Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Before you can conduct your first DACUM workshop, you will need to do considerable planning
in order for it to go smoothly. This includes everything from arranging for workshop facilities
and support services to selecting your DACUM workshop team.
Once these plans are in place, you will need to prepare the agenda,
the meeting room and other workshop materials to conduct a
successful workshop. The tasks in Duty B will prepare you to
effectively plan the DACUM workshop.
Task B-1. Conduct
Occupational Analysis
Literature Search
You may want to search the literature if the circumstances warrant
One of the first tasks the facilitator may want to perform is to
conduct a search of the literature for existing occupational
analyses. However, many facilitators consider this task to be
unnecessary when the standard two-day DACUM workshop
process is used. A well-selected panel of expert workers
properly guided by a trained facilitator can produce results that
are just as high quality, if not higher than those achieved without
using a literature base for reference.
When you are limited to conducting what is commonly referred
to as a modified DACUM (a time period of less than the
recommended two full days), you should probably search the
literature for available occupational analyses, if any, in your area
of concern. A compilation of all the duties and tasks found in
the literature should result in a comprehensive listing of all the
unique duties and tasks found. Three major challenges face the
facilitator in developing such a compilation.
Sources of existing analyses.
First, it may be difficult to fmd one or more recent (less than
eight years old) job or occupational analyses (DACUM or
others). Sources of existing analyses include: (1) DACUM
Research Chart Bank maintained by the Center on Education and
Training for Employment (see page B-18), and (2) some regional
and state operated curriculum centers and laboratories (see page
B-19).
Beware of different terminology.
The second challenge is coping with differences in terminology.
Involve key
administrators.
Administrators. Although the specific administrators who need
to be involved will vary from institution- to institution, persons
such as academic deans, occupational deans, vocational directors, program area coordinators,
staff and program development directors, and instructional development
coordinators are the administrators most likely to be concerned.
All of these persons should be aware of the facilitator's plans,
and some of them will need to approve the time schedule,
budget, personnel involved, and occupational area(s) selected.
Instructors should be
appropriately involved.
Instructional staff. It is obvious that if the DACUM is
intended, for example, to analyze the auto mechanics trade and
the current auto mechanics instructors are to support that effort,
they must become involved. The instructors can usually be
helpful in identifying various employers in the community that
employ the type of experienced people needed for the DACUM
panel. Although the instructors should never serve as
participants on the panel itself, they are probably the best single
source for identifying potential employers and/or participants.
The instructors' involvement in this identification process will
enable them to play a significant role in helping to organize the
panel.
Sometimes an instructor or group of instructors resists
involvement in the planning process. Resistance may arise for
many reasons, but usually it disappears quickly once they
understand what DACUM is all about and how it can help them
do a better job.
Occasionally, instructors who continue to resist the development
of a DACUM chart for their area may be aware that portions of
their training program are out of date, and they may fear any
disclosure of this situation. Such instructors should be assured
that the DACUM chart itself does not reveal, in any public way,
any possible discrepancies between what is being taught and
what should be. That type of analysis is left to the instructors,
program development specialists, and other pertinent school
personnel after the DACUM panel has gone home. In addition,
there are virtually no training programs that do not become out
of date at some point in our technological age. It is to be
expected. That is why the DACUM process should be used to
develop and maintain curriculum relevance.
Support personnel. Depending on the institutional situation,
various support staff may need to become involved and can be
helpful in the planning process. If an institution has curriculum
The ideal panel has 6-10 members. Expert workers are those
who perform the various job tasks of concern and are, without
doubt, in the best position to explain "what they do" that makes
them successful on the job. With fewer than five persons, the
power of the process and the quality of. the resulting DACUM
Research Chart diminishes. With more than 12 persons, the panel becomes unwieldy, and the
satisfaction of panel members
tends to lessen due to more limited opportunities for input.
Be careful about
including supervisors of
the expert workers.
The presence of too many supervisors and managers can present
problems. Supervisors and managers tend to contribute less than
most expert workers, and in at least some situations their
presence inhibits the free exchange of ideas. It is considered
okay to have one or two immediate supervisors on the panel,
provided they do not try to dominate the discussion or inhibit the
free input of the workers. However, these supervisors must not
be supervisors of any of the expert workers on your panel.
When this occurs, some of the workers are likely to be inhibited
to a significant degree.
Even when only expert workers are invited, you are still likely
to end up with one or more supervisors attending. Supervisors
can defmitely be helpful in some ways. The immediate
supervisors provide a "reality check" during the process, since
they also know what the workers are expected to be able to do.
The presence of one or two supervisors also limits the tendency
of some workers to want to "enhance" their occupation by
including management or other higher-level tasks that workers
really do not perform.
A minimum offive
persons are needed for a
high quality DACUM
workshop.
Because a reasonably sized group is required to obtain fair
representation of the types of workers involved in the
occupation, as well as to obtain needed group interaction, a
DACUM workshop should not be conducted with fewer than
five panel members. It is best to select ten to twelve persons,
so that if one or two persons cannot make it at the last minute,
the panel will still be of sufficient size to function effectively.
Task B-4. Develop
Workshop Schedule
You are more likely to
obtain cooperation from
employers if you ask their
help early.
A good schedule is important to a successful DACUM
workshop. First of all, for the standard DACUM workshop,
you need to allocate two full days for most occupations. For
occupations that are highly cognitive in nature and more
abstract, it may be best to allocate two and one-half or three
days. In most cases, two consecutive week days will be best. If
necessary, however, workshops can be successfully conducted
over the weekend, or even on four consecutive half days. In
establishing a date for the workshop, you need to check on the
availability of the facilitator, the avaihibility of the meeting room, and most important, the
availability of potential panel
members. Some occupations are seasonal in nature, and
obtaining the expert workers you want for two days is likely to
be impossible. For example, accountants are busy with tax
preparations each January through April and would not likely be
available then.
The following suggested schedule and activities have proven
helpful and may serve as a guide to avoid forgetting something
really important during the pre-workshop planning phase.
Complete initial
planning.
60 to 90 Days Prior to the DACUM Workshop
Decide on the job or occupational area to be analyzed.
Establish dates for the actual workshop (experience indicates
that two full days are needed to analyze most occupations).
Decide who will serve as DACUM facilitator and confirm
dates and other arrangements. See the section on facilitating
group interactions for details regarding the skills and
personal characteristics needed.
Decide who will assist in the planning and coordination of
the workshop. In most cases, the facilitator or support staff
will initiate and confirm most of the necessary arrangements,
although others may assist, if desired.
Prepare a general written description of the job or
occupational areas to be analyzed. This is needed to guide
the identification and selection of DACUM panel members
and possibly for the orientation of the panel during the
workshop.
Oriellt prospective panel
members about DACUM.
30 to 60 Days Prior to the DACUM Workshop
Complete the identification of employers and/or departments
who are able and willing to release expert workers and/or
supervisors.
Prepare or adapt a written explanation of DACUM to share
with employers and prospective panel members. See the
DACUM Process and Information Sheet (page B-20-21),
which may be used as a DACUM orientation information
piece.
Arrange to visit companies, businesses, and departments
personally, if possible, to explain DACUM and to request their cooperation in the identification
and release of expert
workers.
Contact all nominees in person (if possible) or by phone or email
to explain DACUM and answer possible questions.
Make arrangements for an appropriate workshop meeting
room (recommended arrangements are discussed in detail
later in this section).
Distribute pre-workshop
materials and complete
arrangements.
20 to 30 Days Prior to the DACUM Workshop
Confirm all arrangements made with DACUM panel members
by letter or e-mail, indicating workshop location, time,
directions, and so forth. Your confirmation message should
include the following materials (if they have not already been
sent):
a. Brief DACUM Process and Information Sheet (see pages
B-20-21 for a sample)
b. DACUM two-day workshop agenda (see page B-22 for a
sample).
c. Map and written directions to the workshop location.
d. Letter confirming the purpose of the workshop, dates, time
schedule, location (street address, building, room number),
parking information, and who to contact for more
information. See page B-23 for a sample confirmation
letter.
Copies of these materials and letters or e-mails should also be
sent to the appropriate supervisors or managers of the
workers.
Make the necessary arrangements for refreshments and meals.
Identify someone to serve as recorder during the DACUM
workshop. The sole function of this person is to record the
wording of duty and task statements agreed on by the panel, as
directed by the facilitator. You should not ask a panel
member to do this, nor should you try to do this while
facilitating.
Confirm and finalize
arrangements.
esselltial.
The room should be attractive and located in a quiet area that is
well lighted, well ventilated, and convenient to clean restrooms.
The facilitator should check the lighting and climate controls
before the workshop to ensure that they are functioning
properly. A panel cannot function effectively in an environment
that is too hot, too cold, too stuffy, or without easily accessible
and clean restrooms.
Call tile room
accommodate meals or
breaks?
If breaks and/or meals are to be served in the room, make sure it
is of adequate size and layout to allow for this additional use.
Disruptions by the service staff while the workshop is in
progress should be minimized.
If observers are to be invited, the observers I section of the room
must have easy access to a side door to avoid distracting or
disrupting the committee. If the room to be used is small and
lacks side or rear door accessibility, it is best to discourage
observers, as their movement in and out of the room may be
disruptive.
Media equipment needs.
While the media demands are not high, they are important. The
following equipment is recommended:
One LCD projector
One laptop computer
One projection screen (unless wall is suitable)
One or two flip chart pads with sturdy stands
While the flip chart(s) will be used throughout the workshop, the
LCD projector is normally used for only the fIrst hour of day
one. If the company or agency does not own these, they will
need to be rented locally.
For educators, there are pros andFor
cons to conducting the
Educators
DACUM on-campus versus off-campus. As long as the room is
conducive to group interaction and is free from distractions, the
specifIc location is a secondary consideration. Some schools and
community colleges may want to bring the committee members
to the campus for public relations purposes, as well as to make it
easier for other faculty and administrators to stop by and observe
the proceedings. Others may prefer to use hotel meeting rooms,
which may offer better physical arrangements and greater
convenience for lodging and meals.
For
Business
For companies and government
agencies,
there are similar pros
and cons to conducting the workshop
Trainers
in-house versus at a local
workshop.
The DACUM Facilitator
must be trained and
certified.
DACUM Facilitator. This is the formally trained person who
knows how to plan, conduct, and carry out the recommended
activities of a DACUM workshop. A word of caution is in
order here. Do not employ as a facilitator someone who has
only read about or observed someone else conduct a DACUM
workshop.
In terms of the DACUM Research Chart on the role of DACUM
Facilitator, the facilitator will always Orient the DACUM Panel
(Duty D), Facilitate Chart Development (Duty E), and Facilitate
the Group Process (Duty F). When the facilitator performs only
these three duties, a DACUM coordinator is usually appointed
and assigned to the other duties (A, B, C, G, H, I).
Facilitator teaming works
well for some.
In businesses and agencies where two or more trained facilitators
are available, facilitators report that they often team up to
conduct a workshop. In this situation, they usually take turns
rotating between the role of facilitator and recorder.
Regardless of who actually performs the pre-workshop planning
and recruitment of panel members, it is essential that the
facilitator monitor the process carefully to help assure needed
arrangements are made and the right expert workers are
selected.
A DACUM Coordinator
may carry out pre and
post workshop activities.
DACUM Coordinator. In some businesses, government
agencies, and community colleges, a person designated as the
DACUM Coordinator may be assigned to carry out preworkshop
and post-workshop activities. This person may do all
the marketing activities, the initial workshop planning and the
recruitment of workshop panel members. The coordinator is
also likely to be responsible for most, if not all, post-workshop
activities such as conducting task verification and publishing the
DACUM Research Chart.
If desired, there is absolutely no reason why the DACUM
Facilitator cannot perform these duties and tasks.
The recorder prints the
duty and task statements
DACUM Workshop
Materials
Your DACUM workshop will consist of the following materials:
Workshop agenda.
Sample, high quality DACUM Research Chart.
Task statement criteria handout.
Workshop evaluation form.
DACUM PowerPoint orientation on CD.
The agenda reassures the
panelists that the
workshop is weU planned
and organized.
The workshop agenda should specify the beginning and ending
times of the workshop and outline the major activities and the
approximate times they should occur. The agenda may be
specific to the dates and panel involved or it can be more
generic. It is reassuring to the panel that the workshop is well
planned and members can see the major time frames needed.
The agenda should be distributed at the beginning of the
orientation.
Do not use as an
example a DACUM chart
that is closely related to
the job being analyzed.
You should make sufficient copies of a high quality DACUM
chart to use as an example during the orientation. A void
selecting one that is closely related to the job or occupation you
will be analyzing so that the panelists are not easily tempted to
"copy" the work of another panel. A quality sample DACUM
chart is very helpful to explain and demonstrate to the panel
what the result of their work over the next two days will look
like.
Prepare a handout on
task statement criteria to
assist the panelists.
You should also prepare sufficient copies of a handout that
includes the following pages from the orientation:
Developing task statements.
Job task criteria.
Task statement criteria.