You are on page 1of 20

FACULTY OF CHEMICAL & NATURAL RESOURCES

ENGINEERING
UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA PAHANG

BKF 3553
PROCESS SIMULATION & COMPUTER AIDED DESIGN
LECTURER: DR ING- RIZZA BIN OTHMAN

MINI PROJECT

PREPARED BY:
CHOO WEI CHUN

KE11037

HOR CHEE HENG

KE11029

TAN YONG CHAI

KA11206

LEE HON KIT

KA11182

LEE JHIN ONN

KA11178

DATE OF SUBMISSION:
27th MAY 2014

Table of Contents
1.0

INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................3

1.1 Process Description ............................................................................................................3


1.1.1 Background...................................................................................................................3
1.1.2 History of formaldehyde production ............................................................................4
1.1.3 Objectives ......................................................................................................................4
1.1.4 Scope of study ...............................................................................................................5
1.2 PFD (Process Flow Diagram) ............................................................................................5
1.3 Reaction kinetics.................................................................................................................9
1.4 Operating conditions........................................................................................................10
2.0

MODELLING & SIMULATION METHODOLOGY ...............................................11

2.1 Chemical components definition .....................................................................................11


2.2 Thermodynamic properties selection .............................................................................11
2.3 Flowsheet design ...............................................................................................................12
2.4 Plant capacity....................................................................................................................13
2.5 Input parameters setup for each unit operation............................................................14
2.6 Mass balance of major equipments.................................................................................15
3.0

RESULTS & DISCUSSION ..........................................................................................17

4.0 CONCLUSION & RECOMMENDATION .......................................................................19


References ...................................................................................................................................20

1.0

INTRODUCTION

1.1 Process Description


1.1.1 Background
Formaldehyde is also known as Methanal, Methylene oxide or Formalin. It is the first in
the series of aliphatic aldehydes, with the structure H2C=O. Formaldehyde is a reactive
and versatile chemical intermediate. Pure formaldehyde is a colourless gas with a
pungent and suffocating odour at ordinary temperatures. The ignition temperature of
formaldehyde gas is 430C (Gerberich and Seaman, 2004).
Mixtures with air are explosive. It is stable at 80 - 100C when pure, but small amounts
of impurities such as water cause rapid polymerisation to poly (oxymethylenes).
Formaldehyde liquefies at -19.2C and solidifies at -118C, giving a white paste. At
temperatures of up to 80C, the liquid and gas forms of formaldehyde polymerise
rapidly.
Formaldehyde (CH2O), the target product of this project, acts as a synthesis baseline for
many other chemical compounds including phenol formaldehyde, urea formaldehyde
and melamine resin that subsequently used as adhesives and binders for particle board
and plywood. The most widely produced grade is formalin (37 wt. % formaldehyde in
water) aqueous solution. In this projects study, formaldehyde is to be produced through
a catalytic vapor-phase oxidation reaction involving methanol and oxygen according to
the following reactions:

The first desired reaction is exothermic while the second is an endothermic reaction. The
projects target is to design a plant with a capacity of 50,000 metric ton formalin/annum
with the operating days of 49weeks/343 days in a year. This plant is to include three
major units; a reactor, an absorber and a distillation column. Also it includes pumps,
compressors and heat exchangers. All are to be designed and operated according to this
production capacity.
3

1.1.2 History of formaldehyde production


In 1859, Aleksandr Butlerov, a Russian chemist, discovered formaldehyde. After 10
years, another chemist form German who named August Hofmann finally identified
formaldehyde. The production of formaldehyde began in the beginnings of the twentieth
century. The annual growth rate for formaldehyde production averaged to 11.7%
between 1958 and 1968. The production was 54% of capacity in the mid-1970s. Annual
growth rate of formaldehyde was 2.7% per year from 1988 to 1997. The production of
formaldehyde was ranked 22nd among the top 50 chemicals manufactured in the United
States in 1992. The total annual formaldehyde capacity in 1998 was estimated by 11.3
billion pounds and its production capacity is increasing exponentially in the global until
it reaches a worlds production of 32.5 million metric tons by 2012. The demand of the
formaldehyde becomes high because of its low costs compared to other materials and its
receptivity for reaching high purities. It is also the center of many chemical researches
and alternatives manufacture methods.
Applications of formaldehyde in industries include building block for organic
compounds, photographing washing, woodworking, cabinet-making industries, glues,
adhesives, paints, explosives, disinfecting agents, tissue preservation and drug testing
field.

1.1.3 Objectives
1. To study an integrated design of a plant for formaldehyde production with
specified capacity in a point of view in chemical engineering.
2. To investigate the entire process unit design of the plant such as process flow
diagrams and operation parameters.

1.1.4 Scope of study


1.

To apply knowledge of mass and heat transfer, fluid dynamics, unit operations,

reaction kinetics and process control in the project.


2. To perform mass and energy balances, Hysys simulation of the Process Flow

Diagrams, design of the reactor, design of heat exchangers, design of the absorber
and distillation column and energy optimization in the project.

1.2 PFD (Process Flow Diagram)

Figure 1.2.1: Formalin process flow diagram (Turton et al., 2009)

Figure 1.2.1 is a process of producing formalin (37 wt% formaldehyde in water) from
methanol using the silver catalyst process.

Air (0.21% Oxygen; 0.79% Nitrogen; 25 C; 1 atm) is compressed and mixed the
methanol (30 C; 1.2 bar) which has been preheated, fresh and recycled to provide
reactor feed. The feed mixture contains around 39 mol% methanol in air, which is more
than upper flammability limit for methanol. (For methanol, UFL= 36 mol%; LFL= 6
mol%).
In the PFR reactor, there are two reactions happen:

The reactor (length 0.347m and diameter 0.050799m) is using the silver catalyst (Bed
voidage 0.5 and particle density 1500 kg/cum), in the form of wire gauze, suspended
above a heat exchanger tube bank. It is a must to the remove the heat produced in the
adiabatic reactor section due to the net reaction is highly exothermic, thus the close
proximity of the heat exchanger tubes. Inside the heat exchanger, there is a pool of water
on the shell side. The set point on a level controller is adjusted when it detects the
temperature of the effluent is very high. The level controller will send signal to the
boiler so that to increase the feed water rate entering from the reboiler to the heat
exchanger to increase the water vaporization rate to remove more heat. In general, the
liquid-level controller on the boiler feed water is adjusted to keep the tube bundle fully
immersed. The reactor effluent enters an absorber in which most of the methanol and
formaldehyde are absorbed into water, with most of the remaining light gas purged into
the off-gas stream. The formaldehyde, the methanol, and water enter a distillation
column, in which the overhead product, methanol is recycled; the bottom product,
formaldehyde/ water mixture that contains <1 wt% methanol as an inhibitor. Due to
there are some batch downstream process, this mixture send to a storage tank after
cooling. A suitable amount of water is added inside the storage tank when the
downstream process draws from the storage tank because the composition in the storage
tank exceeds 37 wt% formaldehyde. The storage tank contents must be maintained
between 35C and 45C to prevent unfavourable conditions like polymerization and

formic acid formation from happening. Figure 1.2.2 shows the block flow diagram of
formalin production.

Figure 1.2.2: Formalin block flow diagram


8

1.3 Reaction kinetics


Kinetic information for the methanol oxidation reaction:

The rate expression is:

Where p is a partial pressure in atm, and m refers to methanol. The rate expression is
only valid when oxygen is present in excess. The constants are defined as:

Where T is in Kelvin, the rate data as follows for the side reaction:

The rate expression is:

Standard enthalpies of reaction (298 K, 1 atm) for the two reactions are given as:

1.4 Operating conditions


The process that will be applied in this project is the production of formaldehyde
through the vapor phase oxidation reaction between methanol and air (Oxygen).
In this process, a reactor, an absorber and a distiller are required for the production of
formaldehyde. First and foremost, two streams; first stream is a mixture of fresh
methanol (25C, 1atm) and second stream is recycled methanol (68.3C and 1.2atm)
pumped to 3atm and vaporized to 150C are received by a reactor. The reactor is
designed for 87.4% methanol conversion. Secondly, the absorber receives the outlet
stream of methanol from the reactor at 343C and a fresh stream of water (30C,
138KPa). Absorption of 99% is expected where the liquid outlet is heated to 102C.
Next, the mixed liquid from the absorber is received by the distillation column and
further separated the overhead stream (68.3C, 1.2atm) then recycles it back to methanol
fresh feed mixing point. The bottom formaldehyde stream is pumped and mixed with
demonized water forming (37 wt. % formaldehyde) formalin stream that is sent for
storage.

10

2.0

MODELLING & SIMULATION METHODOLOGY

2.1 Chemical components definition

Figure 2.1: Chemical components involve in formalin production.

2.2 Thermodynamic properties selection

11

Figure 2.2: Properties method selection in Aspen Plus V8.0.

The NRTL model can describe Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium and Liquid-Liquid


Equilibrium of strongly non-ideal solutions. The NRTL model can handle any
combination of polar and non-polar compounds, up to very strong non-ideality.
Parameters should be fitted in the temperature, pressure, and composition range of
operation. No component should be close to its critical temperature. The vapor phase
EOS name for NRTL-HOC property method is Non-Random Two-Liquid on Hayden-O
Connell. Do not use the Hayden-O'Connell-based property methods at pressures
exceeding 10 to 15 atm.
(Renon & Prausnitz, 1968)

2.3 Flowsheet design

Figure 2.3: Flowsheet design using Aspen Plus V8.0.


12

2.4 Plant capacity


Formalin Production statistics:
Optimum Operating hour given:
/ 343 days
Production Rate Given: (50,000 metric tonnes/yr)

Production rate per year =

Since CH2O and H2O has the same no. of mole of CH2(OH)2 produced, therefore, no. of
mole of CH2O and H2O feed is

Table 2.4: Calculation of Molar and Mass Feed rate.


Species

Mole (kmol/yr)

Mass (MT/yr)

Formaldehyde

1041666.67

31280.00

Water

1041666.67

18720.00

Formalin

1041666.67

50,000.00

13

2.5 Input parameters setup for each unit operation


Table 2.5: Input parameters setup for each unit operation
Equipment
Mixer 1

Pump
Heater 1

Compressor

Heater 2

Mixer 2
PFR

Chiller
Absorption Tower

Distillation
Column

Description
Mixing of pure methanol and recycled methanol.
Inlet and outlet temperature 30oC and pressure 1.5 bar.
Inlet and outlet flow rate 76.92 kmol/hr.
Outlet pressure of methanol at 3 bar.
To heat the reactant from 30 oC to 150 oC
To decrease pressure from 3 bar to 2.65 bar.
Vapour-liquid valid phase.
Compress air.
Inlet temperature and pressure are 25 oC and 1 atm.
Outlet temperature and pressure are 174 oC and 3 bar.
Inlet and outlet flow rate 145.94 mol/hr
Oxygen mole fraction: 0.21
Nitrogen mole fraction: 0.79
To heat the reactant from 174 oC to 200 oC
To decrease pressure from 3 bar to 2.65 abr.
Vapour-liquid valid phase.
To mix methanol and air.
Outlet temperature is 175 oC after mixing.
Operation set at 200 oC
Reactor length 0.347m and diameter 0.050799m
Catalyst present in the reactor
Bed voidage is 0.5
Particle density is 1500 kg/cum
Decrease temperature to 100 oC and pressure to 1.5 bar.
Vapour-liquid valid phase.
Rate-based calculation type
30 number of stages
Condenser pressure 1.5 bar
Feed streams above stage 1 (intermediate product)
Feed streams on stage 30 (water)
Equilibrium calculation type
31 number of stages
Total condenser
Reflux ratio of 37.34
Bottom rate is 1 kmol/hr
Condenser pressure 1.5 bar
Feed stream at 18th stages

14

2.6 Mass balance of major equipments


Reactor

n8 = 319.67 kmol/hr
xCH3OH = 0.240622
xO2 = 0.096041
xH2O = 0.302024
xN2 = 0.3613067

n9 = 356.46 kmol/hr
xCH3OH = 0.0825945
xO2 = 0.0561529
xCH2O = 0.1331915
xH2O = 0.3308004
xH2 = 0.0732467
xN2 = 0.3240139

Assumption:

Adiabatic

No pressure drop

Absorber
n11 = 143 kmol/hr
xH2O = 1

n10 = 356.46 kmol/hr


xCH3OH = 0.0825945
xO2 = 0.0561529
xCH2O = 0.1331915
xH2O = 0.3308004
xH2 = 0.0732467
xN2 = 0.3240139

n12 = 327.79 kmol/hr


xCH3OH = 0.0283
xO2 = 0.06096
xCH2O = 0.06819
xH2O = 0.41101
xH2 = 0.07965
xN2 = 0.35193

n13 = 171.67 kmol/hr


xCH3OH = 0.117542
xO2 = 0.0002
xCH2O = 0.14636
xH2O = 0.73508
xH2 = 0
xN2 = 0.0008

15

Distillation column

n13 = 171.67 kmol/hr


xCH3OH = 0.117542
xO2 = 0.0002
xCH2O = 0.14636
xH2O = 0.73508
xH2 = 0
xN2 = 0.0008

n13 = 96.811 kmol/hr


xCH3OH = 0
xO2 = 0.00056
xCH2O = 0
xH2O = 0.997285
xH2 = 0.00002
xN2 = 0.00214

n13 = 149 kmol/hr


xCH3OH = 0.135425
xO2 = 0
xCH2O = 0.01765
xH2O = 0.8469
xH2 = 0
xN2 = 0

Assumption:

Light key component is methanol

Heavy key component is water

Non-heavy key is formaldehyde

16

3.0

RESULTS & DISCUSSION


Table 3.1: Stream results.
1
MIX1
LIQUID

Substream: MIXED
Mole Flow kmol/hr
METHANOL
OXYGEN
FORMA-01
WATER
HYDROGEN
NITROGEN
Mole Frac
METHANOL
OXYGEN
FORMA-01
WATER
HYDROGEN
NITROGEN
Mass Flow kg/hr
METHANOL
OXYGEN
FORMA-01
WATER
HYDROGEN
NITROGEN
Mass Frac
METHANOL
OXYGEN
FORMA-01
WATER
HYDROGEN
NITROGEN
Total Flow kmol/hr
Total Flow kg/hr
Total Flow l/min
Temperature C
Pressure bar
Vapor Frac
Liquid Frac
Solid Frac

2
PUMP1
MIX1
LIQUID

3
HEATER1
PUMP1
LIQUID

4
MIX2
HEATER1
VAPOR

5
COM1
VAPOR

6
CHILLER1
COM1
VAPOR

7
MIX2
CHILLER1
VAPOR

8
PFR1
MIX2
VAPOR

9
CHILLER2
PFR1
VAPOR

10
ASB1
CHILLER2
VAPOR

11

12

ASB1
LIQUID

ASB1
VAPOR

13
DIST1
ASB1
LIQUID

14
MIX1
DIST1
LIQUID

15
DIST1
LIQUID

76.9200
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000

76.9200
0.0542
0.0000
96.5484
0.0019
0.2068

76.9200
0.0542
0.0000
96.5484
0.0019
0.2068

76.9200
0.0542
0.0000
96.5484
0.0019
0.2068

0.0000
30.6474
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
115.2926

0.0000
30.6474
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
115.2926

0.0000
30.6474
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
115.2926

76.9200
30.7016
0.0000
96.5484
0.0019
115.4994

29.4420
20.0165
47.4780
117.9185
26.1098
115.4994

29.4420
20.0165
47.4780
117.9185
26.1098
115.4994

0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
143.0000
0.0000
0.0000

9.2637
19.9816
22.3521
134.7275
26.1084
115.3617

20.1783
0.0350
25.1260
126.1910
0.0015
0.1376

0.0000
0.0542
0.0000
96.5484
0.0019
0.2068

20.1783
0.0000
2.6307
126.1910
0.0000
0.0000

1.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000

0.4428
0.0003
0.0000
0.5557
0.0000
0.0012

0.4428
0.0003
0.0000
0.5557
0.0000
0.0012

0.4428
0.0003
0.0000
0.5557
0.0000
0.0012

0.0000
0.2100
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.7900

0.0000
0.2100
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.7900

0.0000
0.2100
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.7900

0.2406
0.0960
0.0000
0.3020
0.0000
0.3613

0.0826
0.0562
0.1332
0.3308
0.0732
0.3240

0.0826
0.0562
0.1332
0.3308
0.0732
0.3240

0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
1.0000
0.0000
0.0000

0.0283
0.0610
0.0682
0.4110
0.0796
0.3519

0.1175
0.0002
0.1464
0.7351
0.0000
0.0008

0.0000
0.0006
0.0000
0.9973
0.0000
0.0021

0.1354
0.0000
0.0177
0.8469
0.0000
0.0000

2464.6830
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000

2464.6830
1.7334
0.0000
1739.3460
0.0039
5.7923

2464.6830
1.7334
0.0000
1739.3460
0.0039
5.7923

2464.6830
1.7334
0.0000
1739.3460
0.0039
5.7923

0.0000
980.6800
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
3229.7470

0.0000
980.6800
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
3229.7470

0.0000
980.6800
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
3229.7470

2464.6830
982.4134
0.0000
1739.3460
0.0039
3235.5390

943.3853
640.5046
1425.5880
2124.3350
52.6343
3235.5390

943.3853
640.5046
1425.5880
2124.3350
52.6343
3235.5390

0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
2576.1850
0.0000
0.0000

296.8288
639.3862
671.1491
2427.1530
52.6314
3231.6840

646.5566
1.1184
754.4387
2273.3660
0.0030
3.8556

0.0000 646.5565
1.7334
0.0000
0.0000
78.9901
1739.3460 2273.3660
0.0039
0.0000
5.7923
0.0000

1.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
76.9200
2464.6830
52.1992
30.0000
1.2000
0.0000
1.0000
0.0000

0.5852
0.0004
0.0000
0.4130
0.0000
0.0014
173.7313
4211.5590
82.3914
30.6548
1.2000
0.0000
1.0000
0.0000

0.5852
0.5852
0.0000
0.0000
0.0004
0.0004
0.2329
0.2329
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.4130
0.4130
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0014
0.0014
0.7671
0.7671
173.7313
173.7313
145.9400
145.9400
4211.5590 4211.5590 4210.4270 4210.4270
82.4082 37588.4600 59481.0300 30178.8500
30.8119
150.0000
25.0000
174.2000
3.0000
2.6500
1.0133
3.0000
0.0000
1.0000
1.0000
1.0000
1.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000

0.0000
0.2329
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.7671
145.9400
4210.4270
36135.6900
200.0000
2.6500
1.0000
0.0000
0.0000

0.0000
0.0406
0.0000
0.0874
0.0000
0.0917
1.0000
0.3316
0.0000
0.0072
0.0000
0.4416
143.0000
327.7949
2576.1850
7318.8320
43.4087 108331.0000
30.0000
87.0727
1.5000
1.5000
0.0000
1.0000
1.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000

0.1757
0.0003
0.2050
0.6179
0.0000
0.0010
171.6693
3679.3380
75.3443
87.3135
1.5000
0.0000
1.0000
0.0000

0.0000
0.2156
0.0010
0.0000
0.0000
0.0263
0.9957
0.7581
0.0000
0.0000
0.0033
0.0000
96.8113 149.0000
1746.8760 2998.9130
34.2124
59.1553
-43.3864 103.9483
1.5000
1.5000
0.0000
0.0000
1.0000
1.0000
0.0000
0.0000

0.2926
0.1120
0.1120
0.1166
0.0761
0.0761
0.0000
0.1693
0.1693
0.2065
0.2522
0.2522
0.0000
0.0062
0.0062
0.3842
0.3842
0.3842
319.6713
356.4642
356.4642
8421.9860 8421.9860
8421.9860
72856.2000 87930.6300 122158.0000
165.2305
200.0000
100.0000
2.6500
2.6500
1.5000
1.0000
1.0000
1.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000

17

Discussion
We unable to solve the material for block DIST1 which is a rigorous distillation column
calculation. This is because the method used unable to model the behaviour of formaldehyde that
is provided by our reference. In Turton, formaldehyde is assume to follow the water but our
simulation method assume formaldehyde has very weak solubility in water and very volatile. KValue for formaldehyde/water/methanol system is provided in the Turtons reference, however
aspen does not feature that allow the use of this data. Furthermore, distillate of this block
supposedly to contain mostly methanol is recycled back which further complicate the calculation.
The complexities lead to the program unable to solve the calculation under a maximum 200
iteration.
From Turton reference, formaldehyde is able to be nearly fully absorbed by water with 99%
recovery at stream 13. However in our simulation, 47.07% of the formaldehyde is wasted at
stream 12 which is an off-gas stream. This suggests that the NRTL-HOC thermodynamic method
model the formaldehyde properties as more volatile and less soluble in water than it should in
experiment. We have tried more other thermodynamic properties such as NRTL-NTH, UNIFAC,
UNIQUAC but the result remains roughly the same.
Therefore, we recommend that aspen tech should add a feature whereby user is able to key in
experimental K-value data and the program is able to use the data to model the separation process.

18

4.0 CONCLUSION & RECOMMENDATION


Conclusion
We use ASPEN plus V8.0 to plan our operation. We specify the reaction kinetics and NRTLHOC as our thermodynamic property method. The raw material we used is methanol and air and
the product is 37 %wt formaldehyde in water also known as formalin. The unit operator that we
used is mixer, compressor, heater, chiller, PFR reactor, absorber and distillation column. Finally,
we obtained the production of 50,000MT/yr of formalin.
Recommendation
To improve the energy efficiency of the plant, the hot stream of the reactor outlet can be used to
preheat the inlet of the reactor since the reaction is exothermic which require cooling and the
reactant require preheating. Basically design heat exchanger network to save on energy cost.
Furthermore, this process can be further optimize by perform economic analysis to find the
process condition where less operating cost is needed. According to the Ott et al.,(2005),
UNIFAC method is used to produce formalin. The reason we not use this method is because we
are lacking the binary parameter for formalin-methanol system.

19

References
Gerberich, H.R., and G.C. Seaman (2004). Formaldehyde, Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of
Chemical Technology, on-line version (New York: John Wiley & Sons).
H. Renon and J.M. Prausnitz, (1968). "Local Compositions in Thermodynamic Excess Functions
for Liquid Mixtures," AIChE J., Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 135 144.
Ott, M., Schoenmakers, H. and Hasse, H. (2005). Distillation of formaldehyde containing
mixtures: laboratory experiments, equilibrium stage modeling and simulation. Chemical
Engineering and Processing: Process Intensification, 44(6), pp. 687--694.
Turton, R., Bailie, R., Whiting, W. and Shaeiwitz, J. (2009). Analysis, synthesis, and design of
chemical processes. 3rd ed. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Prentice Hall PTR.

20

You might also like