Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
G Bentley V8i G Trimble VX
G ArcGIS Desktop 9.3 G ASPRS Pecora Symposium
Magaz i ne f or Sur veyi ng, Mappi ng & GI S Pr of es s i onal s
Jan./Feb. 2009
Volume 12
1
How to make use of
New Technologies?
First of all, Id like to say Happy New Year and Best Wishes for 2009 to every reader of this
page. Also, Id like to thank all those contributors who shared their experiences and ideas in
columns, reviews and articles. Well try to make 2009 an even better year by providing you
with the latest market developments, trends and opinions. As always, readers are encour-
aged to react to the contents of the magazine and to submit articles by emailing me on
evanrees@geoinformatics.com.
One of the main themes that runs through this first issue of 2009 is the role of Desktop GIS
and that of the GeoWeb. In a review of ArcGIS Desktop 9.3, the question is asked if we still
need Desktop GIS in a time when everyone speaks of the possibilities the GeoWeb offers.
But the GeoWeb also has its shortcomings: in his column, James Fee takes a look at what
happens when GeoWeb Services go down, and what can be done to avoid the problems
that arise when this happens. Before we start to make use of a new environment (like the
GeoWeb), it is wise to think about how it can (or cant) be used. Similar ideas are put for-
ward in an essay by Nick Chrisman, which can be found in an ESRI publication on Geography
and GIS. In his contribution, called Living Inside Networks of Knowledge, Chrisman states
that people tend to use technological improvements in a conservative way: ...the network
technology offers some new possibilities, but we have barely begun to figure them out our
conceptual models have not evolved as fast as our infrastructure. In other words the tech-
nology is there, but we dont think about how best to use it, so we approach it in much the
same way that we have with previous technologies.
Seen this way, the question, is Desktop GIS still needed as opposed to the GeoWeb?, takes
on quite a different slant. Both platforms have their own strengths and weaknesses and it
becomes a matter of how the two can be combined with smart technologies in order to sup-
plement each other. The possibilities of the GeoWeb have put the use of past technologies
in a new perspective, and the industry is now making a concerted effort to ensure both new
and old technologies can work together. Of course, we want to keep you informed on all of
this in GeoInformatics in the new year. At the moment it is clear that Desktop GIS is here to
stay. But its role, as part of a bigger platform that makes up a GIS, is changing. How? Read
all about it in this issue.
Enjoy your reading,
Eric van Rees
evanrees@geoinformatics.com
Jan./Feb. 2009
3
GeoInformatics provides coverage, analysis and
commentary with respect to the international surveying,
mapping and GIS industry.
Publisher
Ruud Groothuis
rgroothuis@geoinformatics.com
Editor-in-chief
Eric van Rees
evanrees@geoinformatics.com
Editors
Frank Arts
fartes@geoinformatics.com
Florian Fischer
ffischer@geoinformatics.com
Job van Haaften
jvanhaaften@geoinformatics.com
Huibert-Jan Lekkerkerk
hlekkerkerk@geoinformatics.com
Remco Takken
rtakken@geoinformatics.com
Joc Triglav
jtriglav@geoinformatics.com
Columnists
Andy Coote
James Fee
Contributing Writers
Florian Fischer
Gordon Petrie
Job van Haafte
Carolyn Gordon
Remco Takken
Huibert-Jan Lekkerkerk
Rani Hellerman
Petr Dvoek
Luigi Colombo
Barbara Marana
Mary Jo Wagner
Lon van der Poel
Account Manager
Wilfred Westerhof
wwesterhof@geoinformatics.com
Subscriptions
GeoInformatics is available against a yearly
subscription rate (8 issues) of 89,00.
To subscribe, fill in and return the electronic reply
card on our website or contact Janneke Bijleveld at
services@geoinformatics.com
Advertising/Reprints
All enquiries should be submitted to
Ruud Groothuis rgroothuis@geoinformatics.com
World Wide Web
GeoInformatics can be found at:
www.geoinformatics.com
Graphic Design
Sander van der Kolk
svanderkolk@geoinformatics.com
ISSN 13870858
Copyright 2008. GeoInformatics: no material may
be reproduced without written permission.
GeoInformatics is published by
CMedia Productions BV
Postal address:
P.O. Box 231
8300 AE
Emmeloord
The Netherlands
Tel.: +31 (0) 527 619 000
Fax: +31 (0) 527 620 989
E-mail: mailbox@geoinformatics.com
c r o s s m e d i a l p u b l i s h e r
Trimble VX
GeoInformatics is presenting a new series on user tests of robotic total
stations. To gain more insight into the day-to-day use of a robotic total
station, GeoInformatics has asked Lon van der Poel, a surveyor and
educator in the Netherlands, to put a number of robotic total stations
from different international manufacturers through their paces. The fourth
and last test is of a Trimble VX.
C o n t e n t
Jan./Feb. 2009
Articles
The Key to managing our Future 18
ImageSats Vision on Geospatial Information
Improving the usability for Web Mapping Services 23
New Portal for Czech Land Survey Office
Building Geo-knowledge 24
Scanning and Imaging in the City of Bergamo
The Middletown-Norwalk Transmission Project 40
Project Management Electrified
SOCET GXP v3.0 44
Geospatial-intelligence Software
Product Review
Multi-brand Test Robotic Total Stations Part 4 6
Trimble VX
Review of ArcGIS Desktop 9.3 12
Do we still need a Desktop GIS?
Interviews
Interview with Kevin Ison from Autodesk 17
Digital Prototyping is the Trend
Extending the Utilization of Geodata throughout
Organizations 28
Erdas Apollo 2009
Columns
What happens with GeoWeb Services go down? 48
By James Fee
A UK Location Strategy - for the Public Sector 57
By Andy Coote
Page 6
Bentley V8i
In November 2008, Bentley launched V8i, the most comprehensive
software portfolio for infrastructure professionals ever delivered in a
single release. Encompassing products for all of the solution communi-
ties served by Bentley, the V8i portfolio leverages and extends the
core capabilities of its interoperability platform to enable integrated pro-
ject delivery.
Page 36
Courtesy Henning Larsen Architects
4
Latest News? Visit www.geoinformatics.com
5
Jan./Feb. 2009
On the Cover:
Surveyor and educator Lon van der Poel is performing a test with
the Trimble VX. Read the review at page 6.
ArcGIS Desktop 9.3
The new release 9.3 of ESRIs ArcGIS has a multitude of new features and
improvements. Florian Fischer has a look on some of the improvements
and address the question why we still need ArcGIS Desktop in the age of
the GeoWeb and its service-based geospatial applications.
Page 6
Navitec 2008
For the fourth time the European Space Agency (ESA) held a workshop on
satellite navigation user equipment technologies at Estec in Noordwijk, the
Netherlands. The conference centre was filled with around 200 scientists
from all over Europe from Finland to Portugal from the tenth to twelfth of
December.
Page 50
Events
Report on the latest ASPRS Symposium 32
on Remote Sensing
Pecora-17 The Future of Land Imaging
The Continuing Story of MicroStation 36
European Launch of Bentley V8i
4th ESA Workshop on Satellite Navigation 50
User Equipment Technologies
Navitec 2008
A Report on the Moscow 2008 Conference 52
Laser Scanning & Digital Aerial Photography:
Today & Tomorrow
Calendar 58
Advertisers Index 58
Page 12
F
o
t
o
:
S
a
n
d
e
r
v
a
n
d
e
r
K
o
l
k
Multi-brand Test Robotic Total Stations Part 4
GeoInformatics is presenting a new series on user tests of
robotic total stations. Each of the next several issues will
include the results of testing a different robotic station.
The same structure will be used for every test so that com-
parisons can be made between the different instruments.
The fourth and last test is of a Trimble VX.
By Lon van der Poel
Choosing a total station is not an
easy job. Depending on the type of sur-
vey and the circumstances in which the
survey has to take place, a potential
user will select a certain brand and
type of total station. To gain more
insight into the day-to-day use of a
robotic total station, Geo Informatics
has asked Lon van der Poel, a sur-
veyor and educator in the
Netherlands, to put a number of
robotic total stations from different
international manufacturers through
their paces. The tests will all be car-
ried out under the same conditions
and the same structure will be used
for every test so that the different
instruments can be compared. The
instruments have been provided by
their Dutch distributors.
Every instrument will be tested on:
1. delivery and instructions for use
2. overall impression of the instru -
ment and controller (field book)
3. user friendliness
4. stake out routine
5a. surveying one man
5b. surveying reflectorless
6. additional functions
Pr oduct r evi ew
Trimble VX
6
Box 1.
F
o
t
o
s
:
S
a
n
d
e
r
v
a
n
d
e
r
K
o
l
k
Jan./Feb. 2009
The Trimble VX
Testing Method
We have chosen to do a user test, which means that standard devia-
tions and so on will not be considered. Each manufacturer is asked to
provide a robotic total station that can be operated by one person,
along with accompanying software, for two days. We have also asked
the manufacturer to provide operating instructions. A test survey is then
performed. Of particular interest is user friendliness during the survey-
ing and pegging out. The test factors are listed in Box 1. (see page 6)
The fourth test is of a Trimble VX.
The configuration as supplied is as follows:
Instrument: VX
Controller: TSC2
Prism: MultiTrack Target
Software: Survey Controller 12.42
Delivery and Instructions
The complete kit was supplied in 2 cases with 2 small bags and of course
a tripod and a prism pole.
The first case contained the instrument, the second case all chargers, the
first bag the MultiTrack prism and the second bag the datacollector. Printed
manuals of software version 12.41 in Dutch and of the instrument in English
accompanied the instrument.
Instrument
Inside the first case with the instrument was also another 360 degree
prism. The MultiTrack target does not fit into the case
at this moment, but I was told that a new case
coming soon will solve this. Beside the instru-
ment is some space, but not sufficient for the
TSC2. The instrument case, including instru-
ment, prism and batteries is not light. The
case has carrying belts, which I did not test.
The VX is based on the S6 but has a video
mode. The Tracklight in the telescope of the
S6 has been replaced by a special digital cam-
era. The instrument has unique motors which are
not servo driven, but magnetically driven. This
makes the instrument rotate without making
any noise, which is weird the first time you
see it because you are used to hearing servo
motors. In one-man robotic mode, the noise
is not important since you are not behind the
instrument, but for reflectorless measure-
ments from behind the instrument it is nice.
The lack of noise is also a benefit for moni-
toring jobs in urban areas.
According to the manufacturer, other benefits
of these motors include that a much faster
rotation speed is possible, so it can track
much faster moving targets, and that there is
no friction which means lower power con-
sumption, and less wear and tear. One bat-
tery should last six hours depending on the
configuration. During my tests it was more like
four hours. The instrument was delivered with
three batteries so sufficient for a full days work
anyway. (the temperature can have an influ-
ence here, because it was freezing cold).
The instrument has an optical plummet (laser
plummet optional), which you need to pull out
to be able to focus. The first time I used it, I
did not manage to get a clear field of view when looking through the
optical plummet and it took a long time to figure out that the optical
plummet had to be pulled out.
When you forget to push it back in, the instrument it looks fragile and
likely to be bent when placing the instrument in the case.
The handle is not in the centre of the instrument. This makes it possible
to use a diagonal eyepiece without removing the handle, which is user
friendly, but when you pick up the instrument it means that it is now a
little bit tilted, which makes it slightly more difficult to put the instru-
ment back in the case.
Standard on the VX is one small screen which makes it possible to do
some settings directly on the instrument such as change the radio chan-
nel and adjust the bubble. Although there is no physical plate bubble
or circular bubble on the instrument, there is a digital one on the instru-
ment display and a circular one in the tribrach, which is clearly visible
when the instrument is in the correct position.
The camera is located under the objective lens in the telescope. This
means that the camera is not coaxial. But once a distance has been mea-
sured the software calculates the offset on the video and adjusts it.
Field Book and Remote Control Unit
The TSC2 is a windows mobile datacollector/fieldbook with colour touch
screen. It has a full numeric and alphanumeric keyboard. The keys have
some resistance and need to be pressed firmly. The ESC key is not at
the location that I expected it to be, so every time, my finger went first
to the top left of the keyboard. During the test a compact flash GPS card
was inserted at the top, making it possible to use
GPS for finding the prism.
The Radio is built in, and the unit can be
attached to the pole or kept in the hand.
During data transfer from the datacollector
to the pc, I had a CF on my desk, so I insert-
ed this into the datacollector. Immediately, I
realized that there is no eject button and I
needed tweezers to get the card out again.
So next time I used the USB stick, which is eas-
ier anyway since you dont need to remove the
top cover to insert the USB stick. The manu-
facturer comments that users are supplied
with pull tabs to attach to cards which elimi-
Latest News? Visit www.geoinformatics.com
Pr oduct r evi ew
Jan./Feb. 2009
Prism
Field book
nates the need for an eject button, and agrees that most people want to
use USB sticks to transfer data anyway.
Two keys on the datacollector are user definable, so the functions most
used can be assigned to those two keys.
User Friendliness during Stake out
Staking out is very intuitive. The voice of a lady tells you in which direc-
tion to move. It is easy to load 500 points for a stakeout job and the
software also has functions to increment the point with any number or
decrease the point number. When I tried to use decreasing point numbers
and store the point I ran into some problems. I staked out point 55 and
stored it as point 10055, so the next point to stake out was 54, but the
automatically stored point number was still increasing so it wanted to
store the point as 10056. Probably there is an option to count down some-
where, but I was not able to find it. Storing the measured point with the
same number as the design point was the option I used later. Of course,
after checking if the design point was not overwritten. All was OK.
User Friendliness during Surveying
After turning on the instrument and the field book they automatically con-
nect, which is user friendly, but can take almost 20 seconds. The first
screen you see on the data collector is the digital bubble screen, so in
one hand I had the pole with the data collector on it and with the other I
had to level the instrument. Moving two screws simultaneously is not very
easy with one hand. The instrument does not have a physical bubble so
the only other solution is to use the digital bubble on the small screen of
the instrument. The third option would be to attach the data collector to
the tripod, using the tripod bracket (which was not supplied to me). The
manufacturer tells us that most surveyors level the instrument using the
bubble on the instrument itself, before picking up the pole.
In the main screen of the data collector you have six icons (File, Key in,
Configuration, Measurement, Cogo and Instrument), which is pretty straight
forward and in most cases you will select the correct option. Sometimes I
was unsure of the choice between Instrument and Configuration, especial-
ly when I wanted to change an instrument configuration. But I started
anyway with Measurement. The options that are available depended on
what I had done until now. In this case it was the start of a new job, so I
only got the Station Establishment menu, which lets you tell the instru-
ment about its location and orientation. I selected stationing. Optionally
you get a screen with all ppm settings, but you can turn this option off if
you want.
The Station point name can be entered, selected from list, or taken from
the map. If you want to select it from the map, you must first go to the
map and select the point (or several points) in the survey area. After that
is done, when you go to the select from map option, you will get a list
with all the points you had selected on the map. After entering the sta-
tion point info and the Backsight point info, you can take a measurement.
On the screen you can immediately see, and change if needed, whether
you measure angles and distances or only angles. After this has been
accepted you return to the main screen with the six icons. When you now
select Measurement, you get different options from previously offered.
Now they include things like topo measurement, stake out and scanning.
The tracking of the prisms works well, also at short distances. During the
test the MultiTrack Target was used, so the instrument is not only tracking
the MultiTrack Targets prism, but at the same time constantly checking if
the lights on the Target are also present. It only tracks the prism if the
lights are also found. This has advantages when surveying near unwant-
ed reflective objects, like cars or road signs. The MultiTrack Target needs a
battery for the lights and therefore it is heavier than a normal 360 degree
prism.
Basically there are 3 different screens you can use for topo survey when
you are in robotic mode with the prism. You can use the normal screen,
Pr oduct r evi ew
Jan./Feb. 2009
8
The handle is not in the centre of the instrument. This makes it possible to use a
diagonal eyepiece without removing the handle, which is user friendly, but when
you pick up the instrument it means that it is now a little bit tilted, which
makes it slightly more difficult to put the instrument back in the case.
which shows name, code, offsets, measurements etc. You can also survey
from the map. In the map there is a button MEAS which measures the
point and than you automatically get the normal screen to enter code
etc. The third option is to use the video screen. In the video you can see
the points which have already been surveyed. This is very useful for check-
ing if heights are measured correctly. If there are lots of points on a road
however, the points clutter up due to the perspective and the function of
displaying already measured points on the screen is not very helpful. You
can also store the picture for selected points or for every point. In this
case, you may need to manually adjust the contrast and brightness of
the video because otherwise you may get over exposed or under exposed
pictures.
The extra time taken to store the image depends on the zoom and the
jpg settings. When the camera is completely zoomed in, it is very fast
and you hardly notice that it takes additional time. When the camera is
completely zoomed out, it takes from 3 seconds up to more than 10 sec-
onds to store the point and the image. The video can also be used for
aiming the instrument, such as when an obstruction between the instru-
ment and prism causes it to lose lock on the prism. This works best with
completely zoomed out camera. Otherwise you have to keep tapping on
the screen to move the instrument in the right direction.
So here is a conflict. For storing images you want to zoom in, for aiming
the instrument you want to zoom out. Zooming in or out 1 step takes
approximately 2 seconds, so continuously zooming in and out is also not
a good way.
I wanted to use the video for collecting inaccessible points such as trees
and lamp posts, while surveying the side of the road in one-man mode.
So I tried doing it by measuring the distance while standing next to the
tree and then aiming at the centre of the tree to measure the angle.
Basically back to the system used in 2 man surveying. On my test loca-
tion, the trees are between 20 and 100 meters from the instrument. I
found that it was difficult to aim to the centre of the tree on the video
when the tree is 100 meters away. You need to zoom in fully and still the
tree is not big and sharp on the screen. By tapping on the screen you
need to aim to the centre, but in practise you tap a bit too far to the right
or a bit too far to the left. The arrow keys of the controller did not solve
this. So basically this way of surveying was not as user friendly as I expect-
ed and I found it was better to measure those points with a distance off-
set or from behind the instrument in reflectorless mode.
In Robotic mode, the instrument can be aimed via the control unit in a
number of different ways.
Using the arrow keys, which is very useful when the instrument is point-
ing in completely the wrong direction:
Using Search, which will start the search in a predefined area, so the
prism has to be in that area, otherwise it will not find it. You can also
tell the instrument where to start searching based on the GPS position
of the small CF GPS card. This does not always work if you are too
close to the instrument because the position of the GPS may not be
accurate enough and the total station would then start searching in
the wrong place.
Using click and move. Here, you guide it by just tapping the location
it should turn to on the display of the data collector. It turns immedi-
ately.
Depending on the situation, I used different methods to guide the instru-
ment to the prism.
Reflectorless Measurement
The reflectorless measurement works well. Measuring to black gravel works
up to around 75 meters. This is one of the most difficult targets to mea-
sure since the angle of inclination is small and the colour of the object is
dark, which means that it absorbs most of the signal. Although a black
chimney could not be measured at a distance of a bit over 100 meters,
signposts and lighter objects could be measured at this range. Measuring
a cable above the highway at 218 meters was not possible.
With reflectorless measurements to corners of buildings, you still need to
be very careful. Aiming at the centre of a pole might give the distance of
the trees behind the pole if you are in TRK mode. For reflectorless mea-
Latest News? Visit www.geoinformatics.com
Pr oduct r evi ew
Jan./Feb. 2009
9
The instrument was delivered with
three batteries so sufficient for a full
days work anyway.
GPS
WOULD BE LOST
WITHOUT US.
IMPROVEYOURGPS.COM
surements to corners, I still prefer to use special offset functions of soft-
ware. For example, by measuring two points on the wall, then aiming to
the corner, measuring only angles and finally storing the intersection. The
software has several offset functions, but I could not find the one to use
for this application. According to the Trimble support person the one that
I wanted is available as a COGO function.
One of the software functions I thought that might do the trick is called
RefLine (reference line). By making the building a ref line, I thought that
the software should be able to calculate an intersection on this refline.
After selecting this option you need to select Measure or Stakeout, so I
selected measure. The next question you get is if you want to use line or
arc. Strangely enough after selecting line I ended up in the stakeout line
menu instead of the measure line menu. The manufacturer explains that
RefLine is a separate survey program. It is very useful, but used for some-
thing completely different, which is why it is located in the Survey menu
instead of COGO.
Scanning (Additional Function):
The VX has the possibility to be used as a basic scanner. In combination
with the video, this opens new possibilities. One of the objects that had
to be surveyed during the test was an earth wall. The shape of this wall
was round and the slope was different on different locations so several
breaklines would have to be measured in case of a normal DTM measure-
ment. With the scanning option the DTM could now be made from one
station, without walking across the area several times. First pictures from
the area were taken, then on the video the scan area was drawn by mak-
ing a polyline around the area. The next step was to define the density of
measurements, which I set to be 20 cm. Based on a measured distance,
somewhere on the object, the rotation angle steps for the instrument are
calculated. In the data you can see that the distance between the points
at the far end of the area is a lot more than the specified 20 centimeters,
so it is important that if you want 20cm as a minimum density you should
measure the distance to the furthest point of your object. The slope of
the area you survey also influences the density of the point cloud (see
Figure 1).
The vertical distance was also set to 20 centimeters, but of course the 20
cm height difference on surface B needs much less of vertical angle rota-
tion than on surface C.
The area was around 100 meters long, but still the total time needed to
scan this area was acceptable. Not hours, but more like 5 minutes. The
instrument is able to take between 5 and 15 points per second.
The result looks nice, the DTM does not have the sharp break lines from
a normal DTM survey but sufficient to see the break lines in the point
cloud of over 3000 points and use the data for volume calculations.
Software
The field software, called Survey Controller, has no modules, so all options
are always available. The software is really multitasking. Not only between
different applications, but also between different parts of the software,
such as the video mode and the normal topo mode, or the edit code
library or the stake out mode or cogo. At the beginning I was sceptical
because you are measuring topo or you are staking out, so I thought,
why would you need multitasking? But during the survey I found myself
switching application every now and then. Not so much between survey
and stake out, but more between surveying and file maintenance, cogo
and code library kind of applications. The export function supports differ-
ent file formats. Looking through the list I not only saw the formats of all
major hardware brands, but also local formats like the Norwegian KOF
format. The software crashed once and the system needed to be reboot-
ed. In general if you are looking for an option, it is located on a logical
place and is easy to find.
Summary
Instrument follows the prism very well, also at short distances
Several search options available. Depending on the situation you can
select one or combine more than one search option
The software is very user friendly
Reflectorless measurement to corners needs attention
The Data collector is fast, can be on the pole, or carried in you hand
The video / image function can be useful but is not a solution for all
types of survey work
Scanning adds an additional function to this instrument which can be
useful in specialised cases.
Lon van der Poel geoinformatics@leop-bv.nl is a
professional surveyor and educator.
This article represents his own opinion.
For more information, have a look at trimble.com.
Many thanks to Trimble for providing the reviewed instrument.
Reaction of the Manufacturer
Nice report. Its really great to read the first response of someone that
is unfamiliar with Trimble Total Stations who has just taken the instru-
ment out of its box and started to use it. We are pleased that the Survey
Controller software was found to be user friendly and that the reviewer
liked the multitasking. Many of the benefits of the scanning and video
technology in the VX come from the use of the data in Trimble RealWorks
office software, which was not included in the review.
There are a couple of points which we should clarify for the readers.
1 It sounds like the auto exposure setting for the camera was switched
off. If you have this on, it eliminates the need to change the
exposure all the time.
2 RefLine is a special survey method for surveying and staking out using
a line as the local reference. Its not a COGO function. Introduced in
the Geodimeter 400 series back in 1986, RefLine has many uses, and
we would like to show the reviewer some more about it.
The Trimble VX has created a revolution in the use of video assisted
surveying. Users have found that their surveying methods have been
re-defined and that their productivity has improved.
Latest News? Visit www.geoinformatics.com
Pr oduct Revi ew
11
Jan./Feb. 2009
Figure 1.
In the video you can see the points which have already
been surveyed.
A review of ArcGIS Desktop 9.3
The release 9.3 of ESRIs ArcGIS has a multitude of new features and
improvements. This article will take a look at some of the improvements
and will address the question of why we still need ArcGIS Desktop in the
age of the GeoWeb and its service-based geospatial applications.
By Florian Fischer
The Revenge of the GIS
Professionals
The concept of Spatial Data Infrastructures
(SDI) resounds throughout the land. In the
age of the internet, GIS systems are dissol -
ving as monolithic pieces of software, hard-
ware and geo data dissolved into interopera-
ble, service-based Spatial Data Infrastructures
(SDI) that continuously provide geo data and
geo functionality over the web. Whereas GIS
systems were efficient only in the hands of GIS
experts, SDIs allow the deployment of geo web
services by non GIS experts within organiza-
tions and enterprises. A multitude of regional,
national and international SDI initiatives will
make the handling of geo data easier than ever
before and grant almost everyone access to
geo web services. When every workflow can
be server based, why do we still need a desk-
top GIS like the new ArcGIS Desktop? The
answer is simple: because we still need GIS
professionals to create, manage and analyse
content and to design the workflows! Or as
ESRI puts it, a powerful desktop GIS is still the
basis for working with spatial data.
ArcGIS 9.3 Desktop Whats New?
ESRI has integrated a multitude of improve-
ments into the new release, ArcGIS 9.3
Desktop. A quick glimpse at Whats New in
ArcGIS 9.3 immediately discloses some
dozens of improvements. It is clear that I can
present only some of them here. But after a
second look at Whats New in ArcGIS 9.3 it
becomes evident that ArcGIS Desktop is not
considered a stand-alone product but one
brick in ESRIs service-based GIS infrastruc-
ture. Today geospatial technology is one com-
ponent in common IT architectures but not
the only component. And while we are mov-
ing toward server-based infrastructures, desk-
top components are essential parts of the
overall architecture: because of performance
issues due to increasing amounts of data, as
design machines for complex workflows, and
as high-end analysis or processing systems.
Cartography
Cartography is definitely a highlight in the 9.3
release of ArcGIS Desktop. A new feature in
release 9.2 was the introduction of carto-
graphic representations. That is, a cartograph-
ic model could be designed to create a true
cartographic workflow which is integrated into
ArcGIS Desktop but still a component sepa-
rated from the geo database. Before, the com-
mon workflow was different. Data capturing,
data management and analysis was done with
ArcGIS. The cartographic production was then
carried out by a piece of software more spe-
cialized in symbolization and cartography.
Troublesome data transfer was necessary
which placed a break line in the workflow.
12
Revi ew
Do we still need
a Desktop GIS?
Application Message in a Bottle using the ArcGIS JavaScript API
Jan./Feb. 2009
As in release 9.2 the editing of geo data and
cartographic representations can be done sep-
arately or connected, but in 9.3 ESRI has
introduced a WYSIWYG technique that allows
editing of geo data by manipulation of the
cartographic representation itself.
Cartographic representations ease and auto-
mate the cartographic workflow, as an exam-
ple from Swiss Topo demonstrates. Swiss
Topo, the Swiss national mapping agency, was
able to revolutionize its workflow for map pro-
duction by integrating the cartographic pro-
cess into ArcGIS. It could make use of many
features of ArcGIS like representation rules,
overrides, geo-processing and cartographic
editing. The advantages are clear. Geo data
for cartography is more flexible to use, and
maintenance of official maps is faster and
more efficient due to automated processes.
More actual data and lower production costs
are the result.
A Kind of OSM Deluxe
This kind of automated cartography is already
deployed in Open Street Map (OSM), a virtu-
al community that collectively gathers and
shares geo data created by GPS devices under
a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike
2.0 license. They also offer sophisticated
maps that are automatically derived from the
raw geo data. The idea is simple. The world-
wide user community gathers around the plat-
form, collects geo data and uploads it.
Professionals design the cartographic work-
flow that creates maps, map-tiles and even
shape files out of the raw data. Although they
use a very simplistic data model at the
moment, it is considered likely to gain com-
no special GIS knowledge is necessary to han-
dle a geospatial PDF. As well, there is no need
for special viewers, and the files are still small
and can be combined with a document and
transmitted easily. With its introduction of
geospatial PDF, Adobe is finally supporting the
diffusion of geospatial products, and we can
expect more in the future.
ESRI Mash-ups
ArcGIS Desktop 9.3 also plays an important
role in a geo browser environment. It is ArcGIS
Desktop that is best used by professionals to
create tasks for a service-based environment.
What is denoted task by ESRI is usually
called service when talking about Service
Oriented Architectures (SOA). That is, tasks
are everything from geo-processing to geo-
statistics. Created by ArcGIS Desktop, a task
can be offered by ArcGIS Explorer. The utiliza-
tion of APIs permits the combination of ESRIs
geo web services with a multitude of visual-
ization platforms as well, such as Google
Maps and Adobe Flex. That way ArcGIS func-
tionality is capable of being integrated into
websites, and thus ESRI mash-ups are made
with ease. Message in a bottle is one exam-
ple of this way of creating ESRI mash-ups (see
Figure 1).
This simple website allows you to track the
path a bottle will take if thrown into the
ocean. If you pinpoint the location where the
bottle was dropped, a task on an ArcGIS
Server is started and processed server-side.
The result is sent back to the website and
shows the track of the bottle calculated on
plexity in the future. The aims of Swiss Topo
are similar. However, they are a kind of OSM-
deluxe as they have even more sophisticat-
ed requirements, a more complex data model
and a higher need for immediate implemen-
tation. The design of OSM maps will certainly
be enhanced in the future but probably at a
slower pace and with the steady credo of
keeping a high level of convenience and
usability. That is not necessarily an aim of
Swiss Topo.
Geospatial PDF
Last year ESRI started to work closely with
Adobe Systems to enable seamless work-
flows. In Acrobat Reader 9 Adobe introduced
the geospatial PDF that, it is assumed, will
be proposed to the ISO Standards group as
well. A geospatial PDF contains information
that is required to geo-reference location data.
When geospatial data is imported into a PDF,
Acrobat retains the geospatial coordinates.
Geospatial data can be either vector or raster
based or a combination of both. One can then
find and mark location data and measure dis-
tance, area and perimeter. Acrobat 9 makes
use of the ESRI Projection Engine to provide
this functionality. By allowing PDF to work
with geospatial information Adobe has pro-
vided a document platform for GIS customers
to use. No special tools and no special exten-
sions to geospatial PDF are needed. Suddenly
all the Acrobat document features have
become available to customers working with
geospatial documents. Traditional document
work flows that could only include flat image
maps can now include fully functioning PDF
Maps. Thus no GIS software is required and
Latest News? Visit www.geoinformatics.com
Revi ew
13
Jan./Feb. 2009
Application Solar Boston demonstrating the use of ArcGIS Flex API
the basis of ocean currents. The Solar Boston
project demonstrates the integration of tasks
with the Adobe Flex platform. The Solar
Boston map allows you to see active renew-
able energy installations within the City, and
to calculate the solar potential of building
rooftops (see Figure 2).
Data Interoperability
In addition to creating tasks that are pub-
lished, ArcGIS Desktop integrates these ser-
vices as well. Connecting to an OGC-compli-
ant Web Map Service (WMS) became a matter
of course a few releases ago. But WMS are
just too limited when it comes to represent-
ing raster data. In the end they only show
images because it is a visualization service.
Styled Layer Descriptors (SLD), an XML
schema specified by the Open Geospatial
Consortium (OGC) that is capable of describ-
ing the rendering of specific WMS layers, is a
way to spice up the OGC WMS. Release 9.3
can now work with these SLDs, but the
release can connect to Web Coverage Services
(WCS) as well. WCS allow requests for geo-
graphical coverages, that is objects or images
in the age of the GeoWeb. In fact, ArcGIS
Desktop is an integrated part of the ArcGIS
environment, contributing to ArcGIS Server,
ArcGIS Explorer and to the GeoWeb. Its
strength is definitely the design of workflows,
the handling of large amounts of data and the
ease of handling computationally intensive
geo-processing. As long as we need a profes-
sional GIS we will need ArcGIS Desktop. And
finally, internet bandwidth is still an issue to
be considered. We are quite spoiled by enor-
mous bandwidth but have to realize that not
every place is connected by similar band-
width. Thus while geography matters, ArcGIS
Desktop rules.
Florian Fischer ffischer@geoinformatics.com,
GIS Editor and Research Assistant at the Austrian
Academy of Sciences GIScience research facility in
Salzburg, Austria.
Links to web-applications.
Message in a Bottle:
http://resources.esri.com/help/9.3/arcgisserver/apis/
javascript/arcgis/demos/geoprocessor/gp_bottle.html
Solar Boston: http://gis.cityofboston.gov/solarboston
in a geographical area. This answers the call
for the deployment of geo-processing func-
tionality and spatial analysis using geo data
from web services. Thus the capabilities of
ArcGIS Desktop can be extended by using
WCS, like doing a classification.
A stepchild in the GIS domain is still the Web
Feature Service (WFS), a service that allows
requests for geographical features. So far the
WFS has not made good concerning its adop-
tion but that might change in future. ArcGIS
Desktop is already primed for WFS. However,
finding out how to start using WFS is not very
easy. It can only be done via ArcCatalog, and
there are still some dialog boxes that do not
say anything about a WFS. Nevertheless the
connection to WFS works fine and completes
the interoperability capabilities of ArcGIS
Desktop 9.3.
Bandwidth is important
The 9.3 release of ArcGIS Desktop has many
new features and improvements in carto-
graphic representation, geo-processing and
data interoperability. But what is more impor-
tant, it shows that a desktop GIS is still key
Latest News? Visit www.geoinformatics.com
Revi ew
15
Jan./Feb. 2009
UNI__GIS
Educating GIS Professionals Worldwide www.unigis.org/uk
Study for a postgraduate qualification in GIS
by distance learning
With over 16 years of experience presenting distance learning courses
to professional standards, UNIGIS offers you access to the premier
international network of Universities in GIS education.
Our courses meet the learning needs of busy professionals, or those
seeking to enter the GIS industry. We support you with personal
tutors, on-line help and optional residential workshops. Our courses
are assessed by coursework - there are no examinations.
Find out why the UNIGIS postgraduate courses are so successful:
call +44 161 247 1581, fax. +44 161 247 6344, email unigis@mmu.ac.uk,
or visit our web site at http://www.unigis.org/uk
WE ALSO OFFER:
Flexible entry requirements
Specialist pathways in GIS, GI Science, GIS &
Management and GIS & Environment
Course modules supported by key textbooks,
software and on-line resources
Flexible study options - full distance learning
or distance learning plus residential workshops
No examinations - full continuous assessment,
plus credit for prior learning or experience
Networking with an international community
of GIS professionals
With a tradition of innovation, NavCom continues to leave its footprint on
the evolving GNSS industry. Propelled by our award-winning engineering
team, our industry leading technology includes the StarFire
network the
worlds first global satellite-based augmentation system (GSBAS) RTK
Extend
D
i
g
i
t
a
l
r
e
a
d
i
n
g
<
3
s
e
c
.
0
.
7
m
m
/
k
m
2
,
0
0
0
p
o
i
n
t
s
m
e
m
o
r
y
.
.
.
a
n
d
m
u
c
h
m
o
r
e
3
0
0
m
w
o
r
k
i
n
g
r
a
n
g
e
T
w
o
c
o
n
g
u
r
a
b
l
e
s
l
o
p
e
s
R
e
m
o
t
e
c
o
n
t
r
o
l
l
e
d
I
P
6
7
w
a
t
e
r
p
r
o
o
f
.
.
.
a
n
d
m
u
c
h
m
o
r
e
3
5
0
m
r
e
e
c
t
o
r
l
e
s
s
2
m
m
+
2
p
p
m
A
b
s
o
l
u
t
e
e
n
c
o
d
e
r
.
.
.
a
n
d
m
u
c
h
m
o
r
e
G
P
S
/
G
L
O
N
A
S
S
R
T
K
N
e
t
w
o
r
k
i
n
g
B
l
u
e
t
o
o
t
h
W
i
r
e
l
e
s
s
.
.
.
a
n
d
m
u
c
h
m
o
r
e
MobileMapper
6
True Mobile GIS for Everyone
MobileMapper 6 provides a complete set of all necessary features required of a
mapping device for anyone who needs productive data collection and efficient asset
management in the field. Unlike consumer-grade units, the low-cost easy-to-use
MobileMapper 6 offers full compatibility with popular GIS software to enable
companies to select and use GIS software of their choice.
The MobileMapper 6 comes with Microsoft Windows Mobile 6, a color touch-screen,
and has Bluetooth for wireless connectivity. This handy feature-rich GPS includes an
integrated 2-megapixel camera, an embedded speaker and microphone to enrich
the collected data with pictures and voice notes.
With MobileMapper 6, Magellan innovates and fills a market gap in GIS data
collection between high-cost devices and consumer-grade products.
Check out today www.pro.magellanGPS.com to equip your GIS crew
with MobileMapper 6
2008 Magellan Navigation, Inc. All rights reserved. Magellan, the Magellan logo and MobileMapper are trademarks of Magellan Navigation, Inc.
All other products and brand names are trademarks of their respective holders.
Features
High-sensitivity GPS
Windows Mobile 6
Bluetooth connectivity
For more information:
France (HQ) +33 2 28 09 38 00
Russia +7 495 980 5400
Netherlands +31 78 61 57 988
professionalsales@magellanGPS.com
Affordable GIS/GPS with
nothing missing
Boost your accuracy with
NEW post-processing feature!