Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sequence stratigraphy of a
condensed low-accommodation
succession: Lower Upper
Cretaceous Dakota
Sandstone, Henry Mountains,
southeastern Utah
Jonathan Antia and Christopher R. Fielding
ABSTRACT
Cretaceous low-accommodation deposits have been extensively studied in the subsurface of the Western Interior of
North America because of their prolific hydrocarbon production and remaining potential. Understanding the stratigraphic complexities of these deposits in the subsurface relies
strongly on detailed outcrop analogs. In this study, the Dakota
Sandstone was examined along 100 km (62 mi) of semicontinuous outcrop between the towns of Hanksville and Ticaboo
in the Henry Mountains of southeastern Utah. This region
represented a low-accommodation setting located over the
forebulge of the Cretaceous Western Interior Basin during accumulation of the unit. The Dakota Sandstone is 0 to 38 m
(125 ft) thick, of Cenomanian age, and records multiple cycles of sediment accumulation. The Dakota Sandstone is subdivided into two condensed top-truncated stratigraphic sequences, the upper of which contains two parasequences. The
basal parts of both sequences are composed of braided fluvial
conglomerates and sandstone overlain by tidally influenced
fluvial sandstone, inclined heterolithically stratified estuarine
mudstone, carbonaceous shale, and coal. The overlying parasequences consist of coarsening-upward lower to upper shoreface mudstone, sandstone, tidal inlet deposits, and oyster shell
concentrations. These facies define tripartite subdivisions of
depositional environments typical of wave-dominated estuaries.
Copyright 2011. The American Association of Petroleum Geologists. All rights reserved.
Manuscript received November 8, 2009; provisional acceptance January 12, 2010; revised manuscript
received April 3, 2010; final acceptance June 30, 2010.
DOI:10.1306/06301009182
413
MARCH
SEARCH
AUTHORS
Jonathan Antia Core Laboratories, 6316
Windfern Road, Houston, Texas 77040;
jonathan.antia@corelab.com
Jonathan Antia received his Ph.D. in geology
from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln in 2009.
He currently works as a staff geologist at Core
Laboratories in Houston, Texas. His academic
research focused on coastal to shallow marine
siliciclastic depositional systems.
Christopher R. Fielding Geociences
Department, 214 Bessey Hall, University of
Nebraska, Lincoln, Nebraska 68588-0340;
cfielding2@unl.edu
Chris Fielding holds the Mr. & Mrs. J.B. Coffman
Chair in sedimentary geology at the University
of Nebraska-Lincoln. He received his Ph.D. from
the University of Durham (United Kingdom)
in 1982 and previously worked for BP Exploration and the University of Queensland in Brisbane, Australia. His research interests lie in the
stratigraphy of continental, coastal, and shallow
marine successions.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The work presented in this article forms part of
a Ph.D. dissertation at the University of NebraskaLincoln, supported financially by the Mr. &
Mrs. J.B. Coffman Endowment in Sedimentary
Geology, and the AAPG Grants-in-Aid program.
We thank Mark Kirschbaum (U.S. Geological
Survey, Denver) for his guidance in the initial
stages of fieldwork, Lauren Birgenheier for
drafting Figure 1, and the editor (Gretchen Gillis)
and referees (Soledad Garcia Gil, Tom Ryer,
Janok Bhattacharya) for their reviews of the
submitted manuscript.
The AAPG Editor thanks the following reviewers for
their work on this paper: Janok P. Bhattacharya,
Soledad Garcia Gil, and Thomas A. Ryer.
5
4
3
CONTENTS
The fluvial deposits may represent lowstand deposits, but overall sediments accumulated during
transgressive systems tracts (TST). The parasequences recorded in the Henry Mountains are similar to the Dakota Sandstone of northwestern New
Mexico and to high-frequency sequences identified in the Kaiparowits Plateau, approximately
80 km (~50 mi) to the southwest, which suggests
eustatic driving mechanisms.
The best potential for hydrocarbon reservoirs
occurs in fluvial sandstones and conglomerates.
INTRODUCTION
Objectives
The Cretaceous Western Interior seaway (KWIS)
of North America represents one of the best studied sedimentary basins in the world, partly because
it contains multiple prolific hydrocarbon-producing
stratigraphic units throughout its geographic extent (e.g., the D and J sandstones and the Fall River
Formation in the Denver-Julesberg Basin of Colorado and Nebraska, the Muddy Sandstone and
parts of the Frontier Formation in basins throughout Wyoming, the Dakota Sandstone in the Uinta
Basin of Utah and the San Juan Basin of New Mexico, the (Ellerslie Member (also known as the Basal
Quartz Member) of the Manville Group and the
Viking Formation in Alberta, Canada). Many of
these units show laterally and vertically complex
stratigraphic stacking patterns because of their accumulation under accommodation-limited conditions. Many studies have characterized these units
in the subsurface of the region (Pattison and Walker,
1994; Peper, 1994; Walker and Wiseman, 1995;
MacEachern et al., 1998; Snedden and Bergman,
1999; Bhattacharya and Willis, 2001; Zaitlin et al.,
2002; Leckie et al., 2004; Ratcliffe et al., 2004; Crerar
and Arnott, 2007; Currie et al., 2008; Feldman et al.,
2008) and fewer others in outcrop (Willis, 1997;
am Ende, 1991; Leckie and Singh, 1991; Ulin,
1999; Holbrook, 2001; Holbrook et al., 2006; Laurin
and Sageman, 2007). However, the complexity
of these units is commonly difficult to fully assess
from subsurface data because of the laterally lim414
MARCH
SEARCH
ited nature of core and well-log information. Therefore, well-exposed outcrop equivalents of these
units are crucial to the understanding, exploration,
and development of these units in the subsurface.
The Dakota Sandstone represents up to 38 m
(125 ft; average, 10 m [33 ft]) of the lower Upper
Cretaceous section in exposures around the Henry
Mountains syncline of southeastern Utah (Figure 1).
The unit is predominantly sandstone, lies within
a mudrock-dominated succession, and is hydrocarbon prospective in the nearby San Juan and Uinta
basins (Figure 2). The Dakota Sandstone is superbly
exposed in the study area along both limbs of the
Henry Mountains syncline in an outcrop belt that
extends for approximately 100 km (62 mi) from the
town of Hanksville in the north to Ticaboo in the
south (Figure 1). This area is surrounded by wellstudied areas such as the Kaiparowits Plateau approximately 80 km (50 mi) to the west-southwest
(am Ende, 1991; Ulin, 1999; Laurin and Sageman,
2007), the Uinta Basin nearly 80 km (50 mi) to
the north (Figure 2) (Currie et al., 2008), and the
San Juan Basin 100 to 200 km (62124 mi) to
the southeast (Owen, 1969; Aubrey, 1989; Lucas
et al., 1998). In the Kaiparowits Plateau, multiple
high-frequency cycles have been reported from
the Dakota Sandstone (Ulin, 1999; Laurin and
Sageman, 2007) and interpreted to be approximately 100 k.y. in duration and involving relative
sea level fluctuations of 10 to 20 m (3366 ft). In
the San Juan Basin, the unit also contains multiple
cycles of sediment accumulation. The stratigraphic
complexity observed in the surrounding areas suggests that the stratigraphy of the Dakota Sandstone
in the Henry Mountains may be similarly complex.
Therefore, this unit represents an excellent outcrop
analog for similar units in the subsurface throughout
the Cretaceous Western Interior of North America.
The Dakota Sandstone successions in the Kaiparowits Plateau and in the San Juan Basin are significantly thicker than in the Henry Mountains and
represent higher accommodation settings associated with different tectonic realms. Thus, comparison of the Dakota Sandstone from the Kaiparowits
Plateau, through the Henry Mountains, and into
the San Juan Basin provides a cross-orogen transect
of the KWIS during the Cenomanian.
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
Figure 1. Location maps showing (A) the Henry Mountains within the state of Utah (left), (B) a close-up of the Henry Mountains including the location of all measured sections (black
dots), and lines of cross sections AA and BB, and (C) a close-up of the Blue Valley area depicting lines of cross section CC and DD. Abbreviations refer to names given to measured
sections and include BC = Bitter Creek; BT12 = Blind Trail 12; BHG12 = Bloody Hands Gap 12; BV1 = Blue Valley 1; CQ 13 = Caineville quadrangle 13; CCB = Cedar Creek
Benches; CC = Clay Canyon; CW = Collie Wash; CB 12 = Copper Creek Benches 12; DC = Dugout Creek; Eg = Eggnog; HC2 = Halls Creek 2; HO = Halls Creek Overlook; HCE or W =
Hansen Creek East or West; JB = Jet Basin; NCR = North Caineville Reef; SP = Saleratus Point; SW = Saleratus Wash; TP12 = The Post 12.
5
4
3
415
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
GEOLOGIC SETTING
The Dakota Sandstone in the Henry Mountains region preserves a record of middle to late Cenomanian continental and shallow marine sediment
accumulation (Hunt et al., 1953; Lawyer, 1972;
Peterson and Ryder, 1975; Merewether and Cobban,
1986; Cobban et al., 2000). During this time, the
Henry Mountains area was located near the western margin of the North American KWIS, approximately 200 km (124 mi) east of the orogenic front
of the Sevier fold and thrust belt (Figure 3) (Hunt
et al., 1953; Kauffman, 1977; Peterson and Smith,
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
417
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
418
Dakota Sandstone Sequence Stratigraphy, Henry Mountains, Southeastern Utah
Figure 4. Regional stratigraphic framework for the Dakota Sandstone and equivalent units throughout the Western Interior of North America. The location of reference sections is
shown in Figure 2. SB = Sequence Boundary. References used to compile this figure include Ellis (1963), Haun (1963), Harms (1966), Merewether and Cobban (1986), Dyman et al.
(1994), Hamilton (1994), Scott et al. (1998), Brenner et al. (2000), Cobban et al. (2000), Scott et al. (2001), Kirschbaum and Roberts (2005), Currie et al. (2008). The time scale used is
that of Gradstein et al. (2004).
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
Figure 5. Stratigraphic
column for the Albian
Turonian (Cretaceous)
section in southeastern
Utah, sea level curves
for the North American
Western Interior seaway
(Weimer et al., 1988;
Kauffman and Caldwell,
1993) and eustatic curves
(Haq et al., 1987; used
with permission from Science). In the sea level
curves, deepening is to the
left and shallowing is to
the right. The stratigraphic
column was compiled
with reference to am Ende
(1991), Cobban et al.
(2000), and Currie et al.
(2008). The time scale
used is that of Gradstein
et al. (2004). SB = sequence boundary.
across the Colorado Plateau based on relative dating of invertebrate fossil content, including palynomorphs, ammonites, and other molluskan fauna
within it or in adjacent units, and by absolute age
calculations from bentonite layers in overlying units
(Merewether and Cobban, 1986; Cobban et al.,
2000; Currie, 2002; Currie et al., 2008). From east
to west, between the towns of Delta, Colorado,
and Castle Dale, Utah (Figure 2), the Dakota Sandstone has been shown to span the entire Cenomanian stage (Merewether and Cobban, 1986).
Correlation to the east suggests that the Dakota
Sandstone in the Colorado Plateau (Figure 4) is
stratigraphically equivalent to units between the
Horsetooth Member of the Muddy Sandstone at
its earliest and the Thatcher Limestone Member
of the Graneros Shale at its latest, in the Denver
Basin of eastern Colorado (Mellere, 1994; Currie,
2002). Deposition of the lower parts of the Dakota
Sandstone, however, has been interpreted as diachronous and progressively younger from the east
Antia and Fielding
419
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
420
Dakota Sandstone Sequence Stratigraphy, Henry Mountains, Southeastern Utah
Table 1. Description of Facies Identified in the Dakota Sandstone in the Henry Mountains
Facies
Lithology
Sedimentary Structures
No trace fossils
Massive or planar and trough
cross-bedded with some clast
imbrication. Contain lenses of
planar and trough cross-bedded
coarse- to fine-grained sandstone
with common graded bedding.
F1
F2
Medium- to coarse-grained sandstone Massive, planar, and trough crossstratification. Cross-bed sets
with scattered chert pebbles and
range in thickness between
granule to pebble conglomerate
0.1 and 1.5 m and commonly
lenses. Typically brownish red to
contain graded bedding. Soft
orange on weathering surfaces and
sediment deformation structures
light gray, white, or beige on fresh
are common. Nested channel
surfaces. Mudstone rip-up clasts
forms exist in some areas.
occur sparsely at the base.
Trough and planar cross-bedded,
Light gray and yellow, very fine to
parallel horizontal, current, and
medium-grained sandstone and
climbing ripple-laminated tabular
inclined heterolithically stratified
to lenticular layers. Herringbone
(IHS) or horizontal pinstripecross-stratification, sigmoidal
laminated very fine to fine-grained
bedding, paired mud drapes,
sandstone and carbonaceous
and lateral accretion surfaces
mudstone.
exist in some areas. Syneresis
cracks, root traces, coaly plant
debris, and leaf imprints are
common. Pyrite occurs sparsely.
F3
Ichnology
No trace fossils
Facies Associations
Depositional Environment
5
4
3
CONTENTS
F4
F5
F6
F7
MARCH
SEARCH
Flood plain
Tidal inlet
5
4
3
421
CONTENTS
422
Dakota Sandstone Sequence Stratigraphy, Henry Mountains, Southeastern Utah
F8
F9
F10
F11
Well-cemented to uncemented
and framework-supported oyster
shell concentrations with a fineto coarse-grained sandstone
matrix grading upward into the
Tununk Member.
MARCH
SEARCH
Upper shoreface
Lower shoreface
Volcanic ash
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
FACIES ANALYSIS
This study of the Dakota Sandstone involved measuring, describing, and physically correlating stratigraphic sections around the Henry Mountains
syncline. Sections were measured at a variety of locations covering the entire region (Figure 1). Careful consideration was given to the sedimentology,
ichnology, paleocurrent directions, and internal architecture in each section as well as to key surfaces
that could be traced laterally into adjacent sections.
Multiple cross sections were made from north to
south and east to west to constrain the lithostratigraphic and sequence-stratigraphic variations in the
unit along directions approximately parallel to depositional strike and dip.
Eleven environmentally significant lithofacies
were identified throughout the study area (Table 1).
These are interpreted to represent environments
ranging from braided fluvial at the base of the unit,
through estuarine channel and basin, tidal flat, tidal
inlet, and coastal swamp in the central part of the
unit, into upper and lower shoreface sandstones
with condensed oyster shell deposits and sparse
bentonite layers in the upper part.
Facies 1: Fluvial Conglomerate
Conglomerates (Table 1, Figure 6A) occur throughout most of the study area at the base of the Dakota
Sandstone and become finer grained from west
to east. Units are commonly 5 m (16 ft) or less in
thickness, but bodies up to 16 m (52 ft) thick occur
(e.g., southeast of Blue Valley, section 17). Paleocurrent directions measured within this facies show
relatively low divergence about mean directions
and commonly trend toward the east and northeast (Figure 7). Erosional relief of this facies into
the underlying Cedar Mountain Formation locally
reaches up to 6 m (20 ft). However, these conglomerates form laterally extensive sheetlike deposits that appear to be contained within broad
Antia and Fielding
423
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
mented along with facies 4. In general, the dominance of coarse clastic sediments, rarity of fine
sheetlike geometry, and relatively low paleocurrent
variability suggest that facies 1 represents deposits
of braided streams during the initial stages of deposition of the Dakota Sandstone.
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
5
4
3
SEARCH
Figure 7. Rose diagrams for different facies in cycles 1 and 2 of the Dakota Sandstone. Statistical data include the number of measurements per diagram (n), mean angle (black arrows), and standard deviation around the mean (gray segments) calculated from
measured orientations of trough cross-bedding (TXB), planar cross-bedding (PXB), ripple cross-bedding (RXB), or imbrication (Imb.).
425
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
426
Dakota Sandstone Sequence Stratigraphy, Henry Mountains, Southeastern Utah
Figure 8. (A) Photomosaic of section 6 in the Blue Valley area showing a composite fluvial channel body. (B) Photomosaic of section 3 in the Blue Valley area showing a cross section of
an estuarine channel dominated by inclined heterolithic stratification sharply overlying conglomerates (facies 1) and abruptly overlain by shoreface sandstones (facies 8).
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
5
4
3
SEARCH
Figure 9. Photographs of facies identified within the Dakota Sandstone. (A) Contact zone between the base of cycle 2 and parasequence 1 showing transition from tidally influenced sandstones at the base, paleosols, and coal, abruptly overlain by offshore mudstone
grading upward into shoreface sandstone. (B) Coarsening-upward parasequence at the top of the Dakota Sandstone near a few hundred
meters south of The Post 1 section with thickly bedded heterolithic offshore mudstone and sandstone at the base grading upward into
shoreface sandstone with chert pebbles and sparse oyster shells.
equal in thickness to mudstone layers. Lateral accretion surfaces are evident in the Blue Valley area
with internal cross-bedding (Figure 7) dipping at
highly oblique angles to the accretionary surface.
Lateral accretion surfaces in combination with
IHS occur continuously over several kilometers,
which suggest that this facies represents intertidal
point-bar deposits in belts of sinuous estuarine
channels (Dalrymple et al., 1992; Boyd et al.,
2006). Sharply based lenses of pinstripe-laminated
sandstone and carbonaceous mudstone are interpreted to represent abandoned estuarine channels.
Bann et al. (2004) have described analogous facies
in the Pebbley Beach Formation in Sydney Basin,
Australia.
Facies 4: Paleosols, Coal, and
Carbonaceous Shale
Paleosols (Table 1, Figure 6GH) typically underlying coal seams or carbonaceous shale (O horizon)
and consisting of moderately to poorly developed
C horizons (parent rock material showing variable
degrees of enrichment of clay material, iron, aluminum, or organic compounds) are preserved in
the northern and central parts of the study area in
the middle of the Dakota Sandstone (Figures 6H,
9A). Coal and carbonaceous shale are common in
outcrops north of the Freemont River in the Blue
Valley area, in North Caineville Reef, and between
Blind Trail and The Post. Typically, only one coal
Antia and Fielding
427
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
seam can be identified and traced laterally for hundreds of meters to several kilometers. The thickness of the coal seam ranges between 0 and 65 cm
(26 in.) with an average thickness of approximately
30 cm (12 in.). Two coal seams, 30 and 15 cm (12
and 6 in.) thick, occur in Jet Basin.
428
The C-horizon part of the paleosols is recognized by root traces (Figure 6H), spheroidal weathering, or complete homogenization of underlying
lithologies (Figure 9A). Commonly, only minute
coaly root traces are present immediately below a
coal seam in carbonaceous shale and heterolithic
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
429
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
Figure 11. Photomosaic of the canyon face opposite to the Eggnog section showing fluvioestuarine sandstone (facies 3) at the base
sharply overlain by tidal inlet (facies 7) and shoreface sandstones (facies 8). This outcrop shows a cross section of a channel (dashed lines
in the photograph) about 3 m (~9.8 ft) thick and less than 100 m (<328 ft) wide in the tidal inlet facies (facies 7).
shoreface sandstone (facies 8) and has been interpreted as tidal inlet deposits at the outer end of an
estuarine embayment. The deposits are analogous to ancient and modern examples described
by Barwis and Makurath (1978) and Kumar and
Sanders (1974).
Facies 8: Shingled Cross-Bedded
Shoreface Sandstone
This facies (Table 1, Figure 10E, F) is the most
laterally continuous and can be traced throughout
most of the study area at the top of the Dakota
Sandstone. It occurs in intervals commonly 5 m
(16 ft) in thickness and as much as 9 m (30 ft)
thick (e.g., Blue Valley section 18). In some places,
bentonite layers subdivide the unit into as many as
three intervals, each less than 4 m (<13 ft) thick.
Cross-sets range in thickness from 10 to 40 cm (4
16 in.) and form laterally extensive shingled sheets
gently inclined east-northeastward. Paleocurrent
data broadly trend westward and southwestward
(Figure 7). Bioturbation is variable but intense
overall (bioturbation index [BI] = 46) and typically higher at the top of individual cross-bed sets,
along bedding planes, and in the basal parts of the
430
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
431
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
432
Dakota Sandstone Sequence Stratigraphy, Henry Mountains, Southeastern Utah
Figure 12. Cross sections and stratigraphic interpretations of the Dakota Sandstone in the Henry Mountains, southeastern Utah, including (A) cross section AA and (B) cross section BB.
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
Figure 13. Cross-sections and stratigraphic interpretations of the Dakota Sandstone in the Blue Valley area in the Henry Mountains, southeastern Utah, including (A) cross-section CC
and (B) cross section DD. Key to symbols in Figure 12.
5
4
3
CONTENTS
DISCUSSION
Sequence-Stratigraphic Framework
Several key stratigraphic surfaces were recognized
throughout the study area using the facies scheme
previously developed (Figures 12, 13). Superposition of the Dakota Sandstone on the scoured surface of the Cedar Mountain or Morrison formations
represents a major unconformity and a sequence
boundary. The hiatus associated with this boundary
has been corroborated by other authors using palynomorph biostratigraphy. It has been determined to
span approximately the Late Albian and Early Cenomanian, where the upper Cedar Mountain Formation is present and overall missing time increases
toward the west (Merewether and Cobban, 1986;
Cobban et al., 2000; Currie et al., 2008).
Another sequence boundary is identified in the
middle part of the Dakota Sandstone by the superposition of fluvial conglomerate and sandstone
(facies 1 and 2) over estuarine carbonaceous shale
(facies 3) (Figures 12, 13). Such disjoint superposition of facies is readily observed in the central and southern parts of the study area but is
more cryptic toward the north, where the fluvial
deposits amalgamate, pinch out, or completely
erode underlying deposits at the base of the Dakota Sandstone.
434
MARCH
SEARCH
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
The TST part of cycle 1 is covered by colluvium or does not crop out south of the The Post
toward Halls Creek Overlook, where only conglomerates are present. Cycle 1 crops out again at
Eggnog as fluvioestuarine deposits at the base of
the Dakota Sandstone (Figure 12A). Eastward,
from Eggnog to Hansen Creek, west cycle 1 becomes progressively thinner, and at Copper Creek
Benches, it is not present.
Antia and Fielding
435
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
Figure 15. Paleogeographic interpretations of cycles 1 and 2 associated with deposition of the Dakota Sandstone in the Henry Mountains region. Channel belts depicted in these maps
were interpolated among measured sections given general paleocurrent trends, similarities in lithofacies, and geographic position, but no subsurface data were used to corroborate the
interpretations.
5
4
3
437
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
Figure 16. Comparison of facies and sequence-stratigraphic interpretations for the Dakota Sandstone in the Kaiparowits Plateau (Ulin, 1999), the Henry Mountains (this study), and
the southern Uinta Basin (Currie et al., 2008), used with permission from the Utah Biological Survey. Note that the side-by-side comparison of the three sequence stratigraphic models is
not meant to imply that the sequence-stratigraphic surfaces are the same age in all three locations. Instead, this figure aims to show the striking similarities among the three sections,
both from a lithostratigraphic and sequence-stratigraphic perspective. FS = flooding surface; SB = sequence boundary; TS = transgressive surface of erosion.
5
4
3
439
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
Figure 17. Comparison of the stratigraphy in the Kaiparowits Plateau (KP), the Henry Mountains (HM), and northwestern New Mexico
(SJ). (A) Isopach map of Lower Cretaceous rocks in Utah and western Colorado and interpreted during the Early Cretaceous forelandbasin system depozone (source: Currie, 2002). (B) Comparison of the stratigraphic characteristics and thickness between the KP (taken
from Ulin, 1999), HM, and San Juan Basin (based on discussions by Owen, 1969; Aubrey, 1989; Lucas et al., 1998). Note that the lines
drawn among the stratigraphic sections are not meant to imply that the sequence-stratigraphic surfaces are the same age in all three
locations. These lines are just meant to show the similarities among the three sections at similar stratigraphic levels. (C) Paleocurrents of
the Dakota Formation in the Colorado Plateau as reported by Mellere (1994), Lucas et al. (1998), Ulin (1999), Currie et al. (2008), and
this study. (D) Time-stratigraphic diagram of the Dakota Sandstone among the KP, HM, and San Juan Basin. (E) Legend of symbols for
diagrams A to D.
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
the stratigraphy of this area, with less preservation potential of the geologic record. Hence, it
seems likely that evidence of subaerial exposure
between the identified parasequences may have
been eroded away during deposition of the overlying unit.
In northwestern New Mexico, the Dakota
Sandstone is also thicker (~80 m [262 ft]) than in
the Henry Mountains and contains similar deposits
to those in the Kaiparowits Plateau. The sequencestratigraphic framework for the unit is not well
developed in this area. However, the sedimentologic similarities are striking. In the San Juan and
Acoma basins of northwestern New Mexico, the
Dakota Sandstone is subdivided into the braided
fluvial Encinal Canyon Member, overlain by carbonaceous coastal plain deposits of the Oak Canyon
Member, and multiple marginal marine sandstone
bodies, namely Cubero, Paguate, and Twowells
tongues, which interfinger with the Mancos Shale
(Figure 17) (Owen, 1969; Aubrey, 1989; Mellere,
1994; Lucas et al., 1998). It is unclear whether the
Oak Canyon Member contains deposits associated
with anastomosing fluvial systems, nevertheless,
it is obvious that the Kaiparowits Plateau section
and the Dakota Sandstone in northwestern New
Mexico are significantly similar. Furthermore,
Mellere (1994), in a reassessment of the Twowells
Tongue in the Acoma Basin, identified an unconformity at the base of the unit overlain by estuarine
valley-fill deposits that grade upward into marginal
marine sandstone and the Mancos Shale, which is
analogous to the sequences in the upper parts of
the Dakota Sandstone in the Kaiparowits Plateau
described by Gustason (1989), am Ende (1991),
and Ulin (1999).
Two important differences between these areas
are (1) the greater presence of marine shale intertonguing with the Dakota Sandstone in northwestern New Mexico compared with the Kaiparowits Plateau and the Henry Mountains and (2)
diverging paleocurrent directions in the fluvial
facies between the Henry Mountains and adjacent
areas to the east and west (Figure 17). The greater
presence of marine shale intertonguing with the
Dakota Sandstone in northwestern New Mexico
is to be expected because this section would have
Antia and Fielding
441
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
5
4
3
CONTENTS
CONCLUSIONS
The Dakota Sandstone in the Henry Mountains
represents a low-accommodation depositional setting on the western margin of the Cretaceous
Western Interior Basin. The unit preserves a record
MARCH
SEARCH
443
5
4
3
CONTENTS
accommodation in this setting resulted in a high degree of compartmentalization and abundant baffle
zones in these potential reservoirs. The best reservoirs would most likely occur in fluvial sandstones
because they are better sorted, are free of detrital
mud, and are encased in mudstones that may act as
sealing lithologies in stratigraphic traps.
REFERENCES CITED
am Ende, B. A., 1991, Depositional environments, palynology, and age of the Dakota Formation, south-central
Utah, in J. D. Nations and J. G. Eaton, eds., Stratigraphy,
depositional environments and sedimentary tectonics of
the western margin, Cretaceous Western Interior seaway: Geological Society of America Special Paper 260,
p. 6583.
Angevine, C. L., and P. L. Heller, 1987, Quantitative basin
modeling: Geological Society of America Short Course
Notes, 80 p.
Armstrong, R. L., 1968, Sevier orogenic belt in Nevada and
Utah: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 79,
p. 429458, doi:10.1130/0016-7606(1968)79[429
:SOBINA]2.0.CO;2.
Aubrey, W. M., 1989, Mid-Cretaceous alluvial-plain incision
related to eustasy, southeastern Colorado Plateau: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 101, p. 443449,
doi:10.1130/0016-7606(1989)101<0443:MCAPIR>2
.3.CO;2.
Bann, K. L., C. R. Fielding, J. A. MacEachern, and S. C. Tye,
2004, Differentiation of estuarine and offshore marine
deposits using integrated ichnology and sedimentology:
Permian Pebbly Beach Formation, Sydney Basin, Australia, in D. McIlroy, ed., The application of ichnology to
paleoenvironmental and stratigraphic analysis: Geological Society (London) Special Publications 228, p. 179
211.
Barwis, J. H., and J. H. Makurath, 1978, Recognition of ancient tidal inlet sequences: An example from the Upper
Silurian Keyser Limestone in Virginia: Sedimentology,
v. 25, p. 6182, doi:10.1111/j.1365-3091.1978
.tb00301.x.
Bhattacharya, J. P., and B. J. Willis, 2001, Lowstand deltas in
the Frontier Formation, Powder River Basin, Wyoming:
Implications for sequence-stratigraphic models: AAPG
Bulletin, v. 85, no. 2, p. 261294
Boyd, R., R. W. Dalrymple, and B. A. Zaitlin, 2006, Estuarine
and incised valley facies models, in H. W. Posamentier
and R. G. Walker, eds., Facies models revisited: SEPM
Special Publication 84, p. 171236.
Brenner, R. L., G. A. Ludvigson, B. J. Witzke, A. N. Zawistoski,
E. P. Kvale, R. L. Ravn, and R. M. Joeckel, 2000, Late
Albian Kiowa-Skull Creek marine transgression, Lower
Dakota Formation, eastern margin of Western Interior
seaway, U.S.A.: Journal of Sedimentary Research, v. 70,
444
MARCH
SEARCH
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
445
5
4
3
CONTENTS
446
MARCH
SEARCH
5
4
3
CONTENTS
MARCH
SEARCH
447
5
4
3