INDIAN EXPRESS

5th December 2015 Saturday Page 4

TIMES OF INDIA
5th December 2015 Saturday Page 8

THE PIONEER
5th December 2015 Saturday Page 3

fullstory

http://www.ptinews.com/news/6816247_1984-riots--CBI-asked-to-con...

Advertisement

Share

Print

E-mail

Comment

[ - ] Text [ + ]

19:42 HRS IST

New Delhi, Dec 4 (PTI) CBI was today directed to conduct further probe in a
1984-anti Sikh riots case against Jagdish Tytler with a Delhi court saying that
statement of arms dealer Abhishek Verma discloses an active role played by
the Congress leader in extending "helping hand" to a witness against him.
The court noted that statement given by Verma to CBI in which he has claimed
that Tytler had sent the son of Surinder Singh Granthi, a key witness against
him, to Canada cannot be a "sheer coincidence" and the agency should probe
if the facts disclosed by Verma were true.
"The statement made by witness Abhishek Verma discloses an active role
played by Jagdish Tytler in sending one Narinder Singh to Canada. Narinder is
none other than the son of Surinder Singh Granthi, a key witness in the present
case against Jagdish Tytler.
"It cannot be a sheer coincidence that Tytler extended a helping hand to
Narinder Singh in 2004-05," Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate SPS Laler
said, adding that a thorough probe was required.
"If the facts disclosed by Abhishek Verma are true, then an inference may be
drawn by the court against Jagdish Tytler in the present case. Thus, it
becomes necessary to find out whether the facts disclosed by him are true or
not," the court said in its eight-page order.
In its order, the court elaborated on 11-points, including whether Verma had
obtained a contract of Rs 50 lakh in 1988 from Air India when Tytler was the
Civil Aviation Minister, which were required to be further probed by CBI.
It also asked the agency to conduct a lie-detection test on Verma, if required.
However, the judge clarified that the agency is "free to investigate the matter by
whatever mode and procedure suitable in the facts of the case and the
aforesaid points are only indicative of the kind of probe that can be undertaken
by CBI to find out the truth."
The court also said that as CBI has filed closure reports in the case several
times, so it would now monitor the probe every two months so that no aspects
of the matter is left uninvestigated.
It has fixed the matter for further proceedings on February 2.
The case pertains to riots at Gurudwara Pulbangash in north Delhi where three
people were killed on November 1, 1984, a day after the assassination of the
then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi.

Post your comments

Name

Email-ID

Subject
Check,if you do not want your ID displayed on the site.

2 of 3

05/12/2015 9:53 AM

Home / India / Further probe 84 riots case against Tytler, court to CBI

Further probe 84 riots case against Tytler,

court to CBI
By FPJ Bureau | Dec 05, 2015 12:25 am

New Delhi : A court here on Friday refused to accept the closure report and directed the CBI
to conduct further investigation into the 1984 anti-Sikh riots case against Congress leader
Jagdish Tytler.
Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate Saurabh Pratap Singh Laler ordered the Central
Bureau of Investigation (CBI) to conduct further investigations and refused to accept the
closure report that gives Tytler a clean chit.
The court also directed CBI to verify the facts given by businessman and arms dealer Abhishek
Verma, who was cited as a witness in the closure report.
Abhishek Verma in his statement told the CBI that Tytler had told him in 2008 that he had met
the then prime minister after which he got a clean chit for his alleged role in a 1984 anti-Sikh
riots case.
Verma also stated that Tytler had tried to influence one of the witnesses by giving him a hefty
sum of money and promising to settle his son abroad. The court also directed CBI to record the
statements of other witnesses in the case.
On the last hearing, the CBI also submitted that it was prepared to investigate the matter further
on the courts permission.

The CBIs statement came while replying to an application filed by the Shiromani Akali Dal
in which the party told the court that it would provide the addresses of three material witnesses.
The CBI had earlier informed the court that these witnesses were not traceable.
Advocate H.S. Phoolka, appearing for victim/complainant Lakhvinder Kaur, whose husband
Badal Singh was killed during the riots, said that in view of the seriousness of the offence, the
court should not accept the closure report.
The court was hearing a petition filed by Kaur against the CBIs closure report its third
giving a clean chit to Tytler for his alleged role in the violence.
Phoolka said the CBIs investigation was faulty, tainted, dishonest and perfunctory.
Earlier, the agency gave a clean chit to the Congress leader twice.
In April 2013, a sessions court rejected a closure report and ordered the agency to further
investigate the killings.
The CBI did that, but filed another closure report on December 24, 2014, saying there was
insufficient evidence to proceed against Tytler. IANS

Court orders further probe against Tytler - The Hindu

1 of 2

http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/court-orders-furthe...

NATIONAL OTHER STATES

Published: December 5, 2015 00:00 IST | Updated: December 5, 2015 05:45 IST NEW DELHI, De

Nirnimesh Kumar

Rejecting the clean chit given to senior Congress leader Jagdish Tytler in an anti-Sikh riot case, a D
further investigate it.
Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate SPS Laler in his re-investigation order also said that the c
As closure report in this case has been filed several times, hence the court is of the opinion that it w
investigation is monitored by the court on bi-monthly basis so that no aspect of the case is left un-in
directed to conduct further investigation in the present case, Mr. Laler said.
Stating that the complainant in the case, Lakhwinder Kaur, had submitted the names and addresses

05/12/2015 2:53 PM

Court orders further probe against Tytler - The Hindu

2 of 2

http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/court-orders-furthe...

court said: Admittedly, further investigation is required in the present case to examine more eye-w
investigation is also required to find out whether the two said witnesses were actually present at the
Lakhwinder Kaur is the wife of a man who was killed by a mob along with two others at Gurdwara P
has accused Mr. Tytler of inciting the mob. The riots had broken out in the wake of the assassinatio
Gandhi.
The CBI had earlier sought to close the case in 2007 and 2009 but the court had rejected it and ord
rejection of the CBI plea to close the case.
The court also directed the probe agency to thoroughly investigate the statement of Abhishek Verm
active role played by Jagdish Tytler in sending out Narinder Singh, son of key witness Surinder Sing
The phone number of Narinder Singh is available on court record which CBI can collect, the court s
The allegations are that businessman Abhishek Verma, son of the late Congress MP Srikant Verma,
investigating agency that Mr. Tytler had paid about rupees one crore to Surinder Singh Granthi and
Narinder Singh to Canada under a deal to make a statement in his favour.
Vermas statement is based on what Mr. Tytler had told him during a meeting in August or Septemb
The CBI in its closure report had said that the evidence by Abhishek Verma indicates that Jagdish T
witness; however, it could not be verified as the witness has since expired.
The CBI had earlier sought to close
the case in 2007 and 2009
Printable version | Dec 5, 2015 2:52:26 PM | http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-state
tytler/article7950490.ece
The Hindu

05/12/2015 2:53 PM

ASIAN AGE
5th December 2015 Saturday Page 1