Sent: 26 November 2012 18:53 To: krischai.t@toyo-thai.com Cc: Komkrit.P Subject: Re: Allowable Nozzle Force and Moment for Main Turbine (RT-4301) Importance: High Attachments: TBM1040028716-082_0.pdf; PTTBV-818-1043 R.1 (1).pdf Page 1 of 3 27/11/2012 Dear Khun Krischai,
Due to our piping stress analysis around Main Turbine RT-4301, We have some question that need to receive confirmation from Main Turbine (RT-4301)'s vendor as below.
1. Refer reply from ELLIOTT (2012-6-17)
" 3. Calculation of combined nozzle load method Because of main exhaust or other piping that connected to turbine nozzle is scope of vendor. <ELLIOTT Reply> Nozzle load to the main turbine exhaust nozzle will be submitted by Elliott.
Other nozzle load and combined nozzle load should be taken care by others.
<TTCL Piping Dept> Please submit main turbine exhaust nozzle loads to us as soon as possible,
We need this data for combined nozzle load checking.
<ELLIOTT Reply 2012-6-17> We have submitted Expansion Joint Drawing. The forces and moment at turbine exhaust is indicated in the drawing." >>> From ELLIOTT's Expansion Joint data sheet : TTCL Piping Dept. review vendor data for find out Fx,Fy,Fz ,Mx,My and Mz (Forces and Moments) ,we can use lateral movent and lateral spring rate for specify lateral forces but we found problem about Pressure Thrust Value that equal to 10969.23 kg (Both Operating and Design condition) .From our checking found this pressure thrust values come from design pressure (1.1 kg/cm^2). (While Turbine Data sheet specify operating pressure at Exhaust nozzle 0.13 kg/cm^2)
Pressure Thrust Force is a force that acting to Exhaust nozzle in axial Direction : refer to EJMA standard
Fs = Force due to thrust force load Fp = Force due to internal pressure Fa = Force due to expansion joint spring rate
Faxial = Fa+Fs-Fp
Now we assume Fa = 0 for estimate load due to thrust force.( No movement at both end of bellow) Internal Diameter of Exhaust Nozzle (Di) = 1067 mm. (Please submit confirm value to us) **** (1.4)
Faxial = 0 kg + 10969.23 kg - 9835.18 kg = 1134.05 kg
>>>> If we use Expansion Joint data at design condition for combine axial movement at both end of Expansion Joint (from Turbine Nozzle and Condenser Nozzle)
Faxial = 276.46 kg +1134.05 kg = 1410.51 kg. (Nearly allowable limit that concern to avialable room for combined forces and moments)
We found Fr @ Exhaust Nozzle = Sqrt(1410.51^2 + 505.49^2) = 1498.35 kg > (Allowable Fr @ Mr =0 Equal to 1462 kg and effect to exceed Allowable Combined Resultants of combined forces and moments )
Page 2 of 3 27/11/2012 1.1 We need clarification of this problem from ELLIOTT. (How to manage this problem?)
1.2 Our Piping Stress Specification specified to use operating condition determine forces and moments at rotating equipment nozzle, Can we use Operating Pressure at Turbine Exhaust Nozzle = 0.13 kg/cm^2 for calculate pressure thrust load and internal pressure load?
1.3 Due to low allowable Forces and Moments ,we hard to adjust piping route within this limit. Can ELLIOTT increase Allowable Forces&Moments factor from 1 to other such as 1.5 ?
1.4 Please specify Internal Diameter of Exhaust Nozzle .
Please reply to us as soon as possible, Thank you very much for your support.
Best Regards,
Mr.Phichit B. Planning & Piping Department Engineering Division TTCL
----- Original Message ----- From: Krischai T. To: 'Phichit B.' Cc: 'Komkrit P.' ; 'nitiwat.b' ; d160@toyo-thai.com Sent: Tuesday, October 30, 2012 9:54 AM Subject: Allowable Nozzle Force and Moment for Main Turbine (RT-4301)
Dear Khun Phichit,
I would like to submit latest Allowable Nozzle Force and Moment for Main Turbine (RT-4301) for your advance information. kindly to review and return comment (if any) via ID-Check MA-260 krub.