Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HUTCHINSON,
chemistry.
G E. 1957. A treatise
1015 PP. Wiley, New
REVIEWS
on limnology.
York.
$19.50.
The development
of the twin sciences which
make ux) the t&le of this journal owes a great deal
to monbgraphic
works d;hich aimed ti provide,
for their time, a comprehensive
account of the
physics,
geology,
chemistry,
and biology
of a
lake microcosm
or of the ocean macrocosm.
Forels Le LBman and Murray
& Hjorts
The
Depths of the Oceans are notable early examples,
while Sverdrup,
Fleming,
and Johnsons
The
Oceans
is the best known contemporary
one.
These works created eminences from which the
topography
of the whole subject could be viewed.
Professor Hutchinsons
two-volume
Treatise
on
Limnology
will, when complete, enter this distinguished
category.
His aim is to give as comnlete an account as possible of the events characteristically
occurring in lakes-no
less. This is a
formidable
task for one author,
but those who
know Hutchinsons
researches
and writings
on
limnology
and cognate fields of ecology, lake history, and biogeochemistry
will anticipate
a comprehensive,
scholarly,
and integrated
account.
In this first volume they will not be disappointed.
This treatise is the fruit of many years 02 research
and literary
labour, and it has proved necessary
to publish it in two volumes.
The volume here
reviewed
covers geographical
and physicochemical limnology.
The second volume, yet to appear,
will deal with limnobiology
and the ecological,
typological,
and stratigraphic
problems
of lake
development.
The whole work is addressed,
not to limnologists
alone, but also to biologists
who may wish to know sdmething of the phyiicochemical environment.
mode of life, and evolutionary significance
of kuch fresh-water
organisms
as they may study from quite different
points of
view; to geologists who are desirous of learning
something of modern lakes in order that they may
better interpret
the record of inland waters in
past times ; and to oceanographers
who wish to
compare the results of their own science with
what has been learned
of the small but very
individual
bodies of water which make UD th\
non-marine
part of the hydrosphere.
Written ai a comprehensive
treatise on physicochemical limnoloav
for the advanced student, the
text carries muck detailed exnosition
aim&z to
provide a background
for research; but con&e,
factual summaries are presented at the end of each
chapter.
These should prove helpful, not only to
the general reader or the elementary
student, but
also to many who will use the volume for reference,
for they will find the index to be inadequate
for a
work of this size and detail.
The bibliography
covers a wider field than any hitherto
published.
and is as fullv internationalas the author could
make it-a w&come change after the insularity
of
some earlier European
and American
texts-although post-war
Russian literature
remains regrettibly
largely
unavailable,
and few papers
108
Volume 1. Geography,
physics and
Chapman & Hall, London.
148/-.
BOOK
REVIEWS
109
110
BOOK
REVIEWS
BOOK
REVIEWS
111
112
BOOK
REVIEWS
BOOK
sometimes-if
they are plant
nutrients-their
importance
is a direct result of their low concentration.
Separate
chapters
are, therefore,
devoted to the cycles of phosphorus,
sulphur, silica,
and nitrogen.
These chapters
introduce
and
elaborate
many of the main themes of chemical
limnology,
and it seems almost irreverent
to dismiss them in a few sentences.
Phosphorus
is
regarded as the plant food most likely to become
deficient and, therefore, to limit biological production in lakes.
Radiophosphorus
is the latest tool
to be applied to studies of exchange within
the
lake system.
Particular
attention
is paid to the
geochemistry
of iron.
Although it is a very minor
ionic constituent
of waters containing
oxygen,
iron is relatively
abundant in the lithosphere
and
in most lake sediments, and it exerts-through
the
ferric/ferrous
system-a
poising influence on the
redox potential
at interfaces
between zones of
oxidat,ion
and reduction
(697-705), for example
near the sediment/water
interface
or sometimes
at the thermocline
in stratified
lakes.
No
clear idea of the biochemical
transformations
in a
lake can be gained without
a consideration
of the
redox potential
(691) and to illustrate
this the
influence
of various
redox transformations
of
sulphur and nitrogen on lake metabolism
is fully
discussed.
The cycle of silicon and its utilization
by diatoms is somewhat less complex, although
the precise form of this element in solution
is
still in doubt.
A number of minor elements are treated
together in one chapter.
It is a little surprising
to
find manganese among these. Although,
like iron,
it is only present in low concentrations
in water
containing
oxygen, it is an important
constituent
of sediments, where the manganese/iron
ratio is
usually considerably
higher than that in the lithosphere as a whole (804). It behaves in a similar
manner to iron in a redox gradient.
The occurrence in lake water of copper, zinc, aluminium,
gallium,
molybdenum,
nickel, and cobalt is described.
Of these only copper has been studied in
any detail, and it is clear that much work remains
to be done on the distribution
and biological
significance
of these minor metallic
elements.
Isolated
occurrences
of other trace metals are
noted but the distribution
of the naturally
radioactive species is more fully discussed, particularly in view of their possible use in dating lake
sediments.
The present lack of knowledge of the nature of
organic matter in lake waters is illustrated
by the
fact that the entire field can be adequately
reviewed in a final chapter of twenty-five
pages.
Little progress can be made with the ubiquitous
brown or yellow coloring
matters until more is
known of their origin, structure,
and reactions-a
complex but promising
field of research.
The
occurrence
of various vitamins
and amino acids
in waters and sediments is briefly discussed.
The relatively
small space given here to the
chemical half of this volume must not be allowed
to obscure the fact that it is an authoritative,
113
REVIEWS
comprehensive,
and most stimulating
review of
the wide field of chemical limnology.
In a subject which embraces the chemistry
of the *earth
and of living things, selection of material
is inevitable,
and it is not surprising
that the author
has laid most emphasis on the biogeochemistry
of biologically
important
elements.
But he has
not excluded aspects of pure chemistry or physical
chemistry
where relevant,
and we are promised
that he will revert
to certain chemical matters
in the subsequent
volume on lake biology.
Its
publication
is most eagerly awaited.
REFERENCES
(Other
bibliography)
BURLING, R.W.
1955. Wind generation of waves
on water.
Ph.D. Thesis, University
of London.
CALOI, P. 1954. Oscillazioni
libere de1 Lago di
Garda.
Arch. Met., Wien, A, 7: 434-465.
CHARNOCK, H. 1958. Wind - generated
water
Sci. Progr.
London,
46: 487-501.
waves.
CLARKE, G. L. 1939. The utilization
of solar
energy by aquatic
organisms.
In MOULTON
(ed.),
Problems
of Lake Biology.
Amer.
Assoc. Advanc.
Sci ., Publ. 10, 27-38.
CLARKE, G. L., AND H. R. JAMES. 1939. Laboratory
analysis of the selective
absorption
of light by sea water.
J. Opt. Sot. Amer.,
29: 43-55.
DARBYSHIRE,
J., AND M. DARBYSHIRE.
1957.
Seiches in Lough Neagh.
Quart.
J. Roy.
Met. Sot., 83: 93-102.
DEFANT, A. 1918. Neue Methode zur Ermittlung
der Eigenschwingungen
(Seiches)
von abgeschlossenen Wassermassen
(Seen, Buchten,
usw.).
Ann. Hydrograph.,
Berlin, 46: 78-85.
FJELDSTAD, J. E. 1933. Interne
Wellen.
Geofys. Publ.,
lO(6): l-35.
FISH, G. R. 1957. A seiche movement
and its
effect on the hydrology
of Lake Victoria.
Fish. Publ., London, 68 pp.
FRANCIS, J. R. D. 1953. A note on the velocity
distribution
and bottom
stress in a winddriven water current system.
J. Mar. Res.,
12: 93-98.
---.
1954. Wind stress over a water surface.
Quart. J. Roy. Met. Sot., 80: 438-43.
GROEN, P. 1948. Contribution
to the theory of
internal
waves.
Meded,
ned. met. Inst.,
B., II, No. 11, 23 pp.
JERLOV, N. G. 1953. Particle
distribution
in
114
BOOK
the ocean.
Rep. Swedish Deep-Sea
Expd.
3: 73-97.
LE GRAND, Y. 1939. La pen&ration
de la lumiere dans la mer. Ann. Inst. Oceanogr.
Monaco, 19: 393-436.
MALLOCK, A. 1920. Eddies and the diffusion
of momentum.
Tech.
Rep.
adv. Comm.
Aero., London, 1: 13-15.
MOORE, J. G. 1947. The determination
of the
depths and extinction
coefficients
of shallow
water by air photography
using colour filters.
Phil. Trans., A, 240: 163-200.
MORTIMER, C. H. 1954. Models
of the flowWeather,
9: 177-184.
pattern
in lakes.
REVIEWS
C. H. MORTIMER