You are on page 1of 15

1

The Cabinetmakers Compromise:


A Commode and the Changing Aesthetic of French Canada

Kyle Johnson

The increased settlement of New France as a


fur-trading
colony in the late 17th century led to
the subsequent development and expansion of the regions interior. As towns and cities grew, so did
1

their capital, creating a class of wealthy merchants apart from the well-to-do officers and officials. This
was most evident in Montreal, as it was the westernmost point accessible by ocean-going ships at the
convergence of the St. Lawrence and Ottawa rivers, thus controlling the passages to the Great Lakes
2

and the interior fur-trading regions. In Montreal, tertiary sectors of the f


ur trading
economy grew to
accommodate new inhabitants, transforming the small town into the economic hub for the French
fur
trading
industry. During this time, population growth in the colony was steady, but in Montreal it
appeared more accelerated, ranging from a few hundred in the later part of the 17th century to
3

approximately 7,500 in 1760. With these new inhabitants in all socio-economic classes came a rising
demand for domestic industries in providing shelter and furnishings. It was these patrons of
woodworkers, carpenters, and cabinetmakers that would dictate the styles of French Canadas
decorative arts, leaving behind beautifully carved and decorated pieces of vernacular furniture.
August 11th, 2012 was a pristine day for an auction in Marlborough, Massachusetts. Skinner,
Inc. was holding their annual August Americana sale at their newly acquired Marlborough location. A
multitude of stunning pieces of American decorative arts and furnishings were up for sale, including a
Dunlap-school chest, a J.W. Fiske butterfly weathervane, a carved Hadley chest, and even a one-room
summerhouse. However, none was more exciting than the top grossing lot of the day, a French
Canadian butternut bombe commode, hammering at $65,000 (fig. 1). This was a piece that garnered

Holmes, Janet, Royal Ontario Museum: Canadiana Department,


Material Culture Review 1
1 (1980).
Webster, Donald Blake,
Rococo to Rustique: Early French-Canadian Furniture in the Royal Ontario Museum
(Toronto:
Royal Ontario Museum, 2000), 4.
3
echne
D
, Louise,
Habitants and Merchants in Seventeenth-Century Montreal
(Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press,
1992), 7.
1

much attention from dealers and collectors alike due to its rare form, old surface, and finely executed
carvings. To put it simply, this piece was astonishing.
This essay will consider the implications of changing aesthetics, fashions, and demographics
within a developing French Canada on domestic furniture design. The bombe commode detailed
above, considered a masterpiece by Canadian collectors, will be attributed to a school of carvers by
examining the stylistic motifs they employed. The significance of
this piece as the perfect
representation of the transitional period of styles in French Canada and possibly the best example of
vernacular furniture produced in Montreal warrants this further research.
This analysis will be based
on carved Rococo friezes and the artisans underlying symbolism, understanding of lines and
proportion, and comparable documented examples. While it is unfortunate that construction details
cannot be ascertained as the commode had been sold and transported by the time of my employment
at Skinner, the aesthetic merits of this piece are strong enough and so unique that the attribution is
unmistakable.
Eighteenth and nineteenth century French Canadian furniture is not synonymous with
conventionalism in form or ornamentation. It is as varied, if not more so, than French and
Anglo-American pieces of the same era. This is in part thanks to the lack of an existing guild system or
4

trade association like those employed throughout England and France. Similar to their southern
neighbors
, French Canada was a melting pot of cultures and ideas, with major design influences taken
from France, Poland, Germany, Ukraine, America, and England. Despite the cessation of New France
to the British in 1763, French Canadian woodworkers and cabinetmakers adhered to a general
aesthetic
influenced heavily by simplified French design through the eighteenth and into the nineteenth

Palardy, Jean,
The Early Furniture of French Canada
(Toronto: Macmillan of Canada, 1965), 12.

centuries. The influence of the Louis XV style, introduced through increased contact with France in
the mid-18th century from colonial wars, was perpetuated in varying degrees through the early 19th
6

century. This was due, in part, to the continued demands of a French majority in the form of
merchants, officials, habitants, and seigneurs; with their Provincial tastes perpetuated by their relative
conservatism.
The second half of the 18th century saw Rococo motifs permeate French and English
decorative arts. While Baroque design continued to be utilized, especially in the era of Thomas
7

Chippendale, there grew a greater emphasis on fantasy, mythology, and nature. This was manifested
in furniture design by the utilization of asymmetrical motifs such as C and S-scrolls, foliate devices,
shell carvings, and other surface ornamentation synonymous with the grotto and the French rocaille
8

style. It was not until 1780 and later that English styles gained notoriety throughout Quebec. The
arrival of English and Scottish immigrants coupled with the estimated 6,600 Loyalists fleeing
post-Revolutionary War America to Quebec allowed for significant growth in demand for the
10

Georgian styles these foreigners had been accustomed to. The influx of these new patrons and styles
expedited the decrease in popularity of French furniture design that began to take hold subsequent to
the Seven Years War.
The commode in question exhibits predominantly French features laced with French Canadian
ingenuity and design. The
bombe-form
commode traces its origins in Continental Europe. The swelled
body can be seen in early Dutch, Italian, German, and French examples; the French being the

ain, Howard, The Heritage of Country Furniture (Toronto: Van Nostrand Reinhold Ltd., 1978), 489.
P
Webster,
Rococo to Rustique
, 9.
7
Prown, Jonathan, and Richard Miller, The Rococo, the Grotto, and the Philadelphia High Chest, A
merican Furniture
(1996), 108.
8
Boger, Louise Ade,
The Complete Guide to Furniture Styles
(New York: Scribner, 1969), 126.
9
Palardy,
Early Furniture of French Canada
, 28.
10
Jasanoff, Maya,
Libertys Exiles: American Loyalists in the Revolutionary World
(New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2011), 357.
5

prototype of our pice de rsistance. At first glance, this commode appears to be a Louis XV commode
of classic form, however, the discriminating eye sees an altogether different object. The piece exhibits a
molded
square top with ovolo corners on a
bombe
-form three-drawer case; the sides with recessed
panels, the apron and knees with heavily carved rococo motifs, all terminating on carved claw-and-ball
feet and casters.
Upon further inspection, there are some apparent peculiarities that stray from traditional
French and even French Canadian
bombe
chests. Generally, commodes of French Canadian origin
have
paneled
or reeded stiles, as opposed to this atypical example, displaying elaborate carvings. In
typical examples of Louis XV commodes, this carving, generally confined to the apron, would be
replaced with elaborate and opulent ormolu mounts depicting cyma scrolls, foliate devices, and masks
of classical figures and caryatids. When looking at the piece in question, one can see where, stylistically,
English or American design has influenced the form and function. This is apparent when discussing its
proportion and analyzing the claw-and-ball feet and its rococo carvings, most notably the cabochons
applied to the swelled stiles.
The treatment of the feet is considerably unusual, especially by French Canadian standards. To
start, the carved claw-and-ball feet are unlike most carved feet being produced in the region in the late
18th century. While French Canadian style is replete with a wide variety of claw-and-ball feet, these
particular feet are reminiscent of those found on American and Georgian tilt-top tea tables. I believe
the foot of our example to be the interpretation of contemporary design by our French Canadian
woodworker for a patron familiar with styles in vogue overseas and in the
Colonies
.
In examples on American and Georgian chests, claw-and-ball feet tend to terminate from
cabriole legs and are quite articulated, showing distinctive talons and claws grasping a ball. Here, the leg

is a continuation of the
bombe
profile outward from the case and leading directly into the foot.
Although the foot seems more primitive than its contemporaries, it shows the work of a skilled
maker
willing to compromise, incorporating new designs into existing forms successfully. Many examples of
this form in late 18th century France exhibit squat down-swept legs and feet. We notice the long,
slender, unarticulated claw extending outward, playing into the relative narrowness of the case,
exaggerating and accentuating the swell considerably (fig. 2).
One can see that this piece exhibits greater focus on proportion as it is diminutive in size
relative to its contemporaries; standing thirty and one-quarter inches high, thirty-one inches wide, and
twenty-one inches deep. The majority of examples observed exhibit greater proportions in a truer
French form, with widths ranging up to forty and even fifty inches.11 Jean Palardy, author of
The Early

Furniture of French Canada


,
considers commodes and chests of this diminutive size as not French,
alluding to a more size conscious consumer, familiar with English and American design. While the
bombe form
does make an appearance in a few American and English
cabinet
making centers, never is
it more
utilized
than by Continental furniture makers, notably the French. Here, the execution of the
bombe form, with its proportion and profile, clearly
indicates the work of an individual familiar with
Canadian character and a muted Louis XV style.
The complexity and ambition of the carving denotes the work of a master. At this time there
were only a handful of individuals, mainly working within the Montreal and Quebec areas that were
skilled enough to complete such work. The eye is immediately attracted to the stiles by the bold
asymmetry of the carved, projecting cabochons, an object we commonly find utilized in Philadelphia
high chest cartouches (fig. 3). This motif makes a statement; not only is this commode a seamless and

11

Palardy,
Early Furniture of French Canada
, 305.

beautiful melding of styles, but the carver is fully capable of understanding Rococo design on a deeper
level. It is this cabochon that exhibits the artisans spirit of creativity, expression, curiosity, and
defiance, key ideals encouraged within the Rococo movement and decorative arts. The cabochon,
resting on its stylized foliate base bordered by expertly carved C-scrolls, tapering to a vine, makes the
perfect segue into another quintessentially Rococo carved frieze. It is here that the carver displays his
prowess and embraces the fundamental Rococo spirit by creating a truly unique scene. The front
12

apron of the commode is evocative of moving water, a familiar theme to Rococo design. The
scratch-carved accents, the scrolled crosiers along the base of the apron, and the curvatures of the
applied S-scrolls are reminiscent of the chaos of waves. These decorative forms accentuate the relative
aesthetic organization and symmetry of the bombe case. These carvings are the unrestrained expression
of natural freedom and the embodiment of French rocaille design. Here the artisan proves their worth
by effectively and commandingly expressing himself in the mastery of his carving while adhering to
guidelines most likely delineated by the patron.
With its inclusion of American and English style devices while not being overtly influenced by
either, this piece can be safely dated to the late 18th century, within a ten year period around 1790. This
conclusion is reached by an analysis of the carvings and their stylistic inclusions. The symbiotic
relationship between the French form and rocaille and Anglo motifs denotes the period prior to the
substantial use of English carvings and design in Montreal furniture. Palardy estimates that four-fifths
of all furniture dating from the early colonial days through the 18th century has been lost due to fires
13

and vandalism. While examples of this rare form still exist, we must also examine armoires, buffets,
and church altars and console tables to attain a complete understanding of the carvers contemporary

12
13

Prown and Miller, Rococo, 111.


Palardy,
Early Furniture of French Canada
, 27.

with this commodes artisan. Through the analysis of the carvers comprehensive knowledge and skill
of carving rococo and rocaille motifs, as well as the utilization of unique devices, we are able to narrow
down the possibilities of carvers responsible for the creation of such an astounding piece.
"The cessation of Canada to the British in 1763 brought to an end the war which had darkened
the lives of Canadians for seven years, and with peace came an unprecedented prosperity. The last 35
years of the eighteenth century and the first two decades of the nineteenth saw a resurgence of
14

imagination and skill in French Canadian crafts beyond anything known before.
The rate and
quality of objects being produced in the Montreal area during this span is unparalleled in Canada.
Montreal, the urban center of this creative resurgence, is where this search is focused, landing squarely
on the Quevillon School of carvers.
This school, centered around the work of Louis Quevillon, comprised of numerous masters
throughout its existence. We see the likes of Joseph Pepin, Amable Charron, and Urbain Desrochers,
all masters in their own right, with documented associations working for and with Quevillon. Prior to
this, Quevillons humble beginnings led him to shingle roofs and carve window frames and furniture.
He eventually rose to prominence around 1790 as a woodworker, receiving commissions to decorate
churches in and around Montreal, carving elaborate altar tables, pulpits, console tables, and
tabernacles. It was through his later works that he was able to hire an extensive team of apprentices, as
15

many as fifteen at one point, creating an assembly line of specialized labor


.
A few outstanding examples, attributed to the Quevillon School in Palardys
The Early

Furniture of French Canada,


exhibit telltale signs of the work of this carver. A console table, dating to
the early 19th century, and two commodes, of late 18th or early 19th century origin, share many of the
McLean, Eric, Early French Canadian Furniture, A
ntiques
, July, 1967, 75.
Louis Quevillon, Dictionary of Canadian Biography, accessed September 10, 2014,
http://www.biographi.ca/en/bio/quevillon_louis_6E.html
.

14
15

unique stylistic qualities our commode displays. The two commodes detailed above have very similar
carved aprons, showing a plethora of French rocaille and rococo elements. But within these carvings, an
unusual decoration is used; flanking the C-scrolls is a very stylized kelp motif (fig. 4). Throughout
Palardys study, we see that Quevillons work incorporates this design in varying degrees. Pieces of 19th
century origin display a bolder variant of this motif, keeping the carved kelp in high relief, while earlier
versions, like the piece in question, showcase a softer, more subtle carving. Another motif synonymous
with the work of Quevillon are articulated crosier terminals of S and C-scrolls. It is this minute detail,
often overlooked, that is indicative of the quality work from this shop seen in our piece.
Through the examination of a console table, a later example of the Quevillon Schools work
documented in Palardys book and dated to the 19th century, it is undeniable that both pieces are of
the same hand (fig. 5). The inclusion of the kelp motif, the execution of the C and S-scrolls, and the
scratch carvings simulating moving water make a compelling case for this attribution. This, coupled
with the claw-and-ball feet and vine-carved knees, characteristics not unique but fairly uncommon in
Montreal woodworking, make for appropriate support evidence. We can make two estimations as to
the purpose of the carving inconsistencies regarding the claw-and-ball feet between the pieces. Had the
commode been carved with an articulated claw, the continuity of the swell of the bombe case would be
compromised, creating a less cohesive and awkward piece of furniture. Alternatively, a progression over
the course of the carvers career through increased exposure and practice may have led to the level of
refinement exhibited by the feet of the console table.
In the summer of 2012, a French Canadian butternut commode, a masterpiece in its own right,
was revealed to the world after having sat in relative obscurity as a television stand on Marthas

10

16

Vineyard. This piece was more than just a commode of Louis XV derivation from late 18th century
Montreal. It was the epitome of design within an evolving province, grappling with a French past and
English future. The use of the French bombe form and rocaille carvings coupled with the inclusion of
notably English and American rococo motifs are seamless incorporations into a coherent expression of
the changing times and fashions. Not only does this commode signify the apex of furniture-making
during this transitional period, but it represents a microcosm of French Canadian society successfully
coping with the changing demographics of a post French-colonial world.

Auction Highlights: A Rare French Canadian Chest of Drawers, Skinner, Inc., accessed September 5, 2014,

http://www.skinnerinc.com/news/blog/canadian-furniture-antique-chest-of-drawers/
.
16

11

Figure 1: French Canadian butternut bombe commode sold at Skinner, Inc. on August 12, 2012 with a
hammer price of $65,000. Source: Skinner, Inc.,
https://www.skinnerinc.com/auctions/2608M/lots/1032

(accessed September 20, 2014).

Figure 2: Detail of the rocaille-carved apron and ball-and-claw feet. Source:


http://www.pinterest.com/pin/296604325432916115/
(accessed September 20th 2014).

12

Figure 3: Detail of the commodes cabochon and a Philadelphia high chests cabochon. Sources: Skinner, Inc.,
https://www.skinnerinc.com/auctions/2608M/lots/1032
and Fine Art and Antiques,
http://www.antiquesandfineart.com/articles/article.cfm?request=948
(accessed September 20, 2014).

Figure 4: Detail of two Quevillon school commode aprons depicting similar, carved motifs as our example. Of
note, the articulation and detail of the C-scrolls and the fineness of the foliage adorning the legs. Source: The
Early Furniture of French Canada. Toronto: Macmillan of Canada, 1965. Plates 504 and 503, respectively.

13

Figure 5: Quevillon school console table with identical carvings as Skinners commode, notably an almost
identical treatment of the side skirts and inclusion of numerous scratch-carved curves . Source: The Early
Furniture of French Canada. Toronto: Macmillan of Canada, 1965. Plate 440.

14

Bibliography

Auction Highlights: A Rare French Canadian Chest of Drawers. Skinner, Inc. Accessed September 5, 2014.
http://www.skinnerinc.com/news/blog/canadian-furniture-antique-chest-of-drawers/
.

Boger, Louise Ade.


The Complete Guide to Furniture Styles
. New York: Scribner, 1969.

Dechne, Louise. Habitants and Merchants in Seventeenth-Century Montreal


. Montreal: McGill-Queen's
University Press, 1992.

Holmes, Janet. "Royal Ontario Museum: Canadiana Department."


Material Culture Review
11 (1980).

Jasanoff, Maya.
Liberty's Exiles: American Loyalists in the Revolutionary World
. New York: Alfred A. Knopf,
2011.

Louis Quevillon. Dictionary of Canadian Biography. Accessed September 10, 2014.


http://www.biographi.ca/en/bio/quevillon_louis_6E.html
.

McLean, Eric. "Early French Canadian Furniture."


Antiques
, July, 1967, 72-77.

Pain, Howard.
The Heritage of Country Furniture
. Toronto: Van Nostrand Reinhold Ltd., 1978.

Palardy, Jean.
The Early Furniture of French Canada
. Toronto: Macmillan of Canada, 1965.

15

Prown, Jonathan, and Richard Miller. "The Rococo, the Grotto, and the Philadelphia High Chest."

American Furniture
, 1996.

Webster, Donald Blake.


Rococo to Rustique: Early French-Canadian Furniture in the Royal Ontario

Museum
. Toronto: Royal Ontario Museum, 2000.

You might also like