Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HESPERIA: SUPPLEMENT II
1939
LATE
A
GEOMETRIC GRAVES
AND
SEVENTH
CENTURY
WELL
IN
AGO
THE
RA
k,'~
BY
RODNEY S. YOUNG
WITH AN APPENDIX ON THE SKELETAL REMAINS:
GEOMETRIC ATHENIANS
BY
J. LAWRENCE ANGEL
a~i
SWETS & ZEITLINGER B.V.
AMSTERDAM - 1975
AmericanSchool of ClassicalStudies
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
V
Abbreviations and Partial Bibliography ............
VII
List of Illustrations .
..................
1
. . . . . . . . .
Introduction . . . . . . ..... .
6
PARTI. The Grave Precinct ................
13
The Graves ..........
21
Catalogue of Graves in the Precinct ..........
Urn-burials of Children, I-X
Grave I ......
Grave II ......
Grave III ......
p. 21
p. 21
p. 23
Grave VI
Grave VII
Grave VIII
......
p. 24
Grave
Grave V ......
p. 26
Grave
Grave IV
IX
p. 28
p. 31
p. 34
.....
....
.....
.
....
p. 36
p. 42
.....
Grave XI ......
Grave
Grave
Grave
Grave
Grave
XIII
XIV
XV
XVI
XVII
Grave XII
p. 44
p. 55
.....
..
.
.....
.....
..
..
Grave XVIII
Grave XIX
XX
Grave
Grave XXI
Grave XXII
p. 67
. p. 71
p. 73
p. 75
..
p. 76
p. 87
p. 93
p. 94
....
p. 98
. . . . p. 98
....
....
....
....
p. 100
p. 103
105
. ...
The Terracotta Figurines .
........
The Graffiti . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . ...
Appendix I
A List of Graves and Important Geometric and Protoattic Vases,
with Their Probable Dating .............
Appendix II
The Isis Grave ...........
........234
Appendix III
Geometric Athenians. By J. Lawrence Angel ........
224
225
229
236
Index
247
PARTII.
..........106
Catalogue of Objects, B 1-B 86 .
PARTIII. The Seventh Century Well ......139
Catalogue of Objects from the Well, C 1-C 187 .
PARTIV. The Pottery
Shapes
....141
.................194
p. 195
..........
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . p. 200
Ornament
...................
........
... ........
p. 212
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
231
ABBREVIATIONS
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
VI
NOTE:
Since the manuscript of this paper left the author's hands, a study of the Protoattic
style
by J. M. Cook has appeared in B. S. A., XXXV, 1934-35, pp. 165 f.; also the publication of the
important collection of Protoattic
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
Fig. 1.
Fig. 2.
Fig. 3.
Fig. 4.
Fig. 5.
Fig. 6.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Fig. 11.
Fig. 12.
Fig. 13.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
Fig. 22.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
23.
24.
25.
26.
Fig. 27.
Fig. 28.
Fig. 29.
Fig. 30.
Fig. 31.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
VIII
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Fig. 93.
Fig. 94.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
95.
96(.
97.
98.
99.
100.
Fig. 101.
Fig. 102.
Fig. 103.
Fig. 104.
Fig. 105.
Fig. 106.
Fig. 107.
Fig. 108.
Fig. 109.
Fig. 110.
Fig. 111.
Fig. 112.
Fig. 113.
Fig. 114.
Fig. 115.
Fig. 116.
Fig. 117.
Fig. 118.
Fig. 119.
Fig. 120.
Fig. 121.
Fig. 122.
Fig. 123.
Fig. 124.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Fig. 125. Geometric and Protoattic Oinochoe Fragments (C 113, 116, 119-120, 124-125).
Fig. 126. Oinochoe C 119. Drawing of Neck Panel
by Piet de Jong.
Fig. 127. Protoattic Oinochoe (C 123).
Fig. 128. Protoattic Amphora (C 127).
Fig. 129. Amphora Fragments (C 128-133, 135).
Fig. 130. Geometric Amphora Fragment (C 134).
Fig. 131. Geometric Amphora Fragment (C 136).
Fig. 132. Geometric Amphoras (C 138-139).
Fig. 133. Oinochoe (C 114, 126) and Amphora (C 137,
140-144) Fragments.
Fig. 134. Fragments of Protoattic Amphoras and
Stands (C 145, 150-153).
Fig. 135. Fragmentary Amphora (C 146).
Fig. 13(6. Fragmentary Hand-made Amphora (C 147)
and Coarse Pitcher (C 156).
Fig. 137. Subgeometric Hydria (C 148).
Fig. 138. Stbgeometric Hut Model (C 149 .
Fig. 139. Fine Hand-made (C 154-155) and Household Ware (C 157-164) Fragments.
140.
of Household Ware Fragments.
Profiles
Fig.
Fig. 141. Brazier (C 165).
Fig. 142. Discs (C 166-173), Loom Weights (C 174175), Clay Ball (C 176), and Whorls
(C 177-180).
Fig. 143. Fragments of Terracotta Figurines
(C 181-187).
Fig. 144. Inscriptions incised on Vases. Drawing
by Piet de Jong.
IX
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
1
INTRODUCTION
The literary evidence for Greek history before the sixth century has been sifted and
resifted; yet the main events even of the seventh century remain vague in their outline
and uncertain in their chronology, while the uncertainty covering those of the eighth
deepens, until a true dark age obliterates three centuries of the early history of Greece.
The chronology of the seventh and eighth centuries is based on traditional chronicles which
are calculated by generations varying from twenty-five to forty years in length, as well
as on lists of kings and Olympic victors which often show signs of late interpolations inserted
either maioris gloriae causa, or in order to fit traditional, and often mythical, personages
into a fixed scheme of " history." A few bare kernels of fact can be arrived at after paring
away an accumulated crust of explanation, comment and myth. And yet by the sixth
century Greek civilization is already formed; art and letters are already in the channels
which they must follow through a logical development; the great sanctuaries with their
cult and athletic rituals are established; and many of the commercial and industrial rivalries
that are to last throughout Greek antiquity are already acute. Greek civilization has
already spread over its allotted territory, carrying with it the structural bones-language
and religion, habits of life and thought, conceptions of art, and a traditional literature-that form the skeleton on which develops the civilization of the classical period.
Thus the era before the sixth century is one of the most important in Greek history;
an era of formation and ferment, in which new ideas are adopted and old ones developed;
in which, in short, the foundations of Greek civilization are laid. New literary evidence
A number of visitors to the Agora have made valuable suggestions. Particular thanks must be
expressed to Dr. Kibler of the German Archaeological Institute for his generosity in discussing and
giving information on his material from the Kerameikos; to Mrs. Semne Karousou for the kindest and
most efficient of help in the National Museum; to Miss Richter for photographs of unpublished vases in
the Metropolitan Museum, and to Dr. Homer A. Thompson for information on the grave group in the
Toronto Museum. Professor G. W. Elderkin of Princeton has read the whole manuscriptand made
valuable suggestions. All the members of the Agora staff have been most helpful; especially Miss
Talcott and Mrs.Thompson. The plan and section of the grave precinct, and the drawing of Grave XVII,
are by J. Travlos; the drawings of the other graves, and the profiles and restored dra-wings of many
vases, are by Piet de Jong. H. Wagner of the German Institute is responsible for most of the photoglaphs, and Miss Alison Frantz of the Agora staTfffor the rest. Thanks are due also to J. Lawrence
Angel of Harvard for his examination of the skeletons and his report on them, here published as
Appendix III. It may be noted here that Angel was impressed by certain resemblances in the bony
structure of the skeletons, suggesting that they belonged to members of the same family, before he was
aware of the archaeological evidence for their relationship.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
on this crucial period is scarcely to be hoped for; nor can the infinite reinterpretation
and recombina.tion of the literary sources be expected to provide much new information.
"New evidence must be awaited" is the eternal comment made on unsolved and
unsolvable problems. Yet even though further literary evidence on the early period
of Greek history is not to be expected, there exists an abundance of archaeological
evidence which may cast some light on the obscure, and which has the advantage,
often lacking in literary sources, of being impersonal. A vast mass of material must be
sifted and dated in order to determine which elements of Greek civilization were inventions
of this formative period, which were handed down or revived from the Mycenaean culture
that had gone before (as, for example, certain cults and sanctuaries, and many technical
methods), and which were introduced from outside the Greek world (for example, coinage
and the alphabet). Four periods cover this long era of nearly half a millennium: the Submycenaean, the Protogeometric, the Geometric, and the Orientalizing.1 While the succession of these periods is clear, and the last can be placed in the seventh century, the lack
of any fixed chronological evidence, such as the finding of dateable Egyptian or Oriental
objects in Greek deposits, has allowed great latitude for the relative expansion or contraction of each of the three earlier periods. A few Egyptian scarabs and faience statuettes
found in Geometric graves have not been helpful, either because they have been impossible
to date within sufficiently narrow limits of time, or because experts have disagreed as to
their dating, or because their dating has been clearly impossibly early to be applied to their
Greek contexts.2 The recent discovery of three small subgeometric skyphoi in a tomb in
Cyprus which contained also a number of scarabs of the XXVIth Dynasty and Saite period, on
the other hand, furnishes strong evidence for the continuation of a degenerating Geometric
style well into the seventh century.3 As a result of the lack of external chronological
evidence, it has been possible for a single grave to be dated by one recent writer at the end
of the ninth century, and by another at the end of the eighth.4 The Geometric period,
represented chiefly by pottery, but also by figurines of clay, bronze and ivory, as well as by
elaborate jewellery and metal work, is clearly a period not only of great technical ability
but also of developed artistic sense. The pictures drawn on the vases give some intimation
1 Objection has been made to the use of almost every one of these terms; also to the term Protoattic. While the objections are often well based (though sometimes merely pedantic), I use these terms
because they have all acquired quite definite and fixed connotation in the minds of most archaeologists
and historians. The purpose of a name, surely, is to evoke a conception of the object named; and when
it has acquired a definite meaning, to change it is only to create confusion.
2
Egyptian objects found in Greece have been listed and identified by J. Pendlebury, Aegyptaicn,
Cambridge, 1930.
3
Amathus, Tomb 9, E. Gjerstad, The Swedish Cyprus Expedition, II, Stockholm, 1935, pp. 55 ff.,
nos. 19, 76, and 122, and pl. XV.
4 Dipylon Grave XIII; Ath. Mitt.,
XVIII, 1893, pp. 127 ff.; B.C.H., XIX, 1895, pp. 273 ff.; Kunze, Ath.
Mitt., LV, 1930, p. 150; Hampe, Friihe griechische Sagenbilder (1936), pp. 36 ff. Kunze has now brought
down his dating of this grave to the second quarter of the eighth century: Gottingische Gelehrte Anzeigen, 1937, p. 291.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
of the life lived by their makers, and even of the myths and poems with which they were
familiar. The distribution of the vases themselves shows that already considerable intercourse and commerce existed between the different parts of Greece, even suggesting in
certain cases the trade relations of some of the cities. Crude inscriptions scratched on the
walls of the vases give evidence that knowledge of the alphabet and of writing was already
spreading. The Geometric culture, then, is the earliest flowering of the Greek genius. The
orientalizing style grows from the Geometric, with the addition of new elements imported
from the east and of old ones revived from the past civilizations of the homeland. It is
clear that the dating of this early flowering must be established before many of the important problems in the pre-classical history of Greece can be solved.
It has been remarked already that there is no certain external evidence for the dating
of the Geometric period. A chronology has been established in the late eighth and seventh
centuries for Protocorinthian pottery found in Greek and Etruscan tombs in Italy and
Sicily.' Because only one possibly Attic Geometric sherd has been found in the west, at
Syracuse,2 it. has been assumed that the Geometric style in Attica was already past when
the western colonies were founded. It has not been remarked, on the other hand, that
neither has Attic orientalizing pottery of the seventh century been found in quantity in the
west. The reasons for the absence of Attic pottery are, of course, that Attica was not exporting her pottery widely before the seventh century, and that the parent cities of the
western colonies-the Euboean and Cycladic cities, and Corinth-quite naturally held the
monopoly of the early trade of their offshoots. The absence of Attic Geometric ware in the
west is, then, of no significance for its dating.
An abundance of Attic Geometric pottery is scattered through the museums of Europe
and America. By combining and arranging individual vases into groups and series,
a number of courses of development for the style can be achieved. More useful, and certainly safer as evidence, are grave groups; observation of these led Wide,3 as long ago
Johansen, Les Vases sicyoniens (1918 and 1923), pp. 179ff.; Schweitzer, Ath. Mitt., XLIII, 1918,
pp. 1 ff.; Karo, Ath. Mitt.,XLV, 1920, pp. 106ff.; for later modificationof this chronology,Payne, ProtokorinthischeVasenmalerei,1933, p. 20. The earlier chronologyis based on a too early estimate of the
date of the foundationof Cumae. See the article by Byvanck in Mnemosyne,IV, 1936-37,pp. 181ff.
2
Not. degli Scavi, 1895,p. 189, fig. 90. The presence of even one sherd, if it is Attic, is of inestimable importance. Whole pots, not sherds, were exported; the rest of the amphoraof which the sherd
was a part undoubtedly exists, certainly shattered into many fragments, somewhere in Syracuse.
Allowing half a century (to be liberal) for the life of the amphorafrom its manufacturein Athens to
its breakingin Syracuse, it cannot have been made much before the middle of the eighth century, and
probablywas made considerablylater. Blakeway, in republishingit in B.S.A., XXXIII, 1932-33,p. 183,
no. 3 and fig. 8 a, calls it " Creto-Cycladic" on the evidence of an amphorafound in Thera. Compare,
however, the four Attic amphoras,Wide, figs. 65-68. Almost all of the sherds and vases illustrated by
Blakeway (B.S.A., XXXIII, 1932-33, pp. 170ff. and pls. 22-35; J.R.S., XXV, 1935, pp. 129ff. and
pls. XX-XXII) as evidence for Greek trade in the west before the period of colonization are subgeometric or native imitations of subgeometric, and date from the late eighth and seventh century.
Ingenuity of course may suggest that in early times ships were ballasted with broken pottery.
3
1*
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
as 1899, to remark that the- Geometric period in Attica (Dipylonperiode) must have had
a rapid development and lasted but a short time. Unfortunately, very few Geometric graves
have been published as units and fully illustrated,' and the more recent material is as yet
unpublished. The Agora has been unexpectedly fortunate in the number of early groups
found. To date, about thirty Protogeometric graves, and an equal number of Geometric,
have been dug; eight Protogeometric and early Geometric well deposits have yielded
Six seventh
groups of vases which are thoroughly compact and consistent entities.
century deposits which contained dateable Protocorinthian vases and sherds, together with
Protoattic and late Geometric pottery, have been found.
It is proposed in this study to present two of the Agora groups. The first, Group A,
consists of the pottery and other objects from twenty-two graves which were found together
in a small closed precinct. The relation of the graves to each other, and marked resemblances among the skeletons found in them,2 strongly suggest that the terrace was a family
burial plot. The limited area must have been filled in a comparatively short time; the
burials (with the exception of two later additions) extend over a period of about two
generations, or sixty years. The earlier graves contained vases of the developed late
Geometric style; the later graves, subgeometric vases. A dating for the vases from the
1 From the
Dipylon, Briickner and Pernice have published (Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pp. 73 ff.) nineteen,
of which one (XIX) is sixth or seventh century, and only two, VIII and IX, are illustrated. Grave XIII
is illustrated in B.C.H., XIX, 1895, pp. 273 ff., and most of the contents of Grave III can be discovered
by piecing together single illustrations in Wide's article in Jhb., XIV, 1899, pp. 188 ff., figs. 51, 88, 97
(right), 99, and, possibly, 96 at the left. Other grave groups from the Dipylon: A.A., 1934, pp. 241-242,
fig. 27, and Hampe, p. 38, fig. 19 and pls. 32-33; Kerameikos 334-338. Some of Brickner and Pernice's
groups may be seen in the National Museum at Athens, almost all incomplete. From the Agora, one
grave: Hesperia, II, 1933, pp. 552 ff. From the slope of the Areopagus, two graves whose vases have
probably become mixed: C. V.A., Athens, I, p. 3 and pl. 1, 1-4 and 5-11. Research in the inventories of
the National Museum can recover four of the vases from the Pnyx grave in which was found the
bronze tripod published in Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 414, and pl. XIV. Four complete graves from
Spata are published in Delt., VI, 1920-21, pp. 131 ff. A grave from Liossia in Copenhagen is published in
C. V.A., Copenhagen, II, p. 51, and pl. 70, 2-8 and 10. The graves at Anavysos (Praktika, 1911,
pp. 110ff.) have become hopelessly mixed, as have most of those from Eleusis. The Isis Grave is
published (without its jewellery, scarabs, and clay balls) in C.V.A., Athens, I, pls. 3-6; of the other
graves combinations of two to five of the vases, sometimes illustrated, can be recovered, but the vases
themselves in the Eleusis Museum have become badly mixed. Of the eighty-seven graves in the
Phaleron cemetery most of the contents of several can be gathered together from the publication in
Delt., II, 1916, pp. 13 ff., and nearly a score of complete groups are on display in the National Museum;
these graves, however, are all orientalizing and subgeometric, and belong in the seventh
century. The
recently excavated graves at the Kerameikos (reports in A.A., 1932-37) are unpublished, and likewise
those of the Marathon cemetery (Praktika, 1934, pp. 35 ff.). A group of vases in the Toronto Museum is
said to be the contents of a grave; the presence of a sixth or fifth century whorl throws great suspicion
on the unity of the group: J.H.S., LI, 1931, p. 164 and pl. VI. Attic vases have of course been found in
graves outside of Attica (Thera, Troezen, Cyprus, Corfu) that contained also Geometric pottery of other
fabrics. Altogether only about fifteen groups are published in their entirety. In the publication of
a group of vases from a grave, one good photograph of the whole group is often worth
forty pages of
text. See also Appendix I, where a list of Attic graves is given, with their probable dating.
2
See Appendix III.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
later graves may be established by comparison with pottery of the first half of the seventh
figurines from a votive deposit at the Agora,l gives additional confirmationof the evidence
supplied by Group C. Three graves, XXIII-XXV, which were found elsewhere in the
Agora, are published with Group A because they contained vases contemporarywith those
from the grave precinct and give supplementary information. Geometric and Protoattic
vases and fragments from in and around the grave precinct are listed separately for
convenience as Group B. Some of these may have come from graves disturbed in later
times; others are important as giving archaeological evidence as to the history of the grave
terrace; and yet others are of value on their own stylistic merits.
Since the two larger groups, A and C, overlap, and since the later group can be dated,
we may find good evidence in our Agora material for the dating of late Geometric pottery
toward the end of the eighth century. Our groups together cover the period from about
725 to about 650, a period of rapid change and innovation, in which the Geometric style was
gradually displaced by the orientalizing.2 We may then analyze the shapes and decorative
motives current at the end of the Geometric period; with the change from the Geometric
to the orientalizing style we may see which shapes and motives die out or are transformed,
and which show a continuous development or degeneration. The term subgeometric is used
of degenerate Geometric shapes and motives which remain free of orientalizing influence.
Subgeometric vases of poor fabric and careless decoration continued to be made over
a long period after the introduction of the new orientalizing style, just as poor blackfigured vases continued to be made long after the introduction of the red-figured style.
Orientalizing vases reflect the spirit of a new age of freedom and adventure. With the
opening of the trade routes to the east, and the establishment of Greek colonies all over the
Mediterranean world, the old confinement to narrow districts and to a feudal agricultural
society, reflected in the Geometric style, broke down. The seventh century was a time of
new ideas and experiment; it was also a time of selection among the new ideas and ex-
periments. From the rather chaotic experimentation of the potters of the orientalizing period
emerged the black-figuredstyle. Much was tried, and much discarded, during the period
of exuberant freedom. The pottery from our graves and our well clearly illustrates the
development from the first intimation of the dissolution of the Geometric style to the full
flowering of the orientalizing. If we can date our pottery, then we may fix more clearly the
limits of this period of change and expansion, and at the same time perhaps throw new
light on some of the problems in the chronology of early Greek history.
I Hesperia, II, 1933, pp. 542 ff.
2
A later group has been published in Hesperia, VII, 1938, p. 412; Group D, of the third quarter of
the seventh century.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Just to the south of the Tholos there is a narrow terrace in which were found twenty
Geometric burials. The terrace, supported by a retaining wall of the Geometric period,
extends for nearly seventeen metres along the lower slope of Kolonos Agoraios; it appears
on the published plans of the Agora.' The retaining wall runs for a distance of 16.80m.
in a northeast and southwest line, paralleling for about half its length the contour of the
hillside, and returning at each end toward the northwest (plan, fig. 1). The return at the
southwest end forms a right angle and runs for a distance of 2.95m. until it meets the
descending slope. At the other end, the Geometricwall returns at an obtuse angle toward
the north and runs for a distance of 2.80 m., where it stops; the continuation which appears
on the plan, from the point where another wall abuts against it, is part of a later repair.
The retaining wall was built partly to hold back the fill in which lay the graves, and
partly to protect it from being washed away. The graves lay well down the slope near to
the bottom of the valley to the east of Kolonos Agoraios; the valley carried off all the waters
draining down from the slopes of the Pnyx and Areopagus, as well as from Kolonos itself.
Through it, too, passed from very early times the road giving access from the Agora to the
southern regions of Athens.2 Thus the grave precinct, bordered by a road which was also
a drain, had need of the protection afforded by its retaining wall: first, to preserve it from
being undermined by the flow of water, and second, to prevent encroachment by traffic
passing along the road.
The terrace wall itself shows that its builders had these two functions in mind. Founded
on bedrock, it is built of rough untrimmed blocks of limestone, mixed with blocks of greenish
micaceous shale; the same sort of shale was used inside the terrace for the covering-slabs
over the graves. The blocks, long and often quite narrow, are laid as headers (section,
fig. 2; figs. 3 and 5); the gaps behind the outer ends of the blocks are rather carefully filled
by small stones making a rough, but presentable, polygonal face as a parapet beside the
road (fig. 4). In appearance, the polygonal face of the wall is quite similar to that of a Geo-
metric wall in Eleusis.3 The thickness of the wall is from 60 to 70cm.; its inner face is
packed with small stones, forming a backing to close the gaps behind the headers of the
wall itself. The roughly finished outer face, the method of laying the blocks as headers, the
better to resist pressure from behind, and the crude unfinishedinner face, together show that
the wall was intended as a retaining wall from the time of its construction. The return at
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
go
~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~)
ir)~
~~ ~
iw
~~3
-I /
I~~~IIu
r.~~~~~r
Cl)
c:
4)
4 1i
C~
4)
4I
1-
tL~~~~~~~0
0
.wc
w
LI
k
Z4
IZ)
Fi
I
I~~~
V)
0
D
__j
<
0
LU
AiA
a
U- (0
<
-J
C)
r)
-i3:
-)
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
P.
gol
RODNEY S. YOUNG
the northeast end, which was not needed as a protection against the flow of water in the
valley, and which did not border on the road, was carried only as far as was necessary to
the terrace. Since the covers of the graves must have lain at least half a metre below the
floor of the terrace, we arrive by addition (1.30+.80+.50)
height for the retaining wall of a little more than two and a half metres.
That the wall belongs to the Geometric period is proved not only by its relation to the
graves which it encloses and by its resemblanceto other Geometric walls, but also by the
W?LL B
dJ
P OM AF1
WALL
6 G.
-Z7
.
,57o70
P 0
|
565-
I
LAYF
--
ji
Si6oo
FILL
57o
WAI9 LAER
A D
Ar4CI<>QP<y^
B-ow
n
ATH
IV
6 C
0
+i
GF
?L
F I LL
56154F
5628 L
I
PPECr
EC T I
A-AN
5ECTIO
1
ih
o
--R--
- --
2.
t
A-A
4
\in
I
J.T
195P
evidence of the fills to each side of it. The fill behind, partly of red gravel and partly of
green broken hardpan containing an occasional Geometric sherd, had been thrown in
behind the wall and over the east end of the terrace, to bring up the level to an even
surface. This fill had been disturbed in many places; but where it was undisturbed, it ran
against the back face of the wall, showing that the wall had been built before it was thrown
in, or at the same time.
The fill along the outer face of the retaining wall was road fill. Layer III of the fill in
the road (section, fig. 2) contained no sherds later than the first quarter of the seventh
century. Because no provision had been made for drainage in the early road, the flow of
water had destroyed the stratification, and it was impossible to distinguish at what level
the terrace wall had been cut through an earlier fill, and at what level the fill had begun
to accumulate against its face. At the back, the wall seemed to have been set into the
layer of sand overlying bedrock (section, fig. 2), below the thrown-in fill of broken hardpan.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
A thick d(elposit of black burned earth and cinders must have been thrown at one time on
the surface of the road. This delposit (Grave XII) contained many fragments of broken
and burned Geometric figurines and vases; it was clearly the refuse from a funeral pyre.
Apparently after the rites had been held at the grave, the pyre was extinguished and its
Outer Face
remains swept up and dumped over the edge of the terrace onto the road. The deposit lay
on the north side of the road, against the face of the retaining wall; the black earth had
penetrated into the cracks in the face of the wall itself. From the position of the burned
deposit it was clear that the precinct wall already served as a parapet along the road when
the remains of the pyre were thrown out. Had the wall been set down through the remains
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
10
RODNEY S. YOUNG
of the pyre, a narrow footing-trench would have shown cleaily that the wall was later.
Since the vases and figurines from the burned deposit are to be dated probably at the
beginning of the seventh century, they furnish final proof that the grave precinct had been
marked off and enclosed by its retaining wall at some time in the eighth.
The height at which the burned deposit lay must represent the level of the surface of
the road at the time when the pyre was thrown out. This level is the only one that can be
fixed in the gradual accumulation of Layer III of the road filling. Sherds later than those
from the burned deposit were found in Layer III, from which are published B 85-86
(fig. 91 below).
A terminus ante quem for the accumulation of Layer III is given by the sherds from
a filling of brown earth thrown onto the hard road surface between Layer II and Layer III
Geometric Retaining
5. Geometric
Fig.
Wall, looking
Retaining Wall,
looking South.
Fig. 5.
Well C
C at
at right
Well
right
(section, fig. 2). This earth contained Protoattic vases and fragments running as late as
the middle of the seventh century; it must then have been thrown over the road at some
time after the middle of the century. The filling was probably brought from elsewhere; it
contained fragments which joined with other fragments of vases found in the votive deposit
of the first half of the seventh century, which lay about a hundred metres away toward the
southeast.'
A number of handsome vases and fragments from this fill are published
southeast.l
(B 64-84; figs. 92-99 below).
of the
from
sherds
IIIofbythea second
half surface
the seventh
the
hard road
ow).Layer
theofface
which ran
II, separated
Layer
precinct
wall, contained
century,
againstand
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
11
from Layer II by a hard-packed surface, contained sixth century sherds, black-glazed and
black-figured of advanced style.
Burials appear to have been made regularly in the grave terrace over a period of about
sixty years, or two generations, from the last quarter of the eighth century into the second
quarter of the seventh. Two later graves of small children (Graves I and II) could be dated
at the very end of the seventh century and in the sixth. It is possible that burials were
made during the second half of the seventh century, and destroyed by the modern Pit A or the
Turkish well B; the absence of any great number of sherds of the later seventh century among
the sporadic finds in the disturbed parts of the area, however, suggests that there were no such
burials. In any case, the presence of two graves at least half a century later than any of the
others indicates that the grave precinct was known and respected as such until the early sixth
century.
;
Fig. 6.
'
.'
and Polygonal
Wall
No burials later than Grave I were found. During the sixth century the grave precinct
seems to have been abandoned, and its retaining wall fallen to ruin. Its lower courses,
buried deep under the accumulated fill of the road, remained undisturbed; but in its upper
part blocks must either have fallen from their places, or been carried away by persons in
search of building material. During the lapse of time between the final burial in the grave
precinct and the rebuilding of the precinct wall, the retaining wall in the northeastern half
of its course was levelled down to a depth of probably about 1.20 m., leaving it standing
to a maximum height of only 1.30m. The quarrying operations of Roman times have
destroyed the evidence as to the history of the southwestern stretch of the wall (fromin
Well D nearly to the corner).
A cut made across the road just to the east of Well D (fig. 6) throws some light on the
subsequent history of the grave precinct. Here, two blocks of worked limestone forming
part of a polygonal wall, are in situ as a parapet along the sixth century road, at the level
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
12
RODNEY S. YOUNG
of the top of Layer I. The cut made across the road showed a footing-trench along the face
of this upper limestone polygonal wall; the footing-trench, cut through a road filling which
contained sherds running into the late sixth century, suggests that the precinct wall was
reconstructedat the end of that century, or in the early fifth. The method of reconstruction
was clear; the trench-probably filled with soft earth-from which the blocks of the upper
courses of the Geometric wall had been taken out, was cleared down to the preserved top
of the early wall. The removal of the blocks had naturally somewhat widened the wall
trench. A mass of small stones was then thrown into the trench to serve as a bedding for
the big limestone blocks of the polygonal parapet along the road at the surface. This
packing of small stones overhangs the outer face of the Geometric wall by about 30-40 cm.,
showing how the edge of the road filling had been cut away by the removal of blocks from
the Geometric wall. The bedding of small stones was thrown in until a depth of about
40 cm. below the road surface was reached; then larger blocks were laid on it to serve as
a levelling course for the polygonal parapet wall. Probably at the same time a correspond-
ing limestone parapet was built along the other side of the road, at the south (plan, fig. 1;
section, fig. 2). Also at about the same time the northward extension of the east terrace
wall, with its return toward the west, mentioned above, was added. This addition is built
of well-jointed small blocks of limestone in polygonal style; it may have been built in connection with a building complex of the sixth century which lay to the north of the grave
area. The terrace, which had in Geometric times been open toward the northwest, was
enclosed by a wall, traces of which were found on the sloping hillside, at the time of the
sixth century reconstruction. A gap in the terrace wall along the road was probably filled
by a ramp or staircase giving access through the grave area to a path leading to the upper
slopes of Kolonos; one block of the staircase parapet at the south side was found in its
original position. The walls of the sixth century are indicated on the plan in lighter shad-
ing.
Grave I, cut off from the rest of the graves by the sixth century wall, probably dates
from the first half of the century, and had been made before the reconstructionof the terrace.
The purpose of the reconstruction is not clear. The sixth century floor of the grave
precinct, which must have been somewhat lower than the Geometric, was nowhere
preserved. A well dug in the sixth century disturbed two of the graves, XXI and XXII. The
digging of a well suggests that the site was lived on; there may have been shallow founded
interior walls which were obliterated by later disturbances. That the sixth century wall
was built on top of the Geometric is in no way surprising, because the road followed the
same course in both periods, and the sixth century builders would naturally carry their
parapet wall along the edge of the road. The line where the Geometricwall had been was,
moreover, probably indicated quite clearly by the softness of the filling that had been thrown
into its trench. At the end of the sixth century, then, and in the early fifth, the grave
terrace remained an undivided unit; it was not until about the years 470-460 that it was
divided by the southwest enclosure wall of the area around the Tholos, which was carried
across the northeast end of the precinct.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
13
The preservation of the grave area is probably due to a late fifth or early fourth century
relevelling of the whole region to the south of the Tholos, at which time a large peribolos,
partly cut into the hillside, was made. At the same time the road was covered by a dump
80 cm. to 1 m. thick; some of this dump was found lying undisturbed over the southwestern
end of the terrace. The dating of the raising of the level is given not only by sherds found
in the dump, but also by the filling of Well D, which was covered by the dump; the filling
was of the late third quarter of the fifth century.1 When the south branch of the great drain
was subsequently built,2 it was carried to the east of the peribolos in a channel cut for it in
the bedrock considerably above the bottom of the natural drainage basin. Presumably the
later inhabitants of the region, finding the bedrock at a higher level to the north and west,
and knowing the position of the drain, did not suspect that an early cemetery lay hidden
in the bottom of the valley at the foot of Kolonos Agoraios.
The late disturbances were not extensive. The reason that only three of the big limestone blocks of the polygonal parapet of the sixth century were found in situ may be that
the other blocks were taken out for re-use in the fifth century when the level of the area
was raised. Some of the blocks were certainly left and taken out in the fourth century
after Christ; sherds of that period were found in the wall trench, from well D to the southwest corner, and to the depth at which the Geometric wall was preserved. The inhabitants
of this time also took away for re-use nearly all of the blocks of the polygonal parapet
wall along the south side of the early road. There were two late disturbances inside the
grave precinct, and one in the road: Pit A, Well B, and Well E. Pit A, a large oval cutting,
was modern; the pit was dug for the construction of the ring-wall near its centre, which
was later used as a cesspool. Pit A disturbed Graves II and XIII, and destroyed Graves VII
and XVI; it is quite possible that another grave, lying between Graves XX and XVII, was
completely obliterated at the same time. Well B was a shallow Turkish well which went
only to bedrock; its digging somewhat disturbed Grave V, and destroyed most of Grave VIII.
Thus of a total of twenty graves in the burial precinct, six were disturbed in modern times,
and three in ancient: two (XXI and XXII) by the sixth century diggers of Well C, and one
(III) probably at the time of the reconstruction of the terrace wall in the late sixth century,
when the level of the terrace floor was lowered. Well E, outside the grave precinct, was
a shallow Turkish pit lined with a ring wall of stone; it caused considerable disturbance in
the early road.
THE GRAVES
The twenty burials in the grave precinct are divided into two types, urn-burials of small
children (Graves I-X) and inhumations of adults (Graves XI, XIII-XIV, and XVI-XXII).
1 Section B, well 2. A numberof vases and fragmentsfrom this well have been publishedby Miss
Talcott in Hesperia,IV, 1935,pp. 517ff., nos. 96-101.
2
See the plan, Hesperia, V, 1936, p. 15, fig. 13. Thompsonsuggests a late third or early second
century date for the constructionof this part of the drain.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
14
RODNEY S. YOUNG
They have been numberedin accordance with what seems to be their chronologicalsequence;
Grave I is the latest burial, and Grave XXII the earliest. The earliest of the urn-burials
(X) is, however, earlier than the latest of the inhumations (XI). Although only twenty
burials were found, twenty-two groups from the precinct are published in the catalogue.
Of the two extra groups one, Grave XII, consists of pottery and figurines from the remains
of a sacrificial pyre which had been burned in the precinct in connection with one or another
of the inhumations. The other group, Grave XV, consists of an amphora neck and
a kantharos found together in the disturbed filling of Pit A. The kantharos was found
tightly fitted into the mouth of the amphorawhere it had been placed at the time of burial;
the two vases came from the same grave. Since neither the pottery from the pyre, nor that
from the late filling of Pit A could be assigned to any of the burials found, each group is
listed separately as a grave group. In addition to the twenty-two groups from the terrace
three burials found some distance away toward the south are published. Although these
burials have no immediate connection with those in the precinct, they are published here
because they are contemporary and furnish information supplementary to that given by
shafts had to be cut in the harder rock. Probably for this reason the southwesternmost
part of the area was never used. An inner row of graves (XI, XVII-XX) radiated from
the base of the hill; an outer lay, with different orientation, across their ends. Of the inner
row four grave shafts were preserved; a possible fifth (between Graves XIX-XX and
Grave XVII) may have been completely obliterated by Pit A. Two graves of different
orientation interrupt the regular succession of the graves of the inner row. One of these,
XVI, had been almost entirely destroyed by Pit A; only its lower end was left undisturbed.
The other, Grave XXII, lay near the southwest end of the terrace; its lower end had been
cut off by Grave XI, and its upper half cut through by Well C. In the outer row there were
three graves; XIII, XIV, and XXI. The last of these, XXI, had been cut close beside Grave
XXII and beside the end of Grave XI; the terrace was there too narrow for another shaft
in accordance with a plan, and that the positions occupied by earlier graves were always
known approximately. In only two cases were early graves disturbed by later; in both
there was probably a considerable lapse of time between the burials. Grave VI was some-
what damaged by Grave II, added more than half a century after the last of the successive
early burials. Grave XXII was slightly disturbed by Grave XI, the latest of the shaft
graves. It is probable that Grave XXII, which lay close in to the hillside and parallel to
it, was the earliest burial made in the precinct. Cut early, and without forethought as to
economy of space, it lay in a position which hindered the placing of later graves in the
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
15
narrow end of the terrace. The wide end was therefore filled first, and the narrow end
used only when there was no longer any room toward the northeast.
Most of the graves of the inner series must have been made before those of the outer.
The oldest must have been XXII, followed by XVII-XX (in what order is not clear). The
graves of the second series, XIII-XIV, were then added, filling the wide end of the terrace,
and compelling the use of the narrow end. Graves XI and XXI were then added, disturbing the earliest grave, XXII.
One grave contained two burials (XIX-XX). Quite clearly they had been made at
different timnes;the covering slabs of Grave XX must have been lifted in order that a second
body might be placed in it, and they were probably replaced afterward. The position of
the grave must have been known, and it was re-used for a second burial intentionally and
not by chance. In all probability the graves were unmarked; no fragments of the very
nor of crude stone stelai such as were found at the Kerameikos
large vases used as aiuTawa,
1
and Eleusis appeared in our grave area. In only one case (Grave XIV), where a stone
placed over the cover at one end of the grave may have served as a bedding for a marker,
was there any suggestion that the graves had been marked. The planning of the two rows
of unmarked graves, the similarity of type among the graves, and the fact that the positions
of burials were remembered and, as far as possible, respected, together lead to the belief
that the burials were made over a relatively short period of time.
The urn-burials of children were tucked in wherever there was room, mostly in the
eastern corner and along the southeast side of the precinct. Two were much later than the
other graves. Grave II, to be dated about 600, was dug near the middle of the terrace and
disturbed Grave VI. Perhaps as a result of the damage caused by Grave II, the latest
grave, I, was placed far to the north where there was little danger of disturbing the earlier
burials, the exact positions of which by that time had been forgotten. Grave III, the latest
of the early burials, was cut, like the latest shaft graves XI and XXI, in the bedrock at the
A number of factors suggest that our grave terrace was a family cemetery. The planning
of the series of graves, which were placed more with a view to economy of space than to
any fixed rule of orientation, and the respect shown for earlier burials, lead to the belief
that the precinct belonged to one family and was used over a short period. The peculiar
relationship of Graves XIX and XX, successive burials in the same grave, furthers the
belief. The intermingling of adult and child burials also suggests that the terrace was
a family burial plot; very often in large common cemeteries, as at Phaleron, Marathon,
Camiros, and some of the Sicilian colonies, a special part of the area was set aside for
children's burials exclusively. Family plots in which successive burials can be traced,
have, moreover, been found at the Kerameikos. The addition of two graves much later
than the others gives evidence that the original function of the terrace was not
forgotten.
Poulsen, p. 18; Eph. Arch., 1912, p. 36.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
16
RODNEY S. YOUNG
No burials of the second half of the seventh century were found to bridge the lapse of time
between Graves III and II; it is possible, though unlikely, that such graves existed and
were destroyed by the late disturbances in the area. A number of fragmentary vases found
in the disturbed filling in various parts of the terrace may have been from such graves;
but they may also be fragments of vases used in ritual observances performed in the
cemetery in memory of the dead. Our precinct was probably in regular use for burials
over a period of about two generations, from the last quarter of the eighth century into the
second quarter of the seventh. Grave II was added about 600, Grave I somewhat later.
Small children were buried in pithoi, amphoras, or hydriai. One of our burials (III)
seems to have been made in a deep bowl of coarse fabric. The vessel containing the body
was always a simple vase without elaborate ornamentation, probably a pot of the type
ordinarily used for the storage or export of oil or wine. Such vases were used for the
burial of small children all over the Greek world. As the neck was often too narrow for
the insertion of the body through the mouth of the pot, a hole was carefully made in the
side, and the section removed was replaced after the body and the grave offerings had been
put in.' The outlines of the breaks made for this purpose may be observed on the burial
urns from our Graves II, IV, V and VI. The hydria used for burial in Grave X (fig. 27)
was broken in a somewhat different manner. Two deep scratches were made, parallel to
each other and at some distance apart, from the shoulder to the foot. The scratched lines
were then chipped until the section of the wall between them could be taken out in one
piece; after the body had been inserted the fragment was replaced. In the case of Grave IX
the pithos used had a mouth wide enough for the insertion of the bodies, and no breakage
was necessary.
The positions of the skeletons in their urns could not always be determined, as the tiny
bones had often been almost entirely disintegrated by damp. The bones in Graves IV, V,
IX and X, however, were sufficiently preserved to show that the children had been buried
lying on their sides, and in a bent position with the knees drawn up. One of the graves (IX)
contained two skeletons; as there was no evidence of any disturbance of the grave for the
insertion of a second body, the two children must have been buried together at the same
time. A similar double burial of children was found at Eleusis.2 The simultaneous death
of two children in the same family may well have been due to some illness of epidemic
nature; Professor Soteriades, horrified by the number of infant burials at Marathon, suggests
that an epidemic took place there.3 In any case, the large cemeteries of children at Phaleron
and elsewhere lead to the belief that infant mortality must have been very high in the
primitive conditions of early Greek times.
1 As at Phaleron(Eph.Arch.,1911, pp. 246-248 and figs. 6-7); at Mycenae(Eph.
Arch.,1912,p. 128);
and at Megara Hyblaea (Monumenti, I, pp. 770-771). The amphora from Grave 28 at Tiryns (Tiryns, I,
p. 132, and pl. XVII, 8) seems to have been neatly cut off at the bottom.
2
Eph. Arch., 1898, p. 91.
3 Praktika,
1934, pp. 37 ff.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
17
The burial urns containing the bodies were always laid on their sides and covered at the
mouth by a flat stone or a large coarse sherd. In the case of Grave X the mouth of the
hydria was covered by a one-handled cup, and the mouth of the amphora in Grave VI by
a plate. The offerings of small vases were usually placed inside the burial urn with the
body, but in Graves VI, VII and IX offerings were found outside as well. One of the kantharoi found in Grave IX contained carbonized matter which was probably the remains of
food placed in the grave with the body. Similar carbonized matter was found in the burial
urns of Graves I, IV and VI. Carbonized remains of food have been found in graves at
Eleusis.1 Liquid offerings of milk or honey may have been made in the coarse pitchers
which stood, always upright, outside the burial urns. Such coarse pitchers were found in
Graves VI-X; the mouth of the one used in Grave VIII was carefully covered with a flat
slab of stone.
After the burial urn containing the body and the grave offerings had been placed in the
pit dug to receive it, the mouth covered, and any further offerings put in position beside it,
the pit was filled. In only one case, Grave IV, was a stone cover used. TIwo flat slabs
were laid directly on the amphora, and a mass of small stones thrown on top of themn
(fig. 11). No rule of orientation was observed in the placing of the burial pots; they were
laid with their mouths pointing in any direction at haphazard as the pits had been dug. The
burial of small children in urns was the method commonly employed in ancient times. The
term iyXvTQeiald;has been suggested for the practice; although it is not actually useld by
<ancientwriters, the verb iyXvrQei;tvappears, and women ca.lled yXvTQiaTQiect
are mentioned,
one of whose functions may have been to prepare the dead for burial by placing them in p)ots.2
I'he shaft burials of adults were of a type used in the late Geometric period at the
Dipylon.3 Rectangular shafts, usually about two metres long and half a metre wide, were
sunk in the filling of the terrace. The body was placed on the floor of the shaft, lying on
its back with the arms extending along the sides. The legs were usually extended straight
downward; in two cases, however, they seem to have been bent, with the knees raised
(Graves XVIII and XXI). The vases offered at the funeral were placed around the body
in the bottom of the shaft; in the case of men's graves at the lower end by the feet, and in
the case of women's wherever there was room. No evidence was obtained as to the clothing
worn by the dead; the fibulae found lay either on the bottom of the grave or among the
vases, or had been put before burial into one of the vases. After the body an(l the pottery
had been placed in the grave, enough earth was thrown in to cover them. In Grave XVII
two of the vases were found resting on the earth fill at a high level immediately below the
cover. In Graves XVIII and XX a fairly evenly distributed layer of ash and cinders
extended over the earth filling covering the skeletons and grave offerings. The evidence
seems clear, then, that the graves were filled before being covered. The depth of the shafts
1
2
3 A.A., 1935.
pp. 262 ff.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
18
RODNEY S. YOUNG
from floor to cover was usually about half a metre. The cover slabs, about a metre long,
were of micaceous green shale. They had been laid across the shafts from side to side;
sometimes their edges overlapped, and usually the cracks between their ends had been
chinked with small stones. They formed, then, a fairly tight cover through which very
little could pass. There was usually a thin layer of fine earth inside, which had sifted
through, and overlay the grave filling; but in almost every case there was empty space
immediately below the cover.
Since the level of the terrace floor of the Geometric period was nowhere preserved, the
total depth of the grave shafts cannot be known exactly. It seems safe to assume, however,
that the covering slabs lay at least half a metre below the surface. Graves of this type
at the Dipylon were usually about a metre deep. T'he shafts in their upper part must have
been as wide and long as the covers over the graves. They were cut, then, with a width
of about a metre to a depth of about half a metre, from which point they were narrowed,
leaving ledges along the sides to support the ends of the cover slabs. The ledges left were
of the firm filling of broken hardpan; no walls were built along the sides of the grave shafts
to help support the covers.
It has already been noted that, with the possible exception of XIV, no evidence was
found to indicate that the graves had been marked; also that they were cut with a view
more to the natural contour of the land and to economy of space than to any fixed rule of
orientation. The positions of the bodies in the graves further show that no rule of grave
orientation was observed. Of the inner row of graves, the bodies in three (XI, XVIII, and
XX) had been laid with the heads toward the southeast, while the bodies in the other two
graves (XVII and XIX) lay with their heads toward the northwest. Graves XVII and
XVIII were both graves of women; Graves XI and XIX both graves of men.
In the case of none of the shaft burials had offerings of vases been left outside the
graves themselves. The grave gifts were always found with the body inside the shaft. For
men the offerings were limited in number, and usually consisted of weapons and drinking
vessels. For women more numerous vases were brought; Grave XVII contained twentytwo pots. Characteristic in women's graves were the pyxides, which were probably used in
life as toilet boxes.' Jewellery in the form of rings, pins, and fibulae was placed in
women's graves instead of weapons. Undoubtedly many vases were brought new to be
offered in the graves; but often vases were offered which showed clearly by their worn
and chipped condition that they had undergone considerable use before being placed in
the grave. Miniature vases were almost always offered in children's graves. Such little
vases were probably used by the children in their lifetime and were not specially made as
grave offerings; a little feeder found in a child's grave at Tiryns, for example, must have
been made for use.2 Some of the vases in Grave IX, which had sixteen small
offerings,
1 Pyxides were customarilyplaced in the graves of women and
girls during the seventh and sixth
centuries in the North Cemeteryat Corinth; see A.J.A., XXXIV, 1930,p. 421.
2
Tiryns Grave 30; Tiryns, I, pi. XVIII, 9.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
19
seemed fresh and new, while others were somewhat worn and peeled. In the graves of
children then, as in the graves of adults, used and new vases were often offered together.
All the vases in a grave were thus not necessarily strictly contemporary; some may have
been as much as twenty years older than other vases found in the same grave. The dating
suggested for each burial is based on what seems a probable approximate date for the latest
vase offered in it; it must always be remembered that some of the other vases may be earlier.
Our cemetery yielded considerable evidence as to the funerl rites ed at the graves.
Two of the women's graves, XVIII and XX, contained thick layers of ash, distributed
fairly evely throughout the shafts, and which must have been thrown in before the covers
were put in place. Small fragments of animal bones were, moreover, found in the same
graves. The combination of ash and the bones of animals suggests that sacrifices were
held at the grave, and that perhaps the funeral banquet or Trle
sQiElvon was eaten there.
in
evidence
favor
of
strong
this
in Grave XI, which was
was
found
Very
supllposition
a normal inhumation of a man. A mass of carbonized matter, however, was found inside
the grave; among the ash and cinders were found many fragments of burned and broken
vases and figurines. A considerable amount of the same carbonized matter, scattered
through the filling ove the grave, produced similar fragments of vases, some of which
actually joined with fragments found inside the grave. Since the cover was too tight to
allow the passage of any but the very smallest sherds, the burned deposit must have been
thlrown into the grave after the body had been put in and before the cover was laid over the
shaft. Throughout the burned deposit were found small fragments of animal bone. The
burned deposit can be nothing but the remains of a sacrificial pyre burned near the grave
at the time of the funeral; a pyre at which animals were sacrificed and at which the meat
for the funeral banquet was cooked. The bits of animal bone found scattered through the
burned deposit came probably from the parts of the victims burned as sacrifices; a whole
collection of unbroken animal bones found in one of the amphoras which had been offered
in the grave may well represent the remains of the funeral banquet. The animal bones
unfortunately were not identified as to species; bones of cows and horses, sheep and hares,
as well as eggshells and seashells have been fotnd at the Kerameikos, Phaleron, and
Eleusis; the bones probably of a pig were found in a grave at the Agora.1 Geometric inhumations showing traces of burning have been found at the Kerameikos and at Eleusis.2
In the case of Grave XI the remains of the sacrificial pyre were used to help fill the
grave. Grave XII, a thick deposit of burned matter found in the road beside the grave
terrace, was part of a pyre similar to that burned beside Grave XI. In the case of Grave XII,
however, the remains of the pyre were swept up and dumped over the parapet wall, instead
of being used to fill the grave. As in the burned matter found in Grave XI, fragments of
animal bones were found scattered through the remains of the other sacrificial pyre,
1 Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 141; Eph. Arch., 1898, pp. 89 and 98;
Poulsen, pp. 22 ff.; Delt., II, 1916,
17
p.
(Grave 3 a); Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 552.
2
Poulsen, p. 25; Eph. Arch., 1912, p. 33.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
20
Grave XII. The similarity in the selection of vases found in the two pyres is, moreover,
striking and perhaps significant: in each case a large pot, amphora or hydria, decorated
with funerary scenes; a pair of bowls on perforated stands; small cups, miniature oinochoai
and lekythoi, and figurines. These vases, broken and thrown into the pyre, are clearly
ritual in character. Vases decorated with prothesis scenes 1 must have been made for use
at funerals and not for everyday life. Bowls on high perforated stands seem to have been
commonly used in funerary rites; bowls of this type were found in the Phaleron cemetery
only in connection with pyres.2 The small oinochoai and lekythoi found in Grave XII can
have been of no use for the ordinary purposes of life. Oil, wine, and perfume may have
been contained in the vases broken at the pyre; all were used at funerals in classical times,
and all were used at the funeral of Patroklos as described by Homer in the twenty-third
book of the Iliad. The contents of our pyres suggest that the custom was continuous from
early times; the big vases contained perhaps the wine, the smaller the oil, and the miniature
lekythoi the perfume; incense may have been burned in the shallow open saucers and
skyphoi. The scene drawn on one side of the neck of the amphora from Grave XII may
throw some light on the ritual. Three figures are represented bringing objects for use at
the funeral (fig. 38); one is a wreath, the second a knife, and the third a vase with a high
lid, perhaps a Ovuttiarqov or incense-burner. The wreath is probably an offering to the
dead; the scene on the other side of the neck of the same amphora (fig. 37) is one of
prothesis, in which a figure is holding a leafy spray over the head of the dead. The knife
is undoubtedly brought for use at the sacrifice.
The evidence of Graves XI and XII is important with regard to funeral ritual. Our
graves show not only that sacrificial pyres were burned beside inhumations, but also that
animals were actually slaughtered, and probably eaten, at the graveside. The evidence as to
offerings of flowers and perhaps incense is welcome. The probability becomes strong that the
traditional ritual of burial as described by Homer was continuous, handed down through the
Geometricperiod into early classical times. Elaborate grave ceremonies such as were performed at Graves XI and XII must have been celebrated only for prominent persons. Grave XI
was a man's burial; presumably the pyre Grave XII, so similar in its nature and contents
to the one burned at Grave XI, was also burned beside a man's grave. Possibly the burial
was our Grave XIII, which is perhaps slightly earlier than the pyre, but which contained
an elaborately made pot suggesting that the person buried was an important personage.
Our graves at the Agora are of normal late Geometric type such as have been found
elsewhere in Attica. The children's burials are of a type common throughout the Greek
world. Our cemetery, however, furnishes new and interesting evidence as to the burial
customs of the early Greek period. A list of Attic graves with their probable dating is
given in Appendix I, p. 231 below.
Geometricscenes of prothesis and ekphoraare listed, Ath. Mitt., LIII, 1928,pp. 17 if.
Deltion, II, 1916, pp. 17 ff.; Graves 3a, 14 a, 40 and 41. All were pyres; human bones are not
mentionedin connectionwith any of them, while animalhones were found in 3 a.
2
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
21
CATALOGUE OF GRAVES
GRAVEI
P'hla. Fig. 1.
Contents. Fiog. 7
Urn-burial of an infant. Height al)ove sea-level 56.62m. The amphora, containing the
skeleton of a small child, had been laid on its side, with a coarse sherd over its mouth, in
a shallow pit scooped for it in the bedrock. It had been partially destroyed by the laying
of a later drain close by. There were no grave offerings. Some carbonized matter and
a number of cinders found in the amlhora with the skeleton suggest that food of some sort
may have been buried with the body.
The coarse amphora of very micaceous clay is of a
type for which I have found no published parallels. An
amplhora of similar shape and fabric was found in a pit
on the north slope of the Acropolis, together with late
seventh and sixth century pottery.1 On the evidence of
the example from the North Slope, our amphora should
lbe dated probably in the sixth century; its fabric finds no
plarallels among the coarse wares of the seventh.
Most of the neck, one handle, part of the rim, and the
body at one side, restored. Egg-shaped body, narrowing to
an irregularly flattened tip: short neck and thick rounded lip.
Smooth, very flaky, lnicaceous clay; unglazed.
I:
Fig. 7. Grave I, Amphora (I I)
GRAVE II
Plan. Fig. 1.
Urn-burial of an infant. Height above sea-level, 55.87 m. Grave II had been slightly
disturbed by the digging of Pit A; it had itself disturbed Grave VI. The amphora lay on
its side with a flat stone stopping its mouth. The three small vases offered at the burial
were found, together with a few of the bones of a small child, inside the amphora.
The burial amphora is a late example from a long series of Attic amphoras extend(ing
thlroughout the seventh century and into the sixth. The small pots are dated at the very
1 I am indebted to Oscar Broneer for showing me this amphora from the excavations on the North
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
22
RODNEY S. YOUNG
century
or the begining
of the sixth.
Pyxis
and skyphos
careless imitations of late Protocorinthian types with linear decoration, which persist in
Corinth until the end of the seventh
century.
and oinochoe,
on
the other hand, seem to stand near the head of an Attic group extending through the sixth
century.
111.
II 2.
II 3.
The vases from Grave II must then (late from about 600.
Amphora.
Skyphos.
Fig. 9
"
II1
Fig. 9
P 4602. H. (pyxis), 0.052 m. II. with lid, 0.091mI. )iam. at rim, 0.072 m.
Flat bottomed pyxis with deep, slightly concave side wall and handles outside the rim.
Around the middle of the body a zone filled by a lozenge-chain; above and below, broad bands
of purple-red, bordered by glaze bands. A wavy line in the handle zone. The convex lid has
a tall knob handle decorated on top w-ith a six-armed cross, and on the side with a purple-red
and a black band; around the lid itself, a procession of birds to the right. Purple-red on the
bodies of the birds. Attic clay; glaze dull brown to metallic black. The shape is taken from
the Early Corinthian type discussed by Payne, Necrocorinthia, p. 292. The bird procession on
the lid is paralleled on a lidded skyphos from one of the latest graves at Phaleron (Delt., II, 1916,
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
23
1. 35, fig. 29: grave 18A). This type of unincised bird decoration is used on an Attic group
common in the sixth century, and apparently beginning at the end of the seventh; several
examples from the Acropolis are discussed in Graef-Langlotz 1, pp. 61 if., 569-583. See also Toronto
274-277; Robinson, Harcum and Iliffe, Greek Vases in Toronto, p1. XXV: dated about 600.
114. Oinochoe.
Fig. 9
._^
I2
113
1I4
'The unincised
pots withl un-
incised animal zones such as those discussed by- Payne, Necrocorinthia, pl. 279, 1 and no. 191.
Plan. Fig. 1.
GRAVE III
Contents. Fig. 10
Urn-burial of an infant. Height above sea-level, 57.20 m. The burial had been disturlbed
at the time of the lowering of the level of the terrace floor in the sixth century. A fragment
of the coarse spouted. basin, in lwhich the body had probably been placed, was found,
together with a small oinochoe and the skull and some of the bones of an infant, in a shallow
round pit scooped out of the bedrock. The grave was too disturbed to give evidence as to
the original position of the basin, or as to the way in which it was covered.
The burial should be dated in the second quarter of the seventh century; vases similar
both to the coarse basin and to the oinochoe have been found in orientalizing contexts.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNCI
24
Spouted
the century.
Fig. 10
..
]i
Fig. 10. Grave III, Bowl Fragment and Oinochoe (III 1-2)
first half of the seventh century. A fragment of another spouted basin of tlhe saine sort was
found in an Agora deposit of the third quarter of the century: Hesperia, VII, 1938, p. 426, D 25,
and figs. 8 9.
Ill 2.
Oinochoe. Fig. 10
P 5347. H., 0.099 m. Max. Diam., 0.085 m.
The band handle, and gaps in the body, restored.. Squat tlat-bottomed body and trefoil niouth.
Soft flaky clay covered with dull black glaze; a reserved band around the middle was decorated
with fine glaze lines. Very badly flaked and peeled.
An oinochoe of about the same shape was found at Phaleron in a grave of the second quarter
of the seventh century (Grave 48; Delt., II, 1916, p. 41, fig. 41, 3).
GltAVE IV
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
25
The larger slab was pierced )by two small holes through its centre, 1pel'halps
for
lowering it onto the amphora in the grave. A mass of small stones piled on
finger-holes
must have been thrown in when the grave xwas filled; among tllem wasthe
slabs
topl of
on its foot.
al
e offerings;
no
2). There
late COe{Illtl'iC
sherd'l (IV
Geomietiric shierd
grave
earl,lsonizc{l
matter
lllatter
TherIe
foiiund
no
f{,l!l~.la lIte
wer were
(IV 2).
offerings; carbonized
grave
found in the amphora with the bones of a small child suggest that foodi had been placed in
ic amphora.
IV 1. Aphllllora. Fig. 12
^.
//
,,
.:
.-
2V1
'_
i';,r-19)
..,.l-a
I:
ig.I'L.
r-
A
TVi
.llin.r
Iv
,
-lliplku
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
l'x
(TV'
l'I
lI
1The
26
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Agora well of the seventh and early sixth century, which contained no Geolmetric potte.ry (A'gora
Inventory P 3469). The amphora C 146 from the seventh century well is of the same type. While
these amphoras clearly have a Geometric ancestry, they are found in seventh century rather than
Geometric contexts. To be noted is the substitution of the wavy line for the St. Andrew's cross
as a handle decoration on very late Geometric and orientalizing vases.
IV 2. Amphora Fragment.
Fig. 13
On
the
preserved
part
of
the
chain;
on the
lip, zigzag,
..
W..jw .
'a.
GRAVE V
Urn-burial of an infant. Height above sea-level, 56.54 m. The neck and mouth of the
hydria, with part of the shoulder, were missing; the grave had been somewhat disturbed by
the digging of Well B. The hydria lay on its side; in it was found the skeleton of a small
child lying on its side with the knees drawn up toward the chest. The grave offering of
two small pots had been placed with the body inside the hydria.
The grave seems to belong in the first quarter of the seventh century. Parallels for the
hydria are to be found in the Phaleron cemetery and in our seventh century well; a group
of hydriai from Rheneia is very similar in shape, fabric, and decoration. The small skyphos
and cup are late in shape and subgeometric in decoration. Since stylistic considerations
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
LATE GEOMETRIC
GRAVES
ANI) A SEVENTH
CENTUiRY
WELL,
ETC.
27
leiad to the dating of Grave VIII, which lay immediately below Girave V, at the end of thel
eighth century, Grave V should probably b)e dated well down in the first quarter of the
seventh.
1.
Hydria.
Fig. 14
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
1RODNEY S. YOUNG
28
true 'Protogeometric. Protogeometric is known to have laste(d late in Boeotia and Thessaly; it
is not impossible that it should have influenced the Cycladic workshops, working its way throu1ghl
the northern Sporades or Euboia. Protogeometric has been found in Skyros (B.S.A., XI, 1904-0),
p. 79; A.A., 1936, pp. 228-234). The Cycladic series which has been attributed by Buschor to
Paros (Ath. Alitt.. LlV, 1929, pp. 142 ff.), is followed by an orientalizing sequel (Delos, XVII.
Vases archaiqules des Cyclades a decor lineaire, lls. XXXI\--XXXVI). The hydria from Phaleron
(1hrave10 iresembles morle closel- those of the later Cycladic seiries, Delos, XVII, Pls. XXXIV-XXXV.
V2.
V3
V2
Fi,. 15.
The shal;e is late and the decoration subgeometric. Part of a very similar c1upwas found in
the seventh century well (C 57, fig. 109 below).
V 3. Skyphos. Fig. 15
P 4615. H., 0.068m. Diam. at rim, 0.109m.
Flat bottom and straight rim tilted slightly outward. Bands on the rim, and zigzags in tl'h
reserved handle zone, with a dot at the centre. Glazed inside, with a reserved dot on the floor.
(Greyish buff clay, badly peeled black glaze. The fabric is Attic, lperhaps nlisfired.
The shape is late, as indicated by the flat bottom, relatively high straight rim, and very
shallow shoulder. Early skyphoi from the Areopagus graves (C.V.A., Athens, I, pls. I-1I) have
a sharply rounded shoulder, low, sharply offset rim, and ring foot. Here the shoulder has almost
disappeared, and the bottom is flat. The decoration is subgeometric.
GRAVE VI
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
29
mouth by a shallow plate. The grave offering of three small pots had been placed in the pit
before the amphora itself, and lay immediately under its neck. One of the small vases offered
had not l)een fired, or had been insufficiently fired; the dampness of the ground had reduced
it to little more than a lump of pinkish clay easily distinguishable from the suilrroundingfill.
It had beeIn spherical in shape; possibly a round-bodied hand-made aryballos of the type
often found in late Geometric graves (like XVII 22 and XXV 4). The pink clay was well
cleaned and very flaky. A coarse hand-made pitcher stood upright beside the neck of the
aml)hora.
The amphora finds p)arallels in subgeometric graves not only in Attica, but also in the
Argolid (Mycenae and Tiryns; also at Troezen). The small vases, late in shape, are
decorated in a carefull subgteometric style; a very close parallel for the plate was foiundl
with a Protoattic amphora in the Eleusis cemetery. Parallels for all the pots of the grave
aire to be noted in the Agora well deposit of the first half of the seventh century. The
pottery from the grave should be dated in the first quarter of the seventh century.
VI11. Amphora.
Fig. 16
..* '
?'"I
'Fig. 1(;. Grave VI, Amllphora(VI )
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
30
VI 2. Cup. Fig. 17
VI 3. Plate.
Fig. 18
VI 4. Oinochoe. Fig. 18
P 4785. H., 0.122m. Max. Diam., 0.074m.
Flat bottom and rolled handle decorated with a ladder. A row of dots below the lip, and
two zigzags across the neck. Interlocking latticed triangles on the shoulder, with a zigzag band
below. The bands on the lower body are interrupted by a zone filled with verticals. Attic clay;
,flaze somewhat metallic, black to redl, and peeled in places.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
31
Three little oinochoai of the same shape were found in a grave at the Dipylon (Grave IX:
Ath. Mitt., XVIII. 1893, p. 117 and pl. VIII, 2, 5 and 8: the third is not illustrated). One has not
only the same shape, but almost identical decoration, as ours. In the same grave were found
five one-handled Phaleron cups, an oinochoe like one found at Phaleron in Grave 78 (Delt., II,
1916, p. 40, fig. 40; a grave of the third quarter of the seventh century), and a ribbon-handled
bowl with subgeometric decoration. The Dipylon grave must belong in the first qnarter of the
seventh century.
VI 5. Coarse Pitcher.
Fig. 18
,l.
V14
Vi3
V15
GRAVEVII
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
32
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Parallels for the amphora, found in subgeometric graves in the Argolid, date from the
very end of the eighth century and in the early seventh. Small cups like the ones from our
grave have been found in graves at Pllaleroni together with Protocorinthian vatses (ateablle
in the late eilghth and early seventh century. Grave VII should be dated probably abol)ut
700 or slightly thereafter.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
33
Cup. Fig. 20
VIs3
V115
V 7
,T4
V' 8
Vd 2
VI 6
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
34
The birds are almost unrecognizable; perhaps, with their long beaks and fluffy tails, they
represent Blakeway's Travelling Ostrich (B.S.A., XXXIII, 1932-33, p. 172, note 1).
VII 7. Kantharos.
Fig. 20
GRAVEVIII
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
35
neck by the diggers of the well. The skeleton, and the grave offerings which must have
lain in the body of the amphora, were therefore lost. The amphora mouth was doubly
stopped by the bases of two other amphoras, one in its neck, the other in its mouth. The
coarse hand-made pitcher stood upright beside the amphora neck; it was covered by a flat
piece of stone.
Grave VIII must be older than Grave V, under which it lies; the lower grave could not
have been dug without disturbing the upper. The pottery, how-ever,is very similar to that
from Graves VI and VII, and there cannot be much difference in time between Graves VIII
and V. If Grave V belongs late in the first quarter of the seventh century, Grave VIII must
b)edated about 700.
Vlfl13
v-3
_I_M^
_;_SSBB
VEIU
VIR
vI 4
Fig. 21. Grave VIII, Amphora Fragments and Coarse Pitcher (VIII 1-4)
a box filled by a St. Andrew's cross. On the handles, St. Andrew's crosses.
a heavy creamy slip; black glaze, brownish where thin. The body was banded.
Part of an amphora like VII 1.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
36
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Fig. 21
Fig. 21
after the pithos had been stopped. Beside the pithos at one side was found a kantharos,
and at the other side another kantharos, with an oinochoe in it, and an oinochoe. The rest
of the grave offerings, twelve small vases and a bronze ring, were found inside the pithos
with the skeletons of two small children. There was no evidence to suggest a reopening of
the grave; both.burials must have been made at the same time. An animal bone found in
the earth under the coarse pitcher by the pithos mouth may have come from a sacrifice
made at the time of the burial; carbonized matter found in one of the small kantharoi in
the pithos may be the remains of food offered in the grave.
The small vases offered in Grave IX find parallels in the late Geometric graves at Spata,
the Isis Grave at Eleusis, and the earlier tD~~~~?
graves
~ of the Phaleron cemetery. The decoration
7
rL11/~l?lV\
\IIV\I
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
37
IX 1.
Pithos.
Fig. 23
P 4960. H., 0.885 m. Max. Diam., 0.60 in. Diain. at mouth. 0.338 m.
Large flat-bottomed handleless pithos with swelling rounded body, concave neck, and plain
lip. Hand-made of coarse reddish-brown clay with small red grits; the outside carefully polished,
the inside left rough. Unglazed.
A pithos somewhat similar in shape from a grave at Phaleron
is illustrated in Delt., IT. 1916, p. 25, fig. 7 (from Grave 81 or
Grave 11; Grave 11 is a grave of the beginning of the seventh
century).
IX 2. Cup.
Fig. 24
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
1 9
IX14
JX12
IX
ITX
X7
6s
IX
X82
12
JX7
C
1(3'
IX1
-(5
1X4
_,
C
IX15
1X17
Fig. 24.
DI16
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
39
IX 8. Kantharos.
Fig. 24
IX 9. Kantharos.
Fig. 24
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
40
RODNEY S. YOUNG
IX 10. Kantharos.
Fig. 24
IX 11. Kantharos.
Fig. 24
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
41
Similar squat oinochoai were found in two of the late Geometric graves at Spata (Delt., VI,
1920-21, p. 134, fig. 8 and p. 138, fig. 12; from graves 3 and 4), and in the Isis grave at Eleusis
(C. .A., Athens, I, pl. 4, 6). Others were found in Anavysos (Praktika, 1911, p. 116, 1) and at
Corinth. The type seems to date from the late eighth century. The similarity of the decoration
to that of late Protogeometric lekythoi is striking.
IX 14.
Oinochoe. Fig. 24
IX17.
IX 18.
Fig. 24
Fig. 25
Bronze Ring.
Coarse micaceous
18
Fig. 73
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
42
RODNEY S. YOUNG
GRAVEX
Plan. Fig. 1. Grave. Fig. 26. Contents. Figs. 27-28
Urn-burial of an infant. Height above sea-level, 55.74m. The mouth of the hydria,
which, like the other burial pots in the precinct, lay on its side, was covered by the onehandled cup X 2. A coarse pitcher stood upright and uncovered beside the neck of the
hydria. The only offering found inside with the skeleton of an infant was a small spherical
pot of pink clay, with a band handle. Like the similar pot from Grave VI, it was unbaked
and had become very soft from the damp; it disintegrated
^
_iE
l."g^^^^
~
X 1. liydria.
-when an attempt
was made to
lift it from its place. It would seem to have been a handmade aryballoid vase of some sort.
The grave is probably to be dated in the late eighth
century, although the vases have neither shapes or decoration easily to be dated; l)arallels can- be found for all of
them both late and early. The manner of burial, however,
is the same as that of the other graves in the precinct; urnburials in the Protogeometric and early Geometric period
are usllylly made witlh the contaiinng pot standing upright
on its foot, often in a hole in the bedrock made for it, and
packed around with stones; whereas the later urn-burials
in our precinct, at Phaleron, and elsewhere, are made with
the containing pot lying on its side, as in Grave X. The
ornament on the shoulder of the hydria is found on
late Geometric amphoriskoi from the Tiryns cemetery.
Fig. 27
Max.Diam., 0.334m.
Straight ring foot, plump ovoid body, and slightly concave neck with flaring rounded lip.
A band handle from the shoulder to the lip, and two rolled horizontal handles at the sides. The
body decorated with widely spaced double and triple glaze bands, with a wider band on the
lower shoulder; the neck solidly glazed. On the upper shoulder, series of short diagoaral lines
pendant from the base of the neck, and a downward-pointed arrow at the centre in front. On the
vertical handle, a St. Andrew's cross. Attic clay with thick creamy slip, somewhat peeled and
pitted; dull black glaze. A section of the lower body was broken out by chipping along the lines
of the breaks desired, so that the section thus removed in one piece could be replaced after the
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
,:
X3
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
43
44
4RODNEY S. YOUNG
in these black glazed one-llandled clips; they seem to have been miiadefrom lProtogeometric to
Protoattic times with v-ariations of rim, handle and profile that follow no consistent sequence.
For a seventh century example, see C 51 below (fig. 106).
X 3.
Coarse Pitcher.
Fig. 28
Fig. 29. Grave XI. Covering Slabs; Well C above, Grave XXI at left
GRAVE
XI
Inhumation, with remains of a sacrificial pyre. Height above sea-level, 56.65m. The
skeleton found in Grave XI is not included in Angel's report (Appendix III) becau,e it had
been sent to the Museum of Natural History in New York for study before his arrival in
Athens. It was that of a man; it lay with the head toward the northeast. The vases offered
in the grave, XI.1--5 had been placed at the lower end of the shaft, over the feet and lower
legs of the body. The amphora XI 2 contained a collection of bones of small animals and
carbonized matter. An iron knife lay across the left knee of the skeleton. There was a
heavy deposit of ash and cinders in the central and lower part of the grave; most of the
fragments of the hydria XI 7 and of the two bowls XI 8-9, and the figurine XI 19, were
found in the burned deposit. Much biurned matter was also found scattered thlrotughthe
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
45
disturbed filling over and around the grave outside; in the burned deposit outside the grave
were found other pieces of the hydria and of the two bow-ls, and the fragments XI 10-17.
fig
20
30
40CX..
its lower end by Grave XI, showed no traces of burned matter or of fragments like those
found in Grave XI. The conclusion therefore seems inevitable that the burned deposit with
its fragments of vases and figurines had been thrown into Grave XI to help fill it before the
cover was put in place. The fragments found outside had probably been thrown into the
upper part of the shaft, above the cover, and had become scattered when the level of the
grave terrace was lowered at a later time. The burned deposit must belong with Grave XI
and be the remains of a sacrificial pyre burned at the time of the burial. The pyre was
prohalblyburned beIsidethe grave. From the grave, XI 1-6; from the pyre, XI 7-19.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
46
RODNEY S. YOUNG
The pottery from Grave XI should probably be dated at the beginning of the seventh
century. The decoration of the vases is drawn in a careless subgeometric manner, and a
number of late motives are used. One of the fragments (XI 14) is decorated with dots of
white paint, which came into use only at the very end of the Geometric period. The
figurines, with those from Grave XII the most elaborate Geometric terracottas that have
been found in Attica, are covered with the same subgeometric decoration as the vases.
Nevertheless, they show a considerable advance, in ambition if in nothing else, over the
simple horses and birds used as lid-handles by the late Geometric potters.
X11. Amphora. Fig. 32
P 5423. H., 0.373m. Max. Diam., 0.222m.
Plumpovoid body on a vertical ring foot; tall neck, slightly concave, flaring to a roundedlip.
Band handles from the shoulderto midway up the neck. The body decorated to the middle by
wide and narrow glaze bands; in the zone below the handle attachments,a procession of birds.
The shoulderis divided into three panels filled at the sides by checker-board,and in the middle
by interlockinglatticed triangles. In the neck panel, a complicatedmeanderformedby two bands
of key pattern running vertically and joined at the top. A zone around the neck above the
handles is filled by another procession of birds; a reserved band on the outer face of the lip is
decoratedwith a row of dots. The handles barred. Thick black glaze, very badly peeled.
The shape, as well as the bird decoration, is very similar to that of the late Geometric
amphora,Wide, fig. 59. Another of the same shape (Wide, fig. 56), but somewhat slimmer, has
decorationvery close in its drawingto that of our oinochoeXlll 1. The two amphorasillustrated
by Wide belong at the end of the eighth century; ours may be slightly later.
XI 3. Ribbon-handled Bowl.
Fig. 32
P 5420. H., 0.069m. Diam. at rim., 0.147m.
Flat bottom, shallow body, and high straight rim, tilted slightly outward. Horizontalband
handles with out-turnedends below the rim. The lower body banded;in the handle-zone,inter-
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
.
MIgBnnnf^W A3KM
g. 32.
-.
Fig. 32. Grave XI, Vases offered in thle Grave (XI 1-5)
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
48
locking latticed triangles. On the rim, zones filled by zigzag and checker-board, separated by
bands. Vertical bars on the handles. The inside glazed, with three narrow reserved bands inside
the rim, a broader reserved band at the shoulder, and a dot at the centre of the floor. Thick
glaze, fired red inside, and black shading to red outside.
The ribbon-handled bowl is a late Geometric shape; such bowls have not been found in early
graves on the Areopagus or at the Kerameikos, nor in any of the early Geometric deposits at
the Agora. The bowls from Dipylon Grave XIII (Hampe, pl. 33), measuring from 20 to 28cm.
in diameter, reflect the tendency toward the making of oversize pieces characteristic of the last
quarter of the eighth century. Smaller bowls of the type, often with lids and with subgeometric
decoration, have been found in late graves at the Dipylon (Grave III; WVide,figs. 97 right and 99;
Grave IX, Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pl. VIII2, 2); at Spata (Graves 1, 2, and 4; Delt., VI, 1920-21,
pp. 131 ff. and figs. 2, 4, and 11); at Liossia (C. '. A., Copenhagen, II, pl. 70, 4); and at Anavysos
(Praktika, 1911, p. 119, 10: an enchanting subgeometric bowl with a mouse-faced horse). Such
bowls with lids may have replaced the pyxis for a short time at the beginning of the seventh
century; the shape with handles was doubtless more useful than the pyxis shape. From the end
of the eighth century, however, the type was made also with high stands, often perforated; the
bowls on stands are made down to the middle of the seventh century or later (e.g. A. A., 1934,
p. 219, fig. 14), outlasting the flat-bottomed type. It might be noted here that three bowls of
the latter type were found together in the same grave with the well-known bronze tripod
from the Pnyx (Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pp. 414 ff. and pl. XIV; Lamb, Greek and Roman Bronzes,
pi. 11 a). The vases from the Pnyx grave (Athens, N. M. Inventory, 169, 186, 201-202) are late eighth
century. On our bowl the interlocking latticed triangles are a late decorative motive (as on the
shoulder of the amphora XI 1) and the checker-board zone at the rim, though carefully done, is
in the subgeometric " shorthand" manner noticed on the cup VI 2.
XI 4. Ribbon-handled Bowl.
Fig. 32
XI 5. Kantharos.
Fig. 32
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
49
band handles are decorated with bars and St. Andrew's crosses. The lower body solidly glazed
outside; above, vertical glaze lines interrupted at regular intervals by wider vertical glaze bands,
running from the lip to the glazed lower body. Glazed inside, with a reserved dot at the centre
of the floor. Attic clay with thick black glaze, thin for the vertical lines.
The shape of the body and the decoration together give a naturalistic effect, as of a tuliplike flower, which is distinctly Mycenaean; compare the Mycenaean jugs, Furtwangler and
Loeschcke, Mykenische Vasen, pl. XV, 102, and pl. XIII, 89; the latter uses single wide bands
alternating with triple narrow ones. The decoration is used sparingly in late Geometric and
subgeometric; compare our krater fragment from the seventh century well, C 103, and our skyphos
fragment B 11. It appears on a cup from a grave at Tiryns which contained subgeometric vases
(Grave 37; Tiryns, I, pl. XVIII, 1). All the vases using this decoration of which I know are of
the end of the eighth and early seventh century.
XI 7. Hydria Fragments.
Figs. 33-35
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
50
RODNEY S. YOUNG
with early orientalizing, and like ours, belong at the beginning of the seventh century. The
Analatos hydria, with its full-blown floral filling ornament, must belong near the end of the first
quarter of the century.
Fig. 33
XI
X 15
X9
Xi?7
,t16
Fig. 33. Grave XT, Vases and Fragments from the Pyre (XI 7-9, 15-16)
bottom of the stand and on the lower body; double zigzags in the stand-panels between the
slots. Multiple verticals beside the handles, which are also decorated with verticals; a band of
net pattern in the handle-zone. Two zigzags around the rim. Glazed inside, with four reserved
bands on the rim. The clay burned grey; dull black glaze, in places peeled.
The pair of bowls on stands XI 8-9 corresponds to the pair from the other pyre, XII 2-3.
Two more pairs of similar bowls were found in Graves XVI and XVIII at the Dipylon (Ath. Mitt.,
XVIII, 1893, pp. 132-133). Mention has been made above of the finding of bowls of this type
in the remains of pyres at Phaleron. Early specimens usually have low stands; two examples are
illustrated by Wide, figs. 101-102, and another was found at Spata in Grave 4 (Delt., VI,
1920--21, p. 138, fig. 12). The bowls from Grave XII, 2-3, are of a different type, probably clay
imitations of bronze tripods; cf. Ath. Mitt., XVII, 1892, pl. X. The early examples of ribbon-
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
51
handled bowls on stands have late Geometric and subgeometric decoration; the later examples,
with higher stands, have orientalizing rather than subgeometric birds as decoration. The stand
from the Kerameikos, A.A., 1934, p. 219, fig. 14, which has mid-seventh century decoration,
has become even higher and more elaborate. Our examples, with their simple subgeometric
ornament and low stands, belong still at the beginning of the century.
Fig. 33
Fig. 35
Fig. 35
XI 12.
Cup Fragment.
Fig. 35
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
52
RODNEY S. YOUNG
lower body; around the side wall a wide zone filled by a meander, and a narrower zone below
filled by a row of latticed triangles. The inside unglazed, and decorated with bands at the
lip. The clay burned grey, and the dull black glaze badly peeled.
Probably part of a flat-bottomed cup like XII 7.
Fig. 35
t?
- -
~.?
1.
040
f %
ev
XI9
Q11
.XIio
s
' 4 -V
X13
og
XI14
XI18
X117
X17
X!7
'01,
Fig. 35. Grave XI, Fragments of Vases and Figurines from the Pyre
a Maltese cross, surrounded by a zone filled with zigzag. In a wide zone around the side
wall, a procession of grazing horses to the left; zigzags and lozenges in the field. Dull
black glaze.
The shape of the body is like that of the saucer XII 4, without the stand and with different
handles, and somewhat deeper; it may be a development of the type of metallic skyphos from
Thera, Ath. Mitt., XXVIII, 1903, pl. III, become very much shallower. Our skyphos, however,
can be very little later than the one from Thera, which itself must date at the very end of
the eighth century.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
53
Fig. 35
XI 15. Jug.
Fig. 33
X117.
Oinochoe Fragments.
Fig. 35
P 6485.
Three small non-joining fragments from the body of a small oinochoe like XI 16. Bands and
a zigzag below the main zone, which is decorated with a procession of horses and
grazing deer
to the left.
Figs. 35-36
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
54
RODNEY S. YOUNG
was continuous w-ith the head, which seems to have had a pinched ridge for a nose, with hollows
to each side for e-es. The front of the neck is decorated with zigzags, the sides and back with
wavy glaze lines representing tresses of hair. A female figure is drawn on the chest; she wears
a long dress and raises her hands to her head in the same gesture of lamentation as does the
figurine on which she is painted; she is flanked on either side by a swastika. The same decoration
of mourner between swastikas is repeated on the back. The arms are decorated with zigzags.
The waist is encircled by a wide belt of latticed triangles with dots between, and the hips are
decorated in front with zigzags. Ladders run up the legs
from the feet to the hips, and short verticals on the feet
indicate the toes. The decoration of the legs runs around
to the back of the lower legs; the upper legs are undecorated. The bottom surface of the figure is concavely
curved, showing that the surface on which it sat was
convex. Buff clay with black to reddish glaze.
The gesture of the arms is unmistakably one of lamen|
tation and not one of adoration. It appears time and again
on Geometric vases in scenes of prothesis or ekphora;
I
bands of both male and female mourners are to be noted
around the neck of the amphora XII 1. Our figurine then
is simply the portrayal in the round of the conventional
painted figures on the vases. Seventh century figurines
representing mourners have been found at the Kerameikos,
seated on the handles of vases (A.A., 1932, p. 198, fig. 5);
free-standing sixth century figures have also been found
there (A.A., 1933, pp. 281-282, fig. 16). Our figure, though
it is earlier than those from the Kerameikos and from
Arkades in Crete (Annuario, 10-12, 1927-29, p. 184,
fig. 205; p. 196, fig. 217-" adoranti "), seems not to be the
earliest of the type; of three figures sitting on the rim
of a Mycenaean bowl from Ialysos, one, a woman, has her
X18
arms raised in the same lamenting gesture (C.V. A.,
British Museum, IIa, pl. 6, 3; Furtwiingler-Loeschcke,
1Fig 36. Grave XI, Terracotta
from the ylre:Mourner
pi. VI, 35). An Attic Geometiric figurine in the MetroFg'ine
(XI 18)
politan Museum, of the same period as ours and very
much like it in modelling and decoration, is brought forward as an argument in favor of the existence of monumental sculpture in the eighth century
(Metropolitan Museum Studies, V, pp. 157 ff.; fig. 10). T'he figurine represents a personage similar
to our mourning woman, but seated on a throne, and w-ith the arms extended along the arms
of the throne, not raised in lamentation. At the back of the throne, used to support the upper
cross-piece, there is, however, a small kneeling figure with hands raised to head in the mourning
gesture; the throned figure was probably, like our XII 25, used at a funeral ceremony. Figures
seated on thrones, are, like mourners' often drawn on late Geometric vases. Such a figure, drawn
on a shallow' metallic skyphos from Dipylon Grave VII, op. cit., p. 162, fig. 6 (in Athens, not
Paris), is used to confirm the existence of eighth century sculpture as suggested by the enthroned
figurine. Its relation to the plastic figure is precisely the same as that of the painted mourner
to the plastic one, or as that of the painted chariot scene to the plastic one (XII 24): the painted
figure is a conventional late Geometric vase ornament. The Geometric potter and coroplast were
clearly one; it seems entirely natural that the potter should try his hand at representing in the
riound those personages, participating in scenes of festival, funeral, and foray, -whom he had
become so accustomed to painting. In the making of plastic birds and horses he had already had
practice, using them to decorate the lids of his vases. The Attic skyphos, it might be noted, is
painted in a style very similar to that of the Protocorinthian aryballos illustrated opposite it
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Fig. 35
GRAVE XII
XII 1.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
56
RODNEY S. YOUNG
the outer edge of the lip, one on the shoulder in front and another at the back, and one running
down each handle. Between the coils of the snakes: on the lip, zigzags; on the handles, conventional birds; and on the shoulder, triangles and zigzags. The body is decorated with plain
glaze bands and zones of interlock, checker-board, and horizontal and vertical zigzags; in
the principal zone around the middle, a procession of five three-horse chairiots to the right.
Three of the charioteers are nude, while the other two wear long dresses; in the field, filling ornament of conventional birds, lozenges, wavy lines (snakes?), and zigzag in bands and columns; a
lozenge-star under each team of horses. The neck is divided at the front and back into three
zones; a nearly square panel between long narmrow
bands above and below. The lowest band is filled,
both front and back, by a dotted lozenge chain, with
.
I'
hooks growing upward and downwalrd from the
apices of the lozenges. The uppermost zone is occupied, at the front, by a procession of six nude men
l
to the right, each man with one arm raised to his
head in a gesture of lamentation, and carrying two
i
spears in the other hand; at the back, a similar procession of lamenting women wearing latticed skirts.
A prothesis scene is drawn in the central neck panel
in front; the dead lies on his bier, over which hangs
a checkered pall. Three women are in attendance:
one kneels lamenting under the bier; a second, standing by its foot, raises her arms to her head; and the
third, standing on a low stool at the head of the bier,
holds a spray of leaves ending in a large flower over
the dead (compare the same gesture in a prothesis
lI
scene on an amphora fragment, Perrot and Chipiez,
VII, p. 57, fig. 5 and Monumenti, IX, pl. XXXIX, 3). In
the field are five wavy vertical lines, probably re- :
presenting snakes. The back neck panel shows three
nude men bringing funerary offerings or objects to be
used in the grave-ritual; the first carries a wreath of
leaves, the second a knife which he holds upright,
and the third some sort of two-handled vessel, possibly a thymiaterion or incense-burner. Each bears
his offering in his left hand, while the right hands of
two are raised to the head in lamentation. In the
field, zigzags, chevrons, wavy lines, and a conventional bird. The clay is Attic; some fragments are
pink, and others burned grey, as they fell inside or
outside the pyre when the vase was broken. The
Fig. 37. Grave XII, Amphora XII 1,
dull black glaze is very badly peeled in places.
Front. Drawing by Piet de Jong
The vase is obviously of a class especially made
for funerary use, and not for everyday life. All the
figured scenes are funerary in character, arranged around the central prothesis scene, and showing various phases of the ceremonies that were observed at a burial. One of the implements
brought, the knife, suggests that the sacrifice of an animal was part of the ritual. The urn carried
by the third man may have contained incense, oil, or wine, all of which had their part in the
ceremonies at the pyre (cf. Iliad, XXIII, the funeral of Patroklos). The scene around the body of
the amphora represents the chariot race at the funeral games; none of the charioteers is armed.
Chariot races, often portrayed on Geometric funerary amphoras and kraters, must have been a
regular feature in a semi-feudal society dominated by great landholders who had little but sport to
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
57
occupy their time; the chariot race was one of the older contests in the Olympic games which
were reestablished, according to tradition, in the early eighth century. Boxing matches, another
feature of the funeral games of Patroklos (Iliad, XXIII, 653 ff.), appeared early among the sports
at the Olympic games; like chariot races, they appear also on late Geometric vases (for example,
C.V.A., Copenhagen, II, pl. 74, 2; Hampe, pl. 23).
Our amphora finds several parallels in shape and decoration. In shape it is similar to the
Copenhagen amphora C.V. A., II, pl. 73, 3, the Berlin amphora 3203 (A. A., 1892, p. 100, 4), and the
amphora Wide, fig. 61. A little taller and slimmer in its proportions than the Copenhagen
amphora, it is in the line of the development toward the tall narrow Protoattic vases. In
decoration as well as in shape it is later than the
Copenhagen amphora; the hooked lozenge band at the
base of the neck is a first appearance of an orientaliz11
ing motive. The drawing of the figures is, however,
very close to that of those on the Copenhagen vase,
and our amphora can be but very slightly later. The
S
filling ornament used on both is the same. An unpublished amphora in Oxford is closely similar in style
to our amphora: a photograph of part of it is published
in Ath. Mitt., LIII, 1928, Beilage VIII, 13. Again close
in style, but somewhat later, is the high footed bowl
Ath. Mitt., XVII, 1892, p. 205, and pl. X, clearly a
ceramic adaptation of bronze tripods like Olympia, IV,
pl. XXXIV. The bowl has new orientalizing motives
in addition to the usual funerary representations.
Found with our amphora were two small bowls of the
:
_
same metallic type: XII 2 and 5. Fragments of vases
,
of the same shapes and with the same style of decoraS
tion were found in Phaleron (Eph. Arch., 1911, p. 251,
figs. 18-19; fig. 18, right, is part of a ring handle from
a footed bowl). Together with the Phaleron frag*
I
S
ments was found a figurine like some of those from
Grave XII (ibid., p. 250, fig. 17). The Phaleron frag;
ments are very like our vases and figurines from
Graves XI and XII, and also like the footed bowll
;
adapted from metal tripods. It seems clear that they
should all be dated together at the very beginningc
.
of the seventh century; the Copenhagen vase perhaps
XII
about 700, the others slightly later. The Phaleron
cemetery produced no grave earlier than the very end
Fig. 38 Grave XII, Amphora XII 3,
of the eighth century; the fragments that must be
Back
with
ours
cannot
be
much
older
than
grouped
very
everything else in the cemetery. Like ours, they
belong to a class of funerary vases that were broken and scattered at the pyre. and like ours
they show signs of burning. From the fact that they are fragments, then, it does not follow that
they are older sherds lying in the fill; they are funerary fragments, belong with the cemetery, and
must be dated by it..
Fig. 39
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
58
lies on the rim in front, with another at the back. The bowl rests on a high, slightly flaring
stand, perforated by two series of long narrow slots; the slots of the upper series fall directly
above those of the lower. The bowl is glazed inside; series of short verticals in a reserved band
on the lip. Ladder pattern running up the backs of the birds, and bars on the handles. The
snakes are glazed black. Zigzag and chevron columns beside the handles, and a zone filled with
triple zigzags around the body; below, glaze bands and single zigzags. In the panels of the stand
between the perforations, rows of zigzags, with continuous zigzags around the zones between the
perforations and below them. Buff clay, in part burned grey; dull black glaze.
X18
,XJ13
X26
XI9
XmI1
XIn
zI2
XI7
E5
Fig. 39. Grave XII, Small Vases from a Pyre (XII 2-9, 11)
A big bowl with a stand of precisely the same shape and with the same kind of ring handles
was found near the Dipylon (Piraeus Street) and is published in Ath. Mitt., XVII, 1892, pp. 205 ff.
and pl. X; stylistic similarities between it and XII 1 have already been noted. The shape, with
its ring handles, is certainly adapted from that of bronze tripods, as noted by Pernice, p. 206;
in the clay, a perforated cylindrical stand had to be substitiuted for the three legs of the metal
prototype. The handles of the Piraeus Street vase undoubtedly had animals, probably horses,
on top to correspond to our birds. A fragment from another such handle, from Phaleron, is
published in Eph. Arch., 1911, p. 251, fig. 18, right. Bronze tripods of the type from which these
bowls were copied are preserved at Olympia: Olympia, IV, pls. XXVII-XXXIV (pl. XXIX, 638 with
a bird very like our birds). The shape of the bowl itself is close to that of skyphoi with inturned
rim (Ath. Mitt., XV
893, p. VIII, 1, 6; Delt., , 1916, p. 35, fig. 28 right, and p. 36, fig. 30 right;
our C 42 below). The decoration is conventional Geometric, rather carefully done; the panels
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
59
beside the handles fine late parallels. The birds are irather conventionalized and are not modelled
in great detail; the scale is too small. Our bowl must be fairly closely contemporary with the
Piraeus Street bowl, even though it has no distinctively o ientalizing features. The Piraeus
Street bowl (height, as restored, 0.59 m.), may have stood over a grave, or been used in funeral
rites; part of its decoration consists of a band of moulning women (Ath. Mitt., XVII, 1892, p. 226,
fig. 10).
P 4991.
Fragments of the body and stand, and one handle with its bird, restored. Shape, decoration,
and fabric the same as XII 2, and the dimensions very closely the same. The two form a pair.
Pairs of ritual vases are often found in graves; compare the pair of bowls from Grave XI
above, and the two pairs from Dipylon Grave VIII (Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pl. VIII 1; a second
bowl like no. 5 is not illustrated).
Fig. 39
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
60
RODNEY S. YOUNG
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
61
from about the end of the eighth century. Late Geometric or early orientalizing lekythoi from
Crete are not unlike our Attic lekythoi in shape: B.S. A., XXIX, 1927-28, pl. IX, 8-9.
Fig. 40
Fig. 39
Fig. 40
Fig. 40
XII 14. Terracotta Bird. Fig. 40. Hesperia, V, 1936, p. 27, fig. 25
T 756. H., 0.027m. W., 0.012m. L., 0.032 m.
Small bird, legless and flat-bottomed, with long beak and flat fan tail. Glaze stripes across
the front of the neck and chest, and bands along the sides of the beak, head, neck and body;
a St. Andrew's cross on the back between the bands. The end of the tail glazed, with incised
lines to indicate the feathers. Round incised eyes, and an incised mouth-line. The clay fired
grey, the glaze red. Hand-made.
Similar birds are often used as lid handles on late Geometric vases; one with fan tail very
like ours stands on the lid of the great pitcher from Dipylon Grave XIII (Wide, fig. 74 a; Hampe,
pl. 32). The plastic bird appears slightly later than the horse as an ornament on pottery; but
he gets his freedom at about the same time. Another unattached late Geometric bird was found
at Sparta (B.S.A., XXIX, 1927-28, p. 78, fig. 2, 10). The Spartan bird has plumage formed by
dots of added white, which show that he is a contemporary of our Attic bird and belongs at the
very end of the Geometric period. Another, later, Attic bird was found in the Agora (Hesperia,
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
62
RODNEY S. YOUNG
1I, 1933, p. 620 and fig. 86, 325); he has a higher stand and a round drooping tail, and is covered
with white slip and painted with red and blue bands; he must date from near the middle of the
seventh century. The bronze birds from Olympia are of the same type: Olympia, IV, pl. XIII,
210. A small group of clay birds decorated, like ours, with glaze, was found at Arkades in
Crete; Annuario, 10-12, 1927-29, p. 174, fig. 194.
Fig. 40. Grave XII, Fragments of Vases and Figurines from a Pyre
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Fig. 40.
63
Fig. 40
XI119.
Fig. 40.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
64
RODNEY S. YOUNG
century context at Phaleron: Eph. Arch., 1911, p. 250, fig. 17. The bottom is flat and unglazed;
the figure may have sat on a throne like that of XII 25.
Fig. 40
Fig. 41
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
65
black glaze. The fabric is very close to that of the enthroned figure, and the scale the same; the
fragment, although it does not join, might have been a part of the seated figure. The enthroned
figure must have been very similar in appearance to the other terracottas from the deposit, and
to the mourners from Grave XI. In the present instance, however, figure and throne were made
together, and were not separable. A late Geometric enthroned terracotta statuette in the Metropolitan Museum (Met. Mus. Bull. 27, 1932, p. 214; Met. Mus. Studies, V, p. 164, fig. 10) has been
referred to above (XI 18). It is complete, and strikingly like ours, giving an excellent idea of
how the latter must have looked. The statuette in the Metropolitan has been cited as evidence
for early Greek monumental scupture. It must, however, have been made as a figurine for use
in connection with funeral ritual rather than as a mere copy of a large statue; our figure belongs
in a funerary context. The small kneeling figure at the back of the throne of the Metropolitan
Museum piece has its arms raised to its head in a gesture
very like the gesture of lamentation of the mouirning
woman from Grave XI, and of so many figures painted on
late Geometric funerary vases. Professor Elderkin makes
the interesting suggestion that the spherical object held
by our figure is a pomegranate, and that we have here the
earliest representation of Persephone. Seated figures
holding pomegranates and receiving gifts and homage from
minuscule mortals are represented on the archaic reliefs from
Sparta, Ath. Mitt., II, 1877, pp. 301 if. and pls. XX-XXV;
also Furtwaingler, Sammlung Sabouroff, pp. 25 ff. and pl. I.
XII 24.
Fig. 42.
Hesperia, V, 1936, p. 27, fig. 25; A.A., 1935,
pp. 167-168, fig. 4
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
66
RODNEY S. YOUNG
a panel filled by zigzags. The decoration is terminated below by horizontal stripes running
around the legs well above the knees. Stripes of glaze down the lower legs at the back. The
neck, forearms, and legs in front are undecorated. The glaze decoration on the body suggests
that a short tunic is represented, extending fronmthe shouldel to the hilps. and with short sleeves
to the elbow.
Horse's head. H., 0.056 m.
The head and neck down to the shoulder are preserved. A slit in the end of the muzzle
indicates the niouth, and served to hold the reins; a small hole pierced through from side to side
forms the eyes. The ears are formed by small triangular lumps of clay. Double glaze bands
down the edges; diagonals on the sides, and bars across the front and mane. The edge of
a spoked-wheel decoration is preserved on the shoulder.
U'
Fig. 42. Grave XII, Fragmeltary 'Ierriacotta from a Pyre: Chariot and Charioteer (XII 24)
Wheel fragments (T 794). Diam. ca. 0.085.m. T., 0.08 m. T. at hub, 0.025 m.
Fragments of a flat circular wheel with pierced cylindrical hub projecting at both sides.
Concentiric glaze lrings on the outer face; the inner face has two lrings around the edge, and
a broad band around the hub, which is banded.
All the fragments are very similar in fabric; clay grey to buff, and dull black glaze. The
horse's head'is on a scale appropriate to the chariot. The wheels are attached separately. The
group should probably be reconstructed like the Vienna group, of which a drawing appears in
Winter, Die Typen der Figiirlichen Terrakotten, I, p. 25, 6; that is, the horses (there was probably
more than one; the Vienna group has four) stood on a flat base, so arranged that a splinter of
wood or wire could pass through it from side to side at the front and another at the back; the
wheels were attached to the ends of these, which served as axles. The chariot could be placed
on the base behind the horses, and probably tied to it with strings passed through the holes at
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
67
the corner. The chariot pole probably tied similarly to a yoke laid across the backs of the
horses' necks, as on the Vienna group. Threads or fine wires were passed through the hands
of the charioteer to the horses' mouths, serving as reins. There were no wheels attached to the
chariot itself; the whole group, like the Vienna terracotta, moved as a unit on its wheeled platform. The various parts were demountable and held togethelr with string (as are those of many
modern Greek conveyances). Our charioteer resembles in his proportions figures painted on late
Geometric and early Protoattic vases-on the lebes in London, and on the Analatos hydria
(Hampe, pls. 22 and 31), and also early bronze and ivory statuettes (Hampe, pl. 31). His short
sleeved tunic, reaching only to the upper legs, and the absence of any weapons or attachment
for weapons (unless they were attached with strings) suggest that he is a chariot racer rather
than a warrior. Perhaps the same distinction can be made among the early Olympia bronze
chariot groups, wlhich arle very like ouI terr]acotta (Olympia, IV, pi. XV, 248, a bareheaded
chariot racei, and 249, a helmeted warrior). An Attic (leometric figurine with a similarly
pinched and notched face, Hesperia, IV, 1935, p. 193, and p. 194, fig. 4 A. A Protoattic chariot
built on the same principle as ours was found in the Agora votive deposit; Hesperia, II, 1933,
1) 619, fig. 85.) On early Greek chariots, see E. von Mercklin, Der Rennwagen in Griechenland.
XII 25.
Chariot Fragments.
Fig. 40
Fig. 73
GRAVEXIII
Inhumation of an adult, disturbed. Height above sea-level, 55.26m. The grave had
been disturbed by the diggers of Pit A. The cover slabs were found piled at the edge of the
pit near the head of the grave. Of the skeleton, only the skull and the bones of the left
arm were found in position; the rest of the bones had been thrown out by the
diggers of the
pit. The skeleton was that of a man; the head lay toward the northeast. At the foot of the
grave, and in a position which must have been below the feet of the body, was found an
5*
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
68
RODNEY S. YOUNG
oinochoe, marked by a ring on the plan. It had been broken into many pieces by the
removal of the covering slabs. Other grave offerings had probably been broken and thrown
out when the grave was disturbed; the amlphora and the kantharos published as Grave XV
may have been among them. The only vase found in the grave dates from the end of the
eighth century.
XlIl 1. Oinochoe. Figs. 43-44. Hesperia, V, 1936, p. 26, figs. 23-24; A.J.A., XXXIX, 1935,
p. 178, fig. 5; A.A., 1935, p. 167, fig. 3; J.H. S., LV, 1935, p. 149, fig. 2; Hampe,
pp. 87--88, and fig. 31
P 4885. H., 0.228m. Max.Diam., 0.154m.
Round-bodied oinochoe with flat bottom, slightly concave neck, trefoil mouth and double
rolled handle. After the vase had been made and painted, but before firing, four roughly
circular holes were cut through its wall: two opposite each other at the sides, and two more
at the front and back, at a lower level. Two carefully made hollow tubes of fine porous clay
were then passed through the body of the vase from front to back and from side to side, and
the edges smoothed. The tube running across from side to side passes about 2 cm. above the
one running from front to back. Both are intact, and neither opens into the body of the vase.
The purpose of these tubes is not clear and no parallel for them exists; although a number of
suggestions has been made, any attempt at explanation remains, in the absence of evidence,
almost pure speculation. It may be noted, however, that the tubes are made of granular porous
clay, rather different from that of the vase itself, and are not covered with slip or glaze. In
consequence, any liquid in the vase would seep through the porous clay of the tubes, but not
through the walls of the oinochoe itself. The conclusion seems safe, that a potter as advanced
in technique as were the makers of the late Geometric vases, must have been fully conscious of
the effect of the porous tubes when he made them, anti that he made them so on purpose. The
oinochoe may thus have been a sort of ritual vase, from which liquid libations trickled out
The decoration of the oinochoe is almost as elaborate as its structure. A band of dots runs
around the lip outside, and a zigzag decorates the base of the neck. In the neck panel a procession of three warriors marches to the right; each wears a long-plumed helmet and a sword
and carries a big hour-glass shaped shield and two spears. Each side of the handle is decorated
with a ladder. On the shoulder, a meander in a zone below the base of the neck; a narrower
zone just below the level of the handle attachment is filled by a zigzag. Bands, and a careless
zigzag, on the lower body. The wide zone around the middle is filled by a figured scene centering on a battle at the back of the oinochoe, under the handle. A chariot drawn by two horses
faces to the right; behind it stand two figures, both sheltering behind the same
great square
shield. The foremost figure is the charioteer; although he wears a plumed helmet, he carries
no weapons. With his right hand he holds the shield, and in his left the reins and
whip. While
the charioteer mounts the car, his companion fights a rearguard action
against two warriors
who attack from behind with sword and spears. Another chariot stands by behind, the charioteer
in the car holding the reins; it is probably the chariot in which one of the warriors on foot
arrived, and from which he dismountedto join in the light. A third chariot, four-wheeledand.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
qlllllle
69
?L?fYiEC*;?)IJBSa)
,4(lr3?;'43'X..8
XII 1
Fig. 43. Grave XIII, Oinochoe (XIII 1)
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
70
RODNEY S. YOUNG
figures are carefully drawn with an attempt at detail not found on the earliest Geometric
representations of men; the eyes are reserved and dotted, and glaze loops are added in front for
nose and chin. For ornament in the field are used zigzag and chevron columns, stars, crosses,
opposed triangles, and lozenges filled with latticing. The clay is Attic with a fine smooth buff
surface; the glaze, thick and black, has peeled in many places.
The round-bodied, flat-bottomed form is the latest development of the Geometric oinochoe
shape. Oinochoai of this form were found in subgeometric and early seventh century contexts
in Graves VI and IX, and in the pyres XI and XII of our grave precinct. Three such oinochoai
were found in Dipylon Grave IX (Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pl. VIII, 2) and one at Anavysos (Praktika, 1911, p. 116, 2). In our seventh century well several more were found: C 113-117. All the
subgeometric examples are miniatures; but they show that the shape continued into the seventh
century. It is perhaps possible to fix an earlier limit to the date of its popularity. Many
oinochoai of this shape are decorated on the sides by large concentric circles, entirely covering
the body from the base of the neck to the bottom. They have been listed and discussed by
Schweitzer (Ath. Mitt., XLIII, 1918, pp. 143 fF.; to his list add two examples from Marathon,
Praktika, 1934, p. 36, fig. 9), who derives the concentric circle decoration flom Cyprus. If, as
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
71.
human figures, as to be quite conceivably by the same hand. Another vase, this time an
amphora, belongs to the group: Wide, fig. 56 (Athens, N.M. Inventory 184). On all three vases
the same figures, the same horses, the same filling ornament; if they are not by the same hand,
they were certainly made in the same workshop, and all within a very short time. By different
lines of evidence we can arrive independently at a late eighth century dating for each vase.
The shape of the oinochoe we have already considered; we have also noticed that an epic scene
is represented in the battle drawn on it-the battle of the Pylians and the Epeians, of the young
Nestor against the Molione. Hampe suggests (pp. 39 ff.) that the earliest epic and mythological
scenes represented on Boeotian fibulae belong in the third quarter of the eighth century. There
is no reason to suppose that such representations began earlier in Attica, while considerations
present themselves which suggest that they probably began later. The same epic-representation
is drawn the embarkation of Helen (Hampe,
argument holds for the bowl in London, on wN-hich
pp. 78 ff.). Another consideration, however, also leads to the dating of the vase at the end of
the eighth century; the development of the shape from that of the British Museum bowl (a photograph showing the whole bowl was published for the first time by Hampe, pl. 22, below) to that
of the Protoattic bowl, Jhb., II, 1887, pl. 4, cannot have covered a long period, and the Protoattic bowl is dateable in the second quarter of the seventh century. A period of half a century
would surely suffice for the further development of the shape to that of the bowl from Aegina
by the Nessos Painter, in the last quarter of the century (Neugebauer, Fihrer, pl. 8). The same
shape is used, then, in late Geometric and in early black figure; certainly a period of eighty to
a hundred years is not too short a time for the development. Finally, the amphora. The
similarity of its shape to our XI 1, from a grave with subgeometric vases and figurines, is to be
noted. But the amphora itself has subgeometric decoration: the band on the neck at the level
of the handle attachments, the band above the figured zone, and the second band below it, are
all filled with "shorthand" checker-board decoration-a method of drawing that we have
noticed in connection with our VI 2, used on subgeometric and not on true Geometric vases, and
a method used very rarely on Early, but almost exclusively on Middle Protocorinthian vases.
All three vases, then, oinochoe, bowl, and amphora, arrive independently at a resting place
in the end of the eighth century. It is interesting to note that our oinochoe, with its epic scene,
and the Dipylon prize oinochoe (Ath. Mitt., VI, 1881, pl. III), bearing the earliest Greek inscription, are of the same shape and date from the same time; a time when writing was still sufficiently
rare to be thought of by epic characters as "baneful signs."
GRAVEXIV
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
72
Fig. 46
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
73
Fig. 46
GRAVE XV
Plan.
Fig. 1.
Grave.
Fig. 47.
Contents.
amphora,
Fig. 48
with a kantharos
tightly
wedged
found in the late filling of Pit A, somewhat to the west of Grave XIII. The relation of the
two vases, the one inside the mouth of the other, where it had
been placed as a lid, makes it certain that the vases came
from a disturbed grave. The elaborate decoration of the
/_''
of
that
the
source
the
vases
was
an
adult
amphora suggests
burial; the amphoras
-'
Fig 47. Grave XV
Neck with Kantharos,Ampllora
as found
in pit A
the disturbance caused by the digging of the pit, in which the amphora neck was ,broken
from its body, the kantharos was not loosened from its position in the mouth of the
amphora.
In shape and style the pottery preserved is quite in keeping with that from the other
graves of the precinct; both vases find parallels in the late eighth century.
XV 1. Amphora Fragment. Fig. 48
P 4886. P. H., 0.217m. Diam. at lip, 0.207m.
Broken off at the shoulder. The neck slightly concave, with flaring lip and band-handlesto
its upper part below the flare. On the outer face of the lip, a linear band of key-pattern; below,
a band of latticed triangles. Across the top and bottom of the neck panels, dotted lozenge
chains. In the neck panels, hatched key pattern, filled by rectangles of checker-board. On the
handles, bars, and panels filled by St. Andrew's crosses superimposed on plain crosses. Attic
clay with fine smooth buff surface; firm, rather shiny, black glaze.
The checker-board pattern on the neck was made by dotting alternate squares of a grill.
The shape is comparableto that of the amphorasillustrated by Wide, fig. 53, decoratedwith neck
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
74
RODNEY S. YOUNG
planels filled by birds with quatrefoils much in the manner of our jug XVIII 1, and fig. 58, which
Wide erroneously says is from the Kerameikos: it is from the same grave at Nca Zcpayeia as the
well-known bronze tripod published by Briuckner in Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 414 and pl. XIV;
cf. Collignon-Couve, Catalogue. No. 179. where the provenience is given as "Abattoirs." From
the same grave are three late bowls like Wide. fig. 96. upper row. (Brickner, in his publication,
gives the numbers of the pots found in this grave: a collation of the numbers of the inventory
in the National Museum with those of the former collection of the Archaeological Society, brought
to light four of the eight pots mentioned by Briickner: their N. M. numbers are 169, 186, and
201-202. The grave is late eighth century.) Nearly the same decoration as on our amphora
appears, less carefully done, on the neck of an amphora from Anavysos (Praktika, 1911, p. 123,
Fig. 48. Grave XV, Amphora Fragment and Kantharos (XV 1-2)
22); the same latticed triangles and hatched key-pattern, and the same dotted lozenge chains and
cross panels on the handles. The decoration of the neck of the Anavysos amphora is, like that
of ours, limited and conservative in the choice of motives used; but the decoration of its body
uses a number of late devices-leaf-bands, and interlocking latticed triangles. A late motive
used on our amphora is the simple linear band of key-pattern on the lip; rare 4nd late in
Geometric decoration, it is popular in subgeometric and orientalizing, and
survives, with the
line-meander, into the black- and red-figured styles. Our amphora fragment, which is similar in
shape though not in decoration to the amphora necks VII 1 and VIII 1, should be dated near the
end of the eighth century.
XV 2. Kantharos.
Fig. 48
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
75
each of the handles. bars. and thriee p)anels filled wvith St. Andrew's crosses bisected by verticals.
A somewhat earlier kantharos from the Dipylon (A.A., 1933, pp. 279-280. fig. 15) has a
slhallow-erbody and more rounded shoulder. and a higiher base: it was found in a grave with
a pyxis with plastic horses on its lid, and probably belongs at the berinnincg of the last quarter
of the eighth century. Our kantharos, with its lower base. deeper and more pointed body, and
flatter shoulder, shows that the development of the shape of the kantharios followed the same
course as did that of the skyphos. The kantharos is very close in fabric to the amphora neck
with which it was found, and may come from the same workshop: the fondness for bands of
latticed triangles, too, is common to both vases.
Plan. Fig. 1.
GRAVEXVI
Contents. Figs. 49-50
Disturbed inhumation. Height above sea-level, 55.56mn. One end of the grave shaft.
0.48 m. in width, was preserved at the northeast edge of Pit A; the rest of the grave had
been destroyed by the diggers of the pit. The shaft had b1een cut with a northeast iland
southwest orientation, interrupting the series of griaves, XNVII-XX, which radiate from the
base of the hill. Presumably the undisturbed end of the grave, in which were found two
pyxides, was the foot.
a"woman.
The offering of pyxides suggests that the grave had been that of
U'
I
I
XVII
;V 2
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
76
The )pyxides found are similar to those from Graves XVII-XVIII, and should be dated
in the late eighth century.
GRAVrEXVII
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
77
the left hand; most of the other vases were piled over the feet and legs of the skeleton at
the lower end of the grave. Four skyphoi were found, stacked one inside the other, under
the large pyxis at the lower left corner of the grave. Some of the pyxides had projected
slightly above the top of the shaft, and had been broken when the cover slabs were put in
place. The amphoriskos and the jug at the other end of the grave lay high up and very
little below the cover; they must have been put in the grave after the body had been
covered by a layer of earth. A large iron fibula and a bronze pin lay on the bottom of the
grave to the right of the skull. Two spiral rings of bronze, a bronze fibula, and four small
iron fibulae were found among the mass of vases over the knees of the skeleton.
A bit of human bone which did not belong to the skeleton of the woman buried in
Grave XVII was found near the amphoriskos and above the skull. The base of a Grey
Minyan goblet was also found in the grave, and a number
of fragments of Grey and Yellow Minyan ware were found
al)ove outside. These stray objects in the earth thrown
into the grave when it was filled suggest that a Middle
Helladic burial had been disturbed by the digging of graves
in the Geometric period.
Selected fragments of Grey
and Yellow Minyan ware from the grave area are published
below, B 22-24. }~~~b~~~elow,B 22-24.
i~Fig.51. Grave XVII. Covering
Grave XVII is the richest found in the Agora precinct.
Slabs; Tholos Floor in BackTwenty-two vases had been offered, together with a number
grouind
of pieces of bronze and iron jewellery.
The vases arc
made
and
and
as
is often the case in graves containing a large
decorated,
not,
handsomely
number of pots, small and careless in their ornament (as in the Isis Grave; C. V.A., Athens,
I, pls. 3-6).
Comparable are the large handsome vases from Grave XIII at the Dipylon
(B.C.H., XIX, 1895, pp. 273 ff.). Three of the pyxides from Grave XVII, like three bowls
from the Dipylon grave, are made on a large scale lwhich must have required considerable
technical skill; graves containing very big vases such as pitchers, bowls and pyxides (not
the kraters and amphoras used as monuments over the graves) must all date from about
the same time, perlhaps over a period of a quarter of a century. We can thus group together
Graves VII and XIII at the Dipylon, our Grave XVII and Graves 1, 3, and 4 at Spata;
some of the Anavysos Graves must have belonged to the same group, which belongs in the
last quarter of the eighth century. It is natural that among a number of vases as large as
that found in Grave XVII there should be great variety of fabric and decoration, as well
as some difference of period. Thus one vase, XVII 8, which shows considerable
wear, may
be somewhat older than the rest; two vases, XVII 7 and XVII 17, are covered with thick
creamy slip; two vases, XVII 13 and XVII 15, may be by the same hand. A kalathos,
XVII 5, may be a Boeotian importation; if it is not, it is certainly influenced by Boeotian
vases of the same shape and decoration. A comparison of XVII 7 and XVII 8 shows how the
same shape may be decorated in either an early or a late manner. The group confirms
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
78
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Wide's feeling (Jhb., XIV, 1899, p. 190) that the great variety of shapes and styles of
decoration found together in the same grave is an indication that the Geometric style
developed rapidly and lasted but a short time.
Fig. 52.
Grave XVII.
Fig. 53.
Grave XVII.
Drawing
by J. Travlos
The jewellery found in the grave suggests, as do the vases, that the woman buried was
a personage of some consequence. Pyxides, of which there were eleven in Grave XVII, and
jewellery, seem to have been considered appropriate offerings at a woman's grave, while
weapons and drinking vessels were offered in a man's. The fibulae belong to a type used
in Boeotia in the late eighth and seventh centuries, and confirm the late eighth century
dating for the grave suggested by the pottery.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
XVII1.
Skyphos.
79
Fig. 54
XVII 2. Skyphos.
Fig. 54
XV113. Skyphos.
Fig. 54
XVII 4. Skyphos.
Fig. 54
XVII 5. Kalathos.
Fig. 54
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
80
RODNEY S. YOUNG
pp. 66-67, fig. 43; A.J.A., XXX1V, 1930, p. 409, fig. 3. An example in the museum at Copenhagen
(C.V.A., Copenhagen, II, pl. 82, 1) is published as Argive. These little vases seem to be of
a shape suited to everyday use, and the holes at the rim (sometimes in the bottom) seem best
explained as intended for a loop of string by which the pot could be hung up; ingenious explanations of the kalathoi as incense burners or pots for cheese-making may then be avoided.
The rim is not suitable for a lid to rest on. Shape and decoration are nearest to the Boeotian
examples. Although the clay and glaze do not seem quite normal for Attic, I have seen four
'I
XV1T
.2'
- X'.
X II 3
"
XVII'l
XVII 2
XV!I 12
XV:1
XI9I 5
XVi'.19
XI'V!
XVII11
1 XV]
XVII
TI
XV
'1 2
XV1 17
XVII 15
XVI! 14
XVII 13
XV1116
XVII 6. Kalathos.
Fig. 54
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
81
XVII 8. Pyxis.
Fig. 54
XVII 9. Pyxis.
Fig. 54
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
82
A plain wavy line is used on the pitcher XIV 1, and on many Phaleron cups like those from our
Graves VII and IX.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
83
alternately with swastikas and single sections of meander. On the bottom, an octofoil at the
centre, the leaves filled with herring-bone pattern. Around the octofoil a wide latticed ring.
The rather high convex lid is decorated with wide and narrow glaze bands, and, near the edge,
two zones filled by round dots linked by tangents, and zigzag. The high stem of the handle,
and the spike, are banded; the knob decorated with zigzags. Dull black to brown glaze.
The three pyxides XVII 14-16 are made on as large a scale as is possible in a thin fabric; they
are the biggest pyxides of which I know. As such they are quite in keeping with the megalomania
of the late eighth century, which made the monumental Dipylon amphoras and kraters, and the
huge one-handled pitchers. Size in itself may not be of great significance; but all the oversized
vases-pitchers and bowls, as in Dipylon Grave XIII (B.C.H., XIX, 1895, pp. 273 ff.) as well as
our pyxides-must have been made at about the same time; that is, when the technical skill of
the potters had reached a point equal to their manufacture, and when popular taste called for
vessels which must, after all, have been somewhat impractical for daily use.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
84
RODNEY S. YOUNG
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
85
type as those on the plate VI S. The many-pointed blob star at the centre is a favorite filling
ornament on such late vases as the cup from Thera, Ath. Mitt., XXVIII, 1903, pl. III, the
Louvre fragment (Pottier, Vases antiques du Louvre, pl. 20), and the amphora from the Kerameikos, Wide, fig. 54.
Fig. 54
Fig. 54
XVII20-21.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
86
RODNEY S. YOUNG
the clay was very porous and friable when damp in the grave, and came off in splinters when
broken, perhaps because of under-firing. The surface is mottled by a black substance, not glaze,
which has adhered to the clay. Hand-made; the two jars are almost exactly alike.
The under-fired or unfired pots placed in Graves VI and X may well have been jars of the
same sort. The mottling on the surface of the clay, which appears in places also on the aryballos XVII 22, may be the effect of some substance like perfume or ointment contained in the
vases when they were placed in the grave. Because the jars found in Grave XVII were offered
without their lids, it is not probable that they contained any liquid substance. A little jar of the
same fabric and shape, but with two handles, was found in Dipylon Grave V (Ath. Mitt., XVIII,
1893, p. 111 and fig. 9). The clay of the Dipylon vase sounds, like ours, under-fired; it is
described as black-perhaps stained through and through by the contents of the pot?
Fig. 54
Fig. 57
XVII 24-25.
Bronze Rings.
Fig. 73
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
87
Fig. 73
B 209. W. of catch, 0.009m. L., 0.02m.
The blade is missing, together with the spring. Convex-concavebow, with a flat square
catch; a fibula of Blinkenberg'sAttico-Boeotiantype.
Fig. 73
IL 167a. L., 0.138m. H., 0.066m.
Most of the blade missing. Large fibula with convex-concavebow, a spring at one end and
a flat square catch at the other. Very much corroded. The measurementswere taken as it lay
in situ in the grave.
A fibula of Blinkenberg'sAttico-Boeotian,and Hampe'sBoeotian, type (Blinkenberg,Fibules
grecques et orientales,pp. 147ff.; Hampe,pp. 1 ff.). Hampehas suggested that fibulaeof this type
were used in Attica in the ninth century, and in Boeotia in the late eighth and seventh. The
suggestion is based on the supposedlyearly contexts of fibulae found in Attica, and the clearly
late contexts of those found in Boeotia. Our fibulahas in Grave XVII a late Attic context. On
this type of fibula, see below, p. 104.
XVII 29-32.
Iron Fibulae.
Fig. 73
IL 167b-e. L., ca. 0.028m.
Muchbroken and corroded;the four fibulaewere found adheringtogether in a mass. All had
the same convex-concavebow, like that of XVII28, and a spring at one end; there seems to have
been a simple catch, instead of a square plate, at the other end.
Plan. Fig. 1.
GRAVEXVIII
Grave. Figs. 58-59, 64.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
88
RODNEY S. YOUNG
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Jug.
89
Fig. 60
-2~'cb^-rr
B BiE
*^B--SSS'^^
-~.
f..
-.,-
"~
.,
.'L,
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
90
XVIII 2. Jug.
Fig. 60
XVII3
XVflm6
Fig. 61. Grave XVIII, Lids and Bottoms of Pyxides XVIII 3 and 6
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
91
Broad low body; a shallow false ring foot continues the line of the side wall, which is only
slightly convex. The diameter is somewhat less at the rim than at the foot. Corresponding
pairs of tieholes through the rim and the lid. Above the foot, bands and a row of dots. The
body is divided into panels by verticals and narrow latticed columns; the panels are filled alternately by checker-board pattern and swastikas. Between the arms of the swastikas, pairs of
dotted rings linked by tangents. On the bottom, at the centre, concentric rings around a cross;
dots between the arms of the cross. A wavy snake-ring, outlined on both sides with dots, surrounds the central decoration; farther out, a ring of dots linked by tangents, another snake-ring,
and glaze bands, with series of short glaze strokes just inside the foot. Dot rosettes fill the
spaces
between the curves of the inner snake ring.
The lid is shaped like an inverted shallow plate, and has a round hole through the middle.
On the flat central part of the lid stand three plastic horses, which served as the handle;
they
are covered with glaze, except for bands and rows of dots linked by tangents on their necks, and
rows of dots between glaze stripes running down their manes, spines and tails. The
exergues
in front and behind the feet of the horses are decorated with swastikas at the
corners, and series
of short glaze strokes at the centre. The sloping.part of the lid is decorated with bands and
rows of dots; two zones at the edge contain series of zigzags separated by stars, and series of
lines separated by St. Andrew's crosses. Attic clay with black to chocolate-brown
glaze.
We have seen (XX 5) this to be the latest pyxis shape. Two pyxides of this type from a
grave
at Spata of the end of the eighth century have horses as lid-handles (Spata, Grave
3; Delt., VI,
1920-21, p. 137, fig. 7). There are a number of pyxides by the same hand as ours; the stereotyped
decoration is so consistently the same that they are unmistakably related. The
body is always
divided into panels filled alternately by swastikas and checker-board pattern, sometimes varied
by a ring of dotted rings linked by tangents. The bottom, which has either a wavy snake-ring
or a multifoil at the centre, has always an outer snake ring, and bands with series of short
glaze
strokes just inside the foot. The lid is invariably bordered at the edge with zones
containing
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
92
RODNEY S. YOUNG
series of zigzags separated by stars, and series of short glaze strokes separated by St. Andrew's
crosses.
The pyxides of this group are: Copenhagen, C.V.A., Denmark 2, pl. 71, 4 a and b; Wiirzburg,
Langlotz, Griechische Vasen in Wiirzburg, pl. V, 54; The Hague, C. V. A., Pays Bas, II, pl. 3, 5 and
6; Kerameikos, 338, Hampe, pl. 33.
I have seen four more, said to be from Spata, in the hands of antiquity-dealers in Athens.
The Kerameikos pyxis was found in a grave together with a little oinochoe which, as Hampe
points out, is directly in the line of development from the latest Geometric to Phaleron ware
(Hampe, p. 38 and fig. 19). The dating of this little oinochoe should then be at about 700; it seems
to be the latest offering in the grave. We can thus confidently date our group of pyxides in the
last quarter of the eighth century.
XVIII 9-10.
Bronze Rings.
Fig. 73
XVIT5
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
93
concave bow, and a square catch-plate. Our fibulae are then examples of Blinkenberg'sAtticoBoeotian type, and similar, in miniature,to XVII28.
A small bronze fibula of the same type was found in fragments with the iron fibulae;it was
too fragile and fragmentaryto be restored.
GRAVE XIX
?:?,??'`'.?;X?.
'F-? 9
r- *
i*c??~
`??.rc;
,. T'dc
--lr
?iI
?.
:
Y
L. .I?I?tr`
,e......
"4
:f
iY
n ,.,,
haE;JC
;
U:J.
"*
-?LI
i,?_
r ...??Y
;t?P
,,
?e
I*??
i 11?
- :
y_5J*"
.i
*?,
*i?Q-`
-c;?
''
fica,
Fig. 64. Graves VI, XVIII, and XIX. Grave XIX in foreground,XVIII above, and VI at left
obliterated. The northwest end, however, was preserved in a cutting in the rock of the
sloping hillside. This cutting, 0.59 m. wide, extended to a total depth of 0.62 m. below the
rock surface. This depth had provided space for two separate burials, one above the other.
The earlier burial, Grave XX, occupied the bottom of the cutting; the later, Grave XIX,
rested on a filling of ash 0.38 m. above it. A thin layer of sand had been sprinkled over
the filling of the earlier burial, to serve as a floor for the later. The skeleton of a man lay
with the head toward the northwest; an iron knife was found lying under the left upper
arm. Other grave offerings may have been removed in Roman times.
Successive burials one above the other are of common occurrence in other Geometric
cemeteries (as at the Kerameikos and Eleusis); but, as far as observed, they have always
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
94
RODNEY S. YOUNG
been fortuitous and haphazard. The second use of this grave cutting in the Agora cemetery
was, on the other hand, clearly no matter of chance; it necessitated the recollection of the
exact position of the grave, and probably considerable effort in the careful removal, and
no doubt replacement, of the stone slabs with which the earlier burial must have been
covered. It may be argued that both burials could have been made at the same time; but
had this been so, we should not have expected to find a layer of ash separating the two
skeletons, or a sprinkling of sand over the ash for the upper body to rest on. In any
event, whether or not the two burials were made at the same time, the double burial suggests
some close relationship between the two occupants, and strengthens our belief that the
grave precinct was a family plot. Grave XX is to be dated in the last quarter of the eighth
century; Grave XIX is somewhat later. The knife found with the skeleton in Grave XIX is
of the same type as the one found in Grave XI; but such knives were probably used over
a long period of time.
Contents. Fig. 67
Inhumation, probably of a woman. Height above sea-level, 55.92m. The skeleton lay
on the same line as that of the man above it, but with the orientation reversed: the head
was at the southeast end of the grave. The grave offerings, with the exception of a pyxis,
had been placed at the lower end of the cutting; the pyxis lay beside the right hand of the
skeleton. The body and the vases had been covered with earth to a depth of 25 cm.; then
a layer of ash and cinders, about 10 cm. thick, had been thrown into the grave. Probably
the whole had been covered with slabs which were later removed to make room for the
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
95
examples of that shape. The pyxis is of the latest pyxis type and finds parallels in a very
late Geometric grave at Spata; its decoration too is often used together with very late
date in the last
Our
eighth
grave must
figured
ZD~~Ib~r
l~J
~CV~LI~~
CC~ quarter
l~~IV ~of the
IV
Vl~rrVlrrJ centulry.
in scenes.
I.
I
^J1
-w- '
:f
/1
XX 1. Skyphos.
Fig. 67
XX 2. Skyphos.
Fig. 67
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
96
RODNEY S. YOUNG
XX 3. Skyphos. Fig. 67
P 4776. H., 0.077 m. Diam. at rim, 0.124 m.
The shape and decoration the same as those of XX 2. Four dot rosettes in the handlezone on one side, five on the other. The glaze black to dark reddish-brown; dark brown
inside.
XX 4. Kantharos. Fig. 67
P 4775. H. to rim, 0.144 m. Max. Diam., 0.195 m.
Low base and deep body with a plain rim. The lower body glazed; bands below the handle
attachments. In the handle-zone, three panels separated by verticals and filled, at the sides by
rX1
i:t
1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Ir
r2 XX
--t
.
XX6
a
tt7,1~~~~~~~~~
?-?I~~~~~~~.
..f.+.
4
?.r
XX3
Ax5
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
97
XX 6. Plate.
XX7.
Fig. 67
Oinochoe. Fig. 67
P 4772. H., 0.225 m. Max. Diam., 0.143 m.
Low base and band-handle. Entirely covered with thick chocolate-brown
glaze except for
a reserved band below the shoulder, and a panel on the front of the neck, which is filled
by a band
of tooth-pattern between horizontal lines above and below. Bars on the handle.
The shape is the same as that of the late round-bodied type (like XIIl
1) except that it is not
truncated at the bottom. It resembles also the taller early Geometric
oinochoai; but here a base
has replaced the usual early ring-foot.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
98
RODNEY S. YOUNG
GRAVEXXI
of the upper right arm, which had been taken off in the digging of
the well. The slabs of the cover were found piled over the foot of
the grave, where one of them had been left in position. Probably
the diggers of the well, after finding the edge of the grave at the
side of their shaft, dug from above and ol)ened the grave, removing
the offerings but respecting the skeleton. The body lay with its head
at the northeast end of the cutting.
'...
Even in the absence of grave offerings there can be little doubt
that the grave belongs to the Geometric period, in view of its situa-
"
.
" .
t
J
.
.
.
e XXI
Fig. 68. Grave XXI.
)rawingby PietdeJoig
GRAVEtXXII
oi'ieilted roughlylr east and w est, was only 0.30 m. wi(le. The grave had lbeen twice disturbed;
of the skeleton only the thigh bones were found. At the east the shaft had been cut through
its lower end by Grave XI; the upper half of the grave had b)een destroyed by Well C. As
the bottom of the grave lay only about 30cm. below- the floor-level of the sixth century
enclosure, the covering slabs must have been removed in the levelling down of the surface
of the terrace. The body had been laid with its head toward the west; the size of the
femurs, the only bones found, suggests that the skeleton was that of a man. No grave
offerings were found in the preserved part of the grave, which had not been disturbed
by the diggers of the well. The ends of two of the cover slabs of Grave XI rested on
the earth in Grave XXII; had the earth bleen removed the cover of Grave XI would hlave
fallen in.
Grave XXII had been disturbed by Grave XI, and was therefore probably considerably
older than Grave XI. Its position at the narrow end of the terrace, close in beside the hill
slope, suggests that it was the first burial made in our family cemetery.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
99
GRAVESXXIII-XXV
Thirty-five metres to the southwest of the grave precinct three more graves were found,
all close together, and cut, like those of the precinct, at the foot of the slope of the Kolonos
Agoraios. They appear on the plan (Hesperia, V, 1936, p. 15, fig. 13) as two small rectangiiles just to the south of the e(lge of the great cultting in the hillside at the south of the
grave precinct. Three burials thus close together must be, like those in the grave precinct,
interrelated, and may belong to the-same family. Like Graves III-XXII they belong to
the end of the Geometric period. Had the grave precinct been a general cemetery instead
of a family pllot, these three contemporary burials would probably have been made in it
instead of at some distance away. The graves are published with those of the precinct
b)ecause they are of the same perio(l, and because they yielded vases of types not found in
the other graves.
GRAVEXXIII
Disturbed cist grave. The rectangular shaft was cut in the rock with a northeast and
southwest orientation; it was 1.62 m. long and 0.52m. wide. The rock cutting was very
shallow, with a d(lelth of only 0.15-0.20 m.; the upper part of the grave must have been cut
in the filling over b)edrock, which had been disturbed over the area around the graves. At
the b)ottom of the cutting there was a layer of small stones which served as a floor for the
bnrial. The disturlbance of the fill above had destroyed the grave and its skeleton; in the
shallow cutting were foulnd a few human teeth and ribs, and one skyphos broken into many
small fragments. The skyphos is Attic in fabric, but (orinthianizing in shaple; it is dateable
in the last quarter of the eighth century.
XXIII 1. Corinthianizing Skyphos. Fig. 69
P 3569. H.. 0.07m. )iam. at rim, 0.106n.
Flat bottom and convex hody with plain rim: rolled horizontal handles, tilted slightly
to below the handle-zone.lwherethere are three bands.
upward, set just below the lip. (;Glazed
IN
I
I
~_
Fig. (i9.
.."I
I~111
a
='s
11 r~311
Cc-C
GIln--
_EO_
Skypllos (XXIII
]I
7f
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
100
Short wavy verticals in the handle-zone; bands on the lip. The inside glazed, with a reserved
band at the lip; the handles glazed. Thin fabric of Attic clay; the dull black glaze is streaky
and, in places, brow-nish.
The shape is imitated from such early Protocorinthian skyphoi with rather shallow open
body and convex side wall as Johansen, pl. IX 1, and pl. X 1. As is usual in Attic imitations
(see below, p. 146), the Protocorinthian ring foot has been replaced by a flat bottom; the Attic
decoration, careless and hasty, contrasts with the overcareful decoration of the Protocorinthian
models. The Protocorinthian vases from which our skyphos is imitated belong in the last
quarter of the eighth century. Another Attic imitation of Protocorinthian vases of this type
was found in a late eighth century grave at Spata (Spata Grave 1; Delt., VI, 1920-21, pp. 132-133,
figs. 2-3). The wavy vertical decoration in the handle-zone of our skyphos is often used for
the filling of decorated zones around the low-er bodies of late Geometric kraters (A.J.A., XIX,
1915), pls. XVII-XXIII). Our skyphos probably belongs near the end of the eighth century.
GRAVE XXIV
Fig. 70.
Graves XXIV-XXV.
Offerings
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
101
were preserved, though much damaged. The skeleton lay on the bedrock, which had been
smoothed for it, with its head toward the south; the arms, lying on the chest, were bent at
the elbow with the hands below the chin. The legs were missing; probably the body had
been buriedwith bent legs and raised knees. The late disturbance which had destroyed the
lower part of the skeleton, and badly damaged the upper part, had removed all traces of
grave offerings. The burial partly overlay Grave XXV, which must then have been earlier.
There seems to be no special relation between the two burials as there was between
Graves XIX and XX; the difference in orientation between Grave XXIV and Grave XXV
suggests that the later grave was placed quite by chance in its position partly over the
earlier.
GRAVEXXV
Contents. Figs. 72. Hesperia, IV, 1935, pp. 364-365, figs. 20-21
The grave of a youth. The shaft was cut in the bedrock to a depth of about 0.30m.;
its upper part, disturbed by Grave XXIV at one side, must have been cut in the fill over
bedrock. The shaft was oriented from northeast to southwest, and measured 2.10m. in
length and 0.68 m. in width. The skeleton lay on its back, the head toward the southwest,
the legs outstretched, and the arms extended along the sides. The length of the skeleton,
the proportions of which suggested that it was that of a youth, from the top of the head
(which was tilted forward) to the ankle was 1.34m.; the youth could not have been very
tall, and had probably not yet attained full growth. The vases offered at the burial lay
at the lower end of the grave: a pitcher which had been laid across the grave below the
feet, with its lid, which probably covered its mouth when it was placed in the grave;
farther down, a jug and a skyphos. These vases were all found in place, but cracked;
a fourth vase, a small hand-made aryballos, lay at one side of the grave near the foot,
broken into two pieces. It is probable that the three decorated vases had been placed whole
in the grave, and that the aryballos had been broken before its pieces were put in. The
aryballos had probably contained oil or perfume, and had been broken at the burial ceremonies; a similar aryballos was found in the hand of the skeleton in Grave XVII. There was
a quantity of black carbonized matter in the filling in the skyphos and the jug;
probably
the remains of food placed with the body in the grave. The types of vases
offered-pitcher,
jug, and skyphos-are the same as those offered in the man's grave XIV, and confirm the
identification of the skeleten as that of a man. In their shapes and decoration the vases
combine a number of late Geometric features; our grave must date from the end of the
eighth century.
XXV 1. Skyphos. Fig. 72
P 3645. H., 0.062m. Diam. at rim, 0.154m.
Low base and shallow convex body with widely flaring lip;
long horizontal rolled handles,
set low. The lower body, and the outer faces of the handles,
glazed; bands below the handle-
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
102
RODNEY S. YOUNG
zone and on the inside and outside of the lip. A latticed lozenge at the centre of the handlezone, front and back, with opposed triangles to each side. The side wall is glazed inside; the
floor is reserved, and filled at the centire by an eight-spoked -wheel suilrrounded by fouirteen
concentric rings. Thin fabric of Attic clay with dull brownish-black glaze.
In shape the skyphos belongs to the class of metallic imitations listed by Kunze, Kretische
Bronzereliefs, p. 76, note 6; such skyphoi have, like ours, decoration on the inside as w\-ell as
on the outside; compare the two from Anavysos, Praktika, 1911, p. 121, 18-19, and from Spata
Grave 3 (Delt., VI, 1920-21, p. 134, fig. 8). The ornament is almost always early orientalizing
or subgeometric. The simple motives used in the handle-zone of our example are usually late;
the latticed lozenge appeairs most often as a filling oirnament under hoirses on late Geometrlic
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
103
The shape, not quite the same as that of XVIII 1 and XVII 18, or of XIV 1, finds a late
Geometric parallel in the big pitcher Wide, fig. 77, which has a plump body and wide, not very
high upper part. The zone of wavy verticals is comparable to the decoration in the handlezone of XXIII 1. It has already been noted that dotted lozenge chains and interlocking latticed
triangles are motives used in late Geometric of the end of the eighth century.
XXV 5.
Jug.
Fig. 72
Fig. 72
Fig. 73
the sporadic
finds in the
grave area, nor did any come from the well deposit. The iron and bronze objects from
the graves are discussed here because they help to throw light on the chronology of the
burials. For the influence of metal work on pottery, see below, p. 223.
The rings of bronze and iron found in Graves IX, XVII, and XVIII, and the bracelet
from the sacrificial pyre Grave XII are all of undistinguished type, and are very poorly
preserved. The spiral rings XVII 24-25 are too small to have been worn on the finger;
they may have been used as ornaments for the hair. Similar spirals, but more elaborately
made and of gold, were found in a grave at Corinth.1 In the same group of graves at
Corinth were found long bronze pins, over half a metre in length. Our pin XVII 26 may
have been of this type; two pins of the same sort, presumably Attic in origin, are in the
Toronto Museum.2 The purpose for which such pins were used is uncertain; as fasteners
for drapery they must have been very clumsy and dangerous.
1 A.J.A., XLII,
1938, p. 152, fig. 5.
2
J.H.S., LI, 1931, p. 166, figs. 2-3.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
104
The iron knives found in Graves XI and XIX are of a type commonly found in the late
Geometric period, and apparently used at least until the end of the seventh century.'
The fibulae are of greater interest. They all belong to Blinkenberg's Attico-Boeotian
type,2 which Hampe3 has called Boeotian. Hampe argues that most of the fibulae
of this type have been found in Boeotia, and that the elaborate incised decoration
of many examples is stylistically similar to the decoration of Boeotian vases of the
late eighth and early seventh century. Examples found in Attic graves are few;
Hampe lists fibulae from the Isis Grave and from Grave a at Eleusis; a silver fibula from
Thorikos, and one in Toronto.4
29-?30
O'
X:VU^26
^
...X:
108
L'
29-50 ^
~ X1
Fig. 73.
?.,_S
vases in Toronto to belong in the ninth century; he is therefore forced reluctantly to the
suggestion that fibulae of the type used in the late Geometric and orientalizing period in
Boeotia had been used in Attica a-century earlier, and then ceased to be made. The Agora
graves XVII-XVIII furnish examples of this type of fibula found in late eighth century
graves in Attica. The Isis Grave and Grave a, moreover, are also late Geometric graves 5
of the end of the eighth century. The vases in the Toronto Museumare published together
One was found in Schiff's Grave at Thera: Thera, II, p. 304, fig. 491 F.
3 Hampe, pp. 1 ff.
Blinkenberg Type VIII; pp. 147 ff.
4
Hampe, p. 5; catalogue nos. 10, 24-27, 148. The silver fibula from Thorikos apparently has no
context.
Other examples, said to be from Attica, are listed; they are scattered through many museums,
and have nothing more than their own internal evidence as to date.
5 On the Isis
Grave, see Appendix II.
2
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
105
with two bronze pins, a bronze fibula, a crystal bead, and a whorl, as the contents of an
Attic grave.1 The whorl is of a type often found in sixth and fifth century deposits, never
in Geometric;2 its presence in the Toronto " grave " group destroys credence in the unity
of the group, so that the vases (early eighth century) cannot be used as evidence for the
date of the fibula.
Thus it appears that fibulae of the sort found in eighth and seventh century graves in
Boeotia are found also in late eighth century Attic graves, and that none can be assigned to
the ninth century. That fibulae of the same sort should have been used at the same time in
Attica and Boeotia is much more probable than that they should have gone out of favor
in Attica nearly a hundred years before they came into favor in Boeotia. Their use in
both districts at the same time suggests that they were made in both districts, and that it
is safer to cling to Blinkenberg's term, Attico-Boeotian, than without reserve to adopt
Hampe's, Boeotian.
It may seem to be an argumzentum in circulo to date our Agora graves by the fibulae
found in them, and at the same time to attempt to date the fibulae by the graves in which
they were found. We do not, however, rely only on the evidence of the fibulae for the
dating of the pottery; many criteria other than the fibulae are used for the dating of the
graves in the late eighth century. Hampe, on the other hand, has produced excellent
evidence for the dating of the fibulae in the same period. Since both graves and fibulae
are contemporary, we cannot be surprised at finding fibulae of this type in our graves. The
misfortune is that of the only other Attic grave groups in which such fibulae have been
found, two should have been for many years dated too early, and the third should be untrustworthy as a group because of an experiment in synthesis on the part of an antiquity dealer.
To Hampe's list of fibulae might be added a silver fibula from Eretria: Ath. Mitt.,
XXXVIII, 1913, p. 295, fig. 4, in addition to those noticed by Kunze, Gott. Gel. Anz., 1937,
pp. 281 ff.
II
SPORADIC FINDS FROM IN AND NEAR THE GRAVE PRECINCT
A number of vases and fragments from various parts of the grave area are
published
in a second catalogue, Group B. It has been thought best to
publish these fragments as
groups according to finding places, rather than to divide them according to shapes.
J.H.S., LI, 1931,pp. 164ff., and pl. VI; the whorl, no 12.
' Seven whorls of this
type have been found in the Agora: two from disturbedareas, the other five
(two found togethel), in four different deposits which were all consistently late sixth and early fifth
century in character,with no Geometricsherds in any. Two more, from the East Cave of the Acropolis, have been publishedby Miss Pease in Hesperia,V, 1936, p. 269, fig. 19, nos. 28-29. No whorls of
this sort have been found in any of the Geometricdeposits at the Agora, the
Kerameikos,or Eleusis.
The Geometrictype of whorl is double-convex;see Hesperia,II, 1933, p.
602, fig. 70, no. 255, and our
C 176-180,fig. 142.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
106
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Although some of them are important in themselves they carry with them no evidence
from their contexts as to their origin or dating. Others, on the other hand, throw interesting sidelights on the history of the grave area. Middle Helladic objects (B 22-25)
suggest by their presence that the site was inhabited, and perhaps used for burials, long
before the Geometric period. They serve also as an example of the finding by chance of
antiquities as early as the eighth century. Fragments found in the trench from which
blocks of the parapet wall had been taken away, among them a number of bits of black
figure (B 34-51), and from the bedding made for the late sixth century reconstruction of
the wall (B 52-58), serve to demonstrate that the terrace had become much dilapidated by
the latter part of the sixth century. Fragments from Layers II (B 59-63) and III (B 85-86)
of the road, and from a mass of earth dumped over the surface of Layer III (B 64-84),
illustrate the gradual accumulation of the road filling and the raising of its level during
the course of time. Large fragments of vases, found near Graves IX (B 6-7) and XX
(B 8) may have belonged to graves disturbed in ancient times; fragments found in Well B
(B 26-29) and Well C (B 30-33) may have come from graves disturbed by the well diggers.
A large number of fragments found scattered through the disturbed filling of Pit A may
also have been thrown out from rifled graves, or have been used and broken in the performance of rites honoring the dead. Most of these fragments are earlier than the middle
of the seventh century, and so fail to bridge the lapse of time between Graves I-II and the
earlier series of burials in the cemetery.
The fragments B 1-5 come from a filling of greenish clay thrown in between Pit A and
Well B (plan, fig. 1), and overlying the fill in which the graves were cut. Fragments of
B 1 and B 2 were scattered through this filling, showing that they were already broken
when it was dumped, at some time after the middle of the seventh century. The five objects
from the greenish clay dump may have come together from quite different original sources.
CATALOGUEOF OBJECTS
B 1. Protoattic Oinochoe. Figs. 74-75
P 4611. H. (as restored),0.32m. Max.Diam. (restored),0.18m.
Restored; preservedare most of the low ring foot, a large section of the front of the body,
and a smaller one at the side, most of the double rolled handle, and a fragment of the neck
with the vertical lines setting off the handle panel and, along its upper edge, the beginning
of the outward flare to the trefoil lip. Above the low ring foot, rays. On the body, two
sphinxes stand facing each other; both have lion's bodies, wings, and women's heads with the
faces drawn in outline. Of the sphinx at the left the back legs are preserved, with the
curving tail hanging down between them; the front legs, and part of the face and wing. The
feathers of the wing are incised and have rounded ends; part of three ranks of feathers is
preserved. A triple band across the neck, in front of the mass of hair that falls down the back
of the neck, indicates a necklace. The artist made and corrected a mistake in the drawing
of the face; a thin line, hardly visible, curves upward and outward from the point where the
neck and jaw-line meet, to the lower lip. This was probablythe original sketch for the outline
of the neck and chin, and the artist, realizing the disproportionof his sketch in time, corrected
it. The other sphinx is similarly drawn, except that the feathers of her wing are drawn in
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
107
outline instead of being incised. She also wears a triple-band necklace; her ear, which is
preserved, is set at the base of the jaw. Incision is sparingly used on the bodies of both
sphinxes for the indication of interior details. The space between the two sphinxes is filled
by a lairge almette coss,seds ith inwaid-tuined palmette filling the upper and lower arieas
enclosed by intertwvined tendrils; another palmette is added at each side of the crossing. The
?'
, Q:
~F?i~1
~ ~a~~~~~~~~
~
~
L~~
t
81
kbs^
body; narrow glaze bands run down the back and side faces of the handle. A small fragment
of the body covered with floral decoration probably belongs at the back below the handle
attachment. Attic clay, with glaze varying from metallic to streaky black, and thin brown.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
108
RODNEY S. YOUNG
The shape, developed from that of the late Geometric oinochoe, is what we should expect
the
middle of the seventh century. An oinochoe in New York (Myres, Handbook of the
by
Cesnola Collection, p. 288, 1702) dating probably from the beginning of the century, has
a straight neck and less pointed body than ours. Although full-sized Protoattic oinochoai of
the same shape as ours have not been found, miniatures from Phaleron (Delt., II, 1916, p. 39,
figs. 37-38) illustrate the tendency toward pointed body and tapering neck. Other Protoattic
examples (Jhb., II, 1887, pp. 45 ff., figs. 3, 5, 6, 8, and 12) show the same tendency, which is
already visible on such subgeometric oinochoai as C 118 (fig. 122 below).
The decoration shows not only an astonishing mastery of drawing, but also a fine sense
for arrangement and restraint in the ornament. The sphinxes fill the body of the pot without
crowding, and the floral ornament between them emphasizes the vertical axis of the vase
without distracting attention from the more important figures. The same arrangement of
l,
:.
t:$
*AL
Fig. 75. Protoattic Oinochoe B 1. Irawing by Piet de Jong
opposed sphinxes with floral ornament between them appears on the shoulder of a Cycladic
orientalizing amphora, and is repeated on the back with horses instead of sphinxes (Delos,
XVII, pls. XII-XIII, Bc 19). The floral ornament of the Cycladic vase is very close to that of
our oinochoe, although the drawing is more coarse. The floral ornament finds
many parallels
in the second quarter and at the middle of the seventh century; comparable is the ornament
on the neck of the oinochoe, Jhb., II, 1887, p. 52, fig. 14, on the cup A.A.,
1934, p. 220, fig. 15,
and on the kantharos C 65 (fig. 113 below). Our oinochoe, however, shows a
regularity and
a discipline. lacking in most Protoattic work, which seems often to take special
pains to
achieve asymmetry. Similar floral ornament appears again on vases with faces drawn in outline
from the Kerameikos; A. A., 1934, pp. 211-214, figs. 9-11, vases of the mid-seventh century.
The sphinxes of our oinochoe, though more finely drawn, are no more advanced in the
technique of drawing than the mourning women of the Kerameikos fragment, fig. 11, and
only slightly more advanced than the figures on the Nessos amphora in New York (J.H.S.,
XXXII, 1912, pls. X-XII; the floral ornament on the back of the same vase, p. 377, fig. 3, is
also illustrated
in Johansen, p. 116, fig. 60). The outline drawing of the human face has been
?~~~~~~~~~
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
109
perfected, and the time has come for further experiment. On the amphora from Kynosarges
(J.H.S., XXII, 1902, pl. III) we have the same fine sharp outline drawing; but now the outlined face is filled with white paint representing flesh-a device still in the experimental stage
in the seventh century, when the white is usually added directly on the clay of the pot, but
used regularly thrloughout the black-figured style, when the white is applied over a glazed
silhouette.
Our oinochoe, made at about the middle of the seventh century, is a link between the
New Yor-k and the Kynosarges amphoras; the former cannot be much more than ten years
earlier, the latter much more than ten years later. Outline drawing is very rare in Protocorinthian; but by comparing the examples that exist with our sphinxes, we may get an outside
check on their dating. Two aryballoi of Johansen's Class B Archaic Style have sphinxes and
a chimaera with their heads drawn in outline (Johansen, pls. XXVI, 5 b, and XXVII, 1 b;
Payne, PV, pl. 20, 1-"second
black-figured style"); these airyballoi date from the second
quarter of the seventh century. The Protocorinthian sphinxes are clearly less advanced than
our Prlotoattic ones; the chimaera, somewhat later, provides a fair parallel, and confirms our
mid-century dating. Many Cycladic and Melian vases have figures w-ith their faces drawn
in outline; the technique was certainly moire at home on the islands than on the mainland,
which they may have influenced. Unfortunately the Delos and Rheneia finds provide no
external evidence for the dating of the Cycladic pottery which will eventually have to be
dated by comparison with the better established Protocorinthian and Protoattic chronology.
Our oinochoe, and fragments of a bowl found in Athens (Ath. Mitt., XX, 1895, pi. III, 2)
demonstrate the skill in drawing attained by the Attic artisans by the middle of the
seventh century.
B"2. Protoattic
Figs. 76-77
Fragment.
P 6469. P.H., 0.159m. P.W., 0.162m.
A fragment from the lower body of a closed pot, probably a hydria. Double rays around
the bottom; the downward-pointed triangles between the bases of the lower series of rays are
filled with white. Above, part of a procession of women to the right. Parts of
three women are preserved; the first and
t
'
third are dressed in long skirts, with an\
overgarment the pointed corners of which
|
hang dowSnfront
in
and behind; their
'
clothes and feet are painted white. The
figure in the middle w-ears a skirt drawn in
YS
outline and filled with dots. In the field
between the figures, bands of zigzags, florlal
volutes, and vertical guilloche bands. Attic
clay, covered with thick creamy slip, which
l
has p)eeled badly, carrying with it much of
the black glaze and vwhite paint.
The
restoration in the drawing, fig. 76, is certain.
Comp)are the garment with that worn by
the figure at the left on the Kynosarges
amphora, J.H.S., XXII, 1902, pl. III, which is
B2
somewhat later. The lavish use of w-hite is
still comparatively rare before the middle of the seventh century, although on the Kynosalrges amphora, a few yearls later than 630,
Fig. 76. lProtoattic Fragment B 2. Drawring by
blotll \hite and red are use(d in quantity.
iet de
de Jolg
Piet
Jonig
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
110
RODNEY S. YOUNG
A hydria neck at the Agora, found in a deposit of the first and second quarters of the century,
is decorated with a procession of women wearing white skirts (unpublished; inventory P 10229);
they are somewhat more primitive in their drawing than the ladies on our fragment.
The floral volutes are comparable to those on a cup from a Phaleron grave of the second
quarter of the seventh century (Grave 48, Delt., II, 1916, p. 43, fig. 45, 1). Our fragment must
belong at about the same time, when experimentation- with white iwas going on, and while the old
subgeometric decoration (as on the skirt of the middle woman) still continued in use. A Protoattic fragment of about the same time -was found on the Acropolis (Graef-Langlotz, 364, p)l. 13;
the fragment ibid., 411 a, is published as Protocorinthian; but clay and glaze, no less than style,
indicate that it is Protoattic of the same stage of development).
B 3.
B 4.
Fig. 77
a band
of zigzag,
consists
of
B3
eel
cred
soldrth
abndoB5
opo
B 5. Whorl Fragment.
Fig. 77
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
111
Fig. 78. Fragmentary Amphora and Basin (B (i-7) from near Grave IX
of the band-handles. The foot glazed; two fairly wide glaze bands around the body. Attic
clay, with dull brown glaze.
Probably somewhat earlier than the amphoras from Graves VII and VIII; the foot is
straight, and the glaze bands are wide and few in number.
B 7. Basin Fragment.
Fig. 78
B 8. Krater Fragment.
Fig. 79
I.*
-- - -
. . ---.e . ..
B8
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
112
RODNEY S. YOUNG
single-arched handles joined to the rim by vertical bands, as A.J.A., XXXIV, 1930, pp. 411-413,
figs. 5-7.
The following fragments, B 9-20, were found mostly in the mixed late fill in the bottom
of Pit A:
B 9.
B 10.
Fig. 80
B 12.
Fig. 80
Fig. 80
Fig. 80
Fig. 80
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
*infli
113
?'~
?i
.2
B20
~'~
..
..
..-4
B^^ES^
_--
89
B 15
^~<^^?
r.
i!*''
'
13'
..1
8 13
B18
/_,
Fig. 80. Geometric and Protoattic Fragments fiom the Grave Precinct (B 9-16, 18-20)
Fig. 80
B 15.
Fig. 80
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
114
B 16.
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Geometric Bowl Fragment.
Fig. 80
Fig. 81
Fig. 80
B 20.
Fig. 80
P 6580.
Two fragments from the wall of a closed pot, probably an oinochoe. Red glaze outside, and
decoration in added white; horizontal lines, with vertical bands of running dog between them.
Compare the decoration of the Protoattic oinochoe C 123 (fig. 127).
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
B 21.
B27'
a many-pointed
an intricate
meander.
Below, a dotted
'
M.
'
.
,'
'
.:
star
115
'
'i
.".
5,
j
^
-X
<
^ -~
.
.^-
lozenge chain, with verticals extending upward and downward from the
apices of the lozenges. Farther down,
part of another zone filled by a
Fig. 82. Geometric Amphora Fragment (B 21)
meander. Pink to greyish clay, with
a fine smooth grey-buff surface, and
dull black glaze, badly peeled. The amphora, with its band of mourners, must have been
a funerary vase like the amphora XII 1 and the hydria XI 7. A fragment in the Louvre has
very similar decoration: the same nude mourners, pinheaded like those of our fragment (Pottier,
Vases antiques du Louvre, pl. 20, A 541). The decoration of our fragment includes most of the
motives that have been pointed out as late, and serves in a way to summarize late ornament:
vertical blobs surrounded by dots, many-pointed blob stars, intricate meander, latticed triangles,
and dotted lozenge chain. End of the eighth century.
PREHISTORIC:B 22-25
Human bones and a large fragment of a Grey Minyan goblet were found in Grave XVII,
suggesting that a Middle Helladic burial had been disturbed. Scattered through the early
fill in the northern part of the grave precinct were found a number of fragments of Grey
and Yellow Minyan ware, and a few small bits of obsidian. Three fragments preserve
recognizable profiles; the rest were either of the same shape, or simply wall fragments.
The large fragment B 22 was found in Grave XVII. If these sherds come from a disturbed
Middle Helladic burial, then the burial must have been disturbed in late Geometric times,
as no traces were found in the vicinity of the grave area of Late IHelladic or Proto-
geometric occupation. A number of Minyan sherds were found, moreover, in a shaft burial
farther to the north.' It is interesting to find here evidence for the fortuitous bringing to
light of antiquities in Geometric times, an occurrence probably by no means rare. Chance
finds of Grey Minyan goblets may well have given rise to the Boeotian kantharos shape;
Hesperia, V, 1936, pp. 20-21.
8*
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
116
RODNEY S. YOUNG
compare the Minyan goblets from Korakou with Boeotian bird kantharoi, possibly modified
adaptations of the same shape.'
B 22.
Fig. 83
B 25.
B 24.
B 25.
Fig. 83
Fig. 83
Fig. 83
823
Fig. 83. Grey. and Yellow Minyan
Fragments; Obsidian Blade (B 22-25)
A few fragments of Geometric and Protoattic were found in the Turkish fill of Well B.
They undoubtedly came originally from the grave precinct; fragments from the body of
a banded amphora may be from the body of the amphora from Grave VIII. The pyxis and
pyxis lids B 26-28 are probably from a grave, perhaps Grave XVI or XXI. From the well
B 26-29.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
117
tooth pattern; above, a zone filled with wavy diagonals. Below the rim, a zigzag with bands
above and below. In the wide zone around the body, a meander. The glaze black to light brown.
In shape, glaze, and decoration very much like XVI 2.
B 28.
Fig. 84
ff830
~
33
31
~~~52
'?f-P
~~~I
- HB 9
c#?
is
~B26
Fig. 84. Geometric and Protoattic Fragments from Wells B and C (B 26-33)
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
118
Well C, which had disturbed Graves XXI and XXII, was dug in the sixth century;
fairly late black-figured sherds were found in its filling. As might be expected, a number
of Geometric and Protoattic sherds, undoubtedly from the grave area, were found among
the sixth century pottery of the well. From Well C, B 30-33.
B 30. Pyxis Lid Handle.
Fig. 84
Broken off at the base. A ribbedstem and roundedknob surmountedby a flat knob; a blunt
spike at the top. The stem glazed, and the upper parts banded.
B 51.
Fig. 84
P 6585. P. H., 0.023m. Diam. at rim (est.), 0.095m.
Convex lid with down-turnededge; the handle missing. Bands around the rim and the base
of the handle; a zone of leaves around the middle. Attic clay with dull black glaze, much peeled.
Protoattic Lid.
The trench along the north side of the road from which the blocks of the reconstructed
precinct wall had been taken contained, from somewhat east of Well D to its corner,
a rather mixed red fill. Partly of sand and partly of red earth and small stones, the filling
seemed to be a mixture of the packing of earth and stones thrown onto the Geometric wall
as a bedding for the sixth century reconstruction, and of sand and gravel from Layer I of
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
119
the road fill (section, fig. 2). The sherds were very mixed, seventh and sixth century
together, and running to nearly the end of the sixth century (B 39). There was nothing
later in the fill than B 39; the sherds from the undisturbed bedding below, where it was
preserved, were earlier. The filling in the trench above the Geometric wall, where undisturbed, proves that the precinct wall, and probably the precinct, were in a state of
dilapidation by the mid-sixth century. From the fill in the wall trench, B 34-51.
Fig. 85
B 35-41.
Black-Figured Fragments.
Fig. 86
r:
seventh
century;
B 41, East
Greek, part of
s39
i?~~~~~~~~~~~-
liI
B42
U
'
~~~838L
.i;'B40 -_-_
B43
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
120
B 42.
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Oinochoe Fragment.
Fig. 86
B 44.
B 45.
Fig. 86
Protoattic Bowl.
Fig. 87
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
121
figures. Incision is used for the hand of the leading figure. Attic clay with creamy slip; black
to brownish glaze.
The drawing is very crude; the liberal use of added purple, however, suggests that the
fragment is not very early. The hair and necklace of the leading lady are reminiscent of those
of the sphinxes on the oinochoe B 1 (figs. 74-75), although very poorly done by comparison. Of
greater interest is the dress of the second wvoman; other examples of dresses with diagonally
divided bodice or skirt are not unknown in the mid-seventh century. The divinity represented
on the terracotta plaque from the Agora votive deposit (Fesperia, II, 1933, p. 604, no. 277 and
figs. 72-73) iwears a bodice of this sort; a woman on a fragment from the Acropolis is dressed in
a similarly divided skirt (Acropolis 411 a: Graef-Langlotz, pl. 13).
B44*.
B46
?'B48
B
47
B50
B51
Fig. 87. 'Protoattic Slerds, Terracotta Lamp, and Loom Weight (B 44-51)
B 47.
Graffito Sherd.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
122
RODNEY S. YOUNG
The inscription was written boustrophedon (fig. 144). The letters of the upper line do not
make sense as they are preserved; they may be part of a proper name. The word in the second
line is clearly a feminine name: MEAANOI;, Dark-flower. On early inscriptions on pottery, see
below, p. 225.
B 48.
Loom Weight.
Fig. 87
B 49.
B 50.
B51.
Fig. 87
Lamp Fragment.
Fig. 87
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
123
Under the sixth century fill in the wall trench there was a filling about 30 cm. thick of
red earth with many small stones. This earth rested on top of the Geometric precinct wall,
and was probably thrown there in the late sixth century as a bedding for the limestone
parapet built at that time along the west side of the road. The fill was not distinctly
marked off from the road filling of Layer II, which was of red gravel also containing small
stones, but fewer and more scattered. The sherds from the bedding over the Geometric
wall were subgeometric and seventh century; they may have come originally from the grave
area. The completeness of several of the vases suggests that they did. From this filling
B 52-58.
B52.
Subgeometric Skyphos.
Fig. 88
55_"
'B
54
5 52
356
B58
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
124
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Thera, Ath. Mitt., XXVIII, 1903, Beilage XI, 7; " Ionian Ware," E. Gjerstad, The Swedish Cyprus
Expedition, II, pl. XV, fourth row from the bottom, fourth and fifth from the left. The skyphoi
from Cyprus were found in Tomb 9 at Amathus (P. 55 ff., nos. 76 and 122) together with a number
of scarabs of the XXVIth dynasty and Saite period; they can hardly be earlier than the first
quarter of the seventh century. That they may be Attic exports is not unlikely; birds like the
ones on no. 122 appear also on our krater fragment from the seventh century well, C 106; the
same type of bird is common on subgeometric Boeotian vases (Hampe, pl. 21, V 30). The finding
of such subgeometric cups in a dateable context in Cyprus gives proof of the continuation of Geometric shapes and decoration well into the seventh century.
B 53.
Subgeometric Skyphos.
Fig. 88
Fig. 88
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
125
. *
\
%
q?
jI
I
I
-9
-"~~~
F-__~~m-ummummi
B r-5
-ft
ft
---.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
126
RODNEY S. YOUNG
sharply offset; it has a ring foot instead of the usual late Geometric low base. Much closer in
shape is another skyphos, whose owner must remain anonymous, from the seventh century well:
C 39. Both of the Agora skyphoi have the same form of body, and both the same straight offset
lip. The decoration of the cup from the well is probahly to be dated near the middle of the
seventh century. Tharios' cup has no decoration beyond a reserved band in the handle-zone:
but such bands are characteristic of Attic subgeometric skyphoi of the first half of the seventh
century and later. The simple narrow reserve(l handle-zone, characteristic of subgeometric vases.
is Inot used on Geometric; the only example of which I know is our XVII 4, where the reserved
band is very much wider than that of the seventh century skyphoi. Tharios' cup should probably
be (lated with the skyphos from the mell, C 39, at about the middle of the seventh century. or
perhaps in the third quarter. The dull quality of the glaze where it is preserved shows that the
fine shiny black glaze that makes its appearance in the second half of the centlury was not yet in
use, so our skyphos probably should not be brought down too near the end of the century. All
of the fragments found with it in the fillinfr of red earth and small stones are. moreover, dateable
in the seventh century rather than in the eighth. For a (liscussion of early inscriptions on
pottery, see p. 22;5.
B 58.
Sherd.
Fig. 88.
Hesperia,
II, 1933, p. 576, no. 1:37, and fig. 34, and p. 575,
fig. 33
P 641
A new fragment joining one already published gives most of the other half of the octopus.
The publisher remarks of her fragment "light on dark style. probably to be dated in the last half
of the seventh century."
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
127
Layer II of the roa(l produced plentiful late geometric and( Protoattic sherds, mixe(I
with some black glaze and early black figure. A few sherds are publishe(d because they
are of intrinsic interest. The bulk of the pottery was late seventh and early sixth century.
)From Layer II, B 59-65.
B 59.
B 60.
Fig. 91
somewhat peeled.
I'art of a late (eometric
&
B62
863
Kantharos
Fragment.
B 67
Fig. 91
B59
In.
0.13 In.
__
885
. . "
-__._
Fig. 91
Fig. 91
the bottom of a late seventh century lekanis or bowl. of the sort found at Vourva. and more
recently at Vari.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
128
B 63.
Lamp Fragment.
Fig. 91
Important as giving a terminus ante quemnfor the accumulation of Layer III of the road
filling beside the grave precinct was a fill of brown earth dumped on the surface of the road
between Layer II and Layer III (section, fig. 2). This earth filling was perhaps brought
from elsewhere, possibly from near the shrine from which the Agora votive deposit was
thrown out (Hesperia, II, 1933, pp. 542 ff.). A number of fragments from the grave area,
one of which was from the brown earth layer (B 71), joined with fragments from the votive
deposit. The dump over Layer III of the road contained many fragments of late Geometric
and Protoattic pottery, some of which mended up into nearly complete vases. The Protoattic fragments belong in the first half of the seventh century; a few (B 64, 68-69, 71) must
belong at about the middle of the century. From this fill B 64-84.
B 64.
Protoattic Stamnos.
Figs. 92-93.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
LATE
GEOMETRIC
GRAVES
AND A SEVENTH
CENTURY
WELL,
ETC.
129
her piglets-a species of animal used on only one other early vase in Attica, the amphora from
Pikrodaphne (B.C.H., XVII, 1893, pls. II-III). The two earliest Attic stamnoi of this shape,
then, hardly go back into he eith h centu; the shape must have been impoited from outside at
a relatively late date. The form of the body of such stamnoi is like that of dee) (Geometiric
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
130
RODNEY S. YOUNG
rolled handle and applied it especially to this shape; tNwoBoeotian stamnoi of the type are
illustrated, pl. 21, by Hampe, who lists a number of vases of this shape, calling them, apparlently
indiscriminately, pyxis, stamnos, or situla. Attica probably got the shape from Boeotia in the
early seventh century; the Bonn stamnos published by Greifenhagen, with its misshapen bird and
latticed triangle decoration, is probably Boeotian and not Protoattic (compare the Boeotian
oinochoe decoration, Hampe, pl. 21, V 37), and should date from the second quarter of the seventh
century. Our Attic stamnos should date at about the middle of the century; the shape was
especially popular in the second half of the seventh, and lasted into the early sixth centlury
(compare the Attic "stamniskos"
Delos, XVII, pl. LIII, 39, with bird
decoration like that of the little
vases from our Grave I). Dr. Kurt
Gebauer has kindly shown me picturles of magnificently decorated
.
:
Protoattic stamnoi of this shape, from
\
Aegina, and dating after the middle
of the seventh century. A fragment
of a stamnos of this shape, with subgeometric decoration, was found in
_
fx
the deposit in our seventh centur
well: C 112 below.
Closest of the Protoattic group
'
in shape and decoration to our vase
is the stamnos in Cambridge, C.V.A.,
I, III H, pl. II, 7. Our example probably had a high ring foot like that
of the Boeotian vase in Copenhagen
,sie
(C.V. A., Denmark, II, pl. 67, 5) instead of a high perforated base. The
Cambridge stamnos is more elaborate
in its decoriation than ours, and pers.
haps a little earlier; both have as
filling ornament the same beaked
reverse spirals. The vase in Cambridge is very close in its drawing
:
and ornament to the Nessos amphora
B4
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
131
also had a sense of humor is shown on the stamnos by the entertaining caricatuling of the ducks
in the filling ornament and in the floral decoration under the handles.
Fig. 94
B 66.
Fig. 94. Geometric and Protoattic Fraglnents (1B65--67, 72, 74-79, 81-84)
The wild goats with their outlined faces and long horns seem clearly to be influenced by the
goats of Camiran ware (Rumpf, Jhb., XLVIII, 1933, pp. 69 ff.), iwhich was especially fond of
decoration with guilloche and zones of goats. Our fragment is decorated on a small scale which
does not allow of elaborate detail in the drawing; the filling olrnament seems to be normal
Protoattic.
Sil)geometric
Krater Fragment.
Fig. 94
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
132
RODNEY S. YOUNG
very close in fabric and decoration to those -with hounds, B 16 and C 99; all may come from the
same workshop, and all date at the very end of the eighth centuir! and beginning of the seventll.
B 67.
B 69.
Fig. 94
Fig. 95
Fig. 96
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
B 70.
133
Fig. 97
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
134
oinochoe, belongs probably in the second quarter of the century. The lions resemlble very nuch
those on the krater from Thebes (Jhb., XXII, 1907, pl. 1); they have the same curling claws, the
same stippled snouts, and the same arched eyebrows curved back at the ends. Our oinochoe and
the krater have in common even the zone of
hooked rays above the foot. The charioteers
of the krater have faces well-drawn in
',
outline, but not quite as advanced as those
of our sphinx oinochoe; the vase belongs
to the same style as does the Nessos
_
amphora in New York, at about the middle
of the second quarter of the century. Our
oinochoe should be dated at about the
same time; the oinochoe from the Agora,
Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 596, fig. 61, the Burgon
I
]ebes (Pfuhl, MuZ, pl. 17, 82), and the
oinochoe Pfuhl, pl. 17, 83 are slightly later
and belong at about the middle of the
71
7
century.
B 73.
B 74.
Oinochoe. Fig. 98
P 6497. H., 0.153 m. Diam. at lip, 0.068 m.
The band handle is missing; gaps in the body restored. Low base and deep abody
iaitli
straight neck flaring to a round mouth. Glazed, w ith two reserved bands, to the level of the
handle attachment. On the shoulder, downward pointed rays. Buff clay with grits; dull brownish
glaze, somewhat peeled.
Possibly not Attic; a fragmentary oinochoe of the third quarter of the seventh century has
much the same shape and decorative scheme: Hesperia, VII, 1938, p. 418, and fig. 2, D 20.
Fig. 94
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
135
Fig. 94
B 76.
B 78.
Fig. 94
Fig. 94
Cup Fragment.
Fig. 94
Fig. 94
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
136
B 80.
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Protoattic Lid Fragment.
Fig. 99
F 9o P c
dg'
B80
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
B 81.
B 82.
137
lid are drawn in silhouette; the period of experiment has passed, and the black-figured horse type
has been evolved. In its manner of drawing and choice of filling ornament, the lid from the
Kerameikos belongs in the orbit of the Kynosarges amphora (J. H.S., XXII, 1902, pp. 29 ff. and
pls. II-IV) in the decade after the middle of the seventh century-about 640. Our lid, on the
other hand, belongs in the circle of the Nessos amphora in New York (J.H.S., XXXII, 1912,
pp. 370 ff. and pls. X-XII), perhaps twenty years earlier. The same outlined faces for the horses,
growing all from one neck, appear on both vases, and the same incised flame manes. The same
floral ornament is used, and the same filling ornament, thinner on the lid than on the amphora.
Somewhat earlier is a fragment from Phaleron, on which appears another chariot scene (Eph. Arch.,
1911, p. 249, fig. 11); the Phaleron fragment uses the same outlining for the drawing of faces,
though somewhat more hasty and careless, the same convention for the representation of horses
one behind the other, and a looped-arc mane decoration that is equivalent in drawing of the
incised manes of our horses. The sharp-pointed beard jutting outward from the chin, which is
characteristic of men of the earlier seventh century, first appears on such vases of the first
quarter as the Phaleron fragment and an amphora in New York (Metropolitan Museum Bulletin,
1923, p. 176, fig. 1), and is used on almost every male figure down to the time of the Kynosarges
amphora. The New York amphora is drawn in a style very similar to that of the Phaleron
fragment, but more carefully and somewhat more conservatively, so that it gives an impression
of being older. A bird of a peculiar sort is drawn on its neck; the same bird appears on a middle
Protocorinthian aryballos of the first quarter of the seventh century (Johansen, pl. XXII, 2 a-d).
Our lid shows the combination of conservatism in drawing with innovation of invention that is
characteristic of many Protoattic vases; it took nearly half a century to outgrow the Geometric
manner in drawing figures, while at the same time elaborate floral and other designs were introduced and the power of invention given free rein. A Cretan urn (Annuario, 10-12, 1927-29, p. 135,
fig. 122) from Arkades demonstrates the free play of the imagination in the orientalizing period:
it has a band of hooks, like those around the handle of our lid, but the hooks end in little
feline heads instead of flowers.
Fig. 94
Fig. 94
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
138
RODNEY S. YOUNG
wavy lines run down the edges and middle of the handle. On incised householdware, see below,
p. 199 and C 156-165;the fabric was common in the seventh century.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
139
III
THE SEVENTH CEINT'URYWEILL
The well lies on top of Kolonos Agoraios near its eastern edge, about eighty metres to
the south of the east end of the Hephaisteion. The round well-shaft, of which the diameter
is about 1.90 m., went to a depth of 16.95 m. below the surface of the rock. It was straight
and well cut; in the first four metres below the mouth the diggers ran into difficulties
because of the soft crumbling nature of the rock. Below, the shaft was cut in good firm
rock; the great diameter of the cutting probably made the work of well-digging easier than
it would have been in a narrower shaft. Geometric wells in the Agora, while they also
are often well cut, are usually narrow in diameter, and rather shallow. The Kolonos well
is by far the deepest of the early wells; it may have been cut at a place where the water
did not penetrate easily through the rock, for even at the depth of nearly seventeen metres
the well gathered water to a depth of only half a metre in its bottom.
The filling of the well, uniform throughout its depth, was of green broken hardpan
mixed with brown earth. The sherds found scattered through this filling indicated that it
had been thrown in all at once, since fragments of the same vases were often found at
widely different levels. Much Protocorinthian, Protoattic, Geometric and subgeometric
pottery was found. The fragments of Protocorinthian were mostly in the upper half of the
well, though some came from near the bottom. A very great number of fragments of twohandled cups, coarsely made and unglazed, were found at all depths; the Geometric sherds
appeared in as great numbers near the top as at the bottom. The well, in short, was not
stratified, and had been filled at one time.
The nature of the filling, which was mostly of broken hardpan, suggested that the
earth from operations in which the hilltop was levelled or otherwise cut was used to fill
the well. Unfortunately, a Roman villa and a late drain at each side of the well had
destroyed any signs of the surface activities of earlier times. The pottery found in the
well-filling was all of the first half of the seventh century, with little that goes back into
the eighth, and none that goes below the middle of the seventh. The vases may be from
graves destroyed in the levelling of the hilltop, or from a nearby shrine. The former
supposition seems unlikely because graves would have been respected, at least for a time.
If there had been any great time lapse between the digging of the graves and their destruction, a few sherds later than those from the graves, as well as bones from the graves
themselves, would have found their way into the well filling. The great number of
fragments of coarsely made unglazed cups, of which there must have been at least ninety,
suggests, on the other hand, that our well filling may be part of a deposit of offerings from
a shrine. Such a deposit was found in the Agora and has been published.1 The character
i Hesperia, II, 1933, pp. 542 ff.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
140
of the pottery from our well is the same as that from the votive deposit; figurines, however,
show that it had accumulated over a period of about fifty years. A few earlier fragments
were naturally found among the seventh century pottery, as early fragments are found
scattered through every deposit; thus our well contained a small piece of Grey Minyan,
about twenty bits of Protogeometric, and an unusual early Geometric fragment. The vases
and sherds selected for publication represent the most complete vases as well as the most
interesting; a few small bits are included because they represent a type of vase or decoration characteristic of the period, but not otherwise found in the deposit. Of many of the
vase types published a large number of additional fragments are stored without publication;
thus there are fragments of several rayed Protocorinthian skyphoi and Attic imitations of
them; of banded plates with conventional Protocorinthian ornament (verticals and vertical
zigzags) in the handle-zone; of subgeometric skyphoi and one-handled cups, and of seventh
century oil amphoras. A large number of whorls and of disks cut from vase fragments are
not published.
The vases and sherds published form, then, a representative collection from the deposit
in the well. Of these, about ten per cent are Protocorinthian. All of the Protocorinthian
vases and fragments belong to the second (" subgeometric") Protocorinthian style, dated
in the first half of the seventh century.2 It might be assumed from these alone that the
Attic vases from the same deposit date from the same time. The assumption is confirmed
by the Attic vases themselves, many of which are direct imitations of Protocorinthian of
the same style and period.
1 It is not impossible that the villa above the mouth of the well
may have been a sanctuary. It had
been built at least as early as Hellenistic times, and
subsequently rebuilt at least twice. In two of the
cisterns connected with it were found a krater of the Hellenistic
period, which had been dedicated to
Dionysos and Artemis, and a faience amulet of Anubis together with a Hadra vase (Hesperia, VI, 1937,
pp. 374 ff. and figs. 39-41).
2 The chronology for Protocorinthian followed is that
given by Payne in his Protokorinthische
Vasenmalerei, p. 20; the linear subgeometric vases are contemporary with the first and second blackfigured styles. Payne's dating is somewhat later than Johansen's; the first Protocorinthian style covers
the second half, instead of the first three quarters of the eighth
century, and the second style is moved
down into the first half of the seventh century. The difference in
dating is the result of a more conservative estimate of the antiquity of Cumae as a Greek colony (about 750; for a discussion of dates in
early Greek history, see the article by A. R. Burn, J.H.S., LV, 1935, p. 130; also the article by A. W.
Byvanck, Mnemosyne, 3rd Series, IV, 1936-37, pp. 181 ff. He suggests, p. 201, that Payne's dating of the
first Protocorinthian style in the second half of the eighth century is somewhat too
early. Whether or
not ByvAnck's chronology is correct, his suggestion that allowance must be made for a
lapse of time
between the foundation date of a colony and its first graves, is
sensible). If the earliest orientalizing
vases of Crete are to be dated in the middle of the eighth century, as
suggested by Payne (B.S.A.,
XXIX, 1927-28, p. 230), and if Corinth derived its repertory of orientalizing motives from Crete (Payne,
Necrocorinthia, p. 4; Johansen, pp. 58 ff.), then it seems clear that the earliest Protocorinthian vases
cannot go back beyond the middle of the eighth century, and Payne's modification of Johansen's
chronology must be accepted.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
141
The dating for the deposit, 700-650, suggested by the Protocorinthian vases and the
Protoattic imitations, is confirmed by the finding of Protoattic pottery of the same sort as
that in the well together with middle Protocorinthian in the Agora votive deposit and in
the Phaleron cemetery. Thus in three different kinds of deposit: in a votive dump from
a shrine, in a well deposit, and in a group of graves, the contemporaneity of Protoattic and
middle Protocorinthian is demonstrated. Confirmation of the dating of the Protoattic is
given by the finding-places of coarse Attic oil amphoras: Gela and Daphne, both founded
in the first half of the seventh century. Thus many of the amphoras which are of the same
type as those found in the late-founded colonies, and which were used for child-burials in
the Phaleron cemetery, must belong in the seventh century. Fragments of a number of
these amphoras were found in the well and in the Agora votive deposit.
A large number of subgeometric vases and sherds was found in the well. These were
The subgeometric style, which is the discontemporary with the earlier Protoattic.
integration of the Geometric, must have continued well into the first quarter of the seventh
century; certain motives were used, in combination with orientalizing decoration, well past
the middle of the century. Subgeometric pottery was found together with Protoattic not
only in the filling of the Kolonos well, but also in the Agora votive deposit. Boeotian subgeometric has been dated by Hampe in the early seventh century.l Strong confirmation
for the suggestion that subgeometric vases free of orientalizing decoration were made in
the first quarter of the seventh century, and perhaps later, is given by the finding of three
imported skyphoi, two with late bird decoration, in a tomb in Cyprus which also contained
a number of scarabs of the Saite period.2
A number of subgeometric vases and fragments from the well are nearly identical in
shape, fabric, and decoration with vases from some of the burials in the grave precinct.
Since the dating for these vases can be approximately fixed not only by their style but by
their context, the graves with similar vases can be dated at the same time. We may thus
safely date Graves V and VI in the first quarter of the seventh century, Graves III and IV
perhaps somewhat later, and Graves VII--XII in the years around 700.
CATALOGUEOF OBJECTS FROM THE WELL
PROTOCORINTHIAN:
C 1-18
Protocorinthian sherds were scattered through the well deposit at all depths and in
relatively large numbers. in addition to the skyphoi published, fragments of a number of
others with rays above the foot were found; the skyphos was the shape most commonly
represented. The Protocorinthian pottery is quite consistent in style and period, belonging
to Johansen's Middle Protocorinthian (" subgeometric") group, and covering the first half
1 Hampe,pp. 20 ff.
Amathus,Tomb 9. E. Gjerstad,The Swedish Cyprus Expedition, II, Stockholm, 1935, pp. 55 ff.,
nos. 19, 76, and 122, and pl. XV.
2
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
142
RODNEY S. YOUNG
of the seventh century with very little (possibly C 1 and C 6-7) that can be carried back
into the eighth. Nothing was found, on the other hand, of the Late Protocorinthian or
Transitional style belonging in the second half of the century. Our Protocorinthian vases,
then, dated 700-650, furnish the key to the dating of the Attic pottery found with them.
The large number of Attic imitations of Middle Protocorinthian (C 19-34), moreover, gives
further assurance that the Attic and Protocorinthian vases are closely contemporary.
Fig. 100
,
.. ; .1
U',
,1
Fig. 100
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
143
Fig. 100
Fig. 100
Fig. 100
C 6. Protocorinthian Kotyle.
Fig. 102
Fig. 100
C 8. Protocorinthian Skyphos.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
144
RODNEY S. YOUNG
C 9. Protocorinthian Skyphos.
Fig. 101
27
-1;
C9
C10
C8
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
145
A
ETC.
A SEVENTH CENTURY WELL,I~~~~~~~14
AND
GRAVES
GEOMETRIC
LATE GEOMETRICLATE
C 15. Protocorinthian Skyphos. Fig. 102
P 7459. Diam. of foot, 0.038m.
Only the lower body and ring foot are preserved. Glazed, with two reselrvedbands; the
decorationof the handle-zonewas probablylike that of C 8-12. Firm red glaze.
C 14.
012
C11
C13
C15
C14
C6
"begins before the middle of the seventh century and lasts at least until the end."
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
146
C 17.
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Protocorinthian Skyphos Fragment.
Fig. 100
Fig. 100
PROTOATTIC
SKYPHOI
OF PROTOCORINTHIAN
SHAPE: C 19-34
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
147
top, of the later skyphos. Ours is a fairly close imitation of the subgeometric type; another similar
Attic imitation was found with an early Protoattic amphora in a grave at Eleusis which surely
belongs in the first quarter of the seventh century (Eph. Arch., 1898, p. 91; the amphora, pl. IllI, 2).
C 20.
Fig. 103
Skyphos.
P 7152. H., 0.131 m. Diam. at rim, 0.14 m.
Both handles and parts of the body restored. Low ring foot; the lower part of the body
solidly glazed. Two glaze bands on the outer face of the handle, as far as preserved; three
reserved bands inside the rim. Attic clay; glaze black to brownish, and dull black inside, where
it is somewhat peeled.
The skyphoi C 20-22 are deeper and narrower at the top than C 19, and therefore somewhat
later; in shape they resemble the rayed Protocorinthian skyphoi C 9-10.
Corinthianizing
C 19
C27
C24
Fig. 103
Fig. 103
Fig. 101
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
148
C 24.
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Corinthianizing Skyphos.
Fig. 103
C 25.
Corinthianizing Skyphos.
Fig. 101
C 26.
C 27.
C 28.
One handle and body fragments restored. Low flat base. Careless decoration. with very
much exaggerated rays. Attic clay; dull black glaze. streaky inside.
Corinthianizing Skyphos.
Fig. 101
Corinthianizing Skyphos.
Fig. 103
Corinthianizing Skyphos.
Fig. 109
Fig. 100
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
14!)
C 30.
pl. IX. I and X, 1, and should belong at the end of the eighth century.
C 31.
C 32.
C 33.
Corinthianizing Sklphos.
1936, l). 1208 andl fig. 8
dog between
'--
leeled.
llllllf!_
C8
C3
Corinthianizing Skyphos.
Fig. 105
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
150
RODNEY
S. YOUJNG
One handle and part of the body restored. Flat bottoin. The lower body glazed; below the
handle-zone three careless glaze lines. In the handle-zone, a wavy line barbed at one end, perhaps meant to represent a snake. Thin streaky brownish glaze.
A later skyphos of the same shape and with the same decoration, but with a large flaring
base, was found in a grave of the second half of the seventh centiury at Phaleron (Grave 59;
Delt., II, 1916, p. 32, fig. 23, 2). Our skyphos
is shallow and open by comparison with the
subgeometric
Protocorinthian
type;
it
pro-
E~--L
C 34.
C 55.
C 36.
C 37.
shape,
Payne,
Corinthianizing
Skyphos.
C35
c32
NC,
'
\
C33
C36
C3
Skyphos.
Fig. 105
Fig. 105
Fig. 106
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
C 38.
Fig. 106
C 39.
Protoattic Skyphos.
1937, p. 370, fig. 34
151
Fig. 107.
C52
C 43
C38
A.J.A.,
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
152
RODNEY S. YOUNG
on the band above, on the triangles inside the bases of the hooked rays of the second series,
and on the bellies of the fishes. Three purple bands inside. Well levigated buff Attic clay
with a creamy slip; glaze red to brownish outside, red inside.
The inscription on the rim gave the name of the owner of the cup; since the letters are
painted on with glaze, the cup must have been made to order. The use of the Attic lambda
shows that, in spite of strong Protocorinthian influence on the technique (the slip was probably
used to give the appearance of Corinthian clay) and on the decoration, the vase was made in
Attica by an Attic potter. The fineness of the letter forms is of course partly due to the skill in
drawing of the practiced hand of the potter. On inscribed pots see below, p. 225. The shape is
the same as that of C 58 and the late Geometric skyphos from Eleusis cited in connection with it;
also of the inscribed cup B 55, but somewhat more developed. The hooked rays and liberal use
of added purple (white is used in late Geometric times) are among the late features of this vase.
The fish appears very late and rarely in Attic Geometric; it is more common in Protocorinthian
(cf. Johansen, pi. IV, 3 and IX, 3; Payne, PV, pl. VI, 3-4-all early), but apparently not iused in
Corinthian. Our skyphos is closest in feeling to the vases of Johansen's second archaic group,
of the second quarter of the seventh century. Its decoration suggests almost that the fishes are,
as far as possible, put into their ow-n element-the hooked rays below suggest a wave pattern, and
the long horizontal zigzags used as filling ornament carry out the illusion of water. A similar
tentative feeling after landscape is given by the presence of bushes in the hare-hunt zone of the
Protocorinthian Chigi vase (Payne, PV, pls. 27 and 28, 3).
Fig. 108
metallic
in origin.
Clay
cups
of
1903, p.
182 and
pl.
IIl),
_
4
I
C49
C50
C4
,
who remarks on the metallic character of.
Fig. 108. Skyphoi (C 40, 45-47), One-handled Cups
the shape. Later (MuZ, p. 1) he suggests
48 50) ad Kalthos ( 84)
that the shape is derived, not from a metallic prototype, but from vases of the type
Wide, fig. 96, upper left. Kunze follows him in this later interpretation, and gives the latest
list of the skyphoi comprising the group (Kretische Bronzereliefs, p. 76 and note 6; to his list
add the skyphos at Wflrzburg, Griechische Vasen in Wiirzburg, 58, pl. 4 and 5; Langlotz calls
this skyphos, which is very close to ours, "Phalerongattung"; add also five examples in the
Empedocles Collection at Athens). The vase from which the type is supposed to develop is very
different in shape and proportions, and only very slightly, if any, earlier than the earliest
examples of the "metallic" type. Pfuhl's first theory seems clearly to be the correct one. The
group now comprises, as far as I am aware, twenty-five pieces, all but two of which (from Thera)
were found, as far as is known, in Attica. No doubt has ever been cast on their Attic origin.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
153
If, then, the type is Attic and derived from metal prototypes, and the shape is unfamiliar to
other Geometric fabrics, it is not too much to assume that the metal prototypes -were also Attic.
Our skyphos is a late member of a late gl'oup; its zigzag decoration in the handle-zone, very
carelessly and unevenly drawn, and its lack of a foot, are thoroughly in keeping with the same
characteristics apparent in other subgeometric vases of the early seventh century.
C 41.
Fig. 109
,,< Cr,
C3
C 30
^
c42
c59
C57
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
154
RODNEY S. YOUNG
on the Phaleron fragments, Eph. Arch., 1911, p. 250, fig. 14, and Delt., II, 1916, p. 39, fig. 37 (from
Grave 19, a grave of the first quarter of the century), and the oinochoe Jhb., II, 1887, p. 45,
fig. 3; in the Cyclades, Delos, XVII, pls. XXVI-XXVII; and at Corinth, Johansen, pl. V, 6 b.
Fig. 106
C 44.
Subgeometric Skyphos.
Fig. 106
C 45.
Subgeometric Skyphos.
Fig. 108
Fig. 108
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
155
Fig. 108
C 49.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
156
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Similar to C 48; perhaps a trifle deeper and more pointed.
Beschrijving, pl. IX, 58.
C 51.
C 52.
C 54.
C 55.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
157
and another band below the rim. Dull black glaze, much peeled; three reserved bands inside
the rim.
A small cup of nearly the same shape was found in Dipylon Grave IX; it was not included in
the drawing published (Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 117 and pi. VIII, 2).
C 53
C 70
C 74
C 72
Fig. 111.
C 71
C 76
C 75
C 57.
C56
C 54
Phlaleron (C 53-56)
0 55
C 73
C69
9 -7(;)
Fig. 109
C 58.
Fig. 109
P. H., 0.043m.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
158
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Bands on the rim and lower body; a quadruple zigzag band in the handle-zone. A reserved
band filled with short verticals inside the rim. Pink clay with buff surface; red glaze. Carelessly
made on the wheel.
The fabric and decoration recall those of the small vases from Graves XI and XII.
Fig. 112. Trefoil Cup (C 60) and Snbgeomctric and Protoattic Kantharoi (C 63-64, 66-67)
zone a procession of birds, with a swastika between each pair. Series of short verticals outside
the lip, and a reserved band inside it. Slightly metallic black glaze.
Other trefoil cups: Wide, fig. 95 and, at Eleusis, Eph. Arch., 1898, pl. IV, 9. Our example,
with its birds carefully drawn in silhouette and compairable to those of the pitcher lid from
Dipylon Grave XIII (Hampe, pl. 32, N. M. 771), must belong in the late eighth century, and be
one of the earliest vases in the well deposit.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
159
From the upper body and rim. Shallow convex shoulder and straight rim, banded. Vertical
wavy lines (probably sigmas) in the handle-zone. Attic clay, black to reddish glaze, somewhat
peeled; a reserved band inside the rim.
Uncertain whether it is from a skyphos, a cup, or a small krater; but it is probably too big
to be from a cup. The rim as on C 38 and C 52.
C 62.
C 63.
Geometric Fragment.
Fig. 109
Subgeometric Kantharos.
Fig. 112
Fig. 112
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
160
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Fig. 113. A.J.A., XL, 1936, p. 194, fig. 9; A.A., 1936, p. 118,
fig. 8; J.H.S., XLVI, 1936, p. 137, fig. 1; Hesperia, VI, 1937, p. 370, fig. 33
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Orientalizing Kantharos.
161
Fig. 112
C 67.
Protoattic Kantharos.
Fig. 112
Fig. 109
UNGLAZED
CUPS: C 69-76
Fragments of small two-handled cups, roughly made on the wheel and unglazed, were
found in the well in great numbers, scattered throughout its depth. In addition to those
published, the bases of eighty more were counted; with other fragments from rims and
handles, there were probably at least a hundred altogether. A cup of this type was found
in the Agora deposit dated after the middle of the seventh century: Hesperia, VII, 1938,
p. 415 and fig. 8, D 10. Such cups are too small to have been of any use in daily life.
They are perhaps votive cups of a crude miniature type often offered at sanctuaries, and
usually found in great numbers; compare a late fourth century votive deposit of miniature
unglazed vases, Hesperia, VI, 1937, pp. 207 ff. All our cups are of pink Attic clay with
rough spirals left on their bottoms by their careless removal from the wheel. There are
small variations of shape; flat-bottomed cups may be distinguished from those with low
bases and those with ring foot; hut otherwise little can be learned from a group of vases
so small and so roughly made.
if
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
162
C 69.
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Two-handled Cup. Fig. 111
P 7196. H., 0.08m. Diam. at rim, 0.095 m.
Parts of the body, and one handle, restored. High flaring ring foot and deep pointed body
with slightly flaring rim.
The shape is rare; probably derived from Protogeometric goblets, which sometimes have two
vertical handles; the conical foot has become truncated. A black-glazed example was found in an
early Geometric child's grave in the Agora (Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 553, fig. 11, 2), and another in
an unpublished well, together with simple Geometric pottery of the first half of the eighth century;
three more, unglazed, came from another Agora well of about the same period. The shape, then,
though rare, seems to have been made continuously throughout the Geometric period. The present
example belongs to the early type, but with rather deeper and more pointed body; the other
examples from the deposit (C 70-76) dispense with the foot and have deep narrow bodies, following the development noted also in other shapes. The original type, however, that of C 69, seems
to have continued to be made contemporaneously with the later cups of the shape developed
from it.
C 70-71.
P 6998, P 7186. H., 0.045 m. and 0.052 m. Diam. at rim, 0.062 m. and 0.067 m.
One handle of C 71 restored. Both have a low flat base and slightly flaring lip, and are
similar in shape to C 69 except at the bottom.
C 72-73.
C 77.
P 7068, P 7067. H., 0.04 m. and 0.044 m. Diam. at rim, 0.059 m. and 0.056 m.
Both handles of C 73 restored. Similar in shape, but deeper and wider in the lower body;
flat bottomed. C 73 has been burned and the clay is grey.
C 74-75.
C 76.
P 7066, P 7167. H., 0.049 m. and 0.06 m. Diam. at rim, 0.06 m. and 0.08 m.
One handle of C 75 restored. Similar in shape to C 72-73, but with high, nearly vertical,
rims. C 75 rather shallow and open in the body.
Fig. 115
P 8366. P. H., 0.088m. Diam. at rim (est.), 0.30m.
Two fragments of the rim, one with one of the rolled handles, from a large plate, fairly deep
and with convex side walls. Around the body, a zone of leaves filled with diagonals; in the
handle-zone, dots linked by tangents. Two reserved bands inside, and series of short glaze
strokes on the upper face of the rim. Black to red glaze, somewhat metallic.
A plate of the same shape and with nearly the same decoration was found in a grave at
Spata together with subgeometric vases of the very early seventh century (Spata Grave IT;
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
163
Delt., VI, 1920-21, p. 134, fig. 4); the plate in the Spata grave appears to be the earliest vase in
the grave group. Both are slightly shallower than our XX 6, and have flatter side walls. Compare the degenerated leaf pattern on the plates from our Grave VI and from Eleusis, Eph. Arch.,
1912, p. 33, fig. 14, both of the first quarter of the seventh century. Our plate, and that from the
Spata grave, must belong near the end of the eighth.
C 79.
Fig. 115
Subgeometric Plate.
...
C81
:1
C82
.
C 81.
Subgeometric Plate.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
164
RODNEY S. YOUNG
9I"
CL
q .90
C94
31
.
Ci1l
I
C89
C88
Fig. 115.
Fragments
Fig. 116.
Lids (C 93-95)
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
165
short vertical zigzags at the centre. Series of short glaze strokes on the upper face of the rim,
and a reserved band half-way down the body inside. Black to red glaze.
Again shallower and less convex than C 79-80, and somewhat later. The bands around the
body are no longer of the fairly wide Geometric bands, but the careless Attic lines used in imitation of the Protocorinthian. The decoration of the handle-zone, too, is the conventional Protocorinthian handle-zone ornament. Fragments of similar plates, with wavy lines in the handlezone, were found in the seventh century Agora votive deposit (Hesperia, II, 1933, pp. 585-586,
figs. 46-47, 185; note especially the profile, fig. 46). A similar plate was found in Dipylon
Grave VIII, which should probably be dated late in the first quarter of the seventh century (Ath.
Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pl. VIII, 1, 3). Plates of this type continued to be made after the middle of
the seventh century; one was found in our Agora group of the third quarter of the century;
Hesperia, VII, 1938, p. 415 and fig. 2, D 12.
C 82.
C 83.
Subgeometric Plate.
C 85.
Fig. 108
Subgeometric Bowl.
Fig. 117
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
166
RODNEY S. YOUNG
The shape is very like that of such late Geometric plates as C 77, but shallower than XX 6;
the glaze is very similar in quality to that of the grave pitcher XIV 1. Probably late eighth
century; spouts appear on such late Geometric bowls as Wide, fig. 92.
C 86.
C 87.
Protoattic Bowl.
Fig. 117
Protoattic Bowl.
Figs. 117-118.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
167
about the end of the eifrhth century; drawing in outline, more popular and probably earlier in the
Cyclades, may have been borrowed by Attica from the islands. The technique, at best rare in
Protocolinthian, appears there in the second black-figured style near the middle of the seventh
century; sec the remarks of Johansen on outline drawing, pp. 112 ff. (the early Protocorinthian
aryballoi, Johansen, pi. V, correspond in drawing rather with the late Geometric Attic pbhaseusing
reserved dots for eyes, outlined skirts filled with dots as on the Analatos hydria, and outlined
fishes, than with the true realistic outlining used in the Cyclades and applied to human and
animal heads; Corinth preferred incision). Our bowl finds another parallel on an oinochoe of near
C 88.
Figs. 115-116
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
1,68
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Figs. 115-116
C 90.
Figs. 115--116
C 92.
Figs. 115-116
LIDS: C 93-95
C 95. Protoattic Lid Fragment. Figs. 115-116
P 8370. P. H., 0.078m. Diam. of rim (est.), 0.26m.
Plain rim, slightly thickened, and somewhat convex wall. Outside, at the edge, rays with
dots between their ends, and, above, bands interruptedby a zone of running dog. Dull black
glaze, badly peeled.
An Agora fragmentwith the same decoration,Hesperia,II, 1933,p. 588, fig. 50, 198.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
169
Figs. 115-116
Figs. 115-116
BOWLS:C 96-101
TWO-HANIDLED
Fig. 117
C 98.
Fig. 117
Fig. 119
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
170
RODNEY S. YOUNG
The bowl probably had rolled handles like those of C 97. On the shoulder below the spout,
multiple vertical bands; in the handle-zone
beside them, part of a hound running to
the left, probably one of a succession. Zigzags for filling ornament. Dull black glaze,
somewhat peeled.
The bowl when complete was of much
.i
41111!
C103
it is dateableat the very end of the eighth century or the beginning of the seventh. The oinochoe
in Copenhagen (C. V. A., II, pl. 73, 4 a-b) with a hare-hunt on its shoulder is of about the same
time. The deep cup Copenhagen, C.V. A., II, pl. 73, 1 and the fragment Graef-Langlotz, pl. IX, 284,
are Protoattic. Compare also B 16 above (fig. 80). The amphora in Wiirzburg (Langlotz 79, pl. 7)
is probably Attic; it has a number of orientalizing motives (winged horses, plant ornament, and
a reverse spiral), and must belong in the first quarter of the seventh century. Shape and decoration suggest for our fragments with coursing hounds (C 30, and C 99, C 143; B 16) a dating around
700 B.C. or slightly later. In the first quarter of the seventh century a hound is used as a shield
device on the Hymettos amphora; Jhb., II, 1887, pl. 5.
C 100.
Fig. 120
fig. 92. Bands around the bottom; above, a row of reserved rays
below a band of upright rays alternating with them. The centre
of the floor of the bowl is preserved, covered with glaze. Attic
clay, black glaze.
The flaring type of base is probably metallic in origin, and
borrowed by Attica from elsewhere. The Attic potters made the
bases of their kraters nearly vertical, and only very slightly flaring
at the bottom (as in Collignon-Couve, 214, pl. XII); they did not
indulge in the impractical flaring bases of Corinthian (A. J. A.,
XXXIV, 1930, p. 412, fig. 6) and of Boeotian (Hampe, pi. 19, V 38)
metal and often ribbed in their upper part, invariably were snapped
foot by the weight of the vases they were intended to support. The
[a __.
Co
100
Fig. 120. Protoattic Base
(C 100)
vases which, imitated from
off around the edges of the
bowl Wide, fig. 92, with its
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
171
very flaring base and band handles with out-turned ends is clearly an imitation of a metal vase.
The base C 100 may be borrowed from Boeotian or Cycladic; the alternating reversed and upright
rays are a common Cycladic decoration (cf. Delos, XV, pls. XVIII-XIX and XXXIV-XXXV).
C 101.
Fig. 121
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
172
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Multiple horizontal bands above dotted rings linked by tangents; above, panels. One is divided
horizontally into three by triple bands; the next is filled by an octofoil. Glazed inside; black to
brownish glaze, somewhat metallic. The same chaotic panel decoration as on C 104.
C 108.
Fig: 121
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
173
skyphos, Eph. Arch., 1898, pl. 5; the little stylized figures in violent motion are characteristic of
the very end of the eighth century, and the beginning of the seventh.
C 110.
Dipylon
Krater Fragment.
Fig. 121
c noC7l0
C 112
co09
C1r0
C 171
Fig. 121. Geoinetric and Sibgeometric Krater Fragminents(C 101, 105-111), Bowl Fragment (C 99)
and Stamnos Fragment (C 112)
The krater in the Metropolitan Museum, A.J.A., XIX, 1915, pls. XVIII and XX, also fills the
coiner of its handle panel with a bird. Our bird is like those on the late Geometric pitcher, Wide,
fig. 72. Late eighth century.
C 111.
Subgeometric
Krater Fragment:
Handle.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
174
RODNEY S. YOUNG
character; the Corinthian krater A.J.A., XXXIV, 1930, p. 411, fig. 5, shows decided metallic influence in its flaring foot and flat band handles, projected for some little distance beyond the join
along the edge of the rim, the flat form of which is also metallic. Bronze kraters may well have
had flat lug handles projecting from the rim and supported below by metal struts; these were
adapted rather than copied by the potters for their vases. Our handle would then be a copy and
not an adaptation; it is certainly the earliest fragment of a column krater known, antedating
by more than half a century the earliest Corinthian example. The centaur is a gentleman of the
same sort as the centaur on the late eighth century amphora in Copenhagen (C.V.A., II, pl. 73, 3;
Johansen, p. 146, fig. 110); he is, however, somewhat more substantial in his proportions. The
filling and rounding out of the bodies of humans as well as animals progressed in the early
seventh century, until, by its middle, some of the figures were almost chubby. Our centaur, with
his more natural proportions and incised eye, should date from the first quarter of the seventh
century.
Fig. 125
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
175
IS
C 116.
Fig. 125
Fig. 122
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
176
RODNEY S. YOUNG
C 118.
Subgeometric Oinochoe.
"ll!
- -IMMOURP
Figs. 125-126
C 120.
'I~~-vC
*
--- C116
C"12z4
C 125
C
I1220
P 7178.
0.131 m.
C
^^
'
,13
|`r~~~~~~~~~I
isCL
m3 I
Fig. 122
P.H., 0.167m.
Max. Diam.,
Fig. 125.
Oinochoe
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
177
The handle and mouth, and most of the neck, missing; the
body restored. Low flat base and deep convex body; narrow neck.
Glaze bands above the base and near the upper edge of the
shoulder; between them, widely spaced vertical bands. The neck
glazed. Pink clay; dull black glaze.
The shape is similar to that of C 118. The decoration with
widely spaced vertical bands is a variation on the similar decoration with vertical lines between the bands, as on XI 5 and C 103
above; both decorations are probably derived from Mycenaean.
Fig. 126. Oinochoe C 119.
A small vertically banded Mycenaean oinochoe from Nauplia (FurtDrawing of Neck Panel by
Piet de Jong
wangler and Loeschcke, Mykenische Vasen, pl. XV, 102) is strikingly like ours. The revival of this Mycenaean mode of decoration
is another link in the chain connecting the Mycenaean and Orientalizing periods; Johansen and
Bohlau (Jhb., II, 1887, pp. 33 ff.) both derive the vast majority of the orientalizing devices and
ornaments of Protocorinthian and Protoattic decoration from Mycenaean. A similarly banded
oinochoe, but of another shape, and decorated with an amphora on the front, was found in the
Agora in the 1937 campaign in a deposit of the third quarter of the seventh century (A.J. A., XLI,
1937, p. 179, fig. 3; Hesperia, VII, 1938, p. 417, fig. 5, D 17). An oinochoe of late Geometric shape
at The Hague (C. V. A., Pays-Bas, I, II f., pi. 1, 5) uses approximately the same decoration, but
alternate straight and wavy vertical bands; from the description of its fabric it does not sound
Attic. Compare also the zones with widely spaced verticals around the bodies of Cycladic
oinochoai: Delos, XV, pl. XXXVII, 14-15 and 29.
C 122.
Subgeometric
C 125.
c 123
Fig. 127. Protoattic
Oinochoe (C 123)
12
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
178
RODNEY S. YOUNG
has light-on-dark decoration (Hesperia, II, 1933, pp. 594-595. figs. 59-60; the oinochoe fig. 59 has
been restored about three centimetres too high. The correct shape is best seen in the Protoattic
oinochoe, ibid., p. 597, fig. 61). The type was popular in the seventh century; another was found
in a context of the third quarter of the century (A.J.A., XLI, 1937, p. 179, fig. 3). Our oinochoe
and the light-on-dark oinochoe from the votive deposit, fig. 59, with their rather plump bodies
and fairly wide necking, are probably slightly earlier than the oinochoe fig. 60, which has floral
decoration of about the middle of the seventh century, and is transitional to the example of the
third quarter with its shallow mouth and sharp narrow necking. For the decoration with white,
compare the fragments B 19, fig. 80.
C 124.
Fig. 125
C 125.
Subgeometric Oinochoe.
Fig. 125
Fig. 133
AMPHORAS: C 127-147
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
concave
neck
(Petrie,
179
.
/
Another,
'
from Phaleron Grave 33, which contained early Corinthian
;
of
vases
the last quarter of the seventh century, is not
illustrated; but a note is made of the fait that it has no
neck-ring. The amphora from our Grave I belongs to
this type; it dates from the very end of the seventh
century and shows in its flaring foot and definitely concave neck the further logical development of the shape.
That the type continued to be made into the sixth
century is suggested by the shape and decoration of the
amphora carried by Dionysos on the Francois vase
c127
(Furtwtngler and Reichhold, Griechische Vasenmalerei, I,
pls. I-II); the body has by now become rather slim and
Fig. 128. Protoattic Amphora (C 127)
pointed, and the foot very flaring. Although a great
number of these amphoras were found in the Phaleron cemetery, only the four discussed above
are illustrated in the publications; the rounded and the echinus rim seem to be used equally,
but the echinus rim is never exaggerated to the proportions attained by Pfuhl's Ionic or Euboean
examples. The graffiti often found on amphoras of this type (at Thera, Gela, and Phaleron;
several in the Louvre from Etruria) must then fall in the seventh century. The example from our
well deposit is one of the earlier members of the series.
Fig. 129
Fig. 129
Fig. 129
C 151.
Amphora Fragment.
Fig. 129
C
35
c129
32
C133
C131
C130
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
180
Fig. 129
Fig. 129
C 154.
Fig. 130
I
I
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
181
ornament is the same. The decoration of the body of the Leyden amphora, which must be at
least from the same workshop as our fragment, shows many late features: two zonies of latticed
triangles; a meander band with nearly vertical hatching, as on C 78 and C 103, instead of diagonal
hatching; and a chariot procession with the horses drawn so nearly like those of our oinochoe
XIII1 that the decoration of both pots may quite conceivably be by the same hand. The popularity
of the dotted lozenge chain s a decorative band on late Geometric pottery is forcibly demonstrated on the Leyden amphora, which has no less than nine bands so decorated. A fragment
of a krater in the Louvre (Pottier, Vases antiques, I, A 519, pl. 20) has similar decoration of
dotted lozenge chains, toothed -wheels, and the same filling ornament; it is probably early sev-enth
century, and has figured bands with one, and possibly two, mythological scenes represented in
them: the battle of Herakles with the Molione in the lower zone (Hampe, p. 48), and perhaps the
slaying of the suitors in the upper. The Leyden amphora and the Agora fragment, slightly earlier
than the Louvre fragment, should belong at about the end of the eighth century. Another
amphora of the same time and with the same shape and decorative scheme for the neck, but
with figurle decoration more like that of the fragment in the Louvre was found in Eleusis;
a picture of it is published by Wide, fig. 57.
C 155.
Geometric
Amphora Fragment.
Fig. 129
P 8383.
Neck fragment from a very big vase with straight neck divided into panels. Part of two
panels preserved; in each, concentric circles, compass-diawn, and filled at the centre by a wavy
vertical; another wavy vertical to each side, and dot rings around the circles. Attic clay with
badly peeled black glaze.
C 136.
Geometric
Amphora Fragment.
A.J.A.,
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
182
RODNEY S. YOUNG
left, not quite touching the ends of the upper two horizontals; possibly meant to be an epsilon.
Attic clay, with glaze shading from black to brown and red, and peeled in places.
The shape of the amphora must have been much like that of the grave amphoras VII 1 and
VYll 1, and of the amphora Wide, fig. 53, which has somewhat similar neck decoration of birds
facing across a panel filled by a quatrefoil, and a banded body. The same bird-and-wheel combination is used on a cup from a late grave with subgeometric pottery in Tiryns (Grave 37;
Tiryns, I, pl. XVIII, 17; from the same grave, ibid., 1, with decoration like that of our XI 5.
and 13, with columns of dashes as on our C 122). The birds are like Boeotian birds of the latest
Geometric phase at the end of the eighth century and beginning of the seventh (Hampe, V 11
and V27; p. 25, fig. 7, and pl. 21). The bird and wheel decoration is itself not uncommon on
Boeotian kantharoi; compare the birds (eating a snake) and wheels on the Boston kantharos
which falls into Hampe's subgeometric group (Boston 285; Fairbanks, Catalogue, pl. XXV;
Hampe's V43). The Tiryns amphora from another grave with subgeometric vases has the same
wheel ornament on the neck; its glazed body, slightly more slim than that of our amphora, ends
in a very heavy flaring foot like the feet of the balloon-bodied Attic oil amphoras (Grave 38;
Tiryns, I, pl. XVII, 1; from the same grave, the oinochoe pl. XIV, 2; the coarse pitcher with
sharply flaring rim and the bowl pl. XV, 8 and 7; and the subgeometric cups and kantharos
pl. XVIII, 3, 8 and 10). The four-spoked wheel is used at Thera on an amphora that has
already an orientalizing band of wave-pattern; Dragendorff remarks that it represents the wagonwheel of the period (Thera, II, p. 136, figs. 316-317, and p. 161). In Attica it is used, together
with the more usual kind of four-spoked wheel, for chariots on late Geometric vases, as on the
krater in New York, A.J.A., XIX, 1915, pl. XX, and on the amphora Wide, fig. 56. As an independent decorative ornament it appears on such late cups of metallic shape as Atlh. Mitt.,
XXVIII, 1903, pl. I (see above, C 40, for a discussion of cups of this shape). The same type of
wheel is used, interestingly enough, as a device on early Athenian coins; Seitman suggests that
it may represent the badge of the Alkmaeonid house, famous for its love of chariot racing (Seltman,
Athens, Its History and Coinage, pp. 34 if., and pl. II, A 23-A 28). The variations in the type of
wheel used on the necks of amphoras, as on early coins, may have significance; though the wheel
may be in origin a solar symbol with magical connotations, by the end of the eighth century
and in the seventh, when it is used on wine and oil amphoras and later on coins, it seems that
its symbolism is more likely to be of commercial significance (a different kind of magic). On
the graffiti from our Agora groups, see below, p. 225.
Fig. 133
C 138-159.
Fig. 132
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
ornament replaces
amphora
,.
Amphoras
C 141.
Geometric
-^-
;-
:j
-
here published
from the same
in the National
Cyprus (N. M.
C 140.
183
,'
c I3
C13^
Fig. 133
Amphora Fragment:
Fig. 133
flaring
143
U4
glaze
bands.
From an
hi
'iSI Ise
4
.
,-
C 137
C137
z "= -C-144l
.
C142
_C
114
C126_
- 141
I1
C
Fig. 133. Oinochoe (C 114, 126) and Amphora (C 137, 140-144) Fragments
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
amphora like
184
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Fig. 133
P 8385.
From two similar tall slim amphoras of the same shape. The body of one is banded, with
two fine lines in each reserved band, and a dotted lozenge chain just below the shoulder. The
other has a zigzag band in addition to the dotted lozenge bands.
Fig. 133
Fig. 133
C 145.
Protoattic
Amphora Fragments.
Fig. 134
P 7183.
L ---- _m-,
.
i
, -- IAI
..-
I'Li
D
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
185
Three non-joining fragments from the wall of a large closed pot, probably an amphora,
decorated with animal friezes; the fragments preserve parts of three zones; on one fragment,
part of a band of lions, and, below it, a band filled with a procession of horses to the right.
The other two fragments are considerably thicker and probably come from lower down in
the amphora wall; they preserve parts of two horses, one galloping hard toward the right.
The faces of the horses are drawn in outline in purple, which is also applied over the glaze
on the manes. Orientalizing filling ornament of volute-plants, beaked reverse spirals, running
dog and wavy lines. Brown clay with a purplish tinge; dull black glaze. The fabric is probably Attic that has fired an unusual color; the clay resembles at any rate that of no othel
fabric. The filling ornament is easily paralleled on other Protoattic vases: for the beaked
reversed spiral, see the stamnos B 64 above, and for the volute plant, the bowl from
Thebes (Jhb., II, 1887, pD. 4). Galloping horses appear on orientalizing pottery from Eretria
(Eph. Arch., 1903, p. 31, fig. 18) and in the Cyclades (Delos, XVII, pl. IX, 2). The filling ornament and the drawing of the horses are characteristic of the mid-seventh century; the banded
oerlions toether with the liberal use of added purple, are intimations
decoration, and the frieze of
of what is to follow in the second half. Drawing in outline with purple is an entirely new
experiment.
C 146.
Protoattic Amphora.
Fig. 135
C 147.
Fig. 136
unglazed.
'he clay is probably Corinthian; the fablic is very
Iiuch like that of the fine hand-made vases with polished
surface found in graves in Corinth (A.J.A., XI1, 1937,
p. 137, figs. 1-2); Iprobably late Geometric of the end
of the eighth century or beginning of the seventh.
Cn
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
186
RODNEY S. YOUNG
HYDRIA
C 148.
Subgeoimetric
Hydria.
Fig. 137
HUT MODEL
Very few examples of an interesting form of vase, the house-model, have been found in
the Greek world. Prehistoric models from Melos and Crete are known, and rather elaborate
late Geometric and early orientalizing houses with peaked roofs from Perachora and from
the Argive Heraeum (F. Behn, Hausurnen, Berlin, 1924; see also the article Hausurnen in
Ebert, Reallexikon der Vorgeschichte, especially the note by Karo, Agaischer Kreis). A hut
model from Corinth in the Berlin Museum consists of three tall round structures pointed
like beehives and peaked at the top, with small rectangular doors in front high up
under the peaks (Inventory No. 4503; Behn, pl. 29e; Ebert, pl. 73e). The Corinthian
huts, taken to be Mycenaean, are thought to represent granaries, and to show the same
stage of development as the beehive tombs. In a period when the rectangular plan
was already used for house-building, the old round plan continues to live on, employed
in grave and barnyard architecture (Behn, pp. 65 ff.). Three late Geometrichut models on
the same plan exist, with the only difference that individual huts are represented, instead of
a triple hut. One was found in a Grave at Eleusis (Eph. Arch., 1898, p. 112, fig. 32);
another, from the Kerameikos, has never been published; it has a peak at the top above the
door, and careless subgeometric decoration of dots, triangles, zigzags, and birds (N. M. Inventory, 698). Fragments of yet another similar model were found in our seventh century
well deposit; decorated also in subgeometric style. With its vertical lines radiating
structure made of
os withe with their
downward from the peak at the top, it suggests aatrct
ends stuck in the ground, woven together with other withes to a certain height to make
a straight cylindrical wall, and then with their upper ends bent and gathered together at
the top and there tied; the upper part of the structure was perhaps afterward thatched.
A ladder up the front gave access to the high door, through which grain could be dumped
for storage inside. Such a granary would of course be a magnet for the attraction of
hungry birds, which arc quite appropriately represented not only on the Kerameikos model,
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
187
but also on the Agora granary, where they walk in procession around the outside, seeking
ingress to the feast. The Berlin model is very simply decorated with stripes of glaze; it
would be interesting to know whether it is really Mycenaean, or, like the other examples
preserved, late Geometric or subgeometric; the only way of telling would probably be
a careful examination of its fabric. If it is Mycenaean, then our subgeometric hut models of the
:
same type furnish another link in the chain of
i
evidence connecting the Mycenaean with the
orientalizing period.
C 149.
c 149
STANDS: C 150-152
Fig. 134
C 151.
Fig. 134
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
188
RODNEY S. YOUNG
zone part of a procession of large birds toward the right is preserved. The upper zone seems to
have consisted of panels with perforations between them; at. the left a panel is broken away,
while at the right the bottom of a perforation is preserved; standing in it, part of a human foot,
modelled in clay and with incised toes, is preserved. The gaps between the panels, then, seem to
have been filled by figurines standing in them. Attic clay with red glaze for the birds, on the
projecting fluted band, and on the floor of the window in which stands the figurine.
Just enough is preserved of our stand to whet the curiosity as to the appearance of so
elaborate a structure when it was complete. The fabric, the fluted rim, and the drawing of the
birds are Protoattic; although I know of no Protoattic vase decorated like this one with figures
standing in windows, Protoattic vases with figurines for ornamentation exist, cf. .A.A., 1932,
p. 198, fig. 5, and A.A., 1933, pp. 271-274, figs. 6-8.
Fig. 134
Fig. 134
P 7488.
Fragment from low down in the wall of a very big vase, unglazed inside and therefore closed;
perhaps an amphora. Glaze bands; their diameter is already too small to allow of their encircling
a neck above them. The head of a long-necked bird surrounded by orientalizing filling ornament
is preserved above the glaze rings; the bird drawn with its head toward the foot of the pot (if
we have placed the fragment rightly). Attic clay with red glaze. The bird is reminiscent of
those on Acropolis 345 (Graef-Langlotz, pl. 12).
C 154.
Oinochoe Fragment.
Fig. 139
Fig. 139
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
189
C 164
C 162
C 160
a
' "
J71---'
--.-'..--
Fig. 139.
^:;?
C154
C 158 _Lz-- -~
'.:..
4
715
Fragments
imlpression, probably intended to represent a bird, and framed above, below, and at the sides,
by double lines.
buff clay.
The aryballos
to the so-called
Monochrome
HOUSEIIOLD WARE:
Micaceous
pale
group.
C 156-165
Fig. 136
H., 0.193 m.
C 157-158.
Pitcher Fragments.
Fig. 139
1) 8390, 8397.
Handle
lines
incised
on the handle,
forming
a St. Andrew's cross, and horizontal double wavy lines incised below the lip and above the handle
attachment.
its top.
wavy
lines running
of the handle,
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
and across
190
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Figs. 139-140
P 8391.
Part of the rim of a similarly shaped pot, with a shallow pouring spout. The vase may have
been a spouted amphora, like the ones from Anavysos,
Praktika, 1911, p. 124, 27-28. Incised cross-hatching
riSMw
on the shoulder; thin fabric.
Figs. 139-140
*,
P 8395.
CBasin
Frag
160.
1
t. Fs.
140. Profiles of Hoisehold Ware
10Fig.
Fig 140. Profiles of Household Ware
From a basin with thickened
rim, slightly
projecting, and flat on top, with a shallow pour-agm
ing spout, like the basin from Grave III above
(fig. 10) and the one from the votive deposit, Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 597, fig. 63, and p. 601,
fig. 69, No. 234.
Figs. 139-140
Figs. 139-140
P 8392.
Part of the rim and shallow concave floor preserved. The rim is straight, keeled along its
lower edge, and sharply undercut; a fluted band of clay runs along the upper surface of the keel.
Incised on the outer face of the rim, a wavy band between straight horizontal lines.
Figs. 139-140
P 8394.
Part of a shallow bowl with a vertical band handle, on a high stand. An incised zigzag runs
around the upper part of the stand, and a double wavy line at the level of the handle attachment.
Another double wavy line runs around the floor of the bowl inside surrounded by a band of zigzag.
Possibly from a lamp like B 51 (fig. 87 above), but on a stand.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
LATE
GEOMETRIC
GRAVES
191
Discs: C 166-173
Twenty-seven round discs cut from the walls of Geometric and Protoattic pots, and
two discs of stone, were found in the well deposit; some are pierced by a small hole through
the centre. These discs have been thought to have been used as counters for a game, or as
lids for small open vases. Occasionally discs are found on which the edges of the hole are
worn smooth, and a groove is worn around it inside, as though a string has been passed
through and either knotted inside, or tied to a short pin; others have the hole big enough
for the finger to pass through; in either case the disc would seem to have been used as a lid.
Similar discs were found in the Agora votive deposit; see Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 603, fig. 71.
C 166-173.
Clay discs.
Fig. 142
P 7448-7451; P 8398-8401.
C 166-168 are cut from Geometric pots; on 166 a leaf band, and on 167 part of a meander
with perpendicular hatching. 169-170 are orientalizing; on 169 is preserved the end of a tongue
between scrolls. 171-173 are from pots with very thick walls of coarse gritty micaceous clay;
perhaps pithoi. 171 is unbored, 172 is bored, and 173 has a hole in one side that does not go
through to the other.
LooMi WEIGHTSAND WHORLS: C 174-180
Loom weights and whorls of the same types as those found in the Agora votive deposit
were profusely represented in the well. Two (C 176 and C 177) are interesting because
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
192
RODNEY S. YOUNG
they have late Geometric connections: one with Grave a and the Isis Grave at Eleusis, and
the other with Dipylon Grave VII. Four loom weights were found, and nineteen whorls.
C 174-175.
Loom Weights.
Fig. 142
MC246, 268.
C 174 is pyramidal, and C 175 flat pyramidal, with a smear of red glaze on one side. These
are of the same type as the Protoattic loom weights from the votive deposit, Hesperia, II, 1933,
p. 602, fig. 70, Nos. 250-253.
Fig. 142. Discs (C 16G-173), Loom Weights (C 174-175), Clay Ball (C 176), and Whorls (C 177-180)
C 176.
Clay Ball.
MC267.
Fig. 142
Spherical, with a small hole bored off-centre. Attic clay. Such balls were found in pumbers
in the Isis Grave and in Grave a at Eleusis; sometimes they were unpierced, and sometimes
speckled all over with dots of glaze. In fabric they are the same as the Geometric pots, and quite
different from the incised clay balls found in the Agora votive deposit (Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 565,
fig. 24, Nos. 94-95); in shape, however, and probably in use, they were the same.
C 177-180.
Clay Whorls.
Fig. 142
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
193
The double-convex type of whorl is the kind used throughout the Geometric period; it has
been found in Geometric well deposits in the Agora extending well back into the eighth century.
So far as has been shown by Geometric finds made to date, such double-convex whorls, and
spherical whorls like C 176 are the only Geometric whorls. No Geometric parallel has yet been
found for the whorl published as Geometric with a group of pots supposed to be a glave group,
in the Museum at Toronto (J.H.S., LI, 1931, pl. VI; whorl No. 12).
TERRACOTTAFIGURINES: C 181-187
C 181.
i..-
C187
C182
C184
C 183
181
C 182.
Fig. 143
C 183-184.
Fig. 143
T 1271, 1272.
Two fragments from the hindquarters of horses; the legs are broken off. On the backs of both
traces are preserved showing that riders were attached; both had the tail attached along one of the
hindlegs, and both are decorated with thin streaky black-to-blown glaze. C 183 has a multiples18
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
194
RODNEY S. YOUNG
spoked wheel painted on its haunch on one side, and a dotted ring on the other; C 184 is
decorated with irregular bands and stripes of glaze. Both are of the seventh century; the manner
of plastering the tail along the hindleg is Protoattic, and the glaze is subgeometric. Similar glazedecorated horses were found in the Agora votive deposit; Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 620, fig. 86.
Fig. 143
C 187.
Fig. 143
IV
THE POTTERY
The pottery included in our three groups, A-C, was made over a period of about three
quarters of a century, from about 725 to 650; a period of rapid change, in which the
orientalizing style displaced the Geometric. Our vases, indeed, represent three styles: the
late Geometric, the subgeometric, and the orientalizing. Some of the Geometric vases
already show the quickening influence of orientalizing art; all of the orientalizing vases
continue to show the influence of the Geometric art that had gone before. The sub-
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
195
geometric vases serve as a link between the two styles.1 While remaining free of orientalizing motives, they employ an ever-degenerating Geometric ornamentation that continues to
be used in subordinate places on fully orientalizing vases. Through the subgeometric
vases we may watch the degeneration of Geometric decoration as it becomes the conventional filling and subsidiary ornament of Protoattic-, and, indeed, of early Black-figured
vases.
It is the purpose here to discuss the changes of fabric, shape, and decoration that took
place during this period of transition, noting the characteristic shapes and ornaments of
the late Geometric style, and observing which were used and abandoned and which transformed by continued use in the subgeometric and Protoattic styles. As might be expected
in a mass of material as great as that found in our Agora groups, many pieces are included
which are of great interest in themselves or for details of their decoration, but which fall
outside the scope of such a discussion. These vases are discussed in full in their places
in the catalogue, to which the reader is referred.
FABRICANDTECHNIQUE
The material used by the late Geometric potters was Attic clay, usually carefully
cleaned and free of grits, baked hard, and varying in color from buff to pink. The surface was often well smoothed and polished before firing; particularly fine examples of the
care taken in the preparation of the clay and the polishing of its surface are the amphora
and kantharos from Grave XV (fig. 48) and the oinochoe XllI 1 (fig. 43). Most, though not
all, of the Geometric vases are well made; even the smaller pots, as the skyphoi from
Graves XVII and XX, are of good fabric. The subgeometric vases, on the other hand, are
of poor fabric. The clay was almost never properly cleaned, contains many grits, and
was not smoothed and polished on the surface before firing. A few of the earlier small cups,
from Graves VII and IX, were carefully made; the large amphora XI 2 (fig. 32), on the
other hand, is of relatively poor fabric. The carelessness of the preparation of the clay for
subgeometric vases is, in general, characteristic also of orientalizing ware. The Attic
skyphoi made in imitation of Protocorinthian (C 19-33) are as careless in fabric as they
are in decoration. Some of the more elaborately decorated Protoattic vases such as B 1
and C 65 (figs. 74 and 113), on the other hand, are of excellent fabric. It may be said
that the early seventh century shows a definite decline in the quality of fabric, but that
the potters were capable of producing vases of fabric as good as the late Geometric when
they considered it worth their while.
1 Subgeometricpottery might be called the pottery to which R. Carpenterrefers as the " Geometric
Overlap"
The estimate
Overlap"
at
twenty-five years is too short; vases which may properly be called subgeometricseem to have been
The parallel between the survival of subgeometric
made almost to the end of the seventh century.
See also Hesperia, VII, 1938, pp. 421 if.
late black figure has already been suggested.
13"
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
and
196
RODNEY S. YOUNG
On occasion slip was used throughout the period under consideration. Three late Geometric pyxides (XVI 1, XVII 7 and 17) and an oinochoe (VII 8) are covered with a thick
creamy slip. There is no reason to doubt that they were made and decorated in Attica.'
Slip is sometimes used on Protoattic vases of the first half of the seventh century, as on
our B 2 and C 39, C 66, and C 95.2 Although the use of slip is not the normal, nor even
a frequent, procedure on the part of seventh century Attic potters, experimentation with
it is not surprising at a time when Attica was open to external influences of all sorts.
A beginning of such experimentation seems to have been made, perhaps under Boeotian or
also in the quality of glaze. The Geometric vases are decorated with a firm, slightly
lustrous glaze, generously applied.' The glaze is put on evenly and thickly so that the clay
does not show through it. Where it is thinned (for hatching and latticing, for example)
it is thinned purposely and applied evenly to give a slight color contrast. Horizontal glaze
bands were usually applied while the pot was on the wheel; the brush was held steady,
and the glaze applied so evenly that it is often difficult to tell where the beginning and
end of a band meet. Contrast the banded decoration of the vases from Grave XVIII
(fig. 60) with that of the two amphoras from Grave XI (fig. 32); the later painter, although he also ran off his banded decoration while the pot was on the wheel, neither
held his brush steady, nor kept an even supply of glaze in it, nor troubled himself.
to smooth over the junctions at beginning and end of the bands. The glaze used by
1 The presence of slip on the krater and oinochoe from Cyprus in New York (Myres, Handbook of
the Cesnola Collection, p. 286 and nos. 1701-1702) does not preclude the possibility of these vases being
Attic, as is suggested by Smith, A.J.A., XXXIX, 1935, p. 414. The decorative system, as well as most
of the motives, of these pots is Attic. The heraldically opposed deer nibbling at a tree, on the krater,
can be matched on an Attic pyxis discussed by Graef in Ath. Mitt., XXI, 1896, p. 448. The only
distinctly non-Attic motive used is the hanging double-axe, common in Boeotia (e. g. Hampe, V 5, pl. 20).
The fondness for quatrefoils and octofoils in panels, with dot rosettes between their petals, is frequently
displayed on late Attic Geometric vases; we have seen it on our XX 5. Two vases in Copenhagen,
a spouted bowl and a kantharos (C. V.A., Copenhagen, II, pl. 72, 4 and 73, 5) which were found in the
Dipylon and of which the Attic fabric has never been doubted, have not only the same multifoil-dot
rosette decoration, but display the same fondness for deer with crumpled legs as does the krater from
Cyprus. A bowl with the same decoration, now at the Hague, is published as Boeotian simply because
it is covered with slip (C.V. A., Pays-Bas, I, III G, pl. 1, 3). In publishing as Attic a stand with the same
decoration (C. V. A., California, I, pl. 1, 2 a-d) Smith felt that in all conscientiousness he must mention
an impression he had had that the stand might have been slipped.
In scale (H. 3 feet, 10 7/8 inches, or about 1.17m.) as well as in shape the Cesnola krater finds its
best parallels in Attica. The krater itself has the same shape as the Attic krater in the Metropolitan
Museum, A.J.A., XIX, 1915, pl. XVII-XIX. The handles are unusual, but similar handles are found on
such Attic amphoras as Wide, figs. 62-63. On the Cesnola krater they are multiplied to four, perhaps
in imitation of Cretan pithoi like B.S.A., XXIX, 1927-28, pl. VII, 9. The amphoriskos (or rather
hydriskos) used as a handle on the lid is like our XV11 9. If the Cesnola krater is Attic, as seems
probable, it is late and must belong at the very end of the eighth century or the beginning of the
seventh; it shows a number of non-Attic influences.
2
Also, e. g., on the bowl from Thebes, Jhb., II, 1887, pl. 4.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
197
subgeometric potters is usually thin, streaky, and rather dull. When it was applied thickly
it often became highly metallic in firing (IX 13 and 16, XIV 1; figs. 24 and 46). The glaze
used on Protoattic vases is the same as that on subgeometric. It is often carefully and
generously applied so as to make an evenly-colored surface; but however carefully applied
it lacks the lustrous quality of the late Geometric glaze. The shiny black glaze of the
Classical period was perfected in the latter part of the seventh century; the first half of
the century marks a decline from the standard of late Geometric ware in the quality of
glaze as in the quality of fabric.
Clay and glaze probably did not interest the potter of the early orientalizing period.
lie was occupied either in making careless, hastily decorated subgeometric vases, or in
experimenting with new shapes and decorative ornaments. Two new technical devices,
however, also presented themselves for experiment: the use of added color, and incision.
Both may have come to him by way of Corinth.
The Attic potters were much slower to use added color than were the Corinthian. Of
the two accessory colors, purple and white, the former appears only three times among
our Agora groups, and each time on one of the later Protoattic vases: B 45 (fig. 87), C 39
(fig. 107), and C 145 (fig. 134).1 Although purple is freely used in Middle Protocorinthian,
it appears very rarely in Attica before the middle of the seventh century. White, on the
other hand, which appears at the end of the Geometric period both in Attica and in
Corinth and is occasionally used in both during the first half of the seventh century, was
adopted by the Protocorinthian potters as a regular part of their palette later than was
purple. The use of added color was no doubt one of the devices brought from the east in
the second half of the eighth century.
White was first used both at Athens and in Corinth at the end of the eighth century
for the drawing or adornment of snakes. A Corinthian Geometric krater is adorned with
a white snake outlined by white dots. Two Attic amphoras are decorated with plastic
snakes dotted with white; 2 perhaps it is significant that the publisher of one of them
called it Protoattic because of the use of white. Snakes decorated with added white dots
are not uncommon on Early Protocorinthian.3 In our Group A we can find only one
fragment, XI 14 (fig. 35), a skypos handle from one of the later graves, which has white
decoration. Two subgeometric fragments, B 20 and B 61 (figs. 80 and 91) are decorated
with white. A number of Corinthianizing pieces (C 27 and C 32, figs. 103 and 105) use
a system of decoration with white that was taken over from Protocorinthian models.
A number of vases and fragments (B 19, fig. 80; B 58, fig. 88; C 125, fig. 127) belong to
1 The vases of the second half of the seventh century, such as the small pots from Grave II, are,
of course, not under discussion. The use of purple becomes commonafter the middle of the century.
2
The krater from Corinth, A.J.A., XXXIV, 1930, p. 411 and fig. 5.
Jhb., XIV, 1899,pp. 196ff., no. 14 and fig. 61; A.A., 1892,p. 100. The white dots on the former of the
two amphoras seem to have escaped the notice of Wide, but they exist and are quite visible to any
visitor to the National Museum in Athens.
3 On Early Protocorinthian, Johansen, pl. V 2, VIII 5, etc., and p. 54.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
198
cover broad areas, as it came to be used on late Protoattic and early black-figured vases
in the second half of the seventh century. The varied uses to which white was put show
that the potters were in a stage of experimentation. They received the new technique
of adding white at the end of the eighth century, and of adding purple somewhat later;
they did not decide on how to use it until well past the middle of the seventh.
The same may be said of incision. Johansen states that incision was first used only
occasionally and without system in the late stages of the Early Protocorinthian style 2-that
is, at the end of the eighth century. If Attica took the technique of incision from Corinth,
we should expect to find our first crude attempt made very early in the seventh century in
Attica. The earliest fragment with incision from our Agora group is the subgeometric
column-krater handle C 111 (fig. 121) decorated with a centaur; the date suggested for the
fragment (p. 173) was early seventh century. Only a few other pieces were found on which
incision had been used.3 On one of them, B 68, the incision is elaborate and careful; the
vase is developed Protoattic of about the mid-seventh century. Conventional use of incision for separating the petals of a rosette and of palmettes was made on B 57 and B 81
(figs. 88 and 94). A late fragment which also employs added purple has black-figured
incision-that is, incision used to mark off interior details (B 45, fig. 87); the same sort
of incision is used on the cup C 39 (fig. 107). On the Protoattic oil amphora C 127 (fig. 128)
incised rings on the neck replace the conventional glaze-ring neck ornament of that type
of amphora. From the foregoing examples of the rather haphazard use of incision we can
see that the potters were engaged in experimentation with it, just as they were in the use
of white. But the reason why incision did not take immediate hold in Attica as it did in
Corinth is shown by two other examples: B 1 (figs. 74-75) and B 80 (fig. 99). On the
oinochoe B 1 two sphinxes are seated confronting each other. The wing of one is solidly
glazed, and the feathers are incised; the wing of the other is outlined, and the feathers are
drawn in finer glaze lines. In both cases the artist achieved the samresort of wing and the
same sort of feathers. The Protoattic lid B 80 shows horses with flame-like incisions representing the manes. A slightly earlier Protoattic amphora in New York 4 has horses with
manes drawn by wavy lines which make very nearly the same flame-like locks. The
1
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
199
Protoattic artist, then, was able to draw very much the same sort of wing or mane either
by incision or in outline; it took him a long time to decide finally in favor of incision.
The Protocorinthian artist, on the other hand, habitually used incision; his experiments
in outline drawing were very rare. There was undoubtedly strong island influence in the
Attica of the early seventh century. The Protoattic artist made use of the two techniques,
Corinthian incision and Cycladic outline-drawing, side by side over a long period. Drawing in outline was not entirely abandoned until well after the seventh century. The faces of
women were drawn in outline and then filled with white down to the time of Sophilos.
Although outline drawing was, in general, favored in Attica in the first half of the
seventh century, incision was seized upon immediately for the decoration of coarse household ware. None of the hand-made pitchers of this fabric found in the graves of Group A
was decorated with incision; on the other hand a number of fragments with rather
elaborate incised decoration are to be noted among the sporadic finds of the seventh century
from the grave area, and in Group C (B 4, 51, 82; C 157-164). Such decoration of household pottery probably started in the late eighth century.1 The fabric of household ware
is quite different from that of ordinary Attic pottery. It was made, however, for a special
purpose and therefore adapted to that purpose; the clay may have been taken from
a different bed than was the clay for ordinary Attic ware, and certainly it was differently
mixed. Household ware, with very little change in fabric, is found in abundance in Attica
throughout antiquity, from the Protogeometric to the Late Roman period; its presence in
great quantity over so long a period indicates that it was made locally. Large pithoi like
IX 1 (fig. 23) were probably used for storage. One-handled pitchers of the sort found in
Graves VI-X were used for cooking; pitchers of this sort are often burned on the outside. The fabric was probably intended to withstand fire; it was used for lamps (B 51 and
63, figs. 87 and 91) and a brazier (C 165, fig. 141) as well as for cooking pots. It is uncertain why pottery of this fabric was always made by hand instead of on the wheel.
A few hand-made aryballoi of different fabric were found: XVII 22, XXV 5, and C 155
(figs. 54, 72, and 139). Two of the three examples are decorated with incised ornament.
They belong to the fabric known as Monochrome Argive.2 Vases of this fabric have been
found in abundance on many Greek sites; not only aryballoi but also oinochoai with trefoil
mouth or long-necked with conical body, as well as small kantharoi, belong to the group.
The aryballoi may have been made to contain oil or perfume of manufacture other than
Corinthian. Small vases made by hand of pale buff clay, and sometimes decorated with
incision, have been found in great quantity at Eleusis. It is quite probable that the vases
of the so-called Monochroine Argive group were made locally at a number of places. Two
of the kantharoi from the Agora, IX 11 and C 66, are made of clay like that of the aryballoi;
they were turned on the wheel, however, and decorated in the normal manner with glaze.
1 Late eighth century examples: from Anavysos, Praktika, 1911, pp. 124-125, nos. 24-29; from the
Dipylon (Grave X), Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 119, fig. 12.
2
Pfuhl, MuZ, pp. 82-83, discusses the group, and gives references.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
200
SHAPES
In the pottery of the late eighth century three types may be noted: vases made for
ordinary use in the daily life of adults, vases made for children, and vases specially made
for funerary use. The children's vases are often miniature imitations of larger models, but
among them are to be found shapes which have no parallels in pottery of ordinary size.
The small vases, made for children, were found in children's graves, and the larger ware
in the graves of adults. Though the two types are contemporary,they are therefore seldom
found together; one burial at Spata,1 however, contained small oinochoai like those from
our Grave IX (fig. 24) together with large pyxides like those from our Grave XVII (fig. 54).
The contrast between the two types is symbolical of a change that took place at the end
of the Geometric period. The potters of the late eighth century had developed high technical ability, and used it in the fabrication of very big pots. Colossal amphoras and
kraters were made to be set up as monuments over graves; comment has often been made
on the skill required for their manufacture.2 Nearly as great skill was necessary for the
making of pitchers, ribbon-handled bowls, and pyxides such as were found in the graves
at Spata, at the Dipylon, and in our Grave XVII (fig. 54).3 Although these vases do not
compare in actual dimensions with the monumental amphoras and kraters, yet the thinness
of their fabric makes them, for their size, triumphs of technique quite as great. Such vases
must have been made over a short period after the potters had acquired the skill necessary
for their manufacture, and while the public taste demanded them; but their very size
rendered them unsuitable for ordinary use, and they must represent merely a vogue of short
duration. The reaction toward smaller vases was strong; almost all the subgeometric and
Protoattic ware is made on a lesser scale than its Geometric predecessors. The reduction
in the size of the pottery made for everyday uses after the end of the eighth century may
have been due in part to reaction against the giantism of many late Geometric vases, in
part to the custom of making miniature vases for children, and in part to the influence of
Protocorinthian ware, which began to make itself felt toward the end of the eighth century.
The trend toward small vases entailed the disappearance of certain Geometric forms.
Most noteworthy among the shapes that ceased to be made after the eighth century is the
pyxis of Geometrictype. Pyxides had been made from early Geometrictimes; several were
found in the Areopagus graves.4 Eatly pyxides, either shallow or deep, were always made
1Spata Grave 3; Delt., VI, 1920-21, pp. 134 ff., and figs. 6-10.
2
e. g. by Miss Richter, who has herself had experience in the throwing of pots. See her remark on
the krater in New York, Metropolitan Museum Bulletin, 1934, p. 172.
3 Dipylon Grave XIII: Wide, fig. 74; B. C. H., 1895, pp. 273 ff.; at Spata in Graves 1, 3 and 4: Delt.,
VI, 1920-21, pp. 132 ff., figs. 2, 6, and 11. Similar pitchers with late Geometric decoration from the
Dipylon, Wide, figs. 71 and 73; from Anavysos, Praktika, 1911, p. 122, 20 and 21. There are nine more
in the Empedokles collection in Athens.
4 C. V.
A., Athens, I, pls. 1-2.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
201
with well rounded wall, and usually with ring foot. Pyxides of this shape continued to be
made throughout the Geometric period; two examples from one of our late graves, XVII 8
and 13 (fig. 54), one shallow and the other deep, are of the conventional early shape. Pyxides
of later type were made with flat bottom or a low base, and with but slightly curved sidewall. The latest examples, like our XVII 15 and 17, XVIII 6, and XX 5 (figs. 54, 60, and 67)
are very nearly straight-sided, and, in two cases, slightly greater in diameter at the base
than at the rim. The latest Geometric pyxides, often made of great size, were also often
adorned with plastic representations of horses as handles on their lids (XVI1 15-17,
XVIII 6). The inconvenience of a handleless form, together with the desire for smaller
vases, was perhaps the cause of the disappearance of the Geometric type of pyxis. It was
replaced probably by the more useful bowl with ribbon handle, sometimes lidded,' by the
lidded skyphos with in-turned rim,2 and by the pyxis of Protocorinthian type.
The great one-handled pitchers of the late Geometric period also disappear, although
small jugs of nearly the same shape continued to be mad'e. The making of big vases did
not, of course, stop; but big vases were made for practical use and not for display. Thus
the ordinary amphora performed in a much more satisfactory way the function to which
overgrown one-handled pitchers had been rather unsuitably adapted, and the pitchers were
no longer made.
With the exception of the pyxis and the pitcher, however, most of the Geometric types
continued to be made into the seventh century, usually on a somewhat smaller scale. With
the continued use of Geometric shapes there was a continuing development of them. The
contrast between the well-rounded early Geometric pyxis form and its nearly straight-sided
successor is typical of the change that took place between early and late Geometric forms,
and that continued into the seventh century. Different shapes underwent different developments, but in general the trend was from well rounded to less rounded forms; from plump
to pointed shapes, and from well defined and sharply offset parts to a blurring and blending
of parts running into each other in continuous reverse curves. With the lessening of the
articulation of parts came the disappearance of some members. The ring foot of the early
Geometric style gives place to a low base, which in turn often disappears, leaving a plain
flat bottom. Rims, usually clearly defined from a well-curved shoulder in early Geometric
vases, are in late Geometric and subgeometric vases either continuous with the side wall or
disappear entirely as separate parts. With the general trend in the development of form in
mind, let us look at individual shapes.
The skyphoi from Graves XVII and XX (figs. 54 and 67) are typically late Geometric
in shape. In comparison with early Geometric skyphoi they are relatively deep and narrow;
they have low bases instead of ring feet, and are somewhat more pointed at the bottom.
1 Like the bowl from Dipylon Grave III, Wide, fig. 99.
2 Like the skyphos from Dipylon Grave VIII, Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pl. VIII, 1, 6. Numerous
skyphoi of this type, lidded, were found in the Phaleron cemetery.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
202
RODNEY S. YOUNG
The well-rounded early shoulder has become much less marked, and the rim is not so sharply
offset. XVII 1 and XX 1 are still reminiscent of the earlier shape; XVII 2-3, XX 3, and
C 37-38 (fig. 106), narrower at the bottom, taller in proportion to their width, and less
curved at the shoulder, are more developed; they are typical late Geometric skyphoi. Still
more developed are early seventh century examples: V 3 (fig. 15) and C 43-44 (fig. 106);
they are also slightly smaller in scale. The later examples are flat-bottomed and are
becoming definitely pointed; they show almost no inward curve at the shoulder, and in them
the offset lip is beginning to become merely a flaring rim. C 44 stands at the head of
a subgeometric skyphos type which continued to be made through the seventh century;
C 45-47 (fig. 108) are examples of this class, abundantly represented in every seventh
century deposit. C 45 has a flat bottom and its lower wall is no longer convex; it curves
inward scarcely at all at the shoulder and has a flaring rim. C 46-47, later than C 45,
are even deeper, narrower, and more pointed at the bottom. To the same type belong
the skyphoi B 55-54 (fig. 88). After the middle of the seventh century subgeometric skyphoi
of this shape, which has gradually become deeper and more pointed through the first half
of the century, become again shallower and wider at the bottom, and have less emphasis
on the flaring lip. Two examples from a pottery group of the third quarter of the century
at the Agora have been published.' The same development is to be followed at Corinth;
middle Protocorinthian skyphoi become gradually deeper and more pointed until, after the
middle of the century, a reaction in the late Protocorinthian and Transitional style made
for skyphoi of shallower shape and wider at the bottom.
Two large skyphoi, both of which bear inscriptions, B 55 (fig. 90) and C 39 (fig. 107),
were made at about the middle of the century and reflect the change that was to come
about. Each has a ring foot, a shallow open body, a high straight offset rim, and very
slightly convex shoulder. In comparison with late Geometric skyphoi they differ at rim
and foot; it is probable that skyphoi like C 38, of typical late Geometric shape, continued
in the seventh century to be made and decorated with conventional subgeometric ornament,
and served as a link between mid-century examples like our inscribed pieces and the true
late Geometric skyphoi with short lip and low base.2
Two other skyphos types are worthy of mention. The first, very shallow, shoulderless,
and with widely flaring lip, has rather long, almost horizontal handles and is decorated on
the inside as well as on the exterior. XXV 1 (fig. 72) and C 40 (fig. 108) belong to this type,
which was clearly influenced by metal work. Skyphoi of this shape began to be made in
Attica only at the end of the Geometric period, and usually are subgeometric or orientalizing in their decoration. The type seems to have no sequel of later date, and was probably
limited to the period of manufactureof the metallic model from which it was copied-from
Hesperia, VII, 1938, p. 413 and fig. 1, D 4-5.
Like a skyphos in Eleusis, Eph. Arch., 1898, pl. 5, 1, decorated with a figured scene of the end of
the eighth century. It has a low base and a short lip, and shoulder more rounded than that of later
examples.
2
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
203
the end of the eighth into the early seventh century. The second skyphos type, with inturned rim, has already been mentioned as a seventh century substitute for the (eometric
pyxis. It was probably imitated from late Geometric Corinthian pyxides of the same shape.'
One fragment of a skyphos of this type was found in the well, C 42 (fig. 109). A similar
skyphos was found in Grave VIII at the Dipylon, and fairly numerous examples, ranging
in date from the beginning to the end of the seventh century, were found in graves in the
Phaleron cemetery.2 Though used over a long period from the beginning of the seventh
century onward, the type remained comparatively rare.
Cups with one handle were, like skyphoi, made throughout the Geometric period. They
seem, in general, to go through the same development as do the skyphoi-from the shallow,
rounded to the deeper, more pointed, form. The flattening of the shoulder is not so noticeable on cups as on skyphoi; and since cups were made from earliest times without ring foot
or base, it is often difficult to date plain back-glazed examples. It might be suggested,
however, that X 2 (fig. 28) corresponds to late Geometric skyphoi like XVII 1 (fig. 54),
while cups like C 51-52, deeper and more pointed, are the counterparts of later skyphoi
like C 37-38 (fig. 106). The subgeometric skyphoi of the seventh century have also their
one-handled counterparts: to the skyphoi C 45-47 correspond the cups C 48-50 (fig. 108).
C 48, fairly wide at the bottom and flaring at the rim, is of about the same date as C 45;
C 49-50, deeper and more pointed, and with less emphasis on the rim, are, like C 46-47,
somewhat later. As do the skyphoi, the cups become shallower and wider at the bottom
after the middle of the century.3 Skyphoi and cups of this sort are the typical cheap ware
of the seventh century. The great majority (sixteen out of twenty-one) of the early in4
scriptions from Mount Hymettos are incised on one-handled cups of this type.
Some of the miniature cups are small models of the late Geometric type. IX 6-7 (fig. 24),
well rounded and with sharply offset rims, are close in shape to cups like X 2 (fig. 28).
Other cups of the same shape, V 2 (fig. 15), VI 2 (fig. 17), VII 4 (fig. 20), and IX 3 (fig. 24)
are deeper, less rounded, and less sharply defined at the junction of rim and body.
A fragment from the seventh century well, C 57 (fig. 109) corresponds closely in decoration as well as in shape to V 2. Even in the miniature cups, then, the same development
seems to take place-from the well-rounded, rather shallow body with markedly curved
shoulder and offset rim, to the more pointed, deeper body with shallow shoulder and less
marked definition of parts. Other small cups from Graves VII and IX (figs. 20 and 24)
are not imitations of larger models; they find parallels, however, in fragments from the well:
C 53-56
1 e.g.,
(fig. 109).
deposit
figs. 22-23.
Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pl. VIII, 1, 6; Delt., II, 1916, pp. 13 Tf.
3
Hesperia, VII, 1938, p. 415 and fig. 1, D 7-8.
4 A.J.A., XXXVIII, 1934, pp. 10 ff.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
204
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Kantharoi show much the same development of shape as do cups and skyphoi. The
kantharos, however, is not an early form; no kantharoi have been found in graves of the
early Geometric period. A fragmentary kantharos was found in a well at the Agora with
vases of simple Geometric style of the first half of the eighth century; the kantharos,
however, is shown by its decoration to be one of the latest members of the group, and
should probably be dated near the middle of the century.1 Kantharoi were probably first
made slightly before the middle of the century and are therefore relatively late-comers in
the Geometric repertory. The oldest examples in our group are XV 2 and XX 4 (figs. 48
and 67). Both are well rounded, with low base and inward-curved shoulder; the rim is
upstanding and clearly defined from the body. Miniatures with subgeometric decoration,
VII 7 and IX 8-9 (figs. 20 and 24), are of the same shape; they show, however, the late
tendency to a lack of clear definition of parts. The tendency is further shown by IX 10
and C 63 (figs. 24 and 112), which are shoulderless and rimless-the former with the
decoration marking off a rim no longer made as a separate member of the pot. C 66 (fig. 112),
a Protoattic kantharos, is of the same rimless shape; the body has become deep and pointed
with straight upper wall marked off from the lower body by a shallow groove, making a sort
of pseudo-rim. The handsomely decorated kantharos C 65 (fig. 113) is of the same shape;
the handles with their lower ends applied against the body suggest that the vase was
influenced by metalwork. C 67 (fig. 112), however, is a kantharos of typically Protoattic
shape-low base, deep, rather pointed body with a shallow shoulder, and high straight rim,
tilted slightly outward. Several kantharoi of this type were found in the votive deposit at
the Agora.2 The shape is close to that of the Boeotian bird-kantharoi; it may have been
common to both Attica and Boeotia. Another kantharos type with flat bottom and wide
body with plain rim slightly incurved (C 64, fig. 112), usually conventionally decorated with
tethered horses or a pair of birds, is very common in Boeotia, rarer in Attica.3 Our example
seems to be Attic in fabric; probably Attic potters made vases of this type under Boeotian
influence. A noteworthy feature of Attic and Boeotian kantharoi of the seventh century
is the oval outline at the rim; the body was slightly pinched before firing, so that the width
at the rim from handle to handle is less than the length from front to back. Geometric
kantharoi have normal round rims; the late vase XI 5 (fig. 32) is, however, oval. It does
not fit into the normal kantharos series; the body is more rounded, and the rim incorporated
into the body in a reverse curve. The effect of form and decoration together is that of
a tulip-like flower; probably the desired effect was considered in advance and the form
adapted to it. Another kantharos, IX 11 (fig. 24), probably shows non-Attic influence; its
nearest parallel is a kantharos from a grave at Tiryns.
Like the kantharoi, the kalathoi in our groups show foreign influence. XVII 5-6 (fig. 54)
are similar in shape to Boeotian kalathoi; XVII 5 shows Boeotian influence not only in its
1 Unpublished; Agora Inventory, P 6402.
2
Hesperia, II, 1933, pp. 585 ff., nos. 200, 203--205; figs. 51, 54-57.
3
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
205
shape but also in its decoration. Another kalathos, C 84 (fig. 108), shows the influence of
Protocorinthian models. True Attic kalathoi of the early Geometric period are deep and
pointed, narrow at the bottom, and with flaring concave walls. Later examples are shallower
and wider at the bottom, with straight, outward-tilted walls. Kalathoi of early and late
type were found together in the Isis Grave at Eleusis.1 Open-work or fenestrated kalathoi
of late shape were made in Attica toward the end of the Geometric period.
The ribbon-handled bowl is, like the kantharos, a late Geometric shape. No examples
have been found in early graves on the Areopagus or in early groups at the Agora. Such
bowls were probably first made after the middle of the eighth century, and they became
very popular in the late Geometric period, continuing to be made into the early seventh
century. Ribbon-handled bowls of great size found at the Dipylon in Grave XIII have
already been mentioned. Only two were found in our cemetery, both from the same late
burial, and both subgeometric in decoration: XI 3-4 (fig. 32). XI 4 is deep and narrow,
with a high rim; its lower body is little curved, and the junction of rim and body is not
sharply profiled. In shape it approaches the kalathos XVII 6 (fig. 54), with the addition of
handles. The rim of XI 3 is tilted outward; earlier bowls have straight vertical rims. From
about the end of the eighth century ribbon-handled bowls began to be made with low perforated stands, like our XI 8-9 (fig. 33). Such bowls are often found, as were our examples,
in the remains of pyres; they were probably made originally for ritual purposes, but came
later into more common use, and gradually displaced the earlier type without the stand.
The howl, however, continued to develop in shape on its stand. Our XI 8-9 are of about
the same shape as XI 3; the rim tilts outward and the shoulder curves but little inward.
The lower body is slightly deeper; a transition must be made to the stand. A mid-seventh
century Protoattic bowl from the Kerameikos2 illustrates the later development of the
shape: the stand has become very high and wide, the body very shallow, the rim is tilted
sharply outward, and only a shallow groove now marks the transition froin the shoulderless
body to the rim.
The ribbon handle with outward-turned ends may well have been of metallic origin. As
used on the bowls it is merely decorative. On plates it served a purpose; it was so placed
at the rim that the plate, simply glazed on the inside but often elaborately decorated outside, could be hung by the handle against the wall. Early Geometric plates, designed to
be hung in the same manner, were made with pierced lugs projecting from the rim. The
ribbon handle, admirably suited to the purpose of hanging, probably replaced the pierced
lug at about the middle of the eighth century. Our plate XX 6 (fig. 67), from a grave of
the last quarter of the eighth century, is fairly deep, markedly convex in its wall, and
stands on a low ring foot. Later plates of the end of the century and the beginning of the
seventh, VI 3 (fig. 18), B 14 and B 76 (figs. 80 and 94) and C 77-78 (fig. 115) are shallower,
1
2
C.V.A., Athens, I, pl. 6, 8 of the older type, and 10 (fenestrated) of the later shape.
A.A.. 1934,p. 219, fig. 14.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
206
RODNEY S. YOUNG
less convex, and have low bases instead of ring feet. Other plates from the well, C 79-82
(fig. 114), are noticeably smaller and more carelessly made; the handle ends are not turned
sharply outward, and the body has almost entirely lost its convexity. All four, and the
fragment B 15 (fig. 80) show Protocorinthian influence in their decoration bands, and
have no Geometricpredecessors. The shape, however, may have been developed by deepening that of the Geometricplate. C 85 (fig. 117) is fairly close in shape to XX 6; instead
of having two handles it has one handle and a spout. The new arrangement was very
practical; the spout could be used for pouring, and one handle remained by which the bowl
could be hung. A number of fragmentary bowls were found in the grave area and in the
well which must have had the same features: B 44 and 77 (figs. 87 and 94), C 86-92
(figs. 115 and 117). On some the spout is a shallow fluting of the rim; on others it is
a mere depression marked on the upper face of the rim by a spot of glaze. The handle is
not preserved on any of our examples; that there can have been only one is shown in several
cases because the rim is preserved to more than half its circumference. C 87, which has
a rudimentary pour-channel on its rim, proves that there was a handle: the decoration is
so drawn that it is upside down when the bowl stands on its foot, but appears in its correct
position if the bowl hangs by its handle from a peg in the wall.
The large two-handled bowls with short rim from the Agora groups are too fragmentary
to furnish much information as to the development of the shape. The handles seem to have
been of two types: rolled handles tilted sharply upward, as on C 96-97
horizontal band handles, as on C 102-103 (fig. 119). Smaller examples of the same shape
sometimes have shallow depressions for pouring in the rim, as C 99 (fig. 121). The
decoration of bowls of this sort is late Geometric, subgeometric, and Protoattic (C 97--98,
figs. 117 and 119); the type was made from the late eighth century to the middle of the
seventh, and later. Its development can be traced in complete examples preserved in
various museums. A late Geometricbowl has a high base and vertical band handles with
out-turned ends; the influence of metal work is strongly felt.2 Another late Geometric bowl
of the same shape has rolled handles and a vertical ring foot instead of a base.3 Made
at about the end of the eighth century, it has a rather deep body, well curved in the lower
part and widely rounded at the shoulder. A later bowl, from Thebes, belongs early in the
second quarter of the seventh century.4 Its foot is a little more flaring, its body shallower,
1 A small plate from the Agora group of the third quarter of the century, Hesperia, VII, 1938,
415
and fig. 2, D 12. A still later example, unpublished, Agora Inventory, P 5413.
p.
2
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
207
and only slightly convex in its lower part; the shoulder is higher and more sharply
curved, and the rim lower. The bowl from Aegina by the Nessos painter, made early
in the last quarter of the seventh century,l has a very flaring foot, still shallower body,
more sharply curved shoulder, lower rim, and nearly straight lower wall. The time
allowed for the development of the shape, about eighty years, covers very nearly three
generations.
Krater fragments from the grave area and the well are, like the bowl fragments, too
small to give any idea of the development of the shape. B 8 (fig. 79) and C 110 (fig. 121)
are parts of Attic kraters of ordinary type, B 8 with goat-head handle. C 106-109 (fig. 121)
are all very late Geometric in decoration; no Protoattic kraters were found. Probably bowls
like C 97 replaced the krater in the seventh century. The column krater, too, seems to have
been introduced, perhaps under the influence of metal work, at about the beginning of the
century. Our C 111 (figs. 115 and 121), a handle, is the earliest fragment of a column
krater that has been found.
Stamnoi, which began to be made at the end of the eighth century,2 were probably also
put to the uses for which Geometric kraters had been made. A number of subgeometric
and early seventh century Attic stamnoi exist; our C 112 (fig. 121) is a fragment of a small
one. The shape reached its fullest development and greatest popularity after the middle of
the century; our B 64 (fig. 92) is an example dating from about 650. A number of handsome late Protoattic examples from Aegina are unpublished.
Jugs were probably first made at about the same time as were ribbon-handled bowls,
and attained great popularity in the late Geometric period. The two shapes, jug and bowl,
have been found in great numbers and seem to have been the types of vase in most common
use in the second half of the eighth century. Earlier examples of the jug like our XVII 18
and XVIII 1 (figs. 54 and 60) sometimes have a low base; the lower body is always well
rounded, and meets the high slightly flaring rim at a marked angle. Later jugs, like XI 15
(fig. 33), are always flat-bottomed and less rounded; the definition of body and rim becomes
less sharp, until finally Protoattic jugs show in profile a continuous reverse curve.3 The
one-handled jugs are simply reduced versions of larger pitchers. The body is usually about
one third, and the rim two thirds, of the total height; the large pitchers are made with body
and rim about equal in height. Small jugs were sometimes used as handles for the lids of very
large pitchers; in such cases the contrast of the proportions of parts in what is essentially
the same shape is very noticeable.4 Pitchers like our XIV 1 (fig. 46) were made of medium
size; they have deeper bodies and lower rims and are, essentially, of amphora shape, but
made with only one handle, which rises from the lip.
i Berlin F 1682; Neugebauer,Fiihrer,pl. 8; Payne, NC, p. 344.
example is Louvre 514, illustrated in Stackelberg, Grdberder Hellenen, pi. IX.
3 cf.
Wide, fig. 80. An exaggerated example of the late shape, dating from about the middle of the
seventh century,is illustratedin A. A., 1934,pp. 211-212,fig. 9.
4 The
pitcher from Dipylon Grave XIII, Wide, fig. 74.
2 The earliest
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
208
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Lekythoi such as were found in the pyre, XII 9-12 (figs. 39 and 40), are late and rare.
Our examples, some of which are very small, must have been specially made for funerary
use. Late Geometric lekythoi of greater size were found at Anavysos and date from about
the end of the eighth century. The shape may have been borrowed from Crete; 1 it is not
unlike that of the ordinary Protogeometric lekythos, but no early Geometric examples
pointing to a continuous life and development of the type have been found.
Late Geometric oinochoai are of two types. The first, with tall, rather plump body and
wide trefoil mouth above a shallow necking, seems to be an invention of the late eighth
century and continued to be made through the seventh. Miniature oinochoai of this shape,
but with very round body, have been found in early Geometric groups at the Agora; the
shape is essentially the same as that of our IX 16 (fig. 24). IX 15 and VII 8 are variations
of the shape with nearly conical body. C 123 (fig. 127) is a seventh century example of
full-size oinochoai of the type; similar Protoattic oinochoai were found in the votive deposit.2 A later example of the third quarter of the seventh century3 is taller, narrower,
and slimmer in its proportions; late Geometric examples found in a well group of the late
eighth century at the Agora are lower and plumper, resembling our IX 17 (fig. 24). The
development of the shape, then, is from a short plump body to a taller less rounded one;
in the course of time the necking becomes shorter, and the trefoil mouth wider and flatter.
The second, and commoner, type of oinochoe goes back to early Geometric times. It
has a rather tall neck and rounded body. An early oinochoe of this type was found at the
Dipylon in the Warrior Grave.4 Its body is tall and pointed, and stands on a ring foot;
its neck is slightly concave in profile. As the shape develops the neck becomes nearly
straight and the body lower and plumper; the ring foot is replaced by a low base. XX 7
(fig. 67) illustrates the development; XIIlI (fig. 43) with flat bottom and very plump round
body belongs to a later phase. Oinochoai of the shape of XllI 1 are often decorated with
large concentric rings on their sides, as C 114 (fig. 133); the decoration is Cypriote in origin,
and must have been brought to Attica after the middle of the eighth century.5 The type
was continued into the seventh century; late Geometric and subgeometric examples, VI 4
(fig. 18), IX 12 (fig. 24), and C 113,115 and 117 (figs. 122 and 125) are of the same shape
as XIII 1. Some subgeometric examples, XI 16 (fig. 33), XII 8 (fig. 39) and C 118 (fig. 122)
show a deepening of the body and widening of the neck; they may have been influenced
"
b)y Early Protocorinthian oinochoai. Later Protoattic oinochoai like B 1 (fig. 74) certainly
show Protocorinthian influence.6 Round-bodied Protoattic oinochoai continued to be made;
1Late Geometric and early orientalizing Cretan lekythoi, B. S. A., XXIX, 1927-28, pl. IX, 8-9.
Hesperia, I, 1933, pp. 591 ff. and figs. 59-60; nos. 211-213.
Hesperia, VII, 1938, p. 417 and fig. 5; D 17.
4 A.A.,
1934, pp. 241-242, fig. 27.
5 Oinochoai with this decoration are listed and discussed by
Schweitzer, Ath. Mitt., XLIII, 1918,
pp. 143ff. Two examples from Marathon, Praktika, 1934, p. 36, fig. 9. Another is in the Empedokles
collection. See also Wide, figs. 90-91.
" Such Early Protocorinthian oinochoai as Payne, PV, pl. 7.
2
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
209
examples like C 119-120 (fig. 125) show an upward tapering of the neck not to be found
on earlier vases of the type.
In addition to oinochoai of the two regular Attic types, examples of various shapes were
found which may have been influenced by other seventh century fabrics, or may have been
the results of experimentation on the part of the potters. B 71 (fig. 98) is close in shape
to Late Protocorinthian oinochoai, and may have been made under the influence of Corinth.l
Vases with round mouth and handle to the middle of the neck, like our C 122 (fig. 122),
were occasionally made in the early seventh century. Squat short-necked oinochoai like
IX 13 (fig. 24) may have been made under the influence of Cretan models; 2 similar
oinochoai were found in the Isis Grave. The oinochoe seems to have been a shape that
lent itself to experiment; our IX 14 (fig. 24) and B 73 (fig. 98) are without parallel.
Numerous oinochoai of unique form were found in the Phaleron cemetery; some Protoattic
examples are quite fantastic in shape.':
The three hydriai V 1 (fig. 14), X 1 (fig. 27) and C 148 (fig. 137) are late Geometric
and subgeometric vases of simple decoration which find Geometric (" Parian") and orientalizing parallels in the Cyclades.4 C 148 lacks both neck and foot. V 1, with body more
pointed and less curved in its lower part, and with Ihigher, more flaring ring foot, than X 1,
is later and shows again the trend of the late eighth and seventh century to deeper, more
pointed body, and more flaring foot. The fragmentary hydria XI 7 (fig. 33) would seem
to have been of about the same shape as X 1 and V 1. The well-known hydria from Analatos 5 is of different type. Its body is long, narrow, and pointed, and its neck very wide.
In form it is like our amphoras C 138-139 (fig. 132), but with higher, more flaring foot.
The width of the neck, like that of our oinochoai XI 16, XII 8, and C 118 may be due to
the influence of Protocorinthian. Early seventh century hydriai like the one from Analatos
have pierced walls of clay uniting the vertical handle to the neck; the plastic snakes with
which they are decorated are often put on in Ipairs, Xan(dare very small and thin in coilparison with late Geometric snakes."
Amphora types are numerous. Early Geometric amphoras have tall, rather narrow neck,
slightly concave; plump rounded body, sloping upward at the shoulder, and low, flaring
ring foot.7 With the passage of time the body becomes slimmer an(d more pointed, less
curved in its lower )part; tlhe neck becomes wider an(l shorter, less concave, and more flar1 Comparethe Late Protocorinthianoinochloai,Payne,
NC, fig. 10, shape A, and pl. 11, 3 which is
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
210
RODNEY S. YOUNG
ing at the top; and the foot becomes higher, losing its flare. Our XI 1 (fig. 32) shows most
of the changes that took place. An amphora in Leyden,' made at about the end of the
eighth century, has an ovoid body still well curved in its lower part; the neck is nearly
straight, and the high ring foot flares only slightly. Of nearly the same shape, but with
slightly more flaring neck and foot, is an early seventh century amphora at Eleusis.2 The
Nessos amphora -in New York, of the second quarter, near the middle, of the seventh
century 3 is noticeably more developed: the foot is more flaring, the body more pointed and
straighter in its lower part, the shoulder is flatter, and the neck more flaring. The Peiraeus
amphora,4 dated by Payne early in the last quarter of the seventh century,5 and something
more than a generation later than the Nessos amphora, shows the further development of
the shape. The foot is very flaring, and the body still more pointed; the shoulder is flatter
and meets the neck at a sharp angle. The development is the same as that followed in the
two-handled bowl; the time it took, again slightly less than three generations.
A number of the Agora amphoras of the late eighth and early seventh century have the
same kind of neck and mouth, but bodies of different shape. XI 1-2 (fig. 32) have bodies
of the normal late Geometric ovoid shape; VIII 1 (fig. 21) and XV 1 (fig. 48) are probably
from amphoras of the same shape. XII 1 (figs. 37-38) and C 138-139 (fig. 132) are slimmer
and taller, following the seventh century trend toward tall thin shapes. VI 1 (fig. 16),
VII I (fig. 19) and C 136 (fig. 131), on the other hand, have very plump rounded bodies;
VI 1 has a heavy round lip. These three amphoras fall between the ordinary Geometric
type the development of which we have traced and a balloon-bodied type, C 127 (fig. 128),
made throughout the seventh century and probably used for the export of wine or oil.
Many of the children's burials in the Phaleron cemetery were made in amphoras of this
sort, and many fragments were found in the votive deposit and in our well: C 127-133.
There can be little doubt, then, that they were made in Attica. Their decoration is conventional and very simple; the body is glazed, with reserved bands around the shoulder, and
the neck is reserved and decorated with wheels, concentric circles, or diminishing triangles
between wavy lines. Amphoras of such simple decoration can hardly have been exported
for their own sake as pottery; yet they have been found as far afield as Daphne in Egypt,
Gela, and Etruria. Clearly, then, they were sent out containing some Attic product which
was exported all over the Mediterranean-presumably oil. Amphoras of this shape appear,
moreover, on the early Athenian silver coins. Seltman has suggested, very plausibly, that
the amphoras shown on the coins represent the vessels in which oil was exported from
Attica." Our balloon-bodied amphoras are closer in shape to those represented on the coins
Brants, Beschrijving, 52; pl. VII.
Eph. Arch., 1898, pl. 3, 2.
3 J. H. S., XXXII,
1912, pls. X-XII; Pfuhl, MuZ, pl. 19, 86-87.
4Eph. Arch., 1897, pl. 5; Pfuhl, MuZ, pl. 19, 88.
5
Payne, NC, chronological table of early Attic black figure on p. 344.
" C. 1. Seltman, Athens, Its History and Coinage, pp. 7 ff., fig. 5, and pi. 1.
2
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
211
than are the Tyrrhenian amphoras, which Seltman suggests contained the Attic oil. Balloonbodied amphoras, moreover, continued to be made until the end of the seventh century and
later; our II 1 (fig. 8) is a late example of the series. A definite development of the shape
may be traced; the two types of lip, torus and echinus, seem to have been equally used
throughout. Early examples have very plump body, high, almost vertical ring foot, and
a short straight neck with a raised ring below the lip. In the course of time the body
becomes slimmer and more pointed toward the bottom, the foot more flaring, and the neck
slightly concave. At some time after the middle of the century the neck-ring disappears.
Our C 127 is a rather early example; the type, however, does not seem to go back into the
Geometric period, and probably began to be made about 700.1 It might be noted here that
C 136, a simply decorated vase with the body of a shape suggesting that it was a vessel
of capacity, is decorated with a wheel ornament which also appears on early coins,2 and
bears a graffito which may have been intended to indicate the number of measures that it
could contain.3
The wheel was used as a neck ornament before balloon-bodied amphoras were made.
The amphora from Dipylon Grave XIII4 has wheel-ornament on its neck; it is of a short,
-plump, shape with wide neck and round lip. The shape continued to be made into the seventh
century; it remains short and plump, but becomes more pointed. The wide neck becomes
slightly concave, and the ring foot more flaring. Our IV 1 (fig. 12) and C 146 (fig. 135)
are well developed seventh century examples of the shape; an amphora of about the end
of the eighth century from the Dipylon is less developed, and falls between our seventh
century amphoras and the amphora from Dipylon Grave XIII.
Our Geometric, subgeometric and Protoattic vases from the Agora show that a continuous development of shapes may be traced through the period during which they were
made. Most vase forms were made with a definite function in view, and as the functions
for which pottery vases were intended cannot have changed very greatly, it is natural that
old forms should continue to be made. A few Geometric shapes died out; and a few Protoattic products resulting from experimentation appeared. Most of the Protoattic forms,
however, were short-lived and had no effect on the subsequent development of shapes; many
were fantastic forms which could not replace well established shapes that had been handed
down from early times and continued to be made for the reason that they best fulfilled the
functions for which they were intended.
1 The earliest amphora of this type found in a dateable context is from Grave 47 at Phaleron, in
which was included a Protocorinthian skyphos (Johansen, pl. IX, 6), of a shape dated by Payne late
eighth and early seventh century: C.V.A., Oxford, pl. 1, 30 and 31. The Phaleron skyphos is more
developed than 31, but is not decorated with rays.
2 Seltman, op. cit., pis. II-IV, and pp. 35 ff.
On the graffito, see below, p. 223.
4Wide, fig. 48; Hampe, pl. 32, N. M. 770.
5 Hampe, pl. 32, Kerameikos 337.
14*
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
212
RODNEY S. YOUNG
ORNAMENT
The repertory of decorative elements handed down from early Geometric times was
small. The simple hatched meander was the most complicated, as well as the most. significant, of the early ornaments. In addition to the meander, such elementary devices as
chains of lozenges, rows of dots, tooth-pattern, and zigzag, were used. Occasional representations of horses and birds, animals familiar in daily life, appear. The design is applied
either in bands running around the body of the vase, or in small rectangular panels reserved
at the front and back. With the passage of time new devices were invented, and the
scheme of decoration extended to cover the whole surface of the pot. The framework of
band and panel decoration remained; the decoration, however, was adapted to the form of
the vase. Wide bands of decoration emphasize the important parts of the shape-neck and
shoulder; panel decoration fills the handle-zone. The choice of ornament is closely confined
to strictly Geometricmotives, and its application to a rigid decorative scheme.
After the middle of the eighth century. the old band and panel decoration begins to dis-
integrate. The old "triglyph and metope" arrangement of square panels separated by
narrow vertical stripes disappears; the " triglyphs " increase in width and prominence until
they are of greater importance than the " metopes." The metopes themselves are sometimes
divided horizontally into narrow upper and lower panels; often they are used, not as part
of a metope and triglyph system, but as interruptions in what is essentially running banded
decoration. Some of our big pyxides, XVII13-17 (fig. 54), illustrate the break-up of the old
metope and triglyph decoration as well as the combination of band and panel ornament;
XVII14, by way of contrast, illustrates the regularity of the older system. The shaking off
of the bonds of the rigid Geometric decorative scheme was completed by the middle of the
seventh century. Protoattic vases go to the extreme of freedom from any restraint; the
ornamentation is often spread all over the surface with no relation to the form it decorates.
It was the task of the later seventh century to bring order again out of chaos, to reimpose
in modified form the order and discipline of the Geometric tradition, and to create the com-
bination of freedom and restraint that became the hall-mark of Classical art.
Many motives appear on vases from our late eighth century graves which are not found
on early Geometricpottery. Favorite motives of this sort are interlocking latticed triangles,
peaked triangles, chains of dotted lozenges, rows of dots or dotted rings linked by tangents,
lozenge stars, complicated and cascading meanders, and leaf bands. All of these, with the
possible exception of the last, are motives of purely Geometric character; most of them
continued to be used in the orientalizing style. With the first wave of oriental influence
after the middle of the eighth century came in a number of new devices that are not truly
Geometric at all: human figures, snakes, lions, deer and goats, coursing hounds; later,
strange birds, hooks, rays, and vegetable ornament. With the subgeometric decline of
fabric and glaze came a similar decline in the drawing of Geometric motives. Let us look
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
213
first at the purely Geometric devices as they are drawn on late Geometric, subgeometric,
and orientalizing vases; then let us consider the early orientalizing motives which appear in
the latter half of the eighth century.
The meander, the most important Geometric device, became very elaborate and complicated in the late eighth century. Only two of our vases, Xi I (fig. 32) and B 21 (fig. 82),
show elaborate late meander; more complicated ones were used, however, on the monumental Dipylon amphoras and large pitchers.1 At the same time as the elaboration of the
meander came also its simplification; it began to be drawn as a single line instead of
a double outline with hatching. A number of vases from the Isis Grave in Eleusis show
a simple line meander; 2 although none of our Geometric vases uses the decoration, it
appears on the orientalizing fragment C 89 (fig. 115) and was frequently employed in the
black-figured style. The simple key-pattern, a less complicated kind of meander, began to
be drawn as a single line at about the same time. Single line key pattern appears on our
XI 4 (fig. 32) and XV 1 (fig. 48), both Geometric, and on the orientalizing fragment C 90
(fig. 115). The swastika, earlier outlined and hatched, appears on late vases as a simple
linear hooked cross: XII 9 (fig. 39), XVIII 6 (fig. 61) and C 60 and 63 (fig. 112). Like
the meander, the swastika was often complicated in the late Geometric style; the ends of
the arms were turned inward.' The simple hatched meander did not cease to be made at
the end of the Geometric period; an elaborate Protoattic vase, and a Protocorinthian
skyphos, show that Geometric meander continued to be used into the seventh century.4 In
the late eighth century, though, it was sometimes put to unusual uses, as when it was run
up and down as a division between panels; it is so used on a late amphora from Eleusis 5
and on our C 134 (fig. 130). Late Geometric and subgeometric painters, too, often saved time
in the hatching of meanders and swastikas by making straight strokes perpendicular to the
outlines, instead of filling them with careful diagonals (XX 5, fig. 67; C 78, C 103, figs. 115
and 119). The line meander of the seventh century is paralleled on Protoattic pots by the
running spiral, drawn in much the same way as the meander; running spiral appears on our
fragment C 95 (fig. 115), on the Nessos amphora in New York, and on an oinochoe at
the Dipylon which may be by the same hand.6 The adventures of the Geometric meander
in the seventh century as contrasted with the career of the Protoattic running spiral
typify the experimentation of the seventh century, and much of its result. The line
meander was freely used and abused; on such vases as the Peiraeus amphora 7 it was made
almost incredibly complicated, but it emerged as its simple self in the black-figured
As Pfuhl, MuZ,III, pls. 1 and 3.
2 C.V.A., Athens,
I, pl. 4, 8 and 16; pl. 5, 5.
3 As on the
pitcher from Dipylon Grave XII, Wide, fig. 74.
4
Protoattic, Grlaef-Langlotz, pl. 12; Acropolis 345. Protocorinthib.n, Hampe, pi. 40; mentioned and
G Nessos
7
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
214
RODNEY S. YOUNG
style.1 The Protoattic spiral, on the other hand, disappeared as suddenly as it appeared;
like much Protoattic ornament, it made a strong momentary appeal to the potters, but was
later dropped.
Line meander and key pattern were simplifications that saved time; quick methods used
for the hatching of Geometric meanders have already been noticed. The aim of the sub.
geometric potter seems to have been to produce many small cheap vases; he devised shorthand methods of drawing, and his haste resulted in a loose and careless ornamentation.
Subgeometric versions of Geometric ornament were used in subsidiary zones and as filling
ornament on orientalizing vases down to the middle of the seventh century.
A favorite late motive, the lozenge-star, appears on our B 18 (fig. 80). It is carefully
made; a square was drawn, filled with checker-board, and bordered; then triangles were
added at the sides and latticed. Similar lozenge-stars appear on two of the ribbon-handled
bowls from Dipylon Grave XIII. A later one fills a panel on VI 2 (fig. 17); it is carelessly
drawn, and the triangles have become more pointed. It is subgeometric, but easily recognizable nevertheless. A quick method of making the same motive, used by subgeometric and
orientalizing potters, appears on XII 1 under every team of horses (figs. 37-38); the square
has become a lozenge, and the added triangles have been replaced by a St. Andrew's cross
inside the lozenge, its ends projecting beyond the sides. Hasty shorthand lozenge-stars of
this type or with sharp-pointed triangles added at the sides become the regular filling
ornament under horses and lions of the Protoattic style.2 A glance at the checker-board on
B 18 and on VI 2 shows again the subgeoimetric shorthand method of drawing; the Geometric example is both careful and even, the subgeometric one neither; it looks like a, poorly
constructed wall of small bricks rather than a checkered band. B 18 is decorated with
a zigzag band, and a succession of sigmas. The same motives appear in subgeometric guise
on XI 2 (fig. 32); the zigzag is uneven, and the sigmas have become mere short vertical
wavy lines. The zigzag as it is used on late Geometric vases is very tall, pointed, and
narrow as compared with its drawing in early Geometric; the pyxis XVII 14 (fig. 54) is
decorated with several bands of steep late zigzag, a favorite decoration for narrow bands.
Several lozenge chains appear on the amphora fragments XV 1 (fig. 48) and C 134 (fig. 130);
the decoration is sometimes used ten or twelve times over on a single late Geometric vase.3
Lozenge chains were used fairly early; in late Geometric times they were dotted, and in subgeometric decoration they became crooked and uneven (as on XI 2, fig. 32), were combined
to make net-pattern (as on XI 7, figs. 33-34), or were decorated with hooks at their apices (as
on XII 1, figs. 37-38).
A zone of net pattern decorates the lower body, and a band of
hooked net-pattern the neck, of the Analatos hydria. Net-pattern, often dotted, was
a favorite motive on late Corinthian Geometric and Early Protocorinthian vases.4
1 As, e. g., on Pfuhl, MuZ,pl. 62, 242.
2 Analatos Hydria, Jhb.,
II, 1887, pls. 3-4; krater in Munich,Jhb., XXII, 1907, pl. 1.
3 Like the vases Pfuhl, MuZ,
III, pls. 1 and 3.
4
Like Johansen,p. 9, figs. 5-6, and p. 47, figs. 16 and 19.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
215
The degeneration of two other late Geoinetric motives, the leaf-band and the chain of
dots or rings linked by tangents, is perhaps worth noticing. The leaf-band as used on
such late Geometric vases as XVII 15 (fig. 55), B 14, and B 76 (figs. 80 and 94) is composed
of rather thin pointed leaves, sometimes outlined, and always hatched; they are even and
carefully drawn. The leaves on XVII 17 (fig. 56) and C 77 (fig. 115) are plumper and less
pointed; those on XVII 17 consist of diminishing outlines, and are not hatched at the centre.
The bands on C 138-139 (fig. 132) show plump blunt leaves, unevenly drawn, and filled
at the centre by a straight line. VI 3 (fig. 18) is decorated with still more degenerate
leaves; they are not only plump and uneven, filled at the centre by a straight line, but they
have been left open at their outer ends. A zone of leaves drawn in the subgeometric manner
decorates the lower body of the Protoattic krater in Munich.1
Rows of dots linked by tangents decorate XVII 9 and 14 (fig. 54), XX 4 (fig. 67), and
C 136 (fig. 131). The large round dots are carefully drawn and evenly spaced. On XVIII 2
and 6 (fig. 60) dotted rings are used instead of plain dots. VII 7 (fig. 20) and IX 7-8
(fig. 24) show the subgeometric way of making the same ornament; the dots have become
elongated blobs and are no longer evenly spaced.
Two decorative devices which appear at the end of the Geometric period are worthy of
notice. The first, round-ended petals in panels such as decorate XV 2 (fig. 48) and XXV 3
(fig. 72), may have been inspired by metal work. A kantharos in Boston is made with
godroons and clearly inspired by a metal model; the godroons are decorated as round-ended
petals.2 The method of decoration, given the nature of the pot, could hardly have been
avoided; on our examples it has been transferred to flat surfaces.
A second device is vertically banded decoration. On three of our very late Geometric
pots, XI 5 (fig. 32), B 11 (fig. 80) and C 103 (fig. 119), appear widely spaced vertical bands
with filling of fine vertical lines between. The effect is more orientalizing than Geometric;
we have noticed that accentuation of the vertical, as in the expansion of the "'triglyph "
and the vertical use of the meander between panels, begins only at the end of the Geometric
style. Vertical banded decoration was used in the seventh century; our oinochoe C 121
(fig. 122) uses vertical bands, omitting the fine lines between. An oinochoe with similar
decoration, dated in the third quarter of the seventh century, was found in the Agora and
has been published.3
With the close of the eighth century the old handle ornaments, bars and St. Andrew's
crosses, began to be replaced by double and triple wavy lines running down the outer face
of the handles. On the amphora C 136 (fig. 131) the St. Andrew's crosses which decorate
the handles are bisected by wavy verticals; on the very late amphoras C 158-139 (fig. 132)
the handles were decorated with triple wavy verticals; and on the seventh century amphoras
IV 1 (fig. 12) and C 146 (fig. 135) single wavy lines decorate the handles. At the same time
1 Jhb., XXII, 1907,pl. 1.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
216
we begin to note the influence of Corinth; the old Attic decoration with wide horizontal
bands, as on XIV 1 (fig. 46) begins to be displaced by the narrower linear Protocorinthian
decoration, as on our C 81-82 (fig. 114). C 79-80 with banded decoration are in the Attic
Geometric tradition; C 81-82
geometric drawing; the subject is dismal enough. The latter half of the eighth century
did not invent only purely Geometric motives; a new figured decoration began to appear.
The end of the eighth centulry and the first half of the seventh saw not only the decline of
Geometric ornament, but the improvement of figured. The centre of interest had shifted;
the plotters were willing to expend their skill on elaborate figured scenes <andfloral ornament, while they filled in the subordinate zones with Geometric decoration done in a very
perfunctory way. The best Geometric vases are those of the last quarter of the eighth
century, which are decorated with elaborate and carefully done Geometric ornament and
enlivened by figured scenes. Let us look at the various kinds of animal life that began to
appear on Geometric vases toward the end of the eighth century; then let us consider
human figures, horses, and floral ornament, and the development of their drawing.
Snakes, deer, goats, lions, and hounds coursing foxes and rabbits, appear toward the end
of the Geometric style. Winged hybrids and centaurs are somewhat later. Most of the same
animals make their first appearance at Corinth in the Early Protocorinthian style of the
second half of the eighth century. Corinth probably got them from the east; from Rhodes
and Cyprus by way of Crete and Thera. Attica, generally thought to have been backward,
in early Greek times, and to have had no great shipping or commerce of her own, probably
got her new repertory of animal and floral ornamen att second hand from her more enterprising neighbors, Corinth, Aegina, Chalkis and Eretria. For this reason the orientalizing
style was perhaps somewhat retarded in Attica; but also it is highly probable that Attica,
with a stronger tradition of Geometric art than any of her neighbors, confined herself at
first in the choice of new elements to those which fitted well into the Geometric scheme.
When the Attic potters finally yielded to the full orientalizing-at
the end of the eighth
century--the inrush of new motives and experiments was so great and so sudden that the
resulting Protoattic style was one of the most chaotic in all Greek vase painting.
The coursing hound, although he is a comparative late-comer among the animals, may
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
217
a skyphos of Protocorinthian shape.' Since in two cases shape and decoration were probably
taken over together from Corinth, the suggestion is very strong that the Attic potters got
the coursing hound, as well as many other early orientalizing animals, through Corinth.
Snakes, which we find on Attic Geometric vases either drawn as snakes (C 134, fig. 130),
applied in plastic form (XII 1, figs. 37-38), or conventionalized into wavy rings (XVIII 6,
fig. 61; B 14, fig. 80), first appear at Corinth in the Early Protocorinthian style.2 The snake
was probably one of the earliest of the oriental motives to reach Attica; he must have been
adopted shortly after the middle of the eighth century. Probably he was of cllt significance;
he is often applied in plastic form to funerary vases.
We know that the snake was
associated with the dead in Mycenaean times and again in the Classical period; probably
the old serlent cult lingered on in the east, to be re-introduced into mainland Greece with
the first wave of orientalizing influence after the middle of the eighth century. rThe snake
outlined with dot rows probally had much influence on late Geometric decoration; perlhaps
from him were derived the wavy line ornament as used on IX 3 and 6 and XIV 1 (figs. 24
and 46) and the wavy dot rows as on XI 2 and XVII 10 and 11 (figs. 32 and 54). Short
wavy lines used as filling ornament on the funeral amphora Xl. 1 (figs. 37-38) were probably intended to represent snakes.
Deer, goats, and fish appear on late Attic Geometric vases. Fish and deer first appear
at Corinth on Early Protocorinthian pottery. Reindeer with branching antlers do not
ap)pear on Attic vases; but they are a favorite ornament on the gold bands of Attic manifacture that often have been found in late Geometric glraves;:; the reindeer first appears in
Corinth on the Early Protocorinthian vases. Goats with head turned back appear on
our C 134 (fig. 130) and on monumental Dipylon amphoras; they are certainly oriental,
and probably Rhodian, in origin.
The lion appears in Attica and in Boeotia at the end of the eighth century.5 The first Attic
lions are drawn on a very late kantharos in Copenhagen; " like many Boeotian lions, they
are engaged in man-eating. Similar man-eaters appear on the Attic gold bands. The late
Geometric lions are very thin matchstick creatures which have need to be fattened; the
abandonedat Corinth for a half century between the true Geometricand the Middle Protocorinthian
styles. Much Corinthian Geometric pottery must be contemporary wvithEarly Protocorinthian. Payne,
in PV, calls the bowl in Toronto "late Geometric*'; PV, pl. 3; Hampe, pl. 22; Robinson, Ilarcum and
Iliffe, Greek Vases in Toronto, no. 113.
3 The gold bands are listed by Kunze, Kretische Bronzereliefs, Anhang 1, p. 265. Reindeer on Protocorinthian, Johansen, pl. VII, 3, and XIV, 1. One Attic example, C.V.A., Denmark, II, pl. 73, 5.
4 Pfuhl, MUZ, III, pl. 1; C.V.A., Athens, I, pl. 8.
5 Hampe, pl. 24, V 8.
6 C. V. A., Dennark, II, pl. 73, 5 b.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
218
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Protoattic painters fattened them. The lions which appear on the Analatos Hydria I have
filled out considerably; they are still drawn in silhouette, with reserved round eyes; they
probably were drawn in the first quarter of the seventh century. The lions on our C 87
(figs. 117-118) seem to have been somewhat more developed; they were made in silhouette,
but with outlined faces. The lions on the krater in Munich are still plumper, and more
developed in their drawing; 2 the krater and our fragment belong in the second quarter of
the seventh century. On the Nessos amphora in New York 3 the lion is well filled out,
but still eating; he is drawn, not too successfully, full-face. The accomplished drawing
of the lion on an oinochoe from the Votive deposit at the Agora suggests that it should
be placed at about the middle of the seventh century, while the Burgon lebes and the
oinochoe from Phaleron,4 which may be by the same hand, are perhaps even later. The
partially preserved lions on our fragment C 145 (fig. 134) seem to be already of the type
used constantly in the later seventh and sixth centuries as members of animal friezes. In
the drawing of ravening lions, sometimes heraldically opposed, and with the heads in
outline, the Attic potters were probably working under the influence of Boeotia and the
Cyclades rather than of Corinth.
The development in the drawing of the lion illustrates the advances made by the painters
of the first half of the seventh century. They filled out the thin angular lions of the Geometric style, added many details, and put them in motion. The same advances were made
in the drawing of men and horses; let us look at the gradual development of drawing from
late Geometric to mid-seventh century chariot scenes.
The chariot procession around the body of a monumental Dipylon krater5 is typical
of the figured scenes of the last quarter of the eighth century. The horses are stiff, thin,
and static; teams of two are represented in a very literal way by the addition of the
forepart of the farther horse in front of the nearer. The human figures in the funerary
scene above are long and very thin, schematically drawn with triangular chests, and
with little attempt at the representation of the features. The filling ornament is sparse and
strictly Geometric-birds and swastikas, zigzag and chevrons, dot rosettes and rows of
dots. A monumental amphora from the Dipylon6 decorated with a prothesis scene has
similar sparse filling ornament and similar tall angular figures. The only attempts made
at the rendering of features are the reservation of a dot for the eye, and the addition
of a projection for nose and chin.
Perhaps twenty years later-more than half a generation-are our XIII 1 (figs. 43-44),
an amphorain the National Museum,the krater from Dipylon Grave III, and a bowl in the
i Jhb., II, 1887, pls. 3-4.
2
Jhb., XXII, 1907, pl. 1.
3 J.H.S., XXXII, 1912, pls. 10-12.
4 Hesperia, II,
1933, p. 596, fig. 61; Pfuhl, MuZ, pi. 17, 82-83.
5 Monumenti,
IX, pl. 40, 1; Buschor, fig. 20.
6
Pfuhl, MuZ, pl. 1; C. V.A., Athens, I, pl. 8.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
219
British Museum.1 The horses have filled out and become rounded; they are beginning to
move. Those on the Dipylon krater are trying to gallop; one team on our XIII 1 is walking
forward with stiffly-bent front legs. The human figures, too, have filled out somewhat; they
are not as tall and thin as those on the earlier vases, and they are more rounded. Eyes
are represented by reserved rings instead of dots; noses and chins by loops of glaze instead
of projecting knobs. The filling ornament has thickened; late vases like our XII 1
(figs. 37-38) and C 134 (fig. 130) show new elements in the filling ornament: blob-stars,
plump verticals surrounded by dots, birds, snakes, and wavy lines; our subgeometric
fragment IV 2, fig. 13, shows the first floral filling ornament. Two amphoras in the Metropolitan Museum demonstrate the advances made in the first quarter of the seventh century;
also the disparity in the products of two contemporary artists in a period of experimentation.
The first 2 is very close in style to the hydria from Analatos, and may be by the same hand;
the tall slim shape with wide neck, the drawing of women and of lions, and certain elements
of the filling ornament are the same on both vases. The horses of the New York amphora
show a considerable advance over our earlier examples; not only are they plumper and
closer to reality in their proportions, but they are rendered in greater detail: the eyes and
ears are represented, and looped outlines have replaced the spiky Geometric mane. The
representation of motion has been mastered; the team advances at an even and
dignified pace. The representation of a team, too, has improved; the farther horse has
retired behind the nearer, and only his head and the upper part of his neck are added
at the front. The human figures also show advance in their more natural proportions
and in the addition of such details as hair and clothing. The filling ornament has again
thickened, and oriental elements such as the reverse spiral have been added; no use
was made, however, of the elaborate floral decoration which appears on the Analatos
hydria.
The second amphora in New York3 is in some ways more advanced, in others more
backward, than the first. The horses are very thin and schematic; nevertheless, their
hindquarters are of natural proportions, their manes are represented by loops of glaze, and
they advance at the same stately walk. The representation of a team has, however,
improved; the farther horse has retreated entirely behind the nearer, and now both heads
spring from a single neck. The human figures, like those on the other New York amphora,
have reserved eyes and long hair; they are dressed in long skirts. The faces of figures on
some fragments in Phaleron,4 which may be by the same hand as the second New York
amphora, are drawn crudely in outline. A heraldic orientalizing bird used as filling
Wide, fig. 56; Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pp. 92 and 104 and fig. 4; J.H.S., XIX, 1899, pl. VIII,
and Hampe,pl. 22.
2
MetropolitanMuseumBulletin, 1911, p. 33 right.
3 MetropolitanMuseumBulletin, 1923, p. 176; Corolla
Ludwig Curtius,pl. 41.
4
Eph. Arch., 1911,p. 250 and figs. 11-13. On one of the Phaleronfragments,as on the New York
amphora,a personage is representedas carrying a roll of drapery ending in fringes over his shoulder.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
220
RODNEY S. YOUNG
ornament on the neck of the amphora finds an almost exact parallel on a Middle Protocorinthian aryballos.1
The two amphoras in New York are probably again about twenty years-more than
half a generation-later
than our very late Geometric examples. Slightly more advanced
is our B 80 (fig. 99). Of the horses only the necks and heads are preserved. The manes
are rendered in incision; the faces are drawn in careful outline. The human figures, too,
have their faces drawn in outline-well done, considering the scale. The filling ornament
of hooks ending in palmette-like flowers and bands of running dog is orientalizing; but
Geometric zigzags remain.
The Nessos amphora in New York,2 to be dated just before the middle of the seventh
century, is perhaps twenty years later again than the other two New York vases, and
slightly later than B 80. It represents the culmination of Protoattic experiment; on it
are combined all the technical methods-incision,
outline drawing, added color; all the
filling ornaments animal, vegetable, and Geometric; and all the advances in the rendering
of human figures and teams of horses, that can be found on the vases of the first half
of the seventh century. The humans and the horses have reached natural proportions
and are ready to be taken over into the black-figured style. Outline drawing of faces
has been mastered; it needs only to be refined and perfected. By the middle of the century
figures like the sphinxes on our B 1 (figs. 74-75) are being drawn. B 1 shows in advance
what is to be the task and the accomplishment of the third quarter of the century: to
bring symmetry and restraint to the chaos of earlier decoration, to develop the technique
of incision, and to thin out the jungle of vegetation that has overgrown every nook and
cranny. The palmette-cross of B 1, symmetrical and carefully placed in relation to the
rest of the decoration and to the shape of the pot, contrasts strongly with the similar but
asymmetrical floral ornament running wild over the surface of C 65 (fig. 113). Floral
ornament on Protoattic pottery does not follow a gradual development. Although small
plants occasionally appear on such subgeometric vases as on our IV 2 (fig. 13) at the
beginning of the seventh century, elaborate and full-blown vegetation appears suddenly
in the first quarter of the century on vases like the Analatos hydria. Rather less elaborate
floral decoration was used on early orientalizing vases at Corinth in the latter part of the
3
eighth century; an aryballos of the first black-figured style4 has decoration like that of the
Analatos hydria. If we are right in assuming that orientalizing decoration came late to
Attica through Corinth, Aegina, Euboea, and the Cyclades, and that the Attic potters, who
were engaged in making late Geometric vases far in advance of any achieved elsewhere,
excluded all new elements but those which 'fitted into the Geometric scheme, then the
1 Johansen, pl. XXII, 2 d; Payne, PV, pi. XI, 1-5. Late in the first
black-figuredProtocorinthian
style; near the end of the first quarterof the seventh century.
2
J.H.S., XXXII, 1912, pis. X-XII.
3 As
Payne, PV, pls. 6-8.
4 Payne, PV, pl. 9, 3-4.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
221
explanation of the unevenness of the Protoattic style is easy: when the barrier of tradition
was finally broken early in the seventh century, new techniques and new decorative motives
were taken over together from all sides, some already well developed. This is demonstrated
by the Protoattic vases themselves. Each painter chose those elements or technical devices
that appealed to him; thus one vase,1 decorated with elaborate incision, is backward in
its drawing of human and animal figures; the Analatos hydria, with advanced floral and
ornithological decoration and heraldically opposed lions, yet has human figures little
better than those on late Geometric vases, and a conventional subgeometric band of
grazing deer; one of the amphoras in New York,2 with little or no filling ornament and
human figures still subgeometric in character, has yet achieved the representation of a
team of horses advancing abreast-but the horses themselves are still like the matchstick
Geometric beasts. An unpublished hydria neck at the Agora 3 bears a procession of women
rather crudely drawn, and early; yet they wear skirts covered with added white. In a
style as mixed and free, but at the same time individual, as the Protoattic it should not
be difficult to pick out the hands of various painters.4 Nevertheless, through the maze
of experimentation with incision, polychromy, and outline drawing, with lions and strange
birds, with floral and animal filling-ornament of all sorts, there runs the thread of a
continuous development in the drawing of the human figure, of lions, horses, and teams.
The thread may be followed directly from the late Geometric to the early black-figured
style. Much of the Protoattic ornament of the first half of the seventh century is highly
appealing and entertaining; but most of it is irrelevant. Before the Attic vase painters
could achieve the black-figured style they had to make trial of every technical and ornamental device. Much had to be discarded in the end; but the half-century of experiment
well served its purpose, and at the same time produced some of the most fascinating and
amusing vases ever made in Attica.
Foreign influence on the shapes and decoration of late Attic Geometric ware has been
noted from time to time. Cyprus, Crete, Corinth, Boeotia, and the Cyclades all contributed.
Corinth, a maritime trading city which began early to export pottery, had the greatest
influence. Early Protocorinthian vases, and Attic imitations of them, are rare in Attica
proper; Eleusis, lying at the crossroads between Attica, Boeotia, and the Isthmus, has
produced more Early Protocorinthian than any other Attic site. Middle Protocorinthian.
on the other hand, has been found in greater quantities not only at Eleusis, but at
Phaleron, Anavysos, and in the Agora. The influence of Corinth, weak in the eighth century,
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
222
RODNEY S. YOUNG
increased in the seventh. Chronologically, we might equate late Attic Geometric with
late Corinthian Geometric' and Early Protocorinthian; Early Protoattic, at first strongly
influenced by Geometric, and later freely orientalizing, with Middle Protocorinthian;
and Late Protoattic-polychrome
vases of the third quarter of the seventh century,
like the amphora from Kynosarges2-with
Late Protocorinthian and Transitional vases.
Early Protoattic pottery was little exported and very little has been found outside
of Attica; 3 Corinth supplied the market for finer wares. Attica did, however, export
oil throughout the seventh century in simple amphoras like C 127 (fig. 128). With
the beginning of foreign influence and the importation of foreign wares into Attica
after the middle of the eighth century, we should expect to find a corresponding
exportation of Attic ware. Attic Geometric has, in fact, been found outside of Attica.4
For almost all the vases and fragments found outside of Attica, parallels can be
cited in the graves at the Agora, the Dipylon, and Spata. The Geometric exports,
then, like the graves, belong after the middle of the eighth century, and the exportation
of Attic ware began at about the same time as foreign influence began to be felt in Attica.
Corinth, known as an early maritime power, is thought by Payne 5 to have come into
contact with the already orientalizing east through Thera and Crete at about the middle
of the eighth century. Athens, which did not become a considerable maritime and trading
power until nearly two centuries later, and which was hemmed in on all sides during the
period of early commercial expansion by the important trading centres of Chalkis and
Eretria, Aegina and Corinth, probably did her trading with the outer world through her
neighbors. It might be noted here that almost all the Geometric vases imported by the
west, and the local vases made in the west in imitation of imported Geometric,6 are very
late Geometric and subgeometric in style, and should be dated at the very end of the eighth
and in the early seventh century.
1 Late CorinthianGeometric:A.J.A., XXXIV, 1930, p. 411, fig. 5;
Hampe,pl. 22.
J.H.S., XXII, 1902, pp. 29 ff. and pls. II-IV.
3 Most of the Protoattic.fromthe find in Aegina is later than the middle of the seventh
century.
4 Attic exports are listed by Pfuhl, MuZ,p. 72. Finding places are Crete (Vrokastro)and Cyprus
(Curium);Thera (to Pfuhl's references might now be added the amphora,Berlin F3901, Neugebauer,
Fiihrer,pl. 3). The sherds from Delos and Rheneiaare now published,Delos, XV, pp.90 ff. and pls. XLIff.
The fragmentfrom Syracuse,Not. degli Scavi, 1895,p. 189,has been discussed above, in the introduction;
it is a fragment of an amphora like Wide, figs. 64-68. Two amphorasof this sort were among the
Attic importationsfound in Thera. The vase found in Corcyrais mentionedby Smith, J.H.S., XI, 1890,
p. 175. " We have in the tomb of Menekratesfrom the KorinthianCorcyra,among a quantity of fairly
developedKorinthianpottery, one oinochoe which is Dipylon in form, technique,and ornament." The
tomb of Menekrates,a cenotaph, is well known for its archaic inscription: I.G. IX, 1, 867; the date
suggested for it is the beginning of the sixth century, and the vases found in it are described, with
epigraphicalscorn, as " aliquot vasa parva fictilia."
2
these vases are, as might be expected, Cycladic and Corinthian;the Chalcidianswere the first settlers
in the west, and no doubt the first Greeksto trade there.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
223
It is not intended to infer that there was no intercourse between Attica and the outside
world before the middle of the eighth century. Occasional intercourse there must have
been; but of a regular commerce and exchange of manufactured goods there is no trace.
Imports from farther afield than Attica's near neighbors were probably brought by itinerant
traders. The ivory of which were made the figurines found in Grave XIII at the Dipylon
did not come from anywhere in the Greek world.1 Perrot and Kunze are both of the opinion
that the statuettes were carved in Attica. Their context we have seen to be of the late
eighth century. The gold used for the bands found in Attic graves 2 must also have been
imported. The gold bands are thought to have been made in Attica; they give evidence
then of a very flourishing metal working industry in the Attica of the late Geometric period.
The influence of metal work is apparent in many late Geometric vases. Very shallow
skyphoi with widely flaring lip and long handles like our XXV 1 (fig. 72) and C 40
(fig. 108) have been thought to be under such influence; the shape gives every indication that
it is taken from metallic models. Kantharoi and pitchers made with godroons 3 show metallic
influence; the latticed petal decoration often used on jugs may be in imitation of godroons.
Handles with out-turned ends, as used on ribbon-handled bowls and spouted basins,4 are
probably influenced by metalwork. Ribbing as used on krater bases and pyxis handles is
probably also metallic in origin. The strong influence of metal work on Attic vases
suggests, then, that there was a considerable Attic metal industry. A number of bronze
vases has been found in Attica; the number is small, probably because bronze is very
rarely found in a condition that renders its preservation possible.5 Although the number
of bronze vases preserved is small, the Attico-Boeotian fibulae and Attic gold bands are
products of a technically advanced and artistic metal industry.6 A gold necklace and
1 B.C.H., XIX, 1895, pp. 273 ff. (Perrot); Ath. Mitt., LV, 1930, pp. 147 ff. (Kunze). Hampe has dated
these figurines in the late eighth century (pp. 36 ff.); Kunze in the late ninth. We have seen reason to
confirm Hampe's dating and reject Kunze's; the ivory was then imported into Attica after regular commercial relations with the outside world had begun.
2 Listed
by Kunze, Kretische Bronzereliefs, Anhang I, p. 265. A gold band with incised subgeometric decoration was found with the two probably Attic amphoras, Wide, figs. 46-47, in a grave at
Troezen. It is illustrated by a drawing in Delt., 1889, p. 164.
3
Kantharos, Boston 271; Fairbanks, Catalogue, pl. XXII; pitcher, Wide, fig. 77.
4
Spouted basin: Collignon-Couve, pl. XII, 218.
"Une tasse de cuivre " from the Dipylon, Poulsen, p. 11, Wide, p. 127, note 22. A "hemispherical
bronze pot" in Eleusis, which was used as a receptacle for bones, Eph. Arch., 1898, p. 114; a bronze pot
used as a lid over a Geometric vase, also from Eleusis, Eph. Arch., 1889, p. 178. A tripod and basin
from the Pnyx, Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, pp. 414 ff. A bronze urn with a lid from Grave III at the Dipylon,
Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 93 and figs. 4-5. A lid, Annali, 1872, p. 136. At Phaleron, a bronze pyxis and
lid were found in Grave 14; Delt., II, 1916, p. 16. A bronze basin from the Dipylon, A. A., 1934, p. 243.
I have seen a well-preserved bronze bowl from an early Geometric grave in private possession at Athens.
6 The fibulae are listed by
Blinkenberg, pp. 147 ff., under the Attico-Boeotian classification; Hampe,
who calls them Boeotian, lists (pp. 90 ff.) 156 examples; to his list might be added a silver fibula from
Eretria, Ath. Mitt., XXXVIII, 1913, p. 295, fig. 4, and a bronze fibula from Dreros, B.C.H., LX, 1936,
p. 487, fig. 29. We have seen reason to believe this type of fibula to be Attic as well as Boeotian.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
224
RODNEY S. YOUNG
bronze bracelets were found in Grave 3 at Spata,l showing that the Attic metal workers
could also turn their hands to fine jewellery. A number of Attic bronze statuettes were
found on the Acropolis and elsewhere.2 There seems, from the number of finds of various
sorts, to be good evidence for a flourishing Attic industry in the later eighth and seventh
century; undoubtedly many bronze vases also were made, which have since perished, but
which had strong influence on the pottery of the period.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
225
used as handle decoration on late Geometric vases.1 The human figures XI 18 (fig. 36),
XII 19-21 (fig. 40) and XII 24 (fig. 42) are very crudely modelled; here and there incision
or added pellets and strings of clay indicate details such as fingers and hair. The subjects
chosen for modelling, however, are of interest. The mourner with arms raised to the head;
the charioteer standing in his car guiding his team; and the enthroned figure-all are
subjects which the Geometric potter painted over and over again on his vases. Bronze
models for chariot groups he may have had; but mourners and enthroned figures were
probably taken from his repertory of painted scenes.
The first coroplast, then, was the potter. He first made figures of horses, birds, and
snakes to ornament his pots; then he made them free-standing. All the early figurines are
made of the same relatively coarse clay as the pots, and are decorated with the same glaze.
A little early seventh century horse from Grave IX at the Dipylon,2 made of potter's clay
and glazed, was covered with decoration of added white. He is the first of the polychrome
figurines of the seventh century in Attica.
Subgeometric figurines of potter's clay,
decorated with glaze, continued to be made through the seventh century; 3 our C 183-184
(fig. 143) are examples. At the same time figures began to be made of fine soft terracotta,
and to be decorated with white, red and blue paint. Our B 50 (fig. 87) and C 182 (fig. 143)
are examples. Horses have become better proportioned, with more barrel-like bodies; the
tails are applied against the back leg, and do not hang to the ground. The terracottas
of poor clay were by-products of the potteries; those of finer terracotta may have been
made by artisans who specialized in figurines and plaques. Probably not until the invention
of the mould, however, did specialization in the making of terracottas begin. No large
terracotta heads of the Dedalic type, dateable to the decade,4 have been found in Attica,
where the art of making terracottas began in an humble way under the influence of
bronzes, and was first used for the ornamentation of vases.5
THE GRAFFITI (Fig. 144)
The earliest Greek inscriptions are incised on vases and sherds. The dating of these
vases may not be decisive on the problem as to when the alphabet was actually introduced
into Greece, since it will always be argued that earlier inscriptions may exist which have
not been recovered. Nevertheless, such dating does give information as to the time by
which alphabetical writing had become known, furnishing a terminus ante quem for the
introduction of the alphabet.
As on the pitcher from Dipylon Grave XIII; Wide, fig. 74, Hampe,pl. 32.
Ath. Mitt.,XVIII, 1893,pl. VIII, 2.
3 Third quarterof the seventh century,
Hesperia,VII, 1938,p. and fig. 10, D 30 and 32.
4 R. Jenkins, Dedalica, Cambridge,1936. SubgeometricDedalic heads can apparently be dated as
2
5 Since the above was written I have discovered that a small terracotta
horse, which moved on
wheels, is included in an early Geometricgrave group at the Kerameikos.
15
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
226
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Seven early inscriptions from the Agora are published here,' of which six are graffiti
and the seventh a dipinto. The crosses and bars incised on the rims and lids of pyxides
of the last quarter of the eighth century (as XVI 1, fig. 50) do not necessarily imply a
JC
Fig. 144.
/6\J16
-CAL6
Drawing
CM
by Piet de Jong
Four of the Agora inscriptions, demonstrably seventh century or later, do not need
lengthy comment. B 47, incised on a fragment of tile, is probably sixth century and was
found with sherds of the sixth century. B 56 is a fragment of an amphora of a common
seventh century type; its glaze suggests that it belongs in the second half of the century.
C 39 (fig. 107) bears a dipinto inscription giving the name of its owner; we have seen good
reason to date it near the middle of the seventh century. B 55 (figs. 89-90), Tharios'
cup, is of the same shape as C 39; it was decorated in the same manner as subgeometric
skyphoi characteristic of the seventh century. In shape it is more developed than the
1 Two more, Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 563, nos. 81-82, and fig. 23. No. 81 is on a fragment of a subgeometric cup or skyphos like C48-50, fig. 108. No. 82 can give no information as to its shape, style,
or date; nor is the incision sufficiently preserved to give assurance that a letter of the alphabet was
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
227
skyphos of the end of the eighth century at Eleusis; it should probably be dated, like
C 39, near the middle of the seventh ceritury.. Note has been made of the fact that its
inscription was incised before firing. The excellence of the lettering on Tharios' cup and
on the dipinto skyphos from the seventh century well is probably due to the fact that it was
done by the potter himself, whose hand was-quite used to fine drawing with pencil and brush.
The same may be noted with regard to the "advanced " lettering of the sherds found in Corinth.2
The one-handled cup C 48, from the seventh century well, has a seemingly meaningless
graffito. Another cup of the same sort, also bearing a meaningless graffito, was found at
Eleusis.3 This type of cup is subgeometric and has been fqund in three Agora deposits
of the seventh century; it does not appear in Geometric graves or well groups. The
evidence of the Agora finds is confirmed by grave groups in the Phaleron cemetery, where
such cups,are also found with middle Protocorinthian and Protoattic vases.4 The dating for
this type of cup is important, because, of the twenty-one " Geometric" sherds with incised
lettering found on Mount Hymettos, sixteen are cups, or fragments of cups, of this
shape.5
1
were cut...
In later Corinthianpottery incised details were done after a first partial firing." If the
inscribed sherds from Corinth are as early as they are said to be (750-725) then the Corinthian potters
were capable of elaborateand developed incised lettering at a time when they were using incision for
decorative detail in a clumsy and experimentalway, and only r]arely. Johansen notes (p. 51) that
incision was employed only here and there, without method, in the later phases of the early Proto-
corinthian style (750-700; cf. Payne, PV, p. 20-" friiher orientalisierenderStil "). If the incised in-
scription from Corinth dates 750-725, and the earliest Protocoirinthian vases employing incision date
725-700 (probably,in fact, later), then one Corinthianpotter must have mastered the technique of incision, as well as the letter forms of the alphabet,far ahead of any of his contemporaries. The Attic
potters who tried their hands at incising letters did not reach the same level until the middle of the
seventh century, at least seventy-five years later. It might be further noted with regard to the sherds
from Corinth, that though they come from a closed deposit, the date of the closing of the deposit is
not given. Presumablythe drain for which they served as a bedding was not Geometric. The context
of the smaller fragment of the inscriptionA-B, which was found elsewhere,is not given. Fragment C,
on which the glaze has fired orange-red, is marked by three thin lines across the top where the glaze
has fired black. The phenomenoncan be due only to the presence of a triple band of added color-red
crGwhite-when the vase was fired. Decoration with multiple bands of added color was not a Geometric,
noi even an early Protocorinthian, device. The fragment C should probably be dated well down toward
the middle of the seventh century. Since this was written, the sherds from Corinthhave been discussed
by Carpenterin A.J.A., XLII, 1938,pp. 58 ff. He employs some of the same argumentsagainst an early
dating that I have suggested, and adds some others.
3
Delt., II, 1916, pp. 42-43. Fig. 44, 2 and 6, are from Graves 48 and 32; both graves of the second
quarter of the seventh century. Fig. 45, 1 and 2, are decorated cups of the same shape; 45, 11 is a
4
developed form of the same shape, and was found in Grave 18 a, a grave of the last quarter of the
seventh century.
5 A. J. A., XXXVIII, 1934, pp. 10ff., and pls. I-III. They are nos. 1-6, 8-9, 11-14,16-18, and 20. It
might
be noted here that of the other sherds from Mount Hymettos, which are all seventh century, no. 10
(ibid., p. 17, fig. 5) is a shallow plate of the type found in the seventh century well, with a wavy line
decoration below the rim as on sherds from the Agora votive deposit (He-speria, II, 1933, p. 586,
15*
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
228
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Of the Agora graffiti there remains the sixth, the amphora fragment C 136 (fig. 131).
We have seen reason to date the fragment at the very end of the eighth, or beginning of
the seventh century. The symbol incised on its neck may possibly be intended to represent
If it is, it is unlike any other early epsilon; those incised on the
the letter epsilon.'
oinochoe from the Dipylon and on the sherds from Hymettos2 have downward-slanting
horizontal strokes set above and below, not at, the ends of the vertical hasta. If the bird
and wheel decoration of the amphora is to be interpreted as symbolic or magical,3 a similar
interpretation may be found for the epsilon-like symbol incised on it.4 It is perhaps more
probable that a numerical figure is represented by our graffito; the vertical incision at the
left may stand for a large unit, perhaps five, and each of the horizontals for a single unit;
the "epsilon" then represents the number eight.5 Thus a number of interpretations are
possible for this graffito; since, however, it is no earlier than the earliest incised alphabetical
inscription known, it can afford nothing new as evidence for the dating of the introduction
of the alphabet.
The inscription scratched on the oinochoe from the Dipylon remains the earliest. The
inscription itself has been illustrated countless times; to the best of my knowledge there
has been only one illustration, a poor drawing, of the vase on which it is incised.6 The
drawing does not accurately show the shape of the vase, which is the same as that of our
XIII 1 (fig. 43). In our discussion of XIII 1 we have noted that the shape is often decorated
with Cypriote concentric rings, and that it continues to be made into the seventh century.
The Dipylon oinochoe, evidently more developed in shape than the first of the oinochoai
decorated with Cypriote concentric rings, should be dated, on the evidence of its shape, at
the end of the eighth century or later. The decoration of its neck, grazing deer and bird,
is such as is found on vases of the end of the eighth and the early seventh century. It
would seem difficult to date the Dipylon oinochoe earlier than 700.
fig. 47); no. 15 (p. 21, fig. 7) should probably be restored rather as a Phaleron oinochoe like the one
publishedby Hampe,p. 38, fig. 19; no. 19 (p. 23, fig. 9) is from a Protoattic jug like Jhb., II, 1887,p. 50,
fig. 9, with decoration of subgeometricgrazing horses of a sort used well into the seventh century for
the subsidiarybands of Protoattic vases. Two of the Hymettos sherds, nos. 7 and 21, are nondescript,
with no decoration or indication of shape to enable them to be dated. Blegen notes that no. 22 is
considerablylater than any of the others, coated with excellent black glaze.
A.J.A., XL, 1936, p. 193 and fig. 8.
2 J.
Kirchner,Imagines InscriptionumAtticarum,pl. I, 1-3.
3
On the symbolism of this motive, see the monograph of Miss Roes: Greek Geometric Art, Its
XXIX, 1925, pp. 239 ff. I am indebted to D. M. Robinson for this reference.
5 Such a
system of incised horizontal and vertical bars, interpreted as representing prices, was in
use in the fifth century; see Hesperia, IV, 1935, pp. 514ff., nos. 85-88 and fig. 28. Such units, it need
hardly be remarked,cannot on our amphorarepresentunits of coinage.
6 Ath. Mitt.,VI,
1881, pi. III. A numberof other illustrations(in Baumeister,Ducati, and elsewhere)
are all taken from the same drawing.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
229
Another sherd has been used as evidence for the early appearance of the alphabet in
Greece,l a small fragment from the Acropolis with painted letters and part of a meander.
The meander, however, is not confined to the Geometric period; a fine meander is used on
the seventh century vase, Acropolis 345.2
A fragmentary oinochoe found in Sicily has on its bottom a scratch which has been
thought to represent letters.3 It appears to be a subgeometric vase of Cycladic fabric.
Although the dating for Cycladic pottery has not yet been established, the decoration on
the oinochoe (verticals and sets of vertical wavy lines) is much the same as that employed
on Early Protocorinthian oinochoai of the late eighth century, and on subgeometric Middle
Protocorinthian vases down to the middle of the seventh. It would seem difficult to date
the oinochoe before 700; on the other hand, it may well be considerably later.
All the inscribed vases and fragments can be dated about 700 and later; a vase bearing
an alphabetical inscription of the eighth century has yet to be found. From the earliest
inscription, that on the oinochoe from the Dipylon, we know that the alphabet was brought
to Greece before 700; how much before seems to be as yet undecided. Perhaps noteworthy
is the fact, however, that the alphabet used on the oinochoe from the Dipylon is not Attic,
(broken-barred iotas, and non-Attic lambdas); the inscription may have been scratched by
a foreigner on a visit to Athens.
CONCLUSION
The comparison of the vases from our group of burials in a family plot at the Agora
with the Geometric, Protoattic, and Protocorinthian pottery from the well has shown that
there is good reason for the belief that the Geometric style reached its highest development
in Attica at about the turn from the third to the last quarter of the eighth century. Geometric vases continued to be made until the end of the century, but there were traces of
degeneration. The subgeometric repertory of shapes and decoration continued in use beside
the orientalizing down to the middle of the seventh century and later. The late Geometric
period was one of activity and mild experiment; a few new motives appropriate to Geometric decoration were adopted from the Orient and used on Geometric vases; horses and
birds were modelled and used to decorate the pottery. At the same time the influence
of a strong local metal working industry made itself felt in the shapes and decoration
of pottery.
Attica lingered behind Corinth in the adoption of orientalizing motives by about twenty
years or a quarter-century. No doubt the reasons were that Attica did not have direct
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
230
RODNEY S. YOUNG
contact with the east, and that she did have a stronger Geometric tradition than had any
of her neighbors; she carried Geometric decoration to a higher development than did any
other part of Greece. The Geometric style is the true reflection of a feudal and provincial
society, conservative and narrow in its outlook, and strictly confined to agricultural interests
within the limits of small localities. With the opening of the eastern trade routes in the
middle of the eighth century and the sending out of colonies to the west shortly thereafter
came an awakening and a change of outlook. Commerce, bringing in new methods and
new ideas, took its place beside agriculture, and the merchant his place beside the
landowner. Corinth and the cities of Euboea led the way; their colonies and their trade
spread to the north and west. Attica lingered behind; she had no fleet, nor did she have
industries that produced products for export. Her trade was limited, and confined to her
near neighbors. In the seventh century Corinth had monopolized the markets for finer
pottery, Corinth and Aegina the markets for bronzes; down to the time of Solon Attica
was exporting oil, the product of her soil, not of her manufactories, in coarse pots. The
awakening came slightly later to Attica, then, than it did to Corinth; Attica, without a
fleet of ships of her own, did her trading, and took new ideas from the outside world,
through her neighbors.
The change from the Geometric to the Protoattic style is one from restraint and
repetition within a set form to freedom and individual expression. It is the change from
a feudal and agricultural society to an industrial and commercial society. It reflects the
change from epic to lyric poetry. Hesiod, who seems to have lived at the crucial period,
describes the earlier world; his interests were local and agricultural, his poetry in the old
epic tradition, repeated and handed down by rote. He voices a distrust for change and
adventuring; the traditional methods and patterns of life are best. With the new age
comes a new expression. The subjective lyric poets are interested in emotions and personalities; they have been freed from the restraint of traditional forms. Lyric poet and
merchant have replaced epic poet and landowning aristocrat in the new world. The former
for his literary expression, and the latter for his commercial pursuits, have need of a
method of writing; perhaps the Phoenician alphabet was not the least useful or important
of the new devices brought to the orientalizing world of Greece from the east.
The period from 750 to 650, then, was one of extraordinary activity and awakening.
In the first years we note a gradual change and loosening of old styles, ideas, and prejudices; a small but steady intercommunication throughout the Greek world, and a limited
adoption of new devices. Toward the end of the eighth century, while the old society
continues to preponderate in Attica, the new gains strength at Corinth. By the early
have a complete change;
seventh century we whaith
the new outlook on life comes a period
of experimentation from which, after half a century, begin to emerge the outlines of the
more familiar world of archaic Greece.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
231
APPENDIX I
A LIST OF GRAVES AND IMPORTANT GEOMETRIC AND PROTOATTIC VASES, WITH THEIR
PROBABLE DATING
Late Geometric vases, many of them very big: monumental amphoras and kraters,
large pitchers, pyxides and bowls. Pyxides with nearly straight side walls; skyphoi,
cups, jugs, and kantharoi with low base instead of ring foot, amphoras and pitchers
with high vertical ring foot. Plastic ornamentation with birds, horses, and snakes.
Good fabric and glaze, careful Geometric decoration. First orientalizing influence on
ornament: figured scenes, snakes, goats; wavy lines and rows of dots. Traces of foreign
influence-Cypriote, Cretan, Boeotian, Early Protocorinthian-on shapes and decoration.
Ivory figurines and gold bands.
Agora: Graves XV, XVI, XVII, XVIII, XX.
Dipylon: Grave III, Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 104. Wide, figs. 51, 88, 97, 99.
Grave XIII, Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 127. B. C. H., 1895, p. 273. Hampe,
p. 36.
Eleusis: Grave XIX, Eph. Arch., 1898, p. 83.
Spata: Grave 1, Delt., VI, 1920-21, p. 132, figs. 2-3.
Monumental Dipylon Amphora, Pfuhl, pl. I, C.V.A., Athens, pl. 8.
Ivory Statuette, Hampe, pl. 31.
B. LATE EIGHTH-EARLY
SEVENTHCENTURY.
Beginning of the breakup of the Geometric style; careless drawing and the use of
shorthand methods. Small vases flat-bottomed; slightly flaring ring feet on larger vases.
scenes and moving processions. First attempts at
Figured scenes in motion-battle
outline drawing. First appearance of many orientalizing motives: coursing hounds,
fish, lions. Appearance of added white, and of incision. First floral ornament, and first
free-standing terracotta figurines. Stronger Protocorinthian influence.
Agora: Graves VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, XIII, XIV, XXV.
Dipylon: Grave VII, Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 111 and fig. 10; Wide, fig. 75.
Grave IX, Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893, p. 117 and pl. VIII, 2.
Grave published by Hampe, p. 38 and fig. 19, pls. 32-33.
Eleusis: Isis Grave. C.V.A., Athens, I, pp. 4ff. and pls. 3-6.
Grave a, Eph. Arch., 1898, pp. 103 ff.
Spata: Grave 3, Delt., VI, 1920-21, pp. 134-137, figs. 5-10.
Grave 4, Delt., VI, 1920-21, pp. 137-138, figs. 11--12.
Liossia: C.V.A., Denmark, II, pl. 70, 2-8 and 10.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
232
C. FIRST
QUARTER
OF THE SEVENTII
CENTURY.
Small subgeometric vases, very careless in fabric and decoration; deep, pointed
skyphoi, cups and kantharoi. Amphoras and bowls with somewhat flaring foot. Middle
Protocorinthian found in fairly large quantity, and freely imitated. Plentiful floral
ornament; added white and incision used experimentally; considerable advance in the
technique of outline drawing. Great variety in kind and quality of decoration, in
accordance with preferences of various artists for outline drawing or incision, figlred
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
233
Fragments from Phaleron; Eph. Arch., 1911, p. 250 and figs. 11-13.
Hydria in Berlin; Ncugebauer, Filhrer, pl. 7, 31312.
Hydria from Analatos; Jhb., II, 1887, pls. 3-4.
Fragments from the Acropolis; Graef-Langlotz 345, pi. XII.
Oinochoe from the Agora; Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 595, fig. 60.
D. SECONDQUARTER
OF THESEVENTIICENTURY.
E.
Elaborate floral ornament and the perfecting of drawing in outline. Rounding and
filling out of the figures of men and horses. Subgeometric ornament continues to be
used, and simple cheap subgeometricvases to be made.
Agora: Graves III-IV.
Dipylon: A.A., 1934, pp. 217-220, figs. 14-15.
Phaleron: Graves 18, 27, 32, 37, 48, Delt., II, 1916, pp. 19 ff.
Grave 18, Johansen, p. 93 and pl. XXI, 1; Delt., II, 1916, p. 29, figs. 15-16.
Grave 32, Johansen, pl. XXIV, 1.
Grave 48, Payne, C.V.A., Oxford, II, p. 59, 10. Payne dates the grave "not
earlier than the first quarter of the seventh century." The skyphos, Delt., II,
1916, p. 32, fig. 22, 2 makes it later.
Amphorain New York; J. H. S., XXXII, 1912, pls. 10-12.
Krater in Munich;Jhb., XXII, 1907, pl. 1.
Bowl from Thebes; Jhb., II, 1887, pl. IV.
Oinochoe from Dipylon; A.A., 1934, pp. 215-216, fig. 12.
Oinochoefrom Agora; Hesperia, II, 1933, p. 596, fig. 61.
Agora B1, B2, B 45, B 55, B 64, B 68, B 69, B 71, B 80, B81; C31, C 39,
C 65, C 87, C 98, C 119, C 145, C 151.
(B 1, B 45, B 64, B 68, B 69; C 39, C 65, C 145 about mid-century).
THIRD
CENTURY.
The perfecting of the black-figured technique; regular use of incision, plentiful use
of white and purple; gradual thinning of filling ornament.
Phaleron: Graves 71, 78, Delt., II, 1916, pp. 19 ff.
Burgon lebes in London; Pfuhl, pl. 17, 82.
Oinochoe from Phaleron; Pfuhl, pl. 17, 83.
Amphorafrom Kynosarges; J. H.S., XXII, 1902, pls. II-IV.
Fragment, 26tes Hallisches Winckelmannsprogrammn,,
pp. 10 ff., and other
stamnoi, unpublished, from the same find.
Unpublished vases recently found at Vari.
Agora: Well deposit, Hesperia, VII, 1938, pp. 412 if.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
234
F.
RODNEY S. YOUNG
LAST QUARTER OF THE SEVENTII
CENTURY.
Early black-figured vases. The Peiraeus amphora, and the Nessos painter. Beginning
of the group of vases decorated with incised birds and rows of dots at about the end
of the century.
Agora: Grave II.
Phaleron: Graves 18 A, 33, 59, Delt., II, 1916, pp. 19 ff.
APPENDIX II
THE ISIS-GRAVE
disregarded, as it was by Skias (Eph. Arch., 1898, p. 120) and by Schweitzer (Ath. Mitt.,
XLIII, 1918, pp. 64 ff.), who thought von Bissing's dating (after 750) of the scarabs too late
for the other contents of the grave. Schweitzer dates the grave, on stylistic grounds, in the
ninth century; Poulsen also (Die Dipylongrdber und die Dipylonvasen, pp. 85 ff.) dates it early
both on stylistic grounds and because it lay in the lowest stratum of the Eleusis cemetery.
Johansen, on the other hand, accepting von Bissing's dating of the scarabs, dates the graves
of the Eleusis cemetery late (Gott. Gel. Anz., 1907, pp. 695 ff.). Furtwangler (Antike
Gemmen, III, 1900, p. 441) states that the Geometric graves of Eleusis belong in the last
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
235
phase of the period, that they are no older than the eighth century and that, in all probability, they extend down into the seventh.
The establishment of the dating of the Isis Grave is important because the vases found
in it have been used to demonstrate early steps in the Attic Geometric style, and because
fibulae found in it have led Hampe, who accepts Schweitzer's ninth century dating of the
grave, to the unfortunate suggestion that the same type of fibula was used in Attica in the
ninth, and in Boeotia in the late eighth and early seventh centuries (Hampe, pp. 3 and 5;
the fibulae, nos. 24-27). The dating of the Isis Grave might conceivably, too, be of help to
a fragmentary ivory pin with incised decoration. The gold earring (Eph. Arch., 1898,
pi. 6, 6) is similar in style to the gold necklace found in Grave 3 at Spata (Delt., VI,
1920-21, p. 136, fig. 10), a grave dating from the end of the eighth century. Both earring
and necklace are decorated with pendants and with halved Boeotian shields. Ivories were
found in late eighth century graves at the Dipylon: Graves XI and XIII (Ath. Mitt., XVIII,
1893, pp. 120 if.). Grave a at Eleusis, a grave contemporarywith the Isis grave, contained
a similar earring and a fragment of an ivory pin, similar fibulae, clay spheres, amphoriskoi,
hand-made tripods, and spouted feeders with strainer tops and basket handles. Grave a
contained also a small terracotta horse; the horse may have come from the lid of a late
eighth century pyxis or amphora, or have been made free standing like the one from
Dipylon Grave IX, a grave of the early seventh century (Ath. Mitt., XVIII, 1893,
pl. VIII, 2, 9).
The Isis Grave contained sixty-eight vases, most of which were small and carelessly
made. Not unnaturally among such a large number, some are much earlier than others.
The grave should be dated, however, by the latest objects found in it, and not by the earliest.
Vases that are certainly early are the amphora and the kalathos, C. V.A., Athens, I, pl. 3, 1
and pl. 6, 8. Possibly early also are the pyxides pl. 5, 4, 11 and 12, and the skyphos
on a ribbed stand pl. 6, 5. These vases may have been taken from earlier graves and
re-used; many graves in the Eleusis cemetery were disturbed by later burials. The hydria,
pi. 3, 2, seems to be of the same fabric as our X 1; its shoulder is divided into two panels
by "triglyphs." The small oinochoai, pl. 3, 7 and 10 and 12-13, and pl. 4, 5-7 and 11,
are like the oinochoai from our Grave IX and from Graves 3 and 4 at Spata (Delt., VI,
1920-21, p. 134, fig. 8 and p. 138, fig. 12), all graves of the end of the eighth century.
The jugs, pl. 3, 14-15 and pl. 4, 2-4, find a parallel in the grave from Liossia in Copenhagen (C.V.A., Denmark, II, pl. 70, 8), which also contained a small oinochoe like those
from the Isis Grave (ibid., no. 3). The miniature pot, pl. 3, 5, finds its nearest parallel in
fabric and decoration in Grave 64 at Phaleron (Delt., II, 1916, p. 46, fig. 50). The skyphos,
pi. 6, 4, is of the same shape as the Eleusis skyphos decorated with a late figured scene,
Eph. Arch., 1898, pl. 5, 1-1 a. Two pyxides (pl. 5, 5 and pl. 5, 17-6, 1) are decorated on
the bottom with quatrefoils and leaf bands which find parallels in our Graves XVIII
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
236
RODNEY S. YOUNG
and XVII. The latter of the two pyxides is decorated with a zone divided into four long
panels filled by zigzags, chevrons, a row of leaves, and a procession of birds. Not only
the scheme of the decoration, but also the drawing of the birds, is late; compare the birds
with those on the pitcher, Wide, fig. 72. The amphoriskoi pl. 4, 10, 12, 15, 17-18, 20-22,
are of a late sagging shape clearly later than that of our amphoriskos, XVII 19. Open
work kalathoi (pl. 6, 10-11) are late, with nearly straight, rather than concave, side walls.
Similar open work is used on the lid-handles of late pitchers: from Anavysos, Praktika,
1911, p. 122, 20; from Dipylon Grave VII, Wide, fig. 75a. Late decorative motives are
used as well as late shapes in the Isis Grave; in addition to leaf bands and late birds,
single-line meander (pl. 4, 6, 8 and 16; pl. 5, 5), wavy rows of dots (pl. 3, 6, 14 and 15;
pl. 4, 2; pl. 5, 10, 11 and 12), and dotted lozenge chain (pl. 6, 6), appear. A clay ball of
the sort found in the Isis Grave and Grave a was found in our seventh-century
well,
in. the Isis Grave, the jewellery and many of the vases find parallels in Attic graves of the
late eighth century. The Isis Grave should probably be dated shortly before 700; its
pottery is provincial and consists of small careless vases.
APPENDIX III
GEOMETRICATHENIANS
ANGEL
By J. LAWRENCE
This appendix does not report on the racial types of Geometric Athens, nor even
summarizethe racial strains apparent in the burials dealt with by R. S. Young. It considers
only age and sex characters of skeletons of six fragmentary individuals (the seventh has
been sent to the American Museum of Natural History for study), as well as the existence
of family traits in the group, and the conclusion indicated by these characters. A scientifically complete report on this material would require more space and more material for
perspective than are at hand now.
In the case of burials XVII, XX, and XIV, animal bones also were present including pel-
vis, tibia, calcanea, and metapodial fragments plausibly of sheep. Of the four burials which
Young places between 725 and 700 B.C., XVII is that of an adolescent female about fifteen
years old, with short stature (141.3cm. based on femoral length), rather small cranial
and mesocephalic categories. The only observed anomaly is the retention of the second
milk molars as caps for the second permanent premolars in both jaws, and in spite of
incipient eruption of wisdom teeth.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
237
Grave XVIII is that of a subadult female of nineteen, with fused epiphyses and a pubic
symphysial face of the ridge and furrow type usual for this age, but with wisdom teeth
like XVII's quite visible in their opening crypts. The stature of 150.8 cm. is below categorical average for adult females, the skull is probably long, and the estimated cranial
capacity (1230-70 cc.) a little below the European mean for adult females. The only
anomaly is the persistence of a metopic suture dividing the frontal bone.
Burials XIX and XX formed a double grave, with XIX on top hence presumably later,
though time separation of them may be small. XX is a rugged individual of doubtful sex,
middle-aged (40-45), and of tall (160cm.) or medium (164cm.) stature depending on
whether the skeleton be female or male. The skull is mesocephalic (77.84), and large
(1460-80 cc. by the Pearson formula). Its most striking feature is a robusticity of malars
and a face width which recall the Obercassel male and other Upper Paleolithic skulls as
well as certain eskimoid mediaeval Icelanders, although in form these faces are not
mongoloid. In contrast to this, burial XIX is that of a normal male young adult (30-35),
of stature slightly below average (162cm.), and a head-form just brachycephalic (80.8).
The skull's capacity, about 1410cc., is normal for European males. Anomalies include
anterior compression of the tenth thoracic vertebra, which is light enough to indicate merely
a slouching or bent posture, and a metacarpal fracture of the left thumb, evidently healed
with some displacement. Arthritic exotoses are present on the lumbar vertebrae in a mild
degree, and the left fifth metatarsal is damaged and perhaps arthritic at its base.
Burial XIV is dated about 700 B.C. It is a young adult, probably a male, and so fragmentary that no calculations can be made for a stature which may have been average. It is
mesocephalic (76.67) and its skull is smaller than of XIX. It is curious that this man should
have lost almost all of his teeth early in life, though the cause is not obvious: it might have
been pyorrhea. Almost equally fragmentary is burial XXI. This is of a female in late
middle age (50-55), ceramically not dateable since robbed. The stature (161 cm. ?) is tall,
the cranial index (75.5) almost dolichocephalic, and the skull capacity large (1410 cc.).
This cataloguing leads to the conclusion that the Geometric inhumation group examined
is a fairly heterogeneous one of about average growth, despite the slight validity of
indirect derivations of stature and skull capacity. There are no osteologic indications of
cause of death. And if it be assumed that XXI was buried within the span of the others,
the group falls into two generation divisions: an older one, born perhaps in the decades
760-740, which includes XX, XIX, and XXI; and a younger, born perhaps from 735-15 B.C.,
including XVII, XVIII, and XIV. This division alone tends to confirm Young's opinion
that this is a family group, and there is more evidence in this direction.
The evidence consists in strong similarities of detail which stand out in contrast to
general variability of the group. The most striking of these is similarity of lower jaws of
XX, XIX, and XXI. From above these have a roughly trapezoidal form marked by strength
of the divided chin, angular body, and straight gonial regions; while from the front the
crescentic rise of incisor edges above plane of molars is almost identical.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
238
RODNEY S. YOUNG
bite of the mill-like variety, Qo that the upper incisors have been worn concavely to conform
Nwithconvexity of lower incisor row as if by a grindstonie. Such convexity in lower iiicisors
Fig. 146.
and XVlII
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
239
are even. The type of bite is a slightly overlapping one which interlocks and scissors
neatly like a crab's claw. And the forms of mouth, marked by wide middle incisors
approaching the shovel form, are almost the same, in spite of difference in palate proportions. XIV probably also had this gothic type of mandible, though its body is more
angular here. All three share the same form of very short and rather wide ascending
ramus. XIV's loss of teeth makes it impossible to decide whether his bite was of the mill
type of XX and XIX or not.
Further, less obvious, similarities occur in type of cheek bones. Similar modelling for
attachments of zygomatic and quadratus labii su)perioris muscles appears in XX, XIX,
and XXI, in spite of gross dimensional variation from very wid(l to narrow in these three
faces; XVIII probably had XX's wide malar
tendency, but her malars are very flat surfaced and unmodelled by muscles. Then XX
and XXI have the same wide swinging but
not complicated sutural pattern, while XIV'
and XXI have the same tendency of the occipital to overlap the parietal bone along the lamboid suture. The glenoid fossae (mandibular
joints) of XVII, XVIII, XX, and XIX are similar in their medium depth with a rounded postglenoid process of weak to medium development; while XIV and XXI share a narrow, deep,
type of fossa with steep articular eminence, in
-:
spite of axial shifting of condylar motion in
XIV as an adaptation to loss of teeth. Finally
the polished granular bone surface of XX, XIX, Fig.
1.17. Riglit Side of 'elvis of XVIII to show
and XIV contrasts with veneered smoothness of
typical Female IsclhiaticNotch
XVII, XVIII, and perhaps XXI.
All these are slight and specific form variations, of which inheritance (by analogy with
breeding of dogs or fruit-flies) is controlled by single or few genes. Such results as the
inheritance of a whole mandible (as opposed to that of a single definite detail of a tootll
depend almost entirely on the linked association of genes in a single chromosome: the combination is not by chance alone. When parts of such a chromosome are split during crossing-over at reduction division of the egg or sperm cell which is going to help form an
individual, that individual can inherit only part of the linkage group. Then the characters
ilfluenced by the rest of the linkage group will be affected by different genes from the
other parent, so that the resulting combination may be disharmonic (tllis assumes that the
germ cell from the second parent does not supply the changed section of chromosome).
Such dishalrmonies, as in creeper fowls, where there is a definite lack or negation of
a specific chromosome or gene in b)oth germ cells, may be lethal. In this case the occurrence
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
240
in two people of the same generation of the same type of disharmony in upper and lower
teeth rows probably can be taken as the effect of switching of linkage groups of quite
~
.
: -i?
xx
"1
*?\
different tendencies, and hence is excellent evidence for family relationship of fairly close
degree. It is also evidence for quite radical hybridization, with difference in dominance
of linkage groups. Further, the crossing-over must have taken place in the previous
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
241
generation, or earlier. So that the combination of two -diverse elements in this case would
have to be two generations back, or earlier: in the time of XX's grandfather at latest.
Even more indicative of family relationship are the dimensions and proportions of these
skulls: niultiple factor characteristics which are controlled additively by many genes on
many chromosomes, and not by single dominants or recessives whose mosaic effectiveness
until selection reduces variety to sameness of a pure-blooded strain: this is the ideal contrast. Now variety in proportions and measurements is typical of the Geometric skulls
Fig
-'
Fig. 1.50. Left
efteB
s (In
) of XX ad XIX, to
under discussion. There is no gain from premature listing of measurements and indices
here, but in the photographs this should be clear in type of headform observed from above.
Thus an examination of similarities in detailed form against a background of variety in
general proportions leads to calling these six skulls part of a famrily group in which
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
242
RODNEY S. YOUNG
knowledge of means and extremes in any given racial group whose individuals are to be
sexed skeletally. The second limitation follows: sexing can be done confidently only within
a known group, for since races differ in their virility, size, or strength, a female of one
Fig. 151. Front View of Crania of XXI (Female) and XIV (Male)
. 1.
Tp Vw
of C
Fig. 152. Top View of Crania XXI (Female) and XIV (Male)
group can appear more male in some characteristics than a male of another race. Confusion of sex characters is normal in any one individual, therefore, but usually with those
of one sex clearly predominating. Difficulty in sexing skeletons comes either when there
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
243
is very little sexual dimorphism, classically as among predynastic Egyptians who tend to
approximate a male norm and among Pueblo Indians who lean toward a female one; or
when there is hybridization of groups differing markedly in balance toward femaleness or
maleness, especially with the added effect of hybrid vigor. In general Europeans show
marked sex distinction, and skeletal sex characters are consistent. But different sub-races
cover the range from ruggedness to gracility; and in mixtures of dissimilar grades unexpected combinations blur the true sex of an individual, since there is no single criterion
or even group of two or three criteria which carry much more weight than many others.
And this sort of mixture best explains the sex criteria of the six Geometric skulls.
Fig. 153.
XVI.
Scissoring Bites,
Shovel
XVIII has capacious pelvis with wide ischiatic notch, light, small-jointed bones, and a
clearly female skull. Likewise XVII. While XIX has a fragmentary pelvis with narrow
ischiatic notch, rugged, large-jointed bones, and male skull characters. But XIV, XXI, and
XX show confusion.
XIV is a male archaeologically (hence culturally). But his skeleton is too broken by
his grave's collapse to show any characters, and the skull has many intermediate ones:
small foramen magnum, smallish brow-ridges, light muscle markings indicate femaleness; but
mastoids, transition from forehead to nose, and form of jaw point to maleness. XXI was
a robbed grave. An innominate fragment with wide ischiatic notch and large attachment
for the sacroiliac ligaments indicates femaleness almost surely. But the skull, in spite of
smoothness and a pure, steep, forehead, has male face size and long mastoids.
XX is the most difficult to sex. Burial furniture shows it socially female. Remains of
pelvis give an ischiatic notch on the wide side of medium, but with small pre-auricular
16*
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
244
RODNEY S. YOUNG
sulcus, though it is possible that if the whole pelvis were reconstructible it would have
female width. Limbs are robust, large-jointed, and a little larger than those of XIX.
Finally, the skull is large, very vigorous, with a vault like a breaking wave, and muscle
markings for the neck and face of a dictator. Yet the foramen magnum is moderate, and
damaged brow-ridges may not have been heavy. Femaleness can be read into a euryprosopic facial index, and a steep forehead. The palate, also, is not relatively large
(54x62 mm.). But on the whole the physiology of XX is too rugged to be female: her
male counterpart would be an ogre, and he may have been. In any case disharmony of sex
criteria as well as of general proportions suggests that one of the groups forming this
hybrid stock was more virile than the others. Apparently its characters tended to dominate
occasionally, just as did the female characters of Japanese gypsy moths which Goldschmidt
XVIII
Vm
Fig. 154. Jaws of XVII and XVIII, fiom in Front and Above, to show Likeness
mated to European ones with resultant series of intersex offspring. This conclusion is
stronger if XX be thought female.
Further possible evidence for slightly dystrophic mixture appears in combination of milk
molar retention, open epiphyses, and incipient wisdom teeth in XVII when this is compared
with XVIII at the same wisdom tooth stage but with fused epiphyses and a pubic syinphysis
(best single criterion of age) of eighteen or nineteen. This suggests a difference in growth
and perhaps in metabolic rates in the mixing racial groups such as might be brought out
most clearly by a strange environment with strange food. It might even have played some
part in the early deaths of the two girls. Contrast between very light bones of these girls
and those of the others is worth noting, especially since XVII shows a third trochanter on
her femur, a development for larger attachment of gluteal muscles which otherwise would
not have enough surface on this slender bone. XXI also has a third trochanter, probably
just from vigor of function: XX and XIX also show well-marked attachments for these muscles, but since the bones are heavier no third trochanters were developed.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
245
A similar effect of muscle action shows in elongated mastoids of XXI and XX, and
medium ones of XVIII when compared to XVII's small and adolescent ones. This results from
an increase in development of neck muscles, and particularly of the balancing sterno-cleidomastoideus, from carrying loads on the head. This is true notably of the women, but also
._
-*
ii_-'
Fig. 155. Crania XX and XIX, to show Similarity in Mill-like Bites, Worn Teeth, and Strong Mandibles
with High Incisor Rows
-
Fig. 156. Jaws of XXI, XX, and XIX, from in Front and Above, showing Similarity in Angulation and Shape
of the men in this group. This brings up the question of posture, and such living habits as
appear in the skeleton. XVII shows only that her rather bowed femur lacks platymeria,
being quite narrow just below the trochanters. But XVIII shows a nicely correlating combination: from vertebral measureinents she probably had a well-defined forward lumbar
curve which probably meant that her pelvis tilted enough for the hip sockets to be directly
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
246
RODNEY S. YOUNG
in plane with the centre of gravity, so that there is almost no forward torsion of the necks
of thigh bones. She shows platymeria, but as in the rest of the skeletons of this group there
is no platycnemia. But this skeleton does have medium backward tilting of the tibial head
as well as squatting facets on ankle joints. Thus the girl may have walked with her knees
bent always, and probably she often flexed her foot far at the ankle joint either in walking
up a steep hill or in squatting over her cooking. XXI's fragments are enough only to show
hyperplatymeria,as do femora of XX. XX's thighs also show the same torsion of neck as
XVIII's, but the lumbar vertebrae are lacking so that here torsion does not correlate surely
with a curving waist. XX's tibia has a less tilted head, but has squatting facets.
XIX contrasts with this balanced posture. He has lumbar orthorachy (straightness) in
which the curve probably was low down and very slight. And he has enough feinoral
torsion forward so that the pelvis probably was quite vertical with hip-sockets in front of
centre of gravity. There is also some indication that his back was a little bowed above the
waist. And he has platymeria, a straightening knee joint, and squatting facets.
The significance of these details is slight: that while squatting facets show some degree
of primitiveness usually, here there lacks narrowing of the tibias, platycnemia, which occurs
often in neolithic Europeans and other primitive peoples. There is no consistent indication
of bent-knee gait, but hints at it would be expected among any people living in a steep and
stony country. And platymeria is notably a result of much climbing and hard walking,
though there may be also some structural factor here: perhaps an economy of bone at a
place where sidesway rather than back and forth motion provides the stress to be borne.
But in general these skeletons show no lack of calcium, while their robusticity is of more
show pronounced wear, with only rare remnant of top enamel on molar cusps. XIX and
XXI both lost a few molars perhaps from decay which began when the dentine was too
exposed by wear. This wear does not seem to have been from the almost purely grinding
action of some cereal eaters (Pueblo Indians), since the teeth do not have evenly worn top
surfaces. Hence the diet was plausibly carnivorous, but had some ground cereal in it with
enough sand to increase tooth wear beyond the present civilized rate. Caries and abscesses
are not lacking except in the mouths of the two girls.
The conclusions that the skeletons have some primitive features in their robusticity,
belong to a family group, yet show a great deal of hybrid variation, can be of interest in
the formationperiod of the second height of Greek civilization, but are of slight importance
historically until more data show why they became true.
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
INDEX
Numbers in plain type refer to pages; those in bold face to the descriptionsof the objects in their
respective catalogues
Black Dipylon, 85
Black-figure, B 34-42; 5, 11, 71, 109, 168, 198, 220,
233
Blakeway, 3, 34, 222, 229
Boeotia, 32, 40, 63, 77, 79, 80, 87, 89, 90, 104, 105,
115, 124, 129, 141, 159, 168, 170, 172, 182, 196,
204, 216, 217, 218, 221
Boeotian kantharoi, 116, 159, 161, 204
Bowl, XI 10, B 16, B 44, B 62, B 77, C 85-92, C 98101, C 162-163; 203
- with ribbon handles, XI 3-4; 200, 205
- with stand, XI 8-9, XII 2-3; 205
- with two handles, C 96-97, C 102-103; 206 ff.
- Aegina Bowl in Berlin, 71, 166, 207
- British Museum Bowl, 67, 71, 206, 219, 232
- Peiraeus Street Bowl, 57, 58, 59, 176, 232
- Bowl from Thebes, 71, 166, 184, 185, 206, 233
Bracelet, XII 26; 103
Brazier, C 165; 199
Bronze vases, 223
Burgon Lebes, 134, 218, 233
Camiros, 15, 131
Centaurs, C 111; 173, 174, 224
Chariot scenes, XII 1, XIII 1, B 80, C 108; 218 ff.
- plastic, XII 24-25, C 185; 225
Checkerboard pattern, VI 2, IX 10-11, XI 3, XII 8-9,
XV 1, XVIII4 and 6, B 18, C 3, C 104; 60, 214
Children's cemeteries, 15, 16
Clothing, 17, 49, 54, 56, 63, 64, 66, 120, 121
Coins, 2, 182, 210, 211, 228
Column krater, C 111; 173, 207
Corfu (Corcyra), 4, 222
Corinth, 3, 18, 22, 40, 41, 103, 146, 154, 185, 186,
197, 216, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 229, 230
Corinthian Geometric, 111, 129, 174, 217
Corinthianizing vases, XXIII1, B 9, B 85, C 19-34;
146
Coursing hound, B 16, C 1, C 30, C 99, C 145; 170,
212, 216 ff.
Crete, 61, 70, 137, 140, 177, 186, 191, 208, 209, 216,
221, 222
Cumae, 140, 142
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
248
RODNEY S. YOUNG
Grave V, 86
Grave X, 96
Grave XIII, 2, 4, 25, 29, 48, 61, 77, 83, 89, 96, 112,
123, 158, 200, 205, 211, 213, 214, 223, 225, 231, 235
Grave XVI, 50
- Grave XVIII, 50
Grave XIX, 4
17
'EyX,VTUetLuos,
Eleusis, 4, 5, 6, 15, 16, 17, 19, 29, 40, 70, 79, 93, 116,
124, 147, 151, 152, 153, 155, 158, 165, 172, 181,
186, 188, 199, 202, 210, 213, 221, 227, 234 ff.
Isis Grave, 4, 36, 41, 43, 81, 85, 104, 168, 192,
205, 213, 231, 234 ff.
Fibula, XVII 27-32, XVIII 11-14; 17, 18, 71, 104 if.,
223, 235
Figurines, XI 18-19, XII 14-25, B 50, B 85-84, C 181187; 188, 224, 235
Fish, C 39; 70, 152, 217
Floral ornament, IV 2, B 1, B 2, B 64, B 67-68, B 72,
B 79-81, C 31, C 65, C 87, C 97-98; 216, 219 ff.
Food, Graves I, IV, IX, XXV; 17, 19, 21, 25, 36, 101
Foreign influence in Attica, 221 ff.
Francois Vase, 22, 179
Funerary rites, 19, 20, 56
Gela, 141, 179, 210
Goats, B 65, C 134; 131, 180, 212, 216, 217
Goblet, B 33
Godroons, 103, 215, 223
Gold bands, 32, 217, 223
Grave monuments, 15, 18, 71, 200
Graves, see Agora, Areopagus, Dipylon, Eleusis,
Liossia, Phaleron, Pnyx, Spata, Tiryns, Toronto,
Troezen, etc.; also Appendix I, pp. 231 ff.
Hand-made ware, IX 11, XVII 22, XXV 4, C 147,
C 154-155; 29, 199
Helen, 71
Ilephaisteion, 139
Hesiod, 230
Homer, 20
Horses, IV 2, XI 13, XI 17, XII 1, Xill 1, B 15, B 6667, B 80, B 86, C 41, C 59, C 63-64, C 107-108,
C 118, C 134, C 145, C 150; 216, 218 ff.
- plastic, XII 18, XVII15-17, XVIII6, B 50, B 83-84,
C 181-184; 224 ff., 235
Ilousehold ware, III 1, VI 5, VII 9, VIII4, IX 18, X 3,
B 4, B 51, B 63, B 82, C 156-165; 199
Human figures, XI 7, Xii I and 4, XIII1, B 1-2, B 21,
B 32, B 45, B 80; 216 ff.
- plastic, XI 18-19, XII
19-24, C 151, C 187; 224 ff.
Hut urn, C 149; 186
Hydria, V 1, X 1, XI 7, B 2, C 148; 209
- Analatos Hydria, 26, 46, 49, 67, 134, 149, 168,
172, 184, 187, 209, 214, 218, 220, 221, 233
Ialysos, 54
Iliad, 20, 56, 57, 68
Incense, 20, 56, 80, 191
Incision, XI 19, XII 14, 22-23, XVI 1-2, XVII 13-14,
22, B 1, B 45, B 57, B 68, B 80-81, C 39, C 111,
C 127; 197, 198 ff., 220, 224, 225, 227
Inhumation, 13, 14
Inscriptions, II 1, B 47, B 55, B 56, C 39, C 48, C 136;
202, 225 ff.
-
Acropolis, 229
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
227
Eleusis, 155
229
Jar, XVII20-21
Jewellery, 18, 103 ff., 224, 235
Jug, XI 15, XVII 18, XVIII 1-2, XXV 3; 207, 228, 235
Kalathos, XVII 5-6, C 84; 204, 235-236
Kantharos, VII 7, IX 8-11, XI 5, XV 2, XX 4, B 60,
C 63-68; 204
Kerameikos, see Dipylon
Knife, XI 6, XIX 1; 20, 56, 104
Kolonos Agoraios, 6, 12, 13, 99, 139, 141
Korakou, 116
Kotyle, C 6-7
Krater, B 8, B 66, C 102-112; 200, 207
- column krater, C 111; 207
249
Persephone, 65
Phaleron, 4, 5, 15, 16, 19, 20, 26, 32, 34, 36, 42, 50,
57, 58, 64, 108, 136, 141, 158, 179, 203, 209, 210,
218, 219, 227
-
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RODNEY S. YOUNG
250
Pit A, 11, 13, 14, 21, 31, 67, 75, 106
Pitcher, XIV 1, XXV 2; 200, 201
-
199
Pithos, IX 1; 199
Plaque, B 49; 121, 129, 140
Plate, VI 5, XX 6, B 14-15, B 76, C 77-82; 205, 206
Pnyx Grave, 4, 48, 74
Pomegranate, 65
Hortr,otov,
124
chronology,
3, 140, 198
Grave
- Grave
- Grave
- Grave
14,
28,
30,
37,
40
16, 32
18, 43
49, 182
Grave 39, 32
This content downloaded by the authorized user from 192.168.52.61 on Tue, 4 Dec 2012 15:14:04 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions