Professional Documents
Culture Documents
July 2016
Tim Fipps
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
TABLE OF CONTENT
1. Introduction .................................................................................................................... 2
2. YTL Power International Berhad ................................................................................... 2
3. Accounting basics ........................................................................................................... 6
4. Financial statements, their users and uses ...................................................................... 8
5. Statement of financial position ..................................................................................... 14
6. Compliance of YTL Power International's annual report with MFRS ......................... 21
7. Summary ....................................................................................................................... 22
8. Conclusion .................................................................................................................... 23
References ........................................................................................................................ 25
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
1. Introduction
In this paper, the International Financial Reporting Standards FSR101, known in Malaysia as
the Malaysian Financial Reporting Standards (MFRS101), are reviewed, and the information
disclosed in financial statements of a public listed company in Malaysia is evaluated, with
particular focus on the statement of financial position.
The selected company is YTL Power International Berhad.
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
100% in YTL Power Generation: combined 1'212 MW power plants in Paka and
Pasir Gudang, both in Malaysia
100% in Wessex Water: water supply and wastewater services in the southwest of
England
20% in Jawa Power: 1'220 MW coal-fired power plant located at the Paiton Power
Generation Complex in East Java, Indonesia
Together with partners from Estonia and China, YTL Power International Berhad -- with a
45% stake -- is developing a USD 2.1 billion oil-shale development project in Jordan, which
includes a shale oil fired power plant with approx. 500 MW planned power output. As the
project partners seek full financial close and final approvals, expected in the course of year
2016, thereupon construction can start and the plant become operational by 2019. [The Star,
2016]
2.3. Parent
YTL Power International is a subsidiary of YTL Corporation, a Malaysian family-controlled
infrastructure conglomerate, which has global investments in utilities, power, cement,
construction, real estate, hospitality as well as information technology.
YTL Corporation Berhad was founded in 1955 by Tan Sri Dato' Seri Yeoh Tiong Lay, after
whom the group is named.
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
The YTL group of companies is controlled and run by members of the Yeoh Tiong Lay
family. Under Francis Yeoh, the eldest son of the founder, the YTL group "has grown from a
small but profitable business focused on cement and building into one of Malaysia's ten
largest groups" [Fagan, The Telegraph, 2002-03-31].
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
As of 13 July 2016, YTL Power International has a market capitalisation of more than RM11
billion, with over 8.1 billion shares outstanding. [Reuters market data, 2016]
With the book value of the stock at RM11.6 billion as per AR2015, the price to book value,
P/B ratio or P/BV, is almost 1:
Price to book value = P/BV = Market price per share / Book value per share = Market
capitalization / Total book value = RM11'504'270k (Reuters, 13 July 2016] /
RM11'628'698k [AR2015] = 0.99
This valuation could indicate that the market sees the company earning rather mediocre
returns on its assets, and does not expect its business conditions to spurt up any time soon.
3. Accounting basics
3.1. Accounting definition
"Accountancy is the art of communicating financial information about a business entity to
users such as shareholders and managers." [Elliott & Elliott, 2011, page 3]
In companies and organizations, accounting provides the basis for management decisions and
accountability through the processes of recording, summarizing and presenting historical and
prospective information.
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
For their limited resources, businesses have more allocation possibilities (opportunities) than
they have resources. The competing potential allocations and their anticipated returns are
established in budgets.
Hence, in financial terms, planning means budgeting.
(3) Analysis and decision-making
Accounting extends from analysis to decision: Historical as well as prospective information is
compiled and analyzed, for management to make decisions and to exercise control.
(4) Accountability and performance appraisal
The recorded information is used for analysis and appraisal of the company performance,
hence ultimately for performance appraisal of those in charge of the company (directors,
management).
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
determining the credit worthiness of the organization; terms of credit are set by creditors
according to the assessment of their customers' financial health
- Tax authorities: for determining the credibility of the tax returns filed on behalf of the
organization
- Investors: for analyzing the feasibility of investing in the company, as investors want to
make sure they can earn a reasonable return on their investment before they commit any
financial resources to the company
- Customers: for assessing the financial position of its suppliers which is necessary for them
to maintain a stable source of supply in the long term
- Regulatory authorities: for ensuring that the company's disclosure of accounting information
is in accordance with the rules and regulations set in order to protect the interests of the
stakeholders who rely on such information in forming their decisions
Accounting information is communicated to external users usually in the form of financial
statements.
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
(IASB) and help to harmonize basic guidelines on financial reporting throughout the world.
With this commitment, FRF and MASB created a local adaptation of the IFRS (International
Financial Reporting Standards): the Malaysian Financial Reporting Standards (MFRS).
[Deloitte IAS Plus, 2014]
On 17 November 2011, the MASB issued a new MASB-approved accounting framework, the
MFRS Framework, which is a fully IFRS-compliant framework and equivalent to the IFRS,
since word-for-word in agreement with the existing standards set by the IASB. The MFRS
Framework comprises standards as issued by the IASB that are effective on 1 January 2012.
The adoption of the MFRS Framework allows Malaysian entities to be able to assert that their
financial statements are in full compliance with IFRS. [Deloitte IAS Plus, 2014]
The MFRS Framework is to be applied by all entities other than private entities for annual
periods beginning on or after 1 January 2012, however, with a few defined exceptions for the
application date.
The MASB plans to implement accordingly also possible future amendments to the IFRS.
[Bernama, 2015a/b]
With regard to all entities preparing financial statements in compliance with the MFRS, the
MASB has also set in place a requirement that these statements include an explicit and
unreserved statement of compliance with IFRS.
The International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), whose IFRS (International Financial
Reporting Standards) guidelines are used in more than 100 countries mainly in Asia and
Europe, and the U.S. Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) have engaged in talks to
align their rules. They have achieved "convergence" in many areas. [Jones, 2012]
14
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
The statement of financial position consists of 3 main segments: (1) assets, (2) liabilities, and
(3) owners' equity.
The accounts under these three segments are connected: a firm has to pay for all the things it
owns (assets) by either borrowing money (taking on liabilities) or taking it from investors
(issuing owners' equity).
This relationship reflects the basic accounting equation: Assets = Liabilities + Owners' equity
The statement of financial position, or balance sheet, gets its name from the fact that the two
sides of the equation above assets on the one side and liabilities plus owners' equity on the
other must balance out.
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
(L2) Financial liabilities, either short-term (repayment less than 12 months) or long-term
(repaid over a period that exceeds one year), excluding amounts shown under (L1) trade and
other payables and (L5) provisions)
(L3) Liabilities and assets for current tax
(L4) Deferred tax liabilities and deferred tax assets
(L5) provisions (for liabilities and charges)
(E) Equity
(E1) Non-controlling interests
(E2) Equity attributable to owners of the parent
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
changes in value. If maturity period is more than 90 days, for example 100 days, then it will
not be considered as cash equivalent.
Cash can be currency, coins, bank overdrafts, cash in savings accounts, cash in checking
accounts, petty cash.
Cash equivalents can be Treasury bills, commercial papers, marketable securities, money
market funds.
(A2) Trade and other receivables
Trade receivables include the amounts that are recoverable from customers upon credit sales.
Trade receivables are presented in the statement of financial position after the deduction of
allowance for bad debts.
Accounts receivable is a legally enforceable claim for payment held by a business against its
customer/client for goods supplied and/or services rendered in execution of the customer's
order. These are generally in the form of invoices raised by a business and delivered to the
customer for payment within an agreed time frame.
Other items include prepayments and deposits.
(A3) Financial assets, either short-term (current) or long-term (non-current), excluding
amounts shown under (A1) cash and cash equivalents, (A2) trade and other receivables, and
(A9) investments accounted for using the equity method
Notes receivable represent claims for which formal instruments of credit are issued as
evidence of debt, such as a promissory note.
(A4) Inventories
Inventories include goods that are held for sale in the ordinary course of the business, or to be
converted into finished goods. Inventories may include raw materials, finished goods and
works in progress.
(A5) Property, plant and equipment
Property, plant and equipment is stated in the long-term or non-current asset section of the
balance sheet. Included in this classification are land, buildings, machinery, office equipment,
vehicles, furniture and fixtures used in a business. Also included in property, plant and
equipment is the accumulated depreciation for these assets (except for land, which is not
depreciated).
17
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
The assets reported as property, plant and equipment are described as long-lived, tangible
assets. They are also described as fixed assets or as plant assets.
Generally, the property, plant and equipment assets are reported at their cost followed by a
deduction for the accumulated depreciation that applies to all of these assets.
(A6) Investment property carried at fair value through profit or loss
Such investment property is often real estate held for investment purposes.
(A7) Intangible assets
Assets without any physical substance are classified as intangible assets. Goodwill is a type
of an intangible asset.
An intangible asset is an asset that lacks physical substance (unlike physical assets such as
machinery, software and buildings) and usually is very hard to evaluate. It includes patents,
copyrights, franchises, goodwill, trademarks, trade names, the general interpretation also
includes software and other intangible computer based assets.
(A8) Biological assets
Biological assets are living plants or animals, which bear agricultural produce for harvest,
such as mango trees grown to produce mango fruits and cows raised to produce milk. They
are either carried at cost less accumulated depreciation and impairment, or carried at fair
value through profit or loss.
(A9) Investments accounted for using the equity method, i.e. investments in associates,
and investments in jointly controlled entities
Equity accounting is usually applied where the investor holds 2050% of voting stock, since
this implies significant influence on the decisions of the associate by the holding company,
though ultimately depends on the nature of the actual relationship between investor and
investee.
The ownership of more than 50% of voting stock creates a subsidiary; its financial statements
consolidate into the parent's. The ownership of less than 20% creates an investment position
carried at historic book or fair market value (if available for sale or held for trading) in the
investor's balance sheet.
In equity accounting, the investor's proportional share of the associate company's net income
increases the investment (and a net loss decreases the investment), and proportional payments
18
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
of dividends decrease it. In the investors income statement, the proportional share of the
investors net income or net loss is reported as a single-line item.
(L) Liabilities
A liability is an obligation that a business owes to someone and its settlement involves the
transfer of cash or other resources.
Liabilities must be classified in the statement of financial position as current or non-current
depending on the duration over which the entity intends to settle the liability: A liability
which will be settled over the long term is classified as non-current whereas a liability that is
expected to be settled within one year from reporting date is classified as current liability.
Current liabilities are liabilities that are expected to liquidate within a year or normal
operating cycle, whichever is longer.
The statement of financial position must distinguish between and present separately current
and non-current liabilities.
(L1) Trade and other payables
Trade and other payables primarily include liabilities due to suppliers and contractors for
credit purchases.
Other payables include accrued expenses.
Accounts payable is money owed by a business to its suppliers shown as a liability on a
company's balance sheet. It is distinct from notes payable liabilities, which are debts created
by formal legal instrument documents.
(L2) Financial liabilities, either short-term (repayment less than 12 months) or long-term
(repaid over a period that exceeds one year), excluding amounts shown under (L1) trade and
other payables and (L5) provisions)
Short-term borrowings typically include bank overdrafts and short-term bank loans with a
repayment schedule of less than 12 months.
Long-term borrowings comprise of loans which are to be repaid over a period that exceeds
one year. Current portion of long-term borrowings include the installments of long-term
borrowings that are due within one year of the reporting date.
Examples for financial liabilities (excluding provisions and accounts payables) are
promissory notes and corporate bonds.
19
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
(E) Equity
Equity is what the business owes to its owners.
Equity is derived by deducting total liabilities from the total assets: Equity therefore
represents the residual interest in the business that belongs to the owners.
Share capital represents the amount invested by the owners in the entity.
Retained earnings comprise the total net profit or loss retained in the business after
distribution to the owners in the form of dividends.
Revaluation reserve contains the net surplus of any upward revaluation of property, plant and
equipment recognized directly in equity.
(E1) Non-controlling interests
Non-controlling interests are to be presented within equity separately from the equity
attributable to the owners of the parent.
(E2) Equity attributable to owners of the parent
20
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Regarding issued share capital and reserves, the following disclosures are required:
- numbers of shares authorized, issued and fully paid, and issued but not fully paid
- par value
- number of shares outstanding at the beginning and the end of the period
- description of rights, preferences, and restrictions
- treasury shares, including shares held by subsidiaries and associates
- shares reserved for issuance under options and contracts
- description of the nature and purpose of each reserve within equity
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
7. Summary
The AR2015 provides information as required by MFRS, and also additional information:
1. Exposure to financial risk
The AR2015 (pages 152-159) explains in detail that and how the firm's activities "expose it to
a variety of financial risks, including market risk (comprising of foreign currency exchange
risk, interest rate risk and price risk), credit risk, liquidity risk and capital risk".
2. Segmental information
The AR2015 (pages 163-165) informs how the group's businesses are broken down in "five
reportable segments", and elaborates extensively how they fared individually:
(i) Power generation (contracted)
(ii) Multi utilities business (merchant)
(iii) Water and sewerage
(iv) Mobile broadband network
(v) Investment holding activities
The group's management "monitors the operating results of operating segments separately for
the purpose of making decisions about resources to be allocated and of assessing
performance".
However, the AR is short of elaborating how lumping these "segments" together under the
22
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
roof of YTL Power International provides benefits across the segments or for the overall
organization.
3. Segment contributions to profitability
The segmental presentation of the results and the descriptive outlook show how much the
company's profitability depends on the group's water segment, Wessex Water. Or, in other
words, how little the remainder segments contribute.
However, the AR does not reveal whether the group is changing its business focus, for
example exploring new areas (besides the Jordan project), or expanding the water business.
4. Historical record
The historical record extensively elaborated in the annual report shows how much the
company has gained from acquisitions, after initially developing the two power plants in
Malaysia. However, it shows also how much the growth of YTL Power International has
come to a halt, as these acquisitions date back several years. Only the communications
segment appears to develop new business, though with arguable success, as the losses made
show. Accordingly, the earnings per share (EPS) have dropped.
8. Conclusion
The purpose of financial reports is to cater for the needs of users of accounting information in
order to assist them in making sound financial decisions. Financial statements serve to
provide key facts about the performance and the disposition of a business to parties external
to this business. To fulfill the fundamental characteristics required from accounting
information (i.e. to be relevant, reliable, comparable, consistent, material, understandable,
and timely), financial statements are subject to accounting and reporting rules and standards.
With the Financial Reporting Act 1997, Malaysian lawmakers have commissioned the
Malaysian Accounting Standards Board (MASB) as an independent authority to develop and
issue accounting and financial reporting rules and standards to be used for statutory financial
statements by companies registered in Malaysia. The Financial Reporting Act 1997 gives
legal authority to the standards issued by the MASB.
In the meantime, the MASB has adopted the International Financial Reporting Standards
23
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
24
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
References
Bernama (2015, December 6). Malaysian companies to adopt international financial reporting
standards by 2018. Astro Awani. Retrieved from http://english.astroawani.com/businessnews/malaysian-companies-adopt-international-financial-reporting-standards-2018-83989
Bernama (2015, December 1). Malaysia to fully converge with IFRS in 2018. Borneo Post
online. Retrieved from http://www.theborneopost.com/2015/12/01/malaysia-to-fullyconverge-with-ifrs-in-2018/
Deloitte IAS Plus (2014, February 14), Malaysia. Retrieved from
http://www.iasplus.com/en/jurisdictions/asia/malaysia
Elliott, B. & Elliott, J (2011). Financial accounting and reporting (14th edition). London:
Financial Times / Prentice Hall.
Fagan, M. (2002, March 31). Who the hell are YTL? The Telegraph. Retrieved from
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/2758352/Who-the-hell-are-YTL.html
Hermanson, R. (1998). Accounting - a business perspective. USA: McGraw-Hill.
Jones, H. (2012, April 29). Long push for new accounting standards. Reuters, The Star.
Retrieved from
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2012/4/29/nation/11193657&sec=nation
Menkhoff, T. & Gerke, S. (2002). Chinese Entrepreneurship and Asian Business Networks.
Research Collection Lee Kong Chian School of Business. Available at:
http://ink.library.smu.edu.sg/lkcsb_research/4795
The Star (2016, May 9). YTL Power increases stake in Jordans Attarat Power Co to 45%
Retrieved from http://www.thestar.com.my/business/business-news/2016/05/09/ytl-powerincreases-stake-in-jordans-attarat-power-co-to-45/
25
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
26
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Attachment 1:
YTL Power International Berhad: "Annual Report 2015", Statement of Financial Position,
page 60
27
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
28
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Attachment 2:
YTL Power International Berhad: "Annual Report 2015", Statement of Financial Position,
page 61
29
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
30
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
Attachment 3:
YTL Power International Berhad: "Annual Report 2015", Financial Highlights 2011 - 2015,
page 2
31
Accounting and financial reporting: YTL Power International Berhad Review AR 2015
32