Canadian Architect Dec - 2010

$10.00 DEC/10 V.55 N.
12
2010 AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE
CIRCLE REPLY CARD 11
HP DE S I G N J E T e M F P
GOOD ARCHITECTURE COMES FROM INSPIR ATION. GREAT ARCHITECTURE COMES FROM COLL ABOR ATION.
INTRODUCING THE WORLDS MOST COLL ABOR ATIVE PRINTER: The HP Designjet T2300 eMFP with ePrint & Share. Now you can scan documents to the cloud directly,1 print from the road instantly and reduce review
cycles by sharing les with partners around the world.2 Nothing else lets you collaborate with your team as seamlessly, while also laying the foundation for the worlds next great structure. Visit HP.CA/GO/COLL ABOR ATE
2010 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. Upgradable functionality will be available in spring 2011. Internet connection is required.
WALLTITE ECO RAISING PERFORMANCE TO NEW HEIGHTS

TM
When youre choosing insulation/air barrier systems, make the right choice: WALLTITE ECO, the purple insulation by BASF, The Chemical Company.
WALLTITE ECO is a medium-density polyurethane foam insulation/air barrier system designed to improve the energy efciency of any type of building. WALLTITE ECOs industry-leading performance results in substantial energy savings by maximizing the effectiveness of the building envelope. WALLTITE ECO meets the stringent requirements of the GREENGUARD Certication Program and GREENGUARD Children & Schools certication, thus ensuring optimal occupant comfort and safety.
SM SM
WALLTITE ECO is the rst closed-cell spray polyurethane insulation to obtain the EcoLogo , North Americas most widely recognized multi-attribute environmental certication. Its formulation includes recycled plastic, renewable content and a zero ozone-depleting blowing agent.
TM
WALLTITE ECO has been optimized through BASFs award-winning Eco-Efciency Analysis which assesses the lifecycle of a product or manufacturing process from cradle to grave over six categories: Materials consumption; Energy consumption; Emissions to air, soil and water; Risk potential for misuse; Health effect potential and Land use.
For more information: Eastern region: 1-866-474-3538 l Western region: 1-800-891-0671 walltite.com l foammasters.ca l walltiteeco.com
ECO stands for the balance between ecology and economy, achieved through the performance of WALLTITE ECOTM. Major prerequisites for renewable raw materials to become an alternative to fossil resources are their availability at competitive prices for industrial applications, without compromising food production and depleting the natural wealth. For its insulation material: WALLTITE ECOTM, BASF Canada has chosen to use renewable content from non-edible crops that do not jeopardize global food production. WALLTITE ECOTM and foam mastersTM are trademarks and Raising Performance To New Heights is a registered trademark of BASF Canada. EcoLogoTM is a registered trademark of Environment Canada. The GREENGUARD Certication ProgramSM and GREENGUARD Children & SchoolsSM are trademarks of the GREENGUARD Environmental Institute.
CONTENTS
20
PATKAU ARCHITECTS
22
CANNON DESIGN
24
5468796 ARCHITECTURE INC.
26 SMITH CARTER ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS/ PARKIN ARCHITECTS
28
ATELIER BIG CITY
30
BAIRD SAMPSON NEUERT ARCHITECTS
34
KONGATS ARCHITECTS
36
PROVENCHER ROY + ASSOCIS ARCHITECTES
38
CARDINAL HARDY | LABONT MARCIL | ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES, ARCHITECTES EN CONSORTIUM
40
ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES
43
JEFFREY MA, MCGILL UNIVERSITY
45
TARANEH MESHKANI, UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO
AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE
A REFRESHING SELECTION OF WORK FROM ACROSS NORTH AMERICA WAS CHOSEN BY THIS YEARS JURY, REPRESENTING AN ENCOURAGING DIVERSITY OF BUILDING PROGRAMFROM HOSPITAL TO FOOTBRIDGE TO FILM CENTRE.
DECEMBER 2010, V.55 N.12
12 THE WINNERS
PROFILES OF THE 2010 AWARD RECIPIENTS.
50 LIST OF ENTRANTS
COVER
THE NATIONAL REVIEW OF DESIGN AND PRACTICE/ THE JOURNAL OF RECORD OF THE RAIC
RENDERING OF THE BLOC_10 RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN WINNIPEG BY 5468796 ARCHITECTURE INC.
12/10 CANADIAN ARCHITECT
VIEWPOINT
DANNY SINGER
ABOVE DESPITE SOME OF THE UNFORUNATE SHORTFALLS EVIDENT IN VANCOUVERS FORMER OLYMPIC VILLAGE, THERE ARE MANY COMPONENTS OF THE ARCHITECTURE AND PLANNING THAT DEMONSTRATE SOLID CONCEPTS OF SUSTAINABILITY.
I thought that we should finish the year on an optimistic note. And so, we begin by giving thanks to the federal and provincial governments for keeping so many architecture firms busy with projects funded by economic stimulus money intended to improve our aging infrastructure. Now for some realism and concern. With all of this infrastructure money drying up, our economy and the public policy that influences itmust now focus on improving the efficacy of large-scale sustainable developments that will result in energy-efficient buildings. Emphasis must also be placed on progressive approaches to urban intensification with all of the attached social, health and economic benefits. However, based on the results of a few recent projects, current approaches to the creation of large-scale sustainable developments need revision. One example is in Toronto, where the Toronto Community Housing Corporation (TCHC) is leading a $1-billion revitalization project for Regent Park, creating a mixed-income community intended for 5,100 households. Amenities intended to improve the developments social sustainability quotient include two daycares, space for local community groups, a learning centre, an employment hub, and plenty of retail and commercial services. The energy savings is targeted between 40 and 50 percent of the Model National Energy Code for Buildings. A water and energy reduction program is being put into place and a new district heating plant will effectively reduce the developments greenhouse gas emissions by 8,000 tonnes a year during Phase I of the neighbourhood revitalization. Yet despite these efforts to transform the area, in early December, 18-year-old Nicholas Yambo became the fourth homicide victim in Regent Park over a two-month period. For Regent Park to be successful as an environmentally and socially sustainable entity over the long term, both the physical and social components need to work in tandem.
6 CANADIAN ARCHITECT 12/10
Another example is in Vancouver, where the $1.3-billion redevelopment of Southeast False Creek (SEFC) was intended to be a leading model of sustainable development, incorporating infrastructure, energy reduction programs, highperformance buildings and easy access to transit. The first phase of SEFC was the Olympic Village for the 2010 Winter Games and Paralympics, hosting approximately 2,800 athletes and officials. While the development was a hive of activity during the Olympics, it remains far from being integrated into the life of the city today. The buildings are spaced too closely together, the condominiums and townhouses command too high a price (even for the Vancouver real estate market), and a lack of adequate views to the water and the North Shore have all contributed to the project going into receivership. Of the 737 market-rate suites, roughly 30 percent have been sold and just over half of the 120 rentals had tenants by the end of November. A deal for the 252 non-market units with BC Housing is pending. The more successful components of the project include a 67-unit seniors residenceCanadas first Net Zero multi-unit residential buildingand a popular community centre. SEFCs lack of adequate urban planning has resulted in significant weaknesses in this supposedly innovative sustainable development. A third example where the focus on sustainable development needs to evolve can be found in the EQuilibrium Sustainable Housing Demonstration Initiative led by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC). While the program addresses occupant health and comfort, energy efficiency, renewable energy production and affordability, it must continue to draw upon the experience of builders, architects and planners from across the country to expand upon recent EQuilibrium case studies for clues on how to better disseminate the lessons learned. This might be achievable with the EQuilibrium Communities program, an association between Natural Resources Canada (NRCan) and the CMHC. Funded by the federal governments ecoACTION initiatives, the three-year $4.2-million demonstration initiative has enabled the research and planning of four projects to dateStation Pointe in Edmonton, the Ampersand in Ottawa, the Ty-Histanis community outside Tofino, and Regent Park in Toronto. Bewilderingly, however, no money or financial incentives will be allocated for subsidizing the hard costs associated with any of the participating projects. Understanding the shortfalls in large-scale development of sustainable communities is crucial if we are to ever implement strategies that result in socially, economically and architecturally sustainable living.
IAN CHODIKOFF
ICHODIKOFF@CANADIANARCHITECT.COM
EDITOR IAN CHODIKOFF, OAA, FRAIC ASSOCIATE EDITOR LESLIE JEN, MRAIC EDITORIAL ADVISORS JOHN MCMINN, AADIPL. MARCO POLO, OAA, FRAIC CONTRIBUTING EDITORS GAVIN AFFLECK, OAQ, MRAIC HERBERT ENNS, MAA, MRAIC DOUGLAS MACLEOD, NCARB REGIONAL CORRESPONDENTS HALIFAX CHRISTINE MACY, OAA REGINA BERNARD FLAMAN, SAA MONTREAL DAVID THEODORE CALGARY DAVID A. DOWN, AAA WINNIPEG HERBERT ENNS, MAA VANCOUVER ADELE WEDER PUBLISHER TOM ARKELL 416-510-6806 ASSOCIATE PUBLISHER GREG PALIOURAS 416-510-6808 CIRCULATION MANAGER BEATA OLECHNOWICZ 416-442-5600 EXT. 3543 CUSTOMER SERVICE MALKIT CHANA 416-442-5600 EXT. 3539 PRODUCTION JESSICA JUBB GRAPHIC DESIGN SUE WILLIAMSON VICE PRESIDENT OF CANADIAN PUBLISHING ALEX PAPANOU PRESIDENT OF BUSINESS INFORMATION GROUP BRUCE CREIGHTON HEAD OFFICE 12 CONCORDE PLACE, SUITE 800, TORONTO, ON M3C 4J2 TELEPHONE 416-510-6845 FACSIMILE 416-510-5140 E-MAIL EDITORS@CANADIANARCHITECT.COM WEB SITE WWW.CANADIANARCHITECT.COM Canadian Architect is published monthly by BIG Magazines LP, a div. of Glacier BIG Holdings Company Ltd., a leading Canadian information company with interests in daily and community newspapers and business-tobusiness information services. The editors have made every reasonable effort to provide accurate and authoritative information, but they assume no liability for the accuracy or completeness of the text, or its fitness for any particular purpose. Subscription Rates Canada: $52.95 plus applicable taxes for one year; $83.95 plus applicable taxes for two years (HST #809751274RT0001). Price per single copy: $6.95. Students (prepaid with student ID, includes taxes): $34.97 for one year. USA: $101.95 US for one year. All other foreign: $120.00 US per year. US office of publication: 2424 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY 143045709. Periodicals Postage Paid at Niagara Falls, NY. USPS #009-192. US postmaster: Send address changes to Canadian Architect, PO Box 1118, Niagara Falls, NY 14304. Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to: Circulation Dept., Canadian Architect, 12 Concorde Place, Suite 800, Toronto, ON Canada M3C 4J2. Postmaster: please forward forms 29B and 67B to 12 Concorde Place, Suite 800, Toronto, ON Canada M3C 4J2. Printed in Canada. All rights reserved. The contents of this publication may not be reproduced either in part or in full without the consent of the copyright owner. From time to time we make our subscription list available to select companies and organizations whose product or service may interest you. If you do not wish your contact information to be made available, please contact us via one of the following methods: Telephone 1-800-668-2374 Facsimile 416-442-2191 E-mail privacyofficer@businessinformationgroup.ca Mail Privacy Officer, Business Information Group, 12 Concorde Place, Suite 800, Toronto, ON Canada M3C 4J2 MEMBER OF THE CANADIAN BUSINESS PRESS MEMBER OF THE AUDIT BUREAU OF CIRCULATIONS PUBLICATIONS MAIL AGREEMENT #40069240 ISSN 1923-3353 (ONLINE) ISSN 0008-2872 (PRINT)
WE ACKNOWLEDGE THE FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF THE GOVERNMENT OF CANADA THROUGH THE CANADA PERIODICAL FUND (CPF) FOR OUR PUBLISHING ACTIVITIES. PAP REGISTRATION NO. 11093
Taking chances isnt in your vocabulary. Thats why its important to have the right expertise and products behind you. And since 1965, thats just what Georgia-Pacific has done. Visit www.gpgypsum.com or call 1-800-387-6823 to locate your GP gypsum architectural specialist.
Building Reputations Together
2010 Georgia-Pacic Gypsum LLC. All rights reserved. BUILDING REPUTATIONS TOGETHER and the Georgia-Pacic logo are owned by or licensed to Georgia-Pacic Gypsum LLC.
OPTICAL ALLUSIONS
IT S TIme TO ThINk INSIde The bOx
PRODUCT : MEMPHIS TO M ILAN AND BACK PATTERN LIBRARY
To learn more call 1 800 267 2149 ext 2128 or visit us online at www.interfaceor.ca. Mission Zero and the Mission Zero mark are registered trademarks of Interface, Inc.
AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE 2010
A TRUE REFLECTION
THE JURY FOR THE 2010 AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE REVIEWED A RECORD NUMBER OF SUBMISSIONS REPRESENTING A WIDE RANGE OF PROJECT TYPES FROM ACROSS NORTH AMERICA.
The jury for the 2010 edition of Canadian Architect magazines Awards of Excellence program studied a marvellous array of entries from across the country. A record number of 144 submissions provided our jury with considerable material to review and discuss, resulting in the final selection of winners that appear in this highly anticipated year-end edition of the magazine. No jury is infallible, but since the awards program began in 1968, every jury has quickly developed its own distinct methodology of reviewing each years submitted projects. What was highly admirable of this years jury was their ability to cast a sympathetic eye and apply an open mind to the wide range of scales, budgets, client mandates and programmatic concerns. The profession of architecture is full of challenges that demand a specialized range of skill sets to shepherd an architectural concept to fruition. Certainly, our jurycomprised of architects James Cheng, Andrew King and Janna Levitt understand these challenges facing todays practitioners, not to mention the incredible demands placed on architects by public- and privatesector clients. Vancouver-based architect James Cheng offers the following general comment about his experiences over the course of the twoday adjudication process in October:
I am pleased to see some highly innovative submissions on multi-family projects. Housing is the most common building type, but due to various reasons such as budget, market acceptance, planning restrictions, etc., it is perhaps the most difficult to innovate. Increasingly, architects and planners are being asked to provide designs for projects in China, the Middle East, India, and other fast-developing countries at an unprecedented pace and scale. With this increasingly smaller global village, it raises questions about regionalism and what kind of new urbanism should result and by what standard we should define excellence. Principal of Levitt Goodman Architects in Toronto, Janna Levitt had the following comments to make about the 2010 Awards of Excellence: When reflecting on which type of projects typically garner attention in Canadian award programs, it seems to me that the stars have shone most brightly in two sectors: public institutional buildings, and the single-family house. It is intriguing and I think a real reflection of our times, that we have three exciting and innovative private-sector projects receiving Awards of Excellence. I suspect there are two reasons for this. The first may be linked to the withdrawal of government from its historically significant invest-
ABOVE, LEFT TO RIGHT
ANDREW KING, JAMES CHENG AND JANNA LEVITT DEBATE THE STRENGTHS OF THE SHORTLISTED GROUP OF SUBMISSIONS IN THIS YEARS AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE.
ment in the built environment, which may have created a void that the private sector is filling. The second may be that the clients of developer buildings such as condominiums, hotels, etc. are becoming more discerning purchasers of design and this has amped up the quality of this type. One issue I found very surprising and which we discussed at length was the generally unimaginative quality of the representational strategies of the submissions. Just as every picture tells a story, every drawing must effectively and creatively describe a key concept. This is particularly felt in an anonymous submission where the jurors have no prior knowledge to bring to their review of the submission. If one needs inspiration, just attend an end-of-term review of senior student work at any of the schools across the country: hand drawings, models, AutoCAD drawings, stills of homemade videos, collagesnothing is sacred and everything is in service of communicating the architectural ideas in a stimulating way.
James K.M. Cheng
Andrew King
Janna Levitt
James K.M. Cheng received his Bachelor of Architecture degree from the University of Washington, after which he moved to San Francisco to work with Henrik Bull of Bull Field Volkmann Stockwell on a variety of urban projects. Shortly thereafter, Cheng apprenticed with Arthur Erickson in Vancouver for three years as a designer on large-scale urban and international projects such as the Vancouver Law Court complex, and the Anthropology and Sociology Faculty office at the University of British Columbia. Cheng was first recognized by Architectural Record magazine and was included in their special Young Architects issue in December 1972 for a condominium project he designed while still an undergraduate working for Mithun Partners of Seattle. Subsequently, this project was included in Architectural Records Record Houses issue in 1974. In 1977 Cheng obtained his Master of Architecture degree from Harvard Universitys Graduate School of Design, where he studied under American architect Richard Meier. Upon graduation, he (in joint venture with Romses Kwan & Associates) won a provincial competition to design the Chinese Cultural Centre in Vancouver. Cheng won his first major design award from Architectural Record in 1977 for a private residence, which was recognized as one of the 20 Record Houses of 1977 along with Richard Meiers Shamburg House. Since these first awards, Cheng has won over 45 major design awards, including the prestigious Governor Generals Medal from the Royal Architectural Institute of Canada, the Canadian Architect Yearbook Award, the Lieutenant Governors Gold Award from the Architectural Institute of British Columbia, and the Interior Design Institute of British Columbias Gold Award of Excellence. His work has been published and exhibited in Canada, the US, Japan, London, Germany, and Hong Kong. In addition to leading a busy and diverse practice, Cheng has also lectured at the University of British Columbia for three years, and has served as a visiting critic and juror on architectural competitions and design award juries, both locally and nationally.
Andrew King is a graduate architect, author, critic, curator, and educator. He has practiced and taught across Canada and in London, Berlin, Budapest, Rome, Seville and Copenhagen. King was selected as one of Canadas design leaders by The Globe and Mail in 2003. That same year, he was awarded the Canada Council for the Arts Prix de Rome and a Canadian Architect Award of Excellence. King has worked with internationally recognized architects such as Zaha Hadid in London, Tim Heide in Berlin, and Brian MacKayLyons in Halifax. He is Design Principal at Cannon Design, currently leading teams in Vancouver and Montreal and overseeing projects across Canada and in Asia. He has led his own design and research initiative AK A for over 20 years, which encompasses architecture, urban design, and installationbased work. King is the Azrieli Visiting Chair at Carleton Universitys Azrieli School of Architecture and Urbanism for 2009-10. In 2004, he was Visiting Professor at Copenhagens Royal Academy of Art, and he has held visiting, adjunct, and special faculty appointments in architecture and fine art at the University of Calgary, McGill, and Dalhousie. King also leads an ongoing research initiative with the Banff Centre for the Arts. His work has been published in national and international art and architecture journals, including Canadian Architect and Canadian Art, and has been recognized with provincial, national and international design awards. Additionally, as a writer and critic, King has contributed to several critical journals, writing about contemporary projects and architectural curation. He is a co-editor of and contributor to building/art (2004), and his work was featured in and on the cover of The Prix de Rome: A Critical Perspective (2006), edited by Marco Polo. His critical art practice (with Angela Silver) has made in-situ and gallery-based installations across Canada and abroad. Commissions include lens for the Banff Centre for the Arts for inclusion in the 2005 Alberta Biennial of Contemporary Art, and ex-urbus for Black Dog Presss Informal Architecture, edited by Anthony Kiendl.
Janna Levitt, Principal of Toronto-based firm Levitt Goodman Architects (LGA), is known around her office as the optimist because she brings a positive energy to her work that draws the best out of people and circumstances. A trailblazer, she also seizes opportunities to find solutions to problems that spark her interest such as the Vermicondoa stylish indoor worm composter for urban dwellers. Levitts background in the visual arts has distinguished her architectural career. She studied fine arts at the Nova Scotia College of Art and Design and at the Museum School of Fine Arts in Boston, graduating with a Bachelor of Arts from the University of Toronto, followed by a Bachelor of Architecture degree in 1986, also from the University of Toronto. As such, she seeks opportunities to integrate art into LGA projects, like the segmented felt walls by Kathryn Walter at the Jamie Kennedy restaurant, and the frit-patterned windows by Melissa Levin at the Canterbury residence. To complement her busy architectural practice, Levitt has been heavily involved in teaching, and is currently an Adjunct Professor at the John H. Daniels Faculty of Architecture, Landscape and Design at the University of Toronto. She is frequently invited as a juror and guest critic, and has lectured extensively on a variety of topics such as environmental strategies for urban conditions, sustainable design and adaptive reuse. Janna Levitt founded LGA in 1992 with her husband Dean Goodman. The firm is responsible for numerous award-winning projects, such as the University of Waterloo School of Architecture in Cambridge (2004) and the Longhouse for Native Child and Family Services in Toronto (2010). Levitts current projects include the renovation and 25,000-square-foot expansion of the main branch of the Kitchener Public Library; a study for the redevelopment of the Scadding Court Community Centre; and an extensive landscape and residential project in Hoggs Hollow. In addition to professional memberships with the Royal Architectural Institute of Canada and the Ontario Association of Architects, Levitts keen interest in apiary culture motivated her to join the Ontario Beekeepers Association in 2009.
! W NE
2010 CertainTeed Corporation
TM
The only gypsum board that clears the air. Doesnt that feel better?
Indoor air contains many pollutants and volatile organic compounds (VOC*s). The VOC*s are found in furniture, carpets, cleaning materials, and many other everyday items. With the growing awareness of the importance of indoor air quality, particularly in hospitals, schools, ofces and residences, its time to clear the air. AirRenew is the only gypsum board that actively improves air quality. Permanently removes VOC*s by converting them into safe, inert compounds. Absorbs VOC*s for up to 75 years, even after multiple renovations, based on tests and analysis. Recyclable and works with most paint and wallpaper. Provides enhanced moisture and mold resistance using M2Tech technology. Only AirRenew improves air quality, providing a healthier environment and peace of mind for generations.
AirRenew captures VOC*s and converts them into inert compounds that cannot be released back into the air.
Visit www.AirRenew.com
* VOCs (volatile organic compounds) formaldehyde and other aldehydes.
WINNERS
5468796 Architecture Inc. is a Winnipeg architecture studio with a diverse range of interests. The firm was established in 2007 to challenge convention at all scales, from branding, architecture and design, to detailing and engineering
systems. Our collaborative studio (one desk, 12 practitioners) explores through conversation and play, models and mock-ups, drawings and revisions, and continuous inquiry. Counterclockwise from bottom left: Shannon Wiebe, Cristina
Ionescu, Zach Pauls, Mandy Aldcorn, Colin Neufeld, Sasa Radulovic, Johanna Hurme, Ken Borton, Sharon Ackerman, Aynslee Hurdal, Michelle Heath, Mark Penner.
Baird Sampson Neuert Architects is organized as a collaborative design studio led by the firms principals. The office has a longstanding interest in the interaction between building, site and community, using sustainability as a driver of innovation. Based in Toronto, it is a mid-sized practice with 15 staff, dedicated to the goals of design excellence and exceptional service. Left to right: Gavin Berman, Renee Leung, Ian Douglas, Jon Neuert, Harvey Wu, Barry Sampson, Jesse Dormody, Mauro Carreno, Andrea Macecek, Kamyar Rahimi, Germaine Hepburn, Yves Bonnardeaux.
Patkau Architects is an internationally recognized architectural design studio based in Vancouver, British Columbia. Principals John Patkau and Patricia Patkau are joined by three associates: David Shone, Peter Suter and Greg Boothroyd. In over
30 years of practice, both in Canada and in the United States, Patkau Architects has been responsible for the design of a wide variety of building types for a diverse range of clients. Current work includes a Visitors Centre at Fort York
National Historic Site in Toronto, the Marcel A. Desautel Faculty of Music and the School of Art at the University of Manitoba, the Goldring Centre for High-Performance Sport at the University of Toronto, as well as a variety of residential projects in diverse locations ranging from a northern island off the coast of British Columbia to a farm in AdDiriyyah, Saudi Arabia. As the circumstances of the work change, their interests expand. They seek to explore the full richness and diversity of architectural practice, understanding it as a critical cultural act that engages our most fundamental desires and aspirations. They refuse singular definitions of architecture: as art, as technology, as social service, as environmental agent, as political statement. They embrace all these definitions together, as part of the rich, complex and vital discipline that they believe architecture to be. Left to right: James Eidse, Luke Stern, Pat Patkau, John Patkau, Thomas Schroeder.
Atelier Big City (Anne Cormier, Randy Cohen, Howard Davies) is known for its innovative and often gregarious approach to architectural design. Two centres of interpretation built in eastern Quebec at Pabos Mills and Trois-Pistoles as well as a housing project on Paper Hill in Montreal (U2) demonstrate the groups desire to build provocatively yet also deal sensitively with issues related to site organization, construction, program and budget. The work of Big City is structured on a strong conceptual approach based on the interpretation of program and siting strategies. Of particular interest to the group is the notion of public space in buildings and the importance of the architectural promenade, a spatial journey animated by relations established between elements of the program, and between the built project and its environment. Each project is an exploration in generating an architectural milieu of grand sensual stimulation through the use of very simple means: colour, volume, material and structure. Atelier Big City has received a number of awards and honours including the Prix de Rome in 1998, and a Governor Generals medal in 2006 for their innovative
urban housing project entitled U2. Their work has been exhibited and presented through lectures in North America and in Europe. Atelier Big City are committed educators at the university level. Anne Cormier teaches and is the Director of the Universit de Montral cole darchitecture, while Randy Cohen teaches at the Universit
du Qubec Montral and at the Universit de Montral cole darchitecture. Howard Davies teaches at both McGill Universitys School of Architecture and at Concordia Universitys Department of Design and Computational Arts. Left to right: Traian Dima, Randy Cohen, Anne Cormier, Howard Davies, Sebastien St-Laurent.
Established in 1947, Smith Carter Architects and Engineers Incorporated has been an integrated firm virtually since its inception. Through its offices located in Winnipeg, Calgary, Ottawa and Atlanta, Smith Carter works with clients from government, institutions and private-sector organizations across Canada and around the world. Collaboration has facilitated innovation at Smith Carter and areas of expertise range across all types of complex projects, with specialties in the design of health-care and research facilities. Projects include: the Canadian Museum for Human Rights, a complex building designed and constructed completely with BIM (Building Information Modelling); Manitoba Hydro Place; and SC3, Smith Carters third purpose-built headquarters, winner of a Governor Generals
Award and the first building in Manitoba to achieve LEED Platinum certification. SC3 serves as a beta test site to investigate and develop new understandings of how buildings and people work. Arguably the most health-care-experienced architect in Canada, Parkin Architects Limited is a longstanding, award-winning leader in this highly specialized field, providing services to clients across Canada and internationally. Ninety percent of Parkins staff of over 100 architects, planners, designers and project managers are engaged solely in hospital commissions. Clients include some of the foremost institutions in Canada, many of which have worked with Parkin for over 20 years, and continue to return for their ongoing planning and design needs. In addition to the more traditional servi-
ces such as master planning, design of new and renovated buildings, site planning and project management, Parkin plays a significant leading role in strategic and operational planning with many of its clients. Smith Carter Architects and Engineers team members in above left photo, from left to right: Javier Uribe, Lynne WilsonOrr, Jaret Klymchuk, Jim Weselake, Bhavana Bonde, Tam Nguyen, Doug Corbett, Clifford Goodwill, Scott Stirton. Parkin Architects Limited team members in above right photo, from left to right: Sohail Akhtar, Chantal Trudel, Cameron Shantz, Jennifer Haliburton, Joy Raymer, Sarah Rahimaldeen, Oksana Posatskaya, Lynne WilsonOrr, Angelique Lucas-Witte, Farima Vahid.
13
Cannon Design is an ideas-based practice, ranked among the leading international firms in planning and design for health care, research, education, corporate, sports and government clients. At present, the firm employs a staff of over 1,000, delivering services in 17 offices throughout North America, as well as abroad in Shanghai and Mumbai. Cannon Design strives to create environments that are a thoughtful response to the program mission, physical setting and functional purpose, reflecting the spirit and person-
ality of each owner. The firm is focused on qualitywith client satisfaction as the ultimate measurement. Cannon Design works continuously to advance the state of the art, contributing to the built environment and quality of life of the people for whom it creates living and working spaces. Top row, left to right: Orest Klufas, Jorge Remolina, Vincent Yen, Marion La Rue, Winston Chong, Andrew King. Bottom row, left to right: Greg Fenske, Larry Podbora, Jennifer Beagan, James Wu. Founded in 1983 by Claude Provencher and Michel Roy, the Montreal architectural firm of Provencher Roy + Associs Architectes has won many awards for its work in Canada. During the 1990s, the initial partnership was strengthened with the appointment of Line Belhumeur and Alain Compera, and then in 2000 with the appointment of Marius Bouchardrenowned for his technical and legal knowledge. In 2005, Provencher Roy + Associs Architectes widened the breadth of its expertise with the addition of interior design firm Moureaux Hauspy + Associs, along with Beauchamp & Bourbeau, a firm that has built its reputation on a strong commitment to sustainable design. Today, the highly trained team of 105 multidisciplinary professionals apply their knowledge toward the design and construction of museums, universities, hospitals, hotels, airports, conference centres, corporate headquarters, and sports facilities. Additionally, urban planning, programming, feasibility studies, technical consultation, and interior and exhibition design are all part of the firms scope of services. Open-mindedness and an unwavering commitment to innovation have allowed the Provencher Roy team to adapt its practice to the major transformations that have shaped the firms design process. Left to right: Eugenio Carelli, Denis Gamache, Claude Provencher, Jean-Luc Rmy, Matthieu Geoffrion.
ALEXI HOBBS
Kongats Architects is gaining a national reputation for the innovation they bring to a wide range of important educational, cultural and public institutions. In addition to the University of Torontos Mississauga Academy of Medicine, current projects include Centennial Colleges Athletic and Wellness Centre, Lambton Art Gallery in Sarnia, and the Foundry District Energy Centre for Waterfront Toronto. The design work of the firm is rational and strictly edited to ensure the projects fundamental ambitions are never compromised while architecturally creating exceptional experiences for daily life. Offering an exceptional experience for daily life also means living in sync with our environment. Green building is an evident characteristic of the firms built projects and feasibility studies, reinforced by their ongoing research into the use of self-sustaining materials and building systems, and by an inventiveness in the design of the exterior building skin. The firms work has been honoured with several awards including a Canadian Architect Award of Excellence for Hespeler Library. In 2006, the firm was nominated for the prestigious New York Architectural Leagues Emerging Voices Prize. Their work has been featured extensively in various publications and has been exhibited in Canada and abroad. Clockwise from top left: Alar Kongats, Danielle Lam-Kulczak, Philip Toms, Sukie Leung, Alessia Soppelsa, David Sasaki. Missing from photo: Dieter Jensen, Andrea Ling, Derek McCallum, Tyler Walker, Steven Addeo, Tymea Sarkozy.
In 1995, Eric Pelletier co-founded Croft Pelletier architectes, where he evolved his skills as an architect through a variety of cultural and institutional projects, many of which have won awards. Some of the more significant buildings include the Charlesbourg Library, the Gaspsie Museum and the Montreal Planetarium. His work has been published widely, both in Quebec and Canada, as well as internationally. In 2009, Pelletier established his own architectural practice, Eric Pelletier architectes (EPA), taking with him the same dynamic and passionate team. The firm has since worked on numerous projects with a broad scope, including architecture, interior design, urban design, landscape design, furniture, exhibition and stage design, and even civil engineering. Recently, the firm received an honourable mention for their proposal for a new open-air amphitheatre in Trois-Rivires, the subject of an open competition. Left to right: Eric Pelletier, Amlie Turgeon, Annie Martineau. Cardinal Hardy (CHA) was founded in 1986 by Michel Hardy and Aurle Cardinal. Led by seven partners, the firm currently employs 70 full-time employees, including 36 architects, nine landscape architects and six urban designers, many with LEED accreditation. Five professionals teach at the university level in the field of urban design and landscape architecture. For the past several years, Cardinal Hardy has been most actively engaged in the rebirth of the Montreal waterfront. The success of the Old Port of Montreal, Cit du Multimdia, Quartier Concordia, and residential communities in Old Montreal and on the Lachine Canalare all the result of their commitment and planning efforts. The office specializes in landscape architecture, urban studies, restoration and recycling of historical sites and buildings, transportation, mixed-use projects and housing. As the firm strongly believes that successful planning is the product of teamwork and the collaborative effort of all professionals, they are particularly well-known for a multidisciplinary approach and for their rigour in urban planning. Cardinal Hardy has been recognized by numerous awards, such as National and Regional Merit
Awards from the Canadian Landscape Architecture Association, an Honour Award for the Waterfront Center in Washington, a Governor Generals Award for architecture, and a Prix dexcellence from the Ordre des Architectes du Qubec. Recently, the firm won the architecture competition for Les Bassins du Nouveau Havre, a master plan proposal of a sustainable mixed-use project for the old Canada Post site on the Lachine Canal. Les Architectes Labont Marcil was founded in 1986. Today, its two founding partnersPierre Labont and Jean Marcillead the 14-person firm. Their work focuses primarily on the cultural and institutional sectors, along with many heritage restoration projects. Labont Marcil is known for its
15
research and technical expertise, in addition to its project management skills. Its three core values focus on creativity, practicality and rationality. Eric Pelletier Architectes team members in top photo, from left to right: Eric Pelletier, Amlie Turgeon, Annie Martineau, Laura Didier, Emmanuelle Champagne, Olivier Bourgeois. Cardinal Hardy team members in above left photo, from left to right: Bao Nguyen, Claude Jean. Labont Marcil team members in above right photo, from left to right: Pierre Labont, Denis Clermont, Jean Marcil.
3.875
Jeffrey Ma was born in 1985 in Hong Kong, and graduated from the School of Architecture at McGill University in 2010, where he was awarded the Ray Affleck Prize in Design for distinction in his final thesis project. During the Masters program, he had the opportunity to participate in several speculative studios and theoretical courses with some of the most respected professors in the field of architecture. Amongst others, professors Alberto Prez-Gmez, Michael Jemtrud, Robert Claiborne, Torben Berns and Andrew King have changed his perception of architecture as a profession. Throughout the two years of his Master of Architecture degree, Ma was faced with the constant battle between logic, understanding and the built environment, from which his thesis entitled Logic Shift was derived. Further, his colleagues in the architecture program contributed significantly to the development of his thesis. Without the continuing dialogue with his colleagues and professors throughout the evolution of this project, Ma believes that Logic Shift would not have achieved the same degree of success.
Head Office and Showroom Location: 170 Esna Park Dr., #7, Markham, ON (905) 475-5460 (416) 491-2275 Out of Town 1-888-PERMAWD
Taraneh Meshkani recently received her Master of Architecture degree from the John H. Daniels Faculty of Architecture, Landscape and Design at the University of Toronto. Previously, she earned her undergraduate architecture degree from Azad University in Tehran, during which time she worked in several architectural firms. In 2008, Meshkani received the Professional Experience Program Award from the University of Toronto and was rewarded internships at Morphosis Architects and Kohn Pedersen Fox Associates. In 2009-2010, she received the Toronto Society of Architects scholarship, which is awarded to a graduating student of the Master of Architecture (M.Arch.) or Master of Urban Design (MUD) program whose thesis project demonstrates an innovative approach to city building and urban form. Meshkani is currently working on the topic of public and private spaces as a continuation of her research for her thesis project.
LAFITT ARCHITECTURAL SERIES

THE BEST WAY TO PREDICT THE FUTURE IS TO INVENT IT.
MODERN + VERSATILE + DURABLE + LEED COMPLIANT
SIXTY YEARS OF EXPERTISE IN CONCRETE PRODUCTS FOR MASONRY.
permaconpro.ca
CIRcLE REPLY CARD 17
If beauty is in the eye of the beholder...
Then behold.
Introducing the solid wood window with an iron clad, 50 YEAR warranty Accoya from Bonneville Windows and Doors. Renewable, Sustainable and 100% Recyclable Accoya from Bonneville offers the natural beauty, retained strength and hardness of wood with absolutely no chemical preservatives. Accoya is non-toxic, UV resistant, indigestible to insects and harder than Teak. An excellent addition to the Eastern White Pine, Douglas Fir and Western Red Cedar woods we now offer. Ask your Architect or Builder to spec Accoya from Bonneville today. The natural choice for those who demand quality, beauty, flexibility of design and a smaller carbon footprint. Log on to www.bonnevillewd.com or call 1-877-966-3202 for a dealer near you.
50 Year Wood Warranty
Accoya, Tricoya and the Trimarque Device are registered trademarks owned by Titan Wood Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary of Accsys Technologies PLC, and may not be used or reproduced without written permission.
BUILD A BETTER WORLD

Smart ideas, green buildings. Take your high-performance, energy-efcient designs to new heights with Canams ecological solutions. Together, we can build a better, more sustainable world. Let your creativity shape the future. Contact our architectural solutions experts at 1-877-499-6049 or online at www.canam-steeljoist.ws/contactus-architect
Canam, a world of green solutions for earth-friendly building projects!
A division of Canam Group

www.canam.ws/architects
AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
COTTAGES AT FALLINGWATER
ARCHITECT LOCATION
PATKAU ARCHITECTS INC. MILL RUN, PENNSYLVANIA
The larger ambition of this project is to stitch together a sense of community from a disparate set of existing buildings and a collection of frag mented and differentiated landscapes. The re tained meadowland above Fallingwater, which is the proposed site of six new cottages, is a frag ment of a recent cultural landscape. It provides a complementary experience to the surrounding native forest from which to appreciate and understand both native ecology and cultural hist ory. The meadow opens a clearing in the forest and within this clearing, the design of the six cot tages is intended to construct synergetic, sus tainable relationships between dwelling and the suns energy. Frank Lloyd Wrights Fallingwater is an ac knowledged architectural masterpiece, a signifi cant artifact of the cultural heritage of the last century. Other Conservancy buildings on the ex panded Fallingwater site are a collection of the vernacular and the architectural. All are inten tional and functional but unrelated and unrecog nizable as the presence of a community of com mon purpose. The introduction of the six new cottages could benefit the whole; they could act as a kind of glue, binding the community together, making linkages between things, setting parts into a new relationship with one another. The existing Conservancy buildings at Falling
water are linked together by the regional land scape of the Laurel Highlands, a gentle landform of swells and falls. No cottage here can compete with Wrights masterpiece. No building form can address the disparate assembly of current Con servancy building facilities. Faced with such a predicament, this project suggests that the six proposed cottages take on the role of the binding landscape, becoming part of the regional land form. In so doing, they add their own immediacy of swell and fall to that of the larger vistas and topographic histories. They have no need of as suming yet another form of architecture on site; they are part of the site. Cuts are made into the landscape: Sunset Cut opens the forest to occasion, and a Pond Cut is located northeast of the meadow, linked to both Sunset Cut and the assorted Conservancy build ings adjacent to the main trail crossing on Route 38. This large pond retains excess water on site, recycles treated wastewater back into the natural water cycle, and increases onsite biodiversity. An enlarged narrative for educational programs is suggested and an onsite source of building material is provided to facilitate the earthworks associated with cottage construction. Cottage form is an intensification of landscape form. Just as Fallingwater is an intensification of the rock outcroppings that characterize Bear Run, the meadow cottages are an intensification of the swelling ground plane of the meadow, made from the very soil and grasses of the meadow itself.
Each cottage forms a small ridge facing due south. In series, the cottages form swells and falls of landform, creating a sheltering microclimate of sunny prospect. Openings in the landforms connect cottage interiors to the meadowland beyond, silently and passively gathering the suns energy in the shoulder and winter seasons, shading openings and providing ventilation during the summers heat. Inside, the cottages are open in plan, gen erous with a sense of luminous space. Interiors are surfaced in lighttoned wood, grounded by concrete floors and sculpted by daylight. A large opening to the southern meadow focuses the living space, allowing easy access to an outdoor terrace. Bedrooms are more enclosed, with double or two single beds as required, and extra guests can sleep on the long couch in the living space. Sustainable building practices take the form of a Net Zero Energy strategy, achievable within the constraints of a modest budget and taking into account material choice, energy, water, and air quality considerations.
A RENDERED IMAGE OF ONE OF THE NEW COTTAGES THAT IS LITERALLY IMMERSED IN THIS SIGNIFICANT PENNSYLVANIA CULTURAL LANDSCAPE. OPPOSITE BOTTOM ONE OF THE MANY ANTICIPATED JET-SETTING ARCHITOURISTS ENJOYING HIS MORNING NEWSPAPER WHILE THE BEAUTY OF THE NATURAL WORLD SURROUNDS HIM.
BOTTOM
JC: This is a wonderful project that is a landscape
sculpture on the exterior, and a cavelike cocoon on the interiorin contrast to Wrights famous bold and open cantilevers over falling water.
AK: This project represents quiet excellence. The earthsheltered house is almost a must do of the critical architecture practice, an essential part of the repertoire. Its a tough challenge that de fines a designer. What this project bravely and succinctly does is almost nothing. It steps back, disappears and is nearing silence. It operates as a foil and counterpoint to the iconic presence of Fallingwater, receding into and becoming the landscape. It is defined only by a series of ele mental window and skylight voids, set into undu lating rows of berms. Within, the project is equally mute, allowing itself to sculpt space from the earth through light and simple undulations. This is a brave project, a John Cagelike sympho ny of almost nothing.
THE RETAINED MEADOWLAND NEAR FRANK LLOYD WRIGHTS FALLINGWATER WILL BE THE SITE OF SIX NEW COTTAGES DESIGNED BY PATKAU ARCHITECTS. RIGHT A SERIES OF DRAWINGS ILLUSTRATES THE PROCESS OF BUILDING AND BURYING THE NEW COTTAGES.
ABOVE
CLIENT WESTERN PENNSYLVANIA CONSERVANCY ARCHITECT TEAM JOHN PATKAU, PAT PATKAU, THOMAS SCHROEDER, LUKE STERN, JAMES EIDSE STRUCTURAL READ JONES CHRISTOFFERSEN LTD., ROBERT SILMAN ASSOCIATES LANDSCAPE MTR LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS LLC INTERIORS PATKAU ARCHITECTS SUSTAINABILITY CONSULTANT RECOLLECTIVE AREA 5,625 FT2 BUDGET $900,000 US COMPLETION TBD
JL: This proposal is really in the private realm,
and as such allows the architects much greater freedom of expression. They really ran with it very beautifully. I think it takes a very mature practitioner to tackle a design that so severely controls all views and infiltration of light. In ad dition, this is the only project this year that is multivalent in its reading: it is both a very build able proposition and it can also be appreciated as a speculative essay on a desirable way to live.
SECTION
21
AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
CAPILANO FILM CENTRE
ARCHITECT LOCATION
CANNON DESIGN NORTH VANCOUVER, BRITISH COLUMBIA
The design of the Capilano University Film Centre addresses many fundamental conceptual issuesincluding creating an environment where the study of film and its allied arts and technologies are fostered and nourished, as well as completing the campus as a legible, compelling and easily accessible building that acts as a gateway to the northern side of the campus. These primary issues form the foundation for the integrated design intent for the building form. The buildings purpose is the driver for many of the formal, spatial and material development design decisions in the work. Recognizing this, the building is defined as a machine for film. In this sense, it addresses notions of film on multiple levels. It becomes a device in support of the teaching of film, it creates moments of potentially cinematic power, and it acts on many scales as a metaphor for cinematic qualities and devices. This is based on an understanding of where architecture and cinema merge. This common ground is becoming increasingly understood as a powerful critical and conceptual generator of ideas and work in both disciplines. The project has a few undeniable givens. First is the very large sound stage component of the
building. This becomes the armature around which all the other building components must exist. Its placement is paramount for the functional considerations of the building, but this component gives little support for nuanced or delicate public spaces. Secondly, the project must navigate the larger-scale issues of maximum build-out, infrastructural access, and various pathways into the campus as a whole. Thirdly, the project has limited and definite program, budget and schedule requirements that cannot be exceeded under any circumstance. The design of the project evolved from a large, sound stage-driven object building into a delicate series of elevated bars and thin support components that wrap, skirt and rise over the massive sound stage element. These can be seen as three clear programmatic components with their own massing, material and special strategies. These are organized on the site such that they allow a large public plaza on the southwest quadrant of the site and a clearly defined conclusion to the primary north/south circulation path of the campus. The first of these primary programmatic components is the sound stage, which is pushed as far north and west as possible, allowing extensive vehicular access to the north. It has been seen as a black box, necessarily sealed and enclosed and as such is perceived as a massive concrete indus-
trial object. It becomes the foundation on and around which the remaining primary programmatic components are placed. The second of the components is the support spaces. These are placed as a screen or shroud around the southern and eastern faces of the sound stage, and include meeting rooms, support for the sound stage as well as extensive accessible circulation spaces. They are interconnected, multi-floor public spaces that tell the story of the building, comprising publicly accessible programming such as cafs, the primary screening room, and the various bridges and connections to the bus access, the north/south campus pathway, the landscape, and the public plaza. This building component is composed of glass and wood. The third primary building component is the elevated bar, which houses classrooms and smaller-scale spaces of learning. This sits atop the soundstage/support building components and pushes across the site to hover over the eastern side of the site, supported by a stair tower near its eastern end. It is the primary iconic component of the project, dramatically hanging across the site, 120 metres long, glazed to the south and north. The raised element defines a true gateway to the campus as the user actually moves under the bar in various ways. It allows protection and enclosure, defines the entry to the building as well as to the campus, and becomes
OPPOSITE TOP, LEFT TO RIGHT
INSPIRED BY A CAMERAS LENS, THE PROJECT IS DEFINED BY THE COMPOSITION OF APERTURES ALONG ITS AXES AND ELEVATIONS; THE SITE PLAN HIGHLIGHTS THE PROJECTS VIEWS; THE COMPLETED MASSING WITH ITS TWO HIGHLY ARTICULATED AXES. ABOVE, LEFT TO RIGHT A SERIES OF SKETCHES ILLUSTRATE THE PROJECTS DESIGN EVOLUTION.
but rather engages the creative possibilities of its academic program (film) and its context (buses, mountains, buildings) enhances its power as a gateway to the campus from the north and a formal terminus from the south.
JC: This project takes apart the traditional hermetic black-box type of solution for film studios and turns its program into a strong formal parti of open bars anchored by the closed sound stage. These long horizontal bars ground the entire project in response to the landscape and the rest of the campus in the best of the West Coast traditions. AK: Andrew King recused himself from commentary and judging due to his professional association with this project. JL: This is a juicy building type that every archi-
an iconic symbol for the university. This building component is defined in steel and glass, with its extensive exposed structural strategy, zinc cladding and glass screen-like faades addressing the exterior public spaces. The fact that the building does not act neutrally
OPPOSITE BOTTOM, LEFT TO RIGHT
conscious building in the best possible way, as the site, construction technique, conjoining of program and meaning are all equally rendered. The architects have resisted the temptation to become too literal by simply employing cinematic techniquessplicing, framing, editing, croppingto assign architectural meaning. Rather, they have done the really difficult work of drilling down to express these attributes in architectural spaces.
CLIENT BILL THUMM, CAPILANO UNIVERSITY ARCHITECT TEAM ANDREW KING, LARRY PODHORA, JAMES WU, WINSTON CHONG, JORGE REMOLINA, DAVE REEVES, VINCENT YEN, JONSCOTT KOHLI, MARION LA RUE, OREST KLUFAS, JENNIFER BEAGAN, WIL WIENS, GREG FENSKE STRUCTURAL EQUILIBRIUM CONSULTING INC. (ERIC KARSH) MECHANICAL AERIUS ENGINEERING (GEOFF MCDONELL) ELECTRICAL MMM GROUP ( ANDREW TASHIRO) CIVIL DELCAN (COLIN KRISTIANSEN) LANDSCAPE PWL PARTNERSHIP ( CHRIS STERRY) GEOTECHNICAL HORIZON ( TROY ISSIGONIS) CODE CONSULTANT LMDG ( GEOFF TRIGGS) COST CONSULTANT BTY ( TOBY MALLINDER, ELLIS PANG) AREA 97,000 FT2 BUDGET $37 M COMPLETION APRIL 2011
A SERIES OF COMPUTER RENDERINGS HELPS ARTICULATE THE STRUCTURES LINEARITY AND RHYTHM WHILE INCORPORATING CINEMATIC METAPHORS OF COMPRESSED SPACE, MONTAGE AND COLLAGE.
tect wants to tackle! The Film Centre is a self-
23
AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
BLOC_10
ARCHITECT LOCATION
5468796 ARCHITECTURE INC. WINNIPEG, MANITOBA
Bloc_10 is a condominium project situated on a busy Winnipeg corridor. Each of the 10 units is a distinct three-storey walkup with expansive interior spaces that traverse the site as they ascend each level. This allows occupants to have views in at least two directions within their unit, as well as making eight of the 10 units into three-sided corner suites. Conceived as white box layouts, a strict service core contains all mechanical services and circulation space. This frees the open living spaces to accommodate a wide range of layout opportunities.
Dotted across each elevation are cantilevered projections that extend the floor plates for a variety of expanded living spaces. Alternating with the projections are intermediate decks crisscrossing the faade, shielded from the street by a vertical wood screen. The standard three-storey walkup building typology is distortedto instead provide 10 unique layouts that are distributed across and through the site.
JC: It is an extremely fresh and innovative solu-
ABOVE
A VIEW LOOKING DOWN NIAGARA STREET. BOTTOM A SERIES OF VIGNETTES THAT EMPHASIZE THE UNITS ADAPTABILITY.
within a single unit is extremely inventive and appropriate on a busy corridor.

AK: This project represents excellence through redefinition. The low-rise condominium project is not often the context for the redefinition of architectural experience. The forces at play are powerful and the momentum is often away from innovation and experimentation. Bloc_10 unpacks completely the way in which multi-unit projects are conceptualized, redefining much of
tion to perhaps the most common and mundane form of the three-storey walkup wood-frame apartment typology. It is both simple and complex. Multiple orientations and spatial diversity
CORE
BLOC
SHELL
SCREEN
COMPONENTS DIAGRAM
HW
HVAC
AIR WATER POWER SERVICES DIAGRAM
our preconceived ideas on how a habitation project is conceived and developed. Program is challenged through entry sequences, building and unit circulation and unit room adjacencies. As a result, notions of house are challenged through the resulting lack of unit definition and identity. Bloc_10 is that achievement within critical architecture: a usable, workable, beautiful and compelling experiment that teaches us all something.
JL: This is a very canny, intelligent tweak of the
ABOVE
EACH OF THE THREE-STOREY CONDOS HAS VIEWS IN AT LEAST TWO DIRECTIONS. EIGHTY PERCENT OF THE DEVELOPMENT COMPRISES THREE-SIDED CORNER UNITS. BOTTOM LEFT AN AXONOMETRIC DRAWING DESCRIBING THE ASSEMBLAGE OF THE 10 DISTINCT UNITS.
conventional (and I mean this in a positive way) stick-frame three-storey residential walkup typology. The functionalist aesthetic is upended with the inventive sectional drawing thats like a riff of Hollywood Squares, illustrating how the design can host a panoply of independent activities.
CLIENT BLOC10 DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, MARK PENNER, KORWYNN BUHLER ARCHITECT TEAM SHARON ACKERMAN, MANDY ALDCORN, MARIA AMAGATSU, KEN BORTON, MICHELLE HEATH, AYNSLEE HURDAL, JOHANNA HURME, CRISTINA IONESCU, GRANT LABOSSIERE, COLIN NEUFELD, ZACH PAULS, SASA RADULOVIC, SHANNON WIEBE STRUCTURAL LAVERGNE DRAWARD & ASSOCIATES MECHANICAL G.D. STASYNEC & ASSOCIATES LTD. ELECTRICAL MCW AGE CONSULTING PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERS CONTRACTOR GREENSEED DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AREA 11,000 FT2 BUDGET $1.5 M COMPLETION 2011
25
AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
WOMEN AND NEWBORN HOSPITAL
SMITH CARTER ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS INCORPORATED IN ASSOCIATION WITH PARKIN ARCHITECTS LOCATION WINNIPEG, MANITOBA
ARCHITECT
ABOVE
THE HOSPITALS MAIN ENTRANCE AT THE CORNER OF WILLIAM AVENUE AND SHERBROOK STREET IS OPEN AND WELCOMING, AS THE BULK OF THE BUILDING IS LIFTED TWO STOREYS ABOVE GRADE, SUPPORTED BY PLAYFULLY ANGLED COLUMNS.
The Women and Newborn Hospital will replace the existing Womens Pavilion at the Health Sciences Centre (HSC) campus constructed over 60 years ago. The 173-bed facility has a floor area of 37,000 square metres and is designed with the patient and family in mind. The building is a five-storey structure above one level of underground parking for patient use. An overhead link and underground tunnel connect the new hospital to the campus, linkages required for critical medical support services and connection to the central power plant systems. There are no significant surrounding buildings that directly inform the design of the new building. The east and south faades will be the public faces of the new hospital. Conceptually, they will be transparent, delicate, well-detailed, and reflective of the womens health programs contained within. The design intent is to simplify the number of different materials in
the building, using products that relate to the existing scale, texture, and character of the neighbourhood. With this in mind, the building will utilize high-performance unitized fritted curtain wall and shingled zinc cladding. Green roofs will reduce rainwater runoff and provide a natural outdoor environment for patient and staff views. A dramatic and welcoming two-storey main entrance and covered dropoff area will occupy the corner of William Avenue and Sherbrook Street. Further, the south faade of the building will have a striking integrated photovoltaic array enclosing a three-storey staff lounge suspended above the entry on levels three to five that will form the architectural signature corner. Using a public consultation process, three principles were identified to guide the design such that the new building should be a place to serve the unique and diverse health-care needs of women through the life cycle; a place to advance care, through excellence in research and education; and a place that is welcoming, respectful, calming and peaceful. Fundamentally, the design is rooted in the philosophy of patient and family-centred care, environmental sustainability, and accommodation of the many different cultures of Manitoba and downtown Winnipeg. A central atrium stair orients and guides patients and families to clinic areas. Consolidation and organization of medical services is another important feature of the design. One of the most significant improvements over the existing hospital is the inclusion of a 60-bed Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU). The site is located at the northeast corner of the HSC campus. In the context of the neighbourhood, this will be an important edge to the campus, as it interfaces with the community and provides an opportunity for the HSC to create a welcoming image for the campus. The critical design interface is oriented towards the residential properties on the north side of Elgin Avenue, and the building massing responds to the West Alexander and Centennial Neighbourhood Plan. The plan requires a landscaped front yard to
match the residential zoning, and a tapered faade as the building height increases to preserve sunlight and reduce the scale. The height is also restricted to five storeys, with no vehicular access off Elgin Avenue. Winnipeg has the largest remaining urban elm forest in North America. This is due to an ongoing unique banding program initiated locally when Dutch Elm Disease was first detected on the continent. The canopy created by the elm branches on the neighbourhood streets is striking and precious. This became the design concept for the building faade along Sherbrook Street. The building is targeting LEED Gold certification and includes plans for 100-percent fresh air in the building, as opposed to recirculated air. Heatwheel technology to reclaim heat and recycled materials from the deconstructed Weston Bakery on site are key sustainable features. Specifically, the most important sustainable criteria will be indoor environmental quality which will include air quality, an abundance of natural daylighting, and low VOC-emitting materials, all for the health, comfort and productivity of occupants. The interior design is feminine, sensitive to the needs of women, warm to the touch and gently exhilarating to the eye. Passive daylighting strategies have been incorporated throughout the buildingmost significantly through a large atrium that penetrates all floors. A womans need for privacy has been addressed by an entrance for new mothers separated from those used by women and families experiencing loss or other potentially devastating health issues. The building envelope is conceived as a skin, conveying support and enclosure. It is easily maintainable in the context of the severe Winnipeg climate and gritty urban location. Simplicity of design, longevity of materials, and efficient systems are the underlying objectives; the concept of biomimicry is used to design and construct a building that will function as elegantly and efficiently as a flower, a building informed by its eco-regions native characteristics.
JC: Hospital programs are complex and rigid, which often results in cold
and hard objects that relate to neither patient comfort nor context. This project demonstrates that hospital design can be elevated to another level of excellence.
AK: The urban hospital can be the anathema of critical architecture. It is a building type so subservient to its program, the orthodoxy of planning strategies, the relationship between patients and users, and the terrifyingly complex matrix of functional demands, that the normative challenges of compelling space and form often recede in priority and investment. This project delicately and convincingly finds the cracks where moments of excellence can take root. Through careful and compelling manipulation of the ground plane, massing at grade, public space, and urban linkages, it defines a delightful series of moments where the user and the building meet. It is good urbanity and good space acting in concert to engage the user. The project uses equally compelling strategies of transparency/opacity along the faade to animate and define the addition while respecting and clarifying the existing context, creating an identity that balances the complexity of the building with the necessary legibility of the building type. This project takes the urban hospital as an opportunity to redefine its context, and to delight users who are often most in need of it. JL: This project provoked a very important discussion about how we define
ABOVE, TOP TO BOTTOM THE HOSPITALS MAIN ENTRANCE; THE NORTH ELEVATION IN THE CONTEXT OF ELGIN AVENUE; A PHOTOMONTAGE OF THE NORTHEAST CORNER IN ITS URBAN CONTEXT.
excellence. The architects of this building took on a very difficult mandate which is to open up the ground floor of the hospital. In doing so, they virtually inverted the type as it is currently designed which is, typically, hermetic. In addition, they extended their reach to the landscape and made a very open and civic institution. Thats a remarkable achievement.
CLIENT PROVINCE OF MANITOBA/WINNIPEG REGIONAL HEALTH AUTHORITY/HEALTH SCIENCES CENTRE ARCHITECT TEAM SMITH CARTER ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS INCORPORATED (PRIME CONSULTANT): SCOTT STIRTON, JIM WESELAKE, DOUG CORBETT, JARET KLYMCHUK, JAVIER URIBE, LORI PENNER, LARRY HAMILTON, BHAVANA BONDE, RON PIDWERBESKY, DONNA TODD, GEOFF BULMER, PHILIP HARMS, TAM NGUYEN, CLIFFORD GOODWILL, DANIEL MELENDEZ, GALEN JOHNSON. PARKIN ARCHITECTS (HEALTH-CARE PLANNING AND CLINICAL AREAS DESIGN): LYNNE WILSON-ORR, CAMERON SHANTZ, SOHAIL AKHTAR, CHANTAL TRUDEL, ANGELIQUE LUCAS-WITTE, JENNIFER HALIBURTON, FARIMA VAHID. STRUCTURAL CROSIER KILGOUR AND PARTNERS MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL SMS ENGINEERING LANDSCAPE/INTERIORS SMITH CARTER ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS ARCHITECTURAL RENDERING NORM LI AG+I PHOTOGRAPHY SMITH CARTER ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS INC./DAVID LIPNOWSKI AREA 280,000 FT2 BUDGET N/A COMPLETION FALL 2014
27
AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
ARCHITECT LOCATION
ATELIER BIG CITY MONTREAL, QUEBEC
U is the third project developed over the years in relation to the Unity Building, a historic property situated on Paper Hill in Montreal. It is a 77-unit housing project, with mixed commercial and professional spaces on the lower levels, and an important urban courtyard space. U is inspired by diverse Montreal typologies: the deeply set-back entrance evokes Montreals typical porte cochre and helps articulate a proper sense of arrival, comprising a drop-off, parking entry, and the principal access to offices on the lobby mezzanine. A three-storey-high gymnasium space is situated above the entry hall, with 30 small studio apartments grouped around this vertical atrium. An exterior courtyard contains the circulation for the upper eight floors of the building. The morphology of the new building responds to that of the Unity building and Unity 2. The alignment of the cornice is respected, and the entrance is reminiscent of the tall double-height lobby of Unity 2. U offers varying views up and down rue de la Gauchetire as it bends along the
St. Jacques ridge. The envelope is an interpretation of a contemporary curtain wall. Floor-to-ceiling windows of mullion-free glazing, with coloured glass spandrel panels and Stanstead granite vertical piers, seamlessly hug the faceted form. An architecturally sensitive issue, the faade of the new project distinguishes itself clearly from its neighbours while addressing their architectural characteristics subtly and significantly. Great care is taken in developing a particular relationship with the Unity Building. An architectural reveal is created at the junction between the two buildings that follows the advancing and retreating movements of the new faade, revealing at times the red brick and concrete frame of the Unity Building. As a vertical city, this project is structured upon the transformative qualities of the inner courtyard typology. A four-storey-deep service core is located in the parking spiral, and a twostorey mall space contains the lobby, business centre, and commercial heart of the project. The first three floors of studio apartments surround the gym/atrium, while the majority of residential units are organized around the outdoor terrace/
circulation spine. Extending out from the courtyard faade is a staccato sequence of light wells, privacy screens and handrails arranged in such a way that daylight can penetrate deep within the courtyard, and the boundaries between public and private domains are maintained. The project emphasizes quality, and the generously sized apartments feature imported fixtures,
SECTION
OPPOSITE
THE UNDULATING FAADE OF U IS A DYNAMIC JUXTAPOSITION TO UNITY 2, AN EARLIER PROJECT ALSO DESIGNED BY ATELIER BIG CITY AND COMPLETED IN THE FALL OF 2005. ABOVE, LEFT TO RIGHT AS IN UNITY 2, US INTERIOR COURTYARD PLAYS AN IMPORTANT ROLE IN PROMOTING LIVELY GROUND-FLOOR ACTIVITY IN THIS DEVELOPMENT.
pre-fab kitchens, closets and door units to create fluid interior environments.
JC: It is often very difficult to push the bound-
aries in high-density multi-family projects. This project excels in all aspects, from the formal resolution of the faade to the innovative unit planning and stacking, resulting in the sophisticated resolution of urban infill.
AK: The high-density commercial housing project
is an enigma within architectural history. Moments of brilliance have emerged from what is generally considered a context for, at best, unrealized potential, or worst, fodder for the marketplace. Creating excellence within this context demands thoughtful strategies and a cunning sense of priority. This project is a superlative example of what can happen when a talented design team has a mature understanding of typology and context in addtion to the making of commercially viable housing. As such, it creates an intensely interesting faade that is tied to unit amenities, a compelling and powerful entry sequence and a complex series of shared public spaces. The project creates its own opportunities and then exploits them in a very mature, convincing and rigorous way.
JL: This is a truly outstanding designintelligent,
AXONOMETRICS
ISONOMETRIC
careful, and sparegrammatically correct keeps coming to mind. The variegation of the front elevation is a four-for-one story, relating the con-
temporary with the heritage, offering individual identity within a larger whole, which gives an urban edge and an exegesis of curtain-wall potential. The fact that the architects convinced the developer to do an interior courtyard and a primarily single-loaded corridor proves their commitment to pushing a high-level architectural goal with every project.
CLIENT FEDERICO BIZZOTTO ARCHITECT TEAM HOWARD DAVIES, RANDY COHEN, SEBASTIEN ST. LAURENT, TRAIAN DIMA STRUCTURAL SILVERIO MARZIN MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL BLONDIN FORTIN AREA 90,000 FT2 BUDGET $9 M COMPLETION TBD
11
6 10 6 10 10 6 6 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 ENTRY PUBLIC CORRIDOR OFFICE GYM RETAIL EXTERIOR WALKWAY 7 ROCK GARDEN 8 STORAGE LOCKERS 9 TERRACE 10 APARTMENTS 11 PENTHOUSE 12 PARKING 1 5 12 12 12 12 9
4 2 7 8 8 8 8 0 10M AXONOMETRIC OF THE URBAN BLOCK
29
AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
BRIAN C. NEVIN WELCOME CENTER, CORNELL PLANTATIONS
ARCHITECT LOCATION
BAIRD SAMPSON NEUERT ARCHITECTS CORNELL UNIVERSITY, ITHACA, NEW YORK
Sited within Cornell Universitys botanical garden, the Welcome Center and related site improvements provide integrated visitor and educational experiences that advance the identity of Plantations as a green garden. A new organizational framework was developed for the overall garden that reinforces the primacy of the existing topography, vegetated states, and resulting spatial conditions. This framework establishes an armature that interconnects existing formal and naturalized garden systems, and anticipates ongoing garden development. The components of this Stage 1 project consist of a 6,000-square-foot visitor services and education center, parking facility, fire access route, and stormwater bioswale. These components emerged through an extended facility and garden planning effort undertaken at the outset of the project. This compact botanical garden possesses an extraordinary topography. The southern edge of the site is defined by an expansive bowl, and a glacial knoll defines its northern edge. Both of these landforms are planted with naturalized vegetation and are criss-crossed by a series of curvilinear pathways that negotiate steep grades. Flatland extends between these two naturalized landforms, and contains a geometric patchwork of plots, formal
gardens and a surface parking lot which currently occupies the central region of the site. Conceived as a pavilion that forms an integral part of the garden experience, the Center is sited deep within the garden at the transition between flatland and knoll where a series of existing pathways converge. Organized into two levels that respond to these two topographic conditions, the lower level of the Center forms an active terrace that accommodates visitor service needs. Educational and events programming are located on the upper level within a flexible multipurpose space. Both levels are organized to connect with outdoor terraces that facilitate programmatic and spatial extensions between architectural and landscape environments. Parking facilities are relocated to the periphery of the site adjacent to established planting. Organized in response to the curved landform of the surrounding bowl, the new parking lot and arrival terrace engage pedestrian linkages from the main campus, and consolidate systems for visitors arriving by foot, bicycle, car, tour bus and public transit. This common point of arrival promotes visitor orientation and interpretation of the facilitys objectives, and directs visitors along a new route that extends between arrival terrace, the Welcome Center and the adjoining campus community. The legible passage of water across the site, the expression of its containment and on-site use, the dependence of plants and people on waterall
PLANTATION MAP
CLIENT PLANTATIONS BOTANICAL GARDEN, CORNELL UNIVERSITY ARCHITECT TEAM JON NEUERT, YVES BONNARDEAUX, HARVEY WU, ANDREA MACECEK, TEDDY BENEDICTO, WINDA LAU, CYRIL CHARRON, HUGH CLARK, JESSE DORMODY STRUCTURAL BLACKWELL BOWICK ENGINEERING MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL M&E ENGINEERING CIVIL TG MILLER ENGINEERING LANDSCAPE HALVORSEN DESIGN PARTNERSHIP SUSTAINABILITY/LEED CONSULTANT BAIRD SAMPSON NEUERT ARCHITECTS AREA 6,000 FT2 + 3.2 ACRES SITEWORK BUDGET $5.5 M INCLUDING SITEWORK AND SERVICING COMPLETION JANUARY 2011
provides a thematic framework that extends through the site, linking new and existing gardens, landscape and architectural environments, advancing the projects educational objectives and green garden mandate. Building materials are used in an elemental manner to advance the idea of an interior topography. Stone is deployed to engage, manipulate and retain the ground plane, and extends the system of dry-laid garden walls used extensively throughout the site. Wood is deployed as an overhead element that provides shelter and modulates light. An expansive ipe louvre extends across the southern face of the building, unifying the faade of the building while providing passive solar shading for the south-facing glazing. Opaque portions of exterior wood walls and roof are super-insulated using spray foam insulation. A rooftop solar thermal system is connected to an in-floor radiant heating system, supplying 80% of the buildings heating needs. Operating systems are designed to achieve an overall 49% energy reduction, addressing all energy optimization credits within the LEED rating system, exceeding current Architecture 2030 Challenge benchmarks.
JC: This beautiful facility is a highly sophisticated and sensitive insertion
into an existing university botanical garden by an architect in full control of his craft. The finely resolved building with simple materials, mediating between a knoll and the flatland, is also highly environmentally responsive.
AK: This project represents excellence and the sublime, in that the sublime context is a mixed blessing. The Welcome Center is located in a place of beauty and its job is to curate our experience of that place in a variety of ways. It must somehow find a presence within this beauty without undermining it. It would, at best, do all this and function as a meaningful public amenity; it exceeds the highest of these expectations. Through architecture, it evidences how truly meaningful the landscape/architecture construct can be. The Welcome Center relates to the landscape in myriad ways. As an object, it emerges from, nestles within, frames and defines views to the landscape. As a curatorial device, it discusses the history, potential and ecological systems of the site. As a spatial construct, it beautifully moves one through spaces and sequences that heighten ones understanding of the building, and of the world the building inhabits. This project achieves the highest aspirations of architecture by moving beyond it. JL: This project represents such a successful architectural act of honouring a
26
DR
IV E
landscape precisely by the surgical insertion of a beautifully scaled and articulated building without in any way deferring to the natural elements. There isnt one false note or cloying move. In addition, this is one of the submissions where every drawing, diagram and image serves to illuminate an intention.
OPPOSITE TOP
HO
15 14 13 11 8 7 6 2
AD
16
18
JUD
LL D FA
RE
ST
FO
17 12 19
AD S RO
10 20 5 3 23 21 4 22
PL AN TA
A RENDERING ILLUSTRATING THE VEW FROM THE BOTANICAL GARDENS TO THE ENTRY COURT AND EXTERIOR CAF. TOP RIGHT THE EXHIBITION HALL LEADING TOWARDS THE ENTRY COURT. ABOVE RIGHT THE ENTRANCE VESTIBULE AND GIFT SHOP IN THE EXHIBITION HALL.
10 ROADWAY AND PEDESTRIAN PATH 11 ENTRY COURT 12 SEASONAL TERRACE 13 WELCOME CENTER 14 KNOLL PLATEAU 15 PAVILION 16 LEWIS BUILDING 17 CONTAINER GARDEN 18 ROBISON YORK HERB GARDEN 19 20 21 22 23 24 YOUNG FLOWER GARDEN MULLESTEIN WINTER GARDEN GARDENS EVENT LAWN TREE GROVE POUNDER HERITAGE VEGETABLE GARDEN 25 MCCLINTOCK SHED 26 BEEBE LAKE
O TI N S RO
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
VEHICLE ENTRANCE/EXIT ARRIVAL PLAZA URBAN FOREST RAIN GARDEN WALKWAY AND PEDESTRIAN BRIDGES RAIN GARDEN/BIOSWALE NEW STORMWATER OUTFALL PATHWAY ROCK GARDEN/ALPINE PLANTS TRANSITIONAL GARDEN
1 25 24
SITE PLAN CONCEPT
100
31
GA-2002/0070
ED-0009/2010
1968 Social environmental movements take hold.
WHO SHAPES THE FUTURE OF GREEN DESIGN?

You do.
1978 Earth Day brings awareness to Earths need for continual care.
What was once a quiet evolution has become a revolutionary force. Your desire for sustainable design has helped redefine the meaning of green. Since we began making nora rubber flooring over 50 years ago, weve evolved with you. Your concern for the environment continues to create new standards for designing in harmony with nature. It is why we continually explore ways to blend the best of technology with greener thinking.
1988 1,000 communities in America initiate curbside recycling.
1998 EPA launches voluntary programs for energy, water, indoor air quality, waste and smart growth.
It starts with you. You and your challenges. You and your world. You and nora.
2008 U.S. Green Building Council member organizations grow to 15,000.
800-332-NORA www.nora.com/us/green34
Follow us: @noraflooring
AWARD OF MERIT
MISSISSAUGA ACADEMY OF MEDICINE
KONGATS ARCHITECTS UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO, MISSISSAUGA, ONTARIO

ARCHITECT LOCATION
ABOVE
THE MASSING OF THE MULTI-TIERED FACILITY IS INTENDED TO CREATE A MORE HUMANE AND INTIMATE SCALE. LEFT A DETAIL OF THE STAINLESS STEEL FINS.
The new Mississauga Academy of Medicine (MAM) at the University of Toronto Mississauga will accommodate teaching and research facilities for the new medical program to be based out of the Mississauga campus. The campus is home to several recent and important buildings that have been recognized for their excellence in design: the Student Centre; the Communications, Culture and Technology Building; the Hazel McCallion Academic Learning Centre; and Erindale Hall. The MAM is the first of three proposed new buildings within the University of Toronto Mis-
sissaugas South Campus. These three buildings, together with the constructed Hazel McCallion Learning Centre and CCT Building, will define a new academic quad for the campus. The MAM is situated on sloped terrain rising up from the outer campus defined by Ring Drive, and will landmark the entrance to the proposed academic quad. The shifting floor plates of the MAM accentuate the soft landscape to the east, south and west, while the Health Science Centres north face in its vertical uniformity provides a more formal faade to the academic quad. The faceted faades of stainless steel will capture both natural
LEVEL 5 LEVEL 4 LEVEL 3 LEVEL 2 LEVEL 1 LEVEL 0 7
8 3
8 3
2 2 2
2 5
4 7
SECTION 1 2 3 4 LECTURE THEATRE CLASSROOM FACULTY OFFICE MEETING ROOM
10M
0m
5 6 7 8
LOUNGE/KITCHENETTE LABORATORY TERRACE GREEN ROOF
10m
and ambient artificial light, ensuring its landmark presence is articulated day and night. The innovative design provides an iconic image for this newest branch of the University of Torontos Academy of Medicine that exemplifies the facultys high level of education and professionalism in the fields of medicine and research. The program for the new Academy of Medicine includes video conference-ready lecture theatres and a studio, classrooms, seminar rooms, faculty offices and an instructional laboratory. The lecture theatres and studio will be connected to the University of Toronto St. George Medical Sciences Building, Trillium Health Centre and Credit Valley Hospital for shared lectures and communication. The new facility will also house the faculties of Biomedical Communications, Anthropology and Forensics, including faculty offices, studios and research laboratories. A skin of glass and undulating stainless steel fins wrap a series of stacked boxes that step up the existing hill of the site. These boxes enlarge and shrink from floor to floor to suit the program
CLOCKWISE FROM BELOW
requirements, with a focus on maximizing views and access to daylight. The residual interstitial outdoor spaces created between the stacked boxes will accommodate accessible terraces and indigenously planted roof gardens with protective overhangs for the occupants on each floor. The project is currently under construction, and will be open for classes in the Fall of 2011.
JC: The development of the glass skin and undu-
scheme. However, this is one of the submissions that suffered from a lack of information both with the graphic material and the text. It made it virtually impossible for the jury to independently verify the architects assertions about such items as innovation and site appropriateness.
lating stainless steel fins is the most interesting aspect of this project.
AK: At its essence, this project is a tough program box with a delicate skin. It effectively achieves what great architecture often aspires to: understanding and assessing a complex and challenging program to the degree that a great building can emerge. This project is defined by very clear, nuanced and beautiful formal and tectonic strategies. Its completeness is evidenced by its structural strategies, its spatial sequencing, and most succinctly in the articulation of its skin. It ultimately acts as a very serious object in a context that is perhaps a bit too architecturally selfconscious, showing the depth that the discipline can achieve without flourish or whimsy. JL: The stainless steel crenellated fins in contrast
CLIENT UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO ARCHITECT TEAM ALAR KONGATS, DANIELLE LAM-KULCZAK, PHILIP TOMS, DIETER JENSEN, DAVE SASAKI, ALESSIA SOPPELSA, SUKIE LEUNG, ANDREA LING, DEREK MCCALLUM, TYLER WALKER, STEVEN ADDEO, ERIC VAN ZIFFLE, TYMEA SARKOZY STRUCTURAL HALSALL ASSOCIATES LIMITED MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL CROSSEY ENGINEERING LTD. LANDSCAPE CORBAN AND GOODE INTERIORS KONGATS ARCHITECTS CONTRACTOR HARBRIDGE + CROSS LIMITED SITE SERVICES MBM CONSULTING INC. ACOUSTICS ENGINEERING HARMONICS LABORATORY WATSON MACEWEN TERAMURA ARCHITECTS CODE CONSULTANT RANDAL BROWN & ASSOCIATES LTD. PROJECT MANAGER PMX INC. AREA 64,155 FT2 BUDGET $25 M COMPLETION MARCH 2011
BUILDING SERVICES LEVEL 5
TWO RENDERED VIGNETTES ILLUSTRATE TWO DIFFERENT APPROACHES TO THE BUILDING; ONE VERSION OF THE ACADEMYS DISTINCTIVE FINS, BETWEEN WHICH STUDENTS CAN BE SEEN SOCIALIZING ON THE OUTDOOR TERRACE.
RESEARCH LABS ANATOMY LABS
LEVEL 4
to the curtain wall is a beautiful moment in the

VP OF RESEARCH BIOMEDICAL COMMUNICATIONS ANTHROPOLOGY FORENSIC SCIENCE
LEVEL 3
MEDICAL ACADEMY ADMINISTRATION FACULTY OFFICES PBLS
LEVEL 2
MEDICAL ACADEMY CLASSROOMS & LECTURE THEATRE VIDEO-CONFERENCING STUDIO
LEVEL 1
LEVEL 0
BUILDING SERVICES
SITE AXONOMETRIC
35
AWARD OF MERIT
CANADIAN ART PAVILION, MUSE DES BEAUX-ARTS DE MONTRAL

ARCHITECT LOCATION
PROVENCHER ROY + ASSOCIS ARCHITECTES MONTREAL, QUEBEC
Since its founding in 1860, the Muse des BeauxArts de Montral (Montreal Museum of Fine Arts) has moved and expanded a number of times. Its growth, in the form of pavilions, has always evolved from a profound reflection on museum architecture. The Michal and Renata Hornstein Pavilion, the Liliane and David M. Stewart Pavilion, and the Jean-Nol Desmarais Pavilion are all tectonic expressions of strong museological visions inspired by cultural and technical concerns specific to the periods in which they were built. The new pavilion is also in keeping with this tradition of continuity and proposes a distinct expression that reflects todays concerns and knowledge. The result is the dynamic integration of a heritage building with an architectural whole that has a strong presence in the urban environment, utilizes the latest museum-building techniques, and creates a harmonious dialogue with the other museum buildings. It does not, however, fall back on stylistic mimicry. The transformation of the Erskine and American Church and the construction of the new Canadian Art Pavilion for the Muse des BeauxArts de Montral demonstrates the museums willingness to preserve the heritage of our built environment while pursuing its goal of preserving and publicly exhibiting Canadian artwork dating all the way back to the 17th century. The project satisfies contemporary museum requirements and blends harmoniously with its existing architectural whole, providing a unique opportunity to create an exceptionally rich heritage environment while legitimately integrating the Erskine and American Church with the museums permanent collection of Canadian art. The Muse des Beaux-Arts de Montral was relocated to its current location on rue Sherbrooke in 1912, after having spent more than 50 years on Phillips Square. In constant need of more exhibition space, the museum developed as a campus-style urban typology. Three new buildings were constructed, each with a contemporary approach to form, materials, technique
TOP LEFT
LOOKING EAST TOWARD RUE SHERBROOKE, THE NEW CANADIAN ART PAVILION IS SEEN FROM AVENUE DU MUSE. LEFT A CUTAWAY VIEW ILLUSTRATING THE COMPLETE ADDITION AND RENOVATION TO THE ERSKINE AND AMERICAN CHURCH.
and spatial organization. Built across the street in the early 1990s, the Jean-Nol Desmarais Pavilion was established with its underground gallery, and a tightly knit cultural network in this dense urban area emerged. In 2004, the museum acquired the Erskine and American Church and selected it as the home of the new Canadian Art Pavilion. The project includes five new exhibition halls and an underground gallery linking the existing network to a new concert hall in the church. Modelled as a journey through time, the exhibition halls are stacked one above each other, and each represents a particular period in Canadian art. From Colonial to Modern, visitors can explore different periods, beginning in the underground gallery and visiting each level, connected via a main staircase. As they ascend, the relationship between light and environment changes, each floor gradually allowing in more and more natural light. The top level, with its glass roof and walls, is literally drenched in daylight and offers visitors a stunning view of the city. From here, one can see all of the museums pavilions, its sculpture garden, and the churchs impressive rooftop. With architectural unity in mind, the exterior cladding is comprised of Vermont white marble originating from the same quarry as the other pavilions, which covers the entirety of the new Canadian Art Pavilions exterior surfaces. The cladding system utilizes a rain screen with a pressurized cavity in the back. The Muse des Beaux-Arts de Montral recognizes the value of the Erskine and American Church as part of the architectural heritage of Montreal and Canada, and wishes to restore and preserve it. Consequently, the museum has restored the churchs envelope and interior finishes, repaired its exterior walls, showcased the stained glass windows, and has also ensured that the organ is in optimum condition. Ultimately, this project represents a decisively contemporary undertaking that complements the existing building in a most sensitive manner.
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP LEFT THE DRAMATIC SLOPING GLASS ROOF; THE DESIGN MAKES A CONSCIOUS EFFORT TO EXPRESS VERTICAL SPACES WITHIN THE NEW ART PAVILIONS FOURSTOREY GALLERY VOLUME; A SECTION ILLUSTRATING THE ARCHITECTS APPROACH TO RENOVATING THE CHURCH AND ADDING FIVE LEVELS OF GALLERY SPACE.
JC: While I appreciate the way this project ad-
dresses the urban context, program and historic precedence, I do have reservations about the way the new engages the old, and also about the formal architectural resolution of the new addition.
AK: This project simultaneously represents urban stitching, artifact and parasite, evidencing a clear and beautiful strategy for the way a city uses and animates its artifacts. It is a wonderfully parasitic but formally distinct addition to an iconic object on a very important street within a loaded context. The project is quietly aggressive, finding crevasses and cracks in the urbanity, topography and geology to link disparate objects into a cohesive and extremely compelling composition of forms and spaces. This success continues as one moves through the public spaces, performance venue and galleries, culminating in a series of buoyant, sky-filled spaces that engage
the complicit buildings and the city beyond. It is a beautifully complex, intelligent and satisfying work.
JL: This is a very challenging project in that it is
part restoration, part adaptive reuse, and part new build. Each aspect in itself is very convincing and the underground connection looks like it will be stunning. It appears to be a very compressed site, but again the submission made it difficult to understand the overarching ideas.
CLIENT MUSE DES BEAUX-ARTS DE MONTRAL ARCHITECT TEAM ANDR BEAUDETTE, ALAIN BLANCHETTE, CLAUDE PROVENCHER, DANIELLE DEWAR, DENIS GAMACHE, EUGENIO CARELLI, JONATHAN BLISLE, JEAN-LUC RMY, KIA MOAZAMI FARAHANI, LAURENT PUTZOLU, MLANIE CARON, MARIE-CLAUDE LAMBERT, MATTHIEU GEOFFRION STRUCTURAL NICOLET CHARTRAND KNOLL LIMITE MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL ENERPRO & LE GROUPE CONSEIL BERMAN LANDSCAPE/INTERIORS PROVENCHER ROY + ASSOCIS ARCHITECTES CONTRACTOR POMERLEAU INC. EXISTING STONE RESTORATION DFS ARCHITECTURE + DESIGN SCENOGRAPHY GO MULTIMDIA AREA 5,400 M2 BUDGET $28.5 M COMPLETION FEBRUARY 2011
37
AWARD OF MERIT
VILLE SAINT-LAURENT LIBRARY
ARCHITECTS CARDINAL HARDY | LABONT MARCIL | ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES, ARCHITECTES EN CONSORTIUM LOCATION SAINT-LAURENT, MONTREAL, QUEBEC
It is rare to witness social and cultural environments as diverse as in the borough of SaintLaurent, and the wealth of cultures introduced by newcomers enriches the community. The library must therefore support a wide range of activities where everyone, no matter where they are from, can learn more about themselves and each other. Consequently, the architecture of such a library should encourage interaction and a feeling of belonging, promote exploration and discovery, and provide places to meet and exchange ideas. The first gesture, on an urban scale, is the creation of a large linear park, a band of vegetation that runs parallel to the library, providing a segue from the existing buildings to Boulevard Thimens and creating a strong, cohesive space. This linear threshold of a wide, planted plaza is dotted with a number of variably sized hard surface areas that form public and cultural spaces. A linear series of planting beds reinforces the visual aspect of the boulevard and immediately introduces the library building, which then extends towards the city. The second gesture is the formation of a landscaped strip that crosses the city to the forest,
which is raised above ground to form a direct outdoor link between the city and the park. Here, the library acts as an important interface between these two components. A true connection between the city and nature is established, offering passersby a visual opening towards the park. In this project, architecture is landscape and landscape is architecture. The architecture changes shape, unfolds, spreads out and rises up, reducing the boundaries between the built space and the site. There are several means of access to the buildinga simple footpath for contemplation along the way, a paved square, a suspended walkway through the trees, or an enclosed space at the heart of the project. All of these mechanisms encourage interaction and discovery. These different paths weave the city and park together, and break down the boundaries between the built form and the site. The library functions as a living environment rather than merely as a public building. The great hall is like an immense forecourta space that is at once spectacular and intimate. Located at the heart of the building, it is similar to a Roman piazza, a place for events, shows and temporary exhibitions, and a place for gathering and interaction. Here, the great hall offers more than one perspective. The vast space beneath the skylight is a spectacle of extraordinary scale, offering
ABOVE
THE DRAMATIC ROOFLINE OF THE NEW LIBRARY. BOTTOM, LEFT TO RIGHT THE SOUTHFACING TERRACE LEADS VISITORS UP TO THE BUILDINGS GREEN ROOF; THE GLASS ATRIUM PROVIDES AN IMPRESSIVE COUNTERPOINT TO THE STRENGTH OF THE BUILDINGS ROOF GEOMETRY.
a vertical connection to the landscape. The roof is an imposing wooden shell that floats above the library, stretching over the spaces in a way that seems to change the geometry, controlling the way the light penetrates the building and the way that sound travels. It projects over the exterior spaces in continuity with the interior, and thus appears boundless. At the very centre of the space, the shell opens towards the sky, allowing a shaft of natural light to illuminate the main reading room. This luminous opening is a beacon to visitors. A poetic yet forceful response to the natural setting, the shell adds richness to the site and helps to architecturally define the space. The clarity of the building materials contributes greatly to the understanding of the structure, but there is also innovation in the librarys mechanical systems: a stormwater recovery system supplies water to the wetland area, a geothermal system connects to a heat exchange loop,
and a passive heating system utilizes the heat that has accumulated in the glass prism for redistribution. Low-flow ventilation through the floors reduces the number of ducts required, and green shelving installed in several locations throughout the library filters out the CO2 emissions. Additionally, the abundance of natural daylight combined with special task lighting translates into major energy-cost savings.
5
9 4 2 6 7 1 3
10
JC: The idea that architecture is landscape and
landscape is architecture is very interesting for a suburban library. The materiality of the faades, especially on the park side, seems not to be as well resolved as the plans and sections.
AK: This project is an example of mediated urbanity, whose primary power is not in its interpretation of a potentially laden program, the community library. It achieves excellence in its complex urbanity and its aspiration to define a community in flux. The project makes a strong argument for the integration of landscape and community architecture, mediated by formal strategies sympathetic to both. The borough of Saint-Laurent is a growing and densifying community, moving from a suburban to an urban condition. The project works hard to define the street, animate the linear park, and mediate access to the wooded area and sports fields behind. The library acts as both a constructed landscape, formally finding a middle ground between the dense housing units, the adjacent schools and big-box sports facilities, and finally, the landscape elements behind. It is architecture as mediator, beautifully creating thresholds and limits necessary to define the parameters of spaces and communities in flux. JL: The roof was an intelligent metaphor and area
B 8
1 ENTRANCE 2 LIBRARY ENTRANCE 3 CAF 4 MULTIMEDIA SECTION 5 YOUTH SECTION 6 CHILDRENS SECTION 7 ENTERTAINMENT ROOM 8 CLOAKROOM 9 MULTIPURPOSE ROOM 10 SHOWROOM SITE PLAN 0 10M
SECTION A
SECTION B
of operation for this design, as the library program is, essentially, one large room. Although the submission hints at a level of interdependency of the building and the site, the drawings do not convey enough information to make this either apparent or convincing. Finally, there is no indication of the material palette for the building which is essential.
RIGHT A VIEW OF THE LIBRARYS DYNAMIC INTERIOR SPACES.
10M
CLIENT VILLE DE MONTRALARRONDISSEMENT DE SAINT-LAURENT ARCHITECT TEAM CARDINAL HARDY: BAO NGUYEN, CLAUDE JEAN. LABONT MARCIL: PIERRE LABONT, DENIS CLERMONT, JEAN MARCIL. ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES: ERIC PELLETIER, AMLIE TURGEON, ANNIE MARTINEAU, LAURA DIDIER, EMMANUELLE CHAMPAGNE, OLIVIER BOURGEOIS. STRUCTURAL SDK ET ASSOCIS INC. MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL LBHA INC. LANDSCAPE/INTERIORS CARDINAL HARDY | LABONT MARCIL | ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES LEED CONSULTANT TEKNIKAHBA AREA 5,700 M2 BUDGET $25 M COMPLETION 2012
39
AWARD OF MERIT
MILLIPEDE
ARCHITECT LOCATION
ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES QUEBEC CITY, QUEBEC
CLOCKWISE FROM ABOVE
The Millipede footbridge is part of Quebec Citys bicycle path development project that crosses the entire municipality before reaching the shores of the St. Lawrence River. This particular section of the path is located in an industrial and railway site just below a main overpassa hostile and unsightly environment that is worrisome for both cyclists and pedestrians. Integrating dedicated bike paths is difficult to achieve in urban areas, but when they are located in an industrial site, the problems are very different. This projects site is primarily characterized by the concrete superstructure of the abovegrade highway, in addition to an existing railway. The main purpose of the Millipede project is to establish a safe bike crossing over the railway of a busy switching yard. The architectural response was to introduce, in the words of the architects, a bit of craziness, a touch of colour, and a new sense of chaos. Rather than integrating a subtle piece of new cycling infrastructure, it was agreed upon that a brightly coloured footbridge would work its way through existing concrete columns. The design intent is to make a clear visual statement when arriving at the site. A long red glazed ribbon with its sides folded and positioned at various angles is able to reflect the lights coming at it from all directions. Perceptible through the existing concrete columns, the new structure will be supported with steel columns arranged in a seemingly random pattern that will only heighten the contrast between the existing and new
THE ENTIRE MILLIPEDE ARMATURE; THE NEW STEEL BIKE PATH SNAKES ITS WAY THROUGH THE EXISTING HIGHWAY INFRASTRUCTURE; AN AERIAL PHOTO ILLUSTRATING THE NEW INSTALLATION PLACED ON TOP OF ITS CHALLENGING CONTEXT; MILLIPEDE WORKS ITS WAY UNDERNEATH BRIDGES AND OVER RAILWAYS TO EXTEND QUEBEC CITYS RECREATIONAL TRAIL NETWORK.
structures. Millipede acts as an object of discovery and site experience, a stroll at various levels and scales that is intended to be an object of curiosity and a new landmark, capable of elevating the cyclists experience.
JC: It is a very interesting and poetic gesture, one
contrast to typically banal highway infrastructure. Unfortunately, the resolution of the bridge itself seems underdeveloped.
AK: As an urban suture, this project is a radical mending. It is active in its attempt to deal with the disastrous results of the ubiquitous 1960s and 70s infrastructure projects which scarred so many of our cities. The projects success is that it
that would be welcomed in any city, especially in
does so not through the normative methods of demolition, gentrification and denial, but through a delicate threading, suturing and mediation. Millipede has a critical neutrality. On one hand, it inherently celebrates what was great about these large-scale infrastructural projects: their ambition, clarity, scale and willfulness. On the other hand, it quietly critiques its context through formal tension and by creating spaces of movement and repose, human scale, and material engagement. Most powerfully, Millipede does all this while beautifully and carefully curating the users experience within this part of the city.
JL: The proposition is very engaging in that it
ing the harsh environment in which it is to be inserted. We all found that although there was much to commend with its conceptual vitality, there was a lack of information about the tectonicsparticularly how its made and with what materialthat acted as a barrier to letting us engage fully with the proposition. If more detail were included, I think it would have made the submission more satisfying.
doesnt shy away from acknowledging/represent-
CLIENT VILLE DE QUBEC ARCHITECT TEAM ERIC PELLETIER, AMLIE TURGEON, ANNIE MARTINEAU STRUCTURAL EMS INGNIRIE LANDSCAPE ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES PHOTOGRAPHER ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES BUDGET $2 M COMPLETION 2012
GALVANIZED STEEL STRUCTURE
RED GLAZED LIGHT CONCRETE PANEL
CONCRETE SLAB WITH RED COLOURED SURFACE
GALVANIZED STEEL CIRCULAR COLUMN 200MM
VARIES (1400MM MIN.)
41
I n n ovat i v e a n d R e s p e ct f u l .
The Arctic is a place of extremes. Extreme temperatures, extreme living conditions, and extreme beauty. These cold climate and remote location projects require expertise in cold climate and remote location architecture and engineering as well as innovative architectural design. With the largest resident staff of architects, engineers and technologists in Northern Canada, we understand the unique challenges involved when building in the North because we not only work in the North, we live here too. Living and working in the North. Thats FSC.
FSC Architects & Engineers Cold climate and remote location specialists
Yellowknife 867.920.2882 | Edmonton 780.439.0090 | Iqaluit 867.979.0555 | Whitehorse 867.633.2400
STUDENT AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
LOGIC SHIFT
STUDENT
JEFFREY MA, MCGILL UNIVERSITY
A decade ago, Alberto Prez-Gmez mapped for us the history of architectural representation in his book Architectural Representation and the Perspective Hinge (1997). He saw that one of the major shifts in our mode of understanding was derived from the collapse of the image and the represented objects near the end of the 20th century. This thesis continues one of his arguments on the fallacy of neutral techniques regarding the tools of the architect. Logic Shift uses Photosynth, a Microsoft software application, as a visual tool for Mas critique. Microsofts intention for Photosynth is to provide a platform in which users around the world can upload photographs of a particular place from different points of view, under differ-
ent conditions and on different dates, to recreate a virtual scene that resembles the represented place. Mas thesis is about reconciling the space of Photosynth, making manifest the space in which the built environment has left traces within the process of Photosynth. Asking the same question that Prez-Gmez left unanswered, can a recording of traces be translated (rather than transcribed) in built architectural projects? Ma belives that a recording of traces can be translated into built architectural projects, but it requires a strong determination on the architects part to dismiss our roots in an object-based understanding. This shift in logic established the foundation for this thesis project.
JC: This is a thorough exploration of the potential
MAS POINT CLOUD IMAGE IS DERIVED FROM A PROCESS THAT DECONSTRUCTS AN OBJECT AND THEN REBUILDS IT DIGITALLY FROM VARIOUS VANTAGE POINTS. BOTTOM, LEFT TO RIGHT MA HAS CONSTRUCTED AN INSTALLATION WHERE A DIGITAL ANIMATION CAN BE READ SIMULTANEOUSLY, ALLOWING THE VIEWER TO EXPERIENCE MORE THAN ONE FIXED POINT OF VIEW IN THE SPATIAL CONSTRUCT AT THE SAME TIME.
TOP
very well presented, and it would be interesting to see if some of these investigations could be developed into design strategies.
AK: Somewhat in tension with its radical imagery and compelling mark-making, on first blush this project seems to fall readily into the representational bucket, where questions of the relation-
of digital media to generate form. The project is
43
A SERIES OF THUMBNAIL SKETCHES THAT, TO QUOTE ALBERTO PREZ-GMEZ, QUESTIONS THE POSSIBILITY THAT WHOLENESS CAN BE EVOKED THROUGH A FRAGMENT. FAR LEFT A SKETCH ILLUSTRATES HOW FOUR SCREENSHOTS FROM DIFFERENT CAMERA POSITIONS PROVIDE US WITH THE FREEDOM TO TALK ABOUT SPACE MORE EFFECTIVELY THAN SINGULAR PLANAR IMAGES CAN. LEFT A SINGULAR IMAGE THAT MERGES FOUR SEPARATE IMAGES CAPTURED BY A VIRTUAL CAMERA FROM FOUR DIFFERENT ANGLES.
ABOVE
scent virtual construct to the act of making and ship between image and methodology drive the back again. In doing so, it challenges the disciexperiment. The work quickly moves past the pline of architecture and the schools in which we reverentially gathered nuggets dropped from the teach it to keep up. well-worn satchel of academic discourse. It engages current and challenging ways in which the world is reconstructing itself, taking these tools JL: I always love students who turn an idea on its and asking what architecture can do with them. head and set out to recapture essential architecVicwest Cndn Arch Half Horz ads:Layout 1 8/23/10 11:04 AM Page 2 The work bounces rapidly and radically from natural ideas, and this is what this thesis does. Em-
ploying a clear methodology, the work illuminates another way in which makers of space can use other, more contemporary means for generating the parameters. The design applications are significant and thats a high note that any great thesis should end on.
Vicwest MCM decorative walls welcome to the great indoors

Interior solutions built to your specs, ready to install
Whether for a lobby, conference room or simply a tastefully appointed interior space, consider Vicwest MCM panels. Available in a wide range of colors and finishes such as marble, granite and wood grain, they are the elegant solution when you need an upscale accent for your interior design challenges. Expand your design possibilities and talk to your Vicwest representative today welcome to the great indoors.
Detail of Granite finish
www.vicwest.com
STUDENT AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
A MANUAL FOR NON-VIOLENT RESISTANCE

STUDENT
TARANEH MESHKANI, UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO
This thesis is concerned with empowering the resistance of sociopolitical movements and their relationship to time and space. At the beginning of the 21st century, grassroots resistance tends to happen in urban settings, challenging the authority of totalitarian regimes. In this context, space plays an important role: spaces of defiance are critical in any power struggle. They can be utilized and activated by both sides of the conflictgovernments and opposition movements. This thesis provides a spatiotemporal analysis of non-violent resistance, situating the practice in the sociopolitical sphere of Iran throughout its history. In analyzing spaces of defiance, Meshkani has chosen non-violent methods of resistance, in particular the 198 methods of nonviolent action articulated by Gene Sharp. These methods can be categorized into three different groups. Firstly, there are methods which look at the possibility of creating extreme multitudes in spaces of defiance. For example, a civic protest becomes a powerful manifestation of the political agenda of the resistance when it goes beyond a specific number of people. After a certain number, it reaches the tipping point and then it becomes difficult to control. In order to meet this critical mass, we need to know the optimal time to take to the streets, and the particularities of the spaces that are host to the demonstrations. Secondly, there are other methods of nonviolent action which use the city as a stage for communicating the message of the movement. Wearing symbols, and using paint and light are some examples of methods that can be adopted. Thirdly, a set of methods can be employed to communicate and disseminate information. Most of the means of communication and mass media are controlled by governments. Totalitarian governments also shut down any alternative means of communication that rely on the infrastructure of the city. If the resistance cannot communicate and disseminate information, there is no way to reach critical mass and orchestrate groups of people. Since in totalitarian systems the government controls mass media sources such as television, radio and newspapers, people must then rely on non-substantial means of communication for informing each other about upcoming events. Ultimately, Meshkanis goal in this thesis is to analyze spaces of defiance and implement all the technologies and new types of media available to enhance the spatial aspect of the conflicts.
Cinemas Theatres
# of Cinemas People reaching and theatres the main street
0-5 Minutes 5-10 Minutes 10-15 Minutes 15-20 Minutes
14 15 9 5
7000 7500 4500 2500 Total : 21500
USING COLOURED PAINT OR OTHER VISIBLE MARKERS SENDS OUT A SUBTLE MESSAGE OF POLITICAL SOLIDARITY. ABOVE MESHKANIS DIAGRAM ILLUSTRATES HOW INFORMATION MOVES THROUGH CITIES TO DEVELOP MOMENTUM FOR PROTEST AND DISSENT.
TOP
JC: Even though these analyses are based in Iran, the lessons learned could be applied to a better understanding of how the technologies of the information age are affecting social behaviours in our urban centres. AK: This is radical activity. Rather brilliantly, this project does not come close to proposing a building. Instead, it proposes direct ideological action within a highly critical understanding of the city. It can possibly be seen as beyond or at least outside of architecture, part of some broader interdisci-
plinary experiment not pertinent to current pedagogy or practice. It is in fact the opposite, a call to arms to designers, a manifesto pointing to spatial territory we have long since acquiesced to artists, theorists and activists. Within the academic context, it does what a thesis project should doit expands our notion of how and where architecture should act, it points to our inadequacies and failed aspirations, and to the increasingly reduced radii of our circular world. In fundamentally questioning where architecture resides, this work is ideological, political and embedded in urbanity.
45
JL: This is an incredible thesis that asks how an
architect can deploy a strategy of protest and civic engagement through an elastic, creative application of architectural tools. What one immediately starts to think about as a result of this work is how the spatiotemporal manual can be applied to other ways within our profession so that we can all become better at consciously engaging in great city-building.
Smoke Flag Semaphore Heliograph
Signalling
Aldis lamp Optical telegraph No rider is needed
Biological
Pigeons
Technological
They need riders

Dogs Horses Reindeers Camels
Communication systems
Wired Wireless
Nonsubstantial CanArc112010_Canadia Architect 10/26/10 9:17 AM Page 1 Substantial
Telegraph
Cable Internet
Telephone
Letter
Cellphone
Walkie-talkie
WiFi
THIS DIAGRAM ILLUSTRATES HOW NEW TECHNOLOGIES ASSOCIATED WITH BROADCASTING POLITICAL DISSENT HAVE THE POTENTIAL TO REDEFINE THE SPATIAL DYNAMICS OF THE CITY. LEFT A CHART REMINDS US OF THE MANY TRADITIONAL AND EVOLVING METHODS OF COMMUNICATING INFORMATION. ABOVE THE HEAVY TOMES OF MESHKANIS RESEARCH ARE BEAUTIFULLY ILLUSTRATED AND ASSEMBLED.
TOP LEFT
Direct Vent 6ft r: Bill Isaman | Photo: Dennis Swanson | SPARK Site Specic 2010 | Colbert Residence | Designe
modern fires that inspire. Whether indoor or outdoor, from 2 - 8, vented or vent-free, our award-winning fireplaces help create relaxed gath-
Fires That Inspire

As the leader in modern gas fireplaces, our mission is to offer fires
ering spaces. See our photo gallery of inspirational installations at www.sparkfires.com or contact us directly at 866.938.3846
Objects Systems Materials
Content
BM
INFO
These objects, plus thousands more, have all been developed by ARCAT BIM experts, so you can rely on them as you do for ARCAT specs and SpecWizards. These 3D objects are packed with all the critical product data you need, and are free of charge like all of ARCAT services!
We put the info in BIM
Content
BM
INFO
www.arcat.com
PRODUCT SHOWCASE
nora pro clean system Reduces Maintenance Time and Costs The nora pro clean system is a unique floor cleaning regimen that reduces maintenance time and costs by eliminating the use of detergents and chemicals during the cleaning process. The combination of water and noras exclusive scrubbing pads keeps nora flooring sanitary, while the absence of chemicals results in improved indoor air quality. By using only water, the nora pro clean system helps save on maintenance costs associated with cleaning agents. For more information, visit www.nora.com/us/pro-clean4. ACO Drain for Emergency Facilities Emergency facilities need to be ready for action 24 hours a day! ACO Drain trench drain systems are used in hundreds of such facilities across Canada to help keep the buildings and equipment in the best possible shape and ready for intervention. Call us today to discuss your project! (877)226-4255 www.acocan.ca
CIRCLE REPLY CARD 83 CIRCLE REPLY CARD 84
PuraVida. A new sense of lightness in the bathroom. PuraVida makes minimalism approachable by giving it a delicate, feminine touch. The collections spft, elegant curves fuse to create a smooth aesthetic that invites touch. The highgloss furniture finishes add to this experience dignified but not flashy. PuraVidas graceful appearance, inviting surfaces and subtle luxury make the collection ideal for people who value timeless timeless and pure enjoyment.
Ciot 1-800-361-0869 www.ciot.com
What does IMI do? The International Masonry Institute offers free technical assistance to the Saskatchewan design and construction communities, plus craftworker training and contractor education. IMI is a strategic alliance between the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers (BAC) and contractors. Team IMI architects, engineers, construction managers and skilled craftworkers offer what no other group can: expertise in training, craftsmanship, design, and installation, promoting quality masonry construction. Contact Pete Loughney at Info@imiweb.org. Granular Series Exterior Finish Enhance your buildings exterior with Vicwests Granular Series. Our granular series finish reflects the appearance of stucco without the drawbacks of early wear-and-tear. With an infinite range of colours, the granular series can be applied to steel cladding profiles, insulated metal panel profiles and architectural panels all with the option for anti-graffiti coating. Visit www.vicwest.com for endless exterior design possibilities.
CIRCLE REPLY 86
WALLTITE ECO BY BASF THE CHEMICAL COMPANY WALLTITE ECO is a medium-density polyurethane foam insulation/air barrier system. Its formulation includes recycled plastic, renewable content and a zero ozone-depleting blowing agent, qualifying it as the first closedcell spray polyurethane insulation to obtain the EcoLogoM, North Americas most widely recognized multi-attribute environmental certification. WALLTITE ECOs industry-leading performance results in substantial energy savings, thus reducing energy costs.
VELUX introduces the Next Generation of Skylights! VELUX introduces the No Leak Skylight: Simplified installation with our patented deck seal Assured water tightness with 3 layers of protection Enhanced aesthetics with a sleeker lower frame and new exterior grey colour Pick & Click brackets for quick and easy blind installation Smart home radio frequency remote controls Energy efficiency with the latest LoE3 glazing Warranty 20 years on seal failure and 10 years on parts and labour.
ProRoc Extra Abuse Gypsum Board for Enhanced Protection CertainTeed Gypsums new ProRoc Extra Abuse gypsum board is ideal for use in fire-rated interior wall assemblies where improved impact, indentation and mould resistance is required. ProRoc Extra Abuse gypsum board with M2Tech achieved scores of 10 and 0 per ASTM D 3273 and ASTM G 21, respectively; the best possible scores for these tests. CertainTeed Corporation Professional: 800-233-8990 Consumer: 800-782-8777 www.certainteed.com
PROFESSIONAL DIRECTORY
DensArmor Plus High-Performance Interior Panel DensArmor Plus High-Performance Interior Panel is designed as a replacement for paper-faced gypsum board for building interiors. The combination of fiberglass mats front and back, instead of paper facings, and moisture-resistant core provides superior moisture and mold resistance when compared to traditional paper-faced drywall. GeorgiaPacific Gypsum offers a 12-month weather exposure limited warranty which means DensArmor Plus panels can be hung before installing doors and windows. Kingspan Insulated Standing Seam Roof System KingZip Insulated Standing Seam Roof System, from Kingspan Insulated Panels, is a pre-engineered, zip-up roofing system created for enhanced performance, design flexibility, aesthetic appeal and fast-track construction. KingZip is an alternative to traditional through-fastened metal roofs. Featuring a thermally broken hidden clip design, KingZip comes pre-engineered as a single component with insulation foamed-in-place, allowing single-step installation. www.kingspanpanels.ca/kingzip Hambro D500: A smart structural floor solution When evaluating your next multi-unit residential or commercial construction project, factor in the many benefits of Hambros proven structural floor system that offers: an economical and efficient solution, longer spans, construction flexibility, high fire resistance, and outstanding acoustical properties. Hambros system fits perfectly with a variety of wall types: masonry, steel frame, metal stud, pre-cast walls, ICF blocks and wood walls. Contact us to see how. 1-800-871-8876 www.hambro.ws/architects Accumet Composite Wall Panels Flynn Canadas Accumet modular wall cladding system uses state-of-the-art aluminum composite material and concealed framing to create an extremely strong, flat surface that eliminates dimpling, buckling, and oil-canning. Accumets pressure-equalized rainscreen design with dry vented joints controls moisture drainage. Fabricated with corrosion-resistant materials, Accumet looks attractive with minimal maintenance for years to come. Visit www.flynn.ca
CIRCLE REPLY CARD 93 1/8 PAGE
www.gpgypsum.com
Noise, Vibration and Acoustics

Consulting Engineers

Architectural Acoustics Building Noise and Vibration Control
Mississauga, Ontario P: 905-826-4044 F: 905-826-4940

HOWE GASTMEIER CHAPNIK LIMITED
www.hgcengineering.com
Murox High Performance Buildings Murox invites you to discover a high performance building system that is the most efficient design-build solution on the market today for the construction of commercial, industrial and institutional structures. Unique advantages: A fast-track construction solution An integrated, energy-optimized solution A profitable and environmentallyresponsible business solution Contact our architectural solutions experts at 1-877-499-6049. www.canam.ws/murox Your product or service could be promoted here! Ad Sizes 1/4 Page, 100 Words 1/8 Page, 50 Words For information about placing an ad in our Showcase & Literature Reviews, contact: Tom Arkell 416-510-6806 Greg Paliouras 416-510-6808 Canadian Architect 12 Concorde Place, Suite 800 Toronto, ON M3C 4J2 www.canadianarchitect.com 49
1/4 PAGE
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
LIST OF ENTRANTS
LEFT TO RIGHT ANDREW KING, JAMES CHENG AND JANNA LEVITT.
Letellier Cyr Ricard Mathieu et associs archi tectes, LArchitecte Jacques Plante, Laroche & Gagn Architecture Design, Les Architectes Corriveau, Girard et Associs, Manon Asselin Architect (Atelier TAG), Saia Barbarese Topou zanov Architectes, Saucier + Perrotte Architectes/ Hughes Condon Marler Architects, Smith Vigeant Architectes, The Arcop Group, WorkshopCalce Dubreuil Architectes.
NEW BRUNSWICK Architecture 2000. NOVA SCOTIA Fowler Bauld & Mitchell Ltd.,
MacKayLyons Sweetapple Architects Limited in association with Manasc Isaac Architects Ltd., Omar Gandhi, Sperry & Partners Architects.
2010 AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE
In addition to this years winners, the editors thank the following individuals and firms for participat ing in the 2010 Canadian Architect Awards of Excellence:
BRITISH COLUMBIA Allen + Maurer Architects,
NEWFOUNDLAND Sheppard Case Architects. STUDENT AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE
BattersbyHowat, Bevanda Architecture Inc., Bing Thom Architects, Bruce Carscadden Architect Inc., Campos Leckie Studio, Campos Leckie Studio in collaboration with Josephine Young & Sevenhaus Design, CEI Architecture, Chernoff Thompson Architects, Chow Low Hammond Architects Inc., DAMBROSIO architecture + urbanism, Dub Architects/Hughes Condon Marler Architects, Gair Williamson Architects/ Ankenman Marchand Architects, GBL Architects Inc., Mackin Tanaka Architects, Patkau Archi tects Inc./Kearns Mancini Architects Inc., Patkau Architects Inc. and MacLennan Jaunkalns Miller Architects, Rural Urban Fantasy Project Ltd., TRB Architecture Inc., Urban Arts Architecture, Wensley Architecture Ltd., Yamamoto Architec ture Inc. and Henry B. Mayuga.
ALBERTA AKA/Andrew King Studio, BKDI Archi tects, Connect Architecture Inc., David J. Fergus on, GEC Architecture, Gibbs Gage Architects, Kasian Architecture Interior Design and Plan ning Ltd. in association with Moriyama & Tesh ima, Manasc Isaac, Shelterbelt Architecture, Stantec Architecture Ltd., Sturgess Architecture, The Marc Boutin Architectural Collaborative. MANITOBA BIOS Architecture, Cohlmeyer Architecture Limited, Herbert Enns, Number Ten Architectural Group. ONTARIO Altius Architecture Inc., ATA Archi
Architecture & Interior Design, Breathe Archi tects, Bruce March Architect, COLE + Associates Architects Inc. in association with Reich + Petch, CS&P Architects Inc., Diamond and Schmitt Architects, Dimitri Papatheodorou Architect, Drew Mandel Architects, gh3, Hariri Pontarini Architects, HOK + Stantec, Ian MacDonald Architect Inc., Ivan Saleff Architect, JCI Archi tects Inc., Kohn Architects Inc., Kuwabara Payne McKenna Blumberg Architects, MacLennan Jaunkalns Miller Architects, MacLennan Jaun kalns Miller Architects in joint venture with HIP Architects, NXL Architects in association with ssg architecture inc., Parker Architects Inc., Paul Raff Studio, RAW design, RDH Architects Inc., RDH Architects Inc. & Lintack Architects, Rodolphe elKhoury (Khoury Levit Fong) with Drew Adams, James Dixon and Fadi Masoud, Shore Tilbe Perkins & Will, ssg architecture inc., Stantec Architecture | Kuwabara Payne McKenna Blumberg ArchitectsArchitects in Joint Ven ture, Sweeny Sterling Finlayson & Co. Architects Inc., Tact Architecture Inc., Teeple Architects Inc., The Kirkland Partnership Inc. in associa tion with Stanford Downy Architects, The Walter Fedy Partnership, Unit A Architecture Inc. + RAW Design, Whiting Design, Zeidler Partner ship Architects.
QUEBEC ACDF* architecture | TLA architectes,
tects Inc., bbb architects Ottawa Inc., Bortolotto

Atelier Pierre Thibault, Bisson | ACDF*_Des gagns architectes, Charest Parenteau & Asso cis, Consortium: Rubin & Rotman Associates ArchitectsDouglas Cardinal Architect, Gagnon
In addition to this years winners, the following architecture students were chosen by their schools to enter their thesis projects in this years awards: Evelyne Bouchard (McGill Univer sity), Andrew Bramm (University of Calgary), Erica Bright (University of Waterloo), N. Paul Chafe (Dalhousie University), Gordon Chan (University of Manitoba), Guillaume Drouin Chartier (Universit Laval), Andrew Chung (McGill University), Mitchell Counsell (Carleton University), Mariela Y. de FelixDavila (Univer sity of Toronto), Maya Desai (University of Toronto), Michael Robert Doyle (Universit Laval), Marc Hberli (University of Calgary), April Hiebert (Dalhousie University), Ken Hoshide (University of British Columbia), Julian Hou (University of British Columbia), Amy C.S. Klassen (University of Manitoba), Alexandre Landry (Universit de Montral), Amanda Law rence (Carleton University), Joe Yiu Ming Lee (University of British Columbia), Bryn Marler (Dalhousie University), Heather Maxwell (Uni versity of British Columbia), Timothy Mitanidis (Ryerson University), Mirna Monla (McGill University), Daan Murray (University of Calgary), Lejla Odobasic (University of Waterloo), Clayton Payer (Ryerson University), Brad Pickard (Dal housie University), Matthew Roper (University of Manitoba), Mark Siemicki (Ryerson University), Andre Silva (University of Manitoba), Andranne Simoneau (Universit Laval), David Smith (Uni versit Laval), Sandro B. Thordarson and Stephen Addeo (University of Toronto), Michael Ryan Trussell (University of Waterloo).
Building Envelope Solutions From Coast to Coast

Art Gallery of Alberta, Edmonton City Hall Podium Roof, Toronto
Glazing & Curtain Walls Architectural Metals Roong Service & Maintenance Roong Systems
River Rock Casino, Richmond
Maple Leaf Square Podium, Toronto
FLYNN CANADA LTD.

flynn.ca
FREE
ADVERTISER PRODUCT INFORMATION & SUBSCRIPTION ORDER CARD

PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY Name ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ Title _______________________________________________________________________________________________________ Company ___________________________________________________________________________________________________ Address _____________________________________________________________________________________________________ City ____________________________________________ Province/State ____________ Postal/Zip Code __________________________ Telephone ( ) _________________________________________ Fax ( ) __________________________________________
E-Mail Address
YOUR BUSINESS OCCUPATION (check one only) o o o o o o Registered Architect o Professional Engineers Interior Designer o Student of Architecture/Design Specication Writer o Landscape Architect Developer/Builder o Architectural Technologist Graduate/Intern/Arch/Arch Asst Other (please specify) _________________________________ ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________
For FREE INFORMATION, nd the Reader Service # under each ad(s) and then circle the corresponding number(s) shown here.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99
YES! PLEASE SIGN ME UP TO RECEIVE CANADIAN ARCHITECT MAGAZINE
FOR FAST SERVICE, FAX THIS CARD TO (416) 510-6875
o Send me 1 year of Canadian Architect magazine 12 issues for only $52.95 (+GST/HST/QST) For United States $101.95 (US funds) For International $120.00 (US funds) o Send me 2 years of Canadian Architect magazine 24 issues for only $83.95 (+GST/HST/QST) METHOD OF PAYMENT o Cheque (payable to Canadian Architect) o VISA o MASTERCARD o AMERICAN EXPRESS
CUSTOMER SERVICE HOTLINE: CDA: 1-800-268-7742 ext. 3539 USA: 1-800-387-0273 ext. 3539 Email: mchana@bizinfogroup.ca URL: www.canadianarchitect.com
CARD# _________________________________________________________________ EXPIRY DATE ______________________________________________________________ SIGNATURE (required) __________________________________DATE ___________________

2010 L K J I H G F E D C B A

Canadian Architect Dec - 2010

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Canadian Architect Dec - 2010

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

$10.00 DEC/10 V.55 N.

2010 AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE

CIRCLE REPLY CARD 11

WALLTITE ECO RAISING PERFORMANCE TO NEW HEIGHTS

5468796 ARCHITECTURE INC.

26 SMITH CARTER ARCHITECTS AND ENGINEERS/ PARKIN ARCHITECTS

ATELIER BIG CITY

BAIRD SAMPSON NEUERT ARCHITECTS

PROVENCHER ROY + ASSOCIS ARCHITECTES

CARDINAL HARDY | LABONT MARCIL | ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES, ARCHITECTES EN CONSORTIUM

ERIC PELLETIER ARCHITECTES

JEFFREY MA, MCGILL UNIVERSITY

TARANEH MESHKANI, UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO

RENDERING OF THE BLOC_10 RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN WINNIPEG BY 5468796 ARCHITECTURE INC.

12/10 CANADIAN ARCHITECT

CIRCLE REPLY CARD 14

AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE 2010

ABOVE, LEFT TO RIGHT

James K.M. Cheng

2010 CertainTeed Corporation

* VOCs (volatile organic compounds) formaldehyde and other aldehydes.

CIRCLE REPLY CARD 16

12/10 CANADIAN ARCHITECT

14 CANADIAN ARCHITECT 12/10

CIRCLE REPLY CARD 28

16 CANADIAN ARCHITECT 12/10

LAFITT ARCHITECTURAL SERIES

If beauty is in the eye of the beholder...

50 Year Wood Warranty

BUILD A BETTER WORLD

Canam, a world of green solutions for earth-friendly building projects!

A division of Canam Group

PATKAU ARCHITECTS INC. MILL RUN, PENNSYLVANIA

20 CANADIAN ARCHITECT 12/10

JC: This is a wonderful project that is a landscape

JL: This proposal is really in the private realm,

12/10 CANADIAN ARCHITECT

CAPILANO FILM CENTRE

CANNON DESIGN NORTH VANCOUVER, BRITISH COLUMBIA

22 CANADIAN ARCHITECT 12/10

OPPOSITE TOP, LEFT TO RIGHT

tect wants to tackle! The Film Centre is a self-

12/10 CANADIAN ARCHITECT

5468796 ARCHITECTURE INC. WINNIPEG, MANITOBA

within a single unit is extremely inventive and appropriate on a busy corridor.

24 CANADIAN ARCHITECT 12/10

AIR WATER POWER SERVICES DIAGRAM

12/10 CANADIAN ARCHITECT

WOMEN AND NEWBORN HOSPITAL

26 CANADIAN ARCHITECT 12/10

12/10 CANADIAN ARCHITECT

ATELIER BIG CITY MONTREAL, QUEBEC

4 2 7 8 8 8 8 0 10M AXONOMETRIC OF THE URBAN BLOCK

12/10 CANADIAN ARCHITECT

BRIAN C. NEVIN WELCOME CENTER, CORNELL PLANTATIONS

BAIRD SAMPSON NEUERT ARCHITECTS CORNELL UNIVERSITY, ITHACA, NEW YORK

30 CANADIAN ARCHITECT 12/10

SITE PLAN CONCEPT

12/10 CANADIAN ARCHITECT

CIRCLE REPLY CARD 20

1968 Social environmental movements take hold.

WHO SHAPES THE FUTURE OF GREEN DESIGN?