Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 CANAL STREET
RFP No.8975-01775
February 16, 2015
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
ranked hotel in the country by both Travel and Leisure and Trip Advisor, which includes 316
2 Canal Street has been one of the most visible and prominent buildings in the New Orleans
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
2 Canal Street is in serious need of renovation to bring the property back to life. Oxford and
its design and development team has envisioned a redevelopment and repositioning strategy
that will reestablish the property as a focal point of downtown New Orleans and serve as an
important bridge connecting many of the citys most popular neighborhoods while providing
of Louisiana. The redevelopment plan features a design inspired by the original Edward Durell
Stone architecture and New Orleans architecture and culture intertwined with the modern
event space at the top floor of the tower; full amenity floor including attractions such as indoor
John W. Rutledge
President & CEO
Oxford Capital Group, LLC
Tel: (312) 755-9500 x 4610
jwr@oxford-capital.com
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A
B
APPENDIX
17
19
45
77
79
89
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Entry and Roof Deck at the IO Urban Roofscape at The Godfrey Hotel in Chicago, Illinois
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
DEVELOPMENT PLAN
A.1
Oxford Capital Groups development plan for 2 Canal
luxury one and two bedroom apartments along with one,
two, and three bedroom penthouse apartments on the
space; 3-meal chef driven restaurant on the ground level;
space at the top of the building; full amenity floor including
attractions such as indoor pool, destination spa, club
lounge, game room, movie screening room, yoga studio,
and a new 5 story structure with 120 automated modular
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
555 days
58 days
26 days
21 days
30 days
33 days
186 days
30 days
30 days
35 days
10 days
35 days
45 days
45 days
Mon 1/25/16
Mon 11/23/15
Mon 11/23/15
Mon 12/14/15
Mon 12/28/15
Mon 1/11/16
Mon 1/11/16
Mon 1/25/16
Mon 5/11/15
Mon 8/31/15
Fri 3/6/15
Fri 3/6/15
Fri 3/6/15
Fri 4/10/15
Fri 4/10/15
Fri 4/10/15
Mon 5/11/15
Mon 5/11/15
Mon 6/22/15
Mon 8/3/15
Mon 9/21/15
Mon 10/5/15
Mon 11/23/15
Mon 11/23/15
Mon 1/25/16
Thu 1/28/16
Fri 12/11/15
Fri 12/25/15
Fri 1/8/16
Fri 1/22/16
Fri 1/22/16
Thu 1/28/16
Thu 4/20/17
Fri 9/25/15
Thu 4/20/17
Tue 5/26/15
Fri 4/10/15
Fri 5/8/15
Thu 5/21/15
Tue 5/26/15
Mon 1/25/16
Fri 6/19/15
Fri 7/31/15
Fri 9/18/15
Fri 10/2/15
Fri 11/20/15
Fri 1/22/16
Fri 1/22/16
Tue 2/23/16
Wed 2/24/16
Wed 8/24/16
Wed 8/10/16
Wed 1/11/17
180 days
170 days
100 days
90 days
30 days
40 days
47 days
25 days
15 days
10 days
0 days
Punchlist Work
Load FF&E and OFOI Assets
Staff Training
Final Clean
Grand Opening Events
Open for Business
Wed 1/11/17
Wed 1/25/17
Fri 2/17/17
Fri 3/17/17
Fri 4/7/17
Thu 4/20/17
Tue 2/23/16
Tue 3/7/17
Thu 3/30/17
Thu 3/23/17
Thu 4/6/17
Thu 4/20/17
Thu 4/20/17
Tue 10/18/16
Tue 1/10/17
Tue 12/13/16
Tue 2/21/17
Mon 10/31/16
Mon 10/31/16
Mon 6/27/16
Mon 8/22/16
Tue 1/26/16
Tue 2/23/16
180 days
Fri 10/23/15
Fri 2/12/16
Mon 5/30/16
Mon 5/30/16
Mon 9/28/15
Mon 11/23/15
Tue 1/26/16
Tue 1/26/16
Selective Demolition
20 days
Build Models for Residential Units
60 days
Install New MEP Risers
90 days
Recondition/Refurbish Mechanical
90 days
Components of Elevators/Escalators/
Revolving Restaurant Motor and Mechanical
Floor 17 and 32
Recondition Building Exterior
110 days
Construction of Lobby, Restaurant, Ballrooms 130 days
and Meeting Rooms on Floors 1-3
386 days
Mon 5/11/15
Mon 5/11/15
Mon 5/11/15
Mon 6/22/15
Mon 8/3/15
Mon 9/21/15
Mon 10/5/15
Mon 11/23/15
Mon 1/25/16
Mon 11/23/15
Mon 11/23/15
Mon 12/14/15
Mon 12/28/15
Mon 1/11/16
Mon 2/1/16
Mon 2/15/16
Tue 2/23/16
Tue 2/23/16
Tue 3/15/16
Tue 4/5/16
Tue 4/19/16
Tue 5/3/16
Tue 5/24/16
Mon 5/11/15
Mon 10/31/16
Mon 1/25/16
Fri 6/19/15
Fri 7/31/15
Fri 9/18/15
Fri 10/2/15
Fri 11/20/15
Fri 1/22/16
Mon 1/25/16
Mon 2/22/16
Fri 12/11/15
Fri 12/25/15
Fri 1/8/16
Fri 1/29/16
Fri 2/12/16
Mon 2/22/16
Mon 10/31/16
Mon 3/14/16
Mon 4/4/16
Mon 4/18/16
Mon 5/2/16
Mon 5/23/16
Mon 6/13/16
Mon 10/31/16
Glazing
Exterior Finishes
Interior Buildout
Punchlist and Final Inspections
Certificate of Occupancy
10 days
15 days
60 days
15 days
0 days
Tue 6/14/16
Tue 6/28/16
Tue 7/19/16
Tue 10/11/16
Mon 10/31/16
Mon 6/27/16
Mon 7/18/16
Mon 10/10/16
Mon 10/31/16
Mon 10/31/16
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
income taxes for the city and state. These taxes and fees
are summarized in the above table and along with the
ground lease/revenue share economics, are projected to
stabilization. Over the course of the development phase
over the full 99 years of the ground lease, these revenues
will generate billions of dollars in income for the City and
State.
substantial job creation resulting from the hotel,
meetings catering, retail, and parking components of
the project. Our business plan contemplates multiple
restaurant and entertainment outlets and a sizeable hotel
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
A.2
parking, and multiple retail, restaurant and entertainment venues. This programming, along with the exterior
improvements, enhanced landscaping and urban design will create a hugely popular world class destination in New
Orleans and further energize the surrounding areas and community. Oxfords proposed redevelopment of 2 Canal
Street includes the following key highlights below, more detail can be seen in the Appendix- Section B on pages 1-2.
516 Room Luxury Lifestyle Godfrey Hotel New Orleans
hotel brands, including the award-winning Godfrey
The Godfrey brand caters to leisure, business and convention hotel guests, while also creating restaurant and nightlife
destinations for local residents and visitors alike. The brand targets the lifestyle guest seeking a high design, social,
and stylish environment. Catering to this emerging demographic is particularly important for New Orleans as the city
continues its efforts and success in staying relevant and achieving new records in leisure and business visitation. We
would be interested in being partners in The Godfrey New Orleans, offering global reservation systems and loyalty
programs. Though we will continue to consider these options, as mentioned above, we are comfortable with and
The hotel will feature several indoor and outdoor restaurant and nightlife venues for hotel guests, apartment residents,
locals, and visitors. These venues will be designed to provide guests with an authentic New Orleans dining and
the building described below can be seen in the Appendix- Section B page 19.
10
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
High energy Lobby Lounge with double height feature bar that will serve signature cocktails with
ample approachable seating.
31st floor Jazz Club on the east and north wings of the building with floor to ceiling windows
performances that guests can enjoy within an intimate venue that pays tribute to New Orleans culture.
Top Floor Lounge that reactivates the famous rotating circular platform paying homage to the
for over 30 years from the 1970s through the early 2000s. The lounge will feature floor to ceiling
windows that provide guests with 360 degree views from one of the highest vantage points in the
city. Oxford plans to create an upscale lounge and event space on this floor that will be one of the
most exclusive and sought after entertainment venues in New Orleans.
13,000 SF outdoor rooftop pool and event space sitting atop a new 5-story annex building
will become a destination venue for locals and visitors, providing entertainment during the daytime
and evenings. This venue will be flexible space that can accommodate corporate events as well as
pool, private spaces on multiple levels, and views of the river and city.
The above mentioned 5-story annex building, in addition to the above outdoor rooftop venue, will include the following
1,700 square feet of prime ground floor retail/restaurant space.
~120 parking spaces utilizing automatic, modular, robotic parking. As such we will still need to
lease a to be determined number of spaces from the adjacent city owned parking lot. Our comments
to the parking agreement can be seen in pages 109-111.
9,750 square foot column-free, double-height grand ballroom on the third floor connected to
pre-function and meeting space in the existing tower accessible by the existing historic escalators.
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
11
amenities with the luxury lifestyle Godfrey hotel beneath will set these residences apart from the competition.
A full proposed unit mix is shown below and drawings and renderings of the apartments can be seen in the AppendixSection B.
Unit Mix
#/Units
SF/Unit
Total SF
Total/Avg.
100.00%
166
1,206
200,122
The 18th floor will feature an expansive collection of amenities, with some restricted to just apartment tenants and
others that will be shared by both the hotel and apartments. The amenity floor will include an indoor pool, destination
library, as well as the many hotel amenities and public food and beverage and entertainment venues throughout the
building.
12
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Building Exterior
The buildings exterior precast pebbled faade will remain and will be repaired, cleaned, and coated to give the
can illuminate the building, and all upper floor windows and curtain walls will be replaced. The third floor balcony/
new annex tower. The existing roof system will be removed and the roof decking will be inspected and repaired. A
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
13
feature the statue of Bernardo de Galvez surrounded by monumental flagpoles, benches, green infrastructure, and
elements and lighting up the building along the louvers will illuminate the iconic building in the New Orleans skyline,
cementing its position as a prominent New Orleans landmark.
Improved Landscaping
planting palette material references to our semi-tropical latitudes with a rich range of palms, flowering trees, colorful
shrubs and vibrant seasonal color. These plantings provide shade, create spaces, frame views, encourage outdoor
activities and simply soften and beautify the surrounding hardscape.
WTC and the Casino, we propose utilizing trees and ground covers for the neutral ground along Convention Center
Boulevard. We also propose planting small flowering trees adjacent to outdoor seating areas, and evergreen shrubs
to screen utility and service areas. The railroad corridor shall feature lawn between the tracks, and the slopes along
the floodwall shall have planting beds featuring a medley of colorful flowering and evergreen shrubs.
14
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
A.3
Oxford plans to redevelop 2 Canal into The Godfrey New Orleans, which will be a high design luxury lifestyle hotel,
leveraging the success of The Godfrey brand with hotels open and/or under development in Chicago and Boston as
and collections that would be interested in being partners in The Godfrey New Orleans, offering global reservation
systems and loyalty programs. Though we will continue to consider these options, as mentioned above, we are
as New Orleans.
New Orleans, leveraging our envisioned distinctively designed guestrooms and world class amenities that will be truly
Godfrey Chicago exhibits an extremely strong social media strategy where we see on average over 30 million
in the coming months upon opening and have already begun management activities in the preopening stage of
59.
base case plan is to self-manage the hotel, residential, and several of the restaurant/entertainment venues directly,
while leveraging through a capable and experienced staff, hired primarily locally. That said, Oxford is in advanced
discussions with well-known local restaurateurs with proven track records who will assist in concepting and executing
many of the propertys proposed food and beverage venues.
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
15
16
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
PROJECT DESIGN
B.1- B.4
MASTE
The
noT
for
consTrucTion.
field
confirmaTion
GUEST ROOMS
STAIRS / ELEVATORS
/ COMMON
RETAIL
B.O.H
RESTAURANT/
AMENITY SPACE
PARKING
verificaTion.
of
exisTing
SITE PLAN
1 = 100-0
16 FEBRUARY 2015
page 2
GETTYS 2014
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
DANA BR WN
Asso iates
17
18
development team
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
DEVELOPMENT TEAM
C.1
This team has the expertise and past success on
numerous projects similar in nature to this endeavor.
National and local experts have come together to
provide this important project the high level of expertise
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
19
John W. Rutledge
Founder, President & CEO
O: 312.755.9500
E: JRutledge@oxford-capital.com
Sarang (Sar) Peruri
Principal
O: 312.506.4112
E: SPeruri@oxford-capital.com
Developer
Oxford Capital Group , LLC
312.755.9500
Brad Mulvihill
Principal
O: 312.506.4113
E: BradM@oxford-capital.com
Matthew Kalt
Senior Analyst
O: 312.506.4116
E: MKalt@oxford-capital.com
0Vaf
\S
;Rd
<_YRN[`
1HZ2UOHDQV%XLOGLQJ&RUSRUDWLRQ
;NaV\[NY
=_R`R_cNaV\[
4_\b]
$(7HDP
0RQWJRPHU\5RWK
-XOLHQ(QJLQHHULQJ &RQVXOWLQJ6/'%(
,QQLW\(QJLQHHULQJ&RQVXOWDQWV6/'%(
'DQD%URZQ $VVRFLDWHV6/'%(
7KH*HWW\V*URXS
2ZQHUV5HSUHVHQWDWLYH
3URMHFW0DQDJHPHQW
)) (,QVWDOO
/bVYQV[T 9\NQ
;<9.
%XLOGLQJ$JHQFLHV
&LW\$XWKRULWLHV
:P1\[[RY
4_\b]
*HQHUDO&RQWUDFWRU
@bOP\[a_NPa\_`
5\aRY <]R_Na\_
2[IRUG+RWHOV 5HVRUWV
20
development team
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
General Contractor
Architect of Record
New Orleans, LA 70130
ID/FF&E Procurement
The Gettys Group
312.836.1111
Structural
Landscape Architect
Dana Brown & Associates
DANA BR WN
Asso iates
MEP Consultant
2626 Canal Street
New Orleans, LA 70119
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
21
Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
credit companies.
Oxfords
investment
activities
have
historically
22
development team
Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
John W. Rutledge
Founder, President & CEO
asset
management,
property
approximately $1 billion
of new
23
Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Brad D. Mulvihill
Principal
While at Oxford Capital Group,
sectors and he has served as a principal in both privately held and publicly traded companies.
24
development team
Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Matthew Kalt
Senior Analyst
investment responsibilities include
performing due diligence, market
research and analysis, as well as
Kerry OHare
Controller and Senior Vice
President, Finance
cial reporting and tax, treasury
George Jordan
Senior Vice President of
Operations, Oxford Hotels &
Resorts
hotel industry for 30 years including The Arizona Baltimore
the development team to purchase and convert to an
George rose through the ranks while attending college
25
26
development team
. Montie Garrison
Julian Anderson
President
Associate Principal
-
Ruben Rodriguez
Senior Manager
27
Focus On Sustainability
every project - whether or not the client is pursuing LEED
LEED accredited project management, engineering, and
estimating staff
Complete sustainability reviews and common sense
application of environmentally responsible building
practices
Solutions that can lead to long term cost savings and
optimization of building systems performance
Safety Standards
We understand the critical importance of safety. Since
our inception it has been our endeavor to develop a truly
elite safety organization. We constantly work to maintain
this elite status through a program that embodies all of
Organizational culture of safety that starts at the top
Accident prevention, with a strong emphasis on training
Aggressive claims management that minimizes costs
but includes the very best in medical care and rapid return to work objectives
Safety Reporting System that includes accountability at
all levels of the organization
Safety Incentive System that recognizes and rewards
safety excellence
28
development team
Allan McDonnel
President
Allan has gained over 29 years
of experience in the construction
industry. Thoughout his career,
he has served in a variety of leadership positions with several
leading New Orleans
Orleans
several historical renovation projects.
New Orleans
Orleans
Armstrong New Orleans
New Orleans
New Orleans
University of
-
out of the design arena and moved on to focus on physical construction and project management.
New Orleans
Tony Montalbano
Vice President, Field Operations
ations, Tony is responsible for
including project logistics, manpower,
company safety plan
administrator and educator, management of subcon-
Louisiana
Chapter.
29
Montgomery Roth
Architecture & Interior Design
W
for architecture, interior design, furniture and lighting
design, purchasing, installation and then some.
30
development team
Science
and
Bachelors
of
Architecture where he graduated
Nathaniel Parks, RA
Project Architect
Nathaniel graduated from Louisiana
Tech University
Louisiana
with a Bachelors of Architecture in
.
Emily Stewart, RID- Associate
Emily has a Bachelor of Science with
successfully managed and coordinated interior design projects
from concept through completion.
She has completed multimillion dollar projects
and coordinated architects, consultants and vendors to
when possible.
31
ery project from a business perspective, blending innovative design with value analysis, investment strategy
and risk mitigation.
As seasoned developers themselves, they have not only
experienced the same challenges and opportunities as
their clients, but they understand the real world and can
help clients navigate its complexities.
The Gettys Group brings expertise in hotel operations
. They have an obsessive attention to detail
and bring a collaborative work ethic to each and every
project.
32
development team
Ben Nicholas
Design Director
of Gettys global growth. DescribGettys as an intern a decade
ago and has been one of Gettys
success.
Ron Degen
Designer
Meg Boyle, NCIDQ, LEED AP
Senior Project Designer
of experience implementing all
phases of a design project from
concept through construction in
commercial, hospitality, retail, and
recognized for Store of the Year for Bath & Body Works,
Apartments.
33
Louisiana
tional Airport, the Sewerage & Water Board of New Orleans, Orleans Levee District, and the Small Business AdWe have the supporting facilities including advanced
to complete any engineering task in a timely manner.
tration, resident inspection, and development of plans,
civil/structural projects involving work on public buildings and infrastructure. As demonstrated through our
vast experience with past clients, we have the profesto perform the necessary work above the expected
conception to successful completion providing leadership to dynamic teams of owners, contractors, public
agencies, private institutions, and the public.
34
development team
Brian Anderson, PE
Project Engineer
Brian Anderson has more than 15
years of experience and has worked
on various civil/structural projects
including roadways, sanitary sewerage, stormwater drainage, building
structures and a myriad of other new and rehabilitation
tions,
manages the bidding process, and performs construction
assessments and developed reports for many projects
involving documenting existing conditions and damage
to infrastructure and projects resulting from various
various software packages and offers fresh ideas and
to-date with new technological advances and his work
James Green, PE
Project Engineer
of experience in various areas of
engineering, construction, and
civil and structural engineering
New Orleans.
35
DANA BR WN
Asso iates
Dana Brown & Associates
creation of landscape architects and planners who
have practiced in diverse professional realms and
geographic regions. We are one of the largest landscape
Louisiana with
New Orleans
36
development team
DANA BR WN
Asso iates
Dana Nunez Brown
ASLA, PLA, AICP, LEED AP
During her 35 years of experience as
a landscape architect and planner,
New
Orleans,
Orange County, California primarily
as a private consultant for two of the largest design
New Orleans, Dana
tion
grants, the New Orleans
scale public presentations, and his use of working digital
models during the design process allows for real world
Gaylan Williams
ASLA, LEED AP
Gaylan is a Senior Associate at
New
Orleans and a LEED Accredited
37
Engineering
Consultants,
mechanical
system
LLC
designs.
are client interface, site inspection and evaluation, contract negotiation, project management, design, and
meetings and coordinates project relevant activities between the Company and the client.
Chauvins professional 22+ year career has revolved
tions for municipalities, offshore oil and gas facilities,
were completed according to a schedule dictated by the
budgets and completed projects under budget.
38
development team
systems.
Gregory Lintinger, P.E.
Electrical Engineering Manager
Gregory Lintinger has over 30 years
of experience in management,
Gregory Pier
Project Engineer
provides conceptual designs, engineering and construction estimates
perience performing research and
design to create the most practical and economical
addition, he contributes to the project design team
and develops and reviews bid and contract drawings
and bid packages.
Michael Leitzinger, P.E.
Project Engineer
systems.
New
Orleans
Engineering.of part-time experience in a variety of design
programs, focusing on producing design drawings and
39
service.
40
development team
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
41
42
development team
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
43
44
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
D.1
Oxford has been involved in over $2.5 billion of
transactions over the past 20 years, including individual
projects as large as approximately $350 million and
projects we deploy our principals capital as well as that
of our investor base coupled with conservative leverage
from one of our longtime relationship lenders that have
ranged from commercial banks to insurance companies
The
0
0
000
000
000
796
000
0
913
019
333
667
623
926
000
693
100
259
0
792
924
179
000
224
Total Capital
128,334,612
52,962,942
75,371,670
256,669,224
% of Total
50.00%
20.63%
29.37%
100.00%
Total Capital
128,334,612
105,925,883
22,408,729
256,669,224
% of Total
50.00%
41.27%
8.73%
100.00%
Notes:
1) Assumes 50% of tax credits are received during construction and 50% at the end of year 1 of operations
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
45
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Intermediaries:
CBRE
Cohen Financial
Colliers
Douglas Elliman
Eastdil
Goldman Sachs
Hodges Ward Elliot
Hospitality Valuation Services
Hunter Realty
Jones Lang LaSalle
Lazard
Mission Capital
Molinaro Koger
Sonnenblick Goldman
Sample of Hotel Companies and/or brands
JWR/Oxford Capital has worked with:
Aramark Corporation
Fowler Hospitality
Hampton Hotels
Hilton Hotel Corporation
Hilton Doubletree Hotels
Hilton Hampton Inn & Suites
Holiday Inn
Hyatt Hotels
InterContinental Hotels Group
Kimpton Hotels
Langham Hotels International
LaSalle Hotel Properties
Marriott International
Marriott Courtyard
Marriott Residence Inn
Marriott Spring Hill Suites
Oxford Hotels & Resorts, LLC*
Radisson Hotels & Resorts
RLJ Lodging Trust
Godfrey Hotel
Felix Hotel
47
: Approximately 140,000
Approximately $75 Million
Oxford principals and Global
Institutional Investment Fund
48
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
49
50
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
450
Approximately 350,000
Approximately $200 Million
Oxford Principals, Global
Institutional Investment Fund, Prominent
Commercial Bank
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
51
52
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Keys: 316
Square Feet: Approximately 400,000
Cost: Approximately $ 200 Million
Funding Sources: Chinese Investment Company
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
53
225
Approximately 100,000
Approximately $60 Million
Oxford Principals, Domestic Real
Estate Opportunity Fund, Prominent Commercial
Bank
54
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Chicago, Illinois
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
55
417
Lower 16 floors of approximately
600,000 building
Approximately $53Million
Oxford Principals, REIT, and a
Prominent Commercial Bank
56
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
764
Approximately 500,000
Approximately $150 Million
Oxford Principals, Global
Institutional Investment Fund, Global Money Center
Banks
beverage venues.
redevelopment,
operational
repositioning
and
York City.
Oxford Capital leased out all food and beverage
outlets and successfully harvested and recapitalized
at in-creasing valuations, culminating in a sale/
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
57
725
Approximately 500,000
Approximately $150 Million
Oxford Principals, Global
Institutional Investment Fund, Global Money Center
Banks
58
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
59
60
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Development of the Year Nominee (Americas Lodging Investment Summit) Godfrey Hotel
Chicago
HSMAI Adrian Awards Social Media Campaign Silver Level Winner Godfrey Hotel Chicago
HSMAI Adrian Awards PR Campaign Bronze Level Winner Godfrey Hotel Chicago
2015 Trip Advisor Travelers Choice Awards Top Hotel In U.S. Award Langham Chicago Hotel
#1 Large City Hotel: Continental US (Travel & Leisure) - Langham Chicago Hotel
Development of the Year Finalist (Americas Lodging Investment Summit) Langham Chicago
Hotel
Developer of the Year Finalist (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards) Oxford Capital Group, LLC
Development of the Year Finalist (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards) Godfrey Hotel
Chicago
Redevelopment of the Year Finalist (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards) - Langham Chicago
Hotel
Special Achievement Award Nominee (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards) Oxford Capital
Group, LLCs lodging strategy
Transaction of the Year Nominee (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards) - 360 North Michigan
Avenue
Platinum and First Place at Green Business Challenge National Conference Center
Downtown Redevelopment of the Year Finalist (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards) - Hotel
Felix Chicago
Chicago Innovation Awards Nominee Hotel Felix Chicago
Ernst & Young Entrepreneur of the Year Awards Finalist Oxfords Founder & CEO
Nations Top Businesses (DiversityBusiness.com) National Conference Center
Global Doubletree Conversion of the Year (Hilton Corporation) The Doubletree Hotel Chicago
Global Doubletree Conversion of the Year (Hilton Corporation) The Doubletree Hotel and
Conference Center, Skokie, IL
Stuart Cornew Leadership Award (Young Presidents Organization)
Best Renovation in U.S. Midscale (Lodging Hospitality Magazine) The Doubletree Metropolitan
Hotel, NYC
100 Largest Mergers and Acquisitions (Crains) The Doubletree Metropolitan Hotel, NYC
Best Renovation in the U.S. (Lodging Hospitality Magazine) The Radisson Lexington Hotel, NYC
Americas Fastest Growing Private Companies (Inc. 500) Potbelly Sandwich Works
Downtown Redevelopment of the Year Finalist (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards) The
Redevelopment of the Year Nominee (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards) Renaissance
Chicago Northshore Hotel, Northbrook, IL
Chicago Business 40 under 40 (Crains) Oxfords Founder & CEO
Chicago Real Estate Intermediary of the Year Finalist (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards)
Oxfords Founder & CEO (Twice)
North Franklin, Chicago, IL
Downtown Redevelopment of the Year (Chicago Commercial Real Estate Awards) Oprah Winfreys
Harpo Studios, Chicago, IL
Leasing Success Story of the Year (Realty & Building Magazine) 10 South LaSalle, Chicago, IL
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
61
62
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Service.
reduced property tax assessment levels over a 12-year period. Oxford and its consultants attended hearings before
out and gained support of our City Council member, our local Alderman, and other important constituents of the
State of Louisiana
City of New Orleans
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
63
64
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
municipalities in the surrounding area. We are familiar with projects that have involved weekly and daily coordination
positive working relationships with these entities throughout the design and construction process.
the engineering support to meet all deadlines; budgets and the ability complete the project correctly.
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
65
D.3
John W. Rutledge
President & CEO
Oxford Capital Group, LLC
66
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
D.4
Godfrey Hotel New Orleans & Luxury Residences Estimated Development Budget
2 Canal Street - 516 Key Hotel + 166 Luxury Apartments
Purchase Price
0
Transfer Tax
0
Acquisition Fee
1,000,000
Due Diligence, Travel, Other
250,000
Legal
4,000,000
Development/Sponsorship Fee
8,878,796
Preopening/Working Capital
5,000,000
Interest Reserve During Planning
0
Interest Reserve During Redevelopment
8,020,913
Financing Fee (1.5%)
1,925,019
Ground Lease During Planning
308,333
Ground Lease During Redevelopment
1,541,667
Real Estate Taxes / Insurance During Planning
375,623
Real Estate Taxes / Insurance During Redevelopment
1,965,926
Tax Credit Legal and Structuring
225,000
Leasing Commissions
77,693
TI Allowance
71,100
Tax Credit Success Fee
1,059,259
EB5 Costs
0
Owner Contingency
17,812,792
Hard Costs
169,613,924
Soft Costs
17,515,179
FF&E / OS&E
17,028,000
Total Use of Funds
256,669,224
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
67
Year Two
2018-2019
66.4%
Year Three
2019-2020
70.6%
Year Four
2020-2021
75.1%
Year Five
2021-2022
75.1%
75.1%
75.1%
$195.24
$211.91
$229.40
$236.29
$243.37
$250.68
RevPAR
$129.56
$149.64
$172.23
$177.40
$182.72
$188.20
Number of Rooms
516
516
516
516
516
516
# of Rooms Sold
124,976
133,361
141,400
141,400
141,787
141,787
# of Rooms Available
188,340
188,856
188,340
188,340
188,856
188,856
% of
% of
% of
% of
% of
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
REVENUES
Rooms
24,400,529
56.5%
$47,288
$195.24
28,260,499
59.3%
$54,768
$211.91
32,437,695
61.9%
$62,864
$229.40
33,410,826
61.9%
$64,750
$236.29
34,507,433
61.9%
$66,875
$243.37
35,542,656
F&B
11,402,606
26.4%
$22,098
$91.24
11,744,684
24.7%
$22,761
$88.07
12,097,025
23.1%
$23,444
$85.55
12,459,936
23.1%
$24,147
$88.12
12,833,734
23.0%
$24,872
$90.51
13,615,308
129,488
0.3%
$251
$1.04
133,373
0.3%
$258
$1.00
137,374
0.3%
$266
$0.97
141,495
0.3%
$274
$1.00
145,740
0.3%
$282
$1.03
154,616
4,821,112
11.2%
$9,343
$38.58
4,965,745
10.4%
$9,624
$37.24
5,114,717
9.8%
$9,912
$36.17
5,268,159
9.8%
$10,210
$37.26
5,426,203
9.7%
$10,516
$38.27
5,588,990
13,656
0.0%
$26
$0.11
15,010
0.0%
$29
$0.11
16,392
0.0%
$32
$0.12
16,884
0.0%
$33
$0.12
17,438
0.0%
$34
$0.12
17,961
2,403,060
5.6%
$4,657
$0.11
2,518,560
5.3%
$4,881
$0.11
2,636,988
5.0%
$5,110
$0.11
2,716,098
5.0%
$5,264
$0.11
2,799,773
5.0%
$5,426
$0.11
2,883,766
43,170,451
100.0%
$83,664
$345.43
47,637,871
100.0%
$92,321
$357.21
52,440,192
100.0%
$101,628
$370.86
54,013,398
100.0%
$104,677
$381.99
55,730,321
100.0%
$108,004
$393.06
57,803,297
Rooms
F&B Expense
6,585,304
8,293,252
27.0%
72.7%
$12,762
$16,072
$52.69
$66.36
7,405,097
7,954,815
26.2%
67.7%
$14,351
$15,416
$55.53
$59.65
8,073,853
8,193,459
24.9%
67.7%
$15,647
$15,879
$57.10
$57.95
8,329,152
8,439,263
24.9%
67.7%
$16,142
$16,355
$58.90
$59.68
8,600,981
8,692,441
24.9%
67.7%
$16,669
$16,846
$60.66
$61.31
8,792,628
9,221,811
2,997,821
62.2%
$5,810
$23.99
2,831,753
57.0%
$5,488
$21.23
2,916,705
57.0%
$5,653
$20.63
3,004,206
57.0%
$5,822
$21.25
3,094,332
57.0%
$5,997
$21.82
3,187,162
Total Revenues
DEPARTMENTAL EXPENSES
0.30
Telephone Expenses
40,969
300.0%
$79
$0.33
45,030
300.0%
$87
$0.34
49,176
300.0%
$95
$0.35
50,652
300.0%
$98
$0.36
52,314
300.0%
$101
$0.37
2,151,781
89.5%
$4,170
$0.00
2,242,379
89.0%
$4,346
$0.00
2,335,373
88.6%
$4,526
$0.00
2,405,435
88.6%
$4,662
$0.00
2,478,913
88.5%
$4,804
$0.00
2,553,280
20,069,127
46.5%
$38,894
$160.58
20,479,073
43.0%
$39,688
$153.56
21,568,568
41.1%
$41,800
$152.54
22,228,707
41.2%
$43,079
$157.20
22,918,981
41.1%
$44,417
$161.64
23,808,764
23,101,325
53.5%
$44,770
$184.85
27,158,798
57.0%
$52,633
$203.65
30,871,624
58.9%
$59,829
$218.33
31,784,690
58.8%
$61,598
$224.79
32,811,340
58.9%
$63,588
$231.41
33,994,532
2,383,682
5.5%
$4,620
$19.07
2,543,085
5.3%
$4,928
$19.07
2,712,827
5.2%
$5,257
$19.19
2,794,934
5.2%
$5,417
$19.77
2,882,193
5.2%
$5,586
$20.33
2,962,554
Management Fees
1,726,818
4.0%
$3,347
$13.82
1,905,515
4.0%
$3,693
$14.29
2,097,608
4.0%
$4,065
$14.83
2,160,536
4.0%
$4,187
$15.28
2,229,213
4.0%
$4,320
$15.72
2,312,132
1,684,858
3.9%
$3,265
$13.48
1,426,840
3.0%
$2,765
$10.70
1,470,103
2.8%
$2,849
$10.40
1,514,687
2.8%
$2,935
$10.71
1,560,632
2.8%
$3,024
$11.01
1,576,990
Franchise Fees
1,987,818
8.1%
$3,852
$15.91
2,291,433
8.1%
$4,441
$17.18
2,619,868
8.1%
$5,077
$18.53
2,698,464
8.1%
$5,230
$19.08
2,786,772
8.1%
$5,401
$19.65
2,870,375
816,531
1.9%
$1,582
$6.53
885,822
1.9%
$1,717
$6.64
958,552
1.8%
$1,858
$6.78
987,609
1.8%
$1,914
$6.98
1,017,552
1.8%
$1,972
$7.18
Utilities
860,358
2.0%
$1,667
$6.88
945,620
2.0%
$1,833
$7.09
1,032,704
2.0%
$2,001
$7.30
1,063,685
2.0%
$2,061
$7.52
1,098,597
2.0%
$2,129
$7.75
1,098,597
9,460,065
21.9%
$18,333
$75.69
9,998,315
21.0%
$19,377
$74.97
10,891,661
20.8%
$21,108
$77.03
11,219,914
20.8%
$21,744
$79.35
11,574,960
20.8%
$22,432
$81.64
11,854,448
13,641,259
31.6%
$26,437
$109.15
17,160,483
36.0%
$33,257
$128.68
19,979,963
38.1%
$38,721
$141.30
20,564,776
38.1%
$39,854
$145.44
21,236,380
38.1%
$41,156
$149.78
22,140,085
0.0%
$0
$0.00
952,757
2.0%
$1,846
$7.14
1,573,206
3.0%
$3,049
$11.13
1,620,402
3.0%
$3,140
$11.46
1,671,910
3.0%
$3,240
$11.79
1,734,099
2.3%
$1,037
$4.28
545,686
2.3%
$1,058
$4.09
556,600
2.3%
$1,079
$3.94
567,732
2.3%
$1,100
$4.02
579,086
2.3%
$1,122
$4.08
590,668
2.3%
$1,924
$7.94
1,022,362
2.1%
$1,981
$7.67
1,053,033
2.0%
$2,041
$7.45
1,084,624
2.0%
$2,102
$7.67
1,117,163
2.0%
$2,165
$7.88
1,150,678
Other Expenses
Total Departmental Expenses
DEPARTMENTAL PROFIT
53,884
6.3
1,033,800
FIXED EXPENSES
FF&E Reserve
RE Taxes
Property Insurance
CAM Reimbursements
Total Fixed Expenses
534,986
992,585
(5,403)
0.0%
($10)
($0.04)
(5,547)
0.0%
($11)
($0.04)
(5,694)
0.0%
($11)
($0.04)
(5,845)
0.0%
($11)
($0.04)
(6,000)
0.0%
($12)
($0.04)
(6,160)
1,522,168
3.5%
$2,950
$12.18
2,515,259
5.3%
$4,875
$18.86
3,177,145
6.1%
$6,157
$22.47
3,266,913
6.0%
$6,331
$23.10
3,362,159
6.0%
$6,516
$23.71
3,469,285
12,119,091
28.1%
$23,487
$96.97
14,645,224
30.7%
$28,382
$109.82
16,802,818
32.0%
$32,564
$118.83
17,297,863
32.0%
$33,523
$122.33
17,874,221
32.1%
$34,640
$126.06
18,670,799
Notes:
1) Proforma assumes market franchise fees for a typical upscale chain/affiliation
Year Five
2021-2022
Year Six
2023
75.1%
Year Seven
2024
75.1%
Year Eight
2025
75.1%
Year Nine
2026
75.1%
Year Ten
2027
75.1%
5 Year
CAGR
3.1%
5.7%
9.0%
0.0%
3.2%
0.1%
75.1%
$243.37
$250.68
$258.20
$265.94
$273.92
$282.14
$182.72
$188.20
$193.85
$199.66
$205.65
$211.82
516
516
516
516
516
516
141,787
141,787
141,787
141,787
141,787
141,787
188,856
188,856
188,856
188,856
188,856
188,856
% of
% of
% of
% of
% of
% of
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
Amount
Revenue
PAR
POR
34,507,433
61.9%
$66,875
$243.37
35,542,656
61.5%
$68,881
$250.68
36,608,936
61.1%
$70,948
$258.20
37,707,204
60.6%
$73,076
$265.94
38,838,420
60.2%
$75,268
$273.92
40,003,573
59.3%
$77,526
$282.14
12,833,734
23.0%
$24,872
$90.51
13,615,308
23.6%
$26,386
$96.03
14,444,480
24.1%
$27,993
$101.87
15,324,149
24.6%
$29,698
$108.08
16,257,390
25.2%
$31,507
$114.66
17,764,889
26.3%
$34,428
$125.29
145,740
0.3%
$282
$1.03
154,616
0.3%
$300
$1.09
164,032
0.3%
$318
$1.16
174,021
0.3%
$337
$1.23
184,619
0.3%
$358
$1.30
201,738
0.3%
$391
$1.42
5,426,203
9.7%
$10,516
$38.27
5,588,990
9.7%
$10,831
$39.42
5,756,659
9.6%
$11,156
$40.60
5,929,359
9.5%
$11,491
$41.82
6,107,240
9.5%
$11,836
$43.07
6,290,457
9.3%
$12,191
$44.37
17,438
0.0%
$34
$0.12
17,961
0.0%
$35
$0.12
18,500
0.0%
$36
$0.12
19,055
0.0%
$37
$0.12
19,627
0.0%
$38
$0.12
20,215
0.0%
$39
$0.37
9.1%
3.0%
3.0%
6.3%
2,799,773
5.0%
$5,426
$0.11
2,883,766
5.0%
$5,589
$0.11
2,970,279
5.0%
$5,756
$0.11
3,059,387
4.9%
$5,929
$0.11
3,151,169
4.9%
$6,107
$0.11
3,218,619
4.8%
$6,238
$0.11
55,730,321
100.0%
$108,004
$393.06
57,803,297
100.0%
$112,022
$407.68
59,962,886
100.0%
$116,207
$422.91
62,213,176
100.0%
$120,568
$438.78
64,558,465
100.0%
$125,113
$455.32
67,499,492
100.0%
$130,813
$476.06
6.6%
8,600,981
8,692,441
24.9%
67.7%
$16,669
$16,846
$60.66
$61.31
8,792,628
9,221,811
24.7%
67.7%
$17,040
$17,872
$62.01
$65.04
8,990,024
9,783,419
24.6%
67.7%
$17,423
$18,960
$63.41
$69.00
9,193,342
10,379,229
24.4%
67.7%
$17,817
$20,115
$64.84
$73.20
9,402,759
11,011,324
24.2%
67.7%
$18,222
$21,340
$66.32
$77.66
9,618,459
12,032,371
24.0%
67.7%
$18,640
$23,319
$67.84
$84.86
6.9%
3,094,332
57.0%
$5,997
$21.82
3,187,162
57.0%
$6,177
$22.48
3,282,777
57.0%
$6,362
$23.15
3,381,261
57.0%
$6,553
$23.85
3,482,698
57.0%
$6,749
$24.56
3,587,179
57.0%
$6,952
$25.30
52,314
300.0%
$101
$0.37
53,884
300.0%
$104
$0.38
55,500
300.0%
$108
$0.39
57,165
300.0%
$111
$0.40
58,880
300.0%
$114
$0.42
60,646
300.0%
$118
$0.43
0.8%
6.3%
2,478,913
88.5%
$4,804
$0.00
2,553,280
88.5%
$4,948
$0.00
2,629,878
88.5%
$5,097
$0.00
2,708,775
88.5%
$5,250
$0.00
2,790,038
88.5%
$5,407
$0.00
2,857,488
88.8%
$5,538
$0.00
22,918,981
41.1%
$44,417
$161.64
23,808,764
41.2%
$46,141
$167.92
24,741,599
41.3%
$131.01
$174.50
25,719,771
41.3%
$136.19
$181.40
26,745,700
41.4%
$141.62
$188.63
28,156,144
41.7%
$149.09
$198.58
3.4%
32,811,340
58.9%
$63,588
$231.41
33,994,532
58.8%
$65,881
$239.76
35,221,288
58.7%
$68,258
$248.41
36,493,405
58.7%
$70,724
$257.38
37,812,765
58.6%
$73,281
$266.69
39,343,347
58.3%
$76,247
$277.48
9.2%
2,882,193
5.2%
$5,586
2,786,772
8.1%
$5,401
$19.65
2,870,375
8.1%
$5,563
$20.24
2,956,486
8.1%
$5,730
$20.85
3,045,181
8.1%
$5,902
$21.48
3,136,536
8.1%
$6,079
$22.12
3,230,633
8.1%
$6,261
1,017,552
1.8%
$1,972
$7.18
1,033,800
1.8%
$2,003
$7.29
1,050,535
1.8%
$2,036
$7.41
1,067,772
1.7%
$2,069
$7.53
1,085,527
1.7%
$2,104
$7.66
1,103,814
1.6%
$2,139
1,098,597
2.0%
$2,129
$7.75
1,098,597
1.9%
$2,129
$7.75
1,098,597
1.8%
$2,129
$7.75
1,098,597
1.8%
$2,129
$7.75
1,098,597
1.7%
$2,129
$7.75
1,098,597
1.6%
$2,129
$7.75
11,574,960
20.8%
$22,432
$81.64
11,854,448
20.5%
$22,974
$83.61
12,143,969
20.3%
$64.30
$85.65
12,443,925
20.0%
$65.89
$87.76
12,754,735
19.8%
$67.54
$89.96
13,110,333
19.4%
$69.42
$92.46
4.9%
6.6%
-1.9%
8.8%
5.7%
6.3%
5.2%
21,236,380
38.1%
$41,156
$149.78
22,140,085
38.3%
$42,907
$156.15
23,077,319
38.5%
$44,723
$162.76
24,049,480
38.7%
$46,608
$169.62
25,058,030
38.8%
$48,562
$176.73
26,233,015
38.9%
$50,839
$185.02
11.7%
$14.28
$20.33
2,962,554
5.1%
$5,741
$20.89
3,045,997
5.1%
$5,903
$21.48
3,132,656
5.0%
$6,071
$22.09
3,222,670
5.0%
$6,245
$22.73
3,329,833
4.9%
$6,453
$23.48
2,229,213
4.0%
$4,320
$15.72
2,312,132
4.0%
$4,481
$16.31
2,398,515
4.0%
$4,648
$16.92
2,488,527
4.0%
$4,823
$17.55
2,582,339
4.0%
$5,005
$18.21
2,699,980
4.0%
$5,233
$19.04
1,560,632
2.8%
$3,024
$11.01
1,576,990
2.7%
$3,056
$11.12
1,593,838
2.7%
$3,089
$11.24
1,611,192
2.6%
$3,122
$11.36
1,629,066
2.5%
$3,157
$11.49
1,647,476
2.4%
$3,193
$11.62
$22.79
1,671,910
3.0%
$3,240
$11.79
1,734,099
3.0%
$3,361
$12.23
1,798,887
3.0%
$3,486
$12.69
1,866,395
3.0%
$3,617
$13.16
1,936,754
3.0%
$3,753
$13.66
2,024,985
3.0%
$3,924
579,086
2.3%
$1,122
$4.08
590,668
2.3%
$1,145
$4.17
602,482
2.3%
$1,168
$4.25
614,531
2.3%
$1,191
$4.33
626,822
2.3%
$1,215
$4.42
639,358
2.3%
$1,239
1,117,163
2.0%
$2,165
$7.88
1,150,678
2.0%
$2,230
$8.12
1,185,198
2.0%
$2,297
$8.36
1,220,754
2.0%
$2,366
$8.61
1,257,377
1.9%
$2,437
$8.87
1,295,098
1.9%
$2,510
(6,000)
0.0%
($12)
($0.04)
(6,160)
0.0%
($12)
($0.04)
(6,324)
0.0%
($12)
($0.04)
(6,492)
0.0%
($13)
($0.05)
(6,665)
0.0%
($13)
($0.05)
(6,843)
0.0%
($13)
$7.78
$4.51
$9.13
($0.05)
2.0%
3.0%
2.7%
3,362,159
6.0%
$6,516
$23.71
3,469,285
6.0%
$6,723
$24.47
3,580,243
6.0%
$6,938
$25.25
3,695,189
5.9%
$7,161
$26.06
3,814,288
5.9%
$7,392
$26.90
3,952,598
5.9%
$7,660
$27.88
21.9%
17,874,221
32.1%
$34,640
$126.06
18,670,799
32.3%
$36,184
$131.68
19,497,076
32.5%
$37,785
$137.51
20,354,291
32.7%
$39,446
$143.56
21,243,742
32.9%
$41,170
$149.83
22,280,416
33.0%
$43,179
$157.14
10.2%
Income
Projected Market Rent
Loss to Lease
Gross Potential Income
Leasing Concessions
Non Revenue Units
Bad Debt Write-offs
Vacancy Loss
Parking Income
Other Income
Effective Gross Income
1.00%
2
1.00%
$2,048
$2.31
N/A
$2.38
3.00%
$2.45
3.00%
$2.52
3.00%
$2.60
3.00%
$2.68
3.00%
$2.76
3.00%
$2.84
3.00%
$2.92
3.00%
$3.01
3.00%
$3.10
3.00%
Year 1
2017-2018
Year 2
2018-2019
Year 3
2019-2020
Year 4
2020-2021
Year 5
2021-2022
Year 6
2022-2023
Year 7
2023-2024
Year 8
2024-2025
Year 9
2025-2026
Year 10
2026-2027
Year 10
2027-2028
$5,544,082
($55,441)
$5,488,641
(54,886)
(66,796)
(54,886)
(411,648)
393,382
340,011
5,633,817
$5,710,404
($57,104)
$5,653,300
(56,533)
(68,800)
(56,533)
(282,665)
405,183
292,666
5,886,619
$5,881,717
($58,817)
$5,822,899
(58,229)
(70,864)
(58,229)
(291,145)
417,339
301,446
6,063,217
$6,058,168
($60,582)
$5,997,586
(59,976)
(72,990)
(59,976)
(299,879)
429,859
310,490
6,245,114
$6,239,913
($62,399)
$6,177,514
(61,775)
(75,180)
(61,775)
(308,876)
442,755
319,804
6,432,467
$6,427,111
($64,271)
$6,362,839
(63,628)
(77,435)
(63,628)
(318,142)
456,037
329,399
6,625,441
$6,619,924
($66,199)
$6,553,725
(65,537)
(79,758)
(65,537)
(327,686)
469,718
339,281
6,824,205
$6,818,522
($68,185)
$6,750,336
(67,503)
(82,151)
(67,503)
(337,517)
483,810
349,459
7,028,931
$7,023,077
($70,231)
$6,952,846
(69,528)
(84,615)
(69,528)
(347,642)
498,324
359,943
7,239,799
$7,233,770
($72,338)
$7,161,432
(71,614)
(87,154)
(71,614)
(358,072)
513,274
370,741
7,456,993
$7,450,783
($74,508)
$7,376,275
(73,763)
(89,768)
(73,763)
(368,814)
528,672
381,863
7,680,702
225,353
72,557
791,419
36,279
106,839
172,323
196,691
45,348
199,532
194,390
282,115
63,487
2,386,332
235,465
74,734
815,162
37,367
50,858
177,493
202,592
46,709
205,518
200,221
290,578
65,392
2,402,088
242,529
76,976
839,617
38,488
52,384
182,818
208,669
48,110
211,683
206,228
299,295
67,354
2,474,150
249,805
79,285
864,805
39,643
53,956
188,302
214,929
49,553
218,034
212,415
308,274
69,374
2,548,375
257,299
81,664
890,749
40,832
55,574
193,951
221,377
51,040
224,575
218,787
317,522
71,456
2,624,826
265,018
84,114
917,472
42,057
57,241
199,770
228,019
52,571
231,312
225,351
327,048
73,599
2,703,571
272,968
86,637
944,996
43,318
58,959
205,763
234,859
54,148
238,252
232,112
336,860
75,807
2,784,678
281,157
89,236
973,346
44,618
60,727
211,936
241,905
55,773
245,399
239,075
346,965
78,082
2,868,218
289,592
91,913
1,002,546
45,957
62,549
218,294
249,162
57,446
252,761
246,247
357,374
80,424
2,954,265
298,280
94,671
1,032,622
47,335
64,426
224,842
256,637
59,169
260,344
253,635
368,096
82,837
3,042,893
307,228
97,511
1,063,601
48,755
66,359
231,588
264,336
60,944
268,154
261,244
379,138
85,322
3,134,180
3,247,485
3,484,531
3,589,067
3,696,739
3,807,641
3,921,870
4,039,527
4,160,712
4,285,534
4,414,100
4,546,523
Year 1
$/Unit
$1,358
$437
$4,768
$219
$644
$1,038
$1,185
$273
$1,202
$1,171
$1,699
$382
$14,375.50
Year 1
$/RSF
$1.13
$0.36
$3.95
$0.18
$0.53
$0.86
$0.98
$0.23
$1.00
$0.97
$1.41
$0.32
$1,979.45
Year 1
% of EGI
4.00%
1.29%
14.05%
0.64%
1.90%
3.06%
3.49%
0.80%
3.54%
3.45%
5.01%
1.13%
42.4%
Year
Year 5
2021-2022
Year 6
2022-2023
Year 7
2023-2024
Year 8
2024-2025
Year 9
2025-2026
Year 10
2026-2027
Hotel Revenue
Apartment Revenue
Total Revenue
43,170,451
5,633,817
$48,804,268
47,637,871
5,886,619
$53,524,490
52,440,192
6,063,217
$58,503,409
54,013,398
6,245,114
$60,258,511
55,730,321
6,432,467
$62,162,789
57,803,297
6,625,441
$64,428,738
59,962,886
6,824,205
$66,787,091
62,213,176
7,028,931
$69,242,107
64,558,465
7,239,799
$71,798,263
67,499,492
7,456,993
$74,956,484
Hotel Expenses
Apartment Expenses
Total Expenses
31,051,360
2,386,332
$33,437,692
32,992,647
2,402,088
$35,394,735
35,637,374
2,474,150
$38,111,524
36,715,534
2,548,375
$39,263,909
37,856,100
2,624,826
$40,480,927
39,132,498
2,703,571
$41,836,069
40,465,810
2,784,678
$43,250,488
41,858,885
2,868,218
$44,727,103
43,314,722
2,954,265
$46,268,987
45,219,075
3,042,893
$48,261,968
Total NOI
Ground Lease
NOBC Portion of Income
Net NOI
$15,366,576
(1,850,000)
(114,128)
$13,402,448
$15,987,020
$18,178,434
$18,736,882
$19,378,988
(3,177,776)
(9,625,096)
(3,177,776)
(9,625,096)
(3,177,776)
(9,625,096)
(3,177,776)
(9,625,096)
(3,177,776)
(9,625,096)
$599,576
$3,184,148
$5,375,562
$5,934,010
$6,576,115
$20,243,738
(9,625,096)
$10,618,642
5.2%
6.9%
6.2%
8.6%
7.1%
10.1%
7.3%
10.5%
7.6%
10.9%
2.9%
5.0%
6.7%
7.1%
7.6%
8.3%
0.8%
1.39
4.4%
1.66
7.4%
1.89
8.1%
1.95
9.0%
2.01
14.6%
2.10
Note:
1) Return on Equity-Leveraged - Includes developer equity as well as tax credit equity
2) Return on Equity - Net of Tax Credit Proceeds -Includes all deductions for payments to tax credit investor
7.9%
13.7%
$21,140,692
(9,625,096)
$11,515,596
8.2%
14.3%
$22,071,175
(9,625,096)
$12,446,079
$23,036,571
(9,625,096)
$13,411,475
$24,151,957
(9,625,096)
$14,526,861
8.6%
14.9%
9.0%
15.5%
9.4%
16.3%
9.0%
9.7%
10.5%
11.3%
15.8%
2.20
17.1%
2.29
18.4%
2.39
19.9%
2.51
D.5
74
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
D.6
Pre-Opening
800
450
350
19
19
0
10
10
0
4
4
0
2
2
0
835
485
350
Year 1
0
0
0
111
98
13
181
127
54
13
13
0
43
27
16
348
265
83
Year 2
0
0
0
121
104
17
181
127
54
13
13
0
43
27
16
358
271
87
Year 3
0
0
0
125
107
18
181
127
54
13
13
0
43
27
16
362
274
88
Year 4
0
0
0
125
107
18
181
127
54
13
13
0
43
27
16
362
274
88
Year 5
0
0
0
125
107
18
181
127
54
13
13
0
43
27
16
362
274
88
Pre-Opening
40,000,000
669,660
405,645
92,233
0
$41,167,538
Year 1
0
4,072,854
4,061,426
616,392
936,887
$9,687,559
Year 2
0
4,512,971
4,183,269
634,884
964,994
$10,296,117
Year 3
0
4,820,179
4,308,767
653,930
993,943
$10,776,820
Year 4
Year 5
0
0
4,964,785
5,113,728
4,438,030
4,571,171
673,548
693,755
1,023,762
1,054,475
$11,100,125 $11,433,128
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
75
76
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
E.1
on the sale.
$308,333
$1,541,667
$1,850,000
$1,887,000
$1,924,740
$1,963,235
$2,002,499
$0
$0
$277,500
$283,050
$288,711
$294,485
$300,375
$0
$0
$114,128
$255,735
$288,711
$294,485
$300,375
$308,333
$1,541,667
$1,964,128
$2,142,735
$2,213,451
$2,257,720
$2,302,874
$1,059,364
$2,894,872
$98,759,687
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
77
78
dbe participation
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
DISADVANTAGED
BUSINESS ENTERPRISES
(DBE) PARTICIPATION
F.1
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
79
80
dbe participation
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
81
2/13/2015
88
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
OTHER REQUIREMENTS
Veracity Statement
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
89
90
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
91
92
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
93
94
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
95
96
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
ATTACHMENT B
Agreement and Signature
By submitting the enclosed response, the undersigned affirms that the facts set forth in it are
true and complete. The undersigned understands that any false statements, omissions, or other
misrepresentations made in connection with the response may result in dismissal of the
undersigned's application.
Name (printed)
Signature
Date
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
97
EXHIBIT A
page 1 of 9
21
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
99
EXHIBIT A
page 2 of 9
BRAND HALLMARKS
REPRESENT THE HOTEL
100
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
EXHIBIT A
page 3 of 9
LTSCAs
LONG TERM SUSTAINABLE COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES
ICONIC
ARCHITECTURE
Iconic architecture
GRACIOUSLY APPOINTED,
ECO-FRIENDLY GUEST
ROOMS
Design features, tech packages, low voltage lighting, heat
exchangers, etc..
UNIQUE
SPACES/VENUE
Each Godfrey Hotel offers unique flexible
spaces/venue for guests to utilize enhancing
their experience of travel.
BRAND CULTURE
SNOBBY
WHO WE ARE
UNIQUE
VIBRANT
TRENDY
HIP
STYLISH
PRENTENTIOUS
PLAYFUL
SURPRISING
BLASE
EVERYONE ELSE
ORNATE
TECHNOLOGY PROUD
CHIC
AUTHENTIC
AVERAGE
BORING
ELEGANT
STIMULATING
WASTEFUL
MEMORABLE
SHALLOW
CONVENTIONAL
MINIMAL
CREATIVE
FRESH
PERSONALITY
DISTINGUISHED
SOPHISTICATED
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
101
EXHIBIT A
page 4 of 9
102
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
EXHIBIT A
page 5 of 9
10
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
103
EXHIBIT A
page 6 of 9
BRAND ADVERTISING
DISCOVER YOUR ELEMENT
11
BRAND COLLATERAL
DISCOVER YOUR ELEMENT
12
104
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
EXHIBIT A
page 7 of 9
BRAND COLLATERAL
DISCOVER YOUR ELEMENT
13
14
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
105
EXHIBIT A
page 8 of 9
15
16
106
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
EXHIBIT A
page 9 of 9
17
1
8
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
107
EXHIBIT B
page 1 of 3
Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton LLP
70 West Madison Street, 48th Floor
Chicago, Illinois 60602
312.499.6300 main
312.499.6301 fax
www.sheppardmullin.com
MEMORANDUM
To:
From:
Re:
Sarang Peruri
Matthew Kalt
Date:
Michael J. Roth
File Number:
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide certain high level comments on the form of lease
agreement (Lease) provided as part of what we understand is an RFP process from the City of
New Orleans, Louisiana and the New Orleans Building Corporation, with respect to the potential
redevelopment of the World Trade Center New Orleans.
At a general level, we note that the Lease as presented appears to represent a very specific
business deal, and that many of the terms in the agreement do not necessarily relate to the
business deal we understand Oxford is proposing in its response to the RFP. We also
understand that you are proposing the specific terms of the Oxford business deal in separate
documents. Accordingly, we have prepared this memorandum to highlight certain high level
comments we identified in the current draft Lease that will require further discussion. In a few
instances, we have also addressed a related Parking Agreement that was provided in
connection with the RFP, where such document relates to a similar concept in the Lease, and
we note that many of the comments here will likely also apply to similar terms in the Parking
Agreement. Finally, we note that this is not an exhaustive list, and that final comments would
come in the form of a markup that has been revised to reflect an agreed business deal.
Comments
1. When the Lease references review, approval, consent, and related concepts from
the City and Landlord, it does not specify who will provide the same. Is there one point
of contact who will have authority to make decisions? Likewise, if the Lease needs to be
amended or modified, who will have authority to do the same?
2. The definition of Comparable Project is overly broad. As drafted, it would require that
the Project be compared to any similar project located anywhere within the United States
within a rolling five year period. This needs to be revised to reflect a standard measured
in comparison with similar projects in the local market, taking into consideration the
nature of this project and the limitations of the same.
3. The Lease effectively locks the tenant into a development program with little room to
change the program during the design and construction process. As drafted, at lease
execution the number of hotel keys, commercial space and number of apartments would
SMRH:204043746.1
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
109
EXHIBIT B
page 2 of 3
be fixed, subject to change only with Landlord approval. This would potentially not allow
the tenant to make changes dictated by the market.
4. The Lease reflects a requirement that the hotel portion of the project be part of a national
franchise system, and contains many requirements related to being part of a franchise
system. We understand that the Oxford project may involve a boutique hotel brand that
may or may not be a franchise, or potentially could be part of a soft-brand system that
may have lesser requirements than a typical franchised hotel. You will need flexibility in
the Lease to pursue the option that fits into your business plan at the proper time,
including any ability to opt in or opt out of a franchise system throughout the Lease term.
In addition, at one point the Lease appears to try to override the requirements of a
franchisor with respect to franchise standard, which will likely not be acceptable to a
franchisor.
5. We assume this will be a lease term of at least 99 years, but it could be helpful from a
future financing standpoint to build extension options into the Lease. Additionally, an
right of first offer or right of first refusal to purchase the property seems appropriate here
given the expected level of investment in the redevelopment by the tenant.
6. The definition of Gross Revenues in the Lease with respect to parking revenues seems
to double count the parking revenue when taken in conjunction with the market rent to
be paid under the Parking Agreement. As drafted, the City would be receiving a market
rate rent on the parking spaces, plus a percentage of the gross revenues from the
parking spaces. The portion of parking revenues on which gross rent should be charged
should be any additional revenues over the market rate, not the gross revenues.
7. The definition of Luxury Apartments requires more flexibility to permit flexibility as the
Lease term matures. Placing a floor on rents, coupled with an obligation to always have
modern fixtures and equipment, will make this difficult to finance, as it creates an
ongoing obligation to (i) constantly modernize the project over an extended term and (ii)
keep rents artificially inflated and not able to respond to market conditions.
8. The Lease needs to grant the tenant the ability to convert the luxury apartments to a
luxury condominium development at a later date. This may include creating separate
leasehold estates and imposing some form of recorded covenants on the building to deal
with bifurcated ownership.
9. The Lease seems to have some potential conflicts of interest where the City controls the
process for some of the covenants. For example, the Lease contains covenants that the
project will comply with zoning requirements, moratoria and other requirements placed in
effect by the City. This seems to be an area where the City would have a form of veto
power over the project. Likewise, the Lease contains fairly typical condemnation
provisions, except that here, the landlord is the party most likely to the condemning
authority. These conflicts need to be discussed in greater detail.
10. In lieu of specific, required uses at the project, as tenant we would prefer that the Lease
specify what uses are unacceptable, with a mechanism for the parties to resolve any
reasonable objection the City may have to a use not listed as an unacceptable use.
11. The process for review and approval of plans and specifications is overly cumbersome.
As drafted the City would have 30 days to review schematic plans, and once approved,
SMRH:204043746.1
110
-2-
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
EXHIBIT B
page 3 of 3
almost any changes would require further City input. Then, once approved, the tenant
has only 30 days to create final construction drawings. As the design process can be
iterative and take longer than 30 days from schematic design to final construction
drawings, we would prefer to see City approval of a design program, with input from the
City afterwards during the process, and more flexibility in terms of timing and tenants
rights to make changes to the plans, so long as they are consistent with the approved
program.
12. The initial deposit should be refundable to the tenant if the tenant is unable to secure
financing within some limited time period. We also note that the requirement for a
binding financing commitment may be unrealistic, as few, if any, lenders will execute
binding commitments to loan money until the moment of loan closing.
13. The ongoing operations and maintenance requirements give the City tremendous control
over the operations and upkeep of the project. Effectively, if the City wants something
changed or upgraded, it has the power to force the tenant to do so, as the tenant would
face default under the Lease if it failed to comply. We anticipate this level of control and
risk will be difficult for a lender to accept. There needs to be a mechanism for a third
party to decide disputes over the tenants compliance with these subjective covenants.
There should be a similar mechanism related to capital expenditures for the project as
the lease term winds down, as the City could receive a windfall by requiring capital
expenditures near the end of the Lease term.
14. The leasehold finance provisions will likely require input from the eventual financing
source, as our recent experience has shown us that most commercial lenders will have
their own specific requirements from a landlord on these provisions.
15. The sublease provisions purport to give the tenant the ability to sublease to qualified
parties, but the decision as to whether a party is qualified depends on the Citys
subjective determination of whether certain standards have been met. There needs to
be a true concept of an objective standard so that the tenant can manage the project
without seeking constant approval from the City.
16. The Lease restricts the ability of the Tenant to make any transfers of indirect ownership
interests in the tenant without prior notice to the City and City approval, no matter how
small or indirect the transfer may be. We propose modifying this to permit indirect
transfers of non-controlling ownership interests, with a list of prohibited attributes for
transferees (e.g., typical OFAC/Patriot Act restrictions).
17. In the event of a total casualty of the building, or a substantial casualty during some
portion of the term, the tenant needs some ability to terminate the Lease in lieu of
rebuilding the same. In addition, the rent abatement provisions may need to be modified
if restoration of a casualty will exceed the tenants business interruption insurance.
18. The insurance provisions will require further input from insurance advisors as Lease
negotiations continue.
19. The Lease mentions confidentiality of the tenants financial information, but also notes
that disclosure of the information may be subject to applicable laws. As the City is
presumably subject to FOIA laws, would this mean that the tenants and any sublessees
financials are also subject to disclosure under FOIA?
SMRH:204043746.1
Oxford Oxford
Capital Group, LLC
111