Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Slide 7
Thesis (1)
A
COTAC Conference 20 November 2014
1 November 2014
Slide 8
Slide 9
Thesis (2)
Antithesis
The
Slide 10
Traditional
Slide 11
Synthesis (1)
Loss
Synthesis (2)
Adaptive
Slide 12
Slide 13
The Risks
Protection of Heritage
Slide 14
Slide 15
Slide 16
ISBN 978-1-84917-035-2
www.historic-scotland.gov.uk/v1/
product_detail.htm?productid=1783
Refer also to NFPA 909:2013 Code
for the Protection of Cultural
Resources
Slide 17
A La Ronde, Exmouth
Unique 16-sided, domestic property
dating from late 18th Century
A tiny jewel in the NT crown
Structure is subordinate to contents
Seashell Gallery is very fragile
viewed by video
2008 FRA noted: that although
desirableany improved
compartmentation would severely
impact on vulnerable fabric. Upper
structure and stairs are timber.
Consideration should be given to an
AFSS
Sprinkler protected since 2012
Slide 18
Slide 19
Schnbrunn Palace
World Heritage Site
Most visited attraction in
Austria
Sprinklers form key part
of its fire protection
programme
Roof spaces, basements,
ground floor and utility
areas are protected
Underground tank and
pumps
Slide 20
Slide 21
Slide 22
Slide 23
Service
A Listed
B Listed
C Listed
Total
Cooking
120
Central
12
17
Electrical Appliances/Installations
119
12
Deliberate
71
Fife
19
Smoking Materials
36
Grampian
43
12
60
Heating Appliances
31
11
19
External Sources
12
30
130
71
249
Hot Work
10
Unknown
Strathclyde
No Data Available
Tayside
23
11
42
Candles
Totals
62
244
112
428
Chemical Reaction
Slide 24
Slide 25
Slide 26
Listed
Slide 27
Ignition sources
Fuel load
Staff
External/arson
Compartmentation
Detection
Intervention and staff fire fighting
Automatic fire suppression
Ventilation and smoke control
Salvage/Damage Limitation
Slide 28
Slide 29
Slide 30
Slide 31
Automatic Suppression
For
a wholly
independent view refer
to BS 5306 Part 0: 2011
Gas systems
Inert gases
Halocarbon gases
New generation gases
Powder systems
Air inerting/oxygen reduction
Water based systems
Sprinklers
Water mist
Foam
Slide 32
Slide 33
Trade Names
Chemical Composition
IG-01
Argotec, Argonfire
Argon 100%
IG-55
Argonite
IG-541
Inergen*
FE-36
C3H2F6
FK-5-1-12
NOVEC 1230
C6F12O
Slide 34
In a word, NO !
In two words, please, NO, NO !
Powder is hygroscopic and will
bake on to stone, wood, brass,
glass and fabric
Powder has no place in buildings
with heritage fabric and fine
objects
Spalding Parish Church
Willful discharge of one 6kg dry
powder extinguisher resulted in
cleanup costs of 350,000 and
litigation
Slide 35
Sprinklers Pr
Pros
Other Alternatives
Air Inerting (Hypoxic)
Systems
Reduces oxygen levels to
below 16/17% to prevent
combustion
Superficially attractive for
heritage protection
Can be used for large new
book/art storage buildings
But:
Compartmental integrity?
Energy costs?
Life safety?
Noise issues?
Foam
Offers no benefits over
water (sprinklers and mist)
Still requires water supply,
pumps and pipework and
visible discharge heads
Some foam compounds are
slightly acidic
Foam compound costs have
increased significantly
Some foam compounds
may cause environmental
damage when discharged
into drains or watercourses
Slide 36
Slide 37
Sprinklers Cons
Co
Watermist
Slide 38
Slide 39
Black steel
Stainless steel
Copper
Listed CPVC
Slide 40
Case Studies
Corgarff Castle
Royal Apartments, Stirling Castle
Pipework Choices
CPVC Benefits
But:
Smaller diameters
Flexible for insertion in voids etc
Cleaner cutting
No need for heated jointing
Should only be used in wet systems
In UK, should only be used in R&D/
Light Hazard & OH 1 systems
Jointing/solvent is critical
Should only be installed by trained
operatives using approved
handbook
Restrictions on unprotected use
See TB 227 of LPC Sprinkler Rules
New LPS 1260 will cover installation
standards including training
Slide 41
Remote location
Poor access often
impossible often between
December and March
Restricted fire and rescue
service response
Poor site utilities and services
Single wooden staircase
extends height of building
Crown Fire Inspectors Report
proposed restrictions on use
of building and exclusion of
upper floors as education
resource
Scheduled Ancient Monument
status restricted opportunities
for changes/improvements
and excavation
Slide 42
Slide 43
Slide 44
Slide 45
Slide 46
Slide 47
The oldest UK
building to be fully
protected by an
automatic fire
suppression system.
May be the oldest in
Europe/the world as
while there are
slightly older
protected buildings
in Venice, these
have partial systems
in roof spaces only
Slide 48
Slide 50
Slide 49
Slide 51
Slide 52
Actuation temperature = 57 C
Slide 53
Slide 54
Slide 55
Additional Benefits
Thesis Sustained?
It is possible to install AFSS in even very old buildings given
proper planning and coordination
Property protection systems will always also provide enhanced
life safety for occupants - and firefighters
Close liaison with the client and architect can pay huge dividends
- eg client provision of craftsmen to make penetrations, chase
plaster and making good, as well as preplanning of pipe runs
Mist and sprinkler heads can be sited for minimal visual intrusion
and visible heads can be camouflaged
Pumps and tanks can be shoehorned into very small spaces and
pumps can be powered by single phase electricity supplies
Joint commissioning approach involving the f&rs can be very
effective in resolving minor issues
Both Project Objectives satisfied:
A very expensive refurbishment of an internationally-important historic
building is now protected by automatic suppression system
A second, nationally-significant heritage building and educational resource
remains open, accessible and protected 24/7
Slide 56
1 November 2014