Professional Documents
Culture Documents
288
immunoprecipitate the antigen from cell
lysates. Therefore, T lymphocytes that
undergo increased DNA synthesis and cell
proliferation express HLA-DR. This has
important implications in the co-operative
interactions among B and T lymphocytes in
regulating the immune response.
Conclusions
In summary, the polymorphic HLA-DR
antigens are a group of cell surface glycoproteins with limited tissue distribution.
They are found predominantly on B lymphocytes; notable exceptions include some
tumor cells (e.g., melanoma) and activated
T lymphocytes. These antigens consist of
two chains, with apparent mol. wt of
34,000 and 28,000. The 28,000 mol. wt
chain contains the observed heterogeneity
of the intact molecule. During their biosynthesis it appears that the HLA-DR antigens
undergo conformational changes, aided in
part by their oligosaccharide moieties. The
surface density of these antigens is maximal
stroma
ADP+Pi
_thylakoid ~ ' ~
rnernb ....
~=~'-~'PQ\I~'
F~ PS2 ~
)1FeS I
I1
, ,~f~S
A ,~
TP
NADP~- / --~ ~
PSl ~1J
~I}
CFo
2t02 2H+~. . . . .
2H+-- . . . .
->H+
Jan M. Anderson is at the Division of Plant Industry, CSIR O, P.O. Box 1600, Canberra City, A. C. T.
inside
2601, Australia and Bertil Andersson is at the
Fig. 1. Schematic representation of photosynthetic electron flow ( - - ) and proton transport (. . . . . . . . ) in
Department of Biochemistry, University of Lund,
thylakoid membranes.
S-220 07 Lund, Sweden.
ElsevierBioraedicalPres~1982 O376 5067182/0(XX)(k'~Xll$(lt(WI
289
T1BS - A u g u s t 1982
.....
111111111111
)) . . . .
..........
>)
gm
partition
St . . . .
thylakoid
......................
Thytakoid breakage by
Yeda press disrupbon
;--:-/:::----:-3,
,,
Membrane resealing
and vesicle formation
Phase partition
@o@
~
upper
phase
lower
phase
/
$1roma
exposed
out
i-,, -I appressed
in
prise only a very small fraction of the total turned inside-out- revealed functionally by
lipid; 80% is neutral galactolipids. Most of their reversed proton and elecL~cal gradthe acyl chains of these lipids have an ients and structurally by freeze-fracture
unusually high degree of unsaturation mak- analysiss. Furthermore, the inside-out vesicles are derived from the grana appressions
ing the thylakoid bilayer very fluid.
A striking structural feature of the as judged by their freeze-fracture particle
thylakoid membranes of most plants and pattern and mode of formations. Fig. 2
some green algae is their differentiation into illustrates how Yeda press treatment rupstacked (appressed) and unstacked (non- tures the grana stacks at their margins, with
appressed) regions (Fig. 2). The outer the attractive stacking forces keeping adjamembrane surfaces of these two regions are cent membranes of the granum appressed.
different, since only the stroma thylakoids Inside-out vesicles form when such appresand the end membranes and margins of sed membrane pairs reseal, while nongrana stacks are in direct contact with the appressed membranes seal right-side out.
chloroplast stroma, the closely appressed
membranes of the grana partitions having Transverse organization of some
limited contact with the stroma. In contrast, thylakoid components
There is some evidence for a vectorial
thylakoids enclose an inner space which is
continuous between appressed and arrangement of the electron transport carstroma-exposed regions. As will be discus- riers, suggesting that the electron donor
sed later, this structural differentiation is sites for both photosystems 1 and II are
accompanied by a functional differentia- located towards the inner thylakoid surface
and the electron acceptor sites at the outer
tion.
surfacex. Such an orientation is required to
explain vectorial electron transport by each
Subfractionation of the thylakoid
photosystem and the inward direction of
membrane
Much of the information concerning the proton pumping. The recent isolation of
organization of thylakoid membranes has inside-out vesicles has been useful in
been obtained from fractionation studies. clarifying certain points concerning the
Thylakoids have been fragmented by transverse asymmetry of thylakoids. The
detergents or mechanical sheafing and vari- inner surface of inside-out vesicles can be
ous centrifugal techniques have been used directly probed by suitable membraneto separate the thylakoid fragments7. Typi- impermeable effectors and compared with
cally, the light fractions contain vesicles the outer surface.
The location of the water-splitting site
derived mainly from stroma thylakoids and
have only the properties associated with has been one area of controversy. Trypsin
photosystem I. The heavy fractions are proteolysis of control thylakoids effectively
derived from more or less intact grana inhibits photosystem II activity. This is also
stacks and contain both photosystems. the case for trypsin digestion of inside-out
These traditional separation approaches thylakoidss. However, addition of an artififailed to give membrane fractions represen- cial electron donor, diphenylcarbazide
tative of the grana appressions without any (known to bypass water-splitting) restores
non-appressed grana end membranes and the activity completely in inside-out, but
margins. Moreover, traditional subfraction- not in fight-side-out vesicles. This clearly
ation methods failed to provide thylakoid shows that the water-splitting site is located
membranes which were turned inside-out. at the inner thylakoid surface. Another way
Such inside-out vesicles have been of great to destroy photosynthetic water-splitting
importance for biochemical investigations consists of Tris-washing, which releases
of the transverse asymmetry of other polypeptides of mol. wt 33,000 and 23,000
from the inner thylakoid surfaces. This
biological membranes.
Both these fractionation problems were suggests the possible identification of the
solved by the introduction of aqueous rust components of the water-splitting reacpolymer two-phase partition for subfrac- tion whose composition has so far remained
tionation of the thylakoid membranes. The unknown.
Another area of dispute concerned the
phase partition technique allows membranes to be separated into the upper or location of plastocyanin, since the original
lower phase according to differences in sur- suggestion that plastocyanin was located at
face properties9. Two membrane popula- the inner thylakoid surface was later contions are resolved from thylakoids frag- tradicted. Therefore, the effect of purified
mented in a Yeda press, one with a high plastocyanin on photosystem 1 electron
affinity for the upper phase and the other for transport was compared with vesicles of
the lower phase. The thylakoids which par- opposite sidednessH. P700 was rapidly
tition to the upper phase show normal reduced by externally added plastocyanin
right-side-out properties. In contrast, the with inside-out vesicles only. Moreover,
lower phase contains vesicles which are immunological analysis showed that plas-
but the inside-out vesicles were agglutinated. This clearly shows that the lightharvesting complex traverses the membrane exposing different antigenic sites at
the outer and inner thylakoid surfaces.
We therefore isolated thylakoid subfractions representing grana stacks, grana partitions (inside-out vesicles) and stroma
thylakoids and compared their relative content of the three main chlorophyll-protein
complexes ~5. These results are summarized
in Table I which also includes analyses of
the cytochrome b/f complex TM and ATP
synthetase17. Most of the photosystem 11
complex and light-harvesting complex is
located in the appressed membranes, with
only 10-20% in the stroma-exposed membranes (Fig. 3). In contrast, most of the
photosystem I complex is located in the
stroma-exposed thylakoids. The low contribution of P S I complex seen in the
inside-out vesicles may be due to contain[nation with stroma-exposed thylakoids (as
judged by CF1 determinations 17 and the
proportion of P700 slowly reduced by plastocyaninas). Hence, it may be that the grana
partitions contain no photosystem I complex. This is also indicated by a recent
improvement of the phase partition procedure which yields grana partition vesicles
that have hardly any photosystem I complex TM. Such an extreme distribution is suggested also by a freeze-fracture study with a
,L,
S
Piq~ro N POOL
.,.,,
~s
by -I~8.
,.--
/./
TABLE1. Relativecontentof the five intrinsiccomplexesin thylakoidsubfractionsrepresentingdifferentrnem- trons are transferred from photosystem
photosystem I. At first sight the most
braheregions
vious candidate for a lateral shuttle is lc
Thylakoid
PhotosysternI Photosystem11 Light-harvesting Cytochromeb/f
ATP
toquinone, since re-oxidation of pl~
fraction
complexa
complex"
complexa
complexb
synthetase: quinone is the rate-limiting step in ph
synthesis, With a half-time of 20 ms (I
Unfractionatedthylakoids
30
13
52
460
4.2
10). While the large pool of plastoqui~
Granastacks
20
13
60
3.4
molecules would be mobile in the m
Granapartitions
(inside-outvesicles)
10
14
65
470
1.2
brane, the uniform distribution of
Sla'omathylakoids
69
5
17
485
I 1.7
cytochrome b / f complex means that sq
electrons would have to be transferred f
a% of total chlorophyll(Ref. 15);bChl/cytfratio(Ref. 16); cArbitraryunits(Ref. 17)
the cytochrome complexes of appre:
photosystem I mutant of maize =. A ATP synthetase and the contrasting membranes to nearby photosystem I c
mechanism for the exclusion of photosys- uniform distribution of the cytochrome b / f plexes in stroma-exposed membra
complex between appressed and stroma- Hence plastocyanin may also be a liP,]
tem I complex from the grana partitions
based upon electrostatic repulsive forces exposed thylakoids has profound conse- lateral shuttle. Plastocyanin, which h
role analogous to that of cytochrome
has been postulated by Barber2L In marked quences for photosynthesis (Fig. 3).
inner mitochondrial membranes, cq
contrast to the asymmetric location of the
either diffuse laterally while still attach~
chlorophyll-protein complexes and ATP Electron transport
Since two of the three membrane com- the membrane or diffuse very rapidly it
synthetase, the cytochrome b / f complex is
uniformly distributed between the different plexes involved in electron transport are not intrathylakoid space which is contint
thylakoid regions (Refs 16, 22, Paterson, uniformly distributed between stacked and between grana partitions and strc
D. and Wraight, C. A. private communica- unstacked regions it is clear that single exposed thylakoids.
structural electron transport chains cannot
The third, but less likely, possibility :
tion).
exist. This was evident, from the lack of lateral shuttle between appressed and
constant stoichiometry between the various appressed regions is the cytochrome
Consequences of lateral asymmetry
The extreme lateral asymmetry of the thylakoid components, seen for example in complex itself. However, Hackenbre
chlorophyll-containing
complexes and the varying chlorophyll/P700 molar ratios has calculated for inner mitochon~
of different plant chloroplasts 1. Moveover, membranes that the relative distances
Melis and Brown2a have shown that the fused by large membrane complexes a
ratios of PS II reaction centres to PS I reac- least two to three orders of magnitude sl
tion centres are rarely unity. Now that the ler than those of the linking compon~
concentrations of various components cytochrome c ubiquinone. Similar cal
involved in electron transport are being tions also suggest that both plastoquil
measured in many different chloroplasts it and plastocyanin could move with d:
is obvious that there is not necessarily a sional velocities great enough to allow
fixed and constant stoichiometry between tron transport.
them. Further, the existence of intrinsic
complexes as structurally independent Light-harvesting
entities in the native membrane is demonContrary to popular notions that
strated since these can now be isolated as chlorophylls of photosystem II and ph,
supramolecular complexes. Thus, while system I are in contact with each other,
the composition of each individual complex data show that most of the chlorop
remains fixed, the relative proportions of domains of photosystem 1I are widely :
each may vary with respect to one another. arated from those of photosystem Ia~,2
Since there are no fixed electron trans- chloroplasts that have grana stacks. "
port chains we need to consider how elec- means that the transfer of extra light en~
ATPsynthetase
PS 2 complex - LHC 2
T I B S - A u g u s t 1982
292
from photosystem II to photosystem I, the
so-called 'spillover', is largely prevented ~.
How, then, do grana-containing chloroplasts regulate the distribution of light energy
between the photosystems? Allen et al. 26
suggest that the reversible photophosphorylation of the outer surface-exposed threonyl
residues of the main polypeptides of the
light-harvesting complex may he implicated. Recently, Barber'7 suggested that the
phosphorylation of some of the photosystem II - light-harvesting complexes would
increase their net negative charge thereby
causing them to move from the appressed
membrane regions to stroma-exposed
thylakoids. This would result in a decreased
extent of appressed membranes and allow
more of the light-harvesting complex to
interact with photosystem I complex,
thereby facilitating light-sharing. Hence,
spatial separation of the photosystems in
combination with phosphorylation would
he one way for the controlled regulation of
light energy distribution between the two
photosystems.
Function o f different chloroplasts
Structurally independent thylakoid complexes linked by mobile electron carriers,
plastoquinone, plastocyanin and ferredoxin, allow great flexibility in the actual
photosynthetic rates achieved by various
membranes. This can be illustrated by a
brief comparison of sun and shade plants 1.
Sun plants have high rates of photosynthesis per unit chlorophyll and much higher
ratios of stroma-exposed to appressed
membranes than shade plants. Because of
the marked lateral heterogeneity of the
complexes, this means sun plants have
higher amounts of photosystem I complex
and ATP synthetase, hence greater rates of
photosynthesis. On the other hand, shade
plants, which receive only limited illumination, need to have greater amounts of
photosystem II and light-harvesting complexes. Shade plants have giant grana
stacks and only limited areas of stroma
thylakoids, hence they have less photosystern I complex and ATP synthetase; in turn
they have much lower rates of maximal
photosynthesis, which are saturated at
lower light intensities than in sun plants ~.
Lateral asymmetry in the distribution of
complexes ensures great versatility in the
functioning of photosynthetic membranes,
an important factor for plants which must
exist in a great variety of environmental
conditions.
References