Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1.
Abstract
The contents of the paper will be about the faade
typology of nine Dutch Public Buildings and the Fort in
the Core and Buffer zone in Melaka. The aim of the
faade typology analysis is that it will contribute to a
better understanding of Dutch architecture in Melaka.
The objective is to clarify the faade typology of Dutch
Public Buildings in Melaka.
The methodology of this study has been done through
the qualitative descriptive method. The study of
principles of Simon Stevin (1548-1620) with regard to
the Fort, descriptive methods and statistical methods.
Through a descriptive method, the observational
method, an inventory has been made containing the
streets and total number of Public Buildings. Inclusive
measurements of the faades and of the doors and
windows. Using a statistical method: a presentation
was made of the location of the buildings, of this study,
in Melaka on a map.
The findings of this study are that Dutch Public
buildings in Melaka have influences of Dutch,
Portuguese and Chinese architecture and decoration.
Dutch architecture shows an exactitude and symmetry
in design. As can be seen in the bays and windows in
the Public Buildings.
Dutch elements are, among others, iron hinges on the
th
doors and windows. As of the 18 century a Portuguese
architectural influence can be noticed in the gable
endings and the arched openings of the galleries of the
houses. A Chinese influence is the green tiling on the
verandah or gallery of the houses.
Introduction
The methodology used in this paper is
Qualitative Research. Qualitative research
broadly defined, means any kind of research
Methodology
A source of information that can be
invaluable to qualitative researchers is
analysis of documents. Such documents might
include official records, letters, newspaper
accounts, diaries, and reports, as well as the
published data used in a review of literature
(Hoepfl, 1997, p. 54).
With regard to this paper literature on the
principles of Simon Stevin (1548-1620) about
the Fort in Melaka has been studied.
Especially the principle De Sterctenbouwing
of 1594 (The Art of Fortification). In this
1
Public Buildings
Architectural Influence
Wide Hall house
The design of the Public Buildings in Melaka
has been influenced by the Wide Hall house
from the Netherlands. The influence is
noticable because in the Netherlands these
kind of houses are deep and the faade is
turned to the street. In Melaka the sides
however are turned to the street. The hall
house has one story as have the Public
Buildings in Melaka.
Figure 1: The Wide Hall house
Source: Zantkuyl (1975:87).
(MPMBB):
Jalan Kota
Achitecture Museum
Dept. of Museum and Antiquities
Stamp Museum
The Fort
Jalan Geraja
Stadthuys
Christ Church
Jalan Tun Tan Cheng Lock
Two Former Warehouses/Heeren-house
Jalan Hang Jabat
VOC Building
Lorong Hang Jabat
Former Warehouse/Shipyard
Guardhouse at the Porta Trenquara
Architecture
Museum
VOC Building
Dep. of Museums
& Antiquities
Stamp Museum
Two Former
Warehouses
Former Warehouse
/Shipyard
The Fort
Guardhouse
Christ Church
Stadthuys
Individual Buildings
Close to the Stadthuys there still stands an
Characteristics
Dutch architecture in Melaka, in the Public
Buildings, shows an exactitude and symmetry in
design. As can be seen in the symmetrically
placed bays, doors and windows. The faades
of the Architecture museum, the Department of
Museum & Anitquities, Stamp Museum, Christ
Church and the Former Warehouse/Shipyard
are divided in bays. In all the buildings the doors
and windows are symmetrically placed in the
faade.
Dutch elements in some buildings are
rectangular or semicircular airvents which are
placed over the door or windows in the outside
wall like in the Stadthuys and the VOC
Building. The VOC Building, Christ Church and
the Stadthuys have fanlights. Most Public
Buildings have front porches. Except for the
Stadthuys, VOC building and Christ Church.
The front porch of Christ Church was added
during the English period. The buildings have
hinges on the doors and windows which are
Dutch in design and allow the windows to open
inward or outward. Over the windows of the
Airvent
Airvent
with glass
Fanlight
Front Porch
Hard wood
framing
Moulded
key-stones
Pilaster
Pilaster
Roof tiles
Sailors
head
Side gable
Stucco
ledge
Stucco
element
Stucco
base
Rectangular window
with
louvre
shutter
Rectangul
-ar
window
with shutters
Cross bar
window
Cross bar
window
Stucco
Pironnen
Terracotta
tiles
Wall
anchors
Weather
vane
Full length
window
with
shutters
with
louvres on
top
Full length
window
with
shutters
with
louvres at
the bottom
Window
with
louvres
Figure 5: Doors
Source: R.C.M.Weebers
Two
separate
parts
Two
separate
parts
Two
separate
parts
Two
separate
parts
Two
seperate
parts
With
Airvent
With
Airvent
Coach
Door
Coach
Door
Coach
Door
Findings
Dutch architecture in Melaka, in the Public
Buildings, shows an exactitude and symmetry
in design. Most of the buildings are rectangular
in form which shows a balance in size and
measurements. The side faades of the houses
are facing the street. The buildings have bays,
doors and windows which are symmetrically
placed. The bays in the faades of the buildings
are similar in size and design, the doors are
similar in size and design and the windows are
similar in size and design.
Dutch, Portuguese and Chinese Influences.
Dutch
Dutch elements of the Public Buildings are:
airvents, fanlight, front porch, hinges, moulded
keystones, pilasters, a sailors head, side gables,
stucco ledge, stucco element, stucco base,
stucco pironnen, terra-cotta tiles, weather
vane and wall anchors.
Portuguese
As of the 18th century a Portuguese
architectural influence can be noticed in the
gable endings and the arched openings of the
galleries of the houses.
Chinese
A Chinese influence is the green tiling on the
verandah or gallery of the houses.
Other Elements
Are the windows and doors. Rectangular
windows with louvre shutters, Rectangular
windows, Crossbar windows with shutters, Full
length windows with shutters with louvres on
7
References
Haan, de H, Haagsma, I. (1990). Architectuur van Erasmus. Een karakterschets van de Nederlandse
bouwkunst. Haarlem, The Netherlands: Architext.
Fockema, A.S.J., Ter Kuile E.H., & Hekker R.C. (1948-1957). Duizend jaar bouwen in Nederland, Amsterdam,
The Netherlands: Allert de Lange.
Jaziah Binti Mohd Ali. (2010). Exploring the Facade of Dutch Townhouses in Heerenstraat Melaka. (Bachelor
Dissertation Architecture, Universiti Malaya, 2010).
Measured Drawing. (2001). Front Facade of Buildings Northwest Jalan Hang Jebat (Jonker Street), Melaka,
Department of Architecture, Faculty of Built Environment, Universiti Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia:
Universiti Malaya.
Measured Drawing. (2001). Southwest Facade Jalan Hang Jebat (Jonker Street) 75200 Melaka, Department of
Architecture, Faculty of Built Environment, Universiti Malaya. Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia: Universiti Malaya.
Rosli Haji Nor. (1996). A Brief History of Malacca and the influence of European Architecture in the Historic
city of Malacca, Ancient Ceylon, Journal of the Department of Archeology, 18, 7-11.
Sandelowski, M. (2000). Focus on Research Methods Whatever Happened to Qualitative Description? Research in Nursing & Health. 23(4)334-340. Retrieved from http://www.wou.edu/~mcgladm/ Quantitative
%20Methods/optional%20stuff/qualitative%20description.pdf (accessed 26 May 2012).
Vanden Berghe, G. & Devreese J.T. Simon Stevin and the Art of War. Retrieved from http://freedownload.is/
doc/simon-stevin-flemish-tutor-of-a-dutch-prince-2328982.html (25th of March 2010)
Vis, L. (1982). The Stadthuys of Malacca, Restoration Proposal National Museum. Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia:
National Museum.
Vis, L. (1988), Nederlandse woonhuizen binnen het voormalige kasteel van Malacca. In De Stenen Droom:
Opstellen over bouwkunst en monumentenzorg: opgedragen aan Coenraad Liebrecht Temminck Groll.
Zutphen, The Netherlands: De Walburg Pers. (113-121)
Vries de, D., Heuvel van den, Ch., Lem van der, A., & Lombaerde P. (2004), Catalogue Exhibition University
Library. Oostende gewonnen, Sluis verloren 1604: een kroniek in kaarten. Leiden, the Netherlands:
Universiteitsbibliotheek.
Appendices
Appendix 1: Elements of the Public Buildings
Windows
Rectangular
with
louvre
shutters
Architecture Museum
Department of Museum &
Antiquities
Stamp Museum
The Stadthuys
Christ Church
The VOC Building
Two Former Warehouses
Former Warehouse/
Shipyard
Guardhouse at Porta
Trenguera
Rectangular
Crossbar
With shutters
Full length
with shutters with
louvres on
top
Full length
with shutters with
louvers at
the bottom
With
louvers
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Doors
Doors
Architecture Museum
Department of Museum &
Antiquities
Stamp Museum
The Stadthuys
Christ Church
The VOC Building
Two former Warehouses
FormerWarehouse/Shipyard
Guardhouse at Porta
Trenquera
Two separate
parts
X
With Airvent
Coach Door
X
X
X
X
Other Elements
Other Elements
Architecture
Museum
Department of
Museum &
Antiquities
Stamp Museum
The Stadthuys
Christ Church
The VOC
Building
Airvents
Fanlight
Front
Porch
HInges
Moulded
keystones
Pilaster
X
X
X
X
X
X
Sailors
head
Side
gable
Roof tiles
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Two Former
Warehouses
Former Ware
house/
Shipyard
Guardhouse at
Porta
Trenquera
Stucco
ledge
Architecture Museum
Department of
Museum & Antiquities
Stamp Museum
The Stadthuys
Christ Church
The VOC Building
Two Former
Warehouses
Former
Warehouse/Shipyard
Guardhouse at Porta
Trenquera
Stucco
element
Stucco
base
Stucco
pironnen
Side
gables
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Terracotta
tiles
X
X
Wall Anchors
X
X
X
X
X
Weather
Vane
X
X
10
8.70
18.44
m
m
Height
Width
1.93
1.97
m
m
Height
Width
2.77
2.03
m
m
Height
Width
1.78
2.03
m
m
Depth
Width
3.60
18.44
m
m
8.70
Front Porch
Roof
Height to
the roof
Elements
1.
7.20
12.70
m
m
Height
Width
1.97
1.60
m
m
Height
Width
2.50
1.73
m
m
Door
11
2.74
11.61
m
m
Depth
Width
2.00
12.70
m
m
Height
to the
roof
7.20
Front Porch
Roof
Elements
Stamp Museum
7.10
19.50
m
m
Height
Width
2.17
1.56
m
m
Height
Width
1.47
0.92
m
m
Height
Width
2.57
2.46
m
m
Height
Width
2.29
2.75
m
m
Height
Width
2.55
2.50
m
m
Height
Width
2.17
1.56
m
m
12
Front Porch
Depth
Width
2.21
19 .50
m
m
Depth
Width
8.50
3.23
m
m
Balcony
Roof
Height
to the
roof
7.20
Elements
The Stadthuys
12.00
11.30 m.
and 88.10
m
m
m
Height
Width
3.24
2.47
m
m
Door
Height
Width
3.74
2.29
m
m
Height
Width
3.00
2.47
m
m
Height
Width
3.74
2.29
m
m
Width
Depth
2.55
1.00
m
m
Width
Depth
11.10
3.77
m
m
Height
2.83
Door/Window
Terrace
13
Width
0.33
Height
Width
1.62
1.38
m
m
Allcove
Height
Width
3.15
2.04
m
m
Roof
Height
to the
roof
12.00
Windows (2x)
Elements
Christ Church
12.49
12.80
m
m
Height
Width
3.40
1.36
m
m
Height
Width
3.40
3.10
m
m
Front Porch
Depth
Width
3.00
12.80
m
m
Roof
Height
to the
roof
12.49
Elements
6.60
4.95
Height
Width
2.20
1.20
m
m
m
m
14
Height
Width
1.80
1.20
m
m
Front Porch
Width
Depth
4.95
2.92
m
m
Roof
Height
to the
roof
6.60
Elements
VOC Building
12.37
14.05
m
m
Height
Width
2.52
1.24
m
m
Height
Width
3.65
2.65
m
m
Height
Width
2.13
14.05
m
m
Depth
Width
3.00
14.05
m
m
12.37
Front Porch
Roof
Height
to the
roof
Elements
Louvred windows. wall anchors, door and window hinges, windowfans, balustrade. Roof
trim, roof-ornarnentation, over hanging roof,
sidegable,
15
Former Warehouse/Shipyard
Height
8.12
17.50
19.00
m
m
m
Height
2.60
Width
1.74
Height
Width
3.28
1.99
m
m
Front Porch
Depth
Width
3.50
17.50
m
m
Roof
Height
to the
roof
8.12
Elements
3.60
13.0
m
m
Height
Width
1.52
0.92
m
m
Height
2.13
Width
1.34
Height
2.25
m
m
m
Width
1.52
Height
Width
3.00
1.80
m
m
Height
1.52
Width
0.92
16
1.52
0. 92
2.13
1.34
1.52
0.92
m
m
13.90
Front Porch
Roof
Elements
Depth
Width
Height
to the
roof
3.60
17