Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter
ABSTRACf
Overburden rock, an essential element of the petroleum system, is that series of mostly sedimentary rock that overlies the source rock, seal rock, and reservoir rock. Generation of hydrocarbons
from thermal degradation of organic matter in the source rock is determined by thickness of the
overburden rock in conjunction with the physical properties and processes that determine temperature in sedimentary basins. Thickness of the overburden rock is a by-product of the fundamental
forces and processes that control the structural development of the sedimentary basin in which the
overburden rock is found. Source rock temperature is largely determined by thickness and thermal
conductivity of the overburden rock, heat flow, and ground surface temperature. Processes such as
groundwater flow and sedimentation may also have significant effects on the thermal regime.
the overburden rock is important to the generation,
migration, and accumulation of petroleum and to the
formation of traps that contain petroleum.
Although the role of the overburden rock in the
petroleum system is multifaceted, this chapter discusses
only the key role of the overburden rock in determining
the thermal evolution of the source rock. Oil and I or gas
is generated from organic matter (kerogen) in the source
rock through one or more chemical reactions that have
an exponential dependence on temperature. For a
normal range of geologic heating rates (1-10C/m.y.),
the main zone of oil generation occurs between 100 and
150C (Quigley et al., 1987). For these temperatures to be
reached, a source rock must be buried by overburden
rock through the process of sedimentation. The extent,
depth, and timing of hydrocarbon generation from the
source rock thus depend on the sedimentation rate and
the geothermal gradient. For a typical geothermal
gradient of 25C/km, most oil generation takes place at
depths of about 3--6 km. However, there is a tremendous
range of natural variability associated with both sedimentation rates and geothermal gradients in sedimentary basins.
Sedimentation rates can vary by as much as three
orders of magnitude, from 1 to 1000 m/m.y.(Figure 9.1).
Rates below and above these values can be important
locally, but burial histories between these limits are most
common. The sedimentation rate for a passive margin
(e.g., Cordilleran miogeosyncline, Atlantic margin, and
Gulf of Lion) changes as it evolves from a rift basin
INTRODUCTION
Overburden rock is one of four essential elements of
the petroleum system, but on the basis of volume, it is
usually the largest part of the basin fill. Overburde11 rock is
that series of mostly sedimentary rock that overlies the
source rock, seal rock, and reservoir rock, the three other
essential elements. In some situations, these other
elements may also be part of the overburden rock. The
remainder of the basin fill is the underburden rock, that
portion of mostly sedimentary rock that lies between the
basement rock and the essential elements of the
petroleum system. The sedimentary basin is the
geometric form defined by the interface of the basin fill
and basement rock (Figure 1.4 in Magoon and Dow,
Chapter 1, this volume).
The overburden rock affects a number of physical
processes important to the petroleum system. Because of
burial, a source rock generates petroleum, a reservoir
rock experiences a loss of porosity through compaction, a
seal rock becomes a better barrier to petroleum
migration, and if oil and gas are kept in a trap at an
optimum temperature, biodegradation is prevented. The
time sequence in which the overburden rock is deposited
affects the geometry of the interface of the source rock
and overburden rock, and of the seal rock and reservoir
rock. In tum, the geometry of the source-overburden
horizon influences the timing and direction of petroleum
migration, and the seal-reservoir horizon dictates the
timing and effectiveness of trap formation. In this way,
165
166
Deming
AGE(Ma)
200
100
100
~
w
0
::>
E 3
CIJ->::
~....
1000
m/m.y.
AGE(Ma)
300
200
0~--_.----~~r-~--~----~~~
~~
~
3
4
PASSIVE MARGINS
6~~~~~~==~==~==~
600
500
AGE (Ma)
500
400
400
300
300
-.;;;;;;;::
Williston Basin
INTRACRATONIC BASINS
6~--~-----=~=:~==~
AGE (Ma)
~ 4
5
6
CE
FORELAND BASINS
~4
9~~~100,
6
500
400
Figure 9.1. Representative tectonic subsidence histories for basins from different tectonic settings. The top graph shows the
slopes of a range of sedimentation rates after compaction and is provided for reference. (After Angevine et al., 1990.)
167
sedimentary
rock
crust
sedimentation
~
mantle
Pm
> Pc > Ps
relative importance of tectonic subsidence and sedimentation as driving forces for the creation of sedimentary
basins varies according to the circumstances involved.
Major river deltas (e.g., Mississippi, Amazon, and Niger)
are primary examples in which sedimentation itself plays
a major role in forcing subsidence and increasing the
depth of a basin. On the opposite extreme, the abyssal
plains of the oceanic basins are relatively sediment
starved. They owe their existence to the cooling and
subsidence of oceanic lithosphere as it moves away from
the site of its creation at a mid-oceanic spreading ridge;
sedimentation is limited and plays an insignificant role in
determining total subsidence.
Jh p dz
constant
(1)
168
Deming
o~~---7~--~--~~--~----~~
60
80
100
Intracratonic Basins
Intracratonic, or platform, basins form on continental
interiors (e.g., the Michigan, illinois, and Williston basins
of North America; Figure 9.1). They are typically a few
hundred kilometers wide and contain a few kilometers
of flat-lying sedimentary rocks recording continuous
subsidence and sediment deposition over periods of time
greater than 100 m.y. (Sleep et al., 1980). Sleep (1971) was
the first to note that the subsidence of these basins was,
like oceanic basins, proportional to the square root of
time, with a time constant of about 50 m.y. This led to
speculation that the formation of these basins, like rift
basins, was controlled by some type of heating or
thermal event followed by thermal contraction (Sleep,
1971; Sleep and Snell, 1976; Ahern and Mrkvicka, 1984;
Nunn et al., 1984; Klein and Hsui, 1987).
For an intracratonic basin to be formed by thermal
contraction, isostasy requires that a considerable amount
of crustal erosion occur during the initial heating, uplift,
and thermal expansion phase. For example, if the basin
fill is 3 km deep, it would be necessary to first remove
about 1 km of the continental crust through erosion.
However, in many instances, there is little evidence that
this type of dramatic erosion ever occurred (Sleep et al.,
1980). Recognition of this problem has led to the
proposal of several alternative hypotheses. These include
(1) an increase in density of the crust due to one or more
phase transitions, (2) rifting, (3) mechanical subsidence
caused by an isostatically uncompensated excess mass of
igneous intrusions, (4) tectonic reactivation along older
structures, or (5) some combination of these or other
theories (see review by Klein, 1991). For example, Klein
(1991) suggests that intracratonic basins in North
169
Foreland Basins
Foreland basins (Beaumont, 1981) are asymmetric,
wedge-shaped accumulations of sedimentary rock that
form adjacent to fold-thrust belts. Migration of the
fold-thrust sheet loads the lithosphere, causing isostatic
subsidence underneath the core of the orogen and
flexural downwarping in the adjacent foreland. The
foredeep that forms next to the orogenic belt rapidly fills
with sediment eroded from the adjacent mountains.
Sedimentation amplifies flexural subsidence, and a
foreland basin is formed (Figure 9.1).
The foreland basin process continues until the forces
driving uplift and orogeny cease. Erosion then
dominates, reducing the weight of the mountain chain,
leading to uplift and further erosion. The life cycle of a
foreland basin is thus typically one of fairly rapid burial
and subsidence followed by a much longer period of
uplift and erosion. Most source rocks buried by the
foreland basin fill probably go through a relatively short
heating and maturation phase, followed by a longer
cooling phase.
Thermal events play a minor role in the formation of
foreland basins. However, the thermal state of the lithosphere influences its flexural strength, thereby exerting an
indirect control on the structural evolution of foreland
basins (Watts et al., 1982).
170
Deming
Factor
Overburden thickness
Heat flow
Thermal conductivity
Surface temperature
Sedimentation
Groundwater flow
Gravity driven
Compaction driven
Free convection
Initial thermal event
1st
1st
1st
2nd
1st
2nd
3rd
Qualifications
Always important
Always important
Always important
Always important
>100 m/m.y.
100 m/m.y.
<10 m/m.y.
1st-2nd
Foreland basins
3rd
Unless focused
Unknown
1st (0-20 Ma)
Rift basins only
2nd (20-60 Ma)
3rd (>60 Ma)
(2)
(3)
MATHEMATICAL DESCRIPTION OF
HEAT TRANSPORT
Sedimentary basins are never in complete thermal
equilibrium, and groundwater flow may drastically
change the distribution of thermal energy within a basin.
SOURCES OF HEAT
Roughly 40% of surface heat flow on the continents
comes from a superficial layer of radioactively enriched
crystalline rocks about 10 km thick (Pollack and
Chapman, 1977). The remaining 60%, or reduced heat
flow, comes from a combination of radioactive sources in
the lower crust and upper mantle, as well as a convective
flux into the base of the thermal lithosphere. The half-life
of common heat-generating elements (K, U, and Th) is on
the order of 109 yr or greater; thus, the radioactive
component of heat flow has not changed appreciably
since the Precambrian (assuming no loss or gain of
mass). In contrast, heat flow into the base of the lithosphere can vary markedly, as shown by the passage of the
lithosphere over hot spots with resultant isostatic uplift,
enhanced heat flow, and volcanism (Crough, 1979).
~ow long do thermal transients in the lithosphere
persist? A useful rule of thumb is that the time (t) taken
for a thermal disturbance to propagate a distance (y)
through a material of thermal diffusivity (a) is (Lachenbruch and Sass, 1977)
t = y2/4a
(5)
171
172
Deming
Temperature (C)
20
40
60
80
100
Temperature (C)
140
40
80
'E
.II:
..
'E 2
.II:
..
.c
.c
0.
Q.
Q)
Cl)
'\
4
4
Figure 9.5. Corrected bottom-hole temperatures (BHTs)
from North Slope basin, Alaska.
F~~HINKPJ
(a)
100
80
60
40
----r----
20
--
----
1----r-_l_
ATI
!~
SBE
KOL
NIN
I
I
173
ETK
DRP
IKP
LBN
(b)
A'
SBE
KOL
IN!
SOH ETK
NIN FCK NKPATI
JWD
DRP
E 2
:::.
Qi
> 3
tO
Q)
rn
:1:
0
Q)
.0
.c
Q.6
Q)
Cl
-- -
-so
75
---
--160
--
50 km
-200
B
'.,
Figure 9.6. Estimated (a) shallow heat flow (in mW/m2)and (b) subsurface temperature (in 'C) from the North Slope basin,
Alaska . Dotted lines are stratigraphic units of cross section; solid lines are isotherms. Numbers on trace of well bore are
corrected bottom-hole temperatures. Abbreviations for wells: ATl, Atigaru Point #1; DRP, Drew Point #1; EKU, East Kurupa
#1; ETK, East Topagoruk #1; FCK, Fish Creek #1; IKP, lkpikpuk #1; INI, lnigok #1; JWD, J. W. Dalton #1; KOL, Koluktak #1;
LBN, Lisburne #1; NIN, North lnigok #1; NKP, North Kalikpik #1; SBE, Seabee #1; and SOH, South Harrison Bay #1. (After
Deming et al., 1992.)
174
Deming
Thermal Conductivity
The thermal conductivity of rocks and sediments is an
intrinsic physical property that is determined by mineralogy, porosity, and temperature. Most sedimentary
rocks are an aggregate of minerals with pore spaces
saturated with saline water. Their bulk thermal conductivity depends on both the solid rock component and the
pore fluid. A number of different mixing models have
been proposed to relate the thermal conductivity of an
aggregate to its individual components (Woodside and
Messmer, 1961). The most common of these is the
geometric mean model:
(6)
(7)
(8)
kw =a + bT + c'fl.
(9)
..
.. .. ..
I
I
I
I
I
...,... ' .
~
~-.
I,
I
,-,.,.
;~
2
NUGGET
..
ANKAREH
J: 3
I-
a..
LLJ
0
.:
GANNET
..
I , ...,.
I .- ..~,
..
TERTIARY
PREUSS
TWIN CREEK
'--.....1'----1
I
r-:-..;---,.,J
.. .
...
. .
L ....
,..-7 ,,
"
. .., .
_.:..1 .......
L - - - ' 1
... .........
I
I
THAYNES
WOOD.- DJNW
L. _ _: - - . .
PHOSPHORIA
I
I
....
WEBER
I
I
I
MADISON
,
2
1rI
<t
... : ..
I
I
56
THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY (W /m K)
data measured on samples from the Anschutz Ranch 3402 well in the Utah-Wyoming thrust belt (Deming and
Chapman, 1988). The discrete points represent matrix
conductivities measured in the laboratory on drill chips;
the dashed lines show estimated in situ thermal conductivities. The in situ estimates are lower than the laboratory measurements due to the effects of porosity and
temperature, and range from about 2 to 4 WI m K. The
wide scatter of measurements for any formation is
partially due to errors in measurement, but most of the
scatter can be attributed to changes in lithology and
mineralogy.
The number of measurements needed to determine
the average thermal conductivity of a geologic unit to an
acceptable level of precision depends on its lithologic
heterogeneity. For some marine Paleozoic units that are
lithologically uniform over hundreds of kilometers, it
may be possible to make only 10-20 measurements for
an entire basin. However, large spatial variations in
thermal conductivity are more typical because most sedimentary rocks tend to have facies changes that occur
both vertically and laterally. It is therefore difficult in
most cases to collect enough data to estimate how the
thermal conductivity of a geologic unit changes
throughout a basin.
To overcome this difficulty, concerted efforts have
been made to estimate thermal conductivity from
175
geophysical well logs. In many instances, strong correlations have been found between thermal conductivity and
one or more log parameters such as resistivity, seismic
velocity, and density (Houbolt and Wells, 1980; Reiter et
al., 1980; Vacquier et al., 1988; Blackwell and Steele,
1989). In other cases, mineralogy has been estimated
from well logs, and the thermal conductivity of the bulk
rock estimated from laboratory-derived values for
different mineralogies (Brig a ud and Vasseur, 1989;
Brigaud et al., 1990; Demongodin et al., 1991). The limitation of all of these methods is the lack of an accurate
mineralogy log. Matrix thermal conductivity is determined by mineralogic composition; correlations and
inferences found to be valid in specific instances cannot
be generalized. Thus, at the present time, there is no
simple algorithm for estimating thermal conductivity
from well logs that is demonstrably accurate. However,
well logs may prove useful in interpolating between
measurement sites when log parameters can be calibrated by laboratory measurements.
CONTROLS ON TEMPERATURE IN
SEDIMENTARY BASINS
Heat Flow and Thermal Conductivity
Because the primary mode of heat transport in the
crust is conduction, both heat flow (determined from
equation 2) and thermal conductivity (measured
directly) are of first-order and equal importance in determining temperature in sedimentary basin fill.
Heat flow is inversely correlated to tectonic age
(Vitorello and Pollack, 1980; Morgan, 1984) and is
depressed by sedimentation (see later discussion). Heat
flow in young (<25 Ma) rift basins can be as high as
90-120 mW 1m2 or higher, but it decreases with
increasing age. Foreland basins are typically associated
with post-Precambrian orogenic belts and therefore tend
to have heat flows in the range of 50-70 mW 1m2.
Intracratonic basins generally have modest heat flows in
the range of 30-50 mW 1m2, reflecting their location on
old, stable cratons. Other types of basins, such as pullapart or backarc basins (e.g., the Salton trough; Lachenbruch et al., 1985) may have young tectonic ages and can
have high heat flows. Heat flow in basins subject to sedimentation rates higher than 100 mlm.y. (e.g., passive
margins) can be extremely depressed.
Thermal conductivity varies by as much as a factor of
three or four among common lithologies. However, any
relatively thick stratigraphic section tends to be
composed of a variety of different lithologies. Some of
these may have thermal conductivities that are relatively
high and some relatively low. A useful rule of thumb is
that the average thermal conductivity of a section
containing diverse lithologies is about 2.5 W lm K. It is
unusual to find a lithologically diverse section of sedimentary rocks with an average thermal conductivity
lower than 1.5 W lm K or higher than 3.0 W lm K.
However, a variation of 100% is of first-order importance.
176
Deming
.........
G
0
+"~.... .
k, > k,
~E
......
3:
k,< k,
'=
Time
~
0
"+
u::
sediment
.c.
15.
1ii
Q)
<II
,/
J:
basement
'\sedimentation ceases
20
40
60
80
100
2000
Elevation
3000
(m)
Figure 9.8. Mean annual air temperatures(+) from rneterologic data (collected by author), and mean annual ground
temperatures () estimated from extrapolation of borehole
temperature logs from the north-central Colorado Plateau.
(Made by Bodell and Chapman, 1982.)
Surface Temperature
Although it is often ignored, surface temperattli'e (T0 )
is an important boundary condition on geothermal
conditions. The temperature at the earth's surface is
determined by climate and has diurnal and annual cycles
that rapidly attenuate in the subsurface. By applying
equation 5, it can be seen that the annual variation of
temperature propagates no deeper than about 10m into
the subsurface. Thus, the quantity of interest in geothermal studies (T0 ) is a long term mean, a fictional
quantity that is usually estimated by the linear extrapolation of a borehole temperature log to the surface. Observations have shown that extrapolated borehole temperatures are closely related to mean annual air temperatures,
but that ground temperatures are always higher by
about 2"-3C (Figure 9.8). This discrepancy is commonly
attributed to the insulating effect of snow cover in
winter. However, the offset between mean annual
ground and air temperatures is also found at low latitude
sites (e.g., Howard and Sass, 1964). Mean annual air
temperature on the earth's surface is -16C, varying
from -25C at the equator, to --22C at the poles (Gross,
1993). Air temperatures also decrease with elevation;
lapse rates typically range from -4 to -10C/km.
Air and ground temperatures vary not only spatially
but also have short and long term temporal trends. From
about 1400 to 1900, air temperatures were about o.soc
colder than present day (the "little ice age"). Before that,
from about 1000 to 1400 A.D., there was a Medieval
warm period when air temperatures were about O.SOC
higher than present day.. Over the past 1 m.y., temperatures have fluctuated about 5-6C as the glaciers
retreated and advanced in a series of ice ages. The last
such ice age ended about 10,000 yr ago as temperatures
rose 5--6C, coincident with the emergence of civilization
(Folland et al., 1990). Since Late Cretaceous time (70 Ma),
Sedimentation
Sedimentation depresses heat flow, and the depression persists long after sedimentation ceases (assuming
no erosion). The magnitude of depression depends on
the thermal conductivity of the sediments deposited and
the rate and duration of sedimentation. A one-dimensional numerical model (Deming and Chapman, 1989)
can be used to estimate the effect of sedimentation on
near-surface heat flow for sediments of different thermal
conductivities (Figure 9.9). The initial background heat
flow in the model is 60 mW fm2, the thermal conductivity of the basement is 2.5 WI m K, and the sedimentation rate varies from 10 to 1000 m/m.y. The thermal
conductivity of the sediments deposited varies from 1.0
to4.0W/mK.
Heat flow is significantly depressed by sedimentation
rates on the order of 100 m/m.y. or greater. The lower
the thermal conductivity of the sediments, the greater the
reduction in heat flow. Once sedimentation ceases, it
may take tens of millions of years or more for the heat
flow deficit at the surface to be alleviated. For example, if
sedimentation proceeds at 1000 m/m.y. for 20 m.y. and
then stops, it takes 40 m.y. for the heat flow deficit to be
reduced to half of its maximum value (Figure 9.9).
Some interesting and unexpected conclusions can be
drawn from this example. Because the depression of heat
flow by sedimentation tends to persist long after sedimentation ceases, underburden rock deposited before a
source rock may affect the eventual maturation of
organic material in the source rock. Also, if sedimentation proceeds at a constant rate, but the thermal conductivity of the sediments deposited increases, heat flow
--
%.
~'1.
-c
0
177
10
co
:::J
0
".>".>
lo..
(.)
t q,
t
0'
.c.
c. 10
!v
..c::
g:
'<::
....
Cl
Q:
~
Q
..,;;;
Q)
:::!:l
c:
t q2
10
Groundwater Flow
s=klpwCwv
(11)
178
Deming
gradients (Hubbert, 1940) or (2) as a result of free convection. Strictly speaking, it is impossible to define a
hydraulic potential for a fluid whose density is variable.
However, the use of a hydraulic potential or pseudopotential is a useful concept that can be used to obtain
insight into geologic problems for which an exact answer
is unobtainable.
Common geologic mechanisms for creating potential
gradients are sediment compaction and elevation
gradients. Groundwater flow driven by sediment
compaction and pore collapse, however, is a relatively
inefficient mechanism for heat and mass transport unless
pore fluids are focused spatially or temporally (Cathles
and Smith, 1983; Bethke, 1985; Deming et al., 1990b).
Flow velocities tend to be very low, and the total amount
of water is limited to the water contained in the original
sediments. Few direct observations of thermal anomalies
have been ascribed to compaction-driven flow. Bodner
and Sharp (1988) speculated that relatively high geothermal gradients associated with fault zones in the Gulf
Coast basin in south Texas may be due to the upward
flow of pore water along the faults. However, they were
unable to rule out alternative explanations for the high
thermal gradients, such as changes in thermal conductivity.
In contrast to compaction-driven flow, regional
groundwater flow over distances of 100-1000 km due to
potential gradients arising from elevation differences has
been documented for several sedimentary basins. There
is virtually no doubt that such flow systems exist (e.g.,
Bredehoeft et al., 1982). Correspondingly, the thermal
regime must be disturbed, with the nature of the thermal
disturbance depending upon the depth and velocity of
groundwater flow. In foreland basins, the following
pattern is typical. In the foothills of the mountain range
where water infiltrates at high elevations, the geothermal
gradient and surface heat flow are depressed as heat is
advected downward by moving groundwater. Near the
midpoint of the basin (axis of the basin fill), flow is
largely horizontal and the effect on basin temperature is
minimal. At the distal edge of the basin, flow is forced
upward by the basin geometry, leading to a high geo
thermal gradient and high surface heat flow. This pattern
has been observed in the Western Canadian basin
(Majorowicz and Jessop, 1981; Hitchon, 1984;
Majorowicz, 1989); the Kennedy, Denver, and Williston
basins of the Great Plains province of the central United
States (Gosnold, 1985, 1990); the Uinta basin in western
United States (Chapman et al., 1984); the Great Artesian
basin in Australia (Cull and Conley, 1983); and the North
Slope basin in Alaska (Deming et al., 1992). The thermal
anomalies associated with these flow systems can
dramatically influence the temperature-dependent
generation of oil and gas, and the flow systems themselves may play a role in oil and gas migration (Toth,
1988; Carven, 1989; Bethke et al., 1991; Meissner, 1991).
Free convection in sedimentary basins may conceivably arise from density gradients due to thermal
expansion or the presence of solutes. For free convection
to occur, the permeability of the porous medium must be
sufficiently high and a density inversion must exist, with
higher density fluid overlying less dense. In most sedimentary basins, however, free convection is probably
inhibited because the increase of salinity (and density)
with depth overshadows the decrease in density due to
increased temperature and concomitant thermal
expansion.
Relatively little is known about the occurrence or
significance of free convection in sedimentary basins;
there are no direct observations of the process. However,
the presence of extensive quartz cementation in sandstones found in the geopressured zone of the Gulf Coast
basin of the southeastern United States requires much
higher fluid volumes than could possibly be supplied by
pore water alone (Land, 1991). One solution to this
discrepancy would be to invoke free convection within
compartmentalized cells in the geopressured zone.
Within each cell, the pressure gradient would be hydrostatic and fluid would be free to circulate (Cathles, 1990).
An interesting new hypothesis by Nunn (1992) attributes
episodic subsidence in the Michigan basin to the catastrophic release of heat by periodic episodes of free
convection in the upper 10 km of the continental crust, as
originally envisaged by Deming (1992). At the present
time, however, the possible occurrence of free convection
in sedimentary basins and the continental crust remains
speculative. For example, little is known about the extent
to which fracture permeability exists in the crust and
what stress states and tectonic processes could create
sufficient permeability to allow for free convection.
Temperature (C)
-10
40
[\'
1 !--
-Cl
36 C/km
\
\
\
\
\
3-
\
\
\
\
E 2
Cl>
.::s:.
.c.
c.
190
140
90
lkpikpuk well
\\
\
5
Figure 9. 11. Equilibrium temperature log (solid line from 0
to 600 m), and equilibrium temperature estimated from
extrapolation of bottom-hole temperature (142C, 4316 m),
lkpikpuk well, North Slope basin, Alaska.
179
(12)
where Tmax is in degrees Celsius. Barker and Pawlewicz' s model is empirically based and is calibrated from
modern temperature measurements in which the
tectonic setting allows a reasonable supposition that the
present-day temperature is the maximum temperature to
which the vitrinite has been exposed .
Because vitrinite reflectance is most sensitive to the
maximum temperature to which it has been exposed,
present-day values at the Ikpikpuk well were most
probably frozen in near the time of uplift, erosion, and
cooling, estimated to be about 55 Ma, and have not
changed since that time (Table 9.2). The vitrinite
reflectance data (Figure 9.12) thus record a snapshot in
time of the thermal conditions existing at the Ikpikpuk
well about 55 Ma.
An examination of the vitrinite reflectance data and
maximum paleotemperatures estimated from equation
11 verifies that substantial erosion has occurred at the
Ikpikpuk well (Figure 9.12). Vitrinite reflectance at the
top of the Nanushuk formation near the ground surface
is 0.40 %Ro, which is equivalent to a maximum paleotemperature of 50C. The present-day mean annual
ground temperature determined from extrapolation of a
temperature log is about -11 oc (Lachenbruch et al., 1987,
1988). For an average geothermal gradient of 36C/km
(Figure 9.11), erosion of about 1.7 km is implied.
However, air and ground temperatures during much of
the Cenozoic were probably at least 10-l5C warmer
than today (Savin, 1984). Similarly, heat flow may have
been lower or higher 55 Ma, or the thermal conductivity
of the eroded Colville Group and/or Sagavanirktok
Formation may have been lower or higher than the
average thermal conductivity of other geologic units at
the Ikpikpuk site. Thus, although it is apparent there has
been considerable erosion at the Ikpikpuk well, it is not
possible to make a precise estimate of the total amount
with any certainty.
Thermal maturation of potential source rocks (Shublik
Formation, Kingak Shale, pebble shale unit) may have
occurred before, during, or after the time of maximum
burial. However, most thermal maturation probably took
place from about 100-50 Ma, when source rocks were
being buried by deposition of the Nanushuk Group,
Torok Formation, Colville Group, and/ or Sagavanirktok
Formation, together representing a combined thickness
of more than 3 km. If one assumes that the kinetic properties of organic matter in source rocks are understood,
the problem of estimating the timing and extent of
hydrocarbon generation reduces to reconstructing the
thermal history of the Ikpikpuk well from two control
points: the present-day thermal state (constrained by
present-day temperature measurements) and the
thermal state about 55 Ma (constrained by vitrinite
reflectance data).
180
Deming
Sedimentation Rate
(m/m.y.)
235
946
320
16
12
14
235-208
208-133
133-122
122-116
116--106
106--95
168
721
0
76
1304
869
6
10
13
130
79
95-55 (?)
55-1 (?)
1-Q
-1000
-1000
10
25
10
interval heat
permeability
2
flow (mW/m ) (10- 14 m2)
4.0
31
10
44
.79
153
4.5
392
293
2.9
61
.16
1
Torok
--
E 2
Pebble
'
shale~
.c
cQ).
3
Sadlerochit
\
\
Lisburne
40
\
'--,
\
60
\+BHT
\
\
80
\
100
\
\
Endicott
basement
5
Temperature Equivalent (C)
Figure 9.12. Average vitrinite reflectance determined from a piecewise linear regression on measurements (solid line), and
predicted for steady-state conductive heat flows of 40, 60, 80, and 100 mW/m2 (dashed lines), lkpikpuk well, North Slope
basin, Alaska. Also shown are interval heat flows calculated from vitrinite reflectance and thermal conductMty data along
with average permeabilites measured parallel to bedding.
181
Table 9.3. Vitrinite Reflectance and Thermal Conductivity Data, lkpikpuk Well
Geologic Unit(s)
Nanushuk Group
Torok Formation
Pebble shale unit
Kingak Shale
Shublik Formation/Sag River Sandstone
Sadlerochit Shale
Lisburne Shale
Endicott Shale
Thickness
(m)
Estimated Thermal
Conductivity
(W/m K)
Vitrinite Reflectance
Top-Bottom
(%Ro)
869
1304
76
721
168
320
946
235
1.4
1.7
1.6
2.0
2.4
2.5
2.9
3.4
0.40-0.48
0.48-0.67
0.67--Q.68
0.68-1.15
1.15-1.50
1.50-2.15
2.15-2.60
~2.60
182
Deming
Temperature (C)
40
+
I\'I\''
I \
\+
I
160
120
80
.::t!
....,
.s:::.
'
' .._.,
'
a. 2
Q)
Cl
._o1
,.1
.....
240
''
\
" -,:001
\
......
E
200
"'
....
....
--- ---
'
''
'
.....
.....
'
l ...
'
''
... '... '
... ot:
References Cited
Ahem, J. L., and S. R. Mrkvicka, 1984, A mechanical and
thermal model for the evolution of the Williston basin:
Tectonics, v. 3, p. 79-102.
Angevine, C. L., P. C. Heller, and C. Paola, 1990, Quantitative
sedimentary basin modeling: AAPG Continuing Education
Course Notes Series 32, 133 p.
Barker, C. E., and M. J. Pawlewicz, 1986, The correlation of
vitrinite reflectance with maximum temperature in humic
organic matter, in G. Buntebarth and L. Stegna, eds., Paleogeothermics: evaluation of geothermal conditions in the
geological past, Lecture Notes in Earth Sciences: Berlin,
Springer-Verlag, p. 79-93.
183
184
Deming
185
186
Deming