Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0 INTRODUCTION
1
BACKGROUND
Zimbabwe imports all of its petroleum which is then refined to produce various petroleum
products like petrol and diesel oil. Despite governments support for the use of unleaded and
leaded petrol which is a health hazard. The use of petrol without fuel oxygenate poses an
environmental threat, Oxygenates help petrol burn more completely, reducing emissions from
motor vehicles; dilutes or displaces gasoline components such as aromatics (e.g., benzene) and
sulphur; and optimizes the oxidation during combustion and they help raise the oxygen content
of petrol. Our group proposes the use of methyl tertiary-butyl ether (MTBE) as an alternative
petrol additive/oxygenates to lead and other additives hence the need for a feasibility study on
the production of MTBE production in Zimbabwe. MTBE fuel blends are likely to have
substantial air quality benefits. Use of MTBE decreases gasoline overall cancer potential by
displacing more potent carcinogenic materials in gasoline. MTBE is approximately seven times
less potent than benzene and twenty five times less potent than 1, 3-butadiene, toxic components
found in gasoline and motor vehicle emissions. Releases of petrol containing either MTBE or
lead could have an impact on some drinking water sources, although the impacts associated with
MTBE tend to relate to aesthetics (i.e. Taste and odor), whereas the impacts associated with lead
generally relate to health risk.
2
High purity MTBE is being used as a process reaction solvent in the pharmaceuticals
industry
Minor use patterns are use as chromatographic eluent and use as a therapeutic agent for in
vivo dissolution of cholesterol gallstones in humans
1 | Page
ETBE (Ethyl tertiary butyl ether), TAME (Tert amyl methyl ether), DIPE(Di isopropyl
ether. These are all ethers like MTBE. There is no field data available due to limited use
of them.
Alkalytes: these are a mixture of high octane, low vapor pressure compounds that are
produced from crude oil through a catalytic cracking process. They have low solubility in
water and are likely not to pose the same risks to water resources. They also increase
PROBLEM STATEMENT
Currently there is no local production of MTBE in Zimbabwe; the country is using lead ,ETBE,
as a fuel additive. Nevertheless, there has been a public outcry rejecting the use of lead with
problems emanating from it being poisonous to human health. We seek to investigate the
technical and economic feasibility of producing MTBE in Zimbabwe.
4
JUSTIFICATION
MTBE production is cheaper since the raw materials are locally available
In Africa there is no production of MTBE, the proposal of a cost effective MTBE
production process will go a long way in alleviating Africas energy challenges.
The country can export excess MTBE to other African countries.
Availability of MTBE can go a long way in solving environmental problems associated
with the widespread use of leaded and unleaded petrol.
RESEARCH FOCUS
This study was conducted to find a technical and economic feasible process for the production of
MTBE in Zimbabwe from locally available raw materials that will account for maximum
2 | Page
production and better quality. The project aims to find a process that is energy-efficient and
affordable technology in the production of MTBE and increase its market potential.
6
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
SCOPE
The project will focus on effect of pressure, temperature and catalyst on the production of MTBE
and conversion of isobutylene. The results from the experiments will be used to design the
process and the equipment used for the production process.
8
STUDY HYPOTHESIS
PROJECT OBJECTIVES
To design a process that is economically and technically feasible.
To make an affordable and cheap fuel additive of which MTBE is cheap.
To make a petrol blend with a long shelf life. MTBE- petrol blend has a shelf life of
several years
C5H12O
18.2 wt.%
(CH3)4CO
Colorless liquid
pressure)
Boiling point
Melting point
Flash point
Auto ignition temperature
Flammable limits in air
Relative density
Vapor pressure
Reactive index
Color
55.2Oc
-108.6oC
30oC
425oC
1.5 8.5%
0.7405g/ml at 20oC
245 mm Hg at 25oC
1.3690
Colorless
4 | Page
UOP-Oleflex Process
Phillips Etherification Process
ABB Lummus Catofin Process
Snamprogetti Process.
Standard (Huls) process
ETHERMAX process (by Huls AG and UOP)
Refinery or Petrochemical plants
Merchant plants
Tertiary Butyl Alcohol
Cracker, along with fresh alcohol are fed to the reactor section. The reactor operation is liquid
phase at mild temperature and pressure. In case of MTBE, high purity MTBE is removed as a
bottom product from the fractionator and all the unreacted methanol is taken overhead. The
overhead product is then stripped of methanol in an extractor using water. The extract is sent to
the fractionator, while the denuded water is returned to the methanol extractor. (Quintain,2013)
2.1.3 ABB Lammus Catofin Process
The ABB Lummus Catofin Process uses a relatively inexpensive and durable Chromium oxide
alumina as catalyst for the dehydrogenation process. This catalyst can be easily and rapidly
regenerated under severe conditions without loss in activity. Dehydrogenation is carried out in
the gas phase over fixed beds. Because the catalyst cokes up rapidly, five reactors are typically
used. Two are on stream, while two are being regenerated and one is being purged. The reactors
are cycled between the reaction and the reheat/regeneration modes, and the thermal inertia of the
catalyst controls the cycle time, which is typically less than 10 minutes. The chromium catalyst is
reduced from Cr6+ to Cr3+ during the dehydrogenation cycle. The raw materials used to produce
MTBE by using this method are butanes, hydrogen and as well as recycled isobutene
from the system itself. In this process, there is an isostripper column, which separates the
heavies, and the light ends from which then could produce MTBE.(Hutchings,1992)
2.1.4 Snamprogetti Process
Similar to Philips Etherification Process, ethers are produced by the addition of alcohol to
reactive olefins in the presence of an ion exchange resin at mild temperature and pressure.
The feed passes through two reactors in series an isothermal tubular reactor and an adiabatic
drum reactor. The second reactor effluent goes to the product fractionation tower where the ether
product leaves the bottom stream and hydrocarbon is recovered overhead. In the MTBE process,
methanol in the overhead stream is extracted with water in the water removal tower. The extract
from the bottom enters the methanol-water fractionator, while the water overhead is recycled to
reactor feed. (Quintain,2013)
2.1.5 Standard (Huls) Process
6 | Page
The key feature of this process is the fixed bed MTBE reactor used prior to the azeotropic
distillation column .Conversions of isobutylene to MTBE are in the range 85-95%.In many
plants two reactors are used in tandem, along with recycle in order to increase the overall
conversion closer to 99%.(Quintain,2013)
2.1.6 ETHERMAX Process
This process which uses reactive distillation technology is developed by combined expertise
of Huls AG and UOP. The feed consists of methanol and hydrocarbon streams containing
reactive tertiary olefins such as isoamylene and isobutylene. Reaction takes place over an acidic
ion exchange resin at mild temperature and moderate pressure. In the MTBE case, feed first
passes through an optional water wash system to remove the resin contaminants. The majority of
the reaction is carried out in a simple fixed-bed reactor. The reactor effluent feeds the reactive
distillation column containing a proprietary packing where simultaneous reaction of the
remaining isobutylene and distillation occur. Overhead from the reactive distillation column is
routed to methanol recovery, a simple counter current extraction column using water, and a
methanol-water distillation column. The recovered methanol is recycled to the reactor section.
Hydrocarbon raffinate is typically sent to a downstream alkylation or oligomerization unit.
(Quintain,2013)
Refinery or Petrochemical
Isobutylene produced is a by product in refinery catalytic crackers and in petrochemical ethylene
plants, is reacted with methanol to produce MTBE.
Merchant plants
Normal butane is isomerized to isobutene, the isobutene is dehydrogenated to isobutylene and
then combined with methanol to produce MTBE.
TBA Plants
Tertiary butyl alcohol is a byproduct of propylene oxide production process. The TBA is reacted
with methanol to produce MTBE.
7 | Page
to
suppress
undesired
side
reactions
that
produce
undesired
products.
(Collignon,1996).The Philips Etherification process uses three distillator but for our process
design we will employ two fractional distillators due to the replacement of mixed butenes with
just isobutylene in the process, thus saving money. In the original etherification process,
methanol is recycled to the reactor feed whilst butenes and the unreacted methanol are treated as
waste.In our process design we recycle both the unreacted methanol and isobutylene, thus
maximizing on raw materials and profits.
Chemical Reaction
The reaction is facilitated by a sulphonated ion-exchange resin catalyst. The reaction is:
8 | Page
High conversion (greater than 98 %) with few by-products compared to other process
The process operates under low pressure and has a low pressure drop and this means that
Reactor
Several reactor types may be considered for use in this process such as:
For our process we are going to use an adiabatic packed bed reactor:
A packed bed reactor consists of a vessel containing one or several tubes of packed catalyst
particles in a fixed, non-mobile bed (Rase, 1990). Packed bed reactors are an economical choice
in large scale production. This is due to the fact that they can operate nearly continuously due to
the long catalyst life; which leads to savings in annual costs and shutdown costs. Reactors with a
single adiabatic bed are traditionally used in either exothermic or endothermic reactions.
However, they are primarily used for exothermic reactions in industrial practice (Satterfield,
1996). This type of adiabatic reactor is the least expensive to produce and is used as often as is
practical. Maintaining an adiabatic state conserves energy and can result in large savings for a
company. A packed bed reactor with adiabatic beds in series is used for high conversion
reactions with no heat transfer to the environment. Other advantages for using an adiabatic
packed bed reactor are Higher conversion per unit mass of catalyst than other catalytic reactors,
9 | Page
Low operating cost, Continuous operation, No moving parts to wear out, Catalyst stays in the
reactor, Reaction mixture/catalyst separation is easy.
Distillation Columns
Batch Columns
In batch operation, the feed to the column is introduced batch-wise. That is, the column is
charged with a 'batch' and then the distillation process is carried out. When the desired task is
achieved, a next batch of feed is introduced.
Continuous Columns
In contrast, continuous columns process a continuous feed stream. No interruptions occur
unless there is a problem with the column or surrounding process units. They are capable of
handling high throughputs.
Our process will use a continuous tray type column where trays of various designs are used to
hold up the liquid to provide better contact between vapor and liquid, hence better separation.
The process will therefore use a fractional distillater which is the most common form of
separation technology used in petroleum refineries, petrochemical and chemical plants, natural
gas processing and cryogenic air separation plants. In most cases, the distillation is operated at
a continuous steady state. New feed is always being added to the distillation column and
products are always being removed. Unless the process is disturbed due to changes in feed,
heat, ambient temperature, or condensing, the amount of feed being added and the amount of
product being removed are normally equal. This is known as continuous, steady-state fractional
distillation. The advantages of using a plate column are: Most cost efficient distillation column
for diameters greater than 0.6 m,the liquid/vapor contact in the cross-flow of plate columns is
more effective than the countercurrent-flow in packed columns, Cooling coils can easily be
added to the plate column(cryogenic applications),Can handle high liquid flow rates costeffectively.
(encyclopedia.che.engin.umich.edu/Pages/SeparationsChemical/DistillationColumns/Distillatio
10 | P a g e
nColumns.html)
3
Heat Exchangers
There are 3 types of heat exchangers namely:
Shell and tube heat exchanger
Plate heat exchanger
Adiabatic wheel heat exchanger
The process will use a shell and tube heat exchanger, Shell and tube heat exchangers are
comprised of multiple tubes through which liquid flows. The tubes are divided into two sets:
the first set contains the liquid to be heated or cooled. The second set contains the liquid
responsible for triggering the heat exchange, and either removes heat from the first set of tubes
by absorbing and transmitting heat awayin essence, cooling the liquidor warms the set by
transmitting its own heat to the liquid inside. When designing this type of exchanger, care must
be taken in determining the correct tube wall thickness as well as tube diameter, to allow
optimum heat exchange. (R. Shankar Subramanian. Shell-and-Tube Heat Exchangers)
Advantages
Here are the main advantages of shell-and-tube heat exchanger:
The pressures and pressure drops can be varied over a wide range.
Thermal stresses can be accommodated inexpensively.
There is substantial flexibility regarding materials of construction to accommodate
corrosion and other concerns. The shell and the tubes can be made of different
materials.
Extended heat transfer surfaces (fins) can be used to enhance heat transfer.
Cleaning and repair are relatively straightforward, because the equipment can be
dismantled for this purpose.( http://www.thomasnet.com/articles/processequipment/heat-exchanger-types)
Pumps
11 | P a g e
Classification of Pumps
Pumps used in process industries may be broadly classified in two main types:
Dynamic Pumps
Dynamic (kinetic) pumps such as centrifugal pumps are pumps in which energy is imparted
to the pumped liquid by means of a moving Impeller or Propeller rotating on a shaft. The
kinetic energy imparted to the fluid in terms of velocity by the moving impeller is converted
to pressure as the liquid leaves the Impeller and moves through a stationary volute or diffuser
casing. (http://www.pumpscout.com/all-pump-types)
Positive-displacement Pumps
Positive-displacement pumps are those pumps in which energy is imparted to liquid in a
fixed displacement volume such as a casing or cylinder by the rotating motion of gears,
screws or vanes, by reciprocating pistons or by plunger.( http://www.pumpscout.com/allpump-types)
The process will use centrifugal pumps, which are often the best choice for low viscosity
(thin) liquids (MTBE and isobutylene) and high flow rates. The pump uses one or more
impellers that attach to and rotates with the shaft. The rotation of the impeller creates energy
that moves liquid through the pump and pressurizes the liquid to move it through the piping
system.
(http://www.energymanagertraining.com/Journal/24092005/SelectionofPumpsforProcessIndu
stries.pdf)
For experimental design in research methodology the mixed butanes stream is replaced by a
stream of pure isobutylene to react with the methanol. The feed components have been altered
therefore the Philips etherification process has to be modified in the process design chapter in
order for it to align with our experimental design and results in the following two chapters.
12 | P a g e
Internet
Experimental results
Consultation of expert engineers
Chemical engineering journals
13 | P a g e
3.3 INTERVIEWS
We visited some industries in the petrochemicals sector and carried out interviews to find out
information about;
Experiment to determine the amount of MTBE produced from one kilogram of methanol
and one kilogram of isobutylene.
14 | P a g e
How the yield of MTBE changes with change in temperature, amount of catalyst and
change in pressure.
Experiment to determine the purity of methanol
After obtaining the product from the reaction of methanol and isobutylene the following tests
were to be done
Catalytic reaction: Methanol was obtained from NCP distillers and isobutylene from
Masasa chemical suppliers. 0. 5 grams of sulphonated ion exchange resin catalyst was
incorporated into the fixed bed. 50 grams of methanol feed and 25 grams (42.5 cm 3) of
isobutylene feed were put into the reaction vessel using a syringe pump and sealed. The
experiment was carried out in a stainless steel fixed bed reactor containing a magnetic
stirrer at 30 bars and 90oC over a period of 2 hrs. Note density of isobutylene =
0.5879g/cm3
Fractional distillation: The product stream from the catalytic reaction was put into a
II
fractional distillatory to separate MTBE and the unreacted methanol. The boiling point
for MTBE is 55.2oC.The boiling point for methanol is 64.7oC and the boiling point of
isobutylene is -6.9oC.So as the MTBE reached its boiling point it turned into vapor and
condensed in the condenser and then collected as product. Hence what remained in the
distillation column was collected.
3.4.2 TESTING FOR THE PURITY OF METHANOL
Aim
Determining the purity of methanol
Apparatus
Beaker, methanol and hydrometer
Procedure
15 | P a g e
A small sample of the condensate was put into the test tube
two drops of chromium trioxide were added
The tube was observed for an immediate (2-5 sec) color change
Aqueous Potassium iodide solution was added into the test tube containing a sample of
the product and observed
16 | P a g e
RESULTS
FOR
THE
CATALYTIC
AND
FRACTIONAL DISTILLATION
EXPERIMENT
Table 2 Results for the catalytic and fractional distillation experiment
Experiment
Pressure(bars)
Temperature(oC)
Mass
Mass
1
2
3
4
5
6
20
20
20
20
20
20
50
70
90
100
110
150
collected(g)
47.78
49.17
51.73
50.45
46.89
40.75
distillation flask
22.56
21.75
20.94
22.10
21.36
20.67
left
in
17 | P a g e
20
200
35.98
19.55
% conversion
81.36
83.68
90.68
90.20
73.00
45.68
22.12
18 | P a g e
20 | P a g e
Formation of an opaque suspension with a green to blue after two drops of chromium trioxide
was observed color was observed. This implies that a primary alcohol is present in our product.
Hence we can conclude that methanol is present in our product since it was fed in excess.
4.3.3 Test for ether
Results
Formation of a tan solution after 3 drops of potassium iodide was observed. This implies that
ether is present in our product. Hence we can conclude that MTBE which is a major constituent
of our product is present in the product obtained
21 | P a g e
PROCESS INFORMATION
E-1 Methanol storage tank
E-3 MTBE reactor
E-4 distillation column for separation of methanol, isobutylene and methanol
22 | P a g e
23 | P a g e
0.598 C5H12O
100Kmol/hr
.
0.349 CH3OH
0.67 CH3OH
0.031 C4H8
0.022 H2O
Figure 5: MTBE reactor material balance
5.3.2 DISTILLATOR E-3
2.22kmol/hr. H2O
3.08kmol/hr. C4H8
26.69kmo/hr.
CH3OH
59.84kmol/hr. C5H12O
34.86kmol/hr. CH3OH
3.08kmol/hr. C4H8
2.22kmol/hr. H2O
24 | P a g e
59.84kmol/hr. C5H12O
8.16kmol/hr. CH3OH
26.69kmo/hr.CH3OH
3.08kmol/hr.C4H8
2.22kmol/hr. H2O
3.08kmol/hr.C4H8
26.69kmol/hr.CH3
H2O
Figure 7: E-5 material balance
2.22kmo/hr.
25 | P a g e
CALCULATIONS
MTBE Reactor
From experimental results isobutylene overall conversion is 90.68% therefore number of moles
of isobutylene that reacted are: 0.9068*0.33*100 = 29.92kmol/hr.
Table 4: MTBE reactor stoichiometric balances
CH3OH (kmol/hr.)
67
1
2
29.92
37.08
Moles
Stoichiometric moles
Actual moles
Reacted moles
Unreacted moles
C4H8(kmol/hr.)
33
1
1
29.92
3.08
T2
T1
CpdT x (n)
Should there is any reaction in the process; we need also to find the values of HR which takes
place in the equipment. The equation, which we used to find HR is:
HR= (F product- F reactant) x n
5.4.1 MTBE REACTOR
27 | P a g e
T = 94oC,
T = 101oC,
P = 2000kPa
P = 2000kPa
Flow
rates Hf
CH3OH
C4H8
(kmol/hr.)
67
33
To
kJ/kmol
-238600
-16830
K
298
298
K
367
367
kJ/hr.
609400
343480
H =95288 0
Table 6: Stream 3
Substance
Hf
To
CH3OH
C4H8
C5H12
H2O
kmol/hr.
34.90
3.10
59.84
2.20
kJ/kmol.
-238600
-16830
-277250
-242000
K
298
298
298
298
K
374
374
374
374
kJ/hr.
351200
35670
670390
6.10
H
=1063360
Stream 2
Hr = 67*(-238600) + 33*(-16830) =-4286.34kW
Stream 3
Hr = 34.9*(-238600) + 3.10*(-16830) + 59.84*(-277250) +2.20*(-242000) = -7083.99kW
28 | P a g e
Energy balance
Q - W = Hr + Hout - Hin + KE +PE
KE = 0
PE = 0
H = Hr + Hout - Hin
Hr. = Hr. (products) - Hr. (reactants)
Hr. = -7083.99-(-4286.34) = - 2797.65kW
H = (-2797.65) + 295.38-(264.69)
H = -2766.96kW
H = Q = -2766.96kW
5.4.2 DISTILLATOR E-4
T = 53.3oC
P = 305kPa
T = 64.5oC
P = 450kPa
29 | P a g e
P = 400KPa
T = 103.3oC
Figure 11: E-4 energy balance
Table 7: Stream 3
Substance
Hf
To
Tf
C5H12O
kmol/hr.
59.84
kJ/kmol
-277250
K
298
K
337.5
kJ/hr.
333170
CH3OH
34.90
-238600
298
337.5
178300
C4H8
3.10
-16830
298
337.5
28160
H2O
2.20
-285840
298
337.5
3150
H = 542780
Table 8: Stream 7
Substance
Hf
To
C5H12O
CH3OH
kmol/hr.
59.84
8.16
kJ/kmol.
-277250
-238600
K
298
298
K
376.3
376.3
kJ/hr.
692550
84720
H =777270
Hf
To
Table 9: Stream 4
Substance
30 | P a g e
CH3OH
C4H8
H2O
kmol/hr.
26.69
3.08
2.22
kJ/kmol
-238600
-16830
-285840
K
298
298
298
K
326.3
326.3
326.3
kJ/hr.
96980
12807
2280
H = 112130
Energy balance
Q - W = Hr + Hout - Hin + KE +PE
W=0
Hr=0
PE=0
KE=0
Q = Hout - Hin
Q = (215.91 + 31.15)-(150.77)
Q = 96.29kW
5.4.3 DISTILLATOR E-5
T = 53.3oC
P = 100kPa
31 | P a g e
T = 40oC
P = 100kPa
T = 30oC
P = 100kPa
Hf
To
CH3OH
C4H8
H2O
kmol/Hr.
26.69
3.08
2.22
kJ/kmol
-238600
-16830
-283840
K
298
298
298
K
313
313
313
kJ/hr.
50950
6770
2850
H = 60170
Hf
To
C4H8
CH3OH
kmol/hr.
3.08
26.69
kJ/kmol
-16830
-238600
K
298
298
K
326
326
kJ/hr.
6770
95930
H = 102700
32 | P a g e
Hf
To
Tf
H2O
kmol/hr.
2.22
kJ/kmol
-238840
K
298
K
303
kJ/hr.
400
Energy balance
Q - W = Hr + Hout - Hin + KE +PE
W=0
Hr=0
PE=0
KE=0
Q = Hout - Hin
Q = (1.88 + 26.65+0.11)-16.71
Q = 11.93kW
5.5.4 Energy balance around preheater E-6
Stream 1
Stream 2
Flow
rates Hf
CH3OH
C4H8
(kmol/hr.)
67
33
kJ/kmol
-238600
-16830
To
K
298
298
K
298
398
kJ/hr.
0
0
H = 0
Substance
Flow
rates Hf
CH3OH
C4H8
(kmol/hr.)
67
33
kJ/kmol
-238600
-16830
To
K
298
298
K
367
367
kJ/hr.
609400
343480
H =95288 0
Q = Hout - Hin
Q = 246.69 0
Q = 246.69 kW
5.5.1 ISOBUTYLENE
- Colorless liquefied gas, odorless.
- Flammable gas. May cause flash fire
- Contents under pressure
- Detection of leak via sense of smell may not be possible if odorant has degraded
- Contact with liquefied gas can cause frostbite
- Liquid can cause eye and skin injury
- Reduces oxygen available for breathing
Physical and Chemical Properties
Appearance and odor:
Ph.:
Na
Vapor pressure:
72 psia @ 37.8 c
2.1
Boiling point:
-12c (10.4f)
Solubility:
negligible
Percent volatile:
100 % volume
Specific gravity:
0.564 @ 15.6 c
Evaporation rate:
>1
liquid
Boiling Point:
64.7oC
Vapor Pressure
(20oC): 128 mb
1.11
full
Specific Gravity:
0.792 g/cm3
liquid-colorless-odor specific
36 | P a g e
12oC
Extinguishing media:
Special firefighting:
Moderate
Reactivity Data
Stability:
Medium
Conditions to avoid:
Oxidizing materials
Incompatibility:
Sulfo-chromic mixtures
Special Precautions
Precaution to be taken in handling and storing Methanol: store in iron or steel Containers
or tanks. Small quantities can be stored in reinforced glass containers.
5.5.3 MTBE
MTBE is chemically stable; it does not polymerize, nor will decompose under normal conditions
of temperature and pressure. Unlike most ether, MTBE does not tend to form peroxides (autooxidize). The physical state of MTBE is that MTBE is in the form of liquid at room temperature
(25oC). It is a colorless liquid with the billing point at 55.2 oC. The freezing point of MTBE is
108.6oC 163.5oC. The density of MTBE at 25oC is 735g/cm3.
Physical dangers
MTBE is non-reactive. It does not react with air, water, or common materials of
construction. The reactivity of MTBE with oxidizing materials is probably low. However,
without definitive information, it should be assumed that MTBE reacts with strong oxidizers,
including peroxides.
Chemical dangers
MTBE is highly flammable and combustible when exposed to heat or flame or spark, and it is a
moderate fire risk. Vapors may form explosive mixtures with air. It is unstable in acid solutions.
37 | P a g e
Fire may produce irritating, corrosive or toxic gases. Runoff from fire control may contain
MTBE and its combustion products.
Inhalation risk
Like other ethers, inhalation of high levels of MTBE by animals or humans results in the
depression of the central nervous system. Symptoms observe red in rats exposed to 4000 or 8000
ppm in air included labored respiration, ataxia, decreased muscle tone, abnormal gait, impaired
treadmill performance, and decreased grip strength. These symptoms were no longer evident 6
hours after exposure ceased. A lower level of MTBE, 800ppm did not produce apparent effects
(Daughtrey et al., 1997). A number of investigations have been conducted to examine the selfreported acute MTBE in gasoline vapors during use by consumers. This research includes both
epidemiological studies and studies involving controlled exposure of volunteers to MTBE
at concentrations similar to those encountered in refueling an automobile (Reviewed in
USEPA, 1997, and California EPA, 1998). In general, the studies involving controlled
human exposures in chambers to levels of MTBE similar to those experienced during refueling
and driving an automobile have not shown effects of MTBE on physical symptoms (e.g.
irritation), mood, or performance based tests of neurobehavioral function.
.
5.5.4 ENVIRONMENTAL CONSDIDERATIONS
Nowadays, environmental issues become very important. Besides this, a good waste treatment
system is also important in order to reduce and minimize environmental pollutants. The
chemical waste in the form of solid, liquid and gases must be treated before being discharged
into sewage, drain and atmospheres.
Any chemical plant to be set up in Zimbabwe must follow the rules and regulations
under the Environmental Management Act (Chap 20:27) Section 140 as read with Statutory
Instrument 10 of 2007 (Hazardous Waste Management), is the legislation that regulates handling
of hazardous waste, and are the legal instrument used to manage hazardous waste in the country.
Under these regulations, no person shall generate, store, sell, transport, use, recycle, discharge or
dispose of hazardous waste to the environment except under a licence from the Environmental
Management Agency (EMA).
38 | P a g e
The plant owner or waste generator must ensure that waste generated is disposed
appropriately to prevent environmental pollution. The proper and suitable methods should be
implemented in dealing with the waste disposal. MTBE plant is not excluded from these
regulations. As our plant produces MTBE which is not hazardous to the environment and
humans if safety measures are taken into consideration. These environmental considerations
depend on the location of our plant.
39 | P a g e
Zimbabwe has the largest known reserves of methane in Southern Africa; our project intends to
utilize this abundant natural resource which is lying dormant for the benefit of the nation. This
means both methanol and isobutylene can be produced locally from the methane. At full capacity
the actual raw material requirement is 67 000 tons methanol and 33 000 tons isobutylene at an
estimated cost of USD 24 990 000.
6.5 Land and buildings
The cost of land and buildings is estimated to be USD 300 000.
6.6 Location and site
The best location is the source of the raw materials to minimize transport costs, therefor the plant
can be set up in proximity to the methane reserves.
Table 13: Fixed assets and fixed costs
FIXED ASSETS
Land and Buildings
Vehicles
Installation labor
MTBE reactor
Distillation column x2
Storage tanks x3
Piping
Plant maintenance
Total
COST
(X$1000)
300
50
100
200
120
45
5
5
825
FIXED COSTS
AMOUNT
Depreciation
Interest
Taxes
Insurance
(X$1000)
480
240
180
120
Total
1020
COST
Methanol
Isobutylene
Catalyst
Total
(X$1000)
16080
8910
800
25790
FACTORY OVERHEADS
COST
Security
Employee benefits
Medical allowance
Total
(X$1000)
120
60
60
240
COST (X$1000)
40 | P a g e
Administrative
Research and Development
Employees
Marketing
Total
240
60
120
60
480
1 year
Source of finance
Bank interest
Accounts receivables
30 days
Raw materials
30 days
Work in progress
1 day
Cash in hand
5 days
Accounts payable
30 days
42 | P a g e
30
$(mill)
Sales income
Total costs
Variable costs
Fixed costs
1,74
41.3
50
100
% CAPACITY
Figure 13: Break even plot
Significant reduction in air pollution due to the reduction in flue gas emission.
Improvement of competiveness as MTBE has a lower cost as compared to other
additives.
Job creation
Likewise implementation of this project will provide for the ever sought for clean solutions. The
production of this product also promises huge exports that will turn over the current economic
situation in Zimbabwe.
APPENDIX
45 | P a g e
REFERENCES
1. Hutchings GJ, Nicolaides CP, Scurrell MS. 1992. Developments in the Production of
Methyltert-Butyl Ether. Catalysis Today. 15: p. 23-49.
2. Matouq M, Tagawa T, Goto, S. 1994. Combined Process for Production of Methyl tertButyl Ether from tert-Butyl Alcohol and Methanol. J. Chem. Eng. Japan 27, p.302-306.
3. Collignon F, Londers R, Martens JA, Jacobs PA, Poncelet G. 1996. Liquid Phase
Synthesis of MTBE from Methanol and Isobutene Over Acid Zeolites and Amberlyst-15.
J. of Catalysis 182, p. 302-312.
4. Armando T. Quitain, Shunsaku Katoh and Motonobu Goto. 2013 Synthesis of BiomassDerived Gasoline Fuel Oxygenates by Microwave Irradiation.
46 | P a g e
5. Casebook#4, Rev 1.Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether (MTBE) Plant. March 1995
6. Encik Mohd Napis Bin Sudin. 2003, Production of MTBE, Malaysia, Kuantan.
Interview,8 July
7. Puan Masri. 2003. Information of MTBE production, Malaysia, Kuantan. Interview, 28
Jun.
8. Ray/Johnston (1989). Chemical Engineering Design Project, a case study approach,
volume 6. Gordon and Breach Science Publishers
9. V.K Vayaraman, B.D Kulkarni. CHEMICAL ENGINEERING AND CHEMICAL
PROCESS TECHNOLOGY-Volume 3-catalytic reactors: A Review
10. Bhanu Pratap Singh, Ram Singh, M V Pavan Kumar and Nitin Kaistha. Steady State
Analyses for Reactive Distillation Control: An MTBE Case Study
11. J.P. Holman, Heat Transfer, 9th Edition, McGraw-Hill, 2002
12. Peters, M.S., Timmerhaus, K.D., and West, R.E., Plant Design and Economics for
Chemical Engineers, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2003.
13. Chemical Engineering World,Vol. XXXV No. 3,March 2000
14. encyclopedia.che.engin.umich.edu/Pages/SeparationsChemical/DistillationColumns/Disti
llationColumns.html
15. http://www.thomasnet.com/articles/process-equipment/heat-exchanger-types
16. http://www.energymanagertraining.com/Journal/24092005/SelectionofPumpsforProcessI
ndustries.pdf
47 | P a g e