Professional Documents
Culture Documents
09/10/15 12:11 pm
- Mrunal - http://mrunal.org -
Prologue
This article series based on Ethics Lectures by Mr.Kavan Limbasiya (AIR-198, IRS-IT) at SPIPA,
Ahmedabad
The Syllabus of UPSC General Studies Paper-4 Ethics is available here click me. Accordingly, we
can divide the Ethics topic into 8 parts
http://mrunal.org/2015/09/e1p1-meta-ethics-judgement-types-freewill-knowledge-normative-ethics.html/print/
Page 1 of 8
09/10/15 12:11 pm
First part would be Ethics and Human interface- further subdivided into three articles
E1/P1: Types of Judgments, Pre-requisite for Ethical scrutiny, Meta Ethics, Applied ethics,
Normative-Descriptive ethics.
E1/P2: Theories of Ethics: virtual ethics, deontological vs. teleological ethics, utilitarianism,
hedonism, epicureanism, egoism, conduct ethics etc.
E1/P3: Values, Role of family-society-educational institutions in inculcating values, ethics and
private and public relationships.
3 Types of Judgments
1.Factual or
Epistemological
Earth rotates around Sun. Whether you test or an alien species tests, the fact
will remain the same. There are only two outcomes: True / False
Theyre not morally right or wrong. Theyre morally empty, theyre amoral.
2.Aesthetic
Judgment
3.Moral
Judgment
Page 2 of 8
09/10/15 12:11 pm
If youre a bigB fan, youd say no he cant be involved because he is a good guy (Moral
judgment). And youd say this without verifying the facts. So, youve internal inconsistency- you
like this guy, so you cant believe he can be bad.
Similar case about Sanjay Dutts involvement in 1992 bomb blasts.
Page 3 of 8
Descriptive
Einsteins equation is E=MC2
Newtons third law: action and reaction are opposite.
It describes this is whats happening.
09/10/15 12:11 pm
Normative / prescriptive
Should we use that equation or knowledge
to build nuclear weapon?
Should we use Newtons third law to build
a rocket or a gun?
It prescribes what should be done or what
ought to be done.
Morality
Perhaps in some ethical school of thought, gay marriage could be considered
ethical because everyone has right to have a life partner to provide him/her
emotional support.
Every moral things may not be legal. If we make lying illegal, then everyone
will be jailed.
Varies from culture, religion and region.
http://mrunal.org/2015/09/e1p1-meta-ethics-judgement-types-freewill-knowledge-normative-ethics.html/print/
Page 4 of 8
region/nation
Murder is illegal
09/10/15 12:11 pm
Pc2: Knowledge
A Child takes iphone 6s plus from table and dips it in a fishbowl. Phone is permanently
damaged. Was Childs action unethical?
Well, Child had free will- (A) Take selfi and upload on facebook (B) dip it in a fishbowl
She chose optionB. But she didnt have the knowledge that iPhone are not waterproof.
We cannot exercise free will in an ethical/unethical manner, unless and until we have
knowledge of its consequence. Hence babys action cant be termed as ethical or unethical.
Fear /
If someone tries to kill/loot you and you kill/injure him in self-defense, youre
http://mrunal.org/2015/09/e1p1-meta-ethics-judgement-types-freewill-knowledge-normative-ethics.html/print/
Page 5 of 8
violence
09/10/15 12:11 pm
acting under fear for your life. So, its subject to legal scrutiny but not ethical
scrutiny. Because it was either you or him.
Ignorance
Foreigner comes to Gujarat and drinks in a desi-liquor den. This is illegal but not
unethical IF the foreigner was unaware of the prohibition law in Gujarat.
Passion
A husband finds his wife in a compromising position with another man, he gets
enraged and murders both of them. Illegal but difficult to scrutinize on ethical
grounds, since his passion was not aroused by himself.
A man takes narcotic drugs and under its influence he rapes/murders/maims
someone, it is both illegal and unethical because he himself aroused his passion.
Hence, In murder cases, court looks at aggravating and mitigating factors.
Pathological
status
Habit,
temperament
Since childhood, Japanese are trained to apologize profusely even for slightest
mistake or discomfort caused to another human.
If an American executive working in Japan, doesnt behave in similar fashion, it
cant be termed as unethical. Because its not in American habits.
Value
system
A fallen Samurai would prefer to commit ritual suicide (seppuku) rather than
suffering torture/humiliation by his enemies. Because it is part of his Bushido
honor code.
If a fallen American soldier doesnt commit suicide, it cant be evaluated on
ethical grounds.
Now you can see the broad picture- consider following Case: Mr.X murders Mr.Y to acquire his
property.
Action
Mr.X
He killed Mr.Y
Mr.Xs action is morally wrong.
It is wrong to murder another human
No person shall be deprived of his
Component
Moral Agent
Human Action. (Recall 3 types of assumptions: if he had
done with out free will, knowledge and voluntary action, wed
have called it non-human action and topic would end here.
Moral Judgment. (Recall 3-types of Judgments-factual,
aesthetic and moral)
Moral Standard=> Ethics => Meta-Ethics.
http://mrunal.org/2015/09/e1p1-meta-ethics-judgement-types-freewill-knowledge-normative-ethics.html/print/
Page 6 of 8
09/10/15 12:11 pm
Leonard Shelby
Waitress
Cop
Motel receptionist
Jason Statham
Nurses
Doctor
Policemen
In the next part (E1/P2) well look at various theories of Ethics. Visit Mrunal.org/Ethics for more study
http://mrunal.org/2015/09/e1p1-meta-ethics-judgement-types-freewill-knowledge-normative-ethics.html/print/
Page 7 of 8
09/10/15 12:11 pm
material on Ethics.
Article printed from Mrunal: http://mrunal.org
URL to article: http://mrunal.org/2015/09/e1p1-meta-ethics-judgement-types-freewill-knowledgenormative-ethics.html
Copyright 2014 Mrunal. All rights reserved.
http://mrunal.org/2015/09/e1p1-meta-ethics-judgement-types-freewill-knowledge-normative-ethics.html/print/
Page 8 of 8