RESPOND COMMENT FOR BLEED WATER MATINDOK

No
1.

Comment from PAQUES

Respond Comment from Engineering

Connect return to caustic.

Drain nutrient and caustic at the same pipe?

Recycle line already connect to caustic.

Drain on nutrient and caustic is connect on the same
pipe since our header is only one (chemical drain
header). We already confirm to our process team
about this issue.

2.

- Our concern to locate the pipe as shown on snapshot is for

No
-

Comment from PAQUES

No low piping pockets.

Respond Comment from Engineering

access operator to operate this valve, since this pipe routes
is locate on our pipe rack with el. +3.1 m.

3.

2x reducer (see P&ID sheet 5)

- This is typical cases if we located reducer on 6 inch line

before tee, since spacing between 2 nozzle inlet & 2 nozzle
outlet on compressor cooler is to short when we attach
reducer.

4.

- The pipe routes is already follow as per P&ID.

No
5.

Comment from PAQUES

Respond Comment from Engineering

- Drain is already revised on our model.

6.

- Drain piping for CIP Tank A/B is already located as shown on

our model.
- Additional for vent point & drain point on line no :
1. 340-CL-1504-3-01L0

No

Comment from PAQUES

Respond Comment from Engineering

2. 340-CL-1505-3-01L0
3. 340-CL-1506-2-01L0
4. 340-CL-1507-2-01L0
V.P : 4 ea (Gate valve SS 316L inch) for line class 01L0
D.P : 4 ea (Gate valve SS 316L inch) for line class 01L0

7.

- Our mechanical team is already conduct the study for

handling tubular modules. We attached monorail on

No

Comment from PAQUES

Respond Comment from Engineering

structure to lifting this modules to laydown area.

8.

- Reducer 3x2 is already moved backward before

flowmeter.
- Additional drain point on line no. 340-WB-1500-01L0 :
D.P : 1 ea (Gate valve SS 316L inch) for line class 01L0
9.

- Isolation valve located near membrane unit to make it

easier for operated/ maintenance.
- Isolation valve can be move on tank, but it can be effect on
pipe spool. On membrane unit is also needed isolation
valve.

No
10.

Comment from PAQUES

Respond Comment from Engineering

- Butterfly valve are located below nozzle tank to make it

easier for operate/ maintenance, since nozzle elevation is
on +2.3 m (from GL.0.00).
- D.P is already rotated as per comment on our model.

No
11.

Comment from PAQUES

Respond Comment from Engineering

- Additional vent point valve on line no. 340-PW-1503-201L0.
V.P : 1 ea (Gate valve SS 316L inch) for line class 01L0

12.

- Drain point is already rotated on our model.

- Tapping position is changing as per Paques comment.

No
13.

Comment from PAQUES

Respond Comment from Engineering

- Temporary cone strainer is not shown on our model.
- This item is already take-off for line no. 340-PW-1506-1001L0 & 340-PW-1507-10-01L0.

14.

- No item FICA 1501 on latest P&ID, since clarification from

GEA is not used.

No
15.

Comment from PAQUES

Respond Comment from Engineering

- Pipe is connected from 340-P-1035A/B (back flush) to back

flush header (N3) on membran unit (see yellow marking on
pipe).
- Additional vent point valve on line no. 340-PW-1518-301L0.
V.P : 1 ea (Gate valve SS 316L inch) for line class 01L0

No
16.

Comment from PAQUES

Respond Comment from Engineering

- Drain point is already revised as per comment on our

model. Pipe spool is changing based on Paques comment.
- Additional drain point on line no. 340-PW-1519-2-01L0 :
D.P : 1 ea (Gate valve SS 316L inch) for line class 01L0