Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GLASGOW 2011
British Academy
PROCEEDINGS OF THE
XIV th INTERNATIONAL NUMISMATIC CONGRESS
GLASGOW 2009
I
CONTENTS
Preface
Editors note
18
19
Inaugural lecture
A foreigners view of the coinage of Scotland, by Nicholas MAYHEW
23
Antiquity: Greek
I Delfini (distribuzione, associazioni, valenza simbolica), by Pasquale APOLITO
35
42
48
Up-to-date survey of the silver coinage of the Nabatean king Aretas IV, by Rachel
BARKAY
52
58
67
Not only art! The period of the signing masters and historical iconography,
by Maria CACCAMO CALTABIANO
73
81
89
97
105
114
123
CONTENTS
131
The coinage of the Scythian kings in the West Pontic area: iconography, by
Dimitar DRAGANOV
140
The royal archer and Apollo in the East: Greco-Persian iconography in the
Seleukid Empire, by Kyle ERICKSON & Nicholas L. WRIGHT
163
170
178
184
189
199
203
213
Archaic Greek coins east of the Tigris: evidence for circulation?, by J. KAGAN
230
237
246
251
The coinage of Chios during the Hellenistic and early Roman periods, by
Constantine LAGOS
259
265
CONTENTS
269
280
285
293
Some remarks concerning the gold coins with the legend , by Lucian
MUNTEANU
304
310
The coinage of the Paeonian kings Leon and Dropion, by Eftimija PAVLOVSKA
319
Le trsor des monnaies perses dor trouv Argamum / Orgam (Jurilovca, dp.
de Tulcea, Roumanie), by E. PETAC, G. TALMACHI & V. IONI
331
337
350
357
365
The coin finds from Hellenistic and Roman Berytas (fourth century BC third
century AD, by Ziad SAWAYA
376
382
Uso della moneta presso gli indigeni della Sicilia centro-meridionale, by Lavinia
SOLE
393
405
CONTENTS
417
427
436
Zur Datierung und Deutung der Beizeichen auf Stateren von Grtyn, by
Burkhard TRAEGER
441
447
461
473
487
The civic bronze coins of the Eleans: some preliminary remarks, by Franck
WOJAN
497
500
Antiquity: Roman
The coinage of Diva Faustina I, by Martin BECKMANN
509
514
The key to the Varus defeat: the Roman coin finds from Kalkriese, by Frank
BERGER
527
Monetary circulation in the Bosporan Kingdom in the Roman period c. first fourth century AD, by Line BJERG
533
The Roman coin hoards of the second century AD found on the territory of
present-day Serbia: the reasons for their burial, by Bojana BORI-BREKOVI
538
CONTENTS
Die Mnzprgung des Thessalischen Bundes von Marcus Aurelius bis Gallienus
(161-268 n. Chr.), by Friedrich BURRER
545
557
569
576
580
592
Analytical evidence for the organization of the Alexandrian mint during the
Tetrarchy (III-IV centuries AD), by J.M.COMPANA, L. LEN-REINA, F.J.
FORTES, L.M. CABALN, J.J. LASERNA, & M.A.G. ARANDA
595
605
613
621
629
635
Monuments on the move: architectural coin types and audience targeting in the
Flavian and Trajanic periods, by Nathan T. ELKINS
645
657
662
CONTENTS
668
New coins of pre- and denarial system minted outside Italy, by Paz GARCABELLIDO
676
686
696
709
Mars and Venus on Roman imperial coinage in the time of Marcus Aurelius:
iconological considerations with special reference to the emperors
correspondence with Marcus Cornelius Fronto, by Jrgen HAMER
715
The silver coins of Aegeae in the light of Hadrians eastern silver coinages, by F.
HAYMANN
720
726
732
742
749
757
765
772
The Nome coins: some remarks on the state of research, by Katarzyna LACH
780
785
CONTENTS
794
800
809
816
822
828
839
846
856
864
Die Sammlung von Lokalmythen griechischer Stdte des Ostens: ein Projekt der
Kommission fr alte Geschichte und Epigraphik, by Johannes NOLL
872
878
888
893
901
Could the unofficial mint called Atelier II be identified with the officinae of
Chteaubleau (France)?, by Fabien PILON
906
CONTENTS
911
916
926
933
941
A stone thesaurus with a votive coin deposit found in the sanctuary of Campo
della Fiera, Orvieto (Volsinii), by Samuele RANUCCI
954
964
973
Numismatics and archaeology in Rome: the finds from the Basilica Hilariana,
by Alessia ROVELLI
983
991
999
1004
1013
1019
1020
1025
CONTENTS
1037
The iconography of two groups of struck lead from Central Italy and Baetica in
the second and first centuries BC, by Clive STANNARD
1045
1056
Personalized victory on coins: the Year of the Four Emperors Greek imperial
issues, by Yannis STOYAS
1067
1073
1082
Gold and silver first tetrarchic issues from the mint of Alexandria, by D. Scott
VANHORN
1092
Note sulla circolazione monetaria in Etruria meridionale nel III secolo a.C., by
Daniela WILLIAMS
1103
Roman coins from the western part of West Balt territory, by Anna ZAPOLSKA
1115
Antiquity: Celtic
La moneda ibrica del nordeste de la Hispania Citerior: consideraciones sobre
su cronologa y funcin, by Marta CAMPO
1135
1142
1148
1155
Trading with silver bullion during the third century BC: the hoard of Armua de
Tajua, by Manuel GOZALBES, Gonzalo CORES & Pere Pau RIPOLLS
1165
1173
10
CONTENTS
1182
1191
1198
New coin finds from the two late Iron Age settlements of Altenburg (Germany)
and Rheinau (Switzerland) a military coin series on the German-Swiss border?,
by Michael NICK
1207
1218
Antiquity: general
La moneda en el mundo funerario-ritual de Gadir-Gades, by A. ARVALO
GONZLEZ
1231
Neues Licht auf eine alte Frage? Die Verwandschaft von Mnzen und Gemmen,
by Angela BERTHOLD
1240
Tipi del cane e del lupo sulle monete del Mediterraneo antico, by Alessandra
BOTTARI
1247
Not all these things are easy to read, much less to understand: new approaches to
reading images on ancient coins, by Geraldine CHIMIRRI-RUSSELL
1254
1261
Preliminary notes on Phoenician and Punic coins kept in the Pushkin Museum,
by S. KOVALENKO & L.I. MANFREDI
1266
Greek coins from the National Historical Museum of Rio de Janeiro: SNG
project, by Marici Martins MAGALHES
1278
1292
The sacred life of coins: cult fees, sacred law and numismatic evidence, by
Isabelle A. PAFFORD
1303
Anton Prokesch-Osten and the Greek coins of the coin collection at the
Universalmuseum Joanneum in Graz, Austria, by Karl PEITLER
1310
CONTENTS
11
1323
1334
Greek and Roman coins in the collection of the orum Museum, by D. zlem
YALCIN
1344
1355
1360
1372
1382
1392
1401
1408
1411
Norwegian bracteates during the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, by Linn EIKJE
1418
1426
1431
1436
1441
12
CONTENTS
1452
1458
1464
Among farmers and city people: coin use in early medieval Denmark, c. 10001250, by Gitte Tarnow INGVARDSON
1470
1477
1492
Byzantine coins from the area of Belarus, by Krystyna LAVYSH & Marcin
WOOSZYN
1500
Die frheste Darstellung des Richters auf einer mittelalterlicher Mnze?, by Ivar
LEIMUS
1509
Coinage and money in the years of insecurity: the case of late Byzantine
Chalkidiki (thirteenth - fourteenth century), by Vangelis MALADAKIS
1517
1535
The money of the First Crusade: the evidence of a new parcel and its
implications, by Michael MATZKE
1542
1552
1557
1564
1570
CONTENTS
13
1580
1591
The discovery of a hoard of coins dated to the fifth and sixth centuries in
Klapavice in the hinterland of ancient Salona, by Tomislav EPAROVI
1597
1605
1614
1620
1625
1633
1640
1649
1664
1671
1679
The money box system for savings in Amsterdam, 1907-1935, by G.N. BORST
1687
1693
14
CONTENTS
1704
1713
1719
1725
1734
1744
1748
Representaciones del caf en el acervo de numismtica del Museu Paulista USP, by Angela Maria Gianeze RIBEIRO
1752
Freiburg im echtland und die Mnzreformen der franzsischen Knige (16891726), by Nicole SCHACHER
1758
1765
1774
The political context of the origin and the exportation of thaler-coins from
Jchymov (Joachimsthal) in the first half of the sixteenth century, by Petr
VOREL
1778
The late sixteenth-century Russian forged kopecks, which were ascribed to the
English Muscovy Company, by Serguei ZVEREV
1783
1789
1796
CONTENTS
15
1807
1813
1821
1826
Numismatic research in Japan today: coins, paper monies and patterns of usage.
Paper money in early modern Japan: economic and folkloristic aspects, by
Keiichiro KATO
1832
1841
A study of medieval Chinese coins from Karur and Madurai in Tamil Nadu, by
KRISHNAMURTHY RAMASUBBAIYER
1847
1852
Silver fragments of unique Byid and amdnid coins and their role in the Kel
hoard (Czech Republic), by Vlastimil NOVK
1862
Numismatic evidence for the location of Saray, the capital of the Golden Horde,
by A.V. PACHKALOV
1869
Le regard des voyageurs sur les monnaies africaines du XVIe au XIXe sicles, by
Josette RIVALLAIN
1874
Les imitations des dirhems carrs almohades: apport des analyses lmentaires,
by A. TEBOULBI, M. BOMPAIRE & M. BLET-LEMARQUAND
1884
1890
Glass jetons from Sicily: new find evidence from the excavations at Monte Iato,
by Christian WEISS
1897
Medals
Joseph Kowarzik (1860-1911): ein Medailleur der Jahrhundertwende, by
Kathleen ADLER
1907
16
CONTENTS
1920
1931
1937
1945
The rediscovery of the oldest private medal collection of the Netherlands, by Jan
PELSDONK
1959
1965
Shines with unblemished honour: some thoughts on an early nineteenthcentury medal, by Tuukka TALVIO
1978
General numismatics
Dalliconografia delle monete antiche allideologia della nazione future.
Proiezioni della numismatica grecista di DAnnunzio sulla nuova monetazione
Sabauda, by Giuseppe ALONZO
1985
1993
The Count of Caylus (1692-1765) and the study of ancient coins, by Franois de
CALLATA
1999
2004
2012
2017
A prosopography of the mint officials: the Eligivs database and its evolution, by
Luca GIANAZZA
2022
2027
CONTENTS
17
2036
2044
Foundation of the Hellenic World. A new private collection open to the public,
by Eleni PAPAEFTHYMIOU
2046
2047
2058
2072
2082
2089
2100
From the electrum to the Euro: a journey into the history of coins. A multimedia
presentation by the Bank of Cyprus Cultural Foundation, by Eleni ZAPITI
2102
Highlights from the Museum of the George and Nefeli Giabra Pierides
Collection, donated by Clio and Solon Triantafyllides: coins and artefacts, by
Eleni ZAPITI & Evangeline MARKOU
2112
Index of Contributors
2118
IGCH, p. 243.
Kagan 1994, pp. 36ff.
IGCH 1790; the author would like to thank Andrew Meadows for making
231
It consisted of more than 170 coins with the bulk - over 150 - being Athenian. No sigloi were
recorded, but 11 of the 16 recorded non-Athenian coins are from Cilicia, Cyprus and Phoenicia.
In addition to a worn archaic Aeginetan stater, there is a late archaic coin of Lete (Berge) and a
unique Thraco-Macedonian coin of a horseman that might also be archaic. Intriguingly for what
we will discuss next, the publishers of this hoard recorded a group of three well-preserved ThracoMacedonian archaic coins which may or more probably may not be related to the above find: a
stater of Dicaea and Stagira from the sixth century and a late archaic tetradrachm of Acanthus.5
Interestingly a slightly later stater of Stagira with the lion attacking the boar obverse and an early
fifth-century stater of Paros were found recently in Afghanistan, possibly as part of a large, much
later hoard found at Ai Khanoum.6 Yet another slightly earlier Stagira was reportedly the earliest
coin from the large well hoard at Mir Zahke.
It is tempting to see evidence here that some of these archaic Greek coins found their way to
Afghanistan shortly after their minting. All the hoards mentioned are notable in that the coins are
not as often test cut or turned into fragments as one is accustomed to in hoards found in Egypt
and the Levant. With this as background, the discovery in this region of a hoard with only sixthcentury coinage should not come as a complete surprise, yet I hope you will agree with me that the
following survival is still remarkable.7
In 2003 a group of probably as many as 50 sixth-century BC Greek coins came to light in
Turkmenistan. The find details, as with all hoards discovered out of archaeological context, are
somewhat murky; but the numismatic community was fortunate in that a collector of later central
Asian coins - Hans Mondorf, who lived at the time in Ashgabat - quickly realized the uniqueness
of the find and did his best to preserve a record. While the exact spot was kept secret, we know
that the coins were uncovered on the left bank of the Amudarya (the Oxus River of the Greeks)
near modern Kerki in Turkmenistan. The coins were not found in a single pot or at one time, but
rather over a period of 10-12 months. There is no evidence of a single intrusion, so the most likely
explanation is that the hoard became dispersed in the ground. There is no way to know how much
of the original hoard was recovered. It is also hard to be certain how much of the recovered hoard
was recorded. Through Mondorfs efforts, weights and photographs of 33 coins and 20 pieces of
hacksilber now exist. At least 15 coins (reportedly Thasian in poor condition) were known to have
been dispersed without being photographed.
This is not the first time ancient coins have been found at Kerki. V. Masson in the 1950s reported the find of a gold daric.8 Kerki was part of Central Asia added to the Persian Empire by
Cyrus in the 530s and re-conquered by Darius after the revolts that marked the start of his reign.
Kerki stands on the border of the Persian satrapy of Bactria to the south, to the east is the city of
Samarkhand, and the satrapy of Sogdiana and Margiana with its capital at Merv lies to the west.
It is at the centre of the Bactria-Margiana Archaeological Complex, an important Bronze Age
civilization that only came to light in the 1970s. Kerki is also situated at a likely crossing point of
the Oxus.
The coins themselves bear great similarities with other sixth-century finds notably Demanhur, Ras Shamra, IGCH 1185 in Brussels and CH VIII.19.9 Also, as seems to be the case with all
these finds, there is a new type, reminding us how much less complete our record of sixth-century
coinage is than, for instance, early fifth-century coinage. Lets take a quick survey of the find. The
Troxell / Spengler 1969, pp. 1-19 = IGCH 1820.
Bopearachchi / Rahman 1995, p. 78.
7
The author intends to publish the hoard fully in a forthcoming AJN;
because of the different sources of photographs, some of the illustrations
5
6
232
J. KAGAN
largest component is Thraco-Macedonian. Of the 33 coins for which we have photos, 17 are from
that region. If one adds the unrecorded 15 Thasian coins to the hoard, the regions representation
goes from half to roughly two-thirds. The mix of Abdera, Dikaia, Berge, Thasos, Stageira and the
uncertain type with the winged-running figure is, with the exception of Thasos, identical to the mix
in Ras Shamra (ancient Ugarit), the hoard thought to have the earliest Thraco-Macedonian coins
found in the Levant.
The running-winged figure (Pl. I, 1) shares dies with Demanhur (52) and Ras Shamra (nos. 5
etc). This type represented 14 of the 38 coins from that latter find. It is fascinating how often coins
of Stageira, an otherwise rare mint, appear in this part of the world. The exact type we have of the
standing boar with a rose underneath was found in Ras Shamra (29), Demanhur (48) and IGCH
1185 (19). The four Berge staters are all early. None of the broad figured dies with the regularized diagonally divided incuses are present. Illustrated are two particularly early types (Pl. I, 2-3).
The first is marked by the very large head of the satyr. The second is unusual in that the nymphs
left hand is raised and in her lowered left hand is a wreath or round instrument. That Berge was
also represented by a fraction is notable as well (Pl. I, 4). It has already been remarked upon that
the presence of these early fractions argue against seeing the coinages purpose as purely tribute
payment. This may well be the first Thraco-Macedonian fraction found in a sixth-century mixed
hoard, and as such it provides a valuable testament to trade rather than tribute leading to the presence of archaic Greek coins in this part of the world. It is de rigeur for an archaic mixed sixthcentury hoard to have at least one stater of Dikaia (Pl. I, 5) without any accompanying distaters.
IGCH 1185, Adana, Sahkha, Ch VIII 19 (to which we share the obverse die) all have a single stater, while Demanhur has three. Of the photographed coins, Abdera is the largest contingent. There
are six tetradrachms and one octodrachm. All are early in Mays Period 1. None bears symbols;
one of the coins shares its obverse die with a specimen from the Persepolis deposit (Pl. I, 6-7).
We have records of two coins of Thasos. If the report was right that there were another 15 coins
from the island badly corroded then this would be the largest contingent. The examples we have
are from the early stages of the mint and consistent with a sixth-century date (Pl. I, 8). An archaic
Thasos fragment we should remember was found in the Kabul hoard.
As we turn to central Greece, the first thing to notice is the absence of any coins of Athens.
That Wappenmuenzen and early owls are rarely found in sixth-century hoards has once more been
confirmed. We have a unique coin that I believe to be an early stater of Corcyra (Pl. I, 9). There are
several reasons for this. It is on the Corcyrean weight standard: 11.5g. versus a theoretical 11.6g.
The reverse star is reminiscent of Corcyra. The obverse type of the Medusa is otherwise unattested
on the island, but I wonder if the depiction of the Medusa and her child Pegasus on the pediment of
the Temple of Artemis earlier in the century might have some connection (Pl. I, 10). The argument
based on coin types that the Pegasus on the pediment represents Corinth has been made by others,
most recently Clemente Marconi.10 Was Corcyra sending her Metropolis a message by choosing
the mother of Pegasus as its coin type? At the recent congress on Epiorote coinage at Ioninna I
argued before knowing of this coin that Corcyra may have had a wappenmuenzen-like series of
staters to go with the facing cow head fractions that predate the cow/calf coinage. This coin from
Berlin may be another in the series, also on the weight standard (Pl. I, 11).11 To go with the Medusa, we have a single one-sided Pegasus stater of Corinth. This coin belongs to the second class
of Ravels first period and is similar to staters found at Mit Rahineh (four of the 23 coins in that
hoard) and Demanhur. The Aeginetan coin is, as would be expected, an early example of Group II
10
11
233
with a thin collar and a windmill reverse with no indication of a proto-skew (Pl. I, 12).
From the Cyclades, only Paros is represented (Pl. I, 13). This coin should be placed in
Sheedys Series B group 2, the same group as the Mit Rahineh specimen. Demanhur and Sakha
had slightly later examples. Ionia is represented by fractions of Teos and Samos (Pl. I, 14-15)
and a stater of Chios. All three coins (including the fractions), were also found in Demanhur. The
solitary coin from Caria is an early lion-forepart usually attributed to Mylasa (Pl. II, 16). That
these coins are early is well-established by their presence in the Croesus-Carian hoard of c.525
(CH VIII.10) found in western Asia Minor. This is, however, the earliest mixed sixth-century
context for the mint.
The presence of four Lydian Croesids two staters and two hemistaters - is just one more
remarkable aspect of this find. CH VIII 19 had the first stater recorded in a mixed context and
the large Demanhur hoard had a single hemistater (Pl. II, 17-18). What is perhaps most comforting about the group is the presence of an extremely worn example. Many of the coins in the
hoard suffer from a degree of corrosion and some wear, but this is by far and away the coin that
shows the most evidence of wear from circulation. We know from the recent archaeological
discoveries from Sardis that the heavy Croesids pre-date the Persian destruction. Their presence
in this hoard that I would date to between 520/515 on the high side and 505/500 on the low side
is perfectly consistent.
Lycia is represented by three boar forepart incuse staters on the local nine gram standard.
The illustrated example has the distinctive reverse type of the three solid triangles and the outline
triangle that was found in Demanhur and CH VII 19 (Pl. II, 19). Finally there is a rare coin with
a facing lion devouring a cow on the obverse and a winged solar disk on the reverse (Pl. II, 20).
Destrooper-Georgiades has convincingly attributed this type to Cyprus based on the type and date.
One of the four previously known examples comes from CH. 2.10, a small sixth-century BC hoard
from Egypt.12
Bullion was an important component of the hoard (Pl. II, 21-22). We have photographs and
weights for 20 pieces. The weights of the Hacksilber range from 2.30g to 14.95g, with an average
weight of 7.15g. There is no evidence of a denominational structure. The bullion helps us understand perhaps the purpose the Greek coins served so far from their place of origin. While it seems
unlikely that the Greek coins had a value in excess of their weight, it is notable compared to coins
found in Egyptian hoards how few test cuts have been made. Also there are no fragmentary coins.
This is perhaps best read as an indication that precious metal did not change hands with a high
frequency in Central Asia compared for instance to the Levant at this date. Coins and hacksilber
were a storehouse of wealth, but not a vehicle for small commercial transactions.
The presence and nature of the bullion should also be of interest to students of South Asian numismatics. The Kabul hoard that we can now date 40 to 50 years earlier than the original publisher
is the first appearance in a datable context of punchmarked coins. It is an argument admittedly ex
silentio (and Kerki may be north of the expected circulation pattern), but the absence of punchmarks on the bullion of the Kerki hoard certainly supports the proponents of a late starting date
for Indian coinage following rather than preceding the appearance of Greek coins in the region.
This hoard leaves us with much to speculate on. When examined in the context of the Persepolis Deposit, the Malayer, Kabul and Balkh hoards and other recent small finds from Afghanistan,
we can clearly state that Greek coins found their way to the eastern fringes of the Persian Empire
very soon after they were first struck. Perhaps we can now reasonably expect to find early Greek
12
Destrooper-Georgiades 1993. The author wishes to thank Dr.
Destrooper-Georgiades for her helpful comments at the Congress.
234
J. KAGAN
coins in Uzbekistan and even China. What influence these coins had other than as bullion again is
a matter for speculation. At least we can see that the iconography of the coins survived their travel
and were not obliterated by cuts and fragmentation. The diversity of the sixth-century hoards recorded from the Persian Empire is a matter of some wonder. Our ratio - 16 different mints out of 33
recorded coins - is not atypical. There is getting to be enough new evidence for the sixth century,
both electrum and silver, to warrant a new synthesis on the purpose and spread of early coinage.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bopearachchi, O. / Rahman A. (1995), Pre-Kushana Coins in Pakistan, Karachi.
Destrooper-Georgiades, A. (1993), Le disque ail inclus dans un motif geometrique sur
une srie de monnaies chypriotes?, CCEC 20, pp. 19-24.
Kagan, J. (1994), An Archaic Greek coin hoard from the Eastern Mediterranean and early Cypriot
coinage, NC 1994, pp. 17-52
Marconi, C. (2007), Temple Decoration and Cultural Identity in the Archaic Greek World, New York
Schlumberger, D. (1953), Largent grec dans lempire Achmnide, in Curiel R. / Schlumberger
D., Trsors montaires dAfghanistan, Paris, pp. 5-64.
Troxell H. / Spengler W. (1969), A hoard of early Greek coins from Afghanistan, MN 15, pp.
1-19.
PLATE I
(1:1)
(2:1)
11
12
10
13
14
(1:1)
15
(2:1)
PLATE II
16
17
18
19
20
21
(both enlarged)
22