Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 9 July 2013
Received in revised form 17 April 2014
Accepted 28 April 2014
Available online 24 May 2014
Keywords:
Vegetable oil
Cutting uids
Oil-in-water emulsication
Atomization
Micro-milling
a b s t r a c t
Signicant amount of work is reported on development of vegetable oil based metalworking uids
(MWFs). Many also report on development and performance evaluation of vegetable based oils. For
many of these water-based MWFs with vegetable oils, much effort is focused on stable emulsication of
vegetable oil in water using a variety of surfactants. It has been found that surfactant-free stable emulsication of oil in water is possible through ultrasonic vibration. However, emulsication through ultrasonic
atomization has not yet been considered, and the feasibility of emulsied metalworking uids through
ultrasonic atomization has not been investigated. In this paper, stable emulsication of vegetable oil in
water has been achieved through ultrasonic atomization without using any surfactant. The emulsied
vegetable oil in water is directly used to investigate its effectiveness as MWF in milling operations. Lower
cutting forces, chip thickness, and burr amount are observed with vegetable oil-in-water emulsion compared to conventional MWF. The experimental results show strong potential for vegetable oil-in-water
emulsion obtained through ultrasonic atomization as an effective MWF.
2014 Published by Elsevier Ltd. on behalf of The Society of Manufacturing Engineers.
1. Introduction
Cutting uids or metalworking uids (MWFs) are extensively
used to cool and lubricate, ush away chips, and inhibit corrosion
during machining operations such as drilling, turning, and grinding. Metalworking uids lead to increased tool life, improved work
quality, enhanced machine tool life, effective chip management,
and reduced process variability. Due to their advantages, the consumption of MWFs is increasing in the machining industry. It is
reported that over 7.5 billion liters of cutting uids were used by
North American manufacturers in 2002 [1]. Because most MWFs
are petroleum-based oils and at least two-thirds of used MWFs
need to be treated and disposed every year, the cost of waste
uid treatment is substantial [2]. Moreover, the treatment is not
always completely effective, and disposal may lead to inadvertent
environmental contamination. In addition to the environmental
challenges, use of MWFs also introduces several health and safety
concerns. The US National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health (NIOSH) estimates that 1.2 million workers are exposed to
MWFs annually and reports health-related issues due to exposure
to MWFs [3]. Although substantial changes to the composition of
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2014.04.005
1526-6125/ 2014 Published by Elsevier Ltd. on behalf of The Society of Manufacturing Engineers.
406
407
Fig. 6. A photograph of the collected solution and solution from the atomization
chamber at 20% oil.
408
Fig. 11. Tool wear photographs at different MWF conditions after milling 25 slots.
3. Micro-milling experiments
3.1. Experimental setup
Fig. 10. Resultant cutting forces with different cutting uid conditions at the feed
rates of (a) 0.3 and (b) 1.0 m/tooth.
409
Fig. 12. SEM photographs of generated aluminum chips with dry, TRIM 5%, and canola oil-in-water emulsion (scale bar = 200 m).
Fig. 13. SEM photographs of aluminum chip thickness at the feed rate of 1.0 m/ute with dry, TRIM 5%, and canola oil-in-water emulsion (scale bar = 5 m).
410
milled (Fig. 11). As expected, more wear is observed with dry cutting. There seems to be slightly more wear with 5% TRIM. At the feed
rate of 1.0 m/tooth, hardly any wear is observed with canola oilin-water emulsion, whereas much more wear is seen with the use
of 5% TRIM solution. This conrms better lubricity achieved with
the use of canola oil-in-water emulsion.
3.2.3. Chip morphology
Chips generated during slot-milling were carefully collected and
examined to verify the chip morphology and thickness. Fig. 12
shows the SEM images of the chips generated at the feed rates
of 0.3 and 1.0 m/tooth with dry cutting, 5% TRIM, and canola
oil-in-water emulsion. The chips generated with both canola oilin-water emulsion and 5% TRIM show smaller and discontinuous
than those with dry cutting, likely due to improved cooling with
the use of atomized cutting uids [10]. Chips generated with both
5% TRIM and canola oil-in-water emulsion are similar in shape and
size. Fig. 13 shows thickness of the chips generated at the feed
rate of 1.0 m/ute. The chips generated with canola oil-in-water
emulsion seem to be thinner than those with 5% TRIM. The chip
thickness is the thickest with dry cutting. The thin chip with canola
oil-in-water emulsion provided indirect validation of the improved
lubricity effect since thinner chips are caused by higher shear angle,
which is due to decrease in the friction forces.
Table 1
Number of slots machined for steel before tool failure.
Feed rate (m/tooth)
0.3
1.0
Cutting uids
Dry
5% TRIM
Oil-in-water emulsion
3
7
4
9
5
13
Fig. 15. Average resultant cutting forces over the number of slots machined before
tool failure with different cutting uid conditions at the feed rates of (a) 0.3 and (b)
1.0 m/tooth.
411
Fig. 16. Tool wear photographs at different MWF conditions after milling 2 slots.
of slots was taken for calculating averages values so that the same
number of slots is taken for all three conditions. Because the tool
failed subsequently under the dry cutting condition while the tools
survived in other conditions, these were the maximum number of
slots possible. As shown in Fig. 15, lower cutting forces are observed
with the canola oil-in-water emulsion at both feed rates, compared
to conventional cutting uids (5% TRIM). This explains why the tool
was able to machine more slots with canola oil-in-emulsion.
3.3.2. Tool wears
Fig. 16 shows optical microscope images taken to observe the
cutting edge of the tool after machining two slots. As expected,
signicantly more wear is observed with dry cutting. Also, cutting edges are almost worn out at the feed rate of 0.3 m/tooth,
due to excessive ploughing and rubbing. There seems to be slightly
less wear with canola oil-in-water emulsion than 5% TRIM at both
Fig. 17. SEM photographs of generated steel chips with dry, TRIM 5%, and canola oil-in-water emulsion (scale bar = 400 m).
412
Fig. 18. SEM photographs of steel chip thickness at the feed rate of 1.0 m/tooth with dry, TRIM 5%, and canola oil-in-water emulsion (scale bar = 10 m).
Fig. 19. Photographs of burrs formed on slot top surfaces after machining two slots at the feed rates of 0.3 and 1.0 m/tooth.
feed rates. These results are in agreement with the number of slots
machined before tool failure given in Table 1 and cutting force
results in Fig. 15.
3.3.3. Chip morphology
Chips generated during machining were carefully collected and
examined to verify the chip morphology and thickness. Fig. 17
shows the SEM images of the chips generated at the feed rates of
0.3 and 1.0 m/tooth with dry cutting, 5% TRIM, and canola oil-inwater emulsion. Similar to the aluminum chips, chips generated
with both canola oil-in-water emulsion and 5% TRIM are smaller
and discontinuous than those with dry cutting. It seems that chips
generated with canola oil-in-water emulsion are slightly shorter
than those with 5% TRIM. The chip thickness at the feed rate of
1.0 m/tooth is shown in Fig. 18. As shown, the chip thickness is
thinnest with canola oil-in-water emulsion while it is the thickest
with dry cutting. This agrees with the aluminum cutting results, and
this indirectly shows that better cooling and lubricity was provided
with oil-in-water emulsion.
3.3.4. Burr formation
Fig. 19 shows photographs of burrs generated on top of the
second slot after machining. The amount of generated burrs
with dry cutting is signicantly larger, especially at the low feed
rate. It shows that the amount of burrs decreased substantially
with the use of oil-in-water emulsion. Increasing the feed rate
to 1.0 m/ute decreased formation of top burrs signicantly.
Increase in the mount of burrs at the low feed rate is likely due to
increased rubbing and ploughing associated with small uncut chip
thickness close to the minimum chip thickness. Consistent with
results given above, results with canola oil-in-water seem to be the
best among the tree conditions examined. This shows signicant
improvement in cutting uid application because, although the
use of surfactants and additives are eliminated, the cutting results
are similar to or better than when conventional cutting uids
are used.
4. Conclusions
The following conclusions can be drawn from the work of this
paper:
Stable emulsication of vegetable oil (canola) in water can be
achieved through ultrasonic atomization without use of any surfactant.
Vegetable oil in water emulsion with the same concentration is
obtained regardless of ratio of oil and water within the atomization chamber when ultrasonic atomization is used to generate
the oil-in-water emulsion.
Reduction in peak-to-valley values of the resultant cutting force
is achieved for both materials examined (Al6061 and Steel 1018)
with the use of the canola oil-in-emulsion compared to the conventional MWF (5% TRIM).
Thinner chip thickness and less burr amount with the use of
canola oil-in-water emulsion indicate that better lubrication is
achieved compared to conventional MWF (5% TRIM).
The results of this paper show potential for vegetable oil-in-water
emulsion obtained through ultrasonic atomization as an effective
and environmentally friendly MWF without the use of surfactants.
Acknowledgement
The authors would like to gratefully acknowledge the nancial support of the Discovery and Engage program of the National
Science and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) of Canada.
References
[1] Adler DP, Hii WW-S, Michalek DJ, Sutherland JW. Examining the role of cutting uids in machining and efforts to address associated environmental/health
concerns. Mach Sci Technol 2006;10:2358.
[2] Abdalla HS, Baines W, McLntyre G, Slade C. Development of novel sustainable
neat-oil metal working uids for stainless steel and titanium alloy machining:
Part 1. Formulation development. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2007;34:2133.
[3] NIOSH. Criteria for a recommended standard occupational exposure to metalworking uids. NIOSH report. Cincinnati, OH; 1998.
[4] NIOSH. Metal working uids recommendation for chronic inhalation studies.
NIOSH report. Cincinnati, OH; 2001.
[5] Norrby T. Environmentally adapted lubricants where are the opportunities?
Ind Lubr Tribol 2003;55:26874.
[6] Clarens AF, Zimmerman JB, Keoleian GA, Hayes KF, Skerlos SJ. Comparison
of life cycle emissions and energy consumption for environmentally adapted
metalworking uid systems. Environ Sci Technol 2008;42:853440.
[7] Filipovic A, Stephenson DA. Minimum quantity lubrication (MQL) applications
in automotive power-train machining. Mach Sci Technol 2006;10:322.
[8] Furness R, Stoll A, Nordstrom G, Martini G, Johnson J, Loch T, et al. Minimum
quantity lubrication (MQL) machining for complex powertrain components.
In: Proceedings of the international conference on manufacturing science and
engineering. Ypsilanti, MI, United States: American Society of Mechanical Engineers; 2006.
413
[9] Skerlos SJ, Hayes KF, Clarens AF, Fu Z. Current advances in sustainable metalworking uids research. Int J Sustain Manuf 2008;1:180202.
[10] Jun MBG, Joshi SS, DeVor RE, Kapoor SG. An experimental evaluation of
an atomization-based cutting uid application system for micromachining. J
Manuf Sci Eng 2008;130:0311118.
[11] Siniawski MT, Saniei N, Adhikari B, Doezema LA. Inuence of fatty acid composition on the tribological performance of two vegetable-based lubricants. J
Synth Lubr 2007;24:10110.
[12] Zimmerman JB, Clarens AF, Hayes KF, Skerlos SJ. Design of hard water stable
emulsier systems for petroleum- and bio-based semi-synthetic metalworking
uids. Environ Sci Technol 2003;37:527888.
[13] John J, Bhattacharya M, Raynor PC. Emulsions containing vegetable oils
for cutting uid application. Colloids Surf A: Physicochem Eng Aspects
2004;237:14150.
[14] Singh AK, Gupta AK. Metal working uids from vegetable oils. J Synth Lubr
2006;23:16776.
[15] Raynor PC, Kim SW, Bhattacharya M. Mist generation from metalworking uids
formulated using vegetable oils. Ann Occup Hyg 2005;49:28393.
[16] Shashidhara YM, Jayaram SR. Vegetable oils as a potential cutting uid an
evolution. Tribol Int 2010;43:107381.
[17] Gryglewicz S, Piechocki W, Gryglewicz G. Preparation of polyol esters based on
vegetable and animal fats. Bioresour Technol 2003;87:359.
[18] Alves SM, de Oliveira JFG. Development of new cutting uid for grinding process
adjusting mechanical performance and environmental impact. J Mater Process
Technol 2006;179:1859.
[19] Sakai T. Surfactant-free emulsions. Curr Opin Colloid Interface Sci 2008;13:
22835.
[20] Kamogawa K, Akatsuka H, Matsumoto M, Yokoyama S, Sakai T, Sakai H, et al.
Surfactant-free O/W emulsion formation of oleic acid and its esters with
ultrasonic dispersion. Colloids Surf A: Physicochem Eng Aspects 2001;180:
4153.
[21] Kamogawa K, Matsumoto M, Kobayashi T, Sakai T, Sakai H, Abe M. Dispersion
and stabilizing effects of n-hexadecane on tetralin and benzene metastable
droplets in surfactant-free conditions. Langmuir 1999;15:19137.
[22] Kamogawa K, Okudaira G, Matsumoto M, Sakai T, Sakai H, Abe M. Preparation of oleic acid/water emulsions in surfactant-free condition by sequential
processing using midsonicmegasonic waves. Langmuir 2004;20:20437.
[23] Rukosuyev M, Goo CS, Jun MBG. Understanding the effects of the system parameters of an ultrasonic cutting uid application system for micro-machining. J
Manuf Process 2010;12:928.
[24] Rukosuyev M, Goo CS, Jun MBG, Park SS. Design and development of cutting
uid system based on ultrasonic atomization for micro-machining. Trans N Am
Manuf Res Inst SME 2010;38:97104.