Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2
Section 2: Effect of Errors (Basic). Use the balance sheet and income statement for Walgreens
(year ended August 31, 2013). DO NOT use information from any other statements. The following
events, which occurred during the year ended August 31, 2013, were accidentally not recorded. No
adjusting entries relating to these transactions were recorded either. Treat each question
independently, and ignore income tax effects. All numbers are in millions (as are the numbers in the
financial statements).
a. In January 2013, Walgreens paid $5 cash to its suppliers, in order to settle some of its accounts
payables.
b. During March 2013 Walgreens purchased land worth $10. Walgreens paid $2 in cash and took
out a loan for the remaining amount. Assume that the entire loan is non-current.
c. On June 1, 2013, Walgreens paid $12 for insurance. The policy covers the period June 1, 2013
to May 31, 2014.
d.
In June 2013, Walgreens issued (i.e., sold) $20 in common stock for cash.
e. Total credit sales on July 4, 2013 were $22. The cost of the inventory sold was $18.
f. In August 2013, Walgreens declared (but did not pay) a $354 dividend on its common stock.
The payment will be made in September 2013.
g. For the month of August 2013, there were electric utility bills of $2, which were not paid until
September 2013.
h. During August 2013, $1 was received from an insurance company as payment for prescriptions
which would not be filled (and thus recorded as revenues) until September 2013.
For each part (a-h) answer the following questions. If the appropriate adjustment were made to
correct for the omission, what would be
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
3
Section 3: Effect of Errors (Advanced). Use the balance sheet and income statement for America
Online (year ended June 30, 1996), which are included in the AOL (B) case (DO NOT use
information from any other statement). The following events, which occurred during the year ended
June 30, 1996, were recorded incorrectly. Treat each question independently, and ignore income tax
effects. All numbers are in thousands (as are the numbers in the financial statements).
a. In June, 1995, AOL correctly accrued for wages earned during fiscal 1995, but not to be paid
until July 1995. In July, 1995, AOL paid these wages (totaling $5,000) but recorded them using the
following entry:
Wage Expense (+E, -SE)
5,000
Cash (-A)
5,000
b. In December 1995, AOL collected $500 in cash on trade accounts receivable relating to sales
previously made (and correctly recorded). AOL recorded this cash receipt as:
Cash (+A)
500
Revenue (+R, +SE)
500
c. On January 1, 1996, AOL spent $4,000 cash to purchase certain license rights. These rights
have a useful life of 2 years (24 months) and no value at the end of that period. AOLs policy is to
capitalize these costs and spread them evenly over the useful life; however, AOL accidentally
expensed these costs immediately.
d. Cash subscription fees totally $800 were received on April 1, 1996, for services to be provided
between April 1, 1996 and March 31, 1997. All $800 were recorded as revenue on April 1, 1996.
Assume the all costs were recorded correctly.
e. AOL was engaged during fiscal 1996 for a two-year consulting project. Total fees were agreed
to be $10, all of which would be paid in fiscal 1997. Total costs were expected to be (and were) $6,
half paid in 1996 and half in 1997. Assume that all costs were for cash. In 1996, AOL recorded this
project using the percentage of completion method, even though corporate policy was to use the
completed contract method for such projects.
For each part (a-e) answer the following questions. If the appropriate adjustment were made to
correct for the error, what would be
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
4
Section 4: Alternate Accounting. We did (or will do) two of these problems in class (AOL and
Microsoft). In both of these examples, the firm is using accrual accounting to separate the effect of
cash flows and income. The problem is then to undo this accrual in order to restate the financial
statements as if the firm had never used this method. As we saw in the two key slides from Notes 4
and Notes 5, there are only 4 possibilities here:
1.
2.
3.
4.
In each of these cases the careful way to do it is to follow the three steps first laid out in Notes 4
(slide 15): prepare the journal entries under each method; solve for any missing data; determine the
effect of the difference.
Roughly speaking, what we end up doing in each case is:
1) adjusting the I/S by the change in the balance sheet accrual account and
2) adjusting the balance sheet by the cumulative amount in the balance sheet account.
a. Refer to the 2013 Walgreens balance sheet and income statement. From footnote 16, we can see
that the accrued expenses and other liabilities line on the balance sheet includes $928 and $772 in
accrued salaries for August 31, 2013 and August 31, 2012, respectively. These represent salaries
already earned by employees at those dates (and therefore expensed) but not yet paid by Walgreens.
If Walgreens had always used cash basis accounting for salaries, what would their 2013 net income
have been? Here, cash basis accounting means that the expense would be recorded when cash was
actually paid, regardless of when the work is performed.
If you cant solve the problem as given, try adding the additional assumption that Walgreens paid
$772 in 2013 for salaries earned in 2012 and that they paid $928 in 2014 for salaries earned in 2013.
This assumption is reasonable, but it is NOT necessary.
b. Refer to the AOL financial statements for the year ended June 30, 1996 (included in the course
packet with the AOL case). Assume that prepaid expenses and other current assets refers to
entirely to prepaid rent. If AOL had always used a cash basis for its rent expense (i.e., if AOL
simply expensed rent when paid, rather than when incurred), what would have been their 1996 net
income? What would have been their total assets, total liabilities and total shareholders equity at
the end of 1996?
c. Refer to the 2013 Walgreens balance sheet and income statement. Walgreens records revenue for
prescription sales at the time of sale, even though cash is received later. If Walgreens had always
used a cash basis for recording such revenue (i.e., if they recorded revenue only when cash was
actually received), what would have been their net income for the year ended August 31, 2013, and
their total assets, total liabilities, and total shareholders equity at the end of 2013? Assume, in
violation of the matching principle, that the cost of goods sold was still recorded at the time of sale,
and assume that there are no write-offs for uncollectible accounts. You should be able to do the
problem without referring to problem a) from section 1.
ACCT 5011 Financial Accounting
Cash (+A)
Y
A/R (-A)
When cash is collected
We want to solve for Y, and since Cash wont be much help, we will analyze Accounts Receivable.
BB
Sales
EB
Collections
We want to solve for X, and since Cash wont be much help, we will analyze Prepaid Rent.
BB
Pymt
EB
Expense
6
c. The journal entries for PE (Property & equipment) look like:
Property and Equipment (+A)
Cash (-A)
When PPE is purchased
X
X
Y
Y
There is no sales entry as none was sold. We want to solve for Y, and since Cash wont be much
help, we will analyze Property and Equipment. Note that this account is reported net, i.e., net of
accumulated depreciation.
BB
Purch
EB
Depreciation
We want to solve for Y, and since Cash wont be much help, we will analyze Dividends Payable.
Paid
BB
Declared
EB
5
5
Assets decrease by 5:
35481 5 =
Current Liabilities decrease by 5:
8883 5 =
Shareholders Equity is not changed: 19454 =
Net Earnings are not changed:
2450 =
b.
Land (+A)
Cash (-A)
Mortgage (+L)
2450
2
8
3
9
Cash (+A)
Common Stock (+SE)
35489
8883
19454
2450
19454
10
35476
8878
35481 3 =
8883 =
19454 3 =
2450 3 =
35478
8883
19451
2447
20
20
35481 + 20 =
8883 =
19454 + 20 =
2450 =
35501
8883
19474
2450
8
e.
22
22
18
18
g.
282
282
35481 =
8883 + 354 =
19454 354 =
2450 =
Cash (+A)
Deferred Revenue (+L)
Assets increase by 1:
Current Liabilities increase by 1:
Shareholders Equity is not changed:
Net Earnings are not changed:
35481
9237
19100
2450
35485
8883
19458
2454
35481 =
8883 + 2 =
19454 2 =
2450 2 =
35481
8885
19452
2448
1
1
35481 + 1 =
8883 + 1 =
19454 =
2450 =
35482
8884
19454
2450
Cash (+A)
Revenue (+R, +SE)
Cash (+A)
Accounts Receivable (-A)
Revenue (-R, -SE)
Accounts Receivable (-A)
5,000
5,000
5,000
5,000
5,000
5,000
958754 =
446252 - 5000 =
512502 + 5000 =
29816 + 5000 =
958,754
441,252
517,502
34,816
500
500
500
500
500
500
958754 500 =
446252 =
512502 500 =
29816 500 =
958,254
446,252
512,002
29,316
4,000
4,000
3,000
1,000
(18 months)
(6 months)
4,000
3,000
3,000
958754 + 3000 =
446252 =
512502 + 3000 =
29816 + 3000 =
961,754
446,252
515,502
32,816
10
d. ACTUAL:
CORRECT:
ADJUST:
Cash (+A)
Revenue (+R, +SE)
Cash (+A)
Revenue (+R, +SE)
Deferred Revenue (+L)
Revenue (-R, -SE)
Deferred Revenue (+L)
CORRECT:
ADJUST:
800
800
800
200
600
600
600
958754 =
446252 + 600 =
512502 600 =
29816 600 =
Receivable (+A)
Revenue (+R, +SE)
Cost of Goods Sold (+E, -SE)
Cash (-A)
Inventory (+A)
Cash (-A)
Revenue (-R, -SE)
Receivable (-A)
Inventory (+A)
Cost of Goods Sold (-E, +SE)
(3 months)
(9 months)
958,754
446,852
511,902
29,216
5
5
3
3
3
3
5
5
3
3
958754 2 =
446252 =
512502 2 =
29816 2 =
958,752
446,252
512,500
29,814
11
X
Y
In moving from the first set of transactions to the second, we see that Walgreens avoids expense of
Z and incurs an additional expense of X. The expense of Y is paid under both methods and so does
not cause a change. Under the existing accounting, Walgreens income statement shows net income
of 2450. Thus, Walgreens 2013 net income under the alternate accounting would have been:
2450 + Z X. In order to get a specific number, we need to know Z X.
12
But this can be obtained by analyzing the Accrued Salaries liabilities account under the actual
method:
Beginning Balance
Ending Balance
The beginning and ending balance are obtained from the problem.
Solving the equation: 772 + Z X = 928 tells us that Z X = $156. Thus, the alternate net income
would have been: 2450+156 = $2,606.
The question did not ask for the balance sheet effect, but it isnt hard. Under the alternate method,
Accrued Expenses and Other Liabilities would be lower by $928, and thus total liabilities would
be lower by the same amount. Retained Earnings (and thus total shareholders equity) would be
higher by $928, in order to keep the balance sheet in balance.
13
b. Prepaid rent at AOL
Under the existing accounting, there are two transactions relating to prepaid rent. During fiscal year
1996:
Prepaid Rent (+A)
X
Cash (-A)
X represents rent paid during 1996.
X
X
In moving from the first set of transactions to the second, we see that AOL avoids expense of Y and
incurs an additional expense of X. Under the existing accounting, AOLs income statement shows
net income of 29,816. Thus, AOLs 1996 net income under the alternate accounting would have
been: 29,816 + Y X. In order to get a specific number, we need to know Y X. But this can be
obtained by analyzing the Prepaid Rent account under the actual method:
Prepaid Rent (A)
Beginning Balance
25,527
X
Y
Ending Balance
68,832
The beginning and ending balance are obtained from the balance sheet (using the assumption that
the prepaid expenses and other current assets account refers entirely to prepaid rent).
Solving the equation: 25,527 + X Y = 68,832 tells us that X Y = $43,305. Thus, the alternate net
income would have been: 29,816 43,305 = ($13,489).
We can also adjust the balance sheet, by writing off the entire (cumulative) amount of capitalized
prepaid rent on the balance sheet, and balancing this against a reduction of retained earnings.
This gives us a summary balance sheet at 6/30/1996 of
Assets
Liabilities
SE
958,754 68,832
446,252
512,502 68,832
=
=
=
889,922
446,252
443,670
14
c. Accounts Receivable at Walgreens
First, make sure we understand the journal entries. If we do not use problem a) from section 1, the
best we can do is:
ACTUAL:
Accounts Receivable (+A)
Net Sales (+R, +SE)
X
X
Cash (+A)
Accounts Receivable (-A)
Y
Y
ALTERNATE:
No entry at delivery
Cash (+A)
Net Sales (+R, +SE)
Y
Y
Starting with the income statement, we see that as we move from the actual to the alternate,
revenues increase by Y and decrease by X. Thus revenues (and NI) increase by Y-X.
Now set up the T-account and solve for the difference between X and Y.
BB
EB
35,481 2,632
16,027
19,454 2,632
=
=
=
32,849
16,027
16,822