You are on page 1of 34

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR

Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Concrete Slab on
Ground
Design

March 28, 2007

Portland Cement Association


CTLGroup (Construction Tech.Labs)
PCA/CTL
Headquarters in
Skokie, IL

Since 1920s: research, testing,


consulting on construction
materials
150 staff: engineers, chemists,
geologists, lab support staff;
ASTM, ACI, ICRI, ASCE, Others

Goals of the Slab Designer


Provide a quality slab structurally
serviceable to the Owner/User within
established budgetary constraints.
Reduce callbacks and complaints.
Link Between Owner and Contractor
- Maintaining the quality process
o Education/Training
o Communication

Concrete Chain of Responsibility

American Concrete Institute


(ACI 360) Definition
Slab Design - The decision-making
process of planning,
sizing, detailing, and
developing specifications
preceding construction of
slabs on ground.

Good Communication

Municipality/Owner

Design

Design Engineer/Architect
General Contractor
- Concrete Subcontractor

Ready Mix Supplier


- Aggregate Supplier
- Cement Supplier
- Admixture Supplier

Testing Company (QA/QC)

Construction

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Materials

30

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Methods of Slab Design

Empirical Procedures
PCA Method
Wire Reinforcement Institute
US Army Corps of Engineers
Post-Tensioning Institute
ACI Committee 223 (ShrinkageCompensating)

Slab Design Criteria


Support conditions (subgrade/subbase)
Floor use (treatment)
Slab loading
Concrete mix design & placement

conditions
Safety factor
Reinforcement

Floor Use (treatment) Criteria


hWill floor be covered/coated (office)?
Include vapor retarder directly beneath concrete
hFreezer or food processing
Sub-slab insulation (k)
Moisture/temperature fluctuations
Drainage & slip resistance
hHeavy wear operations
Surface hardness/durability
hHigh Racks - Superflatness Requirement

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

March 28, 2007

Methods of Slab Design


Mechanistic Procedures
Westergaard Equations (1927)
Computer Programs (AIRPORT, MATS)
Finite Element Analysis

Support Conditions
hModulus of Subgrade Reaction (k)
Pressure/Deflection Relationship (psi/in.)

hMeasurement
Plate Bearing Test
Correlated to CBR, DCP, etc.

hImproved by Base Course


Stable Working Platform
Compactable/Trimmable (Not Sand)

Loading Criteria
hVehicle Axle Loads
hRack & Post Loads
hUniform Distributed Loads (pallets)
hColumn Loads
hSpecial Loads
Rail Spurs
Machinery

31

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Safety Factor

March 28, 2007

Concrete Flexural Fatigue

Safety Factor (SF) Ranges


Vehicle Loads - 1.2 to 2.0
Post Loads - 1.5 to 4.8

Stress Ratio (SR)


Applied Stress / Developed Strength
Inverse of Safety Factor
SF 2.0 = SR 0.50 (50%)

Thickness Determination

Typical Axle Loading

PCA Method
Concrete Floors on Ground
Axle, Post, & Distributed Load Design Charts

Procedures Discussed Well in:


Designing Floor Slabs On Grade by
Boyd Ringo and Bob Anderson
ACI Committee 360

Information Needed for


AxleAxle-Load Design
z

Concrete Working Stress

From materials, site, and designer


-

In general, 80 to 85% of total


loaded vehicle weight on front axle.
Critical Design Axle Load

Concrete compressive strength


Joint conditions
Subgrade modulus
Safety factor

From lift truck specifications


-

Lift truck capacity


Vehicle weight (total axle load)
Wheel configuration and spacing
Tire pressure
Wheel contact area

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

WS =

MR
SF x JF

where,
WS = Working stress
MR = Modulus of rupture (flexural strength)
SF = Safety factor
JF = Joint factor

32

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Slab Stress Per


1,000 lb Axle Load

Concrete Working Stress


MR = 9 fc
SF = 2.0 to 2.2 for unlimited load repetitions (>1.0)

Stress Per 1000 lb Axle =

WS
Axle Load, kips

JF = 1.0 to 1.6
1.0 Load transfer provided at joints
1.6 Load transfer not reliable
Range between at discretion of designer

Vehicle Wheel Data

PCA Axle Load Design Charts

Post Load Design

Information Needed for


RackRack-Load Design
z

From materials, site, and designer


-

From rack specifications


-

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Concrete compressive strength


Joint conditions
Subgrade modulus
Safety factor
Short post spacing
Long post spacing
Spacing between rack units
Post load
Base plate area

33

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Slab Stress Per


1,000 lb Post Load

Concrete Working Stress


WS =

MR
SF x JF

Stress Per 1000 lb Post =

where,
WS = Working stress
MR = Modulus of rupture (flexural strength)
SF = Safety factor
JF = Joint factor

Post Leg Layout

WS
Post Load, kips

Note: If back-to-back posts are close, treat as a single load


(double Magnitude) on the appropriate-size baseplate.
Some designers take a conservative approach to treat
ALL back-to-back posts as a single load (double
magnitude) on a small baseplate which results in a
thicker slab conservative (consider all factors).

PCA Post Load Design Charts

Y = Long Spacing
X or Z = Short Spacing

Distributed Load Design

Information Needed for


Distributed Load Design
z

From materials, site, and designer


-

From owner/user
-

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Concrete compressive strength


Subgrade modulus
Safety factor
Aisle width
Width of distributed load
Load, psf

34

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Concrete Working Stress


WS =

March 28, 2007

Distributed Load Layout

MR
SF

where,
WS = Working stress
MR = Modulus of rupture (flexural strength)
SF = Safety factor
Strip Load
20 to 100 in.
Width, R, in.

PCA Distributed Load Charts

Aisle
6 to 14 ft
Width, ft

PCA Distributed Load Charts


Chart results in stress (psi)
per 1,000 psf distributed load.
Use load in psf to calculate allowable stress:
If stress resulting from chart is 300 psi and
The distributed load anticipated is 1500 psf
Allowable Stress = 300 x (1500/1000) = 450 psi
If the Allowable stress is greater than the Working
stress, the thickness must be increased.

PCA Distributed Load Charts

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

PCA Distributed Load Charts

35

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

What
Whats Behind the Charts?
Charts developed for interior loading by
pneumatic tired wheels
Stresses due to edge loading are higher up to 50% higher
Edge loading occurs at joints that do not
have load transfer
Smooth dowel bars or dowel plates
Aggregate interlock decreases when joint opens
beyond 0.035 in. (not lost completely)

Reinforcement

Reinforcement

Welded Wire Fabric (WWF)


- Mesh - Rolls or Sheets
Reinforcing Bars
- Mats
Fibers
- Steel or Polypropylene
Post-Tensioning
Shrinkage-Compensating

Reinforcing Steel as Crack Control

Welded Wire Fabric (WWF)


- Mesh - Rolls or Sheets
Reinforcing Bars
- Mats
Fibers
- Steel or Polypropylene
Post-Tensioning
Shrinkage-Compensating

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

36

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Reinforcement
9

Bars need to be
chaired to the top
third elevation
9 Transferring steel
through joints
increases the
potential for random
cracking

Reinforcement

Welded Wire Fabric (WWF)


- Mesh - Rolls or Sheets
Reinforcing Bars
- Mats
Fibers
- Steel or Polypropylene
Post-Tensioning
Shrinkage-Compensating

Reinforcement

Welded Wire Fabric (WWF)


- Mesh - Rolls or Sheets
Reinforcing Bars
- Mats
Fibers
- Steel or Polypropylene
Post-Tensioning
Shrinkage-Compensating

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Post-Tensioned Slabs

Tensioned tendons put slab into permanent compression.


Therefore, no tensile stress and associated cracking.

37

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Reinforcement

Welded Wire Fabric (WWF)


- Mesh - Rolls or Sheets
Reinforcing Bars
- Mats
Fibers
- Steel or Polypropylene
Post-Tensioning
Shrinkage-Compensating

Shrinkage-Compensating Slabs

Expansive cement or an expansive admixture causes


concrete to expand (type K cement).
Steel reinforcement is tensioned and restrains expansion.
Concrete is put into compression no cracking.

Requirements of Steel
Reinforcement

Selection of Reinforcement

Determine need for crack control


Placement conditions (inside/outside)
Subgrade drag and other restraints
Plastic vs. drying shrinkage
Evaporation control to address plastic shrinkage
Jointing to address drying shrinkage

Consider no reinforcement
Doweled plain concrete slabs

Required amount (in general)


Temperature - 0.1 to 0.2 percent
Structural - 0.5 percent

Needs to be in top 1/3 of slab or 2 in.


from top surface to allow for cover
Temperature steel should be terminated
6 in. from all joints (not carried through
joint)

Requirements of Fiber
Reinforcement
Dosage (in general) - ACI 544
Plastic: 0.1 to 0.8 percent (0.2% Common)
Steel: 0.5 to 2.0 percent

May need to add chemical admixtures


to mix to improve workability
Consider/test effect on shrinkage

Fibers need to be well-dispersed


Have repulpable bags repulped?

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Slab Design Conclusions


Design for serviceability in accordance
with owners expectations
Maintain good communication throughout
design/construction
Know what to expect from every design
feature and inform the owner
Always design an industrial floor slab.
Dont simply specify slabs

38

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Some Types of Concrete


Design of
Concrete Mixtures

Concrete Goals

Lightweight
High Strength
Mass
No-Slump
Shrinkage
Compensating
White or Colored

Fiber Reinforced
Low Density
Heavyweight
High Early Strength
Roller Compacted
No Fines
Shotcrete
Others..

Concrete Constituents
Concrete

z Design and produce a mixture of CEMENT,


WATER, and AGGREGATES that will meet the
requirements under which it is expected to serve.
z Economy
Reduce callbacks and complaints
Increase market share

Air
Coarse
Aggregate

Water

Maintaining the quality process


- Education/Training
- Communication

Fresh Concrete Properties

Fine Aggregate

Cementitious

Compressive Strength

Workability

- 2,500 to 20,000 psi

Bleeding
Time of Set

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

- Portland
Cement
- Pozzolans

Hardened Concrete Properties

Consistency

Uniformity

Chemical
Admixture

Tensile Strength
- 250 to 1,500 psi

Modulus of Elasticity
- 2,000,000 to 10,000,000 psi

39

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Concrete Strength
Interrelationships

Water-Cement Ratio
The water-cement ratio (W/C) is determined from:

Compressive Strength (fc)


- Easily measured & documented

Flexural Strength (MR)


- 9 fc

Factor 9 ranges from 7.5 to 10

Modulus of Elasticity (E)


- 57,000 fc

ACI 318

Durability considerations
Required strength fcr
Weight of Water
Weight of Cement

w/c =

Water in excess of 0.25-0.28 w/c


is considered water of convenience
For optimum workability during placement
recommend a maximum 0.42-0.50 w/c
or use of chemical admixtures.

Effect of w/c ratio*

Effect of w/c ratio*

*At constant cement content

WaterWater-Cement vs.
WaterWater-Cementitious
Example
z Cement:

600 lb
z Fly Ash: 150 lb
z Water: 300 lb
Slag, Fly Ash, Silica Fume, Metakaolin

w/c: 300/600 = 0.50

*At constant cement content

W/C Ratio Versus Concrete Properties

Excellent

Concrete
Property
Poor
0

0.25

0.5

0.75

Water-to-Cement Ratio

w/cm: 300/750 = 0.40

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

40

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Attributes of Quality
Quality Concrete
High Compressive Strength
Low Water/Cement Ratio

Not for
Slabs!

9Low Shrinkage Potential

March 28, 2007

Assuming Proper Placement, Two


Biggest Slab Performance Issues
Random Cracking and Subsequent
Deterioration
- Plastic
- Drying

ASTM C 157 and ACI 209R

9Good Workability/Finishability
9Required Strength and Durability

Factors in Cracking

Joint Performance
- Joint Spalling
- Joint Stability

Shrinkage and Cracking

Concrete volume change


- Linear
- Curling/Warping
Restraint conditions
- Slab/Subbase Friction
- Slab Penetrations
Tensile strength of concrete

Concrete Shrinkage

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Cracks in Concrete

41

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Concrete Shrinkage

Slab Curling/Warping

Plastic
Drying

Surface Cooler and/or Drier

Bottom Warmer and/or Wetter

Curling and Warping


Originally Defined by Pavement Engineers
in the Early 1900s.
9 Curling is the deformation of the slab surface
due to a difference in temperature between the
slab surface and bottom.
9 Warping is the deformation of the slab surface
profile due to a difference in moisture between
the slab surface and bottom.

Cement Hydration

PC + H2O CSH + CaOH2

CaOH2 + Pozz CSH

Exothermic Chemical Reaction

Temperature Curling

Temperature Curling

Surface Cooler

Surface Warmer

Bottom Warmer

Bottom Cooler

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

42

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Moisture Warping

March 28, 2007

Moisture Warping

Drying occurs from the top downward

Drying occurs from the top downward

Dry top portion shrinks relative to the wetter bottom portion

Dry top portion shrinks relative to the wetter bottom portion


Slab edges warp upward

Measured Moisture Gradient


0
10
20
concrete
placed
(day zero)

30

Depth, mm

40
50
5 months

70-days

40-days

9-days

60
70
80
90
100
50

55

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

RH%

Slab with a vapor retarder immediately below

Measured Moisture Gradient

Moisture Warping

Slab Relative Humidity Gradient


Relative Humidity, Percent
-2

20

40

60

80

Surface Drier
100

120

Slab Depth, in.

0
2
4

7-in.-thick slab

Bottom Wetter

6
8
10

4-year old slab on draining base

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

43

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Permanent Upward Edge


Warping and Daily
Downward Curling
Surface Drier
Sun Warms Slab Surface

Bottom Wetter
Remains Cooler

March 28, 2007

Problems with Slab Warping


Decreased Load-Carrying Capacity
Resulting in Long-Term Slab Cracking
- Mid-Panel Cracks
- Corner Breaks

Slab Rocking Joint Stability


Joint Spalling (Joint Filler Breakdown)
Decreased Vehicle Rideability (Safety)
Floor Covering Distress/Failure

Curling/Warping Distress

Curling/Warping Distress

MidMid-Panel Crack as Warped Edges are Loaded

Actual Deformation Due to Slab Weight


Slab Edges/Corners Crack Under Load

Corner Breaks

Unsupported Corners
(Curling/Warping)
Crane Outriggers

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

44

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Joint Stability

Joint Stability

Rocking as Warped Slab Panels are Trafficked

Rocking as Warped Slab Panels are Trafficked

Joint Spalling

Joint Stability

Joint Stability
Joint Filler Material
Wheel Type/Traffic

Joint Filler

Semi-Rigid Full-Depth
Repair Splits

Wheel Type

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Pneumatic Tires
Steel Wheel
Hard Polymer

45

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Se
mi
-R
igi

dJ

oin

tF
ille
r

Joint Spalling & Tire Damage

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

46

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Measured Moisture Gradient

Floor Covering Failure


Due to Warping

0
10
20
concrete
placed
(day zero)

30

Depth, mm

40
50
5 months

6 months

70-days

40-days

9-days

60
70
80
90
100
50

55

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

RH%

Slab with a vapor retarder immediately below

Slabs Relax
Relax Forcing Joint
Leveling Compound Upward

Debonding Above Joints

Factors Affecting Magnitude of


Slab Warping

Concrete Shrinkage Potential


Concrete Strength and Related Stiffness
Joint Spacing
Slab Thickness
Subgrade Support Stiffness & Moisture Content
Slab Moisture/Temperature Differential
Others

Concrete Repair Bulletin


January/February 2006

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

47

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Minimizing
Minimizing Slab Warping

Preventing
Preventing Slab Warping

Proper Design and Construction Using:

- Shrinkage-Compensating Cement
- Post-Tensioning Reinforcement

Minimize Paste Quantity


- Increase Aggregate Size
- Optimize Aggregate Gradation
- Minimize Cement Content

Increased Design/Construction Cost


ALL Other Slabs Warp

- Magnitude of Warp Determines Serviceability

Minimizing Water (Paste)

Maximize Paste Quality


- Reasonable Water/Cement Ratio
- Just Enough Water for Workable Slump

Maximum Coarse Aggregate Size


S

Use Good Quality Well-Graded


Aggregate

Maximize Coarse Aggregate Size to


Decrease Total Water in Mix

Dmax

Slab Thickness, t: Dmax T/3


Dmax S
For pumped concrete:
Dmax 1/3 diameter of hose or
1 in.
whichever is smaller

Sieve Analysis ASTM C 136

WellGraded
Vs.
GapGraded

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

48

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Large
Topsize
Aggregate
But

High Paste
Content

High
Shrinkage
Concrete

March 28, 2007

Minimizing Paste Quantity


Balance Between:
Low Shrinkage
and

Very Poor
Aggregate
Gradation.

Workability/Finishability
High
Slab Warping
Potential

Other Mix Design Factors

Type of Aggregate
Admixture Promoting Shrinkage
Excessive Slump
Using Cement with High Shrinkage
Dirty Aggregate
High Concrete Temperature at
Placement

Aggregate Shadowing

Curling/Warping Assessment
Edge Elevation
Survey
- Laser Level
- Carpenters Level

ACI 360

Curling/Warping Assessment
Joint Load Transfer
- Dowels
- Aggregate Interlock

Curling/Warping Repair
Slab Subsealing
Surface Grinding

Edge Deflection

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

49

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Batching & Delivery


Batching, Placement,
And Finishing

Truck Mixing and Delivery

Transportation

Delays
Early Stiffening & Drying
Segregation

Mixing speed - 70-100 rev. (6-16 rpm)

Agitating speed - Any revolutions after the


initial 70 to 100 revolutions

Discharge: Time Limit- 1-1/2 hours

Discharge Revolution Limit- 300 rev.

Sampling

Adding water? Additional Rev.

Construction
Subbase Variability
Within Building Envelope
- Roof and Walls in place (weather independent)
Slab Thickness Tolerance
- - in., + 3/8 in. Avg. -3/8 in. Individual -3/4 in.
Protection of Slab After Placement
- Ambient Conditions, Subsequent Construction

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

50

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Thickness Variability

Slab Placement

Placing/Spreading Concrete

Placing/Spreading Concrete
Strike-Off & Consolidation
Leveling - Bull-Floating (Highway Straightedge)
Brooming?
Floating - Recess Aggregates, Bleeding
Troweling - Densify & Close Surface (Burnish)
Jointing - Crack Control
Curing - Promote Hydration
Drying - Moisture Emission

Placing/Spreading Concrete

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Placing/Spreading Concrete

51

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

StrikeStrike-off and Consolidation

StrikeStrike-off and Consolidation

StrikeStrike-off and Consolidation

Leveling/Bullfloating

Restraightening

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

52

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Floating
Purpose:
Consolidate and Level Unformed Surface
Depress Larger Aggregates and Bring
Paste to the Slab Surface.
Leaves Surface Open
- Continued Bleeding
- Wait For Bleedwater to Dissipate.

Troweling
Purpose:
To Provide a Smooth, Hard,
Densified Slab Surface.
Closes Surface
- Low Absorption
- Easy Cleaning/Maintenance

Finishing (continued)
Finishing

Float as soon as concrete has been struck


off

DO NOT SEAL THE SURFACE

- Only one or two passes

Floating must end before visible bleed water


rises to surface
Wait for concrete to stop bleeding

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Sealing
Dusting
Blisters
Crazing

Troweling
-

- Do not tip bull floats

Finishing During Bleeding

Not for outside work


Will be slippery when wet
Trowel burns
Tilting chatter

NO SPRINKLING OR CEMENT ON SURFACE


Cure ASAP

53

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Curing

March 28, 2007

Curing

Curing Methods

Percentage

1. Water Cure
Ponding
Flooding
Mist Spray
Effect of Curing on
Compressive Strength

Curing Methods

Curing Methods

1. Water Cure

1. Water Cure

2. Moisture Retaining

2. Moisture Retaining

Wet Burlap

Wet Burlap

Fabric Backed Poly

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

54

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Curing Methods

Curing Methods

1. Water Cure

1. Water Cure

2. Moisture Retaining

2. Moisture Retaining

Wet Burlap
Fabric Backed Poly

Wet Burlap
Fabric Backed Poly
Poly

Poly

Waterproof Paper

Concerns with Water Curing Methods


1. Discoloration

Concerns with Water Curing Methods


2. Water Temperature

Initial Contact
water within 10
degrees of slab
temperature

Check Slab & Water Temperature

Curing Methods

Curing Methods

1. Water Cure

1. Water Cure

2. Moisture Retaining

2. Moisture Retaining

3. Curing

3. Curing

Compounds

Membrane Forming

Compounds

Membrane Forming
Chemical
Curing Compounds
should not be used on
floors to be covered

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

55

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Winter Concreting
Temporary Heat

Control Joint Detailing

Control Joint Detailing

Placement B

Construction Joint

Re-entrant Corner

Re-entrant Corner
Placement A

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

56

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Control Joint Detailing

March 28, 2007

Control Joint Detailing

Re-entrant Corner

Control Joint Detailing

Control Joint Detailing

Control Joint Detailing

Pinwheel

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

57

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Control Joint Detailing

March 28, 2007

Crack due to thickness variation due


to tire rutting

Evaporation of Surface
Moisture

Plastic Cracking

Air temperature, F
40

60

80

100

100

Relative
humidity, %

100 F

Concrete
Temperature

80
60
40
20

80
60

0.8
20

Rate of
evaporation,
lb/sq ft/hr

0.6
0.4

10

0.2

Wind velocity,
mph

0.0

Jointing
z

Joint Types

Construction Joints
z

Designate Pour Limits

Butt-Type (Formed)

Doweled

Construction
Isolation
Contraction/Control

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Single Days Placement


Keyways Not Recommended
Load Transfer
Prevent Differential Movement

58

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Keyway Joints

Cracking parallel to Joint


z
z
z

Keyways
Depth or Timing
Dowel Misalignment

Form Includes Keyway Notch


Female Side of Joint Cast
Male Side of Joint Cast
Concrete Shrinks and Joint Widens
Load Transfer is Lost
Unsupported Female Side Cracks

Isolation Joints
z

Isolate Floor Slab

Perimeter Walls
Dock Levelers
Slab Penetrations
-

Interior Columns, Drains, Plumbing, Electrical

Joint Material

Compressible
Full-Depth

Contraction Joints
z

Control Random Cracking Due To


Restraint to Concrete Shrinkage
Installed at Proper:

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Spacing
Depth
Timing

59

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Control Joint Spacing

Control Joint Depth


z

American Concrete Institute (ACI)

36 Times Slab Thickness

Create a Weakened Plane to determine


Crack Location

Slab Thickness

6-in.-thick slab = 18 ft joint spacing

6-in.-thick slab = 1-in.-deep joint

Portland Cement Association (PCA)

Joint Spacing (ft) = 2 to 2.5 Thickness (in.)


6-in.-thick slab = 12 to 15 ft joint spacing

Grooving/Tooling or Sawcutting

Beware of Crack Promoting Insert (Vertical?)

Control Joint Timing


Before Tensile Stress Exceeds
Developed Tensile Strength (Crack)

Restraint to Volumetric Decrease


Friction, Penetrations

Just After Peak Heat of Hydration (Cooling)

Drying Shrinkage & Temperature Contraction


Generally 8 to 12 Hours After Placement

0.050 in.

Joint Reinforcement
z

Load Transfer
Transfer load from one slab to the next

Effective Widening
= 0.025 in.?
Aggregate
Interlock

Slab Surface
Widening
>0.035 in.!!!

Minimal Opening
Slab
Required Bottom
< 0.035 in.Widening

<0.001 in.!!!

Minimize Concrete
Shrinkage and
Joint Spacing

- Aggregate Interlock
- Mechanical Devices
Dowel Bars
Plate Dowels

- Transferred Steel Reinforcement

0.001 in.

Sawcut Joint Activation

Be Aware of How
Cracks Form in
Slabs v Shape

Need to Measure Load-Transfer to Determine Aggregate Interlock Effectiveness

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

60

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Mechanical Devices

Mechanical Load Transfer


Devices Installed in
Joint to Transfer
Applied Load From
One Slab Panel to
the Adjacent Slab
Panel.

Align Dowels!

Differential Lateral Movement


Existing

Sawcut
Control
Joint

Replacement

Slab
Repair

Construction Joint

Differential Lateral Movement

Sawcut
Control
Joint

Differential Lateral Movement

Slab
Repair

Construction Joint

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

61

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

Differential Lateral Movement

Sawcut
Control
Joint

Construction Joint

New
Construction

Lateral Restraint Cracking


Really Not Observed Often
But Possible

Differential Lateral Movement

Sawcut
Control
Joint

Construction Joint

Movement at Sawcut Joints

Sawcut
Control
Joint

Sawcut Control Joint

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

March 28, 2007

Differential Lateral Movement

Sawcut
Control
Joint

Construction Joint

New
Construction

Plate Dowels Better


for Constructibility
at Construction Joints

Differential Lateral Movement

Sawcut
Control
Joint

Construction Joint

No Lateral Restraint
Due to Plate Shape
And/Or Side Cushioning

Movement at Sawcut Joints

Sawcut
Control
Joint

No Lateral Restraint
As Panels Shrink
In the Same
Direction
(Not Differentially)
And
Smooth Dowels
Travel with
Slab Shrinkage
Even With
Extremely
Exaggerated
Joint Widening

Sawcut Control Joint

62

SLAB DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, & REPAIR


Virginia Structural Engineers Council

March 28, 2007

Mechanical Devices

Only exception is at rare


T Intersection sawcut joints

Beneat
Consolidate

Transfer Steel Through Joints

h Plates!

Dowels Cannot
Function Without
Good
Consolidation

Slab Jointing Conclusions

ACI Warns that Cracking is Possible

But it has been done effectively

Design joints to control random cracking


Install joints at proper time, depth, and
spacing
Determine load transfer requirement and
design joints as necessary
Isolate slab from fixed structural elements
Install and maintain joint filler to minimize
risk of spalling

when Concrete Shrinkage and Steel Percentage are Minimized.

SLAB REPAIR

SLAB REPAIR

Scott Tarr & Peter Craig

Whats
TheStep
First is
Step
The
First
to:?

O L
B

Accurately determine the


root cause of the
problem
And to select methods and
materials that not only
repair the visible damage
but also correct the
underlying cause of the
problem

63

You might also like