Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Outline
The Autolab instrument
Cell connections and configurations
Basics of EIS
Practical EIS
Data analysis
Applications
The Instrument
Instrumentation requirements
for EIS
PGSTAT
Impedance analyzer
Software for data acquisition and
analysis
The instrument
FRA32M Module
Module for electrochemical impedance
spectroscopy
32 MHz to 10 Hz
1 MHz to 10 Hz in combination
with the PGSTAT
DC range: up to 10 V
Single sine and multi-sine
FRA32M
New impedance analyzer module
Replaces the FRA2
Works with Autolab PGSTAT series
Not available for AutolabIII
FRA32M
32M stands for 32 MHz
!! MAXIMUM Frequency with
PGSTAT: 1 MHz !!
Future developments to raise the limit
FRA32M
Direct DSG output
20 MHz
32 MHz
FRA32M
Uses on-board DSP
Crunches 1 M per channel down to
4096 points
And finally down to 1
Much faster than FRA2
No filtering
FRA2 vs FRA32M
FRA2 vs FRA32M
FRA32M: wrapping up
Very advanced module
Expected product lifetime 10+ years
All procedures are compatible!
The instrument
Possible configurations
PGSTAT128N, 302N, 100N, 302F
Multi autolab with FRA32M module
Autolab III with built-in FRA2
Instrumental limitations
Contour plot
Cell connections
Cell connections
Autolab potentiostat / Galvanostat
Cell connections
PGSTAT provides 4
connections
CE and WE (current
measurement)
RE and S (voltage
measurement)
Electrochemical cell
WE/S
CE
RE
Electrochemical
interface
Electrochemical interface
Interface
Electrode
Potential
+
e-
+
+
+
+
+
+
IHP OHP
Equivalent circuit
Electrochemical interface model
Equivalent circuit
Uncompensated resistance, Ru
Solution between RE and WE
Concentration, cell setup, Temperature,
conductivity, type of ions, mass transport,
Equivalent circuit
Typical values:
up to 100 (aqueous solution)
KCl 0.1 mol/L 20C = 85.69
up to 10 k (organic solvent)
Between 1m to 1 Batteries
Equivalent circuit
Equivalent circuit
Typical values:
Double layer bare metal
Fe2O3 - Ni2O5
Al2O3
Epoxy cast coating
Asphalt coating
10-50 F/cm2
2 F/cm2
0.5 F/cm2
6 pF/cm2
0.5 pF/cm2
Bernard Tribollet & Mark E. Orazem: Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy, Wiley-Interscience, 2008
Equivalent circuit
Equivalent circuit
Equivalent circuit
Electrochemical methods
Large number of methods available
DC: cyclic voltammetry, chrono
amperometry,
AC: electrochemical impedance
spectroscopy,
Advantage of DC methods
Ex: cyclic voltammetry
Most popular technique in
electrochemistry
Provides a complete overview of the
electrochemical interface
Immediately recognizable
Cyclic voltammetry
Platinum in HClO4 0.1 M
Immediately
recognizable
Cyclic voltammetry
Platinum in HClO4 0.1 M
Added EtOH
Anodic peaks attributed
to the oxidation of EtOH
Disadvantage of DC methods
System is driven away from equilibrium
Response is given by individual
contributions
Information about the rate determining
step can be determined
No information on the internal dynamics
of the system
Disadvantage of DC methods
Iron in sea water
No direct information about
electrochemical interface
max
1
R C
C1 = 9.95 nF using R2
C2 = 10.77 F using R3
Alternative: EIS
Electrochemical impedance
spectroscopy
Study of the variation of the impedance
of an electrochemical system with the
frequency of a small-amplitude AC
perturbation
Advantages of EIS
System remains at equilibrium
Non destructive method
Can be applied in many fields
Corrosion, biosensors, solar cells,
semiconductors, superpacitors, fuel
cells, batteries
EIS Basics
EIS Basics
Ohm's law gives a simple relation
between
dc-potential (E) and dc-current (i):
E
R
I
EIS Basics
EIS is a transfer function between
potential and current
et e sin t
Z()
it i sin t
e sin t
sin t
Z
Z0
i sin t
sin t
EIS Basics
it i sin t
et e sin t
The
current
response
leads or lags the voltage
by a phase angle
EIS Basics
When ac-signals are involved the
relation is:
Z ()=
E ()
I ()
Z() Z0e
j( )
Z0 cos jsin
Z ZRe j ZIm
Z() Z e
j( )
Z() R
0
Z() R
0
Resistor
1
Z()
C
Capacitor
Capacitor
1
1
ZC
j
jC
C
90 phase shift
Typical examples: double layer
capacitance, coating capacitance
Capacitor
Inductance
Inductance
ZL jL
90
Typical examples: instrumental
artifacts, adsorption phenomena
Inductance
RC, series
Impedance of element in series =
impedance of elements
E ER EC
i iR iC
1
Z ZR ZC R j
C
1
Z() R R
C
0
2
RC, series
RC, series
RC, parallel
Impedance of element in parallel =
1/R (1/impedance of elements)
1
1
E ER EC i iR iC
1
1
1
1
jC
Z ZR ZC R
R
Z
1 RjC
Z()
0
2
1
C
R
RC, parallel
Impedance vs admittance
Randles Cell
Electrochemical cell model
> ZCdl > 0
max
1
Zf Cdl
Capacitive
contribution
R
Pure resistive behavior,
no phase change.
R + Zf
Pure resistive behavior,
no phase change.
Randles Cell
Electrochemical cell model
R + Zf
> ZCdl > 0
Capacitive
contribution
0
Pure resistive behavior,
no phase change.
Randles Cell
Electrochemical cell model
Fmax
R + Zf
EIS conditions
3 fundamental conditions
Linearity
Stability
Causality
Linearity condition
The applied AC amplitude must be
small so that the response of the cell
can be assumed to be linear (in 1st
approx)
Important choice of the applied
amplitude
Linearity condition
Linearity condition
Linearity condition
Linearity condition
Potentiostatic or galvanostatic control?
Z is independent of the mode
At what DC potential or current?
Always at OCP?
Depends on the system
Requires knowledge of the system
What should the AC amplitude be?
Linearity condition
FAQ # 1
How to choose the amplitude?
Small enough to stay linear
Big enough to measure a response
Stability condition
The overall state of the system should
not change (significantly) during the
acquisition of the data
Important choice of frequency range
and measurement conditions
Stability condition
Corrosion of the electrode, adsorption
or formation of oxides, discharge of
the device, changes in the
electrochemical interface,
Electrochemical system are unstable
Stability condition
Frequency scan
Stability condition
Min. time for Z at 10 Hz: 10.000 s
Scan from 1 kHz to 1 mHz, 61
frequencies, log. distribution
2 h, 47 minutes (estimated)
Scan from 1 MHz to 1 Hz, 61
frequencies, log. Distribution
7 minutes (estimated)
Stability condition
Duration
The experiment
duration is dominated
by the low frequencies
Causality condition
The measured AC response of the
system must be directly correlated to
the applied AC stimulus
Important to shield the cell from
outside perturbations
Avoiding traps
Avoiding traps
Powerful method but not stand alone
Knowledge of the system is required
3 conditions must be respected
Instrument is not a black box
Measurement sequence
Step 1: AC signal is applied on the cell
Step 2: AC response is recorded
Step 3: signals are sent to the
impedance analyzer
Measurement sequence
Lissajous plot
Measurement sequence
FFT is computed for both signals
Impedance is calculated from
frequency domain data
Measurement sequence
Hidden information
Nyquist and Bode plots do not show
all the information
The raw signals are insteresting to
consider
Lissajous plots test the linearity
Lissajous plots
Pure R
Pure C
Real cell
Lissajous plots
Measurement of impedance
V OA
Z
1M
i
OB
D A
OD
sin
33
OA
Lissajous plots
Easy to detect non-linear behaviour
200 Hz / 25 mV AC
20 Hz / 25 mV AC
Kramers-Kronig test
Basic test for data validation
Equations linking real and imaginary
components of complex quantities for
systems fulfilling the conditions of
linearity, causality and stability
Kramers-Kronig test
Diagnostic tool for impedance data
Test the data for consistency
Recalculates the real/imaginary part
based on the measured imaginary/real
part
Kramers-Kronig test
Practical EIS
Practical EIS
Different protocols
Frequency scan: other parameters
are fixed
Single frequency: other parameters
are changed
Combination of both
Frequency
distribution
Amplitude
Wave type
Data analysis
Data analysis
Analysis: crucial part of the EIS
Different tools are available
Difficult and time consuming
Pitfall: extract too much information
Analysis tools
Find circle (quick fit): used to quickly
fit a semi-circle in the Nyquist
Provides a quick estimate using a
R(RQ) circuit
Analysis tools
Find circle (quick fit)
Analysis tools
Find circle (quick fit)
Analysis tools
Fitting using equivalent circuit
User-defined equivalent circuit built
with different elements
R, C, L, Q, etc
Parallel or series
Non-linear least-squares fit
Analysis tools
Circuit description based on
B.A.Boukamp:
Solid state Ionics 20 (1986) 31-44 &
Solid State Ionics 18&19 (1986)
136-140
Analysis tools
Elements
Analysis tools
Fitting tool comes with circuit editor
Analysis tools
Initial conditions,
boundaries, fixed
parameters can be
edited in the dedicated
panel
Fitting progress
Iterative process
Several iterations
required in order to
reach convergence
Report
Practical examples
CE
3 electrode setup
Z measured
between RE and WE
Coating
Steel
WE
Nyquist
Bode
Pure R
Interpretation?
CE
Ru
NaCl
Cdl
Coating
Steel
WE
Poor fit
Case 1 problem?
Element Q
Used to describe an imperfect
behaviour of a reactance
ZQ
1
Y0 j
ZC
j
C
n = 1 capacitor
n = 0 resistor
n = 0.5 uniform diffusion
0.5 < n < 1 rough electrode
0 < n < 0.5 porous electrode
Case 1 Element Q
Case 1 Element Q
Good fit
Electrolyte
Surface film
Csf
Cdl
Rct
Electrode
CE
3 electrode setup
Z measured
between RE and WE
Coating
Steel
WE
Pure C
Two semi-circles
Nyquist
Pure R
Bode
CE
Ru
NaCl
Cdl
Coating
Steel
Pores
WE
Cdl
Coating + pores
Steel
Surface film
Rep
Blister with electrolyte
Csf
Cdl
Zwa
Rct
Electrode
Re
Csf1
Rsf1
Surface
film 1
Rsf2
Surface film 2
Csf2
Cdl
Rct
Electrode
Angle of 45
Indication of semiinfinite diffusion
Randles-like
behavior
ZW
j
RT
1
1
2 2
n F A 2 DO CO
DRCR
Semi-infinite diffusion
contribution
Angle of 45
Indication of semiinfinite diffusion
ZO
1
Y0 j
1
Y0 j
tanh B j
ZW
O element is identical to W
when tanh argument >
Red O2
Blue Air
Air
O2
B
D
RDE
ZO
1
Y0 j
tanh B j
Y Y0 j th B j
Z ( )=
1
Y0 j
coth B j
Diffusion coefficient D
B=
D
>45
1
k j
Y Y0 k j
Case 10 Inductance
High frequencies inductance
Low frequencies inductance
Z=jL
Case 11 Bisquert2
Transmission line element
Case 11 Bisquert2
X3X
X3X
X1X
X3X
X1X
X1X
X3X
X1X
X2
X2
XX
X2
Case 11 Bisquert2
ZB2
X1X 2
2
12 22
L
cot anh
1 2
1 2
sinh
Where is given by
X3
1 2
Case 11 Bisquert2
DSSC V@MaxPP
Case 11 Bisquert2
DSSC V@ OCP
Capacitance
Inductance
Y0 and n
Y0
Finite diffusion
Y0 and B
Bound diffusion
Y0 and B
Gerischer impedance
Y0 and Ka
Conclusions
Summary
Potentiostat setting
FRA setting
Potential scan
Potential Scan: Mott Schottky plot of a
semiconductor
50 mV = 42.1A
10 mV = 6.4A
200mV = 0.39A
Z=1 GOhm
10 mV leads to I=10 pA!!
Monitoring of impedance in
function of time
Battery (LiPo)
References
The reference handbook on impedance
spectroscopy
References
Good reference book, specifically
focussed on Electrochemical
Impedance Spectroscopy
References
The reference handbook on
electrochemistry, also covers
impedance spectroscopy
www.metrohm-autolab.com
Metrohm Autolab
Instruments for Electrochemistry