Professional Documents
Culture Documents
140
LECTURE NOTES
Moving Beyond Your First Draft
Since the first draft is rarely good enough, recognize that youll need to revise the document.
Careful revision can mean the difference between a rambling, unfocused message and a lively,
direct message that gets results.
The third step of the three-step writing process involves four key tasks:
Revising your message to achieve optimum quality and then
Producing your message
Proofreading your message
Distributing your message
141
For informal messages to internal audiences, particularly when using instant messaging, text
messaging, e-mail, or blogging, the revision process is often as simple as quickly looking over your
message to correct any mistakes before sending or posting it.
With more complex messages, try to put your draft aside for a day or two before you begin the
revision process so that you can approach the material with a fresh eye.
After letting the document sit for a day, start with the big picture, making sure that the document
accomplishes your overall goals before moving to finer points, such as readability, clarity, and
conciseness.
To evaluate content, ask:
Is the information accurate?
Is the information relevant to the audience?
Is there enough information to satisfy the readers needs?
Is there a good balance between general information and specific information?
To review organization, ask:
Are all your points covered in the most logical order?
Do the most important ideas receive the most space, and are they placed in the most prominent
positions?
Would the message be more convincing if it were arranged in another sequence?
Are any points repeated unnecessarily?
Are details grouped together logically, or are some still scattered through the document?
Ask whether you have achieved the right style and tone for your audience by answering these
questions:
Is your writing formal enough to meet the audiences expectations, without being too formal
or academic?
Is it too casual for a serious subject?
Does your message emphasize the audiences needs over your own?
After confirming the content, organization, style, and tone of your message, make a second pass to
improve readability.
During your second pass, focus on readability:
Readers will save time and understand your messages better.
Your reputation for well-crafted documents will garner more attention for your work.
Many indexes have been developed over the years in an attempt to measure readability:
Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level score
Flesch Reading Ease score
Although readability formulas offer a useful reference point, they are all limited by what they are
able to measure:
They can measure word length, number of syllables, sentence length, and paragraph length.
They cannot measure document design, the you attitude, clear sentence structure, smooth
transitions, and proper word usage.
Help readers skim your message by
Copyright 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall
142
143
Connectionhelping readers see the relationships between subordinate and main ideas
Headings may be
Descriptivemerely identify the topic
Informativeguide readers to think in a certain way and are self-contained
Headings should be brief and parallel throughout the entire document.
When you edit for clarity, ask yourself whether your message is as clear and as concise as possible
by focusing on your
Paragraph organization
Sentence structure
Word choices
When editing for clarity, be sure to
Break up overly long sentences
Rewrite hedging sentences
Impose parallelism
Correct dangling modifiers
Reword long noun sequences
Replace camouflaged verbs
Clarify sentence structure
Clarify awkward references
When you edit for conciseness, you
Eliminate every word that serves no function
Replace every long word that could be a short word
Remove every adverb that adds nothing to the meaning already carried in the verb
When editing for conciseness, remember to
Delete unnecessary words and phrases
Shorten long words and phrases
Eliminate redundancies
Recast It is/There are starters
As you rewrite, concentrate on
How each word contributes to an effective sentence
How each sentence develops a coherent paragraph
Word processing software offers numerous features for entering and revising text, including
Cut and paste
Search and replace
Tracking a documents revisions
Spell checker
Thesaurus
Grammar checker
Style checker
Before you dive into someone elses work, recognize the dual responsibility that doing so entails:
Unless youve been specifically asked to rewrite something in your own style or change the
emphasis of the message, remember that your job is to help the other writer succeed at his
or her task, not to impose your writing style or pursue your own agenda.
Make sure you understand the writers intent before you begin suggesting or making
Copyright 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall
144
changes.
Answer the following questions as you evaluate someone elses writing:
What is the purpose of this document or message?
Who is the target audience?
What information does the audience need?
Does the document provide this information in a well-organized way?
Does the writing demonstrate the you attitude toward the audience?
Is the tone of the writing appropriate for the audience?
Can the readability be improved?
Is the writing clear? If not, how can it be improved?
Is the writing as concise as it could be?
Does the design support the intended message?
When its time to revise and polish your message, software features and tools can help you with the
following functions:
Cut and paste (taking a block of text out of one section of a document and pasting it in
somewhere else)
Search and replace (finding words or phrases and changing them if you need to)
Revision marks (look for the track changes feature) and Commenting keep track of proposed
editing changes electronically and provide a history of a documents revisions.
Spell Checker compares your document with an electronic dictionary, highlights
unrecognized words, and suggests correct spellings
A computer thesaurus gives you alternative words, just as a printed thesaurus does
Grammar checker tries to do for your grammar what a spell checker does for your spelling
Style checker monitors your word and sentence choices and suggest alternatives that might
produce more effective writing
Keep in mind that spell checkers and grammar checkers cant catch all spelling mistakes and
youre responsible for the final product.
145
Detail
White space
Is free of text and artwork both in print and online
Provides contrast
Provides readers a resting point
White space includes
The open area surrounding headings
The space in margins
The space in paragraph indents
The space around images
The vertical space between columns
The horizontal space between paragraphs or lines of text
Lines of type can be set
Justified (flush on both the left and right margins)
Flush left with a ragged-right margin
Flush right with a ragged-left margin
Centered with ragged-left and ragged-right margins
Justified type
Creates a denser look because the uniform line lengths decrease the amount of the white
space along the right margin
Produces a more formal and less personalized look
Is more difficult to read because it can produce large gaps between words and excessive
hyphenation at the ends of lines
Flush-leftragged-right type
Produces a less formal and more contemporary look
Gives a document an informal, contemporary feeling of openness
Is easier to read (because the spacing between words is the same)
Reduces hyphenation (because only long words are hyphenated at the end of lines)
Centered type is
Rarely used for text paragraphs
Commonly used for headings and subheadings
Flush-rightragged-left type is rarely used in business documents.
The term typeface refers to the physical design of letters, numbers, and other characters.
Each typeface influences the tone of your message.
Serif typefaces such as Times Roman
Have small crosslines (serifs) at the ends of each letter stroke
Are commonly used for regular paragraph text
Can look busy and cluttered when set in large sizes for headings and other display type
Sans serif typefaces such as Helvetica and Arial
Have no serifs
Are ideal for larger sized font
Copyright 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall
146
147
148
Situation
Team Challenge
One possible revision: To protect customers privacy, Daimlers data protection policy complies with the
Data Protection Code of Conduct.
149
paragraphs short. They might also discuss using lists and bulleted items (to help busy readers
who tend to skim a message) and using headings to give readers clues about whats to
follow.
3. Students can list a number of specific functions for headings, describing their use as
organizational tools, attention-getting devices, and links that help readers follow the logic
and organization of your ideas. For example, the benefits of headings include providing a
one-glimpse overview of a documents organization, grouping related paragraphs, and creating
short sections of material that otherwise might appear overwhelming to a busy reader. As
attention-getters, headings can lead readers to information they need (or show readers what
they can skip) and, if well written, can entice readers to read material more deeply.
4. A document can be made more concise by including just whats necessary and composing clear
sentences with no unneeded words and phrases, short rather than overly long words and
phrases, no redundancies, and no It is or There are starters.
5. One computer tool for revising messages is word-processing software, which allows you to
manipulate text by adding, deleting, pasting, and replacing text, as well as merging files.
Other computerized revision tools include the spell checker, thesaurus, and grammar checker.
6. Parallel construction means using the same grammatical pattern for two or more similar
ideas. Writers can achieve parallel construction simply by repeating the pattern in words,
phrases, clauses, or entire sentences.
7. Using verbs instead of noun phrases keeps a message clear, brief, and lively.
8. White space provides contrast with the text, giving readers a resting point as they scan the
document. Headings serve as an invitation for readers to become involved in the message. They
also guide readers through the organization of the message content.
9. Proofreading for spelling mistakes and other errors is important because readers view the
writers attention to detail as a sign of professionalism. Also, when readers notice even small
errors, they wonder whether the writer is really reliable.
10. The factors to consider include cost, convenience, time, security, and privacy.
150
Arthur J. Cogswell
Editor
Enclosure: Manuscript
Message 6.C
Copyright 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall
151
Heres one example of how students might revise the paragraph for improved readability by
removing wordiness, shortening some sentences for clarity and others to vary tempo, and
eliminating extraneous information to shorten the paragraph overall:
Although major league baseball remains popular, more people are attending minor league
games. They can save on admission, snacks, and parking and still enjoy the excitement of
Americas pastime. Connecticut, for example, has three AA minor league teams. They play in
relatively small stadiums, so fans get a close-up experience of everything from the swing of
the bat connecting with the ball to the thud of that ball landing in an outfielders glove. Best
of all, it costs less to take the whole family. They can watch baseballs rising stars for just a
fraction of what theyd pay to attend a major league game.
6.2
Forensic accounting services provide the insights you need in four important areas:
Insurance Claims Accounting and Preparation: the help you need to maximize
recovery of insured value
Dispute Advisory: assistance with discovery, expert witness testimony, and
economic analysis
Construction Consulting: support you can count on when large-scale
construction projects fail to meet schedule or budget requirements
General Investigative and Forensic Accounting Services: fraud detection and
proof of loss analysis
6.3
152
e. Words mean different things to different people. A word such as block may mean city
block, butcher block, engine block, auction block, or several other things.
6.4
6.5
6.6
6.7
6.8
6.9
6.10
6.11
With the indefinite starters removed, the sentences might read as follows:
Copyright 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall
153
a. Several examples here show that Elaine cant hold a position very long.
b. A generous contribution to Mildred Cooks retirement party would be appreciated.
c. Generally reliable sources in Washington report today that the White House will soon
make an important announcement.
d. According to the rule, we cannot work overtime without permission.
e. Your working late the next three Saturdays would be great.
6.12
6.13
6.14
6.15
6.16
154
prepared an announcement for the press: The company was on the brink of bankruptcy.
6.17
6.18
Students may notice that professors use various design elements to enhance readability,
including white space, headings, and sans serif typeface for heads with serif typeface for
text. They may try switching serif and sans serif typefaces to see the effect on readability,
for example.
6.19
Students should comment on the use of typefaces, white space, headings, and other design
elements on the Bloomberg website. They may offer various suggestions for improving
readability, including larger type size, more white space, and other ideas.
6.20
This exercise helps students experience the interpersonal aspect of proofreading someone
elses work and having someone else proofread their work. They may suggest several ways
to improve this kind of critiquing process, such as starting with positive comments; using a
supportive, helpful tone rather than an accusing tone when offering feedback; and being
tactful when suggesting changes.
6.21
6.22
Even though your company does not sell products in the local area, you still have an ethical
obligation to add the information to the website. The construction delays alone could
compromise your companys relationship with the community, and withholding information
about the delays would almost certainly tarnish the organizations image. Doing all you can
to minimize any negative effects of the construction will also aid employees who live in the
local area, since they are likely to receive questions and comments about the project from
their neighbors. Finally, posting information about the construction may help to reduce the
amount of traffic (and, ideally, the number of accidents) in the area around the plant.
155
More experienced writers usually do just the reverse. Early on, they work at discovering
what to say, getting their ideas out onto disk or paper. They write quickly, accepting chance
discoveries, trusting hunches and gut-feelings, willingly making mistakes. Gradually,
though, they feel a need to look back over their work, to ask whether it makes sense, how
their readers will respond. Thus begins the process of revision.
When revising your message, the following questions can improve your writing: Is the style
authentic and engaging?
2. The four elements of the writing context are the reader, writer, purpose, and content. As a
reader of a message, you might ask the following questions:
What sort of person wrote this?
What does the writer hope to accomplish?
How has the content been shaped by the writer's experience and motives?
3. Tightening means cutting extra words, all those that don't contribute to your message.
The following steps are ways to tighten your work:
Look for words that don't do their share of work
Use strong verbs
Don't pile up modifiers in front of nouns
Make the agent the subject
Try combining several short sentences into a longer one