Professional Documents
Culture Documents
~~
-~
WAR
The Nation
1
5
3
1
~.
a demand
for
war
Thus the
oflicial DeutscAesVollcsblatt
publlshedthe
decislon of the Council of Ministers to apply
theseverestmeasurestothe
S&-bs i n BosniaThesewere
t o includeeven a rlgorous
control of their schools, into which military
dlsciplihewouldbeintroduced.
It also assertedthatAustrian
officials mustbeadmitted t o the inquiry which the ServianGovernment was to make into the assassination
Neues Waener Tagehlatt
atSaraJevoThe
spoke of thesatisfactloncausedbythe
belief that Austria would soon, i f necessary,
intervene with ener,T in Servia A strongRezchsposc, which
ertonewasheldbythe
declared
that
diplomatic
methods
would
to
be of no avail wlth Servia, whlch ought
be dealtwith
by Austriasummarlly.The
FrezePresse lookedahead
actual
intervention, or towar,andarguedthat
Russiaought
t o giveAustria
a freehand
a t Melgrade, since it was clear that the ambitlonsandtheplottings
of theSerbs constltuted a dangerto all Europe, as wellas
to Austria,aqdmustbesternlyrepressed
Thegeneralattitude
of the .,Vienna press
by
the^ Reachswas pot- badly,,represented
~,
post when it asserted that Austria was
not
~
threatening
Servia,
but
that Servia
was
menacing the Dual Monarchy.
To all this, the
official declaration of war
It is
byAustrlawasthelnevitablesequel.
a stepwhichwastakenwithout
a decent
regardfortheopinion
of mankind,and
is
fraught with consequences whxh may easily
amount to that
terrlble
catastrophe
of
whlchSirEdward
Grey solemnlywarned
Europe on Monday. Thedullestmustsee
that what Austria is driving at IS not simply
a blow at Pan-Serbism,but t h e acquisition
of Servianterrltory.This,
however, would
surelynotbepermittedbythePowers,
no
matter how rapidmay
be thetriumph
of
a EuAustria?_arms,withoutreferenceto
ropean Conference. TheGermanEmperor
has refused to assent to the calling
of such
a Conference i n advance, i n order t o prevent war, if possible, but it will have to come
later-unless,
indeed, all the Continental niLtlons should,
drawn into theconflict which
Austria
has
arrogantly
and
wickedly
begun.
WILSONS USE OF
The Nation
ing avery clear and biting opinion of the
petty attitude of Senators Hitchcock and
Reed, B e has seized the occasion to set forth
certain convictions and principles of his own
which cannot fail to commend himtothe
sober Judgment of Americans who think.
the first place, he has put vividly his conception of the new banking system as a great
instrument for the general good upon which
it is an outrage for partisanship to lay its
hand. Anything
like
party
scheming
captious meddling, in connection with it, is
a wrong to the whole country. In the endeavor to establishsounderfinancialmethods and t o bring about a genuine prosperity,
there should be, affirms the President, united effort, with nothing of partisan preJudice o r class
antagonism.
Wlthmarked
emphasis he writes: I believe that the judgmentanddesire
of the whole country cry
out for a new temper in affairs.
What the President means bg-this, he has
made very definite. There has been a spirit
of proscription in theair.
Against some
classes of men there has been the grossest
discrimination.Theyhave
been lumped together, after the fashion of the French Revolution, as Enemies of the People.
one
wanted an example of this, one could find it
in the ranting in
which Senator Reed was
indulginglastThursday
atthe
very moment when thenews of Mr. Joness withdrawal was made known in the Senate. Could
we believe him, there are whole groups of
rapacious Americans going about to oppress
and devour their fellow-citizens. It isthe
Terror come again. O cocrse, a manlike
Senator Reed is more than half-conscious
thathe is talking clap-trap.He
1s simply
holding up bogey-men before his frightened
constituents. But the effect of such tirades
as his is most mischievous. It tends not only
to exclude a man like Mr. Jones from a public service which he was ready t o undertake
a t aPersonal sacrifice, but to prevent others of his kind from subjecting themselves
to similar vilidcation and rebuffs.
This was
a point made by the impressive array of Chicago men who urged the co-rmation of Mr.
Jones. How, they asked, if he IS rejected,
can we expect men of hlgh character and
marked ability to undertake public work f o r
the
nation?
They saw clearly that
the
course of the Senate was putting a premium
on littleand
subservient men. President
Wilsoi, too, sees it, and makes plain his abhorrence of the small-minded and intolerant
attitude which would shutoutgreat
capacity from great services. In the most expllcit language, he declared in hisletter that
the manifest injytice done t o Mr Jones
As thefirstmonth
of the operation in
New York State of the Workmens Compensation act draws t o a close, itsreality
as a factor in the peoples life becomes apparent in the news of the day. Such headlines as A Thousand Claims a Day for Cornpensation, Forty-eightDeaths in Twentythree Days, bring home vividly t o the mind
how large a part the simple and comprehensive mechanism of the new system I s going
relieving
to play in reducingdistressand
anxiety among the great mass of toilers in
thisStat?,andin
preserving t o thousands
of childrenopportunities
educationand
advancement of which a wholly unexpectedblow
of fatemight otherwise have deprived them. Thatthelawhasmarked
faults, and that, aside from any specific defects, the system will carry with it difficultiesand evils thatmust be reckoned with
as an offset t o its benefits, may be admitted;
but the feeling must be well-nigh universal,
among persons of right instincts, that here
has been accomplished a greatstrokein
the fight against human misery, a great addition to the sum of human happiness.
es. Butthe
cold figures, when looked at,
largeas they arein themselves, areseen
to be very small 1n comparison with the aggregate expenditures of the well-to-do and
therich. To imagme, as some have done,
thatthemamtenance
of theirstandzrd of
comfort by even the fairly well-to-do, or their
ability t o rear a family, is seriously affected by the cost of the States philanthropic
activities is to form arithmetical conclusions
without
arithmetical
data.
The
state
of
mind at the bottom of suchnotions IS not
altogether unlike t h a t which was wittily ex
posedby a public-spirited man of wealth, a
short time ago. If any man tells you,he
said t o the solicitor for a charity for whlch
a vigorous campaign was
made, that he is
being called upon for s o many things that
he is afraid_ he- will end in the EoorEouse,
just tell him that whenever he gets to the
poorhouse I will refund to him all the money he has ever spent on charity.
We must avoid both the extreme of ignoring the seriousness of the expense that may
be involved in the multiform schemes which
fall under the comprehensive designation of
social betterment, andthe otherextreme
of crying out in exaggerated alarm whenever
any such scheme is broached. Largeas is
the scope of this compensation for injuries
and the expense thereof, it has limits which
would seem t o be pretty well fixed from the
beginnmg by obvious conditions. Thisis
not the case with old-age pensions, nor with
penslon schemes generally; andin
these
there are aptalso t o enter factors which may
be far moredemoralizing, both as t o politicsand as t o individual life, thanisthe
case with the system of compensation for accident.
TRIALS:
~~
hand not to be condemned without convincing evidence, and of the State on the other
not t o be paralyzed in the upholding of the
lawby
trivial o r unreasonabledificulties,
will be paramount, however theexternal
orm may seem to stand in the way. Popes
dictum, Whateer is bestadministered
is
best, applies more truly t o the forms of the
administration of justicethan it does
forms of government in general.
Interesting aspect of the questlon
ed by these comparisons relates to thedegree
of strictness with which the rules of procedure should be appiied. Under the English
system, there has been at various times a
vast amount of abuse arising from a senseless magnifying of technicalities. I n England, procedure was long ago so reformed as
almost completely- t o rid criminal trials of
this reproach. I n our own country, the agitation of the subJect durmg the past twenty
years has accompllshed notable improvement
in pract&e$but there is still room f o r much
more. The fact that all the great natlons of
the Contment get on without a large part of
those rules of procedure which we regard as
so essential does not justify a general and
undiscriminating laxityin the application of
those rules; this would be sure t o mean partiality andinequity at best, and something
like chaos at worst. But that consideration
may properly be adduced t o fortify the argument from common-sense againstthe erection of technical rules into a sacredness that
1s foreign to them nature. The rules should
he obeyedstrictly, and above all uniformly;
but they should not be stretched beyond their
natural meaning,
made so-exacting as to
demand for their fulfilment
performance
that borders on impossibility.
It IS in reference t o the subject of immunity that this question of the limits to the
saeredness of aprinciple
of procedure is
most strikingly exemplified. The Constitutional principle-wholly absent from the procedure i n French trials-that
no person
shall belEompelled, in any criminal case,
to be a witness against himself, has been
construed t o cover so much more than what
the words themselves say, that it has acquired thename of the criminals privilege.
This, it seems t o us, could never have come
about if thedistinction between principles
of high import in themselves and principles
which are mere practical rules
the attainment of an ulterior end had been borne in
mind. Thereisnothinginherently
wrong.
nothing inherently oppressive, about asking
an accused person to tell his
in court;
but the process is liable to abuse, and the
Constitutionalprovision is based solely
T h e Nation.
T H E PUBLIC DEFENDER.
2therwlsecosttoomuch.Manyhavewon
wage settlementswhentheyhad
n o t the
ante of a meal.LiketheLegal
Aid Soxeties,thepubhcdefendergivesthehe
to thechargethatthecourtsareonlyfor
the
rlch.
Portlands
public
defender
has
labored only in police courts.The
Municipal Judge testifies that he has given a new
meaningtotheguarantee
of a fairand
impartialtrial,and
he himselfwrltes
in
Case a n d Oowzment of the correction of the
gravest defect of the Western police courtthedisregard
of therules of evldence observed In a court of record, s o t h a t dozens
o n hearsaytestiof personsareconvicted
mony and testimony otherwise incompetent.
Thereiteratedobjection
to t h e public defender is that the State concedes the accused
everysafeguard;hemustbeindictedby
a
grand
jury,
on a sworn
accusation;
he
he 1s confronted by his witnesses;
LE
allowed challenges
and
pleas,
and
guilt.
twelve men must agree on his
One really wonders, remarks Bench und
Bar, how a conviction can ever be secured.
But
the
fact
is
that
many
charges
are
backed by coloredevidence, and that action
by thegrandJury
is oftenhhrried.The
machinery of the law is directed by a public
officer eager f o r results. Fitted against hired
lawyers, he acquires aggressiveness not easilyshaken off Wheretested,thepublic
defenderbasnothamperedthe
law, buthas
facilitateditbycooperationwiththe
dm
trict attorney, and has reduced expenses by
pointing out cases where prosecution
IS useless H e w ~ l obviously
l
be no moreInclined
toacqult a guilty man than the prosecutor
toconvict an innocent.
- 8
The
, A d
Wation
Foreign Correspondence
SCHOOL EXAMINATIONS IN ENGLANDTHE VALUE OF THE OXFORD LO
CALS-THEIR
SCOPE AND
SIGWIFI
CANCE
LONDON,
July 17
There IS a familiar story of how a Frencl
Minister of Public Instruction one day pullem
out hls watch, and remarkecl that at that mo
ment every schoolboy in France was taking i
lesson insuch-and-such a sublectThe
tal
IS not true, but Den trovato, and the tltle of 1
Trowatore belongs in this sense t o the late E d
ward Bowen, of Harrow.whoinvented
th
story as a satire o n the Contineutkl ten6enc:
to the over-regulation of education. But ther
exists a n office in Oxford where the secretar:
-a
distinguished
mathematical
don-migh
pull out hls watch a t nine oclock next Thurs
d a y mornlng, and declare. At this hour 15,001
Enghsh schoolboys and schoolgirls in all part,
of the country-from
Berwick t o Weymouth
znd fromPenzancetoGreat
Yarmouth-wil
sit down to tackle my examination papers
11
arithmetic For next week is one of thl
most important in the English
school yearthe week of the Oxford Locals
Forcign students of English secondary edu
-ation have scarcely given due attentlon to thc
p a r t played in its development by the local
examinations oJ the older universities.Unti
the last few years the national Governmen
h a d littleto do withthesecondary
schools
There had grown up a large number of sucl
schools of varyingtypes and underdivers
-.ontrol-old endowed schools. schools foundec
3y religious denominations and other corpora,
tlons. and schools owned by private mdivid.
uals. It allseemed utterly chaotic-an
exam.
ple of independence run mad Yet, in fact
;his apparently heterogeneous mass of institu.
:ions was largely coordinated by a n examina.
i o n system, Orianated by Oxford, and afterflards adopted by Cambridge also. which. whilc
tht
tllowing elasttcity of method,brought
Nark of these schools to the test of a commor
jtandard The impartial outside criterlon
thu!
tpplied t o wealthy and poor schools alike gav6
L recognltion to good teachingwherever
pas t o be found. and helped to kill off the pre.
:entiousacademies, so called,whose ineffi.
:iency had hitherto escaped exposure. I n thc
3mallcr ruraltowns, especially. the local extminations of thetwouniversities
did muck
.o raise the tone of the secondary schools
ong before the national Government attemptanything in the way of Inspection and asxstance.
Next weeks Oxford local exammations m1
,e held slmultaneously at 41 centres in or neal
London, 351 in the provlnces. and 1 3 abroad
3f the last group,threecentresare
In Nen
at St. Kitts, one
:ealand, one inNatal,one
n the Bahamas, one at Malta. one at Hong:ong. one at a mission settlement at Chefoo,
the
convent
nd f o u r In Belgium. where
chools for mrls attract many English pupils.
!he establishment of a local centre IS not a
eryintricate
affair Most of thework
is
one by some resident interested in education,
Tho undertakes the duties of local secretary
e gathers around him
localcommittee t o
hare the financialresponsibihtyandtake
urns m assisting in thesupervisioninthe
xamination room Some centresadmit boys
nly, others,glrls, only, and others both boys
s d girls The ldcalcommittee has to guarI
125
m t e e t o the Oxford Delegacy of Local ExamInations that I t will nresentnotlessthan
twenty-fivecandldates, each paying- toheadquarters a fee of 1, o r that, in default of the
of
fullnumber, It will makeupthebalance
fees The committee is authorizedtocharge
the candidates an additional fee of a few shillings tomeetthe
localexpenses
of hire of
examination room, stationery. postage. and the
superintending examiners railway fare, board,
and lodging. At some centres the number of
canddates considerably exceeds a hundred. I n
such cases the local committee can afford to
very small sum, and,
reduce its local fee to
at the same time. have
surplus to spend on
prizes.
Candidates may come fromany school or
may have been privatelytaughtTheyenter
themselves for either the senior, the Junior,
the preliminary examination. Theyarenot
ehmble f o r honors in the senior if over nineteen years of age, o r In the lunior over seventeen, or in the preliminary over fourteen, but
candidates for a pass certificate are admitted
though exceedmg these ages
The senior examination comprises twentythreesections.
(1) arlthmetic: (2) rehaous
knowledge: (3) history; (4) Enghshlanguage
and 1iteraNre; (5) geography; ( 6 ) polltical
economy, etc., (7) Latin; (8) Greek, (9)
French: (10) German. (11) Italian. (12)
Spanish; (13) mathematics; (14) higher mathematics, (15) botany: (16) chemistry: (17)
physics, (18) domesticscience andhygiene,
(19) music; (20) bookkeeping; (21) needlework; (22) natural science, and (23) drawing
To obtam a certificate candldate must satisfy
theexaminers
in at least five sub~ects, of
which four must be from sectlons (1) to (19).
No one may offer morethaneightsubJects
rom sections (2) t o (23) The scheme is thus
distinctly a n elective one, while discouraging
soft snaps It is announced that the quality
of the handwriting and of the spelling and the
style of the composition will be taken into ac-aunt throughout the examInatIon
Still further alternatives are offered in the
3etmls of thevarlous
sections. so that the
schools which send
candidates are not
lbllped
follow a n identical
curriculum
There are choices, for example, in the books of
Scripture that may be stuaed for ( 2 ) . in the
serlods of history f o r ( 3 ) . in the Enghsh classics for (41, and in the Latin and Greek books
Cor (7) and (8). Themusic is entirelytheretical, but no one can pass in chemistry or
mtanywithoutsatlsfymgpractlcaltests
A
31milw- syllabus, butlessadvanced
and less
rarled. is prescribed for the lunior examina;ion, w1thtwenty sections, and fortheprclmlnary, with seventeen
The experience of many years has brought
;he management of theseexaminationsto
a
ugh pitch of efficiency.. The instructions issued from headquarters at Oxford t o superlnending examinersand localcommlttees,
as
re11 as to CanChdates, make what appears like
, complicated
scheme
work
with
perfect
moothness. At each centrethesupenntendn g examiner is an Oxford
appolnted by
he Delegacy
H e has nothingto
do with
udging the answers, but IS responsible for the
upervision during the whole of the examinaton week.
le hdsto see. f o r instance, that
he local committee has housed the exammaLon In adequate rooms with a desk space of
feet for^ each candidate. that the sealed
Nackets of questlon papersare
opened and
he contents
distrlbuted
at the prescribed
tmes,- that the answers are collected accord-