6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

(https://www.techinasia.com) Search

Stream

Join Now (https://www.techinasia.com/register)

Sign In (https://www.techinasia.com/login)

ASIA (HTTPS://WWW.TECHINASIA.COM/CATEGORY/ASIA/)

(https://www.techinasia.com)
Trending
(https://www.techinasia.com)
Latest

Why does China Copy Designs? (https://www.techinasia.com/whydoes-china-copy-designs/)

(https://www.techinasia.com/latest)
TIA Stories
7
(https://www.techinasia.com/why(https://www.techinasia.com/editorial)
Find Startups
doeschina(https://www.techinasia.com/startup)
Find Investors
copydesigns/)
TIA Conference
(https://www.techinasia.com/investor)

Design Translator ( https://www.techinasia.com/author/designsojourn/)

12:10 am on May 17, 2007

(http://events.techinasia.com/tokyo2015/)
Events Calendar
(https://www.techinasia.com/tech(https://www.techinasia.com/author/designsojourn/)

11

startup-events)

US has Google, EBay and 2nd Life and China has Baidu, AliBaba and HiPiHi. In each of the
example, for every US company which makes it work, China will have a carbon copy. This is
reminiscent of Japan in the early 1970s, where they copied and innovated upon the
electronic gadgets and cars. Our resident contributor, Brian Ling
(http://www.designsojourn.com) provides some thoughts about why China copy designs and where this is all
leading to.
Contributed by Design Translator

This post started as an interesting discussion in another post, when a Design Sojourn
(http://www.designsojourn.com) reader wondered why China suffers from this syndrome of copying product
designs from the West. Im no expert on this but having worked with Designers and Vendors from China, as well
as frequent trips there, I would like to give my take on this issue.

https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

1/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

as frequent trips there, I would like to give my take on this issue.

Firstly I need to say I am not trying to defend China nor give any excuse on this issue. This is because the reasons
are rather largely due to cultural factors. In the end I would like to see this post as bridging the cultural gap
between the East and West, by hopefully allowing both sides to understand each other better.
Now lets jump right in.
When I deal with China on the design front, this copying issue becomes a whole other ball game. For one, the
reality of enforcement is not easy possible to do, but not easy. In particular for the medium to smaller Chinese
companies where funding is limited
, I have to work out design strategies that actually deal with and possibly
counter this issue. In reality many companies dont even worry about protecting their designs as its a zero sum
game in their mind. Ill explain a little more about this later.
With the 2008 Olympic Games in Beijing, things are starting to change but in reality the mindset is so ingrained in
the culture it will be difficult to change.
1) Top down living
Dont forget despite all the changes in China, its still a Communist country with a Capitalistic business system.
Special Economic Regions I think they are called. However in reality its still a very top down managed country, a
big brother approach to the culture, and a huge disparity in the rich and poor. Everyone is answerable to the
person above him and thinking out of the box
is not encouraged.
As a result many take a safe approach towards things, and this has far reaching implications.
2) Business decisions are about justified returns
In China almost everything is a business decision. When you grow up in a country where life is cheap, things do
get brutal and money talks. There is no area for the softer aspects of the business, like branding, experience and
emotive products etc. These things are intangible and hard to justify as many decisions are made using an ROI
(Return of Investment) as a base. Money put out equals more money back. Its the best way to make money, but
things start to get very crazy when it goes too far.
Put it this way, its commonly known that Chinese rather spend USD$100/Hr on English lessons than hiring design
consultants. At this time the softer aspects of a business are just not a priority. Want to make money in China?

https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

2/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

consultants. At this time the softer aspects of a business are just not a priority. Want to make money in China?
Teach English.
Another example is patents (https://www.techinasia.com/startup-dictionary/patent/) are only taken out for a
product if it can be later sold, or licensed for royalties. In other words patents are seen as offensive
in the East as
compared to defensive in the West. The viewpoints are actually similar, but there is a subtle difference on how
patents are viewed.
This business mindset is also applies to their interesting view that the world is made from an equal specification
.
OEMs (Original Equipment Manufacture) and most Chinese consumer electronics companies belief that all
products are the same, and its all about taking that product, change its color, tweak a few corners and perhaps its
shape and resell it. Why spend money to make it a little different when 90% of it is all the same anyway. Sounds
like the West a few decades ago, does it not?
3) Money is not the issue, its the risk factor
This lack of risk taking, wanting justified returns, and ROI focused decisions, often leads Chinese consumer
electronics companies down the path of copying a successful designs (such as the iPod). Its logical if you think
about it, though its not really the right thing to do.

Also if you look back in history, its no different from the post-war Industrial Age of Japans move of taking Western
designs and improving on it. China borders have just open up and the softer aspects of design and branding, they
have yet to grasps, but not for long.
Oh dont get me wrong. This is not always an issue about money. The larger companies especially have the money
and are willing to buy design. However there is neither risk management nor contingency plans for introducing a
product to the Market that bucks the consumer trend.
I once consulted and worked with a Chinese company that spent a boat load of money engaging Luigi Colani to do
some design work for them. They related to me it was firstly hell working with famous designers, and secondly the
final design they received was nice but so radical that they could not risk the tooling investment to launch it. They
also felt that the market could not stomach a product of such a visual nature. Perhaps they made a wrong choice

https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

3/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

also felt that the market could not stomach a product of such a visual nature. Perhaps they made a wrong choice
by using Colani for their brand, but I think you see my point.
4) Master Apprentice and student, and the learning system at large
There are some Joint Ventures with western companies in China, but in general copies you see are really just
copies. Personally I think, this whole activity stems from their cultural background and the way Art and Design has
been taught throughout the ages in China.
Chinese Apprentice artists seek and hope to be taken in (ie. looked after) for many years of study under a
Master. Under tutorledge of the Master Artist, the student then follows or emulates the Masters style and
process. Therefore the master imparts his style to that student, leaving very little for external thought or
exploration. Kinda like that 132 moves of the crane, crouching tiger hidden dragon jazz. This is also very much like
in Europe during the Renaissance era, where students seek masters as they truly believe are that best at what
they want to do.

Fast forward to today, this is also similar to (I dare say) most design schools in China where students come from a
rote learning high school background and are thought to follow instead of think. At school they look to famous
designers and architects as examples, and their work naturally becomes very thematic or contain the safest forms
of expression. Furthermore it is expected that Schools focus on technical skills instead to thinking skills, as
learning about creativity is about following a set way of doing things.
Take a look at this quotation from Core 77 (http://www.core77.com/reactor/08.04_china.asp), it follows along the
same line of thinking.

INQUISITIVE ADVANTAGE. However, even as schools pop up, few have evolved from a
classical focus on aesthetics and products to embrace design thinking and research of
the nature that HK Polytechnic promotes. The best Asian schools provide students
with first-rate technical skills, but their graduates leave without the ability to work
https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

4/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

across disciplines or to use design strategically. Theyre not about to do much

business model innovation, for example. Much of this may be attributed to Asian
education systems from primary school on, which still tend to stress repetition over
independent thinking. Says Justice: The U.S. has a quick advantage. We grow up
asking questions. This carries over into our advanced education. They dont have that
in China, and it will take them years to develop that mindset.

5) Consumers not brand conscious

Many companies also copy because the vast majority of many Chinese consumers are not brand conscious but
form conscious. If they like a look or form, its not too difficult to guess that the next decision is not brand but
price. Thats why many companies were falling all over themselves to get into China. A fertile ground of untapped
minds that have no preconceived notion of a brand except that foreign is good. Fortunately of late, Branding (LV,
Alessi and Apple etc.) in China has become very successful with people shunning copies, however its still a
difficult process and there are many mindsets to change.
The Chinese consumers values and what is important to them are so different to us, we cannot even begin to
imagine.
6) Willing to learn and improve and are copying to learn
Now comes to the most frightening part of my discussion. China has realized that they are actually very far behind
the rest of the world under the rule of the Communist styled government. However with their borders now open,
their have a ZEAL and hunger to learn bordering on fanatical. All this is so that they can catch up with the West
whom they look towards as a place of a better life. What took the West to develop through their
industrial/information age, is taking China 1/5 of the time, and perhaps even quicker.
Similar to Japan, copying is only the first step. Once they learn about the inner workings of how things are done
the skys the limit.
https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

One of my ex-colleagues recounted a story about a Chinese Manufacturer proudly showing him

5/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

the skys the limit. One of my ex-colleagues recounted a story about a Chinese Manufacturer proudly showing him
a 100% perfect copy of a German MRI machine at 1/10 of the price and a large contract with all the local hospitals.
AN MRI MACHINE! Think about this for a moment.
Unfortunately many western companies fall off their rockers when their products are copied and react
accordingly. I dont blame them.

However, in Chinese culture, its really about the fact that copying is the greatest form of flattery. Trust me, they
do not waste their time copying the market failures. They copy who they think the market leaders are and only to
learn how they got where they are. There are also many equally horrible stories of Joint Ventures going sour when
the Chinese partner runs off after learning all he needs to know.
Therefore getting them to change is more about changing something so ingrained in the culture, and is almost
impossible to do quickly. However the Wests tendency of focusing on this copying issue is really looking at the
trees instead of the forest, as China will quickly move past this stage and start to create their own innovations
very quickly. As it is companies such as Lenovo and Haier are already in the forefront of this new design
movement. So I do suggest that companies get over the copying issue quickly, and look ahead and focus on their
market positioning, branding, and strategic thinking.
Edit: Im always an optimist at heart and tend to see the good in people more often than not. In this discussion, though
slightly positive, there are always exceptions to the rule. I do know that there are manufacturers in China who knowingly
copy just to ride the wave for the sole purpose of making a quick buck. These are also same many factories in China that
close down daily. Fortunately for me, as a design consultant then, I never had to deal with them and probably never will.
Related Links:
Brian wrote a follow up in his own blog: Is China the only copier on the block?
(http://www.designsojourn.com/index.php/2007/05/23/is-china-the-only-copier-on-the-block/) as a follow up to
this post.

https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

6/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

11

REPLIES
7Comments
Recommend

TechinAsia

Share

Login

SortbyBest

Jointhediscussion
Juaniperz 4yearsago

Thatsnotanexcuse

Reply Share

Jao 5yearsago

AfterlivinginChinaIwilltellyothattheyarebecomingmoreandmorebrandconscious.AndwithChinesesalariessetto
increase,brandingwillplayanimportantfactorinChina.WhydotheChinesecopydesignsandstealtechnology?Itcutsthe
timetocatchupwithEuropeandU.S.A.dramtically.Also,R&Disquiteexpensiveandtimeconsumingsoitmakesperfect
sensetofollowwhatworksandmakeityourown.

Reply Share

encikwan 8yearsago

Yes,tosucceedinChinaandotheremergingmarkets,youneedtotakealongtermview,e.g.morethantenyears.Another
similarstory:HowMicrosoftconqueredChina(http://money.cnn.com/magazines...

Reply Share

DesignTranslator 8yearsago

IthinksolifeishardinChina,andeveryoneishungry.Nomercyfortheweak.Youjustneedtoseethewaytheyliveto
understandit.

Reply Share

nazlihaffiz 8yearsago

Goodarticle.
I'mquiteintriguedbytheChinese,theycouldeasilysurvivethroughanyplaceoranysituations.
Perhapstheyareanevolutionaryrace?

Reply Share

Jeremy 8yearsago

https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

7/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

Jeremy 8yearsago

Wellwrittenarticle.Youraisedmanygoodpoints.
Interestingly,therewasanarticleonTechcrunchtheotherdayabouthowtherearesomanyGermanweb2.0clones.
http://www.techcrunch.com/2007...

Reply Share

chup 8yearsago

heythanksforthegoodarticle,oneofthebetterpostihavereadsofar:)

Subscribe

Reply Share

AddDisqustoyoursite

Privacy

READ MORE

(https://www.techinasia.com/an-informalmeeting-with-xu-hui-ceo-of-hipihi/)
An informal meeting with Xu Hui, CEO of
HiPiHi (https://www.techinasia.com/aninformal-meeting-with-xu-hui-ceo-ofhipihi/)

(https://www.techinasia.com/chineseclone-second-life-hipihi/)
The Chinese clone of Second Life: HiPiHi
(https://www.techinasia.com/chineseclone-second-life-hipihi/)

(https://www.techinasia.com/silicondragon-rebecca-fannin/)
The Entrepreneur's Bookshelf: Silicon
Dragon - How China is winning the Tech
Race (https://www.techinasia.com/silicondragon-rebecca-fannin/)

EXCLUSIVE

https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

Penang is on its way to becoming the Silicon Valley of the East, and IoT is how
(https://www.techinasia.com/penang-silicon-valley-of-east-iot/?
utm_source=sidebar-exclusive-posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=penang-

8/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

(https://www.techinasia.com/penang-silicon-valleyof-east-iot/?utm_source=sidebar-exclusiveposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=penangsilicon-valley-of-east-iot)

(https://www.techinasia.com/mobile-industry-4gupgrade-indonesia/?utm_source=sidebarexclusiveposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=mobileindustry-4g-upgrade-indonesia)

(https://www.techinasia.com/fintech-unbankedfinancial-inclusion/?utm_source=sidebar-exclusiveposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=fintechunbanked-financial-inclusion)

(https://www.techinasia.com/angels-rush-wherevcs-fear/?utm_source=sidebar-exclusiveposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=angelsrush-where-vcs-fear)

utm_source=sidebar-exclusive-posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=penangsilicon-valley-of-east-iot)
By Daniel Tay

Indonesias smartphone revolution starts now

(https://www.techinasia.com/mobile-industry-4g-upgrade-indonesia/?
utm_source=sidebar-exclusive-posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=mobileindustry-4g-upgrade-indonesia)
By Nadine Freischlad

Fintech can be the unbankeds best hope for financial inclusion

(https://www.techinasia.com/fintech-unbanked-financial-inclusion/?
utm_source=sidebar-exclusive-posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=fintechunbanked-financial-inclusion)
By Michael Tegos

Angels rush in where VCs fear to tread in India

(https://www.techinasia.com/angels-rush-where-vcs-fear/?utm_source=sidebarexclusive-posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=angels-rush-where-vcs-fear)
By Nikita Peer

O2Overload: the past, present, and future of Chinas on-demand explosion

(https://www.techinasia.com/past-present-future-of-china-on-demand-startupsexplosion/?utm_source=sidebar-exclusive(https://www.techinasia.com/past-presentposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=past-present-future-of-china-on-demandfuture-of-china-on-demand-startups-explosion/? startups-explosion)
utm_source=sidebar-exclusiveBy C. Custer
posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=pastpresent-future-of-china-on-demand-startupsexplosion)

FOLLOW US
(https://www.facebook.com/techinasia)

(https://twitter.com/techinasia)

(https://www.linkedin.com/company/techinasia)
https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

(https://plus.google.com/+techinasiacom)

(https://www.youtube.com/user/TechinAsia)
9/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

(https://www.linkedin.com/company/techinasia)

(https://www.youtube.com/user/TechinAsia)

FEATURED

(https://www.techinasia.com/tia-podcastepisode-8-news-roundup-june-1519/?
utm_source=sidebar-featuredposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=tiapodcast-episode-8-news-roundup-june-1519)

TiA podcast episode 8: robots, video games, and taxi app madness
(https://www.techinasia.com/tia-podcast-episode-8-news-roundup-june-1519/?
utm_source=sidebar-featured-posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=tia-podcastepisode-8-news-roundup-june-1519)
By C. Custer

(https://www.techinasia.com/china-dating-apppeople-locate-lost-kids/?utm_source=sidebarfeaturedposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=chinadating-app-people-locate-lost-kids)

(https://www.techinasia.com/5-ramadanapps-muslims/?utm_source=sidebarfeaturedposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=5-

In China, a popular social network is asking people to help locate lost kids
(https://www.techinasia.com/china-dating-app-people-locate-lost-kids/?
utm_source=sidebar-featured-posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=chinadating-app-people-locate-lost-kids)
By Rohan Malhotra

5 apps to help Muslims observe the holy month of Ramadan

(https://www.techinasia.com/5-ramadan-apps-muslims/?utm_source=sidebar-featuredposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=5-ramadan-apps-muslims)
By Osman Husain

ramadan-apps-muslims)
Pepper robot goes on sale as SoftBank announces $589M joint venture with
Alibaba, Foxconn (https://www.techinasia.com/pepper-sale-softbank-announcesjoint-venture-alibaba-foxconn/?utm_source=sidebar-featured(https://www.techinasia.com/pepper-sale-softbank- posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=pepper-sale-softbank-announces-jointannounces-joint-venture-alibaba-foxconn/?
venture-alibaba-foxconn)
utm_source=sidebar-featuredBy Colin Moreshead
posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=peppersale-softbank-announces-joint-venture-alibabafoxconn)
This startup wants to end Bangladeshs deadly food scares
(https://www.techinasia.com/startup-end-bangladesh-deadly-supply-chain/?
https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

10/11

6/21/2015

WhydoesChinaCopyDesigns?

(https://www.techinasia.com/startup-endbangladesh-deadly-supply-chain/?
utm_source=sidebar-featuredposts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=startupend-bangladesh-deadly-supply-chain)

(https://www.techinasia.com/startup-end-bangladesh-deadly-supply-chain/?
utm_source=sidebar-featured-posts&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=startupend-bangladesh-deadly-supply-chain)
By Osman Husain

ABOUT US (HTTPS://WWW.TECHINASIA.COM/ABOUT-US) EVENTS (HTTP://EVENTS.TECHINASIA.COM)

(HTTPS://MIXPANEL.COM/F/PARTNER)
ETHICS (HTTPS://WWW.TECHINASIA.COM/STATEMENT-OF-ETHICS) JOIN US (HTTPS://WWW.TECHINASIA.COM/JOIN)
CULTURE (HTTPS://WWW.TECHINASIA.COM/CULTURE) CONTACT US (HTTPS://WWW.TECHINASIA.COM/CONTACT-US)

(HTTP://WWW.SOFTLAYER.COM/CATALYST)

COPYRIGHT 2015 TECH IN ASIA. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

https://www.techinasia.com/whydoeschinacopydesigns/

11/11