Professional Documents
Culture Documents
co
-co
other books by T.
S.
Eliot
SELECTED ESSAYS
DANTE
THOUGHTS AFTER LAMBETH
POEMS, 1909-1925
ASH-WEDNESDAY
SWEENEY AGONISTES
JOURNEY OF THE MAGI
A SONG FOR SIMEON
TRIUMPHAL MARCH
ANIMULA
MARINA
OF
MODERN HERESY
BY
T.
S.
ELIOT
KOt TOt'T
KO.V
fft'
YjSr)
ItoV
Xdfiys
/iavrt/cg firjStv
CEdipus
Rex
1.
460-462.
LONDON
RUSSELL SQUARE
IN FEBRUARY MCMXXXIV
BY FABER AND FABER LIMITED
24 RUSSELL SQUARE LONDON W.C. I
SECOND IMPRESSION NOVEMBER MCMXXXIV
PRINTED IN GREAT BRITAIN BY
R. MACLEHOSE AND COMPANY LIMITED
THE UNIVERSITY PRESS GLASGOW
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
FIRST PUBLISHED
PN
To
ALFRED
and
ADA SHEFFIELD
Chaos
Das
ist; sie,
die in
Spiegel aller
all
und
der Sentimentalitat,
genz
an
dem
Intelli-
nung, des Primates des Geistes und des Spiritualen jegliche Unordnung findet ihr relariv klares oder meist selber
noch neuerhch
p. 65.
PREFACE
and
it
as
monde moderne
Ze
It
qyilit.
also provincialises,
The
three lectures
them
as
misunderstanding
as
considering
upon
set forth,
drawn upon
whose work
the
know.
writers
am
and other
felicitous illustration
of my
writers,
who
in
any literary
of
our
time
to
be
are
unmentioned
included,
survey
ought
or barely mentioned, because they do not provide such
exceptions to
work.
am
thesis,
it,
among
useless.
The
extent to
my purpose
which
is
is
there,
have
the second-rate
were
am
am
my own
writings. If such
but
it;
demn what
its
more than
its
would
absence
confirm it.
There
no doubt some
is
curiosity to
do with
to
hope
that a reader
who
takes
my
pleased to
remind the
literary gossip.
expec-
am uncertain of my ability to
as artists; I
contemporaries
up
with
have been
lectures shah
What
is
that the
shall subse-
quently be written on the same subject; and a lecture composed for the platform cannot be transformed into something
mind
else. I
without a
full
qualifications.
am
aware that
my
assertion
of the obsol-
of one whole
do was merely to
lecture; and what I was
was not one of those
explain that the charge of blasphemy
that I wished to prefer against modern literature. It may be
concerned to
said that
verbal;
and
it
may
PREFACE
be said that there
also
is
'blasphemy', in which
possibly, myself)
a profounder
(including,
may
must depend
upon some good-will on the part of the reader. I do not
In such matters, as perhaps in everything,
quite
perhaps
explicitly
mental matters, to be
tised
where there
is
futile. It
common
me, on
really
funda-
It
requires
common
is
symptom of
is
We
is
one epoch and another. In a society like ours, wormeaten with Liberalism, the only thing possible for a person
with strong convictions
leave
I
it at
is
to state a point
of view and
that.
wish to express
who
helped to
13
make
my
visit
to
memory;
to
my
hosts, Professor
and Mrs. Scott Buchanan; to Professor Buchanan for conand suggestions out of which these lectures
and to the Revd. M. C. D'Arcy, S.J., and Mr. F. V.
versations
arose;
Morley
It is
a pleasure to
were delivered
at
me
to think
American educational
in-
one of those in which some vestiges of a traditional education seem to survive. Perhaps I am mistaken:
stitutions,
but if not,
such institutions to
T.
S.
E.
years ago
the Individual
Some
wrote an essay
Talent.
do
after
not seem to
treat it
tempt
now as
such
in
naturally, does
What
is
it.
first visit
I
it
seemed to
here,
so simple as
conceive
It
me
The problem,
me
to Virginia, for
my
re-formulation.
You
my
have
as the influx
some
parts
itself in the
West: though
tradition here,
it is
else,
should be
/'//
agrarian
to
Take
My
Stand, in
movement
what
is
in the South,
and
look forward
writers.
say that
my
of your country
pressions
have strengthened
thors:
and no doubt
first,
no one,
New
Englander
of sympathy with those au-
speak
my feeling
as a
im-
superficial
Potomac
for the
first
New
state
England
and
transformed into a
is
is
New
as definite
an
here,
monotony
exerted
by
whole of American
disaster
history;
good
while the
we
effects
ill-effects are
it is
just as certainly a
of wars,
if any, abide
obliterated
by
time.
permanently
Yet I think that
away from
and
less
opulent
My
New
soil.
local feelings
were
stirred
very sadly by
my first view
of New England, on arriving from Montreal, and journeying all one day through the beautiful desolate country of
16
hills
had once,
the
forest;
forest
was razed
now
new
to
make
and
and purple wilderness you descend to the sordor of the halfdead mill towns of southern New Hampshire and Massachusetts. It
fertile
is
between
man and
best qualities
which
a long struggle
me
the
of adaptation
in
its
to
transitory as to be
more
know
which was
for a cause
ism
is
against them,
lost
whom we
is
to-day
god
before
fall
it;
that
it
does not so
much
17
matter at
practical, as
There
is
more
serious difficul-
of a tradition and
way
tradition.
What
form
in the course
mean by
have come
of the formation of a
tradition involves
from
the
all
most
those
signifi-
way of greeting a
which
stranger,
represent the blood kinship of 'the same
in
the same place'. It involves a good deal
people living
which can be
of some
significance.
We
is
me
to
a curiosity
become conscious of
these
fall
when
the
be wasted
we
into desuetude, as
aware of
are
to
separately ceased to be
at that
point in a frantic
fall
and
vital.'
endeavour
gum them
blow
onto the
We
are always in
something
we
aim
to return to
some
having been
capable of preservation in perpetuity, instead of aiming
18
imagine
as
that condition in
time.
, It is
atti-
*"
tude towards the past. For one thing, in even the very best
living tradition there
is
not
very
a matter
critical
criticism;
of feeling alone.
few dogmatic
what
notions, for
it is
Nor
one
a healthy belief at
is
traditions as a
way of
worth having,
to discover
should
we
cling to
but
as a political abstraction,
particular place;
what should be
power
what
rejected;
is
population
is
move
race, as in India:
is
You
are hardly
that
it
has
no
The population
where two or more cultures
about.
become
adulterate. 1
which
we
self-conscious or both to
people in a
obviously necessary.
incentive or pressure to
exist in the
for us not
would
should be homogeneous
life
as a particular
the best
is
in the past
to bring about,
desired Stability
what
on
What is
still
original distinctions
from
classes,
of
which
19
is
combine
undesirable.] There
ance
is
to be deprecated.
And
to
make any
large
must be a
and
rural, industrial
a spirit
of excessive
toler-
in
spite
locaj
It is,
of the nation
is
in-
strength and
geographical size depend upon the comprehensiveness of a way of life which can harmonise parts with
its
more than
of their own.
a centralised machinery
it
When it becomes no
may affect some of its
detriment; and
we get the
when
it
It is
more
and
abstract national
patriotism. This
being uttered
a Yankee.
So
1<
in
far I
by
all
its
proper setting,
it is
of "the nation"
mind
is
of
affairs
at the outset
a very recent
V. A. Demant, God,
p. 146.
2O
Man
and Society,
writers.
do not
in-
wished simply to indicate the connotation which the term tradition has for me,
tend to trespass upon their
fields. I
me
it
which
term
romanticism
which
is
fre-
quently used.
tradition to
include a
beliefs',
so
am
good
deal
more
and though of
course I believe that a right tradition for us must be also a
Christian tradition, and that orthodoxy in general implies
term orthodoxy
similar inclusiveness;
I do not
propose to lead the present
of lectures to a theological conclusion. The relation
between tradition and orthodoxy in the past is evident
Christian orthodoxy,
series
enough; as is also the great difference there may be between an orthodox Christian and a member of the Tory
Party.
But Conservatism,
as it has
so far as
it
On
ago, a relation
l
was
hundred years
between the Liberalism which attacked the
certainly, a
their colleagues.
and
his friends as
his 'distributism',
Mr. Christopher
evinced in
/'//
Take
Scottish nationalists.
21
My
Stand,
the Liberalism
to a contemporary,
According
group of Liberals
of Christ. They
dels as fellow-believers.
They would
infi-
deistic
formulary, abolish all
or
adhesions
to
formularies, and reduce relisubscriptions
state
thoughtless public.
Christianity, as
it
l
eighteen centuries, was unrepresented in this turmoil.'
It is well to remember that this sort of Liberalism was
flourishing
by an eminent
still.
it is
also well to
liberal divine
from which
remember
I
that
read an article
have preserved
is
fully
to
lodgment
in
from
Quoted in Northern
22
Catholicism, p. 9.
new wea-
them with
philosopher.'
At
this
point
may do
contemporary
literature
might suggest the assumption that everything worth saying has been said, and that the possible
forms of expression have all been discovered and developed;
the assumption that novelty of form and of substance
always to be deprecated.
point of view which
What
is
objectionable,
have adopted,
is
from
was
the
not novelty or
own
sake.
may
be considered
The
artist's
as
avoid saying what has already been said as well as it can be.
I am not here
occupied with the standards, ideals and
But
rules
which the
or writer should
artist
way
in
which
his
set
before himself,
work should be
taken by
To
critics.
assert
that a
work
is
Contemporary
literature
may
conveniently be divided
as
follows.
There
is first
that
word
'traditional'
word
23
itself
is
commonly
move-
implies a
not write
is
very suspicious; you canof Pope or the stanza of Byron.
Thejsecond kind of contemporary writing aims at an exaggerated novelty, a novelty usually of a trifling kind,
If you
uncritical reader a
fundamental
by an inner
novations,
form has
necessity,
deliberately sought. It
is
of his writings.
period,
asserting that
it
would be
dual by
more
are heretical in
responsibility solely
essential
fair,
what can be
most of us
one
way
that
or another.
Nor
is
and
the
any other
very far from
relevant to rank
It is
orthodoxy.
wrong:
in this or
it is
partly right.
is
It
which
use the
profound
insight,
truth; an insight
we
ourselves,
If
we
astray.
we may
value
And
them
of
affairs,
we
shall
go
we
are
more
make
likely to
that an heresy
a direct
is
we
will already
my
contrast
of
which
creative
It is
temporary and
political
that, simply,
is
of helping to make
by attempting
to write as a 'romantic' or as a
25
'classicist*.
of something that he is
whether it is going to
one
is
what one
is,
at the
moment of
as
from
mean
composition,
cannot
and
'classic'
us permission to avoid
much from
them
the confusion
inevitable shifts
of meaning
in context.
We do not
quite the
romantic, as
romantic. Furthermore,
associated with
whether there
more or
is
any
as
as
may
society,
like 'romantic'
caused by those
a lifetime,
total
it is
less
justly
doubtful
be arrogated to either
is
by excitement of passion and preby reason. Finally and this is the most
generally conducted
judice, rather than
you
all
A thorough-going classicist
individualist, like the
lape'
is
likely to be a
thorough-
going
should be on guard, in using such terms, against being'
thorough-going.
26
an exactness which
it
will
made between
Catholicism.
It is
possible for a
man
classicism
and
necessarily objective:
himself,
for the
is
it
the
terms
'romantic'
and
'classical',
as
professors
of
but on
them from
that
hand you cannot wholly free
context either. There is surely something wrong when a
critic divides all works of art neatly into one group and the
the other
it is
suspicious if you
class in practice:
probably
names
for what
made
the
terms
have
either
merely
you
you admire and for what you dislike, or you have forced
prefer
and
falsified
your
tastes.
Here again
is
too thorough-going.
preface to a small
mary
volume of essays,
a sort
of sum-
literary.
The
facility
with which
made
my own
this
me
that as
it
stands the
27
Thomas
injudicious. It
is
suggest that
which
may
is
all
accept
it
three beliefs
may
on
suggest that
is
not so;
it
may
all
nexions for
own mind
me
these illuminate
my
now
see
and
dramatic posture.
From another aspect also
is
'
perplexity
on
would appear
ions in
this
that while
my criticism,
me
any distress. It
most
correct opinmaintain the
do nothing but
violate
them
in
my
verse;
I feel
by those
critics
who
praise
my
who,
like
Dr. More,
most
and
why
of
writing poetry
is
of the
first
a pious insincerity.
is
intensity
still.
little reli-
The
rare;
and
it is
capacities in the
People
capacity for
existence of both
be rarer
does so
of poetry? Largely,
emotion
writing
ability
is all
ence.
is
It
by
as
could only be
world's history
classical;
but such
being unfaithful
'classical' by being
pseudoand dishonest to their experi-
and
would not
that
'classical'
most of us
he appeared, so
queer and horrifying he would seem even to those who
clamour for him.
recognise a classical writer if
hold
in summing up
that a tradition is rather a way of
and
which
characterises
a group throughout
feeling
acting
generations; and that it must largely be, or that many of
I
the elements in
it
must
tenance of orthodoxy
of
all
is
be, unconscious;
a matter
which
calls
Not only
is it
poss-
good
perpetuate
much
that
is
trivial
29
become out of
criticise itself; it
may
or of transient significance
well
as
what
is
vital
also,
of course repre-
at directly. It
.6
brain:
it is
as a
the means
by which
romantic
and
classic
are both
more
less
this
propose in
flexions
re-
II
that
hope
I have
what
it is
said already
still
to
say, that the sense in which I am using the terms tradition and
orthodoxy
is
to be kept distinctly in
mind
as
not identical
word
by
habit, breeding
to cover
much
arbitrarily chosen.
my
discussion
it
accounted for
supposed that
my meanings were
a relation to the
more
so frequently
is
and environment.
exact meanings
and so subtly
writers, that
in a loose
would
and in-
employ,
terms
which
have
manner,
expert
already been fully and
sharply defined.
With
My
AFTER
ANGE GODS
T'R
The
to.
tradition
is
no accepted
literary job. I
of the
two
View of life'
is
as
good
When
as another's, all
there
is,
is
no custom
to determine
what
religion.
the
The
one man's
more
enter-
But
at this
down
discipline
we
of the Church,
is
Even
narrow path
in the stricter
not a
sum of
which orthodoxy
resides. In
my sense
saying anything at
all.
It
itself,
in
orthodoxy
or even desirable. In many
indulgence of eccentricities
Church
is
is
is
from the
it
enshrines;
it
Mn The
Use ofPoetry.
32
as a
poem;
we
but
it as
we
find
intellectual
of a right
tradition,
the environment in
which the
It is
simply by
take
aware of the
author.
work of literature, we
its
influence
upon
manage-
What
is
it is
disastrous
is
give rein to his 'individuality*, that he should even cultivate his differences
from
and that
others;
his readers
from
the inherited
wisdom of
should
of his deviations
of
them.
What
happens
author intends.
modern world,
It is
Other
writers, indeed,
everything
is
what the
self as a Messiah.
found
is
relative to
its
we
first
understood before; which owing to the backward and confused state of men's minds has lain unknown to this
very
moment; or it may even go back to the lost Atlantis and
the ineffable
fired
wisdom of primitive
is
33
peoples.
A writer who is
likely to have
some devoted
one among many entertainers. And the pity is that the man
may have had something to say of the greatest importance:
but to announce,
known
to
as
mankind,
your
is
own
discovery,
some
truth long
uneducated
is
quite different
for
more than
readers
upon
a generation;
it is
tacitly
last
of the previous generation are as useless as the solwho died in the first year of a hundred years' war (and
leaders
diers
alas,
life
not very well qualified for discriminating between nostrums, it comes to enjoy sampling all, and taking
the public
none
seriously.
lost all
can,
is
And
finally, in a
world
many
people act
upon
as it
well
mere
ones,
self.
is
like
So that a
serious writer
may
as the
It is too much to
expect any literary artist at the present
time to be a model of orthodoxy. That, as I have said, is
different thing to
classical
author in a
classical age,
and
would have
standards
porary authors
whom I shall
mention,
Of the
cannot
contem-
recall
hav-
employed.
it
Perhaps
more
will
me from
and exonerate
real,
paper
of unredeemable
stories, all
that
recent
field;
work
at
Harvard.
the second
is
One
The Shadow
is
Bliss
in the
of some
by Katherine Mans-
Rose Garden by D. H.
known
is
Mr. Joyce's
brief,
is
it
is
is
slight;
What is interesting in
volumes
with
of considerable length.
is
his wife.
entitled Bliss,
The Prussian
respectively.
35
is
Officer,
negligible:
and Dubliners
is
of
first
ecstatic
given neither
of good and
evil,
The
story
is
setting this
is
quite right.
is
limited in this
and
way
what
believe
would be
Lawrence there
is
a great deal
more than
he
that;
is
of
con-
there
is
move
as rapidly as
lated action.
in the twist
An
well
as
as feeling,
accident, trifling in
which Lawrence
gives to
but important
leads or forces the
itself,
it,
is
more
facts
conscious of class-distinctions
she had
he said involuntarily.
Of this
ture
which
"And
he's
disclosure
cruelty.
'
The
shall
this point,
chiefly to notice at
is
36
later.
litera-
What I wish
what strikes me
in
all
of the
any moral or
is
Olympian
great
social sense. It
artists,
and which
characters;
Mr. Joyce's
story,
incidentally
is
very much
much more ela-
which
a
employs
is
saddened by
boy had
risen
to her; and he
was
to
from
had
in
it;
realises that
what
this
boy had
feeling
his eyes
form of
tears
gathered
more
thickly in
saw the
a dripping tree.
as this
what
full
We
the
more eminent
fess that I
which ignores
I
writers of
Mr. Joyce.
con-
these considerations.
bigotry
my time is
when I
not be taken
as
speaking in a
spirit
of
understand-
with Protestantism
itself:
and to
discuss that
should
mean
that
Protestant
is
Christianity
we
and
classified
had reached.
of decay which it
should include those authors who were
infancy,
I
state
even
agnosticism
in the last
two
Protestant
generations.
agnosticism
It
is
this
has
decayed
background,
be-
everywhere except northern Germany and perhaps Scandinavia; it is this which contributes the prevailing flavour of
38
decline to be
nothing could be
from
his
own
much
account)
be supposed to be concerned
primarily with the decay of morals (and especially sexual
duct of her sons. But
morals)
I
will
lest I
admiration: that
memory
of the
late
Irving Babbitt.
It is
French culture; in
his
thought and in
his intercourse
he was
thoroughly cosmopolitan. He
many years he stood almost alone in maintaining against
the strong tendency of the time a right theory of education;
believed in tradition; for
of decadence
and such
effects
work he
held in abomination.
very width of
themselves
as are
manifest in Lawrence's
And
yet to
my
mind
the
in their
extreme reaction against that narrowness. His attitude towards Christianity seems to me that of a man who had had
It
at all
would be exaggeration
his
to say that he
upbring-
wore
his
temporaries
is
significant. Just as I
do not
see
how
anyone
how any-
lences
believe that
I,
well enough to
I
come
do not
to understand
it
ence.
Two
of enlightened mystification.
Woods,
good
left
me
half of the
And I came
40
of Brah-
as in
romantic misunderstanding
how
to think
and
feel as
would
lie
in for-
an American or a Euro-
choice
And
Anglo-Saxon than
is
mind
is
very
much
is
though
be-
nearer to the
spirit
if
regarded by philosophers in a
And
Protestant.
cannot but
feel that in
some
respects
The name of
Ezra Pound
Richards:
it
(his
would seem
that Confucius
and
is
I.
A.
the spiritual
fastidious, in contrast to
Mr. Pound
by everything except
that
which
gives
them
their signifi-
much more
that he finds
Guide
to
as poets:
namely, that
as
which
is
an individualist, and
still
Pound,
like Babbitt,
more a libertarian.
as
Mr. Pound
is
and
become
and
less
and
moments of moral
depending upon
spiritual sanctions,
spiritual struggle
very
being
that
much
alike, that
real. If you
by
which we
do away with
this struggle,
are
nearest to
and maintain
and a re-
a devotion,
on
the part of an
elite,
to Art, the
world will
good
anyone could require, then you must expect
human beings to become more and more vaporous. This is
be
as
as
XXX Cantos.
It
consists
Pound puts in
(I
may have
politicians, profiteers,
financiers,
agents
English, vice-crusaders,
who do
those
golfers,
and
Fabians, conservatives
who
'those
liars,
senses'. It
have
is,
in
imperialists;
and
all
set
its
confusing; but
if
we
see at
think
work
humanitarian,
becomes
it
a little
more
intelligible
(3)
the Protestant.
of this
And
sort: that a
Hell altogether
and circumstances
accidents, then the
trivial
is
and
in Hell,
Heaven
accidental.
between
(if any)
Mr. Pound's
a perfectly comfortable
essential Evil
and
social
its
horrors,
no
one's complacency:
we
it is
1
newspapers, not for oneself and one's friends.
An
modern mind
is
selves
more,
are entitled to
graphies', a
1
mean, of what
know
is
we
Man by Wyndham
43
Lewis.
still
should
which
his
sentiment attached
in
am
of poetic
tradition,
rationalistic
and
make
a tradition, a
He
little
sought for
mous
political
it
in the conception
and
social unity,
is
of Ireland
as
of
us.
an autono-
did another
D. H. Lawrence. The
somewhat
like all
artificially
44
restless
result, for a
long
as
stimulated
folklore, occultism,
by
effect
much of Mr.
of repeated
Yeats's verse
is
is
to
me very
deliberate evocation
of
trance, as
There
is
he virtually confesses in
his essay
to
of
creation,
while
it
by hushing
us with an alluring
holds us waking by
its
variety, to
monotony,
keep us in that
state
of perhaps
from
There
is
good
real trance, in
deal
of truth
liberated
drawn
battle
of
of current
civilisation
but
in favour
mortal beings
Irish
is
and the
45
of
trance,
the
wrong
supernatural world.
spiritual significance,
of holiness or
sin,
It
was not
world of
Good and
Evil,
dying patient
on
its
its
extreme
self-
consciousness
rence
may
it
We
away
his bibelots
an apartment furnished in
few faded beauties remain: Babylive in
in time
At
and
place.
this point,
difficulties
dox and
traditional poet.
could; but
case,
tions
what
have
but he
is
he was
is
individual salvation,
writer,
tional verse,
any
first
is
his ancestry
failed to do.
not nearly so
and
his
Hopkins
much
country for
is
a poet
as a
some genera-
of our time
as
the acci-
adaptable for
strike
times
come
deal
more
is
at issue
To
be a 'devotional poet' is a
limitation: a saint limits himself by writing poetry, and a
author's devotional passion.
poet
who
is
which
in
is
to be penetrated
with
the
is
different
to
him, and most like him: George Meredith. The comparison is altogether to Hopkins's advantage. They are both
English nature poets, they have similar technical
Hopkins
is
beyond
of human
much
the
more
agile.
And where
tricks,
and
Meredith,
and shallow
dissipate; to
wisdom;
between the individual and the
little
apart,
against Liberalism:
and in
this
associa-
ynexion
in a word,
renew our
from
all this
us.
48
Hopkins
little
is
aid to offer
have'vwished to
whom
by reference
illustrate,
have mentioned in
to the
been
much more
effects
shall
be con-
49
Ill
think that there
is
of traditions, in the history of Blasphemy, and the anomalous position of that term in the
tion, for the student
modern world.
It is
which
when
generally,
which
phemy
that
is
countries
term
is
used
at all, it
is
used in a sense
only the
is
which
shadow of the
still
possess a
Crown, people
are usually
whom
have anything to
lose
by
by
all;
and both
social changes.
who
is
presented to them as inspired by 'serious' purwhereas
the only disinfectant which makes either
poses;
blasphemy or obscenity sufferable is the sense of humour:
which
is
funny
may
as
I
purely disgusting.
do not wish
D2
51
am only pointing
abstract. I
would be
tion
in an 'age
of blasphemy
out that
it
it
of faith'; just
as a magistrate's
concep-
of course reduced
to ludicrous inconsistency,
and
is
likely
ibly blaspheme in
may
be said
is
not a
is
being in a
state
of intellectual
error,
my
it
he
is
or
wrong
is
not commit-
reasons.
is
It is
cer-
one of the
blasphemy
requires both literary genius
and profound faith, joined in a mind in a peculiar and unusual state of spiritual sickness. I repeat that I am not defending blasphemy;
am
blasphemy is impossible.
next point is a more delicate one to handle. One
can conceive of blasphemy as doing moral harm to feeble
My
produces fewer and fewer individuals capable of being injured by blasphemy. One would expect, therefore, that
(whatever it may have been at other times) blasphemy
52
might
soul
still
is
now
alive,
be taken rather
or even that
We
we may make
is
of
as a
it
is
spiritual
corrup-
symptom
that the
recovering anima-
choice
a sign
the
first
requisite
of spiritual
life.
whatever
regret, for
of the Evil
most
fruit-
Spirit to-day.
my present purposes,
that
little
insecure of
that the
my
generalisations.
eminent novelists
who
are
But
it
seems to
or not
me
their pre-
to
do
more
they criticised
least
nearly in
its
not of their
own
is
zeal.
observers:
still
however super-
ficial
we
find their
insight
bined
They
are
and passion than these, but who unfortunately comwith the dreary rationalism of the epoch of which
it
she
is
ing
What I have
assertion: that when
morals.
tradition
and orthodoxy
is,
munity formulated, corrected, and elevated by the continuous thought and direction of the Church and when
each
late
inter-
institutional
beliefs;
upon
He
seems to
me
to have
me
as a particularly
good
54
sub-
'
which lends
itself to
is
a passive creature
is
fitted
only in
men
as vehicles for
emotions.
It is
only, indeed,
emotional paroxysms that most of Hardy's characters come alive. This extreme emotionalism seems to me
in their
symptom of decadence;
it is
something admirable
sake, whatever the emotion
emotion for
its
own
is
human
when most
do not
violently excited;
in themselves differentiate
same
ments of his
passion
those
is
life
who abandon
their
humanity; and
conflict there
is
no
its
own
somewhat
his finest
ducing an
air
as a
whole
of inevitability,
ment by which
tour de
ment
stream below
is
him-
a masterly
is however as much
by arrangeones in which the motive intrudes
This scene
force.
as less successful
the
I
It is
a refined
form of
expense of the
at the
torture
on
first
time.
have not so
far
ments considered in
of the
last.
this lecture
illustrating the
certain writers
whom
from
I
tradition
nevertheless
state
of affairs; and
56
it
was for
this
reason that
that
cerned.
may
operate through
character.
very
Sin
is
much
to
not a very
volume of short
stories,
stories,
imagination.
Not
all
of these
stories,
of course,
my purpose,
illustrate
to
which
last
drop of horror
is
extracted
by
the dramatist;
But there
is
we
are in a
world of
House of Grebe
tale
we
are in-
would seem
find this
strain in the
bidity
I
same
artist,
and
aspects,
it is
very
do justice to
difficult to
expect to be able to do
so.
The
first is
all. I
do not
much of information
as
of the
critical faculties
Of this
exposure by Mr.
most conclusive
there
is
Wyndham
Paleface
is
brilliant
by
far the
the
wrong
intuition
of these
fairly;
what we ordin-
of Lawrence, the
Lewis in
profound intuition
drew
side
which edu-
aspects in
and
possible.
this, in
I shall
mind
it is
is
a distinct
necessary to keep
all
no doubt appear
is
almost im-
to give excessive
all, is
successfully considered.
have already touched upon the deplorable religious upbringing which gave Lawrence his lust for intellectual indeI
pendence: like most people who do not know what orthodoxy is, he hated it. With the more intimate reasons, of
and
heredity and environment, for eccentricity of thought
58
them
am
many
And I have
already mentioned
my mind
that
am
which
completely baffled by
that
Lawrence
made
people have
is
so
it as
started life
wholly
from any restriction of tradition or institution, that he jl
had no guidance except the Inner Light, the most untrustis
free
worthy and
dering humanity.
wan- r
It
the
and
his
passions,
social
is
Mr. Joyce
is
it is
serving; an
with self-righteousness,
It
would seem
is
that for
filled
Lawrence any
spiritual force
was
only in the absence of spirituality. Most people, no doubt, need to be aroused to the perception of the simple distinction between the spiritual and
evil resided
>
59
<
alive;
responsibility:
only when
it is
spiritual
they are so
is
little
a very great
awakened
at the
that
same time
less
sensualist.^
Against the
living;
death
oji:
modern^
what he
said
is
unanswerable. As a
criticism
is
tingham, London or industrial America, his capering redskins of Mornings in Mexico seem to represent Life. So they
do; but that is not the last word, only the first.
The man's
vision
is
spiritual,
and the
tale
which
used
as
in the
I
Death. 1
Lady
But
keeper, turns
XI
cannot
Chatterleys Lover.
am indebted
up
Our
see
much development
to an unpublished essay
is
in
so.
60
by Mr. E.
F.
which makes
W. Tomlin
for
well-born
or
^elves to
make
use of
ladies offer
plebeians springs
from
them-
same
the
morbidity which makes other of his female characters bestow their favours upon savages. The author of that book
me
seems to
There
is, I
to
man
indeed.
who
are
from
may not
who are most in need of it. That we can and ought
be those
Modern
work may
to
who
are well
and
criteria for
discriminating
small; the
number of the
half-alive
hungry
for
evil
is
very
any form of
itself as spiritual
experi-
generation has
buncombe and
false
doctrine
come from
it.
Woe
unto the
nothing! O Israel, thy prophets have been like foxes in the waste
places.
And
Son of man,
the
these
men
61
hours, one can undertake to say about such a serious subject as this. In an age
tradition the
of unsettled
man of letters,
beliefs
and enfeebled
my
and for
first lecture,
their
from
supervision of
this
what
supervision
find
Most
it.?
tives,
it is
by
perpetually criticised
I
now
we
as a
I left
this
my
we
fail
to distinguish
we may
it
plausible; so that in
our
The
first
requisite usually
ality
The
at various times
fascinates us
in
the
and in several
the personality
work of philosophy
or
places.
which
art,
tends
dom,
terribly limited
by prejudice and
its
free-
self-conceit, capable
is
to suggest
safer
us.
APPENDIX
after some deliberation called this essay a primer
of modern heresy: hinting that it is offered primarily
to those who may be interested in pursuing the subject by
have
had thought of supplementing it by a graduated Exercise Book, beginning with very simple examples
themselves.
My
perhaps the
is
No.
is
can find.
book would
find to
my
jim not
discomfiture that most
I
languages.
who
possess a familiarity
with foreign
more from
from
Goodness has
sinfulness/
its
its
ugliness than
appeal in
moral beauty
The Moncure
its
J OHN A.
HOBSON:
think
now
a teacher ...
is
the
of Latin
is
a part,
am
it is
'This question
I
my
life as
all
and only a
convinced
the time.
part,
of what
of Education
at the present
moment
is
would give
boy
first
and
science,
one foreign
ough
ear,
and
as his literary
would
would
seek to
education. In his
seek to build
on
make
last
im-
years at school
that foundation
66
that as
some under-
APPENDIX
modern world, why
standing of the
and what
his place
is
in
room
it.
it is,
In that education
it
works,
do not think
DR. CYRIL
how
NORWOOD,
is still
an
we
ideal.'
of December
21, 1933.)
in
'Character, in short,
is
It
all
whatever,
.
is,
tion
is
hibited in a character,
essay.'
in
Modern
19.
IV
'Any
start
saying that
principle
hich
of the unity of
theory and practice in the sense in
have expounded it. And since this is the
truly
67
which
di
v,
this principle,
obj<
of a complete brt
with the assumptions upon which they are based and t
tions to their conclusions, but because
and adapt
make
all
itself to
acti
Th
stration
to
ing
speculative
thought.'
which
is
JOHN MACMURRAY:
68
7847