Professional Documents
Culture Documents
'I
lv o I tage
norma If'J*
P
1. .
TL
ase Phase
ystem
Systems ProducedProduced
by
MEMBER AIEE
H. A. PETERSON
ASSOCIATE AIEE
P. H. LIGHT
ASSOCIATE AIEE
1.aFor.alnmee
1941, VOL. 60
havre
329
EQUIVALENT
PH ASE POWERTHREESOURCE
00-
Figure 1 (left).
System studied
TRANSMISSION CIRCUIT
i,}tn
TRANSFORMER
BANK
-ln
diagram>No.
2.0
|| |||N
1L
No1
1.6
~~~~~(b) Miniature
(a)
4 1.0
_jjC~C
_rC7~
BANoKr
0
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
30
32
34
Cases Studied
Results
system9 equivalent circuit for figure la, in making calculations and in the miniature on load side.
with
which the
study was made.
The
system
Core type.
Sb thebsine-wave
impedance
generator
is
.
2.1. Shell
type.
oftesn-aegnrtri
1-Miniature system single-phase transformers B w hssoe-ofut
very low relative tothe exciting reactance -135 rms volts normal-1,185 ohms normal B
w hssoe
ofut
Of the unloaded transformer hank and the
mt
impeanc
line capacitive reactances used, so that
adgneilzing mpdneSame as for A.
balanced line-to-line voltages are applied 2-Assumed curve having more saturation than
to the circuit at a'b'c' under all conditions. curve 1. Used in making calculationls to de- II. POWER SOURCE UNGROUNDED
LOAD TRANSFORMERS UNGROUNDED
The syste becomes groundedone withtermine the effect of this factor
balanced line-to-ground voltages when 3-Miniature system three-phase core-type A. One phase open-no fault.
switch SN is closed. Resistance and transformer-158 rms volts line to line normal
reactance are neglected in the transmis- wye-840 ohms per phase normal magnetizing 1. Single-phase load transformers.
sion circuit since they are insignificant
impedance
(a). Delta-connected on line side, wye- or deltarelative to the capacitive reactances fcr 4-Miniature system three-phase shell-type conteonlasi.
the lengths of line under discussion. Cl' transformer- 144 rms volts line to line normal B. Oneconductor open-fault-to-ground
and C0' represent the positive and zero- wye-520 ohms per phase normal magnetizing
on system side of open conductor.
sequence capacitances, respectively, on
impedance
the system side of the fuses or single-pole 5-Miniature system special transformers 110 l. Single-phase load tranlsformers.
switches; C1 and C0, the positive and zero- rms volts normal- 13,200 ohms normal mag- (a). Delta-connected on line side, wye- or deltasequence capacitances of the circuit sup- netizing impedance. Single-phase trans- connected on load side.
plying the ungrounded, unloaded transformers
(b). Wye-connected on line side, delta-connected
former bank on the transformer side,onlasie
which in figurelbis
shown as wye con~~~~~~~(c). Wye-connected on line side, wye-connected on
whlch
lnfigurelb1S
shown
as wye conside.
~~~~~~~~~~~load
nected on the line side and delta con- reproductions to scale of typical power
nected on the load side.
transformers. All saturation curves give C. One conductor open-line-to-ground
To obtain various degrees of saturation the ratio of the applied sinusoidal rms
fault on load side of open conductor.
for the miniature, system transformer voltage to the exciting rms current, with 1. Single-phase transformers.
abanks, it was only necessary to vary the voltage and current expressed in terms of
normal operating voltage level in the normal voltage and normal exciting cur- (a).nelta-onnectdsoiindid,we-oedla
miniature system. In obtaining the re- rent, respectively.
lsults herein summarized, the miniature
impedance~~~~~
3:)0
1. Core type.
2. Shell type.
Throughout the
Voltage Conditions
AIEE TRANSACTIONS
>0
0
-J
ci
3 4~
~
~
~ 4~
~ ~ ~ ~ lll
~~~~c
11 XIlllll1111111
^.bS-F4
zU
H~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Xc1/Xm
Xcl/Xm
Figure22
Ho
'
Cuve2-atrtin ure2,Fiur
Curve 3-No saturation
0-Test points-miniature system with saturation curve 1, figure 2
1. Sigle-Phase Transformers
(a). Delta-Connected onl Line Side,
Wye- or Delta-Connected on Load Side.
The curves of figure 3a give the steady~~~~state maximum peak voltage of the open
conductor on the transformer side of the
opening in terms of normal line-to-neutral ..
Curve 2-Saturation curve 2, figure 2
peak voltage with the transformer bank ..
Curve 3-No saturation
delta-connected on the line side, and 0-..OTest points-miniature system with saturawye- or delta-connected on the load side,
.
.tion curve 1, figure 2
versus Xci/Xm for C0= C1. Curves 1, 2,
0.1
1941, VOL. 60
0.5
1.0
2.0
5.0
Xcl/Xm
10.0
20.0
100
01
0.5
1.0
2.0
xcl/xm
Peterson, Lig;ht
Abnormal Voltage Conditions 3.
Clarke,
5.0
10.0
20.0
100
331
crease and remains negative on both calculated and test curves; but before xc,I/xm
= 1 is reached, two other steady-state
values of voltage are possible as indicated
by the calculated curve. Both are positive. Only one of these other indicated
values was obtained in test, the lower of
the two, until Xc,/Xm was decreased to
about 0.2 but for values of xc,/x,n=0.2
or lower, three different values were obtained by test. Figure 4 shows oscillograms of the voltages and currents for the
three possible stable conditions, any one
of which may occur, depending upon the
phases of the voltages at the instant the
switch is opened. With the switch
opened at random a number of times, the
high negative voltage or the low positive
occurred more often than the medium
positive voltage.
Curve 2 of figure 3a was calculated,
using transformer saturation curve 2 of
figure 2. Curve 3 is for no saturation.
Figure 3b is similar to figure 3a except
2. Three-Phase Transformers
(a). Delta-Connected on the Line Side,
Wye-Connected on the Load Side. Figure
6a gives test values of the voltage-to-
thatC1=2Co. Thevoltagesabovenormal
ground of the open phase for both coretype and shell-type transformers, deltaconnected on the live side anid wve-con-
Figure 4 (left).
Delta -connected
load transformer;
co = C, 1 35 volts
line-to-line,lVxi
x= 0.212
age-Times
nor-
Figure 5. Wyeconnected
load't=
transformer, C.
Cj, 120 volts
X.=0.1 5
C a I i b r a t i o n:
Times normal lineto-neutral crest
voltage
332
Zi
iE
aw
AIEE TRANSACTIONS
z4
12;]
.5
.0
2O
i.C
(0
10
2t0
-42
+z
.-J~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~x-2 o2
3
0.5
1.0
2.0
5.0
Xci/Xm
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~LU-3
100
200
-4.
100
0.5
LO0
2.0
/Xc/
5.0
20.0
10.0
Figure 6a. Steady-state voltages on open phase with one conductor Figure 6b. Steady-state voltages on open phase with one conductor
open; no fault on system; power source grounded; C1 = Co, three- open; no fault on system; power source grounded; C1 = Co; threephase load transformer, connected line delta-load wye, ungrounded phase load transformer connected line wye-load delta, ungrounded
Normal line-line voltage=91 volts for coreNormal line-line voltage=79 volts for coretype, 72 volts for shell-type
type, 83 volts for shell-type
0OCore-type; middle leg opened
x-Shell-type; middle leg unopened
Figure 6c (below). Steady-state voltages on
r-Core-type; end leg opened
open phase with one conductor open; no fault
+-Shell-type; end leg unopened
middle leg opened
x-Shell-type;
on
power
source
grounded;
O-Core-type; middle leg unopened
system;
C=2Co;
+-Shell-type, end leg opened
three-phase load transformer connected line
r1-Core-type; end leg unopened
tin.a hiving
hs
volestales htave poniounc.Thedsuharmonichvtan ther
thaepror
coulcednotubehpreictd"byd etor
oused Howbevprer, thedctheydvolages
but littlemethig
than thed.Howev
the calculated voltagesotof ce 1,gh
1,
line-line
Normal
voltage = 79 volts
for core-type
O-Core-type; mid-
rn-Coretpene
le pndw
end
J-1
0
-401
05
...
as
figure 3a.
obtained for values of Xci/Xm in the vicinity of 1 and below. The voltages of
curve
side~
an.et-once
~~
~~~A
voltage condiltions were
Only
two ~
stable
L.
2.0
100
5.0
xcl/xm
100
200
x8'I/x,l
x,'I/x,l
are indicated.
for various values of
The voltages are independent of
B.
ONE CONDUCTOR
x,l'.
OPEN-FAULT-TO-
DU
ORSGL-AE
TRANSFORMERS
~~~~~~~~Connected
1941, VOL. 60
333
..1
I..
0I
an
4
Z
02
in
-4t
0.1
0.2
OA
XC1/Xm
2.0-- 4.0
6.0
aL0
10
Figure
Figure 8 (right).
Wye-connectedload
transformer; Co=
Cl, X.,/X. = 0.89.
Phases b and c open
Calibrations: Current-Times normal
crest transformer excurrent.
citing
Voltlge-Times norcres vletagneuta
delta load
C.
334
0.2,
x(,+C,')/x,x
approximately. This elimination refers
only to the steady-state condition, however. In many cases, long transient con-
AIEE TRANSACTIONS
ungrounded
I=
=
where
27rfCl kv2103
10/6 (2fC )(
kv2
kva =
transformer bank
rated kilovolt-amperes
bank
transformer
27rfCi Micromhos
Per Mile
230-115 .....
5.2
.s..s.
.......69-34
6934.51.5 .........8.
siean1yecnece.o.oa.ie.45-386
Below 13.8 .6.5
Lii~~~~ttl,-~
191
O.6
the
No-3
cc
of
I335
_S,ag Cnitin
Figure 11. Isolated-neutral-system steadystate voltages on open phase with one conductor open. Fault to ground on load side of
open conductor curves calculated using saturation curve I of figure 2
xco'/xcou=
'
x
0
+ XCO,/XCO= 0o 1
A-xc'/x,O= 1 0
-xC0'/xC0=
10.0
ages. See figure 11. Therefore, in addition to imposing the criterion of xc,Ixm_
25.0, restrictions must also be imposed on
the ratio of Xco'/Xm.
From figure 11, the ratio of X(co+co')/xm
should be less than approximately 0.04 or
greater than a value varying from 4.7 to
open phase to
xn,,,/x,.
Xci/xm
ductors open
= 6
= 3.5 per cent rms average
current
NOTE: Allowable length of line varies directly with rms average exciting current
4-
NOT N INT11
0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.
>fl
0
4~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i1.
1Co
90~ ~ ~ ~ 11 Nill + I I~~~~~~~~~~~~~x
V-
BUT
exciting
II
III
-1 i l-I[
ININT TRNFRERBNRATIN
goo
U.
iii _JOfli
Ovrha
005
0.1
IneeuvnIae
FigtuImo
lineprml
.Overhead
t-
7--
12w
.00
0.5 1t0
20
10
ulipyby135201~
_ /
Z
XLA I11
11)
npstv-TTLTASOMRKAO
LOAD
IVO
_*_-
060
0,
OPNCNDCO
SIDEVO
Isoae
eta ytmapoi
so sse
TRIII
egtv-euec
apacitace-
oqe Iseqalt ta
FIgr14
at ageo0quvln ln entsonsse
For
it s o 136KV-,,
ol
I
I
o'lgroude sstm by goning=
thIeurl
slow down and stop. They will then re- which may cause voltages greater than V/3
open
verse their direction of rotation if the
witrh one
negative sequence torque is great enough
I
to overcome the positive sequence torque Xco'/Xm must be greater than 40.0 or less than
arrZsters
tance the appllcalon of ll.h0ng
, . .
0 04
and provide the torque required to start
the motors from rest. With a motor run- Im =3.5 per cent rms average exciting current
ning, the positive sequence torque is NOTE: Allowable length of line varies directly with rms average exciting current
greater than the negative for equal pOSlNOTE: This criterion alone is not sufficient
tie .n ngatv squec votge.A
stadstill these torques are equal for for elimination of overvoltages. The criterion
of figure 12 must be met also. Maximum perequal voltages.
The conditions under which loaded missible miles of line in figure 12 should be
timegsInornmal
colnducto landaid
blown fuse can sometimes cause over- motorswillreversetheirdirection of rota- divided by 4.0 for the isolated-neutral system
overvoltages possible.
The effect of load on the transformers is to
1941, VOL. 60
Conclusions
1. In athree-phase power system, high susresult
in or
some
~~~from
openingmay
of one
twocases
conductors
tamnedthevoltages
which separates ungrounded transformers
from the rest of the system.
2. The transformer connections (wye or
delta) and construction (single-phase, or
337
break and ungrounded transformers supplying the load is greater than that given by
equation 1. Figure 12 can be used directly
when the rms exciting current is 3.5 per cent.
7. The highest voltages appear in an ungrounded system with the simultaneous
occurrence of an open conductor and line-toground fault, such as might correspond to
the breaking and falling to ground of a line
conductor.
8. From the standpoint of open conductors
without faults, the criterion given in conclusion 6 is always conservative for ungrounded systems. However, if the criteria
are to include the effects of permanent
faults, then it is necessary to impose two
approximate requirements, namely, xcl/Xm
must be greater than 25.0, and Xco/xm must
be either less than 0.04 or greater than 40.0.
Figures 12 and 14 can be used when the
rms exciting current is 3.5 per cent.
.
.
9. The voltages arising from open conductors can be calculated with reasonable
accuracy by consideration only of the fundamental-frequency components of voltage
and current as outlined in the appendix.
Appendix
Analytic Determination of the Sustaned Voltage to Ground on Open
Conductors in a Circuit Supplying
an Unloaded Transformer Bank
Using figurcs lb, the following additional
assumptions will be made:
1. The sustailned voltages to be determined
are substantially sinusoidal voltages of
fudmna frqeny
fundamental frequency.
Tr= -C/-j
V/2; VC=-/2j V3/2 (2)
Let
Va=voltage to ground of phase a on transformer side of opening in per unit of normal line-to-neutral voltage
V =voltage to ground of neutral of wyeconnected transformer bank in per ulnit
of normal line-to-neutral voltage
Xm =per unit effective transformer exciting
reactance of any winding at normal voltage, either wye or delta-connected
338
ground
It = current flowing from transformer bank
terminal a
xt = effective exciting reactance of the transformer bank to It
With delta-connected primary windings
and secondary windings either wye- or deltaconnected,
(3)
xt = 3xa0/2
Ia
Va
(Xco/Xci) (XcolXci 1) I
[-[(1[(xci/xab)
xclxcl) -x)
+2xlo/x1) -(2xl/xab) (Xco/xcl) ]
-
=_ 1 (11
V_ 1
-
j.
ab2 -/
(10)
3p
h
obanagahot0vessXiX,we
obtain a graph of Va versus X,,i/x., when the
ratio of x,o/x,l is known.
1. Calculate Va
xCl/xab from (10).
indiAting chlby
z/3
..
~~~~~~~~~delta,
j(It/2+IA)xbj(1t-1A)xa = j10[(9/2)Xaxb .
.t.Xt= (9/2)XaXi/(Xa+2Xh)
(xa+2xb)]
(5)
ATEE TRANSACTIONS
Va
(3Xci/xm) (x,o/Xl1) + (2xa/xm+
/(1
\
'1
/ 8
-XCO/cl)
Xb/ Xm)
6(Xci/xr)(x,,/Ix,)
(12)
IVIVNb 12-3/4
VaN/(xa/xm) =
(13)
______
A V |3/4
12
(14)
real-
VaN
(15)
no
snle
point.
g
P
References
Vt, VG
3. INVERSION
436.
4. MAIHEMATICAI, ANALYSIS OF NONLINEAR CIRCUITS-PART 1, A. Boyajian. General Electric Review, September 1931, page 531. Part II, General
Electric Rcview, December 1931, page 752.
5. ELEETRISCEE SCHALTVORGANGE (a book),
Vba =- Va- Vb | - 1- Vb times R. Riidenberg. Third edition.
6. Talk by F. A. Hamilton, Jr., at a meeting of the
gvntransformer saturation curve, obtain
AIEE Toronto Section reported in Electrical News
(9
givxn co pod
t
VNbl
'normal line-to-line voltage ( a9)nad Engineering, November 1, 1937.
7. EXPERIENCES WITH
Y19)intea of(10 a
(1),
2. Calculate the real part of VNVb from (13).
UigUsig
(18)(8)nd (1)
(1)
(11), CONNECTBED POTENTIAL GROUNDED-NiEUTRAL,
TRANSFORMERS ON UNrespectively,
the procedure for determining GROUNDED SYSTEMS, C. T. Weller. AIEE TRANS3. Obtain the ratio VaN!(Xa/Xm) from a graph of Vb or V, versus xCl/xm for a given ACTIONS, March 1931, page 299.
given tratisformer
(14),
(14),and from the given
transformer satu- ratio xC0/x,j is analogous to that for one 8. LEITSATZE FUR DEN SCHUTZ ELEKTRISCHER
ration curve find values of VaNl and (xa .
open conductor.
ANLAGEN GEGEN UBERSPANNUNGEN, VDE, 0145/
xm) which are in this ratio. The sign of VaN
Wye-Connected Primary Windings. Sec- 1933, page 242.
is the same as that of the real part of V_vbondary Windings (b) Wye-Connected, (c) 9. AN ELECTRIC CIRCUIT TRANSIENT ANALYZER,
Delta-Connected. The procedure for obtain- H. A. Peterson. General Electric Review, Septem4. Calculate Va from (15).
a graph of V0 or V, versus Xcil/Xm for a
5. Knowing Va, calculate xci/xm from the ing
known ratio, xco/x, is analogous
to that 10. SUBDARMONICS IN CIRCUITS CONTAINING
sdfroeoe
odutr xetteei
IRON-CORED REACTORS, Irven Travis and C. N.
impici
eqatin (2),after replacing xco/xci
used
for
one
open conductor, except there (S Weygandt. AIEE TRANSACTIONS, 1938 (August
by its given value.
no quadrature component of voltage in
section).
(c). Wye-connected primary and delta- VNb, and equation (17) is used instead of 11. ANALYSIS OF SERIES CAPACITOR APPLiCATION
connected secondary windings. This case
(7).
PROBLEMS, J. W. Butler and C. Concordia. ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING (AIEE TRANSACTIONS), Audiffers from the preceding in that xt = (9/2) X
gust 1937.
II. POWER SOURCE UNGROUNDED
XaXb/(Xa+2Xb) and
12. EQUIVALENT CIRCUITS OF TRANSFORMERS AND
If the capacitance to ground of the power REACTORS TO SWITCHIsNG SURGES, L. V. Bewley.
VaN = 2 VNb real
(16)
AIEE TRANSACTIONS, volume 58, 1939, pages 797source with ungrounded neutral is large relaThe procedure to determine a graph of Va tive to that of the transmission circuit and 802.
versus xil/xm is similar to that of case (b) bank, the power source can be considered to 13. PROTECTOR TUBES FOR POWER SYSTEMS, H.
except that (16) is used to determine VaN,
have its neutral effectively grounded. R. LUdWig. AIEJE TRAgSACTIONS, volume 59, 1940
and xa/xm corresponding to VaeN is obtained Case II then becomes case I. When this is (May section).
(Xco IXe 1
1)
an
339