ
͍;͵ͳΒͪ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͳͷͪͶͪΒͰ
;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͪͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰͷ
ͬͰͷͪ
ͳͻ͵ͻͪͼͺ͌ͬͻͰͷͰ͵ͪͯͪΒͰ;ͫͶͳͰͼͬͳ;ͳͺ͵ͻͰͽͪ͵;ͼͪͭ;ͳͳ
ͷ;ΒͰͯͻͱͪͬͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷ;ͳΒͰͷΒͰͼͻͰͯͳͽ;
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ;ͯͻ;
ͭͳͷͲͰͷΓͪͷͪͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͪ
ͫͳͶͪͳͯͰΒͪͪͻͳͲͷͪͽͼ͵ͷͬͶͪͯͪͻ;ͼͬͰͽͳ
ͽͰΓ;͆ͪͽͺͳͽͪΔͰ
ͰͯͬΒͳͬͯͰͶͳͰͽ;ͷͪͰΔͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰ
ͶͭͳΒͰ;ͯͫͪͺͻͬͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
ͼͬͻ;ΕͰͷͼͰ
;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͷ͵ͬͳ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͻͷͪͰͭͻͪͯͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͫͳͽͳͪͭͶͪͼͪ͵ͪ;ͬͰͲͳͼ͵;ͶͽͷͷͽͳΒ;͌
ͪ;ͳΒͰͬͰΕͬͳͰͺ;ͽͪͳͼͽͳͪͪͫͶͳͼ͵ͪͺͬͰͲͪͼͽͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͳͳͶͳ
;ͱͪ;ͼͶͬͲͪͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ͊ͻͫͳΒͰͺͻͳͲͪͽΒͳͺͼͬͰΕͰΒͲͪΒͰͯͳͳͪͻͯͪmͪ
ͽͼ;ͼͽͳͪΔͰͰͲͪͬͳͼͰͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͪ;ͽ͵ͰͿͪͶͰͻ͵ͬͰͳͼͺͼͽͬͰͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰ
Γ͇ͪͬͪΒͺͼͶͰͯΔͳͲͪͽͰͬ
ͯͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽ
ͪͼͽΒͪͶͳͼ;ͯͪͳͼͺ;Ͱͼͬͳ
ͷͶͪͯͳͪͻͯͳ̾ͬͻͺͰ͵Βͳͼ;ͺͻͰͽͰͯͬͪͶͳͪͽͯͪͺͼͽͪ;tͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳi
͊ͺͼͽͬͰͳͷͯͺͻͳͼͷͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͷͳͼ;ͼͰ;͵Γ;ͳͬͪͶͳ;ͺͽͳͽ͵ͼͬͰͽͰ
ͺͬͰͼͽͳ́ͯͰͶ͵ͳͫͻͪͼͳͳͷͰͪͳͲͷͳ͵Βͳͼ;ͶͰͱͪͶͳ;ͼͬͳͽͪ͵ͬͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬͽͬͻͳͺͯ;ͬͪͽͪͽͪ͵ΌͰͼ;ͺͽͰͷͰͼͽͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͺͶͳͽͳ
͵ͰͽͰͶͭͳΒͰUSBOTMBUJPJNQFSJJ;ͱͼͰͼͽͬͪͻ;ΒͰ;͵ͬͳͻ;ͰͼͪͽͶ͵ͳͲͪ
ͼͬͪͭUSBOTMBUJP)JFSPTPMZNJ͋ͳͷͼͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪͼͪͫͻͪͱͰͰͼ;ͪͼͫͰ
ͪͳͲͪͷͳͼͪͳ
ͪͻͳͽ
Ϳ;͵ͳΒͪ͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
͵ͪͳ
ͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͭͻͪͷͪͭͻͫͳͰ;͵ΒΒͼ;;ͬͪͰ
͊ͬͪ͵ͳͺͯ;ͬͪͽͲͪͰ͵ͪUSBOTMBUJPJNQFSJJͫͳΒͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͺͻͪ
ΕͰͪͼͽΒͪΔͰͷͯͪͼͰͯͻͱͪͬͳͫͰͲͫͰͯͳͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͰͫͰͼ͵ͳͲͪͽͳͽͳ
͵ͪ̀ͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͳ;ͲͻͲͰͷΓͪͷͪͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͪͫͳΒͰ;ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;
͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͯ͠ͲͪͼͳͬͪΔͪΔͰͭͬͼͽͪͽ;ͼͼͬͰͽͭͭͻͪͯͪ
͉͆ͬͭͳͷͪͳ͆
ͬͭ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͪ
ͳͼͽͳͪΒͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭ
ͼͪͫͳͻͪΔͰͷͲͪͷͰͳͽͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ
ͳ͵ͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͳͺͯͼͽͳͪΔͰͷΔͳͬͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ͆Ͱ͵ͰͯΔͳͫͳͶͰͼ;
ͺͪͶͪͯͳΒ;ͷͳ͏ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͪͪΒͼͶͪͬͳΒͪͳͪͻͳͽͯͰͶͽͬͻͪͫͳͶͪΒͰͳ͵̹ͪ
ͭͻͯͳͰ͇ͯͳͭͳͽͻͳΒͰ͊Ͷ;
ͯͻ;ͭͳͺͻͪͭ;ͭͻͪͯ͏ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
;ͱͳͬͪΒͰ
Ͳͪ
ͼͰ
ͬͻͬ;Ͳͪͽͳͽ;ͼͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ̀ͪͳͷΓͳͬͪΒͰ͵Ͷͼͽ
;ͪ;ͳͯͪͬ
ͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͪ
ͯͪͼ;ͼͶͬͰͼ͵ͳͪͻͯͳ;ͷͭͳͷͺͻͰͼ;ͯͳͷͽͻͰ;ͳͷͪͫ
ͬͰͳͶͳ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪͯͻͱͪͬͼͽͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͺͻͳͬͪͽͪͶͳͳͶͳͺͯͼͽͳͪͶͳ
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
0CPMFOTLZ
PQDJU
*CJE
m͌ͽͳͪΒ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵;ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒ;̓ͳΒͰͬͼ͵Ͱ͵ͰͱͰ
ͬͳͰͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪͶͪΒͰ́͐Ͱ͵ͬͪ
͇ͫͻͪͲ·ͪͬͶͪͯͰͽͰͶ·ͼͬͰͽͰͬͶͰͽͺͳͼͳΊͼͬͯt͈PͬFDN·
ͬͻͰͷͰΆͶͰͽi
ͻͰͿͰͻͪͽͺͻͳͽͪͪͪ;ͷͼ͵;ͺ;͉͊ͬ́ͬͪͳͶͼ͵ͳͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͪͽͪ
͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪͬͼͻͰͯͬͰ͵ͬͪ̾ͬͻͺͪ
͊ͿͳΊ
0CPMFOTLZ
PQDJU
m̺͋΅ͺ͵ͬͪ̀ͪͳͷͬͪ
͋΅ͻͬͷͰͱͯ;̾ͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ
͉ͳͷͳ͏ͪͻͳ
ͭͻͪͯ ́ͯͰΊͽͪͪͺͻͰͼͽͶͰͭͻͪͯ
͋΅ͻͬͼ͵ͪ͵ͳͱͬͪ͵Ͷͪ
m
-PDDJÚ̹ͱͳͶͬ
3FOPWBUJPJNQFSJJ#VMHBSPSVNFU(SBFDPSVN
JO͊ͰͯͰͷͰͽΉͯͪͺͼͻͰ
ͯͰͬͰ͵ͬͪͳͼͽͻͳΊ
͊ͿͳΊ
m
m
̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
͈ͼͬͰͽͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳͳͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
JO͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͪ;
ͻ͵ͬͰͷͱͳͬͽ;ͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͪͻͯͪ
m
͌ͺͻͰͯ;ͪͪͶͳͲ;ͽͳͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͪͯͪΒͰΒ̽̓ͼͽͳΕ
PQDJU
m
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͋ͪ͵ͬͪͰͪ;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ΒͰͼͪͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͷͪ͵ΒͰ
ͪͳͻͰͷͺͶͪ;ͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
ͯͼͳ͊ͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
͇ͬͺͳͽͪΔͰͻͪͲͷͽͻͰΒͰ;ͳͻͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;͵͈ͯ̽ͺͬͳΕ
4BDSBFSFMJRVJBF
m
7ͻͪͯͬͰ;Ͳͫͻͳ͵;́Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͬͻ;ͼͼ͵ʹ͵;Ͷ·ͽ;ͻͰ
FE̸̹ͪͽͪͶͬ
̸̈́ͳͯͬ
ͅͼ͵ͬͪ
͋΅ͺ͵ͬͪ̀ͪͳͷͬͪ
PQDJU
m͇ͷͽͳͷͪͺͻͰͰͽͳͷ;͋ͻͬͲͪͬͶͪͯͪͬͳͰ̸ͼͰ
̸ͬͪͪ͂ͶͰ͵ͼͳͰͬ
̹ͰͶͰͱ͵ͳͲͪͻͪͪͽͪͳͼͽͻͳΊͪͽ΅ͻͬͼ͵ͳͽͰͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳ4UVEJBQSPUP
CVMHBSJDBFUNFEJBFWBMJBFVSPQFOTJB
̺ͰͶͳ͵͋΅ͻͬ
m
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
͊ͶͳͰͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͰͪͶͰͼ;ͷͰͼͽ;ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͳͺͻͬͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ͌
͊ͻͫͳΒͳΒͰͰͶͬͳͽͲͪͼͬͪtΒͰͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳiͺͻͭͻͪͷ;ͯͳͪ
ͼͽͳ͵ΒͿ;͵ͳΒͳͼͽͬͪͻͰ;̿ͳͳ
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶΒͳ͵ͻ;ͳͯͫͰΒͻ͵ͬͳ
ͭͯͰ
ͼ;ͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͳͷͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͷͪm͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳͷ
̹ͭͻͯͳͳͳͷͳ
͈ͻͰͽͰͳͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪmͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͰͰͷͽͳͺͻͬͬͰͪͭͼͻͺͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪ
Γͪ͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪͼ;ͺͻͬͳ͵ͻͪͳ;ͽͷͺͻͪͬ;ͪͳΔͰͳͳͻͪͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ
;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͳͼͷͳΓͪͬͪΔͪ;ͶͭͰΔͰͭͬͭͭͻͫͭ
ͻͪͷ͇ͪͯΒͰͳͺͷͰ;ͽͳͼͬͪͽͪΔͪͽͪ͵ͼͰΒͪͼͺͻͰͺͲͪΒ;;ͻͰͳͷ͈ͪͻͬ
ͬͰͪͭ
ͯͫͻͺͲͪͽͳͷ
ͪͶͳ;ͪ;ͳͰͯͬΓ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͼͪͳͷ
͵Βͳͷͪ
ͺͳͼ;ΒͰͺͯͳͲͪΔͰ͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͰt̸͵ͪͯͭͶͰͯͪͰͺͯͳͲͪΔͰͻͪͷ͈ͪͻͰͼͬͰͽͰ
ͬͪΒͷΒͭͼͺͯͳͼͬͰͽͳ<͊ͳͷͰ>ͬͰͻ;ΒͽͰͷͳ
ͭͼͺͯͳͫͻͪΕ
ͯͪͼͪͷͬͳͯͰ
͵ͪ͵ͼͰΔͰͭͬ;ͷͯͳͱͰ;ͬͳͼͳ;͵ͪͰ͵ͳͰͫͺͪͻͳͻͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͯͻͱͪͪͲͰ
ͷΓͳͬͰͲͪ;ͲͪͷͪͱͰͶͰͲͳͷ
ͺͪͼͰͳͼͽͻͭͪͳ;ͬͳͼͳ;;ͲͶͰͽͰͯͪͯΌͰͯͭͪ
ͫͰͼͷͻͽͭͪͳͼͬͰͽͭͪͳͼͽͳ͵ͪͳͯͪͬͳͯͳͶͪͯͫͱͪͼͽͬͰͭͪͭͻ̺ͪͯͪͳΔͰͭ
͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͪ
ͳΒͳ
;ͳͼͽͳ;ͺͼͽͪͯͰͺͻͪͬͳͭͻͪΌͪͳi͋ͪΒͳͼ͵ͪͲ
;͵ΒͰͷͼͰ
ͭͻͪΌͰΔͰ͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͰͺͬͰͲ;ΒͰͼͺͻͰͫͳͬͪΔͰͷ͊ͳͷͰͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ;̺ͳΔͰͷ͠Ͱͻ;
ͼͪͶͳͷ;
ͳͷͪ
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͳͻͳͲͪͪΒͯͪͽͳͳͺͪͳΒͰΔͰͭͬͭͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͭͻͪΒ
ͼ͵ͭͫͳͽͪͬͪͶͳͽͪ͵ΒͰͯͼͰͱͰ;ͲͶͰͽͷͼͬͭͪ;ͷ͇ͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒͰͯͪͯ
͵Γ;ͰͬͪͲͪͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭͲͪͼͳͬͪΔͪͬͶͪͼͽͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷ
͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭͻͯͪͰͶͳ͵ͪ͊ͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͰΔͰͭͬͭͼͷͳͼͶͪͺͳͬͪ
ͺͪ͵ ͪ ͼͫͰͷ
͵ͪͲ;ͳͼͽͳ͵ͷ ͪͳ; ͷͳΓͰΔͪ
ͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͷ ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷ
ͬͰ͵; ͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͺͶͪͲͰΕͳ ͯ ͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͭ ͺͼͽ;Ͷͪͽͪ ͯͪ ͷͽͳ ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͽͰͶͰͼͳͳ;ΒͰͯͯ;ͬΓͰͳͫͶͳ͵ͰͭͲͳͼͽͰͳΒͰmͽͲͪͳͯͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ
ͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͺͻͰͫͳͬͪͼ̹ͭͷͳΓ;ͯͳͷͪmͪͯͪΒͰͲͪΒͰͯͳͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳΔͳ
ͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͺͺͻͳͻͯͳͼͽͬͪͻͳ
ͰͻͪͲͯͬΒͳͬͪ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰΒͰͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵ͯ
ͯͪͶͰ͵ͼͰͱͳͳͯͰͶ͵ͳ
ͺͪͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͺͼͶͰͯͳͪ̽ͻ;ͭͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ
mͽͬͻΌͰΔͰͯͪΒͰ͊ͳͷͰͺͼͽͪͭͻͪΌͪͳ̺ͳΔͰͭ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͪͺͻ;ͱͳͶΒͰͽͰ
Ͷ͵ͳͼͬͯͪͼͰͳΔͰͭͬͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͽͪͪͼͽͬͼͷͪͽͻͪ͊ͬͰͽͷͲͰͷΓͷ
ͪ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͽͷͼͽͬ͆ͬͳͷ́ͲͻͪͳΓͰͷ́ͪ͵ΒͰͳͯͰΒͪ͊ͻͫͳͷͪ͵ͪͳͲͪͫͻͪͷͪͻͯ;
;ͺ;ΒͷͰͻͳͻͪͲͬͳΒͰͪͳͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͲͪ͵ͻ;ͱͰͪͽͰ͵ͯͳΒͰ
;ͯͰͶ;̽ͷͰ
ͽͳΒͪͬͷ
Ͱͷͪͼ;ͷΔͰ;ͽͯͪͼ;ΒΒͽͰͷͰΓͳͺͶͱͰͳΒ;ͼͬͳͽ9***ͼͽ
ͶͰΕͪ͌ͳΔͰΒͰͽ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͬͰΕͺͷͰ;ͽ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͺͻͰΌͰΔͰͷ͆ͰͷͪΔͰͳͼͽͪ
ͻͲͪͬͰͽͭͪ͠͵ͬͪ̀ͪͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͬͰͷͪΒͰͬͪͱͳͼͽͪΕͳͯͪͼͰͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͰ
ͷͰͽͪͿͻͰͼͽͪ͵ͬͳͷͲͪͰΔͰͷΒͪͬΓͪΒ;;ͰͺͼͻͰͯΒͬͰͲͳͼ͵;Ͷͽͷ͊ͳͷͰ
ͬͳͷͽͳΒ;
ͳͽͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͳͼͪΔͳͬͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ͋ͪ͵͈ͻͬͬͰͪͳ;
ͽͻͰ;ͽ͵;ͺͻͳͼͺͰΕͪͷͽͳΒ;;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͫͶͪͭͯͪͻͳt̹ͭ;ͽͪͪͪͳ
̸ͬͻͪͷͪ
́ͼͪ͵ͪͳͪ͠͵ͬͪi
ͪ͊ͪͬͪͽͪΒͯͭͪΌͪΒͺͻͰͯͳͼͺͻͰͼͷͽͰͶͪͪ͠͵ͬΓͰͬͭ;
ͫͰΕͪ;ͲͰͷΓ;͊ͬͰͪͳͳͯͰ͵ͪͷͽͳΒ;ͼͻͪͲͶͭͷͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͬͻ;
ͰͷͼͶͱͰͭͺͼͽ;ͺ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ͋ΒͰͬͻͼͽͪͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭ
BEWFOUVTB
ͼͳΓͰͷ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪͼͬͰͺͽͰͭDPOTFOTVTB
͵ΒͳͷͼͰͪΒͳͻͪ
ͯͻ;ͽͬͰͪͲͪΒͰͯͳͪͳͼ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ͵ͪͬͻͼͽͪͳͫΒͰͯͳΔͰͪͰͶͳͪ͋ͪΒͼͷͳ
ͼͪͳͷͪ͊ͪͬͳͼͬͰͯͰΔͰͽͷͰͯͪͼ;͊ͳͷͰͬͳͼͳͬͳͯͰ͵ͪͶͳΔͰͭͬͰ
ͷͽͳtͼͪͼͬͷͯͻͱͪͬͷimͳͽtͻͪͯΕ;ͻͪͯ;Β;ΕͳͼͰͳͬͰͼͰΓͰͷͬͰͼͰͶͰΕͳ
ͼͰi͈ͶͰͽͳͼͶͪͬΓͰ͵ΒͳͼͰͽͷͺͻͳͭͯͷ
ͪͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͺͽͳͷͰͼͽͪ
ͺͳͼ;Β;;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͷͱͳͽͳΒ;ͳͲͻͪͲͼ;ͪͻͳͽͭͻͰͶͳͭͳͲͭͼͰΕͪΔͪ
ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪ͋ͪ;ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶͪͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͪHMPSJBͳͷͪͶͪΒͰ;ͬͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;ͳͯ
ͯͪͽ;
ͬͰͷͪͪͭͶͪͰ;ͪͳͪͶ;ͺͻ;͵;͢ͰͼͷͳͼͪͫͳͶΒͰͭͶͪͪͬͪΔͰ
ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͭͳͲͶͪͼ͵ͪΒͰͯͭ͆ͬͭ́ͲͻͪͳΓͪͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵;ͺͲͻͳ;
] ]
̸̸̸̸͇̺͇̻͇͆͊͋͆̓͌̓͌̈́͋͊̾͋͊́̾͆ͅ
́ͯͰΒͳͿ͵;ͼͳͻͪͼͪͯͳ͵ͽͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͪ̓ͪͻͳͲͳͪ
ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
ͪΒͰͺͼͽͪͶͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͼ͵ͳͳΒͪ
ͼ;ͺͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͪͳ
ͷͰͽͪͿͻ̺ͪͳΔͰͭ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͪ͊ͪ͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͷ͊ͻͫͳͼ;ͼͽͰ͵ͶͳͼͺͼͽͬͰͳͼͪ
͵ͻͪͶͳͺͻͼͽͻ́ͪ͵ͻͰͭͳͪͶͭͲͪͰΔͪmΒͰͻͳΒͰͫͳͼͬͰΕͰͶͳͼͽͳ
ͷͪͳͯͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ͊ͬͰͽͭͺͳͼͷͪmͼ;ͭͶͰͯͳͷͼͬͰͽͳͶͳͽͳͷͪͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭ́ͼ
ͽ͵ͪͼͺͪΒͪͶͪͭͪΒͰͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͪ͵ͺͪͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͼͰͳͪͽͷͷͰͼͽ;ͪΒͰͯͪ͵
ͪͳͫΒͪͬͳͶͪͼͳͶ̹ͪͱΒͪ
ͺͯͰͿͳͳͳΒͳΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͪͳͼͬͰͫ;ͬͪͽͪ
̾ͽͪͺͰ;ͫͶͳͪͬͪΔͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͭͭͻͫͭͻͪͷͪͼͽͭͪͽͪͺ͵ͪͲ;Β;tͺͻͪͬͪ
;ͷͰͻͪͯΔͰiͺͻͬͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
ͪ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ΒͻͰͪͶͼͽͳͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;ͷ
ͻͪͲͬΒ;ͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͪ;ͳͺͳͼͪ͵ͪtͺͻͰͶͪͲͪ͵ͳͲͰͯͬΓͼͳͭ;ͻͰ
ͼͪͷͯͻͱͪͬͼͽͳ;ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ΒͺͶͳͽͳ͵ΒͼͿͰͻͳ
;ͼͪͷͯͻͱͪͬͼͽͺͻͪΕͰ
;Ϳͪ͵ͽͳ͵ͷͰͲͪͬͳͼΕ;
͵ΒͪͺͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͼͽͪΒͪΔͰͲͰͷΓͰ;ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒ
ͼ͵Β͵;Ͷͽ;ͻΒͼͿͰͻͳi
͌ͽͷͼͬͰͽͶ;ͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͪ
͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͪΒͰ
ͺͼͬΒΒͿ;͵ͳΒͳ
ͫͳͶͪͺͻͬ
ͳͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͰͼͽͬͪͻͰΔͰͳͻͰͲͪͷͳͼͶͳ͢ͷͰͼ;ͷͪͶͯͳΒͰͫ;ͬͪΕͰͰ
ͺͻͬ̿ͳͪ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͳͅͳͶͰͰͬͪ
͵ΒͪΒͰͺͻͳͷͳͶͪͰͶͰͳ;ͯͽͬͻͰͷͽͳ
ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ͋ͰͺͻͬͰͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͰͭͻͫͳͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͫͳͽͼ;;ͽͳͪͶͰͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͬͰ
ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͰͭͰͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ͈ͯͳͭ;ͽͰͳͲͬͪͷͪͽͳͰͫͶͪ
ͼͽͳͯͻͱͪͬͰm͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͪͳ̿ͳͪͪͻͰͶͪͽͳͬͺͻͪͲͷͺͻͼͽͻ;ͼͰͬͰͻͯ
͉ͪͼͪ
ͪͅͳͶͰͰͬͪͪͭͻͪͳͳͺͻͰͷͪͳͬͰͻͳͷͪmͰͽͪ͵ͬͳͷͪͻͳͽͳͷ
ͺͶͱͪΒͰͷ ͵ͪ ͯͪ ͼͶͰͯͰ ͺͻͫͪ ͼͽͻͪͽͰ͵ͳ ͷͯͰͶ ͋Ͱ͵ ͭͪ ΒͰ ͺͻͪΕͳ ;
;ͻͫͪͳͲͬͪΒ ̺ͳͲͪͽͳΒͳ
ͬͰΕ ͺͻͰ ; ͻ;ͻͪͶͳͷ
ͼͶͪͫ ͻͳͼͽͳΒͪͳͲͬͪͳͷ
ͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪ̾ͬͻͺͰ
;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;ͬͰ͵ͬͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ͵;ͶͽͬͳͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ
ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͳͫͳͶͳͼͬͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͺͻͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
ͼͬͪΕͰͭ;ͼͻͰͯΔ
ͬͰ͵ͬͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ͽͭͺΒͷͪ͌ͼͶͳͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͳͻͪͼͺ;
ͯͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭ
ͲͪͰΔͪ ͯ ͺͻͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵Ͱ ;ͶͭͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳ ͷͳͼͳΒ; ͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͰ ͳ
Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
̸͈͇́͋̾͑͋́͌͢͠ͅͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͳͳͼͻͰͯͳͽͰͳͻͰͺͻͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ͵Ͱ͵Βͪ
ͼͰͯͼͳͪ͵;ͶͽͪΒͺͽͬͪͳΒͰͭͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ̸ͪ͵ͼͽͭͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ
ͻͪͲͷͽͻͳͷͫͳͷ;ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ;ͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͪͬͳ
ͷͱͰͷͼͰͬͰΕͪͺͰͽ͵;
ͺͲͬͪͽͳͪͰ;͊ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕͪ
ͳͲͰͽ;ͺͻͰͭͽͬΒͰͯͰͯͰͰͳΒͰ;ͫͳΓ;
ͺͽͳͻͪͼͺͻͪͬͪͳͺͼͰͫͳͺͻͳͶͭͪͷͪͶͳΒͰͫͻΒͳ͵Βͳͼ;ͫͳͽ;ͪͺͻͰ
ͯͳͶͳͪ;ͪͼͪͲͪΔͪ ͈ͻͫͶͰͷͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
ͼͪͼͬΒͰ
ͼͽͻͪͰ
ͪͻͳͽΒͰͼͶͱͰͲͪͯͪͽͪ͵
͵ΒͳͲͪͽͰͬͪͼͬͰͼͽͻͪͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪΒͺͻͰ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪͰͽͪͺͰ͊ͪͬͳͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪmͼͷͻͽ
ͼͪ
ͻͪͪ
ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰm͵ͪͳͼͺͪΓͳͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͻͰͯ;Ϳͪ͵ͽͳ͵ͳ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵Ͱͷͽͳͼ;ͺΒͪͬͪ͵
ΒͪΒͰ
ͰJQTP
ͼͫͰ
ͽͪͬͳͰͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͳͲͻͪͲͻͳͽ;ͪͶͪͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͳ
Ͷͳͼͽͳ͌ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͽͻͰͫͪͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ;ͺͼͰͫͷ
͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
͵ͪͬͪͱͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͶͳͳͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵Ͱͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͽ
ͬͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͼͪͼͺͼͽͬͰͳͷͺͻͪͬͳͶͳͷͪͳͯͻͰΌͰͳͷͽ͵ͬͳͷͪ͊ͽͳͷ;ͬͰ
ͲͳΒͰͽͻͰΕͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͵ͬͪͱͪͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪ
͵ΒͳͼͰͯͼͳͪ͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͭ
͊ͪͬͰ
ͫͶͳ͵ͳ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵Ͱ;ͲͻͰΔͰͭͬͭ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͪͳ
ͺͼͰͫ
ͪͿ;͵ͳΒ;ͷͽͳΒ;͇ͬͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͷͽͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͫͪͬͳΕͰͷ
ͼͰ;ͪΒ;ͱͰͷͯͻͰΌͰΔ;ͽͭͺΒͷ͈ͪͯͼͽͳͪΒͼ;ͪͷͺͻ;ͱͳͶͳ
ͼΒͰͯͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͳͰͯͪͬͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳm͵Βͳ;ͺ;Ε;Β;ͪͺͬͳ
ͳͽͪͬͪΔͰ͊ͪͬͳͳͱͳͽͳΒͪmͳ
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͺͽͻͰͫͪͯͪͼͰͺͻͫͶͰͷ͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̓;ͶͽͷͷͽͳΒ;͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪͪΒͬͳͰͼͰͫͪͬͳ͈̈́ͪͬͶͬͳΕ
͈ͻͰͭͶͰͯͼͬͰͽͳͷͽͳ
Β;;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬΒͻ͵ͬͳ
̀ͫͻͳ͵͈ͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͭͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͭͿͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽͪ***
mJEFN
̓;ͶͽͬͳͶͳͪͷͽͳͷͪ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭ͵;Ͷ
ͽ͈ͪͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
͆ͪͬͪΒͺͻͫͶͰͷ;ͺͲͻͳΒͰ͊ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
PQDJU
*CJE ̽ ̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ ̿ͳͽͳΒͰ ͼͬͰͽͭ ͊ͪͬͰ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ ͺͻͰͯͭͬͻ
997**m997***
͇͵;Ͷͽ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳͰͽͪͺͪͷͪΔͰͭͬͭ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ͆%FMFIBZF
-FTPSJHJOFTEVDVM
UFEFTNBSUZST
#SVYFMMFT"(SBCBS
.BSUZSJVN
1BSJTm$8BMUFS
"SUBOE
3JUVBMPGUIF#Z[BOUJOF$IVSDI ѮF $VMU PGUIF%FBEBOEUIF$VMUPG3FMJDT
-POEPO
m%"CSBIBNTF
3JUVBMTPG%FBUIJOUIF.JEEMF#Z[BOUJOF1FSJPE
ѮF (SFFL 0SUIP
EPYѮFPMPHJDBM 3FWJFX
WPM
/S
m
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
ͿͳΒͰ͋ͪ͵ͬͪͼ;ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔͪͻΌͰΔ;ͯͼͽͪͻͳͻͯͳͽͰΓͪ
ͯͫͻͷͫͻͪͲͬͪ
Δ;ͳ
ͽΒͰͬͪͱͳΒͰ
ͲͪͷͰΔ;ͷ;ͯͻͼͽͳͺ͵ͪͲͪͷΒ;ͷͶͪͯͼͽͳ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͯͻͳͪΔ;ͯͼͬͰͽͪͳͻͪͼ͵ͳͯ;ͼͺͻͯͳͷ͋;ΒͰͳͼͺͼͫͼͽͳΔͰΔͪͻͪͲ
Ͷͳͳͽͳ;ͯͪ
ͯͳͼͰΓͰΔͪͯͫͶͰͼͽͳͯͭͪΒͬͰΕͰͭmͷΕͳͬͻͪΕͪΔͪ;
ͱͳͬͽ͊ͪͬͳͪͬͳͯͬͳͽͼͽ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺͻͲͻΓͳͬͼͽ
̹ͱΒͳͯͪͻͯͪͲͪΓ;ͯͰͺͼͻͰ
ͯ;ΒͰ͵ͯͬͳΔͳͼͳͶͪ
ͪͳͲͪͯͼͬͰͭͪͯͶͪͲͪ͵;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ͵ͪͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͳͲͻͪͲ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͯͬͳͲͪͬͪΔͪmΒͰͼ;ͺͪ͵ͪͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪ͵Βͪ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
ͪͲͪ
Δͳͷͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰ;ͲͳͷͪͳͲͼͻͰͯΔͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳͱͳͽͳΒͪ͆ͳΒͰ
ͰͬͪͱͳͼͽͪΕͳͯͪͼͰͽͪ͵ͪͬ͊ͪͬͳͶͳ͵ͭͻͪͯͳ;ͬͻͰͷͰ;͵ΒͰͼ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳ
ͰͳͶͳ͵ͪͪΒͳͱ;ͽͪ͵;;ͻͪͲͬΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͪͽ͵ͷͳͽͪͬͰͬͳ
ͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰ̽;ͫ͵ͪ͵ͻͳͲͪͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͭͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽͪ
ͺͻͪΕͰͪͺͽͳͷͺͪ
ͯͪΔͰͷͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰm͵ΒͪͲͪͺͳΔͰΒ͵ͻͪΒͰͷ9*ͬF͵ͪ
ͪͪͯͬͶͪͯͪͬͪͼͰͽͰ͵
;ͺͰͻͳͯ;ͻͰͼͽͪ;ͻͪͳΒͰͺ͈ͯͪͶͰͶͲͳͷͪmͫͳͽΒͰͺͻͷͰͳͶͪͽͰͱͳͽͰ͌
9**ͬͰ͵;ͳͺͻͬΒͺͶͬͳͳ9***ͼͽͶͰΕͪͺͻͽͽͳͺͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͳͳͯͰͪͶͬͻͰͷͰͪ
ͳͼ;ͬͳͰͱͰͼͽ͵Ͱͪͼ͵ͰͽͰͬͰΕͽͪ͵ͬͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͳͻ͵ͬͰͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ͵Βͳ
ͼ;
ͺͺ;ͽ
ͻͰͳͷ
͠ͰͬͼͽͪͽͳΒͪ͊Ͷ;ͼ͵ͭ
;ͼͬΒΒͶͳͼͽͳͫΒͰͯͳΔͪͬͪͶͳͺͻͰ
ͼͽͳ͵ͳͻͪͿͳͷͪͳ;ͺ;ΕͰͼͽ;ͯͻͱͪͬͰͳͼͬͰͽͬͰͺͼͶͬͰͼͯ;ͫ͵ͷ
ͺͻͰͯͪΕ;ͺͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵Βͯ;ͱͼͽͳ͌ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
͊ͪͬͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͫͳΒͰ
ͫͰͲ
ͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͺͻͪͬͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ͵ͼͬͭͬͻͰͷͰͪ
ͪͶͳΒͰͫͶͪͭͪΕͰͼͽͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͯͰͶͪΔͰͷ;ͯ;;ͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ
ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳͫͻͪͲͪͪmͺͪΒͬͳͰͫͻͪͬͳͷͪ
ͳͺͯͬͳͲͪͬͪΔͰͷͪ͊ͬͰͽΒ̻ͻͳͳͯͪΕͳͷͪ;͊ͬͰͽ;ͲͰͷΓ;
͇͵Ͷͼͽͽͼ;ͼͰ;ͯͰͼͪͲͪͷͰΔͪͳͼͺΓͳͶͪͪ͊ͪͬͳΒͲͪΔͰͭͬͭ
ͱͳͬͽͪͬͪͱͪΒͰͲͪͪͪͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪͼͽͭͪͽΒͰͲͪͪΒͯͻͰͯͳͶͪͰͼͪͷ
ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵; ͼͶͳ͵; ͊ͪͬͳͰ ͼͷͻͽͳ ͬͰΕ ͳ ͵͵ͻͰͽͪ ͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵ ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͰ ͳ
0ͲͪͷͰΔͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ;ͻͪͷͳͼͻͰͯΔͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͺͰͻͳͯ;3.PSSJT
ѮF 1PMJUJDBM4BJOUPGUIF&MFWFOUI͊ͰͺUVSZ
JOѮF #Z[BOUJOF 4BJOU
m&1BUMBHFBO
4BJOUFUÊFUQPVWPJS
JOJCJE
m"CSBIBNTF
PQDJU0ͲͪͷͰΔͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ͊ͪ
ͬͳͭ;ͯͰͽͳΔͼͽͬ;ͳͷͶͪͯͼͽͳ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
̿ͳͬͽͼͬͰͽͭͪ͊ͪͬͰͳ̿ͳͬͽͼͬͰͽͭͪ
͊ͳͷͰͪ ͺͻͰͬ̈́ͅͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
ͺͻͳͻ͉ͪͅͻͳ͵ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m͋Ͱͯͼͳ
ΒͰ
̿ͳͽͳΒͪ ͺͻͰͬ̈́ͅͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̹̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
ͺͻͳͻ̹̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m͇ͺͳͼͳͷͪ;ͯͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͯͪͽΒͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͺͻͼͽͻ;ͫͰͪͬͰͯͰͰͫͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
̀ͪͽͪͺͳͽͪΔͪW͉.BHEBMJOP
ѮF #Z[BOUJOF )PMZ .BO JO UIF 5XFMѫI $FOUVSZ
JOѮF #Z[BO
UJOF4BJOU
m3.BDSJEJFT
4BJOUTBOE4BJOUIPPEJOUIF&BSMZ1BMBJPMPHBO1FSJPE
JOѮF
#Z[BOUJOF4BJOU
mPͺͪͯͪΔ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳ;ͽͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;͆(
#FDL
,JSDIFVOEUIFPMPHJTDIF-JUFSBUVSJNCZ[BOUJOJTDIFO3FJDI
.ÛODIFO
.BHEBMJOP
PQDJU
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
Ͷ͵ͳͳͼ͵ͺͪͬͪΔͪ;ͽͻͬͼ͵Βͻ͵ͬͳ͌ͭͻͫͳ;ΒͰ͊ͪͬͳͽͰͶͫͳͶ
ͺͶͱͰ;ͯͻͬͰͷ͵ͬͰͭ;
͵ͪ͵ͼͬͰͯͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ̀ͪͽͳͷΒͰͳͲͪͯΔͰ
ͪ͵ͫͪͬΓͰͰͼͪͻͪͰ
ͺͼͽͪͬΓͰ͵ͪͷͰͳͼͺͷͰͳ͵twͳͺͶͱͳͬͳ͵ͪ
ͷͰͪͼͳͺͬͻͭͻͫͪi̽ͪΒͰͫͳͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͳͻͪͲͷͰͻͪmͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵;
ͬͳͯ;ͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͪ
ͪͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
͵ͪͷͰͰͺͶͰmͼͶͰͯͳͳͲ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬͭͽͬͻΌͰΔͪ
ͯͪΒͰͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͺͻͰ͵ͻͳͬͰͼ͵;ͺͰͳͷͺ͵ͻͬͷtwͳͪͻͼ͵ͷͫͪͭͻͰͳͷ
ͺ͵ͻͳͬͳͭͪíͲͪͯͭͻͫͪ
ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͼ;ͼͬͰΕΔͪ͵ͳͲͶͪͽ͵ͬͪͪ
͵ͪͯͳͶͪ͆ͪͼͬ;ͳͲͶͱͰͳͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͼͪͼͳͭ;ͻΕ;ͼͰͷͱͰͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳ
ͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͳͽͻͬͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ;ͫͶͳͰͺ;ͼͽͪΓͰͷͫͻͪͼ;ͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͰͷͲͪ
ͼͪͻͪ;ͪΒͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͳΒͳͶͳͼͽͳ
͵ͪ͵ͪͬΒͰͬͰΕͯͬͪͺ;ͽͪ
ͪͬͰͻͬͪͽͳͽͻͳ
ͫͳͺͻͳͷͰΔͰ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͷͪ;ͲͶͰΒͳͷͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͆ͪͻͰͯͪͰͽͪͺͪ
͵Γ;ͪ;ͺͻͰͯ;ͻͳͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪͷͽͳΒ;
ͫͳͶΒͰͽͬͪ
ͻͪΔͰ͊ͪͬͳͭͭͻͫͪ
͵ΒͰͼͰͲͫͳͶ
ͺͻͰͷͪ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ;
Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵ͭͯͳͪͪ
͵ͼͪͻͪͰ
ͯ͵͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͪͬͯͳͯͪͼͰͽͯͭͯͳͶͺͼͶͰͼͪͷͭͯͳ;ͯͪͪ
̻ͻͫΒͰͽͬͻͰͻͪͯͳͺͻͰͼͪ͊ͪͬͳͭͽͰͶͪ;ͽͪΘͫͳ;
ͪͽͷͰͼ;ͺͻͰͽͯͳͶͳ
ͯ;ͭͽͻͪΒͳͺͻͰͭͬͻͳͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱͳͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͰͼͽͻͪͰͳͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͼͪͷͭ͵ͻͪΓ̺ͪͶͪ
ͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ;͋ͻͬ͋ͻͬͼ͵ͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶFMFWBUJP
͵ΒͳͺͯͻͫͳͲͼͰͫͪ͊ͪ
ͬͳͪͫͳͭͻͪͿͪ
ͳͲͶͱͰΒͰͪΒͬͰΕͳͷͯͰͶͷ͵ͻͲͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪ
͊Ͷͳ͵ͪͻͰͪͶͳͲͫͳͬͪΔͪͷͱͰͼͰͳͺͪ͵ͺͻͰͺͲͪͽͳ;ͺͳͼ;ͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵ͪ
;ͫͳͪ
ΒͰͳ;ͽͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͳͼ;ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪͼͳͶͪͳͽ͵ͪͳͪͲͪͷͽͪͬͪΔͰ
ͽͰͶͪ
ͲͪͽͳͷͫͶͪͰΔͰͷͽͳΒ;;ͬͼͬͰͪͳͻͪͽ
;ͲͫͪͬΓͪΔͰͺͻͺͳͼͪͳ
ͼͬͰͽͰͳͻͪͯΔͳ
ͳͽͪΔͰͷͶͳͽBͬBͳͺΒͪΔͰͪͯͭͻͫͳͺͪͳͳ̺ͯͪͻ;
͇ͼͬ;ͻ͵ͬͰͼͺͶͱͪΒͰͷͺͻͪΌͰͳͭͻͫͬͪͯͼͳ̺̺΅ͬͶͬ
͆ͬͳͽͰͻͪͲ͵ͺ
͵ͳͪͻ͵ͬͪͽͪt͊ͬͰͽͳͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͅ΅Ͱͳͳiͬ΅̺ͰͶͳ͵͋΅ͻͬ
̸ͻͰͶͭͳΊ
ͭͯ
97
͵
m*%VKǁFW
4BJOU4BWBÆ5ÚSOPWPͰͺ
͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͲͫͻͳ͵
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
-PDDJU
-PDDJU
͆ͪΒͰͯͪ͵ͪͳͫͳͶͳͼ;ͻͰͰͳͭͻͫͬͳ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪ
ͭ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ
ͪͪΒͬͰͻͬͪͽͳΒͰͳͭͻͫ͵ͻͪΓ̺ͪͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳ͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
m
m
m
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
m͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
m;ͪ;ͳΒͰͺͻͳͬͪΕͰͷͳΓͰΔͰͯͪͼ;
ͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͽͻͬͼ͵ͭͭͻͫͪͳͺͻͰͼͽͰͶͪͫͪͬΓͰͳͭͯͳͰ
W͍ͰͻΒͪͳΕ
PQ
DJU
m
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͆ͪͭͶͪͪͬͪΔͰͰͽΓͰͼͽͳ͊ͪͬͳͭͽͰͶͪͳͳ͵ͼͳ;͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰͺͻͰ
ͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭͪ͊ͪͬͰ
W͊ͪͬͳ;Ͱͳ͵
͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭͪ͊ͪͬͰ
JO͊ͻͫΓͪ͵*
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
͇ͬͺͳͽͪΔͰΒ;ͬͰ͵ͳΒͰͺͻ;Ͱ;͵ͬͳͻ;ͰͶͬͳͽͰͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰ
ͲͪͼͬͪͰͪͳͼͽͻͪ
ͱͳͬͪΔ;ͳͲͬͻͪ
ͽͪ͵ͯͪΒͰͳͯͪΓͰͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͲ̻ͪ̾Ͷ;ͫͳͼ͵ͳʹ
́ͼͽͻͳΊ͵ͪͳͲͪ
ͳͳͼͬΊͽΆ·
mͳQBTTJN
-PDDJU͇͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ;ͺͲͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;.BDSJEJFT
PQ
DJU
ͺͼͰͫmDGͳ̸ͅ5BMCPU
'BJUI)FBMJOHJO-BUF#Z[BOUJVNѮF 1PTUIVNPVT
.JSBDMFTPGUIF1BUSJBSDI"UIBOBTJPT*PG$POTUBOUJOPQMFCZѮFPLUJTUPT UIF 4UVEJUF
#SPPLMJO
.BTTBDIVTFUUT
mP͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ;ͲͪͺͪͯΒ ͻ͵ͬͳ3,MBVTFS
;VS &OUXJDLMVOH EFT )FJMJHTQSFDIVOHTWFSGBISFOT CJT [VN +BISIVOEFSU
;FJUTDISJѫ GÛS
3FDIUTHFTDIJDIUF
#E999*7
mͲͪͻͪͲͯͫΓͰͪ͵ͻ͵ͬͰͰͳͲͷͰ͉%FM
MP[
4PDJPMPHJFFUDBOPOJTBUJPOT
-B͆ͪ;Ͱ
8%FPOOB
&:ȡȄ*"$SPZBODFTBOUJRVFTFUNPEFSOFT-PEFVSTVBWFEFTEJFVYFUEFTÊMVT
(FOBWB97**
(FOÍWF
ͺͼͰͫm
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
ͪΒͰͶͪͼͽͳͳΒͳͫͳͶͳͳ;ͼͶͬͳ͵Βͳͼ;ͼͰͯͼͳͶͳͪͳͲͭͶͰͯ
ͽͪͳΒͰͼͽͪΔͰ
ͼͪͷͳͷͽͳΒ;͆ͰͽΓͰͼͽͽͰͶͪ͵ͪ;ͼͶͬͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪͳΒͰͼͰ
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ
;
ͪΒͻͪͳΒͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͯͫͪ;ͺͽͰͲͪͽͰͬͪͶͪ́ͯͳΒͰ
͵ͻͲͳͽͪͬͼͻͰͯΔͳ
ͬͰ͵
ͺͼͽΒͰͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͯͪͼ;ͷͽͳͽͬͪͰ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͰͫͰͲͫͲͳͻͪͪͽͯͪ
Ͷͳͼ;ͺͻͪΌͰͰ;ͬͳͯ;͵ͼͽͳΒ;ͳͶͳͰͶͳͽͰͶͪ͋ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
ͯͼͪͯͪΒͫΓͰ
ͺͻ;Ͱͪͻ;ͼ͵ΒͭͻͪΌͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶͫͳͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͺ͵ͻͰ;ͽͳͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͳͼͽͻͪ
ͱͳͬͪΔͪ͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ̀ͪͺͰͽͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͪͫͳͪͽ
ͯͪͼͰ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͺͳͼͪͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪmͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͺΒͰͯͳͳͳͲͻͪͲͪͳͼͶͳ͵ͪ
͵ΒͰ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͼͰ
ͰͳͲͶͪͲͰͳͲ͵ͬͳͻͪͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰmͳͺͪ͵ͺͯͬͶͪͳͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͰͶͳͷͽͳΒ;ͳͳ͵ΒͰͽͳͼ;͋ͰͶͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
Ͳͪͷͽͺ
;Ͳͯͪͪͼͬ;ͼͬͰͯͰΔͪͰͬͳͯͪͪͳͲ͵ͪͼͳΒͰͭͬͻͰͷͰͪ
ͫͳͶΒͰͯͳͼͽͪ
ͰͽΓͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͻͰͳͷͪΒͰͺͻͰͼͪͻͪͰͫͪͶͼͪͷͬͪͳͽͳͷͰ;ͬͻͽͰ;
ͪΒͺͽͬͪͳΒ;͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒ;ͷͽͳΒ;͌ͺͻͪͬͽͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪͳΔͰͳͪͯͪΒͰ͋Ͱ
ͯͼͳΒ;;ͺͻͳͽͰͯͪͳͲͰͼͰͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͰͪͯͳͶͪͲͰͪΒ͵ͬͰͳͪͶͳΒͰ
ͽͺͼͰ
ͻͰͳͷ͵ͪͯͪͪͭͶͪͪͬͪͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͪͰ
Ͱͼͪͷͯ;ͷͬͰΕͳͽͰͶͷ
ͳ
ͯͪͳͲͭͶͰͯͪt͵ͪͯͪͼͺͪͬͪi͉ͰͳͽΒͰͳͺͷͰͼͪ;ͬͪͳ͊ͪͬͳͳͬͶͪͼͳ
ͽΒͰ
ͺͲͪͽ
ͪͶͳͳ͵ͪ͵ͳͫͪͬͰͲͪͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͺͳͼͪͷͽͳΒ;
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;ͪͷͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͪͫͪͬͰͽͰΔͪ͊ͪͬͳͷ
ͽͻͬͼ͵ͷͭͻͫ;ͳͪ͵ͽͼ;ͷͽͳͳͲΔͰͭͪͺͯͳͭ;ͽͰ͊ͫͲͳͻͷͪ
ͺͼͬͰͯͰ͊ͪͬͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬ
ΒͰͪͼͽͪͬͳͯͪͼͰͺͽ;ΒͰͳͺͻͳͬͶͪͳ
ͷͭͰͺ͵Ͷͳ͵Ͱ̽ͻͱͰΕͳͼͰ;ͼͽͪΓͰͳͫͻͪͲͪͪ
ͫͪͺͳͼͪͪͳͻ͵ͺͻͳ
ͺͬͰͯͪΒ;;ͯͳͷͪ͵ΒBͭͻͫ
ͳͪ͵ͺͻͪͲͪ
ͳͯͪΓͰͳͳ͌ͬͰͻΓͳͬͲͬ;ͳ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬͽͬͻΌͰΔͰͯͪΒͰͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͭͬͻͪΕͰͪͼͽͪͻͷͰͼͽ tͳͺͻͬͳ͵ͪͷͰͺ
Ͷͱͳͬͻͭͻͫͪi
ͳͺͬͺͻͰ͵ͻͳͬͰͺ͵ͻͬͷ͠Ͱͯͪ͵ͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͳͼ;ͳ
ͺͯͪͳ͊ͪͬͳͳͫͳͭͻͪͿͪ͵ͪΒͼ;ͯͫͳͳͽͻͬͼ͵ͭͭͻͫͪ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰͪ͵ͳͲͬͰͼͭͬͻͰͷͰͪͯͶ;ͰͯͪͼͰͲͪͭͻͪͯͳ͵ͪ͵ͷͭͫͻΒ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͊ͷͳͼͪͺΒͪͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͬͰͼ;WJPMBUJPTFQVMDSJͳEBNOBUJPNFNPSJBFͪͪΒͳͻͳͷͼͬͪ
ͷͪͽ;ͷͪͳ*)FSLMPU[
t4FQVMDSBiͰt.POVNFOUBiEFM.FEJPFWP4UVEJTVMMBSUFTFQPMDSBMFJO
*UBMJB
3PNB
m
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͯ͵ͼͰ;ͻͪͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͺͰͻͳͯ;ͰͻͰͷͳΒͪ
;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ ͵;Ͷͽͪ ͲͪͬͻͪͬͪͶͪ ͺͯͳͲͪΔͰͷ ͷͽͳΒ; ͳͲ ͭͻͫͪ ͳ Δͳͬͳͷ
ͺͶͪͭͪΔͰͷͪͺͪͼͷͰͼͽ;ͻ͵ͬͳ
*9ͳ9ͬͰ͵ͫͰͶͰͱͰͳͼ;ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ
ͷͪͷͭͳͲͪͷͰͳͽͳͶͳͼͽͳ
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ͋ͰͿͪͪ́ͼͺͬͰͯͳ͵ͪ
͋Ͱͯͻͪ
͊ͽ;ͯͳͽͪ
ͼͬͰͽ̺ͭͪͼͳͶͳΒͪ͆ͬͭͳͷͭͳͯͻ;ͭͳ͢ͳͬͪͱͳͽͳΒͪͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͰ
ͪ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳ͵;Ͷͽͪ
;Ͳ;ͫͳͪΒͰͪͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪ
ͯͼͰͳͽͪ͵ͬͰͺͯͪͽ͵Ͱ͵Βͳ
ͺͷͪͱ;ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔ;ͼͪͼͬͳͷͯͻͰΌͰͳͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶͪ͌ͽͳͷͪͭͳͭͻͪ
ͿͳΒͪͷͪͰͼͽͼͰͺͯͬͶͪͳͯͪͲͪͷͰͳͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͰ͵͵ͻͪΕͰͬͻͰͷͰͺͳͬͪ
Β;;ͺͻͬͷͭͻͫ;
ͯ͵ͼͰͰͼͽͰ͵;͵ͶͼͽͳͲͪͺͻͰͼ;͵ͪͺ͵ΒͳͽͰ
͋Ͱ͵ͶͼͽͳͫͳͬͪͶͰͼ;;ͼͶͬΓͰͰͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳͷͺͽͻͰͫͪͷͪͳͷͽͳͬͳͷͪͅ
ͽͳͼͬͰͽ̺ͭͪͼͳͶͳΒͪ͆ͬͭͰ͵ͪͶͰͼ;ͪͺͻͰͼͯ͵ͼ;ͼͰΔͰͭͬͳͺͽͬͪͳ
ͻͪͼͺͻͪͬΓͪͶͳ͵ͳͲͫͻͪ͵ͪͰͶ͵ͪͳΒͰͭͻͫͪ ͠Ͱͯ;ͯͪΒͼͶͱͰͳΒͳ
ͳͪΒͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͳΒͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͳͷͪͶͰͼ;ͷͽͳͻ;ͼ͵ͳ͵ͰͱͰͬͪ
ͷ;Ͱͳ͵̹ͪͻͳͼͪͳ̻ΓͰͫͪ
͵ΒͰͼ;ͯͯͭͯͳͰͺͻͰͰͰ
ͪ͵Ͱͽͳͻͳͺ;ͽͪ
͆Ͱͷͪͼ;ͷΔͰ;ͽͯͪͼ;ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ;ͬͭͻͫͫͳͶͰͪͭͳ
ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ;ͫͶͳͰͰ;ͬͳͯ;ͺͻͺͳͼͪͳͫͻͪͲͪͪ
ͪͶͳΒͰͽͪ͵ΌͰͳͲͬͰͼͯͪͼ;
;ͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͰͼͽͬͪͻͳͬͪͰ;ͬͰͶͳ͵ͷͫͻΒ;ͬͪͻͳΒͪBͽB͋ͪ͵ΒͰͺͰ͵ͪͯ
ͷͪͯͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ
ͫΒͪͬΓͰͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͷͭͪͫͳͽͳͺͬͺͶͱͰ;ͲͰͷΓ;͌ͼͽͪΓͰ
ͳͫͳͪΒͫͳΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͯͪͼͰͷͽͳͪ͵ͺͻͰͼͪͺͶͱͰ;ͯͻͬͰͳ͵ͬͰͭ
͇ͬͪ͵ͬͻͰͰΔͰͯͻ;ͭͭͭͻͫͪͫͳͶΒͰ
ͽͪͬͳͰ
ͺͻͪͬͳͶͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͼͪͻͪͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͷͪͪ͋ͪ͵ͪͬ͵ͳͬͽͪΒͰΕͰͼͰ;͵ͻͪͪͬͪ͵ͬͷͯͯͻͪͭ
ͰͳͷͰͽͪͶͪ
ͼͻͪͷͰͽͪͶͳͷͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪͷͪ͊;ͯͰΕͳͺͺͳͼͳͷͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ
͵ͬͳͯͪͼͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽͳ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰͺͼͰͯͬͪͶͰͼ;ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͻͪͼ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ͵Ͱ ͵ͳͬͽͪ ̀ͪ Δͳͷͪ ͳͼ; ͲͪͼͽͪΒͪͶͳ ͳ ͻ;ͼ͵ͳ ̀Ͷͪͽͷ ͳ ͼͻͰͫͻͷ
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
͵ͬͪͳ͵ͳͬͽͳ̹ͻͳͼͪͳ̻ΓͰͫͪͳͲͪͲͳͬͪͶͳͼ;ͯͳͬΓͰΔͰͪ͵ͳͭͻ͵ͳͯͪ
ͼͳ͵ͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͬͳͯͰͶͳͪΒͬͰΕͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ͇ͺͼͰͫΒͼ͵Ͷͼͽͳ
ͻ;ͼ͵ͰͼͻͰͯͳͰͺͻͰͷͪͻͪͼ͵ͳͷ͵ͳͬͽͳͷͪͼͬͰͯͳͳͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔͰͽͷͰͯͪ
ͼ;͵ͬͰͲͳͼͬͰͽͳͻͼͽͬͼ͵ͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ̈́ͰͽͳΒͪͳ́ͼͪͳΒͰ ͳͲͯͻ;ͭͰͺͶͬͳ
Ͱ9**ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͽͰͱͳͶͳͯͰͬͰͽ
ͯͼͼͰͯͪͷͺ;ͯͬͪͲͶͪͽͪ̽ͻ;ͭͳͭͻͫͼͬͰͽͳͽͰ
ΓͪͳΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͷͻͪͫͪͬͰͲͫͳͽͳ;ͬͳͯ;ͯͻͬͰͭ͵ͳͬͽͪ͆Ͱ͵Ͱͷͽͳ
ͺͶͪͭͪͰͼ;;͵ͪͷͰͰ͵ͬͰͭͰ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷͪͶͳ͵ͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͲͳͷͪ͌ͽͪ͵ͬͷͷͪͶͷ
ͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭ; ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;
ͳΒͳ ͼͰ ͫͶͳ͵ͷͱͰͳͺͽͰͽͳͻͰ͵ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪͽͳ
ͺͳͬͪͶΒͰͽͰͶͼͬͰͽͰ͋ͰͯͻͰ͊Ͷ;ͼ͵Ͱͪ͵ͺͻͰͼͪͭͯͳͰ̺Ͱͷͪ
ͼͶͳͪ͵ͪͷͰͳ͵ͬͰͭ;ͬͪΒͰͯͭͯͳͰͷͽͳͻ;ͼ͵Ͱ͵ΔͰͭͳΔͰ͇ͶͭͰ
́ͯͻ;ͭͳͻ;ͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͺͳͬͪͶͳͼ;;͵ͪͷͰͳͷͻͪ͵ͪͷͪ
BͰ;ͯͻͬͰͳͷ
͆Ͱ͵ͳͯͽͳͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͭͪͫͳͶͳͼ;ͪ͵
ͺ;ͭͶͰͯ;ͪ͵ͳͬͽͰ
͵ͬͪͳͼͻͰͫͻͷͳ
ͲͶͪͽͷ͆ͪͽͪΒͪͳΒͰ
ͰͭͯͰͼͻͰͯͳͷ9**ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͽͬͪͶͪͺͻͰͺͯͫͭ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒ͈ͪͰͰͻͼ͵ͭͺͳͷͰ;̻ͰͻͭͳΒͰ;͵ͻͪͼͳ͵ͪͷͰ;ͻͪ͵;ͼΔͰͭͬͳͷͷ
ͽͳͷͪ
͈ͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
ͯͻ;ͭͳͭͻͫmͫͰͲͫͲͳͻͪͪͽͯͪͶͳΒͰͻͰͯͻͬͰͷͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͷͰͷ͵ͬͰͭ;mͼͷͰͽͪͼͰͪΒ;ͱ;ͼͽͻͪ;ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͪΒͰΕͰͺͻͰͯͶͽͪͻͪ
͋ͪ͵ͪͬͺͶͱͪΒ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳΒͰͫͳͳͫͪͬͰͲͪ͊ͪ;ͬͪͳͳͲͬͻͳͺͼͬͰͯͳͶͳ
ͫͳͯͪͼ;ͼͰͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͰͷͽͳͷͭͶͰ;ͬͪͽͳͺͻͪ͵ͽͳͪͫͳͶ͵ΒͰͷͷͰͼͽ;
;ͼͻͰͯͻͪͷͪͳͶͳ;ͲΔͰͭͬͼͰͬͰͻͳͲͳͯ
;ͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͳ
;Ͳ;ͶͪͲͪͬͻͪͽͪͪͼͪͳ
ͪͻͽͰ͵ͼͪ
ͺͪͪ͵ͳ;͵;Ͷͳm;͐Ͱͻͳͭͬͼ͵ͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;ͭͯͳͰͽͰͶ͵Ͱ
Ͳͪ́ͭͻͪ
ͼͬͰͽ̻ͭͰͻͭͳΒͪ͐Ͱͻͳͭͬͼ͵ͭ
ͺͶͱͰΒͰ;͵;Ͷ;͌ͺͼͰͫͳͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪͷͽͳͼ;ͳͲͶͪͭͪͰͺͼͬ;ͯͪ;ͻͪͷ;͇ͽͷͫͳͪΒ;ͼͪ;ͬͪͶͼͰ
ͯͻͪͭͰͼͬͰͯͰΔͰͻ;ͼ͵ͭͯͪͼͳ͵̸ͪͽͳΒͪ͆ͬͭͻͯͼ͵͇ͭͺͳͼ;Β;
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ΕͳͺͼͰͽ;ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵Βͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͰͽͭ́ͶͳΒͰ
͵ͪͱͰͯͪͼͰͺͻͪͲͳͳͷͪͺ
ͳͽͪͬΒͻ͵ͬͳͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;ͼͽͶͬͳͳͪΔͳͷͪͳͲͶͪͱ;ͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͌ͽͷͳͻͰͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͽͻͰͫͪͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͼͬͰͯͰΔͪ͊ͪͬͳͳͱͳͬͽͺͳ
ͼͪͪͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪΔͰͭͬͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ͆Ͱ͵ͰͯΔͳͯͯͪͽͼ;ͼͬͰͽΓͰ
ͰͬͳΒͳͷͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͳͷͪ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳͅͰΌ;ͺͻͪΌͰͳͷͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵ͳͷ
ͭͻͫͳͪͷͪͷͭ;ͼͰ
͵ͪͪΒͻͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͳΒͰ
ͳͲͯͬΒͳͽͳͽͻͳ͵ΒͰͼ;ͫͳͶͰ
ͫͰͶͰͱͰͰͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͲͳͷ͇ͪͼͳͷͬͰΕͺͲͪͽͰͭͻͫͳͰ͵ͻͪΓ̺ͪͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ;Β;
ͭͲͪͺͪͯͷͯͰͶ;ͪͼͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͪΒͰͳͪ;ͲΒ;ͱͳͲͳͯͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͰ͆ͪͼͬ;ͼͽ;
ͯͰͳ͵ͭͺͻͽͽͳͺͪͪͼͰ
ͼͻͪͲͶͭͷ
ͺͻͳͺͳͼ;ΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͳͳ̓ͪ͊ͪͬͳ;ͫͳ
ͺͪ͵ͽͻͰͫͪͶͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵ͬͪͽͳͭͻͫͳ;;ͼͰͬͰͻͳͼͽͷ;ͭͶ;ͰͭͲͪͻͽͰ͵
ͼͪ
͵ΒͪͼͰͯͺͻͰͽͯͰͯͬͰ;ͺͪͯΓͳͬͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ΒͰͬͰͶͳͳͷͳͺͻͪͬ;ͭͪͷ
Ϳͻͷͷ̽ͻ;ͭͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ
ΒͰͯͳͼͰ;Δ;ͷͭͪͼͺ;ͼͽͳͽͳ͵ͬͰͭͼͪ͊ͪͬͳͳͷ
ͽͰͶͷ́Ͳͻͳͳͽ
ͪͺͻͬͳͺͭͶͰͯͰͫͳͽͬͻΌͰΔͰ͊ͪͬͳͳͫͳͭͻͪͿͪͯͪ
ͼ;ͷͽͳ
ͷͪͯͪͺͽͬͻΌͰͰ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͰ
ͺͬͺͶͱͰͰ;ͲͰͷΓ;
ͬͳͯͰͶͳͼͷ
ͳΒͰͫͰͲͪͪͶͭͳΒͪ;ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;̺ͰͻͯͼͽΒͳͲͭͶͰͯͪͳͼͬͰͯͰΔͰ
ͽͷͰͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͳ;ͭͻͫͳ;ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͳ͵ͻͪΓ̺ͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬ͋ͷͰ;ͺͻͳͶͭͳͶͪ
ͫͳͳΔͰͳͪͯͪΒͰͭͻͫͳͪ;ͰͭͲͪͻͽͰ͵ͼ;Ͳͳͯͪͪ;ͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰͷͼͶͭ;ͳͰ
ͷͪͻͳΒͰͯ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͳ
ͺͼͬΒͺͻͳͶͳͳͪͫͻͲͳ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͪͷͺͻͰͼ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͽͪ͵ͬͪͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵ͪͳΒͪ͊ͪͬͳͰͭͻͫͳͰͳͷͪͳͼ;ͽͳͼ͵;ͺͻͳͽͰ
ͪ
ͼͰͯͼͳͪͺͻͬͫͳͽ;ͪͷͰ;ͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵ͰͼͺΓͰͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͰ͋ͪͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ
͵ͪͳΒͪͫͳͺͽͬͻͯͳͶͪͯͪͬͳͲͰͽ;ͽͰͲ;
;ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰͺͯ;ͺͻͽ;ͬͻͶΒͪ͵ͳͷ
ͪͻͭ;ͷͰͽͳͷͪ
ͯͪΒͰͽ;ͼͽͬͪͻͰͪͰͶͬͳͽͪͲͪͷͳͼͪͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͰͭͻͫͳͰ
ͳΒͳΒͰͳͯͰΒͳͽͬͻͪͫͳͼͪͷͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ
͠ͰͯͪͯͲͪͪΒͳͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͪͬͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͅͳͶͰͰͬͰΒͰͼͽͰͳͺͻ
ͪͶͪͲͪ͵ͷͰͻͷͰͻͳͿͻͪͭͷͰͪͽͪ
ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪͽͻͳͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͪ͆ͪͼͬ;;ͼͶͬͪ
Δͳͬͭ ͪͶͪͲͪ
͵ͪ ͳ ͯͻ;ͭͳ ͳΔͰͳͪ
ͯͶ ͼͰ ͯ Ͳͪ͵Γ;͵ͪ ͯͪ ͼ; ͪͯ
ͭͻͫͳͪͷͪ ; ͪͼ; ͳ ͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͳ ͼͽͪΒͪͶͳ ͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͲͳ ͯ ͻͬͰͭ ͷͰͻͷͰͻͪ
*CJE
͇ ̓ͪͯͳΕ
̻ͻͫͪ ͫͰͶͰͱΒͪ ; ͻ͵ͬͳ ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪ ͅͳͶͰͰͬͰ
͊ͪͺͽͰΔͪ
m̾̀ͰͰͬͳΕ
́ͼ͵ͺͪͬͪΔͰͭͻͫͳͰ͵ͻͪΓ̺ͪͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ
͊ͪͺͽͰ
Δͪ
m ͊ ̿ͳͬͪͬͳΕ
̺ ̈́ͰͽͳΕ
ͅͽͳ ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭ ͵ͻͪΓͪ Dͬ
̺ͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
͊ͪͺͽͰΔͪ
m͇̓ͪͯͳΕ
̽ͅͳͳΕ
͈̾ͰΒͬͳΕ
ͪͪͅͼͽͳͻͅͳͶͰͰͬͪ́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰͳͫͬͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯm͈ͻͳΒͰͺΓͰ
m͇̓ͪͯͳΕ
́ͲͭͶͰͯͅͳͶͰͰͬͰ;ͬͻͰͷͰͼͺͪΓͳͬͪΔͪͷͽͳΒ;͊ͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
JO͊ͬͰ
ͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͳͼͽͻͳΒͳͳͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ
FE͊ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
͇ͬͪͼͬͪͽͪΔͪͳͲͶͱͰͪͼ;ͳ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͼͪͪ͵͈ͯ̽ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͭͻͫ
m
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
͋ͻͰΕ;ͭͻ;ͺ;ͿͻͪͭͷͰͪͽͪmͯͰͶͬͰͺͼͽΓͪͯͫͰͶͭͷͰͻͷͰͻͪmͽͻͰͫͪͶͫͳ
ͺͻͳͺͳͼͪͽͳͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭ;ͪͯͭͻͫͳͷͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ́ͲͭͶͰͯͽͭͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͪ
͵ͪͳ;͵;ͺͻͰͰΔͰͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵ͭ
ͺͰͽͺͻͳͬͻͰͷͰͭ͊ͪͬͳͭͭͻͫͪ
ͷͻͪ
ΒͰͫͳͽͳͼͪͼͬͳͷͼͶͳͪͳͲͭͶͰͯ;ͭ;͋ͻͬ;̻ͽͬͳͼͽͬͰͽͪͫͳͶͪͳͷΒͰ
͵ͪͪͼ;ͯͫͳͪ
ͷͪͯͪͲͫͭͺͽͺ;ͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͳͻͪͲͶͭͪ͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͪͼͬ;
ͪͻͰͶ͵ͳͪͶͪͲͪͲͪͼͰͯͪͼ;;͊ͪͬͳΒͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵Βͭͻͫͳͳ
͵ͪͳ;
ͺͻͼͽͻ;ͺͻͰͯΔͰ
ͪ͵ͪͯͫͪͬΓͰͰͼͪͻͪͰ͢ͳͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͽͻͰͫͪͺͬͰͲͪ
ͽͳͼ;ͻͰͲͪͳͷͭͻͫͳͷͪͽͺͳͼͳͷͪͰ͵ͶͳͼͳΒͪͻͪ͊ͪͬͰͳͳͭ;ͷ̸ͪͪͽͪͪͼͳΒͪ
͇ͳͭͶͰͯΒͰͯͪΒͰͪ͵ͺͯͳͲͪΔͪͷͽͳΒ;ͳͼͺͻͪͱΔͰͪͭͻͫͳͪͺͬ
;ͺͽͻͰͫΓͰ̹ͪ;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪΒͰ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳ͊ͪͬͪͫͳͺͻͳͼ;ͽͪ͵ͻͲͼͬΒͰͰͶ
͵;ͺͰͷͽͳ
ͳͲͶͱͰͰ;͵ͳͬͽ;
ΔͰͭͬͺͻͬͳͭͻͫͳͲͭ;ͫͳΒͰͼͷͳͼͪ́ͼͽ
ΒͰͫͳͶͼͭͻͫͷ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ
͵ΒͳΒͰͺͪ;Ͳͪͫͻͪͬ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;ͷͽͳͪ͵ͺͯͳͲͪΔͪͺͻͰͰͽͰ;̿ͳ;͊Ͷ;ͪΒͳͷͼͽͳͪΒͰͷ͵Ͷ
ͼͽͳ
ͯ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͺͻͬͭͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͪ
͵ͪͳͯ͊ͪͬͳͭͷͳͶͰͰͬ
ͼ͵ͭ
ͼͪ;ͬͪͶͳͼ;ͼͰͼͪͷͯͰͶͬͳͺͼͽΓͪ
͠ΒͰͯͼͬͰͯͰΔͰ͊ͪͬͳͭͺͻͬͭͫͳͭͻͪͿͪͷͱͰͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͺ;Ͳͯͪ
ͳͷ͊ͳͭ;ͻΒͰͯͪͼ;ͪ͵ͺͯͳͲͪΔͪͳͲͭͻͫͳͰ͊ͪͬͳͰͷͽͳͺͶͱͰͰ
;ͫͭͪͽ;͵ͻͪͰͯͻͬͰͳ͵ͳͬͽ͇ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪΔͰͭͬͭ;͵ͻͪͼͪmͺͯͺͻͰͽ
ͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͷͯͪΒͰͻͰͳͼͽͷ
ͺͻͬͫͳͽͷ͵ͬͰͭ;mͭͬͻͰͺͳͼͳͺ;ͽͺͳͼͪͪ
ͳͲ97*ͼͽͶͰΕ̺ͪͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬͭͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͺͻͳͼͯͳͰͼͪͷ
ͳͲͼͪͲͪΔͪͯͪͼ;;ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;ͪͽͪΒͪͳ;ͬͪͰͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͷͪͪͬͰΕͳͪͼͬ;ͳΔͰͳͰͯͪͼ;
͵Ͷͳ͵Ͳͪͷ
ͷͽͳͼͬΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰ
Γͪ͊ͻͫͳ;ͬͰ͵;ͬͪͶͳ;ͯͻͬͰͳͷ;͵ͻͪͰͳͷ͵ͬͰͲͳͷͪ
͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪΒͰͰͺͲͪͳͪͺͶͱͪΒ͊ͪͬͳͭ͵ͳͬͽͪ;ͻͪͷ;
͌Ͳ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬͼͬͰͯͰΔͰ
ΒͰͯͳͳͺͯͪͽͪ͵͵ΒͳͺͷͪͱͰͻͰͪͬͪΔ;ͽͭͺͳ
7ͪͺ
͉͆ͳ͵ͶͳΕ
͇ͭͻͫ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳ
͊ͪͺͽͰΔͪ
m͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
m
͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
m
̻ͯͳͰ̺ͶͿͭͪͭͅͳͰͻͳͲ̹ͪͷͫͰͻͭͪͫͰͶͰͱͳͯͪΒͰ͵ͳͬͽͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰtNJU
TJMCFSOWFSHVMEFO#MFJDIMFJO[JFSMJDIÛCFSMFHUi
W.͈;ͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̹ͰͶͰ͵ͪͺ;ͽͺͳͼͪͅͳ
Ͱͻͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͪͭͯͳͰ
͠;ͱͳͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ
ͭͯ9*
Ͱͽ
͵ͪͼͳΒͰ
͈ͪͶ̓ͽͪͻͳͳͼͬͰͯͳͯͪΒͰͻͪ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰtUVUUBHVFSOJUBEJGVPSJ
EBSHFOUPBêHVSF EPSBUFi
%JBSJPEFMWJBHHJPEB7FOF[JBB$POTUBOUJOPQPMJEJ.1BPMP$PO
UBSJOJ
7FOF[JB
͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
ͳQBTTJN
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͽͪΔͪͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ;ͺͳͼ;͈ͪͶͪ̓ͽͪͻͳͳΒͪͳͲͭͯͳͰ͋ͪΒͽͰ͵ͼͽ
ͬͰΕ
ͬͳͰ ͺ;ͽͪ ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͼͪ
ͷͭ;ΕͰ ΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬͳͶ ͺͻͽ;ͷͪͳͽͳ ͽͰ͵
ͼͪͯͪ
;ͼͬͰͽͶͼͽͳͬͳͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔ͇ͪͳͼ;
ͼͪͼͬΒͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͺͽͬͻͯͳͶͳ̓ͽͪͻͳͳΒͰͬͳͼ͵ͪͲͯͪͼ;ͼͰ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳͪͶͪͲͳͶͪͯͬͪͳͼͽͬͰͽͪ
ͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͪmͪͽͼ;͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͳͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͲͳͯͻͬͰͭͷͰͻͷͰͻ͈ͪͻͰͷͪ̓ͽͪ
ͻͳͳΒ;
͊ͪͬͳ͵ͳͬͽͪͶͪͲͳͼͰͲͪͺͪͯ;ͯͼ;ͪͭͻͫ;ͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͳt0MUSF
MBSDBEJTBOUP4BCBwOFIBVOBMUSBWFSTPMFWBOUFwFOFMMBNFEFTJNBBSDBFJM
DPSQPEJSF-BEJTMBPi͇ͯͪͽͶͰͼͶͰͯͳͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵ͯͪΒͰ͵ͳͬͽ
ͫͪͻ;97*ͬͰ͵;
ͫͳ
;ͰͭͲͪͻͽͰ͵ͼ;͈ͯ;ͼͶͬͷͯͪͼͰͯͼͶͬͼͬͪͽͳ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬͼͬͰͯͰ
ΔͰ
ͷͱͰͼͰͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬͳͽͳͯͪͼͰͪͶͪͲͳͺͼͻͰͯͽͭͺͻͼͽͻͪ
Ͳͪͳ;
ͼͶͫͯͼͽΒͰΕͰͷͺͶͱͪΒ;͌ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͿ;ͰͻͪͻΒͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪͰͷͪ
ͪͪͶͭͳΒͪͲͪͽͪ͵ͬͻͰͰΔͰ͆ͪͺͻͽͳͬ
ͼͬͪͺͳͼͪͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͳͻͰͽ͵ͳͼͪ;
ͬͪͳͼͺͷͰͳͳͺͼͬͰͯͳͶͳͫͳͯͪͼ;͵ͳͬͽͳͼͷͽͳͷͪͺͶͪͭͪͳͳͼͺͻͰͯ
Ͷͽͪͻͪ́ͺͪ͵
ͰͽͻͰͫͪͳͲͭ;ͫͳͽͳͳͲͬͳͯͪͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͰͺͻͳͷͰͻͰͳͲͬͳͲͪ
ͽͳΒͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽ͈ͪͼͻͰͯͻ͵ͬͰͼͽͪΒͪͶͳͼ;;t̽ͰͼΒͪͽͳΒiͭͻͫͬͳ͵ͳΒͰͬͼ͵ͳ͵Ͱ
ͱͰͬͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳͳͻͪ͵;ͼͬͰͽ̺ͭͶͪͯͳͷͳͻͪ͌;ͬͰΒͻͪͼͺͻͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ
ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ̹ͻͳͼͪͳ̻ΓͰ̺ͫͪͶͪͯͳͷͳͻͅͷͪͺͻͰͯͶͪͭͪΒͰͯͪͼͰ
͵ͳͬͽͳͼΔͳͬͳͷͷͽͳͷͪͺͼͽͪͬͰ;ͼͻͰͯͻ͵ͬͰͳͪͯͬͳͼͰͫͪͶͯͪͳͷ
͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͺͼͽΒͰΒͪ͵ͳͻͪͲͶͲͳͲͪ;ͬͰͻͰΔͰͯͪͼͰ;ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷ͈ͪͽ͵ͻͪͽͻ;
ͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͰͷͷͪ;ͲͶͰΒ;͊ͪͬͳͭͯͫͪ
ͭͻͫͫͰͶͰͱΒͰͪͅΒͶͪ**̓ͷͳͪ
ͪͶͪͲͳͶ;ͼͪͷΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͻ͵ͬͰ̸ͻͪΌͰͶͪͅͳͪͳͶͪ͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͶͭͳ
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
͵Ͱͺͻͼͽͻͪ
ͯͳͼͽͪΒͰͷͭ;ΕͰͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͽͳͯͪͼͰ;ͼͻͰͯͺͻͼͽͻͪͭͳͲͪͽͪͷΔͰ
ͭͰͲͪͻͽͰ͵ͼͪ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳͪͶͪͲͳͫͶͳͼͽͪͬ
ͼͬͰͽΓͰ͵ͳͬͽmͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͪ
ͬͳͼ͵ͷͺͼͽΓ;
ͪͺͻͬͫͳͽͷͱͯͪͳͺͯͫͪͶͯͪͳͷm͵ͪͿ͵;ͼ͵;Ͷͽͪ
͵Βͳ ΒͰ
ͺͯͷ
ͷͭͶ ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪͽͳ ͷͽͬ ͺ͵Ͷͳ͵ͪ ͇ͯ ͪΒͻͪͳΒͳ
ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͬͻͰͷͰͪͽͪ͵ͬͰͼͰͺ;Ͷ͵ͻͪͶ͵;ͶͽͰͳͼͰͪͳΒͰͼͽͬͪͻͪͰͼ;Ͳͪ
ͺͽͻͰͫͰͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪͪͻͳͽ;ͬͪͱͰͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͈ͼͰͫͪͼͷͳͼͪͳͷͪΒ;ͳͳͼ͵ͪͲͳ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͪͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͪͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͳ͵ͳ
ͬͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͰtͪͬͳΌͰΔͰͼͬͳͷͪi̽ͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽͪͬͪͱͼͽ͵Β;ΒͰͲͪ͵;Ͷͽ
ͳͷͪͰͺͼͻͰͯͪ͵ͽͪ͵ͽͼͷͽͳͷͪ͆ͪΒͺͱͰΓͳΒͰΒͰͫͳͶͯͽͪΕͳ
ͯͼ
ͰͶͳͬͪͽͳ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰ
Ͳͫͭ ͬͻͼͽͭ ;ͬͰͻͰΔͪ ; Δͳͬ; ͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵; ͷΕ
ͪͶͳΒͰͬͰͻͳͷͪͷͭͲͪͳͶͪͳͷͭ;ΕͼͽͯͪͼͰͼͬΒͳͷͳͷͪ;ͬͰͻͰ;ͼͽͬͪͻ
ͼͽΔͳͬͭͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪ͋ΒͰͻͪͲͶͭͽͼ;ͪͰ͵ͳͷ͵ͳͬͽͳͷͪͺͻͫͳΒͰͳ
ͺͼͰͫͳͽͬͻͳ
ͽͪ͵ͲͬͪͰGFOFTUFMMBF͆ͰͷͱͰͷͲͪͽͳͼͪͼͳͭ;ͻΕ;ͪ
͵Βͳͼ;ͪͳͳ;͵ΒͳͷͼͬͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͫͳͶͰͳͲͶͱͰͰ
tͬͳΌͰΔ;i͉;ͼ͵ͳͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͯͪͼͳͳ
ͺͼͰͽͳͳͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͰͺͻͰ
ͼͽͳͰ
ͼͽͪͬͳͶͳͼ;ͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͽͷͰͯͪͼ;̻ͻͳͷͽͳͰͼͽͯͻͱͪͶͳ;
ͲͪͽͬͻͰͳͷ͵ͬͰͲͳͷͪ
ͺͪͪ͵ͳͲͪͺͰͪΕͰͳͷ
͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͰͼͺͻͰͳͶΔͳͬ
ͽͰΕͰΔͰ
ͪͶͳͳ͵ͻͪΌͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ͆ͬͭͻͯͼ͵ͳͱͪͶͳͼͰ
ͽͪ͵
ͯͪͼͰ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪ
ͯ;ͷͽͳͷͭ;ͬͳͯͰͽͳͼͪͷͪ͵ͼͰͯͫͻͺͶͪͽͳ
ͯ͵ͫͳͪͼͬͰͽͷͻͪͯͪͼͪ
Ͱ͵ͪͺͻͪͲͳ͵ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳͶͳͯͪͻͪͷͬͰͼͶͪͬͰͅͽͳͰ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͫͳͶͰͼ;ͳͺͪ͵ͯͼͽ;ͺͳΒͰ͵ͳͬͽͼͬͰͽ̸ͭͬͰͻ͵ͳΒͪ
;ͬͪ;ͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͰͽͭ͊ͺͪͼͪ
;ͪͭͪͅͳ
ͽͬͪͻͪΒͰͯͬͪͺ;ͽͪͼͰͯͷͳ
ͪͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͰ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ;ͳͼͽͳͷͰ
Βͻ͵ͬͳͷͭͶͰͼ;ͼͰͬͳͯͰͽͳͺͰͯͰΓ͵ͷ
ͼͻͰͯͷͳͺͰͽ͵ͷ
͈ͶͪͭͪΔͰͷͷͽͳΒ;;͵ͳͬͽͳΔͰͭͬͳͷͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͰͷ;ͻ͵ͬͳͺͻͪ͵ͽͳΒͰ
ͫͳͲͪͬͻͰͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ͌ͺͻͰͯͼͺͳͼͪͳͷͺͼͽ;ͺͳ
ͷͪͼͽͬͪͻͪͳͼ;Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͳ
͵ͪΔͰͭͬͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͲͳͰͶͰͷͰͽͳΒͰ
ͯͪͯͰͺͯͳ;ͼͶͬͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽ̸ͬͪ͵;ͺͻͰͯͳͷͽͪͯͬͪͺͪͻͪͶͰͶͪͽ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̀ͪͬͺͳͽͪΔͰẄ́ͅͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
͌ͬͻͽͰΔͰͯͰͼͺͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͪ;ͻͰͯͼͬͰ
ͽͳͽͰΓͪ
̹ͭͼͶͬΓͰ
ͭͯ**
ͼͬ
m͚͋ͻͳͿ;ͬͳΕ
͊ͽͪͻͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͻ
͵ͬͰͪͺͰͲͳΒͪ
JO͇͊ͻͫΓͪ͵;
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m ͼͫͳͷͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
ͪͼͽͪ
͵; ͼͶ;ͱͫͳ ͼͬͰͽͷ ͊ͪͬͳ ̽ ̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
͆ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͪ ͼͶ;ͱͫͪ ͼͬͰͽͷ ͊ͪͬͳ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
7ͪͺ
͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
m
m ͼͳͲͬͻͳͷͪͳͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
ͭͻͫͳͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͅͽͳͼ;ͳ;ͳͻͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ͷͻͪͶͰͫͳͽͳͳͲ;ͲͰͽ
ͬͪͱͪͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͺ͵Ͷͳͽͬͪ
ͪͻͳͽͯ9*7ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
ͯͫͳΒͪͪ;ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶͼͽͳͳͺͼͽͪΒͰͼͬͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͳͯͻͱͪͬͳ͉ͪͲͷͰͻͰͽͬͪ
Δͪ
ͺͻͪΕͰͭ;ͼͽͪΓͰͳͷͫͳͪΒͳͷͪͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͪͪ͵ͳͬͽ
ͷͭ;ͼͰͪΒͫΓͰͼͪ
ͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ͵ͻͲͰ͵ͪͯͪΔͰͫͭͪͽͼͽͬͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰ
͵ΒͪͼͰͯͪͪͼͷͱͰ
ͽͰ͵ͿͻͪͭͷͰͽͪͻͻͰ͵ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪͽͳͅͽͳͼ;ͳͭͶͰͯͺͻͰͱͳͬͰͶͰͺͻͬ
ͺ;ͼͽͰΔͰͅͳͶͰͰͬͰͭͯͳͰmΔͳͬͽͬͪΔͰ
͵ͪͳͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͰͪ
͵ͳͬͽ
ͺ;ͲͯͪKFͺͼͬͰͯͰͳͪ͵ͽͭͬͻͰͷͰͪ͆ͪΒͯͻͪͷͪͽͳͳΒͳͽͻͰ
;ͽͪ͵ΔͳͬͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰ
͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͼͬͰͼͽͳͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪ
ͪͪͻͳͽͺͽͷͼͽͬͪ
ͯͫͳͻͪͲͷͰͻͰͺͽͰͪͻͯͰͰͼͻͰΕͰ
ͫͳͶΒͰͼͺͪΓͳͬͪΔͰ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰͺͲͪͺ
ͬͰͼͽͳ͊ͳͪͺͪͰ
ͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͰͻͪͯͳ͵ͪͶͰͪͻͫͪͪͼ͵Ͱͼͽͻ;ΒͰ͵ΒͪΒͰͼͽͰ͵Ͷͪ
ͺͻͰͬͶͪͼͽ͈ͪͻͽͳ͇ͽͷͯͭͪΌͪΒ;ͺͼͽΒͳͳͽͪͬͪͫͳͫͶͳͽͰ͵ͪͻͪͯͬͪ
;
ͳΒͰͷΒͰͼͻͰͯͳͽ;ͫͳͶͪͻͪͼͺͻͪͬͪͽͪΒͭͯͳͳͼͺͪΓͳͬͪΔͪͷͽͳΒ;͇ͯ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ͉́;ͬͪͻͪͯͫͪͳͭͯͳ;
ͪͳͲͰͪͻͭ;ͷͰͽͲͪ
;ͬͳͰͪͬͻͪͽͪ
ͪΒͰΕͰΒ;ͫͳͶͰΒͳͷͪ
ͫͪͬΓͪͰͼ;ͺͶͰͷͳ͵Ͱ;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;
;ͰͼͽͬͬͪͶͳͭͽͬͼͬͳͳͼͽͻͳͪͻͳͯͳͷͰͪͼ͵ͻͪΒͪ9*9ͳͳͲͺͻͬͳͺͰͽͯͰͰ
ͳΒͪ99ͬͰ͵ͪ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
;ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰ
ͺͽͼ;ͺͻ;ͰͳͯͽͪͯͪͰͺͲͪͽͳ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳͳͲͬͻͳ
͵ͪΒͰͯ͵ͪͲͪͯͪͼ;ͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͼͺͪΓͰͰ
ͭͯͳͰ
̀ͪ͵;ͺΓͰͼͽͳͼͽͻͳͪͻͪͽͳͷͯͭͪΌͪΒͰͷͺ͵ͻͰ;ͶͪΒͰΒΒͰͯͺͳͽͪΔͰ
ͷͪͯͪͺͼͽͻͪͳͯͭͶͪͬͭͽ͵ͪͺͶͰͷͳ͵Ͱ͌ͽͻͰΕΒͯͰͰͳΒͳ99ͬͰ͵ͪͺͻͽͪ
͊̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰͬͳΕͺͻͫͶͰͷͪͽͳͲͬͪΒͰͼͪͷͳͼͺͪΓͳͬͪΔ͈ͪͽΒͰͺͻ;ͳ
ͳͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͬͪͯͽͪͯͪͰͺͲͪͽ;ͭͻͪΌ;ͳͲͻ;ͼ͵ͳͪͻͳͬͪ
ΒͰ;͵ͪͲͪͪͳ
ΔͰͳ;ͯͪͻ;ͼ͵ͳͳͲͬͻͳͳͲ97**ͬͰ͵ͪ;ͬͳͰͪͬͻͪͽͪͰͼͪͷͽͼͬͰͯͰ
ͽͬͪΔ;ͷͽͳΒ;;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳͳͪ͵ͭͯͳͰͬͰΕΔͳͷͪͭͬͻͰ
ͪͬͰ
ͷͪͯͻͰΌͰͪͳ̽ͰͼͰͽͪ͵ͭͯͳͪ͵ͪͼͳΒͰͺͻͽͪ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰͬͳΕͬͻͪͽͳͼͰ
ͳͼͽͷͺͻͫͶͰͷ;͌ͲͬͰΕͳͲͰͽ;ͪͻͭ;ͷͰͽͪͳΒ;
ͺ͵ͪͲͪΒͰͯͪͼͰͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪ
ͼͽͻͪͯͪΔ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͷͭ;͵ͬͳͻͼͬͻͼͽͪͽͳ;ͯͬͰͼ͵;ͺͳͰΒͰͯ;͵ΒͪͯͭͪΌͪΒ
ͬͰͲ;ΒͰͲͪ͵ͻͪΒ97*ͬͰ͵ͪͳͯͻ;ͭ;͵ΒͪͭͪͺͻͰͯͰΓ;ΒͰ;ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͯͰͰͳΒͰ97**
ͼͽͶͰΕͪ͋ͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ͊̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰͬͳΕͺͬͳΒͰͼͬΒͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵ͯͪͷͽͳ
ͳͼ;;ͰͶͳͳͼͺͪΓͰͰͭͯͳͰ
ͬͰΕͯͪΒͰΒͰͯͪΔͳͬͯͰͫͳͼͪ;ͬͪ
ͯ͵ͳΒͰͺͼͽͻͪͯͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͯͻ;ͭͰͺͪͻͰͅͳͶͰͰͬͰͭͯͳͰ
ͪͶͳ
ͳͲ
ͭͶͰͯͪ
ͳͽͪͯͪ;ͺͽͺ;ͼͽͳ
ͪ͵ͼͰͳͷͪΒ;;ͬͳͯ;ͼͬͰͯͰΔͪͼͪ;ͬͪΒͻ;ͳ
ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ͌Ͳ̽ͅͻͪͭͬͳΕͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͳͼͽΒͽͰͷͳͼͽͪͬͳͬͰͷͪͼͷ;Ͱ
ͺͻͳͶͭ
ͶͳͰͪ;ͳͼͬͪ
ΒͰͯͳͳΒͰ̽̓ͼͽͳΕ;͵ͪͲͪͪͺͽͻͰͫ;ͯͪͼͰ
ͺͻͫͶͰͷͺͯͻͫͳΒͰͳͼͺͳͽͪ́ͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͪΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼͽͪͶͪͭͽͬͫͰͲ
ͯΒͰ͵ͪͷͰΌ;ͺͽΔͳͷͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͷͪ
͵Βͳͼ;ͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͺͼͽΒͪΔ;͊ͪ
ͬͳͳͷͽͳΒ;ͪ͵ͭͯͳͰͫͳͶͳͼ͵Ͷͳͯͪͽ;ͷͪͰ
ͭͻ;ͫͻͰͰ
͵ͪ
ͷͪͳͺ;ͶͪͳΒ;ͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵ͳͷͪͪ
̸͵ͼͰͯͪͪͼ
ͺͼͶͰͰͲͯͰͼͰͽͭͯͳͪ
ͺͬͳͺͪͱΓͳͬͺͻ;ͰͲͪͺͪͱͪ
ΔͪͺͻͽͰ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰͬͳΕͪ
ͬͰΕͳͪΔͳͯͰͶ;ΒͰͬͰͷͪͻͪͲͶͱ
ͪͭͻͪΌͪ͵Β;
͍͆ͅͳͶͳͺͬͳΕ
̓Θͪ͊ͳͪͺͪͪͳͼͺͪΓͳͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬ͊ͪͬͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
;ͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;
ͪͽͪΒ
ͪ;ΒΒͪͬͼͽͳΒ;ͬͰ͵Ͱͯͼͽ;ͺͪͻ;͵ͺͳͼͺͲͳͬͪͼͰ͉
͊ͪͷͪͻΘͳΕ
PQDJU
̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰͬͳΕ
̻ͻͪΌͪͲͪͼͻͺͼ͵;ͳͼͽͻͳΒ;
m̽ͅͰͯͪ͵ͬͳΕ PQDJU
ͽͪ͵
ΌͰKF;ͳ
ͪͼͬ;ͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰͳͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͪͪ͵ͳͬͽͼͬͰͽͭ
͊ͪͬͰ
ͯͪͼͰͪ͵ͭͯͳͰͰͺͪͱͪͺͪͯͪΔͰ
ͬͰΕ
ͪͺͻͽͳͬ
ͺΒͪͪͬͪΔͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ
̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰͬͳΕ
͊ͺͪΓͳͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭͪ͊ͪͬͰ
m
̽ͅͻͪͭͬͳΕ
͊ͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪͳΒͰͼͺͪΓͰ
͈ͱͪͻͰͬͪ
m
̽̓ͼͽͳΕ
͊ͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪͳΒͰͼͺͪΓͰ;̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ;
̺ͻͰͷͰ
ͯͰͰͷͫͪͻ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
͉ͪͯ͠ͳΕ
͉ͳͷͼ͵ͪ͵;ͻͳΒͪͳΒ;ͱͼͶͬͰͼ͵ͰͲͰͷΓͰͯ97*͎ͯ*͎ͬͰ͵ͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
͊ͪͷͪͻΘͳΕ
PQDJU
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
ͯͼͳͷͱͰͼͰͯͺ;ͳͽͳͳͯͻ;ͭͳͷͺͲͪͽͳͷͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͳͷͪ͋ͪ͵ΒͰ;
ͽ͵;97**ͬͰ͵ͪͬͳͰͬͶͪ͵ͳͬΒͬͯͪͯͪͻͳͬͪͶͅͳͶͰͰͬ;
ͳͼͽͳ;Εͳͯͪͽ;
ͺͳͬͪΒ;ͼͬͰͰͬͰͷͽͳ̻ͯͳͰ̻Ͱͻͪͼͳͷ̽ͫͻͳͶͬͪͯͪͻ;ΒͰ͵Δͳͭ;ͪ
͊ͪͬͳ͵ͳͬͽmt͵ͰͶͰͫͼͳͷͷͽͪͷͼͬͰͽͪͭͪ͊ͪͬͳi͆ͬ;ͼͬͰͽͶͼͽ
ͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͷͭͪͫͳͯͪͫͪͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ΒͰͯͪͺ;ͽͺͳͼͳͳͲͬͻ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰͯͫͻ
ͺͲͪͽ
ͪͶͳͲͪͻͰͪͬͪΔͰͬͭͺͳͽͪΔͪͰͳͼ͵ͻͳΕͰ
ͳͲͬͻͰͷͰͪͺͻͰͰͭ
ͽͼ;ͷͽͳͯͰͽͰͳͲͅͳͶͰͰͬͰ͋ͻͰͫͪ
ͪΒͺͻͰ
ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳͯͪͺͼͰͽͳͳ
ͅͳͶͰͰͬͰ;97*ͬͰ͵;ͪͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͪͳͺͳͼ;Β;͊ͪͬͳͰͷͽͳ̺ͰΕͳͪ
Δͳͷͪͭͬͻͳͼͪͼͬͳͷ;ͺͽͰ͆Ͱ͵ͳͺ;ͽͺͳͼͳͼͬͰͯͰͯͪͼ;ͯ͊ͪͬͳͳ
ͷͽͳΒ;ͬͳͯͰͶͳͼͪͷͻ;͵Ͱ͇ͯͽͳͺͳͼͪ;ͺͪͯΓͳͬͼͰͳͲͯͬͪΒͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬ
͈ΒͰͻͪ̈́Ͱͼ͵ͪͶͺΒͰͪͳͲͭͯͳͰ͇ͺͻͳͪ͵ͪ͵ͼ;ͭͪ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳͺͻͳͬͰ
ͶͳͯͪͰͶͳͬͪtΒͰͯ;ͬͰͶͳ͵;͵ͼͽͻ;͵ͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰi tVOHSBOEPTEVCSBTEF
4U4BWBi
BͯͪͷͪͼͳͽͬͻͯͰ͵ͪ͵ͳͷͪΒ;ͳͰͶͽͰͶͪͅͶͯͪΓͰͼͰͺͬ
ͼͶ;ͱͳΒͰͯͳͷ͵ͪͯͪ͵ͪͱͰͯͪtͬ;͵ͼͽi
ͼͳͷͻͳΕͪͪ
ͰͶͳͬͪΒ;ͼͺͽ
ͬͪΔͰͷͳ͠ͰͬͻͰΒͳͳ͋;ͻͳ̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
ͳͲ̈́Ͱͼ͵ͪͶͺΒͰͬͭͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͼͶͰͯͳͶͫͳͯͪΒͰ
;ͼͷΒͯͰͰͳΒͳ97*ͬͰ͵ͪ͊ͪͬͳͪͻ;͵ͪ
ͲͫͭͼͪͯͪͰͺͲͪͽͳͻͪͲͶͭͪ
ͫͳͶͪ
ͳͲͯͬΒͰͪͳͲͼͬͭ͵ͻͺ;ͼͪͷͽͳΒ;ͳ;ͬͪͪ;ͲͪͼͰͫͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;͋ͪΒ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͺͽͬͻͯͳͫͳͼͬͰͯͰΔͰ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ̹͵ͬͳΕͪm;͵ΒͰͰͷͪͻͪͲͶͭͪͯͪͼͰ
ͼ;ͷΔͪm͵ͪ͵ΒͰ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳͬͳͯͰt͵;ͽͳΒͳ;i;͵ΒΒΒͰ;ͬͪͪͻ;͵ͪͼͬͰͽͭ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͊ͪͬͰ tTDBUUPMJOBwDPOMBNBOPEJ44BCBi
ͳ;ͳΒͳKFͺͼͰͯͳͼͪͷͺͻͳͬͻͰͷͰ
̹ͯͪ;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪͼͰ̹͵ͬͳΕͰͬͪ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͪͯͼͰͪͼͷ;ͳͯͰͬͰͽ;ͯͰͰ
ͳΒ;97**ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͽͫͳͷͭͶͲͪͳͽͳͯͪΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͼͻ;͵ͷ͵ΒͳΒͰͬͳͯͰ
̈́Ͱͼ͵ͪͶͺΒͰ ͯͳͼͽͪ ;ͬͪ ; ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳ ͳ ͺͼͶͰ ͭͯͳͰ ͆ͪ͵ ͽ ΒͰ
͆ͳ͵Ͷ̹ͪ͵ͬͳΕ
ͺͼͺͼͽͬͰͷͺͻͳͲͪΔ;
ͳͲͭ;ͫͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ
ΔͰͷ;ͼͰ
ͰͷͱͰͺ;Ͳͯͪ;Εͳ;ͽͻͪͭ́ͯͳ͵ͪͽͳͬΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͯͪͼͰͻ;͵ͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͳ
͵ͪͼͳΒͰͬͳͰͺ;ͽͪͺͷͳΔͰ̻ͯͳͰͷͪͼͳ͈ͪ͵ͻͰͺͻͳͪΒ;;͉;ͼͳΒͳͯͪΒͰ
ͅͳͶͰͰͬͪͼͺͪΓͰͪͺͻͰͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͺͰͽͭͯͳͪ
ͪͶͳͯͪΒͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͽ͵;ͺͷ
ͼͺͪ
ͼͰͪ͊ͪͬͳͪͯͰͼͪͻ;͵ͪ͆ͪͳ͵ͳͼͶͳ͵ͷͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͳͲͭͯͳͰ
͵Β;
ΒͰͪͅͽͳΒ͈ͪͪͬͶ̺ͬͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͳͺ͵Ͷͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͊ͪͬͳͳ
ͼͪ;ͬͪͼͰ;ͫͪ
ͻ͵Β͵ͪͻͽ;ͳͪͽͺͳͼ;͵ΒͰͷͼͰ͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰtΒͰͯͳͪͻ;͵ͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͼͽͪͶͪ
;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͈ͰΕ͵ͷi͆ͪͽͺͳͼΒͰͯͪ͵ͰͼͪͯͻͱͳͰͳͼͺͳͼͪΒͰͳͪͳ͵ͳͳͲ
ͭͯͳͰͺ͵ͶΔͰΒ̽ͫͻͳΕͰͬ;͌9*9ͬͰ͵;ͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͷͽͳ
ͷͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͬͰΕͼ;ͼͪͼͬͳͷͷͪͭͶͬͳͽͪ͢ͳͬͰͰͼͽͳͰͫͳͶͰͼ;ͪͬͯ
;ͭͻͪΌͰͰ;͵ͻͼͽͳͲͭͯͳͰ͵ΒͳͼͰͯͪͪͼ;ͬͪ;ͯͰͪͼ͵ΒͻͳͲͳͳ͊
ͺͰͽ͵ͪ9*9ͼͽͶͰΕͪͺͽͳͰͳͺͻͰͯͪΔͰͯͪͼͰ͊ͪͬͳͰͷͽͳ;ͬͪΒ;;ͷͪͪͼͽͳ
ͻ;̽ͬΓͳͅͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͽͪ͵ͼ;ͼͬͻͰͷͰͷͺͼͽͪͶͰͯͰͪͻͯͭ
ͺͻͰͯͪΔͪ
͵ΒͰͺͼͽΒͪ;ͬͪͳͼͰΕͪΔͰͪΔͰͭͬ;;ͯͽͬͻ;ͻ;͵;͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
;ͲͺͳͼͪͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪ;ͲͰͽͳ;ͫͲͳͻͳΒͰͯ;ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ;ͳΔͰͳ;
mͯͫͻͼͪ;ͬͪͰͷͽͳͯͰͼͰͻ;͵Ͱ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͊ͬͰͽͰ͋ͻΒͳͰ͵͈ͯΓͰͬͪ
Γͪ
͵ΒͰͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͪͺͻͳͺͳͼ;ΒͰͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͪͬͳ͇ͰͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;Β;ͺͪͱΔ;Ͳͫͭͯͬͪ
ͻͪͲͶͭͪ͆ͪΒͺͻͰͼͽͭͪͽͼͰͪͳͼͽͷͷͰͼͽ;;ͬͪͳͽͪ͵ͲͬͪͳͽͪͺͼͬͰͽͭ
͊ͪͬͰ
͵Βͳͺ;Ͳͯͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͺͻͬͷ
ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͷͼͶΒ;ͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵Ͱͻͳ
] ]
̸͇̺͇̻̺͑͋́͊̾͋͊̾ͅ
ͲͳͰ̽ͻ;ͭ
ͽΒͻ;ͳͯͪͪͼͰͯͼͽͪΒͰͷͪͶͳͺͻͼͽ͋ͪΒͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͷͭͪͫͳ
ͫͳͽͳͯͬͪͱͼͽͳͲͫͭͽͭͪͽͼͰͲͪͯͪΒͰͭͯͳͰͷͳͶͰͰͬͼ͵ͳͷͪ
͆Ͱ͵ͽͪͻͳΒͰͼͪ͵ͬͪ͵ͳͬͽͲͪͺͻͼͽͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ͵ΒͳͼͰͯ;ͭP;ͬͪ;͈ͰΕ͵Βͺͪ
ͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͳ
́ͲͶͱͰͪͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪͰ;ͯͰ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͼͰ
ͳΒͰͯͪ͵ͪͪͯͭͬͻͪ
ͺͳͽͪΔͰͺͲͳΒΒͳͼͽͻͳΒͳͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ͢ͳͬΒͰͳΓͯͪͺͬ
ͽͬͻͰͺͻͫͶͰͷ͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͪ;ͳ
ͳͳͪͷͼͰ
ͳͼ;ͬͳͰͶͪ͵ͳͺΒͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;Ͱ̽ͻ;ͭͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶͫͳͳͲͬͪͳͼͺͳͽͪͽͳͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵;ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ͵ΒΒͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͳͼ;ͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰ;ͰͶͳͳͺͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͰ͈ͯͪͳ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵Ͱͼͺͻͳ
ͼͺͪΓͳͬͪΔ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͭͯͳͰͰͷͻͪΒ;ͫͳͽͳ;ͺͻ
ͽͳͬ;ͻͰͼͽͳͼͺͲͳΒͳͷͼͬͰͯͰΔͳͷͪͺͻͯ;ͱͰͽ͵;͵;Ͷͽͪ;ͼͻͰͯͼͻͰΌͰͭ
ͪͼͪ;ͬͪͰͼͽͪͽ͵ͰmͺͼͬΒͺͻͳͶͳͳͼͬͰͰͬͰͻ;͵Ͱ͋ͪ͵ͬͪͺͻͪ͵ͼͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ
;ͫͳͪΒͰͪͳͻͷͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͪ
ͪͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͪΒͰͳ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰ
ͯͳͳ͌ΔͰΒΒͰͼͬͳΒͰͯͯͽͰͷͰΓͳͪͰͶͪͽͰͶͭͳΒͰͷͽͳΒ;͋
ΒͰͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ΒͰͯͰΓͳͬͼͽͳͳͼͬͰͺͻͳͼ;ͽͼͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽ
;ͬͰͻͰΔͰͯͪΒͰͳ͵ͻͲͪΒͷͪΔ;Ͱͼͽͳ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͺͻͳͼ;ͽͪ;ͼͬΒΒ
ͰͶ͵;ͺͼͽͳͳͫͶͪͭͯͪͽͳ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͼͫͲͳͻͷͪͬͪͱͼͽͳͽͪͬͭͺͳͽͪΔͪ
Ͱͼͪͷ͵;Ͷͽ;ͬͰΕͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵;
ͬͻͰͯͰͶͫͳ;Ͷͱͳͽͳͽͻ;ͯͳͼͬͰͽͽͻΒͳ͵;
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ;ͺͯͬͻΕͳͲͫͳΓͷͳͼͽͻ;ͷͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔ;
] ]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
̸͇̺͇͉͐͌̽͋̾͢
̸̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓
̸͇͇̺͇͉ͣ͐͌̽͋̾͢ͅ
͵ͪͺͻΒ̹ͪͬͪͱΒͰͷͳͶͼͽͳͳͺͽͬͻͯͪͫͶͪͭͪΕͪ
ΒͰͯͰͶͳͼͽͳ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͪΒͰΒͯͻͪͳͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͬͻͰͷͰͪͭͶͪͬͳͷͲͪ
ͷͰΔͰͷͳͰͺͯͳͷ;ͼͶͬͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ͌ͽΒͼͬͰͽͶͼͽͳͺͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬ͊ͪͬͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪΒͰͺΒͪͬͪ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒͳͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͪ
ͺͪͳͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳ͐;ͯͽͬͻͰΔ;͊ͻͫͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͯͼͪͯͪΔͪͪ;͵ͪͺͼͬͰͽͳͶͪΒͰͽͰ͵Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵ͭͶͰͯͪ
;͵ΒͳͷͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͳΒͰͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪ;ͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳͷ
ͯͬΓͳͻ͵ͳͷ͵ͬͳ
ͻͳͷͪ͐;ͯͪ͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭͽͪ͵ΌͰͼ;Ͱͺͽͺ;ͺͻ;Ͱͪ͆ͪΒͬͳͰͺͪͱΔͰ
ͺͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ ͼ; ͷ; ͰͽͶͲͳ ͳ ͳͼͽͻͳͪͻͳ
͵Βͳ ͼ; ͼͽͬͪͻͳͶͳ ͬͰͷͪ ͬͻͰͯͰ
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͰ́ͺͪ͵
ͺͻͫͶͰͷͼ;ͰͼͽͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͶͳ;ͼͳͻͳΒͼ͵Βͻͪͬͳ
ͫͰͲ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͻͰͳͲͭͻͪͲͯͬͪΒͪΔͪͳͲͬͻͭͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭͷͯͰͶͪͯΔͰͭͬͭͺͲͳΒͰͭ
ͿͶ͵ͶͻͭͯΒͰ͵ͪ͌ͪ;ͳΒͰͽͪ͵ͳͲͼͽͪ;ͽͰͷͰΓͰͺ͵;ͪΒͯͪͼͰ;ͽͬͻͯͳ
tͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͪͼͽͻͪͽͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪi͊ͪͬͳͳ;ͯͰͼͪ͋͵ͷͬͳͰͬͰ͵ͬͭͺͼͽΒͪ
Δͪ͊ͪͬͳͭ͵;Ͷͽͪͪͳ͵ͪ͵ͳͼ;ͳͷͪͶͪΒͰͯͪ͵ͳͼͯͳͽͰ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳ;ͳ
Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;
ͬͰΕͼ;ͫͳͶͪ;ͼͶͬΓͰͪͼͶͱͰͳͷͼͺͶͰͽͷ͵Ͷͼͽͳ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳͲͻ͵ͬͰͳͳ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳ͏ͳΓͬͭͭͶͰͯͪΒͰͼͽͰͯͪͼͰ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͰ
͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭͳͼͺͳͽͪͼΔͰͭͬͳͳͲͬͻͳ
ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͺͶͪͲͳͽͪ
͇ͫ;ͬͪͽͳΒͳͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪΒͽͰͷͳͷͭ;ΕͳͶͳͼ;ͺͯͼͽͳͪΒͳͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͳ
Ϳͪ͵ͽͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͳͷͰͽͯͶ͵ͳ
͵ΒͰΒͰ;ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͯͬͰͯͰͰͳΒͰͺ;ͯͳͶͪt
ͬͪͪͭͳͶͭͳΒͪi͇ͳͯͲͬΓͪͬͪΒ;
͵ͪ͵ͪͷͼͰͳͳ
ͯͪͼͰ͊ͪͬͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ
ͼͽͬͳ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪm͵ͪΔͰͭͬͫͳͽͪͼͪͯͻͱͪΒmͼͪͭͶͰͯͪΒ;;ͳͻΒͻͪͬͳ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Β
͵ͪͳ͵;ͶͽΒ
͌ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;ͯ͵Γ;ͰΒͰͬͪͱͼͽͳ͵Ͷͼͽ
;ͪ;ͳͰͯͬΓͳͼ
ͽͪ͵;ͽͪ
ͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͫͳΒͰͯͳͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ΒͳΒͰͲͪͱͳͬ
ͽͪͳͳ;ͯͪ͋ͪ͵ͬ;ΔͰͭͬ;ͷΕ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͲͻͳͳͽͺͷͳΔͰ
ͽͬͻͯͰΕͳͯͪtΒ;ͽͰͶ;ͷͰΌ;ͪͷͪ;ͯͽͬͻͼͽͬͪͺ͵ͪͲͪi͇ͪΒͰ
ͳͲͬͰͼ
ͪ
ͫͳͽͪͪͳͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͶͪͰͼͪͷ͊ͪͬͳͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳtͽͳͺiͬͰΕͳ;͵;ͺͪ͵ͪͻͪ͵
ͽͰͻΔͰͭͬͭ͵;Ͷͽ̸ͪ͵ͼͰͺΌͰͯͺΒͷͬͪͳͬ͵ͪͫ;ͶͪͻͪtͬͰͪͭͳͶͭͳΒͰi
ͺͻͳͲͶͪͲͳͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͪͲͪͱͳͬͽͪͳͷͪͼͽͪͽ;ͼtͼͬͰͽͭͬͰ͵ͪi̽ͻ;ͭͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ
ͻͰΒͰͶͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͪΒͰ
;ͺͰͻͰͺͳΒͳͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪ
ͪͶͳͳͺͽͷͪ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪͫ
ͯͪͻͰͪͪͻͳͽͳͷ
ͪͻͳͲͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͷͼͬΒͼͽͬͳͷͪ͊ͪͬͪΒͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͳͲͪͫͻͪͳ͵ͷ
͵ͻͲ͵ͭͪͯͰͶ;Β;̹ͱΒͪͼͳͶͪͳͷͳͶͼͽ
ͷͭ;Ε;Β;Εͳͷ;ͯͪͳͳ;ͯͰͼͪͯͰͶͪ
͵ΒͪͪͯͳͶͪͲͰͷΕͳͫͳͳͼͷͻͽͳ͵͈ͪͺ;ͽͯͻ;ͭͳtͼͬͰͽͳΓ;ͯͳi
ΔͰͭ
ͬͳͲͪͷͰͳͽͳͺͻͰͽͯͳ͵ͪ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͺͼͰͯͬͪͪΒͬͰΕ;ͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭͳΒ;mͯͼ
ͪͻͳͽͰͫͶͳͼ͵ͼͽͳͼͪͼͿͰͻͷͽͻͪͼͰͯͰͽͭͳtͼͷͰͶͼͽi ͯͻͲͬͰͳΒͰ
ͭ
ͬͻͪ;ͫͻͪΕͪΔ;̹ͭ; QBSSFTJB
͌ͺͻͪͬͽͪͷͭ;Εͼͽͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ̹ͪͱͪͼͽͬ;
͵ΒͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͺͻͪͬͳͳͲͬͻ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ
͵ͪͳͺͼͻͰͯͳ͵ͭͯͰͶͬͪΔͪͲͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻͪ
̀ͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͳ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͷͰ͊ͳͷͰ;ͳͼͬͰͽͷͰ͊ͪͬͳͪͼͪͷͭͶͪͼ
ͬͪ
JO͊ͻͫΓͪ͵*͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰ
͵ͪͳ
ͪ͵ͪͽͳͼͽͳ ͺͻͳͻ͚͋ͻͳͿ;ͬͳΕ
ͺͻͰ̹ͬ̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
1#SPXO
ѮF3JTFBOE'VODUJPOPGUIF)PMZ.BOJO-BUF"OUJRVJUZ
JO4PDJFUZBOEUIF)PMZJO
-BUF"OUJRVJUZ
#FSLFMFZm-PT"OHFMFT
m(BMBUBSJPUPV
ѮF.BLJOHPGB4BJOU
m
ͼͺͻͰͭͶͰͯͳͲͶͱͰͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͷͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͬͭͺͳͽͪΔͪ
DGͽͪ͵ΌͰ"OHFOFOEU
)F
JMJHFVOE3FMJRVJFO
m
.PSSJT
.POLTBOE-BZNFO
m
QBTTJN
] ]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
Γ;ͯͼ͵;ͲͪΒͰͯͳ;
ͰͺͻͰͼͽͪͼͰͳͼͽͳͰ͵ͪͫͳͽ͊ͪͬͳͼͬΒͼͽͬ;ͺͻ
ͼͶͪͬͳͷͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪ
ͱͳͽͳΒͳͷͪͳͼͶ;ͱͫͪͷͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͷ;ͺͼͬͰΕͰͳ͋ͪ͵ͼͰ
ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͭͬͻͳΔͰͭͬΒtͼͷͰͶͼͽͳ͵̺ͪͶͪͯͳͳͼͬͷͰ͎ͻͳͼͽ;iͳͶͳͼͰͺͪ͵
ͪͭͶͪͪͬͪͯͪΒͰͷͶͳͽͬͰ̹ͭ;;ͺ;ΕͳͬͪtͼͪͷͭͷͬͰͻͷͳͼͷͰͶΕ;i
͇ͫͻͪͲͪtͼͬͰͽͭͬͰ͵ͪi
;ͯͽͬͻͪͫͶͳͼ͵̹ͭͭ;ͳͶͳͼͽͳͺͼͰͫͭ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼͪͳͲͪͯͪͽ͵ͪ;ͼͻͰͯͳͳ;͵ΒΒΒͰͱͳͬͰ
ͼͽͬͻͰΒͰͬͰΕ;ͻͪͬͳͲͪͽͳΒ
ͼ͵ͷͷͪͽͬ;͆ͼͳͳͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͫͳͶͳͼ;
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
;ͭͶͰͯͳͪͪͻͰͽͳ
ͪͰ͵ͳͯΔͳͼͽͰ͵Ͷͳͼ;ͯͯͪͽͰͲͪͼͶ;ͭͰ͵ͪͼͳͬͪͳͲͪͪΒͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪ
͠ͰͯͪͯͪΒͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͳΒͳͫͳΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͼͬͰͽͳ͇͊ͪͬͪͼͬͰΕͰͳ
ͳͷͰΔͪ͵ͳ;Ͳͻ
͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ͢Ͱͭͬͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͽͪ͵ΌͰΒͰͫͳͬͪͱͪͺͻͰͯͶͱͪ͵ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪͫͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ̿ͳͬͽͳͯͰͶͼͶͪͬͭͺͪͶͰͼͽͳͼ͵ͭͷ
ͪͪͫΒͰͯͳͳͶͳͼ;ͳͲͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪͳͳͼ͵;ͼͽͪͬͪͪ͵ΒͪͼͰ
ͷͭͼͽͶͰΕͪͯ
ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͶͳ
;ͭͶͰͯͪͳΔͰͭͬͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͼͶͰͯͫͰͳ͵͊ͪͬͪ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͫͪͼͰ͵ͪͻͪͯͳ͵ͪͶͳͪͼ͵Ͱͽͪͳͼͽͪͬͳ͵ͺͰͽͰͻͪ
ͪͶͳΒͰͽͪ͵ΌͰͼͬͪ
ͳͬͯͳͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒ;͵ͳͬͳΒͼ͵;ͫͳͽͰΓͼͬͭͯͫͪͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳΒΒͽͳͺͳ͵͆Ͱ
ͯ;ͼͽͪΒ;Εͳͯͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͺͬͻͰͷͰͭͺͬͶͪͰΔͪ;ͺ;ͼͽͳΔ;
ΒͰͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪͱͳͬͰ͵ͽͪ͵ͽͰͼͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͯͬͻͷ;̓ͼͽͪͽͳͺΓ;̀ͪͪͺͻ
ͫͶͰͷͯͪΒͬͰΕͰΒͰͬͪͱͼͽͳͳΔͰͳͪͯͪΒͰ͇͊ͪͬͪͼͬͰΕͰͳͪͲͳͬͪtͼͬͰͽͳͷ
ͬͰ͵ͷiͳͯͪΒͰ
ͺͺ;ͽͷͭͳͻͪͳͺͯͬͳͱͳ͵ͪ
ͫͳͫͯͪͻͰͼͺͼͫ
Ε;;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ͌ͫͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ͵Β;ͷ;ΒͰͼͪͼͽͪͬͳ̓ͳͻͳͶ͊͵ͳͽͺΓͼ͵ͳͺ
ͯͻͫͼ;ͪͬͰͯͰͪ;ͯͪͽͳΒͰͳͳͲͪͱͳͬͽͪ
͵ͪͳΔͳͬͯΒͰ͵ͷͰΌ;
ͼͶͰͯͫͰͳͳͷͪ
ͪͶͳͳͫͳͳͷͬͰͻͳͳͷͪ͊ͪͬͪΒͰ
ͳͭͶͰͯ
ͺͽͬͪ͵ͪ
ͯ;ͬͳͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽͪΒͬͳͰͭͻͪͭͪͳͼͳͶͪ;ͯͰͼͳͷΕͳ͵ΒͰͼ;ͽͳͽͳ
ͶͰͳͺΒͰͯͳͰͳͳͻ;ͲͪΒͰͯͳ;͠Ͱͯͪ͵;;Ͷͭ;ͲͪͯͻͱͪΒͰͳͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳ
;
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;ΔͰͭͬͭͻͫͳͷͽͳͺͼͽͪͶͳͼͽͰͳͽͰͰͳͼͽͰ
ͫͱͪͼ͵ͰͼͳͶͰ͵ΒͪͭͪΒͰͳͼͺ;ΔͪͬͪͶͪͲͪͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͭͱͳͬͽͪ
͋ͪ͵ͪͬͷͪ͵ͳͳͯͰͪͶͺ͵ͪͲͪΒͰͼͬΒͰͬͻͶͳͰͳͯͰͶͽͬͻͼͽͳ;ͪͻͰͯ
ͳͷ ͻͪͲͯͫΓͳͷͪ ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ ͺͬͰͼͽͳ ͈ͻͪͬͳ ;Ͳͻͳ Ͳͪ ͭͻͪΌͰΔͰ Ͷͳ͵ͪ ͊ͪͬͰ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ͵ͪtͼͬͰͽͭͬͰ͵ͪiͼͽͭͪͼͰͷͭ;ͺͻͪΕͳ;ͻͶ͵ͳͫͶͳͱͳͷ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
̿ͳͬͽ ͊ͬͰͽͭͪ ͊ͪͬͰ ͳ ̿ͳͬͽ ͊ͬͰͽͭͪ ͊ͳͷͰͪ ͺͻͰͬ ̈́ ͅͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
ͺͻͳͻ͉ͪͅͻͳ͵ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͯͪΓͰ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
] ]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
Ͱͺͪͷͪ
ͽͪͳΒͰ;ͷͪ͵Βͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͳͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳͯͼͻͰͯͳͰ*9ͯͺͻͬͳ
ͯͰͰͳΒͪ9**ͬͰ͵̺ͪͰͷͪͺͯͼͽͳͪΒͰͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͰ;ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͬͳΒͪ ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ ͉Ͳͷͪͻͳ ͅͻͳͼ ͇ͪ ͼ; ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͪ ͯͪ ΒͰ ͫͻͪͲͪ tͼͬͰͽͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪiͽͭͯͫͪͫͳͻͪͼͺͻͼͽͻͪΔͰͪͳͻ͵ͷͺͯͻ;Β;ͳ;ͫͶͳͰͪ
ͬͰͷͪͯͼͶͰͯͪͪͳ̓ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳΒͰͯͪͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷͶͳͼͽͳͷͪͺͻͰͬͶͪ
Ό;Β;ͼͳͬͪͳͳͼͽͪͻͰͳͰͲͪͷͰͳͽͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪͳͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳ
ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻm͈ͰͽͪͻͳͲ̸ͽͻΒͰ
͈ͪͬͶͰ̈́ͪͽͻͼ͵ͳ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͳͲ̻ͰͶͪͼͳͪ
̸ͽͪͪͼͳΒͰ
̸ͽͼ͵ͳ
͎ͻͳͼͽͯ;Ͷͼ͈ͪͪͽͷͼͪ
͊ͳͷͰ͆ͬͳ͋ͰͶͭ̀ͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯͼͬΒͰͼͪ
ͫͻͪΕͰ
;ͬͪͱͪͬͪͳͪͶͳtͫͳͳiͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͳͼͽͪͻͰͳͪm͵Βͳͼ;ͼͳͶͳ
ͰͺͳͽͰͽͰ͵ͪͽͼ;NBLBSJPTͳͶͳBPJEJNPTmͽͰͶͳͼͽͳͼ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳͷͰ
ͬͪͰ͵ͪIPTJPT
ͯͼIBHJPT͢ͳͬͪͳͲ;ͲͰͽͼͽͺͽͳͪͶͪΒͰͽ;ͯͪͽͼ;
;ͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬ;ͳͷͪͶͰͺͻͪ͵ͼ;ͬͻ;ͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͯͳͬͳͯ;ͪͶͰͪͼ͵ͰͲͰͳͺͻͳͷͰΔͳͬͪͶͰͶͪ
ͬͻͳͽͼ͵ͳͪͳͱͳͬΓͰΔͪ
ͯ͵ͪͲ;Β;Εͳͽͪ͵;ͼͺͼͽͬͰͷͬͻͰͷͰ;ͷͭ;Εͼͽ
ͯͼͰͲͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͪͳͷͯͰͶͪͺͻͶͼͽͳ͋ͪ͵ͬͳͷͪͼͳͼͷͪͽͻͪͳͼ;ͳͼͽͳ
ͼ͵ͳͷͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽͳͷͪ
ͽͪ͵ͻͰΕͳtͱͳͬͳͷͳ͵ͪͷͪi
ͳΓ;ͯͳͷͪͺͻͰͯͯͻͰΌͰͳͷ
Ͳͪͯ;ͬͬΌͼͽͬ̀ͪͬͪΓ;Β;ΕͳͼͺͼͫͼͽͳͯͪͳͰͺͯͬͳͭͰ
ͳͼ;ͳͷͪͶͳ
ͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭͳΒ; tͼͷͰͶͼͽͳi ͭͬͻͪ ͳ ͺͼͻͰͯͬͪΔͪ ͵ͯ ̹ͱͪͼͽͬͪ
ͺͪ ͽ;ͯͪ ͳ
ͷΕ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪͲͪͱͳͬͽͪͳͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳ̿ͳͬͽͳͺͯͬͳͲͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ
ͺͯͻͫͳͲͶͱͰͳ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪͳͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͷͼͪ
ͼͽͪͬͳͷͪ
ͽͰͼͽͭͪͯͫͻͺͲͪͽͳ
ͼͶͰͯͳͶͳͼ;ͽͪΒͷͯͰͶ;ͼͬͳͷͫͳͽͳͷͪͼͺͰ͵
ͽͳͷͪ́ͼͽΒͰͳͼͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻͷΔͰͭͬͭ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ
ͽΕͰͷͪͼͽΒͪͽͳͯͪ
ͺ͵ͪͱͰͷ̺ͪͱΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͬͰΕͪͺͰͽ͵;ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳͼͫͰͼͽ
ͽͪͳΒͰ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽ;ͼͶͱͰͼͽ͊ͪͬͳͭͶͳ͵ͪ͵ͪtͼͬͰͽͭͬͰ͵ͪi;ͯͼ;ͪͺͷͰ;ͽͰ
ͷͪ͵Ͱ;ͲͻͰ͉ͪͲͶͭͲͪͽͼͪͼͬͳͷΒͰΒͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ͊ͪͬͪΒͰͫͳͳͲͯͪͪ͵ͼͳ
ͬͪͪͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
ͺͻͬͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪ;ͽ͵ͰͿͪͶͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰͳͶͳͼͽ͵ΒͪΒͰ
ͳͷͪͶͪͺͻͰͼ;ͯͪ;ͽͳͪΒͪͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͯͻͱͪͬͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ;ͯͶ;;Β;ΕΒͰͽͪͺͳ
͌ͽͷͼͬͰͽͶ;;ͱΒͰͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳͳΔͰͭͬͪ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ
ͯͼͳΔͰͳ
;ͯͪͼ;Ͱ͵ͪͯΔͳͬͰͷͪͰ͵ͬͰͳͪͶͪ
ͪͯͪͳͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰͪͰͼͽ
ͳͷͪΒ;ͺͼͰͫͪͼͷͳͼͪͳͿ;͵ͳΒ;͊ͽͳͷ;ͬͰͲͳͽͻͰͫͪͳͷͪͽͳͪ;ͷ;ͳͰ͵Ͱ
ͺͽͰͯͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͼͽ͵ͬͰͻͪͲͬΒͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͪ;ͯͫͪ;͵ΒͰͷ
ͼͰ;ͫͶͳͪͬͪͶ͊ͪͬͳͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ͆ͪ͵ͻͪͲͯͫΓͪͺͪͯͪΔͪ;̺ͳͲͪͽͳΒͳ
ͼͰ;9***ͬͰ͵;ͺͬͺΒͪͬΓ;Β;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳ
ͪͶͳͳͬͳͰͰͺͽͳ;ͳͲͻͰͯͪ
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
ͪͪͻͰͽͪ
ͬͰΕͼ;ͽͺͻͰͽͰͱͪΒͬͳͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͳͯͻͱͪͬͰͳͻ͵ͬͰͰ
ͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
̺ͰΕͼͪͷͺͻͳͰͬͻΌͰΔͰΔͰͭͬͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͳ͋Ͱͯ
ͼͳΒͰͺͳͼͪͶͳͼ;͵ͪ;ͯͰͼͪͯͭͪΌͪΒ͉ͪͼͽ͵ΒͰͲͪͰͽͪ͵;ͼͻͯͰͷͶͳͽͬͰ
ͻͯͳͽͰΓͪͯͪͳͷ̹ͭ;ͼͽͪͻͼͽͳͺͯͪͻͳΒΒͰͯͭͺͽͷ͵ͪ
;ͲͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͪ
ͺͲͪͽͰͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͰͺͻͳͷͰͻͰ͊ͽͭͪΒͰͯͺͰͽ͵ͪͬͪͱͳͲͪtͯͰͽͰͺ
ͼͶ̹ͪͯͭͪi͈ͻͰͷͪ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ
ΒͰͫͳt;ͯͰͼͯͰͽͰ
ΒͰͻ
ͽͳΒͰͳͫͳͶͼͪͷͯͰͶΓ;ͯͼ͵ͰͺͻͳͻͯͰ
ͰͭͳͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͼͬͰͼͳͶ̹ͭͭͪ
͵ΒͳͺͫͰΌ;ΒͰͲͪ͵ͰͺͻͳͻͯͰ͵ͪ͵ΕͰi͋͵ͷͻͪͰͷͶͪͯͼͽͳͳͲͪͲͳͬͪ
ΒͰͯͳͬΓͰΔͰ͵ͶͳͰtͻͪͲ;ͷͷ;ͯͰͽͳΔͰͷ;Ͳͻͪͼͽ;iͳͫͻͲͳͷͪͺͻͰͯͬͪΔͰͷ
;;ͰΔ;
ͽͪ͵ͯͪͼͰͭͬͻͳͶt͇ͬΕͰͯͰͽͰͫͳͽͳͰ͵ͬͲͪͷͰΔͰi͆ͪ
ͽͪΒͪͳͺͳͼͪͪͲͪͷͰΔͪͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;
ͲͪͼͰ
;ͼͽͪΓͰ
ͷͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͺͽͳͷͰͼͽͪ́ͼͽͭͺͻͰ͵Ͷͪͼ;ͳͽͺͼͳ
ͯͶ;ͳͷͶͪͯͭͺͻͳͪͯͪͪͺ;ͼͽͳͯͷͳͲͪͷͪͳͼͰ̻ͪͻͳ̸ͽͼ͵Β
;ͺͻ
͵ͼͼͪͱͷͺͻͽͳͬΓͰΔ;ͺͻͯͳͰ͌ͬͰͲͳͼͺͳͽͪΔͰͷ͵ΒͳͷͼͰͫͪͬͳͷ
ͬͻͰͯͳͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳͯͪΒͰͳͼͪͷͳ͉ͪͼͽ͵ͬͭͷͪͰΔͪͳΔͰͭͬͳͲͷͳͪΔͰ
ͻͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ΒͺͽͰͻͳ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͺͻͽ;ͷͪͳ͵ͪ;ͯͰͼͪͯͭͪΌͪΒ
ͭͬͻͰ
ΕͳͽͷͰͪͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͪͳt͇ͬͺͻͬ;ͯͼͪͽͬͻͳ̹ͭͪΔͰͷ;͵ͪͯͪͼ;
ͯͶͳͪ͊ͬͰͽ;̻ͻ;i
͊ͪͬͳͪͷΕ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ
ͪͭͬͰͽͰͪͽͳͷͲͪͷͰΔͳͷͪ
ͽͪͯͪͼͰͳͼͺ
ΓͪͬͪͶͪͰͺͻͰͼͽͪ
ͽ͵ͷͱͳͬͽͪͳͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳ̓ͶͪͼͳͿͳ͵ͪͳΒͪ;ͯͰͼͪ͵
ΒͪΒͰͳͳ
ΔͳͬͪͽͳͺͶͭͳΒͪͳ;ͰͼͽͪͶͼͽΒͪͬΓͪΔͪm͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽ;ͪ;ͳ
ͺ͵ͪͲͪ m ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ; ͻͰͳͽͰ ͺͯͪͽ͵Ͱ ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ; ͳ Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ
͵;Ͷͽͪ;ͯͻͰΌͰΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͳͯͪͽͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;͊ͪͬͳͳͱͳͬͽ
1 .BHEBMJOP
ѮF #Z[BOUJOF )PMZ .BO JO UIF 5XFMѫI $FOUVSZ
JO ѮF #Z[BOUJOF 4BJOU
m3.BDSJEJFT
4BJOUTBOE4BJOUIPPEJOUIF&BSMZ1BMBJPMPHBO1FSJPE
JOJCJE
m1
4DISFJOFS
"TQFDUF EFS QPMJUJTDIFO )FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH JO #Z[BODF
JO 1PMJUJL VOE )FJMJHFOWFSF
ISVOH
m
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
m
͇ͽͷͰ3.PSSJT
ѮF QPMJUJDBM 4BJOU PG UIF &MFWFOUI $FOUVSZ
JOѮF #Z[BOUJOF 4BJOU
̾
1BUMBHFBO
4BJOUFUÊFUQPVWPJS
JOJCJE
m(BMBUBSJPUPV
ѮF .BLJOH PG B 4BJOU
m.PS
SJT
.POLTBOE-BZNFO
m
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
$POOPS
PQDJU
ͳQBTTJN
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͳͼͳ
ͯͶͳͳͲͪͶͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͰͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͰͲͪͼͽͪͬͽͳͰͽͪ͵ͳ
;ͼͷͰͻͰΔͪͼͺͼͽͬͰͭͯͫͪ
ͳͳͼͰͯͪͼ;
;ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;
ͽͰͱͳͶͳ͵ͪͼͽͬͪͻͪΔ;
;ͻͪͬͽͰͱͰͰͰͶͳͰ͇ͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶͯͪͼͰͼͶͳͪͺͻͬͰͻͰͰ
;ͲͻͰ
ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͪͳͼͬͳͷͪͺͻͰͺͲͪͽΓͳͬͪ;ͺͻͳͽͪ
ͪͯͪͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰ
ͫ;ͯͰͼͪͫͻͪͱͰͪͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͳͷͽ͵ͬͳͷ͉ͪͪͲͷͽͻͳΕͰͷͪΒͺͻͰͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻͼͽͪ
ͯͪͻͯͳ;ͯͪ͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ
͌ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͫͳͪΒͳͷͪͬͻͰͷͰͪ
;ͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͷͪͼͰͳͼͽͳͰ͊ͪͬͳͪͺͻͲͻ
Γͳͬͼͽ
ͽΒͰͼͽͼͺͼͫͼͽͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͪΔͪͫ;ͯ;Εͼͽͳ͇ͯͼͻͰͯΔͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͭ
ͻͪͲͯͫΓͪͽͼͬΒͼͽͬtͼͬͰͽͭͬͰ͵ͪiͼͽͳͰͪͻͳͽ;ͺͺ;Ͷͪͻͼͽ͈ͻͳͼ
ͽͰ͵ͶͳͲͽͰͶ͵ͭͺͼͽ;ͶͪͽͪͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭͳΒͳͳͲͪͫͻͪͳ͵ͪͯͪͫ;ͯͰͫͶͳͲͪ͵ͼͪ
̹ͱͪͼͽͬͷ
ͼͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͰͼͽͳͼͺΓͪͬͪͶ;ͻͪͬͳͺͻͪ͵ͽͳͭͳͳͷͪͶ
ΒͰͺͻͪͭͷͪͽͳͰͳΓͰͬͰ͊ͪͬͪΒͰ
;ͪͰͶ;
ͳͷͪͷΕͯͪͺͻͲͳͻͰt;ͼͬͪ͵ͷ
ͬͰ͵;ͽΒͰ;ΔͰͷ;ͳͺͻͻͳͪͰͫ;ͯ;ΕͰíͺͪ͵
ͪΒ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͳΒͳͳͲͻͪͲ
ͽͭͯͪͻͪ
ͼͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͯΒͰ͵ͷ;Βͪͬͼͽͳ
ͳͷͪΒͰͰͼͪͷ͵;Ͷͽ;ͬͰΕͳͪͭͶͪ
Ͱ;ͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵;ͼͬͻ;͉ͰΒͰ͊ͪͬͳͷͺͻͻͳͪΔ;͊ͳͷͰͬͭͳͶͪͯͪͻ
ͼ͵ͭͷͳͻͽͰΔͪtwΒͰͻΒͰ;ͪͺͻͰͯͲͪͲͪ;ͯͪͳͲͶͳͬͪΔͪͷͳͻͪͯΔͰͭͬͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳͷͽͳΒ;͵ΒͪΕͰ̹ͭ;ͳͳͽͳi͊ͪͬͪΒͰͽͪ͵ΌͰͫͳ;ͼͽͪΔ;ͯͪͬͪͼ͵ͻ
ͼͪͬͪ;ͷͻͶͰ͋ͪͬͻͼͽͪ;ͯͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͺͺ;Ͷͪͻͪ;ͻͪͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵Βͪͭͳͭͻͪ
ͿͳΒͳ
ͺͰͶͪΒͰͯͪͭ;ͫͳͪͬͪͱͼͽͳͯ*9ͯ9*ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ;9**ͳ9***;ͰͼͽͪͶͼͽ
ͽͪ͵ͬͳ;ͯͪ;ͺͪͯΓͳͬͼͰͼͷͪΔ;ΒͰ̺ͰͻͬͪͽͳΒͰͼͶ;ͪΒͽͽͼͬͰͰͬͳ
ͫͳͭͻͪͿͳͽ;͊ͪͬͳ;ͷΕͽͰ͵;ͲͭͻͰͯͺͷͳΔ;̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪΔΒͭͬͻͳ;
ͯͬͪͪͬͻͪͽͪ
ͪͳͼͽͳͳͬͰͷͪ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳͪͪͳ͇
ͪͳͷͰ
ͺͻͰͼͳ
ͻͰͳ;ͭͶͰͯͳͼͬͰͽͭͻͼ͵ͳͽͪͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͽͬͻͯͳͶͳͯͪ͊ͪͬͪtͷͭͪͰͳͷͻͽͬͰ
ͬͪͼ͵ͻͼͪͬͪͽͳ
ͪͶͳͼͰ;͵ͶͪΔͪͰͲͫͭͼͬΒͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͰͼͷͰͻͼͽͳíͲ;ͲͰͽͪ͵;ͽͷ
ͺͭͶͰͯ;ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ΒͰ͊ͪͬͳͺͯͳͲͪΔͰͳͲͷͻͽͬͳͫͻͪͽͪ͊ͽͰͿ͇ͪͪ͵Ͷͼͽͳ
;͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰͲͫͳͶͽ;ͯͯͫͻͼ;ͺͲͪͽͰͺͻͯ;ͱͰͽͪ͵ͱͳͬͽ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪ
ͷͫͳΒͰͯͳͲ;ͲͰͽͰͬͪͱͼͽͳ
͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͰͺͻͰͯͼͷͻͽͲͪͷͪͳͳ͵ͪ͵
ͫͳͼͰͺͻͺͳͼͫͪͬͳͶͪͼͷͰͪͪͺͻͰͼͽͶ;͉ͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬΒͰͽͼ;ͱͳͬͽͺͳ
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
ͼͳͺͯͻͫͺͳͼͪͶͳͼͬͰͰͽͪͺͰͽͭͯͭͪΌͪΒͪm͊ͪͬͳͺͻͳͷͪΔͰͯͻͪͷͪͽͳͰ
ͬͰͼͽͳͫͻͪͽͬΓͰͬΒͼͷͻͽͳ
ΔͰͭͬ;ͱ;ͻͫ;ͯͪͯͺ;ͽ;ΒͰ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͳ
ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͼͪͷ
ͳ;ͯͰͼͭͱͳͬΓͪͬͪΔ͈ͪͽͼͰͺͷͶͳ̹ͭ;ͼtͬͰͻͷͳͼͷͰͶΕ;iͳ
ͺͲͬͪͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͰ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳͬͪͼ͵ͻͼͪͬͪΔͪ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵ͫͻͪ
ͽͬΓͰͬͭͬͻͪΕͪΔͪ;ͱͳͬͽt̽ͪͬͳͪͯͫͻͪͽͪͼͬΒͰͭͪ
Ͱ͵Βͳͼ;ͺͶͪ͵ͪͶͳ
ͯΔͰͭͪͽ;ͻͳͬͪͰ
ͳͭΔͰͳͷͼ;ͲͪͷͪͪͼΔͰͭͬͶͳͰͯͬΓ͵ͻͺͳͬ
ͳ
ͽͪΒͳͷ;ͼͻ;ͻͰͳͷͪͽͪΒͬͳͯ;ͳͼͬͰͬͳͯ;ͼͪ͵ͻͳͬͰͭͪͷͭͼͰͲͪ
ΔͰͭͪͷΓͪͰ͈ͻ;ͱͳͬͳͼͬΒ;ͼͬͰͽ;ͯͰͼ;ͻ;͵;ͪͼͻͰΔͰͭͬ
;ͳͷͰ͊ͬͰͽͰ
͋ͻΒͳͰͪͺͳͼͪͺͪͭ;ͽͰͶ;ͼͶͳ͵;͵ͻͼͽͪ
ͳͯͷͪͼͰͽͳ;ͼͬΒͳͷͻ;͵ͪͷͪͯͪͼͰ
ͺ͵ͻͰ;Ͷ
ͳͺͳͺͪͬͳͺΔͰͭͬͳͷͺͻͼͳͷͪ
ͳͬͪͺͰͽͪΌͰͽͺͶͪͳͱͳͬͪ
ͳ
͵ͪ͵ͼͰͬͰͷͪͷͶͳ;ͼͶͳͪͫͳi͌ͽͷͪͼ;
ͯ͵ͼ;ͺͻͳͼ;ͽͳͳͼ͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳ
t;ͱͪͼͳͯͳͬΓͰΔͰi
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͲͪͷͪͳ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
͵Βͳͷ;ΒͰͲͪͽͳͷͺͻͰͷͳ;ͪ
ͻ;͵ͪͷͪt̺ͰͼͰͶͰΕͳͼͰͳ̹ͭͪͫͶͪͭͯͪͻͰΕͳi
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͼͪͻͪͳ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͪͺͽͷ
;ͼͽͶͳͳ͉ͪͯͼͶͪͬͪͲͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ
͈ͯͳͲͪΔͰͳͲͷͻͽͬͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭͺͺͼͽ;ͺ͵;ΒͰͬͰͷͪͫͶͳͼ͵
ͺͳͼͳͷͪ;ͯͰͼͳͳͲͶͰͰΔͪ́ͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͪ;ͯͪͼͷͪͽͻͪͪͼ;ͯͻͪͳͻͳ
Εͪͼ͵ͳͬͻͰͷͰͪΒͰͯͳͷͯͭͶͪͬͳͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪtͼͬͰͽͭͬͰ͵ͪi
ͪͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͷͽͳͷͪͻͰ
ͺ;Ͳͯͪͳͷͯ͵ͪͲͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪͰ͵ͰͶͳͼͽͳ
͇ͯͼͬͳ;ͯͰͼͪͪͼ;
ͳͲͻͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬͳͻͪͲͶͭͪ
;ͱͳͬͪͶͪͪΒͬͰΕ;ͺͺ;Ͷͪͻͼͽ
ͽ͵ͷͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪͶͳͳ͵ͪͼͳΒͰ͌ͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͷͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪ͊ͪͬͳͪͳͼͰ
ͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͪͷΕͰͼͽͼͰͺͷͳΔͰͪ;ͺͽͰͪͳ
ͯ͵ͼͰͯͬͪͽͪ͵ͬͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ
ͺͯͻͫͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪ͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͳ;ͯͰͼͳͼͰΓͰΔͰͻͪͼͶͪͫΓͰͭͲͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰͫͻͪͬ͵ͪ;̿ͳͳͳͷͪͶͬͳͰͼͽͻ;͵;ͳͰͭͲͰͷͺͶͪͻ;ͬͻͰͯͼͽ̽ͭͪΌͪΒ
ͺͳͻͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ͵ͯͫͪ͊ͪͬͳͪͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪ
ͲͪͺͳΔͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͷ
ͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͷͪΒͰͬͪΌͰͼ͵Ͱ;ͲͻͰm;͎ͯͻͳͼͽͬͳͪͺͼͽͶ͈ͪͰͽͻͪͼͺͯͳͲͪ
ΔͰͷͻͪͼͶͪͫΓͰͭmͪͲͪͽͳͷͼͶͰͯͳͬͰͷͪͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͺͳͼͺͼͽ;ͺ͵ͪͳͼͰΓͰΔͪ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ͋ͰͯͼͳΒ;
;ͲͺͷΕ;Ͱͳ͵ͪͺͶͱͳͫͶͰͼͳ͵ͪ;ͷͪͯͳΒ;
;Ͱͭͪ;ͻ͵ͬ;ͳͺͼͽͪͬͳͺͻͰͯͳ͵;͎ͻͳͼͽͪ
t͵ΒͳΒͰͶͰ͵ͪͻͯ;ͪͳͽͰͶͪi
͆ͪ͵ͽͭͪ
t͵ͪͯͪΒͰͺͪͶͪΕ
ͼͪͷͼͽͪͯͰ;ͻ͵ͬͳͼͪͻͪͼͶͪͫΓͰͳͷ
ͳͳ͵ͷͰ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
m
".5BMCPU
'BJUI)FBMJOHJO-BUF#Z[BOUJVN
ѮF1PTUIVNPVT.JSBDMFTPGUIF1BUSJBSDI"U
IBOBTJPT*PG$POTUBOUJOPQMFCZѮFPLUJTUPTUIF4UPVEJUF
#SPPLMJOF
.BTTBDIVTFUUT
m
$POOPS
PQDJU
m(BMBUBSJPUPV
ѮF .BLJOH PG B 4BJOU
m.PSSJT
.POLTBOE-BZ
NFO
mͬͳͻͪͯͬͳ
ͲͪͼͬͪͳͪͪͪͶͳͲͳͳͲͬͻͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͰͳͼͽͪͻͳΒ;ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻ;
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
m͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
Ͱͯͺ;ͼͽͳͯͪͺͻͳΌͰ͵ΔͳͷͪͰͭͼͰͼͪͷͽͻ;ͯͳͯͪͺͼͶ;ͱͳͫͶͷͰw͊ͬͰ
ΕͳͷͼͽͪΒͪΔͰͷͳͺͪͯͪΔͰͷͪͲͰͷΓ;;ͺͯͬͳͭ;ͬͰͶͳ͵ͷͼͬͰͺͻͳΓͰͱͳΒͰ
ͼͰͷΓͪͰͳͪͯͽͰͶͻͪͼͶͪͫΓͰͭͪͪͽ͵ͶͪΔͪͰͼͰ́͵ͪͰ͵ͳͷͶͰ͵ͪͻͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͷͪͲͪΔͰͷͻͪͼͶͪͫΓͰͰͷ;;ͯͰͷͭͳͷͼͬΒͳͷͬͻͰͶͳͷͼ;ͲͪͷͪͳͷͶͳͽͬͪͷͪ
ͻͪͼͽͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͳͺͷͪͲͪi͆ͪ͵ͯ;ͭͰ
;ͼͻͯͰͷͶͳͽͬͰͳͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͳͯ;ͲͰͽͷͯͪ
t;ͼͽͪͰͳͯͳi
tͫͶͰͼͳ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͲͯͻͪͬͯͷͭͭͯͳͪ
ͼ͵ͳͬͳͼͪͷͪ
ͯͳΒͰ͵ͪͼͪͯͻͪ
ΌͪͰi̽ͰͶͽͬͻͼͽͽͪ͵ͬͭͺͼͽ;ͺ͵ͪ
Ͳͪͼͬͪͭͪͺ
ͼͬͰΕͰͳͷͲͪΔͳͷͪ
ͪͶͳͳͲͪͯͼͬͰͭͪͪͬͰͻͳ;̹ͱΒͰtͰͳͲͷͰͻͷͳͶͼͻΌͰi
Ͳͪ͵ͻ;ͱͰͪΒͰ
͵ͪ
ͳͷͻͪͶͳͷͼͽͪͬͷ͌ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͰͽͳ͵ͷͼͬͰͽͳͫͰͼͻͰ
ͫͻͰͳ͵ͪ
͊ͪͬͪͰͼͪͷͯͪͳΒͰͺͻͳͷͳͪͭͻͪͯ;ͲͪͳͼͰΓͰΔͰͬͰΕͳͲͶͰͰͭ
tͫͯͪͻͳͳͽͺ;ͼͽͳͯͪͳͯͰͼͬΒͳͷͪi1IJMBOUSPQIJBΒͰͫͳͶͪͫͳͽͪͳͳͶͪͳͼͰ
ͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ;͈ͯͪͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͰͭͬͪͪ;;ͭͶͰͯͳͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳͷͪ;͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰ
ͫͳͽͪͬͪtͼͬͰͽͳͬͰ͵iͳͶͳ;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;;ͬͪͰΔͰͭͬͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͪΒͰ
͵ͪ͵
ΒͰͽ;ͪ;ͳͺ͵ͪͲͪ
ͳͷͪͶͪͳͲ;ͲͰͽͬͪͱ;ͯͻ;ͽͬͰ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;͆ͪ͵
;ͯͪ;̿ͳͳ͊ͪͬͳͰͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͰͷΕͳͳͲͪͶͰͼ;ͪͭͶͪͼ
ͺͪͼ;ͷ;ͽͪͯͪ
ͯͬͯͳͶͳͷͽͬͫͶͰͼͳ͈ͪͱΔͰͬͻͰͯͳͼ;ͺͯͪͳ͵ΒͰͯͼͳ͋Ͱͯͼͳ
ΒͰͺͻͳͷͰΔͰͳͷͽͰͻͪͺͰ;ͽͼ͵ͳͷͷͰͽͯͪͷͪ͊ͪͬͪΒͰͶͰͳtͺͶͪͭͪΔͰͷͻ;͵;i
ͳͷͶͳͽͬͷ
ͪ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳΒͰͫͶͰͼͰͺͻͳͬͯͳͷͳͻͽͳͬͷͭͻͫ;ͼͬͰͽͭ
͊ͳͷͰ͈ͪͼͰͫͪͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵ͺͻͳͷͰͳΒͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͬͭͲͫͳΓͭͫͶ
ͬͪΔ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ
͵ͭͪΒͰͳͼͰͶͳͬͯͷͼͬͰΕͰͷ͐ͪͼͳͷ͵ͻͼͽͷ͋ͪΒ
ͷͰͽͯͫͳΒͰͻͪͼͺͻͼͽͻͪΔͰͳͻͷͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͪͳͼͷͪͽͻͪΒͰͼͫͳ
ͽͯͰͶͽͬͻͳͷ͊ͪͬͳͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵ͺͳͼͪΒͰ;ͼͬͳͷͬͪͱͳͷͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪ
͵ͯ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͪt̓ͻͼͽͼͬͰͽͳͳͪͼͳͷͳͬͳ
ͽͷͼͬͰΕͰͷͬͯͷͳͽͺͶͷ
ͷͶͳͽͬͷͫͻͪͽͪͪͺΒͳ
ͳͼͬͰͭͪͭͪ͵ͻͺͳ
ͺͶͪͱ;Εͳͻ;͵ͰͼͬͰͽͰͪͪͼ;ΔͰ
ͭͬ;ͭͶͪͬ;wi̓ͷͰͽͪͻͳ;Εͳ;ͯ
ͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪͪ͵ͻͪΒ;Ͳͪ͵Γ;;ΒͰ͵ͪ͵ΒͰ
ͷͶͳͽͬͷͼͬͰͽͭͲͯͻͪͬͳͪΒtͲͪ͵ͭͪͼ;ͳͪΒͫΓͳͶͰ͵ͪͻͳͷͳͼͶͳͶͳͯͪΒͰ
ͳͲͭ;ͫΓͰͲͪͱͳͬͽi͋ͪ͵͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͺͪͬΓͪ;ͬͻͰͱͰͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͯͪͼ;ͼͬͰ
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
)+.BHPVMJBT
ѮF MJWFT PG CZ[BOUJOF TBJOUT BT TPVSDFT PG EBUB GPS UIF IJTUPSZ PG NBHJD JO UIF
TJYUIBOETFWFOUIDFOUVSJFT"%TPSDFSZ
SFMJDTBOEJDPOT
#Z[BOUJPO59997**
m
͋ͪ͵ͬͪͳͯͰΒͪ;ͺ;ΒͷͰͻͳͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͪΒͰΒ;ͱͳͽͳΒ;͋ͰͯͻͪͳͲ͊ͳ͵ͳͪ
W&%BXFT
/)
#BZOFT
5SFF#Z[BOUJOF4BJOUT
0YGPSE
mDGͳ3$PSNBDL
8SJUJOHJO(PME#Z[BO
UJOF4PDJFUZBOEJUT*DPOT
-POEPO
m
1BUMBHFBO
"ODJFOOFIBHJPHSBQIJFCZ[BOUJOF
m#SPXO
MDDJU(BMBUBSJPUPV
ѮF .B
LJOHPGB4BJOU
m
͆ͰͺͲͪͽͳͅͳͶͰͰͬͪ
͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪ;ͼ;Ε;ͼͬͰͽͭͪ͊ͪͬͰ
JO͊ͻͫΓͪ͵*
m
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
"7ÕÕCVT
)JTUPSZPG"TDFUJTNJOUIF4ZSJBO0SJFOU"$POUSJCVUJPOUPUIF)JTUPSZPG$VMUV
SFJOUIF/FBS&BTU
-PVWBJO
m"+'FTUVHJÍSF
-FTNPJOFTE0SJFOU*$VMUVSFPV
4BJOUFUÊ
1BSJT
mͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͻͪͯͳ͵ͪͶͰͪͼ͵ͰͲͰ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ%
1PQPWJǀ
ѮF $VMU PG 4U 1FUBS PG ,PSJØB4UBHFTPG%FWFMPQNFOUBOE1BUUFSOT
#BMDBOJDB
m ͼͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͷ
̺̀ͳͽͳΕ͆ͰͯͰΓ͵ͬͳΕ
̽Ͱͷͼ͵ͪͳͼ͵;ͰΔͪ;͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬͷ
t̿ͳͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽ͈ͭͰͽͻͪ̓ͻͳ͵ͭi
͆ͪ;ͳͼͪͼͽͪͪ͵ͼͶͪͬͳͼͽͪ;̺;͵ͬͰͯͪͰ
͊ͅ͏
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͯͪͳΕͰͼͶͪͫͰΕͳ
ͳͷͪΒ;Εͳ;ͽͰͶ;ͼͬͷͰͱͳͬͽͫͰͼͽͰͶͰͼͳͼͶ;ͭ;͉ͪͯͳ
ͽͭͪͭͪͳͫͰͼͳͰͳͼ͵;ͪͰͽͶͳ͵ ͵;ͻͲͳͬͪ
ΒͰͻ;ͷͶͪͯͼͽͳͼͬΒΒͳ
͵ͪͯͪͼͰͰͪͼͳͽͳͼͪͳΒ;ͼͬΒͳ
ͳͽͳͯͪͯͰͺ͵Βͪ͵ͶͰͳͷͪͼͬΒͳͷ
ͽͰΕͳ
ͪΒͺͻͰͯ;;ͼͬΒ;ͼͶͫͯͳͽͳͯͼͽͻͪͼͽͳ
ͺͯͫͰΕͳͼͰͽͰͰΔ;ͺͻͬͳͼͬͰͽͳ
ͷ;ͱͰͬͪ͵ΒͳͺͻͰͽͰ͵ͰͬͪΒͱͳͬͽͼ͵ͻͫͳͷͪͳͷͭͳͷͺͰͪͶͳͷͪ
ͪͯͻ;ͭͳͯ
Δͳ͵ͻͬΓ;ͼͬΒͷ͵;ͺͳͰͬͰͳͱͳͬͽwi͊ͪͬͪΒͰ
ͷͪͯͪͭͪΒͰͼͺͼͽͬͰ
ͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͰ ;ͬͰ͵ ͬͻͪΕͪͶ ͺ;ͼͽͳͱͳͽͰΓͼͽͬ; ͊ͬͰͽͰ ̻ͻͰ
ͳͺͪ͵ ͳͲͫͰͭͪͬͪ
ͪΒͱͰΕͰͫͶͳ͵Ͱͪͼ͵ͰͲͰmͽͼ;ͯͫͻͲͪͶͳͳΔͰͭͬͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳ́Ͷͳ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽͯͪͬͺ͵ͪͲͪ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰ̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
͊ͪͬͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͺͻͳ͵Ͷͳ
ͼͰ;ͯͰͶͬͪΔ;
͵ͪͳ;ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͳ
ͪͰͶͳͷͪͺͻͰͲͭͳ;ͻͪͬͽͰͱͰͭͼͳͪ
ͳͽͼ͵ͭͷͪͽͬͪ
͇ͼͳͷͺͷͰ;ͽͳ;ͯͪ
͵ΒͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͫͪͬͰͲͷͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻ;ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
͊ͪͬͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͳͼ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΒͰͼͬΒͰͷΕͳͳͪͯͻ;ͭͰͪͳͰ͇ͳ
ͻ͵ͷͺͼͰͭ;ΔͰͭͬͭ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪͭͬͻͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͵Βͳ͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ
;ͳͳtͳͯͻ;ͭͪͷͭͪ;ͯͰͼͪ
͵ΒͪͲͫͭͯ;ͱͳͰͻͰͳͳΒͰͷͭ;ΕͰͺͳͼͪͽͳi
͇ͪͼ;
ͯͳͼͽͪ
ͫͳͶͪͬͰͷͪͻͪͲͬͻͼͪ͊ͪͬͪͼͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͺͻͳ͵Γ;ͳΒ͵ͪ
ͽͰͭͻͳΒͳtͼͬͰͽͳΓ;ͯͳi͵Βͳͼ;ͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷ;ͯͰͼͰͬͳͲͳΒͰͽͳͷͼͰΒͪͬͳͶͪ
;ͼ;ͺͻͪͶͳͲͪ͵ͺͪͫͶͪͭ̀ͪͬͪΓ;Β;ΕͳͼͬΒΒͺΒͪͬͳͳͪͼͽ;ͺ;
͵Βͳ
ͼ;ͳͭͶͰͯͲͻͪͳͶͳͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽͷͳͪͻͳͲͷͷ
;ͼͺͰͬͪΒͰ;ͬͳͰͪͬͻͪͽͪ
ͪ
͊ͬͰͽΒ̻ͻͳ
͵ͪͳͽ͵ͷͷͭͫͻΒͳͺ;ͽͬͪΔͪ
ͯͪͯͪͺͪͯͪͯͬͻͪͽͳtͻͪͲ
ͫΒͳ͵Ͱimͽͼ;ΔͰͭͬͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͺͯͬͰͶͳͺͯ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒ;;ͯͪ͋ͪͯͰͶͪ
ͳͳΒͰͪͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͰͪͳͰ
ͺͻͳͶͪͭΌͰͰ͵Ͷͼͽͳͷͪͼ͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰͼ;ͪ
ͬͪ͆Ͱ͵ͪͯΒͰ;ͼͺͰͬͪͯͪͻͪͲͫΒͳ͵ͰͪͬͰͯͰͪͺ͵ͪΒͪΔͰ
ͯͼͯͪtͫͻͪͽͳ
ͼͻͪΔͳͬͪͪ;ͷͳΓͰΔͰͺͬͰͻͳͳΓ;ͫͪͬͳi̸͵ͫͳͼͰͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͪͼͪͬͰͼͽ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
͇ͬͪΒͳͼ͵ͪͲͽͪ͵ΌͰͼͬͰͯͳͽͷͰͯͪΒͰ;ͰͳͺͳͼͪͯͫͻͺͲͪͬͪͻͪͲ
Ͷͳ͵;ͳͲͷͰΌ;tͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ͵ͻͬͳiͳtͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪͼͪͬͰͼͽͳi
DG)%FMFIBZF
4BODUVT&TTBJTVSMFDVM
UFEFTTBJOUTEBOTMBOUJRVJUÊ
#SVYFMMFT
m̸͠ͰͬͽͳΕ
ͪͅͽͬͳͷ;Ͱͳͽͬ
̻Ͷͪͼͳ͵͈͊͏
m̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
JO̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
͊ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̺̓ͻͪΕ
͈ͰΕ͵ͪ
ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͼͪͼͬͷͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͷ
̹̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
ͬͪ̈́͠Ͱͼͽͬͳͳ͵;ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ΒͳͼͽͪͻΒͼͻͺͼ͵Β͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳ
̹Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯ
m
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͇;ͺͽͻͰͫͳͽͭͽͺͼͪ.PSSJT
.POLTBOE-BZNFO
ͯͬͪͼ͵ͻͬͳͽͪtͼ;ͬͭͲͶͪͽͪi͵
ΒͪΒͰͺͻͪͪͪͺͼͰͯ;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻͪ;͵ͪͲͪͶͪͼ;ͼͰ͊ͪͬͳ;ͬͻͰͷͰͫͻͪͬ͵ͪ;ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷ
ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;̹ͭͻͯͳͰ̾ͬͰͻͭͰͽͳͯͰ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
m͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
m
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
ͳͼͺͼͽͪͬͳͶ͵ͪͰͯͰͶͽͬͻ
͊ͪͬͪͼͰͳΒͰ;ͼͽͰͲͪͯͪͺͼͰͭͰͳͲͪͯͻ;ͭͪͳ
ΒͳͷͻͰͰΔͳͷͪ̓ͪͯͪͼ;ͭͪͪͺ;ͽ;Ͳ̹ͪͻͳͯͳͲͳͪͺͪͶͳͭ;ͼͪͻͳ
tͻͪͲͫΒͳ͵Ͱ
ͰͬͰͷͪΓ;ͫͪͲͳͯͬΓ;ͭͼͽͳͲͫͭͽͭͪͽͼ;ͳͼͺͬͰͯͳͶͳͼͬΒ;ͲͶ
ͫ;ͳͽͼͰͺ͵ͪΒͪͰͺͻͰͯΔͳͷ
ͳͻͪͼ;ͯͳͬͳͬͰ͵Γ;ͫͳͬͷͭͳͷͽͻ;ͯ
ͬͳͷͪΔͳͬͳͷ͵ΒͰͺͻͰͽͻͺͰͰͪͷͻ;ͲͫͭΔͰͭͪ
ͳͰͺͷͳΔ;ΕͳͲͶͫ;
ͺ͵
ͻͳͼͰͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͳ͡;ͫͳͽͰͬͪͰͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͰͳͯͪͯͰͳͷͫͶͪͭͼͶͬͯͲͶͪͽͪ͵ΒͰ
ͪͰi͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͪ͵ͽͪ͵ͬͳ͊ͪͬͳͳͺͯͬͳͭͪ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ;ͼͺͰͬͪ
ͯͪͳͲͫͰͭͰͼ;ΒͰΕͰΔͰͼͬΒͳͪͷͰͻͪͳ
;Ͳͽ
ͪͼͳΓͰͳͺͭͳͫͰΓ
ͳ͵ΔͰͭͪ
t;Όͪ;ͼͰ;ͯͰͼ;;ͯͷͰ͵ΒͰ̹ͭ;ͳͳͼͪΔͳͷi̿ͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͺͷͳΔ;
ΒͰ͵ͪ͊ͪͬͳͪ;ͯͪmͻͰͳͷ;͋ͻͬ;ͪͪͬͰͰͻΒͰ̹ͭΒͪͬΓͰΔͪ̽͵
ΒͰͪͯͪͭͳΒͪͲͷͷͳͽͪͷͶͳͽͬͰͼͬͰΕͰΔͪͬͯͰtͳ͵ͪͯͪΒͰ͵ͻͼͽͫͻͪͲͫͶͪͭ
ͼͳΓͪͬͯ;
ͻͪͲͯͰΓͳͬͪͰͼͰͬͯͪ;͵;ͺͳͳͺͰͽͼͪͼͽͪΒͪͰi͈ͻͰͷͪ͋Ͱͯ
ͼͳΒ;
͊ͪͬͳͪͼͳͶͪͫͳͶͪΒͰͽͶͳ͵ͪͯͪͼ;ͼͰ;ͯͰͼͪͯͰͪͬͪͶͪͳͼͪͷͳͷͲͪͲͳͬͪΔͰͷ
ΔͰͭͬͭͳͷͰ͈ͪͻͼͽͳΓ;ͯͳͳͫͪͳͼͳͻͳͶͳͼ;ͷͶͰ͵ͽͪ͵ͽͫͳ͵ͪͲͪͶͳ
t͊ͪͬͳͪͽͰͷͶͳͽͬͪ;ͼ͵ͳͼͶͪi͋ͪͬͻͼͽͪ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ
͵ͻͰ;ͽͪͺͽͻͰͫͪͷͪ
ͺͺ;ͶͪͻͰͺͫͱͼͽͳ
ͯͫͳͶͪΒͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͲͪͪΒ;ͺͽΔͳͷͰͽͪͺͪͷͪ͊ͪͬͳͭ
͵;Ͷͽͪ
͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰͼͬͳͺͰͪͽͯͪͿͶ͵ͶͻͳͷͰͽͪͶͳͽͰͽ
͆Ͱ͵ͳͯͼͬͰͰͬͳͺͯͬͳͭͪͷͭ;ͼͰͼͬͻͼͽͪͽͳ;ͺͼͰͫ;͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒ;;ͯͰͼͪ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͫͳ͵ͪͯͪͻͯͪ;ͽͳͰͪ͵Ͷͳͷͪͽͼ͵ͰͺΒͪͬͰͳͺͻͳͻͯͰͰͺͭ
ͯͰ͌ͺͳͽͪΔ;ΒͰͽͺͼͻͪͳͻͰ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ΒͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳ*9m9**ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪͳͼ
ͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͼ;ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͪͯͪͼ;ͽͪ͵ͬͰͼͺͼͫͼͽͳtͼͬͰͽͭͬͰ͵ͪiͰͼͽͫͳͶͰ
ͬͰͷͪ͵ͻͳͼͰͳͷͪ͵ΔͰͭͪ͋ͪ͵̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;
͵ͪ͵ΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ
ͺ;ͽ;Β;ΕͳͶͪΌͷͲͪ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ
;ͼͺͰͯͪͷͶͳͽͬͷͲͪ;ͼͽͪͬͳͶ;
Β;t͊ͪͬͰͻͷͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͷͼͷͰͶΕ;͵̹ͪͭ;ͳͰΕͳͼͶͳ͵;͵ͻͼͽͪͪͺͻͽͳͬͰ
ͬͰͽͻͬͰͳͪͷͻͼ͵ͰͬͪͶͰ͵ΒͳͼͰͬͳͼ͵;ͲͯͳͲͪ;
ͺͻ;ͱͪͰͻ;͵ͰͳͺͻͰΕͪͰ
ͳͷͭͬͻͰΕͳwͬͰͽͻͬͳͳͷͻͰ
;ͽͳͪͬͳͼͰͼͽͪͳͽͰi͋ͪ͵ΒͰͳͫͳͶ
ͪ
ͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͳͼ;ͺͻͺ;ͼͽͳͶͳͯͪͳͼͽͪ͵;͵ͪ͵ͼ;ͶͪΌͪͻͳͪͳͻ͵ͻͪͲͭͶͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
ͪͼͶͳͪͪͳ͊ͪͬͪΒͰͻͰͳͺͻͫͶͰͷ͵ͪͯͪΒͰΒͰͯͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͪͺͪͯ
;ͽͪ͊ͬͰͽΒ̻ͻͳ̺Ό;ͻͪͲͫΒͳ͵ͪͳΔͰͭͬ;ͯͻ;ͱͳ;ͫͯͪͻͳΒͰͼ͵;ͺͰͷͯͰΕͷ
ͼͰͯͶͪͳͷ͵ΔͳͷͪͳͳͷͪΔͰͷ
DG̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
m
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
.PSSJT
.POLTBOE-BZNFO
m ͼͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͷͪͳͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
mDG̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼͳͶͳ;ͯͪ͵ͳͼ͵ͻͪͬͪΔͪ;̸͵ͻ;͊Ͷͳͷͽͳͺ;ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͳ͊ͪͬͳ;ͯ
ͼͻͳͫͷ
͵ΒͰΒͰ;ͳͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷΒͰͯͭͯͺͻͰ͵ͷͻͼ͵ͳͺ;ͽͬͪΔͪ́Ͳͷ;
Ͱͷͻͼ͵ͷͫͶͰΕ;
ͺͱͰͶͰΒͰͯͪͫͰͯ;ΒͰͼͬͰͱ;ͻͳͫ;ͳtͯͷͪͼͰͯͷͻͪ
ͳͲͪͯͶͪΌͰ;ͲͬͳͼͳͬͪͶ
ͯͻͱͰΕͳ͵ͪͻ;͵ͪͷͪͺͻͰͬͰͶͳ͵;ͻͳͫ;
ͳ;ͻ;͵ͰͼͬͰͽͭͪ
ͭͯͰͶͰͱͪͰ;ͶͪΌͳ
ͪͺͻͼͪΒͰΔͰͭͬͪͺͶͱͳi͇ͫͪͽͪ;ͯͪͳͼͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪͪ
ͼ;ͺͯͻͫ
ͼͫͳΓͰͷͼͶͳ͵ͬͳͽͳͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ́ͺͪ͵
ͼ;ͯͰΕͳͺͺͳͻ
ͼͽͳͳͱͳͬͼͽͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͪ
ͪͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͰΒͰͪΒͬͰΕͳ;ͽͳͼͪ͵ͼͽͪͬͳͶ͊ͪͬͳ
;ͯͼͭͻͪͯͷ͉ͰΒͰͺͲͪͽΒ
;ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳͰͼͽ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͼͪΒͲͭͯͳ
ͼ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͯͬͻͪ̽ͪͬͳ͵ͯ͵ͻͪΓ̸ͪͯͻͳΒͰ**;ͯͳͺͶͷͪͽͼ͵;ͷͳͼͳΒ;
͊ͪ
ͬͪΒͰͽ͵ͷͫͰͯͪͲͪͽͻͪͱͳͶͰͯtwΒͰͻͼͪͷ;ͼͬΒΒͲͰͷΓͳͪ;Ͱͯͪͼͬͪͭͯͪ
ͺͳΒͰͷͼͽ;ͯͰͬͳi͈ͽͼͰͶͰͯͲͫͭͬͰͶͳ͵ͰͱͰͭͰͳΒͰͷͭͪͺͻͪΕͳ;
ͳͽͪͬͷ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼͽͬ;
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͺͻͳͲͬͪͭͻͪͯͼͰͫͶͪ͵Ͱ̈́ͰͯΒͰͫͰͲͫͰΌͰ
ͪ
tͽͪΒ;ͯͳͳͬͪͳͼͽͳ;ͫͭͯͪͳͭͻͪͯͯ;ͭͼͽͪΒͪͰͰͽͺΓͰ͵ͪͭͻ;ͷͰΔͰi
͑ͽͪͬͳͰ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͳͼͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͫͳͺͲͬͪͯͪ;ͳͳΒΒͰͯ
ͪ͵ͪͯ
;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͰ
͵ͪ͵ͫͳͲͪ;ͼͽͪͬͳͶ;Β;͵ΒͪΒͰͺͻͰͽͳͶͪͯͪͺ;ͼͽͳ;ͭͪͻͼ͵;
ͲͰͷΓ;͋͊ͪͬͳ;ͯ
͵ΒͰͼͰͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;ͼͬͪͽͪ͵ͪͼͶͳ͵ͬͳͽͪͺͻͳͪ
ͳͷͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͰͰͼͬͻͰ
ͳͯͻ;ͭ;
ͬͰͷͪͬͪͱ;ͯͳͷͰͲͳΒ;
͇ΒͰͺͼͶ;ͱͳͶ͵ͪͯͯͪͽͳͳͼͪͱͪͪͻͭ;ͷͰͽ;͊ͪͬͳͳͷͺͻͰͭͬͪͻͪ͵ͳͷ
ͪͺͻͳͷͪͼ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͷ͵ͻͪΓͰͷ͇ͽͷͰͼͬͰͯͳΔͳͬͳͼͯ
ͪ͵ͪͬ͵ͪ͵ͬͭ
ͭͪΒͰͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͳͶͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͼͽͻͪͪ͆ͪ͵;ͯͪ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳ͵ͻͪΓͼͰͫͻͪͽͳ͊ͪͬͳ
t̹ͱΒͳͬͰͰ
ͷͶͳͷ
ͺͻͼͽͳͪͷͽͽͳ;ͺͻͰͺͳͻͳͻͰ͵ͼͷͳͰͼͰΕͪΒ
ͼͰͺͻͽͳͬͪͼ͵̹ͪͭ;ͲͫͭͽͭͪͯͪͰͺͼͽͻͪͯͪͷͰͽ
ΒͰͻͼͳͽͳ
͵ͪͽ
ͬͳͯͳͷ
̹ͱΒͳͼͶ;ͭͪͳ̹ͭͽͰ;ͼͬͰͷ;ͼͶ;ͪi͊ͪͷͼͬͰͼͳͳͪͷͫͳͳͲͳͲͪ
ͼͽ;ͺͳͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͭͶͰͯͳͽͪͽͳͶͳͼ;ͳ͵ͻͪ͵ͯͪΓͰ͇ͳͼ;ͺͼͬͰͯͳͶͳͯͪ
ΒͰ͊ͪͬͪͯͬͻͪͽͳ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͯΒͰͻͰͼͳͳͺͻͳͬͰͭͪͺͻͪͬΒͬͰͻͳ́Ͳͽͭͪ
ͼ;
ͯͪΓͰ
ͳͲͬͰͶͳͯͪͶͰ͵ͼͰͱͪͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵ͯͪ͌ͭͻͳ
ͲͪͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳ͊ͪͬͳ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͷ
ͳͷͪΒ;tͼͬͰͽͪͳ;ͯͽͬͻͪ͵ͻͪΓͪi
͆Ͱ͵ͪͯ͊ͪͬͳͳ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪͳͷͪͶͪͼ;ͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵;;Ͷͭ;
͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͷ
ͽͯͪͪͼͻͰ͵Ͷͳ͊ͪͷͪͺΒͪͬͪͳΒͰͳͷͪͶͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͪ͌ͪ;ͳΒͰͬͰΕͳͼͽͪ͵
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
;ͽͯͪΒͰtͼͬͰͽͳͬͰ͵i*9m9**ͬͰ͵ͪͰ͵ͰͯͼͬΒͳͷΕͳͯ;ͭͬͪͽͷͰͽΒͰ
ͫͳ;ͺͼͰͯ;tͺͬͶͪΕͰͳͲͪΔͪi͵Βͪͼ;ͷ;ͫͰͲͫͰΌͳͬͪͶͪͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͯ;ͬ
ͳͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽ͈͵ͪͲͪΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͯͪΒͰͽͪ͵ͬͪͼͪͲͪΔͪ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͺͼͽΒͪͶͪͺ
ͽͻͰͫͪ
ͷͭͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ;ͼͶ;ͱͫ;ͳͻͳͳͽͰͻͰͼͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵Ͱ
͆ͪΒͳͲͻͪͲͳͽͳΒͳͺͻͳͷͰͻͽͰͬͻͼͽͰΒͰͼͽͰͺͲͪͽ͊ͪͬͳ;ͯͼͪ͊ͽͻͰͲͷ͆Ͱͯͪͬ
ͪͪ͵ͻͳͫͳͼͺͻͬͰͯͰͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͪͼ;ͯͪΒͰ;ͯͰ͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ
; ;͵ͶͪΔͪΔ; Ͱͺ͵ͻͭ ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭ ͬͰͶͳ͵ͪͪ ͼͪͼͬͳͷ Ͱͼͺͻͪ t͌ͫͳͼͽͬ
͵ΒͰͼͰͯͭͯͳͶͷͶͳͽͬͷͼͬͰͽͭͪiͳͲͬͻͰΒͰ;ͳͷͰͬͳͳͯͻͱͪͬͳ
ͳͽͰͻͰͼͪ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͲͰͷΓͪͫͳͶͪ;ͭͻͱͰͪ
ͪͷͭ;ΕͼͽͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͭͽ͵ͶͪΔͪ
ΔͪͺͪͼͼͽͳͳͼͻͺΓͰͰ͇ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͳͽͪ͵ͲͬͪͳtͰͭͪͽͳͬͳ
;ͯͪi
͵ΒͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͳͽͪ͵ͽ͵ͪͱΔͪͬͪͳͶͳ;͵ͶͪΔͪͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͰmͰ
ͼͽͰͫͳͻͪΒ;ΕͳͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪ͌ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ΒͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳͽͪΒͷͯͰͶͫͳ
ΒͰͯͻͪͳΒͰͺͲͪͽ͈ͳ;Εͳ̿ͳͽͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳΒͰͳͰ͵;ͬͻͼͽ;͵ͪͽͪͶͭͪͰͬͳ;ͯͰͼͪͅͰΌ;Δͳͷͪ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͺͻͰ
ͬͶͪΌ;Β;ͪ͵Βͪͼ;;ͳΔͰͪͻͪͯͳͯͫͻͪͰͳͽͰͻͰͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͰ
;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳͳ
Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵tͰͭͪͽͳͬͳ;ͯͪi
̽ͪͶͰ͵ͼͶΒͰͬͳͽͳΒͰͺͷͰͽͯͪͷͪͳͲͬͻͰΔͪ
ͪͶͳͳ͵ͻͪΒΔͰͷͳΓ;
ͫͳͶΒͰ
;ͯͷͳͻͽͰΔͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͭ
;͵ΒͰͷΒͰ͊ͪͬͪͳͷͪͺͻͰͼ;ͯ;;Ͷͭ;͈ͻͳͶͳ
͵ͷͽͭ;ͯͰͼͭͯͰͪͬͪΔͪ͵ΒͰΒͰͬͰͲͪͲ͎ͪͳͶͪͯͪͻͳ͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;͊ͪͬͳͰ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͰͷΕͳͯͶͰͼ;ͯͺ;ͭͳͲͻͪͱͪΒ͇ͪΒͰͪΒͺͻͰͯͪΒͷͪΔͳͺΒͰͯͳ
ͼͽͳͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͳtͳͼͰͪͳΒ;iͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳ;͵ͻͪͪͬͪΔͰͻ͵ͬͰͳ
ͭͻͫͪ
ΒͰͻtͺͻͲͳͻͪͰͫͶͪͭͯͪͽ͵ΒͪΒͰ;ͻͯͳͽͰΓ;ΔͰͭͬ;iͳͲͪΒ;Εͳͺ;Ͳͯͪ
tͯͪΕͰ͎ͻͳͼͽͼͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͽͳͼͬͭͪͼͶ;ͱͳͽͰΓͪi͈ͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͫͻͪΕͪΔ̹ͪͭ;
;͵ΒͰͷͭͪͷͶͳͯͪ;ͼͶͳͳΔͰͭͬ;ͷͶͳͽͬ;ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪΒͰtͼͷͰͶͼͽiͳͬͰͻ;ͽ
tͲͪͯͳͬΓͪͬͪͳ;ͱͪͼͪͬͪi̽ͪͫͳͼͽͬͪͻͳ;ͯͽͪ͵ͬͭͻͪͭͪ
͊ͪͬͪͼͰͷͻͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͵ͻͳͼͽͳͽͳͪͻͳͽͳͷͲͪΔͳͷͪ͵Βͪͼ;ͫͳͶͪ;ͺͼͰͯ;tͼͬͰͽͳΓ;ͯͳi
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪΒͰ;ͺ;ΕͰͼͽ;ͷͰͪͳͲͪͷͷͳͻͽͰΔͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͫͳͶͪͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭͳΒͪ
ͯͪͫͻͪͳ
ͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͶͳͼͽͳ͊ͽͭͪͳΒͰͼͶ;ͪΒͽͽͼͰͬ;ͯ
͵ͪ͵;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;ͽͪ͵ͳ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ
;ͬͰ͵ͯͰͪͬͪͶ;͊ͪͬͳͷͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ;
ͳͶͳ;ͲΔͰͭͬ;ͺͷΕ
Ͱͷ;ͺͽͪ͵ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͇ͳ
ͽͪͬͳͰ
Ͱ;ͬͳΒͰͭͬͻͰtͺͻͰͼ;ͳͬͪΔ;i͊ͳͷͰͬͭͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭ
ͭͻͫͪͪ͵͊ͪͬͳͭͯͶͪͼ͵ͪͪ͊ͬͰͽ;̻ͻ;
͵ͪͳͪͳ;ͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͺ
ͬͺͼͽͪͷͳͻͽͳͬ͆ͪ;ͰͼͽͪͶͰͷͶͫͰ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭͲͪͺͷΕ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰ
ͺͼͶͪ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;ͼͬͭͺͬͰͻͰͳ͵ͪͪ́ͶͪͻͳΒͪͼt;ͽͰͳͷͺͳͼͷͷi;ͺ;
ΕͰͳͷͫͻͪͽ;͊ͽͰͿͪ;ͳͪͻͳͽͷtͺͼͶͪͳͷi
;ͲͳͲͻͳͳͽ;ͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͯͪΒͰ
tͳ͵ͷͰͰͺͻͰͯͪͳͰͺͻͳͽͪíͶͪͻͳΒͰΒͰͳͼͺ;ͳͺͬͰͻͰͳͲͪͯͪͽͪ͵ͽͪ͵
ͽΒͰ͵͊ͳͷͰͬͭͭͻͫͪtͼͬͻͳͼͬͰͽͷ;ΒͰͼͬͰͽͳͲͪͺͬͰͯͳimͳͽ
;ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ;͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ
;ͺͻ͵ͼͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͰΒͺͬͰͻΓͳͬͼͽͳͷͳ
ͼͳΒͰ
ͫͳͯͶ;ͪt́ΒͪͳͯͰͷͼͪͽͫͷi͆ͪ͵ͫͪͬΓͰͳͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪΒͪͬͳ
ͪͼͬͰͪͪͳͺͻͳͽͪͪΒͰtͺͼͶͪͳͪi
ͪͳͲ͊ͳͷͰͬͭͭͻͫͪͺͬΒͰ
ͺͽͰ͵Ͷͷͳͻ
͊ͳͷͰͬͷͳͻͽͰΔͰͫͳͶΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪͼͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪͬͻͰͷͰͪ
Ͱͼͪͷͬͻ
;ͼ͵ͳͳͲͻͪͲ;ͯͽͬͻͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷΕͳm͊ͳͷͰͬͳ
ͪͶͳͳ͊ͪͬͳͳ
mͬͰΕͳͫͳͽͪͳͳͶͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰͺͻͬͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ͊ͪͯͻͱͳͪͳ
Ϳ;͵ͳΒͪͽͭ;ͯͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;ͯͼͶͰͯͼͺͻͬͰͯͰ;ͲͪͷͳͼͪͳΒͳΒͰͽͬͻͪ
͊ͪͬͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ͐;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͰͼͳͬͪͪͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰͳͺͻͬͭͪͳͪͶͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰ
Γͪ͊ͪͬͪΒͰ
ͳͲͷͯͫͻͬΌͰͳͪ͵ͽͳͬͼͽͳ
;ͼͺͰͳͻ͵ͯͪͫͲͪͳmtͪ
ͳͼͽ͵;;͊ͬͰͽΒ̻ͻͳiͳtͪͲͪͺͪͯ;;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͲͰͷΓͳi;ͯͰͼͷͷͳͻͽͰΔ;
ͼͪͷΒͰͳͲͬͰͼͽͳͳͼͶ;ͼ͵ͭͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͪ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͪ
͵ΒͳtͼͷͪͽͻͪͰͽ
Ͳͪ;ͯi͊ͪͬͪΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͼͷͳͼͶͳͳ͵ͻͪΒΔͳͳΓͰͬͭ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ
ͳ
ΒͳΒͰͪ͵ͽͳͬͳͼͪͯͰΒͼͽͬͰͳ͵ͳͼͪͷͫͳ͇ΒͰ;ͳΔͰtͪ;ͯͳͬΓͰΔͰͳ;ͽͰ;
ͫͶͪͭͺ͵ͻͳͷΓ;ͯͳͷͪ
ͯͰͳΔͰͭͬΒͳͪͻͯ;ΔͰͭͬ;
ͬͷ́ͲͻͪͳΓ;i
̻ͻͪͯͰΕͳͶͳ͵ͪͻͳͲͷͪͽͼ͵ͭ
;ͯͽͬͻͭͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͪͯͻͱͪͬͰ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰ;ͼͬ
ΒͳͽͰͷͰΓͰͳͯͰͶ͵ͰͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵Ͱͺͼͽ;ͶͪͽͰͼͬͭͬͻͰͷͰ͇ͪΒͰͼͽͬͻͳ
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
ͼͶͳ͵;͊ͻͫͳͷͪ͵ͪͪͻͯ;͵ΒͳΒͰͼͽͰ͵ͪͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͰͼͽͬͪͻͰͭͷͰͼͳΒͪͼͽͬͪ
͵ͪ͵ͫͳͳ;͵Γ;ͳ;ͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͳ
tͳͲͪͫͻͪͳiͪͻͯͪi
͐;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ͵ΒͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ;ͳͳͲͪͱͳͬͽͪͫͳͶͪͼ;;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳͭͻͪΌͰΔͪ
ΔͰͭͬͭͶͳ͵ͪ͵ͪtͼͬͰͽͭͬͰ͵ͪíͪ͵ͽͪ͵ͬͪ;ͯͪͳͼ;ͼͷͪͽͻͪͪ;ͱͳͷ
;ͼͶͬͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
ͪͼͰ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
ͳͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;͵ͪͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪͫ;ͯ;
ΕͰͭͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͺͼͽ;ͷͪ;ͯͪͫͳͶͪͼ;ͯͪΒ
ͻͪͳΒͳͬͻͰͷͰͪͰͼͪͷ;ͼͶͬͬͰΕͳͯ͵ͪͲͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
ͺ;ͲͯͪͲͪͷͰΔͰ
ͪ͵ͽͳͬͭͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪͼͳͶͰ̹ͱΒͰ͊ͪͬͳͳͫͳͭͻͪͿͳͲͪͽͼ;ͺͯͻͫͺͳͼͪͶͳ
ΔͰͭͬͪͺͼͷͻͽͪ;ͯͪ
͵ͻͳͼͽͰΕͳ;ͽ;ͼͬͻ;ͺͻͬͰͻͰͳͿͯͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͺͽͳͷͰͼͽͪ
͋ͪ͵ΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ;ͼͽͪΓͰͷͫͻͪͼ;
ͺͻͰͯͬͳͯͰͼͬΒ;ͼͷͻͽ
ͪͳͼͪͷ
;ͺ͵ΒͰΔͰͫͳͶΒͰͺͻͪΕͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͷ;ͯͰͼͳͷͲͪͷͰΔͳͷͪmͼͬͰͽͶͼͳͷ
ͲͪͻͰΔͰͷͶͳͪͳͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͷͪΌͰͼ͵ͳͫͳΕͪ́ͼͯͺͻͰͭͬͻͪͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͪͻͪ̓ͪͶΒͪͪͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪΓ̺ͪͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ͵ͺͻͰͼͪ͊ͪͬͳͭ
ͽͰͶͪͳͲ͋ͻͬͪ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬ;ͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͼ;ͽͪ͵ΌͰͺͻͽ;ͷͪͳͶͳ;ͯͷ
ͺͯͳͲͪΔͰͳͺͻͰͼͷͽͳΒ;ͪͻΒͰͯͫͻͳͽͰ͵ͪ͵tͼͽͻͪͭͬͳΌͰΔͪiͳ
ͺͽͷ;ΒͰͽͪ͵ͬ;ͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͳͲͯͪͪΌͰ̹ͱΒͳ͵Βͳͷ;ͼͰ
;Ͷͳ͵;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪ
ͬͰ
Βͪͬͳ;ͼ;͌ͺͰͪͽΓͳͬͳͲ;ͯͰͼͪͯͭͯͳͼͰ
ͺͫͳͪΒ;
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ
ͽͬͪͻͪΔͪͭͻͫͪ͐;ͯΒͰͳͷͪͶΒͬͰΕͰͯͰΒͼͽͬͲͫͭͽͭͪͽΒͰ͊ͪͬͳ
ͽͰͶͺͻͪΌͰtͰͶͳͰͻͪͲͻ;Ͱi
ͳͷͰΒͰͺͻͳ͵Γ;ͰͻͰͯ;ͪͻͳͽ
ͰΔͰͳ
ͰͽΓͰͳͷͽͳΒ;͊ͽͭͪͼͰͽͪΒtͺͻͪͶͪͲͪ͵iͫΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰͯͻͪͷͪ
ͽͳͳͷ
ͺͬͳͰͳͷͽͷtͪ͠Β;ͯͪ
ͫͻͪͽͳΒ
ͼͬͰͽͶͳΒͰͭͯͼͬͳ;ͯͰͼͪ
;ͱͪͼͭͳͳͼͺ;ΔͰͭͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͪͯͳͬΓͰΔͪ
ΒͰͻͼͰͰͻͪͼͺͪͯͰͳͭͻͫͭͪ
͵ΒͳΓ;ͫͳ̹ͭͪͳͳͳͬΓ;ΔͰͭͬ;i͆ͪ͵ͳͲͬͻͰͰFMFWBUJP;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪ
ͼ;;ͯͪ͵Βͪͼ;ͺͽͬͻͯͳͶͪͪͽͺͻͳͻͯͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪͷͽͳΒ;ͳͺͻͳͬ;͵Ͷͪͷ
ͽͬͽͻͬͼ͵ͳͭͻͪΌͪͪ;ͻ͵ͬ;͐ͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ;ͯͳͷͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͵ͪͳ;ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳͷͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͷͪ
;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͺͻͰͬͶͪΌ;Β;ͳͼͰͶͳ
ͽͰΓͼ͵ͪ̿ͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͳͪͬͯͰͺͳͷͰͰt̽ͽͳͪΒͰͷ͈ͻͰͼͬͰΕͰͭͪ
ͽͰͶͪΔͰͭͬͪͰͳͲͷͰͻͷͼͳͶͷͳͫͰͲͫͻΒͷͼͬΒͷͷͳͶΕ;ͯͪͻͬͪͼͶͰ
ͺͳͷͪͺͻͭͶͰͯͪΔͰͳͻͷͳͷͪͯͳͭͶ;ͳͷͪͼͶ;ͳͫͶͳͷͪͳͼͰΓͰΔͰi
͇ͬΒ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬΒͶͳͼͽͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͯͯͪΒͰͳͽͬͻΌͰΔͰͯͪΓ;ͯͳ
tͷ;Ͱͳ
Ͱͳͼͽͳͷͯ;ͼͳͷͪͼͶͫͯͳͫͳͬͪ;i
͋ͬͻͳ͊ͪͬͳͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ͵;ͶͽͪͫͳͶͳͼ;
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͯͶͳͳͲͪͶ
ͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͰͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͰͲͪͼͽͪͬͽͳͰͽͪ͵ͳͬͰͻͬͪΔͪͬͰͲͪͳͲͪ
ͽͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;́ͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭ
ͺͲͪͬͪͶͳͼ;ͪ;͵ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͳͷͼͬΒͼͽͬͳ
ͷͪͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͫͳͶͳ;ͯͯͳͻ;ͼͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪ͊ͽͭͪͳͳͼ;ͺͻͺ;
ͼͽͳͶͳͯͪͳͼͽͪ͵;;ͯͽͬͻ
ͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͯͰΒͼͽͬͽͪ͵ͬͳͽͬͪͻͳm͵ͬͰͭͪ
;͵ΒͰͷΒͰͺͳͬͪͶ͊ͪͬͳͽͰͶ
͵ͪͳͲͰͷΓͰ͵ΔͰͭͬͭͭͻͫͪ͋ͪ͵
ͺͻͰͷͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒ;
tͰͼͪͷͼͬͰͽͽͰͶͺͻͰͺͯͫͭͪͰͭͳͯͻͬ͵ΒͰͬͫͶͪͭͪͰͳ
ͺͻͪͭͻͫͪͫͭͪͽͳ̹ͭͫͶͪͭͬΔͰͷͳͳͼͰΓͰΔͰͷi͋ͬͰͻͬͪΔͰͯͪEZOBNJT
ͳQSBFTFOUJBͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͼͽͪΒ;ͯͰͶͽͬͻͳͪͷͰͼͽ;͵ΒͰΒͰΒͰͯͷͼͬͰͽͪ
ΔͰͭͬͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪͻͰͳͽΒͰͳͶ;ͼͽͻͬͪͽͬͻΌͰΔͰͷ͊ͪͬͳͳͫͳͭͻͪͿͪ
ͯͪͼ;ͼͰͳͪ͵ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͷͽͳΒ;ͪͽͻͬͼ͵ͷͭͻͫ;ͯͰͪͬͪͶͪ;ͯͰͼͪͳ
ͯͪͼ;ͷͭͳͯͶͪͲͳͶͳͻͪͯͳͳͼͰΓͰΔͪ͠Ͱͯͯ;ͯͪͺͳͼͪΒͰͬͰͷͪͺͯͻͫ
ͪͽΒͰͼͭͻͫͪͬͰͷ͆ͰͿͳͽͷ͵ΒͳΒͰΒͰͯͰΕͳ
tͬͳͷͺͽͰͻͰΕͰͳ
ͰͲͪΒ;ΕͳͰͼͽͳͽͽͪͳͳi
;ͼͳͪ͊ͪͬͳͷͭͻͫ;͌ͺΕ
tͺͻͫ;ΌͰ
͵ͪͯͰ͵ͭͪͼͬͰͽͶͭͪi
ͼ͵ͳΒͰͼͭͻͫͪͲͯͻͪͬͳ;ͼͺͻͪͬͪ͋ͪͲͭͯͪͺͻ;
ͱͪͳͯͯͪͽͪͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͪͳ;ͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͳͼͰΓͳͬͪͶͰ͊ͪͬͳͰͷͽͳͳͶͳ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͳͼͬͰͽͪͳΔͳͬͳͷͯͯͳͻͷ͇ͼͳͷͭͼͬͭ
͵ΒͳͼͰͼͪͼͽ
Βͪ;tͯͽͳͪΔ;i
ͯͼtͺͶͪͭͪΔ;͵ͪwͫͶͳͷͷͰͼͽͳͷͪi
;ͲͺͻͳͲͳͬͪΔͰ
ͼͬͰͽͭͪ
ͳͭͶͰͯΒͰͯͪΒͰͺͻͳͷͰΔͳͬͪͳͷͰͽͯͳ͵;ͫͪͳΒͰ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
;
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
ͯͽͬͻͼͽͬ;ͳͼͺͻͪͱΔͰͭ͊ͪͬͳͭͭͻͫͪͭͬͻͳͳͺ͵;ͪΒͫͻͪͽͼͽͬͪͻ͵ͬͰ
͐ͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪͯͪͳͲͬͻͳEBNOBUJPNFNPSJBFmͺͲͪͽ
ͯͯ;Ͱ
ͼͪͷͪ
ͼͬ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͳͲͬͻ̹ͪ;ͯ;Εͳͯͪͼ;ͼͰtͷͱͳͶͪ;ͯͪͪͭͻͫ;ͼͬͰͽͭͪiͳ
ͯͪtͷͽͬͪͻͯͪͯͶͪͲͰΕͳͯͼͪΌͳͬͪͰͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;i
ͷͪͼͳͼ;ͯͶ;ͳͶͳ
tͽͰΕͳͼͪ͵ͻͳͽͳ;ͯͪi
ͯͪͳͼͺ;ͰͱͰΓ;Ͱ͵ͷͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽ;t͵ΒͳΒͰͰͷ
ͼͻͰͫͻͪͳͲͷͶͳͯΔͳͯͪͭͪͼͪͻͪͰ;ͭͻͫ;ͼͬͰͽͭͪ͊ͪͬͰi
͉ͪͲ;ͷͰ ͼͰ ͯͪ ͼ; ͊ͪͬͳͰ ͷͽͳ ͳͼͺΓͪͬͪͶͰ ;ͯͰͼͪ ͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ ͳ ͪ͵
ͺͻͰͼͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;̺ͰΕͽ͵ͷͼͪͷͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰtͼͶͳͬͪͰͼͰͪͻͯͼͪͼͬͳΒ;
ͼͽͻͪͪ
ͯͪͬͳͯͳͳͯͪͼͰͺ͵Ͷͳ
;ͬͳͲͪͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͼͬͰͽ̸̹ͭͪͭͰͼ͵;ͯ
ͯͪͬͪͰͫͶͪͭͯͪͽͯͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭͪͳͷͪ͵ΒͳͳͼͰͼͪͬͰͻͷͯͽͳͪ
; ͠Ͱͻ ͷͭͳ ͷͶͳͽͬͪͷͪ ͼͬͰͽͭͪ ͯͫͳͬͳ ͳͼͰΓͰΔͰ ͯ ͫͶͰͼͽͳ ͵ΒͰ ͳ
ͯͻͱͪ;
ͬͰͼͰͶͯͶͪͱͪ;ͼͬΒΒ͵;Εͳi͆ͪ͵ͼͪͻͪͰ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳ͊ͪͬͪ
ΒͰ
ͺͰͽͪ;ͯͰͼͪͪͳ
ͯͶͪͼ͵ͷ;ͼͪΒͰͯͷͺͫͱͷͼͽͪͻ;
Ͳͪͺ
ͬͰͯͳͼͬΒ;ͯͻ;ͭ;FMFWBUJP͌ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͲͰͷΓͳ
;͵ΒΒΒͰ
ͲͪͶͪͭͪΔͰͷͼͳͬͪ
͵ͻͪΓ̺ͪͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ
ͯͫͳ͵ͪͺ͵ΒͳͽͰ
ͺͬͼͰͫΒͪͬͳtͷͭͳͷ
;ͯͰͼͳͷͪi
ͯͪΒ;ΕͳtͷͭͪͳͼͰΓͰΔͪͫͶͳͷͪͯͷͭͳͫͶͰͼͽͳi͊;ͽͳ;
ͳͺͻͪͬͳͼͷͳͼͪ͊ͪͬͳͭ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪ;ͽͪͪͼͽͬ;ΒͪͼΒͰͳͼͽͪ͵ͪ͋Ͱͯ
ͼͳΒͰ͈ͻͳͯͻ;ͱ;Β;Εͳ͊ͪͬ;ΔͰͭͬͷͼͬͰͽͷͻͯͳͽͰΓ;ͳͳͼͺͳͼ;Β;ΕͳͳͷͲͪΒͰͯ
ͳ͵;͈ͬͪͶ;
ΒͰͳͲͶͱͳΒͰͯ;ͯͰͽͻͪͶͳͳͯͰΒͪͼͬͭͯͫͪ
;
tͼͬͰͽͰΒͯͬΒͳͳi͵Βͳͼ;tͫΒͳͪͼͬͰͽͳͳ;ͯͽͬͻͳi͌Ͳͪͬͻͳͳ
ͼͰ͵ͪͱͰtwͳͽͪͪͼͽͬͼͬΒͰͫΒͳͪͲͪΒͰͯmͽΒͰͼͽ͊ͳͷͰͺͻͰͺͯͫ
ͳͳͼͬͰͼͬͰΕͰͳ͊ͪͬͪmͷͶͳͽͬͪͷ̹ͪͭ;ͼͻͺͼ͵;ͲͰͷΓ;;ͽͬͻΌ;Β;ͳͯͪͺͪ
ͯͪΒͪͺͻͽͳͬͳ͵ͪͫͻͪͰΕͳΒͰ;ͬͪΒ;i
͌ͰͶͳͳͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͪ
;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
ͪͲͪͱͳͬͽͪͳͪͪ
͵ ͼͷͻͽͳ
ͳͰ ͫͳͽͪ ͪͼͺͰ͵ͽ Ͳͪ͵ͻ;ͱͰͰ ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ ͱͳͬΓͰΔͪ ͳ
ͺͯͬͳͭͪ
͵ͷͺͬͪͰͪͼͬ;ͬͪͱͰΕͳͳͲͪͶͪ͵ͳͯͪͫͻͪͳͫͻͪͲͪͪ
͌ͯͬͪͪͬͻͪͽͪ͊ͪͬͳͪ;ͯͰͼͪͼ;ͳͲͶͱͰͪ͵ͪͲͪͼͰͫͪͰͶͳ͇ͪͪͳͰΒͰ
ͯͪͯͭͶͪͬͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ͈ͪͬͪͶͰͳ͵ͻͺͻͳͻͪͰ;̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬ̿ͳͽͳΒͰ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
ΒͰͯͪ͵ͺͻͭͻͪͷͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ;͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬͳͷ̓ͪͳͷͪ
͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰͲͪΒͰͯ
ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΒ;͊ͳͷͰͳ͊ͪͬͪ
W͊ͻͫΓͪ͵*
mͳͯͰΒͳtͼͬͰͽͰͰͯͬΒͳͰi͵ͪͰͽͻͪͶ
ΒͽͰͷͳͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͰͻͰͿͻͷͰ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ̹ͬͭͯͫͪ̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
͈ͻͰͯͭͬͻJO͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
̿ͳͽͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
99*7m997
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͌͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬΒ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͪͬͳͽͳͶͼͰͳ͵ͻͪ͵ͯͪΓͰ
ͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪΒͰ
ΔͰͯͻ;ͭͳ͵ͪ;ͰͶͳͳͺͼͬͰΕͰͼͬͰͰͬͳͷ;ͯͳͷͪ
͵Βͪͼ;ͺͫͻΒͪͪͼͳ
ͼͽͰͷͪͽͳͳͺͳͷͰͰ͋ͪ.JSBDVMBͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͰͪͼ;ͲͪͺͽͻͰͫͰ͵;ͶͽͪͳΒͰ
ΒͰͫͳͽͫͰͶͰͱΒͰͫͳͶ;ͺͻͪͬͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͰ͌ͼͬͷͬͻͰͷͰ;ͳ
ͼͻͰͯͳͳ͊ͪͬͪͼͰΒͪͬͳ͵ͪtͬͳ;ͯͽͬͻͪi͐ͳͰΕͳ;ͯͰͼͪ
ͪͼͽΒͪΒͰ
ͯͪͯͼͰͭͰ
ͺͪͳͪͯͳΌͰͳͲͬͻͰͷͯͰͶͰͺͻͶͼͽͳ
ͯ͵ͪͲ;Β;Εͳͽͪ͵ͷͭ;Ε
ͼͽͰͺͻͰͼͽͪͭͼͽͬͪͻͳͬͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
͵ΒͪΒͰ;ͪͰͶ;ͯͪͽͪΓ;ͯͳͷͪ
͊ͽͭͪΒͰ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͯͪΒͰͺͽͻͰͫͯͪ;ͺͲͻͳt́ͳ͵
͵ΒͳΒͰͼͶ;
ͪͲͪ;ͯͪͽͼͰͯͭͯͳͰͻͪͳΒͰͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͻͳͷͪͳͼͬͰͽͳͷͪ
ͯͪͰͺͻͳͷͳͼ
ͰͬͰͻͳͷͬͪͬͪ;ͯͰͼͪ͵ΒͪͼͰͼͪͯͪͯͭͯͳͰ͠ͰͻͳͬͪΒͳΒͰͫͳ;Όͳ
ͯͼͽͪͻͳͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳ
ͪͺ͵ͪͲͪͼͰͯͪΒͰͷͭͳͷͯͫͻͯͰͽͰΓͳͷͪͰ͵Ͱ
ͳͺͻͰͬͪͲͳͪḯͳ͵͊ͪͬͰ;ͯͽͬͻͪͭͻͪΌͰΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͰͼͪͷͺͻͰͷͪ
ͫͻͪͼͳͷͪtͼͽͪͻͳͳͼͬͰͽͳiͬͰΕͳͪΒͬͰΕͳ;ͲͻͪmͳͳͲ͊ͬͰͽͭͺͳͼͷͪ
͋ͪ tͫͳͫͶͳΒͼ͵ͪ ͽͳͺͶͭͳΒͪi ͊ͪͬͳͳ ;ͯͪ ; ͪ;ͳ ΒͰ ͯͪͬ ;Ͱͪ ͋ͪ͵
ͼͰ͊ͪͬͪ
ͺͯͳͱ;ΕͳͻͪͼͶͪͫΓͰͭ;̿ͳͳ
ͺͲͳͬͪͪͼͶͳ;ͯͪͺͼͽͶͪ
͈Ͱͽͻͪ
ͪ ; ͫͻͪ;; ͼͪ ͊ͽͻͰͲͷ ͪ ͺͻͻ͵Ͱ ́ͶͳΒ;
͠ͰͶͳͼͰΒͪ ͳ ͅΒͼͳΒͪ
͐ͳͽͪͬͪ̽ͷͰͽͳΒ͈ͪͬͪͬͪͶͪ͊ͪͬͳͭͻͪΌͰͪΒͰͪͺͻͰΌͰΔ;͊ͪͬͰͼͅΒͼͳ
ΒͰͷ
;ͼͬΒͼͽͬ;ͫͭͼͪͳͫͭͬͳͪ́ͺͪ͵
ͺͻͪͬͳ;Ͳͻ͊ͪͬͰ;ͯͽͬͻͪ
ͫͳΒͰͼͪͷ͎ͻͳͼͽͼ͈ͼͶͰͯ;Β;Εͳͷ;
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͺͻͻͳͪͯͭͪΌͪΒͰͳͼͽͳͪͬͪ
Ͷ;Β;
ͳͼͰΓͳͬͪͫͶͰͼͰͳͬͪͼ͵ͻͼͪͬͪͷͻͽͬͰ͋ͪ͵ͬͳͼͯͳͽͰΔͰͭͬͳ;
ͯͰͼͳ ͷΕͳ ͽ;ͷͪͳ ΒͰ ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
ͺͬͯͷ ;ͯͪ ; ̿ͳͳ
ͽͬͻͯͰΕͳͯͪΒͰ
t͈ͻͰͺͯͫͳͬͪͳͼͽͳ;;Ͱͳ͵͎ͻͳͼͽͬ
ͺͯͫͰΕͳͼͰͬͶͪͯͳͳͼͬͷͰ
͵ΒͳΒͰ
ͻͰ͵ͪ̓ΒͳͬͰͻ;ΒͰ;ͷͰͰͳͯͰͶͪ͵ΒͪΒͪͳͳͷͳΕͰͳͼͪͽͬͻͳͽͳ
ͪ;Ͳͽͳ
ͬͰΕͪͯͬͳi͋ͪΒͳͼ͵ͪͲ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;ΒͰΒͰͯ;ͯͽͰͷͰΓͳͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͳ
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
ͳͼͽͰͪͭͳͶͭͳΒͰmͯͪͼͰ;ͯͰͼͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͭͪͺͪͬΓͪ;ͬͻͰͷͰ;͎ͻͳͼͽͬ
ͼͺͪͼͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͯͰͶ
ͯͼͯͪ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͰ
;͵ͻͪΒΔΒͶͳͳΒͳ
ͳͷͪͼͽͳͻͳ
Ͷ͵;ͺͻͳͻͯ;ͳͼͷͳͼͪ
͊ͪͬͳͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳ
ͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͬͰͷͪ;Ͱͳ
ͳͲͶͱͳͶͳͼ;;ͼͬΒͳͷ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͳͼͬͰͫͳͽͰͺͼͽ;ͶͪͽͰͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͽͰͶͭͳΒͰ;͈ͯͪͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;
Εͳ͊ͪͬͳͳͷ;ͯͰͼͳͷͪ
ͳͼ;Βͪͼͳͼͽͪ͵ͶͳΔͳͬͼͽͳͻͳͶ͵ͳͼͷͳͼͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽ;Ͷͭ;;ͳͼ͵;ͺͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͷͺͶͪ;t͊ͬͪͬͪ;ͯͰͼͪͬͻͰͼͰͺͻͰ͵ͼͬͰͽͳ
ͻͪͯͳͪͰͭͼͺͪͼͰΔͪ
ͯͪͬͳͯͰͬͳͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͷ̹ͭͪ
ͭͬͻͰΕͳ̽ͳͬͪΒͰ̹ͭ;
ͼͬͰͽͳͷͪͼͬΒͳͷͪi͇ͳͼ;
ͳͭͶͰͯ
ͫͳͶͳͯͫͻ;ͺͲͪͽͳͼͪͼͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪ
ͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͰͪͽͻͺͶͭͳΒͰ
;͵ΒΒͺΒͪͷ;ͯͰͼͭͽͻͰͫͪͯͪͳͲͻͪͲͳ
;ͺ;Ε;ͯͱͳͬΓͪΒͪ͵Β;ͬͰ͵ͳͷͪ;ͼ;ͼͻͰͽ;ͼ̹ͭͷ͐;ͯΒͰ
;ͽͷͼͷͳ
ͼͶ;
ͼͳͷͫͶͳͪ Ϳͻͷͪ ͽ͵ͻͳͬͰΔͪ ͳ ͬ
͵ͻͲ ͎ͻͳͼͽͪ ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰ ͼͪͬͰͲ
̹ͭͪ ͳ ͬͰ͵ͪ ͢Ͱͭͬͪ ͰͽͻͪͶͪ ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͪ ΒͰ Γ;ͫͪͬ m ͫͰͼ͵ͪͪ ̹ͱΒͪ
Γ;ͫͪͬͺͻͰͷͪΓ;ͯͳͷͪ
͵ΒͪΒͰ
ͺͼͰͫͳ
ͪΒͬͰΕͰ
Ͱͳͼ͵ͪͲͳͬ;ͯ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪ
Ͱ
ͳͶͳͼͽͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
;ͼͬΒΒΓ;ͫͪͬͳͺͻͰͷ͎ͪͻͳͼͽ;ͳͫͶͳͱΔͳͷͪ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ΒͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͫͱͪͼ͵;ͯ͋ΒͰͼͷͳͼͪͻͰͳ͵ΒͰ
ͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͪ
ͳͲͭͬͪͻͪ͊ͪͬͪt́ͽͪͬͳͰ
̹ͭͽͰΕͳͪͼͺͻͳͼͬΒͳͽͳͼͬΒΒΓ;ͫͪͬͳ
ͺͻͰ͵
ͼͬΒͳͼͬͰͽͳ;ͯͰͼͪͷͰΌ;ͪͷͪͳͳͯͪͻͪͲ;ͷͰͷ̹ͯͪͭͺͲͪΒͰͼͬͪͳΒ;Γ;
ͫͪͬͺͻͰͷͪΔͰͷ;i͈ͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳ
ͽͰͶ͵ͳͬͻ;ͪͽͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͯͫͳͶΒͰ;
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬͷ͊ͬͰͯͰΔ;Γ;ͫͪͬͳ
͵ΒͰΒͰ͊ͪͬͪͳͲͶͱͳ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͷ͵ͻͪΓ;
ͪ͵ͲͪͷͰͳͽͭ;ͯͪͼͺͻͳͲͳͬͪΔͰͷͭͻͪͯͪ͋ͪΓ;ͫͪͬͺͻͰͷ̹ͪͭ;ͳͲͬͻΒͰ
ͪͻͳͽͰ
ͫͶͪͭͯͪͽͰͰͰͻͭͳΒͰ
tͫͱͪͼ͵ͭͭΔͪi͵ΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;ͯͪΒͰͪͽͺͻͳ
ͻͯ;ͼͳͶ;̀ͪͽΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ
ͳͲͶͪͲͰΕͳͳͲͻ͵ͬͰͪ͵͊ͳͷͰͬͭͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ
tͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ ͼͪͬ ͭΔͰi ͈ͻͪͬͼͶͪͬΒ ͪͽͻͺͶͭͳΒͳ ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ ͳ ͯͻͰΌͰΔͰ
ͪͽͺͻͳͻͯͭ
͵ΒͰͳͼͽͫͭͼͶͬΓͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͻͰͪͶͳͷΓ;ͯͼ͵ͳͷͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͷ
ͼͽͬͪͻͰͳͷͲͪͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ;ͺͻͷͳͼͶͪ;ͺͻͳͻͯͳͳͼͬͰͽ;͊ͽͭͪͼͰ
ͺͳͼͪ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͫͻͪΕͪ͊ͪͬͳͻͰͳͷͪt̀ͪͯͳͬͳͼͳͼͰ
ͺͻͳ
̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
MPDDJUͳͯͰΒͳ*NJUBUJP$ISJTUJ͵ͪͬͪͱͷͰͶͰͷͰͽ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
m
QBTTJN
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͈ͻͫͶͰͷ;ͯͪ
ͼͽͰͶ͵ͭͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ
ͺͼͽͪͬͳΒͰ;ͺͻͪͬͰ͵ͬͳͻͰ̸͠ͰͬͽͳΕ
̹ͱͪ
ͼ͵ͳ;ͯͰͼ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͻͰͶͳͭͳΒͼ͵Β͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳ
JO͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪͿͪͽͪͼͽͳ͵ͪ
m
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
m
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͷͪΒ;ΕͳͪͽͺͻͳͻͯͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬwi͠Ͱͯͪ͵;ͺͻ;͵;ͼͪͯͻͱͳͳ͵ͷͰͽͪͻ
ͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭ ͷͳͻͽͰΔͪ
ͽͪͳΒͰ ͊ͪͬͳͰ ;ͶͭͰ ; ͽͷ ͯͭͪΌͪΒ; t͋ͪ͵ΌͰ ͳ
ͷͭͳͯͼͬͰͽͳ
ͺͻͰͳΔͰͭͬΒ
ͷͭͪͯͰͶͪͳͲͪͯͺͻͳͻͯͰͬͰΒͰͭ;ͼͽͪͬͪ
;ͳͷͰΔͰͭͬ;ͳͳͰi͋ͪ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͪͪͽͺͻͳͻͯͭͳͲͬͻΒͰͼͫͰͭ
ͺͪ
ͻͪͯ͵ͼͪͶͭͪͳͪͷͳΓͰΔͪ͵ΒͳͯͪΒͰͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͳͺͰͪͽͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵Β
͵ͪͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͽͰͶ͵ΒͷͳͼͶͳͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵͇ͪͪ;ͯͬͳͯͳ͵ͪͺͪͻͪͯ͵ͼ
Ͱͽ
ͰͰ͵ͳͬͪͳͰͬͰͻͬͪͽ
ͯͭͪΌͪΒ͵ΒͳͪͯͳͶͪͲͳͺͻͳͻͯͪͽ͵ͼͽͬͪͻͳ
͋Ͱ͵ͪͽͪΒͪͳͷͱͰͼͰͻͪͲ;ͷͰͽͳ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬͺͯͪͼͶͬ;͊ͪͬͳͷͱͳͽͳ
Β;͇ͯͶͪͼ͵;;ͯͭͯͰͪ͵ͪ;͊ͬͰͽ;̻ͻ;ͳͺͻͰͫͳͬͪΔ;;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;
ͳͶͳ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬͼͽ̹ͪͬͯͪͭͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͼͬΒͳ;ͭͯͳ͵ͪ
͵ͪͽΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ
ͺ͵ͻͰ
ΕͰΓ;ͯͰ͵ͪͯͫͻͯͰͽͰΓͳtͰ͵ͷͫͻͫͷ;ͯͰͼͪ
ͷͪ͵ͪͻͳͷͪͶͳͷͪi͐;ͯͪͼͰ
ͼͽͭͪͺͳͼ;Β;ͰͺͳͽͰͽͳͷͪͯͳͬͳͶͳ;ͱͪͼ
ͪͻͰͪ͵ͳΒͰͼͬͰͯ͵ͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͳͷ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͬͪͶͳͯͻͰΌ;Β;ͼͰͼͶͳͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ;ͯͳͬͳͽͳͼͰ
;ͯͳͽͳ
;ͱͪͼ;ͽͳ
͊ͬͪͽͪΔͰͪͽͺͻͳͻͯͭͺͻͱͰͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͺͪͻͪͯ͵ͼͪͶͳͲͷͷͷͱͯͪΒͰ
ͪΒͺͽͺ;ͳΒͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͺͳͼ;Β;ΕͳͯͰΒͼͽͬ͊ͪͬͳͰtͺͼͶͪͳͰi͵Β;
ΒͰͺͻͳͽͪͪͬͪ́ͶͪͻͳΒͰt͠ͰͻͭͯͰͼͰ;ͼͽͪͬͳ;ͼͽͪͬͬͰΒͰͺͻͳͻͯͰ
ͯͪͱͳ
ͬͳͷͻͽͬͳͷͪͺͳ;
ͳͶͳͯͪΔͳͷͪͰͽͭͬͻͰ
ͳͶͳͯͪͷͻͽͬͳͱͳͬͰͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͳ
ͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͳΔͳͬͰͬͻͰ ̸ͶͳͼͬͰͬͳͳͻͰͭͼͺͯͪͷΒͰͭͪ́ͼ;ͼ͎ͪͻͳͼͽͪ
̓ͬͰͻ;ΒͰ;ͷͰͰ
ͯͰͶͪ͵ΒͪΒͪͳͳͷͳΕͰ;ͳͳͽͳ
ͳͬͰΕͪͯͬͳΕͰ;ͳ
ͳͽͳi
͈Ͱ͵ͯ;ͯͪ͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭͷͱͰͯͪͪΔͰͷͳͽͪ;ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪͽͳͺͻͫͶͰ
ͷͪͽͳ
ͺͪͪ͵ͳͲͪͲͬͪͽͳͳͳͻͳͪ͵ͷͰͽͪͻ͋ͪ͵
ͻͰͳͷ
͊ͪͬͳͳͲͪͽͰ
ͬͳͯͪͷ;ͼͰͺͼͶ;ͱͰͼͬͰͱͰ;ͶͬΓͰͪͻͳͫͪͳͻͪͼͶͪΌͰͬͳm͵Βͳͼ;ͫͳͶͳ
ͰͺͼͻͰͯͪ ͺͬͯ Ͳͪ ͯͰͪͬͪΔͰ ;ͯͰͼͪ m ͵ͪ ͯͪ ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪΒ; Ͷͳͼͽ ͼ͵Ͷ;
Ͱͯͳͼͽͳ͵ͳͷͪͬͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͳͷͪͶͺͻͳͷͰͻͰͳͷͷͪ;ͳtͼͬͰͽͷͬͰ͵;i
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͵ͷͰͲͶͪͷͰͻͷͳͳͳͯͪΒͰͺͻͽͳͬi͌͵ͻͪΒΔΒͶͳͳΒͳ
͵ͪͲ;ͳͼͽͳ͵ͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͰͪͻͭ;ͷͰͽͪͳΒͰͺͳͬͪͶͪΒͰͪtͶͭͳ͵ͷͺͼͽ;Ͷͪͽ;iͯͪΒͰ̹ͱΒͪͼͳͶͪ
ͫͰͲͭͻͪͳͪ́ͲͺͻͰͷͳͼͰ̹ͯͪͭͳͷͪͷΕͯͪͳͳͰͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͬͪ;ͯͪͳͲͬͯͳ
ͼͰͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵ͯͪͳͳͳͳ
ͳͲͰͭͪͼͰ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͯͰͯ;͵;Β;ͼͬͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͪ;ͯͪ
ͽͼͰͲͫͳͬͪΒ;;tͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Βͻͪͬͳi͌ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͽͪΒͼͽͪͬΒͰͪΒͼͪ
ͱͰͽͳΒͰ
ͫͰͲͺͳͻͭͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͭͯͳͼ͵;ͻͼͪ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ
ͺͬͯͷͰͬͭ;ͯͰͼͭͷͳͻͽͰΔͪͳ;ͲͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͪ̈́;͵ͳΒͰͬͪΌͰΓͰ
t͠ͰͻͼͰͲͪͯͳͬΓͪͬͪ;ͷͳͼͽͻͪͳͼͬͰΓ;ͯͼ͵ͲͪΔͰ͠ͰͻͯͬͰ͵ͪΒͰͰͷͭ;Ε
̹ͪͯͭͪΒͰͼͬͰͷͭ;Εi
͐;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
͵ͪͫͳͽͪͳͳͶͪ͵;ͶͽͪͪΒͺͺ;ͶͪͻͳΒͰͭͪ
ͳͪͶͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͳͲͷͰͳͶͪͼ;͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͪ͵ͭ;ͫͳͽ͵ͪͯͻͱͪͬͰͼͪͷ
ͼͽͪͶͼͽͳ
; ͯͫͪ ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭ ͺͼͽͪΒͪΔͪ ͺͯ ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͷ ͬͶͪΕ; ͌ ͵Ͷͼͽͳͷͪ
; ͵Βͳͷͪ ΒͰ ͻ͵ͬͰͳ ͵;Ͷͽ ͺͼͽͪ ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ ͪͻͯͭ ͬͰͻͬͪΔͪ ͯͶ ΒͰ ͯ
ͻͪͲͶͪͭͪΔͪͼͬͰͰͬͭͶͳ͵ͪͳΒͰͺͼͽͪͼͳ͵ͻͰͽͳͪͳͪͷͫͳͬͪͶͰͽͪ͌ͿͶ
͵ͶͻΒͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ͊ͪͬͪͳͼͺΓͪͬͪͼͬΒͰ;ͯͰͼͰͷΕͳ͵ͪ;ͳͽͰΓ͵ͻͳͼͳ
ͬͰͽͳͪͳͼͪͬͰͽͯͪͬͪ
͵ͪͫͻͪͺͻͽͳͬͲͶͪ;Ͷͳ͵;ΌͪͬͶͪ
ͪͶͳͳͺͻͫΓͳ
ͬͪͪmͲͫͭͰͭͪ͊ͪͬͳ͵;ͶͽͺͼͽͪΒͰΒͰͲͭͻͯͻͱͪͬͪΔͪͪͳͪͶͭͳͯͰͽͳ
ͽͰͽͪ͊ͪͬͪ;ͯͽͬͻͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼͽͰ͵ͪΒͰ;ͽͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͳͰͭͪͽͳͬͪͼͬΒ
ͼͽ͇ͬͪͳͼͺΓͪͬͪͲͪͬͳͼͽͳͭͰͬ
ͽͳͽͳͬ;͵ͬͰ͵ΒͳͪͺͪͯͪΒ;ͼͽͪͯͪ
ͼͺͻͰͷͪ
ΒͰͯͪͼ;ͻͬͳͰͺͻͪͬͰͯ͵ͪͱΔͪͬͪ͋ͪΒ͊ͪͬͳͬͳ
ͿͶ͵ͶͻͳͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ
ͫͳΒͰͺͶͯͬͻͪΕͪΔͪͰͶͰͷͰͽͪͻͳͷͫͶͳͳͷͪͻͰͶͳͭͳͲͭͱͳͬͽͪͳͺ͵ͪͲͪ
ͽͰΓͳͲͭ;ͫΓͰͭͯ;ͬͭͻͳΒͰͽͳͻͪ̓ͪͽͪ͵ͪͬ
ͬͰͷͪͼͰͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͬͪͯ
Ͷͳ͵ͪ ͊ͪͬͰ ;ͯͽͬͻͪ ; ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷ ͬͰ͵; ͌ ͯͫͪ ͯͻͱͪͬͼͽͳ ΔͰͭͬ ͳͯͰͪͶͪ
ͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳͶͳ͵;ͫͶͳͳͶͳͼ;ͪΒͫͻͪͲͬͪͳΒͳͯ;ͬͳͳ
ͪͺͯͼͽͳͪΒͳͺͯ
ͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͷͬͶͪͯͪΒ;ΕͰͰͶͳͽͰ͋ͪΒ͊ͪͬͳͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͶͳ͵ͫͳΒͰͼͪͫͻͪ
ͱͰͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͽͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͼͽͪͯͪͻͯͳͷͪͬͻͰͷͰͪͳͺͽͬͪΒͰͪ
ͳͻ͵ͷͺͻͼͽͻ;ͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͰͬͪͼͰΓͰͰ
ͪͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰΒͰͺ͵ͪͲͪ
ͯͰͶͽͬͻͼͽ;͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
4DISFJOFS
PQDJU
QBTTJN
͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ
̺ͬͪͬ͠ͳΕ
MPDDJU ͼͪͼͬͷͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
]]
̸̸͇̺͇͉̺͇̻̺͉͈͇̻͐͌̽͋̾͊̾͋͊̾͊͊̓͢
̸̺͇͉͇͊̾͋̽͆́͆͊̈́̾̽͆́͏́
̸̸͉́͊͋̽̈́͆́͏́
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡
ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
̸̸̸̸̸̸͇͉͍͉̻̓͌̈́͋͌̓͊͋̾͆̽͌͋́͆͡ͷͱͰͼͰͭͬͻͳͽͳͼͪͷ;ͼͶͬ
͇ͫͶͳ͵ͽͬͪΔͪͬͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͷͪͪ;ͽΒͷͰͻͳΒͰͼͫͰͯͪͭͪͽͻͰͫͪͼͷͪ
ͽͻͪͽͳ ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͷ ͺΒͪͬͷ ; ͼͻͺͼ͵Β ͵;ͶͽΒ ͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭ ͬͰ͵ͪ ̀ͪͯͪͽͪ͵
ͪͰͭͻͪͯͪͼͽͭͪΒͰͺ͵;ͪΒͯͪͼͰͽͪͺΒͪͬͪͽͼͬͰͼͽͻͪͳΒͰͼͪͭͶͰͯͪ
ͪͳͼͽͻͪ
ͱͳͬͪΔͰΒͰͲͪͼͬͪͪͯͬͪͼͬͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͼͫͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͪͳͲͬͻͪ͋ͼ;̿ͳ
ͽͳΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪͳͺͯͪͳ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶͳͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳ
͵ΒͳͼͰͯͼͰ
ͪΔͰͭͬͭͻͫ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͚;ͻΌͰͬͳͷͼͽ;ͺͬͳͷͪ
̹ͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
ͼͪ;ͬͪͪ;Ͳͫͻͳ͵;ͱͳͽͳΒÄͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ
̽ͪͳͶͪ**
ͪͶͪͱͰͺͻͰͲͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ͵ͻͳΕͰΔͪ
ͪͪͻͳͽͽ;ͷͪͰΔͪ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳ
ͯͪ;ͪ;ͳΒ;ͬͰ͵ͳͼ;ͻͰͰͪͷͭͪͺͳͽͪΔͪ͵ΒͪͼͰͯͼͰͪͻͶͭͳΒ;
ͳͼͬͻ;ΔͰͭͪͼͽͪ͵ͪ͆ͰͼͪͭͶͪͼͼͽͳͺͼͽΒͰͬͰΕ͵ͬͻͰͷͰͪͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͭͱͳͽͳΒ͈ͪͻͰͷͪͼͪͯͪΔͳͷͼͪͲͪΔͳͷͪ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͼͰͯͪΒͰͳͲͬͻͳ
̽ͪͳͶͬͼͺͳͼͲͪ͵ͻͪͽ͵ͬͻͰͷͰͺͻͰͽͻͺͰͫͪͻͯͬͰͳͲͷͰͰ͆ͪΒͺͻͰΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͪ
͆ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳͽͰͻͺͶͳͻͪͳͶͳͳͲͬͪͪͺͳͼͪͲͪͬͻͰͯͰ
ͶͬͰͱͳͽͳΒͪ
ͪͰͭͯͰ͵ͭͯͳͰ
͵ͪͯͪͼͰͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ;ͻͰΌ;ΒͰͲͫͻͳ͵
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪͫͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͺͯͰΓͰͪΒͰͪ̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͻͪͳ̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͪ
͇ ͵;Ͷͽ; ͵ͻͪΓͪ ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ Β ;ͬͰ͵ ͪΒͺͽͺ;ͳΒͰ ͈ͪͬͶͬͳΕ
̓;Ͷͽͬͳ Ͷͳͪ
m P
̿ͳͽͳΒ; ͵ͻͪΓͪ ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
ͼͪ ͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ # #PKPWJǀ
- JEÊPMPHJF
NPOBSDIJRVF EBOT MFT IBHJPCJPHSBQIJFT EZOBTUJRVFT EV NPZFO ÄHF TFSCF
3PNB
m
mWͪͻͳͽͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
mͳQBTTJN
͆ͪͼͬ;ͺͻͰΌͰΔͪͻͶ͵ͳͫͶͳͼ͵ͳͱͳͽͳΒͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪͳ͵ͻͪΓͳͰ͠ͰͶͰͰ
͚͊ͺ͉ͪͯΒͳͳΕ ̸ͽͶͭͳΒͪͼͽͪͻͰͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
ͫͳΒͰ
ͷͳΓͰΔͪͯͪΒͰ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͪͫͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͪͼͽͪͶͪ;ͫͻͲͺͼͶͰ
ͪ͠ͰͶͰͳͪͪ͵
ͭͯͳͰ̽ͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͳͲͼͳ̻ͪͅ͵̽ͪͳΒͰͶ ̽ͪͳͶ**
JO̽ͪͳͶ̽ͻ;ͭͳ
̿ͳͬͽͳ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ ͳ ͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
͵Βͳ ͼͷͪͽͻͪ ͯͪ ̿ͳͽͳΒͰ
͵ͻͪΓͳͰ͠ͰͶͰͰͳͲͬͻͺͻͰͽͯͳ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͷ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ͋ͪͪͻͶͭͳΒͪͽͳͺͻͷͰͪͼͶͱͰΒͰͳͲͪͪͪͳͼͽͻͪ
ͱͳͬͪΔͪͬͰͷͪͬͪͱͺͳͽͪΔͰ
͵ΒͰͽͻͰͫͪͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳ;ͼ͵Ͷͺ;;;ͽͻͪΔͳ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳͺͻͬͳͯͰͰͳΒͪ9*7ͬͰ͵͈ͪͼͰͫ;ͽͰ͵Ε;ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
ͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͲͫͻͳ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽͶ͵ͳͳΒͰͺͻ;Ͱ
͵ͪͽΒͰͳͲͬͰͼͳͽͯͪ
ΕͰͺͪͱΔ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͪͳͯͪΓͰͺͻͳͬͶͪͳͽͳͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳͻ;͵ͺͳͼͳͺΒͰͯͳͳ
ͱͳͽͳΒͪͲͫͻͳ͵ͪ
ͯͼͺͳͽͪΔͰΔͳͬͳͿͳͶͳΒͪͳΒͪ
̀ͪͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͪΒͲͪͪΒͳΒͪΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͼͪͯͻͱͳͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͭͱͳͽͳΒͪ
͵ΒͪΒͰ;ͰͺͼͻͰͯΒͿ;͵ͳΒͳͭͻͪΌͰΔͪͶͳ͵ͪͳͯͰͪͶͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͷͪͪ͌ͽ;
ͼͬͻ;̽ͪͳͶ**ͺͼͶ;ͱͳͼͰͺͻͫͪͳͷͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪmͽͺͼͳͷͪͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͭ
ͺͻͰ͵Ͷͪ͋ͼ;ͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͪ
ͼΒͰͯͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͳͲͿͯͪͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
Ͱ͵ͷͳΒͪͼͽͳ͵ͰͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰͳ
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͳͲͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͰͲͪͼͽͪͬͽͳͰͬͳ
ͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͰͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
͇ͺͳͼͺͻͬͭͻͪͲͯͫΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͭͱͳͬͽͪ
ͭͽͺͻͰͽͯͳͯͰͱͰͬ
ͼ͵ΒͼͷͰͳͪͬͶͪͼͽͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͳͳͲͫͻͪͲͪͪ͵ΒͳͼͰͺΒͪͬΓ;Β;;ͳͼͽͻͳ
Εͪͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͳͷͱͳͽͳΒͳͷͪ
ͪͶͳ;ΔͰͷ;͵ͪͯͪͺͻͰͬͶͪΌ;Β;ͻͰͽͻͳ͵ͪ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͬͻͪ͋ͪ͵ͬ;ͬͻͼͽ;;ͽͳͪΒͪͪ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽ
̽ͪͳͶͪ**ͬͰΕΒͰͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͪ͆ͳͼͶ͉ͪͬͪͪͯͰͬͳΕ̺ͰΕͼͪͷ
ͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͷͶͪͯͭͺͻͳͪͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪΒͰ͵ͪͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽ̹ͱΒͰͭͺͻͷͳͼͶͪ̀ͪ
ͰͽΒͰͺͽͼ;ΔͰͭͬͳͻͯͳͽͰΓͳ
;ͭͶͰͯͪΒ;ΕͳͼͰͪͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͰ;ͲͻͰ
;ͺ;ͽͳ
Ͷͳ;ͼͻͯ;ͷͶͳͽͬ;̹ͭ;́ͼͽͳͰͼͰ
Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͺͶͰͷͰͳͽͺͻͰ͵Ͷ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳΕͪ
͵
ΒͳΒͰt̹ͭͷͪͼͪΌͰͪͭͻͪͪͯͯͫͻͺͶͯͭ͵ͻͰͪiͪΔͰͷ;ΒͰͯͻΌͰΔͪ
ͺͳͬͪͶ̹ͪͱΒͪͫͶͪͭͯͪͽ
ͺͪΒͰͼͽͭͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͫͳtͫͭͲͪͷͰͳͽͯͰͽͰi
ͪ
*CJE
m ͪͅ͵ ̽ͪͳΒͰͶ
͌ͬͯ
JO ̽ͪͳͶͬͳ ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m ͼͪ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͷ ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ ͳͲ;ͪͬͪΔ; ̽ͪͳͶͬͭ Ͳͫͻͳ͵ͪ
JEFN
̻ͰͰͼͳͼ ͳ ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ
̽ͪͳͶͬͭ Ͳͫͻͳ͵ͪ
JO ̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺ ̽ͪͳͶ ** ͳ ΔͰͭͬ ͯͫͪ
FE ̺ ͠ ͚;ͻͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
͆ͪ ͽ; ͳΔͰͳ;
;Ͳ ͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͰ ͼ;ͭͰͼͽͳΒͰ
;ͺͲͻͳ ΒͰ ͚ ͋ͻͳͿ;ͬͳΕ
͈ͻͲͪ
ͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ ̽ͪͳͶͪ **
̓ΔͳͱͰͬͪ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ͼ ͺͻͰͭͶͰͯ ͯͪͽͷ ͼͽͪͻͳΒͷ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͷͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
͇ͽͷͰ̻̈́ͪͅ͵ͯͪͳͰͶ
͈ͻͳͶͲͳͲͪͳͼͽͻͳΒ;t̿ͳͬͽͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪͳͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳi
ͯ̽ͪͳͶͪ**
͈ͻͳͶͲͳ͍̓́͠
͵Δ
ͼͬm
m
͋ͪ͵ͬͰ ͫͻͪͼͰ
͵Βͳ ͺͳͼ;Β; ͻΌͰΔͰ
ͷͶͪͯͼͽ ͳ ͿͻͷͳͻͪΔͰ ͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͭ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳ;3.PSSJT
ѮF 1PMJUJDBM 4BJOU PG UIF &MFWFOUI $FOUVSZ
JOѮF #Z[BOUJOF 4BJOU
m&1BUMBHFBO
4BJOUFUÊFUQPVWPJS
JOѮF #Z[BOUJOF 4BJOU
mͪͻͳͽͯͻͪͭͰͪ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪ(BMBUBSJPUPV
ѮF .BLJOH PG B 4BJOU
QBTTJN
͉͆ͪͯͰͬͳΕ
̽ͪͳͶ**ͳͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͪͯͬͻͼ͵ͪͻͰͽͻͳ͵ͪ
JO̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺ̽ͪͳͶ**ͳ
ΔͰͭͬͯͫͪ
m
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
͵ΒͰͷtͺͳ;̽;ͺͻͰͷ;ͯͻͼͽͳ
ͯ;ͼͽͻͪͪͳͻͪͲ;ͷͪͫͱΒͪi͈ͻͰͺͲͪͽΓͳ
ͬͳͷͫͻͪͼͳͷͪΒͰͯͪ͵ͭͺͻͰ͵Ͷͪ̽ͪͳͶͼͰͼͶ;ͱͳ͵ͪͯͪͭͬͻͳͷͶͪͯͳΕ͵ͷ
;Ͳͻͪͼͽ;
ͼͺΓͳͷ ͳ ;;ͽͻͪΔͳͷ ͼͬΒͼͽͬͳͷͪ
͵ͪ ͳ ͼͽͳͪΔ; ͫͻͪͲͬͪΔͪ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͳΕΒͰ
ͽͪ͵
ͳͷͪtͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͯͳͬͪͳͲͭͶͰͯi
ͪͺͪͻͪͬͳΒͰͫͳtͯ;Ͱ
Γ;ͫͪͲͪiͬͪͼͺͳͽͪΒͰt;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͫͶͪͭͬͰͻΒ;ͳͳͼͽͽͳi
ͪͼͬͰͽͰ͵ΔͳͭͰͳͲ;ͳ
ΒͰtͬͰͽͳͻͪͲ;ͷi͈ͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;Εͳ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬΒͱͰͳͯͫͳ
ͱͳͬͽͺͳ
ͼͪͰͺͻͺ;ͽͪͯͪͳͼͽͪ͵ͰͫͶͪͭͻͯͺͻͰ͵ͶͰͬͰͼͽͰ̓ͪͽͰͶͳͪΒͰt͵ΕͰͻ
ͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͺͶͰͷͰͪ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͪͻͯͪiͳtͫͶͪͭͪͼͽͳͬͪi
ͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳΕͱͳͬͳͼ
ΔͷtͫͰͲͶͫͳͷͱͳͬͽͷiͳͼͪtͼͷͳͻͰͷͷ;ͯͻΕ;i̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͪͬͶͪ
ͯͪͬͳͪͺͲͫͪͳͬͪΔ;ͪͳͺͻͰ;ͲͳͷͪΔ;ͺͻͰͼͽͶͪͽͪ͵ΌͰΒͰͺͳͼͪͪͺͻͰͷͪ
ͬͪͱͰΕͳͷͻͷͪͷͪͱͪͻ̺ͪͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽ;ͯͼ;ͪt͵ͶͰͪͻͰͬͰi
ͯ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΒͰtͼͳͶͷiͳt͵ͻͰͺΕ;iͯͻͱͪͬ;ΒͰͬͯͳtͰͶͷ;ͯͻͰi
ͬΌͰ
Γ;ͫͪͬΓ;ͺͻͰͷ̹ͪͱΒͰͷͲͪ͵;ͼͽͭͪΒͰͫͳtͫͶͪͭͪͼͽͳͬͳͼͪͼ;ͯͺͽͻͰͫͪ
̹ͭ;ͽͰΕͳͺͻͰͽͳΔͰͭͬͳͷͰͺͻͰͯͪͻͯͳͷͪͳͪͻͰͬͳͷͪi͌ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͰͬͶͪͯͪͬͳͰͼͬͳͷͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽͯͪͬͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽ
ͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪͻͰͳ;ͼͺͰͼͳ;;;ͽͻͪΔΒ
ͳͽͳ
ͽΒͰͺͼͰͫͬͪͱ
;ͼͺΓΒ
ͺͶͳͽͳͳ
ͪͽΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͳͷͪͶͲͪͽͭ;ͽͳͪΒͪͪͼͷͰ;ͪͬͶͪͼͽͳͭ
ͯͳͰ͋ͪͳΔͰͳͪͳͺͪ͵ͳΒͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵;̽ͪͳͶ;**ͯͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬ
Ͷͳ͵mͷͪͯͪ;ͺͰͽͼͬͰͯͰΒͿͻͷͳ
ͪͻͳͽ͵ͪͯͪͼͰ;ͺͻͰͯͳͼͫͳͭͻͪͿͳ
Βͷ͵ͻͪΓͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪmͼͪͫͻͪͲͳͳͯͰͪͶΒͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͪ;ͽͻͳͽͪͽͳͬͭ
ͺͻͪͬͰͯ
ͭ
ͺͫͱͭͳ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͫͭͳͲͪͫͻͪͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
͈ͻͰͶͷͳͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵;ͱͳͬͽ;ͳͬͶͪͯͪͬͳͳ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ
ͫͰͲ
ͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͺͻͰͯͪΒͪ
ͯͼͺͯͰͶͪͬͶͪͼͽͳͫͪͬΓͰͪ;̽ͰͱͰͬ;͋ͪΒͯͭͪΌͪΒ
͵Βͳ
ͼ;ͳͼͽͻͳͪͻͳͬͳͰͺ;ͽͪͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪͶͳmͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ͵Ͷͼͽͳ;͵Βͳͷͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼͰͲͫͳ
͵ͪͳ͵ͻ;ͺͳͺͼͶͰͯͳͪͪͺͽΔ;ͼͻͺͼ͵;ͳͼͽͻͳΒ;mͺͯͼͽͳͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳͪͻͪͲͷͳΓͪΔͪͿ;͵ͳΒͳ;ͺͽͻͰͫͰͺͽͳͷͰͼͽͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ
ͺͳͼͳͬͪΔͪͻͰͪͶͭͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͭͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ̽ͪͳͶ**
ͯͫͻΒͰͲͪ
ͺͻͽ;
ͷͪͳΒͰͼͷͰ;ͪͬͶͪͼͽͳ͵ͪͺͼͶͰͯͳ;̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͭͺͪͯͪͼ͵Δͪ
ͯͼ
ͺͻͰͶͷͪͭͰͲͪͯͫͳΒͰͭͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ͆ͰͲͭͯͪͼͰͲͫͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ;ͬͳΒͰͷ
͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔ;ͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ͵ͻͪΓtΒͰͲͯͳͰ͵ͳͷͺͼͶͷͼͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͷͼͬ
Βͷͺͯͭͻͪͯͷ͠ͰͶͰͷiͭͅΒͪͼͳΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
̽ͪͳͶͺͻͰͯͪͬͪͺͼͶͰ
ͯͳͰ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͭͺͬͻͰΌͳͬͪΔ͇ͪΒͰ;ͲͰͷΓͳͳͲͪͲͬͪͶtͬͰͶͳ͵;;Ͳͫ;;
ͳͬͰͶͳ͵;ͱͪͶͼͽi
͵ͪͳͺͻͪͬͯͪ;ͫΒͪͲͪtΒͰͻͪ͵͵ͯ͵ͶͳͪͻͰͬͪ
;ΒͰͲͪͽͪ͵ͪͬͽͬΒͳͲͰͪͯͳͺͪͯ
ͷͳΕͰͷͪͼͳͶͺͽͺͪͼͽͳͺͯͻ;͵;ͽ;Όͳͪ
ͪi͇͵Ͷͼͽͳͺͯ͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰͯͶͯ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͰͺͬͻͰͯͰ;ͳͲͬͻͳͷͪͳͼ;
ͼͬͰͽΓͰͰ
͵ͪͽͳΒͰͺͲͪͽͳ;Ͱͷ;ͼͰͼͬͰͼͪͼͽΒͪͶͪtͷͭͪ;Ͳͫ;ͪ;
ͽͪͪͼͽͬ;i
ͳͽͳ͵ͪ͵ͪͬͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͬͪ;Ͷͭͪ;ͪͼͽͪͶͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
́ͯͳ͵ͪͽͳͬΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͽͽͼͰͯͭͪΌͪΒͲͫͳ;ͰͺͼͻͰͯΒͫͶͳͲͳͳͽͬͻ
ΌͪͬͰ͠ͰͶͰ
͵ΒͪΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͽͪͯͪͷͭͶͪͳͷͪͽͳ;Ͷͭ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͻͰͿ;
ͭͳΒ;ͷͪt͆Ͱ͵ͳͺͼͪiͲͫͭ͵ΒͰͭͼͰ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪͪͺͯ͠ͰͶͰͷͼͽͭͪͫͳ
ͷͱͯͪͽͻͰͫͪͶͼͬͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪΔͰͭͬͺ͵;ͪΒͯͪͼͰ
ͼ;ͰͼͰͲͪͯͬΓͼͽͬͷ
;ͲͰͷΓͳͳͺͻͳͽͳͼ;ͽͯͺͻͽͳͬͳ͵ͪ
ͼ͵Ͷͳ;ͽͬͻΌͪͬ;ͼͪtͼͬΒͷi
Β;ͬͰ͵
ͶΒͪͶͷͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͷ͇ͼͽͪΒͰ
ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͽͬͻͰͺͳͽͪΔͰͽͷͰ͵ͪ͵ͽͻͰͫͪͽ;
ͷͪͳͽͳ ͼͪͷ ͳ ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭ ͺͪͯͪ ͼ ͵Δͪ ́ͪ͵ Ͱ ͺͼͽΒͰ ͻͪͲͶͲͳ Ͳͪ ͼ;ͷΔ;
;ͻͰͪͶͼͽͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ
ͳΒͰͳͼ͵Γ;Ͱͯͪͳͬ̽ͪͳͶͬͼͬͰͯͰΔͰͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ
ͼͫͰΒͽͺͳͳ͇ͪͺͳͬͪͪͼͬͪͽͪΔ;
ͻͪͳͻͰͷ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ͵ΒͰͷΒͰͳͬͪͶͳͯͼͽͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵ͪͲͪͫͪͬΓͪΔͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͯ;ͱͼͽͳ
ͪͽ
ͼͰͰͼͽͳͼ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ;ͺͻͪͬͷͽͳͬͷͺͪͯͪͼ͵Δͪ
͈ͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ ; ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ ͪ͵ ͼͷͰͰ ͪ ͬͶͪͼͽͳ ͳ ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͰ
ͬͶͪͯͪͬͳͰ;ͼͺͼͽͬͰͷͯͰͶ;ͯͻͱͪͬͰͫͳΕͰ
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͯͪΓͳͳͼͽͻͪ
ͱͳͬͪΔͪͳͽ;ͷͪͰΔͪ̀ͪͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͯͪΒͬͰΕͰͭΒͰͲͪͪΒͪ̽ͪͳͶͬͪͳͽͰͻ
ͅ ̽ͳͳΕ
͇ͯͼ ͳͲͷͰΌ; ͵ͻͪΓͪ ͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪ ͳ ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
͉̺̀́
m ͪͅ͵
ͼͳͷͬͳΕ
PQ DJU
m ́ ͚;ͻͳΕ
̽ͰͱͰͬͼ͵ͳ ͼͪͫͻ ; ͯͰͶ; ̽ͪͳͶͪ **
JO ̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺ
̽ͪͳͶ**ͳΔͰͭͬͯͫͪ
m ͼͪͫͳͷͷͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͷ
ͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
m ͼͪͼͬͷͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
̽ͪͳͶ
FE̽ͪͳͳΕ
ͺͻͰͬͯ̽ͪͳͶ
FEͅͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
ͅ ͈ͺͬͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ ͫͻͪͬͳͽͰ ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ ; ͉ͪͼ;
JO ͊ͽͰͿͪ ͆ͰͷͪΔͪ m
ͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͳͷͰͅͳͻͽͳͬͳ
m
4)BGOFS
4UVEJFO[VSBMUTFSCJTDIFOEZOBTUJTDIFO)JTUPSJPHSBQIJF
.ÛODIFO
m
͚́;ͻͳΕ
PQDJU
m
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
ͺͻͰͽͪͳΒͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͰͶͳͼͽͳͳͯͰͶͪ;ͺͼͽͯͰͱͰͬͼ͵ͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;͌ͺͳͼ;
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͱͳͬͽͪͪ͵ͺͻͰͯͪΒͰͬͶͪͼͽͳͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪ̿ͳͽͳΒͪ;ͺͪͯΓͳͬͼͰͷͰ
Δ͇ͪͪ
;ͯͼ;ͪͺͻͬͳͯͰ
ͺͼͽͪΒͰͲͪͽͼͶͱͰͳΒͪ
;ͬΌͰΔͰͷͪͭͳ
ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͺͽͳͷͰͼͽͪ͵ͪͳͲͪͺͼͰͫͳͱͪͻͬͪmͷͶͳͽͪͬͪ
ͯͳΒͪͶͭͪ
ͺͶͪͰͬͪ
ͳͼͺͬͰͯͪΔͪm͵ΒͳͪͭͶͪͪͬͪΒ;͵ͽͰͷͺͶͪͽͳͬ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;̿ͳͽͳΒͪ
ͳͼͶ;ͱͰ͵ͪͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͲͪͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͰͼͶΒͰͬͳͽͭͯ;ͰͬͭͱͳͬͽͪͶͳ
ͼͽͳ͇ͬͯͰΒͰͻͰ;;ͽͻͪΔͰͷ͵ͿͶͳ͵ͽ;͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
̽ͪͳͶ;
ͭ;ͫͳͽͪ͵ͺͻͰͼͽͶͪͯͱͳͬͰ͵ͪ͵ͪͲ;̹ͱΒ;ͲͫͭͭͻͰͪ;ͳΔͰͭͺͻͰ
ͷͪ;t͇ͬͰͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͳ ͫͱΒͰ
ͺͻͰͼͽ;ͺͳͬͳΒͪΒͪͯͳͺͭ;ͫͳͼͪͷͭͪͼͰͫͰ
ͺͯͳͭͪͬͳͻ;͵;ͪͼͬͭͪͻͯͳͽͰΓͪ
ͽͪ͵ͯͪͼ;ͰͬͷΒͰͻͪͰͺͲͪͼͶ;Ͳͳi
͋ͪΒͯͻ;ͭͳͯͰ̿ͳͽͳΒͪͲͪͺͻͪͬΒͰͱͪͻͬͼ͵ͳͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͬͰͷͪͻͪͲͻͯͪ
͋;ͼͰͳͯͪΓͰͯͼͶͰͯͻͪͲͬͳΒͪͶͳ͵ͳͯͰͪͶͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͼͽͳͪΔͰͷͺͻͺͳͼͪͳ
ͬͻͶͳͪͳͯ;ͱͼͽͳ͵ΒͰ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͫͪͬΓͪͳ;ͼͬΒΒͯͰΓͰΒͯͻͱͪͬͳ͇
ͫͻͳͰ
ͪͺͻͬͷͷͰͼͽ;
t͵ͪ͵ͯͪͫͻͪͳͳͽͳͽͳͲͰͷΓ;ͽͪͪͼͽͬͪͼͬͭͪͯͪ
ͳͶͪͼ͵ͪͳͪͼͳΓͪͳͺͶͰͷͰͳͬͪͻͬͪͻͪi̺ͪͱ;ͬͶͪͯͪͶͪ͵;ͫͪͬͰͲ;ͯͪ;ͬͪ
ͳͳͻͳtͺͻͪͬ;ͬͰͻ;imͽͪͯͪͳͭͶͰͯͼͬͻͼͳͼͯ;;ͼͰͬͰͻͳͷͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪ
͊ͻͫͳΒͰm͵ͻͪΓͽͪ͵ΌͰͻͰͬͼͼͺͻͬͯͳt̽ΌͰ;ͽ;ͲͰͷΓ; ͪͬͅ;
ͯͪΒͰͺͻ
ͼͬͰͽͳ
ͳͯͪͪͻͯ
͵ΒͳΒͰͫͳ;ͽͪͷͳͳͷͻͪ͵;ͰͲͪΔͪ
ͺ;ͰΔ;ͫͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͺͳͼͷͪ ͺͻͳͬͰͯͰ ͵ͪ ͼͬͰͽͶͼͽͳ ͼͺͪͼͼͭͪ ͱͳͬͽͪi ̓ͪ ͶͳͰΔͰ ͺͻͪͬͯͰ
ͳͷͳͶͼͻΌͪ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳΒͰͳͼͯͳͽͰtͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͳ;ͯͪ
ͷͳͶͼͽͳΔͰͳͽͳ
ͷͪ
;ͽͰͰͷͪͶͯ;ͳͷͪ
ͼͪͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͰͳͷͪ͵Βͳͼ;;ͼ͵ͻͫͳi͆ͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͲ;
ͯ;ͱͼͽͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪͻ͵ͬͰ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͫͳͭͻͪͿͪͻͳͽͳͼͽͳͰ
ͺͯͻͫ
ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;Εͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͷͳͲͯͪͳͷͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͳͷͪmͰͼͪͷ;ͼͻͺͼ͵Β
ͲͰͷΓͳ ͬͰΕ ͳ ͯͪͶͰ͵ͳͷ ͼͽͻͪͪͷͪ
; ͉;ͼͳΒͳ ͳ ͊ͬͰͽΒ ͲͰͷΓͳ ͈ͻͪͬͯΓ;ͫΓͰ
͵ͪͻͳͽͪͽͳͬͪͳͯͪͽͻͼ͵ͪͯͰͶͪͽͼͽͺͻͳͼͯͰͳͲͺͫͱͼͽͳ͵ͪͽͰͷͰΓͰ
ͬͻͶͳͰͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ̓ͯ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪͫͭΓ;ͫΓͰΒͰͪͻ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
ͼͶ;ͪΒͰͬͳͷͪͼͶͰͯͳͷͪ͵ͳͫͻͪͲ͈ͪͻͰͷͪͼͬͰͯͰΔ;ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͻ
ͳͪͻͪ
ͼͪͱ; ͱͰΓ; ͯͪ ͼͰ Ͳͪͷͪͳ ͳͼ͵ͪͲͳͬͪ ΒͰ ͪͻ ͆ͳΕͳͿͻ ** ͍͵ͪ
m
͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪΒͰͽͪΒͳͯͰͪͶͱͳͬΓͰ;ͯͫͪ̓ͷͳͪ
ͪͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ΒͰ
ͪΒͫΓͰͳͶ;ͼͽͻͬͪͺͻͰͯͼͷͻͽͳͷͷͪͰΔͰͷͪͻͪͪͅΒͶͪ* m
͵ΒͰͷͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪ͆ͳ͵ͳͽ͎ͪͳΒͪͽ͈ͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͼͷͳͼͪͽͭͳͪͫͻͪͲͶ
ͱͰΒͰͳͼͽͳͬͳͷͪ;͵ͶͰͼͪͳͷͪͪͻͰͬͭͻͫͳͼͺͷͰͳ͵;ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷ
ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͈ͪͽ͵ͻͪͽͻ;́ͯͳΒͰ
;9*7ͬͰ͵;
ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰͳͼ;ͺͻͳͷͰͻͳ
ͯͪΒͰͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͬͪͼͳͶͰͬͼͺͻͳͷͪtͪΌͰͼ͵ͳͶͳ͵i,BͯͪΒͰͻͰͪͻ;ͬͪ͠;
7̓ͪͽͪ͵;Ͳͳ; m
͵Βͳ;Ͳͳͷͪͷͪ͵ͳͷͰͪ͠ͼͪͿ
ͽͪ͵ͬͯ;ͬ
ͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͰͪΒͰͺͼͻͰͯͳΒͰΒͰͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽ
͌ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͳͯͰΒͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ;ͷͪ;ͳͷͪͶͪΒͰͬͰͶͳ͵;ͬͪͱͼͽ͢Ͱͪ
ͺΒͪͬͪ
ͳͷͪͶͼͶ;ͪΒ
ͺ͵ͶͪͺͪͼͰͼͪͲͪͪΒͳͷͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͪͷͪ;ͼͷͰͻͰͳͷ
͵ͪͼͽͬͪͻͪΔ;ͼͪͷͼͽͪͶͰͯͻͱͪͬͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͇ͪͫͻͪͲͪΒͰ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͺͻͳͶͳ
͵ͷͭͻͪΌͰΔͪͶͳ͵ͪ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
͵ͪͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪͰͽͪͺͪ;ͪͼͽͪΒͪΔ;ΔͰͭ
ͬͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͪ͵ͪΒͰͲͪ͵ͻ;ͱͰ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͷ;ͬͻͽͰΔͰͷ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰ͋ͪΒ
ͷͯͰͶͬͶͪͯͪͻͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͺͼͽͪΒͰ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳΒͰͯͪͯͽͰͷͰΓͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
ͺͼͪͯͻͱͳͳͳͿ;͵ͳΒͳ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ
;ͪͰͶ;
ͽΒͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ
ͪͶͳ;ΔΒͳͷͪͼͪͼͬͳͷͼͫͰͷͰͼͽͅͰΌ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͬͶͪͯͪͻ
ͼ͵ͳͷͫͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͷͪͼͰͬͳͯͳͲͯͬͪΒͪͺͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻ;ͫͻͪͲͪͪ;ͺͽͻͰͫΓͰ
ͳͲͪͭͻͪΌͰΔͰͶͳ͵ͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͷͪͪ͢Ͱͭͬͪͬͳͪ
;Γͳͬͪ;ͯͻ;ͭͷͯͰͶ;
̿ͳͽͳΒͪ
ΒͰͼͽͰͪͭͶͪͰͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͽͺͼͪ͵ΒͳͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͳͲͬͻΒͳͼͽ
ͻͳΕͪͼ͵Βͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳͳ͇ͳͼ;;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳΒ;ͪͺͿͽͰͭͷͪͷͪPͽͪͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ;̿ͳͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽ̸ͭͽͳΒͪͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ̸ͪͽͪͪͼͳΒͪ
͵ΒͰΒͰ
ͺͼͽͪͶͬͪͱͰΕͳ;ͲͻͺͽΔͳͷͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͷͪͳͼͽͳͪͪͻͰͽͪ͌ͽ͵;
ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪͽͪ͵ͬͳͫͻͪͼͳͳͻ͵ͼ;͵ͻͳΕͰͳmͪͻͳͽ;͵ΔͳͱͰͬ
ͼͽͳͺͪͽͰͻͳ͵ͪ
ͪͶͳͳ;ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͬͻͼͽͪͷͪͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵ͰͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
ͷͰΌ;͵ΒͷΒͰ
ͺͼͰͫͪ;ͽͳͪΒͳͷͪͶͪ̈́Ͱͼͽͬͳͪͬͪͪ̓͠Ͷͳͷͪ͵ͼ͍ͪ;͵ͳΒͪͳͷΒͰͫͳͶͪͯͪ
ͺͳ;ͺͻͺͳͼͪͳͷͰͽͯͪͪͻͰͲͰͳͺͻͰͯͰΔͰ͵ͻͪΒΔͳͳΓͺͻͰͶͪͲͪ͵ͳͲ
ͽͰͶͰͼͰ;ͯ;ͬ;ͻͪͬͪͰͭͲͳͼͽͰͳΒͰ
ͼͬͪΕͰ;͵ͪͷͭ;ΕͼͽͳͽͰͲͳͬͰ
ͳͰͺͻͰͼͽͪͰ͵ͽͰͷͺͶͪͳΒͰ̹ͭͪ͋ͪ͵ͬPͳͲͬͻPͳͬͻͰͷͰͷͼͬͰͽͪP
ͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵PͺͻͰͯͪΔͰΒͰͼͽͰ͵ͬͳͻͲͪͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔͰͺͯͬͳͲͳͷͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳ
͈ͪͻͳͽͷΒͰͬͪͱͪͺͷͰ;ͽͳͯͪͼͰ;ΔͰͭͬͷͱͳͽͳΒ;ͺΒͪͬΓ;Β;ͳͽͺͼͳ
ͻͪͯͳ͵ͪͶͰͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳ͵Ͱ
͵ΒͳͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳͼͳͻͳΒͼ͵ͭͷͪͽͬͪ
ͪ;ͼͻͺ
ͼ͵ΒͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳͺͻͳͷͰΔͰͳͼ;ͪͯͼͶͰͯͪͪͳ;͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬͷ̿ͳͽͳΒ;
ͼͬͰͽ͈ͭͰͽͻͪ̓ͻͳ͵ͭ
͈ͯͬͳͭͰ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ̽ͪͳͶͳͲͶͪͱͰͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳ
͵ͪͼͪͼͽͪͬͰͯͰ
ͶͬͰ ͳͻͰ ͰͶͳͰ ̓ͻͪΓ ͪΒͺͻͰ ;ͷͻͽͬΓ;ΒͰ ͼͬΒͰ ͽͰͶ
ͷ;ͰΕͳ ͭͪ ͼͽͻͭͳͷ
ͺͼͽͷ
ͼͬͰΕͳͷͼͽͪΒͪΔͳͷͪͳͫͯͰΔͳͷͪ̓ͪ͵ͫͳ;ͼͷͰͻͳͼͬΒͰͷͳͼͶͳ͵ͪ
̹ͭ;
͵ͻͳͼͽͳ;ͫͳͪΒͰͷͰͽͯm;ͼͻͯ;ͷͶͳͽͬ;ͳͺΒͪΔͰͺͼͪͶͪͷͪ͐ͪ͵
ͳͼͬΒ;ͼͺΓͪΔͼͽ͵ͻͪΓͼͪͫͻͪͱͪͬͪͳͲͭͶͰͯ;ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͰͳͺ;ͼͽͳΔͪ͵͇ͪͯ
ͫͪͳͬͳͼ͵;ͺͰͰͪΓͳͰ
tͫͶͪͳͼͰ;ͺͰͺͪͰͳͳͼ͵ͻͺΓͰͰ
ͪͺͪͰͼͰ
Βͪ͵;ͱͰͽͷͯͼͶͪͷͰͺͪͭͷͽͰͶ;ͼͬͷͰitͬͻͰͽͳͰͯͯͶͪ͵ͰͽͻͰi͵ΒͰ
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
ͼͳͪͼͰͫͳͪͲͳͬͪͺͪ͵tͻ;ͱΒͰͷi
ͯͼtͻͳͲͷͼͺͪͼͰΔͪi͆ͪͽͪΒͪͳ
͵ͻͪΓͼͶͰͯͳͺͻ;͵Ͱͽͪͪ
͵Βͳͼ;ͼͷͪͽͻͪͶͳͯͪΒͰͫͭͪͽͪͯͰΕͪͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵ͪͳͼͽͳ
ͼ͵ͷͺ͵ͪΒͪΔ;͇ͯ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͳͺͯͬͳͭͪͪͻͳͽΒͰͬͪͱͪΔͰͭͬͫͳͪΒ
ͯͪͺͻͰͫͳͬͪ;ͭͻͫ;̽ͪͳͶ**ͭͪ;ͯͬͪͪͬͻͪͽͪͳͼͽͳͰ
ͺͪͪ͵ͬͰͶͳͯͪͼͰ͵ͻͪΓ
ͪͽͪΒͪͳͺͯͬͳͲͪͬͪͰͼͪͷ;ͼͬͷͯͷ;ͬͰΕͳtͪ͵ͼͰͯͭͯͳͶͯͪͳͯͰ
ͪͰ͵ͳͺ;ͽ
ͪ͵ΒͰͷͭͯͷͰͼͽ;w;ͬͰ͵ΒͰͫͳͳͼ͵ͺͪͭͻͫ;ͲͰͷΓͳ
ͳͷͰͼͽ
ͷͰ͵ͪͰͺͼͽͰΓͰͫͳͶΒͰͺͻͼͽͻͽͽͻ͵ͪͷͰΔͰͳͽͻΔͰi͉ͰΒͰͺͼͽ;ͺ͵;
͵Βͳ;ͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͪͪͻͰͲͰͳͷͪͪͻͳͽͼͷͳͼͪ͵ͪͯͼͶͬͪͳͲͻͪͲtͼͰΕͪΔͪͪ
ͼͷͻͽi͋ͪΒͺͼͰͫͳͫͶͳ͵ͷͰͯͳͽͪͳΒͰͺͻͶͪͲͼͽͳͼͬͰͭͪͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͭm͵Βͳ
ͽͰͶͳ͵;ͺͷͪͱͰͯͪͼͬΒͳͬͻͶͳ;ͰͺͻͳͼͽͻͪΕͪmΒͰͯͪΒͰͯ͵Γ;ͳ
͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͪͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵Ͱͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳ͵Ͱ͌ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͰtͼͬͪ͵ͯͰͬͰͼͷͻ
ͽͳi;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰΒͰ͵ͪͫͻͪͲͪ;̿ͳͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽ̸ͭͽͳΒͪ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷΒͰͺͼͽͪ
ͶͻͪͳͻͰͫͳͪΒͷͰΌ;ΔͰͭͬͳͷͼͶͰͯͫͰͳͳͷͪ̓ͪͺͽͰͷͰͼͽΒͪͬΓͪͼͰ
;ͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵Β͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳͳͽͪͬͭͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͬͪͻͳΒͪͽͰ
ͺͺ;ͽ
ͺͶͪͪͺͻͰͯͭͻͫͪ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͳΒͰͰͬͪͱͺͯͬ;ΕͳͯͪͼͰͽͷͳͼ͵;ͰΔ;͵ͻͪΓ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͳͲͶͪͭͪͼ͵ͶΔͰͯͺͭͶͰͯͪͳͯͪͷ;ΒͰ̽ͪͳͶ
ͺͻͰͷͪͼͺͼͽͬͰͳͷ
ͻͰͳͷͪ
ͫͳtͽͪΒͳͲͪͶͪi͋ͼͬͰͯͰΔͰ;ͺ;Ε;ΒͰͪΒΒͰͯͳͲͬͻͪ
ͰͶͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳ͵ͰmͲͪͽͰͬͲͪͼͪͷͲͪͽͪΒͳͬͪΔͰͷ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺͻͳ͵ͻͳͬͪΔͰͷͼͺͼͽͬͰͳ
ͲͪͼͶ;ͭͪͳͬͻͶͳͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
Ͷͪͼ;ͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪ;̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͷͱͳͽͳΒ;͌ͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳͳͳͼ;ͺΒͪͬͳͫͶͳ͵
ͳͺͽͬͻͯͪͺ͵ͪΒͪΔͪ
ͪͶͳͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͪͬͳͰͷͼͽ;ͺΔ;ͺͯͬͳͭͪ
ͳͲͻͪͲͻͪͯͼͽͳͳ
Γ;ͫͪͬͳͺͻͰͷ̹ͪͭ;͉ͰͳͽΒͰͽͽͼͰ̽ͪͳͶ**ΒͪͼͺͲͳͬͪͪ̈́Ͱͼͽͬͳ;
͵ͪͯͪͼͪͺͽͪͬͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬ;ͷͶͳͽͬ;t̽ͪΒͷͳͳͲͬͻͼ;ͲͪͯͪͷͳΒͰͷͯ;Ͱͬ
ͰͰͳͼͽͽͰ
ͳͯͪͼͰͰ;ͯͪΓͳͷͯ͋ͬΒͰͷͳͶͼͽͳ;ͼͽͻͪͪͳͭͻͲͳͪΒ
ͯͪíͼͽͷ͵ͻ;ͭ;ͼͬͪͽͪΔͪm;ͽͬͻͰͷͰͪͻͳͽͼͫͰͷͲͪͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳ͵;
̸ͽͼͪmͷͱͰͼͰ
ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͺͻͳͺͳͼͪͽͳ̽ͪͳͶͬͼͬͰͯͰΔͰͯ;ͬͳͷͳͷͪ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͳͷ͊ΔͳͷͪΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͬͯͳͺͻͰͺͳͼ͵;
ͪΒͰͯͪͯΔͳ
ͺͳͷͰ;̻ͪ
Ͷͪ͵ͽͳ
ͫͳΒͰͪ͵ͳͲ͠ͻ͈ͯͪͪͻͳͷͪΒ;ΕͳͯΔͳͰͺͳͽͳͷͳΒ;
t͵Ͷͳ͵ͺͻͳͺͪ
ͯͪͲͪΔͰͭͬͰͭͻͰͰi
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳΒͰ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪͰͼͪͷͬͻͶͳ;ͺ͵ͪΒͪΔͪͬͰΕ
ͳͺͼͶ;ͼͽͳm͵ΒͪͲͪ;ͲͳͷͪͭͶͪͬͷͰͼͽ;ͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳͳ̈́ͰͼͽͬͳͰ
̸ͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵ΒͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ
;ͪΒ;ͱͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ͻͰͳ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͳͲͪͺͬͰͼͽ͵ͻͪΓͪ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪͺͼͷͻͽΒͼ;ͯͫͳͳΔͰͭͬͭͽͰͶͪ
͵ΒͪͲͪͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͳͷͪ͵Γ;
ͳͲͪͪΒ̿ͳͬͽͺͳͼͪͽͷͰ͵ͪͱͰͼͶͰͯͰΕͰt̀ͪͺͬͰͯͳΒͰ;ͱͳͬͽ;ͼͬͷͰ
ͳͼͪͼͽͻͪͷ͵ͶͰͽͬͷͳͲͻͰ͵ͪΒͰͭͬͻͰΕͳͪ͵ͼͰΒͪͬͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͪͫͶͪͭͯͪͽ̹ͱ
ΒͪͪΔͰͷ;ͯͪͰͳͲͼͰͽͰͶͪΔͰͭͬͪͯͺͻͪΔͪͬͰͲͰͷΓͰi
ͪͪ͵ͻͪΒ;ͯͯͪΒͰ
t͋ͪ͵ΒͰͳͫͳͶi͋ͪΒͳͼ͵ͪͲͬͳͰͺ;ͽͪΒͰ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͼͪͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͺͶͳ
ͽͳ͵Ͱͼͬͻͼͳͼͯͼͽͳ
ͪͶͳͳΒͰͯͫͳͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͰ
ͳͻͰͽ;ͷͪͰΔͰ͉Ͱ
ΒͰͬͪͱͷͽͺͼ;ͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͽͪͬͳͰͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͷ
ͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪͰͺͼͻͰͯ
ͯͻͪͱͪͬͪΒͰͯͯΔΒͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͳͺͳͷͪΔͪͼͷͻͽͳͯ͠ͻͪͳͻͳΕͪ
ͼ͵ͳͬͻͰͷͰͪͼͷͻͽͼͰm͵ͪͳͳͽͪͬͱͳͬͽmͯͰͿͳͳͰ͵ͪͫͻͫͪ
¢gÝn
ͪͶͳ
ͼͰ;ΔͰͷͽ;ͷͪͰΔ;ͪͺͻͰͯΒͪͬΓͪΒ;ͯͬͪͺͻͰͪͼͬͪͽͪΔ͈ͪͻͰͷͪΒͰͯͷ
ͼͷͻͽΒͰͼͶͫΌͰΔͰͳ͵ͪͪͺͫͰͯͪ
ͯ͵ΒͰͺͻͰͷͪͯͻ;ͭͷ ¢gÝn
ͯͼͶͬ
ͪͭͳΒͪmͽͰ͵ͪͳͺͪͼͪͫͻͫͪ
ͪͻͳͽͷ;ͪ;ͽͻͰ;ͽ͵;USBOTJUVTͪ
͵ͪ
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
ͯͪͼͰͯ;ͪͼ;ͼͻͰΕͰͼͬͪͲͯ;ͳͷͷͳͽͪͻͼͽͬͳͷͪ͋ͪͼ;ͺͻͽͼͽͪͬΓͰͪͼͬͪͽͪΔͪ
ͼͷͻͽͳͳͷͪͶͪͼ;ͳͬͰͷͪͬͪͱͰͺͻͪ͵ͽͳͰͺͼͶͰͯͳͰ͈ͻͬ
ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳ
ͲͪͼͬͪͪͬͰͻͳ;ͫͭͽͬͻͰΔͰͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͰ
ͺͯͼͽͪ͵ͶΒͰͽͬͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ
ͼ͵ͳͷͽͳΒ;̈́ͭͳͪ͵ͼͰ͵ͬͰͪͯͻ;ͭͭ
ͺ͵ΒͰͷͼͰͽͰͶͼͷͪͽͻͪͭͻͰͳͷ
ͳͳͲͬͻͷͽͻͪΒͰͺͪͽΔͰ
ͫͳΒͰͽͺͻͺͻͰͷͪ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͌ͽͷͺͭͶͰ
ͯ; ͪΒͰ͵ͼͽͻͰͷͳΒͪ ͭͶͰͯͳͽͪ ͳ ͺͼͽ;ͺͳ ͺΒͪͬΓͳͬͪͶͳ ͼ; ͼͰ ; ͪΒͼͽͻͱͳͷ
ͷͪ͵ͳͷͼͻͰͯͳͪͷͪ͋ͪ͵̈́Ͱͼͽͬͳͳ͵
ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;Εͳͪͳ;ͱͳͬͽͪ;
ͲͪͷͰͳͽͷͺ͵ͪΒͳ͵ͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͋ͪͷͳͳ Fylak²
͵ͻͪΒ̓ͪͺͰ
͵ͪͱͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭ
ͯͪͫͳtͪΒ͵ΒͳͼͰͽͳͯͪͷ;ͼͰͫͶͳͱͳ͵ͻͪΒͺͻͰ͵ͪͼͽΒͪͽͰ
ΓͪͷͶͳͳͲͪ͵ͶͳΔͪͬͰͶͳ͵ͭͪͬ;ͯͪͭͪͰ;ͯͼͽΒͳΓ;ͯͼ͵ͭͭͻͫͪ
ͬͰΕͯͪͭͪ
͵ͪͷͻͳ;ͫͪͳ;ͻͰ͵;ͳͶͳ;ͺΓͰͲͬͰͻͳͷͪi͈ͻͪͬͳͼͷͳͼͪͽͪ͵ͬͭͼͽͪͬͪ
mͪͺͻͬͳͺͭͶͰͯͰͼͺΒͳͬͭͼͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͫͳͪΒͳͷͪͳ;ͰΔͳͷͪͽͪͪ
mͷͱͰͼͰͻͪͲ;ͷͰͽͳͼͪͷͪ͵ͼͰͳͷͪ;ͬͳͯ;ͪͽͳͷͳΒͼ͵ͳͳͺͪͻͪͯ͵ͼͪͶͪ
ͪͳͷͳΓͰΔͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͳͼͽͷͫͭͼͶͬΓ;͊ͽͭͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͪ
ͺ͵ͪΒͳ͵ͪ͋ͪͷͳͰͳͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪͼͰͯͳͼͽͪ͵ͪͻͪͯͳ͵ͪͶͪmͪͶͳͺͼͺͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶ
ͼͽͳ͇ͪΒͰͺͽͬͻͯͪͪΒͬͰΕͰͷͰͻͰͼͪͷͯͻͳͪΔͪͳͼͬΒͰͭͼͪͬͻͰͼͽͬͪ
Ͷͳͼͽͳ͊ͶͳͰͺͻͰͯͼͷͻͽͰͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͳͳͲͻͳͪͶͳͼ;
ͼͽͭͪ
ͳͯͻ;ͭͳͲͪͷͰ
ͳͽͳͺͯͬͳͱͳͳ͊ͬͰͽͳ̈́;͵ͪͳͲ͊ͽͳͻͳͼͪͪͶͱͳΒͰͯͪͭͪ
ͬͰͲͪͭ;ͱͰͽͷ
ͫͪͰ;ͺͻͬͪͶͳΒ;͵ͪͻͪ;ͲͬͰͻͬͳͷͪ́ͼͽͳͽͺͼͺͪͬΓͪͼͬͰͽͳ̸ͪͼͽͪ
ͼͳΒͰͼͅͰͽͰͻͪ
ͪ;ͻ;ͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͰͻͳͭͬͼ͵ͳͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽ̓ͼͽͪͽͳ
͆ͪͰͶΒͰͯͪ͵ͼͽͪͬͷͭͪΒͰͳͷͪͽͳͳͫͶͪͱ;Ϳͻͷ;
͵ΒͪͼͶͰͯͳͫͻͪͲͪͳͲ
̿ͳͽͳΒͪͼͬͰͽ̸ͭͽͳΒͪ͊Ͷͪͬͳͺ;ͼͽͳΔͪ͵ͪͶͱͳΒͰͺͻͰͯͼͷͻͽ;Ͱͳͳ
ͷͪͯͪͭͪͼͪͻͪͰͽͪΒ;ͺͶͪͳͳ
ͪͯͪͷ;ͭͻͫͰͽͬͪͻͪΒ;͊Ͷͳ;ͱͰΓ;
34UJDIFM
4UVEJFO[VN7FSIÅMUOJTWPO5FYUVOE#JME4QÅUVOEOBDICZ[BOUJOJTDIFS7FSHÅOHMJ
DILFJUTEBSTUFMMVOHFO
8JFO
m ͼ ͪͬͰͯͰͳͷ ͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
͋ͰͶ͵Ͱ ͳ ͯͭͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͬͰ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͽͰͷͰΓΒͰͻͪͲͷͽͻͳͶͪ/)FSSNBOO.BTDBSE
-FT
SFMJRVFTEFTTBJOUT
DGͽͪ͵ΌͰ"OHFOFOEU
)FJMJHFVOE3FMJRVJFO ͼͪͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
̈́Ͱͼͽͬͳͪ
ͬͪ̀͠Ͷͪͽ;ͼͽͳ
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰͫͪͬͰͲͪͺͭͻͰͫͪΓ;ͯͼ͵ͳͲͪ͵͵ΒͰͭͼͰͺͻͳͯͻͱͪ
ͬͪΒ;ͪ͵ͳͯͳͬΓͳͬͪͻͬͪͻͳ1(5-9*
̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
͊ͬͰͽͳͬͪ̈́͠Ͱͼͽͬͳͳ͵
4UJDIFM
PQDJU
$-BOE83$POOPS
ѮF -JGF BOE .JSBDMFT PG 4U -VLF PG 4UFJSJT 5FYU
5SBOTMBUJPO BOE $PN
NFOUBSZ
#SPPLMJOF
.BTTBDIVTFUUT
m ͵ͻͳͽͳ͵ͳͲͯͪΔͰͽͰ͵ͼͽͪͼͺͻͰͬͯͷ
/JDPM
PQDJU
̸͎͊ͻͰͬ
͈ͶͳͽͳͰͼ͵ͪΊͳͼͽͻͳΊͻ;ͼͼ͵ʹ͵ͪͳͲͪͳͳ mͬͬ
ͅͼ͵ͬͪ
1(5997*
mͳͼͽͼͬͰͯͰΔͰJO7FSTJP&WBHSJJ
MPDDJU
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼͪͺͽͳΒͰ;ΒͰͯΒͯͼͬΒͳͪͺͿͽͰͭͷͳΔͰͭͬͼͶͰͯͫͰͳ͵̸ͪͬͪͻͼͰͳΒͰ͌
ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͯͪͷ;ͼͰͽͰͶͰͺͯͳͱͰͳͲͻͰ͵ͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯ͵ͻͪΓͪ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
ΒͳͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ͠ͰͿͻͰͷ
;ͬͪͱͰͳͪͼ͵Ͱͽͪ
ͪͽͪ͵ͬ;ͱͰΓ;ͫͻͪͲͶ
ͱͳΒͰ;ͭͶͰͯͪΔͰͷͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͼͬͰͽ̸ͭͽͳΒ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭ
́ͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵ͪͳΒͪͽͺͼͪ;̿ͳͽͳΒ;͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪͼͪͷΒͰΒͰͯͪ
Ͷͪ͵ͳ
ͯͰͪͰͭͲͪͯͪͽ͵ͪͭͅΒͰͼͶͱͰͳΒͰͺͳͽͪΔͰΔͳͬͭͺͻͰ͵Ͷͪ
ͪͪͻͳͽ
ͻͪͲͶͭͪͳ͵ͻͪΒΔͰͼͬͻͰͲͫͭ͵Βͳͼ;;ͺͽͻͰͫΓͰͳͲͪͺͳͼͳͬͪΔͰ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͱͳ
ͬͽ͈ͪͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͻͪͲͷͳΓͪΔͪͺͻͬͷͺͳͽͪΔ;ͽͻͰͫͪ;ͲͰͽͳ;ͫͲͳͻͺΒͪͬ;ͳ
;ͰͼͽͪͶͼͽͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵ͳͫͻͪͲͪͪ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͱͳͽͳΒΒ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳmͳͽͳ
ͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͳͳͲͶͱͰͳ
ͽͪ͵ͯͪͽͬͻͰͰͶͬͳͽ;ͼͶͳ͵;ͷͪ͵ͭͺͯͬͳͭͪ
͆ͪͽͪΒͪͳ;ͺͽͻͰͫΓͰͳ
ͳͼͰΒͪͼͺͻͰͺͲͪΒ;;ͯͰͶ;̽ͪͳͶͪ**͈ΒͪͬΓ;
Β;ͼͰ;̿ͳͽͳΒ;͵ͻͪΓͳͰ͠ͰͶͰͰ
ͪͶͳͼ;ΒͯͼͶͰͯͳΒͰͳͲͶͱͰͳ
ͼͪͳͻͳͷ
ͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻͷͷͽͳͬͪ
;̿ͳͽͳΒ;͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳ͇ͪͫͻͪͼͰͳͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪ
ͳͼͽͭͺͻͰ͵Ͷͪ͵ͻͳͼͽͳͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ͢Ͱͭͬ̿ͳͽͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
ͯͪͬΒͰ
ͺ͵ͪͲͪ
ͯ;ͫ͵ΒͰͺͻͱͰͽͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵ͳͷͳͯͰͪͶͷ
ͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͪͻͳͽ;ͽͳͪΒ
ͳͷͪͶ;ͰΔͰ̈́ͰͼͽͬͳͰ͋ͪΒͳͯͰͪͶͯͫͳΒͰͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͳͲͻͪͲ;͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͬͷ
̿ͳͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽ͈ͭͰͽͻͪ̓ͻͳ͵ͭ
;ͰͶͼͽͳͭͻͪΌͰͷͺͻͰͷͪͯͪͫͻͪͳͷͷ
ͯͰͶͳͷͪͪΒͱͰΕͰͭͺ;ͼͽͳͱͳͽͰΓͼͽ͉ͬͪͰΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͪͼͽͪͶͳͷ
;ͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͷͬͻͰͷͰͼ͵ͷͻͪͲͷͪ͵;͊ͪͳͳͶͳͼ;ͳͺͳͼͳ͵Βͳͼ;ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͶͳ
ͳͼͽͷ ͯ;ͬͷ ͺͯͰͫΓ; m ͼͬͰͽͭͻͼ͵Β ͼͻͰͯͳͳ ͳͲ ͺͻͬͳ ͯͰͰͳΒͪ 9*7
ͬͰ͵ͪ
;͵ΒΒͼͰ;ͺͻͪͬͽͪͯͪ
ͪͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͪͷͪͳͲͬͻͰͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳ͵Ͱͳͷͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͼͽͬͪ
ͻͪΒ;ͲͪͷͰͳͺͪͶͪͷͳͽͼ͵ͭͫͭͼͶͬΓͪ
͊ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;Εͳ̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
̽ͪͳͶ**ͽͰͱͳΒͰͯͪͼͽͬͻͳ
Ͷͳ͵͵ΒͳΕͰͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͫͳͽͳͼͪͫͻͪͱͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͳͷͪ͵ͷͳͯͰͪͶ;
͊ͽͭͪͼͰͷͱͰͺͷͳΓͪͽͳͯͪͼ;ͷ;
ͼͳͷͬͰΕͺͷͳΔͪͳ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͳͼͪͼͽͪ
ͬͪ
͵ͪ;ͲͻͷͭͶͳͺͼͶ;ͱͳͽͳͳͰ͵ͳͺͼͰͫͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͳ͵Βͳͼ;ͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͶͳ
1(5-97
͚ ͋ͻͳͿ;ͬͳΕ
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ ͼͬͰͽͭ ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪ ͠ͰͿͻͰͷͪ ͯ Ͱͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ ͪͅͻ͵ͪ
̸ͪͶͳ
͍ͳͶͶ͵ͭͿͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽͪ
m
̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
͊ͬͰͽͳͬͪ̈́͠Ͱͼͽͬͳͳ͵
m
͋ ͬͪͬ͠ͳΕ
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ ͈Ͱͽͻͪ ̓ͻͳ͵ͭ
̓ΔͳͱͰͬͪ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͪ 9**
m
ͺͻͰͬͯ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
̿ͳͽͳΒͪ
̿ͳͽͳΒͰͼͬͰͽ͈ͭͰͽͻͪ̓ͻͳ͵ͭ
FE̹̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
mDG%1PQPWJǀ
PQDJU̺ͳͽͳΕ͆ͰͯͰΓ͵ͬͳΕ
PQDJU
̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
͆ͬͰͽͰͱΔͰ;ͼͻͺͼ͵Β͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳ
mJEFN
́ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ͳQBTTJN
͋ͻͳͿ;ͬͳΕ
͈ͻͲͪͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ̽ͪͳͶͪ**
m̽̓ͪͶͰͲͳΕ
̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺ̽ͪͳͶ**ͳ
ͺͳͽͪΔͰΔͰͭͬͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΔͪͳͼͳͪͲͷ;
JO̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺ̽ͪͳͶ**ͳΔͰͭͬͯͫͪ
m
̀ͪͺͽͰ͵ͬͳͻͰDG+.FZFOEPSĒ
#Z[BOUJOF)FTZDIBTNIJTUPSJDBM
UIFPMPHJDBMBOETPDJBMQSPC
MFNT$PMMFDUFE4UVEJFT
-POEPO
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͽͲͪͳͯͪͼ;ͼͰͪͼͬͯͳͶͪͪͻͰͽͻͳ͵;Ϳͳͭ;ͻ;͇ͯͳ͵ΒͰͼͷͬͰΕͪ
ͬͰͶͳͯͬͪͼ;ͬͰͷͪ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳͪ͌ͺͻ͵ͼͳͲͻͳͳͽΒͲͪͫͻͪͳ
ͽͰͶͼͬͰͽͭ
̈́;͵ͰͳͲ͊ͽͳͻͳͼͪͰͼͪͷͽΒͰtͺͯͳͭ;ͽiͳͲͭͻͫͪͬͰΕͼͰ͵ΔͰͭͪͫͻͪ
Ͳͬͪͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͳ͵ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ
ΒͰͯͯͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͳ͵;Ͷͽͳ
ͼͻͰͯͳͽͪ ͽͪͯͪΔͰͭ ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͭ ͼͬͰͽͪ ͉Ͱͳͽ ΒͰ ͳ ͺͻͳͷͰͻ Ͱͻͳͭͬͼ͵ͭ
ͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͪ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͪ
ͳΒͰΒͰͽͰͶ
;ͼ͵ͪͶͯ;ͼͪͲͪͺͬͰΕ;
ͯͳͼͽͪͳͲ
Ͱͽ ͳͲ ͭͻͪͯͪ ͳ ͯͫͪͰ
ͯͪ ͫͳ ͯͷͪ Ͳͪͽͳͷ
Ͳͫͭ ͽͻͰ;ͽͳ ͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳ
ͺͽͻͰͫͪ
ͫͳͶtͺͻͪΌͰiͳͺͻͭͶͪͰͼͬͰͽͳͷ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ
ͽͺͳͳͻͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪ;ͬͰ͵ͳͷͪͽͳͪ;ͷ;ΔͰ;ͼͬ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;t͇ͺͽͰͷͰͼͽ
ΒͰ;ͼͶͬͳͳͲͻͪͲ
Ͳͪ͵͵ΒͳͷͼͰͷͭ;ΕͪͬͪͺͽͰΔͰͳΒͰͫͪͪͶͼͽ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͪͼ͊ͳͼͽͰͷͽͳͲͪ͵ͬͪͳͿͻ;ΒͰ
ͪͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͯͰͳͿͻ;ΒͰΒͰͯͪͷͳͼͪͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳ
ͳͼͽͽͪ͵
;ͼͶͬΓͪͬͪΒͰͯͰͷͳͪͶͼͽͪΔͰi͌ͪͼͽΒͪΔ;ͯͪ
tͯͰͳͿͻ;ΒͰͷiͼͷͳͼͪͽͺͼͪ͵ΒͰͷΒͰͻͰͻͪͲͷͽͻͳΕͰͷͳͯͻ;ͭͳͳͲͬͻ
ͬͪͱͪͲͪͪͺͻͫͶͰͷ͋ͼ;ͺͯͪͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͷͭͻͫ;
ͽͪͳΒͰͼͽͪͽ;ͼ;ΔͰ
ͭͬͭͽͰͶͪ͵ͪͫΒͰ͵ͽͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ
̓ͻͪΓ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͼͪͻͪΔͰΒͰ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͚;ͻΌͰͬͳͷͼͽ;ͺͬͳͷͪ;͉ͪͼ;
Ͳͪ
ͯ;ͱͫͳͳͼͬͭͼͶͪͬͭͺͻͪͯͰͯͰ
ͳΒͳΒͰͯͻ;ͭͳ͵ͽͳͽͻͳͼͪͷͫͳ͋;ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
ͼͬͰͯͰΔ;̽ͪͳͶͪ**
ΔͰͭͬͽͰͶͺͻͰͰͽtͯͼͻͰͷͼ͵ͰͲͰͷΓͰi
ͪͼͷͳͼͪͽͪ
͵ͬͰ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͰͯͶ;͵Ͱ;ͪ;ͳΒͰͬͰΕͯͫͳͳͻͰͽ;ͷͪͰΔͰ͠ͰͯͷͻͪͳΒͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͳͲͰͶͳͼͷͻͪͲͶͭͰͲͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵;ͯͪͼͰ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͻͫͺͻͬͫͳͽ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽͳΒͰͪͶͪͲͳ;ͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͰͽ͚ͭͻΌͪͰͭ;͵ͪͺͰͶͳ;ͶͪͲͰ͵;ͶͰ́Ͳ
ͬͰͼΒͰͯͪͼͰͼͪͼͽΒͪͯͺͯͲͰͷͰͭͻͫͳͰͫͰͶͰͱͰͰͷͰͻͷͰͻͳͷͼͪͻ
͵Ϳͪͭͷ
ͯ͵ΒͰͭͼ;ͯͯͪͪͼͼͪ;ͬͪͳͼͪͷͿͻͪͭͷͰͽͳͺͼͽΓ͈ͪͻͰͷͪ
ͳͲͻͳͳͽͷ
ͬͰΕͪͬͰͯͰͷͽͬͻΌͰΔ;̽ͪͳͶͪ**
ͽͰͶͳͲͭͻͫͪͳΒͰͺͯͳͲͪ
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
͋ͲͪͳͯͪͳΒͰͯͶͯΔͰͭͬͭͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪͳͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͪ;͵ͳͬͽ;
ͽΒͰ
ͲͪͬͻͳͳͳͺͽͬͻͯͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪͰ͵ͰͶͳͼͽͳ͉Ͱͽ͵ͳͻͪͼͺͶͱͳͬͳ
ͳͲͬͻͳͳͲͪͻͰͯͳͼͽͶͰΕͪͰͺͬͻͭͪͬͪΒ;̽ͪͳͶͬͳͼ͵ͪͲ
ͪͶͳͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰ
;ͺ;Ε;Β;ͪͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵ͯͪΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͻͫͫͳͬͰͷͪͺͽͬͪ͆ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͰ
ͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͶͪͲͳͼͰ;͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳ͵ͻͪΓ;ͅͳͶ;ͽͳ;̽ͪͳͶ̹ͪͪΔͼ͵ͭͳͲ͵
ͭͯͳͰ
͵ΒͪͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪͳ͵ͻͪΓͳ;ͷͪΒ͵;͠ͰͶͰ
;͊ͽͳͬͳͯͰͬͰͽͰͺͰͼͷͰmt͎ͻͳͼͽͬͪͻ͵ͬͪͼͬͰͽͶͺͻͪͲ;ΒͰ
ͼͬͰͽͰͷͽͳͬͪ
Ͱ͵ͪͷͭͰ;ͻͳͲͳ;imͷͭͶͳͫͳ
ͪͺͻͬͳͺͭͶͰͯ
ͬͯͳͽͳͲͪ͵Γ;͵;
ͯͪΒͰ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͼͷͪͽͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰͷͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳͲͻͪͲtͼͬͰͽͰͷͽͳi̽ͪͳͶ
̹ͪΔͼ͵ͳ͵ͻͳͼͽͳͪͽͪΒͪͳͼͪͷΒͰͯͪͺ;ͽ
ͳͽ;ͷͱͳͳ
͵ͪͯͪͭͬͻͳ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪtͳͼͽͳͷͰͰΒͰͯͪͻͪͬͰͫͻͪΕͰi̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͰͷͽͳͺͪͼͫ
ͰͺͷͳΔͰ
ͲͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯͅͳͶ;ͽͳͬͳ
͵ΒͰͯͻͰΌ;ΒͰͺͷΕ;ͺͻͺͳͼͪͳ
ͺͽͳͷͰͼͽͪΔͰͭͬͪtͼͬͰͽͪͭͻͫͳͪiͳͲͬͻΒͰtͰͬͰͽͪͼͽͬͰͳͪͻͷͪͽͪi
tͺͻͳͼͱͳͬͽͭͫͶͪͭ;ͪΔͪiͳtͺͽ͵ͪͳͼͰΓͰΔͪi͇ͼͳͷͽͭͪ
ͽͪΒͳͼ͵ͪͲ
ͷͻͪͼͰͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ;ͳͻͰͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰͳΔͰͰͼͬͰͳͯͰΒͰ
ͪͽΒͰ
͵ͽͳ;ͳͽͰͽͼͬͰͽͻͯͰͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ͊ͽͭͪͼͰͳ͵ͪ͵Ͱͫͳͷ
ͭͪͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͺͽͬͻͯͷͯͪΒͰ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͽͰͶͯͳͼͽͪͳͷͪͶͼͽͪͽ;ͼͼͬͰͽͳ
ͷͽͳΒ;͆ͪͼͶͳͪͪͳͽͻͰͫͪͽ;ͷͪͳͽͳͳͺͲͪͽͺͳͼͷͷͪͪ̽ͪͷΒͪͪ
ͳ͈ͪͬͶͪͳͲͭͯͳͰͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;ΕͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͷͪ͵ΒͰͼ;ͬͳͯͰͶͳ;͚;ͻΌͰ
ͬͳͷͼͽ;ͺͬͳͷͪ
ͳͺͷͳΔ;ͳtͼͬͰͽͽͰͶ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪi͈ͼͶͰͯΔͳͳͲ
ͬͻͪͼͽͪͺͻͰ͵ͻͪΒͪ97**ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;͚;ͻΌͰͬͳͼͽ;ͺͬͳͽͰ͵ͺͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ
;ͪ;ͼͽͻͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳͷͻͪͽͬͳͷͪ
;ΒͰͯΒͰͳͪΒͺͻͰͳͲͳΒͳ͆ͳ͵Ͷ̹ͪ͵ͬͳΕ
ͼͰΕͪͼͰͯͪΒͰ;ͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͰͽ͚ͭͻΌͪͬͳͯͰtMBTFQPMUVSBEFM3F%SBHVUJOPwGBUUB
EJVOêOJTTJNP NBSNP EJ EJWFSTJ DPMPSJi͋ͽͬͻΌͰΔͰ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷΒͰͳͭͶͰͯ
ͯ
ͼͳͼͰͪͷͰͻͷͰͻͳͪͯͭͻͫͳͼͺͷͰͳ͵
ͪͰͪ͵ͳͬͽͼͷͽͳͷ̸ͪ͵ͼͰ
;ͺͻͰͯͰͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͷͭͻͫ;͵ΒͪͺͻͰͽͯͰͳͼͶͰͯͰͻͪͲͪͻͪΔ;
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͚;ͻΌͰͬͳͼͽ;ͺͬͪ
ͺͻͳͲͶͪͲͳͯͪͼ;͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͺͼͷͻͽͳͼͽͪͳͺͯͰͶͳͶͳͼ;ͯ
ͫͳ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ̹ͪͳΕͰͯͪΒͰͳͼͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͯͰͬͪͼͽͳͻͪͳ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͭͻͫ
ͪΔͰͭͬͽͰͶ
ͽͪͳΒͰͼ͵ͰͶͰͽͳͼͽͪͳmͼͪ͵;ͺΓͰͳͼ;ͳͼͺͪͼͰͳ
͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͽͰ͵ͯ97***ͬͰ͵ͪΔͳͷͪͼͰͬͳͰͰͭͬͻͳͪ;ͺ
ͽͰͪͳ
ͬͰΕͪͼͪͼͬͳͷͯͻͰΌͰ͋ͪ͵ͪͬΒͰͺͲͪͽͳͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͳͲͭͶͰͯ;̽ͻͪ
ͭ;ͽͳͬͭͽͰͶͪͳͲ͋ͻ͵ͭͻͯͼͶͬͪ
͵ΒͳKF
ͬͪͱΒͰͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳ
ͫͰͶͰ͵ͪ
Ͱͬͳͪbist2 je vsqm2 stra\an2 veliko m$jestven2 i silen2 tqlom2 i krqpok2 do
³qla, egoje i kosti ego svidetelstvova\a, eje m`i isti vidqhom2́Ͳͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͼͶͰͯͳͯͪΒͰͯͼͻͰͯͳͰ97***ͬͰ͵ͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͰͶͰͽͫͳ;ͰͶͳͳͼͪ;ͬͪ͌Ͱ
͵ͺͲͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͻͪͼͺͪͻͪͳͼͽͰ͵ͪΒͰͬͳͰͬͶͪͼͳ͵ͪ͌ͽͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;ͬͰͷͪΒͰͲͪͪΒͺͻͰͯͪΔͰm͵ΒͰ;ͯͻ;ͭΒͺͶͬͳͳ9*9ͬͰ͵ͪͫͰͶͰͱͳ
̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪͯͪͻ̻ͳΓͿͰͻͯͳͭmͽͷͰͯͪΒͰͰ͵ͳ͆ͬͺͪͲͪͻͪͺͳͷͰ;̀ͫͳΕ
ͷͽͳͺΓͪ͵ͪ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷ;ͯͰͶͬͳͷͪͺͻͯͪͬͪ
ͲͫͭͰͭͪΒͰΔͰͭͬͻͯͼ;
ͼͽͳͭͶͺͻ͵ͶͰͽͼͽͬ̽ͪͽͺͻͰͯͪΔͰͳͷͪ;ͺͻͳͽͪ;ͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͳ
ͺͽͬͻΌ;Β;
ͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͪ
ͷͪͯͪ;ͭͶͪͬͷͰͺ;ͲͯͪͪͼͬͰͯͰΔͪͯͪΓΒͼ;ͯͫͳͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳ
ͺͼͷͻͽͳͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪͪͅͶΒͰͬͰͻͬͪͽͯͪΒͰͯͰ͵ͼͽͳΒ;ͺͻͰͼͽͪ;͚;ͻΌͰ
ͬͳͷͼͽ;ͺͬͳͷͪͼͬͰͯͬͻͰͷͰ̻ͪͳΓͿͰͻͯͳͭͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͲͪͺͳͼͪͯͪͼͰ;ͻ͵ͬͳ
ͯͰͼͯͬͻͪͽͪ
ͪͶͪͲͳtͭͻͫͳͪͼͪͷͽͳͷͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪi̺Ͱͻͬͪͽ
ͳΒͰΒͰͯͪΒͰͻ;ͼ͵ͳͺ;ͽͺͳͼͪͲͪͽͰ͵ͪͼͪͷͺͻͪͲͪͭͻͫ
ͪͶͳͳͱͳͬͼͰΕͪΔͰ
ͪͶͳͼͽ͵ΒΒΒͰͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ͊ͬͳͰͼͳͭ;ͻͼͽͳ͵ͻͪΓ;ͼͰͷͱͰͺͻͳͺͳͼͪͽͳ
ͻ;͵ͪͳͲͯͰͪͼ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰ
͵ΒͪͼͰ;ͬͪ;ͼͻͰͫͻͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;ͯͪͽͬͪͷ;
ͺͻͬ;ͺͶͬͳ;9*9ͬͰ͵ͪ͌ͻͰͲͪͪͽͺͳͼͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵;ΒͰͼͬͰͽͳΔ;͵ͪs`a yastÿca
r$ka prepodobnogo w(t)ca n(a)\ego Ïeokti§ta s2rbskago Nemanifla̽ͻ;ͭͳͺͯͪͳ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͷͺͼͷͻͽͳͷͼͽͪͳͷͪmͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͪΒ͵ΒͳͼͰͯͼͳͪͷͽͳ;
ͪͪͼ͵Βͻ͵ͬͳmͼͪͼͬͳͷͼ;Ͱͼͳͭ;ͻͳͳͪΒͰΕͰͼ;ͺͶͯͲͪͫ;ͪͳͶͳͶͰͭͰ
ͯͳ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͺͻͰͯͪΔͰͷͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͽͻͰͫͪͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͷͳͻͽͳͬͼͽͳ
͘ ͑ͪͿͪͻͳ͵·
͊ͻͫͼ͵ͳʹ ͶͰͽͺͳͼͪ· ͳͲ· ͺͰͽ͵ͪ ͭ ͼͽͶͰͽͳΊ
̻Ͷͪͼͳ͵· ̽ͻ;ͽͬͪ
ͼͻͫͼ͵ͰͼͶͬͰͼͼͽͳ
ͼͬ
;ͬͰͻΓͳͬͼͽͬͭͼͬͰͯͰΔͪͰͫͳͽͻͰͫͪͶͯͬͰͼͽͳ;
ͺͳͽͪΔͰ
;ͺͻ͵ͼͼͶͪͫΒͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽͳ͋ͻ͵ͭͻͯͼͶͬͪ͵ͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͭͳͲͬͻͪ
DG
͉͆ͪͯΒͳΕ
͇͋ͻ͵ͷͻͯͼͶͬ;
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̸ ͍ ̻ͳΓͿͰͻͯͳͭ
͈;ͽͬͪΔͰ ͺ ͎ͰͻͰͭͬͳͳ
̹ͼͳ ͳ ͊ͽͪͻΒ ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͊ͪͻͪΒͰͬ
*CJE
m
͑ͪͅ͵ͽͪ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͪͻͳͲͳͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯm͈ͻͳͽͳͪ
ͼͶͪͼͽͻ ͼͫͳͫͶͳ
ͭͻͪͿͳΒͷ
͋Ͱͺͯͪͽ͵ͰͼͪͫͻͪΒͰ͈̈́ͪͬͶͬͳΕ
̓;ͶͽͬͳͶͳͪ
m
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͳͷͽͳΒ;͵ΒͳͼͰͼͻͰΕͰͪΒͺͻͰ;ͅͼ͵ͬͼ͵ͷ͊ͻͫΓͪ͵;
ͪͲͪͽͳͷ
ͳ;ͻ;͵ͺͳͼͷ̀ͫͻͳ͵;ͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͪͅͳͪͳͶ͇ͪͼͬͰͯͳͽͷͰͯͪ
ΒͰt͵;Ͷͽi͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪͯͫͳͬͺͯͼͽͳͪΒ;ͯͻ;ͭΒͺͶͬͳͳ97***ͳ;
9*9ͬͰ͵;mͽΒͰͺͼͰͫͪͺͻͫͶͰͷ
ͬͻͰͯͪͯͪΓͰͭͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪ
͈ͼͷͻͽͳͼͽͪͽ;ͼ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ;ͱΒͰͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳ͵ͪ͵;ͼͬͰͽͶͼͽͳ
ͳͲͶͱͰͳͳΔͰͳͪͽͪ͵ͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͺͽͳͪͰͶͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻ
ͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ͌ͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵Βͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͰͶͬͳͽͷͯͰͶ͵;Ͷͽͪͫ;ͬͪͽͪΒͰ
Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵ͰͶͰͷͰͪͽͪͪͺͻͬͷͷͰͼͽ;
ͪͭͳͶ͵Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͰͼͪͼͽͪͬͰ
ͳΒͪ
ΒͰͿ;͵ͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͻͳͽ;ͪͶͪͲͪͽͳͷ
ͬͳͲ;ͰͶͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͰͶͰͷͰͽ
͵Βͳ
ΒͰͽͰͶͽͬͻͰ;ͳ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͽͻͰΕͳ
ͯͼͶͬ͵ͻͺͻͪͶͪ
ͯͼͳͼͰ
ͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵Ͱͷͽͳ͵ΒͰͼͰͳͲͶͪͱ;ͬͳΌͰΔ;ͳͯͯͳͻ;͈ͼͶͰͯΔͳͳͳͶͪ
ΒͰͬͪͱͪͲͫͭͽͭͪͽͪͺͼͽͻͪ͵ͽͳͺΒͪͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪͺͻͰͬͯͳ;ͽͰͶͰͼͳͳ
ͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͳͫΒͰ͵ͽͽͬͪΔͪmͽΒͰͫͳͽͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͪͺͫ
ͱͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰ̓ͪͯͪͼͰͽͪͺͽͪͪͰͶͪͺͻͳͷͰͰͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
ͺͻͳͲͶͪͲͳͼͶͰͯͰΕͰ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳΒͰͯͫͳͱͳͽͳΒͰ
ͪͶͳͰͳͼͬͳͺͻͼͶͪͬͳ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ
ͪͽΒͰͼͶ;ͱͫͪ͢ͰͭͬͶͳ͵ͬͰ͵ͬͰͰΒͰͷͭͫͻΒͳͷͺͻͽͻͰͽͳͷͪ
͵Βͳ͵ͻͪΓͪͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;Β;;ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͶͳ͵ͽͳͽͻͪ
ͼͳͲͷͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ
ͽͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;Β;ͼͶͱͰͰͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳͽͭͬͻͰͷͰͪ́ͺͪ͵
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬtͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬiͳ͵ͪͯͪͳΒͰͺͽͬͻΌͰͳ͵ͷͳͶͳͺͼͬͰͽͷ
ͻ͵ͬͰ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͳͪͳͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͪͬͯͰͲͪ͵Γ;͵;ͯͪͼͰ͵ͻͪΓͰͬ
ͽͰͶͳΒͰͫΒͪͬͳͶ
ͯͼͯͪΒͰͳͲͭͻͫͳͰtͺͯͳͭ;ͽiͪΒͻͪͳΒͰ͵ͻͪ
ΒͰͷ97**ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳͽͼͽͳͪΒͰͷͪͻͳͽͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ͵Ͷͼͽͳ́ͪ͵ΒͰ̽ͻͪ
ͭ;ͽͳͬͭͻͫ;͚;ͻΌͰͬͳͷͼͽ;ͺͬͳͷͪͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ;ͱͳͬͪͬͰͶͳ͵ͺͽͬͪΔͰ
ΔͰͭͬͽͰͶͫͳͶΒͰͶͳͰͬͻ;ͼ͵ͭͼͽͪͽ;ͼͪͳͪͻͳͲͷͪͽͼ͵ͭ
ͫͶͪͭͯͪͽͭ
ͯͰΒͼͽͬͪ ͋ͪ ͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭͳΒͪ
;ͼ͵ͻͪΕͰͪ ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳ;
ͺͻͳͺͪͶͪ ΒͰ ΔͰͭͬͷ ͫͻͪͽ;
tͼͬͰͽͷ͵ͻͪΓ;iͅͳͶ;ͽͳ;͢ͰͭͬͰͫΒͪͬΓͰͰͷͽͳ
tͰͶͰͳͰͽΓͰͰi
ͫͳͶͰ
ͼ;;̹ͪΔͼ͵ΒͳͲͶͱͰͰ;͵ͳͬͽ;ͳͺͳͬͪͶͰͼ;ͪͪͻͳͽͼͬͰͽͷͷͰͼͽ;;
ͻͪͷ;mͺͻͰͯͶͽͪͻ͈ͪͻͰͷͪͪͰͶͳͷͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͼͪͻͪͰ͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ;ͼͻͰͯ
͈ͪͬͶͬͳΕ
̓;Ͷͽͬͳ Ͷͳͪ
m ͊ͬΒͼͽͬͪ ͷͽͳΒ; ͵ͻͪΓͪ ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ ͽ; ͼͰ ͺͳͼ;Β;
ͪ ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͪͳ svet6e ego mo¹i s$hie i zmajlivie mirotoyivie nam2 podal¢ esi wtayastv$
ego blag$hani• i celbi svoim2 lüdem2 newsk$dno podavae
W͈͊ͻͰΕ͵ͬͳΕ
͆Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͪ̀ͫͻͳ͵ͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͪͅͳͪͳͶͪ
͊ͺͷͰͳ͵̸͊̓97
͊ ͉ͪͯΒͳΕ
͈ͻͽͻͰͽͳ ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ ; ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷ ͬͰ͵;
͊͵ͺΓͰ
m
m
ͺͼͶͰͯΔͪ
ͽͰͷͰΓͪ ͪͪͶͳͲͪ ͺͻͽͻͰͽͪ ͳͲ ͬͻͰͷͰͪ ͵ͻͪΓͪ ͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳ ͳ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͰ
; ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ; ͬͻͰͷͰͰ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ ͳ ͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳ ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ ̹
͋ͯͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ;ͯͫͪ͵ͻͪΓͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
m ͼͪͼͬͷ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
ͽͪ͵ͬͻͰͰΔͰͳͷͪͶΒͰͬͻͰͯͼͽͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵Ͱͺͻ;͵ͰΔͳͷͰΒͰ͵ͻͪΓ
ͅͳͶ;ͽͳͼͽͰ͵ͪͪΒͬͳͳ
ͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͯͬͼͽͻ;͵ͳͼͽͪͽ;ͼmͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽΒͳ͵ͳ
̓ͪͯͪͼͰ;Ͳͷ;;ͫͲͳͻͼͬͰͳͲͶͱͰͰͳΔͰͳͰ
ͯͳͼͽͪ;ͬͰͻΓͳͬͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͷͳΓͰΔͰ ͯͪ ΒͰ ͳͽͰͻͺͶͳͻͪͳ ͲͪͬͻͰͽͪ͵ ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͭ ͱͳͽͳΒͪ
͵Βͳͷ ͼͰ
ͲͪͫͻͪΔ;ΒͰͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;ͳͷͪͲͪͳΓͯͪͼͺͻͰͳͫͻͪͲͬͪΔͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ
;ͺ;ͷͫͶͳ͵;
ͯͼͯͪͫͰͲͫͰͯͳͪͼͶͰΌͳͬͪΔͰͅͳͶ;ͽͳͬΒͺͻͯͳ
Βͭͻͪͳ͈ͽ͵ͻͰͺͳͶͳͫͳͭͪͳͯͻ;ͭͳͻͪͲͶͲͳmͯͳͺͽͰͺͻͳͻͯͰ
͵ͪP
ͽΒͰͺͼͬͰͯͰͪ;ͺͽͻͰͫͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͽͳΒ;;ͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͰͼͬͻͰ
ͺͪͯ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷͯͻͰΌͰͳ
͵ΒͳͼͰͯͼͰͪ;;ͽͻͪΔͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͫͰͶͰͱͰ
ͰͫͻͫͷͲͪͪͼͶͰΌͰͺͻͰͼͽͶͪ͋;ΒͰ
ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͳͭͶͪͬͳͻͪͲͶͭmͼͪͷͪͳΔͰͳ
ͪͯͪΒͰͶͲͪͼͬͰͽͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͺͻͯ;ͱͰͪͺͻͰ͵͵ͻͪΓͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪͅͳΓͰΔͰ
ͯͪΒͰͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͻͺͶͪͳΒͰ̽ͪͳͶͬͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͷͭͶͫͳͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͻͰͳ
ͼͺͳͽͪͽͳ͋ͫͳͼͰͷͭͶ;ͳͳͽͳͪΒͺͻͰͼͽͭͪͽΒͰͪ
ͺͼͪͯͻͱͳͳͳ
ͺͻͰ͵Ͷ;ͫͻͪͼͪ
ͰͯͬΒͳͬͪͯͰͶͳͰ
ͽͪͳΒͰͯͽͺͳ͵ͰͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͰͳͲͪͼ͵Ͱͽ
ͼ͵Ͱ ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͰ
ͪ ͵ΒΒ ̽ͪͳͶ ͭͻͪͯͳ ͬͪͱͪ ͯͰ ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͭ ͱͳͽͳΒͪ ͌
ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔ;͆ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͪͽͪͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͪͰ;ͺͻͰͯͳͬΒͰͼͶͪͫͳΒͰͲͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰͪͳ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͼͰͼͪͼͬͳͷ͵ͬͰͳͪͶͳͷͽͺͼͳͷ͇ͪͼͳͷͽͭͪ
ͼͪͷͰͳͼͽͻͳΒ
ͼ͵Ͱ͵Ͷͼͽͳͳͽ͵ͯͭͪΌͪΒͪͰͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;ͯͬΓͼͬͪͲͪͯͪͽͬͪΔͰͳͽͰͻ
ͺͶͪͳΒͰͺͼͶͰͭͯͳͰ͢ͰͰͺͻ;͵Ͱͽͪͯͪͼ;ͬͰΕͳͲͭ;ͫͳͶͰͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͼͽ
ͳͼͬͻ;͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͳͼͻͺΓ;Β;ΕͪͫͻͫͪͲͪͪͼͶͰΌͰͺͻͰͼͽͶͪͳͲͷͰΌ;̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͰ
ͳͅͳͶ;ͽͳͬͰͺͻͯͳͰͭͻͪͰͼͪͼͬͳͷͼͰͺͻͳͷͪ͵Ͷͪ͵ͪͷͻͪͼͺͶͰͽ;ͪ
͵ͼͷͻͽͳ͵ͻͪΓͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪͳ͵ͻ;ͳͼͪΔͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵̹ͭͪͭ
ΒͪͬΓͰΔͰͭͯͳͰ̓ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͺͻͰͼͽͪͶͳͷͺͻͰͽͰͯͰͽͳͷͪm͊ͽͰͿͪͬ
ͺͶ;ͫͻͪͽ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͺͭͳ;ΒͰ;ͳͲ;ΌͰΒͫͳͳ
ͯ͵ͼͰ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͼͳ
̺ͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬ
͵ͪ͵ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
;ͫͻͲͯͻͰ͵ͪͼͬΒͳͺͻͰͽͰͲͳΒͪͳ͵ͻͰ;Ͱͬͳͷ
ͫͶͪͼͽͳͷ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͳͺͻͰ͵ͻͰͽ;ͯͼ;ͼͪͭͪ
͵ΒͳͼͰͳͼͺͼͽͪͬͳ͵ͪͺͻͰ
]]
,̸̸̸̸͉͉̻͌̈́͋̓̽͌͋́͆͡ћ̸̸̸͇͎͇͆͋̾̓͋́͊͋ͅ
ͼ;ͯͪͲͪ͵ͻͪΒΔͳͳͼͯͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ
ͫͳͶͪΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͺͻͷͰͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͬͭͼͽͪͬͪ
ͺͻͰͷͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷͳΔͰͭͬͺͬͻͪͽͪ͵;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͭͯͳͰ̽ͫͻΒͰ
ͺͲͪͽ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͯͪΒͰ;ͻͰͪͫͳͶͳͽͪͳΒͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͵Γ;;;Ͷͭ;ͳͷͪ̽ͪͳͶ
ͽͪͯͪͳͭ;ͷͪͳͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺͼͻͰͯͬͪΔͰͷ͵ͯͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪmͺ;ͽͰͷͺͳͼͪͷͪͳͺͻͰ
͵ͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ͆ͳ͵ͯͳͷͪ
͵ͭͪΒͰͷͶͳͯͪ;ͽͳͰͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͫͲͳͻͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͰ͵Ͷͼͽͳ
ͰͫͳͽͻͰͫͪͶͯͫͪͳͽͳͷͭ;ΕͼͽͯͪΒͰͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͻͺͶͪͳΒͰ
ͫͳͼͪͷ̽ͪͳͶ**͋ͪ͵;ͰͳͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͯͰͶͽͬͻͪͪͳͼͪ͵ͳͳͼͪΔͪ
ͻͰͰΔͪͽͰ͵ͭͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͭͺͳͽͪΔͪͯͪΒͰͳͲ;ͲͰͽ;Ͷͳͼͽ͵ΒͪΒͰͯͪ͵ͯͫͻ
ͺͲͪΒͰ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͰͱͪͻͬͰͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͰͼͬͭͬͻͰͷͰ̸ͪ͵Ͷͳ͵ΒͰ
ͬͪͱͫͳͶͽͯͪͼͰ;ͲͺͷΕͽͺͳ͵ͰͼͷͰͪ;;ͽͪͻͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ͵ͪͶͰ
ͭͳͽͳͷͪ
ͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰͳͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͺͻͰͬͻͪͽ
ͻͶ͵ͳ
Ͳͪ͵ͻ;ͱ;Β;ͯͬͪ;ͯͪ
͵ͪͽΒͰͺͰͽͪ͵ͫͻͫͰͲͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͬ;ͺͻͰͬͶͪͼͽͫͰͶͰͱͰ̹ͱΒͷ͵ͪͲͷ
m̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͬͳͷͺͪͯͷͼ͵Δͪmͽͪ͵ΒͰͳΔͰ;ͼͺͰͪͳͼͯͺͽͬͻΌͰ̹ͱΒͳͷ
ͫͶͪͭͼͶͬͷm;ͯͰͼͳͷͬͻͪΕͪΔͰͷͬͳͯͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
͆ͪͼͪͷͷ͵ͻͪΒ;ͬͻͪͽͳͷͼͰ͵ͻͪΓ;̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳ;͉ͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰΔͰͭͬͭͻͰͪͶ
ͭͼͽͪͽ;ͼͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ
;ͯͫͻΒͷͰͻͳͲͪͬͳͼͳͯͯͭͬͻͪͪͺͳͽͪ
ΔͰͽͷͰ͵ΒͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͼͬͻͪͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪͲͫͻͳ͵ͪͱͳͽͳΒͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
ͳͻ͵ͬͰͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͰ̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕΒͰͼͷͪͽͻͪ͵ͪ͵ΒͰ̽ͪͳͶͬͪ
ͪͷͰͻͪͫͳͶͪͯͪͼͪͳͳͰ͵;ͬͻͼͽ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͺͻͶͭͪ̽ͳͼͽͪ
ͺͰͽͪ͵̽ͻͪ
ͭ;ͽͳͬͭ ͱͳͽͳΒͪ ͼͪͯͻͱͳ ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳͰ Ϳͻͷ;ͶͰ m tͱͳͽͳΒͰ ͳ ͱͳͲi ͳ
ͳͽͪ͵;ͷͶͳͽͬ;tͫͶͪͭͼͶͬͳ
ͰimͽͺͯͬͶͪͳΔͰͭͬͪͭͳͶ͵ͳͼͷͳ
ͼͪͳ;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͪͽͯͪΒͰͫͳͶͳͽͪ;ͽͻͺͰͲͪͻͳΒͳ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͳͼͽͻͪ
ͱͳͬͪͳͼ;ͯͪͬ;ͳͶͳͺͽͻͰͫ;ͯͪͼͰ̽ͪͳͶͬͺͯ;ͬͪͽͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪ͵ͻͲ
ͳͯͰΒ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱͺͬͻ͵Ͱ
ͳΒͪΒͰͼͰΕͪͷͳͼͪͼͬͰͽͻͯͼͽͳͶͰͭͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͽͳͷͼͽͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ͇ͼͳͷ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ΒͳͼͽͻͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
ͽͪͳͯͰΒͪΒͰΒͪͼ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͪ;ͱͳͬͺͳͼͪͳͷͺͻͭͻͪͷͳͷͪͪΒͺͻͰͺͬͻ͵ͪͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͪͳ
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺͳ͵ͪ
ͪͪͬͻ;;ͼͶͳ͵ͪͳͷ̈́Ͳͪͷͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ́ͼͽͳͪ
ͳ;ΒͰͯͳͷ
ͳ ; ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ ͪͭͶͪͪͬͪͪ ΒͰ ͪͻͳͽͪ ͫͶͪͭͯͪͽ ͺΒͰͯͳͳ Ͷͳͼͽͳ
ͽ ΒͰ
ͫͳͪͳͳͼͽͳͪΔͪͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͪͯͳͻͰ͵ͽͰͶͳͳΒͰͪͼͶͰΌͳͬͪΔ͎ͪͪͻͳͲͷͪ
ͺΒͰͯͳͳ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
;ͬͰ͵ ΒͰ ͺͳͬͪͶͪ ͪ ͼͬͪͽͪΔ; ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͼͽͳ
͵ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬͳͽͰͽͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽͼͬͰͽͻͯͷͺͻͰ͵Ͷ;ͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ̽ͪͳͶ**ͷͱͯͪ
ΒͰͫͳͪΒͫͶͳͱͳͼͬΒͳͷ;ͬͰͻͰΔͳͷͪ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͪͶͱͳͯͪͼͰ;ͺͰΕ͵Β̈́Ͳͳͼͬͳͷ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͳͷͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͳͱͰͰ
ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪΒ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͭͶͪͬͪ͌ͽͷͼͬͰͽͶ;
ͽͻͰͫͪͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳͳͺͻͪͬͷͰͼͽ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ́ͪ͵ͳΒͰͼͽͰ͵ͪ͵;Ͷͽ;
;ͱͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ͻͰͳ
;ͬͪͱͪͬͪΒͰ͵ͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͳ͵ͺͼͬͰΕͰͰͺͻͯͳͰͲͪΒͰͯͳ
Ͱ͌ͼͬͰͽͻͯΒͶͲͳ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳ;ΒͰ
ͬΓͷͼ;ͯͫͳͰ
ͺͻͳͺͪͶͪͫͪͭͻͪͪ
ͪͶͳΒͰ
Ͳͪ;Ͳͬͻͪͽ
;ͺͪͷΕͰ͵ͪͶͳͰΔͰͷͪ͵ͳͬͻͶͳͪͳΒͰͯͪͯͪΒͬͰΕͳ
ͪͼ͵ͰͽͪͷͰΌ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͳͷͪ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
̸̸̸̸̸̸͚̺͉̾͌̈́̽́́̀̽́͆͊͋́̾͆̾́ͣ͢͠ͅͅͅ͵ͻͪΓ͊ͽͰͿͪ͌ͻ***
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͳͲͯͬͪΒͪͼͰͰͫͳͷͼ;ͯͫͳͷ
ͳΒͰͼ;ͫͰͶͰͱΒͰͷͭͳͲͪ͵ͻͰͽͳ
;ͼͺͳͳͺͪͯͬͳ
ͽͻͪͭͳͪͲͪͬͻͰͽͪ͵ͱͳͬͽͪ
ͪͶͳͳͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪͼͽͪͽ;ͼͺͼͶͰ
ͼͷͻͽͳ͊ͽͭͪͳΒͰͰͫͳͽͽͳΔͰͭͬͽͬͪΔͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒͰͯ;ͯ
ͪΒͼͶͱͰͳΒͳͺΒͪͬͪ;͵;ͶͽΒͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ͊ͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ
Ͷͳ͵ͬͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͰͼͪͷͯͪΒͰͼͽͬͪͻͪͺͼͽ;ͺ
ͽ͵ͷͯ;ͭͭͻͪͲͯͫΓͪ
ͬͰΕ
ΒͰ;ͽ͵;ͽͭͻͪͲͬΒͪͫͳͽͷͰΔͪ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͯͶͳ͵Ͱt͈ͻͷͰͰͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽͪi
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͫͳͶͰͼ;ͰͺͼͻͰͯ;ͼͶͬΓͰͰͺͽͳͷͺͬͰͼͳͷͽ͵ͬͳͷͪ
͵
͵ͻͰͽͳͷ ͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͷ ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
͵ͪ ͳ Ͷͳͳͷ ͷͽͳͬͪͳΒͪͷͪ ͺΒͰͯͳͳ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͪ͊ͽͭͪͼͰ͵;Ͷͽ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͷͱͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ
ͻͰͳͽͳͷͳͬͰͷͪͲͪͪΒͳͷͺͻͳͷͰͻͷͺΒͪͬͰ͵Β;ͼ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͲͪͳͶͳ
͵ͪtͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪi
͈ͻͬͪͰͽͪͺͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪͷͱͰͼͰ
͵ͬͳͻ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͽͳ;ͻͪͲ
ͯͫΓͰͬͶͪͯͪͬͳͰ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽;ͪͪ
͵ͪͯͪͪͼͽͪΒͰͺͻͬ̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪ
ͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳͭͪΒͰ̽ͪͳͶͬ͌Ͱͳ͵
;Ͳ̿ͳͽͳΒͰͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ̽ͪͳ
͇ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Β Ͷͳͼͽͳ ͵ͻͪΓͪ ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ ͌ͻͪ *** ͅ ͪͅͶͬͳΕ
͊ͽͰͿͪ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ ͳ
̀Ͱͽͪ
́ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͲͪͺͳͼͳ
ͭͯ999** -**
9-*
m͊ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͬͳͪ͊ͽͰ
Ϳͪͪ͌ͻͪ***
JÓ͊͆
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m ͼͪͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͈ΒͰͯͳͳͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͽͬͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭmͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ
ͪͪͻͳͽͶͳ͵
ͬͳm;ͯͼͪͯͪΔΒͪ;ͳͯͫͻͼ;ͺͻ;Ͱͳ
ͪͶͳ͵;Ͷͽ͵ͪͰͶͳͪͳΒͰͫͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͺͼͰͫͰ
ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰΒ;ͬͰ͵ͪΒͺͽͺ;ͳΒͰ͈ͪͬͶͬͳΕ
̓;ͶͽͬͳͶͳͪ
mWͳ̸̸͊ͶͬΒͰͬ
̓ͪͯΒͰ
̽;ͪͺͻͭͶͪͰͲͪͼͬͰͪ ̓ͻͪΓͪ̽;ͪͬͪͺͬͰΓͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;
̹ͭͼͶͬΓͰ
m͉͠ͰΌͰͺ
̽ͬͪͶͳ͵ͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ;ͼͽͪͻΒͼͻͺͼ͵Β͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳ
̻ͯͳ
Δͪ͵͍ͳͶͲͿͼ͵ͭͿͪ͵;ͶͽͰͽͪ;͆ͬͷ͊ͪͯ;
͵Δ9***
ḿ͚ͅͻΌͰͬͳΕ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
Ͷͪ**ͳͺͰͽͰͫͰͶͰ͵ͰͲͪ̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽;ͪͪ
͵ͪͼͬΒͯͺͻͳͼ̽ͪͳ
ͶͬͷͲͫͻͳ͵;
ΒͰͯͷͯ͵Γ;ͳͺͯ;ͬͪͽͪͰͺͰ
ͲͪͷͳΓͰͷͯͪͫ;ͯͰ
Ͱ͵ͪ ͬͻͼͽͪ ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭ ͺͻͶͭͪ
ͽ ΒͰͼͽ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͪ ͬͶͪͯͪΒ;ΕͰ ͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ ͳ ͻ͵ͬͰ
́ͪ͵ΒͰͻͶͭͳΒͪͪͼͽͪ͵ͪͳ͵ͪͭ;ͫͶͳͪͬͪΔͪͲͫͻͳ͵ͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͼ
ͷͭͳͷͰͺͲͪͳͪͷͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͼ;;ͭͶͪͬͷͼͪͭͶͪͼͳ͵ͽͭͪͯͪͭͪ
;
ͬΒͰͽͪͺͳ
ͽͻͰͫͪͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͽͳ;ͺͰͻͳͯͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͷͻͽͳ̽ͪͳͶͪ**ͳ̽;ͪͬͭ
ͺͻͭͶͪͰΔͪͲͪͪͻͪͳͶͳ
ΒͺͻͰͳͲͳΒͰ
;ͬͻͰͷͰͳͲͷͰΌ;ͳͭͯͳ
Ͱ̓ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͱͪͻͬͼ͵Βͺͻͳͺͪͯͼͽͳ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽͯͪͬ;Ͱ
ͱͳͬ
ͽͺͳͼ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͼͪͯͻͱͳͼͬͰͯͶͳ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͼͽͻͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ͯ͵
ͼ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͺͽͺ;ͺͽͳͼ;ͽͳ͌ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͽͪ͵ͬͳͷͺͻͰͯͰΓͰ
ΔͰͷ
ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔͰͼͰͲͪͼͳͬͪͪͳͲͶͪͭͪΔ;ͯͭͪΌͪΒͪͳ͵Ͷͼͽͳͱͳͬͽͪ
ͯ͵
ΒͰ͵ͽͰͷͺͶͪͽͳͬͪͿ;͵ͳΒͪͱͳͽͳΒͪͭͽͬͲͪͰͷͪͻͰͪ̓ͪ͵ͪͬΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
Ͷͳ͵
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ;ͳͽͰͻͺͻͰͽͪͳΒͳ̽ͪͳͶͬͭ͌Ͱͳ͵ͪͳͼ͵ΒͷΒͰͼͬͻͷͳ͵ͻͪΒ
ΔͳͷͳΓͰͬͳͷͪͼͽͬͪͻͪ
̸͵ͼͰͽͪΒͶͳ͵ͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͪtͼͬͰͽͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪi͵Βͳͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳͫͳͬͪͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͷͻ;mͪͽͼ;Ͱͼͪͷ
ͺͻͺͳͼͪͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͬͻͶͳͪͳͲͪͼͶ;ͭͪͬͰΕͳͺͽͬͻͯͰͫͶͪͭ
ͪΕ;Ͷͳͼͽͳ
ͷΕ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪͳͺΒͪͬͪ;ͯͰͼͳͺͼͷͻͽͳͲͪͷͰΔͪ
mͳͭͶͰͯΒͰͯͪͳΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͭͽͬ;ͰͶͳͳͶͳͰ͉ͰͳͽΒͰͯͪͪ͵ͳ
;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͬͻͶͳͪͷͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͷ͌Ͱͳ͵ͭͬͻͳͼͪͷͪΒͰͯͷ
ͷͰͼͽ;
ͳͽͼͪͼͬͳͷ;͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳ;ͺͽͰt̹ͰͰͺ;ͯͫͻͳͯͰͶͪͳͷͳͶͼͽͳ
Δͪ
Ͱͼ͵;ͯͰͯͪͻͬͰͯͪΒ;Εͳ;ͫͱͪͼͽͬͰͰͻ͵ͬͰͳͯͬΓ͵ͪͳͽͳͷͪiͽͪ
ͼͬΒͼͽͬͪͼͽͰ͵ͪΒͰͲͪͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳͬͳͼ͵ͳͷ;ͲͻͳͷͪͼͬΒͳͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͪtwΒͰͻͯ
ͼͬΒͰͷͶͪͯͼͽͳͫͰͰͪ;Ͱͼͬͪ͵ͷͯͫͻ;ͭͯͷͯͰͶ;
ͬͪͼͺͳͽͪ;ͺ;͵ͪͷͪ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
ͻͯͳͽͰΓͪͼͬͭͪͺͻͰͬͳͼ͵ͭͪ͵ͻͪΓͪi͇ͯͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳͫͶͳ͵ͪͳͼͺΓͪͬͪ
Δͪͺͫͱͼͽͳ͵Βͳͼ;͵ͻͪͼͳͶͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͰͳͲͻͯͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ̽ͪͳͶͬ͌Ͱͳ͵
ͪͭͶͪͪͬͪ Β ͳ ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͰ ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵Ͱ ͲͪͼͶ;ͭͰ ͇ͺͳͼ;Β;Εͳ ͺͯͳͲͪΔͰ ̽Ͱͪͪ
ͬͰͶͰͶͰͺͰͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰͳͭͻͫͰͻ͵ͬͰ
Ͱͺͻͺ;ͽͪͯͪͳͼͽͪ͵Ͱ;ͫͳͪΒͰ;
Ͱͼ
ͪͽͶ͵;ͷͽͳͬͪͳΒ;
͵ͪͳͺͻͳͷͰͻͰ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͪt͋ͻͰͫͪͯͪ;ͳͳͷ
ͳͰ͵ͳͫͭ;ͭͯͳͼͺͷͰ;ͱͳͬͽ;ͷΒͰͷ
ͰͫͳͶͳ͵ͪ͵ͯͫͻ;ͻͰͼͽͰ͵ͪ
ͺͼͶͰͻͪͲͶ;ͰΔͪͷͳͯͬͭͼ;ΒͰͽͭͱͳͬͽͪ͠ͰͻͬͳͯͳͷͯͪͷΒͳͺͻͪͻͯͳͽͰΓͳ
ͳͻͯͳͽͰΓͳͳͯͻ;ͭͳ;ͳͳͰͯͫͻͪͯͰͶ̹ͪͭ;ͳΓ;ͯͳͷͪ
ͳ;ͲͽͺͯͳͭͰͯ
ͼͬͪͫͱͪͼͽͬͰͰͻͪͷͬͰͪͬͪͶ;ͳͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ̹ͭ;
ͪͼͰͫͳͪͬͰͪ
ͼͺͷͰͳͪ;ͬͪΔͰͽͰͶ;ͺͻͪͲͶ;ͰΔ;ͯ;ͰͯͽͰͶͪi
́ͺͪ͵
ͬͻͶͳͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͵ΒͰ͌Ͱͳ͵ͪΒͬͳͰͺͯͬͶͪͳͰͯ
ͼͰͼͰͽͶͳ͵ͪͺͫͱͺͪͪΔͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͪΔͰͭͬͰͻͪͽͳ͵Ͱͼͺͼͫͼͽͳ
ͳͲͪͼͶ;ͭͰ͇ͭͪͺͻͰͯͳͼ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͷ̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͺͫͰͯͳ͵ͷͪͯͳͺͶͰͷͰ
ͳͳͷͪͬͰͻͰͻͪͯͳ
ͳͅΒͼͳΒͰͷ
͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͲͺͷΕ̹ͱΒ;ͺ͵ͻͳtͺͭͪͰͪͻ
ͯͰi
Ͳͪ͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͯͪΒͰΒͰͯͪ͵ͪͼ;ͯͫͳͪͲͪͯͰͼͳͶͪͼͬͰͰ͵ΒͳtͲͶ;ͷͳͼͪͷͳͼͶͰ
ͺͻͽͳͬΔͰͭͬͭͽͪͪͼͽͬͪ
ͽΒͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͲͰͷΓͰìͪͽͪ͵ͪͬͼ;ͯ
ͯͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽ
ͺͼͽΒͪͶͰͼ;ͼͽͬͪͻͰ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͰͼͬͰmͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͬΒͼ͵Ͱͪͯ
̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͷ͵̺ͯͰͶͫ;ͱͯͪͭͯͳͰ
͵ΒͳΒͰͺͶͱͳͽͰͷͰΓͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͺͻͰͬͶͪ
ͼͽͳ̹ͪͪͶ͵ͪ;́ͯͰͪͶͳͶͳ͵ͺͫͰͯͳ͵ͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ̽ͪͳͶͬ͌Ͱͳ͵ΒͰ
ͺͻ
ͺͳͼ
ͲͪͯͰ;;ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͻ;͌ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͽͰͷͰΓͳͷͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͷ
ͼͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶΒͰͯͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͲͪͺͫͰͯ;ͲͪͬͪͶͳͰͼͪͷͼͪͲͳͻ;ͱΒͪ
ͬͰΕ ͳ ͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽͬ; ͬͳΔͳ ͼͳͶͪ ̿ͳͬͽͺͳͼͪ ͺͯͼͰΕͪ ͪ ͽ ͵ͪ͵ ͼ;
ͬ;tͬͰͶͳ͵;ͳ;ͯ;ͳͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪ;ͷͳͶͼͽͳͺͷΕi;ͺͻͶͳͷͬͻͰͷͰͳͷͪ
;ͱͳͬͪͶͳͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͻͯͳͽͰΓͳ
;͵ͪͲ;Β;Εͳͽͪ͵ͪ͵ͽͳ;ͳͽͰͽͺͫͰͯͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͭͪͼͰͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͫͻͪΕͪͼͬΒͳͷͲͪͽͳͽͳͳͷͪ
ͷͰΌ;͵Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;
ͼΒͰͯͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ΔͰͭͬͳͼͬͰͽͳͺͻͪͻͯͳͽͰΓͳͳ
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͪͻͳͽͯͪͫͻͪͳ
ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳ͈ͻͳͺͻͰͷͪΒ;ΕͳͼͰͲͪͯͶ;ͪͼ;͵ͫͼͅͳͪͳͶͷ͑ͳ
̽ͪͳͶͬͳͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ
ͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͰͳͯͰͪͶͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͻͪͲͷͽͻͳͶͪΒͰ͊ͪͅͻ
ΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
QBTTJN
̽ͪͳͶͬͳͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ
ͳͯͰΒͳͳͿ;͵ͳΒͳͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͳͷͪ;ͲͶͰΒ͈ͪͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
̽ͪͳͶͬͳͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ
mͻͪͽͳ͵ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳͷͫͻͪͼͳͷͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ͆Ͱͷͪ
ΔͳΕͪͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
m
m
͈ͅͺͬͳΕ
̺ͰͽͳͪͻͪͽͬͪΔͪͳͱͳͬͽͬΒͳ͵ͪ
JO͈ͻͳͬͪͽͳͱͳͬͽ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͲͰ
ͷΓͪͷͪͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
FE͊ͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
͈̽ͺͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͷͪͷ
͵ͻͪΓͼͰtͰͺͻͰͼͽͪͷΓͪͰͲͪ;ͽͬͻΌͰΔͰͳ͵ͻͰͺͼͽiͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͪͬͳ
ͺͯͼͰΕͪΒ;Εͳͪͽ͵ͪ͵ΒͰͰ͵ͪͯͪͺͷͭͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ;͈ͻͬͬͰͪͷͯͪ;͵Ͷͳ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͬͰͶͳ͵ͪͪ͊ͽͻͰͲ͇ͪͫͻͪΕͪͼͰͳ͊ͳͷͰ;ͳ͊ͪͬͳ
tͼͬͰͽͰΒͯͬ
Βͳͳi
ͳΒͳͷΒͰͷͶͳͽͬͪͷͪͫͳtͲͪͼͽ;ͺͪͳ͵ͻͰͺΓͰ
ͳͻ;ͱͪͬͪͼͳͶͷͼͬͰͽ
ͭͪ̽;ͪi̽ͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽͯͪΒͰ
ͳͼͽͳͷͺͬͯͷ
ͷͶͳͽͬ;;ͺ;ͽͳͳͼͬͰͽͷ
͚ͻΌ;
ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͷͻͪͽͳ͵ͷͲͪͼͽ;ͺͳ͵;͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ͌ͳͳΒͰͽ
ͺͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͷͳ͵ͷͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͷͪͳ͵ͼͽͪͼ;;͊ͽͪͻͷ͆ͪͭͻͳͳ;
ͪ
ͪ͵ͳͲͬΒͰͬͪͰͺͫͰͯͰͳͼͺ;ͳΒͰͫͰΕͪΔͰͯͪͽͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;mͳ͵;ΒͰ;͵ͻͪ
ͼͳͯͻͪͭͰͳͷ͵ͬͷ
ͪͻͪͷͫͭͪͽͫͯͪͻͳ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
;ͪ;ͳ
ΒͰͭͽͬͰͲͪͺͪͱͰͼͽͪͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͯͪΒͰͺͻͰͯͫͳͽ͵;̺ͪͰͶͫ;ͱͯ;͊ͽͰͿͪ̽Ͱ
ͪͼ͵ͳ
;ͺͻͪͽΔͳͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͰ
ͽͳͪͳͪͭͻͫ;ͬͪͱͰͭͺ;ͼͽͳΔͪ͵ͪͪ͠͵ͳͷͪ
͇ͼͭͬͼ͵ͭ͵ͪ͵ͫͳͭͪͲͪͷͶͳͲͪͺͷΕm;ͳͳͬͳ
ͳͽͪͯͪ
tͬͰͶͳ͵ͫͰΕͪ
ΔͰiΔͰͭͬΒͻ͵ͬͳ͆ͪͳͲͭͶͰͯͰͫͳ
ͫͻͪΕͪΔͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͲͪͺͷΕͼͬͰͽͷ
ͽͰͶͳ͵;ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͺͽͰͷͰͼͽͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰͳͷͰͽͪͶͳͽͰ
ͽͪ͌ͼͬͳͷ;ΒͰ;ͬͰͻͰΔͰͯͪͲͪͼͽ;ͺͳͽͬͪͼ͵ͰͽͰmͶͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͪΒͰͯͼͰ
ͭͶͪͼͪͷͬͻͶͰͼͽͬͳͰͬͻͶͳͰ
ͽͰͼͽͭͪͼͽͬͪͻͳͶͪͪͻͳͽ;ͫͶͳͼ͵ͼͽͼ̹ͭͷ
mͳͷͪͳͪΒͬͰΕ;ͷͰͻ;ͯͰͶͽͬͻͼͽͳ̻ͻͪͯͰΕͳͶͳ͵͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͱͳ
ͬͽͺͳͼͪΒͰ
Ͱͬͳͯ
ͼͷͳΓͰͺͻͿͳͶͳͼͪΔͰͭͬͺͫͱͳͼͽͪͬͷͰΌ;
ͰͫͰͼ͵ͳͷͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͳͷͪ͵ͻͪΓΒͰͳͲͪͫͻͪͼͺͼͽͬͰͰͺͻͰͽ͵ͰmͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͰ
ͪͳͪͶͰͲͪͼͽ;ͺͳ͵ͰmΒͰͯͭͶ͵ͪͶͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͼͪͼͪͱͳͷͯ;ͬͳͷ
ͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽͷͳ
ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͲͪͷͰͳͽͭͺͽͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͺͷΕͳ͵ͪ;ͫͳͽ͵ͪͷͪ
ͳͼͬͰͯͰͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
͈ͻͪͬ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;ͼͬͪ͵ͭͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪͪΒͺͻͰͳͲͳΒͰͽ
͵ͻͳͬͪͺͳͼͼͷͻͽͳΔͰͭͬͭͭͶͪͬͭͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͰ͋ΒͰ͵Γ;ͳͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵;
ͱͳͬͽͷͺ;ͽ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͵ΒͳͲͪͪͬͪͼͽͬͪͻͳͺͰͽͪ͵ΔͰͭͬͰͬͰ
ͽͻͪ
ͼͰͯͰͽͰ ͰͭͲͳͼͽͰͳΒͰ ͊ͷͻͽ ͳ ͼͪͻͪͪ tͼͬͰͽͭ ͬͰ͵ͪi ;ͬͰ͵ ͼ; ;ͯͰͼͳ
ͯͭͪΌͪΒͳ
ͺͻͪΕͰͳͲͪͷͰΔͳͷ̹ͪͱΒͰͭͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪ͊ͽͭͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͺͼͷͪ
ͽͻͪ
ͺͳͼͼͷͻͽͳ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ;ͽ;ͷͪͰΔ;ͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪͳͪ͵Βͳ
ͪͳͰͪΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬmͪͺͻͽͳͬ̽ͪͳͶͬ͌Ͱͳ͵ͺͳͻͺͻͳ
ͺͬͰͯͪ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͪͽ; ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭ ͼ;͵ͫͪ ͼͪ ͼͳͷ
͵Βͳ ΒͰ ͯͬͰ ͯ ͽͻͪͭͳͰ
ͼͷͻͽͳ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ ͭͯͳͰ ͉ͪͼͰͺ ; ͺͻͯͳͳ
; ̿ͳͽͳΒ; ͺͻͽ;ͷͪͰ
ͰͬͷͷͻͱΔͷͪͼͽͪͶͷtͺͪͭͬͻ;ͼͬͰͭ;ͫͳͽͰΓͪͼͽͪͻͭΌͪͬͶͪi
ͫͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪͼͪͲͪΔͳͷͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱͪ;͵Ͱ
ͺͼͶͰͯͳͪ̽;ͪͬͰͳͼ;ͬͳͰͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͰ
;ͶͭͰ̺ͪͰͶͫ;ͱͯ;
ͺͻͳͽͳͼ͵ͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͪͬͻͳͶͪͪ̽;ͪͪ
͵ͪͳͼͽͻͪ
ͪͷͶͪͯͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͯͪͷ;ͺͽͷͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͳͲͯͻ;ͭͭͫͻͪ͵ͪͰ;ͭͻͲͰͪͼͶͰΌͰ
ͺͻͰͼͽͶ͉ͪͪͼͺͶͰͽΒͰͪͼͽ;ͺͳ͵ͪͯͪΒͰ̽;ͪͺͻͳͼͳͶͳͪͪ͵ͪ;ͺͻͰ
ͯͪΒ;ͳͲͪͽͬͻͳͭͪͼͺͻͯͳͷ;ͽͬͻΌͪͬ;̀ͬͰͪ
;͵ΒΒΒͰͪ͵ͯͬͪͷͰ
ͼͰͪͳͲͭ;ͫͳͱͳͬͽ;ͰΒͪͼͳͷ͵Ͷͼͽͳͷ͈ͪͲͪͽͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͼͪͭͶͪͼͪ
ͼ;;ͽͬͻΌͰΔ;ͯͪΒͰͼͷͻͽ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͫͳͶͪͪͼͳͶͪ
ͪͶͳͰͳ;Ͱͳ̽;ͪͬͰ
͵ͻͳͬͳͰ͇ͽͷͰͼͰͪͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͪͳͳͲΒͪΔͪͬͪΒ;ͳͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͳͳͲͬͻͳ
ͳͲ
9*7ͬͰ͵ͪ͆ͳΕͳͿͻ̻ͻͳͭͻͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ
ͫͰͲͫͲͳͻͪͪͽͽͳ
ΒͰͳͷͪͼͳͷͺͪͽͳΒͪͺͻͰͷͪ̽;ͪ;
ͽͬͻͯͳͯͪΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ;ͽͪͷͳͰtͺͻͽͳͬ
ͬΓͰͳ;ͲͰͭͯͬͪΔͰͼͳͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͳͺͪ͵Ε;ͽͪͰͷͭ;ΕͳͼͰͼ;ͺͻͽͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ
ͼͳͶͳͷͽͬͪ
ΒͰͻͼͰͫΒͪͯͪͳΔͰͭͪͼͪͷͭͰͲͪͯͰͼͳͰ͵ͲͶiͰͯ;ͭͲͪ
ͽͳͷ
ͺ̻ͻͳͭͻͳͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ
tͼͽͪͻͭͪ͵ͻͪΓͪͼ;;ͯͪͬͳͶͳ;ͽͪͷͳͳ
ͳͽͪ͵
ͼ;ΔͰͭͬͷͱͳͬͽ;ͯͪͶͳͭͻͪ͵͵ͻͪΒ;ͷͰͼͽͳͼͶͪͽ͵ͳͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵ͪͼͻͰΕͰi
͊ͬͳͺͲͳΒͳͻͳͪͻͳͺΒͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͶͳͼ;ͺͳͼͯͭͪΌͪΒͪͳͼͬͰͶͳͭͪͪͰ
;ͫͳͼͽͬ̽;ͪͪ
;ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͽͰͻͰͽͳ͉́ͬͪͪͬͰΔͪͳ
͵ͪͳ̻ͳΒͷ̸ͯͪͷ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͵ΒͳͽͬͻͯͳͯͪΒͰtͼͳ;ͬͪͽͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
Ͳͪͽͬͻͳͭͪͳ;ͷͻͳͬͳͰͰͭͪ
ͭͻͲͪͪͳi͋ͪ͵ͬ;ͬͰͻͲͳΒ;ͯͭͪΌͪΒͪͺͻͰ;ͲͰͶͳͼ;ͳͺͳͼͳͳͲͪͻͰͯͭͼͽ
ͶͰΕ̻ͪͻͳͭͻͳΒͰ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰ̽;ͪͺͼͶͪͪ;̀ͬͰͪtͳͺͼͶͰͰ
͵Ͷͳ͵ͯͪͪͼ;ͯͳͭͪͪͪΒͭͻ;ͼͷͻͽ;ͯͪͬΓͰΔͪi̓ͼͽͪͽͳͅͳͪͳͶͬͳΕ
ͳͲ͇ͼͽͻͬͳͰͳͯͰͳ͵ͻͪ͵ͯͪΓͰͽͬͻͯͰΕͳͯͪΒͰ̽;ͪͼͪͷ;ͼͷͻͽͳͪt̓ͻͪΓ
ΒͰͽͪͯͪͽͳͪ;ΒͰͯͪͭͻͪͯ͵ΒͳͼͰͲͬͰ̀ͬͰͪ
ͪͼͳΔͰͭͬͯΌͰ;ͲͰͷΓ;
͵ͻͪͯͷͳͰ
ͽͪ͵ͯͪͳ͵ΔͰͷ;ͳΒͰͲͪ
ͳͺͻ͵ͻͪͬͳͼͰͯͶͱͳͰ
ͪ
ͼͬͭͪͲͪͯͪͬͳi͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͺͻͳͺͬͰͼͽͰ;ͫͳͼͽͬ;ͺͻͰ;ͲͰͶͳͼ;
͵ͪ
Ͱͺͫͳͽ;ͳͼͽͳ;
ͳͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͪͻͪͽͪΒͳ͇ͪΒͰ;Ͷͪ;ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͻͯͼͶͬͪ
ͪͺͻͳͬͪͽͳͶͳͼ;ΒͰͳ;ͽͳͪΒͳͺͳͼͳ
ͺͺ;ͽ̽;ͫͻͬͪͳͪͪͬͅͻ͇ͪͻͫͳͪ
͇ͯ97ͬͰ͵ͪͽͪͺͻͳͪͯͫͳΒͪͬ;ͯͳͷͰͲͳΒ;Ͷͳ͵̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͺͺͻͳͷͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ
Ͱͷ;ΕͰͬͳͰͻͰͳͫͳͽͳ͵ͪͼͳΒͰ
̿ͳͬͽͺͳͼͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ;ͰͶͼͽͳͺͻͰΕ;ͽ͵;ΒͰͺͷͰ;ͽͰ͵Ͷ
ͼͽͳ́ͺͪ͵
ͼͺͻͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͳͪͷͰͻͪͯͪͼͰͰͲͪͽͪ͵ͪΒ;
ͪͼͶ;Ε;Β;ͼͰ
ͬͰΕͳͲΔͰͭͬͭͲͪͷͪͭΓͰͭͳ;ͬͳΒͰͭͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔͪ͌ͯ;;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭ
ͫͳͪΒͪͯͪͼͰ;ͲͻͳͯͭͪΌͪΒͪͽ;ͷͪͰ;ͼͬΒΒ͵ͻͪΒΔΒͳͼͽͪͳ
ͽͰͶ͵ͳͷ
ͻͪͲͶͭͷ
ͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪ͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰ;Ͳͻ͵ͼͷͻͽͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭtͺͻͷͳͼͪͫͱΒͪi
;Ͳͯͯͪͽ
Ͱ;ͿͰͷͳͼͽͳ͵PͫΒͪΔͰΔͰtwΒͰͻͳ͵ͰͷͱͰͺͫͰΕͳͯͺͻͳ
ͻͯͰͬͰͲͰͼͷͻͽͳ
ΒͰͻͳ͵
Γ;ͫͳͷͳͷΒͳ
ͰͲͪ
;͵ΒͳΕͰͼͰͯͪͳͶͳͪͼͯ;
ͪͻͪͲͶ;ͳͽͳͯͽͰͶͪi͊ͪͼͬͳͷͼͶͳͪͪͳͼͪͺͽͪͬͪΔͪͺͻͰͺͲͪΒͰͼͰ;
̽;ͪͬΒͺͬͰΓͳ̽;ͫͻͬͪͳͷͪͳͲͭͯͳͰ
;͵ΒΒͼͰΔͰͭͬͪͼͳͶͪ
ͯ Ͷͪ Ͳͪ͵ͪͺͻͰ ͼͽͫ ΒͪΔͪ ͬͪtͼ; ͯͷͫͱ Βͳͷi ̀ͪͪ ;ͽͰ ͷ;mͪͽ
OFNJMMFYJU
EFEJUVNRVFOFDBWJUUBOUFRVFQBUFSOFDFEJTTDFMFSFQBSVNJNQJVTOJTJBEEJTTFUFUQB
SJDJEJJQFSêEJBNi
W'3BǁLJ
1SJMP[J[BQPWJFTUIVNBOJ[NBJSFOFTBODFV%VCSPWOJLV
%BMNBDJKJ
J)SWBUTLPK
3BE+";6
LOK-99*7
͆ͪͬͰͯͰͺͻͰͷͪͪͅͅͶͬͳΕ
PQDJU
̻ͻͳͭͻͳΒͰ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
̓ΔͳͱͰͬͳͻͪͯ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ ͺͻͳͻ͈̽Ͱ
ͽͻͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̓ͼͽͪͽͳ ͅͳͪͳͶͬͳΕ ͳͲ ͇ͼͽͻͬͳͰ
ͪ͠ͳͪͻͬͰ ;ͼͺͷͰͰ ͳͶͳ ͽ;ͻͼ͵ͪ ͻͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻͳͻͳͺͻͰ͚ͬ̿ͳͬͪͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
͉ͯͼͶͬͳͳͶͰͽͺͳͼͳ
ͪͬͅͻ͇ͻͫͳ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͼͽͬ͊ͶͬͰͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
̽ͪͳͶͬͳͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ
mͲͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͰͽ;ͷͪͰΔͪͳͺͻͪͬͯͪΔͪͰ;ͭͯͳͳΔͰͳͪ
;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ΒͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͳ͈ͺͬͳΕ
͇ͪͼͽͪ͵;͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
m
FBEFN
͐;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
m
͊͡ͽΒͪͬͳΕ
͊ͽͪͻͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͺͬͰΓͰͳͺͳͼͷͪ*
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯm͊ͻͰͷͼ͵ͳ̓ͪͻͶͬͳm
ͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
m
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
ͼ; ͰͽͪͺͰͳͷͰͪͳͲͪͷͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͪ͵;Ͷͽͪmͺͻͪͬͪͳͼͽͳͪͼͷͻͽͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͳ
ͳΒͰͯͺͻͬͻͪͲͻͰͯͭͲͪͪΒͪͭͅΒͰͬͪͱͳΒͪͳΔͰͳͪͯͪΒͰ;ͽ;ͷͪͰ
Δ;̽ͪͳͶͬͭ͌Ͱͳ͵ͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪͼͷͻͽͼͽͪͶͪͫͰͲͪͻͳͲͷͰ
Ͱ;ͯͰͼͰͪ;ͻͰ
͵Βͪ ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ
͵ͪͳ͵;ͶͽΒͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͲͪ;ͼͶͬ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ͑ͽ;ͻͳ;ͺͽͰ͌Ͱͳ͵ͭͬͻͳͳͺͻͰͼ;ͳͼͪͻͪͳ̽Ͱ
ͪͼ͵ͭt́ͺͻͰͰͼͰͫͳΔͰͭͬͽͰͶͪͼͯͻͳͼͽΓ;ͫͳͬͭͼͳͪΔͰͭͬͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͳͺͶͱͳͰͭͪ;ͻ;͵ͽͬͻͰͷΔͰͭͬ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;;ͻ͵ͬͳ̺ͪͲͰͼͰ
Δ̻ͪͼͺͯΔͰͭͪͷͰͼͽ;Ͳͬͪͷ̽Ͱͪͳi͇ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔ;ͷͽͳΒ;Ͱͷͪͳ
͵ͪ͵ͬͭͺͷͰͪ
BͻͰͳͽͪΒͰͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͺͲͳΒͳͳͲͬͻͳͺͳͼ;Β;ͽͰͯͭͪΌͪΒͰͼ
ͬͳͰͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ͆ͳͳ
ͯͯ;Ͱ
ͰͯͼͰͺͯͪͽ͵ͰͻͶͭͳΒͳͺͻͰͼͪ
ͳͲ̀ͬͰͪͪ;̽ͰͪͰ
ͬͰΕͼͪͷͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔ;͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͽͰͶ͈ͪͻͰͷͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵;
ͽͼͰͯͭͯͳͶͼͰͯͪͷͭͯͳͪͪ͵ͼͪͻͪͰ
ͯ͵̓ͼͽͪͽͳͳͲ͇ͼͽͻͬͳͰ
ͰͯͻͰΌͰ͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳtͺͼͶͰͯͰͬͰͽͭͯͳͪͺͻͭͶͪͰͲͪͼͬͰͪi
͠ͰͯͳͳͺͻͰͳͲͪͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͬͻͰͷͰ;ͺͻͰͼͪ;̽ͰͪͰmͼͪ;ͬͪ;͋ͻ͵ͷ
ͻͯͼͶͬ;
ͯͪͽͬͪͷ;97***ͬͰ͵mͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ΒͰͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͳͲͰ͵ͭͼͽͪͻͳΒͰͭ
ͼͪͯͪ
ͰͺͲͪͽͭͳͲͬͻͪ͋;ͼͽΒͳͯͪΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͼͪͻͪΔͰ;ͼͬΒΒͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͳͽͻͳ
ͭͯͳͰͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳ
;ͲΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͯͪͼ;ΔͰͭͬͰͷͽͳͬͰΕ;
̀ͬͰͪ;ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͰͲͪͷͰΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪͳ͵ͪͽͪ͵ͬͰͺͻͰͰͽͰ;̽ͰͪͰ͆ͪ
ͼͬ;ͽͳͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͵ͪͳͽͪͭͲͪͺͪͱͪΔͪͯͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ;̽ͰͪͰͳΒͰ
ͷͭͶͪͫͳͽͳͫͪͬΓͰͪͺͻͰͲͪͬͻͰͽ͵ͪͳͼͬͰΕͰΔͪͻͪͷͪmͺͻͰͳͲͯͪͽͬͪͭ
͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͳͷͪͽͺͳͼͷͪͪͯͬͻͪͽͳ͵;Β;ͱͭͺͻͽͪͶͪm;ͪ;ͳΒͰͳͼͺͻͪͬ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;ͰͯͪͼͰͪͷͭͶͪͯͳͭͻͪͽͳͺͻͰͯͼͪͷ͵ͻͪΒͳͶͳ;ͽ͵;
ͭͯͳͰ
ͪͯͪͼͰ;ͬͻͽͰΔͰ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͲͫͳͶͰͭͯͰͽ͵ͷͺͻͶͰΕͪͳͶͳͶͰ
ͽͪͭͯͳͰ̽ͪͪͼͰͷͱͰͷͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͽͳͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͪͳͫͳͳͲͬͰͯͰ
ͺͻͰͼ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͽͰͶͪ͊;ͯͰΕͳͺ̽ͪͳͶͬͷ͌Ͱͳ͵;
ΒͰͯͳͷͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͷ
ͳͲͬͻ;
ͺͻͳͲͶͪͲͳͯͪUSBOTMBUJPͷͽͳΒ;ͳΒͰͫͳͶͪͲͪͷͳΓͰͪ͵ͪͼͬͰͪͳ
̽ͪͳͶͬͳͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ
̻ͻͳͭͻͳΒͰ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
̓ͼͽͪͽͳͅͳͪͳͶͬͳΕͳͲ͇ͼͽͻͬͳͰ
͑ͪ͘Ϳͪͻͳ͵·
͊ͻͫͼ͵ͳʹͶͰͽͺͳͼͪ·ͳͲ·ͺͰͽ͵ͪ97*ͭ·ͼͽͶͰͽͳΊ
̻Ͷͪͼͳ͵·̽ͻ;ͽͬͪ
ͼͻͫͼ͵ͰͼͶͬͰͼͼͽͳ
ͼͬ7
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ΒͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽͳͬͭͳͲͬͻ͉ͪ͆ͪͯΒ
ͳΕ
͇͋ͻ͵ͷͻͯͼͶͬ;
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̓ͻͪΕ
PQDJU
m ͼͯͰͽͪΓͷͪͪͶͳͲͷͳͲͬͻͪͳͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
ͼͪͰͺͳ
ͽͰͽͷtͼͬͰͽͳi̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͼͰͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽͺͷͳΔͰ;ͺͬͰΓͳ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽;ͪͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͊ͬͰͽͳ
͈Ͱͽͻͪͳ͈ͪͬͶͪͪ̈́ͳͷ;ͳͲͯͪͽΒ͵ͽͫͻͪͭͯͳͰ̸̺͊ͶͬΒͰͬ
̓ͪͯΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͭͶͪͰͲͪͼͬͰͪ
m̺̿;ΒͰͬͳΕ
͎ͻͳͼͬ;Γͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽;ͪͪͷͪͪ
ͼͽͳͻ;ͼ͈ͬͰͽͻͪͳ͈ͪͬͶͪͪ̈́ͳͷ;
̸͊͊
m
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͽͪ͵ͰͫͶͳͼ͵ͰͬͰͲͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͯͰΕͳͷͶͳͼͽͳͷͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰ
ͪͻͳͽ
ͼ̽ͪͳͶͷ**
ͳΒͰͼͰͲͪͶͪͭͪΔͰͺ͵ͪͲͪͶ͵ͪͺͻͰͼ;ͯͲͪͺͬͻͪͽͪ͵̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
;ͯͷͬͳ;͊ͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͪΒͬͰΕ;ͽͰͱͳ;ͳͷͪͺͻͳͺͬͰͼͽ;ͯͰͼͷͬͻͪΕͪΔ;ͬͳ
ͯͪ͋ͪΒͯͭͪΌͪΒΒͰͫͳͰͼͪͷͲͪͷͰΔͰ̹ͱΒͰͷͳͶͼͽͳͬͰΕͳͺͽͬͻͯͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͰ
ͺͯͫͼͽͳͲͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͯͼͽΒͪͼͽ͈ͬͻͰͷͪͬͪͱͰΕͳͷͫͳͪΒͳͷͪ
ͪͫͳ
ͫͳͶͪͼͺͻͪ;ͼͶ;ͪΒ;ΔͰͭͬͰͳͬͪͶͳͯͼͽͳ̸;ͽͻͳͽͰͻͺͶͪͳΒͰͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
ͯͭͪΌͪΒ͵ͪtͺͻͰͯͳͬ;ͯi
ͼ͵ͻ;ͺͳͷͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͷͺͼͶͰͯͳͪͷͪ
ͫ;ͯ;Εͳͯͪ
ΒͰͪͼͽͻͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͺͻͳͬ;͵ͪͷͭͫͻΒͰͳtͼͳͶͳͷͰͳͽͰiͺͻͳͼͽͪͶͳͰ
ͳͲͻͰͯͬͪͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͰ̺ͪͱΒͰͳͷͪͽͳ;ͬͳͯ;ͯͪͽ;ͯͲͪͽͺͻͰ̽ͪͳͶͬͭ
͌Ͱͳ͵ͪͺͷͳΔ;ͳͯͻ;ͭͳͳͲͬͻͳ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͯͳͺͶͷͪͽͳ͵ͳ͇ΒͰͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ
;͈ͻͳͲͻͰͼ͵ΒͺͬͰΓͳͳͲ
ͪͰͬͳͻͪΔͰͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ͵ͪͯͪͺͼͽͪΒͰͪͻ
ͳͽͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ͵ͭͯͳͰ
͵ͪͯͪͯͶͪͲͳͯͼ;ͺͪͻͳͽͬͪͳͻͪͲͷͳͷͳͶͪ
ͱͰΔͪ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Βͺͻͯͳͳ
ͺͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͳͷͪͺΒͪͪͰͻͪͲͶͭͰͯͪͳͼͽͳͰ
ͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͼͽͼͬͭͯͶͪͼ͵ͪͪͽͻ͋ͪ͵;ͪͻͰͭͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵Ͱͻͳͼͬ;ΓͰ͵ͽͳͽͻ
͵ͪͱͰ̹ͭtͺ͵ͪͲͪͺͻͰͷͪͷͰͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͼͬΒͰͷͳͶͼͻΌͰͬͻͪͽͳͬͳͷͳͼͬͰͽͶͼͽ
ͷΒͳͳΒ;
ͳ͵ͪͯͼͪͷͳ;ͼͽͪͼͷͻͽͼͭͪͪͯͪͳͼͽͻͱͰͷͰͳͺͽͷͰͳͲ
ͬͰͯͰ
ͺͼͪͯͳͷͰͪͺͻͰͼͽͷΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͻͯͳͽͰΓͪͳͺͻͪͻͯͳͽͰΓͪͳ͵ͪͪͻͪͳ
ͭͼͺͯͪͻͪͺͼͽͪͬͳͷͰͲͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͯͻͱͪͬͰͷͭͪͪi͆Ͱͽͪ͵ͳͲͻͳͳͽ
ͪͶͳ
ͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͳͳͼͽͬͰͽ
ͽͼͰͽͬͻͯͳͳ;Ͳͪͺͳͼ;ͶͰͼͬͼ͵ͭͺͳͼͪͻͪ͊ͽͪͳͼͶͪͬͪ
ͳͲͭͯͳͰ
;͵ΒͰͷͼͰ͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳt͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼͽͬͺͻͳͷͳiͰͼͳ
Ͷͷ
ͬͰΕͬΓͷ̹ͱΒͷ͆ͪͼͬ;ͪͳͯͪͪΔͳ
ͬͰͷͪͰͺͽͺ;ͳ
ͼͪͲͪΔͪ
ͽͰ͵ΒͰͪͼͶ;ͽͳͽͳ͵ͪͯͪΒͰmͳͲͷͰΌ; ͺͻͰͼͳͼͪͻͪͪ;
̽Ͱͪͳͷͪ
ͳ ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;
mͳͳͲ͵Βͳͺͫ;ͯͪͽͻͰͫͪͶͺͻ
ͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͺͯͬ;ΕͳͳΔͰͳ;ͯͪͼͰͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͳͲͶͳͶͪͷͳͶͼͽ̹ͱΒͪͳͯͪΒͰ
ΔͰͭͬͪͬͶͪͯͪͬͳͪͫͳͶͪͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͪͭͅͶͫͳͼͰͺͷͳΓͪͽͳͯͪͼ;ͽͰͳͽͰͻ
ͺͶͪͳΒͰͫͳͶͰ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳͳͻͳͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪͲͪ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ
͵;Ͷͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͪͯͪͫͳͫͳͶͰͳͻͶ͵ͳͫͶͳͼ͵ͰͽͷͯͭͪΌͪΒ;
͊ ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
t̀Ͱͽͪ ͺͯ ͷͶͪͯͳͷ ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͷͪi
JO ́ͼͽͻͳΒͪ ͏ͻͰ ̻ͻͰ **
ͽͪ͵ͬ
ͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͳͼ͵ͪͲ;Β;ͻͰͳ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͪ
ͫͻͪͽͪͳͼ;ͺͪͻͳ͵ͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͺͻͰͷͪͼͬͰͯͰΔ;̻ͻͳ
ͭͻͳΒͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͪt̓ͪͯͪͼͰ͵ͪͯͭͯ;ͶͯͪͼͶͰͺ;ͬͰ͵;ͺͻͳͶͳͳͪͻͼͽͬi
DG̻ͻͳͭͻͳΒͰ
͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
̽ͪͳͶͬͳͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ
͈ͬͰΓͰͲͰͷΓͪͷͪͳͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͷͪ̓ͼͬͪ ͺͻͳͻͳͺͻͰ̹ͬ̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
JÒͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰ
̓ͼͬͪ
͈ͻͳͲͻͰm̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̸͊ͶͪͬͰͬͪ
͈ͅͳΓ͵ͬͳ͵͈ͰͺͰ͵
͊ͺͷͰͳͳͲͪͼͻͰ
ͯͰͬͰ͵ͬͪͽͪͳͺͬͪͽͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͪͪͪͅ͵ͰͯͳΒͪ
͊͵ͺΒͰ
͈́ͬͳΕ
̻ͅͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵Ͱͻͳͼͬ;ΓͰ
͆ͬͳ͊ͪͯ
̀ͪͺͳͼͳͳͪͽͺͳͼͳ*
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͫͻ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
͊ͬͳͰͺ;ͲͯͪΔͪͷͱͰͼͰͻͪͲͷͳΓͪͽͳ͵ͻ;ͭͬͳͷͪͳͲ͵ΒͳΒͰͺͽͰ͵Ͷͪͳͳ
ͳΒͪͽͳͬͪͯͪͼͰͯͺ;ͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͱͳͬͽͺͳͼ͆ͼͳͳͼ;ΒΒ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵
ͫͳͶͳͪΒ
ͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͳΒͳͻ͵ͬͰͳͺͻͰͶͪͽͳ
ͼͬͰͽͭͻͼ͵ͳͯ;ͬͳͳ
ͪͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͳ;ͽͳͪΒ
ͯͰͪͼ͵ͷͪͽͬ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳΒͰ
ͲͪͼͰ
ͫͳͽͳΕͰͳ͵ͽͳ͵ͻ;ͭͬͪ
ͽͼͰ
ͳ;ͳͽͰͻͺͶͪͳΒͳ;ΔͰͭͬͷͱͳͽͳΒ;;ͺͪͯΓͳͬͪͭͶͪͪͬͪ̓ͪ͵ͫͳͶ
tͺͻͰ
ͯͳͬ;ͯiͺͬͻͪͽ͵ͪͬͳͯͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
͵ΒͰΒͰͫͳͽ;ͽͳͪͶͪͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ;
ͻͰͪͶΒ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Βͻͪͬͳ
ͯͬͰͯͰΒͰͯͬͻ;ͪͭͽͬͬͰ͵ͯͳΒͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵Βͻͪͬͳ
ͺͼͶ;ͱͳͶ͵ͪͬͪͱͪ;ͺͻͳͪͽͪ͵ͪͲͪͭͻͪΌͰΔͰ
ͬͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͶͳ͵ͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
͈ͼͽ;ͺͳͺͻͰͼ͵ΒͳΒͰͬͯͳͼͽͬͪͻͪΔ;͵;Ͷͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͷ
ͱͰͼͰͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͽͳͳͲΒΒͰͯͭ;ͭͶͪ
͵ͻͲͳͼͽͻͳΒͪͽ̽;ͪͬͭͯͼͪͺͻͰͷͪ
ͰͬΒ;ͼͺͷͰͳ
͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͪ;ͳͬͰΕͫͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͺͪͱΓͳͬͭͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪ
͋ͺͳͽͪΔͰͺͼͷͪͽͻͪΕͰͷͬͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ;ͻͶ͵ͷͼͶͰͯ;͇ͯͪͬΒͰ
;ͰͯͪΒͰ;ͪͻͰͭͪͷͪͺͬͰΓͪͳͲͯͪͽͳͯͺͻͰ;ͲͳͷͪΔͪͬͶͪͼͽͳͯͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ
Δͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪΓ̽;ͪͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͷͭͲͪ͵;ͺΓͰtͳͼͺͬͰͯͪ
ΔͰͷͭͻͰͪi͵ͪͺͼͶͰͯͳͷͼͰΕͪΔͪͭͻͳͱͰͼͪͬͰͼͽͳͲͫͭͪͼͳͶͰͰͬͰͼͷͻ
ͽͳ ͇ ;ͺͻ
ͭͽͬ ͺͼͰͼͳͬ
ͭͬͻͳ ͽͪͽͳͳ ͼͬͰͽͪ ͳ ͺͻͶͪͲͼͽͳ
ͬͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͭ
ͻͪͲͷͳΓͪ tͼͽͻͪͷ ͳ ͰͳͲͻͰͳͬͷi ͪͼ; ͼͷͻͽͳ
ͯͻͽͳ
ͺͻͳͺͷͳͼͶͳͪ̽ͻ;ͭͳͯͶͪͲͪ͵͎ͻͳͼͽͬ͊ͽͭͪͽͻͪͱͳͲͪͽͳͽ;ͬͳΔͳͼͳͶͪ
ͪΒͬͳͰ̹ͭͻͯͳͰͳͼͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ
ͳͽͪͺͼͶͪͳͰͪͺͼͽͶ͈ͪͪͬͶͪ͠Ͱͯ
ͪ͵Ͱ;ͫͳͪΒͰͰͼ;ͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͰͳͽͳͽ;ͶͪͳΒͰͼͬΒͰͺͬͰΓͰͺͽͺͳͼ;ΒͰ͵ͪ
tͭͻͰͳͻͪͫiͳͶͳtͭͻͰͳͳͰͯͼͽΒͳͻͪͫ͊ͽͰͿͪ͵ͻͪΓi͌ͺͻ͵ͼͽͷͰ
;ͬͷͺͰͻͳͯ;̽;ͪͼͰ
ͪͼͽΒͰΕͳͯͪͺͻ;ͱͳͺͻͳͬͪͽΓͳͬͫΒͪΔͰΔͰͺͻͰ
ͬͻͪͽͪ
;Ͱ͵ͳͷͺͻͳͭͯͪͷͪͳͲͻͪͲͳͽͰͭͪͽͳͬͳͲͻͪͱͪͬͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ͋ͪ͵;
ͺͬͰΓͳ͊ͬͰͽͷ͆ͳ͵Ͷͳ;̽ͫͻ;ͽͳ m
͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰtͶ;͵ͪͬͳͬͻͪͭi
ͪͬͰΔͰͭͬͭͪͯͪͭͪͭ;ͻͰ;tͻͬͺͭͳͫͰΓͳi͵ͪ͵ͫͳͷ;Ͱͷͭ;Εͳͯ
ͶͪͲͪ͵ͪͺͻͰͼͽ͢ͰͭͬͯͼͺͻͰͷͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷͯͫͳΒͰͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͳͲͻͪͲ
;;ͬͯ;̽ͪͳͶͬͭͲͫͻͳ͵͈ͪͯͬͶͪͰΕͳͳͯͰΒ;͵ͽͳ;ͳͽͰͽ;ͼͬͰͽͻͯͰ
ͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
ΔͰͭͬͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪΒͰͺͫͻΒͪͼͬͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͰ
ͫͰͲͫͲͳͻͪ
ͪͽͽͳͷͼͰͱͳͽͳΒͪͰͺΒͪͬΓ;Β;;Ͳͫͻͳ͵;
ͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͻͪͼͶͬͳΒͰ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͵ͪtͷΕͭͪͳͼͪͷͯͻͱͪͬͭͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
;;͵ͪͼͬͰͽͭͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ
ͪ ͌ͻͪi ̽ͳͼͽͪͳͻͪΔͰ ͯ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ ͳ ͬͰͲͳͬͪΔͰ Ͳͪ ͵ͻͪΓͪ ͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪ
͵ͪ ͺͻͪͬͭ ͺͻͰͽͯͳ͵ͪ Ͳͪͺͪͱͪ ͼͰ ͳ ; ͯͳͺͶͷͪͽͳ͵Β ͭͻͪΌͳ
ͪ ͺͻͳͷͰͻ ;
ͺͬͰΓͳ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽;ͪͪͳͲͷͪΒͪ
͵ΒͷͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰͼͽͪͻ;̻ͻͳͭͻͳΒ;ͻ͵ͬ;
͊ͬͰͽ͈ͭͰͽͻͪ;̓ͻͳͳ͌ͼͰͶͰ͵ͽͳͬͳͲͶͱͰΒͭͰͰͪͶͭͳΒͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
;
͵ΒΒͰͺͷͳΔͰͪ
ͼͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ͵ͪtͺͻͪ;;͵ͭͼͺͯͳͪͼͪͷͬͶͪͼͭͪ
͊ͳͷͰͪͼͬͰͽͭͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
ͳ;;͵ͼͬͰͽͭͳͺͻͰͬͳͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͻͪi͋ͪ͵ͪͬ
̽;ͪͬͼͽͪͬ
͵ΒͳͯͪΒͰͼͬͰ
ͼͪͷͰͪͷͰͻ;ͯͪͼͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ;ͬͻͼͽͳ;ͼͬͰͽͳ
ͽͰΓͰ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽΒͰ
ͼͳͶͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͫͳ;ͷͰ͵ͪ;ͽ͵;ͳͭͯͳ
Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ̽;ͪ
ͽͰ͵ͫͶͰͼͽͪ
ΒͰͯͬͪͳͲͫͰͭͪͼͷͻͽ͊;ͪͬͪΔͰͼͫͶͳͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ͻͪΒͰͷͫͳͶΒͰͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬ͵ΒͰΒͰͪΔͰͭͪͼͽͪͬͳͶͽͻͪΒͪͺͰͪͽ
ͪͰͺͼͻͰͯ
ͼͰͯͻͪͲͳͶͳͪͯͼͺͻͰͷͪͰͬΒ;ͼͺͷͰͳ͋ͪ͵;ͺͬͰΓͳͳͲ
͵Βͷ͊ͬͰͽ͚ͭͻΌͪ;͈Ͷ͵ͷͯͪͻ;ΒͰ͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;
ͼͬͰͼͽͪtͭͪͼͽͻͪͭ
ͪͼͪi
ͷͶͳͲͪͷͳͶͼͽ͎ͻͳͼͽͪ͊ͺͪͼͪͽ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͰͺͷͳΔͰ;Ͱͭͪͽͳͬͷ
͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͬͰΕ͵ͻͲ;ͫͳͪΒͰ;Ϳͻͷ;Ͷ;tͼͬͰͽͳͺͻͪͻͯͳͽͰΓͳͳͻͯͳͽͰΓͳ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼͽͬͪͷͳi
ͼͪͷͰͻͷͯͪ;͵ͪͱͰͪͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͼͽͼͬͭͪͼͶͰΌͪͺͻͰͼͽͶͪ
͈ͼͶͰͯͳͪͫͶͰͼͽͳͳͺͻͰͼͽͪ͵ͪͻͪͽͳͺͯͪͳͭͯͳͰͫͳͶΒͰ
ͬͳͯͼͶͪͫΓͰΔͰ̽;ͪͬͰ͵ͽͻͶͰͪͯͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͷ
ͽΒͰͲͫͳΓͺΓ;
ΓͪͶΔͰͭͬͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͺͶͱͪΒ͇ͼͬͰͬͰΕͰͷͼͰΕͪΔ;;ͭͻͱͰͼͽͳͪΒͫΓͰ
ͼͬͰͯͳ̽;ͪͬͪͼͽΒͪΔͰ̺ͯͪͯͰͰͳΒͰͯͫͳΒͰͺͻͪͬͭͻͪΌͪͼͽͬͪͳͪͲͳͶͪ
ͲͪͼͰͫͰͳͼͬΒ;ͺͻͯͳ;͌ͽͪ͵ͬͳͷ͵Ͷͼͽͳͷͪ
͵ͪͯͪͳ͵ͪ͵ͳΒͰͬͪΓͪͶͯͪ
ͼͰͲͪͷͰͻͪͻ͵ͬͳ
ͫͳͶͳͼ;͵ͪͼͽͬͻͰͳͺͭͯͳ;ͼͶͬͳͯͪͼͰ
;ͺͻͶͰΕͰ
ͳͶͳͶͰͽ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ;ͬͻͼͽͳ;ͻͰͯͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͋͵ͳͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͽͭͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽ
ͳͼ;ͪͷͺͲͪͽͳͳͲ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳͳͲͬͻͪ
ͬͰΕͪͼͬ;ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔͪͷͶͪΌͰͭͫͳͭͻͪͿͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵͈ͭͯͻͫͳͲͬͰͽͪͬͪΔͰ̻ͻͳͭͻͳΒͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͪͷͱͯͪͼͰͷͱͰͽ;
ͷͪͳͽͳͱͳͬͷ;ͼͺͷͰͷͬͰ͵ͬͰͰͷ;ͺͻͰͯͪΔ;ͳͶͳ͵ͻͳΕͰΔͰͷͰ͵ͭ
ͼͪͯͪͰͺͲͪͽͭͳͲͬͻͪ̓ͪ͵ͫͳͶ
;ͰͳͺͳͼͪΒͰ
ͺͳͼ;Β;ΕͳͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͺͼͰͭͪͲͪͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳͷͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻͷͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵Ͱͪ
ͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ ͳ ͫͻͰͯ FMFWBUJP ͽͰͶͪ ͳ USBOTMBUJP ͳͲ ͭͻͫͪ ; ͵ͳͬͽ ͺͻͰͯͳ ;Ͳ
ͺͷΕ;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͽͺͼͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͱͳͽͳΒͪ͢ͰͭͬͳͭͶͪͬͳͰͶͰͷͰͽͳ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
ͼ;;ͯͰͼΒͪͬΓͪΔͰ;ͼ;ͫͭ;ͭͯͷͬͰ͵;
ͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͭͻͫͪͳͺͯͳͲͪΔͰ
ͽͰͶͪ
ͺͻͪΕͰͲͪͷͰΔͳͷͪ͵ͪͽΒͰͫͶͪͭ;ͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;
ͺͻͰͼͽͰͶͪ;ͬ
ͪͻͳͽ ͳͲͻͪΌͰ ͵ͳͬͽ
ͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪ ͺͽΔͰͷ ;ͯͽͬͻͷ ͯͰͶͬͪΔ;
ͷͽͳΒ;
ͺͻͰ ͼͬͰͭͪ ͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͷ ̓ͻͲ ͽͪ ͺͽͪ ͷͰͼͽͪ ͺͻͫͳΒͪΒ; ͼͰ ͳ
ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͰͫͳͷͭͶͰͳͷͪͽͳͳͲͬͰͼͽͪ
ͬͰΕͳͳͶͳͷͪΔͳ
ͼͽͰͺͰͬͰͻͯ
ͼͽΒͼͽͳͅͰΌ;ΔͳͽͻͰͫͪͼͬͻͼͽͪͽͳ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͰͯͪͼ;tͷͰͯͳΒ;ͷͳiͽͻͼͽͻ;͵ͭ
ΒͪͬΓͪΔͪ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ ͫͳͶͳ Ͱ͵ͶͳͼͳΒͪͻ ͳ ͳͭ;ͷͪ ΔͰͭͬͰ Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰ ͊ ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪͰ
ͽͬͻΌͰΔͰ ͯͪ ΒͰ tͺͻͪΌͰi ͽͰͶ ͳͷͪͶ ͫͶͳ͵ tͰͶ͵;ͺͳi
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͫͪͶͼͪͷͬͪͳͷͽͳΒ;ͳͷͪͬͻͼͽ;ͺͻͳͽͰ;ͺͳͼͪͳͷͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͳͷͪͳ
ͺͻͬͰͻΓͳͬΒͰͯͯͪͯͪͪͼ͆ͪͺͼͻͰͯͪͪͳͫͳͷͭͶͯͪͺͽͬͻͯͳ
ͪͬͯ;͋ͻ͵ͷͻͯͼͶͬ;ͯͪͼͰͽͰͶ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͬͰΕ;̀ͬͰͪ;ͭͶͪͼͳͶ
͵ͪͼͬͰͽ͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͽΓͰͼͽͳ;ͬͻͼͽͳͶΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͽͰ
Ͷ;ͪΒͺͽͬͪͳΒ;͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ͈ͪͼͰͫ;ͺͪͱΔ;
ͲͪͬͻͰΌ;ΒͰͳ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͽͬͻΌͰΔͰͯͪΒͰͺͯͳͲͪΔͰͽͰͶͪͫͪͬΓͰ;ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ;
ͪͻͳΒͰͻͰΒͼ͵ͭͼͪͫͻͪͳͻ͵ͬͰͭ͵Ͷͳͻͪ
ͪͻͳͽͼͪͲͬͪͳͲͪͽ;ͺͻͳͶͳ͵;
̸͵ͫͳͫͳͶͬͰͻͯͼͽΒ
ͫͳ;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͪͽͯͪ;ͬͻͽͰΔͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰͳΒͰͫͳͶͼͺͽͪͺͻͰͼ
;ͪͰͶ;ͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͳͼͽͻͳΕͪ
ͼ͵ͷͬͳͯ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͽͬͪΔͪ
ͬͰΕͻͭͪͳͲͬͪͫͻͰͯͳͲͬͪͳͪͳ
Ͱ͵ͪͬͻͼͽͪ͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͰ͌ͺͻͳͶͭͽͪ͵ͬͷͽ;ͷͪͰΔ;͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͪͳͶͰͫͳͳ
ͻͰͳ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͪͳͲ͇ͼͽͻͬͳͰͯͪΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳtͺͼͶͰͯͰͬͰͽͭͯͳͪͺͻͭͶͪ
Ͱ ͵;ͻͲͳͬͪ
ͲͪͼͬͰͪi
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̀ͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯͷͭͫͻΒͳͰͺͲͪͳͪ͵ΒͰͺͻͪͽͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͺͻͼͶͪ
ͬΓͪΔͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͰͶͰͷͰͽͳΔͰͭͬͭ͵;ͶͽͪΒͰͼ;ͪΒͺͽ
ͺ;ͳΒͰͯͪͪͼͺͲͪͽͻͰͰΔͰ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͿ;ͰͻͪͻΒͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪͳ
;Ͳͽ
ΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͺͻͳͷͰͻͰͶͳͰͼͪ;ͬͪͰ;ͳͲͬͻͷͫͶͳ͵;ͳͼͻͰͯͳͳ͋ͳ
ͼͽͪͯͪͻͯͳͰͶͰͷͰͽͳ
;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͬͰΕͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͭͭͻ
ͫͪͻͯͪͰͶͳ͵ͪͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͳͼ;ͼͪͷͪͻ͵ͬͪͷͪ;ͲͶͰΒ
ͺͯͲͰͷͪͭͻͫͳ
ͪ;ͲͪͺͪͯͷͯͰͶ;ͻͪͷͪ
ͫͰͶͰͱͰͪͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͳͷͷͰͻͷͰͻͳͷͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪ
ͭͷ
ͳ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͪͯͭͻͫͳͺͻͽͻͰͽͪͼͶͳ͵ͪ;ΔͰͭͬΒͫͶͳͲͳͳ͌ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼ
ͬͰΕͼͬͰͽͪͷͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͷͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͷ
ͳͼ;ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΓͰͳͺͲͪͷͳͼͶͳ
ͳͪͶͭ;ͼͪͷͭ͵ͽͳͽͻͪͳΔͰͭͬͳ;ͺ;ΕͰͳͼͪͬͰͽͯͪͬͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵PͻͰͰ
ΔͰΒͰͳͲ;ͲͰͽͲͫͭͽͭͪͽͼͰͽ;
͵ͪͳ;ΒͰͯͷͯͻ;ͭͷͺͲͪͽͷͺͻͳͷͰͻ;
;ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͲͬͪͷͫͶͳ͵;ͷͭ;ͺͻͪͽͳͽͳͯΒͰͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪ
Δͪ͵ͽͳͽͻͪ
ͪͶͳͳͳͯͰͶ͵ͺͶͳͽͳ͵Ͱͺͻ;͵ͰΔͰͭͬͭͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͪ͆Ͱͺ
ͼͻͰͯͪͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͫͳͶΒͰͺͯͳͲͪΔͰΔͰͭͬͭͽͰͶͪͳͲ
ͭͻͫͳͰ;ͲͪͺͪͯͷͽͻͪͬͰΒ;
͵ΒͪͼͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪͬͰͻͬͪͽͳ
ͪͶͪͲͳͺͯͬͰΕͳͷͯ
ͯͬͪͻͪͼ͵ͪͷͰͻͷͰͻͪͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͪ͊ͫͲͳͻͷͪͽͯͪ;̽ͰͪͳͷͪͳΒͰͫͳͶ
ͪͻͰͶ͵ͳͳͼ͵ͺͪͬͪΔͪ
ͰͷͪͷͼͪͲͪΔͪͽͪͷͺͶͱͪΒ;ͳ͵ͼͽͻ;͵ͳ
ΒͳͽͰͭͻͫͳͰ́ͲͬͰͼΒͰ
;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͯͪΒͰͪ͵ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ͵ͻͪΓͰ
ͬͽͰͶͺͶͱͰ;ͻͪͼ͵ͪͯͻͬͰͳ͵ͳͬͽ
ΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͼͪ;ͬͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ͵
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭ͵ͬͰͭͪͲͪͷͽͳ͇ΒͰͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͪͺͪͼͷͰ
ͼͽ
ͳͼͺͻͰͯͶͽͪͻͪ
ͽͪ͵ͽΒͰΒͰͯͷ;ͱͷͼͽͻͪͷͺͻͳͼͶΔͰ;Ͳͳͼͽͳ
ͺͽ͵;ͺͶͳͼͽ;ͫͪ
ͪͲͪͯΔͷ;Ͳͳ͵ͼͽͪͼ͋ͷͺͶͱͪΒ;ͫͳͶͳͼ;ͺͻͳͶͪͭ
ΌͰͳͫͶͳ͵ͳͪͻͳͽͯ;ͫͻͰͲͳ;͵ͻͪͼ͵ͬͰͭͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͳͲͬͰͯͰͼͪͷͪͬͳ
ͯΓͳͬͳͷͼͽͻͪͪͷ͇ͪͻͪͷͰͽͪͶͳͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻͳͰͺͻͰͺͶͰͽͰͰͽͻͪ͵Ͱ
ͻͲͰͽͰ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
ͅͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͿͶͻͪͶͳͳͲͷͻͿͳͷͽͳͬͳ
͵Βͳͼ;;ͲͪͬͻΒͫͻͪͯͳͫͳͶͳͫΒͰͳͳ
ͺͲͶͪΕͰͳ͋ͻͰͫͪͶΒͰͯͪͻͰΓͰͿͳ;͵ͻͪͼ͵ͳͬͽͪ
ͺ;͵;ͺΒͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͳͺΒͰ
ͯͳͼͽͳͷͪ
ͽͰͶͽͬͻͳͳͯͰΒ;ͻͪΒͼ͵ͷͪͼͰΓ;;͵ΒͰͷͺͻͰͫͳͬͪͺ͵Βͳ͵
͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͿ;͵ͳΒͰ
ͫͳΒͰͽ͵;ͶͽͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͪΒͬͳͰͭͻͪͭͪ͢Ͱͭͬ
ͫͶͳ͵m͵ͬͰͭͼͺ͵ͶͺͰͷͪͬͳͼ͵ͳͷͭͪͻͳͷͪmͷͭ;ΕͪͬͪΒͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰ
ͬͳͯͽͬͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͰͶͳͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;
ͪ
ͺͻͰͯͽͭͪ
ͳ;ͺͻͪ
ͱΔͪͬͪΔͰͪͻͳͽͳ͵;ͶͽͳͻͪͯΔͳ
ͷͰΌ;͵ΒͳͷͪͳͶͰͱͪΔͰͳͼͺͯ͵ͬͰͭͪ
ͺͯͼͽͪ͵;ͽ ͬͰͻͷ ; ͷΕ ;ͯͰͼͭ ͳͼͰΓͰΔͪ ͈ͶͱͪΒ
ͻͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͳ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͳͿ;͵ͳΒͪͯͰͪͼ͵ͭ͵ͳͬͽͪͳͷͪͶͳͼ;͵Γ;;;Ͷͭ;;;ͫͶͳͪͬͪΔ;
ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͰͽͺͭͻͪͿͳΒͰͻ͵ͬͰͭͰͽͰͻͳΒͰͻͪ̓ͪͼͻͰͯͼͽͬQSBFTFOUJBͰͼͬͰͽͳ
ͽͰΓͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͲͬͪͽͰͷͰΓ;ͳͯͰΒ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
ͪͽΒͰͪͼͬͰͽͷ͵ͻͪΓ;
͆ͬͼͽͰͰͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͼͽͪͽ;ͼ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͺͯͬ;ͰΒͰͳΔͰͭͬͳͷͺ
ͼͷͻͽͳͷ ͿͻͰͼ͵ͺͻͽͻͰͽͷ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ ΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͳͷ
ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͳͷ ͪ ͼͽ;ͺ;
ͳͲͪͯ͵ͳͬͽͪ
ͺͼͬΒͺͻͳͶͳͳͯͷͪͪ͵ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪͭͯͳͰ́͵
ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ ͽͰ ͺͻͬͰ ͼͬͰͽͰ ͼͶͳ͵Ͱ ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͰ ͳ ͺͻͪͽͰΕͳ ͪͽͺͳͼͳ ͬͰ͵ͬͰͳͶͳ ͼ;
͵Γ;ͳͳͬͰͷͪͼͰͽΓͳͬͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵;ͪͼͽͪ͵;͵;Ͷͽͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ
;ͪͽͺͳͼ;Ͳͪ
Ͱ͵ͪt͊ͬͰͽͳ͵ͻͪΓ̹ͭͷͺͻͼͬͰΕͰͳ͊ͽͰͿͪ͌ͻ***
͵ͽͳͽͻͬͭͼͬͰͽͭ
ͻͪͷͪi
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪΒͰ͵ͪ͵ͺͻͳͼͳͯͰͪͼ͵ͳͻͪͷ͎ͻͳͼͽ;
͵ΒͳͭͪͫͶͪͭͼͳΓͪͳͲ
ͣͅͻͬͳΕ͡;ͫͳ͵ͬͳΕ
͊ͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͯ;ͫͻͰͲ;ͳͼͽͳͷͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪ͠;ͭͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m͑ͪͅ͵ͽͪ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͪͻͳͲͳͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
m
ͼͶ
͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
*CJE
̹̾ͪ͵ͪͶͬͪ
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳ;ͳͼͽ͵ͬ͵;Ͷ·ͽͪͼͬΊͽΆ
JO̺ͼͽͻͳͼͽͳͪͼ͵ͳͰ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳ
m ͼͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͷ
͈̽ͺͬͳΕ
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͪ
m ͼͪͼͽͪ
ͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
FBEFN
4ISJOFPG,JOH4UFGBO6SPØ***%FǁBOTLJ
JO#Z[BOUJVN
'BJUIBOE
1PXFS m
FE)$&WBOT
/FX:PSL
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼͰͭͷͰͽͪͰ͍ͫͪ;͵ͳΒ;ͼͶͳ͵Ͱͽ͵ͻͳͬͪͪͽͺͳͼ;ͲͺͻͽͻͰͽt͈ͻͳͷͳ
̺Ͷͪͯͳ͵
̻ͼͺͯͰ
͈ͪͽ͵ͻͪͽͻͰ
ͺͻͳͼͳͷΒͰͷΓͰΔͰ
ͻͪͫͪͽͬΒͰͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ͵ͻͪ
Γͪ
ΒͰͻͽͳͺͻͳͼͳͷͻ͵ͬ;ͫͱͪͼͽͬͰ;
ͼͪͼͳͷͷΒͳͷ͵ͻͪΓͰͷ͊ͽͰͿͪͷ
̻ͶͰͯͪͷͪͺͻͺͪͯΓͳͬͷͳͽͰͶ
ͼͽΒͰΕͳͪͯͭͻͫͷͼͬΒͳͷͳͫΒͳͷͼͰͽͬͭ
ͼ;ͯͪ͋Ͱͫͳͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͷ
͊ͬͰͯͻͱͳͽͰΓ;
ͺͷͳͶ;ΒͷͰ;ͯͪͼ;ͯΔͳi͆ͪͼͬ;ͼͪ
ͯͻͱͪΒͪͪͽͺͳͼͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͼ;ͯͪͬͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͶͳͯͪΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͽ;ͺͻͳ͵ͪ
ͲͪͰͼͪͷ͵ͪ͵ͽͳͽͻͻ͵ͬͰͬͰΕͳ;ͼͬΒͼͽͬ;ͼͬͰͽͭͲͪͼͽ;ͺͳ͵ͪͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
͵͵ͻͰͽ
ͼͳͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽;ͪͪ͋Ͱͼͺͻͽ;ͷͪͰΔͰ;ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰͯ
ͺ;ΔͰΒͰͬͳͷͲͪͺͪͱͪΔͳͷͪ
͵Βͪͼ;ͲͪͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͯͳͲ;ͲͰͽͭͲͪͪΒͪ
͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͼͺͻͪͬͷΒͰ;͵ͪͲͪͪͺͻͽͳͬ;ͻͰͼͽ͵ΒͪͺͼͽΒͳͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͰͰͭ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͼͽͪͽ;ͼͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͳͺΒͰͯͳͳͯͰͶͬͪͪͽͺͳͼͪ͋ͪ͵ͬͰͼ;ͻͰͳ
ͺͼͷͪͽͻͪΔ;ͼͺͼͽͬͰͭͺͻͺͪͯΓͳͬͭͽͰͶͪ
ͳͼͺΓͪͬͪΔͰͼͽͻͪͪͯ͊ͽͻͪͭ
ͼ;ͯͪ
ͪͪͻͳͽͷͶͫͪͲͪͺͷͳͶͬͪΔͰ;ͼ;ͯΔͰͷͪͼ;͋ͳͳͼ͵ͪͲͳ
ͰͽͻͰͫͪ
ͺͼͰͫͪͭͶͪͪͬͪͽͳ
;ͺͽͺ;Βͼ;ͼ;ͺͻͽͼͽͳͼͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͷͪ;͵ͷ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͷͼ;ͽͪͼͽͬ;͊ͽͳͰͼͰ;ͽͳͼͪ͵ͯͪͼ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷͺͻͳͺͳͼͪͰͻͰ
ͳ͵ΒͰ
Ͳͪͺͻͪͬ
ͳͲͻͪͱͪͬͪΒ;ͽͰΔͪͳͪͯͰΔͰͭͬͭͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͪͳͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͭ
͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽;ͪͪ͌ͺͻͪͬͼͽͭͪͽͪͪͯͭͻͫͪͰͶͳͪΒͰͼͽͰͯͻͪͭͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻ͵ΒͳͭͬͻͳͪͻͳͽͷͽͻͰ;ͽ͵;;ͺͻͰͼ;ͪͼͽͪ͵ͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ
Ͱ͵Β
ͬͻͼͽͳͺͰͽͰͰͽͪͺͰ;ͲͯͳͲͪΔͪ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬ
͵Βͪ
ͳͭͶͰͯ
ͳΒͰͫͳͶͪͶͳ
Ͱͪͺͻͽͳͬ;ͻͰͼͽͳ͌Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳ͵;Ͷͽͪ
;ͳͻͰͷ
ͪͶͳͽͰͷͰΓͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͻͰͳ
ͫͳΒͰͳͼͶͳ͵ͪͳͺͻͭͻͪͷ͵ΒͳΒͰͳͳ͵ͬͳͻͺͼͷͻͽͭͺͻͽͻͰͽͪ̽Ͱ
ͪͼ͵͇ͭΒͰͫ;ͬͪͽͪͳ͵ͰͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͰͪͳ͵ͼͽͪͼ
ͺͼͬΒͺͻͳͶͳͳ
ͪ͵ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͋ͼ;ͳ͵Ͱ͎ͻͳͼͽ͈ͪͪͽ͵ͻͪͽͻͪͳͼͬͰͽͭ
͈ͬͪͪ͠ͻͰͽͰͰͪΒ;ͱΒͼͽͻͪͳ
ͪͪͼͰͬͰͻΒ
ͪͯ͵ͳͬͽͷ
̹ͭͻͯͳͰͼ
ͷͪͶͳͷ͎ͻͳͼͽͷͳͼͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ
ͪΒͺͽͬͪͳΒͰͭͷͶͳͽͬͰͭͲͪͼͽ;ͺͳ͵ͪ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ́ͼͽͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͳͶͳͼͽͳͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͰΒ;ͱͯͳ͵
ͼͽͪͼͪ
ͪͼͺͻͪͷͺͼͷͻͽͭͶͳ͵ͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭmͼͬͰͽͳ͆ͳ͵ͶͪͳͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͽͰͿͪ
͈ͻͬͷ;Ͱͳ͵͆ͪͳͼͽͷͲͳͯ;ͪͼͪͪͶͪͲͰͼͰ͵ͶͼͪͶͪͿͻͰͼ͵ͳ͵ͪ
͎ͻͳͼͽ͈ͪͪͽ͵ͻͪͽͻͪ;ͺͻͳͲͻ;̽ͰͳͲͳͼͪͳͪͯΔͳͷͼͶͳ͵͈ͪͻͳ;ͭͽͬΓͰͭ
ͺͻͰͼͽͶͪ͋ͪΒͼͶΒͰͬͳͽͳ;ͰͰͼͪͽͶ͵ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷ
ͳΒͳͼͰͰ͵ͬͳͬͪͶͰͽͪͶͪ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪͼͶͰΌͳͬͪΔͪ
ͺͯͬͶͪͰΕͳͽͪΒͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͳͽͰͯͰͳͲͳͷͳͲͫͻͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͳͼͳͭͳΒͪ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͪ ̈́Ͳͪ ͼͽͪͬΓͪ ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͰ ͺͻͰͯ ͬͰͶͳ͵; Ͱͯ;ͷͳ;
͊ͽͰͿͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ
ΒͰͯͳͳͷͰΌ;ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͷ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͳͷͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͯͫͳͶͳ
͵;Ͷͽ
ͳΒͰͲͪͰ͵ͪtͼͬͰͽͳi̓ͪ͵ͭͯͯͪͼͰͺͻͽ;ͷͪͳͽͪͳΔͰͳͪm͵ͪ
ͷͪ͵ͪͳͼͺͳͼͳͬͪͪͳͶͳͺͻͷͳΓͰͼͽͪͬmͼͳͭ;ͻΒͰͯͪͪ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͺ
͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͼͬ;ͼͶͱͰͼͽͳͺͻͽͳͬ;ͻͰͼͽͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͳͯͼͪ
̓ͶͰͫΓͳͬͯͼͼͳͪͺͻͰͷͪ;ͬͳͯͪΒͰͳ;ͺͳͼͪͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰ
ͭͪ;̽;ͪͬͳͷͯ͵;ͷͰͽͳͷͪͳͲͯͪͽͳͷͪ͵ͰͬͭͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔ͇ͪ̽Ͱͪ
ͼ͵ͷ ͵ͪ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ; ͺͻͬͳ ͺ;ͽ ͭͬͻͳ ; ͺͬͰΓͳ ͊ͬͰͽͷ ͈Ͱͽͻ; ͳ ͈ͪͬͶ;
ͪ ̈́ͳͷ; ͳͲ ; ͽͷ ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ; ͳͲͼͳ ͬͪͱͪ ͼͽͪͬ ͲͪͪΒ; ͼͬͰͽͳ
ͷͽͳΒ; ; ͬͶͪͯͪͶͪ͵ͷ ͺͻͭͻͪͷ; m ͼͺͼͽͬͰͷ
͵ͪ ͳ ͼͬΒͳ ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͰͽͯͳ͵ͪ͋ͪ͵͵ͪͱͰ
;ͼͬΒͼͽͬ;ͰͬͳͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ
ͯͪΒͰ
tͬͳͯͰͬ;ͫͶͪͭͯͪͽͪwͻͯͳͽͰΓ;
ͼͬͰͽͷ͵ͻͪΓ;͌ͻ;i
ͽͭͪΒͰͺͯͼͽͪ
͵ͶͪͫͪͬΓͪΔͰͺͻͺͳͼͪͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱͯ;ͱͼͽͳmͺͯͳͲͪΔͰͳͫͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͻ͵ͬͰ͋ͼͬͰͯͰΔͰͯͫͳΒͪͺ;ͼͷͳͼͪ;ͼͬͰͽͶͼͽͳͳͲΒͪͬͰͼͺͰͽ͵ͪͪͻͰͭͰ
mͫͰͲͪͪͶͭͳΒͪͷͰΌ;̽;ͪͬͳͷͺͬͰΓͪͷͪm͵ͻͪΒΔΒͼͬͻͼͳͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͭ
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͻͼͽͬͪ͌ͻ͵ͬͪͷͪ͵ΒͰͼ;ͼͪͭͻͪͯͳͶͳ
͵ͪͱͰ̽;ͪ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͳͼ;
ͯͪͶͳͯͪͼͰtͺͶͱͰΔͳͬͪͽͰͶͪ
ͲͪΔͳͬͼͬͰͽͳͼͺͷͰi
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͯͯͪΒͰͯͪ
tΔͳͬͰͼͬͰͽͰͷͽͳͯͪͻ;Β;ͳͼͰΓͰΔͪ
ͶͰͰͷͭͰͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͰͫͶͰͼͽͳͳ;ͻͪ
ͽͬͳͷͪͼͪͳͺͶͰͷͰͳͳͷͪͯͼͰͺͫͰͯ;ͼͬͷͽͪͪͼͽͬ;iͳͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ
Ͱͺͻͺ;ͽͪͯͪͪͭͶͪͼͳ͵ͪ͵ͼͰͼͪͷ;ͬͰͻͳ;ͽͪ;ͯͰͼͪt̸ͳͪͰͳͼ;
ͬͳͯͰͶͰͽΒͰ̹ͭͯͪͻͬͪͳͷͪ͵Βͳ̻ͪͬͶͰi͆ͪͼͬ;ͽͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳ
ͼͻͰͭͼͽͪͬͪͷͭ;ͼͰͪͼͶ;ͽͳͽͳͺͻͪͬͳ
ͯͻͱͪͬͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͻͪͲͶͲͳ͵Βͳ
ͼ;ͪͬͰͶͳ̽;ͪͪͪͽͯͪͺͻͳͬͪͽͳ;ͼͽͪͬΓͰΔͰͰͬͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ;͵ͬͳͻ;ͺͻ
ͭͻͪͷͪͬͳͼ͵ͳͺͻͰͽͰͲͳΒͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ͵;ͶͷͳͳͻͪͺͻͭͶͪͰΔͰͷͪͻͼͽͬͪ
̽;ͪ
ΒͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͪͽͳ͵ͪͺͽͺͻ;ͼͺͼͽͬͰͭͻͯͼͶͬͪ͌
ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͺͷͳͻͰΔͰͼͰͬͷ;ͼͺͷͰͷͺͽͬͻΌ;Β;ͯͳͺͶͷͪͽͳ͵ͳͼͺͳ
ͼͳ;͵Βͳͷͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͼͳͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽtͼͬͰͽͳiͽͪ͵ΒͰ;ͺͬͰΓͳͪͻͪ̽;ͪͪͲͪ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
͊ͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵Ͷ;͵ͯ̓ͱΓͪͳͲͳͺͬͰΓͳ͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;Ͳͪ͊ͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵Ͷ;
;͈ͼͪͳͳͲͭͯͳͰ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
̽;ͪͬ;;ͽͻͪΔͳ͵ͿͶͳ͵ͽͳ
ͻͰͼͪͽͳͷͪ;ͯͼ;ͪͪͰͺͼ;ͼͽͪΒ;ͳ;ͭͯͳͪͷͪͺͼͶͰ;ͼͽͪͬΓͰΔͪ
͵;Ͷͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵͇ͭͽͷͰͼͬͰͯͳͺͬͰΓͪ͊ͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ;̺ͻͪΔͳ
ͼͪ
ͪ;ͽͫͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͷͪ
;͵Ͷͳ͵ͼͰͺͻͳͬͪͽͳΔͰͯͪͽͬͪΔͰͫͶͳͱͰ
ͭͯͳͳ̽;ͪͽ;ͬͰͷͪͽͻͭͬͻͳͰͬͳͷͺͼͽ;ͺͳͷͪ
ͽͬͻͯͰ
ΕͳͯͪͭͪΒͰͲͪͽͳ;ͲͰͽͼ͵Βͼͽͻͪͳ
ͼͪͷͰͻͷͯͪͭͪͺͭ;ͫͳͳͶͳͺͪΓͰ
;ͺͻͭͼͽͬ
ͪͼͬΒ;ͼ;ͯͫͳ;ͼͽͪͬΓͪ;͵ͬͳͻͺͻͳͰͺͻͰ͵ͻͪͼͷ͠ͼͳͿ;
͠Ͱͯͪ͵ͲͶΒͰΌͰͳͼͶ;ͱͰΕͳͼͰͼͶͳͷͫͳͫͶͳΒͼ͵ͷͽͳͺͶͭͳΒͷ
ͭͬ
ͻͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ;;ͬͯ;̀ͪ͵ͳ͵ͪ
͋ͰͺͻͰͼͽͪͬͻͪΕͪΔͰͪͺͳͽͪΔͰ
͵ͻͳͬͳͰ
ͳͭͶͰͯͯ;ͫ͵;͵ͻͰΔͰ
ͷͱͯͪΒͰͫͳͶͺͶͯͰͺͬͰͻͰΔͪ̽Ͱ
ͪͼ͵ͭͺͻͰͷͪ;
ͼͽͬͻͰͭ;Ͱͼͳͭ;ͻͳͷͬͻͰͷͰͳͷͪͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͭͺͻͭ
ͼͽ̸ͬͪ͵ͽͳͺͻͬͫͳͽͳ;ͲͻͳͺͻͯͳͭͻͪͼͰͺͪͳͲͷͳ;ͺ͵;ͪΒ;ͽͪͭ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͪ
Δͳͬ͵ͻͪΒΔͳͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͷͭΒͰͶͪ͵ͰͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͽͳ͆ͪͼͪͯͪΔͰͷ
ͼͽͰͺͰ;ͼͪͲͪΔͪͷͱͰͷͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͯͪΒͰ͵ͻͪΓ
ͯͼͪͻ̽;ͪͺͻͳͲͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͼͽͪͽ;ͼ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͪͶͳͰͳΔͰͭͬ;ͬͯͰΕ;ͺͶͳͽͳ͵;;Ͷͭ;
ͪͺ
ͭͽͬ;ͰͪΒͬͳͳͻͪͭ;ͻͯͼͶͬͷͼͽͪͫͶ;͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
͈ͼͷͪͽͻͪͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ͵;ͶͽͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰ
ͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͺͻͬͰͰͽͪͺͰ;ͻͪͲͬΒ;
ͽͬͪΔͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͷͱͰͼͰͻͰͲͳͷͳͻͪͽͳͪͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͪͳͪ͵
ͼͷͻͽͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳΒͰͯͫͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼ
ͪͪ͵;ͬͻͽͰΔͪ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰΒͳ
ͼͬͰͽ;ͼͶͳ͵;;ͬͳͯ;ͺͼͷͻͽͭͺͻͽͻͰͽ͈ͪͻͳͺͪͶͪͼ;ͷ;ͳͰͼͺͻͪͺͻͳͲͪ
ΔͪͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͲͬͪͳͳͯ͵;ͷͰͪͽͪ
͵ͪ͵ͺͬͰΓͪͽͪ͵ͳͼͶͳ͵ͪ
͌ ͽͷ ͺͰͻͳͯ;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳΒͰ ͯͫͳ ͼͶ;ͱͫ; ͳͽͳ ͺͻͪͬ; ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒ;
ͯͪ͵ͶͰͰͺͻͼͶͪͬͰͼͪͼͽͪͬͰͺ͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰ;ͳͼͽͷͼͬͰͽ;ͯͬͪΒ͵ͪͯͪͺͻͰ
ͺͲͪͬͪͶͳͼͽͳͼ͵ͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͳͭ;ͻͪͺ͵ͪͲͪͽͰΓͯͪͷ;ͼͰ͵;ͶͽͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͻͳΒͰͼͽͰͳͲͼͽͪͪ͵ΔͰͭͬͳͼͬͰͽͳͼͶͳ͵ͪͽ͵ͷͳͽͪͬͭͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ
͊ͺͷͰͳͳͲͪͼͻͰͯͰͬͰ͵ͬͪͽͪͳͺͬͪͽͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͪͪͪͅ͵ͰͯͳΒͪ***
FE̸͊ͶͪͬͰͬͪ
͈ͅͳΓ͵ͬͳ͵͈ͰͺͰ͵
͊͵ͺΒͰ
m
͊ͶͬΒͰͬ
͇ͯͪͫͻͪͳͼͺͷͰͳͳ
̸̺͊ͶͬΒͰͬ
͈ͬͰΓͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽;ͪͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;ͼͬ͆ͳ͵Ͷͳ;̺ͻͪΔͳ
͈ͻͳͶͲͳ͍̓́͠
mͲͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯ̽̓ͻͪΕͪ ͈ͬͰΓͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽;ͪͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ
ͺͬͰΓ;ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳ;ͭͯͳ;
;ͬͻͰͷͰͺͻͰͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
;ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰͳͲ
Ͱͽͳͼ;ͯͫͻͳͻͪͲͶͲͳͯͪͼͰͯ͵;ͷͰͽͯͪͽ;ΒͰͫͶͳͱͰͭͯͳͳ
WͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
ͪͺ
͊ͶͬΒͰͬ
MPDDJU
͉͆ͪͯΒͳΕ
̀ͪ͵ͳ͵ͪͻͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽;ͪͪm
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
7ͪͺ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͵͈ͪͻͰͷͪͽͷͰ
;ͺͻͬΒͰͽͪͺͳ͊ͽͰͿͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͳͷͪΒͰ͵;ͶͽͭͻͪͳͰͭ
ͫͳͷͪ
ͪΒͬͰͻͬͪͽͳΒͰͺͯͼͽͳͪͳͲͻͰͯͬͪͬͳͼ͵ͭ͵ͶͳͻͪͳͷͪͽͬͪΔͰ
ͭͬͰͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰ͊ͪͯͻͱͳͪͳ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ͵;ͶͽͪͺͰͶͳͼ;ͫͳͽͯͪͼͰͷͰΔͪΒ;;
ͺͻͬͳͷͯͰͰͳΒͪͷͪ97ͼͽͶͰΕͪ
͆ͬͺͯͼͽͳͪΒͻͪͲͬΒ;͵;Ͷͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͯͪΒͰͲͪͬͶͪͯͪͬͳͰ
ͯͰͼͺͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͪ
;ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͳͼ͵;ͰΔͪͲͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵;ͯͻͱͪͬ;ͪ͵ͪͅͻͳ͵Ͱͳ̓ͼͬͼ͵Ͱͫͳͽ͵Ͱ͌;ͼͶͬͳͷͪͼͬͰͺͽͰ͵ͻͳ
ͲͰ
ͫͰͲͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͺͻ;ͱͪͶͪͼͬͰͽͻͯͪͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͯͻ;ͽͬͰͪ
ͰͶͳͽͪ;ͬͪͶͪΒͰͯͲͪͫͻͪͬͪͽͰ͵ͬͳͰͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͪ
ͪͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰΒͰ
ͼͪͼͪͱͳͷ
ͼͽͬͪͻͪͶͪ͵ͳͷͲͪͷͪͷ
ͪͼͽΒͪͶͪͯͪͼͽͬͻͳͬͪͯ;ͬͪ;ͺͻͳͽͪ͊ͽͳͷ
ͳΓͰͷͰͭͬͪͳͼ;ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͪͻͳͽ
ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
ͪͼͽͬͪͻͪͳͼ;ͳͬͳ
ͼͪͫͻͪͱͰͳͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶ
ͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ̾ͺ;ΒͰ
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͫͰͶͰͱͳ͵ͼͬͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽ͵ͰͲͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
ͪͼͽͪ͵ͪͺ͵;ͪΒͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪͯͪͫΒͪͼͰͼͺͼͽͬͰ;ͽͻͪͭͳ;ͼͽͬͪͻͼͽ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͯͫͳͶͪΒͰͬ;ͯͳͷͰͲͳΒ;ͫͪͬΓͪΔͰͷͯͻͰͬͭͳ;ͳ
ͬͰͻͲͪͶͭͫͻͪͼͪ
͵ͪ͵ͪͬΒͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͪͻͽͳͻͳΒ;ͷ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͶͳ͵͵ͰͲͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ;ͫͶͳͪͬͪͼͰ͵ͪͶͳ͵ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ
ͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ͵ͪͲͪͯ;ͬͳͷͻͪͶ
ͪͰͶ͋ΒͰͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͫͳͶͪͬͪͼͪͯͻͱͳͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳ
ΒͰ
͵Βͪ;ͻͪͳΒͰͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͳΒͰͺͲͪͬͪͶͪ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ
͋ͷͬͷͳͯͰͪͶ;ͬͻͰͷͰͪ;ͺͯͫΓͰΒͰͳͶͳ͵͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵͇ͭͯͪͬ
ΒͰͲͪͺͪͱͰͯͪͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͳͪͼͽͪͪ͵ͯͬͪ͵;ͶͽͪͳΒͰͼͶ;ͪΒͼͽ͇ΒͰͺͻͽ;
ͷͪͰͯ;ͫΓͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͷͳͯ;ͬͷͷͽͳͬͪͳΒͷ
͵ΒͷͼͰ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
Ͱ͵ͪͬͻͼͽͪ͵ͽͳ;ͳͽͰͽͪͳͲͷͰΌ;͊ͻͫͳΒͰ̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͪͳ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͇ͪͫ
ͬΓͰͳ͵;Ͷͽ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͽͪ͵ΒͰͯͫͳͼͬΒt͵ͼͬͼ͵ͳiͼͷͳͼͪ
;͵ͪͲ;Β;Εͳͪ
ͺͼͽΒͪͼͽͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͭͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
͌ͲͽͰͽͰͷͰΓͰ͵ͬͳͻͰͲͪͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰͬͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͶͳ͵ͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͽͻͰͫͪͳͷͪͽͳ;ͬͳͯ;ͳͳͻͳ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪͼͽͪ͵ͪΔͰͭͬͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͺͻ
ͳͲͪͪͳͲͽͪͯͪΔͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ;ͫͪͶ͵ͪͼ͵ͳͷͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ͌ͽͬͻͰͷͰ
ͯͫͻΒͰ
Ͳͪ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪΒͰΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͳͬͳͶͳͲͪͳΒͼ͵ͺͯͻ;ΒͰ
ͫΒͰͯͳΔͰͽͺͻͷ
ͺͻͰͷͪ ͻͳΕͪͳͷͪ ͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͼ͵Β ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪͳΒͳ
ͳ ͺͻͼͽͻ ͰͺͻͰͼͽͪͳ
ͷͳͭͻͪͳΒͪ͵ΒͰͼ;ͳͷͪͶͰͳͲ;ͲͰͽͺͶͯͽͬͻͰͼͽͬͪͻͪͶͪ͵ͰͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͰ͊ͽ
ͭͪ Ͱ ͽͻͰͫͪ ͯͪ ;ͯͳ ͽ ͽ ΒͰ Ͳͪ ͵ͪ
Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ ;ͫͶͳͪͬͪΔͰ ͵;Ͷͽͪ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͲͪͼͶ;ͱͪͫͳͶͪͶͳͼͽ͵ΒͪΒͰ
ͺͫͻͪͲͬͪΔ;
ͯ;ͬͷͼ͵Ͷͺ;ͳ
ͱͳͬͽͷͺ;ͽ;
ͰͺͼͻͰͯͺͻͳͲͪͶͪͳͲͺͷͰ;ͽͳ͵Ͷͼͽͳ̻ͻͳͭͻͳΒͰ
͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵
ͻͯͷͳͲ͋ͻͬͪ
ΒͰͯͻͪͲͯͫΓͰͼͬͭͰͷͳͻͭͱͳͬͽͪͺͻͬͰΒͰ
;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ m
ͳͲͪͽͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͪͳͭ;ͷͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪ̽Ͱͪͪ
ͪͺͳ
ͼͪΒͰͺͳͻͼͬͰͰͬͱͳͽͳΒͰ
ͼͶ;ͱͫ;ͳͼͳͪ͵ͼͪͻͼ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰ
͌ͽ͵;ͫͻͪͬ͵ͪ;̽Ͱͪͳͷͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͫͳ;ͺͻͳͶͳͳͯͪͼͰ;ͺ
ͲͪͼͪͼͬͳͷͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪͱͳͬͽͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͭ͵ͽͳͽͻͪmͳͷͳͲͺͳͼͪͳ
ͳͲͬͻͪ
͵ͪͳͳͷͳͲͫͻͳͱΓͳͬͰͭͬͪͭͺͻͰͯͪΔͪ͊ͶͰͯͫͰͳ͵ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭ
ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪ͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒͪ
ͲͪͷͰͳͽͭͺͳͼͪͳͯ;ͬͳ͵ͪ
ͳͬͻͼͳͲͪͶͪͳͼͽ
ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͰͱͳͽͳΒͰ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳ
ΒͰͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͱͳͽͳΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͵ΒͰ
ͼͰͫͳͽͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͬͪͶͯͼͪͼͽͪͬͪ̽ͪͳͶͬͭ͌Ͱͳ͵ͪ͌ͳͳΒͰͽͼͷͳΓͰ
ͯͳͼͽͪͳͻͪΒ;Εͳ ͼͰ ͯ ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ ͼͬͭ ͺͻͰͽͯͳ͵ͪ
ͳ ͼ ͪͷͰͻͷ ͯͪ ͳͲͰͼͰ
tͺͻͪͬ;ͳͼͽͳ;iͱͳͬͽͺͳͼ;ͼͬͭΒ;ͪ͵ͪ͋ͪΒͬͳͶͳ͵̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͳͼͽͻͪͱͳ
ͬͪͳͼ;ͬͰΕͺͻͰͳͲ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͪͶͳͽΒͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͷ;Ͱͳ͵
ͱͻͽͬͪͰͺͻͪͬͯͰ
͵ΒΒΒͰͫͳͳͲͶͱͰͳͽͪͬͭͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ;ΒͰͯͺͻͪͬͰͯͳ͵ͼͺͻͰͷͪͪͽͻͺΓͰΔͰͳ
Ͱͺ͵ͶͰͫΓͳͬ;;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔ;ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͬͻͶͳͪ̀ͪͽͷͪΔͰͺͪͱΔͰ
ͺͼͬͰΕͰΒͰͺͳͽͪΔ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͼͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪͺͷΕ;͵ΒͳΒͰͼͽͬͪͻͰͽͪΒ
ͬͳͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͪͪͻͳͽͺΒͰͯͳͳͷ͵Γ;ͳͷͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͷͪ͵;Ͷ
ͽͪ
͵ͪͽΒͰ͵ͬͰͭͼͷͽͳͷͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͌͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͳͷͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪ͵ͷͺͰͽͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͶͳ͵ͪ
;ͯ
ͼ;ͪͼͺͳͼ̽ͪͳͶͬͭ͌Ͱͳ͵ͪ
ΒΒͰͼͶͪͫͳΒͰͲͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰͪ
ͽͪͳΒͰͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰ
ΒͰ ͺͳͼͪͪ ͳ ͬͻͰͯͬͪͪ ̓ͻͪΓͰͬͰ ͬΒͳ͵Ͱ ͲͪͼͶ;ͭͰ ;Ͳͯͳͭ;ͽͰ ͼ; ͪ ͬͳ;
ͻͪͬͪ͵ͻͲͺͻͰΌͰΔͰͼͫͳͫͶͳΒͼ͵ͳͷͺͻͽͽͳͺͳͷͪmͅΒͼͳΒͰͷ
́ͼ;ͼͷ͆ͪͬͳ
ͷ
͵ͪͳͼͬ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͷ̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ͋ͻͳΒ;ͷͿ͵̺ͯͰͶͫ;ͱͯͪ
ͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳ
ͳͲͻͪͲ ͻͪͽͳ͵ͳ ͬͻͶͳͪ
ͯͰ ΒͰ ͊ͽͰͿͪ; ͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽ tͺͫͰͯͳͽͰΓͪi
ͪͶͳ ͳ
tͪΒͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳΒͰͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪiͫͳͽ͵;ͺͻͽͳ̹ͬ;ͭͪͻͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳΒͰͯͫͳ
ͺͻͰ
ͷͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͷͽ;ͷͪͰΔ;
ͽͰ͵ͪ͵ͺͷͳͻΓͳͬͳͪͶͳ;ͲͪͶ;ͯͳͺ͵;ͪΒͪ
ͯͪͼͰͼͺͻͷͳͻͻͪͲͻͰͳ́ͯͰΒͪͯ;ͬͭͬΒͳͼͽͬͪͪͻͳͽΒͰͺͻͳͼ;ͽͪ
;͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳt͇ͫ;ΕͳΕͰͼͰ;͵ͶͺͺͻͪͬͯͰ
ͪͼͽͪͬͳΕͰͶͰͷ
ͼ;ͯͰͶͳͰͷͰͻͳ
͈ͻͳͷͳΕͰͽͳͽͰͺͫͰͯͳͬͳ
ͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͺͻͰͺͯͫͳΒͰi͌Ͱ͵ͳͷͼͶ;ͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ
ͪΒͰͪͯͭͻͪΌͰͪ;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͳͼͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͳͷͳͯͰͪͶͳͷͪͰͺͰ͋ͪ͵ͷͶͳͽ̹ͬͪ
ͭ;ͲͪͺͫͰͯ;͵Β;ͺͻͰͯͫͳͽ͵;;ͼͬͷͪͽͻ;ͳͲͭͬͪͻͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͳͷͪͲͪͳͼͯ
ΔͰͭͬͼͬͰͽͶͼͲͪͻͰΔͰtwΒͰͻͽͪ͵ͬΒͰͯͰͶͷͶͳͽͬͪͰͽͺ;ͽͪͭͪ
͵ΒͳͼͰͷͶͳͽͪ͵ͬͭ͵ͪ͵ͬͭͺͻͳͷͪ
ͷͭͼͬͰͽͶͳΒͰͭi͊Ͷͳͪͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵
ͼ;ͫͶͳͷͪͳΒͰͲͪͺͪͱͪͼͰͳ;ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔ;ͫͻͫͳͲͪͺͻͰͼͽͳͲͷͰΌ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͳΔͰͭͬͭͺͶ;ͫͻͪͽͪ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͪ́ͬͭͪͺ;ͽͪͽΒͰͺͫͰͯͪͺͻͪͬͯͰ
ͺͽ
ͼ;ͳͼͻͺΓͰͳͺ͵;ͪΒͳͯͪͼͰͪͼͳͶͳ͵;ͻͪͲ;ͷͳ͋;͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͪtͳͼͽͳͪi
;ͺͪͯΓͳͬͯ;ͯͪͻͪͯͽͬͻΌͰΔͪͯͻ;ͭͳ
ͯͭͪΌͪΒ;ͫͶͳͼ͵ͳͳͲͬͻͪ͋ͪ͵ΒͰͬͰΕ
ͺͷͳΔͪͳ̻ͳΒͷ̸ͯͪͷͺͼͬͰͯͳ
;ͲͼͶͳ͵ͬͳͽͰͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ
ͯͪΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ
;ͷͻͳ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͪͪͰ;ͬͰͼͬͳͻͰͺͪͳ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͺͻͳͺͳͼ;ΒͰ̽Ͱͪ
ͼ͵ͷͳͯͻ;ͭͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͲͪͼͶ;ͭͰͳͬͻͶͳͰ͌Ͳ;ͫͳͪΒͰͰ
͵ͪ͵ͬͪΒͰ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͪ
ͯͰͶͪͽͼͽ
ͳͼͽͳͰͼͰͳͫͻͫͪͲͪͳͼͽͽ;ͬͰͻͰ͌̿ͳͽͳΒ;ͪΒͰͳͶ;ͼͽͻͬͪ
ͪͺͳͻͳͼͺͻͳͪͷͰͺͳͲͯͷ
ͪͪͻͷͳͶͳͰͷͼͬͪ͵ͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͬͰ
ͬͪͱΒ;ͶͲͳ͵Β;ΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͳͷͪͲͪͬͻͰͷͰͫͻͪͬ͵ͪ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;
;ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͳͷͬͰͻͼ͵ͳͷͻͪͼͺͻͪͷͪͳͺͫͰͯͳͺͪͶͪͷͳͽͪͪͯͬͪͻͶͪͪͷͳͽͼ͵ͷΒͰͻͰ
ͼͳ͌͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳΒͰͽͪ͵ͷͺͰͽͪΒͳͲͻͪͱͰͳΒͪ;ͲͼͽͳͬͰ͵ΒͳͳͲͼͰͫ
ͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͰͼͽͪͬͬͰͺͻͪͬΒͬͰͻͳ
ͪͭͶͪͪͬͪͼͰͳͶͳͳͯͺͻͳͼ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
;ͫͻͫͳͺͻͽͳͬΒͰͻͰͼͳ
͵ͪ;ͳͻͷͼ;ͰͽͬͻͽͰͺͰͼͷͰt͐ͬͰ͵ͫͰͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͺ
ͺͻͳͻͯͳͳͲͪͯͬͰ͵ͪͺͻͰͬͼͽͳ
͵ͪͯͻ;ͭͳ́ͶͳΒͪ͵ͪͱΔͪͬͪΒ;ΕͳͰͪ
ͼͽͳͬͰ
ͪͭͻͪΌ;Β;ΕͳͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͰ
ͪΒͰͻͰͽͳ͵ͪͰͯͪ͵ͪͯ;Ͱͭ;ͫͰͬ;͵ͬͰͳͲ
ͼͬΒͰͫͶͪͼͽͳͭΔͪͰi͈ͻͰΌͰΔͰͼͺͻͻ͵ͷ́ͶͳΒͷ
ͪͼͬ;ͳͼͺΓͰͰ
ͻͰͬͼͽͳ
͵ΒͰͼͰͺͪͬΓͪ;̿ͳͽͳΒ;ͳ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳ
ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪΒΒͰͯ;ͼͫͳ;
ͳͯͰͪͶͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪmͽΒͰͺͼͺͰͰΔͰ
̹ͯͭͪͪͯͪ;ͽͪͱ;ͻͫͪ;ͳͲͬͻͰΔ;
ͯͫͻͳͯͰͶͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬ;;ͺ;ΕͰͼͽ;ͫͻͪͼͰͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͰͬͶͪͯͪͶͪ͵Ͱ
ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͺͽͬͻͯͳͶͫͳͳͺͻͰΌͰΔͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͼͺͻͻ͵ͷ̽ͪͬͳ
ͯͷm̹ͱΒͳͷͳͲͪͫͻͪͳ͵ͷ͵ΒͳΒͰͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰtͪͻͳ͵ͻͽͪ͵;ͼͷͰͻͼͽͳi
mͳ͊ͶͷͷmͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͰͷ̹ͱΒͰͭͻͪͷͪ́ͼͽΒ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͳͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͳ
ͺͻͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͳͺͻͰΌͰΔͰͼ͠ͼͳͿͷmͽͳͺͷͰͺͻͪͬͰͯ͵ͪͱΔͰͭͺͻͪ
ͬͰͯͳ͵ͪ͵Βͳ;Ͳ̹ͱΒ;ͺͷΕͪͯͬͶͪͯͪͬͪͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͰ
̓ͯ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͪΒͰͽͽΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ͵͵ΒͳͰͯ;ͱͪͽͻͺͳͰͺͻͪͬ
ͯ;ͳͪ͵ͻͪΒ;ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͳ͵ͪͬͪͱͳͬͽͼ;ͽͳͪΔͰͭͬͭͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽͪ̽Ͱ
ͪͼ͵ͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ͽͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪͬͳͰͺ;ͽͪͺͪͬΓͪ
tͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͷͰΌ;ͪͻͰͬͳ
ͷͪiΒͰͯͬͼͽͻ;͵ͬͰͪmͬͰͰͷͪͻͼͽͬͪͳͬͰͰͷͷ;Ͱͳͽͬͪ͌
ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
͵ͪΔͰͭͬͰͪΒͬͰΕͰͬͻͶͳͰͬͪͶͰͼͰͳͲͯͻͱΓͳͬͼͽͳͼͺͼͫͼͽ
ͽͻͺΓͰΔͪ
ͺͪͰͳͲͰͪΌ;ΒͰͽͽΒͰͺͻͪͬͰͯͳͬ͠Ͱ;ͺͻͰͯͳͬͪΒ;ͰͼͽͪͶͳ
ΒͳͺͻͪͫͻͪͲ͊ͽͰͿ͇ͪͬͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͰͺͻͳͷͪͫͰͲͰͭͯͬͪΔͪͳͽͺͻͪ
͵ͪ
ͲͪͶͭ;ͫ;ͯ;ΕͰ
ͬͰͰͺͻͪͬͯͰ
ΒͰͻ
͵ͪͱͰ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵t̓ͪ͵ͫͳͫͳͼͪͬͻͰͷ;
Ͱͳ͵ͪ͵Ͱͬͪ͵ ͠ͰͻΒͰͯͪΒͰ;ͯͰͷ;Ͱͳͽͬͪͪͷͭͳͼ;ͪͳͳͼͷͻ
ͽͳi̓ͻͪΒΔͳͼͷͳͼͪͺͯͬͳͭͪtͯ;ͰͽͻͺͰΓͳͬͼͽͳi͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͰͺͻͰͼͽͪͪ
ͭͶͪͪͬͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭͳͺͻͷͳΓͰͳͷ͵ͻͳΕͰΔͰͷͫͳͫͶͳΒͼ͵ͳͳͽͪͽͪ
t͋ͻͺͳ͊ͽͰͿͪͰ͌ͽͻͺΓͰΔ;ͬͪͰͷͼͽͰͳͽͰͯ;ͰͬͪͰi ̈́͵
ͷͪͶͯͪΓͰ
ͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͪ͵ͪͱͰtwͰͯͼͽΒͪ<ͼ;>ͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪͼͪͯͪΔͰͭͪͬͻͰͷͰͪͺͻͰͷͪ
ͫ;ͯ;ΕΒͼͶͪͬͳ͵ΒͪΕͰͼͰ;ͪͷͪͽ͵ͻͳͽͳ̹ͯͭͪ
ͳ;͵Ͷͳ͵ͼͺΓͪΔͳͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
̓́ͬͪͬͪ
̓͋ͪ͘͵ͳͰͬ
͈ͪͽͻͳͪͻ̾ͬͽͳͷͳʹ
ͼ΅ͳͰͳΊ
͊ͿͳΊ.-B#BVWF
)ÊSCFSU
)FTZIBTN
8PSME8FBWJOHBOE)BHJPHSBQIZѮF-JUFSBSZ4DIPPMPG1BUSJBSDI&VUIZNJ
VT
.ÛODIFO
͇ͪͰͶͳͷͪͳͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵ͭͱͳͬͽͪW5»QJEMJL
.5FOBDF
3ƀFNVT
2VFTUJPOTNP
OBTUJRVFTFO0SJFOU
3PNB
m ͼͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͷ
̓́ͬͪͬͪ
͊ͽͪͻͪͫ΅Ͷͭͪͻͼ͵ͪͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ*7̿ͳͽͳͰͺͳͼͳͽͬͻͫͳ
͊ͿͳΊ
mW͈̽ͺͬͳΕ
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ
m
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
͚͋ͻͳͿ;ͬͳΕ
͊ͳͪ͵ͼͪͻͼ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
JO#Z[BODFFU
MFT4MBWFTUVEFTEFDJWJMJTBUJPO.ÊMBOHFT*WBO%VKǁFW
1BSJT
;ͺͻͰͬͯ;ͪͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ
ΒͰͲͳ͵ ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
m
;ͳΔͰΒͰͺͻͰͬͳͯ
ͺͪΒͰͳͲͼͽͪͬΓͰͺͷͰ
ͳͼͺͼͳ͵ͪ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
ͼͺͼͫͼͽtΒͪͼͭͬͳΌͰΔͪiͯͼͰͲͪΔͰͷͽͪ͵ͬͭͼͽͰͺͰͪͬͻͶͳͰͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳΒͰ
ͰͺͳͽͰͽtͰͫͰͼ͵ͭͬͰ͵ͪͳͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͭͪΌͰͶͪi͋ͪΒͬͳͪͫͳͽ;ͼ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵ͳͳͷͪ͵ͳ
ͪΒͫΓͰͭͬͻͳͺͻ͵ͶͪͷͬͪͷͳͯͰͪͶͷͽͳͺ;ͼͬͰͽͳ
ͽͰΓͪ;ͽͪͯͪΔΒͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ
̓Γ;ͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͪͬͳͪ
;ͯͼ;ͪͼͪͼͽͪͬΔͰͭͬͭͺͻͰͽͯͳ͵ͪ
ΒͰͼ;;ͯͰͼͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͰͶͳͼͽͳ͋ͰͳͲ;ͲͰͽͰͼͫͳͰͫͳͶͰͼ;ͪ
ͭͬͰͽͰͰΒͲͪͱͳͬͽͪ
ΒͰͻΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͳͷͪ͵ΒͳtͭͶͰͯͪΒ;̹ͭͪͷͳ
ͼͶͰͳͷͳͷͪͳͳͼͺ;ΔͪͬͪΒ;ͼͰͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͷͻͪͯΕ;i͊ͽͰͿͪͬͪͪͻͳͲͷͪ
ͳͼͺΓͳͶͪͼͰ͵ͪͫͶͪͭͯͪͽ͵ΒͪΒͰͲͻͪͳͶͪͼΔͰͭͬͭͶͳͪͳtͼͬͰ͵ΔͰͷ;ͺͻͳ
ͬͶͪͳͶͪi͆ͳΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͳͷͪͶͼͶ;ͪΒͽͽͼͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵;
ͼͬͰͽͳ
͆ͳ͵Ͷͪ ;ͯͰͼ Βͪͬͳ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ Ͱ ΒͰͯͷ m ͬͰΕ ͽͻͳ ͺ;ͽͪ ͋ͪ ͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ
ͼ;ͼͰ;ͺ;ΒͷͰͻͳͳͼͺΓͳͶͪͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲ;Β;ΕͳͼͰ͵ͻͲ;
ͯͽͬͻͰΔͰͷͽͳΒ;
ͭͶͪͬ;ͺͽͬͻͯ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽ͇ͬͪͼͳͷͽͳͺͳͼ;ΒͰ
͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ ͳ ͼͷͰͽͪ ; ͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ ͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͷͻͪͶͳ ͵ͬͳͻ ;ͳΔͰͪ
;ͯͪͼ;ͺͶͯͬͻͼͽͰͬͰͻͰ
ͬͻͶͳͪͳͯͫͻͳͯͰͶͪ
ͪͳͲͪͯͼͬͰͭͪͺ͵ͪͲͪͰͼͷͰͻ
ͼͽͳͲͪͬͪΓ;Β;ΕͳΔΒ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͪͯͳͶͪͲͳtͺͻͳͻͯͰͲͪ͵ͰiͳtͯͼͽͳͱͰ
ͬͻͰͷͰͪͪͯͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͪ
ͪͼͽͪΔ;Β;ΕͳͼͰ͵ͪͬͰͶͳ͵ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͼͪͷ;Ͱͳͳͷͪi
͉ͰͺͰͻͽͪͻ;ͳΔͰͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ;ͯͰͼͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͱͳͬͽͺͳ
ͼ; ͻͰͳͽ ;Ͳͻͪ͵
ͪ ͽͪ͵ ΒͰ ͳ ͵ͯ ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͪ ͆ͪ ͺͻͬͷ ͷͰͼͽ; ͺͪͯͪ ; ͳ
ͽͯͪͼ;ͼͬͪ;ͯͪͬͰͲͪͪͲͪ̽ͰͪͰ
ͽΒͪͼͼͬͰͯͳ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ;ͳͺͼͰͭ;
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͼ;ͺͰͻͳͻͼͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͳͼͰΓͰΔͪͪͯͶͰ͵ͪͻ
ͼ͵ͳͷ)+.BHPVMJBT
ѮF MJWFT PG #Z[BOUJOF 4BJOUT BT TPVSDFT PG EBUB GPS UIF IJTUPSZ PG NBHJD JO
UIFTJYUIBOETFWFOUIDFOUVSJFT"%TPSDFSZ
SFMJDTBOEJDPOT
#Z[BOUJPO
m1
)PSEFO
ѮF %FBUI PG "TDFUJDT 4JDLOFTT BOE .POBTUJDJTN JO UIF FBSMZ #Z[BOUJOF .JEEMF &BTU
JO
.POLT
)FSNJUTBOE"TDFUJD5SBEJUJPO
FE8+4IFJMT
1BETUPX
m
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͳͼͽͬͰͽͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͪͼͬͰͯ͵Ͱ͵ͻͳͼͽͳ
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;Εͳͱͳͬͽ;ͼͬͰͽ͈ͭͰͽͻͪ̓ͻͳ͵ͭ
W͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
̿ͳͽͳΒͪ ͺͻͳͻ
̹̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
mtͰͺͻͳͻͯͷiͬͳͯ;ͼͷͻͽͳ1""HBQJUPT
.PS
UVBSZ5ZQPMPHZJOUIF-JWFTPG4BJOUT.JDIBFMUIF4ZOLFMMPTBOE4UFQIFOUIF:PVOHFS
JO-FTWJFT
EFTTBJOUTÆ#Z[BODF(FOSFMJUUÊSBJSFPVCJPHSBQIJFIJTUPSJRVF
ͰE10EPSJDP
1""HBQJUPT
1BSJT
m
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
DGͳ̹ͅͶͪͭΒͰͬͳΕ
͐ͰͶͳͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪ̽Ͱͪͪ
JO̽ͰͪͳͳͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͪ;ͷͰͽͼͽͼͻͰͯͳͷ9*7ͬͰ͵ͪ
m͇ͯΒͰͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͲͫͳͬͪ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
ͳͼ;ͫͳͶͰ;ͯͽͬͻͰͼͪͷͷͽͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͬͰΕͳΔͰͭͬͪtͳ͵ͪi
ͽΒͰͼͽ
ͺͻͽͻͰͽ͇ͽͷͰͼͬͰͯͳͺͻͳͺͬͰͼͽ;ͯ;ͼͪ͠;Ͱͷ
͵ΒͳΒͰ
;ͼ;
͵ͻͰ;
;ͻ͵ͬ;ͼͪͷͰͻͷͯͪ;ͫͳΒͰͯͰͪͼ͵ͭͪͼͽΒͪͽͰΓͪ͌ͽͷͪͼ;ͺͻͰͼͻͰͭͪΒͰ
tͰ͵ͳͼͽͻͪͳͷ;ͱ
;͵ͻͪͰͪͻͼ͵ͷͯͰΕͷi
͵ΒͳͼͰͺΒͪͬͳtͯͷͰͼͽͪͭͯͰ
͵ͬͰͭͼͽΒͳ
ͼͪͯ;ͭͷͳͺͻͼͰͯͷͫͻͪͯͷ
͵ͪͽΒͰͳͪͼͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳ;ͯͪͻͳͭͪ
ͺͶͳ;ͳͺͻͼͳͷͪͼͬͰΕΔͪ͵ͷ͵ΒͳͳͷͪΌͪͰ;ͻ;͵ͪͷͪi͋ͪͰͺͳͲͯͪͻͰͳͽͪΒͰ
ͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪͳΒͪͯͻͰͬͰͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵Ͱͯ͵ͽͻͳͰͪͽͺͻͳͻͯΒͼͳͶͳ͵Βͪ
ͯͰΒͼͽͬ;ΒͰ͵ͻͲͳ͵ͰͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͰΕͳͳͳͲͬͻͷͳͼͰΓͰΔͪ
ͪͶͳͳͺͼͻͰͯ
ͳ͵ͷ̹ͱΒͰ͵ͪͲͰ
̾ͶͰͷͰͽͳͼͽͬͪͻͼͽͳͺͻͰͺͲͪΒ;ͼͰͳ;Ͱ͵ͳͷ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͳͷ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͳͷͪ
;ͬͰͲͳͼͷͽͳͷ̸ͪ͵ΒͰͺͳͼͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ
͵ΒͰͷͺͳͰͼͬͰͶͳ͵ͰͬͻͰͷͰͼ͵Ͱ
;ͯͪΓͰͼͽͳ
ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͺͽͰͷͰͼͽ
ͽͼͰͳ͵ͪ͵ͰͷͱͰͻͰΕͳͲͪΔͰͭ
ͬͪͼͬͰͯͰΔͪͫͻͰͯͳͷͪͽͬͪΔͪͷͽͳΒ;
͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰ
͵ͪͯͰͪͼ͵ͳͳͭ;ͷͪ
ͷͻͪͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͬͪͽͳͰͼͪͷ͵ͪͰͬͳͯͪͬͰΕͳ͵ͪͪ͵ͽͳͬͳͼ;ͯͰͳ͵́Ͳ
͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͭͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔͪΒͪͼͼͰͬͳͯͳͯͪͼ;ͬͰͻͳͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰͪͳ
ͺ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪΔͰͷͳͯͯͳͻͷ
ͯͪͬͪͶͳͺͽ;͵ͳͬͽ;ͼͷͽͳͷͪ
tͯͽͳ;ΕͳͭͪͼͰͺ
ͫͱ;ͼͪͷͪͳͳͷͪiͳ͵ͻͺͰΕͳͭͪͼ;Ͳͪͷͪ͊ͬͰͶͳ͵ͷͷͰͻͷͺ;ͲͯͪΔͪͷ
ͱͰͷͽͪ͵ΌͰͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳ͵Βͳͼ;ͯͰͶͬͳͷͽͳΒ;ͫͳͶͳͽ͵ͻͳͬͰͳͳͳͲͶͱͰͳ
ͽͬͪΔ;͋ͪ͵͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͺͲͳͬͪͬͰͻͰͯͪt͵ͻͺͰͼ;ͲͪͷͪͻͪͯͼͽͳΔͰͭͬͰͼͬͰͽͰ
ͼͽͺͰiͳͯͪtͳͲΓ;ͫͰͺͻͼͳ
ͻͳͲͳ;ͷͭͳͯͫͪͻͪíͺͪ͵
;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͯͻͰͬͳͷ
ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͫͳͪΒͰͷ
;ͼͻͰͯͳͽ;ͺͫͱͰͺͪͱΔͰͫͳͶͰͼ;ͻ;͵ͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͵ΒͰ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵;ͼͪͷͯͬͰͻͰͰͳͰͺͷͳΔͰͪ͵ͺͰͽͺ;ͽ͇ͪͰͼ;tͪΒ͵ͻͪͼͳΒͰi
ͳtͪΒͼͬͰͽͳΒͰi
tͷͳͻͳͼͳΒͰͯͼ͵;ͺͰͭͪͻͯͪi
ͪͺͻͪͫͻͪͲͼ;ͳͷͅΒͼͳΒͰͬͰ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͻ;͵Ͱ
tͺͻ;ͱͰͰ̻ͪͻͳͻͪͯͳͺͻͳͷͪΔͪͽͪͫͶͳͪͲͪ͵ͪi͇ͯΒͰ͵ͷͼͽͬͪͻͳͫ
ͻͰͯͪͷͭ;ͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͳͰ͵ͳͯͰͶͬͳ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰ̓ͳͬͽΒͰͽ;ͺͰͬͪ͵ͪͼͻͰͯͳΔͪ
ͽͪ͵ͪͯͰͪͼ͵ͰͫͳͽͰΓͳmͷͪͼͳͭͪ;͵ͶͫͳͶͪͲͰͺΒ;ΕͳͺͰͼͷͰ
ͪͷͽͳ
ͰͶͳͬͪΒ;ͳ͵ͻͺͰͼ;ͲͪͷͪΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͳͳͶͪͪΒͳͻͰͭͯͻ;ͽͬͰͭͫΒͰͯͳΔͪ
ͬͪΔͪm͵ΔͰͭͪͼͰͼͽͳ;ͼͬͳ
tͼͬͰͽͰͳͳͳͪͻͰͬͳ
ͳͳͳͷͳͻΒͪͳ
ͫͭͪͽͳ
ͳͳͽͳi̸ͽͻͳͫ;ͽͳͷͽͳΒ;ͪͬͰͯͰͳ;̿ͳͽͳΒ;ͳ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;
ͼͬͰͽͪͰͽͺͼͰ͵ΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͯͻͰΌ;Β;͵ͪtͯ;ͬΓͰͪͽͰͶͰ
ͼͪͺͻͰͫͳͬͪͶͳͽͪͫͱΒͪiͳtͼͺͪͼͼͰͳͲͬͻͰi
ͺͼͻͰͯͳ͵ͪͳͲͷͰΌ;ͲͰͷͪΓ
ͼ͵ͭ ͳ ͼͽͻͪͭ ͋ͪ͵ ͼ; ͳ ͷͽͳ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ tͻͳͲͳͪ ̹ͱΒͳ ;ͯͰͼͪi
ͳtͷͳͶͽͪΒͼ͵;ͺͰͳΒͪiͰͳͰ;ͯͪ
ͽͰͳͼͰΓͰΔͪͳͽͳͽͰͯtͼͬͪ͵Ͱ
ͻͪͰͯ;ͰͺͻͺͪͯΓͳͬͰi͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͪͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵ͪ
͵ΒͪͳͳͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͲͳ
ͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳ͵ͬͳͻͼͬͪ͵ͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͷͺͻͭͻͪͷ;
ͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͪΒͰͺͻͰΌͰΔͰͷ
ͯͰͪͼ͵ͰͭͻͫͳͰͼͪ͊ͳͶͪͷͷ
ͺͽ͵ͷͽͳͲͬͳͻͰͳͲͫͻͯͪ͊ͳ̹ͪͰͲ
ͫͲͳͻͪͪͼͬͪͽͪͼͽͪͯͪͻͯͪͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪ
͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͫͳͺͼͬͰͯͳ
ͶͳͯͪΒͰ͵;Ͷͽ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ;ΔͰͭͬͬͻͰͷͰͫͳ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͬͰͲͪͲͪͯͰͪ
ͼ͵ͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ͋ͺ͵ͪͲ;Β;Ͳͪͬͻͳ
ͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͼͽͳͬͳͼͶ;ͱͫͰ
͵ΒͳͼͬͰͽͭ
͵ͻͪΓͪͲͪͪͬͪΒ;͵ͪt;͵ͻͪͰΔͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵Βͻ͵ͬͳiͳ;ͲͼͰͷͶͳͽͬ;ͫͻͪͽͼͽͬͪ
t͎ͻͳͼͽͬ;ͭͯͳͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͰͳ;ͯͽͬͻͰͬͪͳͼͽͳ;
ͪͼ͵ΒͰͼͪͫͻͪΒͰͼͳͬͯͰͳ
ͽͪͷͼͪͫͰͻͳ;ͪͼͽͳͼͺͪͼͰͳiͳͼͽͳͼͷͳͼͪͳͷͪͳͲͪͬͻͪͺͻ;͵ͪ̿ͳͽͳΒͪ
ͼ
ͷͶͳͽͬͪͷͪͳt͵ΒͰͼͷͪͲͬͪͶͳͼͽͪͯͽͬͭͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪi
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͲͪͷͰͳͽͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪͻ;͵ͪͷͪͳΔͳͬͷͽ
ͬͪΔ;+,BMBWSF[PV
)FMQJOH)BOETGPSUIF&NQJSF*NQFSJBM$FSFNPOJFTBOEUIF$VMUPG3FMJDT
BUUIF#Z[BOUJOF$PVSU
JO#Z[BOUJOF$PVSU$VMUVSFGSPNUP
FE).BHVJSF
)BSWBSE
m
͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
́ͼ͵ͪͲͯͪͯͰͪͼ͵ͪͫͻͪͽͳΒͪ͵ͳͬͽt;͵ͶͫͳͶͪͲͳi
;ͺ;Εͳͬͪͫͳ
ͪͺͻͬͳͺͭͶͰͯ
ͪΔͰͭͬͼͶͫͯͪͺͶͱͪΒ;ͻͪͷ;ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͬͰΕͳͼ
ͽͪ͵;ͽ
ͫͻͪͯͪͺͻͬͫͳͽͭ͵ͳͬͽͪͰͼͽͪͬΓͪͷͰͼͽͪͼ;ͷΔͳ;ͽͯͪͼ;ͬͳͯΓͳͬͰͳͼͶͫͯͰ
ͫͳͶͰͼͪͷͯͬͰΔͰͭͬͰͼͽͻͪͰmͺͻͰͯΔͪͳΒ;ͱ͈ͪͫͪͷͰ;ͽͰͻͰͳͳͲ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͰ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰ
ͷͭͶͰͫͳͳͷͪͽͳͳͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͳͼͷͳͼͪ͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͺͻͳͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͱͰΔ;Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͳͲ
ͰΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͯͪͻͬͪ
ͼͬͰͽͰͼͶ;ͱͳͽͰΓͳͫͳ
ͳͲͶͪͲͰΕͳͳͲͺͻͽͰͲͳͼͪ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷ;ͶͪͲͰΕͳ;Ͷ
ͽͪͻ͵ͻͲͪͻͼ͵ͰͯͬͰͻͳ
ͳͳͶͳͺͯ͵͵ͬͰͭͪͼͷͽͳͷͪͅͱͯͪΒͰ;ͺͻͪͬͽͫͳͻͪͲͶͭ
ͯͪͼͰ͵ͳͬͽͺͼͽͪͬͳͼͪͼͰͬͰͻͰ
ͪͰͼͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͰ
Β;ͱͰͼͽͻͪͰͳ͵ͼͽͪͼͪ
ͪ͞·̽ͪͷͪͼ͵ͳ
͋ͰͳͲͶͱͰΐͰͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬʹͬͰͻΆ*7
FE̸̹ͻͲͬ
͈͊ͰͽͰͻ
ͫ;ͻͭ
ͻͰͺͻ ͅͼ͵ͬͪm͉ͼͽͬͪ̽;
W "OHFOFOEU
)FJMJHF VOE 3FMJRVJFO
m
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
W͈̽ͺͬͳΕ
4BDSBFSFMJRVJBF
m
̿ͳͽͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
m
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
́ͺͪ͵
ͬͰΕ;ͺͻͬΒͯͰͰͳΒͳ97ͬͰ͵ͪͺͰͶͳͼ;ͯͪͼͰͼͽͬͪͻͪΒ;;ͼͶͬͳͯͪ
͵;Ͷͽ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͺͰͯͪͺͺͻͳͷͪͺͽͳΒͳ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ͇ͯͬͰͶͳ͵ͭ
ͲͪͪΒͪ
;ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;
ͷͻͪͶͪΒͰͫͳͽͳͺͼͰͽͪ͵Β;ΒͰͭͯͳͰ̽Ͱͪͳͷͪ
;ͳͳͶͪͷͪͳΔͪ͠ͰͬͭͰͳΒͪ
;ͯͬͳͪ͵ͰͲͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪͪͪͅͼͽͳͻ;
ͺ;ͼͽͰ
ͷͯtͲͶͰͼͽͳͬͳΒͰͲͳ͵ͳͼͷͪͳͶͽͼ͵ͳi
͠ͰͬͭͰͳΒͪΒͰͬͻͪͽͳͶͪͯ;ͲͰͽͪͳͷͪΔͪ
ͳͯͪͻͬͪͶͪͬͪ
ͽΒͰͺͽͬͻͯͳͶͪͺͬͰΓͷ̀ͪͪ;ͽͰͷ;ͯͪͻͳͽͭΒͰ
ͲͪͪΒͪͽͽͪ̽ͰͪͰͪͲͳͬͪtͫͳͽͰΓͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ͌ͻͪ͋ͻͰ
ΕͰͭìͪͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͪͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪ
ͪͶͳͳΔͰͭͬͯ;ͬͳͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͫͳͶΒͰͯͰ;ͺͻͰͯͳͬͰͬͪͱͼͽͳ͇ΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵
;ͽͳͪͶͳͪͳͻͰΔͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
;ͽͶͳ͵ͺͻͰͽΒͰͫͻͪͲͪ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪͫͳͯͳͪͼͽͳͷͪͳͲͺͻͯͳͰ̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͺͻͰͺͲͪͽΓͳͬͳ
ͫͶͳͲͪ͵͌ͺͻͪͬͲͫͭͽͰͼ;ͽͳͼ͵Ͱͼͻͯͼͽͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳΒͰ
͵ͪͺͻͰͽͰͪ͵Ͱ
ͲͪͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳͷͪͼͬͰ;ͼͶͬͰͯͪͺͼͽͪͰͯͰͶͽͬͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵͌
ͽͷͼͬΒͼͽͬ;ͺΒͪͬΓ;ΒͰͼͰ;ͅͶͫͰͷ͵ͪ;͵Βͳͷ;ΒͰ͵ͼͻͰͯͳͰ97ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͯͪͪͼͰͺͲͪͽͳͺͳͼͪ
;ͺͲͪͽͼͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͷ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͷ͊ͽͰͿͪ
;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
ͳͲ͵ΒͰΒͰͺͻͰ;ͲͰͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͼͽͻͿ͈ͪͳͼͪͺͻͰͯͼͪͷͼͶͷ
ͯͻͱͪͬͼͽͳ
;ͪͽͷͼͿͰͻͳͽͰͼ͵ͫͰͳͫͰͲͪΌͪ
ͽͪΒͷͶͰͫͪͼͰͷͱͰ;ͺͻͰͯͳ
ͽͳ
ͺͺͻ;ͳͳͿ;͵ͳΒͳ
ͼͳͷͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͷͼͬͰͽΒ
Ͳͪͽͳͽͳͳ ͋ͻͬͪ
ͪͼͽͪͶͳͷ ͰͺͼͻͰͯ ͺͻͰͯ ΔͰͭͬ ͺͪͯ ̓;Ͷͽ ͼͬͰͽͭ
͵ͻͪΓͪͽ;ͼͽͳͰͬ;ͯͳͷͰͲͳΒ;͇ͪͼͰͰͯͼͳͽͶͳ͵ͪ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͼͬͰͽͳ
ͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͶͳ͵ͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ̓ͪͳ͵ͯ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͪ
ΒͰͪͻͳͷ;Ͱͳ͵
ͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ
ͷͪͻͪͬͪͼͳ
ͬͰͪͳ͵ͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͷ;Ͱͳ͵̓ͪ;͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬΒ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳ
;
͵ΒΒΒͰtͼͬͭͽͪͪͼͽͬͪͰͺ͵ͶͰͫΓͳͬͳͫͰͯͰͷͳͼͬΒͰͫͳͽͰΓͳͰͻͪͲͻ;ͳͬͳ
Ͳͳͯi
ΒͰ;ͅͶͫͰͷ͵ͪ;tͰͫͻͳͬͳͼͽ;ͫͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͽͰΓi̻Ͷͪͬͪͬͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪ͵Β;ͯͼͳͽͪΒͼͪͼͽͪͬΒͰͼͽͰͷͭͼͪͱͳΒͰͪͭͶͪͰͪͺͼͻͰͯͳ͵ͪ;Ͷͭͪ
͊ͽͰͿ͇ͪͬͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰtͭͶͰͯͪͽͰΓͰͳͲͻͰͳͬͭi
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͺͼͶͰͯΔ;ͪͯ;;
ͼͺͪͼ
ͺͪͷ;ͼͰͬͪͺͪΒͰͷͫͻͪΕͪΒ;tͭͅͳͷͪͺͻͬͪͳͪͺͪͼͽͳͷͪ
͵ͪͽͰͫͳͺͻͳ
ͫͰͭͪͬͪͷ
ͼͶͪͬͳ
͎ͻͳͼͽͬͬΒͳͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͰ
ͯͼͺͺͪͶͳͪͼͰͬΓͪͼͪ;
ͬͪΒi̽;ͬͳ͵;ͶͽͳͼͯͳͽͰͽͳͷͶͳͽͪͬͪͫͳͶͳͼ;ͳͯͪΓͰͯͰͪͼ͵ͳ
ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳΔͰͭͬͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ
̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
;ͯͻ;ͭΒ
͵Γ;ΒͰͽͪͺͳͻͪͲͬΒͪ͵;Ͷͽ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͺͺͻͳ
ͷͳΒͰͫͳͽͰͯͶͳ͵Ͱ
͵ΒͰΕͰ
;ͪͰͶ;
Ͳͪͯͻͱͪͽͳͽ͵ͷͪͻͰͯͳͼͽͶͰΕͪ͌
ͽͷ ͻͪͲͯͫΓ; ͊ͽͰͿͪ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ ΒͰ ͼͽͰ͵ͪ ͽͰͷͰΓͳ ͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ m ͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ͋ͪͯͪΒͰͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽͯͫͳͳͺͻͪͬͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰͳͼͶ;ͱͫ;
ͽΒͰͫͳͶͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͪΔͰͭͬͭͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪ
Ͱ
ͰͺͼͽΒͰͺͯͪͳ͵Βͳͫͳ;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳͪͽͯͪΒͰ͵;ͶͽͰͭͬͪͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷ
ͼͬͰͽͳͼͶͳ͵ͪ́ͪ͵ΒͰͽͬͪΔͰtͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪiͳͯͪΓͰͫͳͶ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͬͰͲͪ
Ͳͪ̽ͰͪͰ
;ͽͬͻͰͷͰͺͰͶͳͼ;ͯͪͼͰͼͽͬͪͻͪΒ;ͲͫͳΓͳͺͻͰͯ;ͼͶͬͳͲͪΔͰͭͬ
ͳͻͰΔͰ
̻;ͫͳͽͪ͵ͯͻͱͪͬͰͼͪͷͼͽͪͶͼͽͳͳΒͰͳͷͪͲͪͺͼͶͰͯͳ;ͺͪͯͪΔͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͆ͪͺͻͽͳͬ
Ͷͳ͵ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͫͶͳͳ̻ͻͳͭ
ͻͳΒͰ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͳͷͪΒͰ;ͽͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͳͻ͵ͭͯΒͰ͵͈ͪͻͰ;ͲͰͶͳͼ;ͭͪͺͳͼͳ
ͻͯͼͶͬͪ
ͺͻͰͼͰΕͳͺ͵ͶͰΔͳͷͪͺͻͰͯͪΔͰ͵ͻͪΓ;͵ΒͳΒͰtͻͪͬͪͼͽͪi
ͷ;Ͱͳͳͷͪ͊ͪͱͪͻͪͼͽ͵;Ͷͽͪ;ͯͻ;ͭΒͺͶͬͳͳ97ͳ;97*ͬͰ͵;ͺͼͬͰ
ͯͰΒͰ;ͺͪͯΓͳͬͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͫͻΒͰͷͺͻͰͺͳͼͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͳͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͼͪͼͽͪ
ͬͪͺͼͬͰΕͰͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ̺ͪͱͪͺͯͼͽͳͪΒͼͳͭ;ͻͼ;ͷ;ͯͪͶͰͼͬͰͽͰͼͶͳ
͵Ͱ
͵ΒͰͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽͺͼͽͪΒ;ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͽͬͪΔͪ̓Γ;;
;Ͷͭ; ; ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔ; ͽͰ ͬͰ
ͬͳͲ;ͰͶͰ ͵ͷͺͰͽͰ ͵;Ͷͽͪ ͳͷͪ ΒͰ ͈ͻͪͲͳͳ
ͷͳͰΒ̹ͱͳͯͪͻ̺ͪ;͵ͬͳΕͪͳͲͭͯͳͰ
͵ΒͳΒͰͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͳ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬ;
ͼͶ;ͱͫ;ͼͬͰͽͷ͵ͻͪΓ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷΒͰͻΌͪ͵;ͅΒͼͳΒ;
͵ΒͳͼͰͷͭͽͻ;ͯͳ
͵ͽͪͷͺͪΔͪͽͰ͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͳͲͪͼͶ;ͭͪͲͪͽͽΒͰͼͬΒͳͷ;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͺͷͭͪ ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰ ͳ͵ͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰ Ͳͪ ͯͻͬͻͰͲ; ͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪͳΒ; ͵Βͪ
ΒͰ͵ͻͪͼͳͶͪͺͰͽͪ͵͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰ͋ͪ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͪ
;͵ΒΒͼͬͰͽͳ͆ͳ͵Ͷͪͺͻͳͬͯͳ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
͎ͻͳͼͽ;͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
ͺͼͽͪͶͪΒͰͳ͵ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͫͻͪͲͪͲͪͽͳͺͼ͵ͰͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬͰ;ͷͱͪͬͪͰͽ͵ͷͪͻͰͯͪͯͬͪͼͽͶͰΕͪ
͇͈ͫͬͪͰΕ͵ͰͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͰͭͯͳͰͯͪͶͪΒͰͬͲͪͷͪͽͬͪΔ;ͼͬͰ
ͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ̓ͪͯͪΒͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷ͵;ͶͽͬͳͷͪͻͰ
ͬͯͰΕͳͯ;ͬͳͳ͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͻ͵ͬͰͼͽͬͻͳͶͳͼ;ͫ;ͬͪͽͪͳͼͬͻͼͳͼͯͪͺͻͭͻͪͷ͌ͲͪͳͪͶͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰ
ΓͰ
ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔ;ͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬ;
ͼͬͰͽ̸ͭͻͼͰͳΒ̸ͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰͺͰΕ͵ͰͼͬͰͽͰ
ͼͪͻͳͽͷͺͪͱΔͷͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪͶͰͼ;ͼͰͶͳͼͽͳͳΒͳͼ;
ͺͯͬͳͲͳͫͳͶͳͬͰͲͪͳͲͪͺͯͻ;ΒͰΒ;ͻͳͼͯͳ͵ͳΒͰ͈ͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͰmͯͯͻͰͬͳ
;ͭͶͰͯͳͫͪͶ͵ͪͼ͵ͳͺ;ͼͽͳͱͳͽͰΓͪͯͬͳͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ
͵ͪͽΒͰͫͳͼͬͰ
ͽͳ̻ͰͻͭͳΒͰ͆ͬͳ͋ͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͷͻ;ͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͰΒͰͳ͊ͽͰͿͪ̽Ͱͪ
ͼ͵ͳ͋ͪ͵ͪͬͼͽͪͽ;ͼΒͰͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ͵ͳͷͱͳͬͽͷͳͼͺͻͰͷΕ;ͯͪ
ͲͪͻͪͯͬͰͻͰͳͼͽͻͺͳͪΒͬͰΕͪͳͼ͵;ͰΔͪ͌ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪͺͼͽͪΒͪΔͪͺͯͽ;ͻͼ͵ͷ
ͬͶͪΕ;ͽͰ͵ͯͪͼͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͷͪͻͯ;ͷͭͶͪ;ͺ;ͽͳͽͳͺͻͳͷͰͻͰͳΒͪͺͻ;͵ͪ
͈ͼͶͰͯΔͳͯͰͰͳΒͪ97*ͳ;97**ͬͰ͵;
;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͪͼͽͪΒͰͲͪͽͪ
ͫͻΒͳ͵ͪͪͯͪ;ͽͳ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͳͷ̿ͳͽͳΒͰͷͪΔͳͷͪΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͵ͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;;ͯͻ;ͽͬ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰͳͶͳ;ͼ͵Ͷͺ;
ͺͻͳͲͻͪ͵ΒͳͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;Β;;ͯͰͼͪΒͪͬΓͪΔͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͰͫͰͼ͵ͭͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪ
̽ͬͰͯͽͳͳ͵ͪͼ;
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽ;ͪ;ͳͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͰ
Ͱ͵ͪͯͷͭͶͰͼͽͪΒͪ
ͽͳ͵ͻͪΒ͵ͳͬͽͪ
ͳͰΕͳͪͽͪΒͪͳͰ͵;ͬͻͼͽ;Ϳ;Ͱͻͪͻ͵;ͶͽͰͰͶͳͰ
͊ͽͪͻͳΒͪ
ͱͳͽͳΒͪͳ͵ͪͲͪͷͰͳͽΒͰͯͰͶͲͭͻͪͿͪ̈́ͭͳͪͳͲͭͯͳͰ
ͪͯͪͅΒͰͷͭͶͪͪͼͽͪͽͳͺͱͰΓͳͯͰͪͼ͵ͭͫͻͪͽͼͽͬͪ
ͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͳͳ
ͺͻͳͶͭͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͪ
͵ΒͳͼͰ
ͽͰ͵ͫͶͰͼͽͪ
ͫͻͪͽͳͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͽͰͿͪ;ͲͪͺͷΕ
ͪͼͬΒ;ͷͶͫ;ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͺͳͻͳͷͲͪͺͳͼͷ́ͪ͵ͲͪͺͻͰͯͶͱͪ͵ͳͷͪ͏ͪͷ
ͫͶͪ͵ͬͰͺͻͼͶͪͬͰͼͪͼͽͪͬͰͺͼͬͰΕͰͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
ͳ͵ͪͳΒͰͺ;͵ͪͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪͳ
ͣͅͻͬͳΕ͡;ͫͳ͵ͬͳΕ
́͵ͼͽͪͼͻ͵ͬͰͼͬ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ;̺ͰͶͳ͵Β͎ͳ͈ͻͳͶͭͺͻ;
ͪͬͪΔ;͵;Ͷͽͪ͊ͽͰͬͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
͊ͽͪͻͳͪͻ
ͼ
*9m9 m
͈͊Ͱͽ͵ͬͳΕ
̈́ͳ͵ͬͳ͊ͻͫͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͽͪͷͺͪͳͷ͵Δͳͭͪͷͪ9*7ͬͰ͵ͪ
̀̈́͌
m
ͼͪͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
̹ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
́ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
m
͈͊Ͱͽ͵ͬͳΕ
̀ͳͯͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬͪͺͯͻ;Β;͈ͰΕ͵ͰͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͰm
͆ͬͳ͊ͪͯ
mJEFN
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͪͫͬͪ͌ͷͰͽͼͽͺͻͬͳͯͰͰͳΒͪͺͫͬͳ͈ͰΕ͵ͰͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳ
ΒͰ m
JÓ͊͆***
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͣͻͬͳΕ͡;ͫͳ͵ͬͳΕ
́͵ͼͽͪͼͻ͵ͬͰͼͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ;̺ͰͶͳ͵Β͎ͳ
m͑ͪ
͵ͽͪ
PQDJU
m͋ͯͳΕ
͐ͪͪ͵ͅͰͯͳΕ
PQDJU
m ͼͪͼͬͷͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰ
ͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
̹͋ͯͳΕ
̈́ͳͳͲͪͺͳͼͳͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͪ
JO͈ͻͳͬͪͽͳͱͳͬͽ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͲͰͷΓͪͷͪͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
Βͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͭͱͳͬͽͪ
ͬͰΕΒͰͼͪͼͬͳͷͼͫͰͯͰͶ͵ΒͰͼͪͱͳͷͪͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͰͰͶͰͷͰͽͰΔͰͭͬͭͽͬͪΔͪ͌ͲͺͷΕͳ͵ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͻͰͰΔͪ
ͳͪͭͶͪͼͪ͵ͪ
ͪͽͺͳͼͪ
ͽͰͼͷͳΓͰͳͷ͵ͷͺͬͪΔͰͷͼͰͪ
ͪͳ͵ͳͼ;ͺͻ
ͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͰͭͶͪͬͰͯͶͳ͵Ͱ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͭͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͭͶͳ͵͇ͪΒͰͺͻͪͬͰͯͳ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻ͵ΒͳͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͰͺͫͰΌ;ΒͰͼͪͭͷͬͰͻͰͳͷͶͳͽͬͰ
ͽͳΕͰͳ͵ͼͬͰͽͭ
͆ͳ͵ͶͰͳͼ;ͫΒͰ͵ͽΔͰͭͬͭ;ͯͰͼͭͯͰͶͬͪΔͪ
ͪͳͲͪͯͼͬͰͭͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͷ;Ͱͳ͵
͵ͽͳͽͻͳͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͼͬͭͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ͈ͪͬͪͶ;tͼͬͰͽͷ͵ͻͪΓ;ḯͭͳΒͰ
ͼͳͷ;ͼͶͳ͵ͪΒͿͻͷͳ
;ͺ;ͽͳͳͺͳͼͪͷͻͰΒ;
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͬͳ͊Ͷ;ͱͫ;̸͵ͪͽͳ
ͼͽ;͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵̹ͭͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳ;ͰͳͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͯͪͫͻͪͳͺͰͽ
ͼ͵ͳ ͷͰͽͪͿͻͪ
ΒͰ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ ͺͳͼͪ ͵ͪ t;͵ͻͪͰΔͰ ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪi ͳ t;Ͳͻ
ͽͻͺΓͰΔͪi
͵ͪtͼͽ;ͫiͳtͼͽͰ;i
ͫͻͲͭͺͷΕͳ͵ͪ;ͰͬΓͳͳΒͰͯͳͭͲͪͼͽ;ͺ
ͳ͵ͪ͊ͽͰͿͪΒͰt̽ͰͪͳͷͪͬͰͶͳ͵;ͽͬͻΌͰΔͰi
ͪͶͳͳt;͵ͻͪͼͼͬͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͲͰͷΓͰi
ͳtͺͬͪͶͪͬͪͼͰΓͰͰi͌ͼͻͰͯͳͽ;ͺͪͱΔͰΒͰ͵ͳͬͽͼͷͽͳͷͪ
ͽͼͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;
ͼͽͪͶͭ
ͷͱͰͽ;ͷͪͳͽͳ̈́ͭͳͬͳͷͰͺͼͻͰͯͳͷ;ͰΕͰͷ;ͫͻͰͯͳͷͪͬͰͲͪ
ͳͷͲͪͪΒͬͰΕ;ͯͰͪͼ͵;ͼͬͰͽͳΔ;͆ͰͽΓͰ
ͫͶͪͭ;ͪͳͷͳͻͽͳͬ
ͽͰͶ
tͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪiͫͳͶΒͰͲͪͼͬͰ͵Βͳͼ;ͷ;ͼͬͰͻͷͺͻͳͶͪͲͳͶͳtͳͼͽͳ͵ͷͭͳ
ͳͼͰΓͰΔͪi;ͬͳΒ
ͬͪͬͻͰͷͰͼ͵Βͻͪͬͳ
ΒͰ
ͼͯͪͰͶͳͷͪͽͰͶͭͳΒͰ
ͷͽͳΒ;
ͼͬͪͽͪ͵ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͪΒͪͳͪΒͪͬͪͼͺͪͼͰΔͪ̽ͰͶͪͲͭͻͪͿͪ̈́ͭͳͪ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽͼ;ͪΒ;ͲͬͳͰͳΒͳͳͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͳͲͻͪͲͽͬͪΔͪ;ͺ;ΕͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
͌Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳ͵;ͶͽͪͪͼͽͪͶͪͼ;ͳͯͻ;ͭͪ
ͷͱͯͪͷͪΔͰͽͪͪͪ
ͪͶͳͬͰͷͪͲͪͳ
ͷΓͳͬͪͼͽͬͪͻͰΔͪ͋ͪ͵ͬͪΒͰͳ͵ͪͺͰͶͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ 97**ͬͰ͵
͵ΒͪͼͰ
ͪͼͬ;ͯͳͷͰͲͳΒͪ
ͫͶͳ͵ͪͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪmͺͬΓͰͭͪͬͷ͵ͳͬ
ͽ;ͳͲ9*9ͬͰ͵ͪmͬͰͲ;ΒͰͲͪ͵ͬͰͭͼͷͽͳͷͪ͊ͪͯͻͱͳ;ͳ͵ͰͺͻͰͳͲͫ
ΒͪΔͪͬͪͪͽͺͳͼt͊ͪͻͪͪͼͬͰͽͭͬͰͶͳ͵ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪͷͰΌ;ͪͻͰͬͳͷͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭi̓ͻͪΓΒͰͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ͵ͪ͵ͶͰͱͳͪͯͻ;
ͳͼͺͻͰͯͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰ;͵Β;ΕͰ
ͷ;ͫͳͽͳͺͶͱͰͽͰͶ
ͯ͵ͷ;ͪΌͰͶͳ;ͲͼͰͯ;;ͪͰ͇ͫΒͰ͵ͻ;ͱͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͳͷͪͼͬͳͯͻ;ͽͬͰͳͼͽͪͶͰͱͪͳͶͪͬͳͷͪͺͻͯͳͰ
ͺͰͶͷ;
ͫͪͬΓͪΒ;ͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͳͻ͵ͬͰ
ͯ͵ͷ;͵ͻͪΒ;ͲͭͶͪͬΓͪͼͽΒͰͪͻͳ
Ͱͺͳͼ͵ͺ̽ͪͳͶͳͳͭ;ͷ̸ͪͻͼͰͳΒͰ͊ͬΒͰͬͻͼͳͳͼͽͻͳͳͲͪͷ͵ΒͳͯͶͳ͵;ΒͰ
ͽ;͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͼ;ͬͰΕͳͼͽͪ͵Ͷͳ
͵ͪͳΔͰ;ͺͻͪͬ;ͼͬͻ;͊ͬͰͽͪ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪ͵ΒͪΒͰͬͰ͵ͬͰͳͶͪͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵͊ͽͰͿͪͬͭͺͻͰͶͪͼ͵ͪͳͲͬͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͭ;
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
ͬͰͳͱͳͬͽͫͳͶͪΒͰͰ͵ͪͬͻͼͽͪͺͻͪ;ͲͻͪͲͪͺ͵ͶͰΔͪͷͪͪͳͬͰͻͳ͵ͪ͵Βͳ
ͼ;ͼͰͪͯͪͺͷͰͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͵;ͺΓͪͶͳ͵͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭͭͻͫͪ
ͷͳͼͽͳͼͰ
ͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱ;Β;Εͳͳͷͪͽͼ;ͼͰ
͵ͻ;ͱ;Β;Εͳͼͪͷͻͽͳͯͪͻ
ͺͼͶͰͯΔͳͺͻ
ͼͽͳͶͳͼΔͳͷ
͊ͬͻͰͷͰͷΒͰ͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͯͪͶͰ͵ͪͯͳͪ͵ͬͳͻͰΔͰ
ͭͬͰͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰ́ͲͻͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬͳͻͪͲͶͭͪ
ͪͻͳͽΒͰͫͳͻͪͲͬͳΒͰͪͺͯͻ;
Β;ͅͰͽͳΒͰ
;ͬͪͽͳͬͳͯ;ͫ͵Ͱ͵ͻͰͰ;ͪͻͯΒͺͫͱͼͽͳ͉ͪͳͻͳ
ͼͰͳ;͈ͬͪͻͯͪͻΒ;
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ;͇ͬͰͷͺΓ;
ͭͯͰΒͰ͵ͻͪΓ;
͵ͪ͵ͼͰͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶ
ͬͰͻͬͪͶ
ͼͬͰͽͳ͆ͳ͵Ͷͪ;ͯͷͬͻͪͽͳͬͳͯ͊ͪͯͻͱͳͪͳ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͳͭͶͰͯͼ;ͳͷͪͶͳͯΒͰ͵ͪͳ;ͯͪͶͰ͵ͳͷͼͽͻͪͪͷͪ
Ͱͷ;ͭͬͻͳΔͰͭͬͻͪͼ
ͺͻͼͽͳͻͪΔͰ;͉;ͼͳΒͳ̺ͳͼ͵;ͭͶͰͯtͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪiͺͽͬͻΌͰΒͰͳͪͼͫͰ
ͪͳmͰ;ͼͺͰͶͷͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͷ͉ͳͷ͵ͪͽͶͳ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰͯͪͼͰͫͪͬͳ͵ͪͳ
ͲͪͳΒͪͳͶͳͫͪͻͫͰͪͽͳͿͳ͵ͪͳΒͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͰ͊ͻͫͳͺͻͳͯͫͳ
ͶͳͲͪ;ͳΒ;̓ͭͻͰͭͪͳΒͪͲͪͺͻͺͪͭͪͯ;ͬͰͻͰͲͪͯ;ͱͳͶͪΒͰ
ͳͲͽͳͻͪͲͶͭͪ
ͺͪͺͼ͵ͭͷͳͼͳͪͻ͍ͪͻͪͪ̈́ͰͪͻͯͳΒͪͯͪͯͰ;̽ͰͪͰͳͺͯͰͼͰͳͲͬͰͽͪΒ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͷͷͽͳͷͪ
ͽΒͰͳ;ͳͳͭͯͳͰ͌ͺͻ͵ͼͷͭͫͻΒͳͷ
Ͱͽͪͼͽͳͷͪ͵ΒͳͷͪͫͳͶ;ΒͰΔͰͭͬͳͲͬͰͽͪΒ
͵Ͷͳ͵ͲͫͭͰͫͪͬͰͽͰͼͽͳ
ͽͶͳ͵ͳͲͫͭͽͰͯͰͳͲͼͽͳ
ͽͼͬͰͯͰΔͰͷͱͰͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͬͰͻͯͼͽΒ
ͳͷ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͽͬͪΔ;ͷͽͳΒ;̈́Ͱͪͻͯͳͽͪ͵͵ͪͱͰͯͪͼͰͰ;ͬͪΒ;;
̽Ͱͪͳͷͪͳ;ͱͳͬͪΒ;ͪΒͬͰΕͰͺͽͬͪΔͰ͵ͪ͵ͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͳͽͪ͵ͳ͵ͪͽͶͳ
͵ͳͻͳΕͪͪ
ͪͯͪͼͰ͵ͻͪΓͼͷͪͽͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰͷͲͫͭͼͬͭͺͻͳͷͰͻͭͱͳͬͽͪ
ͺͻͪͬͰͯͼͽͳͳͺͫͱͼͽͳ͇ͽͪ͵ΌͰͳͲͬͰͽͪͬͪ
ͪͼͬ;ͼͬͰͯͰΔͪt͵
ΒͳͷͪͼͰͺ;ͲͯͪͷͱͰͬͰͻͬͪͽͳi
ͯͪΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͽͰͶ;ͰͶͼͽͳͼͪ;ͬͪͳͯͪ
ΒͰͳͼͯͳͽͰͷͭͳ;ͯͰͼͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͊ͬͰ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͳΒͪͼ;ͺͼͽͪΒͪͶͪͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͲͬͪͪͳͼͺΓͪͬͪΔͪ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰ
ͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͢ͰͭͬͶͳ͵ͰΕͰͰͭͻͪͳΒͰͺͼͽͪΒͰͯͰͱͳͬͺͳͼͪ
ͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͼͰͪͳ͵ͪͷͪͳͭͻͪͿͳ͵ͳͷͶͳͼͽͬͳͷ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵;
ͺͺ;ͶͪͻͼͽͲͪͯͫͳͶͪΒͰͼͰͪ;ͯͰͼͭͬͻͪΕͪΔͪͬͳͯͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
͵Βͪ;ͶͪͲͳ
;ͼͪͼͽͪͬͷͭͳͳ͵Ͷ;ͼͪ͊ͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ
Ͱͼͪͷ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͬͰΕͳ;ͻ;ͼ͵Β;ͷͰͽ
ͼͽͳ97*ͳ97**ͬͰ͵ͪ+ͰͯͪͯͰͶͰͷͰͪͽͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ͵;ͶͽͪͼͫͳͽKF
ͻͰͳͽͳͬͰͷͪͬͪͱͪ͋ͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͢ͳͬ;ͪΒ
ͻͪͳΒ;ͺΒͪͬ;ͯͪͪͼͳΒͰͷͭ;ΕͰͺͻͰͳͲͯͻͰͯͳͽͳ
ͪͶͳͫͳͼͰ
ͪͼͬ;ͻͪͼ
ͺͶͱͳͬͳͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͪͷͭͶͪͺͪΒͺͻͰͷͭͶͪͬͰͲͪͽͳͲͪͻͪͲͯͫΓͰͪ͵ͫ
ͬͰ͈ͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͰ͉ͪͼͺͪͻͪͬͪΔͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͯͻͰͬͪΒͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͫͳͪΒ
Ͳͪͼͬͪͪ;ͬͰͻͰΔ;ͯͪͼͰͫͶͪͭͯͪͽͪͼͳͶͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͰΒͰͯͪ͵ͼͪͱͳͼͺΓͪ
ͬͪ;ͼͬͪ͵ΒΔͰΒͰͼͽͳͳ͋ͪͼͬͪͽͪΔͪ
;ͲͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͪͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͪͽ;ͷͪ
ͰΔͪ
ͫͳͶͪͼ;ͯͫͻͺͲͪͽͪͳͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ
ͯ͵ͷͽͬͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ
ͷͽͳΒ;ͳΔͳͬͳͯͰͶͳΕͪ;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͪͽͯͪͼ;ͪͫͳͶͪͼͪͱ;͵ͻͰΔͰͪ;
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ͇ͽͷͰ͵ͪ͵ͬͪΒͰ
;ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;
ͫͳͶͪͼ;ͯͫͳͪͷͽͳΒ;͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱ
ͪͼ͵ͭͺͳͼͪͳͳͲͬͻͳͳͽͪͰͭͬͻͰ́ͪ͵ͼ;ͯͰͪͼ͵ͳͷͪͼͳͼͳͭ;ͻ
ͺͷ;ͬͪͶͳͼͬΒ;ͪΒͬͰΕ;ͯͻͪͭͰͼͽ
ͯͼ;ͼͽͬͶͰͬͰͻ;͵ͰͳͽͰΕͰΔͰͭͶͪ
ͬͰΒͪͼͺ͵ͪͲ;Β;ͯͪͷͽͳͳͼ;ͺͻͰͽͻͪΒͪͶͰ;ͰͶͬͳͽͷͫͶͳ͵;͆Ͱͯͪͬ
ͼ;
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͳͲͰͽͳͯͫͻͳͻͪͲͶͲͳͲͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵;ͯͪͼͰͯͰͶͳΕͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ
͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͪͶͪͲͳ;ͽͲͬ̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͷ͵ͻͼͽ;
ͼͽͪͬͻͽͰͳͯͪͽͬͪΒ;
97*m97**ͬͰ͵
͵ΒͪͼͰͯͪͪͼ;ͬͪ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;̺ͪͽͺͰͯ;ͪ͊ͬͰͽΒ̻ͻͳ̀ͪ
ͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͯͪΒͬͰΕͰͭΒͰͲͪͪΒͪͽͽͼ;ͼͰ;̽Ͱͪͳͷͪͼͪ;ͬͪͶͰͻͰͶͳ
͵ͬͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͭͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪ͠ͰͯͪͯΔͳΒͰ͵ͷͪͯͼ;ΌͰͻͪͽͪͷͱ;ͽͰͫΒͰ
͵ΒͳͷΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰͷͺͻͰͯͪΔ;
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͺ͵;ͺͳͼͬΒ;͵ͻͬ;ͪͼ;
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
͵ͪͯͪͼ;ͭͪͼͶͰͺΓͳͬͪͶͳ
ͪͺͻͪΔͰΒͰ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;ͫͶͳ͵;ͯͻͬͰͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͼ
ͳͼͺͳͼͪͳͷ͵ͻͳͺͽͭͻͪͷͳͷͪ̽ͻ;ͭͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͪΒͰ͵ͻͬ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͪ
͵ΒͪͼͰ;ͬͪ
;ͯͬͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ͇ͪͼͳͷ;ͺͷͰ;ͽͷ
;͵ΒͰͷΒͰͳͼ;ΌͰͻ
ͪͼͰ
;ͺͳΒͰͪ;
ͽ͵ͪͳ;ͲͰͶͰͰͫΒͰ
;ͬͪͳ;͵ͳͬͽ;ͳͲͭͯͳͰ
ͼΒͰͯͷͰͼͽͳͷ͐ͪ
ͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͳͯͰͶͳΕͳͷͪͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳͬͻͪͪ
ͼͬͰͽ̸ͭͶͳͷͺͳΒͪ͊ͽͶͺͳ͵ͪͳ
ͼͬͰͽ͈ͭͪͽͰͶͰΒͷ͉ͪͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪΒͰͽͪͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵ͬͪͪͪͽͺͳͼͷt͊ͬͰͽͪ
͵ͻͬͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭi̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͫͻͪͽͼͽͬͳͳͯͰͶͲͳ͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱͻ
͵ͬͰͳͭͶͰͯͼ;ͱͰͶͰͶͳͯͪͳͪͽͪΒͪͳ
ͬͰͻͳͷͪͪΒ;ͺͰͪͽΓͳͬͳΒͳ
ͺͻͳ
ͫͶͳͱͰͶͳ͵ͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ́ͯͰΒ;ͼ;ͺͯ;ͺͻͶͳͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳͷ
ͺͻ
ͬͰͻͰͳͷͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪmͺͻͰΌͰΔͰͷͼͪΒͯͻͪͭͰͳΒͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪͬͪͼͺ;ͱͬͪͳͼͽͪͳ͵ͻͬͳͳͷͪͶͳͼ;;Ͳͻ;͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳͷ
ͪͳΓͳͷΒͰ
ͫͳͯͪͺ͵ͪͱ;͵ͪ͵ΒͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͯ͵ͻͪΒΔͳͭͻͪͳͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳͷ;Ͱͳ͵;
ͼͷͻͽ
ͺͼͶͰͯͬͪ͊ͺͪͼͳͽͰΓ;͊Ͷͳ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;ͷͭͶͰͼ;ͳͷͪͽͳͯͰͪͼ͵Ͱ
ͰͼͽͳͰ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͳͬͶͪͼͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͰ͵ͼͰ
͵ΒͰΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪͺͻͰͯͪΔ;
ͼͬͰͽͳ
͊ͪͬͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͯͫͳͯΒͰͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͭͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪ͠ͰͻͰͷͳΒͰͳ͵ΒͰͼ;;ͬͪͰ
;Ͳͷͽͳ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͌ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;t͊ͽͻͪͼͽͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͰiͫͳͶͰͼ;
ͪΒͬͰΕͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͳ
ͺͺ;ͽͯͻ;ͭͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͺͻͰ͵ͶͷͳͲ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͪ
ͳͷͪͶͰ
ͼ;;Ͷͭ;ͼͬͰͽͪͭ;Ͳͻͪͺͻͳͼͬͪ͵ͷtͺͻͰͰΔ;iͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͳͪͼͽΒͪΔ;ͯͪ
ͼͰ;Ͷ͵ͪͶΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͳͲͬͻͳͰ͵ͼͬͰΕͰΔͰ͆ͪͻͳͽͼͷͳͼͪͳͿ;͵ͳΒ;
ͳͷͪΒͰͳͫͳͪΒͯͪͼͰ;͵ͳͬͽͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͺͶͪͱ;ͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͰͯͻͪͭͰͼͽͳ
͇ͼͳͷͺͷͰ;ͽͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͽ;ͼ;ͪ͵ͪͯͼͽͪͬΓͰͰͳͯͬͰͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰ
ͪͷͺ;ͶͰ
ͯ͵ΒͳΒͰΒͰͯͪͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͶͪͰͼͽͳ;͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ
ͪͯͻ;ͭͪͼͪͼ;Ͱ;
ͽͰͼͽͰͺͲͪͽͭͺͻͰ͵Ͷͪ͌͵ͳͬͽ;ͼͰͪͶͪͳͷͪͶͪ͵;ͽͳΒͪͼͷͽͬͷ
ͼͳͽͳͯͰͶͳΕͪͷͽͳΒ;ͲͪͪͽͳͷͳͼͰͳͺͪͻͰͯͰͱͯͰ
ͳͯͰͽͳͰͽ͵ͪͳͳ
̻ ͗ͻͳͳΕ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ ͺͻͬͰͪ·
͆ͬͳ ͊ͪͯ
̈́ ͈ͪͬͶͬͳΕ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵Ͱ ͪͷͺ;ͶͰ
̀ͫͻͳ͵ͅ;ͲͰΒͪͺͻͳͷͰΔͰͰ;ͷͰͽͼͽͳ
-PDDJU͑ͪ͵ͽͪ
PQDJU
- 1FUFST
#MVU VOE 8BTTFS
JO 3FMJRVJFO
7FSFISVOH VOE 7FSLMÅSVOH
FE " -FHOFS
,ÕMO
m-FHOFS
3FMJRVJFOJO,VOTUVOE,VMU
m
͗ͻͳͳΕ
MPDDJU͉̻ͻ;ΒͳΕ
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
JO͆ͪͻͯͪͰͳ͵ͶͺͰͯͳΒͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͻͬͪͽͼ͵ͼͶ
ͬͰͪ͵ͪ
FE͊ͽ͊ͽͪΒͰͬͳΕ
͵Δ***
͈ͪͬͶͬͳΕ
PQDJU
m
30VTUFSIPVU
'MFYJCMF(FPHSBQIZBOE5SBOTQPSUBCMF5PQPHSBQIZ
JOѮF 3FBM BOE *EFBM +F
SVTMFNJO+FXJTI
$ISJTUJBOBOE*TMBNJD"SU
FE#,ÛIOFM
+FXJTI"SU
WPMm m
m̸̹̈́ͰͶΊͰͬ
̻ͻ̻ͫͼͺͯͰ·ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳͼͬΊͽʹͲͰͷͶͳ
JO͎ͻͳͼͽͳͪͼ͵ͳͰͻͰͶͳ
͵ͬͳͳͬͷͼ͵ͬͼ͵ͷ̓ͻͰͷͶͰ
FË̸́ͅͳͯͬ
ͅͼ͵ͬͪ
m1.BHEBMJOP
-ÊHMJTFEV
1IBSFFUMFTSFMJRVFTEFMB1BTTJPOÆ$POTUBOUJOPQMF 7**Fm7***Fm9***FTJÍDMFT
99$POHSÍTJOUFSOB
UJPOBMEFTFUVEFT#Z[BOUJOFT5BCMFSPOEF-FTSFMJRVFTEF1BTTJPO
1BSJT
m ͺP
Wͳ
͈ͺͬͳΕ
4BDSBFSFMJRVJBF
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪͽͺΓͰΒ͵ͻͬΓ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͆Ͱ͵Ͱ
Β;ͬͰ͵ͰͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵ͬͪͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
mͺͪͻͰͯͰΕͰͳͯͬͪ͵ͷͪͯͪͯͻͬͰͽͪmͪͶͪͲͳͶͰͼ;ͼͰ;͵;ͽͳΒͳͼ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳͷ
ͬͶͪͼͳͷ͈ͪͻͳͶͲͳͼͬͰͽͷ͵ͻͪΓ;ͷͭͶͳͼ;ͫͳͽͳͳ;ͬͳͯ;ͪ͵ͳͽͪ͵Βͳͷͪͼ;
;͵ͻͪͪͬͪͰͷͽͳ
ͽͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰͳͲͬͰͽͪΒͿͻ̹͈ͪͪͶͪ;ͶͪͳͲͭͯͳ
Ͱ͋ͰͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͰΒͰͼͻͰͯͳͷ9*9ͼͽͶͰΕͪͬͳͯͰͳͺͳͼ̻ͪͰͯͰ͠;ͻͳͳΕ
t͌ ͵ͳͬͽ; ͪ ͻ;ͳ ͼͬͰͽͭ ͵ͻͪΓͪ ͬͳͯͳ ͼͰ ΒͰͯͪ ͺͲͶͪΕͰͪ ͭͻͳͬͪ ͵ͻ;ͺͳͷ
ͫͳͼͰͻͷͳͼ͵ͳΕͰͪͳͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͪͺͻͼͽͳͷͪͺͻͼͽͰͪͼͻͰͫͻͳ
ͳͷͪͽͪ͵ΌͰͯͬͪ
ͺͻͼͽͰͪͺͻͼͽͪwi͋ͳͯͪͻͬͳ;ͳΔͰͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;͵ͪͳͲͻͪͲͷͶͫͰͳͶͳͲͪ
ͬͪͶͼͽͳͲͪ;ͳΔͰ;ͯͫͻͫͳͽͺͼͽͪΒͪͶͳͼ;ͳͼͪͷͳ
;ͯͯͳͻ;ͼͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͷ
Ͱ͵ͪͬͻͼͽͪͼͰ͵;ͯͪͻͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͳͲ;ͲͰͽͳͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪͳͷΕͳ
͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͻ͵ͬͰͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͪͪͻͳͽͪͻͯͰͺͫͱͼͽͳ
ͪΒͬͪ
ͱͳΒͪͽͰ͵ͬͳͪ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͼͽͪͬΓͰͪͺ͵ͶͰΔͳͷͪͫͳͶͪΒͰΔͰͭͬͪ;
ͯͽͬͻͪͷΕ͉ͰΒͰtͺΒͪͬͳͯ;ͭͭͽͻͪΒͪΔͪi
ͭͽͬͫͰͲͪͪͶͭͳΒͪ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͵ͺ͵ͽͳ;ͳͽͰͽ;ͽͪ͵ͳͺͪͳ;ͳͼͺΓͪͬͪΔ͇ͪΔΒͼͬͰͯ
ͳͺͫͱͪͺͻͪ͵ͼͪ
ͱͳͬͪͼͬͰͯͺͼͶͰͯΔͳͯͰͰͳΒͪ99ͼͽͶͰΕ͇ͪͪΒͰͳͷͪ
ͶͪͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͰͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͺͻͳͺͬͰͼͽͳ;ͯͳͷͪ
͵ΒͰͼ;;ͅͰͽͳΒͳͪͯͳͶͪͲͳͶͰ
ͪͳͪͶͰͳ͵ͿͰͼͳͪͶͰ͵ͬͳͻͰ
ͯͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͫͻͰͯͪͬͰͲͪͳͲͪ
tͼͬͰͽ;ͬͯ;i̽ͬͪͪΒͺͽͬͪͳΒͪ͵ͶͪͯͰͪ͵Βͪͼ;ͯͬΌͰͪ;ͰͺͼͻͰͯ;ͬͰ
Ͳ;ͼͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͷ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͷͪͶͪͲͳͶͪͼ;ͼͰ;ͫͶͳͲͳͳΔͰͭͬͰͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰ
͵ͪ
ͳͻ͵ͬͰ;͇ͬͰͷͺΓ;͵Βͪͷ;ΒͰͫͳͶͪͺͼͬͰΕͰ͉ͪͪͲ;ͷΓͳͬΒͰͯͪΒͰͭͶͪͬ
ͳͼͯͳͽͰ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪͫͳ͵ͳͬͽͼ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͷͷͽͳͷͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͽ͵ͷͷ
ͭͳͼͽͶͰΕͪͳͼͺΓͪͬͪ;ͯͰͼͰͷΕͳ͆ͪΒͰΕͰͼ;ͬͰͻͳ;ͺ;ΕͳͬͪͶͳͷͶͳͽͬͰ
ͲͪͳͼͰΓͰΔͰͯͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳͫͶͰͼͽͳͳͶͳͲͪͯͫͳΒͪΔͰͺͽͷͼͽͬͪ
ͪͶͳͼͰͯͰͶ
ͽͬͻͼͽtͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪi
ͼͽͳͪΒͰͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ
ͰͼͽͳͼͺΓͪͬͪͶͪ
ͳ͵ͻͲͽͪ͵ͲͬͪͪͰͭͪͽͳͬͪ;ͯͪm͵ͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͰͪͼͳͶͳ͵ͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͺ͵;ͪͶͳ
ͯͪ;ͭͻͲͰͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳΔͰͭͬͫͻͪͽͼͽͬ͐;ͯͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͪ
͵ͺͻͬͰt͵ͪͽͪͶͭͳͲͪͳΒͰi
͵Β;ΒͰͪͳͳ̻ͻͳͭͻͳΒͰ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͺͰͽ͵ͷ97
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪͼ;ͬͰ͵ͬͳͷͪͯͰ͵ͶͰ͵ͽͳͬͭͺͪͷΕͰΔͪͳͫͻͳͱΓͳͬ;ͬͪͳͳͺͻͰ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
ͰͳͺͻͰͯͪΔͪ͋ͪΒ͵ͪͽͪͶͭͺͻͬͳΒͰͫͬͳ
;ͽͻͰΕΒͯͰͰͳΒͳ99ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪͻͳͷͪͯͻͳͽ̈́ͰͽͳΒͰ͆ͳ͵ͬͳΕ
ͬͰͷͪͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳͯͰͪͼ͵ͳͼͽͪͻͰͳͪ͌Ͳ
ͺͲͪͽͰͶͰͭͰͯͰ
ΒͰͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͳͳͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪ
͵ͪ
ͺͽͬͻͯ;ͯͪ;ͯͽͬͻͪͷΕͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͳΒͰͺͼ;ͼͽͪͶͪ
͋͵ͬͳ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ;ͬͳΒͰͯͫͪͪͯͳͶͪͲͰ͵ͬͳͻͰ
ͬͭͻ͈ͪͯͪͷͳΔͰͷͳ
ͳͺͪ͵
;ͭͶͪͬͳͷͫͻͳͼͳͷͪ
͵ͪͳͶ;ͼͽͻͪͳΒ;ͪͰ
ͺͰͽͰͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵Ͱ͵ͽͳ;ͳͽͰͽ;͵;ͶͽͪͳͼͪͫͻͪͱͪͬͪΔ;tͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽͪi
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͵ͶͼͽͳͷͪͳͺͽͻͰͫͪͷͪͰͺͰ͆ͪͺͻͰͯͼͳͼͽͻͪΒͪͬͪΔͰͷͿͶ
͵ͶͻͳͫͶͳ͵ͪͽͬͪΔͪ
;97***ͬͰ͵;ͺΒͪͬΓ;Β;ͼͰͬͰͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵Ͱͳͳͳ
ΒͪͽͳͬͰ͆ͪͻͳͽͲͪͼͶ;ͱͪͲͪͳͻͰΔͰ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͫͳ
ΒͰ̻ͬͪ͠ͰͻͭͳΒͰͬͳΕ
ͯͰͪͼ͵ͳͷͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ
ͫͪͬΓͪΒ;ΕͳͳͲͬͪͱͳͻ͵ͬͰ
ͳͿ;͵ͳΒͪ
;ͲͪͺͻͰͯͬͪͯͺͶͱͪΒͪ͵ͪͻͶͬͪ͵ͭͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽ͈ͪͻͳͬͻ
ͱͰͼͽͰ͵ͪͯͪΔͰͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪΒͰͼͳͼͽͰͷͪͽͼ͵ͷͫͻͳͭͷ̽Ͱͪͳͷͪ
ͳΔͳͬͷͼͬͰͽͷͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓ;
ͺͪͼͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭ
ͭͯͳͰͺͼͽͪͻͪ
͵ͯͬͻͰΔͪͲͶͪͽͽ͵ͪͭͺ͵ͻͬͪͲͪ͵ͳͬͽ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͽͻͪͰ
;ͲͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ̸ͪͻͼͰͳΒͪ*7ͬͪͬ͠ͳΕͪ
ͳΒͳΒͰͪͻͳΌͪ͵ͫͳ
ͳͷͪΒͰ
͵Γ;ͳ;ͽͳͪΒͪͳͻͰΔͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ͵ͻͪΓͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ;ͬͷͼͻͺͼ͵ͷͼͽͪͳͽ;
ͫͶͪͼͽͳͷͪͺͻͰ͵͊ͪͬͰͳ̽;͈ͪͬͪͺ;Ͷͪͻͼͽͳ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͪͻͳ
ͽΒͰͯͺͻͳͰͶͪͭͻͪͬͳͻͪͳͲͭͯͳͰ
ͪ͵ΒΒΒͰͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪͪͬͰͯ;ͽͪ̽Ͱͪͪ
;ͲͶͳ͵ͬͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͳͺͻ;ͳ̸ͪͻͼͰͳΒͪ*7ͬ͠ͰΕͳ;ͽͳͪΒͳͷͪͶͪΒͰ͵ͷ
ͺͲͳͳΒͪ;ͯͰͼͭΒͪͬΓͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷͯͭͯͳͰ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪͪͪͳ͵ͼͽͪͼ;ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱͯͬͻͼ͵Ͱ͵ͪͺͰͶͰ
ͪͼͰ
ͬͰͷͪͰͼͽͼͶͳ͵ͪͶͪͪͺͯͻ;Β;̓ͪͻͶͬͪ͵ͰͷͳͽͻͺͶͳΒͰ͈ΒͪͬͪͳͳͻͰ
ΔͰͽͰͼͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͳΒͰΒͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͷͰͼͽͫͳͼ͵Ͷͳ͵ͼͽͪͼͪ
ͷͭͶͳͼ;ͫͳͽͳͯ
ΒͰ͵ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͳͽͰͷͪͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͼͶͳ͵ͪͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͪͬͰͲͪͳͲͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͪ;
ͯͪͳͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺͻͳͷͰͻͰͰͻΒͼ͵ͭͱͻͽͬͬͪΔͪͲͪͬͰͻ;̓ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͬͳͲ;ͰͶͷͰͶͰͷͰͽ;͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͯͳͲ;ͲͰͽͰΒͰͬͪͱͼͽͳͫͳͶͽͽΒͰͶͳ͵ͼͬͰͽͭ
͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͯͫͳͷͰͼͽ;ͬͰͻͼ͵ͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͷͺͻͭͻͪͷ;̓ͪͻͶͬͪ͵Ͱ
ͷͳͽͻͺͶͳΒͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͷͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͼͶͳ͵͇ͪΒͰͪͻͳͽΒͪͼͺͻ͵Ͷͪͷ
ͬͪ;ͺͶͪͳͻͪͷͪͶͳͰͫΒͪͬΓͰͷͯͰͶ;4FSCJBJMMVTUSBUBͳͲ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷ;
ͲͪͷͰͳͽΒ͊ͽͰͷͪͽͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͿͻͪͦͰͿͪͻͬͳΕͪͳ͋ͷͪͼͪͅͰͼͷͰͻͪͳͲ
ͭͯͳͰ͊ͽͰͿͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͽͪ͵ͺͼͽͪΒͰͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͪ4FSCJBTBODUB
ͺ
ͬͻ͵ͰͪͳͪͶͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪmͼͽͪͻͳͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͳͳͬͳͼͻͰͷͼ͵ͳmͼͪ
ͷͼͬΒͭͰͫͰͼ͵ͭͺͪͽͰͪͼͷͳΓͰͭͻͪͯͳͯͫͻͪͰͳͻͪͲͬΒͪͬͰͻͼ͵ͭͳ
ͪͳͪͶͭͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽͪ͌ͽͷͼͽͶͰΕ;͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪͪͯͭͻͪΌͰ
ΒͰ ͳ Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪ ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪ ͼͬͰͽͷ ͊ͽͰͿͪ; ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ ͪͶͪ
ͼͰ
ͼΒͺͰͽͼͶ;ͱͫͳ͊ͻͫͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͷͪ
;ͻͪ͵ͬͪ͵ͷ͊ͻͫΓͪ͵;ͳͲ
ͭͯͳͰ
ͪ ͺͽͷ ΒͰ ͺͻͰͽͪͷͺͪͪ ͳ ; ͺͲͳΒͳͷ ͳͲͯͪΔͳͷͪ m ͻͳͷͳ͵ͷ ͳͲ
ͳ ͷͶͰͽͪ͵ͷ ͳͲ ͭͯͳͰ ͊ͽͰͿͪ ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳ ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪ ΒͰ
;Ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͰͪͳͪͶͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰ
͇ͺͽͷͼͽͳͳͻͷͲͪͲͪΒͰͯͳ͵;ͼͶ;ͱͫ;ͼͬͳΒ;
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͵Β;ΒͰͼͪͼͽͪͬͳ̻ͬͪ͠ͰͻͭͳΒͰͬͳΕͳͲͷͰΌ;ͳ
ͭͯͳͰ͆ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͳͺͲͪͽͳͺͻͰͺͳͼͼͪ;ͬͪΒͰ;ΔͰͭͬͷ͈ͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼ;͊ͽͰͿͪ
;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
ͻͪͼ͵ͷͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;͵ΒͳΒͰͼͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ;͵ͻͪͼͳ͆ͳ͵Ͷͪ͆Ͱ͵
ͬͳΕ̻ͬͪ͠ͰͻͭͳΒͰͬͳΕ
;ͽͬͻͰͷͰͬͻͪ͵ͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺ
ͳΒͰͲͪͫͻͪͬͳͼͬΒͰ
͵ͪͯͪΔͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ
ͺͪΒͰͽͪΒͻ;͵ͺͳͼͬͰΕͳͯ;ΕͰͭͯͳͰͺͼͶͪ;̽ͰͪͰ
͠ΒͰͯͪͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͼͪͼͽͪͬ
;ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰͳͼͺͻͪͬͪͽͻͳͫ;ͳͻͪͳͯͪͽͬͪ
ͺͼͬͰͯͳͫͳͺͻͳͬͻͱͰͼͽͻͪͼͰΓͰͳͯͰͪͼ͵ͳͷͪͪͼͬͷͼͬͰͽͷ͵ͻͪ
Γ;ͳΔͰͭͬΒͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͳ͋ΒͰͺͬͪͶ͈ͪͰͼͷͪͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
͵Β;ΒͰ͵ͭͯͳͰ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;̽ͳͬͳ
ͼͪͳͳ͠ͼͳͿ͊ͽͪ
ͬͳΕ
ͪͼͬΒͰͳͷͰmt͠ͼͳͿͷͪimͽ͵ͻͳ;ͪ͵ͻͼͽͳ;
͌97***ͬͰ͵;ͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͳͳͶͰͼ;͵ͼͳ;ͱͳͬͽͪ;ͷͪͪ
ͼͽͳͻ;͈ͯͳͶͳͼ;ͳͷͭͳͯͪͼͳͳͳͺ;ͽͳͳ
ͯ͵ΒͳͳͰ͵ͳͬͰ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
ͷͪ;ͭͶͰͯͳ
ͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͫͻͪͽͼͽͬͺͷͼͰͼͽͪͻͪͶͯͪͯͻͱͳͳͺͻͳͻͳ
͵;Ͷͽͼͳͬͪͪ͋ͪͼͽΒͪΔͰͳͷͪͶΒͰͺͼͰͫͪͼͷͳͼͪͪ͵;͵ͳͯͪΔ͈ͪͰΕ
͵ͰͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͰͭͯͳͰ͌;ͼͶͬͳͷͪͿͪͪͻͳͽͼ͵ͰͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͼ͵Ͱ;ͺͻͪͬͰ
͵;ͶͽͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭͼͳͬͪͪͼͪͱΒͰͺͯ;ͺͳͻͪͰͼͪͷͼͻͺͼ͵;;ͺͻͪͬ;
ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͷͬͰΕͳͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͳͽͰͽͼͺͼͽͬͰͰͻ͵ͬͰͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ̓;ͶͽΒͰͲͫͭͽͭͪ
ͪͯͭͻͪΌͰͬͳͷͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͷͪ
͵ͪͽͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭͲͪ
ΔͰͭͬ;͵ͻͬͪͳΔͰΒͰͭͯͳͰͺͼͰͫͪ
ͬͰΕͺͷͳΔͪͳ͵ͳͬͽ̓;Ͷͽ
ͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ;ͺͻΒͰͳͼͽͻͪΒͪͬͪͳͽ͵ͷ9*9ͼͽͶͰΕ͇ͪͽͷͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͪΒͰ;
ͼͬͰͼͽͳͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪͫͳͶͪͬͪͱͼͽ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͳͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͯͳͺͳͼͷ͵
ΒͰΒͰͭͯͳͰͼͽͪͻͰͳͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪ;ͺ;ͽͳͬͶͪͯͳ͵͈ͪͰͽͪͻ*͈ͰͽͻͬͳΕ
͢Ͱ͇ͭͫͪͬͰͽͪͬͪΒ;Εͳͭͪ;ͼͽͪ͵;͵ΒͳͼͰͼͺͻͰͷͪͺͻͽͳͬ͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ
͢Ͱͭ
ͭͪ;ͺͲͻͪͬͪͪͽͯͪͯͫͻ;ͬͪͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͳͺͻͰͯͶͪͱͰͷ;ͯͪͳ
;ͼͶ;ͪΒ;ͺͪͼͼͽͳͺͻͰͰͼͰͪ͏ͰͽͳΔͰ̓Γ;ͳͺͯͼͽͳͪΒͻͪͲͬΒ;͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͯͪͶͪΒͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͪͫͬͪ̽ͰͪͪͺͰͽ͵ͷ9*9ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;
ͽͻ;ͯͷͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳ
ͼͽͪͻͰͳ͎ͪͪΘͳ̽ͪͳͶͪͳ͎ͪΘͳ̀ͪͪͻͳΒͪ
ͱͳͬΓͰͳͳ;ͪͺͻͰΌͰͳͼͬͳͫͶͳ
ͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͭͱͳͬͽͪ͌ͼ͵Ͷͺ;ͽͳͪ͵ͽͳͬͼͽͳ
ͭͯͳͰͪͳΔͰΒͰ
ͺͻͰͺͳͼ͈ͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
ͼͺͻͽͻͰͽͳͷͪ͵ͽͳͽͻ͎ͪͪΘͳ̽ͪͳͶͪ
ͳ͎ͪΘͳ̀ͪͪͻͳΒͰ͵ΒͰΒͰͪͼͶͳ͵̸ͪͶͰ͵ͼͳΒͰ̈́ͪͲͬͳΕ͊ͫͲͳͻͷͪͽͯͪΒͰ
͈ͪͻͪ͵ͶͳͼͫͳͰͺͼͻͰͯͺͬͰͲͪͼͷͽͳͷͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭmͼͶ;ͱͫͪΒͰͳͽͪͪ
ͯͬͪͺ;ͽͪͭͯͳΔͰ;ͻͰͯͬͷͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͷͳ͵Ͷ;ͼ;
͵ͪͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͼͰͽͪ
;ͭͶͰͯͳͯͪͼͳ͵ͪmͳͿ;͵ͳΒͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͳͪͼͽΒͪͽͰΓͪ
ͽͬͪͪͳ
;ͬͪͻͪͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͯͫͳͶͪΒͰͬͪͱͪͳ;ͼͬͷͬͻͰͷͰ;ͬͳͳͼͷͳͼ̹ͪͶͳͼ͵ͪ
ͬͰͲͪͼͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͷ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽ;ͪ;ͳͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽ
ͺͯͬͶͪͳͶͪΒͰΔͳͬ͵ͽͳͽͻ
ͼ͵ͳͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
ͺͪͽͳͷͰͳ;ͽͰͷͰΓͰͼͽͳͼͪͷͼͽͪͶͼͽͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ
͉ͪͲͬΒ;͵;Ͷͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ;ͺͻͬΒͺͶͬͳͳ9*9ͬͰ͵ͪͯͺͻͳͰͶͪ
ͼ;ͳͰ͵ͪͯͬͪͱͳͼͽͻͰͷΓͰΔͪͽ͇ͭͯͫͪͫͬͪ͵;ͶͽͬͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳΔͳͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͵ͪͫͳͽͪͰͶͰͷͰͽͻͰͿͻͷͰͬͰͻͼ͵ͭͱͳͬ
ͽͪ
ͳͷͪͶͪΒͰͼͪͱͭͯΒͰ͵ͪͳ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ̓ͪͳͪͯͻ;ͭͳͷͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͼͽͻͳͷͪ
ͪͯͫͳΒͪͪͭͶͪͰͪͳͪͶͳ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͅͰΌ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰ
ͽͳͽͰΓͳͷͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳΒͰ;ͱͳͬͪͪΒͬͰΕͰͺͽͬͪΔͰͽͪ͵ͼͰ;͈Ͱͼͷͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪͺͬͪͶ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͷͪ
͵Β;ΒͰͽͪͷͺ̸ͪͽͳͷ͉ͪͯΒ͵ͬͳΕ
ΔͰͭͬͰͷͽͳ
;ͲͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ
ͲͪͪͬͪΒ;͵ͪͪΒͲͪͪΒ
ͳΒͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ͠ͰͯͪͯͰͺͼͻͰͯͳͺͼͶͰͯͳͪͽͪ͵ͬͭͺͶͰͽͪ͵;Ͷ
ͽͬͪͫͳͶͪΒͰͳͲͻͪͯͪͬͳ͵ͳͬͽͪͲͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ̽Ͱͪͳͼ;
͵ͪͳ
;ͬͰ͵
ͺͻͰͯΔͪͳͶͳ;ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔ;ͼͬͭͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͫ͠ͻͪͽͳͶͳͼ;
ͼͰ͵ͰͲ;ͅͳͶ;͇ͫͻͰͬͳΕ;
ͷͶͰΕͳͭͪͯͪͺͷͭͰͺͺͻͪͬ͵;ͯͽͻͪΒͪͶͭ
͵ͳͬͽͪ͊ͬΒ;ͪͷͰͻ;ͼͽͬͪͻͳͶͳͼ;ͰͽͯͳΒͰ
ͭͯͳͰ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ
ͺͯ
ͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͷ͵ͰͲ̸ͪͶͰ͵ͼͪͯͻͪ̓ͪͻͪΌͻΌͰͬͳΕͪ
ͲͪͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͰͷͽͳͳͲͻͪ
ΌͰͬ͵ͳͬͽ͋ͪΒtͼͬͰͽͳ͵ͳͬͽͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͳi
͵ͪ͵ͼͽΒͳ;ͪͽͺͳͼ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ΒͰͻͪͲͬͳΒͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͺͻͭͻͪͷ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰ;ͽͰͳͳͯ;ͫͻͰͲͪͳͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
;
͵ΒͰͷΒͰͳͼͽͳͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͳͶͳ͵͊ͽͰͿͪͬ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳΒͰͳ;ͽͷͼͽͶͰΕ;
ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͼͶͳ͵ͪ
ͳΒͳ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͼͬͰͯͳͰͼͪͷͬͳͼ͵ͷ
;ͭͶͰͯ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͬͰΕͳͼͫͰͳͷͽͰͱΔͪͷͪͬͻͰͷͰͪ̓ͪͬͪͱͼͻͰͯͳͽͰ
ͯͪΕͪ
ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻΒͰͺ͵ͶͳͳͷͪͳͲͯͪͬͪͺͺ;ͶͪͻͰͭͻͪͿͳ͵ͰͼͶͳ͵ͷ
ͼͬͰͽͭ ͵ͻͪΓͪ ͈ͺ;Ͷͪͻͼͽ ΒͰ ͲͪͯͻͱͪͶͪ ͳ ͼͰͪ ;ͯͰͼͭ ͬͻͪΕͪΔͪ ͬͳͯͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪ;̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͷ
ͷͪͯͪͼͬͳͷͲͪͰΔͰͷ͈ͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰͪ;Ͱ͵ͳͷͯͪΒͻͰ
ͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͳΒͳͻͪͷͬͪ̓ͰͱͰͬͳͰ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ;͊ͪͫͻΒͳ͋ͺ
ͳͯͰͻͼ͵Βͻ͵ͬͳ
ͪ;ͬͳΌͰΔ;ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪͺͺͻͳͷͪͷͻͪͶͳͲͪͽͻͼ͵ͪͳ
ͪͶͳͼͷͳͼͪ
́ͺͪ͵
ͼͬͰͺͻͷͰͰ͵ΒͰΒͰͼͫͷͼͳͶͬͻͰͷͰͳͼ;ͳͲͷͰͳͶͰͳͲͬͻͳ
ͳͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳͫͶͳ͵ͽͬͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ̓ͳͬͽͳͲͼͻͰͯͳͰ9*9ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͪͷͰͼͽͼͽͪͻͭ
;ͬͪΒͰͰͽΓͰͰͷͽͳ
͵Βͳͷͪͼ;ͺ͵Ͷͳͳ
ͺͻͳͶͪͲͳͶͳͼͪΒͯ;ͫΓͳͷͺͽͬͪΔͰͷͳͬͰͻͷ;ͷͭ;Εͼͽͳͼͽͬͪͻͼͽ;ͯͰ
ͼͪͭͫͅͻΒͳͼ;ͳͻͪͲͻͯͳͳͲͬͻͳ͵ΒͳͼͬͰͯͰͽΒͺͫͱΒͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͳ͵ͪͼͬͳ͵ͿͰͼͳΒͪͪͺͯͻ;Β;͊ͽͪͻͰ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ͆ͳͽͪͼͰͫͳͽ
;ΔΒͳΒͰͺͻͷͰͳͶͳ;ͪͻͰͯͷ
99ͼͽͶͰΕ;
ͺͪͳͯͪ͵ͪͯͪͼ;
ͺͻͰͯ
]]
̸̸̸̺͉͍͊̾͋́̓͊͋̾͆̽̾͐͆͊̓́͡
̽ͻ;ͭͳͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳͻͪͽ
ͷͽͳͺͻͰͰͽͰ;ͬ͵ͳͬͽ͋ΒͰͷͰͽͪͶͳ͵ͬͰͭͺ
ͶͱͰ;ͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͭͯͻͬͰͭͷͰͻͷͰͻͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ
ͪ͵ͭͽͬͰͼͽͼͽͶͰΕͪ
ͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͪͬͷͰͼͽΒ;ͱͯͶͽͪͻͼ͵ͳͯͬͰͻͳ
;ͺͻͪͬ;Ͳͪͺͪͯmͳͼͽ͵
͋;ͼͬͰͽͳ͵ͻͪΓͺͳͬͪͳͯͪͪͼ
ͽͳͽͰΕͳͼͬΒͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͯͼͬͳͳͼ͵;ͰΔͪ͵ΒͰ
ͷ;ΒͰͯͰͶͷͯͰͻͯͫͪ
7̀ͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰ̓ͼͬͪ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
̀ͪͺͳͼͳͳͪͽͺͳͼͳ*
ͫͻ
͊͡ͽΒͪͬͳΕ
͊ͽͪͻͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͺͬͰΓͰͳͺͳͼͷͪ*
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯm͊ͻͰͷͼ͵ͳ̓ͪͻͶͬͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
ΌͰ́ͺͪ͵
ͰͽͻͰͫͪͼ;ͷΔͪͽͳ;ͽͯͪΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͽͰͶͫͳͶͺͭͻͰͫͰͪ
;ͫͳͪΒͰͪͳ
;ͺͯͲͰͷ;ͻͪ͵;͆ͪͯΔͷΒͰ
͵ͪͪͯͲͰͷͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͫͰ
ͶͰͱΒͰ
ͺͯͳͭ;ͽͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͳ͵ͪͷͰͳͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭ͌ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ΒͿ;ͰͻͪͻΒ
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͽΒͰͽͪ͵ΌͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͻͰͰΔͰ
ͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͷͪͳͲ͊ͽ;ͯͰ
ͳͰ
ͅͳͶͰͰͬͰ
͊ͺΕͪͪ
̻ͻͪͯͪ
̽Ͱͪͪͅͻͪ͵ͳͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭ
͵Βͳͯͼͪͯͪ
ͳΒͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͬͪ
;ͼͬΒΒͬͻͼͽͳͬͰͷͪΒͰͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ͵͋ΒͰ
ͺͺ;ͽ
ͼͶͳͳͫͰͶͰͱΒͪ
ͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͫͶͳ͵ͬͪͼͺͷͰͳ͵
ͯ;ͭͪͪ͵
ͳͻ͵
ͪͬͳͼ͵
ǸͪͯΔͷͼͽͻͪͷͺͻͳͼͶΔͰΒͰ;ͲͪͲͳͯ͊ͪͼͽΒͳͼͰͯͺͻͪ
ͬ;ͭͪͭ͵ͬͰͭͪͳͷͪͼͳͬͭͺ͵ͶͺͪͼͪͲͪ͵Ͱͳͷͼͽͻͪͪͷͪ́ͼ͵ͶͰͼͪ
ΒͰͯͫͰͶͼͳͬͭͷͰͻͷͰͻͪͳͳͷͪΒͰͯͼͽͪͬͪͺͶͪͼͽͳͳ;͵ͻͪͼ͐ͳͰͭͪͻͰͶͪ
ͽͳͬͺͶͳͽ͵ͳͺͻͿͳͶͳ͵ΒͳͽͰ͵;ͯ;ͱͰͰͳͫͰͫͰͼͽͻͪͰ͵ͬͰͭͪ͌
ͰͶͳͳͺͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͭΒͰͯͫͻ;ͬͪ
ͪ͵ͼͰͳͲ;Ͳͷ;ͷͪΔͪͽͰΕͰΔͪ
ͪͺ͵Ͷͺ;
͵ͪͳͺͲͳΒͰͻͰͼͽͪ;ͻͪͽͻͼ͵ͰͳͽͰͻͬͰͳΒͰ
͵ΒͳͷͪΕͰͯͪΓͰ
ͫͳͽͳͬͳͰͻͰͳ͌ΒͰͯΒͫͳͽΒͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͻͪ͵ͳͼͺͷͰͳ͵;ͼͬͷͬͻͰ
ͷͰ;ͳͼͻͰͯͳͳͰͷͪͪͪͶͭͳΒͪ̀ͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯͼͬͳͺͲͪͽͳͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͳ
ͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͪ
ͳΒͳͼ;͵ͬͰͲͳ͵ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪͳͯͲͪͼͰͫͳͺͶͪ
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ͵
ΒͰͷͶͳͽ
ͳͲͯ;ͫΓͰ;ΒͰͯͷ͵ͪͷͰͷͫͶ͵;́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͼͰͺ;Ͷ͵ͻͪͶͰ
;ͷͰͽͼͽͳͯͫͻͲͪΒ;ͯͪͻͰͳΒͰͽͰͳ͵ͷ
ͬͰΕͷͭͼͶͱͰͳΒͰͷͺͳ
ͽͪΔ;ͅͶͳͽͳͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͲͳ;͵ΒͰͼͰͺͶͪͭͪͶͽͰͶͺ͵Βͳ͵ͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͳ
ͼ;ͪͽͳ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;͌ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
͵ͪͯͪͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͫͻͰͯͼͪͻͪͰͪͶͪͱͰ
ͺͶͪͭͪΔͰͽͰͶͪ;ͲͰͷΓ;
ͳͭ;ͫͰͼͬͻ;ͳͫͳͬͪΒ;ͲͪͷͰΔͰͳ͵ͷͺͲͳͽͳͷ͵
ͼͽͻ;͵ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͳΒͪΒͰͿ;͵ͳΒͪͳͼ͵Γ;ͳͬͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͪͅͻͪ͵ͳͼͺͷͰͳ͵
ͷͭͪͫͳͫͳͽͳͯͰͶͷͪΒͼͽͻͪͳͲ͈ͷͻΒͪmͫͶͪͼͽͳ;͵ΒΒͼͰͼͪ;ͬͪͰͼͪͷ
͵ͽͳ;ͳͽͰͽͪͽͳ͵ͰͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͰͬͰΕͳΔͰͳͼͰͺ;Ͷ͵ͻͪͶͳͼͺͷͰͳͳ͊ͯͻ;
ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͺ;͵;ͺͷͳͲͭͶͰͯ;
ͪͶͳͳͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͪΒͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͺͻͿͳ
ͶͪͳΒͪ
;ͺͽͺ;ͼͽͳͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͿ;ͰͻͪͻΒͺͶͪͼͽͳͳͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
͋Ͱͳ͵ͳͿͽͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͼͳͷͪΔͰͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͪ
͵ͪͳ͵ͼͽͻ;͵ͳΒͰͺͯͳͭ;ͽͰͪͯΔͳͷ
ͫͪͬͳͶͪͼͪͷ;͵ͽͫͻ;ͭͯͳͰ̀ͫͭͺͻ;ͱͰͰͺͷΕͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͼͳͷͪΔͪͲͪͬͪͶͪ
ͼͪͷ͵ͶͰͭͳ̓ͻͪͳͼͶͪͬ;̺ͻͪͳΕ;
*CJE
mΒͰͯͪͯͻͰͽ͵ͳͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪ͵ͪͫͳͫͳͳͷͰͻͷͰͻͳͷͶͳͽͳͲ̸ͻͳΓͪ
ͲͪͽͰ
Ͱ;ͲΒ;ͱ;Ϳͪͼͪͯ;ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͳΒͳͫͶͳ͵ͳͿ;͵ͳΒͪͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;Β;ͯͪΓͰͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͰ
DGͅ
͐ͪͪ͵ͅͰͯͳΕ
͊ͬͰͽͳ̸ͳͶͳΒͰ;̸ͻͳΓ;́ͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ͪͻͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪͳͺͻͼͽͻͳͼ͵Ͷͺͷͪͪ
ͼͽͳͻͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͼͶ
*)FSLMPU[
t4FQVMDSBiFt.POVNFOUBiEFM.FEJPFWP4UVEJTVMMBSUFTFQPMDSBMFJO*UBMJB
3PNB
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͆ͪΒͬͳͰͶͳͳͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͭͰ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳ
͵Βͳͼ;ͷ;ͪΒͫͶͳͱͳͳͺ
ͬͻͰͷͰ;ͪͼͽͪ͵ͪ
͈ͺ;ͽͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͳͿ;ͰͻͪͻͳͰͶͳͪ
ͽͪ͵ΒͰͳͪ;ͅͻͪͳͫ;ͬͪ
ͽͪͶͪ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͪͯͭͻͫͳͺͻͽͻͰͽ͵ΒͳΒͰͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͪͯͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͷ̽ͪͪ
Δͪ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͪͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽKFͫͬͰͳͲͭͯͳͰ
ͪͶͳ͵ͬͳͬͳͯͪ
ͽͻͪ
ͳͭ;ͷͪͪ͋ͷͰͳ͵ͰͲ̺ͪ;͵ͳΕ̺ͪ;ͰͽͳΕͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͼ;;ͺͬͻͳ
ͳͲͪͺͻͰͼͶͳ͵ͪͭͺͻͽͻͰͽͪͺͻͬͭ͵ͽͳͽͻͪ͆ͬͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͼͳͭ;ͻͰͺͪͬΓͪ
ͬͰͻͳ;ͼͬͳͷͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪͺͻͬͫͳͽͳͺͻͽͻͰͽͳͲ9***ͼͽͶͰΕͪ͆ͰͽͻͰͫͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼ;ͷΔͪͽͳ;ͽͯͪΒͰͺͻͰͰͽͪΔͰͭͬͪͼ;ͽͳͪmͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͷͶͳͽͬͰ ͳͼͺͻ;ͱͰͰ ͻ;͵Ͱ ͳ ͼ ͷͯͰͶͷ ͻͪͷͪ
͵ͭͪ ̹ͭͻͯͳͪ ͺͻͳͬͯͳ
͎ͻͳͼͽ;ͪͺͻͰͼͽͶ;͋ͪ͵ͪͬͽͳͺ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͰ
ͽͳͺͳͪͲͪ9***ͬͰ͵
͵ΒͳͪͭͶͪ
ͪͬͪͰͼͪͽͶ͵ͳͼͷͳͼͪͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͫͳΒͰͺͻͰͅͻͪͰͬͰΕͼͽͬͪͻͰ
;ͼͶͳ͵ͪͳͷͪͼͪͷͫͶͳͷͪ͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͰͳͅͳͶͰͰͬͰ͇ΒͰͽ;ͫͳͯͰͳͻͰͭͺͻ
ͭͻͪͷͪ
ͳͲͻͪͲͳͽͼͽͳͻͳͶ͵ͭ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͪ
ͪͼͪͺͽͰͭͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͼͶͳ͵ͪ
ͼͽͰͷͷͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪͳͬͪͼ͵ͻͼͰΔͪ̽ͪͪͼͰͷͱͰͷͺ;ͲͯͪͲͪͽͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͪΒͰ
;
ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͫͳͶͪͼͪͯͻͱͳͪͿͻͰͼͪ͵ͪ;ͲͪͺͪͯͷͽͻͪͬͰΒ;ͅͻͪͰ͌ͫͳͪΒͰͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰͼͿ;ͰͻͪͻͳͷͪͼͳΒͪͳΒͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͵ͬͰͼ;̺ͪͼ͵ͻͼͰΔͰ̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳ͊ͳͶͪ
Ͳͪ͵;ͪͯ
͵ΒͰͼͰ;ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͳͷͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͷͪ9***ͬͰ͵ͪͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;ͪͶͪͲͰͪ
Β;ͱΒͼͽͻͪͳ
ͳͲͪͯ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵Ͱ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͰ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͳ97*ͬͰ͵ͪͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪͶͳ
ͼ;;ͯͻ;ͭΒͳͽͻͰΕΒͲͳͪͼͺͻͪͷͭ
ͼͰͬͰͻͭͲͳͯͪ͋ͪ͵ͪͬͺͶͱͪΒͳΒͰ
ͷͻͪͯͪͺͳͽͳΔͳͬͰͼͪͽͶ͵ͳͼͷͳͼͪ
ͪͻͳͽͪ͵ͼͰͯͲͬͶͳͷ
ͭ;ΕͼͽͯͪΒͰͰ͵ͪͼͪͻͪͪͫͪͬΓͰͪͳͪͼͰͬͰͻΒͼͽͻͪͳͲͪͺͪͯͭͽͻͪͬͰΒͪ
͵ͪͽΒͰͽͫͳͶ;ͫͳͪΒͰ;ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͳͷͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͷ͉ͪͪͲ;ͷͰͼͰͯͪͼͰ
ͽͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͪͷͱͰͺͻͬͰͻͳͽͳͼͪͷͪͻͰͶ͵ͳͷͳͼ͵ͺͪͬͪΔͳͷͪ̓ͪͯͪΒͰ
ͺͪ͵ͻͰͱͳͬͺͳͼͪͷͺͻͭͻͪͷ;ͳͲͪͯͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͪͳ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͪͯͭͻͫͭ
ͺͻͽͻͰͽͪ
ͽͪΒͰ;Ͱͯͪͫ;ͬͪͽͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰ͵ΒͰͼͪͯͻͱͰͪͭͶͪͰ;
ͬͪͼ͵ͻͼ;ͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵;͌ͯͻ;ͭΒͲͳͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͳͼ;ͷͰͯͪΓͳͼͺͺͻͼΒͳͷͪ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
ͅͻͪͪ ͭͻͫ͵ͰͲͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪͼͪ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͷ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͷͳͲͭͯͳͰ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
̺ͪͭ͠ͳΕ
̓ͼͽͪͽͳ͍ͳͶͼͿͳΔͰͭͬ̿ͳͬͽ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͪͯͰͼͺͽͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͪ
̻Ͷͪͼͳ͵͊͌̽
͵Δ
͉;ͬͪͻͪ
QDJU
͉ͯͼͶͬͳͳͶͰͽͺͳͼͳ
͉ͯͼͶͬͳͳͶͰͽͺͳͼͳ
m
͉ͯͼͶͬͳͳͶͰͽͺͳͼͳ
9
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
ΕͰͯͫͳͽͳͺ;Ͳͪͷͪ;ͪͻͰͯͷͼͽͶͰΕ;̹ͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰͪΒͬͰΕͪͬͳͪΒͰͼͽͰ
͊ͽͰͿͪͬͪͽͳͽ;Ͷ͇ͪΒͰͽ;ͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽ;ͪͽͺͳͼ;ͼͶͬΓͰ͵ͪkral2 steçan2
͉Ͱͳͽͳͼ;ͳͪͽͺͳͼͳͪͼͬͳͳͷͪ͵ΒͳͼͬͰͽΓͪͬͪΒ;ͯͼͼ;ͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͽͳͽ
ͻͪ
ͫͬͳͽͰΓͪͅͻͪͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ;ͬͪͱͰͷͺͻͰͽͯͳ͵;͇ͳͼ;ͬͰͷͪͺͻ
ͷͳΓͰͭͻͪͯͳͻͪͳ͌ͷͶͳͽͬͳ͵Β;ͯͻͱͳ̹ͭͻͯͳͪ
ͺͼͻͰͯ;Β;ΕͳͺͻͰͯ
͎ͻͳͼͽͷͲͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͺͯͬͶͪͰͼͰΒͰͬͪΌͰͼ͵ͳ;ͲͻͳͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͪͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͷͪ
ͺͪͻͪͫͶ;;ͯͬͳͳΒͶͰͺͽͳw vse bl(a)gi g(ospod)i prim` prino\en`e raba svoego
&ako je primil es` i vadovi dve ceti. ͅͶͰͳΒͰͳͭ;ͷͪͪ͋ͷͰͪͯͬͰͲ;ΒͰͼͰͪ
ͺͻͰͽͯ
;ͲͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͺͻͬͭ͵ͽͳͽͻͪw preyista mati b(o)ji&a ` w
mne se pomol` h(rist)9 vl(a)d(i)ci da pri(mi)t2 maloe potr9jden`e &ako je i prve&e.
ͅͶͳͽͬͪ͵ͰͲ̺ͪ;͵ͳΕ̺ͪ;ͰͽͳΕͪ
ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͭͶͪͪͺͬͻ͵Ͱ
ͪͰ͵ͳͪͳ
ͼͪͱͳͷͪͫͰͺͻͰͽͯͰͳͲͪ͵ͻ;ͱ;ΒͰͳͽͪͬ;Ͳͪͷͳͼͪw m(a)ti b(o)ji&a i w mne
gre\nem spomen` h(rist)9 vl(a)d(i)ce da pri(mi)t2 ` na\e maloe potrujden`e &ako je
priel2 esi vadovi dve ce(ti).͢Ͱ;ͼ;ͽͳ;ͷͭͶͳͫͳͼͷͯͻͰͯͳͽͳ͵ͪͪͼͽΒͪ
ΔͰͬͳͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͻͪͯͪͯͰͶͽͬͻͼͽͼͬΒͳͷͶͳͽͪͬͪ;ͽͰͷͰΓͰͪͪ;ͽͻͳ
ͽͰͽ;ͺͻͬͭ͵ͽͳͽͻͪ
́ͲͼͷͰͯͰͰͳΒͰ97*ͬͰ͵ͪͺͽͳͰͳͺͷͰ;ͽͳͷͪ͵ͳͺͻͽͻͰͽ͊ͽͰͿͪ
ͬ
ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͪͼͰͬͰͻͷͲͳͯ;ͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͰ͆ͪΔͰͷ;ΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪ;ͺͻͪͽΔͳͼ;
ͺͻ;ͱͳͰͳ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽ
ͼͳ̺ͪͶͪͯͳͼ Ͷ
ͪͬͪ̓ͪ͵ͼͷͬͰΕͳͼͽͪ͵Ͷͳ
ͳͳͼͰ
ͯͪ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͪ
;ͭͶͪͬͳͷͻͽͪͷͪ
ͺͪͬΓͪͼͽͪͻͳΒ;ͼͶͳ͵;͋ͬͻͳͷͪͺͻͭͻͪ
ͷͪͳͲ97*ͬͰ͵ͪͪΒͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪΒΒͰͯͪͯͪͳͪͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ;ͼͺ
ͷͰͰͪͷͻͪ͵ͭ͵ͽͳͽͻ͈ͪͽͷͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͽͳͷΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͷͪ͵
ͳͷͰ
͵ͪͳͳͷͰΔͰͭͬͰͼ;ͺͻ;ͭͰ
ͫͳͶͰͺͲͪͽͬͳͯͳͼͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͼ;ͷͪͶͲͪͶͳ
ΔͰͭͬΒͺͻͯͳͳ͋ͻͰͫͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬͳͽͳͯͪͼ;ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͺͻͯͳͳͳ
ͰͬͰͽ;ͪͶͳͷͪͼͶͰͯͳͳͷͪ͵ͰͲͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪͼͬͻͰͷͰͷͺͽ;ͶͰ;Ͳͪͫͻͪͬ
͆ͪͽͫͳ
ͼͪͼͬΒͰͼͽͻͪͰ
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳͻͯͼͶͬͳͳͶͰͽͺͳͼͳ
;͵Βͳͷͪ
ͲͪͻͪͲ
Ͷͳ͵;ͯͺͻͯͳͰͭͻͪͰ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ̽ͪͬͳͯͪ
Ͱͷͪͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͳͺͷͰͪͺͽͷ
ͳͷͪ͵ͰͲͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
̺ͻ;ͼ͵ͰͫͶͳ͵ͰͽͬͪΔͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͼͽͳͰ;ͪͻͰͯͷ
97**ͼͽͶͰΕ;̽ͪͫͳ
ͼͰͳͻͪͲ;ͷͰͶͳ
ͷͻͪΒ;ͼͰͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ;ͳͻ͵ͳͷͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͷͳͬͰͻͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪͰͺͰ
ͯͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪ;͊ͻͺͼ͵Βͻ͵ͬͳͯͺͶͱͪΒͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪͅͻͪͰ
ͳͼͽͻͰͷΓͰΔͪΔͰͭͬͭͫͻͪͽͼͽͬͪ́ͼͽͻͳΒͪͅͻͪͰ;97**ͬͰ͵;ͯͼͽͪΒͰͯͫͻ
ͺͲͪͽͪ ̓ͪ ;ͭͶͰͯͪ ͳ ͷΕͪ
ͪ ;ΒͰͯ ͼ͵ͻͬͳͽ ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ
ͪ ΒͰ ͯ ͼͪͷͭ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͰͽ͵ͪͼͽͶͰΕͪͫͳͶͪͼͻͰͯͳͽͰ͵;ͺΓͪΔͪͬͪͱͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ͵ͪͻ͵ͬͰͳͪ
ͻͯͪͳͷͰͼͽͬͰΕͪΔͪ
ͪͬͳͰͷͻͪ͵ͳ͵ͪͶ;ΌͰͻͪͼͽͰ͵ͶΒͰͬͳͼ͵ͰͺͶͱͪΒͰ;
͊ͻͺͼ͵Βͻ͵ͬͳ͆Ͱ͵ͰͯͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͳͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͪͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰͽͳ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;
ͰͺͼͻͰͯͼͰͽͳ;ͪͰͽͰͷͰ
ͽΒͰͼͽͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽͪͷͻͪ͵ͭ͵ͽͳͽͻͪ;ͽͷ
ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;͇ΔͰͷ;ͼͬͰͯͳͬͳͰͺͳͼͪͳͳͶͳ͵ͬͳͳͲͬͻͪ
͵ΒͰΕͰͷͻͪͲ
ͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͺͻͶ͵ͷͻͰͯ;
͌ͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ
ͪͼͽͪͶΒͺͻͰͭͻͪͯΔͷͰ͵ͪͯͪΔͰ͵;ͶͰ
ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪ
ΒͭͯͳͰ
͊ͽͰͿ̺ͪ;͵ͪͬͳΕͺͬΒͰͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪ;ͼͬΒͼͽͬ;͵ͽͳͽͻ͇ͪ
ͺͻͳͼͳͷͯͰͶͻͪͷͪ
ͯ͵ͭͪͼͬͰͽͳ͆ͳ͵Ͷͪͺͻͳͬͯͳ̹ͭͻͯͳͳͼ͎ͪͻͳͼͽͷ
ͪͺͻͰͼͽͶ;͇ͺͳͻͪͪͽͺͳͼ;Ͳ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͶͳ͵ͼͬͰͯͳͽͷͰͯͪΒͰ97**ͬͰ͵
ͫͪͽͳͳͯͺͻͰͽͯͭͼͽͶͰΕͪͳͯͰΒ;ΔͰͭͬΒ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵Βͽͳͽ;Ͷͳͳͺͻͳ
ͻͳΒͰͳͯͻ;ͭͳͷͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͷͪ͆ͪͽͺͳͼͭͶͪͼͳv2 h(rist)a b(og)a bl(a)govqrn6 kral2
i g(ospo)din2. steçan2 s(i)n2 velikago kneza vl2kana. v2n$k2 s(ve)taago s½mewna neman&e
htitor2 s(ve)tago mqsta sego.͊ͪͷͽͻͳͭͯͳͰͯͳΒͰ
;ͺͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼ;͊ͬͰͽͭ
͊ͽͰͿͪͪ;ͳΔͰΒͰ͵Γ;ͳͳͼ͵ͻͪ͵͋;ΒͰ
ͪͼͰͬͰͻͷͲͳͯ;
ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͪͪ͵
ͰͽͬͻͽͪͺͻͰͯ;͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͪ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͪ;ͅͻͪͳ;ͿͻͰͼ͵ͽͰͳͳ
ͽΒͰ
ͼͪͷͺͼͰͫͳͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪͭ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͻͪͽ;ͳͼͷͯͰ
Ͷͷͻͪͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͺͻͰͺͻ;;ΒͰ̹ͭͻͯͳͳͼ͎ͪͻͳͼͽͷ
ͪ ͺͻͰͼͽͶ; ͌ ͪͽͺͳͼ; ΒͰ ͊ͽͰͿͪ ͺͻͬͳ ͺ;ͽ ͽͳͽ;Ͷͳͼͪ ͵ͪ sv(e)t6 kr(a)l2
steçan(2) s(i)n2 velikago kneza vl(2)kana.
͋ͪ͵ͫͲͪΔͰͪͳͯͰΒͪͼͬͰͽͷ͵ͻͪΓ;ͯͲͬΓͪͬͪͪͷ
͵ͪ
ͯͪ;;ͱͰͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;ͻͰͳͭͬͻͳͷ͵;Ͷͽ;͵ͰͲͪ͊ͽͰͿ͇ͪͪΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵
ͪͼͽͪ;ͅ
ͻͪͳ ͵ͪ ͺͶͯ ͺͫͱͭ ͼͰΕͪΔͪ
ͪͶͳ ͳ ͺͻͷͳΓͰͰ ͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͰ ΔͰͭ
ͫͻͪͽͼͽͬͪ͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳͲͪͳΒͰ
ͳͳͪͷͼͰͯͪͫͳͽͪΒ͵;ͶͽͽͻͰͫͪͶ
ͼͬͻͼͽͪͽͳ;Ͷ͵ͪͶͰ
ͪͰͺͻͰ͵ͳ;ͽͰ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽ;ͳͳͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ
̈́ͰͽͳΒͰ͈ͪͬͶͬͳΕ͊ͽͰͿͪͬ͵;Ͷͽͼͳͫͳ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͰͶ͵ͪͶͭͰͼͪ
ͷͪͼͬ;ͼͬΒͰͽͰͻͳͽͻͳΒͪͶͰͭͻͪͳͰͼͽͳͬͰΕͳͼͽͭͪͽͳ͵ͪͯͪͳ
ΒͰͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͼͬͰͰͶͰͷͰͽͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͽͬͪΔͪͲͯͻ;ͱͰͰ;ΒͰͯ;ͰͶͳ;
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
ͅͻͪͪ ͭͻͫ͵ͰͲͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪͺͼͶͰͫͬͰͭͯͳͰ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͋ͪ͵͊ͽͰͿͪ;ͳ͵ͪͯͪͳͼ;ͪͺͳͼͪͳͱͳͽͳΒͰͳͼͶ;ͱͫͪ
ͪͶͳͼ;ͼͶͳ͵ͪͰͳ͵Ͱ
ͼΔͰͭͬͳͷͶͳ͵ͷ͐ͳͳͼͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͯͪͼͰΔͰͭͬͽͬͪΔͰͪΒ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͳΒͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪ
Ͷ͵ͻͲ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ;͵ͰͱͰͬΒͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͳ
͊ͻͰͯͳͷͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽͳͭͯͳͪ97**ͬͰ͵ͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͭͻͫ;ͅͻͪͳͯͫͳ
ΒͰͺͽͺ;ͬͳͲͭͶͰͯ͆ͪͷͰͻͷͰͻͳͼͪͻ͵ͿͪͭͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͪΒͰͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͪ
ͳ͵ͪͼͪͶͳ͵ͬͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͳͼͰͪͷͪͳͲ͊ͪͬͳͭͱͳ
ͬͽͪ́͵ͪΒͰͺͻͳͬͻΕͰͪͺͷΕ;ͯͬͰͪͻͳͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͰͷͪͼͳͬͰͭͻͰ
ͯͰ
ͫͻͳͱΓͳͬ;͵ͺͪͰ;ͲͪͺͪͯͳͲͳͯͳͼ;ͼͰͯͳͺͳͶͪͼͽͪͻ͇Ͱͼ;ͺͳͽͪͬΒ
ͼͬΒΒ ͺͬͻͳͳ ͫͳͶͰ ͼͶͳ͵ͪͰ ͿͶͻͪͶͳͷ ͷͽͳͬͳͷͪ m ͵ͻ;ͺͳͷ ͺͶͪͬͳͷ
ͳͻͬͰͳͷͬͰͽͬͳͷ̻ͪͻͰͯͰͼ;ͯͷͪ͵;ͽͰͯΒ;ͱͭͲͳͯͪ͵DN
ͪͱͶͰ
ͫͬͳͼͫͳͼͽͻͪͪ
ͪͼͽͪͶͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪͭͻͰͯͪ
ͪͺͬͻͳͳ
ͿͻͰͼͪ͵ͪͫͻͳͱΓͳͬͼ;ͻͰͼͽͪ;ͻͳͼͪͳ̀ͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵Ͱ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͰ
ͪͲͪͺͪͯͷͲͳͯ;
͵ΒͪͽͷͳͽͰͻͬͰͳΒͷͳΒͰͽͰΕͰͪ
ͿͻͰͼ͵ͪͪͫΒ
ͼͽͻͪͳͺͳͶͪͼͽͻͪmͶͳ͵ͪͺͼͽͶͪ͋ͳͽͪmͫͳͶͪΒͰͯͰͶͷ;ͳͽͰͪ͊ͽͭͪͼ;ͺͻͰ
͵ΔͰͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͰͬͰͽͰͶͪͽͳͰ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷͼͶͳͰͳͷͪ͵ΒͰ;͵ͻͪͪͬͪΒ;ͺͬͻ
ͳͰͺͷͰ;ͽͳͼͰΕͳͭͻͰͯͪ̀ͪͬͪΓ;Β;ΕͳͽΒͬΒ͵ͼͽͻ;͵ͳΒͳ
ͽͰͱͪ͵
ͳͫͭͪͽ;͵ͻͪͰ͵ͬͳͻͳ͵ͰͳΒͰͪͶͰͭͪͰͺͼͻͰͯͪͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭ
ͬͰΕΒͰ
ͼͺΒͯͬͰͰͶͳͰͫͳͼͽͬͪͻͰ;ͷͰͽͪΔͰͷΒͰͯͰͷͪΔͰͭͻͰͯͳͰ
ͼͪͽͺͳͼͷͳͲ
mͭͯͳͰ
͵Βͳͯͼͳͺͯͪͽ͵Ͱ͵ͽͳͽͻͳͷͪͳ͵Ͱ͊Ͷͳͪ͵
ͼͽͻ;͵ͳΒͪ
ͼͪͳΔͰͪ ͯ ͯͬͰ ͷͪͼͳͬͰͭͻͰͯͰ͵ΒͰͼͰͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶ;ͳ͵;
ͫͳͶͪΒͰͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͪͳͪͪͼͺͻͪͷ;
ͼͰͬͰͻ;ͼͽͻͪ;ͲͪͺͪͯͭͽͻͪͬͰΒ͇ͪͯͺͻ
ͬͫͳͽͰͳ͵ͰͼͪͯͪΒͰͼͪ;ͬͪͼͪͷͻͪͼ͵ͳ͵ͬͳͻ
ͺͪͻΔͪ͵ͷ;ͲΒ;ͱͳ
Ͳͳͯ
ͯ͵ͳ͵ͪͼͶͳ͵ͷ͈ͬͪͪ͠ͻͰͽͰͰͳͼͰͪͷͪͳͲΔͰͭͬͭͱͳͬͽͪͺͽͳ
ͰͳͲͭͯͳͰ͋ͻͰͫͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬͳͽͳͯͪͼͰͳͽͪ͵ͼͽͻ;͵ͳΒͪͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ
ͪͯͰ͵ͳͷͭͻͫͷͳͶͳ
ΒͬͰͻͬͪͽͳΒͰ
ͪͯ͵ͳͬͽͷͲͪͷͽͳ͆ͪͱͪͶͼͽ
ͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ;ͽͬͪͰͶͳͼͽͳͳͲͬͻͳͳͼ;ͼͽͪͬͳͶͳͽͻ͈ͪͭͪ;ͽ͵ͪͲ;ͽͷ
ͺͻͪͬ;ͷͭͪͫͳͫͳͽͳͷͰͯͪΓͼͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͷ͌ͼͺͰΔͪͼͬͰͽ̺ͭͪͼͳͶͳΒͪ
ͷ
ͱ͇ͯͪͼͽͻ͵ͭ
͵ΒͳͼͰͪͶͪͲͳͪͯΔΒͳͬͳͳͳ͵ͰmͽΒͰͺͻͫͶͰͷ͵Βͳ
ͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;ΒͰͯͪΓͰͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰ͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͼͻͰͯͳͷ97**ͬͰ͵ͪͳͽͪͬ
ͲͪͺͪͯͳͽͻͪͬͰΒͷͻͪ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰͯͫͳΒͰͬͳͲͭͶͰͯ͵ΒͳΒͰͫͳͺͯͻͰΌͰͺͽͻͰ
ͫͪͷͪͬ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͪ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
͊ͽͰͿͪͬͫͬΓͰͳͭͻͫͫͳΒͰͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪͬͳͪ
͵ͪ͵ͪͳͯͰΒͷͽͪ͵
ͳͪͺͻͼͽͻͬͳͲ;ͰͶͷͺͶͪ;͈ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰͷͽͰ͵ͼͽͻ;͵ͳΒͰ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͪ
͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͪ ΒͰ
; ͯͼͶͬͷ ͼͷͳͼͶ; ͻͰͳ
ͺͽͳͼ;ͽͪ ; ͯͻ;ͭͳ ͺͶͪ
ͪ Ͱ͵Ͱ
ͯ͵ͶͳͼͶͳ͵ͪͺͳͽͰͰͼ;;͵ͻͳͼͽͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͭͳͬͻͶͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͭͺͻ
ͭͻͪͷͪ͌ͷͰͼͽͼͽͪͻͰͳͯͰΒͰͳͼ͵;ͺͳͽͰΓͼ͵Β;ͶͲͳ͵ͽͳͽͻͼ͵ͭͳͪ
ͳͼͽͳͰͼͰ
ͫͶͳͼ͵ͼͻͯͼͽͬ͵ͽͳͽͻͪͼͼͳͬͪͳͷͪͳͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͳͷͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͳͷͪͼͬͰ
ͽͻͯͰͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
ͳΒͳ͵;ͶͽͯͱͳͬΓͪͬͪͼͪͱͪͺͶͰͽͪͳͽͪͬͷͺͯͻ;Β;
ͫͬΓͰͰ͈ͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͰ̀ͪͷͰͳͽͳͷͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͷͪͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱ;ΒͰ
ͼͰͳͷͻͪ͵ͳ͵ͽͳͽͻ
͵ΒͳΒͰͯͬͪͺ;ͽͪͪͼͶͳ͵ͪ;ͯΔͰͷͻͰͭͳͼͽͻ;ͳ͵Ͱm;
ͼͰͳ;ͼͺͰΔͪ
ͼͪͫͻͪͱͰΒͿ;ͰͻͪͻΒͪͷͰͳͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͪ
ͳͯͫͻͺͲͪͽΒ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͲͳͯͪΔͪͅͻͪͰ
;͵ΒΒΒͰͲͪͰ͵ͪkral2 steçan2 s(i)n2 velikago
kneza vl2kana
͆ͬͳͲͭͶͰͯ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͭͭͻͫͪ;ͪ;ͳΒͰͬͰΕͻͪͳΒͰ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͪ͠ΒͰ
͍ͻͪͰͅͰͼͰͼͰͶͺͻͳͷͰͽͳͯͪΒͰ;ͫͶͳͰͪͺͯͫͳΒͰͻͳͷ͵ͪͽͶͳ͵ͳ
ͫͳͶͽͪͻ͈ͪͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͽͰͲͪͺͪͯͰ͵ͷͺͰͽͰͳͻͰΒͰ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͼͪ͊
͈Ͱͽ͵ͬͳΕ͈Βͪͬ;ͽͳ;ͽͳͪΒͪΒͰͯͬͰ;ͬͰͲ;ͼͪͱͳͬͳͷ͵ͽͪ͵ͽͳͷͪ͵ΒͰ
ͼ;
ͺͻͰͭͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ;ͳΒͳ
ͅͻͪͪͳͯͻͱͪͬͪͶͳͼͻͳͷ͵ͪͽͶͳͳͷͪ͋ͳͷ
ͭͶͰͯͳͽͳͷͪ
;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͺͭͶͰͯ;Ͳͪͼͬͪͳͷ
ͷͭͪͫͳͼͰͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͳͽͳΒΒͰ
ͯͪͼͶΒͲͪͰΔͪ͵Βͳͼͪͯͻͱͳ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͭͻͫͳͲ97**ͼͽͶͰΕͪ̓ͪͫΒͰ͵ͪͽ;
Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͽͪͳΒͰ͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;ΒͰͯͰͶͳͼͽͳ
Ͳͪ;Ͳͳͷͪ͵Γ;
ͷͰͼͽ ; ͽ͵ͬͳͷͪ ͻͪͲͬΒͪ ͽͰ ͬͻͼͽͰ ͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͪ ͆ͪͼͽͪ ͵ͪ ͳͫͻͳͯ ͯͰͶ
͵ΒͰͼͰͼͪͼͽΒͪͶͯͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͪ
ͪͶͳ͵ͷͰͻͷͰͻͷͫͪͻ͵ͷ
Ͷͽͪͻ;
ͳ͵Ͱ͵ΒͪΒͰͺͯͼͰΕͪͶͪͪͶͽͪͻͼ͵;ͺͪͶ;ͳͷͪͼͳͬͰͭͻΔͰͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͰ
;ͼͬͷͬͻͰͷͰ;ͳͼͻͰͯͳͳͰͷͪͳΒͰͯ;ͪͪͶͭͳΒ;͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͺ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
ͼͰͺͳͶͪͯͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͰͼͶͪͬͰ͌ͳͼͽͷͼͽͶͰΕ;ͷͻͪ͵ͳ͵ͽͳͽͻͺͷͳ
ΔͰͼͰͳ;ΒͰͯͷͺͳͼͪͷͯ͵;ͷͰͽ;͇ΒͰͬͻͰͯͪͺͪͱΔͰ͵ͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬ
ͻͰͰͺͳΒͳͶͳ͵ͪ͵ͰͲͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͪͰͲͫͭͼͬΒͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͰͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽͳ
͉ͰΒͰͲͪͺͳͼ;ͳͲͭͯͳͰ͵ΒͳΒͰͺͻͰͺͳͼͪͺͻͽͺͺ͉ͪͯͰͳͲͺͶͰͷͰͪ
͋ͻͰͫΒͰͪͪ
ͪͬͯͼͺͻͰͯͶ͵ͪͳͲͭͯͳͰ͌Ͳͪͺͳͼ;ΒͰͳͲͶͱͰͺ
ͻͯͳͼͽͪͫͶ̺;͵ͪͬͳΕͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͼͰͽ;ͽͳͽ;ͶͳͰͪͯͬΒͪ͵ͪͳͪΒͺͻͰ
͵ͪSteçan2, veliki gospodar2 vsei serbskoi zemli bastoynim2 i zapadnim stranam2
ͯ͵
ͼͰͰͽͯͪΓͰ͵ͪͱͰͯͪΒͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ͵ͰͲ̺;͵ͪͻͯͳͯͬͪͼͳͪ
dimitria velikago
j$pana i steçana, velikago krala ije sagradi moray$͌ͪͼͽͪͬ͵;ͼͽΒͳΒͳͼͶͰͯͰ
ΕͰse6je steçan2 b6st2 neplodn m i vzimaeva mesto sina nik\$ sestriyina svoego, i
vazam2 em$ jen$ ot2 vninyeskie zemli, da¹er2 leonovu i vazvede na san2 preyviterstva
m i ostavi nik\$ popa͇ͯͽͭ͆ͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͰͷͪͶ͵ͪͶͷͺͻͰͯͪΔ;
ͺͽͳͰͻͯ
͋ͻͰͫΒͰͪͪ
͌97***ͬͰ͵;
ͪͪͻͳͽ;9*9
ͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ͵ͰͲͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
͵ͪͳͽͶͳ͵ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͶͳͼͽͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰ
ͺͳΔͰͯͪͼͰͻͪͲͶͪͱͰͳͺͼͽͰͺͰͺͺͻͳ
ͷͪͿͶ͵ͶͻͰͯͶͳ͵Ͱ̺ͪͱΒͰͳͺͪ͵ͻͰΕͳͯͪΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͬ͵;Ͷͽͺͻͯ;ͱͳͶͪͺ
ͺ;ͶͪͳΒͪͳͲͻͪͲͳͽͯͳͪͻͼ͵ͪͺͷͰͽͪͶͳͽͰͽ;
ͼͪͼͪͱͳͷͼͰΕͪΔͰͷͲͪ͵;Ͷͽ
ͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͪ ͳ ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶ ͻͪͲͬͳΒͰͳͷ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ ͺͪͷΕͰΔͰͷ ͊ͽͳͰ ͼͰ
;ͽͳͼͪ͵ͯͪͼ;ͷͻͪ͵ͳ͵ͪͶ;ΌͰͻͳ
ΒͰͯͪ͵͵ͪͳΔͳͬͳͼͬͰͽͬͳͼͪͺͶͰͷͰͳ
ͳ
ͽͪͺͻͰͺͲͪͶͳͫͳͽͰͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ͊ͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͽͷͰͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;
ͺ;ͽͺͳͼͳ
ͯͼͺͳͼͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪͅͻͪͰͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͰͳ;9*9ͬͰ͵;͌ͪͻͯ
Β
Ͱͺͼ͵ΒͼͬͰͼͽͳ͊ͽͰͿͪΒͰ
ͫͪͬͰͲ
ͼͶͬͳ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͳ͵ͻͪΓͳ͵ͽͳͽͻͲͪ
ͷͰͳͽͭͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪͅͻͪͰ͈;ͼͽͪΓͰͷͫͳͪΒ;
ͺ͵ͶͰΔͪͼ;ͺͻͰͼͳͶͪ
ͺͻͳͺͬͰͼͽͳͽͷͰ͵ͪ͵ΒͰͺͻͪΌͰͷͰͼͽͲͪͲͳͯͪΔͰͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ͈ͪͻͰͯͪΔͰ
͵ͪͱͰ ͯͪ ΒͰ tͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ ͵ͽͳͽͻ
͵ͪ ͺͻͳi
ͯͪͬͳ ; ͽͰ ͵ͻͪΒͰͬͰ
ͫͳ ͪͻͪ
ͺͻͳͻͯͳͷͶͰͺͽͪͷͪ
ͪͪͻͳͽͬͯͺͪͯͳͷͪ͊ͬͰͽͳͭͻͰ͆ͳͼ;ͳͲͼͽͪͶͪͳ
;ͯͰͼͪͲͪͷͰΔͪ͆ͪͲͪͻͪͬͳ;ͼͻͰͯͬͻͶͰͽͭͺͻͰͯͰͶͪͷͰͽͪͳͼ;͵ͻͪΓ;ͺ
͵ͪͲͪͶͳ͵ͻ;͵ͬͯͻͬͪ͵ΒͰͷΒͰΕ;ͭͻͰͶͪͼͬͰΕͪmͽΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ͵ͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͶͯͪͻ͵ͬ;;ͺͻͪͬͽ;ͺͯͳͭͰ͋ͰͱͳͽͰ͵;ͶͽͪͼͽͪͶͪΒͰ
͵ͪ͵
ΒͰͯ;ͬͰ͵ͳͫͳͶ
ͭͻͫͳͪ;͊ͽͰͿͪͬΒͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͳ͇ͪΒͰͳͼͺΓͪͬͪͶͪ;ͯ
ͽͬͻͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ͌ͼͬͰͼͽͪͻͯͪͯ;ͫ͵ͼͰ;ͻͰͲͪͶͬͰͻͬͪΔͰ;ͽͯͪͫͳͼͬͪ͵ͭ
ͭ͵ͫͳͺ͵;ͪͯͪΒͰͽͰͽͳͳͶͳͼ͵ͻͪͬͳͼͪͶͪͷ;͵ͪͳͰͼͬͰͼͽͳͪ
ͽͰ
ͫͳͽͪ͵ͫͳͼͺͻͰͰ;ͼͬͷͪ;ͷ;͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪΒͰ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͭͻͫͫͳͪͻͳ
ͽͯͰͶͽͬͻͪ;ͯͯͳͻ;ͼͰͬͰͻͳͳͷ͈ͪͼͰͫͺͺ;ͶͪͻͪͫͳͶͪΒͰͺͻͳͪ
ͼ;ͯͫͳͳͰ͵ͳ͋;ͻͪ͵ͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͺ͵;ͪͶͳͯͪͭͪͺΓͪ͵ͪΒ;́ͲͭͻͫͳͰΒͰͽͪͯͪ
ͼ;͵;ͺͶͪͷͰ
ͪͪͼͳͶͳͳͺͼͽͪͶͳͷͪͳͽͳ
ͺͪͼ;ͼͰ
ͫͰͱͰΕͳͯͰͬͳͯΓͳ
ͬͰͼͳͶͰ
ͼ;ͻͬͪͶͳͳͲͶͳͽͳͰ͊ͬͰͽͳͭͻͰ͈ͻͰͷͪͳͼͽͷͺͻͰͯͪΔ;
͵ͪͲͪͷͰΔͰ
ͽͭ;ͯͪͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͪͭͻͫͳͳΒͰͼͽͪtͯ;ͫ͵ͱͳΓͪ͵i
ͪͪΔͰͷ;ͻ
ͽͻͪͭͺͶͪͷͰͪ
͆ͪ͵ͻͪΒ;
ͽͪͫͳͫͳͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵ͪͰͭͺͻͳͶͭͪ ͆ͳΒͰͪͷͫͳͳΓͯͪͳͲ
ͶͱͳͷͬͪͼͪͲͪΔͪͷͻͪ͵ͷ͵ͽͳͽͻ;mΒͰͻΔͳͷͭ;ͯͰͽͳͼͪͷͬͳ
ͳͲͬͻͳmͬͰΕͯͪͺ;ͯͳͷͳͻͰͼͬͰͯͯͼͪͯͪΔͳͲͪͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰͳͽ;
ͷͪͰΔͰΔͰͭͬͰͼͫͰ͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪΒͰ;ͼͬͷͬͻͰͷͰ;͵ͰͲ͊ͽͰͿͪͫͳ;ͭͶͰͯ
ͪͳͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͪͶͳͼͽ
ͼͼͫͰͳͷͪ;ͽͻͳͽͰͽͷ͵ΒͳͳΒͰͺͻͳͼͽͳͪͳͲ
ͰͺͼͻͰͯͭ;ͰͼͽͬͬͪΔͪ;ͬͶͪͼͽͳ̸͵ͷ;ΒͰͼͺͼͽͬͰͬͻͰͷͰ;ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
Ͱͽͳ;ͼ͵ͻͪͽͳͶ
ͺͽΔͰͭͪΒͰͪͭͻͪͯͳͶͳͲ;ͲͰͽͳͷͳͽͻͪΒͳͷͫͶͳͳͷͪ
ͽͬͪΔͪ
]]
̸͇͉͇͉̻͇̺̓͋́͋͐̾́̾̓͌̈́͋͢ͅ
͉̺̾̈́́̓́̾͠
̸̸̸̸̺͉͇͇̻́̈́̽͊̓́̽̾̈́́͠
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&
̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
̸͇̺͈͇̺͋̾̓͊͋͊͆́͐̓̾̾̾͊͡ͺͪͼͬΒͻ͵ͬͳ;̿ͳͳ
ͳͼͺͳͼͪͪ;ͶͪͲ;;
͵;Ͷ;
ͲͪͺͳΔͰͪͬΌͰΔͰͷͯͪͻͬͪ͵ΒͰ͵ͻͪΓ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳͼͪͼͳͷ
͉ͪͯͼͶͪͬͷͺͻͳͶͪͱͰͻͪͷ;͌ͲͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͰmͳ͵Ͱͳ͵ΔͳͭͰ
ͯͻͪͭͰͰͼͪ
ͼ;ͯͰ
ͲͪͬͰͼͰͳͺ͵ͻͬͰmͽ;ͼ;ͪͺͻͬͷͷͰͼͽ;ͺͫͻΒͪͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰtwͼͬͰͽͰ
ͰͼͽͳͰͪͼͭͳͱͳͬͽͬͻͰΕͰͭ͵ͻͼͽ̻ͪͼͺͯΔͰͭͪͳͼͬͰͽͳͼͽͻͪͼͽͳ͎ͻͳͼͽ
ͬͳͳͯͻͳͲͰͳͺΒͪͼ͈ͪͻͰͼͬͰͽͰ̹ͭͻͯͳͰͳͯͯͰͼͳͰͼͬͰͽͭͪͺͻͻ͵ͪ
͈ͻͰͽͰͰ̓ͻͼͽͳͽͰΓͪͬͪͪ͠
͵Β;ͺͶͱͳͪͽͰͷͰ̻ͼͺͯΔͰ͵ͻͼͽͰΕͳͭͪ
ͳͯ
ͭͶͪͬͰ͈ͻͰͽͰͳͰͳͯͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͳͼͬͰͽͳͪͺͼͽͶͪ
ͺͻͻ͵ͪ
ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪͳ
ͺͻͰͺͯͫͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪi͋ͪ͵ͪͬͯͪͻ
ͺͫͻΒ;ͳͯͪͫͳͻ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ΒͰͯͳ
ͼͽͬͰΒͰ;ͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͻͼͽ̸ͬͪ͵ͼͰ
;Ͳͽ
ͳͷͪ
;ͬͳͯ;ͯͪΒͰͺͻͳͶͱͰͻͪͷ;͵ΒͳΒͰͫͳͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͼ͵ͼͰͯͳͽͰͳ͵ͻ;ͳͯ
ͫͰͪͻ͵ͬͪ
ΒͪͼΒͰͯͪΒͰͻͰͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͷͳ;
ΒͰͯͷ;ͳͲ;ͺͯ;ͬͪͽͪ
͊ͪͬͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͼͽͬͪͻͰͳ;ͭͯͳͪͷͪͺͻͰͶͷͳͷͲͪ;ͼͽͪͬΓͰΔͰͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰͳͻ͵ͬͰ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͌ͪΒͯͼͪͯͪΔΒͪ;ͳͺͻͫͶͰͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͵ͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͪ;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;
;ͬͪͰ
ͳΒͰͫͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͺͼͰͫͭͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪ͋ͪͺͻͪͲͳͪͪͻͳͽΒͰͬͰ
Ͷͳ͵ͪͪ͵ͼͰͳͷͪΒ;ͪ;ͷ;ͲͪͪΒͳ;ͶͭͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͅͽͳͼͬͰ
ͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͵ͪͳͫΒͰ͵ͽͳͰͺͼͻͰͯͬͰͲͪͳͲͪͶͳͼͽͳͰͫͰͼ͵ͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
ͫͳ
ͶͰͼ;ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͰͰͭͲͰͭͰͲͰ
Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͫͻͰͯͪ
ͪͶͳͳͪΒͼͪͱͳΒͰͭ
ͳͼͺΓͪͬͪΔͪͺͫͱͼͽͳ͇Ͱͼ;ͫͳͽͪ
ͰͻͪͲͶ;ͳͬͳͯͰͼͬͪ͵ͭͻͪͷͪ
͵ͪ
ͽͼ;ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳͳͳͶͳͪΒͼ;ͭͰͼͽͳͬͳΒͳͬͳͯPSOBNFOUBFDDMFTJBF̀ͫͭ
ͽͭͪΒͰͬͪͱ
ͯͪͫͳͼͰͻͪͲ;ͷͰͶͪͺͻͪͬͪͼͬͻͪͺͻͭͻͪͷͪͼͽͬͪͻͰͭ;̿ͳͳ
ͫͪͻ;͵ͻͪͽ͵;͵ͪͲͪͽͳͪͼͷͳͼͪͳͿ;͵ͳΒ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;ͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ΒͷͳͼͶͳ
ͪͶͳͳ;͵;ͺΒͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ̽ͭͷͪͽͼ͵ͰͼͬͰͪ͵Βͳͷͪͺͳͬͪͼͬͪ
ͽͪΔͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪΒͰͯͪ͵Ͱͼ;
;͵ͻͪΒΔΒͶͳͳΒͳ
ͽͰͷͰΓͳͷͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͪͷͪͽͰͶͭͳΒͰ
ͳ͵ͪ͋;ͷͳͼͪ
ͳͲͶͱͰ;ͪͼͳͽͰͽͳͪͪͳ
ͪͼͶΔͰ;ͪ͊ͬͰͽͺͳͼͷ
ͳͼͬͰͽͽͪ͵ͺͻͰͯͪΔͰ
ͫͻͪͲͶͪͭͪΒͰ;ͼͬΒͳͷͼͺͳͼͳͷͪͬͪ̽ͪ͠ͷͪͼ͵ͳ
ͺ
Ͷͱͳͬͳͽͪ͵ͼͬͰͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͭͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͭͪ;͵ͪ͵ͪ͵ͳ͵ͪͷͪͽͪ͵ͳ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪ͢Ͱͭͬͪͼ;ͽͳͪͼͪͼͽΒͳͼͰ;ͼͬͪͽͪΔ;ͯͪͼ;͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳͷͽͰͶ
ͽͬͻͰΔͰͷͬͰ͵ͳͺͻͳͻͯͪͫͭͽͬͻͰͳ͇ͳͼ;ͯͻͰΌͰͳͳͺͻͱͰͽͳͽͻͪ
ͼͰͯͰͽͳͷ
ͳͲ Ͱͭͪ ͳ ͺͻͳͼͽͳͰ ͷͭ;Εͼͽ ͯͪ ͼͰ ͳͼ͵;ͼͰ ͬΓͪ ͳ ͷͳͶͼͽ
̹ͱΒͪ
ͪͼͬͰͽͼͽͺͺͻͳͷͳͺΒͪͬͰͫͶͳ͵Ͱ̀ͪͰͶͬͳͽͽͰͶ͵;ͫͶͳͰΔͰ
ͽͰͳͯͰΒͰͺͼͰͫΒͰͲͪͼͶ;ͱͪͪͅ͵ͼͳͷ́ͼͺͬͰͯͳ͵͈ΔͰͷ;
ͳͼ͵;ͺΓͰΔͰΒͰ
ͽͻͪΒͳͺͻͰͼͫͱͰΔͪ
ͰͺͻͰ͵ͳ͎ͯͪͻͳͼͽͬͪͳ͵ͪͻͪͳΒͪ
͵Βͪͫ;ͬͪͽͪ
ͷͳͼͽͳͰ
ͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͻͪͶͰ
ͪͶͳͳͽͰͶͰͼͰͫͶͳ͵Ͱ;ͺͻͼͽͻ;ͳͬͻͰͷͰ;
͆ͪΒ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͳΒͳͷͫͶͳͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͼͽͳͼͷͪͽͻͪͰͼ;ͲͪͶͭͰ͵ΒͰtͼͪͺͻͰͼͽͶͳ
ͳ ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳi ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ; ͼͬͰͽ; m ; ͬͳͯ; ͼͺͼͽͬͰͭ ͽͰͶͪ
ͽ ΒͰͼͽ ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪ
ͼͬΒͰͽͰͶͰͼͰͰͭͲͳͼͽͰͳΒͰ̹;ͯ;Εͳͯͪͷ;ͰͳͳͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
ͫͳͽͪͬͪΒ;ͼ̹ͭͷͳͼΓ;ͯͳͷͪm͵ͪ͵ͽ͵ͪͱͰ͊ͳͷͰ͊Ͷ;ͼ͵ͳmΔͳͬͪ
ͽͰͶͪ
;ͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͷͪͶͳͫΒͪͬΓͰͷͫͶͳ͵;
ͺͼͽͪΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳͼͪͼ;ͯͳͳͶͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
̽ͪͷͪͼ͵ͳ;
tͯ;ͬΓͰͪͽͰͶͰͼͪͺͻͰͫͳͬͪͶͳͽ̹ͪͱΒͪiͳtͼͺͪͼͼͳͳͲͬ
ͻͳi͇ͪͼ;
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͲͪͷͰΔ̹ͪͱΒͰͷΕͳͳͺͼͻͰͯͳͳͳͲͷͰΌ;ͰͫͰͼ͵ͭͳ
ͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵͇ͭͯͪͽͶͰͺͻͳͼͯͰΔͳͬͪ;ͯͽͬͻͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͲͪͽͳͽ
ͳ͵ͪͳͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͪ
͵ΒͪͯͪΒͻͪͳΒͳͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͬͻͰͷͰͪͳͰΒͰͲͭͻ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͪ͌ͺͽͻͰͫͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳͲͪͽͳͻͪ
͇Ͱͼ;ͳͷͪͶͰͬͪͱͷͰͼͽ;ͫͭͼͶ;ͱͫͰͳͷͫͻͰͯͳͷͪͳͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔ;Ͷͳͽ;ͻ
ͭͳΒͼ͵ͰͭͯͳͰ͆Ͱ͵ͰͯΔͳͳͼͽͳͪͰͼ;͵ͪQBMMBEJVNͭͻͪͯͬͪͳͶͳWFYJMMJVN;
ͬΒͳͷͺͯͳͷ͈ͪͼͬͰͯͰΒͰͳ͵ͻͳΕͰΔͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;Βͪͬͷͱͳͬͽ;
ͳͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͪͷͪ
ͻͰͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͪͬͳͪ͵ͽͳͬͼͽͳ͵ΒͰͼ;ͼͺͻͬͯͳͶͰ
ͳͯͻͱͪͬͪͳͻ͵͇ͬͪͰͪΒͺͽͬͪͳΒͰ
ͺͺ;ͽ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͳͶͳͻ;Όͪͼͽͻͪ
ͯͪΔͪ
ͷͭͶͰͼ;ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͽͳͼͿͰͻͳͯͻͱͪͬͰͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͽͪ͵ͽͼ;ͳͳͶͰͯͰ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͳͻͳͲͳͪ
ͺͪͳͼͪͷͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͳͼͳͭͳΒͪ
͊ͪ;ͬͪͳͳͲͬͻͳ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͺͻͬͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
ͺ͵ͪͲ;Β;ͯͪ
ͼ;;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ͵ͻͪΒͰͷ9**ͳͺͰͽ͵ͷ9***ͬͰ͵ͪͼͷͳͼͪͳͿ;͵ͳΒͪͻͰ
Ͷͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͫͳͶͳͯͫͻͺͲͪͽͳ͇ͼͳͷͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͪͬͪͽͬͪΔ;ͷͽͳΒ;;ͭͶͰͯ
ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͯͺͼͰͫͰͼ;ͬͪͱͼͽͳͺͯͪͳ͵ΒͳͭͬͻͰͬͳͰͼͽͻ;͵Β
;ͺͽͻͰͫͳ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ͌ͪ;ͳΒͰͬͰΕ;͵ͪͲͪͪͺͫͰͯͳ͵ͲͪͰΔͰ͆Ͱ
ͷͪΔͳͭͺͰ͵ͽͻͪͶͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͳΔͰͭͬͷͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵;ͽͻͰͫͪͶͯͪͫ;ͯͰt;ͬͪͻ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
́ͼͽ͵ͪ͠ͰͯͪͯΔͰͭͬͳͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͳͺͼͶͰͯͳͪͫͳͶͪΒͰͽͰͷͰΓͪͺͻͷͰ
ͪͽͺͭͻͪͿͳΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;ͽͪͯͪΔͰͷͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;̀ͪͼͶ;ͭͷ͊ͪͬͰ
͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͽͪͺͻͰͻͪͼͺͯͰͶͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͳΒͰͲͪͫͳͶͪͳ͊ͻͫͰ
Ͱͷ;ͪΒͫΓͰ
ͼͬͰͯͰͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͳͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͰͭͼͶΒͪͱͳ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰ
ͺͫͻΒͪͳ;ͼͳͬͪ͵Β
ͺͬͰΓͳ
͈ͻͬͽͼͰͺͻͳͷͰΕ;ΒͰΒͰͼͽͰΔͰͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ
ͽΒͰͼͽͳͲͫͻͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ͇ͪͰ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͪΒͬͳͳͷͶͳͼͽͳͷͪͰͫͰͼ͵ͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
ͪ
ͼͳͷͽͭͪ
ͳͲͳ
ͻ͵ͭ ͻͰͺͰͻͽͪͻͪ ͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ ͵ΒͰ ͼ; ; ͽ ͯͫͪ ͫͳͶͰ ; ͰͺͻͰ͵ͳͯͷ ͺͻͷͰͽ;
ͰͺͭͻͰͳͬ ͼ; ͯͪͫͻͪͰ Ͱ ͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͰ
ͬͰͲͪͰ Ͳͪ ͎ͻͳͼͽͪ
̹ͭͻͯͳ;
͈ͻͰͽͰ;ͳͪΒͫͶͳͱͰ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͰͼͶͰͯͫͰͳ͵Ͱ͋ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͽͶͰΕͳͷͪͼ;ͳͳ
ͶͰΒͰͲͭͻ͵;ͶͽͪͪΒͼͶͪͬͳΒͳͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͶͳͽͪ
ͯ͵ΒͰ;Δͳͬͷͺͻ
ͼͶͪͬΓͪΔ;ͺͻͪͲͳͳͷͪ;ͰͼͽͬͬͪͳͬͪͼͳͶͰͬͼͼͪͶͪͬͳͷͪͯͬͻͪ
͆ͪΒͰΔͰͳΒͪͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪm͵ΒͪͼͰͳ;̿ͳ͵ΒͺͬͰΓͳͺͷͳΔͰ
ͪͺͻͬͷͷͰͼͽ;mͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ΒͰ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ͇ͯͭͯͳͰ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͪͻ́ͻͪ͵Ͷͳ
ΒͰͺͻͰͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ;;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ
ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͪͺͻͰͼͽͳͪͺͼͽͪͶͪΒͰͭͶͪͬͳ
ͻͪͼͪͯͳ͵͵;ͶͽͪtͪͼͭͯͻͬͰͽͪi͢ͰͭͬͳͻͰΔͰͳͻͪͲͭͻͪͪͬͪΔͰͺͻͪΕͰΒͰ
ͽ͵ͷͬͻͰͷͰͪ
ͬͳͯͳͷ;ͷͱͪͬͪΔͰͷͫͻΒͪͰͼͽͳ͉ͪͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪΒͰͪΒͺͻͰ ;
7*ͳ7**ͬͰ͵;
;ͬͪͪ;ͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͰͽͰ͊ͿͳΒͰ
ͪͯͰͺͰͪͻͰͬͪͷͪ͵Ͱͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
ͺͪͼͬͰͯ
ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪͼͰ;ͪͻͼ͵Β͵ͪͺͰͶͳm;ͻ͵ͬͳ̹ͭͻͯͳͰ
͍ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͵ΒͪΒͰͳͳͶͪͯͰͼͶͱͰͭ͵ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͻͰͲͳͯͰͳΒͰͅͰΌ;
ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͷͪ͵ͻͼͯͻͬͳͷͪͶΒͰͪΒͳͻͳͻͪͼͺ;ͺͽͻͰͫͰ͈
ͻͰͯͽͭͪͽΒͰͳͷͪͶͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;mͪͺͻͪͲͳ͵͌ͲͯͳͲͪΔͪ͐ͪͼͭ
͵ͻͼͽͪ
;ͫͻͰͯͳͷͪͽ͵ͷ͊ͽͻͪͼͰͼͰͯͷͳͰͳͶͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͰͼͳΒͰͪͬͭ;
ͼͽͪ m ΒͰ ͯ ͪΒͻͪͳΒͳ ͬͻͰͷͰͪ ͽͬͪ Ͳͫͭ ͼͬΒͳ ͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ ͳ
Ͳͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͳͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪ̓ͪͳͼͽͻ;ͷͰͽͬͰͻͰ
͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ͵ͻͳͼͽͳͼͰͺͻͳ
͇͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ;͵ͪͫͻͪͼ;;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒͷͳͼͶͳͳ;ͷͰͽͼͽͳͺͼͽΒͳͬͰͷͪͫͳͷͪ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ̀ͪͺͻͫͶͰͷ͵ΒͳͷͼͰͬͯͰͫͪͬͳͷW'/JFIPĒ
6NCJMJDVTNVOEJm%FS/BCFMEFS
8FMU+FSVTBMFNVOEEBT)FJMJHF(SBCJN4QJFHFMWPO1JMHFSCFSJDIUFO
VOEmLBSUFO
,SFV[[ÛHFO
VOE3FMJRVJBSFO
JO0SOBNFOUBFDDMFTJBF
m DͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͷ
́ͲͬͻͰ͵ΒͳͼͬͰͯͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪͺͻͰͰͽͳͷͪ̀ͪͺͪͯͺͼͶͰͼͪͫͻͪΒͰ͉3JBOU
%FTEÊQPVJMMFTSFMJHJFVTFTFOMFWÊFÆ$POTUBOUJOPQMFBV9***FTJÍDMFQBSMFT-BUJOTFUEFTEPDVNFOUT
IJTUPSJRVFTOÊTEFMFVSUSBOTQPSUFO0DDJEFOU
1BSJTPͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪ͵ΒͰͼ;͵ͪͺͶͰͷͶͰ
ͽͪ͵ͭͯ;ͱͯͪͺͻͳͼͽͳͭͶͰ;̺ͰͰͳΒ;̸'SPMPX
/PUFTTVSMFTSFMJRVFTFUMFTSFMJRVBJSFTCZ[BOUJ
OFTEF4BJOU.BSDEF7FOJTF
ȄʆʌʔʝʐʎʔʈʥȖʒʊʓʔʊʂʎʊʋʜʥȁʒʗʂʊʐʌʐʄʊʋʜʥȅʔʂʊʒʆʝʂʥ
m
"ʉʜʎʂʊ
m͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͵ΒͰͼ;ͪ͵ͺͻͰͼͽͪͶͰ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;ͪΒͺͽͺ;ͳΒͰ
ΒͰͻͪͲͷͽͻͳ
ͪͼͬ;ͺ;ͽͺͳͼͳ
ͪͶͳͳͯͻ;ͭͳͳͲͬͻͪ
(͉.BKFTDB
3VTTJBO5SBWFMFST
UP$POTUBOUJOPQMFJOUIFGPVSUFFOUIBOEGJGUFFOUI$FOUVSJFT
8BTIJOHUPO
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
Ͷͳ͵ͷͯͻͱͪͬͪΔͪͼͪͫͻͪͳͶͳͺͶͪͭͪΔͪͲͪ͵ͶͰͽͬͰ̀ͪͻͪͲͬΒͳ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͯ ͪͻͳͽͰ ΒͰ ͬͪͱͼͽͳ ͫͳͶͪ ;Ͷͭͪ ͵Β; ΒͰ ͐ͪͼͳ ͵ͻͼͽ ͳͷͪ ; ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Β
ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͳ͈ͻͳͬΒͳͷͺͯͳͷͪΒͰͫͳͭͶͪͬͻ;ΌͰͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͬͪͼͰΓͰ
ͼ͵ͳͪͻͰͬͪ
͵Βͳͼ;ͺͻͰͯͳͷͪ;ͬͰ͵ͳͷͪͶͳͺͫͰͯͳ͵ͳͲͪ͵̓ͼͽͪͽͳͪ
̺ͰͶͳ͵ͭ̓ͪͪͻͼ͵ͲͪͷͰΔͰ
ͳͷͪΒͰͬͪͱ;;Ͷͭ;;ͯͬͻͼ͵ͷͰͻͰͷͳΒͪͶ;
ͪͼͽͪͬͻͽͰ͵ͰͼͯͻͪͭͰͳͷͰͼͽͳͪͷͪͳͳͶͰͼ;ͭͽͬͰͳͲͼͽͪͬͳͯͰͬͶͪ
ͯͪͻͼ͵ͭ ͪͺͪͻͪͽͪ ͌Ͳ ͐ͪͼͳ ͵ͻͼͽ
͵ͪ ͭͶͪͬ ͻ;ΌͰ ͳͲͫͪͬΓͰΔͪ ͼͶͬͳͶͰ ͼ;
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͊ͽͻͪͼͽͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳ͋ͰͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͰmͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ͵ͺΓͰ
ͽͻͼ͵;
ͼ;ΌͰͻ
͵ͶͳͬͰmͫͭͼͶͬͳ͈ͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͰͻ͵ͬͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͶͳͼ;ͼͬͰΕͰͳͷͯͯͳͻͷͼ
ͽͰͶͷͳ͵ͻͬΓ;͊ͺͪͼͳͽͰΓͰͬͷ͈ͷͰ;ͽͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪ
͵Βͳͷͪͼ;;
9*ͬͰ͵;ͺͻͳͯͯͪͽͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͺ;ͻͺ;ͻͳͺͶͪͽͳͽͻͬͬͰͪ
ͫͳͶͰͼ;ͪΒͬͰΕͪ
ͲͪͷͰͳͽͼͽͪͻͼ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰ;̹ͭͻͯͳͳ͍ͪͻͼ͵Β͆ͰͺͼͻͰͯͺͻͰΔͰͰ
ͺͻͺͪͼͽͳͭͯͳͰͽͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰΒͰͼͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͯͳͬΓͰΔͰͷͺͳͼͪͶͰ͵Ͷͳ͵
ͺͼͰͽͳͶͪͪͺͻͰͼͽͳͰ͊Ͷͳ͐ͪͼͷ͵ͻͼͽ;
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪͳͷͪͶͰ
ͼ;ͬͳͰͼͽͻ;͵;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;́Ͳͬͻͳͽͪ͵ͼͬͰͯͰͽͷͰͯͪΒͰͼͬͰͽͷͼͷͪͽͻͪͪ
Ͳͪ͵ͶͰͽͬͪ͵ΒͪͼͰͺͶͪͭͪͶͪͺͻͰͯͽͻͬͳͷͬͰͰͷ
͵ͺΓͰͷͳ͵Ͷͳͬͳͷ͈ͪͽͬͻ
ΌͰͪΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
;ͶͭͪͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͺΓͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͫͰͶͰͱͪͬͪΔ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭͺͰͽ͵ͪ;
ͪͻͼ͵ΒͺͪͶͪͽͳ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
͈ͼͶͰ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͳ͊ͽͻͪͼͽͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳ;̿ͳ͵ΒͺͬͰΓͳͺͷͳΔ;ͼͰ
ͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͪ;ͼͽͪΓͰͳͷͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͷͰͫͰͼ͵ͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
ͯͬͰͪΒͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
̹ͭͻͯͳͳͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰmͻͳͲͪͳͺΒͪͼ͉ͳͲͪΒͰ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;ͯ7ͬͰ͵ͪ;ͬͪ
ͪ;ͺͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼ;
ͲͪͺͻͪͬͬͰͶͳ͵ΒͰͽͻͪͶΒͭͻͪΌͰͬͳͳͺͻͳͲͳͯͪΒ;Ͳͻ͵ͬ;
̹ͭͻͯͳͰ;̺ͶͪͰͻͳ͋;ΒͰͪͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪͪͺͼͰͫͳͷͺͻͪͲͳ͵ͷ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ
;ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ;ͪͻͼ͵ͰͺͻͯͳͰ
ͳͲͶͪͭͪͪͬͰͻͳͷͪͪͰͶͳͬͪΔͰ͊ͬͰͽͳΔͪΒͰ
ͬͪͱͳͶͪͲͪΒͰͯͪͯͺͪͶͪͯͳΒ;ͷͪ͏ͪͻͼͽ̺ͬͪͰͻͬͪͶͼͰ
ͪͳͷͰ
ͯͪΒͰͭͯͳͰ
ͼͺͪͼͶͪ͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͯͪͬͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͯͻ;ͼ͵ͰͪΒͰͲͯͰ͌͵ͪ;͵ΒͳΒΒΒͰ;*9
ͬͰ͵;ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳ͠ͼͳͿ͎ͳͷͭͻͪͿͪͼͰͪͲͳͬͪtͬͻͼͽͳͷͫͰͯͰͷͷiͺͻͰͼͽͳ
ͰͳͳͲͬͻͷͫͰͲͫͻΒͳͳͼͰΓͰΔ̺ͪͰͷͪͺͽͬͪͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͫͳΒͰͳ
̹ͭͻͯͳͳͺΒͪͼ
͵ΒͳͼͰ;ͬͪ;ͻ͵ͬͳͺͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼ;ͺͯͳͭ;ͽͷ;Ͳͻͪͷ̹
ͭͻͯͳͰ͎ͪͶ͵ͺͻͪͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱ͊ͬͰͽͳΔͳͼ;ͺͻͳͺͳͼͳͬͪͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪͼͶͳͪͳͷͪ
ͽͳΒͰͳͷͪͷͪͿͻͳͳͲ̺ͶͪͰͻͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͪΒͰͫͰͯͰͷͷͭͻͪͯͪͳͳͲͬͻͷ
ͼͪͭͰ
ͲͯͻͪͬΓͪͳͯ;ͬͳͯͫͪͻͪ́ͽΒͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͳ
͵ΒͪΒͰͼͳͶͪͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽ
tͪͻͼ͵Ͱi
͵ͶͪΔͪͶͳͼ;ͼͰͰͼͪͷͷͭͳͯͪͼͳͳͬͰΕͳͼͪͷͳͬͪͼͳͶͰͬͼͳ
͆ͪͻͳͽͪ
ͱͰͼͽ͵ͪͺͫͱͼͽͳΒͳͼ;ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͫͳͶͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͽͰͱͳͶͪΒͰ
ͺͼͰͯͬͪΔ;ͼͽͪͽͪ͵ͪͼͬͳͶͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͰͼ;ͫͳͶͰͰͺͼͻͰͯͺͬͰͲͪͰͼ͎ͻͳ
ͼͽͷ͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͈ͬͪͪ͠ͻͰͽͰͰmͪͺͼͰͫͭͶͪͬͪͳͯͰͼͪͻ;͵ͪmͫͳͶͰͼ;ͼͽͭͪ
ͪͳͲ;ͲͰͽΒͰͳ
ͺͪͼͰͳ;̿ͳ͵ΒͺͬͰΓͳͺͷͳΔ;ͯͷͪͺͼͶͰ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳ
ͳ̹ͭͻͯͳͳͳ̓;Ͷͽͬͪͪ̓͠ͻͼͽͳͽͰΓͪͻͪͳͻͳͼͰ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;͵ͻͪΒͰͷ*7
ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳͯͰΔͰͭͬ;ͭͶͪͬ;
ͺͻͪ
ΌͰ;;͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ;ͪͯͪͬͅͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͳͲͬͻͳͺͻͰͼͰͬͳͰͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͪͺͻͰ
͵Ͷ;ͽͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
ͳͼ;ͼͪͭͶͪͼͳ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰΔͰͳͷͭͶͪͬͳͷͼͬͰͽͳͶͳͽͳͷͪ
;ͻͪͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͫͳͶͪΒͰͽͻ͵ͬͪͬͪͪ̓͠ͻͼͽͳͽͰΓͪ;͎Ͱͫͯͷ;
ͪͯ9m9*
ͬͰ͵ͪͼͶͪͬͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͊ͽ;ͯͳ;͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪͷͪͪͺͻͪͲͳ͵͌ͼͰ͵ͬͪΔͪ;͊ͽ;ͯͳ
;ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͬͪΒͰͪͻͼ͵ͳͯͬͻ̓ͻͪΒͰͷ9**ͳͺͰͽ͵ͷ9***ͬͰ͵ͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
͇ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪ ͵ͪ ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬ; ͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͪ ͼͬͰͽͰ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͰ
͵ͪ ͳ ΔͳͬΒ ͯͳͯͪ͵ͽͳ͵Β
Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳ,SPPT
PQDJU
m
7ͪͺ
̺ͻͼͽͰͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͪͯͰͳͳͲ͊ͬͰͽͰͲͰͷΓͰ͵ͶͪͼͳͿͳ͵ͬͪΒͰ̺#BHBUUJ
&VMPHJF1BMFTUJ
OFTJ
0$1
WPM97
m
͌ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰͬͻͰͯͰͯͺͻͳͼͰͬΒͺͻͫͶͰͷͪͽͳͳͯͪΒͰ͆#FMUJOH
#JMEVOE,VMU
&JOF(FTDIJDIUFEFT#JMEFTWPSEFN;FJUBMUFSEFS,VOTU
.ÛODIFO
ͺͼͰͫͪͼͽͻm
DBͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͻͰͰΔͰͳͺͽͳͫͻͪͲͪͽͪ͵ͬͰtͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͳΒͰiͫͳͶͪΒͰ͵ͪͺͰͶͪ
ͪͻͼ͵ͰͺͪͶͪͽͰ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;͇ͼ;ͽͳͳΔͰͰͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͰͺͼͻͰͯͼͬͰͯͳ
͵ͭͯͳͰͪͻͼ͵ͳͼ͵ͰͬͿͳͶͪ͵ͼ͆ͳ͵ͶͪͅͰͼͪͻͳͽͳͼ͈ͽΒͰͺͫͻΒͪ
ͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͰ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
͵ͪͱͰ ͯͪ ΒͰ ͪͻͼ͵ͪ ͵ͪͺͰͶͪ ;ͳͼͽͳ; tͯͻ;ͭͳ ͊ͳͪΒ
ͬͳ̺ͳͽͶͰΒͰͷͳ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷi
ͯͪΒͰͪͽͷͷͰͼͽ;͎ͻͳͼͽͼͻΌͰͳ͵ͻͽͰ
ͺͻͳ
ͫͳΒͰͪ͵ͻͼͽͳͺͭͻͰͫͰ;ͽΒͻ͵ͬͳm̹ͭͻͯͳͳ͍ͪͻͼ͵ΒmΒͰͯͳͼͽͪͳ
ͬͪͼ͵ͻͼͪ
Ͱͷ;ͼͬͰͯͰ͵ͪͷͰͳͺ͵ͻͬͼΔͰͭͬͭͭͻͫͪ
͋ͪ͵ͬͼͬͪͽͪΔͰ
;ͳΒΒΒͰͼͬͳͺͻ;͵ͪͬͰͻͳͷͪͯͪͺͼͶͰͯͬͪΔͰ͎ͻͳ
ͼͽ;ͼͽͬͪͻͰ͵ͻͲͼͺͼͽͬͰͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬ
ͳͷͪͶΒͰ;ͽͪͯͪΔͰͷͼͬͰͽ;ͭͻͷͪ
ͯΒͰ͵͌ͼͬͰͼͽͳ͵ͰͱͰͬͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰ͉;ͼͳΒͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͳͯͰΒͪUSBOTMBUJP)J
FSPTPMZNJͼͽͪΒͪͶͪΒͰ;ͰͺͼͻͰͯΒͬͰͲͳͼͳͯͰΒͷUSBOTMBUJPJNQFSJJ
ͽͰΒͰͽͪ͵
ͫͳͶͪͬͪͱͪͳͳͶͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͉;ͼ͵ͳͯͳͪͼͽͳͼ;ͼͰ
;ͽ;ͼͬͻ;
ͼͶ;ͱͳͶͳ ͺͻͫͪͳͷ ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͳͲͷͰΌ; ͼͽͪͶͭ ͺͻͳ͵;ͺΓͪΔͰͷ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰ͵ͶͷͳͲ͊ͬͰͽͰͲͰͷΓͰͳͳͲͫͻͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͫͶͳ͵ͷͪͼͳͻͪ
Ͷͳ̻ͪͻ̻ͫͼͺͯΔͳ ̻ͽͬ ͯͪ ͼ; ͰͫͻΒͰͳ ͺͻͳͷͰͻͳ ͽͪ͵ͬͰ Ͱͬ͵ͪͳΒͰ
͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͪ ; ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ ̀ͪͺͪͯͪ
ͼͽͬͪͻͰͳ ͺͷΕ; ͻͪͲͬͻͼͳ ͼͳͷͫͳͲͪ
ͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͳͯͻ;ͭͳ;ͷͰͽͳ͵ͳͫͶͳ͵̺ͪͻ;ͼ͵ͳͳͲͻͪͲͽͳͼͽͻͰͷΓͰ
ΔͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
4BJOUF$IBQFMMF̈́;Βͪ*9͊ͬͰͽ̻ͭͻͪΌͰͪ͵ͪͽͻͰͲͻͲͪ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰmͷͰΌ;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;ͺͪͼͷͰͼͽͳͷͪͶͪͻ;ΌͪͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪͲͪͺͶͰΔͰͪ
;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;mͽͻͰͫͪͶΒͰ͍ͯͪͯͻͪ;ͼ͵Ͱͪͳͳ̽ͻ;ͭͳ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ
ͼͻͰͯͳ
Δ;ͽͪ͵;ͬͻͰͷͰͰNBQQBNVOEJ͋ͳͲͻͳ͵ͷͽͬͻͯͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͻͳͪͻ̻
ͽΒͰͯͰ̓ͷͳ (BVUIJFSEF$PNVU
͵ΒͳͬͰͶͳ
ͺͬͯͷͼͬͰΕͰΔͪ4BJOUF$IBQFMMF
ͭͯͳͰ
ͯͪͼͰ͊ͬͰͽͪͲͰͷΓͪͼͪͯͪͬͳͰͪͶͪͲͳͪ̀ͪͺͪͯ;Ͱͭͪ́ͼͽ͵;
͑ͽͪͬͳͰ
ͳ;ͼͪͷΒͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͳΒͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͽ;ΒͰ
ͭͽͳ͵ͳͷͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͺ
ͬΓͰͺͻͪͬͳͺͻͽͽͳͺm͵ͪͺͰͶͪͪͻͼ͵ͰͺͪͶͪͽͰ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;͇ΒͰͿͻͪ;
ͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͫͳͺͲͪͽͬͰΕͳͽͪͬ;ͭͰͰͻͪͳΒ;
ͯͬͻͰͷͰͪ͵ͪͯͪΒͰ͉ͫͰͻͯͰ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
̓ͶͪͻͳͺͯͻͫͺͳͼͪͻͳͲͳ;̹ͭͻͯͳͰ͍ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͪͲͬͪͬͳΒͰtͼͬͰͽͷ
͵ͪͺͰͶͷi
͋ͰͱΔͪͯͪͼͰ;ͼͺͼͽͬͰΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬͳͫͻͪͲ͊ͬͰͽͰͲͰͷΓͰΒͪͼΒͰ
ͺͼͬͰͯͰͪͳ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ;ͼͬͳͽ9***ͬͰ͵ͪ̈́ͳͼͽ͵ΒͪΒͰͽ;ͳͯͰΒ;ͼͷͳͼͶͳͶͪ
ͳ;ͳͳͶͪͯͰͶͽͬͻͷͫͳΒͰ
ͺͬ
͊ͪͬͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕ͏ͳΓͰͬͳ͵ΒͰΒͰ;ͽͷ
ͼͷͳͼͶ;ͫͲͪͳͳͷͪΒ;ͬͻͰͯͼͽͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͭͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͪ͋ͪ͵ͬΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͬͷͼͬͰͯͰΔ;
ΔͰͭͬͪͼͽΒͪΔͰtͯͪͼͺͻͰͷͳ̻ͼͺͯ;ͼͪͬͻͰ
ͪͻͯiͳͯͪ;ͽ;ͼͬͻ;t;ͼͽͻΒͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͳͺͻͼͽͻͪͺ;ͽ͵ͪ͊ͬͰͽΒ̻ͻͳwͳ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ;͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͳ;͊ͳͪΒͳ;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͰͼͽͭͯͰͼͰͳͷͰ;ΒͰͳͷͰ̹ͱΒͰi͌
ͪ;ͳΒͰ
ͺͬͯͷͱͳͬͺͳͼͪͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ;ͺͽ͵;ͺͶͳͷͺͻͼͽͻͳͷͪ̿ͳͰ
ͳͺͰΕ͵ͳ͊ͬͰͽͳͪͺͼͽͶͪ
;ͬͳͰͪͬͻͪͽͪͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪͺͻͫͶͰͷͺͻͳͬͪͽͪΔͪ
ͼͳͼ͵ͳ
ͯͼΒͰͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͳͫͻͪͲͪͪ͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ;9***ͬͰ͵;͌ͳͼͽͷ
͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͽͻͰͫͪͶͫͳ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͽͬͪͻͰ;
̿ͳͳ͋ͪ͵ͬͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͳ
;ͼ;ͽͳͳΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͳͺͼͬΒΒͿ;͵ͳΒͳ
ͪͻͪͲͶͳ
ͳͽͳͼͪͷͺ;ͺͽͻͰͫΓͰͳͷͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͫͳͶͳͼ;ͺͯͻͰΌͰͳͳͼͽͷͳΓ;͈ͻͰ
ͰΔͰͫͻͪͲͪͪ͊ͬͰͽͰͲͰͷΓͰͽͻͰͫͪͶΒͰͯͪͺͯ;ͺͻͰΒͰͯ;ͯ͊ͪͬͳͳͳͯͰΒͪ
ͬͯͳΓͪ
ͪͽΒͰͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͳͲͪͫͻͪͭͪͻͯͪͳΒ;ΕͰͳͼͽͻͳΒ;ͬͯͳͽͳ̹ͱΒͳ
ͺͻͷͳͼͪ͆;ͱͪ;ͼͶͬͲͪͪͼͽͪͪ͵ͽͭtͼͪͬͻͰͭiͪͻͯͪͫͳͶΒͰΔͰͭͬ
ͺͻͼͬͰΕͰΔͰ
ͽΒͰ;ͬͻͰͷͰͲͪͳͶ;ͼͬͪΒͪΔͰͽͰͷͰΓͳͪͰͶͪͺͻͪͬͼͶͪ
ͬΓͪͳΔͰͷ;ͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͳͫͶͳ͵ͪͯ;ͬͼͽͳ͊ͽͭͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ
ΒͪͼͼͶͰͯͳ
ͯͪΒͰͱͳ͵ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͻͪͳͷͪͽͳͭͻͷ;;Ͷͭ;ͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͳ
͊ͪͬͳͳͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͪ͵ΒͰͼ;ͫͳͶͰͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͷͳͼͳͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͼtͺͻͼͬͰ
ͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵Ͱi͆ͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͪͷͰΌ;Δͳͷͪͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ΒͰͫͳͶͪͺͻ͵ͶͪͷͪͳΒͪ͊ͳͯͳ͵ͪ
͉ͫͰͻͯͰ̓Ͷͪͻͳ
MPDͼJU
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
̺ͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͰͿͻͰͼ͵Ͱ;͠;ͭͼͶͪͬͳΒͳ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
mJEFN
͊ͬͰͽͳ$BͬBͳ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬΔͰͭͬͭͯͫͪ
JO͊ͪͬͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕmͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ
mJEFN
JO̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
͊
ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̺̓ͻͪΕ
͈ͰΕ͵ͪͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m̹͋ͯͳΕ
͆ͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͰͲͳͯ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ;$̸ͬͺͼͽͶͳͷͪ;͈ͰΕͳ
̀̈́͌
mJEFN
͋Ͱͷͪ͊ͳͼ͵ʹͰͻ͵ͬͳ
ͬͻͪͷͬʹͯͰ͵ͻͪͳͳ9***m9*7ͬͬ
JÓͰͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͬͻ;ͼͼ͵ʹ͵;Ͷ·ͽ;ͻͰ
m ͼͪͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
ͳͼͬͷͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͇ͬͺͳͽͪΔͰͽͰͷͰΓΒͰͻͪͲͷͽͻͳ
ͪͼͬ;ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͪͶͳͳͲͬͻͪͳͼͶͳ͵ͪͳͺͻͭͻͪ
ͷͪ
̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
͊Ͷͳ͵ͪͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
̻Ͷͪͼ̸͎͎͎͊͆͌͊͊͊7͑
͵Δ
m
ͺͼͰͫm
̹̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
͊;ͽͳͪͺͻͼͬͰΕͰͼͽͳ;͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͳͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
͆ͪ;ͳͼͪ
ͼͽͪͪ͵ͼͶͪͬͳͼͽͪ;̺;͵ͬͰͯͪͰ
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬΓͪͳͲͬͰͯͰͪ;̿ͳͳͭͯͳͰ͈ͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͯͻͪͭͰͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ
ͳ͵ͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͳͭ;ͻKFͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͫͳͶͼͪͱͪͼͶͪ͊ͪͬͳͷ
ͳͲͶͪͭͪΔ;ͼͬͪͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͭͪ;͵ͪ
ͪͪͻͳͽͰ͵ͳͷΔͰͭͬͳͷͪͭͶͪͼͳ
ͷͪ͋ͪ͵ͬͰͼ;ͲͪͺͬͰͼͽͳͯͪͼͰͽ;Β;ͫͻͪͲͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͪ
̹ͭͻͯͳͰͳͼͬͳ̹ͱΒͳ
;ͭͯͳ͵ͪ
͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽͳͼͬͰͽͪͷͰͼͽͪ
ͪͶͳͳ;ͺ;ͽͼͽͬͪͻ͵ͬͰͼͪͫͻͳͷ
ͽ
ΒͰͼͽͰ͵ͶͳͼͳͶ͵ͳͷͪͰͶͳͷͪͺͻͪͬͰͬͰͻͰ
͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪͳͼ;ͼͺͻͳͻͪͲͶͲͳͲͫͭ͵Βͳͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͪΒͬͳͰͭͻͪͭͪ
ͯͫͳͶͰͷͰͼͽ;ͬͼͬͪΒ͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͪͅΒͳͻ͵ͪͬͪ
ͳΒͳΒͰ;͵;ͺ
ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͪͻͳͽͰͼͶΒͰͬͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭtͼͳͼ͵;iͻͰͯͪ͵
ͳΒ;ͼͶͳ͵ͪ;ͺͽ͵;ͺͶͷͺͻͼͽͻ;ͳͶͳͺͻ;͵ͰͪͺͼͽͶͼ͵Ͱͺͳͼ͵ͺͼ͵Β
ͼ;͵ͰͼͳΒͳ͢ͳͬ;ͷͭ;Ε;;Ͷͭ;ͽͻͰͫͪͶͫͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳͳͼͫͲͳ
ͻͷͪͳΔͰͳ;ͯͪΒͰ̿ͳͪͫͳͶͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͪͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪ
;ͺͬͰΓͳͳͲͻͳͳͽ
ͺͻͰͯͰΓͰͪ͵ͪ͵ͻ;ͳͯͫͰͳͻͪͷ͠;͵ͶͪͼͳͳͷͯͰͶͳͷ͇ͪ͋ͻͪΒͽͳͭͰͻͪ
͈̾͑ͻͪͷͪͳͶͳ9͍ͳͶͳͪͺ͵ͪͲͪΒͰͯͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
;Ͳͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͼ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͰͳͼͳͭͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͪͺͪͻͪͽ;
ͳͽͰ͵ͪͼͺͻͪͯͳͳ
ͯͯͪͽͪ͵
ͬͰΕ͵ͪͫͳͽͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͯͰ͵ͻ;ͼ͵ͭͽͻͰͲͻ̸ͪͪͶͳͲͪͳͬͰͽͪͻͪ
Ͱͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͻͳͲͳͪͺ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͯͪͼ;Ͱ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͶͰ
ͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͰ ͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
ͳΒͳ ΒͰ ͯͫͳͻ ͼͪͼͬͳͷ ͼͶͳͪ ͷ ; ̿ͳͳ ͋ͪ͵ͪͬ ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͰͻͳͲͳͰͽͪͯͪΔͰͭͼͬͰͽͪ
͵ͪͺͰͶͰͪͻͼ͵ͰͺͪͶͪ
ͽͰ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;
͵ΒͪΒͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪͺͽͰͬͪͱͰΕͳͫͻͪͲͪͳͪ́ͼͽ͵;ͳͪ
̀ͪͺͪͯ;͠ΒͰͻͳͲͳͪ̓ͪͻͶ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͶͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͺͼͰͯͬͪͶͪ
͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ
ΒͰͯͪͼͬͰͽͳ͵Ͷͳ
ͼ;ΌͰͻͳ͵ͺΓͰ
͵ͷ̹ͪͯͭͻͯͳͳͰͯͰΕͰ
͠Ͱͻͷ̸ͪ͠ͰͬͽͳΕ
́ͲͫͭͼͶͬΓͪ͊ͬͰͽͭͪ$BͬFm̿ͳ͵ͪͫͰͼͰͯͪ͊ͬͰͽͭͪ$BͬFͺͻͪ
ͬΒͬFQV
JO͊ͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪmͼͺͷͰͳͪͺͬͯͷͼͪͷͼͽͭͯͳΔͳͰͻΌͰΔͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m ͼͪͳͽͰͭͻͪͶͳͷͽͰ͵ͼͽͷͫͰͼͰͯͰͳͫͳͷͳͷ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͷͪ
7ͪͺͽͪ͵ͬͳͷͪͭͶͪͼͳͷͪ;ͼͶͳ͵ͪͷͺͻͭͻͪͷ;̿ͳͰWͳ͈ͅͳΒͬͳΕ
JO̓ͪͅ
ͪͳ
͚̹͵ͬͳΕ
͈ͅͳΒͬͳΕ
̿ͳͪmͳͼͽͻͳΒͪ
ͪͻͳͽͰ͵ͽ;ͻͪ
ͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m̹͋ͯͳΕ
́͵ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͱͳ͵ͳͿͻͰͼͪ͵ͪ9***ͬͰ͵ͪ
͊ͪͺͽͰ
Δͪm m
m ͼͪͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͇5SFJUJOHFS
%JFPTUSÕNJTDIF,BJTFSVOE3FJDITJEFFOBDIJISFS(FTUBMUVOHJNIÕêTDIFO ;FSF
NPOJFMM
+FOB
1 &4DISBNN
)FSSTDIBGUT[FJDIFO VOE 4UBBUTTZNCPMJL WPN *** CJT 97* +BISIVOEFSU *m͑
4UVUUHBSUm
ͪͻͳͽͺͭͶͪͬΓͪ%FSt5BMJTNBO,BSMTEFT(SPTTFOiNJU"VTCMJDLFOBVG
EJFNJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFO#SVTULSFV[FVOESFMJRVBJSF
#E*
m,SPOFONJU3FMJRVBJSFJO,SPOFO
GPSNm,SPOFOBVG,PQGSFMJRVBJSFO
#E***
m
)'JMMJU[
%JF*OTJHOJFOVOE,MFJOPEJFOEFT)FJMJHFO3PNJTDIFO3FJDIFT
8JFOm.ÛODIFO
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
͵ͪͳͰͼͽͳͰͷͽͳΒ;͈ͬͪͪ͠ͻͰͽͰͰͳͰ͵ͶͳͳͰͪͺͼͽͶͪ͑ͽͪͬͳͰ
ͯ ͬͻͰͷͰͪ ̓ͻͪͯͪ ** m
ͽͻͳ ͽͪ͵ͬͰ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ m ͐ͪͼͳ ͵ͻͼͽ
Ͳ;ͫ
͈ͻͰͽͰͳͳͼͬͰͽ͵ͺΓͰͼ͵ͶͳͷmͲͪΒͰͯͼ;;ͬͪͰ;ͲͪͷͰͳͽͷͻͰͶͳ
͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;
͏ͪͻͼ͵ͷ͵ͻͼͽ;
͵ΒͳΒͰ
;Ͳ͊ͬͰͽ;͵ͻ;;
ͫͳͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͪͳͼͳͭͳΒͪ
͆Ͱͷͪ͵ͭͪͻͼͽͬͪ́;ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͯͻͱͪͬͪͷͪͺͻͰͼͪͳͪͶͭ
͵ͼͽͳͽ;ͳͼͪΔͪ
ͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͯ9*ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͪΕͰKFͼͶͳͷͺͻͪ͵ͼͷ
ͺͪͳͼͳͭͶ͵ͲͪͰΔͰ
;ͳͻͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;ͻͰͳ
ͼͽͳ;͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽͳͰ͵ͪͯ
ͻ;ΌͪͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪ͋ͪ͵ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
ͼͪͼͬͰͽͳͷ͵ͺΓͰͷͰͭͯͰͯͭͯͳͰ
ΒͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͷͳͼͳͭͳΒͷ͆Ͱͷͪ͵ͭͪͻͼͽͬͪ͊Ͷͳͪͼͽͪͽ;ͼ
mSFHBMJTMBODFBmͼͽͰ͵ͶΒͰͽ͵ͷ9*ͳ9**ͬͰ͵ͪ;͈Γͼ͵Β
͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Βͳ͐Ͱ͵Β
͊ͬͰͽ͵ͺΓͰͳͪͻͳͽ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽͳͷͪͶͳͼ;ͬͰͶͳ͵;;Ͷͭ;;ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͳͳ
ͰͻͰͷͳΒͪͶ;͵ͻͼͽͪ͵ͭ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼͽ͈ͬͪͼͰͫΒͰͻͰͳͽͪͼͪ
ͯͻͱͳͪͿͻͪ;ͼ͵Ͱ͵ͻ;ͼ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰͳͲͯͫͪ̈́;Βͪ͊ͬͰͽ͈ͭͪͼͷͰͼͽͽ;
ͼ;Ͳͪ;ͲͳͷͪͶͰͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ
ͻ;ΌͪͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪmͳͽͽͻͬ
ͬͰͪ
ͼ;ΌͰͻ
ͯͰ͵ͺΓͪͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͺ;ͻͺ;ͻͳͺͶͪͽm͵ͷ̹ͪͯͭͻͯͳͳͰ
ͻͳͲͰͳͯͰͭͶͪͬͰ͈ͬͪͪ͠ͻͰͽͰͰͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪͼͽͪͽ;ͼͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͳͼͳͭͳΒͰͳͷͪΒͰ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͽͻͬͬͰ̺ͪͰΕͺͷͰ;ͽͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͻͳͪͻ
ͼͶ;
ͱͰΕͳͼͰͼͷͰͶͳͷͺͻͰΌͰΔͰͷ
tͬͳͯͰΒͰiͽͪΒͬͰͪͪͭͶͪͬͳ̈́;Βͪ͊ͬͰͽͭ
;ͬͰͻͰ
;ͽͯͪΕͰͭͪͿͻͪ;ͼ͵ͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͳͼͳͽͳͼͬͰͯͯͪͪ͊ͽͻͪͭͼ;ͯͪ
̀ͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͳͼͯͳͽͰ͵;ͶͽͪͽͳͯͻͪͭͰͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͪͶͪͲͳͶͼͰ;̺ͳ
ͲͪͽͳΒͳ
;͵ΒΒͼ;Ϳͻͷ;ͶͳͼͪͪͳͺͽͪͪͰͶͪΔͳͬͰ;ͺͽͻͰͫͰ͊ͫͲͳͻͷ
1&4DISBNN
7FSTVDIFJOFS3FLPOTUSVLUJPOEFT)PSUFTVOEEFTTPOTUJHFOCFXFHMJDIFO)F
SSTDIFSCFTJU[FT
4POEFSESVDLBVT1&4DISBNNVOE'.ÛUIFSJDI
%FOLNBMFEFSEFVUTDIFO
,ÕOJHFVOE,BJTFS
.ÛODIFO
ͳQBTTJN DͪͬͰͯͰͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
'JMMJU[
PQDJU
m
m
5m0ͽͰͶ͵ͷͼͷͳͼͶ;Ͱͷͪ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͳͼͳͭ
ͳΒͪͳΔͳͬΒͿ;͵ͳΒͳ;ͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;W34UBBUT
5IFPMPHJFEFS3FJDITLSPOF
0UUPOJTDIFt3FOPWBUJPJNQFSJJiJN4QJFHFMFJOFS*OTJHOJF
4UVUUHBSU
1̾4DISBNN
)FSSTDIBGUT[FJDIFOVOE4UBBUTTZNCPMJL
WͺͭͶͪͬΓͰ%JFt)FJMJHF-BO[Fi
3FMJ
RVJFVOE)FSSTDIBGUT[FJDIFOEFT3FJDIFTVOEJISF3FQMJLJO,SBLBV&JOƮCFSCMJDLÛCFSEJF(FTDIJD
IUFEFS,ÕOJHTMBO[F
#E**
m̀ͪͬͪΓ;Β;ΕͳͼͷͳΓͰͰͭͬͪΒͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ͵ͽͳ;
ͳͽͰͽ;Ϳͻͪ;ͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼͽͬͪͼͯͻͱͪͬͷ̓ͪͻͶ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭ
͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͺΓͪͰͭͬͪΒͰͳ;
͍ͻͪ;ͼ͵Β
WJEFN
%FS,ÕOJHFWPO'SBOLSFJDI*
8FJNBS
/BDIESVDL%BSNTUBEU
)&ͪͅ;ͰS
%BT1POUJêLBMF WPO 5ZSVT VOE EJF ,SÕOVOHEFSMBUFJOJTDIFO,ÕOJHFWPO+FSVTB
MFN;VHMFJDIFJO#FJUSBH[VS'PSTDIVOHVCFS)FSSTDIBѫT[FJDIFO VOE 4UBBUTTZNCPMJL
%01
ͺͼͰͫmWͳ/,FOOBO,FEBS
4ZNCPMJD.FBOJOHJO$SVTBEFS"SDIJUFDUVSF
$"
m
́ͬͰͽͪͻͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;4BJOUF$IBQFMMFͯͼͳ13JBOU
%FQPVJMFTSFMJHJFVTFT
m
͆ͪͬͰͯͰͺͻͰͷͪ#FMUJOH
%JF3FBLUJPOEFS,VOTUEFT+BISIVOEFSU
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪͽͯͪΒͰͳͯͰΒͪJNJUBUJP$ISJTUJ;ͼͬͳͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶ
ͭͳΒͰ
ͽͳJOTJHOJBSFHBMJBͷͻͪΒ;ͫͳͽͳͰͺͼͻͰͯͪͯͻͪͲ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳ́ͺͪ͵
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰͻͰͳͼ;ͳͷͪͶͰΒͰͯͪ͵;;Ͷͭ;;́ͼͽͷͪͻͼͽͬ;ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
ͺͼͰͫͷͶͪͯͳͷͲͪͺͪͯͳͷͯͻͱͪͬͪͷ̺ͪ͌ͳͲͪͽͳΒͳ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽͯͪͬ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;ͳ͇͋ͻͪΒͽͳͭͰͻ
ͼͿͰͻͳͯͻͱͪͬͰͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵ͰͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͶͰͼ;ͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽ
ͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰmͅΒͼͳΒͰͬͽͪͺͳ͊Ͷͷͬͽͻ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͷͪͯͪ
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͪͻͼ͵ͳͷ
ͺͫͰͯͳ͵ͳͷͲͪͷͰΔͰͷͳͲͪͪͬͪ͵ͪtͬͪͼͳͶͳ͵ͼͼͽͪ
ͬͻͼi
ͳΒͰ
;ͼ;ͽͳͳ
ͳͷͪͽͪ͵ͪͬͼͽͪͽ;ͼ͋ͷͰΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͫͳͽͯͺͻͳͼͳ
Ͷͪ͵ͶͼͽͯͪΒͰͬͪͼͰΓͰͼ͵ͳͪͻͻͪͼͺͶͪͭͪͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͫͻΒͰͷͽͪ͵ͬͳͰͼͽͳͪ
ͳͯͪͳΒͰͺ͵ͶͪΔͪͯͻ;ͭͳͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͳͷͪ
Ͳͪ͵ΒͰΒͰͯͻͱͪͯͪͼ;ͷ;ͺͯͻͰΌͰͳ
͉ͰΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵
Ϳͳͳͷ
ͷͪͯͪͬͪͱͳͷͳΒͪͼͪͷͪ;ͼͬͪͽͪΔ;
;ͽͶͳ͵ͺͻͰ
ͽ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͺΒͪͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͼͳͭͳΒͰͳΒͰͬͻͼͽͯͻͰΌͰ̀ͪͽΒͰ
ͽͰ͵ͺͻͼ;ΌͳͬͪͽͳͽͷͰ;͵ΒΒͼ;ͷͰͻͳͱͳ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͫͳͶͰ;͵Γ;ͰͰ
;ͼͳͼͽͰͷͯͻͱͪͬͰͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵Ͱ͇ͼͬͰͲͪͻͪͲͷͳΓͪΔͰ;ͽͷͺͻͪͬ;ͳͺͪ͵ͺ
ͼͽΒͰ͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
͊ͻͫͳΒͪΒͰ;ͻͪͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͼͬ
ΒͰͯͻͱͪͬͼͽͳͫͶͳͱͪͼͶͳͳͷͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͽͬͻͰͬͳͪͷͪͰ̺ͭͳͲͪͽͳΒͳ͋
ͼͰͭͶͰͯͪ;ͪͭͶͪͪͬͪΔ;ͪͳͪͶͰ͵ͷͺͰͽͰ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͷ
ͼͺͼͽͬͰͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
͵ͪͳ;ͬͰͲͳͬͪΔ;ͲͪͺΒͰͯͳͰͳͼͳͭͳΒͰ͋ͪ͵ͬͳͬͶͪͯͪͻ
ͼ͵ͳͲͪͳͫͳͶͳͼ;͆ͰͷͪΔͳ͵ͺΓͰͳͺͰ͵ͽͻͪͶͼͪͰͼͽͳͷ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ
t͊ͬͰͽͳͬͰͪi
ͽΒͰͼͽ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͪ͵ͻ;ͪ͵ΒͷΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ;
ͬͰͪ
ͺͻͬͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ͵ͻͪΓ
ͫͳΒͰͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͺͼͬͰͷ;ͼ;ͯͰΕͳ
ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͳͳͽͻͪͼͺͰͻͼͪͶ
ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͲͪ͵̸͵ͼͰͺͻͳͽͷͰͳͷͪ;ͬͳͯ;ͼͪͱͪͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͪͼͬͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
͵ΒͪͺͼͶͰͯͬͪΔͰ͎ͻͳͼͽ;ͳͼͽͳͰ͵ͪͼͬ;
ͯ;ͱͼͽ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
ͷͱͰͼͰͺͷͳΓͪͽͳͪͽͯͪͼ;͎ͻͳͼͽͬͰͳͼͳͭͳΒͰͺͶ
ͱͰͰ;͵ͻ;ͳͯͫͰ;ͻ͵ͬ;͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͳͷͪͶͰͬͻͰͯͼͽͳͯͰͪͶͭͺͻͽͽͳͺͪ
͑ͽͪͬͳͰ
ͭͽͬͼͰͪͷͰΕͰͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͪ
ͪͱͪͶͼͽͰͺͻͬͰͻΓͳͬͪ
ͯͪͼ;ͼͰ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
͈ͻͪͬͰ͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ
ͪͺͼͰͫͪ;ͽͰͽͳͼͽ͈ͻͰͽͰͳͰͯͰͼͳͰ;ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͪ͵
ͽͰ͵ΒͰͯͻͰͯͳͽͳ̺ͰΕͺͷͰ;ͽͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͼ͈ͻͰͽͰͳͷͯͰͼͳͷͳͺͼͬͰͽͳͷͪͽ
ͺͳͼͷ̸Ͱ̓ͷͳͰ;ͬͪͼͰ;97**ͬͰ͵;;ͻ͵ͬͳ4BJOUF.BEFMFJOFÆ$IBUFBVEVO ͬͪͺ
͆ͪͼͬ;ͺ;ͽͺͳͼͳͳͲͬͻͪͳͲ9*7ͳ97ͬͰ͵ͪͳͲͶͪͲͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͯͪΒͰͽͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͼͽͪͶͪ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;ͳͯͪͼͰͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ;ͻ͵ͬͳ̹ͭͻͯͳͰ͈ͰͻͳͬͶͰͺͽͰ
DG&CFSTPMU
PQDJU
ͪͺ.BKFTDB
PQDJU
͈ͻͰͷͪΒͰͯΒͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ
ͫͳͶͪͫͳͽ͈ͻͰͽͰͳͪͯͰͼͳͪ
ͯͪͪͼ;ͷ;ͲͰΒ;͊ͪͻͪΒͪ
͵Β;ͼ;ͲͪͺͶͰͳͶͳ͋;ͻͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͼͬͪΒͪΔͪ͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͪ
ͭͯͳͰ͈ͻͰͷͪͯͻ;ͭΒͬͰͻͲͳΒͳ
ͽΒͰͻ;͵ͪͺͲͪͽͪ͵ͪtͻͯͼ͵ͪi
͵ΒͪͼͰͯͪͪͼ;ͬͪ;͏Ͱ
ͽͳΔͼ͵ͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͋ͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͵ͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͯͶͪΒͰ;ͺͻͬΒͺͶͬͳͳ97ͬͰ͵ͪ
;ͻ;͵ͰͷͪͶͽͰ͵ͳͬͳͽͰͲͬͪ͵Βͳͼ;ΒͰͯͰͶͳ͉ͪͯͼ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷ
;97*ͬͰ͵;
ͪͪͅͶͽ;
̾
#SBEGPSE
ѮF 4IJFME BOE UIF 4XPSE ѮF ,OJHIUT PG .BMUB
-POEPO
̓ͪͯͪKF
͆ͪͺͶͰ̹ͪͺͪͻͽͪͲͪ;ͲͰͽͼͽͻͬ
͵Ϳͳͼ͵ͬͪΒͰͽͻͰͲͻͻͰͯͪΒͬͪͬͪͪ
;͵Γ;;
Β;Εͳ ͳ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͰ m ͵Βͳ ͼ; Ͱͽ ͵ͪͼͳΒͰ ͺͻͺͪͶͳ ; ͫͻͯͶͷ; ͵ͯ ̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪͯͻͳΒͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͿͻͪ;ͼ͵ͭͺͯͪͪ̾ͭͳͺͪͽ̹;ͯ;Εͳ̹ͯͪͪͺͪͻͽ;ͼͪͷͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͼ;Ͳͪͳ
ͷͪͶͰ
Ͱͼ;ͼͽͪͶͰͼͪ;ͬͪͰ
W͆4DJDMVOB
ѮF 0SEFS PG4U+PIOPG+FSVTBMFNBOE1MBDFTPG
JOUFSFTUJO.BMUBBOE(P[P
.BMUB
mͪͅͶͽͰ͵ͳͬͳͽͰͲͬͳͺ͵ͶͳͶͳͼ;Ͳͪͽͳͷ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͻ;ͼ͵ͷͪͻ;͈ͪͬͶ;
ͺͳΒͰͷͪͶͭ;ͼ;ͲͪΔͳͪͳΔͰͳͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳ
͇ͯͽͪͯͪͼ;ͬͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰͳͳͶͰͯͰͻ;ͼ͵Ͱͪͻͼ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰ
ͼͬͰͯͻͰͬͶ;ͳΒͰ͋ͪͯͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͰͱͰΕͳͺͻͰͯͫΓͰͬͳͳͷͪ
ͪͻͳͪͷͪΒ͵ͪͪͅͻͳΒ͍ͪΒͯͻͬͪͺͻͰͯͪͶ͈ͪͻͰͽͰͳ;ͯͰ
ͼͳ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͷ͵ͻͪΓ;̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪͯͻ;̓ͪͻͪΌͻΌͰͬͳΕ;
͵ΒͳΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ;ͺͶͱͳ;ͯͬͻͼ͵;
͵ͪͺͰͶ;ͪ̽ͰͯͳΔ;͆ͪ͵ͰͼͽͪͺͻͳͶͼ͵ͭͪͺͪͯͪͻ;͵ͪΒͰ
ͼͯͻ;ͭͳͷ͵ͻ;ͼ͵ͳͷͯͻͪͭ
Ͱͼͽͳͷͪ
Ͱͬͪ͵;ͳͼͪͪͳͲ̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͪͳ;ͬͪͪΒͰ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͊ͬͰͽ̺ͭͪͼͳͶͳΒ͇ͪͼͽͻ͵ͭ
͈ͼͶͰͲͪͬͻͰͽ͵ͪ̽ͻ;ͭͭͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͭͻͪͽͪͪΒͰͲͪͺͶͰΔͰͪͳͯͰͺͬͪͪ;ͽͻͰͲͻ͆ͪͻͯͰ
ͫͪ͵Ͱ;͈ͯͭͻͳͳ͌ͬͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰͺͻͰͰͽͪΒͰ;ͰͽͳΔͼ͵ͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳͺͶͱͰͪ;͵ͳͬͽ
ͼͬͰͽ͈ͭͰͽͻͪ͏ͰͽͳΔͼ͵ͭ͊ͻͯͪ;ͲͪͬͪͶͼͽͲͪͺͯͪͽ͵ͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͳ͈ͻͰͽͰͳͰͯͰͼͳͰ
ͯ;ͭ;ΒͰͷͪͻ̽ͻͪͭͷͳͻ;̸ͬͳΕ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͰͯͳ͵;͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭͰͻͪͶͯͳ͵ͭͯͻ;ͽͬͪ
͈͈ͺͬͳΕ
͇ͼͻͺͼ͵ͷͪͽͺͳͼ;;͊ͳΒͰͳ
͈ͻͳͶͲͳ͍̓́͠97*m
m
ͼͶ
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͈ͼͶͰͯΔͳͺ;ͽͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ;ΒͰͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪͶͪͣͅͻͬͳΕ͡;ͫͳ͵ͬͳΕ
͈ͻͰͽͰͳͪͯͰͼͳͪ
ͳͯͻ;ͭ͵ͻ;ͳͼͪΔͰ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭ
͊ͽͪͻͳͪͻm
m
m ͼͺͽͺ;ͷ
ͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͵ͪͱͰ͵ͪ͵ΒͰͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪt͵ͪͯͻ;ͭͳ;̹ͭ;͈ͻͰͽͰͪͳ̓ͻͼͽͳͽͰΓi
7#FMUJOH
PQDJU
ͭͯͰͼ;ͪͬͰͯͰͳͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͼͪͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
͇ͬͰͳͲͬͻͰͪΒͺͽͺ;ͳΒͰΒͰͻͪͲͷͽͻͳ͊͊ͽͪΒͰͬͳΕ
͇ͯͰͼΒͻ;ͳ̓ͻͼͽͳͽͰΓͪͬͪͪ͠
͠;ͭͼͶͬͰͼ͵ͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͪͼͺͳͼ***m ͡;ͫΓͪͪm̀ͪͭͻͰͫm̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
͊͡ͽΒͪͬͳΕ
͊ͽͪͻͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͻͳͼͬ;Γͳ
ͪ͵ͽͳ
ͫͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ
ͶͰͽͺͳͼͳ
ͽͳͺͳͳ
ͺͷͰͳ
ͳ
Ͳͪͺͳͼͳͳͯͻ
͊ͺͷͰͳ͵̸͊̓***
͊ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̹ͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ͵ͻͪΓͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪ;͌ͶͳΒͪͻͼ͵ΒͺͬͰΓͳ
JO̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺ̽ͪͳ
Ͷ**ͳΔͰͭͬͯͫͪ
FE̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m ͼͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͷͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͬͰ
ͺͬͰΓͰ
*EͰN
JO͈ͰΕ͵ͪͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͪ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
ͯͪΔͪ
͵ΒͪͼͰͽͪ͵ΌͰͳͲͻͳ͵ͷͺͷͳΔ;;͌ͶͳΒͪͻͼ͵ΒͺͬͰΓͳ͆ͪΒͬͰΕͰͱͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͪͭͰͼͽͳ
ͳͭͶͰͯ ΒͰ
ͺͻͰͰͽͰ ͼ; ; ͈ͰΕ
ͷͱͯͪ ͬͰΕ ͪ͵ ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭ
ͺͻͯͻͪ;ͰͼͽΒͯͰͰͳΒͳͳͶͳͰͭͯͰ;ͺͼͶͰͯΔΒͰͽͬͻͽͳͳ9***ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ͼ;ͼͰͬͰͻͳͯͰͶͬͳͯͻͱͪͬͰͺͼͽͪͶͳͽͻͪΒͳΒͰ;ͭͻͱͰͳ͈ͻͰ;ͲͳͷͪΒ;Εͳ;Ͷͭ;
ͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͼ͵ͭͼͰͯͳͽͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͳ̽ͷ͊ͺͪͼͬͳΒͰͺͳͽͳͼͽͪͽ;ͼ̿ͳͰ
ͬͰΕͼͰͼΔͷͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵ͬͪ͌ͽͷͰͼ;ͲͪͪΒ;ͺͻͳͽͰͷͻͪͶͰͫͳͽͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳΔͰͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͰͳͲͼͽͪͻͳΒͰͪͅΒ͵Ͱͻ͵ͪͬͪ
͈ͲͳΒͪͼ;ͯͫͳͪͼͽͪͶͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͪͳͲͱͳ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰͭͽͬΒͰͺͽͺ;
ͰͺͲͪͽͪͅͱͰͼͰͼͪͷͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬͳͽͳ
ͫͰͲͼͶͪ;ͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
ͯͪͼ;;ͬͻͰ
ͷͰͳͷͪͽ;ͻͼ͵ͰͪΒͰͲͯͰ
ͼͺͻͰͰΔͰͷͯͻͱͪͬͭͼͰͯͳͽͪ
ͪͶͳͼͬͰͬͳͰͳͻ
͵ͬͰͭ
;ͼͰͬͰͻͰͫͶͪͼͽͳ
;Ͱ͵ͷͽͻͰ;ͽ͵;ͺͻͰͼͰΓͰͰͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͋ͳͷͰͫͳ
ͼͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͷͭͶͫΒͪͼͳͽͳͽͽΒͰ͈ͻͰͽͰͳͪͯͰͼͳͪͫͳͶͪ;ͺͼͰͯ;̹ͻͪ
͵ͬͳΕͪͺͻͰͰͭͽΒͰͯͼͺͰͶͪ;ͻ;͵ͰͷͻͰΒͼ͵ͭͯͰͼͺͽͪ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͺͪͺͰ͈ͳΒͪ**
͇ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͱͳ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͷͪΒͷͪΔͰͼͰͲͪ͐ͰͼͽͳͰ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ
ͳͼͽͳͪ
ͺͷͳΔ;ͼͰ;ͬͳͰͪͬͻͪͽͪ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;͵ͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͯͪͻͺΒͰͯͳͳͷͻ͵ͬͪͷͪ
ͪͶͳͼͰͪͼͬ;ͻͪͼͺͶͱͳͬͳͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͪͰͷͱͰͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͯͪͶͳΒͰͻͰͯͰ
ͶͬͪΔ;ͱͳ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͶͳ
ͽΒͰͷͭͬͰͻͬͪͽͳΒͰ
ͰͼͽͳͪͷͪͪͫͪͬΓͪ
ͳͷͪͯͻ;ͭͳͪͳ͇ͽͬͻͰͪͼͽͪΒͰͳͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͪͺͻͰ͵Ͷ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͊ͽΒͪͬͳΕ
MPDͼJU
͇ͺͻͰͼͰΓͰΔ;ͱͳ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͭͬͻͳͳͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͺͻͰͼ;ͽͰͶͪ͠ͰͬͼͽͪͽͳΒͪ*ͳͲ̿ͳͰ
;͈ͰΕ
ͫͻͳͭͷΔͰͭͬͭͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͪͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪͪ͠͵ͬͪ̓ͪͻͪͲͶͭͲͪͺͻͰͼͪͬ
ͯͳͼͰtͬͰͶͳ͵ͪͪͺͪͼͽͯͺͯͳͲͪΔͪͻͪͽͪͳͰͷͪͶͪ;Ͳͫ;ͪͪͽͼͬͰͽͷͰͼͽͲͬͪ̿ͳͪi
̽ͪͳͶ**
̿ͳͬͽͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪͳͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ ͺͻͳͻ̻ͪͅ͵̽ͪͳΒͰͶͳ͈̽Ͱͽͻ
ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
PQDJU
m
͇ͼͽͪͽ;ͼ;̿ͳͰͳ͈ͰΕͳ͵ͻͪΒͰͷ9*7ͳ;ͺͻͬΒͺͶͬͳͳ97ͬͰ͵ͪJCJE
m
͈ͼͰͫͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͰ
͵ΒͰͪͯͳͶͪͲͳ͵ͬͳͻͰͬͭͻͪͯͪ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;ΒͰͫͳͪΒͼͻͺ
ͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͯͪͺ͵ͶͪΔͪΒ;ͰͼͽͳͰ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͼͬΒͳͷͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͷͪͳͶͳͯͻ;ͭͳͷ;ͭͶͰͯ
ͳͷͻͪͷͬͳͷ͉ͪͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͰͼͯͰͶͳΕͳͷͪt͵ͻͼͭͯͻͬͰͽͪimͯ͵Βͳͼ;Ͱ͵ͳͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͶͳ
ͬͰͷͪͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͰͪͽͺͳͼͰmͯͪͻͬͪͶͳͼ;
ͻͰͳͷ
͵ͻͪΓͳͪ͠ͰͶͰͪͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͊ͺΕͪͳ
ͷͪ .POVNFOUB4FSCJDB
ͳ͵ͻͪΓͅͳͶ;ͽͳͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͰͽ͈ͭͰͽͻͪ;͉ͪͼ; JCJE
̸͵ΒͰ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽͳͪͽͺͳͼͳͷͪͳͲ97**m97***ͬͰ͵ͪͪ͵ͻͼͽͬͳͷͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳͷͪͳͲ̽Ͱͪͪ
Ͱͼͽͳ
Ͱ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͺͯͪͻͳͶͳͼ;ͽͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͵ͻͪΓ͊ͽͰͿͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͳͳͪͻ̽;ͪ
DGͅ
͑ͪ͵ͽͪ
̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͪͻͳͲͳͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
ͼͶͪͼͽͻm ͼͪͼͬͷͼͽͪͻͳΒͷ
ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;ͬͳͯ;͵ͻͼͽͪ
ͼͪͪͼͳͷͯͻͬͰͽͷͳͯͰͶͳΕͰͷ̹ͭͻͯͳͳͭ
ͺΒͪͼͪ
ͺ͵ͶͳΒͰͳ͵ͰͲ̈́ͪͲͪͻͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;̺ͪͽͺͰͯ;
DG(.JMMFU
͠1BSHPJSF
-1FUJU
3FDVFJMEFTJOTDSJQUJPOTDISÊUJFOOFTEV.POU"UIPT
1BSJT
͈ͻͰͷͪͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳͲͪ
ͫͰͶͰͱͰΒ͵ͻͪΒͰͷ97**ͬͰ͵ͪ
Ͱͼͽͳ;͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͺ͵ͶͳͶͪΒͰͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬͳ
ͯͰͼͺͽͳͪͪͅͻͪ
͵Εͳ͚;ͻΌ̹ͪͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͪ
DG͈ͪͅͽͳΕ
̽;ͫͻͬͪͳ͆ͳ͵Ͷ̹ͪ͵ͬͳΕ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
ΌͰͳͼ;ͳ;Β;ͱͷ͵ͻͪ͵;ͽͻͪͼͰͺͽ͉ͪͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΒ;ΕͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͻ;͵ͳΒͰͳΔͳ
ͬ;ͷͭ;Ε;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;
͐ͪͪͅ͵ͅͰͯͳΕͳͲͰͶͪΒͰͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵;
͵ΒͪͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;ΒͰ
ͺ;;ͺͪͱΔ;
ͯͪΒͰͼͬͰͪͳͪͷͰͽͪΒ͊ͺͪͼͬͰͻ͵ͬͰͼͶ;ͱͳͳͲͶͪͭͪΔ;ΔͰͳ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͈ͻͫͶͰͷ;ͬͪΔͪͳ
ͪͻͳͽ
ͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪͻͳΕͪ
ͼ͵ͭ́ͼͽ͵ͪͳΒͰ;ͯͼͪͯͪΔΒͪ;ͳͺͯͻͫͺͻ;Ͱ
ͪͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͬͰͷͪͼͶ
ͱͰ
ͲͪͽͰͬͪͫͳͺͼͰͫ;ͼͽ;ͯͳΒ;͆ͪͳͳͷͰͼͽΔͳͬͭͽͬͪΔͪͫͳͶͳͼ;
ͬͳͰͼͽͻ;͵;ͼͶͬΓͰͳͪΒͺͻͰͼͪͷͷͬͻͼͽͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͪͻͳͽͰ͵ͽͼ͵ͳͷ
;ͼͽͻΒͼͽͬͷͻͪͷͪ;͵ΒͰͷͼͰ;ͬͪͶͪ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͷͰͺͷͳͶͳͪ
ͻͳͽͳͷͺͽͻͰͫͪͷͪ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͳͷͯͻͰͯͫͪͷͪͽͳͺͳ͵ͪ͌ͽͰͷͰΓͰͳ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͷͺͳͽͪΔͳͷͪͷͭͶͳͫͳͼͰͳͲͬͰͼͽͳͽͰ͵ͪ͵ͽͼͰͺͪͱΓͳͬ
ͻͪͲͷͽͻͰͺͯͪͳ͵KFͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;ͳͲͬͻͳ
͵ͪͳͼͺͻͪͯͳͼͪ;ͬͪͪͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ
ͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽ͇ͬͪͬͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͫͶͰͷΕͰͷͼͪͷͺͼͽͪͬͳͽͳͪͷͪͶͷ
ͪͶͳͬͪͱͷ;Ͳͻ͵;mͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͳͶͳͽͳͷͪ͵Βͪͼ;;ͬͪͶͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͳͯͰͽͳͰͱͳ͵ͳͷ
͊ͽͪͬͻͽͰ͵ͰͼͪͰͼͽͳͪͷͪ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ;ͺͻͰͼͽͳͳͳͼ;ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͰ
ͻͰͽ͵ͼͽ
ͪͶͳͼ;ͭͶͪͬͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͫͳͶͰͺͯͰΓͰͰͳͲͷͰΌ;ͯͬͻͪͳͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳ
ΒͰ̀ͪͼͰͯͪͼ;;͊ͬͰͽΒ͊ͿͳΒͳ;ͻͪͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ; 7**ͬͰ͵
ͽͻͳͯͻͪͭͰͰ
ͰͼͽͳͰ;ͬͪͰ;ͯͻͬͰͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;
ͺͻͪΔͰͷ;ͻͷͪ͵ΒͳͼͰͪͶͪ
ͲͳͪͼͰͬͰͻΒͼͽͻͪͳͻ͵ͬͰ͆ͪͳ;ͬͪΔͪͽͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ;ͭͶͪͬΒͻͳͲͳͳ
͏ͪͻͼͽͬͪ
̹ͭͻͯͳͳ͍ͪͻͼ͵Β
ͳΒͰͯͬΓͺͲͪͽ̓ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳΒͰͯͪ
ͼͰͺͼͰͽͳͳͪͻͼ͵Ͱ͵ͪͺͰͶͰͯͻͰͯͪͲͪͯͬΓͪͬͪΒ;ͪͫͻͪΒͪΔͰͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
Ͱ
;ͺ;ͽͪΒ;ΕͳͼͰ;ͺͳͼͳͬͪΔͰͪͳͪΔͳͬͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͳΒͰ͊;ͯͰΕͳͺͼͬͰͯ
ͰΔͳͷͪͻ;ͼ͵ͳͯͪͼͳ͵ͪ
;9*7ͳ97ͬͰ͵;ͺͻͰͼͽͪͶͰͰͼͽͳͰ;ͬͪͰͼ;
;Ͷͽͪͻ;͊ͬͰͽͰ͊ͿͳΒͰ͈;ͲͯͪͼͰͲͪ
;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͯͪ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͇ͪͳ;ͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͪͳͽͬͪΔͪ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ;ͽ͵;ͫͻͰͯͪͪͬͰͺͻͪͲͳ͵ͰͻͪͼͺͻͪͬΓͪ
ͼͰ;ͻͪͯͬͳͷͪͪͬͰͯͰͳͷ;ͪͺͲͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰ͵ΒͰͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;Β;ͫͻͰͯ;ͲͯͳͲͪΔͪ
ͳͪͯͻͪͳΒͰ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪDG$I8BMUFS
"SUBOE3JUVBMPGUIF#Z[BOUJOF$IVSDI
-POEPO
m DͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͷͪͳͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
7%1BMMBT
-FDJCPSJVNIFYBHPOBMEF4BJOU%ÊNÊUSJPTEFѮFTTBMPOJRVF
̀ͭͻͪͿ
m ͭͯͰͼ;ͪͬͰͯͰͳͳ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͼͪͳͳͲͬͻͳ
.BKFTDB
PQDJU
m
*CJE
m
&CFSTPMU
PQDJU
$JHHBBS
.BKFTDB
PQDJU
&CFSTPMU
MPDͼJU
7ͪͺͺͻͰͷͪΒͰͯΒͷͳͳΒͪͽ;ͻͳ͇͵ͼͿͻͯͼ͵ͭͷͰͶͭͪ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻΒͰͺͷͰ;ͽͷ
ͺͻͪͲͳ͵;ͳͲͶͪͭͪͬͰͻͳͷͪͪͰ͵Βͬͻͼͽͳͽͻͪ
W8BMUFS
PQDJU
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷ͈ͪͬͪͪ͠ͻͰͽͰͰ
ͺͲͪͽΒͰͯͪͼͰ;͊ͽ;ͯͳ;ΔͰͭͬͪͭͶͪͬͪ;ͬͪ
Ͷͪ;ͻͪͽͻͳΒ;ͷ;Β;ͱͯͶͽͪͻͪ
ͭͯͰͼ;ΒͰͬͰͻͳͰͶͳͬͪͶͳͳͺͪͶͳͶͳͼͬͰΕͰ
͈ͻͰͽͰͳͪͯͰͼͳͪͪΒͬͳͰΒͰͺͻͳͬͶͪͳͶͪͺͪͱΔ;
ͳͳͼͰ
ͼͬΒͳͷͳͲͭͶͰͯͷ
ͺ;ͽͺͳͼͳͼͬͰͯͰͽͷͰͯͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͯͶͳͼͪ;ͬͪͪͳͺͻͰͬ;Ͱͪͼ͵;ͺͰ
ͷͲͶͪͽͷͺͶͪͽͷ
͌ͰͶͳͳͺͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͰͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ;ͬͪͶͰͼ;ͼͰ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
;Ͷͽͪͻͼ͵ͷͺͻͼͽͻ;ͭͶͪͬͰͻ͵ͬͰͳͶͳ
ΒͰΕͰ
;ͳͼͽͷ
ͯͰͶ;ͫͳͺͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͭͻͪΌͰͳ;ͽ;ͼͬͻ;͈Ͱ͵ͪͯͼ;ͼͰͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ;
ͺͼͰͫΒͯͪΒͳ
ͼ͵ͰͬͿͳͶͪ͵ͳ;
ͳΒͳͺͶͱͪΒ;ͻ͵ͬͳͳΒͰͫͳͼͽͻͭͯ
ͻͰΌͰ͊ͬͰͽͳΔͰͪΒͬͳͰͭͻͪͭͪͬͰͻͳͼ;ͷͭͶͳͯͪͬͳͯͰͳͰͶͳͬͪΒ;ͼͪͷ;
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪmͺͻͪͲͳͳͷͪ͌ͷͭͳͷͺͻͰͼͽͳ͵ͳͷͻ͵ͬͪͷͪ͵
ΒͰͼ;ͺͼͰͯͬͪͶͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͫͻΒͯͻͪͭͰͼͽͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͬͰΕͳͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰͼͽͪͶͳͲͶͱͰͪ
ͳͽ;ͼͬͳͷͯͰͶͬͳͷͪͻͪͷͪ͌ͳͷͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͳͷ
͵ͪ
ͽΒͰ͊ͬͰͽͪ͊ͿͳΒͪ
;ͲͺͷΕͰͫͻΒͰͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͽͬͪͻͰͪΒͰͼͫͰͪ
ͽͺͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͺͻͼͽͻͪ
ͳΒͰͼ;ͭͶͪͬͰͽͪ͵ͰͫͳͶͪͷͰͼͽͪͪ͵Βͳͷͪͼ;ͽͬͪͰ
ͺΒͰͯͳͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ͌ͽͳͼͪ͵͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;ͪͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͰͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽͳ͵ͪ͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͪͳͲͬͻͼͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;Β;ͻͰͳͰͭͶͰͼ͵ͭͪͳͷͪͼͺͰͽ͵ͪ
9**ͬͰ͵ͪtwUPUVNFOJNUFNQMVNTBODUBF4PQIJBFNJYUVNFTUDVNTBDSJTSFMJ
RVJTTBODUPSVNi̸͵KFͼ;ͯͳͽͳͺͼͬͰͯͰΔͳͷͪͯͪͼͳ͵ͪͳͲ9*7ͳ97
ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͽͪΒ;ͽͳͼͪ͵ΒͰͳͽͪͯͪͫͳͺͯΒͰͯͪ͵ͼͪͱͪ
ͷͪͯͪΒͰ͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;ͽͬͻͰͷͰ
ͬͰΕͳͲͭ;ͫͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͯͰͼͬΒͳͻͳͲͳͪ
ͅͰͼͽ ;ͬͪΔͪ ͳ ͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͪ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ ; ͱͳ͵Β ͊ͺͪͼͬΒ ͻ͵ͬͳ ͽͰ͵
ΒͰͼͪͼͳͭ;ͻΕ;ͯͻͰͯͳͽͳ͇ͯͪͬͳͲͰͽͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͪͺͻͰͷͪ͵ΒΒͼ;ͼͰ
ͰͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ;͵ͪͺͰͶͳͪͼͺͻͪͽ;͵;ͶͰͲͪͼͬͪͪΒͰͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͷͺͻͭͻͪͷ;ͽͰ
ͺͻͼͽͻͳΒͰ͊ͽΒͰΕͰͿͳͭ;ͻͰ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͪͳ͠ͰͶͰͰͳͪͯΔͳͷͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
͉ͪͼͺͰΕͪ
ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͰͪͳͼͽͷͲͳͯ;
ͯͳͼͽͪͼ;ͻͰͰΔͰ͵ΒͰΒͰͪͻͳͽͼͬΒ
ͼͽͬͰͳ͵ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͼͽͪͬͻͽͰ͵ͪ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͪΒͪ͵ͳͷ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
ͻͪͲͶͲͳͷͪͺͳͬͪͷͳΓͰΔͰ͐ͪͪͅ͵ͅͰͯͳΕͯͪΒͰ;̿ͳͳͼͬͰͪͳ͵ͪͷͰͳ
ͪͷͰͽͪΒͼͶ;ͱͳͲͪͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ͈ͪͻͰͯͽͭͪͽΒͰ;͵ͪͲͪͶͪͪͼͻͯͰ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͰ;ͻͪͷͬͳͷͪͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͪ
;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;;ͭͶͰͯͰͼͬͰͽͳ
ΔͰ;ͬͪͰͺͯͺͻͼ͵ͳͳͽͪͻͳͷͪ
ͯͼͫͪͶͯͪͳͳͷͪ
͐ͪͪͅ͵ͅͰͯͳΕΒͰ
ͺͯͬ;͵ͶͪΒΒͰͯ;
ͲͪͬͺͳͽͪΔͰͬͰͷͪͬͪͱ;ͳΔͰͳ;
ͪͽͼ;;ͲͻͳͲͪ
ͺΒͰͯͳͪͻͰͰΔͪ͊ͺͪͼͬͰͻ͵ͬͰ͌ͲͼͽͪͶͰmͼͬͰͽͭͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͪͳ
ΒͰͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵Ͱm͵ͪͬͪͱͪͫͻͪͲͪͺͼͶ;ͱͳͶͪΒͰͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ͊ͬͰͽͪ͊ͿͳΒͪ
͵ΒͪΒͰ;̿ͳͳͪͯͪ;ͶͪͫͶͳ͵ͼͺΓͰͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͰͼͪͲͬͳ͵ͷ
ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ
ͻͭͪͳͲͪͳΒͰͺͻͼͽͻͪ
͵ͪͳͻͰͰΔͪͻ͵ͬͰͭͪͷͰͽͪΒͪ͐ͳͳͼͰ
;ͽ
Ͷͳ͵ͺͻͰ
ͯͪΒͰͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪ͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͪͷͻͪͶͪͳͷͪͽͳͬͻͰͯͼͽͺͻͽͽͳͺͪͳ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪ
ͼͫͲͳͻͷͪΔͳͬ;ͼͬͰͯͰ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;̽ͷ
͊ͺͪͼͬ
ͺͺ;ͽͺͻͰͼͽͳ͵ͰͪͅΒ͵Ͱͻ͵ͪͬͪ
ͫͳΒͰͭͶͪͬͳͼͪͫͻͳͻͪͷ
ͺͻͰͯ
ͬͳΌͰͲͪ͵ͻ;ͳͼͪΔͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪͳͳͻͽͳͼͪΔͰͻ͵ͬͰͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪ
͈ͻͳͷͰͻͳ͵ΒͰͼͷͪͬͰͶͳͺͽͬͻͯͳͶͳͫͳͯͪͼ;tͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳiͺͻͭͻͪͷͳ;
ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͺͯͻͪͱͪͬͪͳͺͳͯͰΒͳͳͿ;͵ͳΒͳmͬͳͰͰͭͺ
ͿͻͷͪͶͳͷͼͬΒͼͽͬͳͷͪ
́ͺͪ͵
ͰͽͻͰͫͪͳͼ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͳͷͭ;Εͼͽͯͪͼ;ͳͿͻͷͪͶͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰͻͰͷͰͻͷͰͻͷͪͷͰͽͪΒ;͊ͺͪͼͬͰͻ͵ͬͰ
ͼͳͶͪ;ͼͰͫͳͯΒͰ͵ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ
ͼ͵ͳͻͰͰΔͪ̓ͪͽͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͊ͽͻͪͼͽͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳ;ͯͻͪͭͰͷ͵ͻͼͽ;
;ͬͪͰͺͯͫͪͶͯͪͳͷͳͼͺͻͰͯͼ͵ͰͬͿͳͶͪ͵ͳͪ͊ͬͰͽͰ͊ͿͳΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ͼ;ͳͺͯ
ͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͳͷ ͺͻͼ͵ͳͳͽͪͻͳͷͪ ;Ͳ Ͷͽͪͻͼ͵; ͺͻͰͭͻͪͯ; ̿ͳͰ
ͼͽͪͶ ͳͶͳ
ͺͻͪͲͳͳͷͪ
ͷͭͶͰͫͳͽͳͳͲͶͱͰͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͽͪͬͳͰͳͰͪΒͬͻͰͯͳ
ΒͰ
ͺͺ;ͽ͊ͽͻͪͼͽͳ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳ͌Ͱͯͼͽͪͽ͵;ͯͻ;ͭͳͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͪͬͪ
ͳͲͬͰͼͰ
ͺͯͼͽͳͪΒͰͲͪͻͪͲͷͳΓͪΔͰ;ͽͷͺͻͪͬ;͵ͪͯͪͺͻ;ͱͪͯͰ͵ͻͪͳΒͪͱͳ͵ͳ
ͺͰͬͳͪ
͵ΒͰͼ;ͼͬΒͷͳͼͽͷͼͽͻͪͷͭͽͬ;ͻͪͬͳͼͶͽͪͻͼ͵ͷͺͻͰ
ͭͻͪͯͷ͢ͳͬͺͻͭͻͪͷ
ͳΒ;͵ͼͳ;ͳͰͺͻͳͲͻͳ͊ͽͻͪͯͪΔͪm͉ͪͼͺͰΕͰͳ
͊͵ͳͯͪΔͰͼ͵ͻͼͽͪmͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳ;ͯΔ;ͱͳͬͺͳͼͪ;Ͳ;
ͪͶͳͳͪͻͳͽͪͻͰ
ͰΔͪ
͵ͪͽͼ;̹ͭͻͯͳͪ͊ͽͻͪͼͪͳͪͻͪΌͰͼͻ;ΌͳͷͪͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪͪͺ
ͬͻͳͪͷͪͺͳͶͪͼͽͻͪ;ͲΒ;ͱ;ͺͰͬͳ;
ͬͰΕͯͪͬͼ;ͪͬͰͶͳ͈ͅͳΒͬͳΕͪͯͪ
ͳͯͬͰͯͰ;ͬͰͲ;ͼͪͱͳ͵ͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷ͇ͪͬͷͳΓͰΔͰ
ͳͲͰͽͫͰͲͳͻͰͭ
ͫͻͪͲͶͪͭͪΔͪ
ͷͭͶͫͳͼͰ;ͽ͵;ͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͺͽ͵ͻͰͺͳͽͳͳͯͻ;ͭͳͷ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͻͪͲͶͲͳͷͪ͢Ͱͷ;;ͺͻͳͶͭͭͬͻͳͶͪͫͳͰͼͪͷͼͪͯͪΔͪͼͪͲͪΔͪͺͼͽΒͪΔ;
ͼͬͰͪͭͪͷͰͽͪΒͪ;͊ͺͪͼͬΒͻ͵ͬͳͬͰΕͳͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͳͬͳΒͳͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͪ
͵
Βͪͼ;ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͪͯͪΒͰͪͻͳͽͽͳͺͺͫͱͼͽͳ
ͬͰͲͪͲͪ͵ͽͰͷͺͶͪͳΒ;ͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͪ
͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳ
ͪ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳͪͲͪ9**ͳͺͰͽB͵9***ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͳͷͪͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ;ͽͳͪΒ
ͪtͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͰiͳͼͶͳ͵ͪͰͺͻͭͻͪͷͰͽͭͯͫͪ
ͯͬͯͰΕͳͰͼͽͳͯΔͳͬͭ
ͺͻͱͳͷͪΔͪ̽ͪΒͰ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͽͪͬͻͼͽͪͺͫͱͼͽͳͳͷͪͶͪͼͪͱͭ
ͯΒͰ͵ͪ
ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͳͼ;ͺͪ͵ͳͼͯͳͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔ̹ͪ͋ͯͳΕ͉ͪͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΒ;ΕͳͼͶͳ͵ͪͰ
ͺͻͭͻͪͷͰ̿ͳͰͳͅͳͶͰͰͬͰ
ͪͼͽͪͶͰͺͯͺͻͰͼ;ͯͳͷ;ͽͳͪΒͰͷͺͻͬͭͼͻͺͼ͵ͭ
ͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ
ΒͰͺͯͬ;͵ͪͲͪͪΒ͵ΒͳΒͰͽ;ͯͪͽͺͻͳͲͻͳͷͪ͊ͽͻͪͼͽͳͳͼͺͻͪ
ͬͷͳͯͬͰ;ͬͰͲ;ͼͰ͵ͳͷͯͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͳͪͭͶͪͼͪ͵ͪ͊ͪͬͳͰͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͳͼͶͳ͋ͪ͵ͬͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ
͊ͪͬͳͪ;ͺͪͯΓͳͬͪͲͪ͵;ͺΓͰͼͽ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͳͷͼͽͻͪ
ͯͪΔͰͷͪ͵ͻͼͽ;
͵ΒͰΒͰͼͬͪͽͪͰͼͪͷ͵ͪͱͻͽͬ;ͳͲͪͶͭ;ͼͺͪͼͰΔͪͬͰΕͳ
͵ͪͺͯͼͽͳͪΒͲͪͳͲͬͻͰΔͰͼͺͼͽͬͰͰͪͺͼͽͶͼ͵ͰͷͳͼͳΒͰ
̓ͪ͵ͫͳͶ
ͰͽͻͰͫͪͳͲͭ;ͫͳͽͳͳͲͬͳͯͪͯͪΒͰ͊ͺͪͼͬͪͻ͵ͬͪ
ͼͳͷͪΒͬͻͰͯ
ͳΒͳͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ
ͺͼͰͯͬͪͶͪͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͫͻΒͯͻ;ͭͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͳͲͷͰ
Ό;ͼͽͪͶͭͳͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
Ͱͷ;ΒͪͼͼͬͰͯͳ̿ͳ͵ͪͺͬͰΓͪ͆Ͱ͵Ͱͯ
Δͳͼͳͭ;ͻͼ;ͫͳͶͰͼͽͪͶͯͼͽ;ͺͰͽͬͪΔ;ͬͰͻͳ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͼͰmͺͻͪΔͰ
Ͱ;ͼͬKͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͰ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽͫͳͶͳ;ͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͳͷͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͳ
Ͷͳͽͳͷ͉ͪͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳͼͷͽͳͷͪ
ͳΒͳͷͫͶͳͳͷͪͯͪͪͼͳͽͪͰͲͪͷ
ͷͭͶͳͼ;ͼͽͪΒͪͽͳͪͰ͵ͷͯͺͪͼͳͷͰͼͽͪ
ͻͰͳͷͪͶͽͪͻͼ͵ΒͺͻͰͭͻͪͯͳ
͵ͪ ; ͭͶͪͬͷ ͳͼͽͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷ ̸ͺͼͽͶͳ; ͇ͳ ͼ; ͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͷͭͶͳͪͶͪͲͳͽͳͳͪͯͻ;ͭͳͷͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ;ͻ͵ͬͳm;ͫͳͷ͵ͪͺͰͶͪͷͪ
ͺͪͳ;
ͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͳmͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪΒͰͽͪ͵ͬͪͺͻͪ͵ͼͪͬͳͰͼͽͻ;͵ͺͼͬͰͯͰͪ;͊ͬͰͽΒ͊
ͿͳΒͳ̓ͪͳͼͬ;ͯͪ;ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;
͵ͻͪΒΔͳͳΓͺͼͰͯͬͪΔͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͫͳͶΒͰΔͳͬͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͰͬͰͻͳͷͪͽͰ͵͵ͪͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͺͺ;ͶͪͻͰSFMJHJPDBSOBMJT
͵ΒͪͺͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͬͳΌͰΔͰͳͯͯͳͻ
Ͱͼ;ͳͼͺ;ΔͪͬͪͶͰͼͬΒ;ͺͻͪͬ;
ͪͪͭ͵;
ͼͬͻ;mͫͶͳ͵ͬͪΔͰͺͫͱͼͽͳ;SFMJHJPTQJSJUVBMJT
͆ͬͪͳͫ;ͬͪͽͳΒͪͼͪͲͪΔͪͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷͰͽͪͺͪͷͪ̿ͳͰͳΔͳͬΒ
ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬΒͻͶͭͳΒͳͷͭ;ΕͳͶͪͼ;ͯͪͼͰͬͻͰͷͰͼ͵ͳͺͻͰͳͲͳΒͰͯͻͰͯͳͳ
ͼͽͬͪͻͰΔͰΔͰͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ̺ͪͰΕͳ;ͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ͵ΒͰͼͰ
ͺͷͳΔ;;̿ͳ͵ΒͺͬͰΓͳ͊ͪͬͪΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͯͰͼͪͺ;ͽͬͪΔͪ;͆ͳ͵ͰΒ;͢Ͱͭ
]]
4"$3"&3&-*26*"&̸͈͇̺͊͊̾͏͉̺̓̾͌̿́͐́
ͬͳͫͳͭͻͪͿͳ͵ͪͱ;ͯͪΒͰͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͯͬͰ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͷͻͪͷͻͳ͵Ͱͳͱͳͬ
ͺͳͼͰ͵Βͳͼ;;ͻ͵ͬͳ
ͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ;ͫͶͳͰΒͯͭͯͳͰ
ͳͲͬͰͶͳͲͪͬͻ
ͰͻͪͯͬͰ;ͰͽͰͻͳΒͰͻ;͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
;Ͳͽ
ͳͲͻͳͳͽͬͰͶͳͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ
͵ͪͯͪ
ΒͰͼͽͳͭͪ;̿ͳ;
ͻ͵ͬ;;͵ͻͪͼͳͳ;ͽͬͻͯͳͷͽͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͳ͌ͽΒͯͻ;ͭΒ
Ͱͽͪͺͳ
ͺͼͶͰͭͯͳͰ
ͳͲͬͻͰͰͼ;ͳͲͷͰͰ;ͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ΒͲͪͷͳͼͶͳmͺͻ
ͳͻͰΔͰͷͶͽͪͻͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͽͻͪͺͪͼͽͿͻͳΒͪͷͪ
;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͪͼͶͱͰͳΒͳͷͺͽͻͰ
ͫͪͷͪͬͼͬͪͰ͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ͋ͪͯͪΒͰ͊ͺͪͼͬͪͻ͵ͬͪͯͫͳͶͪͳͼͬͰͪͳ͵ͪͷͰ
ͳͪͷͰͽͪΒ
ͪͷͰΔͰ
ͳͲͷͰΌ;ͼͽͪͶͭ
ͳͲͶͪͭͪΔ;ͼͬͰͽͳΔ͎ͪͻͪͷ
ͫͰͲͼͺΓͰ
ͺͻͳͺͻͪͽͰ
ͫͳΒͰ;ͰͶͳͳͲͪͬͻͰͯ͊ͺͪͼ̺ͬͯͪͪͰͷͪΒͰͬͰͻͬͪͽ
ͯͪͼ;;ͺͻͪͬͪͽͪΒͺͻͪͲͳ͵
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͪͯͻͱͪͼͬΒ;ͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵;ͫͰͼͰͯ;
ͻͰ
Ͷͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽͫͳͶͰͼͬͰͪͳͲͶͱͰͰ͈ͼͽΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳͪͭͬͰͽͪΒͳ
ͯͪΒͰͱͳ͵ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͵ͪͯͰ;͵;ͺͰͲͪͷͳͼͶͳ̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͳΒͰ
͊ͪ
ͬͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͺͻͰͯͬͳͯͰͳͺͻͰͭͯͳͰ
Β;ͻͪΒͰͽͪͺͳͻͪͯͬͪͪͻ͵ͬͳ
͇ͽͷͰͫͳͷͭͶͯͪͺͼͬͰͯͳͺͻͬͺͻͰͳͪͪͬͪΔͰ͵ͰͺͳΒͰͶͽͪͻͼ͵ͭͺͻ
ͼͽͻͪͳͯͰͶͪͺͻͰͯͶͽͪͻͼ͵ͷͺͻͰͭͻͪͯͷ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰͺͻͷͰͷͫͶͳ͵ͪͼͪͪ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͲͪͺͰͽͺͯͳͲͪΔͰͪͯͲͰͷͭͯͰͶͪͻͪͷͪ͋ͪͳͲͷͰͪ
͵Β;ͫͳͽͻͰͫͪͶ
ͯͬͰͼͽͳ;ͬͰͲ;ͼͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͰͳͷͻ͵ͬͰͳͷͪͷͰͽͪΒͰͷ
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͪͫͳͪͽͯͪ
ΒͰͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͪͲͪͷͳͼͪ̿ͳͰ
;͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪͯͺͰͽ͵ͪͯ
ͻͰΌͰͪ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͺͼͽͰͺͰͼͽͬͪͻͳͬͪͪ͋ͪ͵ͬΒͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬͳͳͶͪͫͳ;
ͺͻͳͶͭ ͳ ͯͻ;ͭͪ
; ͬͳΒͰ ͬͻͰͷͰ ͳͲͰͽͪͻͪͲͷͳΓͪΔͪͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͷͳΓͰΔͰ
̻̹ͪͫͳΕͽͷͰͯͪΒͰͳͺͻͰͯͫͳΒͪΔͪͪ;ͽ͵ͰͿͪͶͼͽͳͱͳ͵ͪ͊ͺͪͼͬͪ
ͻ͵ͬͪͼͬΒͷͺͼͬͰͽͷ;Ͳͯͳͭ;ͽͪͪͪΒͬͳͰͷͰͼͽ;ͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͻ͵͈ͪͬͪͅͰͽͻͬͳΕ
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͳͼͽͪ͵ͪΒͰ;ͬͳͰͪͬͻͪͽͪͯͪΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͲͪͯͪͽͳͳΓ
ͳͪͲͪ͵ͻͪ͵ͳͼͺͻͰͯͼͬͭͬͻͰͷͰͪͳͯͪΒͰΒ
͵ͪͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͳͪͻͳͷͪͯͻͳͽͫͪͬͳͫͳͽͰͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͰͲͪ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰͼͪͷ
ͼͽͪͶͰͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰ
ͯͼ̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͳΒͰ;̿ͳͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̿ͳ͵ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
Ͳͪͼͬͪͪͼ;ͬͰͻͰͷͺͲͪͬͪΔ;Δͳͬͭ
ͽͰͶ͵ͭͼͷͳͼͶͪ
͵ͪͳͻͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͳͷͭ;Εͼͽͳ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͲͪ͵ͻ;ͱͳ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ;̽ͷ͊ͺͪͼͬͺͻͰͰͷͽͳͼͬͭͫͻͪͽͪ
ͺͻͬͬͰͪͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͪ;
ͳͬͳͰͺ;ͽͪͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪͺͳͽͪΔͰͽͷͰͯͪͶͳΒͰ̿ͳͪͫͳͶͪͲͪͷͳΓͰͪ͵ͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪͬͪͭͻͫͪͻ͵ͬͪͯͪͪͼͽͻͰͫͪͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͽͳ;Ͱͽͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰͷͼͬͰͽͶ;
̽ͳͼͽͪͺͼͽΒͰͪͭͬͰͽͪΒͳͯͪΒͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͲͪͼͳͬͪΔͪͻͪͷͪ;ͲΒ;ͱͳͲͳͯͲͪ
ͺͪͯͭͽͻͪͬͰΒͪͫͳͶͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͰͷͰͼͽͲͪ͵ͻͪΓͰͬ;ͭͻͫͳ;͋ͫͳͼͰͷͭͶ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͪͼͬ;ͺͶͱͪΒͪͬͻͪͽͪ;ͽͷͽͻͪͬͰΒ;
͵Βͪͼ;ͺͻͳͷͪ͵;ͽͪͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷ;ͲͳͼͽͳͲͳͯͺͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼͪ͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͰͪΒ;ͱͷͲͳͯ;ͫͰͲͫͰͯͳͶͯͬΓ
ͷͰͼͽͪͲͪͼͪͻ͵Ϳ͇ͪͭͯͽͰͳͯͰΒͰͼͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
;ͫͻͲͯ;ͼͽͪͶ
Ͱͷ;ͼͬͰͯͳͳ
ͽͽͺͯͲͰͷͪͭͻͫͳͪͳ͵ͪͯͳΒͰͫͳͶͪͳͲͬͰͯͰͪ̽ͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͯͪΒͰ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ͊ͪͬͪͼͪͻͪͳ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ
ͺͻͰ͵ͺ;ͽͪ
͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪΒͰ
ͪͼͬ;ͪͳͼͪͯͪΔͳͼͪͲͪΔͪ
Ͷͪ͵
ͰͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͽͳͻͪͲͶͭͰͲͪ͊ͪͬͳ;ͺͻͷͰ;ͯͶ;͵Ͱ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳͳΒͰ
ͼͪͻͪΔͰ;̿ͳͳΒͰͻΒͰͫͳͶͬͪͱͯͪ;Δ;ͫ;ͯͰͼͬͰͪͯͰͽ͵ͪͫΒͪͬΓͰͳ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ
ͪ͵ͺͻͺͳͼͼͺͻͬͰͯͰͳFMFWBUJPͳUSBOTMBUJPͷͽͳΒ;͋ͰͶ
ͼͬͰͽͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͺͶͱͰ;ͪͅΒ͵;ͻ͵ͪͬͪͳ͵ͻ;ͳͯͫͰͳͻͪͷ
ͫͳͶΒͰ
͵ͪͳ
; ͯͻ;ͭͳͷ ͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭ ͼͬͰͽͪ
ͺͽͬͻͯͪ ͫ;ͯ;Εͳͷ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͳͷͪ ̹ͭͷ
ͯͪͻͬͪͭͼ;ͬͰͻͰͳͽͰͽͪͳͲͪͶͭͪͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͼͽͳ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;ͯͰͽͰ;͊ͺͪ
ͼͬ;ͻ͵ͬ;
ͷͽͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭͺͼͽͪͶͰͼ;ΒͰͯͪͯͱͳ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ
͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͳͽͪͳͪͶͪ
ͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͰͪͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͳͷͺͽͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷ
̹ͳΒͰͽΒͰͯͪͯ͊ͪͬͳͳͺͽͰͲͪͪΒͬͰΕͰͭͷͭ;ΕͰͭͯͷͰͽͪ͢ͳͷͰͼ;͊ͻͫͳ
ͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳ;͵ͻͯͳͪͽͰͼͬͰͽͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰͳͯͻͰΌͰͳ͵ͪtͼͪͬͻͰi
ͯͼ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͪͻͯ
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0
̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
53"/4-"5*0͈͉͇͇́̈́́̾͆͊͑͋́͌͠ͅͼͪͼͽͪͬͳΒͰͯͰͳͻͰͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ
ͫͻͰͯͪ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ͋ΒͰͰͽͪͺͪ͵ΒͪͼͶͰͯͳͺͼͽ;ͺ͵;
FMFWBUJP
ͺͯͳͲͪΔͪͽͰͶͪ
ͪͺͻͰͽͯͳͲͪͬͻͷͳ;ΔͰͭͬͭEFQPTJUJP"EWFO
UVT
;ͬͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͺͼͰͫͪͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ̽ͼͶͬ
ͲͪͪͬͪͯͶͪͲͪ͵
ͺͻͳͼͺͰΕͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͪͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͰͯͻͰͯͳͽͰ͊;ͽͳ
ͼ͵ͳ
ͽΒͰͪΒͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵;ͳͼͽͻͳΒͳͻ͵ͬͰͳͯͻ;ͽͬͪ͵ͪͯͪͼͰͳͻΒͲͪΒͰͯͳͳ
Βͪͬ ͳ ͼͬͰͪ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ ͬͳ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ m ͪ ͪ ͭͪ
ͺ;ͽͰͷ ͺͻͺͳͼͪͳ
ͫͻͰͯͪͳͻͪͯΔͳ
ͺͻͳͬͪͽͪ͵ͪͭͼͺͯͪͻͪͳͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪ
͉ͳͽ;ͪͶͰͻͰͷͳΒͪͶͰͺͻͷͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͯͽͪͳͪͻͪͲͻͪΌͰ;ͼͻͰͯ
ΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
ͳͷͪΒͰͯ;ͫ͵Ͱ͵ͻͰͰ;ͪͽͳ͵ΒͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ͎ͰͶͰͳͼͽͳ͵ͳͳͻͳͷ
ͼ͵ͳBEWFOUVTSFHJTͲͪͪͬͪΒͰͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳ;ͶͪͲͪ͵ͪͻͪ;ͭͻͪͯ
ͺͻͪΕͰͯͭ
ͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͷͺͷͺͷ͆ͰͭͯͰͯ**ͬͰ͵ͪͺͻͰͪͰͰͻͰͽͪ͵ͬͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͰͺͳͿͪͳΒͰ
ͺͼͽͪͶͰͼ;ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͳ;ΒͰͯͰͲͪͬͳͼͳͰͶͰͷͰͽͰͻͰͷͳΒͰͪͻͼ͵ͭͽͻͳΒ;ͷ
Ϳͪ͊ͬͻͰͷͰͷͼ;Ͱ͵ͯͳͿͳ͵ͬͪͰͺͼͰͫͳͷͺͻͺͳͼͳͷͪͳͯͫͳͶͰͼ;ͼͶ
ͱͰ;ͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵;
ͺͪΒͰ;ͽ͵;ͼͬͰͪͼͽͳͪͻͼͶͪͬΓͰ͵ͪEFVTQSBFTFOT
ͯͫͻ
ͳͳͽͰΓͳͼͺͪͼͳͶͪͼͬͰͽͪ͋ͪͽͻͪͼͰͯͰͽͪͯͳͷͰͲͳΒͪͪͻͼ͵ͭͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪ
ͪͭͶͪͰͪͬͰΕ;͇͵ͽͪͬͳΒͪͬͷ"EWFOUVT;"VHVTUJͺͽͺ;ΒͰͺͻͰͬͶͪͯͪͶͪ
;ͼͬͰͪͼͽͳ"EWFOUVT%JWJͳͲͬͻͰͷͰͪ,ͼͽͪͽͳ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭ͆ͪ͵ͺͫͰͯͰ
ͻͳΕͪͼͽͬͪͽ͵ͬͳͻͪͲͬΒͪͯͬͰͶͳͼ;ͯͫͳͽͰͺͻͷͰͰͽͰͱͳͽͪ͆ͪͼͶͰ
ΌͰͳͫͻͪͼͳͼͰͻͳͼͽͳΒͪͳͲ;Β;ͳͯͫͳΒͪΒ;ͬͪͯͻͰΌͰΔͪ
ͽͪ͵ͯͪͼͰΕͳ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͰͺͰͺͼͽͪΒͰ"EWFOUVT%PNJOJ́ͯͰΒͪͯͶͪͼ͵;ͅͰͼͳΒͰͼͪͺͽͪͬͪͪ
ΒͰ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͷͳͼͶͳ͵ͷ
ͪͯͬͪͼͬͪͪͳͪͺͻͬ
͵ͻͲͽͪ͵Ͳͬͪ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼ͵;ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬ;͎ͻͳͼͽͬͭ;Ͷͪͼ͵ͪ;͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰ́ͼ;ͼͯͰ͵ͪ͵ͪ͵ͻͪΓ
ͳͼͺͪͼͳͽͰΓͼͬͰͽͪ
ͪ;ͫͶͳͰ;;ͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳͪͽͳ͵ͭͪͯͬͰͽͪ
ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ
͵ͪ
ͰͼͪͽͶ͵ͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺͪͻ;ͼͳΒ͎ͪͻͳͼͽͬͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ̽ͻ;ͭͭͯͶͪͼ͵ͪ
͌ͯͫͪͽͪͪΒΒͰͯͪͬͪͱͪͽͰͶ͵ͳͪ;͵ͰͺͼͻͰͯΒͰ;ͫͶͳͰͺͻͰͷͪ
ͫͻͪͼ;ͪͽͳ͵ͭ"EWFOUVTͪSFHJTͪ͋ΒͰBEWFOUVTBOJNBF
;ͼͺͳΔͪΔͰͯ;Ͱ
ͺͻͪͬͰͯͳ͵ͪͳΔͰͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͺͻͰͯ͵ͪͺͳΒ;̺ͳΔͰͭ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͪ
ͭͯͰ
ΒͰͼͬͰͪͯͰ͵;Β;ͯͪͫͻͪͰͶͳͼͽͳͰͫͰͼ͵ͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
͌ ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷ ͬͰ͵; ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳBEWFOUVT ͳ͵ͪ͵ ͳΒͰ ͳͲͭ;ͫͳ ͪ ͬͪͱͼͽͳ
͈ͻͰͳͪͰΒͰͼͪͷΔͰͭͬ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻmͽͪͳΒͰ
ΒͰͻͳͼͽͳΒͪͳͲͬͪmͽ
ΒͰͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͼͫͰͭ
ͻͰͬͰͻͲͳͫͳͶͭͺͻͰͼͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͰ;ͲͳͷͪΔͪͷͯͰͶͪ
͆ͪͳͷͰ
͎ͻͳͼͽͬ;ͶͪͲͪ͵;͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ
͵ΒͳΒͰͰ͵ͪͯͪͪͼͽͪͺͼͽ;ͺ͵ͷJNJUBUJP
JNQFSBUPSJT
ͼͪͯͪͼͪͷͺͼͽͪΒͰͫͻͪͲͪͪͻͼ͵ͭͪͯͬͰͽͪ
ͻ;͵ͬΌͰͲͪͽͰͬͷ
Ͳͪ*NJUBUJP$ISJTUJ͎ͻͳͼͽͳΒͪͳͲͪͳΒͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͰͭͶͰͯͪͶͪͼͰͰͼͪͷ;ͲͪͷͰ
ΔͳͷͪͰͳͷͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷm͵ͪ͵ͬͳͼ;͵ͻͼͽͬͳͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳ
ΒͰmͬͰΕͳ;ͳͲͫͻ;ͪ͵ͶͪͷͪͳΒͪͳͺͰͼͪͷͪ
͵ΒͰ;͵ͪͲ;Β;ͪͽͯͪΒͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͪͯͬͰͽͺͺͻͳͷͳͫͶͳ͵Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͭͫͻͰͯͪ͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͰ
ͰͺͳͿͪͳΒͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͺͼͽͪΒ;ͺͽͰͷͰͼͽͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
ͪͶͳͳͰ
ͻͰͷͳΒͪͶͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͼ;ͬͰͻͰ͈ͪΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͼͬͰͪͳͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͪͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͭ
ͬͪͼͳͶͰͬͼͪmͪͻͳͽ;ͶͪͲͪ͵;ͺͻͰͼͽͳ;ͳΔͰͰͬͪͱͰͻͪͷͬͰmͲͪͫͰͶͰ
ͱͳͶΒͰͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳͻͳͪͻͪ͊ͶͳͳͫͳͪΒͳͰͭͬͪͳͼ;ͳ;
ͲͪͺͪͯͷͼͬͰͽ;
;͵ΒͰͷΒͰͯ9ͬͰ͵ͪͺͻͰͯ;ͻͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭBEWFOUVTͪͫͳͶͪ
ͺͻͺͳͼͪͪͺͼͰͫͳͷ0SEJOFTBESFHFNTVTDJQJFOEVN
́ͲͬͰͷͪͫͳͷͰͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰͳͲͯͬͪΒͪͷͼͪͷͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͰͻͪͯͬͰ
Ͱ͵ΒͳͫͰͶͰͱͪͬͪ
Β;ͭͶͪͬͰͰͽͪͺͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͬͭͺͳͽͪΔͪ&1FUFSTPO
%JF&JOIPMVOHEFT,ZSJPT
;FJUTDISJѫGÛSTZTUFNBUJTDIFѮFPMPHJF
m05SFJUJOHFS
%JFPTUSÕNJTDIF,BJTFS
VOE3FJDITJEFFOBDIJISFS(FTUBMUVOHJNIÕêTDIFO;FSFNPOJFMM
+FOB
m
QBTTJN&
),BOUPSPXJD[
ѮFt,JOHT"EWFOUiBOEUIFFOJHNBUJDQBOFMTJOUIFEPPSTPG4BOUB4BCJOB
JO
4FMFDUFE4UVEJFT
/FX:PSL
m ͺͻͬͫͳͽͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͳͲ
4.BD$PSNBDL
$IBOHF
BOE$POUJOVJUZJO-BUF"OUJRVJUZѮF $FSFNPOZ PG "EWFOUVT
)JTUPSJB
m0
/VTTCBVN
(FMFJU
JO3FBMMFYJLPOGÛS"OUJLFVOE$ISJTUFOUVN*9
DPMm..D
$PSNJDL
&UFSOBMWJDUPSZ
5SJVNQIBMSVMFSTIJQJOMBUFBOUJRVJUZ
#Z[BOUJVN
BOEUIFFBSMZNFEJF
WBM8FTU
$BNCSJEHF1%VGSBJHOF
"EWFOUVT"VHVTUJ
"EWFOUVT$ISJTUJSFDIFSDIFTVSMFY
QMPJUBUJPOJEÊPMPHJRVFFUMJUUFSBJSFEVODÊSÊNPOJBMEBOTMBOUJRVJUÊUBSEJWF
1BSJT
,BOUPSPXJD[
PQDJU
m8%PU[BVFS
%JF"OLVOGUEFT)FSSTDIFST%FSGÛSTUMJDIFt&JO[VHi
JOEJF4UBEU CJT[VN&OEFEFT"MUFO3FJDIT
"SDIJWGÛS,VMUVSHFTDIJDIUF
#E
m
/VTTCBV
PQDJU
m18JMMFNT
%FS)FSSTDIFSt"EWFOUVTiJN,MPTUFSEFT'SÛINJUUFMBM
UFST
.ÛODIFO/)VZHIFCBFSU
-FTEFVYUSBOTMBUJPOTEVSPJTBJOU0TXBMEÆ#FSHVFT4B
JOU8JOPD
3FWVFCÊOÊEJDUJOF
m.D$PSNJDL
PQDJU
QBTTJN"/JFEFSTUBUUFS
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
,ÕOJHTFJOUSJUUVOEHBTUVOHJOEFSTQÅUNJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFO3FJDITTUBEU
JO'FTUFVO'FJFSOJN.JUUFMBM
UFS
FE%"MUFOCVSH
++BSOVU
))4UFJOIPGG
4JHNBSJOHFO
m
͇ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͳͳͪͯͬͰͽ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ)%FMFIBZF
-FTPSJHJOFTEVDVMUFEFTNBSUZST
#SVYFMMFT
#,ÕUUJOH
%JFGSÛIDISJTUMJDIF3FMJRVJFOVOEEJF#FTUBUUVOHJN,JSDIFOHFCÅVEF
"SCFJUTHF
NFJOTDIBGUGÛS'PSTDIVOHEFT-BOEFT/PSESFJOm8FTUGBMFO
#E
m)FJO[FMNBOO
PQDJU
m/VTTCBV
PQDJU
m/(VTTPOF
"EWFOUVT;FSFNPOJFMMVOE5SBOTMBUJPO
WPO3FMJRVJFO
7JDUSJDJVTWPO3PVFO
%FMBVEFTBODUPSVN
'SÛINJUUFMBMUFSMJDIF4UVEJFO
m"OHFOFOEU
)FJMJHFVOE3FMJRVJFO
m
QBTTJN ͼͫͳͷͷͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͷ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͶͳͳͽͳͷͯͪͫͻͪͳͷͷͰͼͽͳͷͪ͆ͪͻͰͯͪͼͰ͵ͬͰͪͺͻͰͼͪͰͺͼͻͰͯͺͻͳͲ
ͶͪͲͳͳͲͺͻͰͽͯͰ͋ΒͰPDDVSTVTͳͶͳͯͰ͵ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͅͰΌ;Ͷͳͼͽͳͷͪ͵ΒͰ
ͳͷͳͲͶͪͲͰ;ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͪͶͪͲͳͶͳͼ;ͼͰ
ͼΒͰͯͰͼͽͻͪͰ
͵Ͷͳͻͳͳͳͷͪͼͳ
ͪͼͯͻ;ͭͰ
Ͷͪͳͳ
͵ΒͳͼͰͯͪΓͰͯͻͰΌ;Β;ͺͻͰͷͪͯͻ;ͽͬͰΒͺͻͳͺͪͯͼͽͳ͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪ
Β;
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰΒͰͼͪͰ͵ͳͬͪNJYUVNQPQVMVTͳͶͳ
ͽͪͳΒͰ
PNOJTDJWJUBT
;Ͳͯͭ
ͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͰͫͻͰͯͰͻͪͯΔͰ͌ͽ͵;PDDVSTVTͪͫͪͬΓͪͼͰTVTDFQUJP
ͺͻͳͷͺͻͰͯͪΒͪ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ̀ͪͬͻͳͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶͪΒͰJOHSFTTVTͳͶͳJOUSPEVDUJPm;ͰΔͰͻͰͶͳ
͵ͬͳΒͪ;ͭͻͪͯ
ͯͼ;ͻ͵ͬ;
ͳΔͳͬͺͶͪͭͪΔͰͪ͵ͪͯͻͰͯͳͽͰ͌
ͽ͵;JOHSFTTVTͪͳͶͳͰͺͼͻͰͯͪ͵ΔͰͭͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͰͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪ;ͯͳͷͪ
ͳͷͰΒͰͺͻͳͼ;ͽΒͲͪΒͰͯͳͳͺͻ;ͱͪͯ͵ͪͲͰͼͬΒͰͼͺͼͫͼͽͳͯͪΒΒͫ;ͯͰEP
NJOVTͳQBUSPOVT͇ͫͻͰͯͼͰͲͪͬͻͪͬͪͼͬͰͺͽͳͷͼͶͪͬΓͰͷ
;ͲͫͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͰ
ͻ͵ͬͰͳͪͻͯͪ͋ͪΒͯͪͫͪͬͰͲͼͰͫͰͶͰͱͳ͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;;ͼͽͪͬͳ
ͺͻͪͲͳ͵
͌ͪͬͰͯͰͳͷͺͽͳͷ͵ͬͳͻͳͷͪ;ͱΒͰͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;͢ͳͬͫͻͪͲͪ
ͺͲͪͽΒͰ
;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰΒͰͺͻͰ
ͼͷͷͽͳΒ;͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;ͭͯͳͰ
ͪͬͪͱͼͽͽͭ
ͷͯͰͶͪͲͪͽͰͬͪͯͪͷ;ͼͰͺͼͬͰͽͳͪͻͳͽͪͺͪͱΔͪ́ͲͶͱͳΕͰͷͪΒͺͻͰͿͪ͵ͽ
ͭͻͪͿͳΒ;ͺͻͰͼͪ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͽ;ͷͪͰΔͪΔͰͭͬͳͫͳͽͳͰͶͰͷͰͪͽͪ
͇ͫͻͰͯ͊ͳͷͰͬͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͬͰͷͪΒͰͯͫͻͯ͵;ͷͰͽ͇ͬͪͺͳͼͪͶͳͼ;
ͭͪ
ͪΒͺͻͰ
ΔͰͭͬͳͼͳͬͳ͊ͪͬͪͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ
;ͰͼͳͳͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ
ͪ
ͺͽͷΒ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ͋ͰͪͻͪͽͳͬͰͳͲͬͻͰͲͪͪΒͯͺ;Δ;Β;
Ͷͳ͵ͬͳmͼͶͳ͵ͪͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰͺͻͰͼͪ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ
͊ͺΕͪͳͷͪͳ̻ͻͪͯ;
͋ͪ͵ͲͪͷͯͪΒͰQSPGFDUJP͊ͳͷͰͬͳͷͽͳΒ;;ͺͻͳͶͳͰ;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;ͯ
ͷͪͪ͵ͺͯͳͲͪΔͪͽͰͶͪ
ͪͺͻͪͽΔ;
ͺͻͰͯͬΌͰ;͊ͪͬͷ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
ͳͳͶͳͼ;
tͻͳͼͽΓ;ͫͳͬͳͳͳͲͬͻͼͳͼͽͪͻͳ͊ͬͰͽͰ̻ͻͰi͌ͼͶͰͯͳͶΒͰͺ;ͽͬͪΔͰ;tͽͪ
ͪͼͽͬi
ͯ;ͭͳͽͰͭͫ
ͲͫͭtͬͰͶͳ͵ͭͷͰͽͰͱͪiͳͲͪͲͬͪͭͶͪͽͳͼ͵ͳͷͪͺͪͯͳ
ͷͪͪ͊ͬͰͽ;̻ͻ;͊ͶͰͯͰΕͪͬͪͱͪͰͽͪͺͪͫͳΒͰBEWFOUVTͪͽͰͻͳͽͻͳΒ;ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰ͇ͽͷͰͯͪΒͰͫͳͬͰͷͪͺͪͱΓͳͬͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΓͰͼͬͰͯͳͺͻͰͺͳͼ͵ͪ
̾ͽͪͺͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͳͽͰͽͳͳͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͳͲͶͱͳΒͰ.)FJO[FMNBOO
PQDJU
m
͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ
͊ͪͫͻͪͳͼͺͳͼͳ
̿ͳͬͽͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ ͺͻͳͻ͡͠;ͪͼ̻ͰͻͭͳΒͰͬ
ͼ͵ͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͯͪΓͰ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
̿ͳͬͽ͊ͬͰͽͭͪ͊ͪͬͰͳ
̿ͳͬͽ͊ͬͰͽͭͪ͊ͳͷͰͪ ͺͻͳͻ͉ͪͅͻͳ͵ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͯͪΓͰ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
̿ͳͽͳΒͪ ͺͻͳͻ̹̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͯͪΓͰ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͊ͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ
͊ͪͫͻͪͳͼͺͳͼͳ
̿ͳͽͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭͪ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ ͺͻͳͻ̹̽ͭͯͪͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͯͪΓͰ͊ͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
ͬΌͰͪͳͲͷͰΌ;͊ͪͬͰͳ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
͵Β;ͺͷͳΔ;ͼͬͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳ͆ͪͬͰͼͽ
ͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͪͬͪΔ;ͺͬͻ͵Ͱͼͷͽͳͷͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪͳ̺;͵ͪͳͲͪͶͳͼ;ΒΒ;ͼ;ͼͻͰͽ
ͳͽͼͬͰͶͳ͵ͷͻͰͬΕ;
ͯͼtͱ;ͻi̸ͯͬͰͽ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳ
Βͪ
;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͬͪͱͰΕͳͷͫͳͪΒͳͷͪ
ͯͭͯͳͼͰͪͭͻͪͳͳ
ͽͳͲͬͻͳͳͼ;
ͺͻͺ;ͼͽͳͶͳͯͪͳͼͽͪ͵;͈ͻͰͷͪ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ;
ͼͰͲͫͳtΒͪ͵ͻͪΒ;ͲͰͷΓͰ
ͼͬΒͰi
ͪͺͻͰͷͪ͋ͰͯͼͳΒ;
tͪͭͻͪͳͳͼͬΒͰͳͭͻ͵ͰͲͰͷΓͰi͇ͯͼͬͳͱͳ
ͬͽͺͳͼͪͪ͊ͪͬͪΒͰͪΒͯͻͰΌͰͳΒͳ
ΒͰͻͳͺͻͰͳͲͯͻͰΌ;ΒͰͽͷͰͼͽ͵͎ͪͬ
ͼ͆ͰͺͼͻͰͯͪ͵ͪEWFOUVTͪ;ͼͶͰͯͳΒͰPDDVSTVT͈ͻͳͷͰΕ;ΒͰͼͰͯͪͼ;ͺͳ
ͼͪͳͳͲͬͻͳͪΒͬͳͰͺͪͱΔͰͺͼͬͰͽͳͶͳ;ͺͻͪͬͽΒͰͽͪͺͳͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ̽Ͱ͵
ͷͽͳΒ;ΒͰͯͽͪͳͪͼͶͰͯͳͺͻͺͳͼͪͪͺͻͪͬͳͶͪ͊͵;ͺͳͪͶͳͼͽͳ͵Βͪ
ͳͷΒͰͳͲͪͶͪ;ͼ;ͼͻͰͽͫ;ͬͪͽͪͶͪΒͰͼͬͰͼͳΒͪͶͰ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͰ
ͯ;ͬͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͶͪͳ͵ͰͳͶͳ
ͺͻͰͷͪ͊ͪͬͳͳͷͻͰͳͷͪ
tΒͰͻͰΒͰͳͳͭ;ͷͪͰͼͪͷͭͳͷͷͪͼͳͷͪ
ͳͼͪͫΒͪͻͳͷͪͼͬͳͷi͊ͪͬͪΒͰͪΒͫͶͳͱͳͳͲͬͻͷͽͺͼ;PNOJTDJWJUBT
ΒͰͻ
͵ͪͱͰͯͪͼ;͊ͽͰͿͪͳ̺;͵ͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͯͰ͵ͪͶͳtͼͪͼͬͷͯͻͱͪͬͷi͇ͫͪͬͰ
ͲͰͺͻͪͽͰΕͰͺΒͪͬͰPDDVSTVTͪmͬͰͼͰΓͰ
;ͼͳΕͰΔͰͳͼ;ͲͰͻͪͯͼͳͰmͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͼ;ͺͳͼͪͰ;ͼͬͳͷͺͷͰ;ͽͳͷͱͳͽͳΒͳͷͪ
͵ͪͳͼͬͰͽͰͰͻͪͯΔͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͰ;
ͽͪ͵ͬͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ͋ͪ͵͈ͻͬͬͰͪͳͼͬͰͯͳͽͷͰͯͪtͼͻͰͽͪͬͳͷͽͳ
ͼͬͰͽͰ
;ͳͳͼͷͫΕ;ͷͶͳͽͬ;ͪͽͷͷͰͼͽ;
ͼͪͺͼͪͶͷͳͷͪͳͺͰͼͷͪͷͪ
ͳ
ͺΒ;Εͳͽ;ͪͯͭͻͫͪͺΒͪΔͪͼ͵ͪͯͳͶͳͷͪͳͺͻͳΒͪͽͳͷͷͳͻͳͼͳͷͪi͊ͶͪͬΓͰͺ
ͬͯͷͯͰ͵ͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͷͽͳΒ;ͳͷͪͶΒͰͳͬͪͱ;ͳͯͰͶ͵;ͯͳͷͰͲͳΒ;
ͲͫͭͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͭ;Ͳͻͪͼ͵ΒͳͷΒͰ;ͺͻͰΌͰmͺͻͰͼͷͪ͠͵ͬΓͰͬͭͽͰͶͪͳͲ
̾ͭͳͺͽͪ;ͫͰΕͪ;ͲͰͷΓ;͋ͻͰ;ͽͪ͵ͺͻͳͷͺͻͰͯͪΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͯͼTVTDFQ
UJP;͎ͬͼ;
ͺͷͳΔͰ
ͳͽ͵ͪͰͽͽͼͰͺͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪ
ͼͪͷ͊ͪͬͪ͊ͬͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͰͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΒ;͵ͻͰͽͪΔ;ͺͬͻ͵Ͱ͵ͪ͵ͪͷ
ͳΓ;͇ͯͺͼͰͫͰΒͰͬͪͱͼͽͳͼͬͰͯͰΔͰͽͷͰͯͪͼ;;ͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰ
ͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
tͼͪͼͬͰͽͰͳͳͷͪͲͪΒͰͯͳͼͪͼͬͳͷͫͶͪͭͻͯͳͷͪi
;Ͱͼͽͬͬͪ
ͶͳͳΔͰͭͬͳͼͳͬͳ̀ͪͳͷΓͳͬΒͰͯͪͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͳBEWFOUVTͳͲͪͬͻͳͳ
JOHSFTTVTͪͪͻͪͽͳͬͳͳͲͬͻͳͺͳͼ;Β;;͵ͻͪͽ͵ͳ;ͺͽͰ̓ͪͲͳͬͪΔͰͳͷͼͰ
ͼͬͯͳͪͽͬͻͯΔ;ͯͪΒͰ͊ͳͷͰͼͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͺͪͼͽͳͷͪ
ͼͺͼͪͶͷͳͷͪͳͺͰͼͷͪͷͪ
ͺͶͱͰ;ͭͻͫ͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͪͺͻͰͯͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΓͰ;̹ͭͻͯͳͳΒͻ͵ͬͳ͇Ͳͪ
ͬͻΒͰͽͪͺͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶͪͰͽͬͳͰ͵ͪͱͰͼͪͷ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ͈ͯͪͳ͵ΒͰͯͼͳ
ͳͪ͵ͼ͵;ͯͳ
ͼͬͰͯͰͺͽͬͪΔ;;ͼͽͪΓͰͳͫͳͪΒ͈ͪͳͼͪͽͪ͵͵ͪͱͰͯͪ
ΒͰͪ͵ͺͶͪͭͪΔͪͷͽͳΒ;;ͺͻͳͶͳͰͪͼͶ;ͱͫͪͲͪͺ͵Βͯ;Ͱ
ͪͯͪΒͰͲͪͽͳͷ
;ͼͶͰͯͳͶtͬͰͶͳ͵ͼͶͪͬΓͰi͋ͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳͫͭͪͽΒͰͯͪ
ͻͳͬͪtͳͼͬͰͳͽͰ
͵ΒͳΒͰͷͭͯͶi͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
͊ͪͬͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͳΒͰͺͻ
ͺ;ͼͽͳͯͪͺͻͰͳͲͪͬͰͯͰͯͪͽ;ͷͯͭͪΌͪΒͪmͿͰͫͻ;ͪͻm͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͼͽͪͬΓͰ
͵ͪͺͻͪͲͳ͵ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
̈́ͪͺͳͯͪͻͼͽͪͻͪͽͳͬͳͳͲͬͻͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͳͼͪͼͽ;ͯͰͳ͵ͰͰͻͰͷͳ
ΒͰ;ͲͪͪΒΒͷͰͻͳͪͯ͵ͪΌ;Β;ͼͶͳ͵ͪͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰ͊ͳͷͰͬͭͺͻͰͼͪ͋
ͼ;ͯͫͻͺͲͪͽͰ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͰͳͲͳ͵Ͷ;ͼͪͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͳͷͰ;ͪ
;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳΒ;ͬͰ͵ΒͰͳͽΓͳͬͪ
ͼͺΕͪͼ͵ͪΒͰͯͶͳ;ͬͪͪ
ͯ͵ΒͰͭͻͪ
ͯͪ͵ͪ ͼͶͳ͵ͪ
͵Βͪ ΒͰ ͫͳͶͪ ͯͰͶͳͷͳ ͬͳͯΓͳͬͪ ͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳ ͭͯͳͪ 99 ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼͪͯͪͺͽͺ;;ͳͽͰ͉ͪͰΒͰͼͶͳ͵ͪͷͪͺͻͰͼͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷͽͳΒ;͵ΒͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͰͫͻͪͼͰͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵Ͱͳ͵ͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ͋Ͱ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͰ
ͺͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ;ͳͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͳͭͽͬͳͯͰͽͳͰ
ͪͼͽͪͶͰͼ;
ͪΒͬͰΕͳͷͯͰͶͷ
ͪ
ͼͬ;͊ͪͬͳͭ̿ͳͽͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ́ͺͪ͵
ͽͰͱͳͽͰͯͭͪΌͪΒͪͫͳͽΒͰ
ͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰͪͼͶͳͳͰͭ;ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ̓ͷͺͲͳͳΒͪͰͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;ΒͰBEWFOUVT
;͎ͬͼ;
ͪͭͻͪͳͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͲͰͷΓͰ
ͬͰΕͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͷͽͳΒ;;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;
ͽͪͳΒͰ
ͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵PDDVSTVTͪͺͻͰͯͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͼ͵ͳͷͫͰͯͰͷͳͷͪ͋;ΒͰͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪͪͺͬͻ͵ͪͼ
ͷͽͳͷͪ͵ΒͰͪͻͪͷͰͳͷͪͼͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳͳͼͳͬͳ;ͺͻͪͽΔͳͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͰ͌ͼ;
ͼͻͰͽͳͷͳͲͶͪͲͳͼ͵;ͺͳͪͷͪͪ
ͺͻͰͯͬΌͰͪͻͪ͵ͳͷͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͷ
ͼͬͰͶͳ͵ͷ
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
ͳ͵ͷ̹ͭͻͯͳͰ̸ͭͳͼͻͳͽͳͼͰ͈ͻͳͲͻͼͰͲͫͳͬͪͺͻͰͯͲͳͯͳͪͷͪͷͪͪͼͽͳ
ͻͪ͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͰ
͵ΒͳΒͰͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪͰͫͳͬͰͻͯͼͽΒ
͋ͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͷ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͷͽͳΒ;;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͪΒͰͳ
ͻͪͲͻͪΌͰͪͬͪͱͪͻ͵ͬͰͪͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪ
ͪͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰΒͰͯͻͰΌͰ
ΔͰͳͯͰͶ͵ͳ͵ͬͳͻ͌ͽ;ͷͪͰΔ;͵ΒͰͼͶͰͯͳͪͼͽΒͪΕͰͷͯͪͺ͵ͪͱͰͷͼͷͳ
ͼͪͺΒͰͯͳͳͰͶͰͷͰͪͽͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
͵ͪͳͳΔͰͳ;ͯͪͼ;
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͳͽͭͻͳͽ;ͪͶͪͫͳͶͳͺͽͪͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͪͽͰ͵ͬͳͪ
ͼͪͱ;͵ͻͰΔͰͪ;
ͪͽͳ͵ΒͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ
͈ͰΕͰͷͯͺͬͯͪͳͻͪͲͶͭͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͯͬͰͶͳͯͺͻͰͼͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͳ
ͷͽͳΒ;͆ͬͳΒͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͼ;ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͪͯͪΒͰͬͰΕͳͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ
͵ͬͳ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ ͫͳͶͪ ͺͯͼͽͪ͵;ͽͪ ͽͻͰ;ͽͳͷ ͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͷ
ͺͽͻͰͫͪͷͪ
ͽ
ͪͻͪͬ
Ͱͯͬͯͳ;ͺͳͽͪΔͰΔͳͬͺͽͳͳͯͰͶ͵ͳͺͻ
̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
́ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͰ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͷͼͶͳ͵ͪͻͼͽͬ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͪͬͰ͵ͪͳΔͳͬͰ͵Δͳ
ͱͰͬͰͺͪͻͪͶͰͶͰ
͉̺̀́
m(#BCJǀ
-FTDIBQFMMFTBOOFYFTEFTÊHMJTFTCZ[BOUJOFT
1BSJT
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͭͻͪͷ
ͳΒͳΒͰͳΓͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͲͪͼͳͬͪΔͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ͌ͪͰͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;ͽͰͳͼͽͻͳΒ
ͼ͵ͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱͯͫͻͼ;ͺͲͪͽͰ
ͪͳͲͬͻͳ͵ΒͳΔͳͷͪͪΒͺͯͻͫͳΒͰͳͲͬͰ
ͽͪͬͪΒ;ΒͰͼ;ͼͺͳͼͳ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒ͇ͪͯͶ;͵ͪͺͻͰͼ;ͯͰͽͪΒͰ;
͵ͶͼͽͳͷͪͭͻͪΌͪͼ͵ͭͻͪͽͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͲͰͷΓͪͫͳͶͪt;ͬͰͶͳ͵ΒͰͬΓͳ
͵ͪ;Ͱ͵ΒͽͰͼ͵ͫͳ
ͺ;ͼͽͰͬͳͯͷͭͺͶͰΔͰΔͪͳͺͻͶͳͬͪΔͪ͵ͻͬͳ
ͺͻͺͪ
ͯͪΒ;Εͳͯ͵ͻͪΒͪͯͭͶͪͯͳͲͫͭͰͻͪΔͪ
ͽͪ͵ͯͪͼ;ͼͰͷͭͳͻͪͲͳͶͳͺͽ;ΌΒ
ͲͰͷΓͳi͌ͺͳͼͷ;;ͺ;ΕͰͷ͊ͪͬͳ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͳͭͪͷͶͳͯͪͯͰͼͰͷͽͳ͵ͪ
͵ͫͳͼͰtͽͪͪͼͽͬͪͰͺͻͼͬͰͽͳͶi
ͪt̹ͭͺͼͽͪͷͳͶͼͻͯͪͺͻͰͷͪͪͷͪ
ͳͪͰͻͪͼͰΒͪΔͰͼͪͫͻͪ;ΒͰͯ
ͳͺͻͽͳͬͳ͵ͰͪͰ;ͳͽͳi͋ͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ
ͼͬͰͽͭ ͊ͳͷͰͪ ͺͳͬͪͶͪ ΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͪ ;ͬͰͻͰΔ; ͯͪ ͼ; ͯͶͪͲͪ͵ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ ͳ
ΔͰͭͬͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͲͪͶͭͪͯͫͻͪͰ
ͷͳͻͪͳ;͵;ͺͭͪͺͻͰͽ͵ͪͯͻͱͪͬͰ͋ͼͬͪ
ͽͪΔͰ
;ͻͳͼͽͳΒͪͳͲͬͪΒͬͪͻͳΒͪͽͳ
ͯΒͰ͵ΒͰͳ͵ΒͰͺͻ͵Ͷͪͷ;ΒͰͪͽͳ͵ͳ
GFMJYBEWFOUVT͈ͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳ;ͶͪͲͪ͵ͪͻͳͷͼ͵ͳͪͻΒͰͼͶͪͬΓͰ͵ͪ
SFYQBDJêDVTͳͼͺͪͼͳͶͪ
ͪΔͰͭͬͪͯͬͰͽͰͼͽΒͰͽ;ͷͪͰ͵ͪͪΒͪͬͪͲͶͪͽͭ
͇ͯͫͪͬͻͰͷͰͳͳͲͬͻͳͼͬͰͽΓͪͬͪΒ;
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͻͪͼͺͻͼͽͻͪΔͰ;ͬͰͻͰΔͰͯͪ
ͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͳͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪͻͪͬͰΕͼͪͷͳͺͼͰͫͳͽͳͽͰͭͻͪͯ
ΒͰͻͯΔͰͭͪͽ͵ͶͪΔͪΒ;
ͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͼ͵ͰͪͺͪͯͰ̺ͻͶͼͶͳ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;ͳͷͪΒͰͯͻͪͭͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ
͵ͪͳͪͯͬͰͽͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͵ͪ͵Γ;ͳͳͳͶͪͰͬͪͭͰͶͳͲͪͳΒͰͳͯͻ;ͽͬͰͰ͵
ͼͶͳͯͪͳΒͰ̾ͬͻͺͰ͈ͼͶͰͯͳͪBEWFOUVTͪͫͳΒͰDPOTFOTVT̽ͶͪͲͪ͵ͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
͵ΒͳΒͰͲͪͪͬͪͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͳͲͪͳΒ;ͯͽͪͯͪͺͻͿͪͭͺͻͼͽͻͪ
ͫͳΒͰͬͰͶͳ͵ͳ
ͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵ͼͶͪͬΓͪͳͺͽͰͼͶͳͯͪͻͼͽͳ
ͺͬͯͯͪͼͰͲͪΒͰͯͳͪͺ͵ͪͱͰ͵ͪ
ͷͭͰͪͰͶͳͪ͆ͬͼͽͬͻͰͼͬͰͽͷͰͼͽͺͼͽͪΒͪͶΒͰͬͪͱ;ͺͻͳͽͰ
ͷͳͼͳͪͻͼ͵ͳͪͺͻͪͯͪͼͰͲͪͽͰͰͪSVTUJDJUBTͲͪͷͰͳͪͰͶͷSFWFSFOUJB
͵Β;
ͽͻͰͫͪͼͬͪͽͳͽͳ;ͪΒͳͻͰͷͼͷͳͼͶ;m͵ͪͻͳΕͪͼ͵;ͺͻͼͬͰΕͰͼͽ
͠ ΒͰͯͪ ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͪ ͳͯͰΒͪ
ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͪ ͳ ; ͫͳͽͳ ͼͽͳͻͳͶ͵ͪ
ͷͱͰ ͼͰ ͺͻͰͺͲͪͽͳ ; ͲͪͷͳͼͶͳ ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭ ͪͯͬͰͽͪ ͊ͺͪͼͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͪ
͇ͬͺͳͽͪΔͰͺͯͻͫΒͰͻͪͲͷͽͻͰ;ͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͳͷͪͲͫͻͳ͵ͪ1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSF
ISVOH
ͪ͡ͅ͵ͼͳͷͬͳΕ
͇ͭͯͳͳͺͻͰͼͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳͳͷͽͳΒ;;͊ͻͫͳΒ;
͉̺̀́m
m
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
m
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
,BOUPSPXJD[
PQDJU
m.BD$PSNBDL
PQDJU
m ͭͯͰͼ;ͪͬͰͯͰͳͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳ
ͳͲͬͻͳ
1#SPXO
3FMJDTBOE4PDJBM4UBUVTJOUIF"HFPG(SFHPSZPG5PVST
4PDJFUZBOEUIF)PMZJOUIF
-BUF"OUJRVJUZ
-POEPO
m
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
̓ͻͳΕͰΔͰͬͳͷͽͳͬͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͪͯͬͰͽͪͻͳͷͼ͵ͳͪͻͰͬͪͪͪͶͳͲͳͻͪͶͪΒͰ4.BD$PS
NBDL
PQDJU
m ͼͪͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
.BD$PSNBDL
PQDJU
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͇ͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͳͷ;Ͳͻͳͷͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳͪ͠͵̺͚ͬͪ͠;ͻͳΕ
͊Ͷͳ͵ͪͳ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
̻Ͷͪͼ̸͊͆͌
mͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
m
(VTTPOF
PQDJU
m
.BD$PSNBDL
PQDJU
,BOUPSPXJD[
PQDJU
/VTTCBV
PQDJU
.D$PSNJDL
PQDJU
;ͬͳͷͻͪͯͬͳͷͪ
ͪͬͰͯͰͳͼ;ͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͼͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;ΕͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
.BD$PSNBDL
PQDJU
.D$PSNJDL
PQDJU
QBTTJN
"1PQQF
1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOHJOEFS,JFWFS3VT%FSBQPTUFMHMFJDIF)FSSTDIFSVOE
TFJOF.BSUZSTÕIOF
JO1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͻͪͬ;
ͽͲͪͳͿ;͵ͳͪͶ;ͪͪͶͭͳΒ;BEWFOUVTͪ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ͉Ͱ
ΒͰͳͷͼͶ;ͪΒͪͬͳͷͪ;͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͳͼ;ͬͰͻͰ;Ͱͼͽͬͬͪ;ͺͻͰͼ;
ͼͬͰͽͭͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͪͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͫͪͬΓͪΒ;Εͳͺͻͳͽͷͳͽͪ͵ͬͰͻͪͯΔͰ͵ͪͽΒͰ
ͰΔͰ͵ͬͰͭͪͼͷͽͳͷ͈ͪͷͰ;ΕͰͷͼͪͷͪΒͼͶͪͬͳΒͰ
ͺͬͰͲͪͰͼͷͰ
ͼͽͳͷͪͼͪͼͽͪͽ;ͼͷMPDVTSFHBMJT̻ͯͳͰ
;ͫͶͳͼͽͪͬΒͳͼͰͪͳΒͳͺͪͽͪ
͊ͳͱͰͪ
̈́;Β7**ͺͻͰͰΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͳͼͳΒͪ;ͬͼͪͭͻͪΌͰͳͻ
͊Ͱ̽ͰͳΒ͎ͪͰͻͳ͵**̾ͭͶͰͼ͵ͳͫͪͬͳΒͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒ;ͷͽͳΒ;̾ͯͬͪͻ
ͯͪ́ͼͺͬͰͯͳ͵ͪ;ͬͰͼͽͷͳͼͽͰͻͼ͵;͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶ;
ͪͯͬͰͭͯͳͰͯͳΒͰ;ͫͻͰͯ;
ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͳ͵ͪͳͲͪͳΒͰ̓ͪͻͶ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭͪ͵ͽͳͬΒͰ;Ͱͼͽ͍ͬͬͪͻͳͯͻͳ
̹ͪͻͫͪͻͼͪ̀ͪͺͳͽͪΔͰ͵ΒͳͷͼͰͫͪͬͳͷͪͻͳͽΒͰͬͪͱͪBEWFOUVTͳͲ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͪͻ͎Ͱͻͳ͵***ͼͳ͵ͬͰͭͼͷͽͳͷͪͼͬͭͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷΔͰͭͬͭ
ͺͻͰͼͪͳͲ͌ͽͻͰͽͪ;͑ͺͪΒͰͻ͌ΒͰͯͷͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͷͳͲͬͻ;ͽͪΒͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵ͺͻ
͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͼͪΒͰͻͰͳͷͪͯͪΒͰͪͻͼͬΒͳͷͭͰͼͽͷͰͼͪͷͼΓ;ͫͪͬΓ;ͳͼͺ;ͳ
ͫͪͬͰͲ;ͼͳͪͺͻͰͷͪ;ͬͰΕͯͪΒͰ
ͼͪͼͰΕͪΔͰͷͼͬͰͽͭͼͽͻͪͪ
ͳͼͺ;ͳͳͯ;
ͱͼͽͼͶ;ͭͰͺͻͰͷͪͭͼͺͯͪͻ;͋ͪΒͳͺͫͱͭͫͪͬΓͪΔͪͯ;ͱͼͽͳ
ͳͼ
ͺ;ΔͰͼͽͻͪͺͽͬͪΔͰͷ
ͪͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͳͪͳͫΒͪΔͪͬͪͽͪ͵ͬ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͰͬ;
ͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬ;͌ͳͬͳͶͳͲͪͳΒͳͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪͭͰͼͽͬͳͼ;ͫͳͶͳͺͻͰͺͲͪͽΓͳͬͳ
ͳͺͻͰͳͲ;ͽͬͻΌͰͳ͵ͯͬͳ͵ͷ;ͳ͵ͪͳΒͰͽͪ͵ͯͪͰΔͰͽͰͻͰͽͪ
ͺͺͻͳ
ͻͯͳͼͽͬͪͻͳ
ͳΒͰͼͺͪͯͪͶ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱͪ͵ͽͳͬͼͽͳͅͰΔͪΒ;Εͳ;ΒͰͯͷͻͳ
ͽ;ͪͶͷͽͻͰ;ͽ͵;ͼͬΒ;ͼͺΓ;ͺΒͪͬ;͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͶ;ͱͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;
ͬͶͪͯͪͻΒͰ
;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͺͪͼͽ̹ͭ;ͳΔͰͭͬͷͳͲͪͫͻͪͳ͵;͉ͰΒͰͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͷ;ͳͱͪͬͪ
Δ;
ΒͰͯͷͯͫͶͳ͵ͪNJTFSJBFSFHVN͋ͪ͵ͪͬͺͫͱͳͼͽͪͬͳͼ͵ͪͲͳͬͪͼͰͳͪ
ͯͻ;ͭͰͪͳͰ͆ͪͻͳͽ;ͺͰͪͽΓͳͬ;ͳͷͪͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪͫͳͶΒͰͯͶͪͭͪΔͰ
ͪͻͼ͵ͭͺ;ͻͺ;ͻͪ͠ͰͯͪͯͪΒ;ͬͰͳΒͳͽͪ͵ͬͳͭͰͼͽͬͪ;ͳͳΒͰͪͻ͋Ͱͯ
ͼͳΒͰ **
͵Βͳ ΒͰ ͫͷͽͪ ͼͬΒͳͷ ͺ;ͻͺ;ͻͳͷ ͺͶͪͽͷ ͭͶͪͬ; ͬͪͪ͠ ͈ͻͰͽͰͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷΔͰͭͪͯͬͰͽͪ;̓ͼͽͪͽͳͺΓ͋ͽͼ;ͼͳͬͳ͊ͳͷͰͪ
͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
;͵Γ;;Β;Εͳͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͼͳͶͳΔͰͭͬ͵ͬͰͭΒͰͼͽͰͳ͵Βͳ
+1FUFSTPIO
4BJOU%FOJTm8FTUNJOTUFSm"BDIFO%JF,BSMT5SBOTMBUJPWPOVOEJISF7PS
CJMEFS
%FVUTDIFT"SDIJWGÛS&SGPSTDIVOHEFT.JUUFMBMUFST
m
͇ͬͪΒͳͲͬͻͪͬͯͳͳͽ;ͷͪͳ
;ͳͻͰͷͺͻͫͶͰͷͼ͵ͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
+1FUFSTPIO
,BJTFSUVN
VOE,VMUBLUJOEFS4UBVGFS[FJU
JO1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH
m
͊;ͺͻͽͼͽͪͬΓͰͯͼͳͲͷͰΌ;tHFTUFTEVSPJiͳtHFTUFTEVUSBWBJMiͻͪͲͷͽͻͳΒͰ+$4DINJUU
-BSBJTPOEFTHFTUFTEBOTM0DDJEFOUNFEJFWBM
1BSJT
W1FUFSTPIO
PQDJU
- #PSOTDIFVFS
.JTFSJBF 3FHVN 6OUFSTVDIVOHFO [VN ,SJTFO VOE 5PEFTHFEBOLFO JO EFO
)FSSTDIBGUTUIFPMPHJTDIFO7PSTUFMMVOHFOEFSPUUPOJTDITBMJTDIFO;FJU
#FSMJO
QBTTJN
1(-97**
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
ΒͰͺͳͬͪ;ͺͻͪͬͪͽͪ͵ͬͳͷͼͬͪͽͪΔͳͷͪ
ͽͰͯͬͼͷͳͼͶͰͺͽͬͻΌ;Β;ͪ
ͻͪͽͳͬͳͳͲͬͻͳ̀ͪͪΒΒͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͽͽ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
ͺͳͼ;Β;ΕͳͯͭͪΌͪΒ
Ͱͺͻͺ;ͽͪͯͪͳͼͽͪ͵Ͱ͊ͳͷͰͬͯͬͼͽͻ;͵ͳͼͽͪͽ;ͼΒͰͼͬΒͳͷͼͳͬͳͷͪ
ͫͳͰͼͪͷͽͪͬͰΕͳtͯͫͻͳ;ͳͽͰΓͳͭͼͺͯͪͻi͆ͪΒͰ͵ͼͺͶͳͳͽͳΒͳΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ͆ͪ͵ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͯͪͼ;ͫͻͪΕͪͷͽͳͺͰͶͪtͪͼͬΒͳͷͻ;͵ͪͷͪi
͵ͪͱͰͼͶͰͯͰΕͰt̸ͺͰͽͼͬͳͼͰͯͳͬΓͪ;ͬͰͶͳ͵ΒΓ;ͫͪͬͳͼͪͷͯͻͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͳΔͰͭͬΒͺͻͰͬͰͶͳ͵ΒͼͷͰͻͼͽͳ
ΒͰͻͰͽͰΌͪͰͪͻͼ͵ͰͫͪͭͻͰͳͰ
Ͱͭͳͽ;
ͼͪͷ;ͪͼ;ͼͬΒ;ͭͶͪͬ;;ͺͻͪͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͳͺͯͷͰͽͪͰͺͻͰͯͭͪͷͪͺͻͰͺͯͫ
ͳͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;Εͳ
ͷͶͳͽͬͰͯͼͬͳΒ;ͳͫͶͪͭͼͶͬͰͯͪͺͻͳͷͳͷͶͰΕͳi͊ͻͫͳ
ͼ;
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͶͳͳ;ͼͬΒͳͶͳͽͰͷͰΓͳͲͪͽͰͬ;ͺ;ΕͰͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͷͼͳ
ͳͷͪͬͶͪͼͽͳmͯͪFYBMUBUJPͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͷͻͪͺͳͬͪͽͳͪΔͰͭͬΒͻͳΕͪͼ͵Β
IVNJMJUBT
͇ͫͻͪͲͪBEWFOUVTͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;ͼͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͽͻͪͼͶͪ
ͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪͼͽͪΒͰͪͼͪͲͳͳ;ͬͻͰͷͰΔͰͭͬͳͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͪͪͯͪͅ
ͼ;ͺͻͰͼͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭͻͰͶͪͽͳͬͼ͵;ͯͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͳ;ͺͳ
ͼͪͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
ͳͳͼͰͯͪͼ;ͫͳͶͳͰͶͬͳͽͳͺͻͺͳͼͼͺͻͬͰͯͰͳ͋ͻͪ
ͼͶͪͳΒͪ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;ͪ͵͵ͻͪΓͰͬͰͼͷͻͽͳͼͳͭ;ͻΒͰͳͷͪͶͪͿͻͷ;ͼͬͰͪͭ
ͪͯͬͰͽͪ
;͵ΒͰͷͼ;
ͼͳͷͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͳͶͳͼͽͳͼͬͰͽͬͰͳͯ;ͬͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳ
ΒͰ
;ͰͼͽͬͬͪͶͳ͊ͪͬͪ
ͽͪͯͪͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
͵ͪͳͼͳͬͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬ
ͬͰ͈ͪͭͺͻͳͼͺͰΕ;;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;ͫͻͰͯΒͰͳͲͬͰͯͰt͵ͪͽΒͰͯͼͽΒͳ
ͫͭ;ͭͯi
tͼͪͺͼͪͶͷͳͷͪͳͺͰͼͷͪͷͪͳͷͳͶͼͽͳΔͷͺͻͰͷͪͳͽͳͷͪi
ͪ͵
ͰͭͪΒͰ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͽͰͶͺͶͱͰ;̹ͭͻͯͳͳ;ͻ͵ͬ;͊ͪͼͬͳͷΒͰͼͶͳͪ
ͺ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ;ͳͼͬͰͯͰΒͿͻͷͳ
ͺͳͼͯͻ;ͭͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭ;̿ͳ;́
ͪΒͰͺͻͪΕͰͪtͺͼͪͶͷͳͷͪͳͺͰͼͷͪͷͪͳͼͬͪ͵ͷͪΕ;i
ͪͪ͵ͺͶͪͭͪΔͪͽͰͶͪ
;ͼͶͰͯͳͶΒͰͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͰ;ͫͭͳͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͼͶͪͬΓͰ͈ͼͽΒͰΒͪ͵ͳͻͪͲͶͲͳͲͪ;ͬͰͻͰ
ΔͰͯͪΒͰͱͳ͵ͳͪͯͬͰͽͷͻͪͫͳͽͳͬͰͷͪͼͬͰͪͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪ
ͪ͵ͼͰͳͷͪΒ;;ͬͳ
ͯ;ͼͷͳͼͪͳͿ;͵ͳΒͪͽͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ͈ͻͬͬͰ͇ͪͭͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͯͰ;͵;ͺͭ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͭͺͻͭͻͪͷ̸ͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͳΒͰͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͳͷͺͽͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͷͪ
ͬͰͲͪͳͷͲ͎ͪͻͳͼͽͪ
̹ͭͻͯͳ;
͈ͬͪͪ͠ͻͰͽͰ;ͳͪͺͼͽͶͰ
ͽͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͳͯͯͪͽͰͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͺͻͬͭͪͳͪͶͭ͵ͻͪΓͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
#PSOTDIFVFS
PQDJU
1FUFSTPIO
,BJTFSUVNVOE,VMUBLUEFS4UBVGFS[FJU
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰ
͈ͺͬͳΕ
4BDSBFSFMJRVJBF
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͈ͯͻͫͳͼͷͭͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͺͳͼͪͪΒͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺ
ͼ͵ͭͳͲ͋ͻͬͪ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬ;́ͪ͵ͪͿͻͷͪͶͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͳBEWFO
UVTͪFQJTDPQJ
ͫͻͰͯΒͰͼͶͰͯͳͫͻͪͲͪͺͻͰͼͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͪͳͷͪ
ΒͰͳͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͳͼͶͳ;
ͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;͇ͫ;ͬͪͽͪΒͰͼͬͰͺͻͺͳͼͪͰ
ͰͽͪͺͰ
͵ͪͳ;ͰΕͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
͵ͻͪΓ̺ͪͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ
;ͰͻͰͷͳΒͳͺͻͰͼͪ͋ͻͪ
ͼͶͪͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͳͷͪͶͪΒͰͳͼͬΒͰͼͫͰͼͽͳ
;ͼͶͬΓͰͰ͵Ͷͼͽͳͷͪ;
͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰͯͬͳΒͪͶ͇ͪͫͻͰͯΒͰ
ͻͰͳͷ
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͳͺͻͰͼͪ͵Βͳͼ;
ͫͪͬΓͰͳͪ͵;ͯͰͼͰtͬͳͲͳΒͰi͌ͪͰͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;ͫͳͶΒͰͽtͼͽͻͪͬͳ
ΌͰΔͰiͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͪͻͪ
;͵ΒͰͷͷ;ΒͰ͊ͪͬͪ
tͼͪͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͺͻͰΕͰΔͰͷi
ͪͶͱͳ
ͳͲͬͻͰΔͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ͋ͪͬͳͲͳΒͪͲͫͳͶͪͼͰ͵ͪͺͼͶͰͯͳͪͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͽͺͻͪ
ͯͪͲͪͷͰͳͽ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ;ͺͻͰͯͪΒ;ͼͻͺͼ͵Βͼͽͻͪͳ́ͲͳͼͽͳͻͪͲͶͭͪͺͶͪͲͪ͵ͳͲ
͋ͻͬͪͳΒͰ;ͫͶͳͰͰͻͰͷͳΒͪͶ
͵ͪQSPGFDUJP
ͬͰΕΒͰͳͲͬͰͯͰ;ͬͰͶͳ͵Β
ͫͻͲͳͳ͌ͼͽͻͪ;̹ͯͪ;ͭͪͻͳͰͺͻͷͰͰͯͶ;͵;
͊ͻͫͳtͼͪͬͰͶͳ͵ͷͱ;ͻͫͷ
;ͽͰ͵ͰͽͪΒͯͭͻͪͯͪ͋ͻͬͪi
ͳͽͫͰͲ͵ͻͪΓ̺ͪͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͽͰ͵ͯͳ
ΒͰͼ;ͼͽͳͭͪͺͬͻ͵;
͇ͼͽͪͶͰ ͰͽͪͺͰ ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ ͼͬͰͽͭ ͊ͪͬͰ ͺͳͼͪͰ ͼ; ͺͷΕ; ;ͫͳͪΒͰͳ
ͫͻͪͲͪͪ
ͪͶͳͼ;ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
;ͯͼ;ͪͺͻͰͼͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪͯ
ͭͻͪΌͰͰͬͳͷͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͷͪ́Ͳ;ͲͰͽΒͰͬͪͱͪͺͲͪͽͳͺͳͼͰΔͪ͵ͬͰͭͪ
ͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͭ;ͰΕͪ;ͫͻͰͯ;͵Βͳͯͼͳ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ
͊ͪͬͰt̸͵ͻͪΓ̺ͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬ
͵ͪͰ͵ͪͯͪͺͻͻ͵̽ͪͬͳͯ
ͺͻͰͯΕͳͬͽͷͼͬͰͽͭͪ
ͼ͵ͪ͵ͪͰͳͭͻͪΒ;ΕͳͳͬͰͼͰͶͰΕͳͼͰ
ͻͪͯͼͽͳͳͬͰͼͰΓͪͳͼͺ;ΔͪͬͪͰͼͰi͊Ͷͳ
͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͳ͋ͰͯͼͳΒͰt̺ͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬ͵ͻͪΓͫͻͲͯͼͽͳͱͰͼͬͰͽͭͪ;ͰΔ;
ͳ
͵ͪͰ͵ͪͯͪ̽ͪͬͳͯͺͻͰͯΕͳͬͽͷͻͪͯͬͪͰͼͰ
ͳͲͶͪͲͰΕͳͳͺͻͰͯͬͯͰΕͳΔͰͭͬͰ
ͷͽͳi͊ͪͳͯͰͶ͵ͭͭͶͰͯͳͽͪ
ͻͰͳͽΒͰͺͻͰΌͰΔͰͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͭͪͻͪ
ͳͺͻͻ͵ͪͼͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͷ
ͽΒͰͼͽ̽ͪͬͳͯͪͳ͵ͳͬͽͪͲͪͬͰͽͭͼΒͰͯͳͷ
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
ͯͭͪΌͪΒͰͷͳͲͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰ͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͷͽͳͬͶͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͪͺͻͰͯͬ
ͯͳͺͻͰͼͳΒ;ͼͷͽͳͷͪͲͪͳͷΓͳͬΒͰͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͪͼͶͰΌͰͳͫͻͪͲͪͪ
ͽΒͰͯΒͰ͵DVSTPSͪ
͵ΒͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͻͳͷͼ͵ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͪͯͬͰͽͪ͵ͻͪͪͳͼͺͻͰͯ
ͼͬͰͪͰͺͬͻ͵Ͱ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;ͼͪͼͽͰͭͷ;ͻ;ͳ̓Γ;ͰͽͻͰ;ͽ͵Ͱ͊ͪͬͳͰ
ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰmBEWFOUVTͳPDDVSTVTmͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͪͻͪͽͳͬͳͳͲͬͻͳͺͳͼͪͶͳͼ;ͺ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷ;ͫͳͪΒͰͰͽͺͳ͵Ͱ̽Ͱ͵ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;ͺͻͳͶͳͰΒͰͪ͵ͽͼͰ
ͺͬͻ͵ͪͺͻͳͫͶͳͱͳͶͪtͲͰͷΓͳͼͬͭͪͽͪͪͼͽͬͪi
ͪ;ͼ;ͼͻͰͽΒΒΒͰͳͲͪͪPN
OJTDJWJUBTmtͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺ̸ͻͼͰͳΒͰͼͪͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͳͷͪͳͳͭ;ͷͪͳͷͪͳͼͪͷͭͳͷ
ͫͶͪͭͻͯͳͷi͇ͯͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͭΒͰͲͪͪΒͪͽͽΒͰͺͳͼͪͯͬͰͽͪ͊ͪͬͳͳ
ͷͽͳΒ;;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͲͪ͵ͻ;ͱͰͺͻͰΌͰΔͰͷͼ͎ͪͻͳͼͽͬͳͷ;Ͷͪͼ͵ͷ
;͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ́ͯͰΒ;ΒͰΒͪͼͳͲͶͱͳ̽ͷͰͽͳΒͪtwͳ͵ͪͽΒͰͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͪ
ͰͯͪͳͲͳΌͰ;ͼ;ͼͻͰͽ͎ͻͳͼͽ;ͼͪͭͻͪͳͪͷͪͳͭͻͪͪͷͪ
ͬͪͺͳΒ;ΕͳͳͭͬͻͰ
Εͳ̹ͶͪͭͼͶͬͰ͵ΒͳͭͻͰͯͰ;ͳͷͰ̻ͼͺͯΔͰ
ͪͻ́ͲͻͪͳΓͰͬ
ͳͰ͈ͯͪͬͭͻͰ
ͼͬͰΕͰͭͪͼͻͰͽͰͭͪͼͪͫͭͬͪͶͳͷͺͰͼͷͪͷͪͷͰͼͽͷͪͼͶͳͳͭͻͪͪi
͆ͪ Ͱ ͽͪ͵ Βͪͼͪ ͪͳ
ͪͶͳ ͰͯͬͼͷͳͼͶͰ
ͳͯͰΒͪ ΒͰ ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͪ ͳ ; ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳ
ͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰt͆Ͱͭͯͪ;͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͳ͊ͳͪΒͺ;ͽͬͪͬͳ
ͼͪͯͪ
;ͽͪͪͼͽͬͼͬΒͰͯͪΒͰͼͳi̸ͯͬͰͽ͊ͪͬͳͳͷͽͳΒ;;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͯͳͭͻͪ
ͼͰ;;ͫͳͪΒͰΒͪͽͷͼͿͰͻͳͼͶͪͬΓͪͳͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪ͊ͬͷͰͽͪͪͼͽͬ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓΒͰ
ͯͰtͺͻͰͼͬͰͽͶ;ͻͪͯͼͽi
ͪͭͪΒͰͯͰ͵ͪͶtͼͪΓ;ͫͪͬΓ;iͳtͼͬͰͽͶͶͳ͵;
Β;Εͳi̸ͯͬͰͽΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͳͼͺ;ͳͳͽͰͭͻͪͽͳͬ;ͯͻ;ͽͬͰ;;Ͷͭ;
ͽͪ͵ͽΒͰ
͵ͳͼͽͭͳΓͪ͵;ͺͳtͼͬͪͰͯͪͽͪͪͼͽ͈ͬͪͻͰͼͬͰΕͰͭͪiͳtͼͪͫͻͪͳͪ
ͼͪͫͻͺͻͪͲͳͰΓ;ͫͪͬͳͼͬΒͰi͈ͻͰͷͪ;ͼͽͪΓͰͷͫͻͪͼ;
ͬͰͷͪͼͪͱͰͽ
ͺͳͼͪͰͼ;ͲͪͬͻͰͰͽͪͺͰͫͻͰͯͪ͌ͼͬͰͪΒͺͬͻͳͳ;ͲPͫͪͬΓͪΔͰͺͻ
ͺͳͼͳͼͬͰͽͰͳͻͪͯΔͳͷͽͳͼ;ͯͰͽͰ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬ;ͳͺͶͱͰͰ;ͺͻͳ
ͺͻͰͷΓͰͳͭͻͫ͆ͪ͵ͽͭͪ;ͼͶͰͯͳͶΒͰͼͶͪͬΓͰ
ͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͰͳͽͳͳ;ͼͺͼͽͪ
ͬΓͪΔͰͺͻͪͲͳ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͷͰ͇ͽ͊ͪͬͳ;ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒ;ͳͲͯͬͪΒͪͯͼͻͯͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͫͻͰͯͪΒͰͼͽͰͪͭͶͪͰͪ;ͰͼͽͪͶͼͽ;ͯͽͬͻͰΔ͉ͪͪͲͶͳͳͽͪ;ͯͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪͪΒͰΕͰͳͼͰΓͰΔͪ
͊ͪͬͳͰͷͽͳͳͳͶͰͼ;;ͼͬͳͷͬͪͱͳͷͽͻͰ;ͳͷͪ
ͻͳͽ;ͪͶͪmͪ͵FMFWBUJPͽͰͶͪ
;ͪͼ;BEWFOUVTͪ;ͼͻͺͼ͵;ͲͰͷΓ;
ͪͽͪ͵ΌͰ;
ͽ͵; ͵ͻͰͽͪΔͪ ͺͬͻ͵Ͱ ͆ͪ ͽͪΒ ͪͳ ΒͰ ͺͻ;ͱͪ ͯ͵ͪͲͰ ͼͬͭ ͼͽͪͽ;ͼͪ ;
ͬͰͼͽͳ
ͽΒͰͼͽͼͺͼͫͼͽͳͯͪͲͪͼͽ;ͺͪͼͬΒͪtͰͯͪiͳtͽͪͪͼͽͬimͽ
ΒͰ
ͼ;ͯͰΕͳͺͼͬͰͯͰΔͳͷͪͳͲͬͻͪ
ͳͫͳͶͪ͵ͻͪΒΔͪͼͬͻͪ͊ͪͬͳͭͪͯͬͰͽͪ;
͊ͻͫͳΒ;͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͬͪͱͼͽͳͽͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ;ͺͼͽ;ͺ͵;ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͪ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͯ
ͳͳΔͰͳͪͯͪΒͰͫͻͰͯ
ͼͳͷͽΒͰͺͳͼͪ;ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪ͵ͪͽͼ;ͱͳͽͳΒͪ
ͯͫͳͫͭͼͶ;ͱͫͰ;Ϳͻͷ;
ͺͻͬͳͼͪͷͼͽͪͶͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͽͰͬͻͼͽͰ͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ
ͪͽ
ΒͰ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
͌ͬͻͰͷͰͳͷͪ͵Βͪͼ;;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪͼͬͰͯͰΔͪͺͻͰͼͳͷͪͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͳͬͶͪ
ͯͪͻͪͺͼͽͪΒ;͵ͻͪͽ͵ͪͳ;ͺͽͰͪͳͶͳͺͽͺ;ͳͲͼͽͪΒ;͋ͪ͵Ͱͷͪͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ
͵Βͳͫͳ;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͶͳͪͼͬͰͪͳͺͻͰͼͽͰͶͪ͵ͻͪΓͰ͉ͬͪͪͯͼͶͪͬͪͳ̺ͶͪͯͳͼͶͪͬͪ
͋ͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͻͪ*;͊ͺΕͪͰͺͷͳΔͰͼͰ
ͯͯ;Ͱ
;ΔͰͭͬͷͱͳͽͳ
Β;
ͪͶͳͪͪͳ͵Βͳͳ͵ͪ͵Ͱ;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͪͼͬͰͪͳͪͯͬͰͽtwͳͫͳͪͼͺͻͰ
ͰͼͰͽͰͶΔͰͭͬ
ͳͺͶͱͳͰͭͪ;ΔͰͭͬͳͷͻ;͵ͪͷͪͼͪͲͯͪͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;
;ͯͷ;ͼͬ͋ͻΒͳͰi̽ͳͼͽͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪͽͰ͵ͯͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͲͪͷͳͼͶͳ
ͬͪ;͵ͶͼͽͳͷͪͪͼͳͶͭͼͬͻͭͪͬͪΔͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͻͪͼͺͻͰͼͽͶͪͳΔͰͭͬͰ
ͼͷͻͽͳ;ͺͻͭͼͽͬ;͐ͳͳͼͰͯͪΒͰͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪ͵;ͽΒͭͰͰͻͪͳΒͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ͵ͻͪΓͳͰ͠ͰͶͰͰ̸ͱ;Βͼ͵Ͱ;̻ͻͪͯͪ́ͪ͵ͼͰͺͻͰͼͯͳͭͻͪ;
ͰͺͬΓͳͷͬͻͰͷͰͼ͵ͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ
ͺtΓ;ͽΒͲͳͷͳi
͵ΒͪΒͰ;ͼͶͬͳͶͪ;ͼͺ
ͻͰ ͵ͻͰͽͪΔͰ ͳ Ͱͼͽ Ͳͪ;ͼͽͪͬΓͪΔͰ ͺͬͻ͵Ͱ
ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ ͯͪ ΒͰ ͳͲͬͰͯͰ ͵ͪ
ͼͬͰͪͪͰͻͰͷͳΒ͇ͪͽͷͰͺͪΒͬͳͰͼͬͰͯͳͽͽΒͰͼͪͻͪͪͫͪͬΓͰͪ
;Ͳͪ͵ͽͳͬ;ͰΕͰͪΒͬͳͳͶͳͼͽͳͯͻͱͪͬͰͳͻ͵ͬͰ
͵ͻͪΓͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪͳ
ͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ͊ͪͬͰ**
ͺͻͪΕͰͭͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͳͷͪͳͳͭ;ͷͪͳͷͪ͊ͪͷͪͼͪͻͪͪͽͪ
͵ΌͰΒͰͳͲͬͰͯͰͪͺͻͰͷͪͺͻͰͺͲͪͽΓͳͬͳͷ
ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳͷͫͻͪͼͳͷͪ͋ͰͶ
͵ͻͪΓͳͰͷͪΒ͵ͰͼͳΒͰΔͰͼͳ
͵ͻͪΓͅͳͶ;ͽͳ
;ͲͺͰͬͪΔͰͺͼͪͶͪͷͪͳͺͰͼͪ
ͷͪ ͆ͪ͵ ͺͶͪͭͪΔͪ ; ͭͻͫ ;ͼͶͰͯͳͶ ΒͰ ;ͫͳͪΒͰ ͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͰ ͼͳͻͷͪͳ
ͳ ͬͰͶͳ͵ ͼͶͪͬΓͰ ;ͺͻͳͶͳͰ tͼͪ ͰͶͳͷ ͼͪͫͻͷ ͽͪͪͼͽͬͪi ́Ͳ ͬͻͰͷͰͪ
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
͠ͰͶͰͰ̸ͱ;Βͼ͵ͰͺͽͳͰΒΒͰͯͪͬͪͱͪͳͲͬͻͲͪͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͰͻͪͲͬΒͪͳͼͷͳ
ͼͶͪͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͳͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ͋ͼ;ͯͬͰ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͰͺͻͰͼͪͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͰͪ
ͲͪͺͪͯͷͲͳͯ;ͭͻͪͯͪ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰ͆ͪͱͪͶͼͽ
ͲͫͭͼͶͪͫͰ;ͬͪͼͽͳͿͻͰͼͪ͵ͪ
ͺͳ
ͽͪΔͰΔͳͬͰͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵ͪͳΒͰ;ͪ;ͳΒͰΒ;ͬͰ͵ͽͬͻͰ
ͺͪͰͯͲͬΓͪͬͪ
ͯͰΔͰͳͻͳͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵ͪ́ͺͪ͵
ͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͶͳͼͽͳͰ
ͷͰΔͪͫͳͽ͵ͻͪΒΔͳͼͷͳͼͪ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͪ
ͪͼͽͪͶͳ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ
ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͳͪͭͶͪͪͬͪΔͪΔͳͬͭͼͬͰͽͻͯͭͺͻͰ͵Ͷ͉ͪͰ
ΒͰͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ΒͳͯͰΒͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰͳͲͰͺͰ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͻͪ
͵ΒΒ
ͼͳͷͯͳͺͶͷͪͽͳ͵ͳͳͪͻͪͽͳͬͳͳͲͬͻͪ
ͼͬͰͯͳͲͪͷͳͼͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻ
ͫͬͪͳͺͻͽͻͰͽͪ;͊ͺΕͪͳͷͪͳ̻ͻͪͯ;͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͽͻͰͫͪͳͷͪͽͳͪ;ͷ;ͳͽͯͪ
ΒͰ;ͺͻͪͬ;ͯͫͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͻͪ*
ͺͻͰͼͷͷͽͳΒ;͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ;
͊ͺΕͪͰ
ͳͲͬͻͰͪΒͰͯͪͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͬͰͷͪͬͪͱͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪUSBOTMBUJP
͵Βͪ
ΒͰͷͻͪͶͪ;͵Γ;ͳͬͪͽͳͳͼͬͰͪͳBEWFOUVT
̸͵ΒͰͼ;ͯͳͽͳͺͼͪ;ͬͪͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
ͫͻͰͯͼͬͰͪͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͽͻͪͼͶͪ
ͳΒͰͳΒͰͼͰͬͳͰͺͬͳ;ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͅͽͳ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͯͼͽͻͪΔͰͳͲͯͳͻͰ͵ͽͰͶͳͳΒͰͪͼͶͰΌͳͬͪΔͪ
Ͱͼͪͷͯͪͳͼ;ͺͼͷͪ
̈́ͳͼͽͳͳΒͰͼͰͷͽͳͺͻͰͼͰͯͼͪͯͪΔͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵ͬͪͶͳͼ;ͪͻͪͲ
Ͷͳͳͽͪͳ͚̹͵ͬͳΕ
͊͆ͰͪͯͬͳΕ ̻ͻͪͯͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
ͺͷͳΓͪͶͳͼ;ͪ
͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔ;
͊ͪͬ;ͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ
ͪͶͳͫͰͲͯͶ;ͭͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͪͣͅ
ͻͬͳΕ͡;ͫͳ͵ͬͳΕ<͇ͯͻͪͲ͵;Ͷͽͪͼͬ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ;ͷͰͽͼͽͳ
͊ͽͪ
ͻͳͪͻ
ͼ
9**
>ͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬͳͶͪΒͰͯͪΒͰͻͰͺͻͰͼ;͆ͰͷͪΔͰ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳ;ͳͶͳ
͈ͻͬͬͰͪͭ;̿ͳ;ͷͰΌ;ͪ;ͳͳͷͪΒͰͪΒͬͰΕͰͭͯΒͰ͵ͪͳͷͪͶͷͳΓͰΔͰ̺͚͠;ͻͳΕͪ
́ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͰ**
m
ͼ͵ͻͳͽͳ͵ͳͷͼͬͻͽͷͪͼͽͪͻͳΒͪͷͳΓͰΔͪ
ͯͪΒͰ;
̻ͻͪͯ;ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ;ͅͳͶͰͰͬ;ΒΒͰͯ;ͳͺͽͰͲ;ͺͻͳͯͯͪΒͰ
͉͆ͳ͵ͶͳΕ<͈ͻͳͶͲͳͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔ;ͱͳͬͺͳͼͪͳͬͰ͵ͪ;ͫͶͪͼͽͳ͉ͪͼͪ
͉ͪ͵ͪͫͪͽͳͪ
m>
ͼͷͪͽͻͪΒ;ΕͳͯͪΒͰͽͺͻͰͼ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͻͪ;͊ͺΕͪͰ͈ͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵;ͯͪΒͰ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰͺͬͻͭͪΒͰΒ̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
ͼͺͻͪͬͷͪͭͶͪͼͳͬ
ͳͯͪΒͰͽͪ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͪͬͰΕͫͳͶͪͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͪ;Β;ͱͷͺͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼ;̻ͻͪͯͪ
;ͼ͵Ͷͺ;ͳ͵Ͷ;ͼͪ
ͺͼͬͰΕͰͭͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͳͷͰ;ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͼͽΒͰͳͽͰ͵ΕͰͯͪͼͰͺͻͰͼͳͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵;Β;͵ͪ
͊ͪͬͳͳͶͳͼͽ͵ΒͪͼͰͺͻͰͼͳͯͰͬͰͪΒͰ͵ͪͷͪ
ͪͰ͵ͪͪͻͳΒͰͻͰΒ͌Ͳͽ
ͯͰΕͪ;ͺ
͵ΒͰͭͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͪΒͰͪͼͰͬͰͻΒͳΒ;ͱΒ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͳ
ͽͲͪͳͯͪͼ;ͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͰͳͶͳͯͬͰ
ͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͰͶͳͼͽͳͳͶͳͯͬͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ͌ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͽͻͰͫͪͶͫͳͳͼͺͳͽͪͽͳͷͭ;Εͼͽ
ͯͪͼ;;̻ͻͪͯ;ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲͪͳͺͻͰͼͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰ̸ͪͭ͵ͽ;ͰͶͼͽ͵;ͶͽͪͺͻͬͭͼͬͰͽͭ
͵ͻͪΓͪ;ͽͬͻͰͷͰͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰͯͶ;͵ͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͌ͻͪͯͪͰͬͰͷͽͳͺͻͰͰͼͰ;͊ͺΕͪͰ
DG
͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
m͆ͪͽͪΒͪͳͶͪ͵ͰͫͳͼͰͫΒͪͼͳͶͯͼ;ͼͽ͈ͬͻ
ͬͬͰͪͭ
ͽΒͰͼͽͷͪͪ͊ͳͷͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͼͬͰͽͳͷͺͻͰͳͷͪͲͪͼͽ;ͺͳͳͷͪ;ͼ͵Ͷͺ;͵ͽͳͽͻ
ͼ͵Ͱ͵ͷͺͲͳͳΒͰ
DG͉͊ͪͯΒͳΕ
͈ͻͽͻͰͽͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
͊͵ͺΓͰ
͇̓ͪͯͳΕ
ͪͪͅͼͽͳͻ̻ͻͪͯͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͼͪͼͽͪͻͳΒͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫ
mͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͽͻͪͰ͵ͪͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ͵;ͶͽͪͬͰΕΒͰͳΔͳͬͪFMFWBUJPͳͲͻͳ͵ͷͲͪͫͻͪΔͰͪ͆ͳ
ͶͰͭͳͽͳͷͳͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͺͻͰͼͽͶͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
tͼͬͰͽͳ͵ͻͪΓi͊ͽͰͿͪ͌ͻ**ͅͳ
Ͷ;ͽͳ
͵ͪͯͪͳΒͰͯͫͳͺͻͺͳͼ;ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒ;́ͼͽͳͪ
ΔͰͭͬͪͼͷͻͽͲͫͳͶͪ
ͼͰ;ͬͪͻͰͯͳͷ
ͻͪͽͳͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ͌ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔ;̽ͪͳͶͪ**
͵ΒͳΒͰͫͳ
ͻͭͪͳͲͪͽͻͳͳͲͬͻͳͶͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͬͶͪΌ;Β;ͼͬͰͯͰΔͪͽͰ͵Εͪͷͪ
ͼ͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰͼ;ͪͬͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͳͲͬͻͰΔͪͲͪͯͪͽ͵ͪt̀ͪͺͬͰͯͳͰͯͪͼͰͼͺͻͰͷͰ
͵ͶͪͼͪͳͲͪͫͻͪͳͷ͵Δͳͷͪ
ͯͪͺͶͱͳͬͳͪΔͳͽͰͶͫͶͪͱͰͭͪͳͺͻͰͬͳͼ
͵ͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ
ͳͺͻͰͰͼ;ͭͪ͵ͪͼͺͻͰͷΓͰͷͷ;ͭͻͫ;w͆ͪͷͭͳͷͷͰͼͽͳͷͪΒͪͬΓͪ
Ͷͳͼ;ͼͰͺ;͵ͬͳͬΒͳ͵ͪ
ͷͳͼͶͰΕͳͯͪͺͼͽͳͭ;Ͱ͵;ͼͬΒ;ͬΓ;ͳͯͪ;ͭͻͪͫͰͰ
ͽͯͳ͵ΒͳͼͰͽͰͶͫͶͪͱͰͭͪ
ΒͰͻ;ͽͬͻͰͷͰ
͵ͪͽͻͰ͵ͼͷ
ͫͰͰ
ͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͰͽͰͱi̽ͪͳͶ͵ͪͱͰ
ͯͯ;Ͱ
ͯͪΒͰͺͺͻͳͼͺͰΕ;ͷͽͳΒ;;̹ͪΔͼ͵;
;ͳΔͰtͼͬͰͫͳͽΒͰͺͲͪ͵ͼ͵ͷ;ͼͽͪͬ;iͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
;ͷͰͼͽͺͳͼͪ
Ͱ͵ͪͯͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͻͪͯͼͽͳ
ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͳͳͲͬͻͰͳ;ͯͰͼͪͪ͵ͺͶͪͭͪΔͪ
ͽͰͶͪ;ͻ͵ͬ;͊ͬͰͽͭ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͼͶͰͯͳͼͪͷ͵ͻͪͽ͵ͼͪͺͽͰΔͰt́ͽͪ͵ͺͻͰͯͪ
ͯͰͭͻͫ;ͪͼͳͫͶͪͱͰͽͰͶͬͭͪͫͶͪͭͪͼͽͳͬͭͪͳͻͳͼͽΓ;ͫͳͬͭͪͳ
ͺͻͰͬͳͼ͵ͭͪ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ͌ͻͪ́ͻͪͲͳΌͰͼͰͼͬͪ͵ͳͼͬΒΒ͵;Εͳi̻ͰͰ
ͻͪͳΒ;ͯͳΒͰ
ͺͼͶͰͯΔͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ͵ΒͪΒͰͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ
ͪ;ͳͲͬͻͳͷͪͺͬͼͰͲͫͳͶͪ;ͺͼ͵;ͻͳͷ͵Ͷͼͽͳͷͪ
ͺͻ;Ͳͻ͵ͬͪͳͷ
ͪͼͳͶͷͼͷͻΕ;͊ͽͰͿͪͪ̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ͊ͽͭͪͳΒͰͼͶ;ͪΒͽͽΒͰͽͳͻͪ
ͪͽͰ͵ΒͰͯͳͷͽ;ͻͳͷͳͼ͵ͪͲͷt͈ͻͰͰͼͰͫͳΔͰͭͬͽͰͶͪͼͯͻͳͼͽ
Γ;ͫͳͬͭͪͼͳͪΔͰͭͬͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ
ͳͺͶͱͳͰͭͪͪͼ;ͻ;͵ͽͬͻͰͷΔͰͭ
ͬͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;;ͻ͵ͬͳ̺ͪͲͰͼͰΔ̻ͪͼͺͯΔͰͭͪͷͰͼͽ;Ͳͬͪͷ̽Ͱͪͳi
́ͲͶͱͰͰͳΔͰͳͰͬͯͳͶͰͫͳͲͪ͵Γ;͵;ͯͪΒͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳBEWFOUVTSFMJRVJBSVNͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͺΒͪͬ;ͻͰͶͪͽͳͬ͵ͻͪͽ͵ͭͽͻͪΒͪΔͪ
ͬͰͲͪ;ͲͪͻͪͲͯͫΓͰͺͻͬͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ́ͲͭͶͰͯͪͪͷͰͼͺͻͯͪΒͰͲͪͼͶ;ͭͪͼͬͰ
ͽͭ͊ͪͬͰͽͽΒͰ;ͬͻͰͷͰͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͪͼͪͷͼͽͪͶͰͯͻͱͪͬͰͽͪͯͰͶͽͬͻͪͰͬͻͺ
ͼ͵ͪͳͯͰΒͪͺͼͽͪͶͪͼͪͯͻͱͳͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͺͻͭͻͪͷ͉ͪͪͲͶͲͳͲͫͭ͵Βͳ
ΒͰͫͻͰͯ;ͫͻͲͳͲͭ;ͫͳͪͬͪͱͼͽͳͼͳͭ;ͻͳͼ;ΒͰͯͼͽͪͬͳ͇ͫΒͪΔͰΔͪͫͳ
ͼͰͷͭͶͪͽͻͪͱͳͽͳ;ͰͼͺͼͫͼͽͳͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͪͯͪ;ͯͰͶͼͺͻͬͰͯ;ͬͳͼ͵ͷͯͰͶ
̽ ͈ͺͬͳΕ
̓;Ͷͽ ͵ͻͪΓͪ ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
m ͼͪ ͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ ͳ ͼͽͪͻͳΒͷ ͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
̽ͪͳͶ̽ͻ;ͭͳ
-PDDJU
͊ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͬͳͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ***̽Ͱͪͼ͵ͭ
JÓ͊͆*
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
̽ͪͳͶͬͳͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ
̽ͪͳͶͬ͌Ͱͳ͵
ͯͻ;ͭͳͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ̽ͪͳͶͬͭͲͫͻͳ͵ͪ ͺͻͳͻ
̻ͪͅ͵̽ͪͳΒͰͶ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
]]
̸̸̸̸͉͈̺͉͊͊̓̈́̽͊̓53"/4-"5*0̸̸͇͉͍̓͋́͌̈́͆́͠ͅ"%7&/564
͵ΒͳΒͰͫͪͬͰͲͳͬͪͳͶͳ;ͷͰΌ;ͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͳͷͼ;͵ͫͳͷͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͫͰͶͰͱͳͶͳͼͷͰͰ
ͪͺͻͰͼͽͶ;;ͽ͵;ͬͶͪͯͪͬͳͰͬͳͰͭͰͰͻͪͳΒͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ̀ͫͳͬͪΔͪͼͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͷͭ;ͽ;ͷͪͳͽͳͺͽͳͷͽ͵ͬͳͷͪͻͪͲͬΒͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͊ͫͲͳ
ͻͷͪͽͯͪͼͰͯͯͫͪ͵ͻͪΓͪͅͳͶ;ͽͳͪ͊ͻͫͳΒͪͺͻͰͯͰͶͳͶͪͲͪͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷ
ͽ;ͻͳͷͯͰͶ
ͺͻ͵Ͷͪͷ;Β;ΕͳͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͬͳͼ͵ͰͺͻͰͽͰͲͳΒͰ;ͬͪͼͰΓͰͼ͵ͷͺ
ͻͰͽ͵;́ͼͽ͵ͪ
ͺͰͶͪͼ;ͼͰ͵ͻͳͼͽͳͽͳͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͪͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪͯͪͫͳͼͰͫͻͪͲͶͱͳͶͪ
ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͪͺͻͳͻͯͪͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
;ͱΒͰͳͷͪͽͳ;
ͬͳͯ;ͯͪΒͰͳ;̾ͬͻͺͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͪͰͺͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ͵ͪͪͰͭͯͰ͵
ͼͻͰͯͳͰ9***ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ͵ͰͭͪͼͰͽͪͺͻͪ͵ͼͪ
ͳͲ;ͲͳͷͪΒ;Εͳ;Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵͍ͻͪ;ͼ͵;
ͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͻ;ͽͳͼ͵ͳ
ͫͰͲͼͬͰͱͳͳͯͰΒͪͳͳͲͬͻͭͳͯͰΒͭͿͻͷͪͽͪ
́ͺͪ͵
ͪͯͬͰͽ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ ͫͬΓͰ ΒͰ ͵ͯ ͊ͻͫͪ Β ΒͰͯͷ
; ͺ;ͷ ͫͳͷ;
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ ͺͻͰͼͪ ͷͽͳΒ; ͵ͰͲͪ ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ ͳͲ ͈ͻͳͽͳͰ ;
͉ͪͬͪͳ;͇ͱͳͬΓͪͬͪΔͰͫͻͰͯͪͫͳͶΒͰ;Ͳͻ͵ͬͪͺͽͻͰͫͪͷͪͽͻͰ;ͽ͵ͪ
ͯ
ͼͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪ;ͺͼͽ͵ͼͬͼ͵Β͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͼ;ͰΒͼͪ;ͭͻͱͰͷͯͻͱͪͬ
Ε;ͳͰͳͲͬͰͼͷͫ;ͯ;ΕΕ;͋ͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ͵ͰͲͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͶͪΒͰͼͬͰ
ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͰͰͽͪͺͰ
͵ΒͰͼ;ͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͰ;ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͷ͵ͰͲ;
̈́ͪͲͪͻ;͆ͪͻͳͽͺͯͻͫͺͳͼͪͰͼ;;͊Ͷͬ;͵ͰͲ;̈́ͪͲͪͻ;ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪ̽ͪ
ͳͶ̹ͪͪΔͼ͵ͭ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;͵ΒͳΒͰͳͷͪͱͳͽͳΒ;ͳͷͪͻͽͳͻͶ͵ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵;
Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;
͵ͪͳ͊Ͷͬ;ͰͺͲͪͽͭͺͳͼͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͫͳͼͬͰͯ͵̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͰͽͻͪ
ͼͶͪͳΒͰ ͈ͻͰͼ ͽͰͶͪ ͵ͰͲͪ ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ ͫͳ ΒͰ ͬͰͷͪ ͫͻͳͱΓͳͬ ͺͻͳͺͻͰͷΓͰ
͐ͳFMFWBUJPͷͽͳΒ;ͲͫͳͼͰ;ͺͻͳͽͳͼ͵Βͻ͵ͬͳ̺ͪͲͰͼͰΔ͎ͪͻͳͼͽͬͭ
;
ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ;ͪΒͬͳͳͶͳͼͽͳm͵ͰͭͳΔͰͅͳͶͳͰ
ͼͳͬͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪͳ̺;͵ͪ
͵ͪͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪͻ͵ͬͰ͆ͪ͵ͺͻͪͶͪͱͰΔͪtͰͶͭiͽͰͶͪͯͶ;͵;QSPGFDUJP
ͯͰΒͰtͫͭͼͳͼͪͫͻi͵Βͳͼ;ͳͳͶͳͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͳ
Ͱͺͳͼ͵ͺͳ
ͳͭ;ͷͪ
ͳͳͫͶͪͭͻͯͳ͈ͻͬͳBEWFOUVTͳPDDVSTVTͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͯͳͭͻͪͶͳͼ;ͼͰ;̹ͻͬͰ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͳ͵;ͅͽͳͷͪΒͰͳͲͪͪ;ͼͻͰͽͪΔͰ̺;͵̹ͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͼͺͻͯͳͷ
;ͺͻͪͽΔͳ
ͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͰ
ͪ͵Ͱͭͪͼ;;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͳtͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͺͶͪͳͻͳͯͪΔͰiͅͽͳͼ;ͺͻͰ
ΕͳͶͰ;͈ͪͬͶͳͳ
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳͳͫͻͪΕͰͅ;ͼͳΕ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳͼͰͼͽͻͳΕͪͳ͵ͼͬͼ͵ͳ
ͼͪͼͽͻͪͯͪͶͳ͵ͪ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͪͼͽͪͬͳͶͰͺ;ͽ͊;ͼͻͰͽͪΔͰͺͬͻ͵ͰͺͻͰ͉ͯͪͬͪͳͷ
ͫͳͶΒͰͬͰͷͪͼͬͰͪͪͰͻͰͷͳΒ͈ͪͻͰͯͷͱͳͷͪͻͯͪ
͵ΒͳͼͰ͵;ͺͳͼͪ
ͼͬͳ
ͺͪͳͯͪͶͰ͵ͳͼͽͻͪͪ
;ͲͺͪΓͰΔͰͼͬͰΕͪͳͽͪͷΒͪͪͳ;ͲͭͶͪͼͪͻͳͪΔͰ
ͺͬͻ͵;ͼ;ͺͻͰͯͬͯͳͶͳ̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳͼͳͬͳ͊ͽͰͿͪͳ̺;͵
͵ͻͪͪΒ;ΕͳͳͼͺͻͰͯ
͵ͬͰͭͪ̿ͳͬͳͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔͰͽͳͷͯͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪ
͵Βͳͼ;ͼͷͰͽͰ
ͳ;͵͵ͻͰͽͯͻͰΌͰͺͻͼͽͻͳͬͻͰͷͰ
ͽͻͰͫͪͽ;ͷͪͳͽͳͳΔͰͳͷͯͪͳ
ΒͰͺͳͼͪͰͬͳͯͪ̓ͪ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͳͷͭͳͷͯͻ;ͭͳͷͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͷͽͻͪ
ͼͶͪͳΒͪͷͪ
ͪͻͪͯͳͺͽͬͻͯͰͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽͳͼͬͰͯͰΔͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͪͳͷͳΒͰ
ͺͻͺ;ͼͽͳͯͪͪͭͶͪͼͳ͵ͪ͵ΒͰtͫͳͳͬͳͯͰi͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
;ͽͷͼͪͼͽͪͬ;
ͺΒͪͬΓ;Β;ͼͰͳͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͪͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪ
ͳΒͪΒͰͿ;͵ͳΒͪͫͳͶͪͯͪͺͻͰͯͰ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵;ͳͼͺͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶ;ͼ;ͽͳ;̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͭͺͻͰͼͪ͋ͪ͵ͬΒͰͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͪ
ͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͭ͠ͼͳͿͪ
ͪͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͳͯͰΒͪ͆ͬͷ́ͲͻͪͳΓ;
͵ΒͪͼͰ
;͵ͽͰ͵
ͼͽ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ
ͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽΒͪͬΓͪͪ͵͵;ͶͽͳͼͺͳͼͪͺͼͬͰΕͰͳ
͊ͳͷͰ;ͳ͊ͪͬͳ
̀ͪͬͻͳͳͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ͵ͰͲͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪͲͫͳͼͰ;͉ͪͬͪͳͳ͋;ͼ;ͳͲͬͻͰ
ͳTVTDFQUJͳJOHSFTTVTmͺͻͳͷͺͻͰͯͪΒͪͷͽͳΒ;
Δͳͬ;ͰΔͰ;ͻ͵ͬ;ͳ
ͺͶͪͭͪΔͰͪ͵ͻͪΒΔͰͯͻͰͯͳͽͰ
ͪ͵ͰͭͪΒͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;;ͼͽͪͬΓͰͺͻͪͲͳ͵
̻Ͷͪͬͳͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͪͻͪͬͪͳ͵ͭͪͯͬͰͽͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ͵ͰͭͳΔͪͅͳͶͳͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͪ
;ͯͬͳͪ͢ͰͳͭͰͼͽͬͳͳͪͻͳͪΔͰͪͯ͵ͳͬͽͷͪΒͫΓͰͺͳͼ;Β;͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ
ͰͻͰͷͳΒͰ͌ͷͰͼͽͰ͵ͪͯͪΔͰͭͼͶͪͬΓͪͳͶͳ͵ͬͪΔͪ
ͫͰͶͰͱͳͶBͼ;ΒͰͼͰΕͪΔB
ͽͰͼ͵ͫͰ
ͪΒͪͳͳͲͭ;ͫΓͰͭͼͶͪmͶͳͽͰͻͪͻͺͻͰͯͰBͬͷͬͻͼͽͷ
ͱͪͻͬͪ
ͪͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͺͶͪͰͷ͉ͪͬͪͳ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳBEWFOUVT
ͺͼͶͰͯΔͳ;
ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͫͬͳΒͰͺͻͰͯ;ͻ;ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͭͫͻͰͯͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͷ;ΒͰͫͳͽͳͲͷͰͳͼͷͳͼͪͳͿ;͵ͳΒ;͈ͻͷͰͪͼͰͷͱͯͪͪΒͫΓͰͭͶͰͯͪ
;ͺͬͷͯͻͰΌͳͬͪΔ;ͺΒͷͪͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪ͋ΒͰͼͪͯͪͺͫͰͯͪͯ;ͬͭͪͰͶͪ
ͳͼͬͰͼͪͱͻͽͬͪͲͪtͪͻͼͽͬͰͫͰͼ͵i͵ͪͽͰͷͰΓBͼͪͯͻͱͳB͵;Ͷͽͪͺͻͬͭͼͻͺ
ͼ͵ͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ
]]
̸͉̺͈͇͉͈͈͉͈̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͊͊̓́́͊͋͌͠
̸͉̺͈͇̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͠
͉͈͈͉͈͊͊̓́́͊͋͌
̸͉̺̓͌̈́͋̾̈́́̓́͠;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͵ͪͳͯͻ;ͭͯͰ;ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;
ͳͷͪΒͰͬͳͰͼͽͻͪ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;mͫͭͼͶ;ͱͫͰ;ͳͰͻͰͷͳΒͪͶ;
ͪͺ
ͽͻͺͰΒͼ͵;ͳͳͼͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵;͇ͼͳͷͼͬͰ
ͻͰͶͳͭͳͲͰͳͯ;ͬͰ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͼ;ͷͭͶͰͳͷͪͽͳͳͬͪͱ;ͺͶͳͽͳ͵;;Ͷͭ;̀ͪͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔͰͽͭͺͳͽͪΔͪͬͻͼͽ
ͷͰͽͯͶ͵;ͺͻͳͽͰͺͻ;ͱͪͰͪ͠ͳͻͭͰ͈ͪͰͽͰͻͼͪ͵ΒͷͻͰͲͳͷͳͻͪ
ͻͪͯͬͰ͵;ͺΓͰͰ;Ͳͫͻͳ͵;1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOHJN)PDINJUUFMBMUFS
͈ͰͽͰͻͼΒͰ;͵ͪͲͪͪͳΔͰͳ;ͯͪͼ;ͻͰͶͳͭͳͲͳͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͪͼͺͰ͵ͽ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͯͼͪͷͭͺͰͽ͵ͪͫͳͶͳͽͪ͵ͳͼͺͻͰͺͶͰͽͪͳͯͪΒͰͰͼͽͰͷͭ;ΕͰͻͪͲͯͬΒͳͽͳ
Δͳͬ;ͺͻͳͷͪͻ;ͳͼͰ͵;ͯͪͻ;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;͊ͷͪͽͻͪΒ;ΕͳͯͪͯͼͺͶͳͽͳ͵Ͱͳ
͵;ͶͽͪͽͻͰͫͪͳͲ;ͪͬͪͽͳ͵ͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵;ͺΒͪͬ;
͈ͰͽͰͻͼΒͰͳͼͽͪ͵ͪͯͪͼͰ͵;Ͷͽ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳΔͰͭͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͱͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳtͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͷi;͵Ͷͳ͵ͽͪ͵ͪͬ
͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͷͪΒ;ͻͪͲͶͲͳͲͫͭ͵ΒͳΒͰͪͼͽͪ
ͳΓͰͬͳ͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰͼͶ;ͱͳͳͺͻ;
͵Ͱ͵ΒͰΒͰͼͳ͋ͳͷ͵ͻͳͽͰͻͳΒ;ͷͷ
ͯͬΓͳͻ͵ͳͷ
ͪ;ΒͰͯͺͻͰͳͲͳͷ
ͻ;͵ͬͯͳͶͳͼͷͼͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͭͻͪΌͰ
̹ͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͬͰͷͪΒͰͫͳͷͪ͊ͪͷ;ͺͼͶͰͯΔΒͯͰͰͳΒͳͽ;ͺͻ
ͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ͵; ΒͰ ͪ ͼͳͽͰͽͳͪ ͪͳ ͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪͶ ͬͳͰ ;ͭͶͰͯͳ ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͪ " -BQQMF
3FMJRVJFO7FSFISVOH
(FTDIJDIUF
,VOTU
"VHTCVSH-FHOFS
3FMJRVJFOJO,VOTUVOE,VMU
(+$4OPFDL
.FEJFWBM1JFUZGSPN3FMJDTUP&VDIBSJTU
-FJEFO"OHFOFOEU
)FJMJHFVOE
3FMJRVJFO-FTSFMJRVFT͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳͬͳͼͼ͵;ͼͽͬͰͳ͵;Ͷ·ͽ;ͻͰͬͼͽͻͳͼͽͳͪͼ͵Pͭͷͳͻͪ͋Ͱ
ͲͳͼΆͯ͵ͶͪͯͬͳͷͪͽͰͻͳͪͶΆͷͰͱͯ;ͪͻͯͭͼͳͷͺͲͳ;ͷͪ
FË̸́ͅͳͯͬ
ͅͼ͵ͬͪ
͎ͻͳͼͽͳͪͼ͵ͳͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳͬͷͼ͵ͬͼ͵ͷ̓ͻͰͷͶͰ
FE"̈́ͅͳͯͬ
)WBO0T
ѮF 8BZ UP
)FBWFO3FMJDWFOFSBUJPOJOUIF.JEEMF"HFT
#BBSO
+1FUFSTPIO
1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOHJN)PDINJUUFMBMUFS&SHFCOJTTFVOE%FTJEFSBUF
JO
1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH
mͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͷͪͼͺͰ͵ͽ;͵;ͶͽͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪWͽͪ͵ΌͰ
(FBSZ
'VSUB4BDSB#4DIXJOFLÕQFS
$ISJTUVT3FMJRVJFO7FSFISVOHVOE1PMJUJL
#MÅUUFSGÛSEF
VUTDIF-BOEFTHFTDIJDIUF
+BISHBOH
m%3PMMBTPO
4BJOUTBOE3FMJDTJO"O
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͊ͳͭ;ͻ ͯͪ ͳΒͰ ͼͶ;ͪΒ ͽ ͽ ͼͰ ͺΒͪͬͪ ͳͯͰͶ͵ͳ Ͳͪͼͬͪͳ ͻͰ
Ͷͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳͺͯ;ͯͪͻͪͼͫͻͫͷͲͪͯͻ
ͱͪͬ;ͼͪͷͼͽͪͶͼͽͺͯͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͷ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ͵ͻͪΒͰͷ9**ͳͺͰͽ͵ͷ9***
ͬͰ͵ͪ͢ͳͬͯ;ͬͳͽͬͻͪͫͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ
ͪΒͷͶͪΌͳͼͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͬͰͶͳ
͵ͭͱ;ͺͪͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰͳͺͻͬͳͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ;ͽ͵ͰͿͪͶͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰ̓;Ͷͽ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪͳͼͺΓͳͼͰͪͯͬͪͼͬͪͪͳͪ͵ͻͲͽͬͪΔͰͺͽͰ
ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
;ͬͰͲͳͼͪΒͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͳΒͳͷͶͳͼͽͳͷͪͰͫͰͼ͵ͰͳΒͰ
ͻͪͻͳΒͰ
ͪͪͻͳͽ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ
ͳ͵ͪ͵;ͶͽͷͽͳΒ;ͪͳͪͶͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
͉ͪͲͷͽͻͳΕͰͷͪΒͺͻͰͺͻͬͳͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͺͻͫͶͰͷͪ͌ͯͼͪͯͪΔΒͪ;ͳͬͰΕͬͳ
Ͱͺ;ͽͪΒͰͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͯͪͼ;;ͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷ
ͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͷͼͬͰͽ;ͭͶͪͬͳͫΒͰ
͵ͪͽͽͬͪΔͪͫͳͶͰͳ͵Ͱ
ͯ͵ΒͰ͵;ͶͽͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͰͻͳͷ͵ͪͽͶͳ͵ͷ
̀ͪͺͪͯ;͋ͪ͵ͬͭͶͰͯͳͽͰͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰ
;ͺͻͳͳͺ;
ͳͺͫͱͪͺͻͪ͵ͼͪ;ͼͻͰͯ
ΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ́ͺͪ͵
͵;ͶͽͲͪͷͰͳͽͳͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͳͷͪΒͰ
ͬͪͱͷͰͼͽ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͺͻͭͻͪͷ;͊ͽͰͿͪͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
ͼͳͬͪͪͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
͵ͪͳΔͰͭͬͳͰͺͼͻͰͯͳͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͪ
ͅͰΌ;ΔͳͷͪͺͼͰͫͪͲͪͪΒͳͰͼͺͻ;ͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͺͶͳͽͳ͵;Ϳ;͵ͳ
Β;ͳͷͪΒͰ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ̓ͷͪͯͳΕͽͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
͵Β;ΒͰͺͻͰͽͯͼͳ͵
ͬͻͪͽͪͳ;ͲΔͰ;ͺͷΕͺͫͰΌͳͬͪͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͰ
͆ͰͷͪΔͪmͽͪͯͪͬͰΕͪͽͼ͵ͳ
ͷͪͺͯͳͷͰͷ͊ͳͷͰmͺͼͶͪΒͰͼͪ͊ͬͰͽͰ̻ͻͰͼͳ;͊ͽͰͿͪ;
ͺͻͬͷ
͵ͻ;ͳͼͪͷͼͻͺͼ͵ͷ͵ͻͪΓ;͌ͬͻͰͷͰͷͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͷͳͲͬͻ;m̿ͳͽͳ
Β;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰmͺͻͰͳͲΒͰͺͳͼͪͪͿ;͵ͳΒͪͽͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͵ͪ
ͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͭWFYJMMJVNͪ͋ͻͰͫͪͶΒͰͯͪͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͷ͵ͻͪΓ;ͳΔͰͭͬͳͷͺͽͷ
]]
̸͉̺͈͇͉͈͈͉͈̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͊͊̓́́͊͋͌͠
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ;ͻ;ͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͯͪͶΒͰͼͪͱͪͺͰͪͽͺͫͱͷͷͰͽͪͶͳͽͰͽ;
Ͷͳ
ͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵Βͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ
ͪͶͳͳΒͪͬͷͱͳͬͽ;ͳͯͻͱͪͬͳͷͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͪͷͪ͆Ͱ͵Ͱͯ
ͽͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͲͪͯͫͳͶͰͼ;ͼͽͪͽ;ͼͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳSFHBMJBͳͼͷͪͽͻͪͰͼ;ͼͳͷͫͶͷ
ͼͬͰͬͰΕͰͰ͵;ͷͰͼ͵Ͱ;ͶͭͰͻ;ͼ͵ͰͯͻͱͪͬͰͳͻ͵ͬͰ͊ͶͳΒͰͫͳͶͳͪ̀ͪͺͪ
ͯ;͋ͪ͵ΒͰ
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͻͳͲͳͪ̓ͪͻͶ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭ
ͪΒͻͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͳΒͪͲͫͳͻ͵ͪ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͬͭͬͻͰͷͰͪ
ͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͶͪͬͳͰͯͻͪͭͰͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ
ͷͰΌ;Δͳͷͪ
ͳͰͼͽͳͰ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͼ;ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͳͯͪΒͰ͵;Ͷͽ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ
ͯͫͳͪͲͪͷͪ;ͪ͵ͭͯͳͰ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͬͰΕͳͪͽͳͰͼͽͳͪͺͻͰͰͽͪͳͲ
͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͪͪ̀ͪͺͪͯ͌ͺͻͪͬ;ͽͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͷ
ͽͻͰͫͪͺͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͽͳͻͪͲͬΒ͵;Ͷͽͪ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
͋ͪΒ ͵;Ͷͽ ͯͫͳ ΒͰ ͪ Ͳͪͷͪ; ͳ ͼͽͰ͵ͪ ͺͻͪͬͳ ͳͯͰͶ͵ͳ ͵ͬͳͻ ; ͯͻ;ͭΒ
ͭͰͰͻͪͳΒͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ̀ͪͼͶ;ͭͪͲͪͽͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͪͬͳ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͷ̓ͪͯ
ͶͳͪͲͪͶͪͽͰͶ͵ͭͪ;͵ͪͳͺͫͱͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͭͼͬͰͽͪͳ
;Ͳ
ͽ
ͺͶͳͽͳͪͻͳͲ;ͲͰͽͳͼͺͼͫͼͽͳ
͊ͪͬͪΒͰͫͳͯͫͻ;ͺͲͪͽͼͷͭͳͷ
;ͯͽͬͻͳͷͼͬΒͼͽͬͳͷͪͽͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͈ͼͽΒͳͬͳͰͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ͵Βͳͺ͵ͪͲ;Β;
ͯͪΒͰΔͰͪ;ͺͽͻͰͫͪͫͳͶͪͺͯͼͽͪ͵;ͽͪͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͷͺͽͻͰͫͪͷͪ͆ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͳͼ
ͰͶͳͽͰΓͼ͵;ͷΕͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͊ͪͬͪΒͰͺͽͬͻͯͳͬͻͪΕͪΔͰͷ;ͱͳͬͽͫͶͰͼͭ͊ͽͰ
Ϳ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ;ͲͺͷΕͬͯͰͼͬͰΕͰͰ͐ͪͼͳͷ͵ͻͼͽͷ͊ͪͬͪΒͰͫͻͪͽ;
ͱͳͬͽͺͻͯ;ͱͳͪ͵ͻͪͽ͵
ͪͶͳͯͬΓͯͪͫͳͭͪͺͻͰͯͼͷͻͽͲͪͷͪͳͳ
ͻͭͪͳͲͬͪͪͼͶͰΌͳͬͪΔͰͺͻͰͼͽͶͪͪͺͻͺͳͼͪͪͳ͈ͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͳͳ
ͳΒͳΒͰͳΓͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͲͪͼͳͬͪΔͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͫͳͶΒͰ͊ͪͬͳͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ͎ͪͳͶͪͯͪͻͪͼͽͪͬͻͽͰ͵ͷͼͪͰͼͽͳͷ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ͵Β;
ΒͰͯͫͳͯͪͻͪͬͪͪ͠***̺ͪͽͪͪ͆ͪͽͪΒͪͳͺͯͲͪͽͳͽ;ͪΒͬͰΕͰͻͳ
Εͪͼ͵ͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰͼͽͪͬΓͰΒͰͯ;ͬͼͻͰͯͳͽͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͪ͊ͬͰͽΒ̻ͻͳ
͵ͪͽΒͰͽ;ͻͪΌͰͳ;͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ
ͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͷͼͻͰͯͳͽ;;ͷͪͽͳͳͷ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͲͰͷΓͪͷͪ
]]
̸͉̺͈͇͉͈͈͉͈̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͊͊̓́́͊͋͌͠
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
;ͲΒ;ͱ;ͺͰͬͳ;͋ͰͼͶͳ͵ͰͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͳͼͽΒͳͯͰΒΒͼͿͰͻͳ͵ͪͳͽͰͶ͵ͪ
ͼͬͪͽͪΔͪ͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ
͵Βͪͼ;ͯ;ͫ͵ͺͻͱͰͽͪͺͻͷͳΓͪΔͰͷ͎ͻͳͼͽͬͰͳͼ
͵;ͺΓ;Β;ΕͰͼͷͻͽͳ͆ͪͻͳͽͪͬͻͼͽͪͺͫͱͼͽͳ
ͼͫͰͪͲͪ͵ͻͪΒ9**ͳͺͰͽͪ͵
9***ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵Β;ͯͶͳ͵;ΒͰͼͪͱͪͳͰͷͺͪͽͳͪ͵ͽͰͷͺͶͪͳΒ͎ͪͻͳͼͽͬͳͼͽͻͪ
ͯͪΔͪ
ͳͭͶͰͯΒͰͳͷͪͶͪ͵ͻͰͪͽͳͬ;ͻͰͰͺͳΒ;;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ
̀ͪͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪΔͰͰͶͳͰͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͼͽͬͪͻͰͰ;̿ͳͳͯͼ;ͽͳͼ͵ͰΒͰͬͪ
ͱͼͽͳͼͪͯͻͱͳͪΔͰͰͻͳͲͳͰ́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͼ;ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͪͯͪͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͽͭͻͪͭͪ
ͺͬͰͲͪͰͼͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͳͷͶͳͼͽͳͷͪͰͫͰͼ͵ͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
ͪͼͪ͵;
ͺΓͰͰͪͷͰͼͽ;ͼͪͼͽͪͽ;ͼͷMPDVTSFHBMJT
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͰͺͻͷͳΓͰ;ͰͶͳ;
ͼͶΒͰͬͳͽͭͲͪͰΔͪͳͿ;͵ͳΒͰ͆ͪΒͺͻͰ
ͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳ
Βͪ
ͬͰͲͪͳͲ͎ͪͻͳͼͽͪ
̹ͭͻͯͳ;ͳ͈ͻͰͽͰ;
ͳͲͶͱͰΒͰͰͶͬͳͽͺͻͭͻͪͷ
ͳ͵ͷͳΒͰ ͼͺͪͼͰΔͪ
͵ͻͲ ΔͰͭͬͰ ͭͶͪͬͰ ͯͭͷͪͽͼ͵Ͱ ͳ tͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱi ͰͽͪͺͰ
ͬͪͺͶΕͰΔͰͳ͵ͻͽͰΔͰ
ͼͽͻͪͯͪΔͰͳͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͯͼͷͻΕ;͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͪͺͼͽͶͪ
ͫͳͶͰͼ;ͺͪ͵;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳͳͯͰΒͰͪͺͼͽͶͼ͵ͷͺͻͰΒͰͷͼͽͬ;
ͽͰͼ;ͼͽͭͪͳͷͪͶͰ
ͪͭͶͪͰͰ͵ͶͳͼͳͶ͵ͳͼͷͳͼͪ͊ͫͲͳͻͷͪͳΔͰͳ;ͯͪΒͰ̿ͳͪͫͳͶͪ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͪͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͳ͵ͻ;ͳͯͫͰͪͻ͵ͬͪ
ͺͼͽΒͰͬͻͼͽͳͻͪͲͶͲͳͲͪ;ͬͰͻͰ
ΔͰͯͪͼ;ͺͷͰ;ͽͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͶͰͼͿͰͻͳͯͻͱͪͬͰͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵Ͱ͇Ͱͼ;
ͺͼͬΒͺͻͳͶͳͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͰͺͻͽͽͳͺJOTJHOJBSFHBMJBͺͻͬͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
́ͲͬͰͼΒͰ
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻ
ͯͪͼ;͆ͰͷͪΔͳ͵ͺΓͰͳͺͰ͵ͽͻͪͶͼͪͰͼͽͳͷ͐ͪ
ͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͳͷͪͶͳͳͼͳͭͶ͵ͲͪͰΔͰ
ͫͪ͵ͪͳtͼͬͰͽͳͬͰͪi
ͽΒͰͼͽ
͵ͻ;ͪ͵ΒͷΒͰͬͰͪͺͻͬͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ͵ͻͪΓ͊ͽͰͿ͉ͪͰͳͽΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ
;͵ΒͰͷͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͳͲͬͻͳͺͷͳΔ;Ͱͼͽͳ;͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͽ;ͼͰ
ͺͻͰͯͳͼͪͼͽͪͻͲͪͬͰͽͳͷ͵ͻͪΓͰͷ̽ͪͬͳͯͷͳ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͷ̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳͷ
ͳͷͰ
ΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͺͺͻͳͷͳͶͪͪͭͶͪͰͳͯͰͶ͵ͲͪͰΔͰ
ͯͼͺͶͳͽͳ͵;
ͼͬͻͬͳͽͼͽ̸ͪͶͳͲͪͳͬͰͽͪͻͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͻͳͲͳͪͺ
͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͯͪͼ;Ͱ
͵ͪͳͱͳ͵ͪ
ͺͼͰͯͬͪͶͰͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ;ͬͰͲͳͼ͎ͻͳ
ͼͽͷ
̹ͭͻͯͳͷ
ͬͪ͠ͷ͈ͻͰͽͰͷͳͪͺͼͽͶͳͷͪ͋ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͯͫͻ
ΒͰͺͲͪͽ
ͳͷͪͶͰͼ;ͳͿ;͵ͳΒ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳJOTJHOJB
ͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽͳ
]]
̸͉̺͈͇͉͈͈͉͈̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͊͊̓́́͊͋͌͠
ͼͬͰͽ͵ͺΓͰmSFHBMJTMBODFB͋ͪ͵ͬͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͼͪͯͻͱͳͪͻͳͲͳͰ̓ͪͻͶ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭͳ
ΔͰͭͬͳͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͪ
͵ͪͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͳͽͻͰͲͻͪ͌ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͈Γͼ͵Ͱͳ͐Ͱ͵Ͱ
͌ͼΒͪΒΒͭͽͳ͵ΒͳͼͰͪͳΒͳͰͼ;ͫͳͶͰͳͲͶͱͰͰ;4BJOUF$IBQFMMF̈́;Βͪ*9
͊ͬͰͽͭͭͫͅͻΒͪͼ;ͳͬͰͷͪ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪ͵Βͪͺ͵ͪͲ;Β;ͯͪ
ͼ;ͯͻͪͭͰͰͲͫͳͻ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͵ΒͰͼ;ͼͰͽ͵ͷͬͰ͵ͬͪͿͻͷͳͻͪͶͰ;͉;ͼͳΒͳ
ͳͷͪͶͰͰͼ;ͷΔͳͬͳͯͰͶ͵ͳͼͷͳͼͪͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;͊Ͷͳͪͺͻͪ͵
ͼͪͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͪΒͰͳ;ͰͺͼͻͰͯͷͼͻͺͼ͵ͷͼ;ͼͰͯͼͽͬ;
;̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵Β͋ͪͷ
ͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͷͪͶͰͬͪͱ;;Ͷͭ;ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͫͻͪͲͬͪΔͪͯͻͱͪͬͳͼͻͰͯͳͽͪ
mͪΒͺͻͰ͊ͪͷ;ͳͶ͈ͬͭͪͻͰͼͺͳ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷ;͋ͻͬ;
ͺͻͰͼͽͳͳ̽ͻ;ͭͭͫ;
ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͪͻͼͽͬͪ͆ͰͽͻͰͫͪͺͼͰͫͪͭͶͪͪͬͪͽͳͯͪΒͰͲͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͳͺͻͽͽͳͺ
ͽͳͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͲͫͳͻ͵ͪͷͪͫͳͶͪͻͳͲͳͪͪͻͼ͵ͰͺͪͶͪͽͰ;͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯ;
͵ΒͪͼͰ
ͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ;ͻ͵ͬͳ̹ͭͻͯͳͰ͍ͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
͈ͺ;ͽͺͷͰ;ͽͳͻͳͲͳͪ
ͽͪ͵ΒͰͳͪ;̿ͳͳͼͳͶͪ;ͼͰͫͳΒͪͼͳͼ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ;ͳͯͰΒ;͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ;ͳ͊ͬͰͽΒͲͰͷΓͳ
͵ΒͪΒͰ;̾ͬͻͺͳͼͽͰ͵Ͷͪͭͻͷ;ͺ
ͺ;Ͷͪͻͼͽͪ͵͵ͻͼͽͪ͵ͳͻͪͽͬͪ́ͲͶͪͭͪΔͰͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͵ΒͰͼ;ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͶͰ
ͭͶͪͬͳͷͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͳͷͪΒͰͬͪΌͰͼ͵ͳͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ;ͺͻͼͽͻ;ͻͪͷͪͼͽͬͪͻͪ
ΒͰͺͼͰͫͪͪͷͫͳΒͰͽ
ͬͳͯͰͬ͵ͪͳΒͰͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͰͽͺͭͻͪͿͳΒͰ͊ͬͰͽͰͲͰͷΓͰ͇ΒͰ
ͬͰͻͳͷͪͷͭ;ΕͪͬͪͯͪͼͳͷͫͶͳͳͪͰͷͺͪͽͳͪͪͳ;ͳͰͯͪΕͰ
ΔͰͳͷͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͷͪ͋ͪͳͯͰΒͪUSBOTMBUJP)JFSPTPMZNJͰͼͽΒͰͫͳͶͪͰͺͼͻͰͯ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͬͰͲͪͪͼͳͯͰΒͷUSBOTMBUJPJNQFSJJ
ͽͰΒͰͽͪ͵ͫͳͶͪͬͪͱͪͳͳͶͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ
ͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͈ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪͽͪ͵ͬͭ
ͪΒͬͳͰͭͻͪ
ͭͪͽͻͰͫͪͶΒͰ
ͼΒͰͯͰͼͽͻͪͰ
;ͼͺͼͽͪͬͳͽͳͼͳͷͫͶͳ;ͬͰͲ;ͼΒͰͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͼ͵ͷ
ͪͅΒ͵ͷͻ͵ͪͬͪͳ
ͼͪͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͼͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͭͻͪͯͷ̓ͼͽͪͽͳͺΓͰͷͳΔͰͭͬͷ
ͼͬͰͽͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͷ̀ͪͷͰͳͽͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͭͺͻͰ͵ͶͪͼͽͭͪͼͰͼͬͪ
ͽͪΒ;͵ͪͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͳͺͻͰͼͽͳͰ
ͪͪ͵ͺͪͯͪ͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͪͳ͵ͪͲͪ͵ͪͼ;͵Ͱͼͳ
ΒͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ
͊ͽͭͪͼͰͷͱͰͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͯͪΒͰ;̿ͳͳͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͽͬͪͻͰ
ͳͯͰͶ͵ͳͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͪΒͬͳͳͺͻͰͽͰͲͳΒͪ͢ͰͭͬͼͬͳͳΓ
ͫͳͶΒͰͪͼͽΒͪΔͰͯͪͼͰ;ͼͻͺͼ͵;ͼͻͰͯͳ;ͺͻͰͰͼͰͫͻͪͲͪ͊ͬͰͽͰͲͰͷΓͰͳͪ
ͽͪΒͪͳͺͶͱͰͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͳͽͰͷͰΓͳͬͼͽͬͻͰΒͯͻͱͪͬͳ́ͯͰΒͪΒͰ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ͵ͻ;ͱͰͪ͵ͪͯͪͼ;;̿ͳ;ͺͻͰͰͽͰͷͽͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰͪͭ͆ͪ͵ͳͲ
ͬͻͰͭͫͻͰͯͪUSBOTMBUJP͊ͽͰͿͪͬͽͰͶͼͽͰ͵ͶΒͰͼͽͪͽ;ͼͬͪͱͰͪͳͪͶͰ
ͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
͵ΒͪΒͰͺͻͳ͵Γ;ͰͪͲͪͷͰͳͽͳͷ
ͺͽͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪ
ͱͳ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰ͇ͯͽͭͯͫͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͳͼ;ͼͰ
ͺͺ;ͽͯͻ;ͭͳͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
͵ͻ;ͳͼͪͶͳͪͯͼͬͰͽͳͷͽͰͶͷͼͬͭͻͯͪͰͶͳ͵͈ͪͻͰͷͪͷͰͻͳͶͳͷͪ
ͬͻͰͷͰͪ
ͽΒͰͲͪͳͶͯͪͼͰͺͬͰͼͽ͊ͻͫͪ
͵ͪͬͭͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͭ
tͳͲͪͫͻͪͭ
ͪͻͯͪi
;͵Γ;ͳͶͪ;ͽ͵ͬͰͼͬͰͽͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰ
̿ͳ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͫͳΒͰͫͶͳͼͽͪͬ
ͪͶͳ͵ͻͪͽͪ͵;ͲͶͰͽ͊ͰͯͳͽͰ
̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͳΒͰͺͼͽͻͪͯͪͶΒͰ;ͯͻ;ͭΒͺͶͬͳͳ9***ͬͰ͵ͪͳͺͻͰͰͽΒͰ
͵ͪ
ͳΔͰͭͬͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
;͈ͰΕ͌ͪͻͰͯΒͰͺͳ͵;ͶͽͪΒͺͽͬͪͳΒͳͻͳΕͪ
ͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͳΒͰͼͰͳͲͭ;ͫͳ
ͪͶͳͳͯͰΒͳͿͻͷͪͽͱͳ͵ͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪͳΒͰ
ͺͬΓͰ̺ͰͶͳ͵ͳ;ͭͶͰͯͳͭͶͰͯΒͰͳͷͪ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ͌ͺͳͼͪͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪ
ͽͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͰ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
ͺͷͳΔͰ;ͬͰͲͳͼͬͶͪͯͪͻͳͷͪ
ͰͽͻͰΌͰ;ͬͰͲͳͼ
ͻ͵ͬͰͳͷͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͳͷͪͳͶͳ
;ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͺͲͭͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͳͷ
ͶͪͬͳͷͪͺͶͰͷͼͽ͈ͬͪͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͳͬͶͪͼͽͳͳͲͯͪͬͪͶͳͼ;ͼͬΒͰͺͬͰΓͰͲͪ͵Ͷͳ
Δ;ΕͳͼͰͪ͐ͪͼͳ͵ͻͼͽ
ͪͯͻͪͭͰͰͰͼͽͳͰͺ͵ͶͪΔͪͶͳͼ;ͼͬΒͳͷͲͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪ
ͷͪͳͶͳͰ͵ͳͷͪͻͳͽ;ͭͶͰͯͳͷͻ͵ͬͪͷ͈ͪ;ͲͯͪͼͰͲͪͯͪͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ;
ͺͼͰͯͬͪͶͳ͊ͺΕͪͳ
̽Ͱͪͳ
ͅͳͶͰͰͬͪ
͊ͬͰͽͳ͈Ͱͽͪͻ;͉ͪͼ;
ͪͬͰͻͬͪͽ
ͳͯͻ;ͭͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳ͈ͼͬͰͯͰͪΒͰͳͺͻͪ͵ͼͪͯͪͼͰͰͼͽͳͰ͐ͪͼͭ
͵ͻͼͽͪͯͪͻ;Β;ͼͬͰͽͭͻͼ͵ͳͷͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳͷͪ̽ͰͶͳΕͳͽͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ;ͬͪͳͼ;;
]]
̸͉̺͈͇͉͈͈͉͈̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͊͊̓́́͊͋͌͠
ͼ͵;ͺͰͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳͷͪͼͽͪͬͻͽͰ͵ͪͷͪ
ͯ͵ΒͳΒͰͯͯͪͪͼͼͽͪͶͼͪ;
ͬͪͼͪͷͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ͵ͪ͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͼͬͰͯͺͲͭͼͻͰͯΔͰͭ
ͬͰ͵ͪͳ͵ͻͪΒͪͯͻͱͪͬͼͽͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ;ͯͷͰ;ͺͪͽͻͪͱͰ
ͬͯͰΕͳͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͯͻ;ͽͬͪͳ
;ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͼͬͰͽͬͰͳ
ͯ;ͬͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ
͌ͺͻͬΒͺͶͬͳͳ97ͬͰ͵ͪ
;ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͺͼͽΒͪΔͪͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱͯͻ
ͱͪͬͰ
ΒΒͰͯͷΒͰ;ͳΔͰͺ͵;ͪΒͯͪͼͰͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͺͻ͵Ͷͪͷ;ΒͰ
ͺͻͭͻͪͷͬͳͼ͵ͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͺͻͰͽͰͲͳΒͪ̀ͫͳͶͼͰͽ;ͬͻͰͷͰͯͰͼͺͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪ
ͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͰͬͳΕͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ̹ͯͰͭͻͪͯͪͼͽͬͻͳͼͬΒ;ͬ;ͺͻͰͼͽͳ;̀ͪͼͪͷ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵ͭͯͳͪ
͵Ͷͳ͵ΒͰͽͻͪΒͪͽͪΒͺͯ;ͬͪͽ
̹ͰͭͻͪͯΒͰͯͫͳͰͼͪͷ
ͻͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͪͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͶͳ͵ͬͰΕͳͬ
ͺͻͷͳΓͰͼͽͬͻͰͯ;ͬͳ
ͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ͈ͳͼͪͳͳͲͬͻͳͰͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ;ͷͰͼͽͪͼ;ͷΔͳ;ͽͯͪΒͰͺͻͰͼͽͳͪ
ͯͰͼͺͽͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪͲͪͷͳΓͰͪ͵ͪͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͳͺͻͼͽͻͳΒͳΒͰͺͻͪͬͳͷͯͰͶͫͳ
ͳͯͰͪͶͳͭͻͪͯm͆ͬͳ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ͋ͪΒͺͻΒͰ͵ͪͽ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰͬͰͷͪͼͶͱͰͳͷͼͻͰͯ
ͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͫ;ͬͪͽͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͶͭ
ͺͻͳ͵;ͺΓͪΔͰͬͻͰͯͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͢ͳ
ͬͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰͪͿ;͵ͳΒͪͯ;ͬͭͽͳͽͪͳ;ͯͽͬͻͳͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͳͷͪͶͪΒͰ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳͪͻͳͽ;ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͼͽ;ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͪͷͪͼͬͰͬͰΕͰͭͽͷͪͼ͵ͭͪ
ͯͳͻͪΔͪ͋ͪ͵ͼ;;̹ͰͭͻͪͯͳͲ̺ͳͯͳͪͺͻͰͰͽͰͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͳͪͻͳͰ
͋ͰͿͪ
ͪͺͻͳͫͪͬΓͰͪΒͰͳͳͲ;ͲͰͽͬͻͰͯͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͪmͻ;͵ͪͪͻͪ̓ͼͽͪ
ͽͳͪ
͵ΒͪͼͰ
;ͼ͵;ͺͰͷͻͳͭͳͪͶͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;
ͯͪͪͼ;ͬͪ;ͷͼ͵ͬ
ͼ͵ͷ̓ͻͰͷΓ;͇ͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͰͼͪͷͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͯͻͱͪͬͰͬͰΕͳΔͰͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ
ͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷ;ͰͰͽͺͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͻͰΌͰ͵ͪ͆ͬͳ̓ͼͽͪͽͳ͈ͼͶͰͯ
Δͳͺ͵;ͪΒͯͪͼͰ;ͲͺͷΕͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͯͻͱͪͬͪͼͺͪͼͰͯͺͻͺͪͼͽͳͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰΒͰ
ͭͯͳͰ͋ͪͯͪΒͰ
ͪͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬ;ͯͰͼͺͽ͚ͪ;ͻΌ̹ͪͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͪ
ͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͭ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
;ͺͻͰͼͽͳ;͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͺͻͰͰͽͽͰͶΒͰͬͪΌͰͶͳͼͽͰ̈́;͵Ͱ
̹ͳͶͪΒͰͽͬͰͷͪͼͬͰͪͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪ
ͺ͵ͻͪΒΔΒͼͬͻͼͳͰ͵ͼͺͶͳͳͽͺͶͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
̸͉̺͈͇͉͈͈͉͈̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͊͊̓́́͊͋͌͠
Ͷͪͬͪͱ;;Ͷͭ;;̓ͳΒͰͬͼ͵Β͉;ͼͳΒͳ
ͪΔͰͪtͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͪiͿ;͵ͳΒͪͯͶͪΒͰͯ
ͺ;ͭͳͲͻͪͱͪΒͪ;͵;Ͷͽ;͵ͰͱͰͬͪͷ;Ͱͳ͵̹ͪͻͳͼͪͳ̻ΓͰͫͪ́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͼ;
;͵ͪͲͪͶͳͪͳΔͰͳ;ͯͪΒͰͳͻͰΔͰΔͳͬͭ͵;ͶͽͪͫͳͶͪΒͼͪͱͳΒͰ;ͬͻͰͷͰ
ͽͪͽͪͻͼ͵ͰͪΒͰͲͯͰ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;ͯͪͽͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ͵Ͷͼͽͳͺͯͼͽͪ͵ͶͰͻ;ͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͰ
ͪͽͯͪͼͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͺͻͳͷͰͻͺͻͬͳͻ;ͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͬΓͱͻͽͬ;Β;Ͳͪ͵ͳΒͰͬ
ͼ͵;ͯͻͱͪͬ;͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͫͳΒͰ͵Γ;ͳͳͳͶͪͬͶͪ
ͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰͳͪͳͪͶͰͳͽͰͭͻͪͳΒͰ;ͳͲ;ͲͰͷͪΓͪͲͪͺͪͯͰ
ͼͰͬͰͻͰ
ͳͰͽͻͪͶͰ̾ͬͻͺͰ͌ͳͻͰΔ;ͽͭ͵;ͶͽͪͺͻͰͼ;ͯ;;Ͷͭ;ͳͷͪͶͰͼ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ
ͷͽͳ
͵ͪͳͫͻͰͯͳ;ͬͰͲͳͼΔͳͬͳͷͽͬͪΔͰͷ
͌͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͲͪͼͶ;ͭͷͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
ͽͪΒͺͻͭͻͪͷ
;ͳΒΒΒͰͼͬͳͫͳ͵
ͰͺͽͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͷͪͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͺͻͷͬͳͼͪΒͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ;ͬͻͽͰΔͪ͊ͳͷͰ
ͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
ͻͯͪͰͶͳ͵ͪͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ
;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰͳͽͪͯͪΒͰͫͳͬͪͱͪͽͰ
͵ͬͳͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ̺ͰΕͽͪͯͪΒͰ͵;ͶͽͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͫͳͺͯͻͫͻͪͲͻͪΌͰ;ͼͬͳͷͫͳͽͳͷͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪmͽͰͶ͵ͳͷ
Ͷͳͽ;ͻ
ͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͷͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͷ͌ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͺͻͪ͵ͼͷ;ͫͳͪΒͰͷ;ͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;
͵;Ͷͽ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰͫͳΒͰͻͰͲ;Ͷͽͪͽͼͽ;ͺΔͰͬͳͽͭͳͼͶͱͰͭͺͻ
Ͱͼͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͫ;ͬͪͽͪͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͰͽͪͺͪͳͷͪͰΔͪ
ͺͯͳͷͰͷ͊ͳͷͰ
ͳ;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͰYFOJUJBͰ
ͽΒͰͼͽͱͳͬͽ;ͪͼ͵ͰͲͳͪ͊ͬͰͽΒ̻ͻͳͼͷͻͽͳͺͻ
ͬͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ;ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͎ͳͶͪͯͪͻ;
͵ΒͰΒͰ
ͷͱͯͪ
ͫͳͶ
ͺͻͪΕͰͷͳͻͽͰΔͰͷ͵ͪΒͰͯͳͷͯͪΒ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͳΒͳͲͪͷͰΔͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
tͺͻͪͶͪͱͰΔͰiͷͽͳΒ;
ΔͳͬͺͻͰͼ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͳͺͶͪͭͪΔͰͽͰͶͪ;͊ͳͷͰ
ͬ ͷͪ;ͲͶͰΒ ; ͊ͽ;ͯͰͳͳ ͵ͪ ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͪ
ͺͻͪΕͰ
ͷͳͻͽͰΔͰͷͳ;ͯͳͷͪ͌ͽ͵;ͽͭͺͻͰͼͪͺͼͽͰͺͰͼ;ͼͽͬͪͻͪͳͪͭͳͶ
"1PQQF
1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOHJOEFS,JFWFS3VT%FSBQPTUFMHMFJDIF)FSSTDIFSVOE
TFJOF.BSUZSTÕIOF
JO1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH
m̾ͅͻͪ͵ͬͪ
͊ͪͷʹͶͬͪ
PQ
DJU
m
3'PM[
-FTTBJOUTSPJTEVNPZFOÄHFFO0DDJEFOU 7*Fm9**FTJÍDMFT
#SVYFMMFTWͳͻͪͯ
ͬͰ + &IMFST 1PMJUJL VOE )FMJHFOWFSFISVOH JO 'SBOLSFJDI
m
& )PGGNBOO
1PMJUJTDIF
)FJMJHFJO4LBOEJOBWJFOVOEEJF&OUXJDLMVOHEFSESFJOPSEJTDIFO3FJDIFVOE7ÕMLFS
m
"
(JFZT[UPS 1PMJUJTDIFJNIPDINJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFO1PMFOVOE#ÕINFO
m
(,MBOJD[BZ ,ÕOJ
HMJDIFVOEEZOBTUJTDIF)FJMJHLFJUJO6OHBSO
m
JO1PMJUJL VOE )FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH+MF
(PĒ
4BJOU-PVJT
1BSJT
ͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ̽;ͪͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ
ͺͼͰͫͪͼͽͻm
͇ͺͻͰ͵Ͷ;ͳͻͪͲͬΒ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ͵;Ͷͽ̻ͬͪͶ;ͫͳͼ͵ͳʹ
́ͼͽͻͳΊ͵ͪͳͲͪͳͳͼͬΊ
ͽΆ·)%FMFIBZF
-FTPSJHJOFTEVDVMUFEFTNBSUZST
#SVYFMMFT/)FSSNBOO.BTDBSE
-FTSFMJRVFTEFTTBJOUT%VWBM
"VQSÍTEFTTBJOUTDPSQTFUÄNF.,BQMBO
%FMBEFQPVJMMFÆMBSFMJ
RVFGPSNBUJPOEVDVMUFEFTTBJOUTÆ#Z[BODFEV7FBV9**FTJÍDMF
JO-FTSFMJRVFT
m
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͵Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͳ
͵Βͳͼ;ͯͫͳͶͳ͵ͪ;Ϳͻͷ;;ͯͬͪ͊ͳͷͰͬͪ
ͱͳͽͳΒͪͳ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳͼͬͰͽͷ͊ͳͷͰ;͋ͪ͵ΌͰ
ͯͼͪͷͭͺͰͽ͵ͪͭͻͪΌͰΔͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͼͪͱΒͰͫͳͶͪͪͭͶͪͰͪΔͰͭͬͪͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͪͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͪͿ;͵ͳΒ͇ͪͪΒͰ
ͳͳͶͪΒͰͲͭͻͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͳͳͷͪͶͪΒͰͯͶ;;Β;Ε;;Ͷͭ;;
ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔ;͵ͰͺͽͪͼͬͰͽͭͻͯͪͰͶͳ͵ͪͳͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪͯͻͱͪͬͰ
̓;Ͷͽͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪΒͰͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͫͳͽͳͰͶͰͷͰͪ
ͽͪ͆ͪΒͺͻͰ
ͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͺͻͳͷͰͻ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͪͻͼͳͺͯͳͲͪͶͳͼ;
ͼͰͫͳͺͼͰͫͰͭͻͫͰͻ͵ͬͰͳ;ΔͳͷͪͺͻͳͺͻͰͷͪͶͳͻͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͰͭͻͫͬͰ
ͪͅ;ͲͶͰΒͳ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͳͼ;ͫͳͶͳͼͪͷͳͯͳͬͳͯ;ͪͶͰͬͰΕͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͰͳͶͳ
ͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͰNFNPSJBF͇ͳͼ;
͵ͪͪΒ;ͭͶͰͯͳΒͳͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳͼͬͭͯͫͪ
ͪ
;Ͳͽ
ͳͼͻͰͯͳͽͪͺͻͼͬͰΕͰͼͽͳͳ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
ͫͳͶͳ͵ͻͰ;ͽͳͪΒͳͻͳͷͳͽͰͻͰͼͳͷͪ
ͯͻ;ͽͬͰͰͲͪΒͰͯͳͰ͌ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳͪͻͼͽͬ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͶ
ΒͰ
͵ͪͳͯͻ;ͭͯͰ;ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽ;
;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͷͬͻͶͳͪͷͪͳͯ;ͱͼͽͳͷͪ
ͳͯͰͪͶͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ͌ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳͽͪ͵ͬͰͲͪͼͶ;ͭͰͳͭͶͰͯͼ;ͫͳͶͰͬͰͷͪ
ͬͳͼ͵ͰΔͰͰ
ͺͪͼͰͼͽͭͪͷͭ;ͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͬͪͱͳͷͰͶͰͷͰͽͷͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰ
ͶͭͳΒͰ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ
͈ͺ;ͽͼͶͳͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͪ;ͲͶͰΒͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳͰ͆Ͱͷͪ
ΔͳΕͪͫͳͶͰͼ;ͼͳͳͳͯͰΒͰͯͻͱͪͬͼͽͳͳͼͻͰͯͳͽͪͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵Ͱͺͻͺͪͭͪ
ͯͰ͋ͪ͵ͪͬͼͽͪͽ;ͼͫͰͲͫͰΌͳͬͪͶͰͼ;ͳͷ
ͪͺͻͬͷͷͰͼͽ;
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͳͬͶͪ
ͯͪͻͪ͵ΒͰͼ;;Δͳͷͪ;ͬͪͰͅͽͳͼ;ͫͳͶͰͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͳͳͯ;ͬͳͿ͵;ͼ
͵;Ͷͽͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͇ͪͰͼ;ͺͳͬͪͶͰ;ͻͪͼ͵ͳͷ͵ͳͬͽͳͷͪ
ͼͷͰͽͰͳͷͪͺͪͼͷͷͰͼͽ;
ͳͼͺͻͰͯͳ͵ͼͽͪͼͪ͋;ͼ;ͫͳͶͰͺͻͰͰͰ
ͪ͵ͽͫͳͼͰͫΒͪͬͳͶͰ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͰ
ͳͲͭͻͫͪ;ͲͪͺͪͯͷͽͻͪͬͰΒ;ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͫͰ
ͶͰͱͰͭ ͼͪͻ͵Ϳͪͭͷ ͋ͪ͵ ͼ; ;ͺ͵ΒͰͳ ͬͶͪͯͪͻͳ
ͳ ͻͰͪͶ ͳ ͼͳͷͫͶͳ
ͺͻͰͶͪͲͳͶͳͺ;ͽͯͲͪͺͪͯͪ͵ͪͳͼͽ͵;͋ͪΒͻͳͽ;ͪͶͳͺͻͰͼͺͳͬͪΒͰͪͳΒͰ
ͻͪͽͼ͵ͷͼͬͪͽͪΔ;ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭͺͻͼͽͻͪͻͪͷͪͳ;ΔͰͷ;ͼͰͭͶͰͯͪͳͲͷͰΔͰ
ͼͽͪͽ;ͼͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͽͰͶͪͪ͵ͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͪ͆ͪͳͷͰ
;ͺͻͬͫͳͽͷͭͻͫ;ͪ
ͼ;ͺͽͬͪͪ͵ͪͲͰͷͳͼͽͪͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪ
ͪ;ͯͻ;ͭͷ
ͺͻͳͷͪ͵;ͽͷͶͽͪͻ;
͵ͪͼͬͰͽͰͷͽͳ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͳ͵;Ͷͽͪ͆ͪͽͪΒͪͳͼ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͼͬͰͽͳͬͶͪ
ͯͪͻͳͫͳͶͳͺͻͳ͵Γ;ͰͳͶͳͼͽͳͷͪͰͫͰͼ͵ͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
;ͼͬΒͼͽͬ;Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺͳ
͵ͪͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰͳͯͻͱͪͬͰ
]]
̸͉̺͈͇͉͈͈͉͈̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͊͊̓́́͊͋͌͠
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
34UJDIFM
4UVEJFO[VN7FSIÅMUOJTWPO5FYUVOE#JMETQÅUVOEOBDICZ[BOUJOJTDIFS7FSHÅOHMJD
ILFJUTEBSTUFMMVOHFO
8JFO
mͲͪ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳͰͺͻͳͷͰͻͰW./JDPM
.FUFPSB
ѮF 3PDL .POBTUFSJFT PG ѮFTTBMZ
-POEPO
$-BOE83$POOPS
ѮF -JGF BOE .J
SBDMFTPG4U-VLFPG4UFJSJT5FYU
5SBOTMBUJPOBOE$PNNFOUBSZ
#SPPLMJOF
.BTTBDIVTFUUT
m.ͻͪ͵ͬͪ
͊ͪͷʹͶͬͪ
PQDJU
͈̽ͺͬͳΕ
̓;Ͷͽ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳB
m
. )FJO[FMNBOO
5SBOTMBUJPOCFSJDIUF VOE BOEFSF 2VFMMFO EFT 3FMJRVJFOLVMUFT
5VSOIPVU
]]
̸͉̺͈͇͉͈͈͉͈̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͊͊̓́́͊͋͌͠
ͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪ
ͼͬͻ;Ͱͷ;ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͷBEWFOUVT;͋ͪΒͳͼͬͰͪͰͳ
ΒͪͬͰͺͻͷͳΒͰͬͭͪͳͪͶͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒͰ
ͺͿ;͵ͳΒͳͳ
͵ͻͪΒΔͰͷͳΓ;
͵Ͷͳ͵ͼͿͰͻͳ͵;ͶͽͰͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͽͶͳ͵ͳͼͿͰͻͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵Ͱ̓ͪ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͰΕͰͷͪͬͰͼͽͳͺͻͬͳͳͺͼͶͰͯΔͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͪͯͬͰͽ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷ
ͬͰ͵;
͈ͻͬͳͪͯͬͰͽͲͫͳͼͰͭͯͳͰ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͰͼͪͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳ
ͷͰͪͼͪ͊ͬͰͽͰ̻ͻͰ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;͋ͼͰͯͭͯͳͶ;͵ͶͼͽͳͷͪͭͻͪΌͪͼ͵ͭͻͪͽͪ
ͳͯ;ͫ͵ͰͯͻͱͪͬͰ͵ͻͳͲͰ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ͈ͻͪͬͰͻͪͲͶͭͰͽͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͺͻͰͳͲͼ;
ͺͳͼͪͶͳ͊ͳͷͰͬͳͱͳͬͽͺͳͼͳ͇Ͱ͵ͳͬͪͶͼͰ
ͪͳͷͰ
ͯͪΕͰͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͻͰͶͳ
͵ͬͳΒͪͺͷͳͻͳͽͳͼ;͵ͫΓͰ;ͫͻͪΕ;
;ͬͻͼͽͳͽͳͯͻͱͪͬ;ͳͺͷΕͳΒΒͯͪͼͪͬͶͪͯͪ
ͼͺΓͰͰͺͻͳΒͪͽͰΓͰ̸EWFOUVTSFMJRVJBSVNͼͳͬͪͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱͯͳͪ
ͼͽͳΒͰΒͰͯͪΒͰͯͺͼͶͰͯΔͳ;ͳͲ;Ͱͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͪͯͬͰͽͪ͵Βͳͷͪͼ;;ͼͽͪͬΓͰͳ
͵;ͶͽͬͳͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͻͰͳͷͼͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͳͼͳΒͪ;͊Ͱ̽ͰͳΒ;͵͈ͯͪ
ͻͳͲͪ
̾ͯͬͪͻͯͪ́ͼͺͬͰͯͳ͵ͪ;̺ͰͼͽͷͳͼͽͰͻ;ͳͶͳ̓ͪͻͶ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭ;̸Ͱ;
ͯͪ
ͪͬͰͯͰͷͼͪͷͪΒ;ͬͰͳΒͰͺͻͳͷͰͻͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪͰͼͪͷͯͪΒͰͳͷͪ
ͶͪΒͰͯͪ͵ͳͯͰͶ͵ͳͳΓͬͰΕΒͰͳͺͻͰͯ;ͻͪͶͳͲͬͰͯͰͪͪͼͶͳͪͪͳ
͌ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;ͪͻͳͽΒͰͬͪͱͪ͵ͶͼͽͯͪΒͰ;ͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ
ͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͪͯͻͱͪͬͰ
͵ͪͳ;ͪͬͰͯͰͳͷͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͷͪ
;Ͱͼͽͬͬͪ
ͼͪͷͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͳͼ;ͬͰͻͰ
ͪͽΒͰͫͳ͊ͳͷͰͬͼͳ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͻͬͬͰͪͳ
͈ͼͶͰͯΔͳBEWFOUVTSFMJRVJBSVN;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳͫͳΒͰ;ͰͶ
ͼͽͳ;ͼͶͬΓͰͯͪͽͳͷͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͷ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽͷ͉ͰΒͰͪΒͯͻͪͷͪͽͳͳΒͰͷͽͻͰ
;ͽ͵;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͳͼͽͻͳΒͰ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͪ͵ͺͻͪͲͪͪ̓ͼͬ;
ͭͯͳͰͳͺͭͳͫͳΒͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
͵ͰͲͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͪ͵ͪͳͲͭ;ͫͳͶͪͼͬΒͰͷͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͽͳͰ
Β;ͱͰͽͰͻͳͽͻͳΒͰ͈ͻͰͼͷͽͳΒ;͵ͰͲͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪͼ̓ͼͬͪ;͉ͪͬͪͳ
;
ͭͻͫ;ͻ͵ͬ;͵Β;ΒͰ͵ͰͲͺͯͳͭͪͪͼͰͬͰͻ;ͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͫͳΒͰ
ͺͿͻͷͳ
ͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳ ͫͻͰͯ ͊ͪͯͻͱͳͪ ͷ; ΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͫͳͶͪ ͫͳͽ ͳͲͷͰΔͰͪ
Ͱͷ; ͬͰͷͪ ͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪ ͼͬͰͯͰ ͺͳͼͪͳ ͳͲͬͻͳ ͌ͷͰͼͽ ;ͫͳͪΒͰͭ
ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳͲͷͪͳͼͶͪͬΓͪ
ͰͻͰͷͳΒͪΒͰͳͲͬͰͯͰͪ;ͪͽͷͼͿͰͻͳͱͪͶͼͽͳ
͵Βͪ
ΒͰ;ͶͳͽͰͻͪͻͳͷͳͲͬͻͳͷͪͼͪͺͽͰͪ͵ͻͲͱͪͻͺͶͪͪ
ͪͼͪͷ͵ͰͲ̈́ͪͲͪͻͺͻ
ͼͶͪͬΓͰΒͰ͵ͪͺͻͬͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͷ;Ͱͳ͵
̓ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͻ͵ͬͰͳͷͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͳͷͪ
Ϳ;Ͱͻͪͻͪͺͻͪ͵ͼͪͳ͵;ͶͽͷͽͳΒ;
ͺ͵ͪͲ;Β;ͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰͳͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͰͳͼͶͳͼͽͳ;ͺͻͰΌͰΔ;ͼͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͷ͋ͪ͵
ͼͰ
;ͺͻ͵ͼͳͲͬͰͼΒͺͻͳͶͪͭͯΓͳͬͼͽͳͫͳͪΒͪ
͵ͪͳͺΒͰͯͳͳͷͳͲ;ͲͰͳͷͪ
ͯͷͳͪͽͷͳͯͰΒͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͼͪͻͪͰͻ͵ͬͰͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪͷͱͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ
ͺͼͽΒͪΔͰͲͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͭͷͪ;ͲͶͰΒͪ͆ͪͽͪΒͪͳ;ͺͻͬͷͺͶͪ;ΒͰͫͳͶͪͳͼͽͳ
ͽ;ͳΒͪͻ͵ͬͰ
ͪͰͶͳͼͽͳͳͲͪͼͶ;ͭͰΔͰͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻ͍ͪ;͵ͳΒ;ͷͪ;ͲͶͰΒͪ
ͻ͵ͬͰͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪͳͷͪͶͪΒͰ̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͳΒͪ
ͯͳΒͰ͈ͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͪ;͈Ͱ
Εͳ̓ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ͈ͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͰ
͵ΒͳͼͰͯͪͪͼͼͪͼͽΒͳͯͽͻͳͻ͵ͬͰͫ;ͬͪΕͰͰ
ͲͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͳͷͪͻͽͰ͵ͼͷ
ͪͼͽͪΒͪΒͰͽ͵ͷ9***ͳ;ͺͻͬͳͷͯͰͰͳΒͪͷͪ9*7ͬͰ
͵ͪ
ͪͯͼͪͷͭͺͰͽ͵ͪͫͳͶͪͷ;ΒͰͯͯͰΓͰͪͿ;ͰͻͪͻͪͪͷͰͪ
͊ͪ ͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ Ϳ;͵ͳΒͰ
ͼͪͻͪͰ ͳ ͺͼͷͻͽͳ ͫͻͰͯͳ ͻ͵ͬͰͳ ͺͻͰ
Ͷͪͽͪͺ͵ͪͲ;Β;ͫͳͽͰͼͶͳͼͽͳͼͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͷ͈ͰͬͯͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
ͺͻͬͭ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ
;͊ͻͫͳΒͳΒͰΒͪͼͳͲͻͪͱͰͪͼͽΒͪΔͰͯͪͼͰ͵ͪͳ
Ͳ;Β;ͪΒͬͳͳͻ͵ͬͰͳͯͼͽΒͪͼͽͬͰͳͳ͋ͪ͵ͼ;͊ͪͬͳͰͷͽͳͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͶͰ
͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͳͪΒͺͽͬͪͳΒͳ
tͰͶͳi
ͽΒͰͼͽͫͪͶͼͪͷͬͪͳͽͰͶͪ͋ͪ͵ΌͰ
;
ͺͼͽ;ͺ͵; ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔͪ ͵;Ͷͽͪ ͺͻͳͷͰΔͰ ΒͰ ͰͶͬͳͽ ͻͳͽ;ͪͶ FMFWBUJP ͳ USBOTMBUJP
ͷͽͳΒ;
;͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͼͬͰͪͳBEWFOUVT͈ͼͽΒͰΕͳͺͳͼͪͳͳͲͬͻͳͰͯͬͼͷͳ
ͼͶͰͺͽͬͻΌ;Β;ͪͭͶͪͰ;ͳͯͰͶ͵;ͳͺͶͳͽͳ͵;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;ͽͭ͵;ͶͽͪͰ
ͼͪͷͽ͵ͷͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪͬͰΕͳ;ͻͪͲͯͫΓ;ͽͷͪͼ͵ͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ͆ͪͰͶͺ
]]
̸͉̺͈͇͉͈͈͉͈̾̈́́̓́̾́̈́́͋́̓͊͊̓́́͊͋͌͠
ͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͫͻͰͯͭͻͪΌͰΔͪ͵;Ͷͽͪͻ͵ͬͰͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪͫͳΒͰͼͪͼͬͳͷͼͶͳͪͬͶͪ
ͯͪͻͼ͵ͷ̀ͪͺͽͻͰͫͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͳͷͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͼͳͷͪ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰͼ;
ͺͳͼͪͳ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͶͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵ͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳmͱͳͽͳΒͪͳͼͶ;ͱͫͰmͪΔͳͬͪͽͰͶͪͼ;
ͪ͵FMFWBUJPͺͶͪͭͪͪ;ͼ͵;ͺͰͰ͵ͳͬͽͰ͋ͻͰͫͪͳͺͪ͵ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳͯͪΒͰ;ͼͻͰͯ
ΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͼͪͷͰ͵Ͷͳ͵ͪͻͳΒͰͻͰΒͪͯͫͳͶͽͪ͵ͪͬ
ͰͶͬͳͽͻͪͲͻͪΌͰ͵;Ͷͽ
͑ͽͬͪΔͰͬͰΕͳͰͻ͵ͬͰͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪͳͷͪͶΒͰͼͬͰͯͰ;Ϳͻͷ;ͳͫ;ͬͪͽͪͶ
ΒͰ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
ͱͳͽͳΒͰͳͻͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͳͭͻ͇ͫͽͬͪͻͪΔͰͭͻͫͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽͻͳ
ͽ;ͪͶͰMFWBUJP
ͳΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͫͳͶͺͻͪͬͳͶm
ͻͰͳͷ
ͳΒͰͳͲͬͰͯͰͪ͵
ͳ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͽͪ͵ͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽΒͶͳͼͽͳ͵ͪͽΒͰͫͳ̽ͪͳͶ**̀ͪͼͶ;ͭͰ
ͽͭ;ͰͭͳͼͬͰͼͽͻͪͭͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪͳͼ;ͫͳͶͰͼͪͷ;ͪͼͽΒͪΔ;ͯͪͼͰͿͻ
ͷͳͻͪ͵;ͶͽͰ͵ͳͯΔͰͭͬͳͺͻͰͽͯͳ͵ͪͬͰΕͳ;Ϳͻͷ;ͶͪͳΒͳͳͯͰͶ͵ͳ
ͼͬͪΔͳͬͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔ͇ͪͽͷͰͼͬͰͯͳͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶ
ͯͰͶ̽ͪͳͶͪ**
Ͳͫͻͳ͵ͺͯͪͼͶͬͷ̿ͳͬͽͳ͵ͻͪΓͰͬͪͳͪͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳ
͵Βͳͼ;ͯͳΒͰͺͻͯ;ͱͳͶͳΔͰͭͬͳͪͼͽͪͬΓͪͳ͌ͽͷͯͰͶ;ΒͰ
͵ͻͲ
ͫͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͪͻ͵ͬͰ
ͳͲͶͱͰͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͼͬͪͽͪΔͰ
ͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͳͪͳͪͶͳͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͪ
ͯͻͱͪͬͰͳͪ;ͽ͵ͰͿͪͶͰͻ͵ͬͰ͈ͯ
ͬ;ͰΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͪͻͷͳͪͯͼͼͬͰͽͬͰͳͯ;ͬͰͬͶͪͼͽͳ
͵ΒͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪ
ͬΓͪ ΒͰͯ; ͯ ͫͳͽͳ ͯͶͳ͵ͪ ͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ ͺͶͳͽͳ͵Ͱ ͻͰͪͶͼͽͳ ͼͻͰͯΔͰͭ ͬͰ͵ͪ
Ͳͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;̺ͯͳͲͪͽͳΒͰ
ͪͪͻͳͽͲͪͺͪͯͳͯͻͱͪͬͪ
;͵Βͳͷͪͼ;ͽͳͯͼͳ
ͫͳͶͳͫͰͶͰͱͰͳͫͻͫͷͲͪͺͻͳͷͪͽ͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͽͰͱΔͪͯͪͼͰͳͼͽͳͽ;
ͳΒͳͼͬͰͽͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͺͻͳ͵Γ;ͳͳͼͬͰͽͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻͻ͵ͬͰͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͺΒͪͬͳ͵ΒͪΒͰ
;Ͱͪ;Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵ͯͻͱͪͬͪͲͪͺͪͯͰͳͰͽͻͪͶͰ̾ͬͻͺͰ
̓ͪͯͪΒͰ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͰ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺ
;ͰͶͳͳͺͼͷͪͽͻͪ
ͷ
ͭͪͫͳͼͰͺͳͼͪͽͳ͵ͪtͰͽͰͽͻͳͪiͺ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ;ͳͯͻͱͪͬͽͬͻͪͺ͵ͻͪΒ
ΔΒͼͬͻͼͳ͆ͪΒͺͽͬͪͳΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰmͼͳͲ;ͲͰͽ͵ͷ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪmͫͳͶͰͼ;
ͺͬͰͲͪͰͼ͵ͪͽͰͭͻͳΒͷͶͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͰͼ;ͳͳͶͰͬͻͯͻ;ͽͬͰͰͳΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
ͳ ͵ΒͰ ͼͰ ͼͽͭͪ ͷͭ; ͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ ͵ͪ IPNJOFT QPMJUJDJ ͋ͰͷͰΓͪ ͳͯͰΒͪ ͫͳͶͪ
ΒͰ
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;͈ͻͰͯͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺͽͬͪͰͼ;ͳ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͻ͵ͬͰͳͺͭͶͪͬͪͻ̹ͪͳͶͳͼ;ͽ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;
ͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͳͷͽͳͬͳ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳͪͻͳΒͰͻͰΒͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͳͪͬͰͯͰͳͼ;;͈ͪͬͶͬͳΕ
̓;ͶͽͬͳͶͳ͚ͪ͊ͶͳΒͰͺͰͬͳΕ
́ͼͽͻͳΒͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͰͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͰͻ͵ͬͰ*͇ͯͺ͵ͻͽͪͬͪΔͪ͊ͻͫͪͯ͵ͻͪΒͪ97**ͬͰ͵ͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
͇ͶͳͼͽͳͳͯͰͶ;̽ͪͳͶͪ**
;͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ΔͰͭͬͰͰͺͰ
WͲͫͻͳ͵̸ͻͳͰͺͳͼ͵ͺ̽ͪͳͶ**
ͳΔͰͭͬͯͫͪ
FE̺͚͠;ͻͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
7ͬͰΕͺͷͰ;ͽͰͻͪͯͬͰ;Ͳͫͻͳ͵;1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH ͪͺ
$G4DISFJOFS
PQDJU
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼͪͳ͵;ͶͽͬͳͭͅͻͰΌͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳͺͽͬͪͰͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳ
ΒͰͪͼ͵Ͱͽͪͺ;ͼͽͳͱͳͽͰΓͪ
͵ͪͽΒͰ;9***ͬͰ͵;ͫͳ͈Ͱͽͪͻ̓ͻͳ͵ͳͳͶͳ
ͺͻͰͯ͵ͻͪΒ9*7ͬͰ͵ͪͷͪͼͳͼͳͪͳͽͳ
͵Βͳͼ;;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͺͻͰͫͰͭͶͳͺͻͰͯͽ;ͻͼ͵ͳͷ
ͼͬͪΒͪΔͳͷ̹ͪͪͶ͵ͪͪ͆Ͱͷͪͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͰͼ;ͷΔͰ;ͽͯͪΒͰͬͰΕͳͪͽͳ͵;Ͷͽͬͪ
ͺͳͬͪͶͪͪͪ;ͽͰͽͳΒ
ͺͰ͵ͪͯͳͻͪͯͳ͵ͪͶΒͼͺͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶͼͽͳ́ͺͪ͵
ͳ
ͽͳͼͰ͵;ͶͽͬͳͰͷͭ;ͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͳͲͬͪtͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͭi͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪ
͵ΒͳͼͰͺͻ
ͽͰͱͰ;ͪΒͳͻͰͷͻͪͼͺ;mͯͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͺͪͽͻͪͱͰͯͳͽͰͻͰͼͪͳͼͽͻͪͽͰͭͳΒͰ
Ͷ͵ͪͶͰͻ͵ͬͰͰͻͭͪͳͲͪͳΒͰ͆ͪ͵ͻͪΒ;mͪ͵ͼͰͺͻͫͶͰͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͵ͯ
͊ͻͫͪͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪΔͳͬͰͳͯͰͶ͵Ͱ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͰͿ;͵
ͳΒͰmͷͱͰͼͰͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͯͪͼͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͯͻͱͪͬͪ;͵Γ;ͳͬͪͶͪ;
ͼͬͰͽͼ͵ͳͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͳͺͻͰͯͪ͵ͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͐ͪͼͭ͵ͻͼͽͪ
ͪͪͻͳͽ
ͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͼͺͼͽͬͰͳ
ͪͳͪͶͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠
(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
̸̸̸͇̺͉͆͊̈́̽ΒͰͺͪͻͪͿͻͪͲͪͯͫͻͺͲͪͽͳͻͰͯͬͪͳͲ͊ͶͬͪͺͻͰͼ;ͷ
ͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;̻ͻͳͭͻͳΒͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͪ̽ͪͺͯͼͰͽͳͷm;ͲͪͬͻΒ
ͺͬͪͶͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͳͺͳͼͪ͵ͪͱͰt͇ͯ;ͲͰΒΒ̺Ͷͪͯͳ͵ͪͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵;ͼͶͪͬ;
ͪͯͪͻͬͪ
ΒΒͼͻͺͼ͵;
ͰͼͽͪͬͳͬͳΒͺͻͬΒͳͽͪi͋ͪ͵ΒͰͯͳͼͽͪͳͲͭͶͰͯͪͶm;
ΒͰͯͷͼͫͳͽͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͷͽͻͰ;ͽ͵;͉ͰͪͶͼͽΒͰ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͼͰ
ͫͳͶͪͰ;ͺͻͰ
ͯͳͬͼͶͱͰͳΒ͈ͪͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͰͼͪͷͯͪΒͰΒͰͯͪͯͪΒ͵ͷͺͶͰ͵
ͼͳΒͳͺΒͪͬͪ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰ͵;ͶͽΒͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͫͪͶ͵ͪͼ͵ͳͲͰͷͪΓͪͬͰΕΒͰͳͼͬΒͰ
ͬͻͼͪͷͰͽͪͿͻͪΔͳͬͰͯͻͪͷͪͽͳͰͼ;ͯͫͳͰ;ͽ͵;ͷͭͳͼͽͶͰΕ͇ͪͬͷ
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͫͶͰͷͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͻͪͲͷͽͻͳΕͰͷͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͳͻͰ
ͼͬͪΕͰͭtͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͭͺͻͭͻͪͷͪimͫͻͰͯͪͳͺͻͪ͵ͼͰͽͬͪΔͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͪͪͻͳͽΔͳͬͰͿ;͵ͳΒͰ͌ͽ;ͼͬͻ;ͫͪͬͳΕͰͷͼͰͻͪͲͯͫΓͳͷͪ;͵Βͳͷͪ
ΒͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳ͵;ͶͽͳͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͯͰͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰͳͯͻͱͪͬͽͬͻͭ
ͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͫͳͶ;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵Βͳ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ͇ͼͫͰͼͽͳͽͪ
ͯͬͪͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͪͽ;ͷͪͳΕͰͼͰ;͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͯͪͽͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ͵ͶͼͽͳͳͺͶͳ
ͽͳ͵ͰͼͬͻͬͳͽͼͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ
͇ͬͪͽͻͪ͵ͳΒͼ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͪͽͶͳ͵ΒͰͺͺ;ͶͪͻͪͯͪΒͰͰͽͻͰͫͪͺͯͻͫ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͽͳ͈ͪͻͪͼ͵Ͱͬͪm͈Ͱͽ͵ͪ
ͻΌͰͪ;̾ͺͳͬͪͽ;͵ͯ̓ͪͶͳ͵ͻͪͽͳΒͰ
ͱͳͬͰ
ͶͪΒͰ;ͯͻ;ͭΒͺͶͬͳͳ9ͬͰ͵ͪ͊Ͷͪͬ;ΒͰͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳͶͪͽͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͺͯͬͳͲͳͷͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͪͼ;ΒΒͼͰͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳͷͽͳͫΒͪͬͳͶͰ
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͼ;ͺͻͰͰͽͰ;ͻ͵ͬ;͊ͬFͽͳ
ͪͺͼͽͶͪ;̓ͪͶͳ͵ͻͪͽͳΒͳ͌ͽΒͪΒͻͪͳΒΒͰͽͪͺͳͻͰΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵
ͽͳͺͳͷ
Ͷ͵ͪͶͷ͵;Ͷͽ;
͵ΒͳΒͰͺͳͬͪͪͬͰͻͳ;;ͯͽͬͻ;ͷΕͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ͇ͪΒͰ
ͺͯͼͽͪ͵ͪͳͪͼͽͪͪ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͪ
͵ΒͰΒͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͰ͵ͳͷͰͼͳ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͳ͵
͋ͱͳͽͳΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ͼͰͲͪ
ͼͺͪΓͰΒͰͼͻͰͯͳͷ9**ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͪͻͰΌͰΔ;ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪ
͆ͳ͵ͶͰ*7ͅ;ͲͪͶͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͰͳͯͪͼͪͼͽͪͬͰͲͪͯͬΓͪͬͪͼͬͰ͵ͪ
ͼ͵ͰͳͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͰͼͽͪͯͪͻͯͰ͊ͽͭͪΒͰͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪͶͱͳΌͪ͵;̺ͪͼͳͶͳ͵;
ͺͻͰͼͽͳ͵ͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͽͳ
ͯͪͪͯͼͽΒͪͪͳͺͳͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͱͳͬͽ͊ͪͯͻ
ͱͳͪͽͭͬͭͱͳͽͳΒͪ
;ͺͯͫΓͰͭͷͰͽͪͿͻͪͼͽͿͼ͵ͳͷͺͻͪͬͳͶͳͷͪ
ͺͲͪͽͪ
ΒͰͲͪͬͪΓ;Β;ΕͳͺͲͳΒͰͷͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͷͺͻͰͺͳͼ;̺ͪΓͪͯͷͪͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳmͼͪͷͪ
͵ͶͼͽͯͪΒͰͬͪͼͰΓͰͼ͵ͳͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪͪͲͪͼͯͯͪͼͪͷͳͽͰͻͬͰͳͰ;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;ΒͰͯͭͶ͵ͪͶͭ͵;ͶͽͪͯͬΓͼͬͰͯͳͻͪͲͷͰͻͪͷͪͽͬͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͰ
͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ ͋ ͰͺͼͻͰͯ ͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰͳͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͼ;ͲͪͺͽͻͰͫͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͼͳͷ
ͺͷͰ;ͽ̺ͭͪͼͳͶͳ͵ͬͭ
ͻͰͽͻͼ͵ͭͱͳͽͳΒͪ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͪͭͻ͵ͷΒͰͲͳ͵;ͳ
ͯͻ;ͭͳͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳ
͵ͪͽͼ;͈ͻͶ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰͳ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪ
ͺͲͪͽͳ
ͪͼͬ;ͺͲͳΒͳͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͺͻͰ͈ͬͯͪͻͰͰͭͽͺͻͰΌͰͷͪͼͬͳ
ͺͻͫͶͰͷͪͰͭͻͪͯͪmͪͽΒͰͻͰͰͺͳΒͪ͵;Ͷͽͪ;ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵Βͳͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ
mͳͲͶͱͳΕͰͷ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ;͵ͻͪͽ͵
͵ͪ͵ͪͬͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳͷͯͰͶ;
ͯͰͭͻ͵ͳͺͻͽͽͳͺͳ͆Ͱ͵ͳͯͲͪͼͽ;ͺΓͰͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒͪͼ;͵ͬͰͳͪͶͳ
ͪ
Ͱ͵ͳͼ;ͼͫͰͳ
ͺͪͳͳͲ;ͲͰͽͳ
ͅͰΌ;ͺͻͬͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͽͻͰͫͪͼͬͻͼͽͪͽͳͯͭͪΌͪΒͰ͵ΒͳͼͰͽͳ;͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͰͼͷͻͽͳ
ͳͼͪͻͪͰ
͵ͪͳͺͼͷͻͽͰͻͳͽ;ͪͶͰ;ͬͰͲͳͼͫΒͪͬΓͳͬͪΔͰͷͳͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͷ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
*CJE
mͫͻͰͯͳͷͪͬͰͲͪͳͷͲͪͼͷͻͽͳͰͽͪͺͪͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ&1B
UMBHFBO
4BJOUFUÊFUQPVWPJS
JOѮF#Z[BOUJOF4BJOU
m%"CSBIBNTF
3JUVBMTPG%FBUIJO
UIF.JEEMF#Z[BOUJOF1FSJPE
ѮF(SFFL0SUIPEPYѮFPMPHJDBM3FWJFX
m(B
MBUBSJPUPV
ѮF.BLJOHPGB4BJOU
mͬ;ͺͻͫͶͰͷͪͽͳ͵;ͯͼͪͯͪͼͷͬͳͰͺ;ͽͪͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪ
Ͷͳ͈̽ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
mͰBEFN
̓;Ͷͽ͵ͻͪΓͪ
̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪ
mFBEFN
0ͪͼͽͪ͵;͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
m;ͬͳͷͻͪͯͬͳͷͪ
ͯͪͽͪΒͰͳͺͳͻͪͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͪ
0͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ;ͳͼͷͳͼͶ;ͼͽͶͺͳͽͬͪ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͳͺͲͷͬͳͲͪͽͳΒͼ͵ͷͻͪͲͯͫΓ;.PS
SJT
.POLTBOE-BZNFO
m ͼͪͳͲͬͻͳͷͪͳͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͷ
́ͬͪͬͪ
PQDJU
ͰͽΓͰͳͷͷͽͳͷ̸ͪ"OHFOFOEU
$PSQVTJODPSSVQUVN&JOF-FJ
UJEFFEFSNJUUFMBMUFSMJDIFO3FMJRVJFOWFSFISVOH
4BFDVMVN
m
mDG͈ͺͬͳΕ
͊ͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ
m
́ͬͪͬͪ
PQDJU
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷ;ͯͽͬͻͼͽͬͳͷͪ)$,FF
.JSBDMFJOUIF&BSMZ$ISJ
TUJBO8PSME
/FX)BWFOm-POEPO$-$POOPS
"SUBOE.JSBDMFTJO.FEJFWBM#Z[BOUJVN
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
ͪͽͬͬͻͼͽͺͳͬͪͶͪͺͻͳͳͺ;TUBCJMJUBTMPDJ͈͆ͪͰͽ͵ͳͰͻͰͷͳͽͼ͵ͳ
ͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽΕͰͷͼͰͬͻͪͽͳͽͳ
ΒͰͻΒͰ;ͯͫͪͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪ͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒͪͳͷͪͰͺ
ͼͻͰͯͪͳͼͪͱͪ;ͽͳͪΒͪ͵;ͶͽΔͰͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͋ͫͳ
ͽͺͻͳͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͫͳͶͳͼͬͳͰͶͰͷͰͽͳ͵;Ͷͽ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;
ͼͪͯͻ
ͱͪͳ;ͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͷͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͺͻͬͫͳͽͰ
ͭͻ͵ͰͻͰͯͪ͵ͳΒͰ͋ͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳmͺ
ͳͻͱͳͽͳΒͰ
͈ͻͶ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰͳ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪmͺͻͰͬͰͯͰͳͼ;ͪͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳΒͰͲͳ͵
ͪ͵ͺͻͰͼͪͷͽͳΒ;ͳͲ̓ͪͶͳ͵ͻͪͽͳΒͰ;͋ͻͬͭͯͳͰ
;ͯͫͻͲͪ
ͳͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͷ͵Ͷͼͽͳͷͪ
͵ΒͳͷͪͼͬͰͯͳ̈́ͰͽͺͳͼͰͻͪͼ͵ͪͲ͋ͪͽͻͪ
ͼͶͪͳΒͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͬͪͳͺͻͰͼ;ͯͪͰͽͪͺͪ;ͻͪͲͬΒ;͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ
͵ΒͪΒͰͫͳͽͳͲͷͰͳͶͪͼͽͪͽ;ͼͳͼ;ͯͫͳ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͋ͺͽͬͻΌ;Β;ͺͻͼͶͪͬͳ
ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͪͼͽͪͶͳͪ͵ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ͆ͪΒͬͪͱͳΒͳͷͰΌ;ΔͳͷͪΒͰ
ͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵
̈́Ͱͽ
ͺͳͼͰͻͪͼ͵ͪͲ
Ͳͪͺͻͪͬ͊ͶͬͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;mͯͰͶͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽ
ͳ;Ͱͼͳ͵ͪͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ
ͪͲͪͷͳΓͰ͵ͪͪͼͽͪͬͪ͵̺ͪͼͳͶͳ͵ͬͭ̿ͳͽͳΒͪ
͈ͻͰͼΒͰ;͵ͻͪͽ͵ͺͳͼͪͳ;͈ͻͶ͵ͷͱͳͽͳΒ;
ͽͪͳΒͰΔͰͭͬͷͯͻ;ͭͷ
ͯͰͶ;
͵ΒͳΒͰͬ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͯͯͪͽͪ͵ͺͻͰͬͰͯͰͷͭͻ͵ͷͺͻͽͽͳͺ;͉ͰͳͽͰ
ͼ;
ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͳͳͽͰͻͬͰͳΒͰ
ͽΒͰͼͽͳͽͰͻͺͶͪͳΒͰ;͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳ
̈́ͰͽͺͳͼͰͻͪͼ͵ͪͲͼͬͰͯͳͽͷͰͯͪͼ;ͼͶͪͬͪͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͳΔͰͪ;ͯ
ͽͬͻͼͽͬͪͫͳͶͳͽͶͳ͵ͻͪͲͭͶͪͰͳͯͪΒͰͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͪͻͼͳͶͺͱͰͶͰͯͪͯΌͰ
;ͺͼͰͯͷͽͳΒ;́ͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱ͵Ͷͼͽͳ;͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰͼͺͻͬͰͽ;ͪ͵ͳΒ;ͯͫͻ
ͼ;ͺͲͪͽͰ͊ͪͼͰΕͪΔͰͷͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳͲͷͪͪ͵ͺͫͰͯͰ͵ͯ̓Ͷ͵ͽͳͰͳ
ͺͰͬͳͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽt͆ͬͳ̸ͼͰi
ͪͻ́ͬͪ**ͽͺͰΒͰͺͻͰͭͬͻͰͼ̈́ͪͽͳͳ
ͷ͇ͪͯΔͳ
͵ͪͱ;ͳͲͬͻͳ
ͳΒͰͲͪͽͻͪͱͳͳ͵ͪ͵ͬ;ͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶ;ͯͻͪͭͰͼͽ
ͳͪ͵ΒͰͽͷͭͪ
ͬͰΕͰͺͻͺͪͯΓͳͬ;ͼͬͰͽͳΔ;mͰͽΓͰͽͰͶͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ͉Ͱ
ΒͰ
ͪͻͪͬ
ͽͺͼ;͵ΒͳͺͻͳͺͪͯͪͰͼͪͷͼͿͰͻͳ͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;ͬͰΕͳͼͿͰͻͳ
ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͰ
ͪ͵ΒͳͽͻͰͫͪͯͪͳͼͽͪ͵ͰͪͻͰͬͺͻͭͻͪͷͼ͵ͯͫͪͳͬͪ
ΔͰ ͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͳ ͬͻͰͯͼͽͳ ͳ ͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͰ Ͳͪ ͯ;ͬ ͪͰͶ ͌ͫͳͪΒͰͳͷ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͽͺͼͳͷͪͫΒͪΔͰͳͼ;ͳͻͪͲͶͲͳͲͫͭ͵ΒͳΒͰ́ͬͪ;̸ͼͰ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͫͳͶͪ
ͽͶͳ͵ͬͪͱͪ͋ͻͰͫͪͶΒͰͯͪͪͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵Βͯͻͱͪͬͳͫ;ͯͰtͰͼͽͳͺͬͪͶͪ
ͳͻͪ
ͯͼͽͳͬͰͼͰͶͳͰ
ͺͷ΄ͰͺͫͰͯͳͷͪ
;͵ͻͰͺͬͪͰͪͪͻͼͽͬͽͼͳ
ͰͼͪͷͺͻͰͲ
ͽͲͳ ͬͰ͵
ͳ ͬ ͫ΅ͯͰ΄ͳΊi ͌ ͼͬͪ͵ͷ ͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͪ͵ ;ͼͺͰ ͫͪͬΓͰͳ
ͺͻͰͭͬͻͪ;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪΒͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪͷͽͳΒ;͆Ͱͷͪͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͰͼ;ͷΔͰ;ͽͯͪΒͰ;
ͺͳͽͪΔ;ͫͳBEWFOUVTSFMJRVJBSVNͪΒͬͳͰͭͻͪͭͪ
ͺͪ;Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵ͳͲͰͪΌ;ΒͰ
ͼͬͰͯͰͪͳͪ͵ΒͳͳͲͬͻͳΔͰͷ;ͭͬͻͰ̸͵ͼͰ;ͯͻ;ͱͰͺͯͪͳ͵ΒͰͼͪͯͻ
ͱͰ͈ͻͶ͵ͱͳͽͳΒͰͳ̈́ͰͽͺͳͼͰͻͪͼ͵ͪͲ
ͼͪͲͪΒͰͷͼͶͰͯͰΕͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪΒͰ
ͫͳͶͪͼͬͰͪͪ
ͺͽͰͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͻ͵ͬͰͪͳͪͻͯͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪ
ͳΒͪΒͰͻͭͪͳ
ͲͪͳΒͪͫͳͶͪͺͬͰͻͰͪͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽ;ͪͅͻ͵;͈ͬͻ͵;
ͺͻͳͼͽͳͭͶ;;tͼͶͪͬͰ
͏ͪͻͰͬͭͻͪͯ͋΅ͻͬi
ͯͰ͵ͪͶͳͼ;ͪͻͼͺͯͪͳͳͷͪ
ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳͷͽͬ
ͪͻ͇ͯͪͺͳͼͼͬͰͪͼͽͳͲͪͬͻͪͬͪͼͰͺͯͪͽ͵ͷͯͪΒͰͪͻͷͽͳͺͶͱͳ;
tͼͬΒ;i
ͽΒͰͼͽtͪͻͼ͵;iͻ͵ͬ;͈ͳͽͪΔͰͳͯͰͽͳͿͳ͵ͪͳΒͰͽͰͻ͵ͬͰ
͵ͪ͵ͼͰ
ͳͳ
;ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ΒͳͼͽͻͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳͼͽͪͶΒͰͯͯͪͪͼͽͬͻͰ
ͪͰͯͪͬΒͰ
͠ͻ̸ͯͪͶͰ͵ͼͳΒͰͬͳͲͯͬΒͳͳ;͵ͻͪͽ͵ͺͻ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͳͼͪͰͽͳͻͳͯͼͪͯͪͺͻͰͯ
ͶͱͰͪ ͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ tͪͻͼ͵ͪ ͻ͵ͬͪi ͷͭͶͪ ͫͳ ͫͳͽͳ ͯͬͻͼ͵ͪ ͵ͪͺͰͶͪ
ͻͪͷ
͐ͰͽͻͯͰͼͰͽ ͷ;Ͱͳ͵ͪ
͵ͪ ͳͻ͵ͬͪ ͪ͏ͪͻͰͬ;
ͳͲͬͪͯͬͻͼ͵ͭ ͵ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼͪ
ͳͽͪͯͬͰͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͰͶ͵ͪͳΒͰ͋ͪΒͯͳͼͽͪͼͶͱͰͺͻͫͶͰͷͼͬͪ͵ͪ
͵ͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;ΒͰͯͪΓͰͳͼͺͳͽͳͬͪΔͰ͊;ͬͻͰͷͰͳͳͲͬͻͳ
ͪͱͪͶͼͽ
ͰͼͪͯͻͱͰ
ͺͯͪͽ͵Ͱ ͵Βͳ ͫͳ ͭͪ ΒͪͼͳΒͰ ͼͬͰͽͶͳͶͳ ́ ͳͪͰ KF ;Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵ Ͱͫͳ ͽ
ͽΒͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ;͋ͻͬͺͯͻͫͳΒͰͯͰͬͳͯͪͪͺͳͼͪ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͵ͬͰ͵ͳͺͯͳΒͰ
ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒͰ͋ͪ͵ͼͰ;ͬͰ͵ͳͲͬͪͺ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰ͵Ͷͳ
͵ΒͰͽͰ͵ͺͻͼ;ΌͳͬͪͽͳͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͳΔͰͭͬͳͷͷͰͻͳͶͳͷͪͬͪͱͼͽͳ̀ͪ
ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͰͯͭͪΌͪΒͪͺͰͽͪͳͭͶͰͯͳΒͰͫͳͶͪ;ͪͻͪͳΒͳͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ
ͬͰΕ
;ͺͻ;ͳ
Βͪͼͺͻ͵ͶͪͷͬͪΒ;ͲͪͬͻͷͼͶͪͬͼͶͬΓ;̈́Ͱͽͺͳͼͭͻͪͼ͵ͪ
Ͳͪt͈ͻͰͺͯͫͪͷͪʹ͵
ͺͻͳͰͷͳͽͪͲͳͷͪͶ͵ͪͺͬͪͶͪ
͵ΊͽͽͳͺͻͳͪͼΊͷͰͽ
ͼ΅ͻͰͳͯͪʹ
ͷͶͳͷͽͳͼͰ
ͷͳͻͪͪͳΊͱͳͬͽ
ͫͶͪͭͺͶ;ͳͰͪ΅ͻ͵ͬͳͽͰ
ͼͳͶͪͳͷͭ΅΄ͰͼͽͬͪͪͳΊͪͻͼͻͰ΄;ͺͻͽͳͬͳͳͽͰ
͵ͪͽͺͪͲͳͳͲͪ͵ͻͳ
ͶΊͫͶΊͻͳͽͰ
ͬʹͳͳͽͰͳͻͪͽͪi͆ͬ;͈Ͱͽ͵ͳ;;Ͷͭ;
͵ͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͰͳ
;ͯͽͬͻͳͰtͪͻͼͽͬ;Β;ΕͰͭͭͻͪͯͪi
ͽ͵ͻͳͬͪΒ;ͳͯͬͰͳͽͰͻͺͶͪͳΒͰ;ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
͊Ͷ;ͱͫͰ
͈ͻͰͷͪͽͷͰ
ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͫͳͶΒͰ;ΒͰͯͷͺͰͻͳͯ;ͯͰͪΒ
ͬͳͰͺͶͳͽͳ͵Ͱͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͰͯͻͱͪͬͰmͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͺͪͽͻͪͱͰͳͼͽͪͻͪΔͪ
ͯ;ͬͰͰͶͳͽͰmͪͶͳͳͪΒͳͻͰͼͬͪΕͰͰͺͺ;ͶͪͻͰͺͫͱͼͽͳ̸͌ͯͫͪͼͰ
ͬͪͪͼͬͰͽ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͪͺͼͽͪͶͪΒͰͲͪͽͳͽͳ̹ͪ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͰͳΔͰͰͺͻͰͼͽͳͰ
ͪ
ΔͰ ͵;Ͷͽ ͺͺͻͳͷͳ ΒͰ ͯͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͳͯͰͶ͵ͳ ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ ͳ Ϳ;͵ͳΒ; ͉Ͱ
ΒͰͺͻͫͶͰͷͪͽͳͳ͵Βͪ;ͫ;ͭBͻͼ͵Βͪ;ͳͳͷͪͯ;ͭ;ͳͺͶͯͽͬͻ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒ;
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͽͰͼͽͭͪͬͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͪͬͯͳͷͼͪͷͼͬͰͳΔͰͳͰ
;Ͳ
Ͱ͵ͪͲͪͺͪͱͪΔͪͳͪͭͶͪͼ͵Ͱ
͈ͻͰͼ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;;͋ͻͬͭͯͳͰͫͳΒͰͼͪͷͯͰͳͻ
͵ͭ ͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ ; Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳ ͳͯͰΒͰ 3FOPWBUJP JNQFSJJ #VMHBSPSVN FU (SBFDPSVN
͵Βͳͼ;ͼͺͻͬͯͳͶͳͶͪͬͳͯͳͪͼͽͳΒͰ̸ͼͰͬͪͪͪ͵ͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪ͵ͯ̓Ͷ
͵ͽͳͰ ̓Γ;ͳ ͰͶͰͷͰͽ ͽͭ ͺͻͭͻͪͷͪ ͫͳͶ ΒͰ ͿͻͷͳͻͪΔͰ ͺͻͰͼͽͳͰ
tͪͻͼͽͬ;Β;ΕͰͭ ͭͻͪͯͪi ͋ͻͬ ΒͰ ;ͫͶͳͰ ͺͻͰͷͪ ͪΒͻͰͺͻͰͲͰͽͪͽͳͬͳΒͳͷ
͵ͼͽͪͽͳͺΓͼ͵ͳͷͫͻͪͼͳͷͪ
ͼͳΓͰͷͯͪͼͰͬͪͺͻͰͼͽͳͪͺͻͰͫͻͪͲͳ
;tͼͬͰͽͰͳi
tͫͭͻͪͳͷͳiͭͻͪͯ͌ͼͽͬͪͻͪΔ;ͽͪ͵ͬͭ
ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭͺͻͼͽͻͪ
ͺͻͰͼ;ͯ;;Ͷͭ;ͳͷͪͶͰͼ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͽΒͰͫͳͳͲͻͪͲͯͻͰͬͭ
ͼͬͪͽͪΔͪΔͳͬΒ;ͯͽͬͻΒͳͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ΒͷΕͳ͌͵ͻͪΒΔΒͶͳͳΒͳ
ͽ
ΒͰͺΒͪͬͪ͵ΒͪͺͻͰ͵Ͷͳͷͪ;ͳͯͰΒͳUSBOTMBUJPJNQFSJJ
ͪΒͰΕͰͼͽͬͪͻͰΒͷͰ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
ͪͳͲͷͷUSBOTMBUJP)JFSPTPMZNJ͇ͯͶ;͵ͷͺͻͰͰΔ;;ͭͶͰͯͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ
́ͬͪ**̸ͼͰͼͪͷͼͰͪͯͬͰͲͪͪͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͰͺͻͰͽͯͳ͵ͪmͪͻͪ́ͬͪͪ*
̸ͼͰͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ;͋ͻͬͯͰͷͽͳ+P͉ͬͪͪͳͶͼ͵ͭ
ͳͪͻͪ̓ͪͶΒͪͪ
ͲͪͼͶ;
ͱͭͲͪͺͻͰͼͅͳͪͳͶ̺ͪͳͪ
͈ͬͪͪ͠Ͷͳͬͽͼ͵ͭ
́ͶͪͻͳͪͅͰͭͶͰͼ͵ͭ
ͳͼͬͰͽͰ͍ͳͶͽͰΒͰ̀ͪͬͶͪͯͪͬͳͰ́ͬͪͪ**ͽͳͷͼͬͰͽͳͷͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͳͷͪ͋ͻͬͪ
ͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͰͪΒͰͳ͈Ͱͽ͵ͪ̾ͺͳͬͪͽͼ͵ͪ
ͪͷͱͯͪͳ̻ͪͬͻͳͶ̈́Ͱͼͬͼ͵ͳ
̀ͪͺͻͫͶͰͷ͵ΒͳͷͼͰͫͪͬͳͷͼͬͻͼͳͼͯΒͰ;ͺͻͰͯͳͽͳͽͪΒͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ
͵ͬͳΒͪͻͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͪΒͬͳͳͺͻͰͽͰͲͳΒͪͼͯͭͬͪͻͪΒ;Εͳͷͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͷ
͵ΒͳΒͰ;
ͺͻͬͳͷͯͰͰͳΒͪͷͪ9***ͬͰ͵ͪͼͽͬͪͻͰ;̿ͳͳ̹;ͯ;Εͳͯͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ;ͽͬͻͰͷͰ
ͳΒͰͺͼͽΒͪͶͪͺͻͰͼͽͳͪ͵ͪ;ͻͫͪͪͪͭͶͷͰͻͪͳΒͪͳͯͻͱͪͬͼͻͰͯͳͽͰ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼ;ͺͻͪΔͰͰ;ͻ͵ͬ;͵ΒͪΒͰͫΒͰͯͳΔͪͬͪͶͪ͵ͻ;ͳͯͫͰ;ͳ͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶ
;Ϳ;͵ͳΒ;*NJUBUJPJNQFSJJͽ;ΒͰͼͽͬͪͻͰͪͼͫͰͪͳ
ͳͲͫͻͷͼͬͰͽͳ
ͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ ͋Ͱ ͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ ͺͻͳͫͪͬͳ ΒͰ ͊ͪͬͪ ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͳ ͪ͵ Ͷͪͽͳͼ͵ͭ
ͼͬͪΒͪΔͪ͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͪͭͯͳͰmͷͰΌ;ΔͳͷͪͳͰ;ͬͰͲͳͼ͎ͻͳͼͽͷ
̹ͭ
ͻͯͳͷ
ͬͪ͠ͷ͈ͻͰͽͰͷͳͪͺͼͽͶͳͷ͉ͪͰΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͪΒͬͻͰͯͳΒͳͷ
ͽͪ
͵Ͳͬͪͳͷtͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪi
͵ΒͰͼ;ͳͳͶͰΒͰͲͭͻ͵ͼͽͪͽͳͺΓͼ͵Ͱ
ͯͬͻͼ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰ̿ͳ͵ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷΒͰͲͪ͵ͻ;ͱͰ͵ͪͯͪΒͰͽͳͷͺͽͰͻͳΕͪ
ͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͰͽͳΔͪͷͪͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͰͪͳΒͰͯͪͪͳͪͶͪmͷͽͳͺͻͬͭ͵ͻ;ͳͼͪͭ
ͼͻͺͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪΓͪ͊ͽͰͿ͈ͪͪͻͬͬͰ̹ͪͭ͌;ͭͪͻͼ͵Β
;͵ΒΒͼ;ͳͷͺͰͻͳΒͪͶͰ
ͳͺͻͰͼͽͳ͵ͰͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͰͫͳͶͰ;͵ͻͰΔͰͰΒ;͈ͯͫͪͻͬͭͪͻͼͽͬͪ
ͳͯͰΒͪ
tͼͬͰͽͷiͭͻͪͯ;ͼͽͬͪͻͰͪΒͰͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͳͷͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷ̹ͪ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͺͻͭͻͪͷͽͪ͵
ΌͰΒͰͺͳͬͪͪͼͷͳΓͰͷͳͲͫͻ;ͼͬͰͽͳͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺͻͰͼ;
ΔͳͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;͋ͻͬ
ͪͶͳͼͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͳͷͳͬͻͶͼͫͰͳͷͪͭͶͪͼͳͷͪ
͆Ͱ͵ͳͯΔͳͫͳͶͳͼ;ͪͻͳͽͬͪͱͳ͈ͻͰͷͪͷͳΓͰΔ;̹́ͬͪͪͱͳͶͬͪ
ͷͽͳ+P͉ͬͪͪͳͶͼ͵ͭ
ͪΒͺͺ;ͶͪͻͳΒͰͭͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
͇͵ͻͰͳͻͪΔ;ͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭͺͻͼͽͻͪͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͵ͪͬͳͯ;USBO
TMBUJP )JFSPTPMZNJ 3 0VTUFSIPVU
'MFYJCMF (FPHSBQIZ BOE 5SBOTQPSUBCMF 5PQPHSBQIZ
JO ѮF
3FBMBOE*EFBM+FSVTBMFNJO+FXJTI
$ISJTUJBOBOE*TMBNJD"SU
FE#,ÛOFM
+FXJTI"SUm
m̈́ͳͯͬ
PQDJU̹ͪ͵ͪͶͬͪ
PQDJU
m̸̹̈́ͰͶΊͰͬ
̻ͻ̻ͫͼͺͯͰ·
ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳͼͬΊͽʹͲͰͷͶͳ
JO͎ͻͳͼͽͳͪͼ͵ͳͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳͬͅͼ͵ͬͼ͵ͷ̓ͻͰͷͶͰ
FË̸́ͳͯͬ
ͅͼ͵ͬͪ
m1.BHEBMJOP
-ÊHMJTFEV1IBSFFUMFTSFMJRVFTEFMB1BTTJPOÆ$POTUBOUJOP
QMF 7**7***m*9TJÍDMFT
JO99F$POHSÍTJOUFSOBUJPOBMEFTÊUVEFT#Z[BOUJOFT5BCMFSPOEF-FT
SFMJRVFTEFMB1BTTJPO
1BSJT
m
̸͂ͶͰ͵ͼͳͰͬ
̹ͰͶͰ͵ͳͲͪͻͪͪͽͪͳͼͽͻͳΊͪͽ΅ͻͬͼ͵ͳͽͰͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳ
JO4UVEJBQSPUP
CVMHBSJDBFUNFEJFWBMJBFVSPQFOTJB
̺ͰͶͳ͵͋΅ͻͬ
mJEFN
̀ͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰmͺ
͵ͻͬͳͽͰͶͳ
m
͈̽ͺͬͳΕ
4BDSBFSFMJRVJBF
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͽͻͰͫͪͶΒͰͯͪ;͵ͪͱ;ͪ͵ͽͳ;ͳͽͰͽͼ͈ͻͬͳͷͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͷͪͻͼͽͬͷ
ͯ͵ͼ;
ͻͰͳͷ
ͷͽͳ̻ͪͬͻͳͶͪ̈́Ͱͼͬͼ͵ͭͺͻ͵ͶͪͷͬͪͶͰͼͽͪͬͺͻͰͷͪͲͪͺͪͯͳͷͽͰ
ͻͳͽͻͳΒͪͷͪ ͯͻͱͪͬͰ ͌ͳͬͰͻͲͪͶͳͼͽͳ͵Ͱ ͺͻͰͽͰͲͳΒͰ
ͼ ͯͻ;ͭͰ ͼͽͻͪͰ
ͫͳͶͰ ͼ;
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͰͪͺͲͪͽͪͳ
͵ͻͲ͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͭ̽ͳͷͳͽͻͳΒͪ
ͼͽͳͷͽΒͰͳͺͻͼͶͪ
ͬΓͰͷͼͶ;ͼ͵ͷͷͳͻͽ;ͺͻͳͺͳͼͪ
ͺͻͰ͵ͪ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͺͻͰ͵Ͷ
͠ͰͯͪͯͬͪͱͳͺͼͶͰͯͳͪͽͻͬͼ͵ͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͫͳͶͪΒͰͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬͪ
ͺͽͰ͵ͶͪͳͲͪΒͬͳͳͻ͵ͬͰͳ͵ͻ;ͭͬͪ
ͯͪͼͰ;ͻͰͯͯͬͰͯ;ͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͼͪͼͽͪ
ͬͳͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͽͻͳͷͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͪͷͪΒͰͯͪ͵ͭͳͷͰͪm͈Ͱͽ͵ͳ̾ͺͳͬͪͽͼ͵Β
͈Ͱͽ
͵ͳ͉ͳͷΓͪ͵ͳͳ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳ́͵ͳΒͼ͵Β͋ͪͪ͵ͳΒͪ
͵ΒΒͰͺͼͻͰͯͼͬͰͯͳ̈́Ͱ
ͽͺͳͼͰͻͪͼ͵ͪͲ
ͺͳͬͪͶͪΒͰͪͲͪͽͰͬ;ͯͪͼͰͽͻͬͼ͵ͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͪͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪ
ͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͰͪͳ
ͺͯͫͪΔͰͷͻͪͭ;
ͪͰ͵ͪͺͻͰͺͯͫͪͳͶͳͷ;Ͱͳ
ͪ͆ͪͳͷͰ
ΒΒͰͯͪͬͺ͵ͪͲͪͯͪͼ;ͳ;ͼͪͷͷ͋ͻͬ;ͳͲͬͰͼͬͻͰͷͰͲͪ
ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ ̾ͺͳͬͪͽͼ͵Ͱ ͵ͻͳΕͰͳ ͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͳ ͺͼͬͰΕͰͳ ͈ͪͻͪͼ͵Ͱͬͳ
͉ͳͷΓͪ͵ͳ
ͪͽͪͺͻͪ͵ͼͪͺͻͯ;ͱͳͶͪͼͰͳͯͳΒͰ;͵ͻͪΒͰͬͳͷͪ;ͯͪΓͰͳͷͯͺͻͰ
ͼͽͳͰ͊ͶͳͰͺΒͪͬͰ;ͰͰͼ;ͳ;ͳ͵ͭͻͪͿͳΒͳͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ
;ͻͰͽ͵ͳͷ
ͼͪ;ͬͪͳͷͱͳͬͺͳͼͪͳͷͳ͵Ͷ;ͼͳͷͪͳͲͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
͆ͪ͵ͺͻͰͼͪ;͋ͻͬͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱͳͼ;ͺͻͰͼͽͪΒͪͶͰͯͪͫ;ͯ;ͺͻͰͯ
ͷͰͽͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͼͽͪͻͪΔͪ͢ͳͬͼͽͪͽ;ͼͳΒͰͯͪͯͿ;͵ͳΒͪͺͼͬͰͯͰͳͼ;
ͼͻͰͯͳͷ9*7ͬͰ͵ͪ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳͳͷͫͻͰͯͷmͲͪ͵ͶͳΔͪΔͰͷͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͷ͉ͪͰΒͰͯͬͪͯ͵;ͷͰͽͪͳͲͬͻͰͷͰͪͪͻ̸ͪ́ͬͪͪͶͰ͵ͼͪͯͻͪ͠ͰͯͪΒͰ;ͭ
ͬͻͳͲͭͯͳͰ
ͼ͵ͶͺΓͰͼ̺ͰͰͳΒͷ
;͵ΒͰͷͼͰͪͻͲͪ͵ͶͳΔͰ̹ͪͭͪ
͇ͪ
̽Ͱͬ;ͪͅͻͳΒ;
͊ͬͰͽͳͱͳͬͽͬͻͳ͵ͻͼͽͳͼͬͰͽ;͈Ͱͽ͵;͋ͻͬͼ͵;͌ͳͼͽͷ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͳͼΒͰͯͪ͵ͳͷͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͪͼͰͺͷͳΔͰͳ;ͺͳͼͷ;ͺͬͰΓͳ
ͳͲ ͭͯͳͰ
͵ΒͰ ΒͰ ́ͬͪ ̸ͶͰ͵ͼͪͯͪͻ ;ͺ;ͽͳ ͬͰͰͳΒͪͼ͵ͷ ͯ;ͱͯ;
̸ͽͻͳͫ;ͽt͋ͻͬͼ͵ͪiͯͷͳͳͻͪͳ;ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪ͵Βͳͼ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͳͺͼͬͰΕͰͳ
;9*7ͬͰ͵;5PΒͰ
ͪͻͪͬ
ͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͳͳͷͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͳͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͳ
͵Ͷ;ͼ
ͲͪͳΒͳͼ;ͪͼͽͪͪ͵ͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒͰͳΔͰͭͬ͵ͻ;ͭ͵ΔͳͱͰͬ
ͳ͵ͪͳͯ;ͬͳ͵ͪ
͋ ͻͪͲͯͫΓͰ ΒͰ ͬͻ;ͪ ; ͻͪͲͬΒ; ͵;Ͷͽͪ ͼͬͰͽͰ ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ
ͫͪͻ ͵ͪͯͪ ΒͰ ͻͰ
ΔͰͭͬΒͼͪͯͻͱͳͳͳ͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻ;
͵ΒͰͽ͵ͻͳͬͪͳͲͬͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͪͪͺͳͼͪͳ
ͲͪͺͽͻͰͫͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ͌ͺͼͶͰͯΔͳͷͯͰͰͳΒͪͷͪ9*7ͬͰ͵ͪ
͵;ͶͽΒͰ
͵ͪͳͻͪͳΒF
ͫͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽ͈ͬͪͰͽ͵ͳͺ
ͳͻͱͳͽͳΒͰͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒͰͼͪͳͳΒͰͺͪͶͭ;ͪͻͪ́ͬͪͪ͑ͳͷͪ
͈ͪͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͪͼͰͯͪΒͰͳͽͪ
;ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͰͺͻͯͳͰ
ͪ
ͺͻͪͲͳ͵ ͊ͬͰͽͰ ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ
ͳ ͽ ; ͻͪͷ; ͵Βͳ ΒΒ ΒͰ ͫͳ ͺͼͬͰΕͰ ͌ ͽͷ ͯͰͶ;
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͰͻͰͽͻͳ͵Ͱ
ͺͻͱͰͽͷͳͼͳͪͼͽͳ͵ͷͼͺͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶΕ;
͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͼͬͰ
ͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͶͳ͵ͳͯͶͳ͵ͰΔͰͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͪͯͭͻͪΌͰͳͼ;ͬͳͷͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͷͪ
͋ͪ͵ͬΒͰ
ͪΒͺͻͰ
͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͺ;ͼͽͳͱͳͽͰΓͼͽ̺ͬͪͱΒͰͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳͯͪͼ;;ͺͻͪ
ͬͽͪΒͪͼͺͰ͵ͽ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͭͱͳͬͽͪͳͺͳͼΔͰͰͻͪͰͷͶͪͯͼͽͳͳͳͶͳͯͰͺͻͬ
ͫͳͽͰ
ͪ;ͽͻͼ͵ͰͻͰͯͪ͵ͳΒͰ̿ͳͽͳΒͪ
ͽΒͰΒͯͪͬ;ͽͬͻͯͳͶͪ̓ͶͳͷͰͽͳͪ
́ͬͪͬͪ̽ͪ͵ͶͰ
ͲͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯ;ͺͽͰͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͰͳͲ̺ͪͼͳͶͳ͵ͬͭ̿ͳͽͳ
Βͪ
͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒͰΒͰͼͽͬͻͳͰͶͬͳͽ;ͳ;ͼͬͳͷͼͰͭͷͰͽͳͷͪͻͪͲͻͪΌͰ;ͼͶͳ͵;ͰͻͰ
ͷͳͽͼ͵ͭͺͯͬͳͭͪ́ͼͽͪ͵ͪͬͳΒͪͺͰͽ͵;͈ͯͪͰͽ͵ͳͯͰͶͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪ
JNJUBUJP QBUSVN
ͼͽͬͪͻͰ ; ͼͺͼͽͬͰͷ ͬͻͰͷͰ; ͳ ͺͻͼͽͻ;
Ͱͺͳͬͪͽͼ͵;
ͺͯͬͳͱͳ;ͺͻͰͯͳͼͺͻͻ͵ͷ́ͶͳΒͷͳͬͪ͠ͷ͈ͻͰͽͰͷ
ͺͻͪͫͻͪͲͳͷͪ
ͼͬͳͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͳͺ;ͼͽͳͱͳͽͰΓͪ̀ͪͽͳͷͳͲͶͪͱͰ
ͼͬͻ;ͼ͵ͳͷͺͲͪͬͪΔͰͷ
ͰͻͰͷͳͽͼ͵ͭͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͭͪͼͶͰΌͪ
ͺͻͺͳͼͪͰͰͽͪͺͰͺ;ͼͽͳΔͪ͵ͭͱͳͬͽͪͳ
ͳͯͰͪͶͪ͋ͼ;ͺͻͰͯͰΓͰΔͰͲͪͯ;ͬͪͰͶ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͬͰΕ;ͻͪΒͷͶͪͯͼͽͳ
ͯͻͳͪΔͰͯͼͬͰͽͪͳͯͶ;͵ͪͯͪͼͰͼͽͻͪͼͽͬ;ΒͰ
ͺͻͪͶͪͲͪ͵ͺ;ͼͽͳΔͰ
ͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
ͷͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͪͼͽͳͰͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽtͱͳͽͰͶ͵ͪͪͺ;ͼͽͳΊi
ͪͰͽΓͰͼͽͳ;ͯ
ͽͬͻͼͽΔͰͳͷͽͳΒ;ͯͬͰͯͰͰͼ;;͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳ;ͰͺͼͻͰͯ;ͬͰͲ;ͼͯͰͶͳ
ͽͬͷ͋ͪͬͰͲͪͺͳͬͪͶͪΒͰͪͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͬͰͷͪͼͶͱͰͳͷͺͼͽ;Ͷͪͽͳͷͪ
ͪͶͳͳͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͳͷͪͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵Ͱͺͻͪ͵ͼͰ́ͼͽ͵͈ͪͼͽΒͪͶΒͰ
ͪͳͷͰ
ͬͻͼͽ;ͬͰͻͰ
ΔͰͯͪͼ;;ͺͻͪͱΔͪͬͪΔͰͷͺͻͺͳͼͪͭͻͰͱͳͷͪͱͳͬΓͰΔͪͽͰͶͳͳͼͽͳͪͶͳ
ͼͺͼͫͼͽͯͪͪͯͳΌ;ͭͻͪͳͰͼͺͼͽͬͰͰ͵ͻͺͻͪͶͼͽͳ͈ͽͫͳͼͰͺͻͰ
ͫͻͪͲͳͶͳ;ͭͽͬͫͰͼͽͰͶͰͼͪͫͳΕͪ
tͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͰͪΌͰͶͰi
ͳΔͳͬͪͽͰͶͪͫͳͬͰΕ
Ͳͪͱͳͬͽͪ
ͪͫͪͬͰͲͺͼͶͰͼͷͻͽͳ
ͼͽͳͪͶͪͪͻͳͽͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪͳͷΕͳ͠Ͱͯ
ͯͽͳͼͬΒͼͽͪͬͪmͼͳͶͪͯͪͼͰͯͭͰͫͰͼͬͳmͫͳͶΒͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͪͺͻͳͬͳͶͰͭͳΒͪ
ͺ;ͼͽͳΔͪ͵ͪ
ΒͰͻΒͰͫͻͫͪͼͯͰͷͳͷͪͫͳͶͪͯͰΔͳͬͭͳͼ͵;ͼͽͬͪͳͰͲͪͫͳͶͪ
Ͳͳͼͽ;ͺͪΔͪͼ͵Ͱͽͼ͵ͭͺͯͬͳͭͪ͊ͽͭͪͳΒͰͼͶ;ͪΒ
͵ͪͽͳΒͰͳͪͭͳ
ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͪͻͰͽͻͳ͵ͪ
ͽͽͼͰ;ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪ͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͳͪͷΕ
ͪͯͯͰͷͳͷͪͪͻͳͽͪͭͶͪͪͬͪ
͌͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒͰͬͷ̿ͳͽͳΒ;
;ͯͼ;̺ͪͪͼͳͶͳ͵ͬ
ͻͪͲͻͪΌͰͪͼ;ͳͯͻ;ͭͪ
ͲͫͳͬͪΔͪͳͲ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͭͱͳͬͽͪ
ͺͪͳͪ͵ΒͪͼͰͽͳ;ͼͷͻͽͳ
ͼͪͻͪͰͳͺͼͽ
;ͷͳͫͻͰͯͪ;ͬͰͲͳͼͺͻͪͶͼ͵ͷͷͽͳΒ;
ΔͳͬͷFMFWBUJPͳUSBOTMBUJP
͋;ΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ΒͰͬͰΕͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽ
ͼͪ;ͬͪͳͪΒͺͯͻͫͳΒͳͺͳͼͺͻͰͼͪͷͽͳΒ;
;͋ͻͬ̽ͭͪΌͪΒΒͰͺͻͬͳͺ;ͽͺͳͼͪͼͪͼͬͳͷͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪ͵ΒͰͺͯͻͪͲ;
ͷͰͬͪͰͶͬͳͽͳBEWFOUVTSFMJRVJBSVN
ͪͺͷͳΔ;ͼͰͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͰͳΔͰͳͰͳ
Ͷͳͼͽͳ͵ΒͳͰͷͪ;̈́Ͱͽͺͳͼͷͻͪͼ͵ͪͲ;ͳ͈ͻͶ͵ͷͱͳͽͳΒ;
ͯͪ͵ͶͰͼͪ
ͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͼ;ͬͻͰͷͰͳͷͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͳ̀ͫͳͬͪΔͪ͵Βͪͼ;ͰͺͼͻͰͯͺͻͰͽͯͳͶͪ
ͺͻͰͼ;mͺͻͰͭͬͻͳͼ̈́ͪͽͳͳͷͪͳͼͺͻͰͷͼͽ̸́ͬͪͪͼͰͪͯͪͲͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ;
;ͼͽ;ͺͳtͳͺͶͬͳ;ͼͬͭͪͻͼͽͬͪi
͵ͪͳΔͰͭͬͪͫͰͲͭͻͪͳͪͻͪͯͼͽ͵ͪͯͪΒͰ
ͼͬΒͪ;ͷͺͼͽͳͭͪmͺͳͼͪͪͼ;ͼͬͳͰͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͳ;ͲͺͷΕͼͶͱͰͳΒͳ
ͻͰͽͻͼ͵ͳͼͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͪ͊ͪͷͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪͽͰ͵ͶͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ;͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒ;
ͪͼͶͰͯͰΕͳͪͳ͆ͪΒͺͻͰΒͰͪͻ
ͼͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͺͪͼͽͳͷͪ
;̓ͪͶͳ͵ͻͪͽͳΒ;ͺͼͶͪ
ͪͅͻ͵ͪ
ͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽ̺ͪͰͶͳ͵͈ͭͻͰͼͶͪͬͪ
ͬͰͷͪ;ͭͶͰͯ;Ͷͳͼͽ
ͼͪͲͪͯͪͽ͵ͷ
ͯͪͻͭͪͳͲ;ΒͰͺͻͰͼ͇ΒͰͽͳ;ͳͳ
;ͻͰͯͳͬͳͼͬͰ;ͬͰͲͳͼͺͻͼͶͪͬͷ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͭͯͳͰ͋ͼ;͈ͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼͳ͵ͪͪͅ͵ͪͻͳΒͪ
͈ͪͻͪ͵ͶͳͼͫͻͳͲ͉;ͷ;ͼ͵Ͱͪ͵ͪͯͰ
ͷͳΒͰͪ;͵ͪ
͵ͪͳͿͻͪͭͷͰͽͬͰͻͬͪͽ͈ͻͶ͵ͭͱͳͽͳΒͪ
ͱͪͻͬͼ͵ͳ;ͫ
ͶͳͰ͵ͪͷͶͳͽͬͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͺͻͰͺͲͪͶͪͳͫΒͪͬͳͶͪ̓ͶͳͷͰͽͳͪ́ͬͪͬͪ
̽ͪΓͳͽ͵ͯͭͪΌͪΒͪͯͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽ͆ͪ͵ͺͪͯͪ͋ͻͬͪͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ
͵Ͱ
͵ͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͰ͋ͰͿͪͳͼͬͰͽͰ͍ͳͶͽͰΒͰ
ͺͻͰͰͽͰͼ;;̺ͳͯͳ
;͵ΒͰͷͼ;ͼͽͪͶͰͯͭͯͳͰ͆ͰͲͪͼͰͳͽͪͪͳ;Δͳͬͭͺͻ
ͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪ;ͽͷ͵ͻͪͽ͵ͷͺͻͰͶͪͲͷͺͰͻͳͯ;́ͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͳͼ;ͳͼ͵Γ;ͳͶͳ
ͷͭ;Εͼͽͯͪͼ;;ͽ;ͼͬͻ;ͷͭͶͳͫͳͽͳͼͪͳΔͰͳͰ͵ͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳ
ͺͺ;ͽ͊Ͷͬͪ
͵ΒͰΒͰͼͬͰͽΒ͍ͳͶͽͰΒͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͪ͠ͼͪͿ͇ͳ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͯͯͪͪͼ
ͳͼ;ͺͻͪΌͰͳ̓ͪ͵ͫͳͶ
ͯͰͼͺͽͪͽ̓ͼͽͪͽͳ̹ͪͯͳͪ
ͺͼͶͰͯΔ;ͼͪͷ
ͼͽͪͶ;ͽͬͻͰͬͳ;
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͼ;;ͼͺͰͶͰͯͪͼͪ;ͬͪΒ;̓ͻͪͽ͵ͽͻͪΒͷͬͳͯͳ
ͼ͵ͷͰͺͳͲͯͷͲͪͬͻͪͬͪͼͰͼͳͭ;ͻͪΒͫͶͳͼͽͪͬͳΒͰ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͻͪͲͯͫΓͰ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;͋͵ͷΔͰͭͬͭͽͻͪΒͪΔͪͼͬͰͽ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͶͪͯ;ͭͺ;ͽmͯͶ͵ͪͶͰͽͻͪ͵ͳΒͼ͵Ͱ;ͯͽͬͻͳͰͺͼͽͪͶͪΒͰͲͬͪͳͺͻͳ
ͲͪͽͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͪ
ͳΒͳͼ;tͱͳͽͳΒͰͳͱͳͲi;ͺͯͫΓͰͳͪΒͬͳͳͷͪͭͳͭͻͪͿ
ͼ͵ͳͷ ͳ ͳͷͶ͵ͳͷ ͼͽͪͯͪͻͯͳͷͪ ͆ͪ͵ ͽͭͪ ͈Ͱͽ͵ͪ ΒͰ ;Ͳͯͳͭ;ͽͪ ; ͻͪͭ
ͼͬͰͽͰͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓ͵ͰͺͻͰͼͽͭͭͻͪͯͪ͋ͻͬͪ
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺͳͰͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͰͯͻͱͪͬͰͳ
ͪͻͯͪͳͭͪͻͪͽͪΔͰͰͼͳͭ;ͻͼͽͳ͆ͪ͵ͻͪΒ;
͵ͪͶͳͰΔͰͯ;ͬͭͳͪͼ͵Ͱͽ
ͼ͵ͭͪͰͶͪ
ͼͽͪΒͪͶͪΒͰ
;ͼͬΒͼͽͬ;ͰͫͰͼ͵ͰͷͶͳͽͰΓ͵Ͱ
ͪͺͼͶͰͯΔΒͶͳͳΒͳ
ͯͫͻͪͰͺͻͰͯͳͬͰͻͳͷͪ
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͻͪͲͯͫΓͰ͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͫͳͶΒͰ
;ͯͼ;ͪͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵
Ͱ;ͺ
ͻͰͯͳͬ͵ͻͪΕͰͳͷͪΔͰͬͰͶͳͪͼͽͬͰ
ͪͶͳͳͺͪ͵ͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͳͼͪͯͻͱͪΒ͈ͻ
ͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰͽͰͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͰͳͷͪͶΒͰ
;ͼͽͪͶͷ
ͯ;ͭ;ͽͻͪͯͳͳΒ;;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬ
Β͊ͻͫͳΒͳ͌ͽͷͺͭͶͰͯ;ͯͪͻͳͽͭΒͰͲͪͪΒͪͳΔͰͳͪͯͪͳͲͼͻͰͯͳͰ
9***ͬͰ͵ͪͺͽͳͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͺͻͰͺͳͼͼͶ;ͱͫͰͰͺͳͬͪͽͼ͵ΒͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͳ;͈ͻͪͲͳͷ
ͷͳͰΒ;/P
͵ΒͳͼͰ;ͬͪ;̸ͻͳͬ;̸͊͆͌;̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ;́ͪ͵ͼͽͻ;͵ͽ;ͻͪͽͰ
ͼͶ;ͱͫͰͺ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͯͻͰΌͰͰͰͺͯ;ͯͪͻͼͽͳ;ͯͼ;ͪͪΒͼͽͪͻͳΒͳ
ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳ
ͺͻͰͺͳͼͼͪ;ͬͪ;̽ͻͪͭͪͬͷͷͳͰΒ;mͽ;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵Ͱ;Ͷͳͽ;ͻͭͳΒͼ͵Β
ͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ͠;ͱͳ͊ͶͬͰͪ;9***ͬͰ͵;mͯͬͪͼͪͼͽͪͬͪͼ;ͺͼͪͯͻͱͳͳͳͯͰͽͳͪ
͋ͼ;ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͪͬͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔ͉ͪͪͯͼͶͪͬͰ͋ͻͳͿͬͰ
͵ΒͪΒͰͼͺͻͪͬͷͳͼ
ͽͪ͵ͶͪͯͪͼͰ͵;Ͷͽ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ̾ͺͳͬͪͽͼ͵ͰͼͳͻͳͲͬͪͳͻͳͺͯͻ;ΒͰͷ̹ͪͶ͵ͪ
*EFN
͋΅ͻͬͼ͵ͪͽͪ͵ͳͱͬͪ͵ͶͪͳͻͪͲͬͳͽͳͰͽͪͳͷͳͪͽͪͺͰͲͳΊͬͼͽͪͻͪͽͪ
ͫ΅Ͷͭͪͻͼ͵ͪͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
͋΅ͻͬͼ͵ͪ͵ͳͱͬͪ͵Ͷͪm
m
́ͬͪͬͪ
̿ͳͽͳͰͽ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͪ͋΅ͻͬͼ͵ͪ
͈̽Ͱͽ͵ͪͬͪ
͊ͽͪͻͫ΅Ͷͭͪͻͼ͵ͪͶͳͽͰͻͪͽ;ͻͪ
͐ͪͼͽ** 9***m97***ͬͰ͵
͊ͿͳΊ
m
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͺͶͱͪΒͻ͵ͬͰ͌ͼͺͰΔ̹ͪͭͻͯͳͰ
ͼͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͼ͵ͳͷͯͬͻͷ;̽ΔͰͷͭͻͪͯ;
ͼͻͰͯͳͪ97ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͷ͈ͪͅͺͬͳΕ;
͇ͪͽͷͰͯͪΒͰͼͬͰͽ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳͽͬͪͪͳͺͻͰͰͭͽͼ;ΒΒͷͽͳ
ͽ;ͺͻͰͰͽͰͼͬͰͯͳͳͶͳ͵ͬͪͭͻͪΌͪ͌ͱͳͬͺͳͼͪͷͺͻͭͻͪͷ;ͻ͵ͬͰ;͆
ͬΒ͈ͪͬͶͳͳ
ͪͼͽͪͶͷ;ͬͻͰͷͰ͵ΒͰΒͰͰͺͼͻͰͯͺͻͰͽͯͳͶͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͳ
ΔͰͶͳ͵ͪͪͼͰ;ͿͻͳͲ;ͺͺͻͼΒͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͳͪͼͶͳ͵ͪͳͪͲͪͺͪͯͷͲͳͯ;
͉ͰͳͽΒͰͽͽͼͬͰͽ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͪͽ;ͼͳͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽt͋ͻͬͼ͵ͪi
̽͵ ΒͰ ͺͻͳͼͺͰΕͰ ͼͬͰͽͰ ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ ; ͋ͻͬ ͫͳͶ ͵ͻ;ͪ ΒͰͯͭ ͫͶͳͼͽͪͬͭ ͳ
ͺͶͰͽͭ
ͯͻͱͪͬͽͬͻͳͷͺͯ;ͬͪͽͳͷͪͫͰͶͰͱͰͭͻͪͲͯͫΓͪͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵Ͱͺ
ͬͰͼͽͳ
ΔͰͯͶͪͲͪ͵;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͲͫͳͼͰ;ͽͰ͵ͳͷͬͻͰͷͰͳͷͪͯͰ͵ͪͯͰͳΒͰ͵
Βͪ ͼ; ͪͭͬͰͽͪͬͪͶͪ Ͱ;ͷͳͽ; ͺͻͺͪͼͽ ͅͽͳͼ;ͺͻͰͰͽͰ ͭͯͳͰ
;
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
ͬΌͰͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͼͽͻͪͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬͳͶͪΒͰͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͼͬͳͷͲͰͷͪΓͼ͵ͳͷ
ͬͻͰͯͼͽͳͷͪ
ͽΒͰͽͺͼͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͳͲͼͽͪͻͳΒͳͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͪ;͵Βͳͷͪ
ͼ;ͺͳͼͪͳͺͻͰͭͬͻͳ́ͬͪͪ**̸ͼͰͪͼ̈́ͪͽͳͳͷͪ͌ͫͳͪΒͰͳͷͺͽͳͷͷͰ
ͼͽͳͷͪͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͳͳͲͻͪͲͳ;ͼͳΕͰΔͪͳͯ;ͫ͵Ͱͽͻ;ͽͼͽͳͲͫͭͽͭͪtͽͼ;
ͼͽͰ͵Ͷͳͽͪ͵ͬ;ͻͳͲͳ;
ͼͪ͵ΒͷΒͰͳͽͪͬͼͬͰͽͰ;ͺͻͰͯͳͬi͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
Ͱͼ;ͷΔͳͬͯͻͪͲͻͰͪͶͳͲͫͳͬͪΔͪΒͰͼͽͰͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͽͷͰͯͪΒͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ
ͼ͵ͪͺͻͯͳͪͯͪͻͳͬͪͶͪͷͽͳͼ͵;ͺͰͳͷͲͶͪͽͳͷͯͰΒͪͳΒͰͷ͌ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪΒͰ
ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪͷͽͳΒ;;͊ͻͫͳΒ;͆ͪͼͬ;͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͭͽͬͻΌͰΔͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͶͳ
͵ͬͳΒͪͺͶͱͰͪt;ͼͬͰͽ;ͻ͵ͬ;
͵ΒͪΒͰ;Δͳͬͷͯͷ;i
ͷͱͰͼͰͺ;Ͳͯͪ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͯͪΒͰͺͻͬͯͻͰͯͳͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;ͫͳͶͪͺͻͳͯͬͻͪͻ͵ͬͪ;
̓ͻ;Ͱͬ;
ͺͲͪͽͪ͵ͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͳͪ͢ͳͬͪ;ͶͭͪͫͳͶͪΒͰͯͪͼͻͺͼ͵;ͯͳͪͼͽͳ
Β;tͫͰͼͺͻͰ͵ͻ;ͬͪͯͪͳͶͪͲͰΕͳͪͺͪͯͪΒͪi͈ͳͼͪ͊ͶͬͪͰͺͻͺ;ͽͪͯͪ
ͳͼͽͪ͵ͰͲͪͼͶ;ͭͰ͊ͻͫͪͲͪͽͽͼ;ͯͻͪͭͰ;ͼͬͰͽͳΔ;ͼͪ;ͬͪͶͳͯtͬͪͻͬͪͻ
ͼ͵ͭͫͰͲ;ͷΓͪi͊ͪͻͳͽͳͷ;ͬͪͱͪͬͪΔͰͷͭͬͻͳͱͰͪͷͪ͵ΒͰͼ;ͳͲͬͰͶͰ
ͳͽͪͬͺͯ;ͬͪͽ
ͪͲͳͬͪΒ;ΕͳͳtͫͭΓ;ͫͪͲͳͷͳͬͰͶͳ͵ͺͬͪͶͳͷͷ;ͱͰͬͳ
ͷͪi͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͬͼͽͪͬͯͪͼͰtͻͪͲ;ͷͷͼ;ͯͳͽΒͰ͵ͻͰͺ͵ͳͷ;ͱͪͼͽͬͰ
ͪͰ
ͫͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͳͻͯͰiͷͭͪͫͳͫͳͽͳͺͪͻͪͿͻͪͲͪͻͰͳͳͲ̿ͳͽͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ
ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͪ ͠ͰͬͽͳͷͳΒͪ ͽͷͰ ͯͪ ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͪ tͺͻͳͯͫͳ ͬ ͱͰͼ͵ͪͽͪ ͺͻͳͻͯͪ
ͷ΅ͱ͵ͳͻͪͲ;ͷi
ͯ͵
;ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͼͬͰͯͳͼͳͼͽͰͷ;ͬͻͰͯͼͽͳ;͵ΒͰͷ
ͼ;ͺͪͷͰͽ
ͺͻͰͯ;ͲͳͷΓͳͬͼͽͳͬͻͼͽͳͪͼͷͪͽͻͪͰͽͳͺͳͷ;͵ͳͷͬͻͶͳͪ
ͷͪ͊ͶͬͼͰͲͪͬͻͪͬͪͺͳͻͷ
ͯͫͻͺͲͪͽͷͺͬͪͶͷ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ΔͰͳͷ
ͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͳͷͪͳͳͼͺͼͳͪͷͪ
ͷͪͼͳͷͪ
ͺ;ͼͽͳͱͳͽͰΓͳͷͪͳͪͻͳΒͰͻͰΒͳͷͪ
͆ͪ͵ͻͪΒ;ͼ;ͯͶͪͲͪ͵ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͳͲ̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͰͳΔͰͺͻͳͼͺͰΕͰ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͺͻͽ;
ͷͪͰͳ̹ͱΒͳͷͺͻͷͳͼͶͷmͯͪͼͰͲͪͺͪͯͪͲͰͷΓͪtΔͰͳͷͯͶͪͼ͵ͷͼͬͰͽͳ
ͳͪͫΓͰ;ͽͬͻͯͳi
͊ͶͬͺͻͰͼ;ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ΒͰͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͪ͵ͭͯͳͰ
ΒͰͻ
ͼͰͪΒͰͯͷͷͰͼͽ;ͺͷͳΔͰͯͰͼͺͽͼ͵ͪͽͳͽ;Ͷͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͬͪ
ͪͺͻͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ͋ͪΒͬͪͱͪͯͭͪΌͪΒ
͵ΒͰͷͼͰ;ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;Ͱͭͬͻͳ
Ͳͫͳ
ͼͰͰͭͯͰ;ͺͻͬΒͯͰͰͳΒͳ97ͼͽͶͰΕͪ
ͪͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͺͼͶͰͭͯͳͰ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;
͊ͻͫͳͲͪͯͫͳͶͳ̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ͋ͪͯͪͼ;ͲͪͺͰͽͳͺͼͰͱͳͻͪͯͬͳͪΔͰͭͬΒͻͰ͵
ͼͽͻ;͵ͳΒͳ
ͼͳΓͰͷͯͪͼͰͭͻͪͯͳͯͰΒͳͭͻͪͯͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳ;ͫͶͳͳ͵ͪͬͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͪ
ͺͻͰͼͽͳ͇ͪͽͳΒͰͷͭͪͺͼͽͪͽͳͫͰͲͼͬͰͽͳͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͪ
ͶͳͰͳ;
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
;ͯͽͬͻͳͷͳ͵ͪͷͪͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷͷͽͳͷͪ̽Ͱͼͺͽ;͊ͽͰͿͪ;ͺͶΒͰ
Ͳͪͻ;͵ͷͯͪͯΌͰͯͬͰͷͪͬͻͰͯͳͼͬͰͽͳΔͪ
͵ͪͽΒͰͫͳͶͪͻ;͵ͪ̓ͼͽͪͽͳ
̺ͪͰͶͳ͵ͭͳͶͳΒͰͯͪͰͻ;͵ͽͬͻͰͳͫͻͪͲ̹ͭͻͯͳͳ͋ͳͷͯͻͪͭͰ
ͼͽͳͷͪͺͻͳͯͻ;ͱͰͰͼ;ͳͰͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͰͳͲ̹;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͰmͷͽͳͪͻͳͰ͋ͰͿͪͳ
ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ͈ͻͬͫͳͽͷͰͼͽ;ͬͪΔͪͽͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͯͪͪͼͳΒͰͺͲͪͽmͰ
ͲͪͼͰͪ͵ͳͯͪͶͳͼ;ͫͳͶͰͭͻ;ͺͳͼͪͰ;ΒͰͯͷͻͪͷ;ͳͶͳͻͪͼͺͻͰΌͰͰͺ
ͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳͷͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͷͻ͵ͬͪͷͪ͊ͫͲͳͻͷͪͳͲ;ͲͰͽ;ͼͶͱͰͼͽͺͳͽͪΔͪ
ͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵ͰͷͰͼͽ;;ͬͪΔͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͬͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͷͱͰͷ
ͳͲͶͱͳͽͳͼͪͷ;ͭͶͪͬͳͷͻͽͪͷͪ
͠Ͱͯͪͯͷͭ;ΕͳͶ͵ͪͳΒͪ
ͺͪͪͶͭͳΒͳͼ̓ͻ;ͰͬͰͷ
ͫͳͶͪͫͳͯͬͻͼ͵ͪ
͵ͪͺͰͶͪ͵ΒͪΒͰͳͳͶͪͯͰ͵ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼͪͻͰ͵ͼͽͻ;ͳͼͪͭͲͪͷ͵ͪͼͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͻͰ
ͲͳͯͰͳΒͷ͋;ͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵;
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
Ͱͺͯ;ͺͳͻͰͳΒͰͯͪͺͳͼͪͳͳͲͬͻ
̸͵ͼ;ͼͰͷͽͳͽ;ͳ͵ͪͯͪͳͪͶͪͲͳͶͰ
Ͱͼ;ͷͻͪͶͰͫͳͽͳͺͻͰͼͰΓͰͰͪ͵
ͯͶͪͼ͵ͪͪͅΌͪͻͪͭͯͳͰ
ͫ;ͯ;ΕͳͯͪΒͰͺͻͼͽͻ̻ͻΔͰͭͭͻ̹ͪͯͪͰͭͻͪͯͼ͵Ͱ
ͽͬͻΌͪͬͰͽͪͯͪͲͪͽͬͻͰͲͪͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͳͱͳͬͪΓ͊ͶͰͯͰΕͪͷͭ;ΕͼͽΒͰͯͪͼ;ͷ
ͽͳ;ͬͪͰ;ͻ͵ͬͳͺͼͬͰΕͰΒͼͬͰͽΒ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳ
ͳΒͰͺͼͽΒͪΔͰͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰͯ͵;
ͷͰͽͳͲͯͪͽ;̽;ͫͻͬͳ͵;ͅͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͰͼͪͷͯͪͰͷͪͳͲͬͻͪ͵Βͳͫͳ
ͽ;ͳͺͽͰͲ;ͺͽͬͻͯͳͶͳͬͰΕͼͰͳͽͪͰͲͪͳͶ͵ͪͳΒͳͻ͵ͬͰ͊ͪͯͪΔͰ
͵;ͶͽͷͰͼͽ
͵ΒͰͼͰͬͰͲ;ΒͰͲͪ;ͯͽͬͻͳͳͲͬͻͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ
ͳ͵ͪ͵Ͱ
ͷͱͰͫͳͽͳͳͺͻͬͫͳͽ
ͲͫͭͯͬͪͻͪͲͶͭͪͺͻͬ
͵Ϳͳͭ;ͻͪͳΒͪͻͰΓͰͿͪ
͵Βͳ
ͳͳͼͽͻͷͪͺͪͯͳͪ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷΒͰͰͺͯͰͼͪͲͪͲͪͼͳͬͪΔͰͭͻͪΌͰͬͳͰͳ
ͯͻ;ͭ
ͼͪͷͳͲͬͻͫͳΒͰ;ͯͪΓͰͯͽͪͯͪΔͳͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͫͰͯͰͷͪͽͰ͵ͺͰͯͰͼͰͽͪ͵ͷͰͽͪͻͪ
ͽΒͰ
ͳͲͬΒͼͽͻͪͽͰ͵ͳͻͪͲͶͭͪ
Ͱͷͭ;ΕͪͬͪͶͺͯͳͲͪΔͰͫͳͶ͵ͪ͵ͬͭ
ͺͪͳͼͪ͵ͻͪͶͭͫΒͰ͵ͽͪ͋ͻͰΕͪͷͭ;ΕͼͽΒͰͯͪͼ;ͷͽͳ;ͬͪͰ;ͻ͵ͬͰͷ
ͼͻͰͯͳͽ;mͷͪͪͼͽͳͻ;͌ͼͺͰΔ̹ͪͭͻͯͳͰ
ͪͺͻͼͽͻ;̽ΔͰͭͭͻͪͯͪ
ͪ;Ͳ͵
ΒͳΒͰͫͳͶͪͺͯͳͭ;ͽͪͳͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͼ͵ͪͻͰͲͳͯͰͳΒͪ͋ͪͶ͵ͪͳΒͪ
ͫͰͲͫͲͳͻͪ
ͪͽͯͪͶͳΒͰͺͻͬͫͳͽͪ
ͰͼͺͻͪΒͰͯͭͯͳͰ
ͪͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͪΒͰͬͰΕ
ͺͷͰ;ͽͳͷͺͳͼͷͷͫͰͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͭͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͪ͋ͰͿͪͪͷͼ͵ͬͼ͵ͷͬͰͶͳ͵ͷ
͵ͰͲ;̺ͪͼͳͶͳΒ;́ͪ͵ͼͰ;ͽΒͭͻͪͷͽͳͺͳͷͰͰͺͷͳΔ;ͼͪͷͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͪͯ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰͳͽͪͷͶͰͫͪ
ͳͲͽͰ͵ͼͽͪΒͪͼͼͶͰͯͳͯͪͼ;;ͽͬͻͰͷͰ;͌ͼͺͰͼ͵ͷ
ͻͪͷ;;ͬͪͰͼͬͰͫͰͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
͆ͬͳͻͰͲ;ͶͽͪͽͳͪͻͰͶ͵ͳͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͫͰͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͰͅͳͽͻͺͶͳΒͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͺͻ;ͱͪΒ;ͺͼͻͰͯͪͪͶͳͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͽͷͰͯͪͼ;ͼͰ
ͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱͽ;ͪͶͪͲͳͶͰͬͰΕͯͺͰͽͰͯͰͰͳΒͰ97ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪ͵ͰͳͻͪͳΒͰ
͌ͽͬͻΌͰΒͰ
ͪͳͷͰ
ͯͪΒͰͼͳͲͬͻͪ͊ͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ
͵ΒͳͼͰͳͯͪͪͼͺͽ;ΒͰ͵ͪ
ͶͰ͵ͬͳͽ
ͬͯͪͫͳͶͪͼͺͻͬͰͯͰͪ;͵ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼͷͪͪͼͽͳͻͪ͌ͼͺͰΔͪ
ͳͽͯͬͰͶͳ͵Ͱ
ͯͬͻͪͰͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͼ͵ͭͯͬͻͪ͆ͪͽͷͷͰͼͽ;ͳͼͽͳͪͶͪΒͰ͵ͻͲͯͰ͵ͻͪͽͳͬ
ͷͯͰͶͬͪ;Ϳͽͪ;
ͪͺͽͷΒͰͼͪ͵;ͺΓͪͪ;ͳͼͽͰͻ;͵ΒͪͼͰͪͶͪͲͳͶͪͳͲ
ͷͰΌ;ͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͼ͵ͭͯͬͻͪͳΒ;ͱͭͲͳ̹ͯͪͭͻͯͳͳͰͻ͵ͬͰ͋;ͼ;ͼͰ
ͼ
ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰͲͳͯͪ
ͷͭͶͰͪͶͪͲͳͽͳͷͽͳ
ͪͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͷͷͰͼͽ;
Β;ͱ
ͯͶͽͪͻͼ͵ͳͯͬͰͻͳ
ͺͪͫͳͳ
ͽͪ͵
ͼͪͷͲͳͯͯͰͶͳͯͳͼͽͰͻͰ̺ͪͱΒͰ
ͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳͯͪΒͰͻͰͳͼͽͰͻͳͼͿͳͶͽͰͻͫ;ͪͻͷ
ͯ͵ΒͰͯΒͰͬͯͪͯͿͽͪ
ͰͫͳͶͪͼͺͻͬͰͯͰͪͰͬͳͷͪ͋ΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͫͳ;ͻͰΌͪΒͼͶͱͰͰ͵ͼͽͻ;͵ͳΒͰͳ
ͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶͭͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
͵Βͳͽ͵ͻͳͬͪͬͪͱͪͪͼͺͰ͵ͽ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͭ͵;Ͷͽ͈ͪͻͰͷͪ
ͽͷͰ
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͳͳͲͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͪtͰͳͼͻͺͳͷͼͽͻ;ΒͪͷͪͬͯͰ͵Βͪͽͳ
ͳͼͰΓͰΔͰiͳͼͺͲͳͬͷΓ;ͯͳͷͪͯͪͺͻͳΌ;ͳͲͪͬͪͽͰΒͰͳͼ;ͼͪͷͶͳͽͰͻͪͻͪ
ͺͽͪͷͰͼͽͪͬͰΕͼ;ͳͯͻͪͲͻͰͪͶͳ͵Ͷͼͽͳ͊Ͷͳͪ;ͻͰΌͪΒͪͷͰΔͰͯͬ
ΌͰΔ;ͼͬͰͽͰͬͯͰ
;Ϳ;͵ͳΒͳ͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͭ͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͷͭͪΒͰͺͼͽΒͪͽͳͳ;ͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵Β
ͼͻͰͯͳͳ
ͽͫͳͬͻͰͯͰͶͺͻͬͰͻͳͽͳͪͻͰͶ͵ͳͷͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͳͷͪ͠ΒͰͯ
ͷͰͼͽ̹ͪͰͭͻͪͯͼ͵ΒͽͬͻΌͪͬͳͪΒͬͰͻͬͪͽͳΒͰΒͰͺͬͰͲͪͼ͵;ͶͽͷͼͬͰͽͰ
͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ ͈ͻͰͷͪ ͼͪ;ͬͪͷ ͺͻͰͯͪΔ;
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ ͺͻͰͼͪ ; ̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ ͷͽͳ ͼ;
ͺͻͰΕͳͶͰ;ͷͪͶΒͺͰΕͳͳ͵ͪͺͳͳ͵ΒͪΒͰͳͯͪͪͼͺͻͰͺͲͪͽΓͳͬͪ
ͪͪͶͪͲͳ
ͼͰ;ͼͪͼͽͪͬ;ͭͻͪΌͰͬͳͰͺͻͳͲͳͯͪͰ;Ͳͬ;ͻ͵ͬ;͊ͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ͌͵Ͷͳ͵ͺͷͰ
;ͽͺͻͰͯͪΔͰͳͷͪͫͳͶ͵ͪ͵ͬͰͼͽͬͪͻͰͼͬͰ
ͫͳͶͪͫͳͽͺͼͶͰͯΔͪͰͬ͵ͪͳΒͪ
͈Ͱͽ͵ͳͭͺ;ͼͽͳͱͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͭͪͫͳͽ;ͼͪ
͈ͻͰͼͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͳͷͪΒͰͰͺͼͻͰͯͭͯΒͰ͵ͪ;ͼͪ
ͼͽͪͬͳͷͪ͵Βͳͼ;ΒͰͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪͶͳ̸͵ͼͰͳͲ;ͲͷͰ͊Ͷ̻ͬͻͳͭͻͳΒͪ͏ͪͷͫͶͪ͵ͪ
;
͊ͻͫͳΒͳͲͪͺͽͻͰͫͰ͵;Ͷͽͪͳͼ;ͼͪͳΔͰͰͬͰͽͬͻͰͬͳͰ
ͬͰΕͼ;ͬͻͰͰͻͰͯͪ͵
ͳΒͰ
ͺͻͰͻͪͯͰͳͶͳͯͺ;ͰͺͼͽΒͰΕͳ͋ͰͳͽͰͻͬͰͳΒͰͼ;
͵ͪͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͻͰ
ͷͰͪ
ͬͰͷͪͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͪͳͼͶͱͰͪͭͻͪΌͪ
͵ΒͪͫͳͲͪͼͶ;ͱͳͬͪͶͪͺͼͰͫͪͻͪͯ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͊;ͽͳͪͳͷΒͰ;ͳͼͽͳͪΔ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͲͰͷΓͰͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
;ͲͷͶͳͽͬ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ͵ͳͲͪ
ͺͷΕͳͺͼͻͰͯͬͪΔͰ́ͲͷͰͰͳͯͺ;ͰͺΒͪͬΓ;Β;ͼͰ;Ͱ͵Ͷͳ͵ͺͻͰͺͳͼͪ͠Ͱͬ
ͽͳͷͳΒͰͬͭ̿ͳͽͳΒ͇ͪͬͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͪͬͯͳͷͰ͵Ͷͳ͵͵ͪͻͪ͵ͽͰͻͳͼͽͳͳ
ͺͻͳͷͰͻͪ͌ͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;/PͳͲͭͯͳͰ ͊ͪ͵ͽ͈ͰͽͰͻͫ;ͻͭ
͉̹͆
;ͲͪͭͶͪ
ͬΓͰ̿ͳͽͳΒͪͳͽͰͻͺͶͳͻͪͼͰͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͯͪͼ;ͷͽͳͺͻͰͰͽͰ;tͺͻͰͼͶͪͬͰΒ;Β;
ͲͰͷΓ;ͼͻͫͼ͵;Β;i;ͼͰͯͷΒͭͶͪͬͳͻͰͳͺͬͪͶͰtwͽͳΒͰͼͳ̹Ͷͭͪͻͷ͵ͻͪͼͽͪi
ͲͪͷͰΔͰͰͼ;ͼͪtwΒͪͲͳ͵;ͼͻͺͼ͵ͷ;͵ͻͪͼͽͪi͆ͪͼͶͳͪͪͳͼͰ;ͻ;͵ͺͳ
ͼ;/PͳͲ97*ͬͰ͵ͪ ͅͼ͵ͬͪ
͉̻̹
;ͲͪͭͶͪͬΓ;
͵ͪͱͰͯͪͼ;ͷͽͳͯͰͽͰ;
tͼͶͪͬ;Β;ͲͰͷΓ;ͼͻͫͼ͵;Β;iͳͲͲͪͬͻͰͷͶͳͽͬͰͳͲͫͪͰͰͼ;ͼͬͰͻͰͽͻͼ͵ͰͿͳ
ͭ;ͻͰ;͵ΒͳͷͪͼͰͺͷͳΔͰͫ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͪͻͳͲͪͷͰΔͰͰͷͶͳͽͬͷͯͪͼͰͼͪ;ͬͪtͫͶͪ
ͭͪͼͽͳͬͳͭͼͺͯͳͪͯͰͼͺͽ͚;ͻͪΌi͋Ͱͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͺͻͰͻͪͯͰ̿ͳͽͳΒͪ
ͱͪͻͬ
ͼ͵ͳͽͻͪͼͿͻͷͳͼͪͰ
ͪͺͼͰͫͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͪͳͳͼͺΓͳͶͰͼ;ͼͰͯͳΒͰ;
ͺͻͰͺͳͼ;ͼͪ;ͬͪͷ;ͅͳͰΒ;̹ͱͳͯͪͻ̺ͪ;͵ͬͳΕͪͳͲͭͯͳͰ
́ͽͰͻͬͰͳΒͰͼ;ͬͻͰͰͳ;ͯͻ;ͭͳͷͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷ͈ͪͻͰͺͲͪΒ;ͼͰ;ͬͰΕͺͷͳ
Δͪͷ͈ͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼ;ͳͲ͉;ͷ;ͼ͵Ͱͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͰͪ;͵ͪ
ͭͯͰͼ;;ͫͪͰͳͻͰͯͬͳ͈Ͱͽ
͵ͳͷͯͶͪͼ͵;t͵Ͳͪͺͪͯ;i͈ͻͰͻͪͯͰͼ;ͪΒ;ΓͳͬͳΒͰ;͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳ
͵ΒΒͼ;ͺͻͳ
ͯͯͪͽͰͬͰͼͽͳͳͻͰ͌ΔͳͷͪΒͰͼͬFͽB͈Ͱͽ͵ͪtͼ͵ͳͺͽͪͻͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͳͲͪͽͳͽͳͪi
tͲͰͷΓͳͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͺͷΕͳͪi
ΔΒͼͰtͻͪͯ;ΒͰͭͻͪͯͼͻͺͼ͵ͳi̓ͪͱͰͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳͽͯͪΒͰͼͬͰͽ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͪtͳͼͬͳͷ͵ͶͳͷͲͰͷΓͪͷͪͲͪͽͳͽͳͪi
ͪ;tͼͶͪͬͳi
ͭͶͪͼͼͷͳ
ͼͽΒͳͳͼͶͰͯͰΕͰt͊ͽͭͪͼͰͳ̓ͪͶͳ͵ͻͪͽͳΒͪͬͰͷͪͻͪͯ;ΒͰͺͻͰͰΔ;
ͷͽͳΒ;ͽͬΒͳ
ͺͻͰͺͯͫͪi͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͪ͵ͺͻͰͼͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;
ͼͬͰͽ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͪͼͽͳͰͪͽͻͳͫ;ͽt̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͪi͈ͻͰͼΔͰͭtͺͼͻͫΓͪͬͪΔͪiͷͱͰ
ͼͰ͵ͽͳ;ͳͻͪͺͻͪͽͳͽͳͽ͵ͷͯ;ͱͰͭͻͪͲͯͫΓ͈ͪͲͪͽΒͰͺͻͳͷͰͻͺͺ͈ͪ;
ͪ
͵Βͳ;97***ͬͰ͵;ͺͳͰͯͪͼͬͰͽ͈ͪͰͽ͵ͪtͫͰͰͽͲͰͷΓ;ͼͻͫͼ͵;Β;i͋ͪ͵ͬͳ
ͺ͵;ͪΒͳ
͵ΒͳͯͶͪͲͰͯͬͻ;ͪ;ͻͷͪͽͳͪͻͼ͵Β
ͺͪͽͻͳͽͼ͵Βͳͼͽͻͳͭͻͪ
]]
͉̺̺͈̾̈́́̓́̾͊̾͋̾̾͋̓̾͠(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅ
ћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
̸̸͇͇͇͉͇̻͉͍͌̽ͣ́͊͋́́́̓͌̈́͋͠͠ͅͳͳ͵ͭͻͪͿͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱmͪͺ
ͼͽͶͪͳΒͰͬͪΌͰͶͳͼͽͰ
ͺͻͬͭͳ͵ͺͳͼͪͳtΓ;ͫΓͰͭͶͰ͵ͪͻͪimͫͳͶͳͼ;Ͱ
ͯͪͬͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͽͰͷͰΓͰͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰ
ͲͪͼͬͪͰͪͳͼͻͺͷͻͪͲͷͪͽͻͪΔ;ͻͪͼͺ
Ͷͱͳͬͳ ͳͲͬͻͪ
͵ͪ͵ ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳ ͳ ͪͭͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳ ͽͪ͵ ͳ Ͷͳ͵ͬͳ ͌
ΔΒΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͼͺͻͪͬͷ;͵ͪͲͪͪͽͯͪ͵ͻͪͽ͵ͽͻͪΒͪͪͶͳͬͪͱͪͫͻͪͬͪ͵
̈́;͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ;ͬͳΒΒͪ;ͳͳΒͰͳͷͪͯΒͰ͵ͪ
ͯ͵ΒͰ;Ͳͪͺͪͯ
Ͱͬͻͺͼ͵ΒͳͼͽͻͳͭͻͪͿͳΒͳ;ͺͽͺ;ͼͽͳͺͻͰΕ;ͽ̺ͪͳͰͼͽͻ;͵ͳͼ;ͻͪͲͶͲͳ
Ͳͫͭ͵Βͳͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͽͰͲͪͷͰͳͽͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳͯ
ͯͭͯͳͰͲͪͬͻͰΌ;ΒͰͺͪͱΔ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳ͈ͬͪͪͻͰͼͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;
͵Ͱ;͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬ
ͷͽͳͬͳͼͪͺͻͰ͵ͷͺͽͻͰͫͷͯͪͼͰ;ͭͻͱͰΒ̽Ͱͼͺͽͬͳͳ
ͫͰͲͫͰͯͳͰͫͰͼ͵ͳͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓ
ͫͪͬΓͰΒͰͪͳͳͳΒͪͽͳͬ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͺͯΔͰ
ͭͬͳͷͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽͬͷ
ͪͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͺͼͶͰͯΔ;USBOTMBUJPSFMJRVJBSVN;ͼͻͺ
ͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒͯͻͱͪͬͳ͈;ͭͶͰͯ;ͪͯͻͰͬͰͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͰͫͳͪΒͰ
ͪͶͳͳ
ͼͻͺͼ͵;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ;ͺͻͪ͵ͼ;
ΒͰͲͪͷͳΓͰ͵ͪͬͰͶͳͪͼͽͬͰͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͳͲͬͰͯͰͪ;Ͳ;ͰΕͰͼͬͳͼͶΒͰͬͪͯͻ;ͽͬͪ
ͺͽͪ;ͽͬͻΌͰͳͷͰͽͪͺͪͷͪͳͼͪ
ͼͬͳͷͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͰͳͷͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪ͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪͺͻͰͯ;ͻͰ
͵ͪͳͿ;͵
ͳΒͰ
ͫͻͰͯΒͰͳͷͪͳͰͺͼͻͰͯͭͺͻͰͽͰ;mͺͻͰͼͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰͳͲ
̺ͳͯͳͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͭͯͳͰ́ͪ͵ΒͰ
ͯͪ͵ͶͰ
ͻͰͳ;͵ΒͳΒͰͳͷͪͯ;ͫ͵Ͱ
͵ͻͰͰ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ
ͺͻͰͼ̈́;͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;ͼͪͯͻͱͪͬͪΒͰͳͲͪͽͰ
ͬͳͰ̀ͪͻͪͲͶͳ͵;ͯͻͪͳΒͳͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ
ΒͰͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͻͰͶͪͽͳͬͳͷ
ͫͳΓͰͷͺͳͼͪͳͳͲͬͻ͇ͪͳ
;Ͳͽ
ͼͪͯͻͱͰͷͭ͵͵ͻͰͽͳͺͳͼͪͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ
ͳͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ
ͻͪͳΒͰͼͪͼͬͳͷͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰͳ
͵ΒͳͲͪͪΒͺͻͳͻ;Β;ͪͪ
ͲͪΔͪͺΒͰͯͳͳͷͪͼͺͰ͵ͽͳͷͪ͵;ͶͽͪͷͽͳΒ;;ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ͈ͻͰ
ͯͪͬͪΔ;ͻͰͪͶͼͽͳͼͳͭ;ͻͷͭͯͺͻͳͼͳͽͽΒͰͼͬͰͪͼͽͺͻͰͼͪ
ͼͳͷͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰͷ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͷ
ͺͳͼͪͪͳͪͪͻͯͷΒͰͲͳ͵;̀ͫͭͼͬͰͭͪ
ͽͭͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͷͭ;Ε;ΒͰͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪ;ͯͪͽͪΒ
ͯͭͪΌͪΒ
ͼͳͷ;͵;ͶͽΒ
ͯͬΓͺͻͰͳͲͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪͳ;ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵Βͻͪͬͳ
͈ͻͰͼͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ;͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͭͯͳͰͺͳͼͪΒͰ;Ͱ͵
Ͷͳ͵ͷͰΌ;ͼͫͰͲͪͬͳͼͳͺͻͲͳͳͳͷͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͼͪͼͽ̺ͪͬͪͰͷͪΒͰͬͪ
ͱͪ͵Ͷͼͽͽͽͼ;ͳͼͪ;ͬͪͳ;ͯͬͪͻ;͵ͺͳͼͪ͵ΒͪͼͪͯͻͱͰͳͼ͵Γ;ͳͬ
ͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͰͪͷͰΔͰͰͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔ;ͬͭͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ͠ͰͯͪΒͰͽͪ͵Ͳͬͪͳ͈ͪͻͳͼ͵ͳ
ͻ;͵ͺͳͼ ͆ͪͳͪͶͪͫͳͫͶͳͽͰ͵ͪ
TMBWF
Ͳͫͻͳ͵͵ΒͳͼͪͯͻͱͳͰͼͽͺͻ
ͲͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͪͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͳͼͽͻͳΒͪͽ;̈́;͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;͇ͯΔͳͼ;Ͳͪͪͪ
ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪͪͻͳͽͬͪͱͳͰͽͬͻͽͳͳͺͰͽͳ͊ͶͬͽͻͰΕͰͷͺͻͰͼ;ͳͲ͉
ͭͼͪ;͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͳͽͰ͵ͼͽ;ͯͳͷͪ͵Βͪͼ;ͼͰͲͫͳͶͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒͳ̽ͻ;ͭͳͻ;͵ͺͳͼ
͈ͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͳΒͼ͵ͪͫͳͫͶͳͽͰ͵ͪ
ͫͻ
ΒͰͼͽͰͲͫͻͳ͵
ͺͲͪͽ͵̹ͪͰͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳ
͇ͫ;ͬͪͽͪͯͬͰͼͶ;ͱͫͰͭͶͪͬ;
Ͳͪ͵ͽͫͪͻ
ͳ͊Ͷ;ͱͫ;ͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
ͲͪΒͪ;ͪͻ
;ͼͶͬͪͲͬͪ;͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵͇ͪͯͳͷͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͪͽ;ΒͰ
ͳΒͰͯͪͺͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼ͵ΒͳͼͪͳΔͪͬͪΒ;ͷͶͫͪͰͼͽͳͳͻͰͳ͵ͪ͌ͲΔͳ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͼ͵ͳͻ;͵ͺͳͼͼͪͯͻͱͳͳtͺͬͰͼͽiͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͳ͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬ̀ͪ
ͻͪͲͶͳ͵;͈ͯͪͻͳͼ͵ͭͻ;͵ͺͳͼͪ
;͵ΒͰͷͼͰͯͭͪΌͪΒͺͳͼ;ΒͰͼͪͱͰͽͳ͵͵ͻͰͽ
;Ͳ;ͺͽͻͰͫ;ͪͻͯͭΒͰͲͳ͵ͪ
;̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷΒͰͳͲͶͱͰͺͳͻ
ͽͰ
Ͷ͵ͳͪͯͭͻͪΌͰͳͪͯͰͭͬͪͷ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͷΒͰͲͳ͵;͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͲͪͺͽͻͰͫͰ
ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͪͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵ͰͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͰΒͰͳͺͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼ͵ΒͳͼͰͪͶͪͲͳ;͈ͼͪͶͽͳͻ;
ͼͪͺͼͶͰͯͬͪΔͰͷ ͅ;ͲͰΒ͈͊͏
ͫͻ
ͪ͵ΒͳΒͰͪͼͽͪͰͲͪͬͳͼͯͺͷͰ;ͽͭ
ͺͪͻͪ͵Ͷͳͼͪ;̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;
͋ͳͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͪͼͽͪͶͳͼ;ͳͲͷͰΌ;Βͪ;ͪͻͪ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;ͷͽͳ
ͯͰͽͰ;͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬ
ͳΔͰͭͬͭͺͪͯͪͳͯͰΔͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰΒ;ͪͭͯͳ
Ͱ
ΒͰͻͼͬͰͯͰͽͷͰͯͪͼͰͼͬͰͽͳ̈́;͵ͪͽͪͯͪΒ;ͬͰ͵ͪͶͪͲͳ;ͺͻͰͼͽͳͳ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͲͫͻͳ͵͵ͬͳͻΒͰͺͻͰͯͰΓͰ
ͪͼͬ;ͿͳͶͳͭͻͪͶ͵Ͱͪͪ
ͶͳͲͰ
;Ͱͼͽ;ͯͰͰͳΒ;97ͬͰ͵ͪ
ͪͲͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͳͺͷͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ;͊Ͷ;
ͱͫͳ
͵ͪͳ;͈ͬͰͼͽͳͺͻͰͼ;
ͼ;ͲͳͫͳͭͻΔ;ͬͻͰͷͰͼ͵;ͭͻͪͳ;ͪ
ͭͯͳ;
ͯ͵ΒͰͽͻͪΒͰͼͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼͽͬͯͰͼͺͽ͚ͪ;ͻΌͪͳ̈́ͪͲͪͻ͈ͪͪͻͳͼ͵ͳͻ;͵
ͺͳͼͯͪͽͬͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪͬͯͰͷͲͪ͵;
;͵ͻͪΒͼͰͯͷͰͳͶͳͺͰͽͪ͵ͼͷͰͯͰͰͳΒͰ
97ͬͰ͵ͪ͋ͷͰ;ͺͻͳͶͭͳͪͫͳͯͪͬͳͲͰͽͲͪ͵Γ;ͪ͵
ͲͪͼͬͪͪΒͪ͵ͳͷ
ͪͻͭ;ͷͰͽͳͷͪm;ͪ;ͳ
ͪͱͪͶͼͽ
ͰͯͬΓͳͼ͵ͻͳΕͰmͯͪΒͰͻ;͵ͺͳͼͷ
ͻͪͪͼͽͪͽͳͪ͵ͼͷͻͽͳͼͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵ͭͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽ̸ͪͽͪͪͼͳΒͪͷͪͻͽͪ
ͪͬͰͻͬͪͽͳͪ͵ͯͶͪͼ͵ͪͪͻͳͰͪͅͻͰͳͯͰͼͺͽ̻ͪͻͭ;ͻ͈ͪͪͻͽ;
ͭͯͳͰ͆ͰͯͬΓͭͯΒͰ͵ͪͷͰΌ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͳͷͪͳͷͪͶΒͰͳͷͳΓͰΔͰ
ͽͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͳͷͪ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷͯͻͰΌͰͳͼͷͭ͵͵ͻͰͽͳͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ͈ͻͬͳͺͽͰͲ
ͯͰͼͺͽ͚ͪ;ͻΌͪͫͳͶͪΒͰͺͻͬͰͻͪͪ;ͽͰͽͳͼͽͳ̈́;͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳ
ͽͪ͵;ͶͽͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪm;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
ͪͶͳͳͯͳΒͰmͫͳͶΒͰͽ;ͼͬͪ͵ͷ
ͺͭͶͰͯ;͵Γ;ͺͳͽͪΔͰ͇ΒͰͪͻͳͽ;ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͼͽͲͪͯͫͳͶͪ͵Ͷͪͽͳ
ͼ͵ͭͼͬͪΒͪΔͪ͏ͪͻͳͭͻͪͯͪ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;ͺͻͰͼͽͳ͵Ͱ
ͪͶͳͳͯͻ;ͭͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ
͵ͪͽ͵ͪͯ
ͼͳͺͽͰ͵ͷͼ;ͷΔͳͬͭͺͻͰ͵Ͷͪ
ͯͼͺͰͶͰ;ͷͭͰͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͰͻͳͲͳͰ͊ͽͭͪΒͰ
;ͽͬͻΌͳͬͪΔͰͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͼͽͳͰ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͫͳͶͳͲ;ͲͰͽͬͪͱͪͳͼͶͱͰ
ͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵
͵ΒͳΒͰͼͺͻͬΌͰͪͼͬ;ͷͭͫͻΒͳ
ͽͪ;ͽͬͻΌͰͳ͵ͻͳͽͰ
ͻͳΒ;ͷͪ͌ͪͰͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;ͬͰͽͪͰΔͰΒͰͼͳͭ;ͻͶͪ͵ͪͬͪͶͽͽΒͰ;Ͳͷ
ͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;ͪ͵ͫͻͯͶͷͪͯͼͺͰͶͰ;͉ͭͼ
ͺͻͪΌͰͼͬͳͽͪ͵
Ͱ͵ͪͬͻͼͽͪͼͰͻͽͳͿͳ͵ͪͽͪ͵ΒͪͼͰͰͼͽͺͻͳͶͪͭͪͶͪ;ͲͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͈ΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ
ͺͻͬͰͻͰ͵Β;ΒͰͺͻͰͯ;ͲͰͯͰͼͺͽ͚;ͻͪΌͺͲͪͽͰͼ;ͪͷͳͲͺͲͳΒͰͭͳͲͬͻͪ
ͺͳͼͷͪ ͵ΒͰ ΒͰ ΔͰͭͬͪ ;;͵ͪ ͪͅͻͳΒͪ
;ͯͬͳͪ ͵ͻͪΓͪ ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ ͋ͷͪͰͬͳΕͪ
;ͺ;ͽͳͶͪͭͯͳͰͬΒͬͯͳ́ͬͪͳ;̺Ͷͪͽ͵ͬͳΕ;͵ͪͯͭͬͻͪͷͶͰͽͪ͵
ͼͺͻͪͬͪΔͰͪ;ͽͰͽͳͼͽͳ̈́;͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;͋;ͼͰ͵ͪͱͰͯͪͼͰͯͰͼͺͽͪΒͺͻͰ
ͫͻͪͽͳͪΒͬͳΒͳͼͽͪͳmͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ;͆ͳ͵ͯͳͷ;
ͺͭͶͪͬͪͻ;ͻ͵ͬͰ
ͯ͵
ͭͪΒͰͯͫͳͷͳΓͰΔͰͯͪΒͰͻͰtͺͻͪͬͳͷiͷͽͳͷͪ tWFSBNFOUFRVFMMPÍT
-VDBi
́ͺͪ͵
͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͰͳͲͫͰͭͶͪͼͬͪ͵ͪͷͭ;ΕͼͽͺͭͻͰ͵Ͱ
ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻΒͰͯͰ
ͼͺͽͪ;ͺ;ͽͳͪͼͬͰͽͭͻͼ͵ͭͺͻͽͪ͵ͪͪΒͺͲͬͪͳΒͰͭͲͪͫͪͬΓͪΔͰͰ͵ͼͺͰͻͽͳ
ͲͰtwMVJTBDFSUJTTJNBNFOUF
QFSÖDIÍMÆTPOPTDSJUUVSFEFUVUUJMJTBODUJJONB[PS
QBSUF
FMJTPOPBOUJDIJDBMPHIFSJFGSBUUJ
MJRVBJMTBOPEFQSJODJQJPi͈ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷ
ͼͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵ͭͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽ̸ͪͽͪͪͼͳΒͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ;ͽ;ͼͬͻ;ͽͺ;ͽͬͪͪ͊ͬͰͽ;
̻ͻ;
ͪͳͳͼͰͳͶͳͳͷ͵ͽͪ͵ͽͷ
ͯͰͼͺͽΒͰͯͺͻͽͪͯͫͳͺͲͳͽͳͬͪͯ
ͭͬͻt&NJTTMPQSPUITBQJFOEPEFDFSUPDIFRVFMMPFSBT-VDBwi
͈ͳͼͷ͵ͻͪΓͳͰͪͅͻͳΒͰͬͰͷͪΒͰͬͪͱͲͪͼͪͲͪΔͪͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻ
Βͺͻͪ͵ͼͳ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ΒͰͻΒͰΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͳ;ͽͶͳ͵ͯͻͪͭͰͳΒͰͼͬͰͯͪ
ͼͽͬͺͻͬͰͻͳͪ;ͽͰͽͳͼͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͷͽͳΒ;͠Ͱͯͪ͵;
ͯ͵;ͷͰͽͪͻ
;ͬͻͰͯͼͽͺͳͼͷͳͷͪͳͲͪͼͪͭͶͰͯͪͬͪΔͰͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ͵Βͳͼ;;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͳ͈ͽ
7,4DISFJOFS
;VN8BISIFJUTWFSTUÅOEOJTJN)FJMJHFOVOE3FMJRVJFOXFTFOEFT.JUUFMBMUFST
4BFDVMVN
m)FSSNBO.BTDBSE
-FTSFMJRVFTEFTTBJOUT
m-FHOFS
3F
MJRVJFOJO,VOTUVOE,VMU
m)1MBUFMMF
(VJCFSUEF/PHFOUFUt%FQJHOPSJCVTTBODUPSVNi
3JDIFTTFFUMJNJUFTEVODSJUJRVFNÊEJÊWBMFEFTSFMJRVFT
JO-FTSFMJRVFT
m
͊;ͫͽͳ̻Ͷ;ͫͬͳΕ
PQDJU
' 3BǁLJ
1SJMP[J [B TCJSLV TSCTLJI J CPTBOTLJI MJTUJOB
3BE +";6
LOK *
m
ͷͭ;ΕͰͷͳͯͰͽͳͽͰͽ;ͽͪͯͪΔͰͭͼͬͰͽͭͻͼ͵ͭͺͻͽͪ͊;ͫͽͳΕ
PQDJU
ͪͺͼͷͰͯͰ
ͻͰͬͼ͵ͷͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽ;̸ͽͪͪͼͳΒ;ͪ͠ͅ͵ͬͳΕ
̾ͺͳͼ͵ͺͳΒͰͳͷͳͽͻͺͶͳΒͰͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱͻ͵ͬͰ;
ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
ͪͺ
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
ΒͰͺͻͳͫͪͬͳͷͳΓͰΔͪͪΒͺͲͬͪͳΒͳͳͼͽͳͽ;ͳΒͪ
ͯͰͼͺͽ͚;ͻͪΌΒͰ;ͺ;ͽͳ;
͠ͰͯͻͰͰͳͲͪͼͶͪͳ͵ͪͼͪͼ͵;ͺͰͳͷͯͪͻͬͳͷͪ͵ͪ͵ͫͳͯͼ;ͶͽͪͪͅͰͷͰͯͪ**
ͯͫͳͯͲͬͶ;ͯͪͫͪͬͳͺͻͰͼ͌ͼͺͰͷͳͼͯ;ͷͳͼͳΒͰ
ͺͺͽͰͷ;ͬͰ
ͻͰΔ;ͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪͪ
ͫͳͽΒͰͯͺͻͳͰͶͺͼͻͰͯͬͪΔͰͼ;ͶͽͪͳΒͰͪͅͻͰ
ͯͰͼͺ
ͽͬͰ͵ΕͰͻͳ́ͺͪ͵
ͯͶ;;Β;Ε;;Ͷͭ;ͷͻͪͶͪΒͰͳͷͪͽͳͳͲ;ͲͰͽͬͰͶͳ͵ͪͼͬͽͪ
ͬͪ͵Β;ΒͰͯͪͲͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ;͇ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪͽͰ͵;ͺͺͻͯͪΒͰͰͽ
ͬͳͰͼͪͲͪΒͰͷͳͲͬͰΕͺͷͰ;ͽͭͺͳͼͷͪ͵ͻͪΓͳͰͪͅͻͳΒͰ
͵ͪͳͳͲͺͳͼͷͪ͵ΒͰ
ΒͰͳͼͽͰ
ͭͯͳͰͷͶͰͽͪ͵ͷͯ;ͱͯ;;ͺ;ͽͳͼͺͶͳͽͼ͵ͳ͵ͰͲ̸ͯͻͳΒ̺ͪͰͰ
ͻͳ͌ͬͷͯͻ;ͭͷͼͰ͵ͪͱͰ
;ͲͺͲͳͬͪΔͰͪͯͰͼͺͽͬ;;;͵;͵ͪͳͲͬͻ
ͯͪ
ΒͰ͚;ͻͪΌ̹ͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͪͬͯͺͶͪͽͳͷͽͳͽͻͳͯͰͼͰͽͳΓͪͯͪͯ;͵ͪͽͪ
ͪͶͳͯͪ
ͽͪΒͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͳΒͰͺ;Ͳͯͪ twFTFMDPNQSÖTFDPOEPMJDSFEF
NBOPOTBEJDFS
UP
QFSEVDBUJ
FGÍQPSUBSFMEFUUPDPSQPJO4NFEFSFWPi
́Ͳͺͳͼͷͪ͵ͻͪ
ΓͳͰͪͅͻͳΒͰ
͵Βͪ
ͲͪͻͪͯͼͺͼͽͬͰͰ͵;ͺͺͻͯͪΒͰͺͲͳͳΒͰ
ͷͶͳͯͪͼͰΔͰͪ
ͼͪͲͪΔͪͰͼͪͺͽͪͬͪΒ;ͷͶͰͽͪ͵Β͊ͳΔͻͳΒͳ
ͺͻͳͲͶͪͲͳͯͪΒͰͯͰͼͺͽ͚;ͻͪΌ
ͺͻͬͫͳͽͽͻͪͱͰ;Ͱ;;ͼͺͰͯͪͼͺ;ͼͽͳͪͺͰͽͪͰͼͽͳΓͪͯͪͯ;͵ͪͽͪ
ͪͯͪͷ;
ΒͰͯͻ;ͭͪͺͶͬͳͪͬͪͬͻͪΕͰͪͼͷͽͳͷͪ twFMPSTJBDPO[ÖBNJMJB
FE
BMUSJNJMJBQPSUÖJOESJPEJT-VDBi
͋ͻͰͫͪͶΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ͼͰͳͳ
ͯͪͽͳͺͰͽͪ
ͰͼͽͳΓͪͯͪͯ;͵ͪͽͪͺ͵ͻͳΒ;ͽͻ͵ͬͰͺͼͶͪͼͽͪͬͪͳͺͻͰͼͪ
͵ͪͳͷͭͳ
ͺ͵Ͷͪmͽ;ͻͼ͵ͷͼ;Ͷͽͪ;
ͲͪͺͬͰͯͳ͵;͉ͭͼͪ
ͼͬͰͽͭͻͼ͵ͷͺͻͽ;
Bͼͬͪ
͵ͪ͵ͳͯͻ;ͭͳͷͬͪͱͳͷͶͳͼͽͳͷ͇ͪͳͭͶͰͯ
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͳͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱͼ
ͬͻͰͷͰͷΒͰͻͪͼͶͪͰͪ̽͵ΒͰͲͪͺͬͰͯͳ͵͉ͭͼͪͲͪΔͳͺͶͪͽͳtͼͪͷiͰͼͽ
ͼͽͽͳͪͯ;͵ͪͽͪ
ͯͰͼͺͽ͚ͪ;ͻΌͪ
;͵;ͺ;ͲͰͬ
Ͱͼ;͵ͽͪͶͰͽͪͺͰͯͰͼͰͽ
ͺ;ͽͪͬͳͰ̺ͻͰͯͼͽͷͽͳΒ;ͷͭͶͪͼͰͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͽͳͳͪͯͻ;ͭͳͪͳ͋ͪ͵ΒͰ
͵ͻͪΓͳͪͪͅͻͳΒͪͯ;ͭͪͻͼ͵ͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͯͫͳͶͪͺ;ͯ;ͯͪΒΒͲͪͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ
̈́;͵Ͱ;ͼͽ;ͺͳͽͻͳͯͰͽͳͻͳͲͪͷ͵ͪ;ͽͻͪΒͬͶͪͼͳͽͬ twPWFSDBTUFMMJJO
QFSQFUVVNi
͋ͻͰͫͪͪͭͶͪͼͳͽͳͯͪΒͰ;ͺͻͼ;ΌͳͬͪΔ;ͼͪͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵ͪͬͳͼ͵ͪͰͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪͶͪͼͪͱͪͪͻͭ;ͷͰͽ;ͯ͵ͪͲͳͬͪΔ;ͪ;ͽͰͽͳͼͽͳͰ͵ͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
͋ͪ͵ͻͪͼ;Ό;ΒͰͳ͵ͻͪΓͳͪͪͅͻͳΒͪ
͵Βͪ͵ͪͱͰͯͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͯͰͼͺͽͳ͚;ͻͪΌͳ̈́ͪͲͪͻ
ͼͳͭ;ͻͰͫͳͯͪͶͳͽͶͳ͵Ͱͯ;͵ͪͽͰͯͪͳͼ;ͫͳͶͳͺͽͺ;;ͬͰͻͰͳ;ͪ;ͽͰ
ͽͳͼͽ̈́;͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ; t*TJHOPSEFTQPUI;FPS[JFETJHOPSEFTQPUI-B[BSP
OPO[ÍTUBJEEFUBMJOUFMMFUUP
DIFIBWFTTFEBEPUBOUJEVDBUJOPOTBQJBOEPEJDFSUP
VUSVNGPTTFEJT-VDBPOPi
͌ͼͬͪ͵ͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;
ͺͷͰ;ͽͳͳͲͬͻͳͬͰͷͪͼ;
ͲͪͳͷΓͳͬ
;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͺͻͪ͵ͼͳͪͫͪͬ͵Ͱͳ
͵;ͺͺͻͯͪΒͰͯͻͪͭͰͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͺΒͪͬͳ͵ΒͪΒͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;ͫͳͶͪ;ͫͳͪ
ΒͰͪͳͬͰͷͪͻͪͳͻͰͪ
͊ͪͷͳͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵ͰͼͬͰͽΓͰΒͰͼͯͬͪͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͪͼͽͪͬͳ
ͽ͈ͪ͌ͪͻͳͼ͵ͷͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;ΒͰͺͳͼͪͼͷͭͼͽͬͪͻͳͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ
ͯ͵
ͼͰ;̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷͲͫͻͳ͵;ͯͭͪΌͪΒͳͰͼͽͽ;ͷͪͰ;ͻͪͬͳ;ͯͰͼ͈ͭͻͳͺͻͰͷͰ
ͲͪͺͻͰͼ
ͲͪͺͰͽͰͭͯͳͰ
ͲͪͬͻͳͶͰͼ;ͼͰͼͶͪΔͰͷͺͼͶͪͼͽͬͪ;͉
ͭͼ͈ͻͰͯͬͯͳͶͳͼ;ͭͪͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͺͻͳͲͻͰͼ͵ͳ͵ͳͻͅͳͪͳͶ
ͶͰͽͳΒͪͼ͵ͳ
ͳͭ;ͷ̺ͪͰͰͯͳ͵ͽͳͫΓͪͻ͊ͽͰͿͪ
ͯͰͼͺͽͬͼͪͬͰͽͳ͵͈;ͽͯͯͻͰͯͳͽͪ
ͽͻͪΒͪΒͰ
;;ͼͶͬͳͷͪͲͳͷͼ͵ͭͺ;ͽͬͪΔͪ
ͯͬͪͯͰͼͰͽͼͪͷͯͪͪ̀ͫͳͬͪΔͪ͵Βͪ
ͼ;;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪ
ͺͳͼͪͪͼͪͷ;̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷͲͫͻͳ͵;
ͺͻͳͺͪͯͪΒ;ͯͫͻͲͪΒ͵ͪ
ͽͰͭͻͳΒͳ
ͺͲͪͽΒ͵ͪGVSUBTBDSB͆ͪͳͷͰ
͵ͪͯͪͼ;ͭͻͪΌͪͳ͉ͭͼͪͼͪͲͪͶͳͲͪ
ͯͶͪͲͪ͵͊ͻͫͪ
ͼͪ͵ͻͳͶͳͼ;ͷͽͳͼͬͭͼͬͰͽͭͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪ;ͭͻͪͯͼ͵;͵;Ͷ;
;ͪ
ͷͰͻͳͯͪͼͺͻͰͰͯͰΔͰͼͬͰͽͳΔͰ͌ͲͺͷΕͽ;ͻͼ͵ͭͲͪͺͬͰͯͳ͵ͪ
͊ͻͫͳͼ;
ͼͰͺͼͶ;ͱͳͶͳͶ;͵ͪͬͼͽͬͷ;Ͷͳͼ;;͵;Ͷ;͵ͻͲͽͪΒͳͺͻͶͪͲͳͯͶͳ;ͺͼͰͯ
ͷͽͳΒ;
ͪͲͪͽͳͷͼ;;ͪΒͬͰΕΒͫͻͲͳͳͺͫͰͭͶͳͳͲͭͻͪͯͪ
;ͼͺͰͬͳͯͪͳͲͷͪ͵;
ͺͽͰͻͳ̽ͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽͯͪΒͰ;ͼͻͰͯΔͰͷͬͰ͵;
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͷͪͻͰ
tͼͬͰͽͪ͵ͻͪΌͪi
͵ͪͳtͺͫͱͪͶͪͱi
ͳͷͪͶͪͺͻͪͬͯͪΔͰͪ͵ΒͰͫͳͶͪͻ;͵ͬΌͰͪ
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
tͳͼͺͻͪͬͷͪͷͰͻͷiͳͷͽͳͬͳͼͪͪtͺͫͱͳͷͻͪͲͶͭͷi̸;ͽͻ̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
ͼ͵ͭͻ;͵ͺͳͼͪͰͼͪͷͽ;ͺͽͺ;ͼͽͳͺͻͪͬͯͪͬͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵ͬͰΕͭͪͳ
ͪͯͭͻͪΌ;ΒͰͰͶͰͷͰͽͳͷͪ;ͯͰͼͭ͋ͪ͵ͪ͵ͯͬͪͺ;ͽͪͺͯͬͶͪͳͯͪΒͰͯͶͪͲͪ͵
;͊ͻͫͳΒ;ͫͳͶͪͱͰΓͪͼͪͷͭͪͺͼͽͶͪ̈́;͵Ͱ̽ͪΒ;ΕͳͰ͵;ͬͻͼͽ;ͺͽͬͻͯͰͯͪΒͰͻͰ
̹ͱͳΒΒͬΓͳ
ͺͳͻͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪͽͷͰ͵ͪ͵ΒͰͺͼͶͪͼͽͬ
ͫͰͱͰΕͳͼͪ
ͼͬͰͽͳͷͷͽͳͷͪ
ͪ;ͯͰͼͪͪͳ
Ͱ͵ͬͪͼͳͬͳͼͰ
ͺͻͰͶͻͰ͵;
ͪͽ;Ͱͺͳ
Ͳͯ;ͺͻͰͯͳͼͯͪͫͻͪͳͷ;ͲͻͳͷͪmͅΒͼͳΒͰͬͳͷͺͻͰͶͪͼ͵ͷͺͻͰ͵͏ͻͬͰͭ
ͷͻͪͳ;ͯͰͼͳͷͰΔͰͷ͵ͬͰͭͪͲͪͬͰͽͪͺͻͰ͵͠ͻͯͪͪ͊ͪͼͽͪͬͳͽͪ
ͼͪͷͭͫͻͰͯͪͺͻͰͼͪ
͵Ͷͼͽͳ;͵ΒͳͷͪΒͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͺͼͶͪͼͽͬͪͺ;ͼͽͳͶ
͉ͭͼͰͯͬͼͷͳͼͶͰͭͬͻͰͽͷͰͯͪΒͰͳͲͼͽͪQSPGFDUJP
ͼͬͰͪͳͺͶͪͲͪ͵
͵ΒͳΒͰͺͻͬͪͰͽͪͺͪͼͬͪ͵ͰͰͶͬͳͽ;ͫͶͳͰͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͆ͪͻͰͯͰͰͽͪͺͰͺͻͰͼͪͯͬͳΒͪͶͰͼ;ͼͰ
ͺͼͬͰͷ;ͼ;ͯͰΕͳ
ͻͰͭ;ͶͪͻͳͫͰͲ
ͬͰΕͳͺͻͰͺͻͰ͵ͪ́Ͳͬͻͳ
ͯͯ;Ͱ
ͰͭͬͻͰͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͪͺ;ͽͬͪΔͪ
ͪ͵
ͼͰͳͲ;Ͳͷ;tͷͭͪ;ͯͰͼͪͳͳͼͰΓͰΔͪi͵Βͪͼ;ͷͽͳͽͷͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ;ͳͳ
ͶͰ͌ͳͲͬͻͳͷͪͼͰͰͺͷͳΔͰͳͳͽͳͰͻͰͻͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ͋;ͺͻͪͲͳ;ͺͼͻͰͯ
ͺͺ;Δ̹ͪͬͪͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͰͬͶͰͽͺͳͼ
;͵ΒͰͷΒͰͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͯͪͼ;ͷ
ͽͳ
ͺ;ͽ;Β;ΕͳͺͻͰ͵̓ͼͬͪ
ͺͻͰΕͳͶͰ;̻ͻͪͪͳͳ͆ͪΒͬͰΕ;ͺͪͱΔ;
ͺ
ͺͻͳͻͯͳͼͽͬͪͻͳ
ͳͲͬͻͳͼ;ͺͼͬͰͽͳͶͳͰͽͻͪͶͳͷͯͭͪΌͪΒͳͷͪͺͻͰͼͪ
ͪͽ
ͼ;PDDVSTVTͳBEWFOUVT̽Ͱ͵ͷͽͳΒ;;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͲͰͷΓͳͻͭͪͳͲͬͪΒͰ͵ͪ
ͼͬͰͪͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪͪΒͬͳͰͭͻͪͭͪ
;͵ΒΒͼ;;ͰΕͪ;ͲͰͶͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͳ
ͼͬͳͯͻ;ͽͬͰͳͼͶΒͰ͈ͬͪ;ͼͽͪΓͰͷͫͳͪΒ;
;ͼͻͰͽͪΔͰͼ;ͺͻͬͳͳͲͪͶͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͳͻ͵ͬͰ͊ͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪͳͲͬͻͪͷͰΌ;ͼͫͼͰͻͪͲͶͳ͵;Β;;ͺͳͼ;
;Ͱͼͳ͵ͪͽͭͲͪͪΒͭͳ͈ͪͻͰͷͪ;ͺͽͰͷͳͲͬͰͽͪΒ;͈ͪͻͳͼ͵ͭͻ;͵ͺͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͼͪ
ͷͽͳͼ;ͪͻͰͳͅͻͪͬͳͯͰ͵ͪͶͳtͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͳͺͷͻͼ͵ͳ͵ͳͻ
͆ͳ͵ͯͳͷ
ͼͪͼͬͰͽͰͳͷͰͺͳͼ͵ͺͳͷͪ
ͳͺͺͬͳͷͪͳΌͪ͵ͳͷͪͳͼͬͳͷͪͼͳͷ
ͻ͵ͬͰͳͷ͵Ͷͳͻͷi̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͳͲͫͻͳ͵ͰͼͪͷͽΒͰͷͭͺͯͻͫͳΒͳ
ͬͰΕΒͰ
͵ͪ͵ͳͲͭͶͰͯͪ
ͳͬͰͻͯͼͽΒͳΒͳ;ͺͻͳͺͬͰͯͪΔ;ͯͭͪΌͪΒͪ͌ΔͰͷ;ͼͽΒͳ
ͯͪΒͰ
;ͺͻ͵ͼͯͰͼͺͽͬΒͳͲͻͳͳͽΒͪͻͰͯͫͳ;ͺ;ΕͰΒͺͭͶͪͬͪͻ;ͻ͵ͬͰͳͬͳͼ
͵ͷ͵Ͷͳͻ;
ͺͪͽͻͳΒͪͻ͆ͳ͵ͯͳͷ
ͲͫͭͫͶͰͼͽͳ
ͫͳͺͻͳ;ΌͰͯͪͳͲͼͽͪͰͼͪ
ͼͬͰͪͼͽͳ͇ΒͰͳͺͪ͵ͼͬͰ;ͳͳͯͪͰͻͰͷͳΒͪͺͻͽͰ͵ͰͺͼͬͳͷͬͪͱͰΕͳͷ
ͺͻͪͬͳͶͳͷͪ
t͵ͪ͵ΒͰͽ;ͫͳͪΒͰͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͶͳͽͳΒͪi
;Ͳ;ͰΕͰtͷͳͽͻͺͶͳ
ͽͪ
ͳͭ;ͷͪͪͳͰͶ͵;ͺͭ͵Ͷͳͻͪi
̺ͻ;ͪͫͻͰͯͪͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰͫͳΒͰͪͯͬͰͽ;͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬΒͪ;ͪͻͪ
ͭͯͳͰ̹ͳͶͪΒͰͽͬͰͶͳͪͼͽͬͰͪͼͬͰͽ͵ͬͳͪ͵ΒͪΒͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ;̹Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͭͲͫͻͳ͵ͪ
ͪͯͳͶͪͪͽͳ͵tͶͳͷͺͳΒͼ͵ͺͲͻͳͽͰi͇ͺͳͼͼͬͰͪ
ͼͽͳ
ͪͻͳͽͺͯͻͫͳͲͶͱͰ;ͽͷͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;
ͺ͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͯͪΒͰͪͫͳͶͪ
ͲͪͷͳΓͰͪͳͯͯͰͽͪΓͪͳͲͬͰͯͰͪͺͬͪͱͰΕͳͷͺͻͪͬͳͶͳͷͪͪEWFOUVTͪSFMJRVJB
SVN͊ͯͻ;ͭͰͼͽͻͪͰ
ͺͯ͵;ͷͰͽͪͻΒͬͻͰͯͼͽͳͳͼͶͳ͵ͬͳͽͷ
ͼͽͬͪͻͷ
ͺͻͳ͵ͪͲ;ͪͽͷͼͿͰͻͰͺͲͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͰͺͻͰͼͳΒͰ
ͽͳͺͳͼͳͺͻͰͯ
ͼͽͪͬΓͪΒ; ΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰ ͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬ ͽͰ ͬͻͼͽͰ ; ͼͻͺͼ͵ͷ ͵ΔͳͱͰͬͷ ͪͼͶͰ
Ό;͊ͽͭͪΒͰ;ͬͰͻΓͳͬͷͳΓͰΔͰ
ͯͪͬͳͲͰͽ
ͯͪΒͰΔͳͬͪ;ͽͻͫͳͰ
ͼͪͷͰͬͳͯͪͬͰΕͳͪ͵ͽͳͬͳ;Ͱͼͳ͵ͯͭͪΌͪΒͪͯ͠͵ͼ;ͷͽͳͺ;ͽͬͪͶͰ
ͺͻͰͷͪ͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬ;
ͰͰ;ͼͬͰͪΒͺͬͻͳͳ;ͲͺͻͳͭͯͺΒͪΔͰ
ͺͯͼͽͪ
͵ͶͰ ͼ; ͺͫͱͪ ͼͰΕͪΔͪ ͼͽͪͬͳͽͬͪ ͷͭͳ ͼ; ͺͻͰ͵ͳͯͪͶͳ ͺͼͶͬͰ ͳͶͳ
;ͼͽͪΒͪͶͳͯͫͰͯͪ͵ͪ͵ͫͳͳͷͳͲͪͶͳ;ͼ;ͼͻͰͽ
ͯͪͶͳͺͽ;ͳͶͳͼͰͺͻͳ͵Γ;
ͳͶͳͺͻͪͽΔͳ͉ͰΒͰͽͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͷ
ͻͳͽ;ͪͶͷͫͶͳ͵;ͺͪͪΔͪ
͵Βͳ
ͪͶͪͱͰͯͪͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͶͪͼ͵ͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳ͵ͰͼͽͪͰ;ͼͬͷͯͷ;͈Ͱ
͵ͪͯΒͰͪ͵
ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͬͪͱͳͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪ
ͫͳͶͪͺͻͺͳͼͪͪͳͻͪͲͯͪΓͳͪ͵Β;
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵ͳͭͻͪͯͼͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͷͺͶͱͪΒͰͷͻ͵ͬͰ̹ͶͪͭͬͰͽͰΔͪ
ͼͻͰͯͳͪ97ͬͰ͵ͪ ͺͻͰͷ͈ͪͅͺͬͳΕ;
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ΒͰͪͻͯͽͻͰͫͪͶͯͪͺͻͰͬͪͶͳͺͻͪͽͰΕͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ,ͪ͵ͽͫͳͪΒͳͪͶͪͱ;
ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;ΒͰ;ͼͻͰͽͪΔͰ
ͪͯtͺͰͽͺͺͻͳͽͪiͯͭͻͪͯͪͳͲͪͪͼͪͷͬͶͪͯͪͻ
ͺͻͪΕͰͺͻͯͳͷͳͬͶͪͼͽͰͶͷ̸;ͽͻ͈ͪͻͳͼ͵ͭͻ;͵ͺͳͼͪͺͪͼͫͳͷͰ;
ΒͰ͚;ͻΌͰͬ;ͼ;ͺͻ;ͱͳ;ͯͰͼͺͽͳ;͠Ͱͻͳ;ͳΔͳͬͪtͫͭͷͯͪͻͬͪͪͰͯͪi
mͼͳͬͰ̻ͻͭ;ͻͪ
͊ͽͰͿͪͪͳ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪͳ͵ΕͰͻͳͪͅͻͳΒ;ͳ͠ͰͶͰ;̓ͪͯͪΒͰͺͬͻ͵ͪ
ͫͳͶͪͪͯͷͪ͵ͭͻͪͯͪ
;ͼ;ͼͻͰͽΒΒΒͰ͵ͻͰ;ͶͪͬͰͶͳ͵ͪͷͪͼͪͪͻͯͪ
ͼͪͼͬͰΕͪͷͪ;
ͻ;͵ͪͷ̹ͪͳͶͳͼ;ͺͻͳͼ;ͽͳͼͬͳͼͶΒͰͬͳͼͽͪͬͳͽͬͪmͼͬͰͽͰͳͳͳͳͳ
ͫͭͪͽͳͳ;ͫͭͳ
ͱͰͰͳͯͰͪmͫΒͰͯͳΔͰͳ;ͷͶͳͽͬͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;ͯͪͳͷͺͯͪͻͳ
ͼͺͪͼͰΔͰ͈ͯͰͼͺͽͬͷͪͻͰΌͰΔ;
͵ͳͬͽͼͷͽͳͷͪͺͻͰ;ͲͰͶͳͼ;ͼͬͰͽͰͳ
ͳ
͵Βͳͼ;;ͼͬͰͪΒͺͬͻͳͼͳͶͳͺͲͶͪΕͰͰͼͬͰΕΔͪ͵Ͱ
͵ͪͯͳͶͪ
ͳ͵Ͱ
ͳͻͳͺͳͯͰ͈ͻͳͺͬͰͯͪͼͬͰͯͳͽͷͰͯͪͼͰ͵͵ͬͰͭͪͼͷͽͳͷͪͼͽͬͻͳͶͪ
ͽͪ͵ͬͪͭ;ͱͬͪͯͪΒͰͯͪΓͰ͵ͻͰͽͪΔͰͫͳͶͰͷͭ;ΕͰ
ͲͫͭͰͭͪΒͰͯͰͼͺͽͫͳͺͻͳ
;ΌͰͯͪͺͼͽͪͬͳ;ͬͪͻͰ͵Βͳͼ;͵ͻͳͶͳͺ;ͽ͋Ͱ͵ͽͪͯͪ
ͳͽΒͰͯͬͪ
ͺͻͰͼͳΒͪ
ΒͰ;ͼͺͰͶͪͯͪ;ΌͰ;ͭͻͪͯ
͌Ͷͪͼ͵ͷ;ͺͻͰͼͽͳ;ͽͺͰΒͰͲͪͬͻͳͯͰͰͻͰͷͳΒͰͪͯͬͰͽͪ JO
HSFTTVTͳEFQPTJUJP
ͅͽͳͼ;ͪΒͺͻͰͯͰͽͰ;ͯͬͻͼ͵;ͻ͵ͬ; tͻ͵ͬ;ͺ
Ͷͪͽ;i
͵ΒͪͼͰ
͵ͪ͵ͼ;ͽͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͪͬͳΒͪͳͼͽͻͪͱͳͬͪΔͪ
ͳΒͰͪͶͪͲͳͶͪ;
͵ͷͺͶͰ͵ͼ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͲͪͷ͵ͪ
ͬͰΕ;Β;ͭͲͪͺͪͯͷ;ͭͶ;̺ͰͶͳ͵ͭͭͻͪͯͪ͊ͷͰͯͰ
ͻͰͬͼ͵ͰͽͬͻΌͪͬͰ͋Ͱ͵͵ͪͯͪΒͰͺͪͶͬͰͰ
ͷͽͳͼ;ͺͻͰͰͽͰ;Ͳͪͷͪ͵;ͪͅͶͷ
ͭͻͪͯ;ͳͺͶͱͰͰ;ͬͰͶͳ͵;ͼͪͶ;ͯͻͱͪͬͭͼͪͬͰͽͪ͋;ΒͰ
;Ͳ;ͰΕͰͼͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͪ
ͯͰͼͺͽ͚ͪ;ͻΌͪͳ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
ͯͻͱͪͫͯͰͳΒͰ͵ΒͰΒͰͺͽͻͪΒͪͶͯΒ;ͽͪͻΔͳͪͼ
ͬͪ͆ͪ͵ͽͭͪͳͲͬͰͯͰͪΒͰͼͬͰͪͪͺͻͰͼͳΒ͈ͪͪͻͰΌͰΔ;ͯͰͼͺͽ͚ͪ;ͻΌͪ
͵ͳͬͽΒͰͺͯͳͭ;ͽͳ
;ͲͪΒͬͰΕͰͺͪͼͽͳͳͺͻͺͳͼͪͰͼͬͰͽͰͰͻͪͯΔͰ
ͪͻ;
͵ͪͷͪͺͻͰͰͽͯͺͼͻͰ̺ͯͰͶͳ͵ͭͭͻͪͯͪ͌ͳ;ͰΔͪ͵ͬͰͭͪ;ͰͼͽͬͬͪΒͰͳ
ͼͪͷͯͰͼͺͽ̈́ͪͲͪͻmͳͷͰΒͰͯͬͻ̹ͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͪͺ͵ͪͲͪͼͬΒ;ͯͫͻ;;ͺ;ΕͰͼͽ
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
;ͫͳͪΒͰ;ͬͰͲͳͼͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͪͷͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ͬͪͱͰΕͰ͵ͪ͵;Ͱͬͻͺͼ͵Βͽͪ͵ͳ
;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͼͻͰͯͳͳ͌ͼͶͰͯͳΒͰͬͻ;ͪͽͭͽͪ͵ͲͪͪΒͭͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭ
ͫͻͰͯͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰ;Ͱͼͳ͵ͰͼͬͰͪͼͽͳͷͻͪͳͼͺ;ͳͽͳͪΒͬͰΕͳͷ;Ͳͫ;ΌͰΔͰͷ
͈ͬͻ͵ͪ
;͵ΒΒͼ;͵ͻͪͪͶͳͼͬͳͶͪͬͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͯͷͪͳͼͳ͵Ͷͳͽͪ
͵ͪ
ͳͪΒͬͳͳͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬͳͳͻ͵ͬͰͰΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰ
͵ͻͰ;ͶͪΒͰͯ;ͱͼͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵ͳͫͰ
ͯͰͷͪ
ͺͻͳͲͳͬͪΒ;Εͳ;ͼͰΕͪΔͰͼͬͰΕͰͳͫͳͫͶͳΒͼ͵ͳͫͻͪͲͪmͰΔͰ͵ͬͰͭͪ
ͲͪͬͰͽͪ͵͠Ͱͻͳͪ͊ͬΒ;ͺͼͶͰͯΔ;ͪͯ;;ͼͺͪͼͭͻͪͯͪͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͯͻͱͪͬͰͳ
ͼ;ͺͻͰͽͳͶͳ;ͷͶͳͽͬ;ͯͪ
ͺͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ
tͼͽͰͳͭͻͪͯͪ;ͽͬͻͯͰͽ
ͼͰͳͰͺ͵ͶͰͫͳͷͳͺͻͰͫ;ͯ;ͽi̓ͪͯͪͼ;ͷͽͳͫͳͶͰͳͼͬͰͽͳͶͰͭͻͪͯ
ͺ
ͬͻ͵ͪͼͰ;ͺ;ͽͳͶͪ͵ͪͬͼͪͲͯͪΒͷ;ͷͰͽͪͶΒͻ͵ͬͳͺͼͬͰΕͰΒ̹ͶͪͭͬͰ
ͽͰΔ;͋;
;ͭͶͪͬ;Ͳͪͯ;ͱͫͳ;ͯͰͼͺͽ͚ͪ;ͻΌͪͳ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶ;ͻ͵ͬ;
͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵ͰͷͳͽͻͺͶͳΒͰͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͳͭͻͫͳͻͪͷ
ͺͶͱͰͰͼ;ͷͽͳͼͬͰ
ͽͭͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪ̽ͰͼͺͽͬͳͰ̹ͳΒͰͽͺͼͶͰͯΔͳͯΒͰ͵ͼͽͪͻͰͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͰ
;ͼ
ͺͼͽͪͬΓͰͰ
ͲͪͼͶ;ͭͷͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
Β;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͷͺͻͭͻͪͷ;͵ͪͽͰͯͻͪͶͰ
;̿ͳͳ͌ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͰͷͪΔͳΕ͵ͳͷͪͼͶͰΌͰͷͫͳͶΒͰͳͺͪͼͷͰͼͽ
tͯͰͼ
ͯͼͬͰͽͳͯͬͰͻͳi
ͪ͵ΒͰΒͰͺͶͱͰ͵ͳͬͽͼͷͽͳͷͪ̀ͪͬͻͰͰͽͪͺͰͯ
ͭͪΌͪΒͪ
;ͰͶͳͳͺͼͷͪͽͻͪͰ
Ͱͯͼͽ;ͺͪΒ;ͯ;ͼͽͪΓͰͳͫͳͪΒͪ
ͪͳΔͳͬ
ͺͳͼͪΒͬͰΕͳͷͯͰͶͷͺͳͬͪͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰΒͽͺͳͳ́ͺͪ͵
Ͱ͵ͰͰͺͳͲͯͰͳ
ͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳͷͭ;ͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͼͪͼͬͳͷͳͲ;ͲͰͽͳͷ
͆ͪ͵ͺͶͪͭͪΔͪͷͽͳΒ;ͯͰͼͺͽΒͰ;ͼͬΒΒͺͪͶͪͽͳͺͻͳͻͰͯͳͬͰͶͳ͵;ͼͬͰͽ
͵ͬͳ;
͵ΒͷͼͰͫͪͬͰͲͲͪͬͻͪͬͪͼͬͪ͵ͳͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͪͯͬͰͽͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳ
Βͪ͌ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪΒͰͬͰͷͪͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͪͰͺͳͲͯͪ
ͳͼͺͻͳͪͪ͵ͪ;ͯ͆ͪͳͷͰ
͵ͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͯͪͼͰͲͪͺ;ͽͳ;ͺͪͶͪͽ;ͪͼͶͪͬΓͰ
ͯͰͼͺͽΒͰͲͪͯ;ͱͳͷͳͽͻͺͶͳͽͪͳͯͬͻͼ͵ͭ
Ͱͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ ͯͪ ͯͫͻ ;ͬͪΒ; ͼͬͰͽͳΔ;
ͽ ͼ; ͳ ͳ ;ͳͳͶͳ m ͲͪͫͻͪͬͳͶͳ ͼ;
͵ͳͬͽͳͪΔͰͭͪͼͽͪͬͳͶͳ͵ͪͽͪͰ͋ͪΒͺͼͽ;ͺͪ͵ΒͰͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͯͻͪͲͼͽͬͪͻͳͺͻͳ
Ͷͳ͵ͪ;ͬͰͲͳͼ;ͬͪΔͰͷͳͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͰͷͷͽͳΒ;͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼ;
ͯͫͻΒͰͺͲͪͽ
ͫͳͶͰͺͻͪΔͰͰ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͻͰͳͽͰ͵ͺͬͻͰͷͰͳͲͶͪͭͪͰͰͺͼͻͰͯͷͯͯͳ
ͻ;ͬͰͻͳ͆ͪͼͬ;ͺͳͼͪͳͳͲͬͻͪͷͱͰͼͰͲͪ͵Γ;ͳͽͳͯͪͼ;Ͳͪͺͷ;ͫͻͳ
ͭ;͵Βͷͼ;ͫͳͶͰ͵ͻ;ͱͰͰͺͼͽΒͪͶͳͷͭͼͽͻ;͵ͳͻͪͲͶͲͳmͯͳͭͳΒͰͼ͵ͳ
͵ͪ͵ ͫͳ ͼͰ ͼͺͻͰͳ Ͱ͵ͽͻͶͳͼͪͳ ͯͯͳͻ ͫͶͰͼͳ
ͳͶͳ ͫͰͲͫͰͯͼͳ
ͻͪͯͳͼͺͻͰͪͬͪΔͪ͵ͻͪΌͰ
ͺͪͯͬͳͳ
tͼͺͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶͳi
͵Βͳͼ;ͺͳͬͪͶͳͪ
ͼͬͪͽͪΔ;ͯͪSFTTBDSBFͷͭ;ͫͳͽͳͯͼͽ;ͺͰͳͼ͵Γ;ͳͬͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͷͪ͌ͪͰͶ;
ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼ;ͫͳͶͰ;ͪͯͶͰͱͼͽͳͻ͵ͬͰͰΒͰͻͪͻͳΒͰͳͺͯͶͱͰ͵ͽͻͶͳ
Ͱͺͳͼ͵ͺͪ
ͽͰͺͼͻͰͯͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰͳͼͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵ͳͺͻͳͷͰͻ͈ͻͳͺͬͰͼͽ
Ͳͪ͵Γ;ͪͬͪΔ;͵ͳͬͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵ͰͳͷͪͶͪΒͰΒΒͰͯͪͬͪͱͪͪͭͶͪͼͪ͵͈ͽ
ͼ;͵ͪͽͪͳͽͻͳΕͳͲͪͻͰͯͷͺͪͯͪͶͳͼ͵ͳͬͽͪͳͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷΒ;ͽͻͰΔͪͪͶͪͱͰͳ
ͪͲͰͷΓͳ
ͺͻͳͰͷ;ΒͰ͵ͬͰͭͼͽͪΒͪͲͪͺͰͪΕͰ
ͪͯͶͰͱͳͼ;ͪΒͲͪͯͻͪͲ;ͷͰͶͳ
ͺͻ;͵;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪΔͰͭͬͪΒͰͷΕͽͶͳ͵ͪͯͪΒͰ͵ͪͯͪͻͼͪͷͼͰͫͰͯͪ;ͬͪ͋ͯͪͷ;
ͼͰͰͷͱͰͺͻͳΕͳͫͰͲΔͰͭͬͭͽͰΔͪͳͼ͵;ͼͳΒͰͳͰ͵ͳΌͪ͵͵ΒͳΒͰͲͪͰͷͰ
ͺͽΒͰ;ͺͻͶͪͲ;ͷͪͽͳΒͷͰͽͳͰͯͯͳͻ;͵ͳͬͽ́ͪ͵ͳͼͺͻͳͪ͵ͪ
ͼͶͳ͵ͬͳͽͪͪͰͭͯͽͪ
ͳͽͪͬͯͭͪΌͪΒͲͪͺͻͪͬͳͶ;ͼͽͻ;ΒͰͬͪͱͪͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͪ
;͵ͼͬͰͽͪ͵ΒWJSUVTmͪͽͺͻͳͻͯΒͷΕͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪͳΔͰͭͬͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
͈ͪͯͪ;ͳͯͪͼ;ͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ͵Βͪͼ;;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪͪ͵ͺͶͪͭͪΔͪ͵ͳͬͽͪ;̹Ͷͪ
ͭͬͰͽͰͼ͵ͳͻͪͷ
ͺͻͰͷͪͬͳΌͰΔ;ͺͳͼ̹ͪͰͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͭͲͫͻͳ͵ͪ
ͺͻͱͰͽͪͯ;
ͷ;ͯͰͼͭͪ͵ͳͯͪ͵ͪͯͪͼͰͽͳ;͵͵ͻͰͽͳ
ͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͳͳΔͰͳͪ
͋ͪ͵ΒͰͫͳͶͼͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͰͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ
ͺͻͺͳͼͪͷͫͻͰͯͷͻͪͯΔͷ͵Β;ͳ
ͼ;ͺͻͺ;ͼͽͳͶͳͳͶͪͬͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͭͯͷ̹ͪͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͪ͊ͪ;ͬͪͳͳͲͬͻͳ
ͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͭͬͻͰͽͷͯͪͻͳͬͪΔ;̹͌Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷͲͫͻͳ͵;͵ͪͱͰͼͰ͵ͪ͵ΒͰ
ͯͰͼͺͽ͚;ͻͪΌͼͬͰͽͷ̈́;͵ͳͺ͵Ͷͳͬ͵ͳͬͽ
ͪΔͰͭͬͪ͵Εͳͪͅͻ̹ͪͻͪ͵
ͬͳΕͿͰͶͯͼͳͻͳΒͼ͵Ͱͽ͵ͪͳͰ͈͌ͪͻͳͼ͵ͷͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;ͼͽΒͳͯͻ;ͭͪͳΒͰͯͰͼͺͽ
͚;ͻͪΌͯͪͻͳͬͪΒͰ͵ͳͬͽͲͶͪͽͷͳͼͻͰͫͻͷ
ͯͻͪͭͳͷ͵ͪͷͰΔͰͷͳͫͳͼͰͻͷ
͵ͪ
ͳͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳͷͼ͵;ͺͰͳͷͯͰͱͯͪͷͪͪͅͻ̹ͪͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͼͰͰͺͷͳΔͰ
ͯ͵ͼͰ
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
͵ͪͺ͵ͶͯͰͼͺͽͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪͪͬͯͰ͵ͳͬͽͳͼ͵;ͺͰͰͲͪͬͰͼͰ;͵ͻͪͰͰͲͶͪͽ
ͳͷͫͻͪͲͳͷͪ͆ͰͼͪͭͶͪͼͼͽͳͲͬͻͪ
ͻͰͳͽͪͼͫͲͳͻͷͪͽͯͪΒͰͯͪͳͼͽͳ
ͰͲͪͼͶ;ͭͰͯͰͼͺͽ͚ͪ;ͻΌͪͳΔͰͭͬͰ͵ΕͰͻͳ
ͯ͵ͯͻ;ͭͳͺͯͬͶͪͳ;Ͷͭ;ͯͰͼͺͽͪ
̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
; ͪ;ͳ ΒͰ ͬͰΕ ;Ͱͪ ͳ ͺͻͳͷͰͻ ͽ;ͷͪͰͪ ̀ͪ ͪͰ ͺͳͽͪΔͰ ͯ
ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͭΒͰͲͪͪΒͪͺͳͼ;ͯͪ͵ΒͰͼͰͯͭͯͳͶ;ͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬ;ͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱͺͻ
ͯͳͰͽ͵ͷͯͪͻͳͬͪΔͪͷͽͳΒ;̓ͪͯͪΒͰ͵ͳͬͽͽͬͻͰ
ͺͻͳͼ;ͽͳͼ;ͼͪͲͪͺͻͰ
ͺͪΕͰΔͰͷͼͬͪͽͳͶͳͯͪͼ;ͼͰͷͽͳͺͯ;ͱͳͳ;ͬͰΕͪͶͰͲͪͺͶͪͶͪ͵ͽͪ ͵
DN
͈ͻͷͰͪΒͰͳͭͶͰͯͫͳͶͪ;ͺͪͯΓͳͬͪ
ΒͰͻΒͰͽͰͶ tͭͻͰͯͭͶͪͬͰͳ
ͯͶͰͯͭ;i
ͼͪͯͪͲͪ;ͲͳͷͪͶͳͽͪͬ͵ͬͰͭ
ͺͪΒͰͳͲΔͰͭͪͪ͵ͳͼͺͪ͵ͬͰͱͳΕ
ͼtͰ͵ͳͷͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͳͷͪi͵ΒͳΒͰΒͻͪͳΒͰͺͻͳͶͱͰͷͽͳͷͪ͋;ͯͳͲͪͲͬͪ
ͶΒͰͰͬͰͻͳ;tͷͪͶͯ;ͳi̓ͪͯͪͼ;ͺͻͳͼ;ͽͳtͯͶͳ͵ͼͰͫͳi
ͼͺͫͱͳͷ
ͼͽͻͪͺͽͬͪΔͰͷͺͻͳͼͽ;ͺͳͶͳͼ;͵ͳͬͽ;ͳͫͪͬͳͶͳͺͻͰͼͬͶͪͰΔͰͷͽͳΒ;
;ͿͰͶͪͅͻͰ̹ͻͪ͵ͬͳΕ tͬͺͼͶͪͳͿͰͶͼͳΒͰͫͶͪͰͽi
͌ͽͷͪͼ;ͳͲ
͵ͳͬͽͪͼ;ͺͰͶͪͯͪͼͰͳͻͰͻͪͲͶͳ͵ͪͫͶͪͭ;ͪΔͪmͪͼͷͳͻͪ
ͶͳͬͪͪͳͶͳ
͵ͻͳͪ
ͪͼͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͭͬͰΕͪͳͶͳΒͪͫ;͵Ͱm͵Βͪͼ;ͳͼͺ;ͳͶͪͳͽͪͬ;ͻ͵ͬ;ͳ
ͺͻͽ;tͪͅͶͯ;ͳiͼ;ͼͰͺͬͭͶͪͼͳͶͳ
ͽͬͻͰͳͼ͵ͪͲ;Β;Εͳͼ;ͷΔ;;
ͽͯͪͼ;;͵ͳͬͽͼͽͪͬΓͰͳͪͻͷͪͽͳ͉Ͱͽ͵ͫͳΓͰͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͪ͵ΒͰͺͻ;ͱͪͬͪΒ
ͺͳͼͼͬͪ͵ͪ͵ͲͪͼͶ;ͱ;ΒͰͺͼͰͫͪ͵ͷͰͽͪͻ͆ͪͺͻͬͷͷͰͼͽ;
ͳͲΔͰͭͪͼͰͷ
ͱͰͫͪͻͯͰ͵ͶͰͪͼͶ;ͽͳͽͳ͵ͪ͵ͪͬͼ;ͫͶͳ͵ͳͷͪͶͰͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ̸͵ΒͰ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽͳͼͪͼͽͪͬΓͪ;ͫͰͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͰͺͬͰͼͽͳ
ͷͽͳ͵ΒͰͼ;ͯͼͺͰͶͰ;͉ͭͼͫͳ
ͶͰͼ;tͰͶͰͳͰͬͻͰͱͯͰͰiͳͳͼͺ;ͽͪͶͰtͷͭͪͫͶͪͭ;ͪΔͪi̹ͳͶͪΒͰͽ
ͺ
ͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ
ͪΒͰΔͰͳΒͪͬͻͼͽͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪm;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͪͺͽͬͻͯͪͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͭ
ͪ;͵ͪͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͷͬͪͼ͵ͻͼ;ͽͰͶͪͳͯ͵ͪͲͯͪͳͲͪͫͻͪͳͳ̹ͱΒͳͳͼ;ͺͯͶͱͳ
ͺͻͺͪͯΓͳͬͼͽͳ̓ͪ͵ͬͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͯͪΓͪͼ;ͯͫͳͪͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ
ͳΒͰͪͷͺͲͪͽ
ͪͶͳͺͷͰ;ͽͳͳͼ͵ͪͲͺͻ;ͱͪͼͬͰͲͪͺͻͰͽͺͼͽͪͬ͵;ͯͪ;͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͰͳͼ;
ͼͽͳͭͶͰ;ͰͶ͵;ͺͷͼͽͪΔ;͋ͪ͵ͶͼͽͰͫͳͫͳͶͪͳͷͪͶͰͫͳͪ
ͼͫͲͳ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͻͷͪͽͯͪΒͰͻͪͼͺͪͻͪͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;ͫͳͶ;ͼͽͪΓͰͪͺͻͪ͵ͼͪ;ͻͳΕͪͼ͵ͷ
ͼͬͰͽ;ͽ͵ͷͳͽͪͬͭͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵͇ͪͭͶͪͪͬͪΔͰͷͽͳΒ;ͫͶͪͭ;ͪΔͰͷͽͪ
͵ΌͰͽͻͰͫͪͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳ;ͫͳͪΒͰͷͺΒͪͬͷ
ͲͪͷͰΔͰͷ̹ͱΒͰͭͺͻͳͼ;ͼͽͬͪͳΒͰͯ
ͷ ͯ ;ͫͰͯΓͳͬͳ ͺͽͬͻͯͪ ͼͬͰͽͼͽͳ ́ͼͽͳͳ Ͳͪ ͬΓ;
ͽ ͼͬΒͼͽͬ ͻͰͽ͵
ͼͰͳͼͺΓͪͬͪͶ;ͽͪ͵ͬͷͳͽͰͲͳͽͰͽ;ͳͻͪͼͺ;ͷͳͷͳͻͳͼͪ͵ͪ͵ͯͼͬͰͽͭ
̈́;͵Ͱ͋ͻͪͯͳͳͪͶͳͷͫͳͪΒͰͷͷͱͰͼͰͼͷͪͽͻͪͽͳͳͺͶͪͭͪΔͰͻͪͲͶͳͳͽͳ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͪ
ͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;ͯͻͪͭͰͳ
;͵ͳͬͽͼͷͽͳͷͪ
͵ͪͽΒͰͽ;ͳΔͰ
ͼ͵ͬͰͱͳΕͰͷ͵ΒͳͼͰͪͶͪͲͳ;͵ͳͬͽ;ͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ͌ͯͯͳͻ;ͼͪͼͬͰͽͳΔͷ
ͽͪ͵ͬͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͳͫͳͳͼͪͷͳͺͺͻͳͷͪͶͳ;ͯͰͼͰͷΕͳͳͺͼͽͪΒͪͶͳͰ͵ͪͬͻͼͽͪ
ͼͰ͵;ͯͪͻͳ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ ͠Ͱͯ ͯ ͺͪͱΔͰ ͬͻͰͯͳ ͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͪͬͪ ΒͰ ͳ
ͺͻͰͼͬͶͪͰΔ;ͷͽͳΒ;
ͬͪͱΒͼͬͰͽͰΒͻͪͯΔͳ͵ΒͪͼͰ
;ͲͺͻͺͳͼͪͰͫ
ͻͰͯͰ
ͫͪͬΓͪͶͪ;ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͳͷ͵Ͷͼͽͳͷͪ
ͪͺͺͻͪͬͳͶ;ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷͺͻͷͰͰ
ͬͶͪͼͳ͵ͪ͆ͪΒͲͪͯ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷΒͰͳͲ;ͲͰͽͪͺͷͰtͷͪͶͯ;ͳi
ͽͪͳΒͰͼ͵Ͱͺͽͳ
͵ͪ͵Βͳͳͼ;ͫͳͶͳͼ͵ͶͳͯͪͺͬͰͻ;Β;;;ͯͰͼͪͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ̓ͻͳͽͳ͵ͳͯͼ
ͺͻͰͷͪͬͰͻͳ;ͪ;ͽͰͽͳͼͽͳͯͰͶͽͬͻͼͽͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪͳͷͪΒͰ
ͪͰͬͻͺͼ͵ͳͷͺͻͼͽͻͳͷͪͯ;ͭ;
ͯͫͻͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪ;ͽͻͪͯͳͳΒ;̓ͯ͊ͻͫͪ
ΒͰͬͲͪͼͪͯͪͺͻͳͷͰͻͫͰͲͪͪͶͭͳΒͪ
͵Βͳ
ͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͶͭ
ͼͬͰͯͳͯ;ͫ͵ͳͷ
ͺͻͷͰͪͷͪͼͬͪͽͪΔͪͳͷͰͽͪͶͳͽͰͽͪ͵ΒͰͼ;ͼͰͲͫͳͶͰ;ΒͰͯͷ;ͻͫͪͷͪͷͫͳ
ΒͰͽ;ͺͲͭͼͻͰͯΔͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
͌ͪͰͷͼͶ;ͪΒ;ͼ͵Ͱͺͽͳͳͼ;
ͳͺͪ͵
ͳͳͶͳͷͪΔͳ;͇ͳͭͶͰͯΒͰͯͪͼ;
ͷͭͳͬͰͻͬͪͶͳ;;ͯͽͬͻͰͷΕͳͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵ͰͳͯͶͪͲͳͶͳͼ;ͯͪͷ;ͼͰͺ͵Ͷ
ͰͳͺͽͻͪͱͰͺͷΈͲͬͻͳͼͬͰͯͰͽͷͰͯͪͼ;ͳͷͪ͵Βͳͫͳͳͷͺͻͳͼͽ;
ͺͳͶͳͼͬͰͻͷͷͽͳͺͻ;ͱͪͶͰͳͼͰΓͰΔͪͯͽͰͶͰͼͳͳͯ;ͰͬͳͫͶͰͼͽͳ
ͳͽtͼͬͪ͵ͭͯͪͪͳͼͬͪ͵ͭͪͼͪi͇ͻͪͲͷͰͻͪͷͪͽͬͪΔͪͪΒͫΓͰͼͬͰͯͳ
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
ͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰ;̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷͲͫͻͳ͵;ͽͷͰͯͪͼ;ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͳ;ͺͯͰ
ͯͶͪͲͳͶͳͳͯͪͼͳͳͳͲͯͪͶͰ͵ͳͼͽͻͪͪm͆Ͱͷͪ͵Ͱ
ͪͅΌͪͻͼ͵Ͱͳ́ͽͪͶͳ
ΒͰ͋;ͼ;ͳͬͰͷͪͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͪͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͪ͵Βͪ;͵ͪͲ;Β;ͪͷͰͽͯͰͳͲͶͰͰΔͪ
͇ͼͳͷ ;ͫͳͪΒͰͭ ͺͻͳͬΌͰΔͪ ͫͶͰͼͳ͵ͪ ͵ͳͬͽ; ͻͪͯͳ ͰͶͳͬͪΔͪ ͳ ͯͯͳͻͪ
ͺͷͳΔͰͼͰͳͳ͵;ͫͪͳΒͪ
ͽΒͰͼͽͺͶͪͭͪΔͰͫͶͳ;Ͳͻͪ͵;ͼͷͽͳͷ͈ͪͳͼͪ
Ͱ ͺͻͺ;ͽͪ ͳ ͽͷ ͺͻͳͶͳ͵ͷ ͯͪ ͳͼͽͪ͵Ͱ WJSUVT ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪ ͳ ͳͼͺΓͪͬͪΔͰ
ΔͰͭͬͰͬΓͰ͆ͪͳͷͰ
ͯͳͼͰΓͰΔͪͳΒͰͯͶͪͲͳͶ;ͬͰ͵
ͬͰΕͼͪͷͯͪ͵ͪͯͪ
ͫͳͼͬͰͽͳ̈́;͵ͪͽͪ͵ͯͶ;ͳ͉ͰͺͰͻͽͪͻͼͬͰͰͬͳ;ͯͪͺͼͰͫΒͰͳͬͰͷͪ
ͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͺͳͽͪΔͰ͌Ͳͪ;ͫͳͪΒͰͪ
̈́;͵ͳͼͰͺͻͳͺͳͼ;ΒFͳͼͪͷͺͼͰͫͳ
;ͯͪ͵Βͪͼ;ͺͫͻΒͪͪ;͈ͪͻͳͼ͵ͷͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;͇ͪͼ;ͳͼͺͻͳͪͪͪͪͻͯͷ
ΒͰͲͳ͵;ͳͳͲͶͱͰͪ;Ͱ͵Βͬͻͼͽͳ͵ͪͽͪͶͭͪ
ͺͯͪͼͶͬͷ͇;ͯͰͼͰͼͬͰͽͪͭ
ͰͬͪͭͰͶͳͼͽͪ ̈́;͵Ͱ
͵Βͳ ΒͰ ͺͻͳͶͱͰ
; ͬͳͯ; ͲͪͼͰͫͭ ͯͰΓ͵ͪ
͈ͻͳͺͬͰͼͽͳ
ͺͻͰͼ;ͷͽͳΒ;ͅͰΌ;ΔͳͷͪͺͻͰͬͶͪΌ;Β;ͳͲ;ͲͰͽͳͳͰͫͳͳͯͭͪΌͪ
Βͳ;ͬͰͲͳͼͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͷͳͲ͉ͭͼͪ;͊ͻͫͳΒ;
͵ΒͰͪ;ͽͻ
ͼͪͼͬͳͷ;ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͪ
ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͳͷͬͳΌͰΔͰͷͳͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͷͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͷ
ͽ;ͷͪͳ͵ͪ;ͯͪ͌Ͳ
Δͳ
ͺͷͳΔͰͼͰͳͳͼͰΓͰΔͰtͫͰͼͷͷ;ͰͭiͬͰ͵ͪ
ͲͪͽͳͷͼͬͰΕͰ͵ΒͰͼ;ͼͰ
;ͭͪͼͳͶͰͳͺͽͷͼͪͷͰ;ͺͪͶͳͶͰ
͵ͪͳͲͪͳͷΓͳͬͪͰͺͳͲͯͪ;͵ΒΒͼͰ
ͺͬ
ͺͷͳΔ;tͰͬͰͻͳi;ͺͭͶͰͯ;ͳͼͺͻͪͬͼͽͳ̈́;͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;͋ͪ͵ͷͶͳͽͬͪ
͵Β;ΒͰͰ͵ͳͺͻͳͭ;ͷͪ͵ͳͻͪ͠͵ͬ;ͺ;ͽͳͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓ;ͯͪͷ;ͳͼͰͶͳͫͶͰͶ
͵ͳΒͰͫͳͶͪ;ͼͶͳͰͪ
ΒͰͻtͼͬΒͳͷͺͷͳͼͶͷiͳΒͰͬͰͻͬͪ;ͪ;ͽͰͽͳ
ͼͽͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͋Ͱ͵͵ͪͯͪͼͰͺ͵ͪΒͪͳͺͪͳͳͰͺͻͰͯ͵ͳͬͽͷ
ͳͼͰΓͰΒͰ
ͳͽͽͪ͵ͽΒͰͪ͠͵ͬ͵ͷͯͯͳͻ;ͼͬͰͰͬ;ͻ;͵;́ͪ͵ͼͪͼͬͳͷ;ͲͭͻͰͯ
ͳͲ
ͺͳͼͪͼͪͲͪΒͰͷͬͪͱͪͺͯͪͽͪ͵ͽͷͰͯͪΒͰͽͬͪΔ;ͬͰͻͳͫͳͶͪͳͲͶͱͰͪ
̈́;͵ͳͪͻ;͵ͪ͋ͪ͵ͶͼͽͼͪͷͺͽͬͻΌ;ΒͰ;ͫͳͪΒͰ;ͳͯͻͰͬ;ͺͻͪ͵ͼ;͵ΒͪͼͰ
;ͺͻͪͬͼͶͪͬͷͼͬͰͽ;ͼͪ;ͬͪͶͪͳͯͪͳͯͪͪ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̀ͪͺͽͻͰͫͰͳͲͶͪͭͪΔͪͳͽͬͪΔͪͷͽͳͼ;
ͲͪͬͪΓ;Β;ΕͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͷͺ
͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͼͽͬ;
ͯͫͳͶͰͬ
ͼ͵;ͺͰͳ͵ͳͬͽ͆ͰΕͰͫͳͽͳͼͶ;ͪΒͽͽ
ͼͰ;ͺͻͪͬͽͳͷͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͷͲͪͬͻͪͬͪͺͬͰͼͽͺͻͰͼ;ͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͰͪ;̹Ͱ
ͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;͋;ͼͰ͵ͪͱͰ͵ͪ͵ΒͰͯͰͼͺͽͪͻͰͯͳͯͪͼͰͪͳͳͻͪ͵ͪͯ
ͺͲͶͪΕͰͭͼͻͰͫͻͪͳ;Δ;ͺͶͱͳͽͰͶͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ
ͼ͵ͬͰͭͷ;͵ΒͰͷΒͰͯ
Ͱͽ͋ͪΒ͵ͳͬͽ
ͺͼͽͪͬΓͰ;̹ͶͪͭͬͰͽͰͼ͵;ͻ͵ͬ;
ͫͳΒͰ
ͫͰͲͼ;ͷΔͰ
ͳͯͰΒ
ͳͬͳͲ;ͰͶͼͻͰͯͳͽͰ͵;Ͷͽͪͅ;ͷͰͽͪͶͭͫͶͳΒͪ
ͫͶͳͼͽͪͬͳͼ͵;ͺͰ
ΒͰͺͻͰͯͼͽͪͬΓͪtͲͶͪͽͳͯͷͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͪiͳͪͽͳͳͺͪͳΒ;ͻͪͷͪ;͆ͰͫͰͼ͵ͷ
͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷ;͌ͲͺͷΕͺͻͫͪͭͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͪ
ͯͻͪͭͰͳͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͪͶͪm͵Βͳͼ;
ͼͷͪͽͻͪͳͰ͵ͷͬͻͼͽͷtͱͳͬͰͷͪͽͰͻͳΒͰiͲͪMBQJEFTWJWJͬͰͻͰ;͎ͻͳͼͽͪm
ΒͰͽͰͶͽͬͻͪͬͪͼͬͪͽͪΔͰͯͪͼ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͰͷͽͳtͻͳͲͳͪͷͭͰͪi
ͬͻͰͯͳΒͰͯͲͶͪͽͪͳͯͻͪͭͭ͵ͪͷͰΔͪ
ͳͳͼͽͬͻͰͷͰΒͰ;͵ͪͲͳͬͪͪͪ͵ͽͳͬ;
ͼͪͭ;ͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒ͈ͪͯͬͶͪͰΕͳͳͯͰΒ;DPSQVTJODPSSVQUVN
ΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰ
ͫͳͷͰͽͪͿͻͪͬͰͻͰ;;ͯͰͼͪͼͬΒͼͽͬͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͳͽͰͶͪͳͷͭ;Εͼͽ
ΔͳͬͭͺͻͰͫͻͪͱͪΒͪͪ͵ͼΒͰͯͳΔͰΔͪͼͯ;ͷ;ͪͻͼͽͬ;ͰͫͰͼ͵ͷ̽ͪͪͼ
ͷͱͰͷͼͪͷͪͼͶ;Εͳͬͪͽͳ͵ͪ͵ͬΒͰͯͰΒͼͽͬͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͭͬͰ͵ͪͷͭͪ
ͳͷͪͽͪ͵ͪͬͻͪͼ͵ͪ͵ͳͬͽͼ;ͯͽͬͻͷͼͬͰͽͳΔͷ͆Ͱͷͪͳ͵ͪ͵ͬͰͼ;ͷΔͰ
;ͽͯͪΒͰͯͻͪͭͰΕ;ͲͪͼͰΔͳͬͪͺͭͶͰͯͰͳͺͯͼͽͳͪͺͬͳͰͪͻͰͶͳͭͳ
ͲͪͼͰΕͪΔͪ͋ͻͰͫͪ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͬͰͻͬͪͽͳͳͯͪΒͰͫͳͺͻͰͯͷͰͽ͵ͽͰͷͺͶͪͳΒͰ
t;ͷͳͷͳͷͪiͳͻͰͰͺͳΒͰtͺͻͰͷ;ͯͻͳͷ;Ͷͳͷͪi
͆ͪ͵ͼͬͳͽͳͲͫͳͬͪΔͪ͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵ͰͲͪ͵ͻ;ͱͰΒͰ;ͼͽͪͬΓͰΔͰͷ
ͯͬͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͰͬͪͺͻͪͲͳ͵ͪm͵ͽͫͻͪ
ͪͯͪͺͻͰͼͽͪͬΓͰΔͪ
ͳΒͪ;ͪͻͪ
͵ͪͯͪΒͰͫͪͬΓͰͺͻͰͼ͇ͯͷͪͲͪͽͳͷ
͵ͪͯͰΒͰͯͳͼͽͬͰͰͲͪͷͳͼͶͳͳͪ͵ͳ
ΒͰ
;ͼͶͰͯͳͶΒͰͺͳͼͪΔͰͺͻͼͶͪͬͳͽͰ͵ͼͽͬͪ
ͫΒͰͯͳΔͰͳ;̹Ͱͭͻͪͯͼ͵ͷͲͫͻ
ͳ͵;͌ͪ;ͳΒͰͬͰΕͳͼͽͪ͵;ͽͯͪΒͰͯͰͶͽͪ͵ͼͫͰͰͼͪͯͻͱͳͰ
ͺͻͳͲͪͶ
ͳͲͪͷͰͻͰͯͪͼͰͪΒͰͯͷͷͰͼͽ;ͼͪ͵;ͺͰͼͬͳͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͺͽͻͰͫͳͲͪͼͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵
ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ
ͺͼͬΒͺͻͳͶͳͳͪͼͽͪͶͲͪͺͽͻͰͫͰͼͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵Ͱ̹ͶͪͭͬͰͽͰ
̺ͻͰͯͳͪͺͷͰ;ͽͳͯͪͼͰ;͈ͪͻͳͼ͵ͷͻ;͵ͺͳͼ;ͲͪͺΒͪͷ͵ͳͬͽͯͼͶͰͯ͵ͻͳͼͽͳͳͲͻͪͲ
t͵ͳͬͻiͽͪ͵ͬͳͺͻͳͷͰͻͳͳͼ;;ͼͪͷΓͰͳ
W̓ͳͬͻͳʹ
JO͎ͻͳͼͽͳͪͼͽͬ
Έͳ͵ͶͺͰͯͳͰ
ͼ͵ͳʹͼͶͬͪͻ·
FE̸͊͊ͬͰͻͳͰͬ
̸͆ͅͰ͵ͬ
͈͗͆ͺͬ
ͅͼ͵ͬͪ
͊ͽͪͻ
ͫ΅Ͷͭͪͻͼ͵ͳͻͰͳ͵*
͊ͿͳΊ
̀ͪͬͪͺͳͽͪΔͪW-FHOFS
3FMJRVJFO
m+$4DINJUU
-FTSFMJRVFTFUMFTJNBHFT
JO-FT
SFMJRVFT
m%JFSLFOT
PQDJU
m
͉͊ͪͯΒͳΕ
͇;Ͷͳͷͪͳ;Ͷͼͽͳ;ͼͻͺͼ͵Β͵ΔͳͱͰͬͼͽͳͼ͵ͻͪΒͪ9**ͳͳͲ9***ͬͰ͵ͪ
JO
͇ͯͪͫͻͪͳͶͪͳͳͼͽ;ͯͳΒͰm
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯm͆ͬͳ͊ͪͯ
m
͊;ͫͽͳ̻Ͷ;ͫͬͳΕ
PQDJU
DGͳ͈ͪͬͶͬͳΕ
͇͊ͬ̈́;ͳ
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͺͻͬͳΒͰͺͻͰͬͰ͠ͰͬͻͰΒͰͺͻͰ͵͏ͻͬͰͭͷͻͪ
ͯ͵ΒͰͯͻ;ͭͳͷͭͰͪͻͯͰͳͲ
ͬͰͳͲͼͶͪͭͷͻͪͫͰͲͬͰͻΒͪͳͺͻͰͬͰ;ͫͭͺͲͪΔͰ͈ͪͻͪͶͰͶͪͼͅΒͼͳΒͰͷ
ͯͼͽͳͱͰͬͻ;ͪ;ͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͼͶͱͰΒ
ͰͼͪͽͶ͵ͳͫΒͰΒͷͳͼͶͳ͵Βͪ
;͵ͪͲ;ΒͰͪͬͪͱͪͳͳͶͪͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͺͶͳͽͳ͵ͰͽͰͶͭͳΒͰ͉ͰΒͰͺͻͰΌͰΔ;̈́;
͵ͳͳͷͽͳΒ;ͼt͵ͪͷͰͳͷͽͪͫͶͳͪͷͪi
ͼͪͪͶ;ͲͳΒͷͪͪΒͼͺͪͼͼͳͼͪͬͰͲ
ͼ̹ͭͷ͵ΒͳΒͰ͆ͬͷ́ͲͻͪͳΓ;ͯͰͲͪ͵
ͪtͷͽͬΓ;ͯͳͺͻͰͬͰ;ͫͰ
Εͪ;ͲͰͷΓ;̺ͳΔͰͭͪ͠Ͱͻ;ͼͪͶͳͷͪi
͆ͼͰΕͪͷͳͼͪͳͼͬͳͪͭͶͪͼͳ͵;ͶͽͪmͪͻͳͽΒͪͼͳͼ͵ͪͲͪͳ;ͳͷ
ͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͳͷͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪmͫͳͶͳͼ;;ͼͻͯͪͷͶͳͽͬͪͲͪͼͺͪͼͳͲͪͲͳͬͪΔͰͺͷΕͳ
ͬͳΔͳͼͳͶͪ͌ͽͷͼͷͳͼͶ;
ͼͬͰͽͳ̈́;͵ͪͳΒͰͫͳͽͰ͵;ͫͳͪΒͰͳͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ
͵ͬͳͺ͵ͻͬͳͽͰΓͯͻͱͪͬͰ
Ͳͪͼͽ;ͺͳ͵ͳͽͰͻͰͼͪΔͰͭͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͪͻͯͪ
͇ ΒͰ ͫͳ ͳͲͫͪͬͳͽͰΓ ͳ ͺͼͶͰͯΔͪ ;Ͳͯͪͳͪ ͊Ͷ;ͱͫͪ ͳ ͷͶͰͺͼͽͬͳΒͪ ͼͬͰͽͷ
̈́;͵ͳͳͲ;ͲͰͽͼ;ͼͬͰͯͪͼͽͬͼͽͪΔ;ͯ;ͪ;ͯͪΔΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ
ͪͶͳͳͪ
ͳͻͳͷͫͪͶ͵ͪͼ͵ͳͷͺͻͼͽͻͳͷ͇ͪΒͰͫͰͶͰͱͰͼͰΕͪΔͰͷͫͶͳͼ͵ͭ͵ͻͪΒͪ
ͼͺͼͽͬͰͳͯͻͱͪͬͪ
ͼΒͰͯͰͼͽͻͪͰ
͵ΒͰͼ;ͰͼͽͪΒͪͶͰͺͻͰͯͪͶͰͽͷͳͬͰͻ
ͳ
ͳ
ͼͯͻ;ͭͰ
ͳͽͪͬͭ;ͭͻͰͭͻͰͲͶͭͼͬͰͽͪ
ͪͯ͵ΒͳͷͼͰͪͯͬͳͶͪͺͻͰͽΔͪ
̽ͻ;ͭͭͯͶͪͼ͵͎ͪͻͳͼͽͬͭ͋ͰͭͲͳͼͽͰͳΒͪͶͼͰΕͪΔͰͼͽͻͪͪͯͫ;ͯ;Ε
ͼͽͳ
͵ͪ͵ͫͳͼͷͯͪͪͼͻͰ͵Ͷͳ
ͪͶͳͳͬͰͻͪ;ͱͳͬͽͫ;ͯ;ΕͰͭͬͰ͵ͪ
ͯͻͪͲͳͶͳͼ;
ͼͰ;ͼͪͼͽͪͬͳͷͪͺͼͬͰΕͰͳͷ̈́;͵ͳͪͯͬΒͪ͵ͪͳ͠Ͱͯͪ
ͫͭͼͶͬͼ͵ͳͬͰͷͪ
;Ͱͳͷͳͼͪͯ;ͫ͵
ͳͼ͵ͪͲͪΒͰͷͳͶͰͪͻͳͼͽͳ͵ͰͺͻͰ͵;ͺͪͳΒͰͬͻͰͷͰͪͺ
ͼͻͰͯͼͽͬͷͺͪͻͳͷͳΒͪ
ͺͻͰ;ͲͰͽͳͳͲ̓Δͳͭͪͺͻͻ͵Ä́ͼͪͳΒͰ
m
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
ͳ͠ͳͶͪ
m
͵ΒͰͼ;;ͷͰͽ;ͽͰ;͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵;ͼͶ;ͱͫ;͢ͳͬͪͼͬͪ
ͺͻ;͵ͪ
ͼͪͺͽͰͪͺΒͷͬͳͷΒͰͲͳ͵ͷͪͼ͵Ͱͽͳ͵Ͱ
ΒͰͼͽͰͺͲͳͬͪͼͺͲͪΒ;ͼͺ
ͼͽͬͰͰͭͻͰͼͽͳͳͳͼͽͳͼ͵ͺ͵ͪΒͪΔͰ tͻͪͲͯͰͻͳͽͰͼͻͪͼͬΒͪͪͰͪΓͳͰ
ͼͬΒͰi
ͪͺͻͰͼͬͰͭͪͪ͵ͻͰͽͪΔͰͳ;ͼΌͰΔͰ͵̹ͪͭ; tͼͬͳͷͼͻͰͷͬͪͳͷ
ͺ
ͼͽͷͳͺͶͪͰͷͳ;ͷͳͶͰͳΒͰͷi
͵ͪΒͰͯͳͷͳͲͬͻ;ͼͺͪͼͰΔͪ tΒͰͻΒͰͷͳͶͼͽͳͬ
ͳͱͪͶͼͽͳͬ
ͼͺͻͪͭͰͬͳͫͳͶͪͷͳͶͼͻΌͰͷi
̺ͰΕͳͪͺͻ;͵ͪͼͪͯͻͱͪͳ
;͊Ͷ;ͱͫͳͳͺͪͻͪ͵ͶͳͼͳͷͪͫͳͶͪΒͰ
ͳͺͪ͵
ͼͪͺͽͰͪΒͰͯͼͽͪͬͳΒͳͷΒͰͲͳ͵ͷͳ
ͪͯͼͶͬͪͪͳ͇ͰͼͰͪΒͺͻͰͷͭ;ͺͳͼͪͽͳ͵ͪͲͪͲͳͬͳ
ͬͪͺͪΒͳͲͪͺͷΕ
ͳͼͺͪͼͰΔͰ
͵Βͳͷͪͼ;ͫ;ͬͪΕͰͳͼͬͳͬͪͱͳͳͳͳͽͪͯͪΔͰͭͯͻ;ͽͬͪ͋ͪ
͵ͼͰͼͬͰͽͳ̈́;͵ͪ;ͷΓͪͬͪͯͪtͺͻͼͬͰͽͳiͼͻͺͼ͵;ͯͻͱͪͬ;ͳͪͻͯ;ͲͪΒͰͯͳ;
tͼͶͪͬͪͭͪͺͼͽͶͪͶ;ͪͷͳͺͻͼͬͰͽͪΒͰͼͻͫͼ͵ͪΒͪͼͪͬͪ͵;ͺΓͰͳΒͪi
ͽͰͯͪͼͪ
;ͬͪͳ;ͽͬͻͯͳͬͶͪͼͽΔͰͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͯͰͼͺͽͪ t̺ͶͪͯͳͳͰ
ͷͶͳͼͳͪͼͬΒͰͭ
ͳ̹ͭͪͪͰͭͼͪͻͪͳͽͳͯͻͱͪͬͳΒͰͯͬͼͪ͵ͳͫͰͯͳͼ͵ͻͫͰΒi
tͫͶͪͭͪͼͽͳͬͳ
ͯͰͼͺͽͪͳͼ͵ͳͺͽͻͪ;ͽͬͻͯͳi
͌ͰͼͽͪͶͰͼ;ͳͷͶͫͰͯͪͼͰͲͰͷΓͪͼͺͪͼͰͯ
tͫͰͲͫͱͳ̸ͭͪͻͰͪi
tͬͪͻͬͪͻͼ͵ͳͰͽͪͳΒͪiͳtͪͪͼͽͬͳΒͪͳͺͶͰͷͰͳi
͆ͪͻͳͽͷͰͼͽͳͷͪΒ;ͷͶͳͽͬͰͲͪͼͺͪͼͭͻͪͯͪtwͳͼͺͪͼͪΒͭͻͪͯͼͳ̺ͶͪͯͳͳͰ
ͳͱͰͽͰͶͪͺͼͽͶͬͼͪΓ;ͫͬͳΒ;ͺͻͳΒͰͷͳíͷͪΒ;ΕͳͼͬͰͽ;ͬͳͯ;
ͷͱͰͷ
ͼͰͼͶͱͳͽͳͼͯͪͬͳͲͰͽͷͰͷͯͪΒͰͼͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼ͵ͳ͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ
;ͺͻ
͵ͼ͵ͻͪͽ͵ͷͫͻͪͬ͵;ͷͽͳΒ;;ͺͼͶͰͯΔΒͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͺͻͰͼͽͳͳ
ͺͺͻͳͷͳ
ͳͻͳ
ͪͳͪͶͳͲͪͪΒ
ͪͰͶ͵ͪͶͳ
̓ͪͽΒͰͺͲͪͽ
͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͼͰͺͻͰͯͪͶͫͰͲͫͻͫͰΒ;ͪͭͯͳͰ
͌ͯͼ;ͯͷͳͼͽͻͳΒͼ͵ͷͪͼ;ͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱͳͼ;ͺ͵ͪͲͪͶͰͰ͵ͳͬͪͳ
WJSUVT ͊ͽͭͪ ͼͰ
; ͺͭͶͰͯ; ͯͰͶͽͬͻͼͽͳ
Ͱ ͷͭ; ;ͺͻͰͯͳͽͳ ͼ ͷͽͳͷͪ
ͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵Ͱ͇ͫͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͷͪͶͰͼ;ͳͳͪͰͷͭͽͭͪͲͪΒͰͯͳ͵ͭ͌ͪͰ
Ͷ;ΒͰͯͪ͵ͳͫͳͶͳͼ;ͷͽͳͬͳͲͪΔͳͬ;ͪͫͪͬ͵;ͳͺͽͳͺͬͰͼͳ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽ;
͵ΒͰͷͼ;ͫͪͬΓͰͰͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒͰ
͵ͪͳͺͻͰͯͬͳΌͰͪͲͪͽͳͽͳ͵ͪͿ;͵ͳΒͪ
͆ͪ͵ͺͪͯͪ͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪͳ͵ͪͰͺͻͺͪͼͽͳͼͪͷͼͽͪͶͰͼͻͺͼ͵ͰͯͻͱͪͬͰͶͪ
ͬͳͺͻͯͳͰ̹ͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͷͻͪͶͳͼ;ͯͪͪͺ;ͼͽͰͭͻͪͯͅͰΌ;ΔͳͷͪΒͰͫͳͶͪͳ
ͪͅͻͳΒͪ
ΕͰͻ͵ͪͯͰͼͺͽͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪͳΒͰͯͪͯͺͻͽͪͭͳͼͽͪͺͼͶͰͯΔͰͭͺ͵;ͪΒͪ
ͼͺͪͼͪͬͪΔͪ̽ͰͼͺͽͬͳͰ͇ͪͼͰ;ͪͺͻͳͶ;;ͯͪͶͪͲͪͫͼͪͼ͵ͭͺͻͰͼͽͶ
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
ͪͼͶͰͯͳ͵ͪ͊ͽͰͿͪͪ͋ͷͪͰͬͳΕͪ
͵ΒͳΒͰͽͳͷͳͷͺͼͽͪͬͶͪͯͪͻ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
̓ͪͯͪͼ;ͯͶͪͲͳͶͳͳͲ͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪ
̹ͻͪ͵ͬͳΕͳͼ;
ͼͯͺ;ͽͰΔͰͷͼ;Ͷͽͪͬͳͷ
ͺͻͰ;ͲͰͶͳͳͼͬΒͰͯͻͪͭͰͼͽͳ
;͵Γ;;Β;ΕͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰ͋ͪ͵ΒͰ͠ͰͶͰͪ
;ͯͬͳ
ͪͯͰͼͺͽͪ̈́ͪͲͪͻͪ
ͺͰͶ͈ͪͻͰͽͰͳ;ͯͰͼͳ;
ͯͻͰͬ;ͼͬͰͽͳΔ;ͱͳ͵Ͱͻͳ
ͲͳͰ
ͪͪͅͻͪ
͵ͪͼͬΒͷͳͻͪͲ
ͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵Ͱ͋ͪΒͽͻͰ;ͽͪ͵Ͳͪͳ
ΒͰ͵Γ;;ͺͻͷͰ;ͼͽͪͽ;ͼͪͽͰͲͪͷͰͳͽͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͳͻͪͲͷͰΌ;;ΔͰΒ;͵;ͺ
ΒͺͬͰͼͽͳͰ͵ͪͯͪͺͪͶͪͯͳΒ;ͷͯͻͱͪͬͰ
ͪΒͰͽͪͯͪͺͼͽͪͶͪͺͻͳͬͪͽͬͶͪͼͳ
ͽ͈ͬͼͶͰͯͳͰͽͰͺͻͷͰͰͫͳͶͰͼ;ͽͻͰ;ͽͰͳͬͰͷͪͲͪͪΒͰmͷͽͳͼ;
ͺͼͽͪͶͰͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͬͰΕͺͷͳΔͪͰͽͻͭͬͳͰͳͰΔ͵ͪΔͪͳͲͷͰΌ;ΔͳͬͰͬͶͪͼͳ
ͰͳͲͪͳͽͰͻͰͼͬͪͳ͵;ͺͪͪ̽ͪΓͪͳͼͽͻͳΒͪͷͽͳΒ;ͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵ͰͺͲͪͽͪΒͰ
;ͼͬͳͷͭͶͪͬͳͷͰͽͪͺͪͷͪͳͯ͵;ͷͰͽͬͪͪͳͲͷͺΒͰͯͳͼͽͳ͆ͪ͵ͽ
ͼ;ͯͰͽͰͳͲ͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪ
Ͱͼ;ΒͰͯͬͻͰͷͰͫͳͶͰͺͻͪΔͰͰ;ͽͬͻΌͪͬͳ͋Ͱͪ͵
͵ͯ̀ͬͻͳ͵͈ͪͻͰͯͽ;ͻͼ͵ͷͺͪͼΕ;͊ͽͰͿͪ͋ͷͪͰͬͳΕ;ͫͻͲͳΒͰͺͻͰ
Ͱ;ͼͬΒ;ͺͻͰͼͽͳ;ͪ͠ΒͰ̺ͰΕͭͯͳͰͺͷͳΔͰͼͰͯͪͼͰͽͪͷͪͶͪͲͰ
;ͻ͵ͬͳ͊ͬͰͽͰͪͅͻͳΒͰ͆ͳͽ;ͼͰ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳͼ;ͯ;ͭͲͪͯͻͱͪͶͰ̓ͪͯͪͼ;
͋;ͻͳͼͽͳͭͶͳͺͻͰͯͪ͠ΒͰ
͵ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵ͳͺͪͻΒͰͺͫͰͭͪ
ͽͼ;ͳͼ͵ͻͳͼͽͳͶͳͿͻͪ
ΔͰͬͳͳͯͰͶͳͷͽͳͪͺͯͻ;ΒͰ̽;ͫͻͬͪ͵ͰͻͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵Ͱ̀ͫͳͬͪΔͪ͵Βͪͼ;
;ͼͶͰͯͳͶͪͼͬͰͽΓͰͪͼ;ͲͪͬͪΓ;Β;Εͳͼͪ;ͬͪͳͷͺͳͼͷͳͷͪͳͲͭͯͳͰmͯ;
ͫͻͬͪ͵ͰͺͽͳͰ
͵ͻͪΓͳͰͪͅͻͳΒͰͳͼͺͶͳͽͼ͵ͭ͵ͰͲ̸ͪͯͻͳΒͰ̺ͰͰͻͳΒͪ
̓ͻͪΓͳͳͼ;͵ͫͼͿͻͪΔͰͬͳͷͪ͵ͬͶͪͼͳͽͬͪͪͯͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͷ͵ͪΒͰ
ͻͪͲͻͰͰͪͭͯͫͷ
ͺͪͼ;ͷͽͳͽͰͳͼͽͰ
ͭͯͳͰͺͻͰͰͽͰ;ͅͶͰͽ͵Ͱ̹ͳ
ͶͪΒͰͽΔͳͬͪͺͼͶͰͯΔͪ
ͺͰͽͪͺͻͰͯ;ͽͻͪͼͶͪͳΒ̺ͪ͌ͰͰͳΒͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ
ΒͰͯͰ͵ͪͪͼͬͰͶͳ͵ͳͷͼͶͪͬΓͰͷͳͺͶͱͰͪͪΒͺͻͰ;ͻ͵ͬ;͊ͬͰͽͭ͆ͳ͵ͶͰ
ͪͷͻ;
ͪͲͪͽͳͷ;ͻͪͷ͊ͬͰͽ̹ͭͰͻͪͯͳͪ
ͺͲͪͽ͵ͪ4BO+PC
;͵ΒͰͷͼͰ
;ͬͪͳͯͪͪͼ͌ͼ͵Ͷͪͯ;ͼͯͻͰͬͳͷͫͳͪΒͰͷ
;ͅͶͰͳͷͪͼ;ͷͽͳͺͶͱͰͰ
;ͬ
ͼ͵;ͺͰ͵ͳͬͽ͆ͳΒͰͳͷ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͫͳͶͼ;ΌͰͯͪͺͳͬͪΒ;;ͷͳͻ;
]]
͇̺͇̻͑͋́͊̾͋̈́͌̓̾ͅћ̸̸͉͈͈͇͊͊̓̾́̀̽
ΒͰͻͼ;ͯͷͪͺͺͻͳͼͺͰΕ;ͺͼͽͪͶͰͺͻͰͯͷͰͽͬͭͼͺͻ͇ͪͼͰͬͯͳͳͲͷͰΌ;
̺ͰͰͳΒͰͳ͈ͪͯͬͰm͈ͪͯͬΓͪͳͼ;ͽͬͻͯͳͶͳͯͪͼͰͪ;ͽͰͽͳͰͷͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ
̈́;͵ͰͪͶͪͲͰ͵ͯΔͳ͋ͪΒͼ;͵ͫ
͵ΒͳͼͰͺͻͽͰͭͪͯͪͰͭͬͻͰͷͰͪͳͺͯ
ͻͪͲ;ͷͰͬͪͱ;ͪͺͳͼͷͪ
ͷͭͫͻΒͰͰ͵ͼͺͰͻͽͳͲͰ
ͪͻͫͳͽͻͪͱͰ
ͺͪͳͲͪͫͻͪͰ
͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͺͻͰͯͷͰͽΒͰͯͼͽΒͪͪΒ;Ͳͫ;ͯΓͳͬͳΒͰͭͻͷͪͪ
ͪͶͳ
ͪͱͪͶͼͽ
ͳͲͶͪͲͳͳͲ
͵ͬͳͻͪͬͭͻͪͯͪ
͊ͽͭͪͲͪ͵Γ;;ΒͰͷͰͼͺͻΒͰͯͪͼ;ͳͪ͵ͪͺ;ͽͪΔͪ͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪͷ
ͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ̈́;͵ͰͼͽͪͶͰͬͰͷͪͰΔͰͪ
ͪ͵ͳͬͰͷͷͰͻΓͳͬͪSFTTBDSB͇Ͱ
ͷͰΌ;ͽͳͷ
ͳ͵ͪͯͪͳͼ;ͺͬͻͪͽͳͶͰ;ͼͺͳͻͳͽ;ͪͶ;ͼ;ͽͳ;
ͳͻ͵ͯͻ;ͽͬͰ
ͳ ͲͪͪΒ ͳ ͺͶͳͽͳ͵; ͪ͵ͽ;ͰͶͼͽ ͵ΒͰ ͼ; ͳͷͪͶͰ ; ͼͻͺͼ͵ͷ ͻͪͲͯͫΓ; ͼͬͭ
ͫͳͽͳͼͪΔͪ
ΒͰͲͪͺͳͼͪͯͪͼͰ;͵ͬͰͭ;mͼͽͪͻͷͳͰ;ͭͶͰͯͷ
ͼͺΓͪ;͵ͻͪͰͷͫͪͻͰΓͰͿͳͷͶͳ͵ͬͳ
ͷͪΒͰͬͪΌͰͶͳͼͽͰͳΔͰͭͬͭͼͳͷͫͶͪmͽͪͯͪͪͶͪͲͳͶͪtͶͫͪΔͪͼͪͰͽ͵ͱͰͪͶͳ;
ͯ͵
ͼ;ͭͽͬͼͬͳͲ;ͫͳ;ͬͳͶͳͪͷͪ̓ͼͽͳͶͰͬͰͭͰͷͳͳΕͳͷͪͼ;ͼͺΒͰͰ;͵ͶͰͳͷͪ
ͯ͵
ΒͰͼͽͺͪͶͫͰͭͰͯͰͶͳͷͳͼͪ;ͬͪͼͪͷ;ͼ͵;Ͷͳͷ͇ͪͯͼͽͪͶͳ͵ͼͽͳͼ;ͽ;͵ͪͻͶͳ
Ͱ
ͫͰͯͻͰͰͳͰͬͪͳͰ͆ͰͯͼͽͪΒ;ͯͰͼͪͭͪ
ͭͻ;ͯͳ͵
ͻ;͵Ͱͳͪ͵Ͱḯ͈ͪͬͶͬͳΕΒͰ
ͽͪ͵ΌͰͲͪͫͰͶͰͱͳ͵ͪ͵ͰͺͼͽΒͳͺͽͬͻͯͪ
ͳͽͳͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͪ
ͯͪΒͰͻͰͷͽͳͷͪ͵ΒͰͼ;
ͺͻͰ͵ͶͷͳͲ͊ͷͰͯͰͻͰͬͪ
͇ͽͷͰͯͰͽͪΓJCJE
m
]]
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
5)&$6-50')0-:36-&34"/%3&-*$4
*/.&%*&7"-4&3#*"
]]
*/530%6$5*0/
5)&46#+&$50'5)&TUVEJFTBTTFNCMFEJOUIJTCPPLBSFUIFDVMUT
TBJOUTBOE
SFMJDTUIBUQMBZFEBWJUBMSPMFJOMBZJOHUIFTBDSBMGPVOEBUJPOTPGUIFEZOBTUZBOE
UIFTUBUFJONFEJFWBM4FSCJB"TGPSUIFTBJOUT
UIFGPDVTJTPOOBUJPOBMDVMUT
FJUIFS
PGUIFSVMFSTPSPGPUIFSQSPNJOFOUNFNCFSTPGUIF/FNBOKJǀGBNJMZ"TGPSUIF
SFMJDT
UIFFORVJSJFTFODPNQBTTCPUIUIFJMMVTUSJPVTBMM$ISJTUJBOPOFTBOEUIPTF
OBUJPOBMmUIFSFMJDTPGUIF4FSCJBOIPMZLJOHTѮF MBUUFS BSF OPU POMZ UIF DPNNPO
EFOPNJOBUPSCVUBMTPUIFTVCTUBODFPGUIFUXPUIFNBUJDXIPMFT
/FFEMFTTUPTBZ
TBODUJUZXBTBLFZDBUFHPSZPGNFEJFWBM$ISJTUJBODJWJMJ[BUJPO
6OEPVCUFEMZUIFTBJOUJTBUSVFIFSPBOESPMFNPEFMPGUIBUMPOHHPOFFQPDIѮF
TBJOUJTBQFSTPOXIPFWFOJOIJTMJGFUJNF
BOEBTBSVMFWFSZFBSMZ
DPNFTUPCFSFD
PHOJ[FEBTBiIPMZNBOu8IBUEJTUJOHVJTIFTIJNGSPNPUIFSQFPQMFJTUIFTUSFOHUI
PGIJTGBJUIBOEMPWF
IJTJSSFTJTUJCMFVSHFUPQSBDUJTFWJSUVF
IJTSFNBSLBCMFFOEVS
BODF
BOEIJTXJMMJOHOFTTUPQVUIJNTFMGUPTFWFSFTUPGPSEFBMT
FWFOEFBUI
GPSIJT
JEFBMT4FFNJOHMZQBSBEPYJDBMBCPVUUIF$ISJTUJBOTBJOUJTUIBUIJTUSVFFYJTUFODF
JTUIFQPTUIVNPVTPOF0XJOHUPBMJGFTQFOUJOWJSUVFBOEBTDFUJDFOEFBWPVS
IF
QPTUIVNPVTMZBDRVJSFTBTQFDJBMTUBUVT
CPUIJOUIJTXPSMEBOEUIFOFYU*OUIFGPS
NFSIFCFDPNFTUIFPCKFDUPGEFFQFTUSFWFSFODF
PGBTBJOUMZDVMU
XIJMFJOUIFUSBO
TDFOEFOUBMSFBMNIFFOKPZTUIFQSJWJMFHFPGKPJOJOHUIFDIPJSPGTBJOUTTVSSPVOEJOH
UIF-PSETUISPOF*UJTPOMZJOIJTQPTUIVNPVTMJGFUIBUUIFTBJOUGVMêMT IJT CBTJD
GVODUJPOmUPNFEJBUFCFUXFFO&BSUIBOE)FBWFO0ONFOIFCFTUPXT
GPSEFWPVU
SFNFNCSBODFBOEXPSTIJQ
BOEBTBQMFEHFPGFUFSOJUZ
UIFPCKFDUTBOEQMBDFTBT
TPDJBUFEXJUIIJTQIZTJDBMFYJTUFODFѮFTF BSF BCPWF BMM IJT UPNC BOE SFMJDT
CVU
BMTP TBDSBM TQBDFT XIJDI
CFJOH DIBSHFE XJUI EJWJOF GPSDF
NBOJGFTU NJSBDVMPVT
QPXFST5PNFEJFWBMNBOUIFTBJOUXBTBTVQSFNFTQJSJUVBMBVUIPSJUZBOEBSFMJBCMF
TVQQPSUJOUIFJSMJGFUJNF
IFQSPWJEFEQSPUFDUJPOBOEIFBMJOH
BOEHSBOUFEUIFJS
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
]]
*/530%6$5*0/
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
]]
*/530%6$5*0/
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
4)BDLFM FE
ѮF #Z[BOUJOF 4BJOU #JSNJOHIBN
&1BUMBHFBOBOE13JDIÊ FET
)BHJPHSBQIJF$VMUVSFTFUTPDJÊUÊT 1BSJT
#'MVTJO
.JSBDMFFUIJTUPJSFEBOTMPFVWSFEF$ZSJMMFEF4DZUIPQPMJT 1BSJT
$ (BMBUBSJPUPV
ѮF NBLJOH PG B 4BJOU ѮF MJGF
UJNFT BOE TBODUJêDBUJPO PG /FPQIZUPT UIF
3FDMVTF $BNCSJEHF
%VSJOH UIF MBTU EFDBEF BO FOUJSF TNBMM MJCSBSZ PG XPSLT IBT CFFO XSJUUFO PO UIJT JTTVF "
SFMJBCMFSFWJFXPGFBSMJFSSFTFBSDIBOEêOEJOHT PG UIF iOFX IJTUPSJDJTNu BOE iOFX IBHJPMPHZu JT
PĒFSFE CZ " # .VMEFS#BLFS FE
ѮF JOWFOUJPO PG TBJOUMJOFTT -FJEFO
BOE10EPSJDP
BOE""HBQJUPT FET
-FTWJFTEFTTBJOUTÆ#Z[BODFTJHOJêDBOU BEWBODFT JO NFUIPEPMPHZ BOE
DPOUFOUBSFNBEFCZ".5BMCPU
i0ME8JOFJO/FX#PUUMFTѮF 3FXSJUJOH PG 4BJOUT-JWFTJO
UIF1BMFPMPHJBO1FSJPEu
JO4ſVSǁJǀBOE%.PVSJLJ FET
ѮF 5XJMJHIU PG #Z[BOUJVN "TQFDUT
PG$VMUVSBMBOE3FMJHJPVT)JTUPSZPGUIF-BUF#Z[BOUJOF&NQJSF 1SJODFUPOm/FX+FSTFZ
QQ
m ( %BHSPO
i-PNCSF EVO EPVUF -IBHJPHSBQIJF FO RVFTUJPO
97Fm97*F TJÍDMFu
%01
QQ m +B -KVCBSTLJK
i/FX 5SFOET JO UIF 4UVEZ PG #Z[BOUJOF )JTUPSJPHSBQIZu
]]
*/530%6$5*0/
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
'PVOEBUJPOTGPSUIFTUVEZPGUIFDVMUPGSFMJDTJOSFDFOUTDIPMBSTIJQXFSFMBJE
JOUIFTBOETCZUIFTFNJOBMXPSLTTVDIBT"OESFZ'SPMPXTCPPLPOUIF
SFMJDBOESFMJRVBSJFTPGUIF5SVF$SPTT
PSUIFDPNQSFIFOTJWFBOE
JOUFSNTPGJUT
EPDVNFOUFEOFTT
BTZFUVOTVSQBTTFETZOUIFTJTCZ/JDPMF)FSSNBOO.BTDBSE
*NQPSUBOUSFTVMUTIBWFBMTPCFFOBDIJFWFEJOFYBNJOJOHTPNFTQFDJêD QSPCMFNT
4PNFPGUIFTFBSFHJWFOUIPSPVHITUVEJFT
TVDIBT.BSUJO)FO[FMNBOOTEFWPUFE
UPSJUVBMTBTTPDJBUFEXJUISFMJDT
PGXIJDIUIFUSBOTMBUJPOPGSFMJDTXBTFTQFDJBMMZ
JNQPSUBOUѮPTF ZFBST XJUOFTTFE JOJUJBM BUUFNQUT BU TVQFSTFEJOH UIF QPTJUJWJTU
BQQSPBDI&YDFQUJPOBMMZTVDDFTTGVMXBT1BUSJDL(FBSZXIPTPVHIUUPJEFOUJGZSF
MJHJPVT
TPDJBMBOEQPMJUJDBMNPUJWFTUIBUIBEMFEUIFQFPQMFPGBOFQPDIJOUIFJS
QVSTVJU PG PCUBJOJOH QPTTFTTJPOPGSFMJDT
CZGBJSNFBOTPSGPVM *O UIF GPMMPX
JOH EFDBEF JOUFSFTU JO UIF TVCKFDU PCWJPVTMZ JODSFBTFE
XIJDI SFTVMUFE JO WBMV
BCMFBOEJOUFSFTUJOHDPOUSJCVUJPOT5PCFTJOHMFEPVUBSF
GPSFYBNQMF
UIFCPPLT
PO UIF SPVUFT PG SFMJD USBOTMBUJPOT BOE PO QJMHSJNBHFT UP UIF IPMZ QMBDFT JO UIF
&BTU
PSBTZOUIFUJDXPSLEFWPUFEUPUIFPSJHJO
GPSNTBOEGVODUJPOTPGUIFDVMU
PGSFMJDTJOFBSMZ$ISJTUJBOUJNFT*OUIFT
UIFJOUFSFTUXBTGVSUIFSGVFMMFE
CZNPOVNFOUBMTUVEZFYIJCJUJPOTEFWPUFEUPSFMJDT"TUIFJSMBTUJOHSFTVMUSFNBJO
TPNFFYDFMMFOUDBUBMPHVFT
XIJDI
JOBEEJUJPOUPXFMMEPDVNFOUFEQSFTFOUBUJPOT
PGUIFFYIJCJUT
JODMVEFTDSVQVMPVTTUVEJFTCZMFBEJOHTDIPMBST*GXFBMTPUBLF
JOUP BDDPVOU TJHOJêDBOU SFTVMUT BDIJFWFE JO TUVEZJOH UIF OBUJPOBM DVMUT PG TBJOUT
BOESFMJDT
BOEBMNPTUFWFSZ&VSPQFBOUSFBTVSFPGBOZJNQPSU
JUJTOPUTVSQSJTJOH
UIBU PVS UJNF JT NBSLFE CZ UIF BQQFBSBODF PG TJHOJêDBOU TZOUIFTFT .PTU DPNF
GSPNUIF(FSNBOTDIPMBSMZNJMJFV7FSZJOëVFOUJBM IBT CFFO )BOT #FMUJOHT DBQJ
]]
*/530%6$5*0/
) #FMUJOH
#JME VOE ,VMU &JOF (FTDIJDIUF EFT #JMEFT WPS EFN ;FJUBMUFS EFS ,VOTU .VOJDI
"-FHOFS
3FMJRVJFOJO,VOTUVOE,VMU[XJTDIFO"OUJLFVOE"VѪMÅSVOH %BSNTUBEU
""OHFOFOEU
)FJMJHFVOE3FMJRVJFO%JF(FTDIJDIUFJISFT,VMUFTWPNGSÛIFO$ISJTUFOUVNCJT
[VS(FHFOXBSU .VOJDI
(+$4OPFL
.FEJFWBM1JFUZGSPN3FMJDTUPUIF&VDIBSJTU -FJEFO
+1FUFISTPO FE
1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOHJN)PDINJUUFMBMUFS 4JHNBSJOHFO
&
#P[ÓLZBOE".)FMWÊUJVT FET
-FTSFMJRVFT0CKFUT
DVMUFT
TZNCPMͰT #SFQPMT
̸ ͅ ̈́ͳͯͬ FE
͎ͻͳͼͽͳͪͼ͵ͳͰ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳ ͬ ͷͼ͵ͬͼ͵ͷ ̓ͻͰͷͶͰ .PTDPX
̸
ͅ ̈́ͳͯͬ FE
̺ͼͽͻͳͼͽͳͪͼ͵ͳͰ ͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳ .PTDPX
̸ ͅ ̈́ͳͯͬ FE
́ͰͻͽͺͳΊ́ͼͶͰͯͬͪͳͰͼͪ͵ͻͪͶ·Άͺͻͼͽͻͪͼͽͬ .PTDPX
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
CFFOJNNFEJBUFMZSFMFWBOUUPNZSFTFBSDI
CVUTPNFPUIFSJOUVSOIBWFDSFBUFEBO
JOFWJUBCMFGSBNFXPSLGPSUIFQVSTVJUPGNZFORVJSJFT'PSFNPTU
PGDPVSTF
JTUIF
QSPDMBJNFEJNBHFPGUIFJEFBMSVMFS
JOUFSNTPGIJTQSFTDSJCFERVBMJUJFTBOEEVUJFT
BTXFMMBTIJT0MEBOE/FX5FTUBNFOUNPEFMT"OJNQPSUBOUQMBDFJTBMTPHJWFOUP
BUZQPMPHZPGIPMZSVMFST
BTJUJTJOEJDBUJWFPGUIFXBZTJOXIJDITBODUJUZXBTBD
RVJSFEѮF TBNF HPFT GPS BMM RVFTUJPOT QFSUBJOJOH UP UIF TBDSBM MFHJUJNBUJPO PG UIF
TUBUF
PSUIFNFBOTBOENFDIBOJTNTTFUJONPUJPOXJUIUIFWJFXUPBDRVJSJOHUIF
BVSBPGTBODUJUZ0GUIFMBUUFS
NZQBSUJDVMBSBUUFOUJPOIBTCFFOESBXOUPRVFTUJPOT
UIBUOBUVSBMMZBSJTFGSPNUIFTUVEZPGSFMJDT
QSJNBSJMZUIPTFXIJDI
JOBCSPBEFTU
TFOTF
UPVDIVQPOUIFEPNBJOPGTUBUFTZNCPMJTN
*ODPOUSBTUXJUIUIFêSTU UXP TFUT PG QSPCMFNT m IBHJPMPHZ BOE UIF TVCKFDU PG
SFMJDTmXIFSF*IBWFCFFOBCMFUPSFMZPOTQFDJBMJ[FETVSWFZTCVUOPUPOEPNFTUJD
TZOUIFTFT
NZXPSLPOSPZBMJEFPMPHZIBTCFFONBEFNVDIFBTJFSJOUIBUSFTQFDU
8JUIJO B TIPSU TQBO PG UJNF
UIF TDIPMBSMZ DPNNVOJUZ XBT PĒFSFE UXP TUVEJFT
EFWPUFEUPUIF4FSCJBOSPZBMJEFPMPHZPGUIF.JEEMF"HFTѮF HSFBUFTU NFSJU PG
UIFCPPLCZ#PØLP#PKPWJǀJTJOBDRVBJOUJOHUIFGPSFJHOQVCMJDXJUIUIF4FSCJBO
NBUFSJBMTBOEJOJOGPSNJOHUIFEPNFTUJDQVCMJDBCPVUBHFOFSBMÊUBUEFSFDIFSDIÊJO
UIFêFME0OUIFPUIFSIBOE
UIFTUVEZCZ4NJMKB%VØBOJǀ.BSKBOPWJǀ
CSPBEMZ
GPVOEFEJONFUIPEBOEFYBDUJOQSPCMFNEFêOJUJPO
MBZT B SFMJBCMF HSPVOEXPSL GPS
BMMGVSUIFSBOENPSFUIPSPVHISFTFBSDIJOUP4FSCJBOSPZBMJEFPMPHZ
*OUIFBNQMFHFOFSBMMJUFSBUVSFEFBMJOHXJUISPZBMJEFPMPHZ
NZêSNFTU QPJOUT PG
TVQQPSU
BTFYQFDUFE
IBWFCFFOUIFTUVEJFTUIBUGSPNEJĒFSFOU WJFXQPJOUT EJTDVTT
UIFiIPMZLJOHu
DFOUSBMRVFTUJPOPGNFEJFWBMSPZBMJEFPMPHZ4PNFPGUIFCPPLT
XSJUUFOTFWFSBMEFDBEFTBHPIBWFOPUMPTUUIFJSSFMFWBODF(.'FEPUPWTTUVEZPG
# #PKPWJǀ
-JEÊPMPHJF NPOBSDIJRVF EBOT MFT IBHJPCJPHSBQIJFT EZOBTUJRVFT EV NPZFO ÄHF
TFSCF 3PNF
UIFCPPLIBTJUT4FSCJBOFEJUJPOUPP̹̹ΒͬͳΕ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬͼͽͬͳͼͬͰͽͼͽ
͈Ͷͳͽͳ͵ͪͿͳͶͲͿͳΒͪͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬͰ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ #FMHSBEF
UIFSFBEFSPGIJTCPPLNBZ
CFTPNFXIBUTVSQSJTFECZUIFGBDUUIFBVUIPSTCSPBEJOGPSNFEOFTTBCPVUUIFDVSSFOUTDIPMBSMZ
USFOET
BTQSFTFOUFEJOUIFTDIPMBSMZBQQBSBUVT
IBTMFѫ MJUUMF USBDF JO UIF UFYU QSPQFS XIFO JU
DPNFTCPUIUPFTUBCMJTIJOHBNFUIPEPMPHJDBMGSBNFXPSLBOEUPTPMWJOHDFSUBJOQSPCMFNT+VTUBT
EJēDVMU UP VOEFSTUBOE BSF UIF SFBTPOT UIBU IBWF MFE UIF BVUIPS UP JHOPSF UIF êOEJOHT PG4FSCJBO
TDIPMBSTBTSFHBSETIBHJPMPHZBOESPZBMJEFPMPHZ
BTTIPXOCZIJTSFDFOUMZQVCMJTIFETUVEZ#
#PKPWJǀ
i&TDIBUPMPHJFFUIJTUPJSF$BSBDUÊSPMPHJFEFMIBHJPHSBQIJFTVETMBWFEV.PZFO"HFuJO
-FTWJFTEFTBJOUTÆ#Z[BODF
QQm
͊ ̽;ͪͳΕͪͅͻΒͪͬͳΕ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪ ͳͯͰͶͭͳΒͪ ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕͪ ̽ͳͺͶͷͪͽͳ͵ͪ ͼͽ;ͯͳΒͪ
#FMHSBEF
&BE
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͼ͵Ͱ ͳͼͳͭͳΒͰ ͳ ͯͻͱͪͬͪ ͼͳͷͫͶͳ͵ͪ ; ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ ͯ 9*** ͯ 97
ͬͰ͵ͪ #FMHSBEF
]]
*/530%6$5*0/
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
]]
*/530%6$5*0/
UIFJSCJPHSBQIJFT
XIJDICFMPOHUPUIFEJTUJODUJWFHFOSFPGSPZBMIJTUPSJPHSBQIZ
ѮF NPOBTUJD JEFBMT BOE WJSUVFT BSF EFQJDUFE CZ NFBOT PG BO FTUBCMJTIFE SFQFSUPJSF
PGDPNNPOQMBDFTEFTDSJCJOHUIFTUBHFTPGUIFBTDFUJDMJGFBOEGFBUTѮF iIJTUPSJD
JUZuPGUIFBTDFUJDQSBDUJDFTPGUIF/FNBOKJǀJTBTFQBSBUFBOEWFSZJOUFSFTUJOHUPQJD
BOEUIFBWBJMBCMFFYBNQMFTmUIFBTDFUJDJNBHFPGLJOH%SBHVUJOCFJOHFTQFDJBMMZ
QSPNJOFOUmPĒFS B DIBMMFOHJOH UBTL BT SFHBSET UIF VTF
SFBM NFBOJOH BOE VMUJNBUF
QVSQPTFPGIBHJPHSBQIJDUPQPJ
ѮF DPODFQUT PG iIPMZLJOHuBOETBJOUMZEZOBTUZ
FTUBCMJTIFEBOEJEFPMPHJDBMMZ
FMBCPSBUFEJO/FNBOKJǀUJNFT
CFMPOHUPUIFQFSJPEPGUIFNFEJFWBM4FSCJBOTUBUFT
SJTF BOE FYQBOTJPO m IFODF JUT FNQIBUJDBMMZ EZOBTUJD GVODUJPO BOE TUBUFCVJME
JOHQVSQPTF*OUIFMBTUEFDBEFTPGUIFGPVSUFFOUIDFOUVSZ
IPXFWFS
JOBDIBOHFE
IJTUPSJDBMTFUUJOHDBVTFECZUIF0UUPNBODPORVFTUT
XJUIEJTBTUFSMPPNJOH
UIFSF
PDDVSSFE B NBKPS UVSO JO UIF EPNBJO PG SPZBM JEFPMPHZ *O QPTU,PTPWP 4FSCJB
UIFJNBHFPGUIFJEFBMSVMFSXBTBDDPNNPEBUFEUPUIFNBSUZSQBUUFSO
QSPQPOFOU
PGUIFTQJSJUVBMQSJODJQMFBOECFBSFSPGBEFFQGFMUFTDIBUPMPHJDBMQSPHSBNNFѮF
OFXWBMVFTZTUFN
TQJSJUVBMBOENPSBM
XBTSFëFDUFE JO B OFX DPODFQUJPO PG TBOD
UJUZ*UGPVOEJUTTVCMJNBUFEFYQSFTTJPOJOUIFêHVSF PG QSJODF -B[BS
NBSUZSFE BU
,PTPWP
CVUTPNFFBSMJFSSVMFSDVMUTDBNFUPCFSFNPEFMMFEBTXFMMѮJT JT UIF DBTF
PG4UFGBOPG%FǁBOJXIP
JOUIFFBSMZêѫFFOUI DFOUVSZ
BTTVNFE BEJĒFSFOU JEFOUJUZ
UIBUPGBNBSUZSѮF OFXMZTBJOUFE $ISJTUJBO NBSUZST XFSF FYQFDUFE
BCPWF BMM
UPQSBZGPSUIFTBMWBUJPOPGUIFiGBUIFSMBOEu0OUIFXIPMF
JOUIBUQFSJPEUIFIPMZ
SVMFSTNBJOGVODUJPOXBTMJUFSBMMZTPUFSJPMPHJDBM
ѮF IPMZ SVMFS DVMU JO NFEJFWBM 4FSCJB DPNQSJTFE TFWFSBM FTTFOUJBM FMFNFOUT
XIPTFVMUJNBUFQVSQPTFXBTUIFTUBUFTTBDSBMMFHJUJNBUJPO*OBEEJUJPOUPIBHJP
HSBQIJDBMBOEIZNOPMPHJDBMPOFT
JOUFOEFEGPSMJUVSHJDBMWFOFSBUJPO
BOJNQPSUBOU
SPMFXBTBMTPQMBZFECZSJUVBMFMFNFOUT
BTXFMMBTUIPTFUIBUNBZCFUFSNFENBUF
SJBMPSWJTVBMѮF SJUVBM FMFNFOUT
CBTFE PO #Z[BOUJOF IBHJPHSBQIJD QBUUFSOT CVU
TJNJMBSUP8FTUFSOFYBNQMFTJOGVODUJPO
XFSFDFOUSFESPVOEUIFIPMZSFMJDTBOE
BSUJDVMBUFEUISPVHITFWFSBMLFZTUBHFTUIFFMFWBUJP
USBOTMBUJPBOEEFQPTJUJPPGSFM
JDTѮF USBOTMBUJPO PG UIF 4FSCJBO SVMFST SFMJDT XBT BO FMBCPSBUF DFSFNPOZ DVMNJ
OBUJOHJOUIFUSJVNQIBMBEWFOUVT'SPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPGJUTVMUJNBUFQVSQPTF
UIJT
BDUPGGPSNBMBOEQVCMJDJOBVHVSBUJPOPGBOFXOBUJPOBMTBJOUCFMPOHFEOPUPOMZ
UPUIFTQIFSFPGEFWPUJPOBMQSBDUJDFTCVUBMTPXBTBQPXFSGVMNFBOTPGEZOBTUJD
QSPQBHBOEB
ѮSPVHI DBSFGVMMZ EFTJHOFE CVJMEJOH
GVOFSBSZ PS SFMJD QSPHSBNNFT
CVU NPTU
PGBMMUISPVHIQBJOUFEJNBHFT
UIFNBUFSJBMFMFNFOUTPGUIFDVMUDPNNVOJDBUFEUIF
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
QSJODJQMFTBOENFTTBHFTPGSPZBMJEFPMPHZ
BOEUSBOTMBUFEUIFBCTUSBDUOPUJPOPG
TBODUJUZJOUPDBUFHPSJFTVOEFSTUBOEBCMFUPUIFNBTTPGUIFGBJUIGVM4PNFPGUIPTF
FMFNFOUTXFSFPGQBSUJDVMBSJNQPSUBODFJODSFBUJOHUIFIPMZSVMFSDVMUBCPWFBMM
UIFSPZBMGPVOEBUJPOTmSFQSFTFOUBUJWFGVOFSBSZDIVSDIFTXJUINPOVNFOUBMSPZBM
UPNCTѮFZ XFSF GVSOJTIFE XJUI EJTUJODUJWF GSFTDP QSPHSBNNFT XIJDI XFSF FY
QSFTTMZ FTDIBUPMPHJDBM JO OBUVSF CVU BMTP DPOWFZFE DMFBS EZOBTUJD NFTTBHFT ѮF
TBDSBMGPDVTPGBSPZBMNBVTPMFVNXFSFUIFSFMJDTPGJUTLUFUPS
UIFIPMZSVMFS
FO
TISJOFEJOBTVNQUVPVTSFMJRVBSZBOEHJWFOBQMBDFPGIPOPVSJOGSPOUPGUIFJDP
OPTUBTJT"TBSVMFJOUIFGPSNPGIJHIMZSFWFSFESFMJDT
UIFiXIPMFuPSiTXFFUTNFMM
JOHuCPEJFTmPS
JOUIFDBTFPG4U4JNFPO.ZSPCMZUFT
IJTUPNCmUIFIPMZSFNBJOT
XFSF UIF TPVSDF PG NJSBDVMPVT EJWJOF QPXFST 1SPWJEJOH B SBOHF PG DVSFT
GSPN
USPVCMFTPGUIFCPEZUPiQBTTJPOTPGUIFNJOEu
UIFZFēDJFOUMZ HSBUJêFE UIF OFFET
PGQPQVMBSQJFUZ0OUIFPUIFSIBOE
BTEZOBTUJDFNCMFNTPGIJHIFTUSBOL
UIFIPMZ
SVMFST SFMJDT QPTTFTTFE FOPSNPVT TZNCPMJDBM QPXFS ѮFZ XFSF DPOêSNBUJPO PG
UIFBDIJFWFETBDSBMBVSBPS
JOPUIFSXPSET
PGUIF4FSCJBOTUBUFTMFHJUJNBDZJOUIF
XPSMEPSEFS
BOEBUPLFOPGEJWJOFQBUSPOBHFPWFSUIFEZOBTUZBOEUIFQFPQMF
ѮF DVMU PG UIF IPMZ SVMFST SFMJDT GPSNFE QBSU PG B CSPBEFS SFMJD QSPHSBNNF
XIJDIXBTPOFPGUIFNPTUFēDJFOU NFBOT PG TBDSBM MFHJUJNBUJPO PG LJOHTIJQ BMM
PWFSUIF$ISJTUJBOXPSME*UXBTOPEJĒFSFOU XJUI UIF 4FSCT
XIFSF UIF VTF PG SFM
JDTGPSTVDIQVSQPTFTNBZCFUSBDFECBDLUPUIFUJNFTPGHSBOEßVQBOTIJQJOUIF
MBTU EFDBEFT PG UIF UXFMѫI DFOUVSZ *U JT OPU BU BMM CZ DIBODF UIBU PG BMM JMMVTUSJ
PVT$ISJTUJBOSFMJDTJUXBTUIF5SVF$SPTTUIBU/FNBOKBDIPTFBTIJTQSPUFDUJOH
BOESFHBMFNCMFN
UIFSFCZKPJOJOHUIFMBSHFGBNJMZPG&VSPQFBOSVMFSTXIPQMBDFE
UIFJS EZOBTUJFT BOE TUBUFT VOEFS QSPUFDUJPO PG UIF 7JDUPSJPVT $SPTT " TVQSFNF
BDIJFWFNFOUJOUIBUSFTQFDU
JOCPUIDPODFQUJPOBOESFBMJ[BUJPO
XBTNBEFBUÂJǁB
JOUIFFBSMZUIJSUFFOUIDFOUVSZ"UUIFNPNFOUUIFWJUBMJOTUJUVUJPOTXFSFCFJOH
DPOTUJUVUFEJO4FSCJB
JOEFQFOEFOUTUBUFBOEDIVSDI
UIFDPSPOBUJPOBOEDBUIFESBM
DIVSDISFDFJWFEBSFMJDQSPHSBNNFPGIJHIFTUSBOL*UJOWPMWFEUIFNPTUJMMVTUSJPVT
PG$ISJTUJBOSFMJDTPSJHJOBUJOHGSPNUIF)PMZ-BOEBOEBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFDIJFG
QSPUBHPOJTUTPGFWBOHFMJDFWFOUT*OUIFHJWFODPOUFYU
UIFZXFSFBOJNQPSUBOUFMF
NFOU PG TUBUF TZNCPMJTN
DSFBUJOH
NPSFPWFS
B EJTUJODUJWF LJOE PG TBDSBM TQBDF
B TVCTUJUVUF GPS UIF )PMZ -BOE "T FMTFXIFSF JO $ISJTUFOEPN
BUIVT DPODFJWFE
USBOTMBUJP)JFSPTPMZNJFDIPFEUIFJEFBPGUSBOTMBUJPJNQFSJJBOESFTVMUFEGSPNUIF
JOUFOUJPOUIBUUIF4FSCT
BTBiDIPTFOQFPQMFu
TIPVMECFEVMZJOUSPEVDFEJOUPUIF
NBJOTUSFBNPG4BDSFE)JTUPSZ
.VDI MJLF UIF DVMU PG IPMZ SVMFST
UIF DVMU PG SFMJDT VOEFSXFOU B TJHOJêDBOU
DIBOHFJOUIFTUBUFTMBTUQFSJPEPGJOEFQFOEFODF"MUIPVHIBWBMVBCMFDPMMFDUJPO
]]
*/530%6$5*0/
PGSFMJDTJOUIFUJNFTPGEFTQPU4UFGBOIBTCFFOEPDVNFOUFE
UIFIBMMNBSLPGUIF
FQPDIJTUIFUSBOTMBUJPOPGUIFSFMJDTPG4U1FULBBOE4U-VLF
GPSXIPNUIFSPMF
PGQSPUFDUPSTPGUIF4FSCJBO%FTQPUBUFXBTJOUFOEFEѮPTF TPMFNO SJUVBMT
QFS
GPSNFE BDDPSEJOH UP BMM UIF SVMFT PG UIF BEWFOUVT SFMJRVJBSVN
XFSF BO FYQSFT
TJPOPGUIFMBTUIPQFBOEBSEFOUQSBZFSTGPSUIFTVSWJWBMPGi(PETëPDLu(SBOE
JODPODFQUJPOBOEPVUTUBOEJOHJOSFBMJ[BUJPO
UIFQSPHSBNNFPGUIFTUBUFTTBDSBM
MFHJUJNBUJPO
MBJEEPXOCZ4U4BWBPG4FSCJB
IBECFêUUFE 4FSCJBTOFFETBOENFBOT
JOUIF/FNBOKJǀBHF*OBTJUVBUJPOTVDIBTJUXBTCFGPSFUIFGBMMPGUIFTUBUF
UIF
QSPHSBNNFOPMPOHFSIBETVQQPSUJOSFBMJUZ"ѫFS BMM
UIF %FTQPUBUFT TBJOUMZ QSP
UFDUPSTGBJMFEUPEFNPOTUSBUFUIFJSNJSBDVMPVTQPXFST
ѮF TUVEJFT JO UIJT CPPL UIBU * OPX TVCNJU UP UIF QVCMJD XFSF NPTUMZ XSJUUFO
BOEQVCMJTIFEEVSJOHUIFMBTUUFOZFBST m
CVUTPNFPGUIFNBQQFBSGPS
UIFêSTU UJNF JO PSEFS UP SPVOE PĒ UIF EJTDVTTJPO PG UIF TVCKFDU ѮFZ BMM BSF UIF
SFTVMUPGBSFTFBSDIQSPDFTTGPDVTFEPOUIFDVMUTmQSJNBSJMZUIPTFPGUIF4FSCJBO
SPZBMTBJOUTBOESFMJDTmUIBUQMBZFEBOJNQPSUBOUSPMFJOUIFTUBUFTTBDSBMMFHJUJNB
UJPOѮFJS BJN IBT CFFO UP BEESFTT UIJT NPNFOUPVT UPQJD PG 4FSCJBO DVMUVSBM IJT
UPSZJOBNFUIPEPMPHJDBMMZBQQSPQSJBUFNBOOFS
UPEFêOF JUT SFTFBSDI GSBNFXPSL
UPTPNFFYUFOUBUMFBTU
BTXFMMBTUPJEFOUJGZUIFNBJOQSPCMFNTѮF SFTFBSDI IBT
CFFOEPOFPOBTFMFDUFEOVNCFSPGTBNQMFT
XJUIOPBNCJUJPOUPBDIJFWFBTZO
UIFTJT
CVUXJUIIPQFUIBUJUXPVMEQSPWFVTFGVMGPSTPNFGVUVSF
DPNQSFIFOTJWFMZ
EFTJHOFEQSPKFDUPOUIF4FSCJBOiIPMZLJOHuBOEUIFDVMUPGSFMJDTJOUIF.JEEMF
"HFTѮF FTTBZT BSF HSPVQFE BDDPSEJOH UP UIFJS UIFNBUJD BTTPDJBUJPO SBUIFS UIBO
JOUIFDISPOPMPHJDBMPSEFSJOXIJDIUIFZXFSFXSJUUFO$POTJEFSJOHUIBUUIFSFJT
JOTFWFSBMDBTFT
BDPOTJEFSBCMFJOUFSWBMCFUXFFOXSJUJOHBOEQVCMJDBUJPO
UIFEBUF
PGFBDIFTTBZJTDPOTDJPVTMZTQFDJêFE TP BT UP TFSWF BT BO FYQMBOBUJPO GPS UIF PNJT
TJPOGSPNUIJTWPMVNFPGTPNFXPSLTQVCMJTIFEJOUIFNFBOUJNF"TGPSUIFDJUFE
MJUFSBUVSF
XIJMFQSFQBSJOHUIFCPPLGPSQVCMJDBUJPO
*IBWFDPNFUPUIFDPODMVTJPO
UIBUVQEBUJOHJUNBZOPUCFVTFGVMGPSTFWFSBMSFBTPOT/BNFMZ
XJUIUIFCFOFêU
PGIJOETJHIU
UIFFBSMJFTUTUVEJFTXPVMEIBWFCFFOEJĒFSFOU JO NFUIPE BOE CZ GBS
NPSFFYUFOTJWFJOTDPQFѮFSFGPSF
FYDFQU GPS NJOPS MJOHVJTUJD BOE PSUIPHSBQIJD
JOUFSWFOUJPOT
UIFUFYUTBSFCSPVHIUPVUJOUIFJSPSJHJOBMGPSN*ONBLJOHTVDIB
EFDJTJPO*IBWFBMTPCFFOHVJEFECZUIFXJTIUPNBLFUIFSFTFBSDIQSPDFTTBOEUIF
TUBHFTPGUIFSPBEUSBWFMMFEWJTJCMF
JODMVEJOHNBOZBEJēDVMUZ BOE QSFEJDBNFOU *
DBNFBDSPTTBMPOHUIFXBZ
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
#FMHSBEF +VOF
]]
)0-:'03&'"5)&34
͋͆̾$6-50'454*.&0//&."/+"
"$0/53*#65*0/505)&456%:0'5)&$6-5
0'3&-*$4".0/(5)&4&3#4
" TQFDJêD JTTVF QFSUBJOJOH UP UIF SFMJDT PG 4U 4JNFPO
GPVOEFS PG UIF 4FSCJBO
/FNBOKJǀEZOBTUZ
JTEJTDVTTFEIFSFPS
NPSFQSFDJTFMZ
UIFJSGPSNBOEUIFDBUFHPSZ
UPXIJDIUIFZCFMPOHFEѮF BQQSPBDI UBLFT B CSPBEFS WJFX PG UIJT JOTVēDJFOUMZ
TUVEJFE QSPCMFN
FYBNJOJOH UIF JEFBT BOE QSBDUJDFT PG UIF NFEJFWBM $ISJTUJBO
XPSMEѮF TVSWJWJOH TPVSDFT BOE NFBHSF NBUFSJBM FWJEFODF JOEJDBUF UIBU UIF HFO
FSBMDPODFQUPGSFMJDT SFMJRVJBF
ʌʆʝʘʂʎʂ
DPNQSJTFECPUIXIPMF
PSJOUBDUCPEJFT
ʛʎʓʢʓʔʊʚʄʊʐʊ
BOETLFMFUBMSFNBJOTPGTBJOUT ʔʂʟʓʔʂ
PTTB
ѮF EFDJTJWF TJHO
PGTBJOUIPPEXBTUIFHJѫ PG NJSBDMFXPSLJOH SBUIFS UIBO UIF GPSN PG SFMJDT
BT FY
QPVOEFECZUIFNPTUTJHOJêDBOU UIFPMPHJBOT TJODF QBUSJTUJD UJNFT
'SPN UIF BOBMZTJT PG UFSNT BOE QISBTFT FNQMPZFE JO NFEJFWBM 4FSCJBO IB
HJPHSBQIJFT
JUGPMMPXTUIBUUIFTFTPVSDFTBSFUPBHSFBUFYUFOUUSVTUXPSUIZXIFO
SFGFSSJOHUPSFMJDT'SPNUIFDPNNPOQMBDFTUZQJDBMPGUIJTMJUFSBSZHFOSF
UIFCJPH
SBQIFSTPG4FSCJBOLJOHTBOEDIVSDIMFBEFSTTFMFDUFEPOMZUIPTFUIBUSFëFDUFE UIF
BDUVBMTUBUFPGBĒBJST ѮFZ BMXBZT SFGFS UP UIF JOUBDU SFNBJOT BT iXIPMFu PS iVO
DPSSVQUFECPEJFTu)PXFWFS
UIJTCBTJDUFSNJTBTBSVMFFOIBODFECZWJWJEIBHJP
HSBQIJDFYQBOTJPOT
NPTUGSFRVFOUMZEFTDSJCJOHUIFiOBUVSBMuBQQFBSBODFPGSFMJDT
%FTDSJQUJPOTPGUIFJSCFJOHQMBDFEJOTISJOFTBOEQVUiPOEJTQMBZuDBOCFUBLFOBT
BSFMJBCMFQSPPGUIBUUIFSFMJDTCFMPOHFEUPUIJTDBUFHPSZ0OUIFPUIFSIBOE
UIFFY
QSFTTJPOiJOUBDUSFNBJOTuTIPVMECFDPOTJEFSFEBTBHFOFSBMDPODFQUSFMBUJOHCPUI
UPiXIPMFuCPEJFTBOEUPXFMMQSFTFSWFETLFMFUFMSFNBJOT
"MMSFTFBSDISFTVMUTIBWFMFEUPUIFDPODMVTJPOUIBUUIFSFMJDTPG4U4JNFPOEJE
OPUCFMPOHUPUIFDBUFHPSZPGiXIPMFuVODPSSVQUFECPEJFT̺;UIFUIFPMPHJDBMBOE
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
QSBDUJDBMTUBOEBSETPGUIBUFQPDI
UIJTGBDUEJEOPUJOBOZXBZCSJOHJOUPRVFTUJPO
UIFJSIPMJOFTT
UIFNPSFTPBT4U4JNFPOIBECFFOBNJSBDMFXPSLFSBOEBNZSPC
MZUFT'JOBMMZ
JOWJFXPGUIFGBDUUIBUUIFCPEJFTPGUIFTVCTFRVFOU4FSCJBOSVMFST
XFSFBTBSVMFVODPSSVQUFE
UIFGPSNPG4U4JNFPOTSFMJDTJTJOUFSQSFUFEJOUIFMJHIU
PG DPODSFUF IJTUPSJDBM DJSDVNTUBODFT *G XF UBLF JOUP DPOTJEFSBUJPO UIF QPMJUJDBM
GVODUJPO PG SFMJDT
PCWJPVT XIFO SVMFSTTBJOUT BSF JO RVFTUJPO
JU GPMMPXT UIBU BU
UIFUJNFPG4JNFPOTEFBUI
UIFFNCBMNJOHPGIJTCPEZ
FRVBMUPIJTCFJOH
QSPDMBJNFEBTBJOU
XPVMEIBWFSFQSFTFOUFEBOVOBDDFQUBCMFBDU
OPUSFOEFSFEQPT
TJCMFVOUJMBѫFS UIF IJFSBSDIZ PG TUBUFT DPMMBQTFE XJUI UIF GBMM PG $POTUBOUJOPQMF JO
ѮVT
UIF CPEZ PG 4JNFPO /FNBOKBT TPO BOE IFJS
4UFGBO UIF 'JSTU $SPXOFE
XBTFNCBMNFEBѫFS IJT EFBUI
BOE TPMFNOMZ EJTQMBZFE BU ÂJǁB
UIFDBUIFESBM
BOEDPSPOBUJPODIVSDI
0/5)&&45"#-*4).&/50'5)&$6-50'4"*/54*.&0/
#BTFEPOUIFQSFTFOUSFTVMUTPGTUVEJFTPGUIFDVMUPGTBJOUT
BOEFTQFDJBMMZPOUIF
DPOUSJCVUJPOTPGUIFTPDBMMFEiOFXIBHJPMPHZu
UIFQSPCMFNPGTBJOUIPPEPG4JNF
PO/FNBOKB
UIFGPVOEFSPGUIFNFEJFWBM4FSCJBOTUBUFBOEUIF/FNBOKJǀEZOBTUZ
JTBEESFTTFEXJUIJOBGSBNFXPSLCSPBEFSJOTDPQFUIBOUIBUDPNNPOTPGBSѮF
GPSNBUJPOPGUIFDVMUJTTUVEJFEJOUIFDPOUFYUPG/FNBOKBTFQPDI
XIJDIDPOTUJ
UVUFTBEJTUJODUTUBHFCPUIJOUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPG&BTUFSO$ISJTUJBODVMUTBOEJO
4FSCJBOJOUFSOBMBĒBJST BU UIF UVSO PG UIF UXFMѫI BOE UIJSUFFOUI DFOUVSJFT
*OBDDPSEBODFXJUIDPOUFNQPSBSZQSBDUJDFTPGUIF#Z[BOUJOFXPSME
UIFDVMU
XBTCVJMUHSBEVBMMZBOEQVSQPTJWFMZ
XJUIBOBXBSFOFTTUIBUUIFJNBHFPGBIPMZ
QFSTPOXBTCBTFEPODFSUBJOFMFNFOUTBOETUSVDUVSFTJOEJDBUFECZIBHJPHSBQIJD
UPQPJCVUBMTPPOUIFBDUJPOTVOEFSUBLFOCZBTBJOUJOIJTMJGFUJNF*UXBTBMPOH
BOE DPNQMFY QSPDFTT XIJDI
BT VTVBM
DPOTJTUFE PG TFWFSBM TUBHFT m JO 4JNFPOT
DBTFIJTUBLJOHPGBNPOLTIBCJUBOEBTDFUJDMJGFPO.PVOU"UIPTIJTEFBUIBOE
UIFêSTU SFWFMBUJPO PG IPMJOFTT JO UIF NPOBTUFSZ PG )JMBOEBS
QPTTJCMZ BDDPNQBOJFE
CZ NZSSIQPVSJOH BT B NBKPS TJHO PG TBJOUIPPE UIF FMFWBUJP PG IJT SFMJDT
UIFJS
USBOTMBUJPUP4FSCJBBOEEFQPTJUJPOBU4UVEFOJDB
4JNFPOTCVSJBMDIVSDIBOEUIF
êSTU EZOBTUJD NBVTPMFVN PG UIF /FNBOKJǀêOBM SFWFMBUJPO PG TBJOUIPPE GPMMPXFE
CZNJSBDMFTDPOêSNJOH IJT IPMJOFTT *O UIF DPVSTF PG UIBU QSPDFTT
IBHJPMPHJDBM
MJUVSHJDBM UFYUT JO UIF TFSWJDF PG UIF DVMU XFSF DSFBUFE HSBEVBMMZ UP SFDFJWF UIFJS
êOBM GPSN JO 4JNFPOTUXPCJPHSBQIJFTBOEFTQFDJBMMZJOUIF4FSWJDFUP4U4JNFPO
]]
)0-:'03&'"5)&34
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
UIFPMPHJDBMFYQMBOBUJPOPGUIJTNJSBDMFBOEUIFNBOOFSPGJUTFĒFDUVBUJPO
JF BO
BQPMPHZPGUIFQJPVTBUUJUVEFBTEFêOFE CZ UIF FYQSFTTJPO QJBGSBVT
*OGVODUJPO
UIFDVMUPG4U4JNFPOXBTBOFMFNFOUPGUIFTUBUFEZOBTUJDQSP
HSBNNFJOUFOEFEUPVOEFSMJOFUIFTBDSBMPSJHJOTPGQPXFSPGUIF/FNBOKJǀѮFSF
GPSF
DISPOPMPHJDBMMZTQFBLJOH
JUIBECFFOGVMMZBOEêOBMMZ GPSNVMBUFE CFGPSF UIF
TUBUF BOE UIF DIVSDI HBJOFE JOEFQFOEFODF ѮF JEFPMPHJDBM NPEFMT FNVMBUFE UP
UIBUFOEBOESFBMJ[FEUISPVHIUIFDVMUmBTJOPUIFSTJNJMBSJOTUBODFTPGGPVOEJOH
NFEJFWBMTUBUFTmBSFBOBMZ[FEIFSFBOEWJFXFEGSPNUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGUXPCBTJD
JEFBTUSBOTMBUJPJNQFSJJBOEUSBOTMBUJP)JFSPTPMZNJѮF NFBOJOH BOE GVODUJPO PG
4UVEFOJDB
BT XFMM BT UIPTF PG UIF PUIFS FBSMZ FOEPXNFOUT PG UIF /FNBOKJǀ
ͪSͰ
BOBMZ[FEJOUIFDPOUFYUPGUIF+FSVTBMFNJEFB*OUIFêSTU EFDBEFT PG UIF UIJSUFFOUI
DFOUVSZUIPTFNPOBTUFSJFTNBVTPMFVNTJOJUJBUFEUIFDSFBUJPOPGBOFXTBDSBMHF
PHSBQIZPG4FSCJBBOE
UISPVHIUIFDVMUTPGIPMZSVMFST
QMBZFEBOFTTFOUJBMSPMF
JOUIFPWFSBMMTPDJBMJOUFHSBUJPOBOEFOMJHIUFONFOUPGUIF4FSCJBONJMJFV
JOUIF
NFEJFWBMTFOTFPGUIBUDPODFQU
5)&3&-*$40'454"7"
ѮF JTTVF PG 4U 4BWBT SFMJDT JT EFBMU XJUI JO UIF OBSSPXFTU TFOTF PG UIF XPSE
BT
B QIFOPNFOPO SFQSFTFOUJOH B EJTUJODU BOE WFSZ JNQPSUBOU BTQFDU PG UIF DVMU PG
TBJOUTѮJT BTQFDU GPSNT QBSU PG UIF PWFSBMM SJUVBM OPU POMZ JO UIF 4FSCJBO CVU BMTP
JOUIFFOUJSF&BTUFSO$ISJTUJBODVMUPGBTBJOUѮJT SFDPOTJEFSBUJPO IBT CFFO JO
TQJSFECZUIFSFTVMUTPGSFDFOUJOWFTUJHBUJPOBUUIF.JMFØFWBNPOBTUFSZ
XIJDIIBT
PQFOFEOFXQPTTJCJMJUJFTPGDIFDLJOHUIFDMBJNTPG4BWBTCJPHSBQIFST%PNFOUJKBO
BOE5FPEPTJKFQFSUBJOJOHUPUIFFTUBCMJTINFOUPGUIFDVMUPGUIFNPTUDFMFCSBUFE
4FSCJBOTBJOU
'SPNUIFBOBMZTJTPG4BWBTCJPHSBQIJFT
USBWFMBDDPVOUTPGBMBUFSEBUFBOEUIF
TVSWJWJOHNBUFSJBMSFNBJOT UPNCTBOETBSDPQIBHJ
TFWFSBMJOGFSFODFTIBWFCFFO
ESBXO'JSTUMZ
UIBU4U4BWBTSFMJDTCFMPOHFEUPUIFDBUFHPSZPGUIFNPTUWFOFSBUFE
UIBUJTDPNQMFUFMZQSFTFSWFE
VODPSSVQUFECPEJFT4FDPOEMZ
UIBUUIFFOUJSFQSP
DFEVSFPGUIFFMFWBUJPBOEUSBOTMBUJPPGUIFSFMJDT
BXFMMFTUBCMJTIFEQBUUFSOJOUIF
#Z[BOUJOFXPSMEBUUIFUJNF
XBTGPMMPXFEJOUIFQSPDFTTPGFTUBCMJTIJOHBTBJOUT
DVMU*O4BWBTDBTF
JUJOWPMWFEUIFFYJTUFODFPGUXPUFNQPSBSZUPNCT
CPUINBSLFE
CZNPOVNFOUBMTBSDPQIBHJ
POFBUUIF$IVSDIPGUIF'PSUZ.BSUZSTBU5JSOPWP
]]
)0-:'03&'"5)&34
XIFSFIFQBTTFEBXBZ
BOEUIFPUIFSJOUIFOPSUIFBTUDPSOFSPGUIFFYPOBSUIFYPG
.JMFØFWB
XIFSFBUPNCGPSIJNXBTQSFQBSFECZUIF4FSCJBOLJOH7MBEJTMBW"ѫFS
UIFUSBOTMBUJPOPGIJTSFMJDT
IJTêOBM SFTUJOH QMBDF XBT
BDDPSEJOH UP UIF FTUBCMJTIFE
QSBDUJDF
BSSBOHFEBTBMBWJTIMZEFDPSBUFETISJOFXIJDIJOBMMQSPCBCJMJUZXBTMP
DBUFEJOUIFFYPOBSUIFYPG.JMFØFWBBTBGSFFTUBOEJOHTUSVDUVSF
ѮF TVCTFRVFOU IJTUPSZ PG 4U 4BWBT SFMJDT JT UPVDIFE VQPO 4VSWJWJOH TPVSDFT
BTXFMMBTNBUFSJBMFWJEFODF
QPJOUUPUIFTUSFOHUIPGUIFDVMUBOEUIFQSBDUJDFPG
QSFTFOUJOHPĒFSJOHT UP IJT TISJOF UISPVHIPVU UIF .JEEMF "HFT BOE JO UIF 0UUPNBO
QFSJPE "O JOUFSFTUJOH IZQPUIFTJT JT QSPQPTFE BOE BSHVNFOUFE
XIJDI IPXFWFS
IBTQSPEVDFEMJUUMFSFTQPOTFJOTDIPMBSMZDJSDMFTTPGBS
OBNFMZ
UIBUOPUBMMPG4BWBT
SFMJDTXFSFCVSOUJO
BQPSUJPOXBTQSFTFSWFEmIJTSJHIUBSN'SPN1JFSSF
-FTDBMPQJFSTSFDPSEPGJUBQQFBSTUIBU4U4BWBTBSNIBECFFOLFQUJOBTQFDJBM
SFMJRVBSZFWFOCFGPSF)FODFUIFOFFEGPSBNPSFUIPSPVHIJOWFTUJHBUJPOPG
UIFSFMJDPGBSJHIUBSN
USBEJUJPOBMMZBUUSJCVUFEUP4U4BWB
BUUIF$IVSDIPGUIF
)PMZ5SJOJUZOFBS1MKFWMKB
5)&.*3"$-&њ803,*/(0'454"7"0'4&3#*"
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
BOE5FPEPTJKF
BTXFMMBTCZUIFBVUIPSTPGTFSWJDFTEFEJDBUFEUPIJN
ѮF XIPMF MJGF PG 4BWB PG 4FSCJB
GSPN IJT DPODFQUJPO BOE CJSUI
BDDFTTJPO UP
NPOLIPPE BOE UISPVHI OVNFSPVT BDUT BOE EFFET
XBT EFTDSJCFE BT B NJSBDMF
GVMM PG PNFOT
XIJDI QSPDFFEFE BDDPSEJOH UP (PET TQFDJBM QMBO )JT QPXFS UP
XPSLNJSBDMFTLFQUNBOJGFTUJOHJUTFMGCPUIJOIJTMJGFUJNFBOEBѫFS IJT EFBUI
BOE
UIFUZQPMPHZPGUIFTFNJSBDMFTPĒFST FMPRVFOU JOGPSNBUJPO BCPVU UIF OBUVSF BOE
GVODUJPOPGIJTDVMUJOUIFHJWFONJMJFVBOEIJTUPSJDBMDPOUFYUѮF SBOHF PG 4BWBT
NJSBDMFTXBTRVJUFXJEFBOECBTFEPOUIFXFMMQSPWFONPEFMTPG#Z[BOUJOFIB
HJPHSBQIZѮVT IF IBE UIF QPXFS UP GPSFUFMM UIF GVUVSF
UP IFBM GSPN B WBSJFUZ PG
JMMOFTTFT
UPESJWFPVUEFNPOT
BOEFWFOUPSBJTFGSPNUIFEFBEѮF MBUUFS QPXFS
UVSOFE PVU UP CF WFSZ JNQPSUBOU
CFDBVTF IF NBOBHFE UP CSJOH CBDL UP MJGF IJT
CSPUIFS
LJOH4UFGBOUIF'JSTU$SPXOFE
GPSBTMPOHBTJUUPPLUPUBLFIJTNPOBTUJD
WPXBOEPQFSBUFBQSPQFSTVDDFTTJPOPOUIFUISPOF4PNFPUIFSPG4BWBTNJSBDMFT
BMTPIBEBEJSFDUTUBUF
EZOBTUJDBOEFWFOQPMJUJDBMGVODUJPOѮVT IF NBEF TLJMGVM
VTFPGIJTQPXFSUPDPOUSPMUIFFMFNFOUTJOPSEFSUPSFJOGPSDFIJTQPTJUJPOJOIJT
OFHPUJBUJPOTXJUIUIF)VOHBSJBOLJOH"iOFHBUJWFNJSBDMFuXBTUIFFMJNJOBUJPOPG
UIFEJTPCFEJFOU#VMHBSJBOMPSE4USF[
XIPIBEDPNQSPNJTFETUBUFJOUFSFTUTѮF
NPTUDPNQMFYPG4BWBTNJSBDMFT
CPUIJOUFSNTPGNFUIPE
UIFPMPHJDBMFYQMJDBUJPO
BOEJUTVMUJNBUFHPBM
IPXFWFS
XBTIJTGBUIFS4U4JNFPOTNZSSISVOOJOHHSBWF*U
XBTUIFDSVDJBMTUFQJODPOTUSVDUJOHUIFJNBHFPGBDIBSJTNBUJD
NJSBDVMPVTQBUSPO
PGTUBUFBOEQFPQMF*OLFFQJOHXJUIUIFUSBEJUJPOBMQBUUFSOTPGTBJOUMZMJWFT
4BWB
PG 4FSCJB XPSLFE B TFSJFT PG QPTUIVNPVT NJSBDMFT
EVSJOH UIF DFSFNPOJFT TVS
SPVOEJOHUIFFMFWBUJP
USBOTMBUJPBOEEFQPTJUJPPGIJTSFMJDT)JTCJPHSBQIFSTTDSV
QVMPVTMZEFTDSJCFEUIFNJSBDVMPVT
IFBMJOHQPXFSTPG4BWBTUXPHSBWFT
BU5JSOPWP
BOE.JMFØFWB
BTXFMMBTUIFPCKFDUTUIBUIBECFFOJODPOUBDUXJUIIJNѮFZ BMTP
FMBCPSBUFEPOFPGUIFGVOEBNFOUBMJEFBTPGUIF/FNBOKJǀSPZBMJEFPMPHZUPHFUIFS
XJUIIJTGBUIFS
BTUIFiTBDSFEUXPu
4BWBXBTFYQFDUFEUPQSPUFDUUIF4FSCJBOMBOET
BOEJOUFSDFEFGPSIJTQFPQMFXJUIJOUIFDIPJSPGTBJOUT
4BWBTJNBHFPGBNJSBDMFXPSLJOHTBJOUDSFBUFECZIJTNFEJFWBMCJPHSBQIFST
XBTGPVOEFEPOUIFJSNBTUFSMZLOPXMFEHFPGUIF0SUIPEPYBOUISPQPMPHZBOEUIF
PMPHZPGNJSBDMFT*UXBTTIBQFEPOUIFJOJUJBUJWFPGUIFSVMJOH
DIVSDIBOETUBUF
FMJUFTBOEVQUPUIFIJHIFTUTUBOEBSETPGJUTUJNF"ѫFS UIF TUBUF MPTU JOEFQFOEFODF
JOUIFêѫFFOUI DFOUVSZ
UIJT JNBHF PG UIF TBJOU CFHBO UP EJTJOUFHSBUF BOE EVSJOH UIF
DFOUVSJFTMPOHQFSJPEPG0UUPNBOSVMFCFDBNFSFEVDFEUPBOFMFNFOUBSZGPMLMPSJD
JEFOUJUZ
]]
)0-:)&*34"/%46''&3&34
5)&$6-50',*/(%3"(65*/ћ.0/,5)&0,5*4504
"TQFDJêD GPSN PG UIF WFOFSBUJPO PG UIF 4FSCJBO LJOH 4UFGBO %SBHVUJO m
n
XIPBTTVNFEUIFIBCJUPGBNPOLVOEFSUIFOBNFPGѮFPLUJTUPT TIPSUMZ
CFGPSFIJTEFBUI
JTEJTDVTTFEIFSFѮF SFTFBSDI JT CBTFE PO UIF BOBMZTJT PG UXP EJG
GFSFOUTPVSDFTUIF-JGFPGLJOH%SBHVUJO
TVSWJWJOHJOUIFIBHJPHSBQIJDDPMMFDUJPO
QFOOFECZUIFBSDICJTIPQ%BOJMP**
BOEUIFEBUBBCPVUIJTUPNCJOUIFNPOBTUFSZ
PG%KVSEKFWJ4UVQPWJ
ѮF BOBMZTJT PG %SBHVUJOT -JGFSFWFBMTUIBUJUTNBJOPCKFDUJWFXBTUIFDSFBUJPO
PGUIFJEFBMDIBSBDUFSPGUIFSVMFSNPOL5PUIBUQVSQPTF
QBUUFSOTPGWBSJPVTPSJ
HJOXFSFFNQMPZFEѮF êSTU QFSJPE PG UIF LJOHT MJGF mCJSUI
ZPVUI BOE UIF UJNF PG
IJTSVMFPWFSBMM4FSCJBOMBOETmXBTEFTDSJCFEXJUIUIFIFMQPGQBUUFSOTUBLFOGSPN
#Z[BOUJOFFODPNJB
DPOKVSJOHVQUIFQJDUVSFPGBQPXFSGVM
KVTUBOEQJPVT(PE
DIPTFOSVMFS*OUIFBDDPVOUPGUIFLJOHTMJGFBѫFS
XIFO %SBHVUJO XBT GPSDFE
UP DFEF UIF UISPOF UP IJT ZPVOHFS CSPUIFS BOE UP MJNJU IJT SVMF UP UIF OPSUIFSO
SFHJPOTPG4FSCJBmUIFTUSVDUVSFPGUIF-JGFCFDPNFTNPSFDPNQMFYѮF QSFWBJM
JOHQBUUFSOTBSFCPSSPXFEGSPNUIFIBHJPHSBQIZBOEUSBEJUJPOBMBTDFUJDMJUFSBUVSF
PGUIF&BTUFSOXPSME"NPOHUIFNPEFMTJUJTQPTTJCMFUPSFDPHOJ[FUIF-JGFPG4U
"OUIPOZCZUIFQBUSJBSDI"UIBOBTJPT
UIFJOTUSVDUJPOTPGUIF-BEEFSPG%JWJOF"T
DFOUCZ+PIO,MJNBY
BOEJOBMMQSPCBCJMJUZTPNFTQFDJêD DPNQPTJUJPOT
TVDI BT
ѮF 8PSE BCPVU UIF &NQFSPS /JLFQIPSPT ** 1IPDBTѮFTF QBUUFSOT BSF FNQMPZFE
JODPOTUSVDUJOHUIFNPOBTUJDDIBSBDUFSPGLJOH%SBHVUJOѮFZ EFTDSJCF JO HSFBU
EFUBJMBMMQSFTDSJCFEGPSNTPGBTDFUJDJTNGSPNPWFSDPNJOHUIFUFNQUBUJPOTPGUIF
ëFTI BOE TQJSJU
UP UIF QSBDUJDF PG BTDFUJD WJSUVFT TVDI BT QFOJUFODF BOE UIF DPOTUBOU
SFNFNCSBODFPGEFBUI
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
4QFDJBMBUUFOUJPOJTHJWFOUPUIFJOUFSQPMBUFEFOEJOHPG%SBHVUJOT-JGFGPSCJE
EJOHUIFPQFOJOHPGUIFLJOHTUPNC*UJTTIPXOUPCFBUPQPT
BMTPCPSSPXFEGSPN
UIFBTDFUJDMJUFSBSZUSBEJUJPO*UTGVODUJPOXBTUPQSFWFOUUIFSFWFMBUJPOPGUIFSFMJDT
UIBUJT
UIFQSPDMBNBUJPOPG%SBHVUJOBTTBJOU4VDIBOJOUFSQSFUBUJPOJTDPOêSNFE
CZUIFDPVSTFPGIJTUPSJDBMFWFOUTmUIFGBDUUIBUUIF4FSCJBOIPMZEZOBTUZDPOUJO
VFEUISPVHIUIFPQQPTJOH
.JMVUJOTCSBODI
ѮF EBUB PCUBJOFE CZ UIF FYBNJOBUJPO PG UIF UPNC PG LJOH %SBHVUJO
XIJDI JT
TJUVBUFEJOUIFNPOBTUFSZPG%KVSEKFWJ4UVQPWJBU4UBSJ3BT
DPOêSN UIF BGPSFNFO
UJPOFEDMBJNGSPNUIF-JGFѮF BOBMZTJT PG UIF BWBJMBCMF TPVSDFT MFBET UP UIF DMFBS
DPODMVTJPOUIBUUIFCBOPOUIFSFWFMBUJPOPGUIFSFMJDTXBTPCTFSWFEѮF LJOHT
CPEZXBTMJѫFE PVU PG UIF UPNC BU UIF FOE PG UIF TFWFOUFFOUI DFOUVSZ BU UIF FBSMJFTU
UISPVHIGPSDFPGDJSDVNTUBODF
BѫFS UIF EFTUSVDUJPO PG UIF NPOBTUFSZ JO "VTUSJBO
5VSLJTIXBSTѮFQSFTFSWFESFNBJOTCFDBNFUIFPCKFDUPGWFOFSBUJPOBTMBUFBTUIF
UVSOPGUIFFJHIUFFOUIBOEOJOFUFFOUIDFOUVSJFT
'JOBMMZ
JU NBZ CF DPODMVEFE UIBU LJOH %SBHVUJOmNPOL ѮFPLUJTUPT EJE OPU
IBWFBDVMUJOJUTGVMMGPSNBOEJOUIFOBSSPXTFOTFPGUIFXPSE"MUIPVHIIFXBT
BDDPSEFEB-JGF
BTFSWJDFUPIJNXBTOFWFSDPNQPTFE
IFXBTOFWFSEFQJDUFEPOBO
JDPO
OPSXBTBDIVSDIEFEJDBUFEUPIJN$POUSBSZUPUIFPUIFSiIPMZLJOHTuGSPN
UIF/FNBOKJǀGBNJMZ
IJTCPEZXBTOPUFNCBMNFEBOEEJTQMBZFEJOBTISJOF0OUIF
PUIFSIBOE
%SBHVUJOFOKPZFEVOEPVCUFESFTQFDU
BTBNFNCFSPGUIFIPMZGBNJMZ
BOEBTPOFPGUIFHSFBUFTUBTDFUJDTBNPOH4FSCJBOSVMFST
5)&)0-:,*/(45&'"/0'%&ƀ"/*
7FOFSBUJPOPGLJOH4UFGBO6SPØ***PG%FǁBOJ m
BSVMFSPGBOVOVTVBM
MJGFNBSLFECZNBOZVQTBOEEPXOT
PGBUSBHJDFOECVUBOFYUSBPSEJOBSZQPTUIV
NPVTFYJTUFODF
JTPOFPGUIFNPTUDPNQMFYEFWFMPQNFOUTJOUIFDVMUJDQSBDUJDFPG
NFEJFWBM4FSCJB/PUPOMZXBTIJTTBJOUMZJNBHFCVJMUJOTUBHFT
PWFSBMPOHQFSJPE
PGUJNF
CVUJUDPOTJEFSBCMZDIBOHFEDIBSBDUFSBOEGFBUVSFTJOUIFQSPDFTTѮFTF
iJEFOUJUZuDIBOHFTXFSFEJSFDUMZEFUFSNJOFECZUIFDIBOHJOHIJTUPSJDBMBOEQPMJUJ
DBMDJSDVNTUBODFT
BTXFMMBTCZUIFQFSTPOBMNPUJWBUJPOTPGDFSUBJOIJTUPSJDBMQSP
UBHPOJTUTѮF DVMU PG 4UFGBO PG %FǁBOJNBZUIFSFGPSFCFDPOTJEFSFEBTJHOJêDBOU
FYBNQMFPGUIFQIFOPNFOPOEFTDSJCFECZSFTFBSDIFSTBTUIFiNBLJOHPGBTBJOUu
]]
)0-:)&*34"/%46''&3&34
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
5)&,5&5030'.03"ƀ""/%)*4$6-5
]]
)0-:)&*34"/%46''&3&34
4PVSDFTEBUJOHUP4UFGBOTUJNFTBSFRVJUFTDBOUZ#BTJDJOGPSNBUJPOJTQSPWJEFE
CZUIFLUFUPSTJOTDSJQUJPODBSWFEBCPWFUIFQPSUBMPGUIF$IVSDIPGUIF%PSNJUJPO
PG UIF 7JSHJO BU .PSBǁB EBUJOH UP *U NBLFT OP NFOUJPO PG 4UFGBOT UJUMF
JEFOUJGZJOHIJNJOTUFBEBTUIFTPOPGHSBOELOF[7VLBOBOEHSBOETPOPG4U4JNF
PO/FNBOKB*OUIFBCTFODFPGXSJUUFOFWJEFODF
GPSNPSFDPNQSFIFOTJWFVOEFS
TUBOEJOHPG4UFGBOTJNBHFBOETUBUVTPOFNBZSFMZPOUIFEFTJHOPGIJTCVSJBMQMBDF
BTXFMMBTPODFSUBJOJDPOPHSBQIJDBMFMFNFOUTJOUIFQBJOUFEQSPHSBNNF4UFGBOT
UPNCFOUJSFMZDPOGPSNTUPUIFGVOFSBSZQSBDUJDFPGUIF/FNBOKJǀ*UDPNQSJTFTB
NPOVNFOUBMNBSCMFTBSDPQIBHVTBOEUIFLUFUPSTGVOFSBSZQPSUSBJUTIPXJOH4UFGBO
XJUIBNPEFMPGIJTDIVSDIJOIBOETCFJOHMFECZUIF7JSHJOUPFOUISPOFE$ISJTU
"MUIPVHIUIFXBMMQBJOUJOHTJOUIFOBWFBDUVBMMZSFTVMUGSPNUIFSFOPWBUJPO
UIFSFBSFêSN HSPVOET UP CFMJFWF UIBU UIF LUFUPSTQPSUSBJUCBTJDBMMZSFQSPEVDFTUIF
PSJHJOBMUIJSUFFODFOUVSZPOFѮF TBNF BQQBSFOUMZ HPFT GPS 4UFGBOT QPSUSBJU BT B
NPOL
QBJOUFEJOUIFOBSUIFYJOѮJT XPVME NFBO UIBU 4UFGBO CFDBNF B
NPOLBUBOBEWBODFEBHF"OPCWJPVTSFëFDUJPO PG UIF PSJHJOBM QBJOUJOH JT BMTP
BTFSJFTPGNFEBMMJPOTPOUIFXFTUFSOOBWFXBMM
JOUFSMJOLFECZNPOPHSBNTSFBE
JOHiLOF[4UFGBOPTuѮJT QSPWJEFT JNQPSUBOU FWJEFODF GPS UIF USVF UJUMF PG 4UFGBO
7VLBOPWJǀ$JSDVNTUBOUJBMFWJEFODFGPSUIJTUJUMFJTQSPWJEFECZIJTJODMVTJPOJOUP
UIF QBJOUFE 5SFF PG UIF /FNBOKJǀ
XIFSF IJT UJUMF JT DPOTJTUFOUMZ iLOF[u 4UFGBOT
QSFTFODFJOUIFEZOBTUJDHFOFBMPHJDBMUSFFTTIPXTUIBUIFXBTSFHBSEFEBTCFJOHB
EJTUJOHVJTIFEBOEMPZBMSFMBUJWFPGUIFSVMJOHGBNJMZ
*OUIFDFOUVSJFTUPDPNFUIFNFNPSZPG4UFGBOXBTQSFTFSWFEJOXSJUJOHTTVDI
BTHFOFBMPHJFTBOEBOOBMT)FJTEFTDSJCFEUIFSFBTBLOF[BOEUIFLUFUPSPG.PSBǁB
BOE IJT SFMJDT SFGFSSFE UP BT IPMZ GPS UIF êSTU UJNF " OFX BOE DSVDJBM TUBHF JO
4UFGBOTWFOFSBUJPOJTBTTPDJBUFEXJUISFGVSCJTINFOUTUPUIFNPOBTUFSZPG.PSBǁB
JOUIFT)JTNBSCMFTBSDPQIBHVTXBTSFTUPSFEBOE
JO
IJTQPSUSBJUBCPWF
JUSFQSPEVDFEѮF PSJHJOBM LUFUPSTQPSUSBJUUIFOHPUDPNQBOZPGUIFNPOBTUFSZT
OFX DPOUSJCVUPST
IFHVNFO 5PNB BOE LOF[ 7VLJǀ 7VǁFUJǀ $FSUBJOMZ UIF NBKPS
OPWFMUZXBT4UFGBOTSPZBMUJUMF*OIJTTJYUFFOUIDFOUVSZQPSUSBJUT
UIFLUFUPSTPOF
JOUIFOBWFBOEUIFNPOBTUJDJOUIFOBSUIFY
IFXBTJEFOUJêFE BT iLJOH 4UFGBOu GPS
UIFêSTU UJNF
)JTXPSTIJQUPPLPOJUTTVQSFNFGPSNTJOUIFOFYU
TFWFOUFFOUI
DFOUVSZ*O
UIFMJUUMF$IVSDIPG4U/JDIPMBT
GSFTDPFEJO
IFXBTQPSUSBZFEPODFNPSF
UIJTUJNFBTiLJOH4UFGBOu0OMZUISFFZFBSTMBUFS
JOIJTQPSUSBJUJOUIFDIBQFMPG
4U4UFQIFOT
UIFDSVDJBMTUFQXBTUBLFOCZEFTDSJCJOHUIFLUFUPSPG.PSBǁBBTUIF
iIPMZLJOH4UFGBOuGPSUIFêSTU UJNF ѮF TBNF UJUMF PDDVSSFE JO IJT JDPOQBJOUFE
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
QPSUSBJUT BOE JO XSJUUFO EPDVNFOUT )JT SFMJDT BMTP CFDBNF SFGFSSFE UP BT IPMZ
ѮFTF GBDUT UFTUJGZ UP UIF QSPDFTT PG FTUBCMJTIJOH B DVMU *U XBT MPDBM JO DIBSBDUFS BOE
POMZQBSUJBMMZTIBQFEDPOTJEFSJOHUIBU4UFGBOXBTOFWFSHJWFOBWJUBPSBTFSWJDF
ѮF DFOUSF PG IJT DVMU XBT IJT HSBWF BU .PSBǁB
DPNQMFUFMZSFNPEFMMFEJOUIFT
0OUIFNBSCMFTBSDPQIBHVTXBTMBJEBNPOVNFOUBMJDPOTIPXJOH4UT4JNFPOBOE
4BWBBTXFMMBTTDFOFTGSPN4BWBTMJGFѮVT UIF FBSMJFS LUFUPSJBM DPNQPTJUJPO
XJUI
JUTNFTTBHFBCPVUUIFSFEFNQUJWFTJHOJêDBODF PG CFOFGBDUJPO
XBT FDMJQTFE CPUI
MJUFSBMMZBOETZNCPMJDBMMZѮF FNQIBTJT TIJѫFE UP UIF LUFUPSTDMPTFSFMBUJPOUPUIF
GPVOEFSTPGUIFIPMZEZOBTUZѮF BQQFBSBODF PG UIJT GVOFSBSZ XIPMF JT SFNJOJTDFOU
PG$BUIPMJDTJEFBMUBST
BOPUIFSJOUFSFTUJOHOPWFMUZJOEFWPUJPOBMQSBDUJDFTPGUIF
4FSCTѮF DSFBUJPO BOE SJTF PG 4UFGBOT DVMU TIPVME CF JOUFSQSFUFE JO UIF DPOUFYU
PGBTQFDJêD TJUVBUJPO XJUIJO UIF 4FSCJBO DIVSDI BOE
QBSUJDVMBSMZ
PG UIF HSPXJOH
BNCJUJPOT PG UIF .PSBǁB CSPUIFSIPPE *U XBT UIFN UIBU QMBZFE UIF MFBEJOH SPMF
JOVOJPOOFHPUJBUJPOTXJUI3PNFUIF4FSCJBODIVSDIXBTGPSDFEJOUPJOUIFNJE
TFWFOUFFOUIDFOUVSZ
BOEUIFZPCWJPVTMZUSJFEUPTFDVSFQSJWJMFHFETUBUVTGPSUIFJS
NPOBTUFSZ
ѮBU 4UFGBOT DVMU DPOUJOVFE JOUP UIF FJHIUFFOUI DFOUVSZ JT DPOêSNFE CZ SBSF
CVUWBMVBCMFEPDVNFOUTѮPTF GSPN UIF OJOFUFFOUI DFOUVSZ
IPXFWFS
SFWFBM UIBU
IJTJEFOUJUZBTTVNFEGPMLMPSJDGFBUVSFTѮF WFOFSBUJPO PG 4UFGBO BT B iIPMZLJOHu
IBTSFNBJOFEBMBTUJOHBDIJFWFNFOU
BOEIJTNBKPSCFOFGBDUJPOmUIFFSFDUJPOPG
UIFNPOBTUFSZPG.PSBǁB
]]
3&-*$4"/%30:"-*%&0-0(:
5)&4"$3"&3&-*26*"&0'5)&$)63$)0'5)&4"7*063"5Â*ƀ"
5)&'06/%"5*0/DIBSUFSHSBOUFEUPUIF$IVSDIPGUIF4BWJPVSBUÂJǁBJO
CFHJOTCZJUFNJ[JOHUIFHJѫT CFTUPXFE PO JU CZ LJOH 4UFGBO UIF 'JSTU $SPXOFE
BU
UIFUPQPGUIJTMJTUCFJOHUIFSFMJDTUIF5SVF$SPTT
UIFSFMJDTPG$ISJTUT1BTTJPO
UIF7JSHJOTSPCFBOECFMU
+PIOUIF#BQUJTUTSJHIUIBOEBOETLVMM
BTXFMMBTSFMJDT
PGUIFBQPTUMFT
NBSUZSTBOEPUIFSTBJOUTѮJT VOJRVF HJѫ JO UIF IJTUPSZ PG 4FSCJBO
EPOBUJPOQSBDUJDFXBTBQSPHSBNNBUJDBDU
HJWFOUIBUJUXBTNFBOUGPSBDIVSDI
JOUFOEFEBTUIFDPSPOBUJPODIVSDIBOETFFPGUIFJOEFQFOEFOU4FSCJBOBSDICJTI
PQSJD
"UUIFUVSOPGUIFUXFMѫI BOE UIJSUFFOUI DFOUVSJFT UIF 4FSCJBO NJMJFV XBT XFMM
BDRVBJOUFEXJUIUIFTJHOJêDBODF BOE GVODUJPO PG SFMJDT JO UIF $ISJTUJBO XPSME
BT
SFMJBCMZFWJEFODFECZXSJUUFOTPVSDFT#VUJUXBTBUÂJǁBUIBUBOFWFOUDSJUJDBMUP
UIFEFWFMPQNFOUPGUIFDVMUPGSFMJDTUPPLQMBDF
BOEUISPVHIUIFFĒPSU PG 4BWB
UIFLJOHTCSPUIFSBOEêSTU 4FSCJBO BSDICJTIPQ *U XBT IJN UIBU CSPVHIU NPTU PG
UIFSFMJDTGSPNIJTKPVSOFZUP/JDBFB
XIFSFIFIBETFDVSFEJOEFQFOEFOU
TUBUVTGPSUIF4FSCJBODIVSDI*OUIBUXBZIFQBSUJDJQBUFEBDUJWFMZJOBSFEJTUSJCV
UJPOPG$ISJTUJBOSFMJDT
UIFNBKPSJUZPGXIJDIIBEFOEFEJOUIF8FTUBѫFS UIF GBMM
PG$POTUBOUJOPQMF
ѮF PSJHJOBM DPOUFOU PG UIF ÂJǁBUSFBTVSFDPNQSJTFESFMJDTPGUIFIJHIFTUSBOL
JOH êHVSFT GSPN UIF DFMFTUJBM IJFSBSDIZ
BU UIF UJNF SFHBSEFE BT CFJOH UIF NPTU
QSFDJPVTPGBMM$ISJTUJBOSFMJDT4PNFNPSFSFDFOUSFTFBSDIIBTEFNPOTUSBUFEUIBU
BTTFNCMFEJOPOFQMBDF
UIFSFMJDTPGUIBUPSEFSIBEBNVMUJQMFBOEDPNQMFYNFBO
JOHѮVT UIFJS XFMMUIPVHIUPVU TFMFDUJPO BOE QSFTFOUBUJPO BU ÂJǁBDPNNVOJDBUFE
BOFYUFOTJWFQSPHSBNNFPGUIFFDPOPNZPGTBMWBUJPO
XJUIJUTQSJODJQBMEPHNBUJD
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
BOEiIJTUPSJDBMuTUBHFTmUIFJODBSOBUJPOBOECBQUJTN
QBTTJPOBOESFTVSSFDUJPO
ѮF BQPTUMFT SFMJDT XFSF JO UIF TFSWJDF PG UIF DPODFQU PG BQPTUPMJD TVDDFTTJPO
UIFSFCZDPOWFZJOHJNQPSUBOUFDDMFTJPMPHJDBMNFTTBHFT/VNFSPVTBOBMPHJFTGSPN
UIF$ISJTUJBOXPSME
&BTUBOE8FTUmUIFNPTUQSPNJOFOUQMBDFCFJOHIFMECZUIF
*NQFSJBM$IBQFMJO$POTUBOUJOPQMFmDPOêSN UIBU UIF ÂJǁBSFMJDTBMTPFWPLFEUIF
JEFBPG+FSVTBMFNBOEPUIFSTJUFTGSPNCJCMJDBMIJTUPSZ%JTQMBZFEJOBDIVSDI
UIFZ
DSFBUFEBEJTUJODUTBDSFETQBDF
BTZNCPMJDBMTVCTUJUVUFGPSUIF)PMZ-BOE
NBLJOH
JUQPTTJCMFGPSUIFCFMJFWFSTUPQBZJUBTZNCPMJDBM
FNQBUIJDWJTJU
(JWFOUIBUUIF$IVSDIPGUIF4BWJPVSBUÂJǁBXBTBSPZBMGPVOEBUJPOBOEDPSP
OBUJPODIVSDI
JUTFFNTWFSZMJLFMZUIBUUIFSFMJDTmBCPWFBMMUIPTFPGUIF5SVF$SPTT
BOE$ISJTUT1BTTJPOmCFMPOHFEUPUIFTQIFSFPGTUBUFTZNCPMJTN4VDIQIFOPN
FOPO JT XFMM LOPXO JO NFEJFWBM TUBUFT PG 8FTUFSO &VSPQF
XIFSF DFSUBJO SFMJDT
GVODUJPOFEBTUIFJOTJHOJBPGSPZBMQPXFSѮJT NBZ IBWF CFFO UIF DBTF JO 4FSCJB
BTXFMM
FTQFDJBMMZCFDBVTFUIFSPZBMJEFPMPHZPGUIF/FNBOKJǀJTLOPXOUPIBWF
CFFODMPTFSUPXFTUFSOUIBOFBTUFSONPEFMTJOUIFFBSMZUIJSUFFOUIDFOUVSZѮJT JT
SFëFDUFE
JOUFSBMJB
JOUIFGBDUUIBUJO4FSCJBUIFTUBUVTPGJOTJHOJBXBTFOKPZFECZ
UIFQFDUPSBMBOETQFBSPGUIFGPVOEFSPGUIFEZOBTUZ
4UFGBO/FNBOKB
BTXFMMBTCZ
UIFDSPXOPG4UFGBOUIF'JSTU$SPXOFEѮFJS JEFBM QSPUPUZQF NBZ IBWF CFFO UIF
JOTJHOJBPG$ISJTU
UIBUJT
UIFSFMJDTPGIJTQBTTJPOEJTQMBZFEBUÂJǁB
0GUIFPSJHJOBMÂJǁBUSFBTVSFPOMZIBTUIF#BQUJTUTSJHIUIBOETVSWJWFE
XJUI
BO JOTDSJQUJPO SFGFSSJOH UP UIF êSTU 4FSCJBO BSDICJTIPQ 4BWB *U JT OPX JO 4JFOB
DBUIFESBM
XIJMFUIFGBUFPGPUIFSÂJǁBSFMJDTJTWJSUVBMMZVOLOPXO:FU
NPSFSFDFOU
SFTFBSDIJOUPUIF$IVSDIPGUIF4BWJPVSIBTDPNFVQXJUIJNQPSUBOUJOGPSNBUJPO
BCPVUTPNFFTTFOUJBMBTQFDUTPGUIFPSJHJOBMSFMJDQSPHSBNNF*UIBTTIPXOUIBU
UIFDIVSDIJOUFSJPSXBTFRVJQQFEXJUIDFSFNPOJBMTUPOFGVSOJUVSFJOUIFGPSNPG
QSPTLZOJUBSJBëBOLJOH UIF BMUBS TDSFFO ѮFSF BSF HPPE SFBTPOT UP BTTVNF UIBU UIFZ
TFSWFEGPSUIFEJTQMBZPGUIFSFMJDT
4U4BWBPG4FSCJB
UIFUSVFBSDIJUFDUPGUIFCVJMEJOH
GSFTDPBOESFMJDQSPHSBNNF
GPSÂJǁB
SPVOEFEPĒ IJT QSPKFDU BOE UPPL JU UP JUT DVMNJOBUJPO CZ IBWJOH UIF SFMJDT
PG4UFGBOUIF'JSTU$SPXOFEUSBOTMBUFEUPÂJǁB
XIFSFUIFZKPJOFEUIFNPTUSFWFSFE
VOJWFSTBMSFMJDT'SPNUIBUNPNFOUPOXBSET
BTJOPUIFSTUBUFTPG&VSPQF
UIF4FS
CJBOSVMFSTXFSFDSPXOFEJOUIFQSFTFODFPGUIFJSêSTU LJOHTIPMZCPEZ0ODFBU
ÂJǁB
UIFSFMJDTPGLJOH4UFGBOBTTVNFEUIFTUBUVTPGBOBUJPOBMSFMJDѮFJS JODMVTJPO
JOUP BO BMM$ISJTUJBO DPOUFYU DPOWFZFE BO JNQPSUBOU NFTTBHF
OBNFMZ
UIBU UIF
4FSCTIBECFDPNFMFHJUJNBUFQBSUJDJQBOUTJO4BDSFE)JTUPSZBOEIFODFJOUIFDVS
SFOUIJFSBSDIZPGOBUJPOT
]]
3&-*$4"/%30:"-*%&0-0(:
4&3#*"/30:"-53"/4-"5*0"45)&53*6.1)"-"%7&/564
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
3&-*$4"/%10-*5*$4*/.&%*&7"-4&3#*"
"TFMTFXIFSFJOUIF$ISJTUJBOXPSME
UIFDVMUPGSFMJDTJONFEJFWBM4FSCJBXBTQPMZ
WBMFOUJOJUTGVODUJPO*OBEEJUJPOUPUIFJSCBTJDSPMF
SFMJHJPVTBOETQJSJUVBM
SFMJDT
DPVMEQMBZBOJNQPSUBOUQPMJUJDBMPOF*OBOBMZ[JOHUIJTQSPCMFN
XFIBWFBEPQUFE
BTCPUICSPBEBOEQSFDJTFFOPVHI
UIFNFUIPEPMPHJDBMTUBSUJOHQPJOUPG+1FUFS
TPIO BT FYQPVOEFE JO UIF DPMMFDUJPO PG XPSLT 1PMJUJL VOE )FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH JN
)PDINJUUFMBMUFSSFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFOQPMJUJDTBOEDVMUTIPVMECFTUVEJFEBTBIJT
UPSJDBMQIFOPNFOPO
BOEUIFDVMUPGBTBJOUBOEIJTPSIFSSFMJDTNBZCFSFHBSEFEBT
IBWJOHCFFOiQPMJUJDBMuJOTPGBSBTTVDIXFSFUIFSFBTPOTUIBUMFEUPJUTFNFSHFODF
UIFQVSQPTFTJUTFSWFEBOEUIFNFTTBHFTJUDPNNVOJDBUFE
ѮF EFWFMPQNFOU PG JEFPMPHJDBMMZ GPVOEFE SFMJD QSPHSBNNFT JO NFEJFWBM 4FS
CJBDPJODJEFTXJUIUIFTUSVHHMFGPSJOEFQFOEFODFVOEFSUIF/FNBOKJǀEZOBTUZBU
UIFUVSOPGUIFUXFMѫI BOE UIJSUFFOUI DFOUVSJFT ѮFJS BSDIJUFDU XBT 4U 4BWB
HSBOE
ßVQBO/FNBOKBTZPVOHFTUTPOBOEêSTU BSDICJTIPQ PG UIF 4FSCJBO BVUPDFQIBMPVT
DIVSDIѮF DVMU PG SFMJDT GPVOE UXP CBTJD GPSNT PG FYQSFTTJPO BT WFOFSBUJPO PG
BMM$ISJTUJBOSFMJDT
BTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIFNPTUQSPNJOFOUêHVSFT PG UIF DFMFTUJBM IJ
FSBSDIZ
BOEBTWFOFSBUJPOPGUIFSFMJDTPGUIFOBUJPOBMIPMZSVMFST
"TGBSBTUIFêSTU GPSN JT DPODFSOFE
B QBSUJDVMBS EZOBTUJD BOE QPMJUJDBM GVOD
UJPOPGUIFDVMUPGUIF5SVF$SPTTTIPVMECFOPUFE8SJUUFOTPVSDFTQSPWJEFFWJ
EFODFGPSUIFSPMFPG/FNBOKBTQFDUPSBMDPOUBJOJOHBQJFDFPGUIJTNPTUSFWFSFE
SFMJD*UXBTUIFEZOBTUJDWFYJMMJVNBOEBIFSFEJUBSZSPZBMFNCMFN
TZNCPMPGUIF
EZOBTUZTMFHJUJNBDZ/PUBUBMMCZDIBODF
UIFSFMJDXBTLFQUBU4UVEFOJDB
UIFEZ
OBTUJDNBVTPMFVNPGUIFêSTU UXP HFOFSBUJPOT PG UIF /FNBOKJǀ
*O UIF FBSMZ UIJSUFFOUI DFOUVSZ
PXJOH UP 4U 4BWB BOE IJT CSPUIFS 4UFGBO UIF
'JSTU$SPXOFE
4FSCJBTêSTU DSPXOFE LJOH
B MBSHFTDBMF SFMJD QSPHSBNNF XBT DBS
SJFEPVUBUÂJǁB
UIFDBUIFESBMBOEDPSPOBUJPODIVSDI5BLJOHBEWBOUBHFPGBCVTZ
SFMJDUSBēD GPMMPXJOH UIF GBMM PG $POTUBOUJOPQMF JO
4BWB DBNF JOUP QPTTFT
TJPOPGTPNFNPTUQSFDJPVT$ISJTUJBOSFMJDTBQJFDFPGUIF5SVF$SPTT
BSFMJDPG
UIF1BTTJPO
GSBHNFOUTPGUIF7JSHJOTSPCFBOECFMU
+PIOUIF#BQUJTUTSJHIUIBOE
BOEBQJFDFPGIJTTLVMM
BTXFMMBTUIFSFMJDTPGUIFBQPTUMFT
QSPQIFUTBOENBSUZST
ѮJT DPMMFDUJPO JT RVJUF TJNJMBS UP UIF DPOUFOUT PG PUIFS SPZBM USFBTVSJFT JO &VSPQF
XIPTFDPNNPOQSPUPUZQFXBTUIF7JSHJOPG1IBSPTJO$POTUBOUJOPQMF3FTFBSDI
IBTTIPXOUIBUUIFTFIPMJFTUPGSFMJDTBTTFNCMFEJOBQMBDFFOKPZJOHUIFTUBUVTPG
BMPDVTSFHBMJTDPOWFZFEUIFFYQMJDJUJEFBPG+FSVTBMFNBOEUIF)PMZ-BOE
UIFSFCZ
QSPWJEJOHTZNCPMJDBMTVQQPSUUPUIFNPTUTBDSFEQMBDFTJO$ISJTUJBOTBDSBMUPQPH
]]
3&-*$4"/%30:"-*%&0-0(:
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
5)&3&-*$40'451&5,"(-03*"#6-("3*"&ћ(-03*"4&37*"&
4U1FULBIBTSBOLFEBNPOHUIFNPTUQPQVMBS#BMLBOGFNBMFTBJOUTGPSDFOUVSJFT
)FS WFOFSBUJPO JT OPU POMZ POF PG UIF NPTU DPNQMFY QIFOPNFOB JO UIF #BMLBO
QFPQMFTDVMUJDQSBDUJDFT
CVUJUBMTPNBZTFSWFBTBNFUBQIPS GPSUIFJSESBNBUJD
IJTUPSJDBMEFTUJOZѮF QBSUJDVMBS DBTF PG 4U 1FULBT SFMJDT JT WJFXFE IFSF GSPN UIF
QFSTQFDUJWFPGSFMJDXPSTIJQBOE
FTQFDJBMMZGVODUJPO
XJUIUIFBJNUPJEFOUJGZUIF
GFBUVSFTTQFDJêD UP UIF #VMHBSJBO BOE 4FSCJBO BUUJUVEF SFTQFDUJWFMZ
1FULBPG&QJWBU
BѮSBDJBO TBJOU MJWJOH JO UIF TFDPOE IBMG PG UIF UFOUI DFOUVSZ
DBNFUPCFSFWFSFEGPSIFSBTDFUJDJTN"ѫFS IFS EFBUI
IFS SFMJDT XFSF BOOPVODFE
BOEUSBOTMBUFEUPUIF$IVSDIPGUIF)PMZ"QPTUMFTBU,BMJLSBUJB)FSêSTU
QPQVMBS
WJUBFWFSXSJUUFOXBTCVSOUJOUIFUXFMѫI DFOUVSZ BOE SFQMBDFE CZ B DBOPOJDBM POF
DPOGPSNFEUPUIFTUBOEBSEUPQJDTPG#Z[BOUJOFIBHJPHSBQIZ'PSUIFTBJOUTXPS
TIJQ
BTFSWJDFUPIFSXBTBMTPDPNQPTFE
]]
3&-*$4"/%30:"-*%&0-0(:
ѮFTF XSJUJOHT XFSF USBOTMBUFE JOUP #VMHBSJBO VOEFS *WBO "TFO **
XIFO UIF
WFOFSBUJPOPG4U1FULBJOUIBUDPVOUSZCFDBNFFMFNFOUPGIJHIMFWFMQPMJDJFTPGUIF
TUBUF'PSJOUIFUSBOTMBUJPOPG4U1FULBTSFMJDTUP5JSOPWPUPPLQMBDFBTQBSU
PGUIFFYUFOTJWFQSPKFDUPGSFOPWBUJPJNQFSJJ#VMHBSPSVNFU(SBFDPSVNVOEFSUBLFO
CZUIF"TFOEZOBTUZBѫFS UIF WJDUPSZ BU ,MPLPUOJDB ѮVT UIFZ KPJOFE UIF PUIFS
QSFWJPVTMZ USBOTMBUFE
SFMJDT XIPTFGVODUJPOXBTUIBUPGUIFIFBWFOMZQBUSPOTPG
UIF#VMHBSJBODBQJUBMѮF WFSZ FWFOU PG USBOTMBUJPO
PSHBOJ[FE BT B TPMFNO BEWFO
UVTSFMJRVJBSVN
XBTUIFOEFTDSJCFEJOGSFTIMZXSJUUFO
#VMHBSJBO
UFYUT0ODFJO
5JSOPWP
UIFSFMJDTXFSFVOEFSSPZBMQBUSPOBHFѮF TBJOUT DVMU XBT BU JUT QFBL JO
UIFTFDPOEIBMGPGUIFGPVSUFFOUIDFOUVSZ
XIFOUIFJMMVTUSJPVTXSJUFSBOEQBUSJBSDI
&VUIZNJVTQFOOFEIFSMJGFBOETFSWJDFѮFTF XSJUJOHT MBJE FNQIBTJT VQPO IFS BT
DFUJDEJTDJQMJOF
VOEPVCUFEMZBDFOUSBMJEFBMBUUIFUJNFѮF TBJOUT SFMJDT BTTVNFE
OFXBUUSJCVUFT
JODMVEJOHNJMJUBSZ
JOSFTQPOTFUPUIFDVSSFOUTJUVBUJPOmUIF5VSL
JTI BEWBODF JOUP UIF #BMLBOT ѮFSFGPSF UIF DPēO DPOUBJOJOH IFS SFMJDT CFDBNF
UIFEPNJOBOUUIFNFJOUIFIZNOPHSBQIJDXPSLTEFEJDBUFEUPIFS
BOEPCWJPVTMZ
JUBMTPQSPWJEFEBGPDVTGPSQVCMJDHBUIFSJOH"TUIFMBTUSFTPSU
UIFTBJOUXBTDBMMFE
VQPOUPEFGFOEIFSDJUZ
BGVUJMFBUUFNQU
BMBT
BTFWJEFODFECZUIFGBMMPG5JSOPWPJO
/PSDPVMEIFSSFMJDTTBWF7JEJO
UIFMBTUJOEFQFOEFOUQPMJUZ
XIFSFUIFZIBE
CFFOUSBOTGFSSFEJO
ѮF 4FSCJBO QIBTF JO UIF IJTUPSZ PG IFS SFMJDT CFHBO JO
JO UIF EJēDVMU
UJNFTQSFDFEJOHUIFMPTTPGJOEFQFOEFODF(JWFOUIBU4FSCJBXBTJOVSHFOUOFFE
PGTBJOUMZQBUSPOT
QSJODFTT.JMJDB
NPUIFSPGUIFDVSSFOUSVMFS4UFGBO-B[BSFWJǀ
WJTJUFE7JEJOBOENBOBHFEUPPCUBJOQPTTFTTJPOPGUIFQSFDJPVTSFMJDT1FULBTSFMJDT
IBE CFFO USBOTMBUFE UP UIF QBMBUJOF DIVSDI BU ,SVØFWBD -B[BSJDB
BOE UIF TPM
FNOFWFOUXBTEFTDSJCFEJOUIF0SBUJPOPG(SFHPSZ$BNCMBL)FVOEFSTDPSFEUIF
VMUJNBUFQVSQPTFPGUIFBDUUIFSFMJDTXFSFFYQFDUFEUPQSPUFDUUIF4FSCJBOTUBUF
BHBJOTUUIFiPODPNJOHBUUBDLTu4PNFUJNFJOUIFêSTU EFDBEF PG UIF êѫFFOUI DFO
UVSZ
UIFSFMJDTXFSFUSBOTMBUFEUP#FMHSBEFѮF OFX 4FSCJBO DBQJUBM
DPODFJWFE BOE
EFTJHOFECZEFTQPU4UFGBO
IBEJUTPXOTBJOUMZQBUSPOTѮF QSFDJPVT SFMJDT
JODMVE
JOH4U1FULBT
BQQFBSUPIBWFCFFOEFQPTJUFEJOUIFNFUSPQPMJUBO$IVSDIPGUIF
%PSNJUJPOPGUIF7JSHJO
XIFSFUIFJSQSFTFODFGSPNIBTCFFOEPDVNFOUFE
'PSIFSXPSTIJQ
BTPQIJTUJDBUFEEFWJDFXBTNPVOUFEDPNQSJTJOHBGPVOUBJOBOEB
DJTUFSO
XIJDITVQQMJFEUIFXBUFSDPOTFDSBUFEUISPVHIDPOUBDUXJUIIFSSFMJDT
ѮF DVMU PG IFS SFMJDT TFFNT UP IBWF EFDMJOFE BѫFS UIF GBMM PG #FMHSBEF JO
1FSIBQTPOMZUPPBXBSFUIBUGPVS#BMLBODBQJUBMTVOEFS4U1FULBTQSPUFDUJPOIBE
GBMMFOPOFBѫFS BOPUIFS
UIF MBTU 4FSCJBO SVMFS
EFTQPU %KVSBEK #SBOLPWJǀ
DIPTF
]]
%"/*$"10107*ſ
6/%&35)&"641*$&40'4"/$5*5:
BOPUIFSQBUSPOGPSIJTTUBUF*UXBT4U-VLF
XIPTFSFMJDTXFSFHJWFOBNBHOJêDFOU
BEWFOUVT BU 4NFEFSFWP ѮF TUPSZ PG 1FULBT SFMJDT EJE OPU FOE OFWFSUIFMFTT "M
UIPVHIOPUUIFTPVSDFPGTUBUFCVJMEJOHHMPSJBBOZNPSF
UIFZDPOUJOVFEUIFJSUPVS
PGUIF#BMLBODBQJUBMT
CFJOHUSBOTMBUFEUP$POTUBOUJOPQMFJOBOE+BǨJJO
4U1FULBIBTPVUMJWFEUIF.JEEMF"HFTBOESFTUPSFEIFSTUSFOHUI
UIJTUJNFXJUIB
GPMLMPSJDJEFOUJUZBOEJOUIFDPOUFYUPGQPQVMBSQJFUZ
5)&3&-*$40'45-6,&ћ5)&4&3#*"/&1*40%&
*OUIFDPVSTFPGUIFJSMPOHIJTUPSZUIFSFMJDTPG4U-VLFIBEB4FSCJBOFQJTPEF"M
UIPVHICSJFG
UIFJSTPKPVSOJO4FSCJB m
JTJNQPSUBOUJONPSFUIBOPOF
XBZ0OUIFPOFIBOE
JUPĒFST B XFBMUI PG JOGPSNBUJPO SFMFWBOU UP UIF TUVEZ PG UIF
MBUFNFEJFWBMDVMUPGSFMJDTBOE
POUIFPUIFS
JUDPOUSJCVUFTUPBCFUUFSVOEFSTUBOE
JOHPG4FSCJBTTPDJBMBOEQPMJUJDBMTJUVBUJPOJOUIFMBTUEBZTPGJUTJOEFQFOEFODF
ѮF BDRVJTJUJPO PG 4U -VLFT SFMJDT XBT EFTQPU %KVSBEK #SBOLPWJǀTQFSTPOBMJOJUJB
UJWFBJNFEBUQSPWJEJOHBOFēDJFOU IFBWFOMZ QSPUFDUPS GPS IJT TUBUF JNQFSJMMFE CZ
UIFBEWBODJOH0UUPNBOT*OUIBUVOEFSUBLJOH
UIFEFTQPUIBEBEJSFDUNPEFM
UIF
SFMJDTPG4U1FULBIBWJOHCFFOUSBOTMBUFEUP4FSCJBGPSFYBDUMZUIFTBNFSFBTPOTB
HFOFSBUJPOFBSMJFSѮF DJSDVNTUBODFT TVSSPVOEJOH UIF BDRVJTJUJPO PG 4U -VLFT SFM
JDTBOEUIFJSUSBOTMBUJPOUP4FSCJBBSFSFMBUJWFMZXFMMEPDVNFOUFE
UIFCBTJDTPVSDFT
CFJOHUXPUFYUTJOEFQFOEFOUMZDPNQPTFEJO4FSCJBCZUXPDPOUFNQPSBSJFTXJUI
UIFFWFOUT
XIJMFBOVNCFSPGJOUFSFTUJOHEFUBJMTNBZCFJOEJSFDUMZEFEVDFEGSPN
UIFTPNFXIBUMBUFSFQJTUPMBSZNBUFSJBM
"MUIPVHIUIFNBKPSFWFOUXBT
JOUIFTQJSJUPGNFEJFWBMUFBDIJOHTBOEDPO
DFQUJPOT
EFTDSJCFE JO NJSBDVMPVT UFSNT
UIF TPVSDFT DPOUBJO B OVNCFS PG EBUB
NBLJOHJUQPTTJCMFGPSUIFUSBOTMBUJPOPG4U-VLFTSFMJDTUPCFWJFXFEBHBJOTUUIF
BDUVBMIJTUPSJDBMCBDLHSPVOE"UUIFNPNFOUEFTQPU%KVSBEKXBTDPOTJEFSJOHUIF
QPTTJCJMJUZPGBDRVJSJOHUIFSFMJDT
UIFZXFSFLFQUJOUIF(SFFLUPXOPG3PHPT 4BO
.BVSP
VOEFS0UUPNBOSVMFBUUIFUJNF
XIFSFBDPOKVODUJPOPGDJSDVNTUBODFT
IBECSPVHIUUIFNGPMMPXJOHUIF-BUJODPORVFTUPG$POTUBOUJOPQMFJOѮF
EFTQPUTêSTU NPWF XBT UP WFSJGZ UIFJS BVUIFOUJDJUZ
BOE UIF UBTL XBT FOUSVTUFE UP
UIFNPTUDPNQFUFOUQFSTPOT
JODMVEJOHUIFQSPUPTPG.PVOU"UIPTѮFO QBZNFOU
GPMMPXFEPGJNQSFTTJWF
EVDBUT
DPWFSJOHUIFSFMJDT
HJѫT BOE PUIFS FYQFO
EJUVSFT 8JUI UIF TVMUBOT QFSNJTTJPO
IF TFOU B NJTTJPO PG FNJOFOU JOEJWJEVBMT
]]
3&-*$4"/%30:"-*%&0-0(:
UP3PHPT"TUIFUSBOTGFSPGUIFIPMZSFNBJOTEJEOPUHPTNPPUIMZ
UIFDJUJ[FOTPG
3PHPTCFJOHVOXJMMJOHUPHJWFVQUIFJSIPMZSFMJD
UIF4FSCTIBEUPSFTPSUUPTVS
SFQUJUJPVTNFUIPET)BWJOHUBLFOUIFSFMJDTVOEFSDPWFSPGEBSLOFTT
UIFZNBEFB
IBTUZEFQBSUVSFBOENBOBHFEUPFTDBQFUIFQVSTVFST"ѫFS UIFJS EBZ KPVSOFZ
PO+BOVBSZ
UIFNJTTJPOBSSJWFEJO4NFEFSFWP
4FSCJBTDBQJUBMBUUIFUJNF
"NBHOJêDFOU DFMFCSBUJPO FOTVFE
GVMMZ DPOGPSNFE UP UIF SVMFT PG UIF USBEJUJPOBM
BEWFOUVTSFMJRVJBSVN*OBEEJUJPOUPBOBDDPVOUPGUIFNBJOTUBHFTPGUIFSJUVBM
mBOPDDVSTVTCZUIFIJHIDMFSHZBOEUIFSVMFSKVTUPVUPG4NFEFSFWP
BQSPDFTTJPO
BUUFOEFECZQFPQMFGSPNBMMTPDJBMTUSBUB
UIFEFQPTJUJPOBOENJSBDMFXPSLJOHPGUIF
SFMJDTmUIFTPVSDFTDPOUBJOTPNFTUSBJHIUGPSXBSEJOGPSNBUJPO
RVJUFVOVTVBMGPS
UIF4FSCJBONJMJFV
TIFEEJOHMJHIUPOUIFFWFOUJOJUTBDUVBMTFUUJOH0GBOFYDFQ
UJPOBMEPDVNFOUBSZWBMVFJTUIFEFUBJMFEJUJOFSBSZPGUIFQSPDFTTJPOUISPVHI4NF
EFSFWP
BNJETUFOPSNPVTUISPOHTPGQFPQMF
BOBDDPVOUPGUIFBDUJPOTBOESJUVBMT
DFOUSFESPVOEUIFSFMJRVBSZ
BTXFMMBTUIFJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUEPOBUJPOTNBEFCZ
NFNCFSTPGUIFSVMJOHIPVTF6OVTVBMJTBMTPUIFSFQFSUPJSFPGNJSBDMFTBUUSJCVUFE
UPUIFSFMJDT
BTXFMMBTUIFGBDUUIBUUIFZXFSFEFTDSJCFEJOUIFWFSOBDVMBSBOEMJTUFE
JOBTPSUPGBDBUBMPHVF"VOJRVFFYBNQMFJOUIF4FSCJBOSFMJDSFMBUFEQSBDUJDFTJT
BSFGFSFODFUPUIFiMPXTQJSJUFEu
TDFQUJDTPWFSUMZFYQSFTTJOHUIFJSEPVCUTBTUPUIF
BVUIFOUJDJUZPG4U-VLFTNJSBDMFT
"ѫFS UIF USBOTMBUJPO
UIF SFMJDT XFSF EFQPTFE JO B OFX BOE MBWJTI SFMJRVBSZ
FOTISJOFEJOBGPVOEBUJPOPG%KVSBEKBOEIJTTPO-B[BS#SBOLPWJǀ
UIFOFXMZCVJMU
DBUIFESBMBOEGVOFSBSZDIVSDIPGUIF"OOVODJBUJPO'JOBMMZ
UIFTUSVDUVSFPGUIF
TBJOUT DVMU XBT CSPVHIU UP DPNQMFUJPO CZ UIF XSJUJOH PG BQQSPQSJBUF EFWPUJPOBM
DPNQPTJUJPOTѮFJS DPOUFOU
FTQFDJBMMZ UIF TFSWJDF BOE QBSFLMFTJT
DMFBSMZSFWFBMT
UIFGVODUJPOPG4U-VLFTDVMUJO4FSCJB'BDJOHUIFJNNJOFOUMPTTPGJOEFQFOEFODF
BOEPWFSXIFMNFECZBQPDBMZQUJDNJMMFOBSJBOFYQFDUBUJPOTPGUIFEPPNTEBZ
UIF
4FSCTQMBDFEUIFJSMBTUIPQFTJOUIFOFXMZGPVOEIFBWFOMZQSPUFDUPSѮF TBJOUT
WJSUVT
IPXFWFS
GBJMFEUPEFMJWFS
BOEJO4NFEFSFWPGFMMXJUIPVUSFTJTUBODF
ѮF SFMJDT XFSF UIFO USBOTGFSSFE UP #PTOJB
BOE JO
BѫFS NBOZ JODJEFOUT
UIFZ
êOBMMZ BSSJWFE JO 7FOJDF
XIFSF UIFZ TUJMM BSF *O DPOUSBTU UP UIF TUBUVT PG B TUBUF
QBMMBEJVNUIFZFOKPZFEJOUIFJS4FSCJBOQFSJPE
UIFJSTVCTFRVFOUIJTUPSZTBXUIFN
CFDPNF QSJWBUF QSPQFSUZ
UIF PCKFDU PG USBEF BOE CBSHBJO
BOE êOBMMZ UIF DBVTF
PGBDFOUVSJFTMPOHEJTQVUFCFUXFFO7FOJDFBOE1BEVBPWFSUIFQPTTFTTJPOPGUIF
BVUIFOUJDSFMJDT
]]
̸͉͊̓ͣ̾͆́͏̾
"# "OBMFDUB#PMMBOEJBOB
#SPXO
ѮF $VMU PG UIF 4BJOUT 1#SPXO
ѮF $VMU PG UIF 4BJOUT
*UT3JTFBOE'VODUJPOJO-BUJO
$ISJTUJBOJUZ
-POEPO
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
̻Ͷͪͼ̸͊͆͌ ̻Ͷͪͼ͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ̸͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͰͪ;͵ͪͳ
;ͷͰͽͼͽͳ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̻Ͷͪͼ̸͊̓ ̻Ͷͪͼ͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ̓ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵Ͱ̸͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͰ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̻Ͷͪͼͳ͵͊͆̽ ̻Ͷͪͼͳ͵͊͵ͺͼ͵ͭͪ;ͭͯͻ;ͽͬͪ
͊͵ͺΓͰ
̻Ͷͪͼͳ͵͊͌̽ ̻Ͷͪͼͳ͵͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ;Ͱͭͯͻ;ͽͬͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
+¸# +BISCVDIEFS¸TUFSSFJDIJTDIFO
#Z[BOUJOJTUJL
8JFO
]]
̸͉͊̓ͣ̾͆́͏̾
0$1 0SJFOUBMJB$ISJTUJBOB1FSJPEJDB
#SVYFMMFT
0%# 0YGPSE%JDUJPOBSZPG#Z[BOUJVN*m***
/FX:PSLm0YGPSE
1( 1BUSPMPHJBm1BUSPMPHJBFDVSTVT
DPNQMFUVT4FSJFT(SBFDB
FE+1
.JHOF
1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOH 1PMJUJLVOE)FJMJHFOWFSFISVOHJN
)PDINJUUFMBMUFS
FE+1FUFSTPIO
4JHNBSJOHFO
3BE+";6 3BE+VHPTMBWFOTLF"LBEFNJKF[OBOPTUJ
JVNKFUOPTUJ
;BHSFC
]]
̸̽͆́͏̸͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
͈͇͇͉̺͇̽̓́̾͊̾͋͊͋́͡ͅ
͉ͯͼͶͬͳͳͶͰͽͺͳͼͳ ͊ͽͪͻͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͻͯͼͶͬͳͳͶͰͽͺͳͼͳ
ͺͻͳͻͰͯͳ͊͡ͽΒͪͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯm͊ͻ̓ͪͻͶͬͳ
͊ͪͬͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕmͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ ͊ͪͬͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͳΕmͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ
́ͼͽͻͳΒͪͳͺͻͰͯͪΔͰ
FE̺͚;ͻͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
͊ͪͺͽͰΔͪ ͊ͪͺͽͰΔ͉ͪͰͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͭͲͪͬͯͪ
ͲͪͲͪͽͳͽ;ͼͺͷͰͳ͵ͪ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͰ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
͊ͺͷͰͳ͵̸͊̓ ͊ͺͷͰͳ͵͊ͻͺͼ͵Ͱ̓ͻͪΓͰͬͼ͵Ͱ
ͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͰ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̸͊͊ ͊ͽͪͻͳͼͻͺͼ͵ͳͪͻͳͬ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
͊ͽͰͿͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͪmͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͳͷͰ ͊ͽͰͿͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͪmͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͳͷͰ
ͅͳͻͽͳͬͳ ͅͳͻͽͳͬͳ́ͼͽͻͳΒͪͳͺͻͰͯͪΔͰ
FE̓ͪ͠ͶͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
̺̺ ̺ͳͲͪͽͳʹͼ͵ͳʹͬͻͰͷͰͳ͵
͈Ͱͽͻͭͻͪͯmͅͼ͵ͬͪ
̀̈́͌ ̀ͫͻͳ͵ͲͪͶͳ͵ͬͰ;ͷͰͽͼͽͳ
ͪͅͽͳͰͼͻͺͼ͵Ͱ
͆ͬͳ͊ͪͯ
͉̺̀́ ̀ͫͻͳ͵ͻͪͯͬͪ
̺ͳͲͪͽͶ͵ͭͳͼͽͳͽ;ͽͪ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
]]
0̸̸̹̺͉͇̺̾͆́̽́͠͡
͊ͬͰͽͳͽͰΓͼ͵ͺͻͼͶͪͬΓͪΔͰ͊ͳͷͰͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͰ͈ͻͳͶͭͺͻ;ͪͬͪΔ;͵;Ͷͽͪ
ͷͽͳΒ;͵ͯ͊ͻͫͪ
͉̺̀́
m
͇ͪͼͽͪ͵;͵;ͶͽͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͳͷͰͪ
JO͊ͽͰͿͪ͆ͰͷͪΔͪmͼͬͰͽͳ͊ͳͷͰ
ͅͳͻͽͳͬͳ́ͼͽͻͳΒͪͳͺͻͰͯͪΔͰ
FE̓ͪ͠ͶͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
ͅͽͳͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ
JO͊ͬͰͽͳ͊ͪͬͪ;ͼͻͺͼ͵ΒͳͼͽͻͳΒͳͳͽͻͪͯͳͳΒͳ
FE͊ͣͳͻ͵ͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
͐;ͯͽͬͻͰΔͪͼͬͰͽͭ͊ͪͬͰ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͭ
JO͐;ͯ;ͼͶͬͰͼ͵ͳͷ͵;Ͷͽ;ͻͪͷͪ
FE̸̽ΒͯͪͳΕ
͆ͬͳ͊ͪͯ
m
̓;Ͷͽ͵ͻͪΓͪ̽ͻͪͭ;ͽͳͪmͷͪͪ͋Ͱ͵ͽͳͼͽͪ
͉̺̀́
m
̓ͽͳͽͻͅͻͪͰͳΔͰͭͬ͵;Ͷͽ
JOͪͪͅͼͽͳͻͅͻͪͪ
FE̹͋ͯͳΕ
͈̽ͺͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
m
4BDSBFSFMJRVJBF͊ͺͪͼͬͰͻ͵ͬͰ;̿ͳͳ
JOͪͪͅͼͽͳͻ̿ͳͪ̀ͫͻͳ͵
ͻͪͯͬͪ
FE̻͊;ͫͽͳΕ
̓ͻͪΓͰͬ
m
͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪͬͶͪͯͪͻͼ͵ͪUSBOTMBUJP͵ͪͽͻͳΒ;ͷͿͪͶͳBEWFOUVT
JO͋ͻͰΕͪ
͠;ͭͼͶͬͰͼ͵ͪ͵ͿͰͻͰͳΒͪͬͳͲͪͽͶͭͪ
FEͪ͡ͅ͵ͼͳͷͬͳΕ
͉͆ͪͯͰͬͳΕ
͉̾ͪͯ;ͶͬͳΕ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯm̓ͻ;Ͱͬͪ
m
3FMJDTBOE1PMJUJDTJOUIF.JEEMF"HFTUIF4FSCJBO"QQSPBDI
JO
̺ͼͽͻͳͼͽͳͪͼ͵ͳͰͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳͳ
FË̸́ͅͳͯͬ
ͅͼ͵ͬͪ
m
͉ͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͰͼͬͰͽͰ͈Ͱͽ͵ͰHMPSJB#VMHBSJBFmHMPSJB4FSWJBF
JO̹΅ͶͭͪͻͳΊͳ
͊΅ͻͫͳΊͬ͵ͽͰ͵ͼͽͪͪͬͳͲͪͽͳʹͼ͵ͪͽͪͳͬͳͶͳͲͪͳΊ
FE̺̻ΉͲͰͶͰͬ
̸ͅͳͶͽͰͬͪ
͉͊ͽͪ͵ͬͪ
͊ͿͳΊ
m
]]
$*1m͵ͪͽͪͶͭͳͲͪͳΒͪ;ͺ;ͫͶͳ͵ͪͳΒͳ
͆ͪͻͯͪͫͳͫͶͳͽͰ͵ͪ͊ͻͫͳΒͰ
̹Ͱͭͻͪͯ
uu
uu
uu
͈͇͈͇̺́ͣ
̽ͪͳͪ
͈ͯ͵ͻͳΓͰͷͼͬͰͽͼͽͳ͵;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͳͬͶͪͯͪͻͪͳͻͰͶͳ͵ͬͳΒͪ;
ͼͻͰͯΔͬͰ͵ͬΒ͊ͻͫͳΒͳ̽ͪͳ͈ͪͺͬͳΕ̹Ͱͭͻ̹ͪͯͪͶ͵ͪͶ͵ͳ
ͳͼͽͳͽ;ͽ̸͊͆͌
̹Ͱͭͻ̸ͪͯͶͽͪͬͪ
ͼͽͻͳͶ;ͼͽͻͷ
͈ͼͰͫͪͳͲͯͪΔͪ͊ͻͺͼ͵ͪͪ͵ͪͯͰͷͳΒͪͪ;͵ͪͳ;ͷͰͽͼͽͳ
̹ͪͶ͵ͪͶ͵ͳ
ͳͼͽͳͽ;ͽ
͆ͪͼͺͻͪͼͶͼͽͻ6OEFSUIF"VTQJDFTPG4BODUJUZ͋ͳͻͪͱ͆ͪͺͷͰͰͳ
ͫͳͫͶͳͭͻͪͿͼ͵ͰͻͰͿͰͻͰͰ;ͲͽͰ͵ͼͽ4VNNBSZ
*4#/
ͪ
̓;ͶͽͼͬͰͽͪͪ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ͊ͻͰͯΔͳͬͰ͵ͫ
̺Ͷͪͯͪͻͳ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ͊ͻͰͯΔͳͬͰ͵
͈Ͷͳͽͳ͵͉ͪͰͶͳͭͳΒͪ͊ͻͫͳΒͪ͊ͻͰͯΔͳͬͰ͵
$0#*4443*%