Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Managing Essentials
International
come up. Titles are especially attractive in this context since expertise seems to be attested by a reputable institution or peers. They form a shield against allegations and questions. Titles give authority and chances to get away with a false claim increase with time. A career with real achievements puts this misdeed more and more into the background. However, motivations may mix in individual cases and such pretension can be a serious matter as by doing so the person transgresses accepted moral boundaries. On first sight it also seems a little odd, especially on the background of an otherwise successful career. Why should somebody who has successfully led a company with thousands of employees list a fabricated bachelor degree? However, the odder it is on the one hand, the more serious it is on the other especially when looking towards a longer career. The behavior points to the ethical core of personality and the danger lies exactly in the fact that this act was easy and unnecessary. The lack of a need points to the motivational strength. What borders would such a person cross in a situation with really strong incentives? No, such individuals may be real jungle fighters knowing neither limits nor borders, but not necessarily. Consciously and carefully deliberating decisions their conclusions might not differ from those made by others. Obviously they care a lot what others may think about them and having a weak spot may make them even a little more careful. However, there is the danger that they do not notice how the incentives tempt them and they may consequently engage unintentionally in higher risks. Of course such cases also reflect badly on the social environment in which these individuals work. In most cases it needed real opponents to bring such cases up. These opponents may be critical chairmen of boards or political contra hands. That opponents are needed indicates how easy it is to get away, and that this misbehavior unfolds in an environment of negligence and disinterest or even companionship. In the German cases of plagiarism the question came up that doctorates should not be given too easily to aspiring politicians who might later act as testimonials for the quality of the business schools. It remains a bit of a mystery why commissions of 5-6 professors and the two doctor fathers in their extensive opinions did not note the problems, The cases discussed above also express a general problem of personnel marketing. Most companies realize that realistic and truthful information about candidates is a must but at the same time look in their advertisements for talent rarely found. Applications are in general self advertisements in which some beautification is permissible. The talent pressure is reinforcing this window dressing and so a well deserved holiday must transform into a hopefully correctly certified foreign language course. In consequence nearly everywhere in the world, screening companies have sprung up to provide an in depth look into candidates
Managing Essentials
International
curricula vitae and references. At least some of these efforts could be spared if companies would advertise not only their ideals but also their realities.
The Guttenberg Plagiarism Scandal: 'German Society Is Applying a Double Standard' (Der Spiegel) www.managing-essentials.com/2ep Yahoo CEO isnt the only leader who has fudged rsum www.managing-essentials.com/2eq