Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
January - March, 2014; pp. 57-126
Historiography and commentary on the 16 June 1819 Kutch Earthquake, Gujarat, India
Sujit Dasgupta1* and Basab Mukhopadhyay2
1Formerly with Geological Survey of India. Present Address: 16/1D, Bose Pukur Road, Kolkata 700 042, India
2Geological Survey of India, Central Headquarters, 27 J. L. Nehru Road, Kolkata 700016, India
Abstract: Transcriptions from original documents describing the effects of the 16 June 1819 Kutch earthquake in the western India
constitute the basic theme of this paper. The objective is to collate all relevant rare and out-of-print materials and compile them in
the form of a comprehensive document to facilitate future research. Descriptive accounts for this earthquake and contemporary research
based on such sources indicate that this earthquake was a very large event and one of the vastly documented earthquakes of the
Nineteenth Century. Re-evaluation of archival materials suggest that this earthquake might have been produced from a north-dipping
blind thrust with listric geometry at depth producing fault-propagating fold which is manifested by the presence of 100-km-long
sinusoidal Allah Bund with steeper southern scarp and gentler northern face in the Runn of Kutch. The tentative epicentral location
is around Wagajakot / Vigakot placed north of Allah Bund. Such a major earthquake followed by another one almost 200 years later
on 26 January 2001 (Mw 7.7) at Bhuj with numerous moderate- to low-magnitude shocks in between, including the Anjar earthquake
(Mw 6.0) of 1956 mark the seismic vulnerability of this Stable Continental Region (SCR), and thus necessitates reconciliation on
available seismic hazard assessment.
Keywords: 1819 Kutch Earthquake, Runn of Kutch, Allah Bund, north-dipping blind thrust, archival material, seismic hazard
Introduction
The region of Kutch has significant political history coupled
with notable seismic record. In the earlier part of 19th century,
Kutch was in commotion for a considerably long period of
time; 35 years of misrule by an ineffective and insane ruler of
Kutch, Rao Roydhunjee till 1813, followed by a similar reign
of bloodshed, treachery and falsehood under Rao Bharmuljee,
the British Government (Company) decided that the affairs of
but a few assailants injured. Minor son of late Rao was selected
State:
58
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Tranquillity was for the first time for years displaying its benign
influence over the face of nature; mans worst passions, which
the current of events had called into action, were gradually
subsiding, when, as if to show the nothingness of a nations
convulsions and revolutions, as if to make the chief actors in
these scenes feel the utter feebleness and helplessness of man,
or thousands of men, a mighty earthquake visited the Province,
shaking every house, from the Princes palace to the paupers
grass hut, to its centre; nor were the resting- places of the dead
exempt from the devastation committed by this mighty
convulsion of nature. The Raos palace was rendered temporarily
uninhabitable, while hundreds of houses in Bhooj, Anjar,
Mandvee, and Lukput were buried to the ground, burying
hundreds of men, women, and children in their ruins; numbers
also of the forts, including the marauders strongholds, were
dismantled, and not again allowed to be repaired. The accounts
of the desolation of Bhooj forcibly remind one of the descriptions
given of the last days of Pompeii. A number of extraordinary
phenomena are reported to have occurred at the moment of the
shock, an instance or two of which I hope to be pardoned for
noticing.... The Runn, and Bunnee, lying on the north of Kutch
and between it and the Punchum Island, which were quite dry,
were suddenly covered over with a sheet of water; the extent
of it, east and west, is not known, but in width it was about six
miles, its depth was upwards of two and a half feet; after which,
in a few hours, the water sank down to about half that quantity.
Horsemen who crossed the track on the day following the
shock, describe a number of cones of sand elevated above the
water, the summits of which were emitting air and water. The
dry beds of the rivers were generally found flooded with water
for a short space of time, the water having the colour and taste
of the soil, from which it would appear to have been forced by
some convulsion of nature below. Many wells, which were
previously sweet, became salt, and vice versa, while a mighty
up-heaving of a large bank in the western part of the Runn
completed what the enmity of the Ameers of Sind had previously
commenced, viz, the shutting out of the Indus waters from
Kutch. This bank bears the name of Ulla Bund, or the Bund
or embankment of God; its height above the original level is
estimated at about 18 feet, while its length is undefined, running,
some think, as far as the Punchum Island, but at all events, for
many miles in that direction. It is estimated as being at least
50 miles long; its width varies from 10 to 15 miles. This Bund
is situated in the Runn about 10 or 15 miles south of Raoma
Bazar in Sind, a portion of it being passed en route from that
place to Loona in Kutch, though the greater portion of it remains
on the right of the road or track. The Jogees or religious devotees
of Deenoder, the highest hill in Kutch, on which there is a
monastery, declare that during the earthquake of 1819 fire issued
from the hill. It bears evident traces, in common with others
in Kutch, of having been subjected to volcanic action at some
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
59
Contemporary Research
This great earthquake provides the earliest well-documented
instance of faulting during an earthquake (Richter, 1958).
Chandra (1977) gave epicentral co-ordinate as 23.6N: 69.6E
with maximum intensity (MM scale) XI; he further
summarized the Allah Bund as a 80-km-long, E-W-trending
low ridge or swell of 24 km width; the land to the north of
the bund elevated by about 56 m and subsided to the south
by 35 m. Quittmeyer and Jacob (1979) assigned epicentral
location at 24.0N: 69.0E with a possible magnitude range
of Ms 7.258.25; Intensity (MM) of IX-X; rupture length
varying between 90 and 140 km with assumed rupture width
of 30 km; average displacement assigned as 79 m and Mo
(1.57.0) x 10 27 dyne. cm. IMD catalogue gives a magnitude
of 8.0 with coordinates of the epicentre as 24.0N and 70.0E;
and BARC catalogue gives magnitude of 8.3 with location
and intensity as that of Chandra (1977). Johnston and Kanter
(1990) estimate moment magnitude (Mw) of 7.8 which has
been adopted by Chung and Gao (1995) and also by Schulte
and Moony (2005). In most of the previous studies the
epicentral location has been plotted much south of the Allah
Bund fault; Bilham (1998) through his detailed study
concluded that the 1819 rupture occurred 515 km north or
northeast of the Allah Bund and the longitude cannot be
determined by the available data to better than 1. Combining
intensity and deformation data, Bilham further assumed a
magnitude of Mw 7.7 0.2. He also modelled the deformation
as a north- or northeast-dipping near-surface reverse fault
that slipped locally for more than 11m and the rupture extended
at least 80 km along strike. Rajendran and Rajendran (2001)
carried out paleoseismological studies in the area and noted
that a 90-km-long tract of elevated land with a peak height
of 4.3 m is the most visible surface expression of this
earthquake. These authors further concluded that the scarp
morphology is suggestive of a growing fold (as originally
suggested by Oldham, 1926; see his Figure 1) related to a
buried north-dipping thrust; preferred epicentral location is
24.25N: 69.25E. In their subsequent publication (Rajendran
60
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Fig. 1. Isoseismal map of 1819 Kutch earthquake. Intensities in MSK scale (after Ambraseys and Douglas, 2004).
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
61
Fig. 2. Isoseismal map of 1819 Kutch earthquake. Intensity values in MSK-64 scale (after Pande, 2011).
62
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Archived Material
and during that short period the city of Bhooj was almost
leveled with the ground. The walls, from the sandy nature
of the stone, were crumbled into dust; nearly all the towers
and gateways were demolished; and the houses, which were
left standing, were so shattered as to be uninhabitable. The
fort, which stands at some distance from the city, is so
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
63
heaving of the ground; and during the time the shock lasted,
could with difficulty keep their feet; and the riders, when
the earth like the beating of the no-but, and occasioned the
64
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
severe, took place on the 23d, at midnight. Some houses
were sensibly felt in the camp before Bhooj for more than
could not stand, that the pillars of the building shook and
his duties at the time, and was thrown down, as was also
the peon who went to assist him. These persons, with many
thirty miles from Bhooj; and about ten days after the first
(i)
(ii)
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
65
at about 300 yards distance, and from the sea face of the
timbers. The earth opened, and water issued from the cavity
the fort which I had been walking on not five minutes before.
66
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
some old houses down, and violently shook the seats of those
who were seated within doors, which caused them to run out
of their houses; but these inferior alarms are not to be compared
with yesterdays awful phenomenon. It was observed that all
animals were much frightened during the great shock; the
dogs lay down on their bellies and would not be moved. The
earthquake has been felt far and wide, but its effects appear
to have been less violent in the interior than on the sea shore.
I fear that all the line of towns and fortresses situated
immediately on this coast have suffered much. I am this
moment informed that fifty men were killed by the fall of
walls at Mangrole, on this coast, which is distant sixty miles
in a S.E. direction. The shock appears to have proceeded from
west to east. The injury which this fort has sustained is
estimated at half a lac of rupees. There is nothing in nature
more awful than to see the proudest works of men in an instant
vanishing, and becoming a heap of shapeless ruins.
Porebunder, 18th June, 1819.I have viewed the whole
extent of injury at this place, since writing to Col. B., and
am sorry to inform you it far exceeds the estimate which I
had formed; were I now to address the Colonel, I would
rather say, twenty pieces of cannon could not have produced
so much destruction. I have corrected my heights and
distances by measurements, which are as now mentioned,
though in some places they differ from the original letter.
As Dr. A. and myself, yesterday morning, at daybreak, were
riding on the borders of a lake, we were alarmed by a strong
smell of sulfur, and an appearance of smoke resting on the
still waters. On the opposite side of the lake is a jungle,
beyond and above, which is a range of sand hills; we thought
we saw on these a line of thick flame about three feet high,
but the distance was too great to allow of our being positive.
I am the more inclined to believe that what we saw was a
flame, as I am since informed that at a place on the S.E.
coast, distant hence forty miles, the earth opened, and a
flame issued from the cavity. I am informed that at a place
distant hence sixteen miles N.W. by N., what was a rising
ground or small hill, has become a level. My varandah tiles
were turned but ten days ago for the monsoon, but are now
quite removed in some places, and in all greatly disordered,
so as to induce Lieut. L. aptly to observe, that they appeared
as if they had been convulsed. That part of the parapet which
I described as having been so violently agitated, now leans
considerably on one side, and retains its wave like shape.
Dr. A. and myself experienced a pain and weakness in the
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
June 16
at 7. 20 PM awful to a degree
17
18
at 7 AM rather strong
19
21
at 9 AM rather strong
23
at 2 AM strong; the house and furniture in great agitation three quarters of an hour
29 & 30
July 8
67
at 11 PM slight
11
at 5 AM alight
21
at 10 PM strong, the house, &c. in agitation three quarters of a minute. (Bombay Gazette, Aug. 4.)
68
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
June 21st, 1819 Thermometer at 2 P.M. 90 degrees; slight
while in bed; removed bed, and slept in the open air, lest other
S.S.W.; our first rains set strongly in at 12 last night, with the
change of the moon; there were then tremors in the earth, but
the former date has been so far correct, that the principal
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
69
sensations felt since the 25th have been so slight, that were
actually rocked, particularly the mess one of the 1st bat. 19th
regt., in which the officers were at dinner at the time, and the
huts of the soldiers were a good deal damaged. The heat for
I now, Sir, bid you adieu, with the assurance, that we have
experienced the truth of the admirable Blairs assertion, that
this world is a region of danger, in which perfect safety is
possessed by no man.
(v) Information relating to the earthquake from some distant
places (page 184)
Muttra [Mathura 27.50N:77.73E], June 19, 1819: We had
a smart shock of earthquake here on the evening of the 16th,
the last two or three days has been excessive, and not a drop
of rain has yet fallen.
(vi)
about 30 or 40 seconds.
against the sides of the shades. When I reached the open air,
was felt here on the night of the 16th June, 1819 at a quarter
the earth still moved, and it is my belief that the shock must
have lasted nearly a minute and a half; I did not return into
the house for some minutes after the trembling ceased. When
70
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
upwards, it was succeeded by an oscillatory motion of a more
was between west and east; and this direction was distinctly
water from the brim of a large earthen jar, two or three feet
to the eastward of it; the vessel is about two feet high, and
water stood about five inches below the brim, and this is of
stone and other materials, and was not less so for the famous
shaking violently, the tiles falling from the roofs, and the
while riding out saw the minars come down; the tops were
the termination of the shock, it could not have been less than
four or five minutes. The sky was overcast, dark and cloudy,
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
71
place, and the loss of lives terrible. The fort and town are
been much injured, and the walls rent in many places. The
most fortunate, amidst all our disasters, that not a single life
evening, the city of Surat, its vicinity for some miles round,
we had one very severe, which shook the houses and caused
glad to get off of it; the house was considerably agitated, the
on the alert, and quitted our houses in haste; but the shock
the wall, and the lamps swung violently. I ran down stairs
intervals during the whole of the day. The last which I felt
our feet. The shock lasted about five or six minutes, and
fell down; report says one man was killed. I likewise felt two
there. The Adawlut has suffered, and the walls rent; the
slight shocks about half past 8 last night and 10 minutes past
houses, and the water in the well of the jail, which is ordinarily
Our watches vary much, having nothing but the sun and
the river was also much agitated, and the water from the tank
72
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
c)
told a word of its being felt at all to the westward of the little
boxes were moved from their places; that the pagodas and
that the thanadar was also at his duties at the time, and was
thrown down, as was also the peon who went to assist him.
the capital of Sind; and if any thing like the effects which
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
73
the springs, and even the position, shape, and colour of certain
or about the same day that we had ours. If you can collect
of the weather, and in the state of the tides, must have existed
74
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
in Cutch; and as it appears to have been remarkable in India
for the great extent of its range, and also for the very confined
drawn to it.
passed on with the clear and serene sky, the burning sun, and
that if the motion had continued for more than two minutes,
slate rock in the town of Anjar, and close under a large round
tower with four heavy guns mounted on it. Our notice was
been lifted up, and a noise from the doors and windows, as
its feet. When the shock was at its height, the motion of the
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
75
noise like that of a numerous flight of birds; but this did not
of July there were not fewer than two or even three shocks
precede the event; I think, on the contrary, that the noise was
every day; one daily throughout that month; one every three
manner of 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th, implying the degree of their
severity. Of the 1st, we had only the first and most violent;
day. During the whole of this time the shocks were generally
very slight; many persons did not feel what was sensibly felt
which I was at first one) believed that the direction was nearly
76
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
appears since to be corroborated by circumstances, was that
Chunar the severe shock was felt at seven minutes past eight
E. Long
E. Long
E. Long.
Calcutta
88 28'
Chunar,
82 54'
Pondicherry
79 58'
Bhooj,
69 58'
Bhooj
69 58'
Bhooj
69 58'
18 30' or diff
12 56' or diff
10 00' or diff
TIME
TIME
TIME
1h 14m
0h 51m 44s
0h 40m
8h 20m
8h 7m 0s
8h 0m
7h 6m
7h 15m 16s
7h 20m
sensibly on the evening of the 16th June, the exact time not
Etna was threatening to bury in its lava the cities in its vicinity;
was either not noticed or did not occur; but it was severely
Amercote, and Jesilmer, which all lie in the Desert and north
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
77
have seen its effects in these places and in Cutch declare the
for ten days after the 16th; and this last feeling among Europeans
trifling degree. The south and western sides of the town are
the occurrence of the slight shocks; but for a short time after
situated upon a low ridge of sand rock, and the water from
78
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
also been overturned in many places, and not a hundred yards
level with the ground, 1333 yards destroyed to within ten feet
of entire wall left. The town has been utterly destroyed in the
of the bottom, and only 667 yards standing to the rampart, and
the greatest part of this split in half [The walls of Anjar were
are not more than one hundred and ten years old]. All the
case every where, that buildings situated upon rock were not
inner and in others the outer half has crumbled into ruins. The
whose foundations did not reach the bottom of the soil, which
east and swampy face is down to the very surface of the earth.
Venjan [Vinjhan], and many other towns of the same size and
and in some places forty feet high; and in this extent are
Bhooj
[23.27N:69.67E]
1140*
Anjar
[23.13N:70.02E]
165
Mothora
[23.20N:69.13E]
73
Thera
[23.28N:68.93E]
65
Kotheree
[23.13N:68.93E]
34
Nulliah
[23.26N:68.82E]
Mandvee
[22.86N:69.39E]
45
Luckput
[23.82N:68.77E]
13
1543
* Registered and discovered; but upwards of 300 bodies never found in the ruins
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
79
on the spot reported the circumstance, and that the hill had
been shattered, and rent into ravines: the height was likewise
fire].
As far as comes under our notice, the face of nature has not
been much altered by the shocks. The hills, which are most
found a strong stream from bank to bank; nor did they learn
having had large masses of rock and soil detached from their
the cause till they reached the town. It is remarked that rivers
in the valleys, and those with sandy beds, were alone affected.
Wells every where overflowed, many gave way and fell in,
ball of a large size was vomited as it were into the air, and
the westward, and the Runn or desert, and swamp called the
had sunk, and the spot where the fire-ball was supposed to
deep. This was when the tide was at ebb; and when at flood
the depth of the channel was never more than six feet, and
80
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
about eighty or one hundred yards in breadth: the rest of the
than one or two feet of water. This branch of the river Indus,
belief adopted by all sects and descriptions was, that the world
sea [It is many years since the eastern branch of the Indus
has been almost deserted by the waters of the river], has since
of their houses and shops which had fallen into the road.
has been found to contain from four to twenty feet from the
scattered over its surface, still there does not exist even a
the Vedes after much study. From the Shri Bhud Maha Grunth,
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
81
say that for two months we never had a day without some
Damotherjee is truth.
mind].
was pawing for his food, and strict injunctions were issued
the Dyets and Dewas, and fabricated the most ludicrous stories
on the subject. Prophets sprung up from all classes, casts and
sects; some asserted that they had foretold the calamity which
had occurred; others boldly pointed out the hour and moment
at which still more calamitous events were to happen; and in
short there was a superabundant display of every thing absurd
or extravagant that could be advanced by ignorance and
presumption, deceit and superstition.
has quitted the town, and lives outside, it being really not
[letter of 17 June].
82
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Yesterday morning we went out to the westward of the town
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
83
Since the 16th constant shocks have been felt, perhaps all
together nearly thirty in number. The weather continues much
the same as might be expected at this season. The wind is
very variable: heavy squalls are suddenly succeeded by dead
the shock. There are reports of fire having issued from hills
84
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
light air, scarcely perceptible, was sometimes felt from the
walk on the ramparts of the fort, and had gone nearly all
was; and five minutes after, I heard a distant sound not unlike
over a part of the fort which I had been walking on not five
minutes before.
occurrence that was met with near it, was the horse-keepers
with the horses in their hands standing in the open air; having
The earth opened, and water issued from the cavity, in a plain
face of the fort, which ran at right angles with the one we had
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
impregnated with a strong smell of sulfur and between 10
A.M. and 2 P.M. there were several other shocks, which
brought down some old houses: but these shocks were not to
be compared with yesterdays awful phenomenon. It was
observed that all animals were much frightened: the dogs lay
down on their bellies and would not be moved. The earthquake
in the interior appears to have been less violent than near the
sea-shore. I am this moment informed that fifty men have
been killed by the fall of walls at Mangarole [Mangrol], which
is distant hence 80 miles in a S.E. direction.
The sixth and the last letter printed in the Transactions of the
Bombay Literary Society was from G. A. Stuart, Assistant
Surgeon from camp - Sirdas, addressed to Capt. Kennedy dated
17 June, 1819:
(v) Dr. G. A. Stuart
Being a Member of the Literary Society, I deem it a kind of
duty that attaches to me, to record for the information of the
Society any fact or circumstance of considerable interest
which may fall under my observation connected with the
objects of the Society In these sentiments, I now have to
mention the occurrence of the shock of an earthquake here
yesterday evening. It occurred about seven oclock. It was
such as to alarm every one who felt it. The earth under us
seemed to rise and fall very considerably; so considerably,
indeed, that I myself could not stand steadily. Every one who
felt it became in some degree giddy. It was not felt by any
one who was on horseback; and this was the case with several
of our officers. Every one, however, who was on the ground
felt it to be very alarming. The duration of it was not measured
by any one, but I think it lasted about two minutes. It was at
first slight, and towards its termination the motion became
less and less violent. We have had no accounts of it from
neighbouring towns; so that I am led to suppose it has not
been so violent as to do much mischief in other places. This
country, Kattiwar, is rocky and rugged. The rock is of the
trap kind, containing great quantities of agate and crystallized
quartz. I have observed nothing of a volcanic nature, unless
the trap to be considered such.
85
the spot where they once reared their heads! Another mosque
86
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
of elegant structure, which lies to the left of the road leading
towers which formed the grand entrance into the citadel have
a noise issued from the earth like the beating of the no but,
houses.
keep their feet; and the rider when upon the ground, were
Neither the rush of the sea into this new depression, nor the
lying on was so great that I was glad to get off it; the house
table close to me kept striking the wall, and the lamps swung
the water filling the space within the walls, and the four
are elevated, and at all loosely built, creaked like the masts
level plain. To this uplifted tract they gave the name of Ullah
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
87
when the tide was at ebb and at flood tide never more than
f) 1843 R. Baird-Smith:
six feet; but it was deepened at the fort of Luckput after the
other parts of the channel it was found, that where previously
the depth of water at flood never exceeded one or two feet,
it had become from four to ten feet deep. By these and other
remarkable changes of level, a part of the inland navigation
of that country, which had been closed for centuries, became
again practicable. In describing the effects of the shock in
this neighbourhood, Captain Burnes remarks: Wells and
rivulets without number changed from fresh to salt water; but
these were trifling alterations compared with those which
took place in the Eastern branch of the Indus and the adjacent
country. At sun-set, the shock was felt at Sindree, the station
at which the Cutch government levied their customs, situated
on the high road from Cutch to Sinde, and on the banks of
what had once been the Eastern branch of the Indus. The little
brick fort of 150 feet square, which had been built there for
the protection of merchandise, was overwhelmed by an
inundating torrent of water from the ocean, which spread on
every side, and in the course of a few hours converted the
tract, which before had been hard and dry, into an inland lake,
which extended sixteen miles on either side of Sindree. The
houses within the walls filled with water, and eight years
The only dry spot was where the bricks had fallen upon one
injured, many levelled with the ground, and among their ruins
another. One of the four towers only remained, and the Custom
numerous lives were lost. The first and greatest shock occurred
following day.
88
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
But it was soon discovered, Captain Burnes continues, that
the hills of the island, and they point out several considerable
where the soil was previously low and level. It extended East
the Phurraun river from the sea. The natives called this mound
allusion to its not being like the other dams of the Indus, a
did not appear more elevated in one place than another, and
appearance of the hills and lava which covers the face of the
were very great. They are thus described: The first and
greatest shock took place on the 16th June 1819, a few minutes
shores; and that many towns, now far inland, formed its
the ground, the crash of the buildings, and the dismay and
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
89
to get off it; the house was considerably agitated, the furniture
was almost levelled to the ground. The walls, from the sandy
and the lamps swung violently. I ran down-stairs, and got out
nature of the stone, were crumbled into dust; nearly all the
heaving of the ground; and during the time the shock lasted,
spot, and at all loosely built, creaked like the mast and rigging
with difficulty keep their feet; and the riders, when on the
which formed the grand entrance into the citadel have been
being deficient.
the couch on which I was lying was so great, that I was glad
90
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
level continues unaltered, that there is now taking place a
feet high, were thrown up. The details of this earthquake have
in time be furnished.
1819 June 16; 6.45- 6.50 PM: This was one of the most severe
and destructive earthquakes on record in India. The main
Changes in Landscape
We would now put in place the original papers that dealt with
the north of this tract, about 5 miles, a long low ridge or swell
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
91
which had been raised, did not injury of entirely exclude the
92
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
brick fort of 150 feet square, which had been built there for
tract, which had before been hard and dry, into an inland lake,
The houses within the walls filled with water, and eight years
it at that time. It has been engraved for this work, and faces
dry spot was the place on which the bricks had fallen upon
Fig. 3. The Sindree Fort as on 1808, eleven years before the Cutch earthquake. This engraving was prepared from a sketch
by Captain Grindlay who visited the site in 1808. This has been printed in Travel into Bokhara- A Voyage on the Indus,
Volume III by Burnes (1834). The same has been published by Sir Charles Lyell in his book, where in the footnote
he adds: I am assured by Captain Grant, and others well acquainted with the scene that the land introduced by the
artist in the back-ground is ideal. The flat plain of the Runn could alone be seen in that direction as far as the eye can
reach. The mirage so common there may have caused the apparent inequalities which have been introduced as rising
ground into the sketch. The reproduced sketch of the fort in the NW panel is after Pande (2011).
But it was soon discovered that this was not the only alteration
in this memorable convulsion of nature; as the inhabitants of
Sindree observed, at a distance of five miles northward, a
mound of earth or sand, in a place where the soil was previously
low and level. It extended east and west for a considerable
distance, and passed immediately across the channel of the
Indus, separating as it were forever the Phurraun river from
the sea. The natives called this mound by the name of Ullah
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
93
by water.
To the eye it did not appear more elevated in one place than
1826, when information was received that the Indus had burst
water had spread over the desert which bounds that country
The inland lake which had been thus formed, extended for
boat, and sailed up the river. At Lucput, and for twelve miles
about 2000 square miles, and its limits were well defined,
up, it was about 300 yards wide, and from two to three fathoms
it. The one led from Nurra to Loonee and Raomakabazar, and
town, the channel shallowed to four or five feet, for two miles;
that bounded the horizon on all sides, amid which the remaining
for boats of 100 tons from the sea to Lucput, which had never
of soft clay and shells, elevated about ten feet from the surface
of the water, and cut through like a canal, with perpendicular
banks on either side. The channel was about thirty-five yards
broad, and three fathoms deep; and a body of fresh water, a
portion of the real Indus, rolled down it into the lake which
that the bunds of the Indus had been burst, and that the
the river and lake were deeper in all places by two feet, the
94
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Besides the facts which have been recorded, it appears clear
these openings for a period of three days, and that the water
with six, and even ten feet of water. The shepherds with
all the wells dug on a level with the Run become salt. The
the principal sea-port, and its brick ruins are yet visible.
under water, was then dry, and that the fort of Sindree existed
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
95
outside, and one well: the creek here is about a mile and a
quarter broad, and has a ferry across. The travellers who take
and deepened; the banks are irregular in their height, and the
a road in the light sand, of which the dry part of the Run is
run through the country, and are cut into a variety of channels,
is there about 400 yards broad, and soon after widens very
much, with high sand-hills on the banks, and a few huts with
96
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
opportunity, on that account, would be very favourable for
its examination.
make its whole length upwards of fifty miles. That there must
be some foundation for the extent of it eastward is clear; for
there is an elevated mound, about a mile broad, on the road
from Luna to Raoma ca bazar, sixteen miles south of that
place, in the middle of the Runn, which is made the halting
ground in wet weather, and which was not there prior to the
earthquake of 1819. The elevation of Allah-band prevents
rain-water settling on it and I am more inclined than ever to
view it as a tract which might be very easily brought under
cultivation. A little to the eastward of the mouth at Allahband, I observed the remains of a band which had been
thrown up by Fateh Muhammed, to prevent the water of the
Caira-nalla flooding the road between Cutch and Sinde,
one of the many memorials of that public-spirited and
enterprising chief. It is, of course, now useless, for the road
is not open during the monsoon between the two countries.
already given.
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
97
of water spread over the desert, after it burst through all the
artificial dams on the river including the (co-seismic) Allah
the relevant part of map along with Burnes document (Fig. 4).
Fig. 4. Map of River Koree or eastern mouth of the Indus [redrawn after Burnes 1827; present frame taken from Oldham
(1826)]. Note the location of Ullah Bund, Sindree Lake and the Sindree Fort (in cross).
98
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
1840 - C. W. Grant
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
99
reproduce the note of Capt. Baker along the map and section
Mittee, joins the Pooraun at Chuttee Tur; the third, called the
and five miles south of that village falls into the Pooraun.
The Goonee being directly fed from the Indus, would have
The Mora Bund, the Bunds at Chuttee Tur and three miles
July last to enquire into, and report upon, the causes which
below it, the Bunds of Alli Bunder and Lallah Puttun, and
led to it.
100
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
The Mora Bunds are on the Goonee. The first or original
the sides) that is in now dry in some places, and being one
foot higher than the level of the lake, and seven feet above
The Bunds at and below Chuttee Tur are across the Pooraun;
they have had the mischievous effect of encouraging large
deposits of salt at their several localities, and of rendering
the onward progress of the water still more precarious. On
the other hand, they retain pools of fresh water for the use
of the scanty population and their cattle, and favor the
cultivation of the open spaces in the bed of the river.
The length of the Alla Bund has not been ascertained, but
water from the salt, and preventing the latter from spreading
which still lifts its head above the waters, alone breaks the
the channel.
monsoon, which drives the sea water up the Koree into the
lake; and that on the setting in of the north winds, a large
proportion of the present expanse of water would become dry
land. It is highly desirable that the extent of the Sindree Lake
and of the Alla Bund should be accurately traced, but the survey
would be a work of difficulty, in consequence of the barren
nature of the country, and of the total want of fresh water.
We now reproduce the text by Sir Charles Lyell from his eighth
revised edition of Principles of Geology published in 1850.
It may be noted that Sir Charles Lyell included just one
paragraph on this earthquake in his first edition published in
1830.
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Fig. 5A.
Map of part of Lower Scinde showing the situation of the bunds on the Goonee and
Pooraun rivers (After Baker, 1846).
101
102
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Fig. 5B. Profile along the same rivers from Mora Bund in the north to Sindree Lake in the south (After Baker, 1846).
miles farther, it was feebly felt. At the former city, the great
Anjar, the fort, with its tower and guns, were hurled to the
some days until the 20th; when, thirty miles north-west from
change of level.
some large masses only of rock and soil were detached from
the precipices; but the eastern and almost deserted channel
of the Indus, which bounds the province of Cutch, was
greatly changed. This estuary, or inlet of the sea, was, before
the earthquake, fordable at Luckput, being only about a foot
deep when the tide was at ebb and at flood tide never more
than six feet; but it was deepened at the fort of Luckput,
others well acquainted with the scene that the land introduced
by the artist in the back-ground is ideal. The flat plain of
the Runn could alone be seen in that direction as far as the
eye can reach. The mirage so common there may have
caused the apparent inequalities which have been introduced
as rising ground into the sketch]
one or two feet, it had become from four to ten feet deep.
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
103
Neither the rush of the sea into this new depression, nor the
water was less copious, and finally it became more salt than
Cutch is impregnated.
wide expanse of sea. The tops of the ruined walls still rose
two or three feet above the level of the water; and standing
the Indus.
years before all was land, and the only land visible consisting
Ten years after the visit of Sir A. Burnes above alluded to,
salt. He was told that it has now only four or five, feet of
of clay filled with shells. The new channel of the river where
threw such a body of water into the new mere, or salt lagoon,
104
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Fig. 6.
View of Fort of Sindree as in March 1838, looking from West, located in the midst of lake; prepared by Capt. Grant from
surveyors plan (reproduced from the book Principles of Geology by Charles Lyell, 1850).
But during the monsoons, when the sea runs high, the salt-
up of the Runn, some towns far inland are still pointed out
sand six or eight feet in height were at the same time thrown
up on these lands.
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
105
visit the Sindri Lake- Allah Bund area and based his narration
across it, even with the aid of a telescope, and the ruined Fort
of Sindree, which still lifts its head above the waters alone
1819; its bastons are still visible and left standing here and
106
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
their escape in boats. The water up there is so salt, that fish
dry bed of the old river until we reach the Chuch, some
three kos higher up, where the water is waist high and salt;
above described.
ever reading or hearing of, yet they are shown to have effected
the Meers Bund, but it is not the only one This bund is 10
who saw it four years ago, as one hundred yards long, twenty
five broad and four high, above it the water sweet and waist
high, below only driblets or dry; during the monsoon the
India to visit the Sindri Fort and Lake in January 1869 since
map of Kutch the location and extent of the Allah Bund and
that of Sindri depression, apparently from earlier map by Grant
(1840) and that of the Pooraun River, after Baker. Wynne also
made a sketch plan and view of the remnants of the Sindri Fort
(Fig. 7) and view of the Fort in 1869 (Fig. 8) along with the
Muthar, where the water is waist high at all times; this is half
a kos long; then comes the Ibrahim Shah Peer flag station,
where there is nine feet of water or more, which continues
past Sindree until the Ullah Bund is reached; through this
minutes,- to keep the feet was not easy, and the motion of
trifling shocks occurred and on next day the earth was
frequently in motion, attended by gusts of wind and a noise
like that of wheeled carriages.
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
107
that has been either seen or heard of, which would from its
Sir C. Lyell states that the shocks only occurred till the 20th
of June, and that the movement was felt over an area having
The dry beds of the Kutch rivers are said to have been all
filled to their banks for a short time, the water having the
have been forced. Many wells which had been fresh, became
salt, and vice versa. This part of the account may have a
and it may be that the lower portions of the river courses only
point.
With all this ruin the face of nature in the interior of Kutch
the hills, and vast clouds of dust were seen to ascend from
the fresh water was not quite arrested until about the year
ball of large size was vomited into the air and fell to the
ground still blazing. The hill next day was found rent and
bordered.
and south sides near Dera Bet or Beyt, and in the vicinity of
Nurrha.
108
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
In those days, Sindree was a station at which the Kutch
on the left bank of what had been the Koree river about 25
upper waters) from the sea. The natives called this mound by
tract, before hard and dry, into an inland lake which extended
The Runn and the Bunnee between Kutch and the Putchum
(also dry), were at the same time suddenly covered with a
sheet of water, the extent of which east and west was unknown,
but in width it was about 6 miles; its depth was upwards of
two and a half feet, and after a few hours sunk to half that
quantity. Horsemen who crossed this tract the day after the
shock described a number of cones of sand (6 - 8 feet) elevated
above the water, the summits of which were emitting air and
water. The inundation here was doubtless connected with
that at Sindree fort, where it was of much greater depth, that
the houses within the walls filled with water and one only of
its four towers remained standing; projecting sufficiently
above the flood for the custom house officers to save their
the water at ebb tide being about a foot and at flood not more
than 6 feet deep; but after the earthquake the depth at the fort
eight miles.
same place or very near it; a sharp bend occurs in the old
desert, burst every artificial dam in the river, and forced its
always been deep drohs or pools, while the rush of the sea
stream, the river was 300 yards wide, and from two to three
of Sindree, and about five and half miles to the north, the
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
109
leagues [12 miles] distant from that town, the channel shoaled
vary from two to eight miles. Its greatest height was on the
borders of the lake, above the level of which it rose 20.5 feet.
elevated about 10 feet from the surface of the water, and cut
through like a canal with vertical banks on either side. The
channel was about 35 yards broad and three fathoms deep;
and a body of the fresh water of the Indus rolled down it into
the lake. Here he met several boats laden with ghee, which
had descended from Wunga-Bazar; and he further observes
This is the only observer who mentions that the Allah Bund
had any slope on the north side; and the section submitted
1762.
3 or 4 feet thick, and that hardly any traces of the ruins of the
great alterations had taken place: the river and lake were
deeper in all places by 2 feet, and channel through the Allah
Bund was much widened, and the sheet of water was now
entirely salt, but the stream passing the Allah Bund was fresh,
northward of this river was dry and without salt; but its bed
or never seen on the Runn Proper), which led to the old river
bed for about a mile on each side of it, but outside this limit
without water, and encrusted with salt, and was told that it
courses to the east and west. He thought the Allah Bund lower
lagoon had diminished both in area and depth, and part near
110
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
sand hills formed the highest ground that he saw anywhere
Allah Bund to the extent of three kos (six miles). The shocks
within historic times was the first shock of 1819. The accounts
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
111
weight, the great fact of the Indus flood finding its way into
all but a small part of the highest tower of the fort. The
The access of the sea water to the Sindree basin may have
112
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
to the supposition that an obstruction 19 feet in height and four
miles in width was insufficient to divert the river from its old
channel, while there appears to have nothing to prevent its
turning aside over the lower ground to the east or west.
If the old channel was not entirely filled up, but a passage of
some 6 or 8 feet deep remained upon, this would still leave the
obstruction so much higher than the river bank above that it
seems hardly possible for the stream to have avoided seeking
another course, unless the country to the east and west of the
river is much higher than would appear likely from the situation.
From the amount of detail given in Captain Bakers profile
section, it seems to have been very carefully constructed, but
the difficulty still remains that, if correct, the country on each
side of the Lower Pooraun cannot be flat; or if it be so, the
stream must have preferred to ascend a rising ground, opening
a new channel across it 20 feet deep and four miles long,
rather than to seek the lowest level in the neighbourhood.
On the whole, while it is impossible to assert that some trifling
elevation may not have taken place, it seems improbable that
this amounted to throwing up a bund 10, 15, 18, or 20
feet in height.
Otherwise, if the maximum subsidence at Sindree took place
along a somewhat irregular line corresponding to the place
of the Allah Bund, and leaving the level of the ground to the
northward but slightly, if at all, altered, then a bank or scarp,
like that of the Allah Bund, might naturally result, its length
being conterminous with that of the depression and its height
marking the amount of this depression. Seen from Sindree,
within the depressed area, rising beyond the widely spreading
inundation, such a bank would assume the appearance of a
low hill, and present a marked feature in a view which had
previously been bounded by a distant line to all appearance
as level as the horizon of the sea itself.
Tradition far more ancient, though certainly less reliable, than
the history of the events of 1819, has left an impression with
the people of North-West Kutch that subsequently to the
period when the Runn was a navigable inlet to the sea, having
the ancient city of Veego-Gud upon its shore, another ancient
maritime city flourished near Sindree, which was its port, or
bunder, on the Pooraun or Koree river. In course of time the
river shoaled so much by accumulation of silt that navigation
was impeded, and the site of the city following the limits of
deep water was changed to Sindee or Sindu in the Sayra
country. Here again the channel became reduced in depth,
and the people moved their city till further down the stream
to Lukput, which had once a considerable trade, but is now
almost deserted; its traffic having left it for the same cause
and being now transferred to Kotesir and Narainsir on a
deeper part of the estuary which was formerly the mouth of
the Koree river. Mingled with tradition are vague tales of the
silting up of the Indus near Sukkur and the formation of the
Alore Bund near where the Nurrha or Pooraun distributory
branched from that river in Sind; these changes having
prevented the southward flow of the fresh water inundations
which formerly fertilized the now ruined country of Sayra.
In connection with the objects of the Geological Survey an
endeavour was made to reach the Sindree basin from Lukput
in the middle of December 1868, but this was impracticable
from want of water in the old river channel. Another attempt
was made from Nurrha in the following month with the
help of camels carrying supplies of wood and water.
The road lay from Nurrha northeast by Hajee Peer to Loona
about 10 miles, first over kanta or babul country and then
over Runn and laana. Thence northwards four miles across
the Bunnee to a group of grass huts and shallow wells (naess)
on its margin, called Bitaro. From this, the last place at which
fresh water could be obtained, the track to Raoma-ka-bazar
was followed for 12 miles mostly over salt Runn and kuller.
Branching from it to the left, at Jerruk Dhooi, about 4 miles
further on Ahmrai Dhooi was reached.
The whole of the Runn here was covered by a painfully
glaring, strong crust salt, as white as snow, thrown up into
waves by the shrinking of the ground beneath, and in the
neighbourhood of the dhooi thickly strewed with small salt
and sun-dried fish, marsh or land shells, and portions of
coleopterous insects. From here the direction or distance of
Sindree were but imperfectly known to the guides. Leaving
Ahmrai Dhooi left to the southeast, for about 2 miles the salt
was firm and even; then entering upon the mud of the Sindree
basin..the tower of Sindree at length rose to view
above the horizon of mud and half dissolved salt, but was not
reached till sunset. Upon approaching the place it was found
to be a small spot, still surrounded by water; about 50 yards
of ankle-deep, transparent brine with a sheet of white salt
beneath, having to be crossed to reach the tower.. The place
of the old river course was occupied by brine, without banks,
in which no current could be perceived; its width was estimated
at about 250 yards, and it extended as far as could be seen to
the northward and southward. All else around was level Runn,
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Fig. 7.
Map of Sindri Lake - Allah Bund area from Sindu in the south to Chuttee Thur Bund in the north, mapped by A.B. Wynne and F. Fedden
of Geological Survey of India, 1868-69. Note that the course of Pooraun River is taken from the survey of Capt. W. E. Baker, Bengal
Engineers.
113
114
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
over which to the south and southeast the Kutch hills as far
as Dhenodhur could be seen; to the east the Putchum
mountains; and to the north a thin dark line of rising ground
115
and 5B) which was not printed with the original document of
Baker (1846).
over his original view that the Allah Bund was the
such places as water was said to have issued from during the
great earthquake.
was once a dry land. This aspect has been dealt with by Oldham
116
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
this apparent elevation was in reality a barrier, as implied by
the sum of this and the depression which certainly took place
side and found their way round, and not through, the supposed
g) 1911 - H. F. Reid
plain known as the Runn of Cutch only a few feet above the
level of the sea and which was indeed formerly a sea bottom
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
some years before 1819 no water had flowed through this
channel on account of dams built across it further up. The
great shock occurred a little before seven oclock in the
evening of June 16 and was so severe that all villages in the
neighborhood were destroyed and a mosque at Ahmedabad
about 250 miles to the east which was erected nearly four
hundred years earlier fell to the ground; the vibrations of the
earthquake were felt in northwest India, to a distance of eight
hundred miles.
In the midst of the Runn and near the old bed of Pooraun,
stood the Sindree fort where customs were levied on commerce.
At the time of the earthquake the land in the neighborhood
of this fort sank a distance of about ten feet. Water apparently
burst up from the ground and rolled in from the sea by the
channel of Koree; an immense lake was formed of unknown
extent east and west but about six miles from north to south,
which was a feet deep and covered all but the highest parts
of the region. Two or three miles to the north of Sindree
117
about fifty miles which was called by the natives The Allah
Bund or the Mound of God. Mr. A.B. Wynne in the
Memoirs of the Geological Survey of India has described the
geology of the region and collected the available information
regarding the earthquake. He concluded that the land south
of the Bund had sunk, but the Bund itself did not represent
an elevation as was generally supposed at the time of the
earthquake, but was merely the scarp left by depression of
the land to the south. This depression did not extend indefinitely
but from the depth of water accumulated there it is evident
that the greatest depression occurred near the Bund and
diminished towards the south. Indeed there are some reports
of a slight elevation about eighteen miles south of the Bund
though they are probably not very reliable. No account is
given of any change on the sea coast forty or fifty miles to
the southwest except the apparent deepening of the channel
of the Koree which may be due to scour. A tidal wave would
undoubtedly have followed a sudden depression of the coast
but none was mentioned. The water which appeared over the
plain was supposed by some to have come from the sea
through the Koree; but this does not require tidal wave, for
the level of the new lake was so low that in August 1827 at
the time of the monsoons the sea water was driven up the
118
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
subsidence of a portion of the land due to squeezing out of
dividing the land which was depressed from the region not
its area; and we find that lake so formed was not merely a
Principles of Geology
The Runn of Cutch, formerly below the sea level was gradually
raised by vertical forces which were stronger towards the
north. An elastic shearing strain was thus set up which finally
resulted in a rupture of the rock along an east and west line,
with an upward filling of the northern side to form the Bund,
and a corresponding downward fling of the southern side to
form the lake, the total relative movement being about twenty
feet, practically the same as the relative horizontal displacement
at the time of the California earthquake. It seem rather strange
that Professor Suess, who pointed out so clearly the relations
of earthquakes to fault lines, should not have seen that in this
the scarp was merely the surface indication of the general
movement on an underlying fault.
g) 1926 - Sir R. D. Oldham:
to the sea, by Lakhpat and the Kori creek. This river was
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
bordered by a fertile tract known as Saira which according
to Burnes included the country between Lakhpat, Saira
(Sahera) and Mundhan in Cutch extending northwards to a
few miles north of where Sindri once stood. Shortly after
1762 the then ruler of Sind constructed a bund at Mora
diverting the stream into other channelsother dams lower
down the stream intercepted the overflow till about 1802, the
bund at Ali Bandar finally stopped the flow of fresh water to
the sea even when the river was in flood. By this stoppage
of the flow of the Puran the aspect of the district of Saira was
changed and a productive rice country relapsed into a barren
rann........The old channel seems to have remained navigable
for Capt. R.M. Grindlay, accompanying a Mission to Sind,
119
south of the Allah Bund; in the southern part of the lake the
and one well; the creek here had a width of about a mile and
feet above and 10 feet below the level of the lake in July
monsoon.
1844, which would represent very closely the mean sea level
the uplift on the north being 20 feet, less the original height
120
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
that it was reported to have been traced eastwards towards
The limits of the flooded area around Sindri were only known
to from the facts, that, on the west, the road from Lakhpat to
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
121
survey. Over the greater part of the Runn the two surveys
Island, and beyond that again for another thirty miles to the
and 1852, but by 1880 aeolian deposits had again raised the
change from rann to bhet has taken place, is well defined, but
version that the island was raised from the Runn. The map
across the Runn and that vessels loading near Ruhema Bazar
122
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
and Kanjee Kacote sailed across the Runn and landed cargoes
at Nurra on the north of Cutch..shortly after the earthquake
the guns of Sindri were removed by boat and landed within
two miles of Nara, a proceeding which could only have been
possible if the land then stood at a lower level than it did at
the time of his survey, nine years later. These statements and
the fact that the inhabitants of Sindri had to take refuge from
the flood in the tower of the fort, indicate that the initial
depression may have been greater than the permanent one
and that there was a partial recovery of this in the months
immediately following the earthquake.
However this may be the extended flooding appears to have
been of short duration and things settled down into the
condition found by Sir Alex Burnes in 1827 and 1828, buton
both his visits the water level on the flooded area stood higher
than it would normally do during the dry weather. His first
visit was before the monsoon had commenced but at that time
a large body of fresh water was pouring into the lake, which
was separated from the broad estuary at Lakhpat by a length
of about twelve miles of river channel.. the level of the
lake must have stood at three feet above the sea level. On the
second visit the inflow of fresh water ceased, but the monsoon
was at its height, and the sea level in the Kori creek raised
to its maximum. On both occasions the ground at Sindri was
under water, just as described by the accounts of what took
place when the earthquake occurred.
The next visit.is that of the surveyor sent by Captain Grant
to make a plan of Sindri and Allah Bund in March 1838. The
only account of this which has survived is contained in Sir
C. Lyells Principles of Geology, where a sketch of the Fort
of Sindri as stood in March 1838, said to have been drawn
by Captain Grant from surveyors plan, is reproduced [See
Figure 6]. In this sketch the ruined walls of the fort are shown
as rising from an expanse of water, but this is in contradiction
with the accounts, which distinctly states that the lagoon had
diminished in area and depth and part near the fort was dry
land. This statement is probably correct as it is confirmed by
Mr. A.B. Wynnes account of his visit; it does not necessarily
indicate a change in level of the land in the ten years which
had elapsed since Burnes visit but it does conflict with the
account of what took place at the time of the earthquake, and
if this is to be believed the ground must at first have been
depressed to a lower level than that at which it stood in 1838,
and have recovered some of the depression at some date after
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
still well marked where it leaves the Runn to enter on the
alluvial area of the Indus delta, in which any former indications
can no longer be traced. Eighty miles therefore is a minimum
estimate of the length of this dislocation, it may well have
extended to one hundred and even more, if that part is included
where the displacements underground were too small to
produce any appreciable effect at the surface.
123
124
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Discussion
In compiling this commentary on the earthquake of 1819, we
have consulted quite a large number of publications in English
language that were published during the first half of the
nineteenth century. However, we are not aware of any published
or unpublished documents in local language that may have
been written from localities that suffered massive damages.
After the Garhwal earthquake of 1803, the Cutch earthquake
of 1819 was the next earthquake that has been sufficiently
documented during the early nineteenth century. In this
comprehensive volume our primary objective is to collect and
reproduce all available published accounts from rare and outof-print sources at one place as a historical document and at
the same time to facilitate future research.
Historical records of great earthquakes in Runn of Kutch
prior to the 1819 Kutch earthquake e.g. the events of AD
893 and AD 1668 were reported to be severe, with epicentre
to the north and northwest of the Great Runn in Sind area,
Pakistan (see Frere, 1870; Oldham, 1883; Rajendran and
Rajendran, 2001; Thakkar et al., 2012). The 1819 Kutch
earthquake attracted the geologist world over because it
produced direct evidence of surface deformation. After
some confusion on the nature of the Allah Bund during
the later half of the nineteenth century it was R. D. Oldham
whose publications in 1898 and then in 1926 established
that Allah Bund and the Sindri Lake were undoubtedly
morphotectonic features that were co-seismic in nature.
Oldham (1926; see his Fig. 1) presented a diagrammatic
section through Allah Bund - Sindri Lake that clearly
depicts a surface fold with a steep southern limb and
gentler northern limb. This surface deformation pattern
depicts the geometry of a fault-propagation fold with a
south-facing steep scarp that obviously resulted from
reverse slip along a north-dipping blind fault; land area
south of Allah Bund sank by a few metres to accommodate
the co-seismic surface deformation causing towards
northern side of it, allowing sea water to inundate through
Kori creek resulting in the formation of Sindree Lake,
which still persists.
Acknowledgements
We have extensively used the website of Google Books for
consulting almost all archive materials. Constructive comments
and interest shown by the Editor and his team, learned reviewer
and Shri Subhas Chandra Chakraborty, Director (Geology),
Mission III have considerably improved the scientific content
of the paper.
References
Ambraseys, N. N. and Douglas, J., 2004: Magnitude calibration of
north Indian earthquakes. Geophys. Jour. Int., 159: 165-206.
th
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Fig. 10.
125
The disposition of Allah Bund (after Oldham, 1926) and the envisaged causative north-dipping hidden thrust vis-a-vis the tentative
position of the epicentre (star) of 16th June 1819 Kutch Earthquake postulated by the present authors. In inset: a schematic NNESSW section drawn across the tentative epicentre to show the overall structure.
Bilham, R., 1998: Slip Parameters for the Rann of Kachchh, India,
16 June 1819, earthquake quantified from contemporary accounts.
In: Coastal Tectonics, I. S. Stewart and C. Vita-Finzi, (eds.), Spl.
Pub. Geol. Soc., London, 146: 295-319.
Burnes, A., 1834: A Memoir on the Eastern Branch of the Indus, and
Baker, W. E., 1846: Remarks on the Alla Bund and on the drainage
of the eastern part of the Sinde basin. Transactions Bombay
Geog. Soc., 7: 186-188.
126
Sujit Dasgupta and Basab Mukhopadhyay / Indian Journal of Geosciences, 68(1): 57-126
Raikes, S. N., 1855: Memoir and brief notes relative to the Kutch
State. Selections from the Records of the Bombay Government.
No. 15, New Series, 1-80 p.
Thakkar, M. G., Ngangom, M., Thakker, P. S. and Juyal N., 2012: Terrain
response to the 1819 Allah Bund earthquake in western Great Rann
of Kachchh, Gujarat, India. Curr. Sci., 103(2): 208-212.