Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Edition: US
FRONT PAGE
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
POLITICS
BUSINESS
MEDIA
WORLDPOST
Like
SCIENCE
TECH
HEALTHY LIVING
5.3m
Follow
HUFFPOST LIVE
Futurist and inventor Ray Kurzweil predicts humans are going to develop emotions and
characteristics of higher complexity as a result of connecting their brains to computers.
Were going to be funnier. Were going to be sexier. Were going to be better at expressing
loving sentiment, Kurzweil said at a recent discussion at Singularity University. He is involved
in developing artificial intelligence as a director of engineering at Google but was not speaking
on behalf of the company.
Kurzweil predicts that in the 2030s, human brains will be able to connect to the cloud, allowing
us to send emails and photos directly to the brain and to back up our thoughts and memories.
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brab0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 1 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
This will be possible, he says, via nanobots -- tiny robots from DNA strands -- swimming
around in the capillaries of our brain. He sees the extension of our brain into predominantly
nonbiological thinking as the next step in the evolution of humans -- just as learning to use
tools was for our ancestors.
And this extension, he says, will enhance not just our logical intelligence but also our emotional
intelligence. Were going to add more levels to the hierarchy of brain modules and create
deeper levels of expression, he said. To demonstrate, he gave a hypothetical scenario with
Google co-founder Larry Page.
So Im walking along, and I see Larry Page coming, and I think, I better think of something
clever to say. But my 300 million modules in my neocortex isnt going to cut it. I need a billion
in two seconds. Ill be able to access that in the cloud -- just like I can multiply intelligence with
my smartphone thousands fold today.
In addition to making us cleverer in hallways, connecting our brains to the Internet will also
make each of us more unique, he said.
Right now, we all have a very similar architecture to our thinking, Kurzweil said. When we
can expand it without the limitations of a fixed enclosure" -- he pointed to his head -- "we we
can actually become more different."
People will be able to very deeply explore some particular type of music in far greater degree
than we can today. Itll lead to far greater individuality, not less.
This view is in stark contrast to a common perception, often portrayed in science fiction, that
cyborg technologies make us more robotic, less emotional and less human. This concern is
expressed by Dr. Miguel Nicolelis, head of neuroengineering at Duke University, who fears that
if we rely too much on machines, well lose diversity in human behavior because computers
operate in black and white -- ones and zeros -- without diversion.
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brab0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 2 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
Evolution creates structures and patterns that over time are more complicated, more
knowledgable, more creative, more capable of expressing higher sentiments, like being loving,
he said. Its moving in the direction of qualities that God is described as having without limit.
So as we evolve, we become closer to God. Evolution is a spiritual process. There is beauty and
love and creativity and intelligence in the world -- it all comes from the neocortex. So were
going to expand the brains neocortex and become more godlike.
Nanites? Robots.
But will brain nanobots actually move out of science fiction and into reality, or are they
doomed to the fate of flying cars? Like Kurzweil, Nicholas Negroponte, founder of the MIT
Media Lab, thinks that nanobots in our brains could be the future of learning, allowing us, for
example, to load the French language into the bloodstream of our brains. James Friend, a
professor of mechanical engineering at UC San Diego focused on medical nanotechnology,
thinks that we're only two to five years away from being able to effectively use brain nanobots,
for example to prevent epileptic seizures.
However, getting approval from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration would likely be very
difficult, Friend told The WorldPost. He thinks approval would take anywhere from only a few
years to never happening because of people being concerned about swimming mysterious
things into your head and leaving them there," he said.
Other scientists are skeptical that brain nanobots will be safe and effective anytime soon or at
all, largely due to how little we currently understand about how the brain works. One such
scientist is David Linden, professor of neuroscience at Johns Hopkins University School of
Medicine, who thinks the timing of Kurzweils estimation that nanobots will be in our brains in
the 2030s is premature. Linden says there are huge obstacles, such as adding a nanobot power
source, evading cells that attack foreign bodies and avoiding harming the proteins and sugars
in the tiny spaces between brain cells.
Although the science is far from application in brains, nanotechnology has long been heralded
as a potential game changer in medicine, and the research is advancing. Last year, researchers
injected into living cockroaches DNA nanobots that were able to follow specific instructions,
including dispensing drugs, and this year, nanobots were injected into the stomach lining of
mice.
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brab0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 3 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
And we are learning how to enhance our brains, albeit not with nanobots. Researchers have
already successfully sent a message from one human brain to another, by stimulating the
brains from the outside using electromagnetic induction. In another study, similar brain
stimulation made people learn math faster. And in a recent U.S. government study, a few dozen
people who were given brain implants that delivered targeted shocks to their brain scored
better on memory tests.
Were already implanting thousands of humans with brain chips, such as Parkinsons patients
who have a brain chip that enables better motor control and deaf people who have a cochlear
implant, which enables hearing. But when it comes to enhancing brains without disabilities
and for nonmedical purposes, ethical and safety concerns arise. And according to a survey last
year, 72 percent of Americans are not interested in a brain implant that could improve memory
or mental capacity.
Yet, some believe enhancement of healthy brains is inevitable, including Christof Koch, chief
scientific officer of the Allen Institute for Brain Science, and Gary Marcus, professor of
psychology at New York University. They use the analogy of breast implants -- breast surgery
was developed for post-mastectomy reconstruction and correcting congenital defects but has
since become popular for breast augmentation. Brain implants could follow the same path,
they say.
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brab0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 4 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
Here are Kurzweils answers to a couple of the questions he took at the Singularity University
discussion:
You have predicted that in 2029, we will reach the singularity -- the point at which
artificial intelligence outpaces human intelligence. Your opening remarks suggest that
youre fundamentally positive about AI in the post-2029 world. Other speakers have
been a little more ambivalent, certainly regarding the future of employment. Would you
elaborate on your overall sentiment on the post-2029 world?
Ive actually written about the dangers of AI more than most. But Im also optimistic, having
looked at the positive impact that technology has had on human life.
When it comes to the existential threat of AI, the primary strategy comes from governance and
social systems. We will have conflict between different groups of humans, each enhanced by AI.
We have that today with humans using intelligent weapons. The best tool we have to combat
that is to continue to work on our democracy, liberty and respect for each other.
When it comes to potential unemployment caused by AI, its always been the case that we can
clearly see the jobs that are going away. This started 200 years ago in the textile industry in
England. The weavers, who had enjoyed a business model passed down for centuries, were
suddenly losing their jobs to machines that could spin thread or weave cloth. You could look at
almost every job, and it would not be long before itd be automated. The reality is that
employment went up, and prosperity went up. The common man or woman, rather than just
having one shirt, could now have a whole wardrobe. Life became better, and there were
actually more jobs.
Ray Kurzweil: A.I. Will Result In More Human Jobs, Not Fewer
If I were a futurist in 1900 and said, OK, about [40 percent] of you work on farms and a third
work in factories. I predict, by the year [2012], only about two percent of us will work on farms
and [nine percent] in factories, everyone would go, Oh my God, were going to be out of
work! Id say, Don't worry. Youre going to get new jobs creating apps, web sites, chip designs
and data analysis -- nobody would have any idea what Im talking about.
Were destroying jobs at the bottom of the skill ladder and creating new jobs at the top. Weve
invested more in education in the U.S. over the last century. Weve increased per capita
investment in K-12 education significantly. We had 50,000 college students in 1870; we have
[20 million] today.
Its a difficult political situation because people can see the jobs that are going away, and that's
painful. You say, Well but there will be new jobs, and people say, What new jobs? And you
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brab0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 5 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
say, Well, I don't know; they havent been invented yet. Its kind of a weak argument. But its
true.
Were also creating jobs that move up Maslows hierarchy so we can spend more time doing
things that give us gratification. People a century ago for the most part were happy if they could
have a job and provide for their family. Today, to an increasing degree, people get gratification
from what theyre doing. They look for a career that meets their passion -- lots of people are
pursuing entrepreneurial ideas. We have 20 million college students and an equal amount of
people who teach them and support that infrastructure, all to think about knowledge and
organize knowledge. Thats not something people spent much time doing a century or two ago - were going to keep moving in that direction.
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brab0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 6 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
By the 2030s, the AIs will be able to create avatars that will seem very close to a human who
actually lived. We can take into consideration their DNA. In the 2030s, we will be able to send
nanobots into living peoples brains and extract memories of people who have passed away.
Then you can really make them very realistic.
I have collected and keep many boxes of information about my father. I have his letters, music,
8mm movies and my fading memories of him. It will be possible to create a very realistic avatar
in a virtual environment or augmented reality. When you actually interact with an avatar
physically, it will ultimately pass a Frederick Kurzweil Turing test -- meaning hell be
indistinguishable from our memories of the actual Frederick Kurzweil.
Kurzweils comments have been edited for clarity. This is part of the WorldPost Series on
Exponential Technology.
Also on WorldPost:
1 of 16
University of Edinburgh
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brab0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 7 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
MORE: Nanotechnology, Brain Nanobots, Nanobots, Kurzweil Nanobots, Kurzweil Brain Nanobots, Ray Kurzweil, Brain Nanotechnology, Nanomachines, Nanomedicine,
Artificial Intelligence, AI , Exponential Technology, Worldpost Science And Tech, WorldPost Future Series, Nanorobot
Suggest a correction
address@email.com
FOLLOW HUFFPOST
Subscribe!
HuffPost
Like
5.3m
Weird News
Like
1.1m
CONVERSATIONS
192 Comments
Sort by Top
HUFFPOST NEWSLETTERS
Get top stories and blog posts sent to me each day.
Add a comment...
address@email.com
Subscribe!
Chad Hanson
Mike Barden - I found it obvious that he assumed that the mind and the soul
were one in the same thing! That is not true. The mind receives and processes
and the soul creates and expresses. His bots are only going to magnify what's
already there to be worked with....not actually expand it from it's already finite
potential. The capacity of your intellect and aptitudes will remain basically the
same.
Like Reply
Jon Adam
That and your wife will be able to know exactly what you are thinking at all
times. Scarey scarey!
Like Reply
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brab0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 8 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
Wanda Lee
Exactly Garth....they can keep it, I'm not interested.
Like Reply
Chris Miller
Earthquake predictions are even worse!
Like Reply
Uncl Mark
Great, that's all we need...a way for the gov't to access/influence our thoughts in the
cloud (i.e. a futuristic "Patriot Act"). Will we have worry about Chinese or Russian
hackers too?
Like Reply
Uncl Mark
Would this mean that people would be able to contact you mind to mind via a
cloud? Could you imagine the nightmare of everyone being able to contact you
all the time...anytime...being unable to be alone with your own thoughts?
Sounds like a lot of futuristic insanity, if there is no on & off switch/filter to this
mental cloud.
Like Reply
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brab0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 9 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
Once our brains become interwoven with AI, we will start the permanent change to
digital presence, and organic bodies will eventually be left behind. Within a hundred
years, we could be totally digital, moving easily between a virtual world and interfacing
with a mechanical body in the real world. The next stage in our evolution will be learning
to live in a "hive mind", where the entirety of our mind will be open to everyone else - it
will be, by far, the most loving and the scariest experiences possible.
Like Reply
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
Jon Adam
Odd that such a smart man fascinated with increasing emotional intelligence and
expannding the human mind's capabilities can't seem to see the obvious pitfalls in his
vision of the future.
Kurzweil may indeed be a great idea generator, but it's blantantly obvious he lives a life
cloistered from reality.
Like Reply
Trent Balalis
Wouldn't this open the door to hackers? Can you imagine planting a virus in the cloud
that causes all our brains shut down or false memories. we can't even protect our
current technology from hacking.
Like Reply
Craig Schultz
F-erenc Szabo - Or, the idea for mass shootings being planted in sick minds by
the wide broadcast of reports of mass shootings by the news media.
Religion has pretty much been OK, with dark periods every one in a while but
mass shootings specifically and terrorist activity doesn't seem to be winding
down anytime soon and is more likely to escalate much more due to the ability
to instantly become world famous, or infamous by committing ever more
heinous acts.
Like Reply Oct 6, 2015 3:12pm
Page 10 of 11
Ray Kurzweil: In The 2030s, Nanobots In Our Brains Will Make Us 'Godlike'
10/7/15, 4:46 PM
So sick of all these naive, human-centric, "thinkers" who truly believe technology will
make the world a better place. How about nanotech that will save and make life better
for ALL creatures humans share the planet with?
Like Reply
Edward Stew
Resistance is futile.
Like Reply
John Gorn
Setting aside the ethical issues, I think his timeline is way off. The 2030s are 15 years
away and there is nothing remotely close to suggesting that technology at this level will
emerge in 15 years.
Ray's vision is sort of an extension of Google - a massive collection of data. But you
need more than data to develop something like this. It also requires the intelligence to
process it and the technology to integrate it into biological systems. Not only does none
of that exist, but those biological systems are not even deeply understood.
I think 100 years might be closer to the mark, unless the dreaded AI singularity occurs
and takes over from humans to accelerate the technology. I hope to be dead before that
happens and not to be "resurrected" as an avatar.
Like Reply
Half W. Satire
In your world, if a tree falls in the forset and YOU are not there to hear it.
It makes NO sound !
Like Reply
Jon Adam
Brian Sharritts Not even close.
Like Reply
Advertise
User Agreement
Privacy
Comment Policy
About Us
Contact Us
FAQ
"The Huffington Post" is a registered trademark of TheHuffingtonPost.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
Part of HPMG News
http://www.hungtonpost.com/entry/ray-kurzweil-nanobots-brb0af3706dbe1e2?section=weird-news&ncid=fcbklnkushpmg00000022
Page 11 of 11