Professional Documents
Culture Documents
of
Metropolitan- Museum
Art
--
IK^
t4.
A
;-?
,?
F'
ft.
.0 ,~
tI
I 4I
~ '
'AJ
- :,g'.
-a
rlass
_ _o_
---.-
. - !.7
-f
J__L -
A:.
_vf-A
-
.=Xr~:
~~:---_...::~"~
---a.: --_: j-,.,.~, -;
- -:---~ ,,
'*
-'
j<$itr
_x.:-',-'--:---:'.'::---'--a
S
. -
:l
-,-
.
--,_....-.-
.:.-
, ".:
..
5i
::. ':
::--...
..
..__ -
*-*
*~t~~
J
pl
Ir
.1
t
.4<y
54
?.?
- -
_?
?-=
11-
zl~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..
't'
-0-
'
*4
r
??
-L3
-r.
..
-r.
1\
C)
r
?=,i
C
... A
..
?r?
?'-- --? --,- -,?
....
?.?-?.
-r
ec
r
cl
"
? t
,rkl
.--.,
k~~-
*I
-'
3,
?r,
U-
t-
'J
;
Ct
\a
Li4
I ".Vb
A\
11
*.
-~ ;t
-I
ni} ll
,,n31
1,
Jl
.N
:;:
tIt
11I1
B1'
Dl1
~,o T
Itt,If
/ i
........
-1--il
^^
?^^I'LlI
+.r-
I.
r
"!'S.
......
r'\?
rr
THE
BUILD
OF
THE
PAPACY
AND
SUZANNE
THE
ARCHITECI'IRE
BOORSCH
METROPOLITAN
MUSEUM
OF
ART
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
VATICAN
c'I:'Y
00
r-
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
Pia Tower
Stanze of Raphael
Cortile del Belvedere
Library of Sixtus V
Corridor of Bramante
Cortile della Biblioteca
Braccio Nuovo
Cortile della Pigna
Nicchione del Belvedere
Belvedere of Innocent VIII
Scala di Bramante
Fontana della Galera
Casino of Pius IV
Fontana dell'Aquilone
Fontana del Sacramento
Vatican Gardens
13 :
IDIZ
"ThE"
;@
JL<__
18
22
8
W.
DIRECTOR'S
NOTE
Cover:Detail, SaintPeter's
Basilicaandpiazza.
GiovanniBattistaPiranesi,
1748 (seepp. 30-31)
Insidefrontcover:Detail,
The CortiledelBelvedere
fromthenorth.MasterHCB,
1565 (seepp. 52-53)
Throughout the centuries the Vatican has become one of the world's most
remarkableensembles of architectureand art. The splendors of the basilica of
Saint Peter's, Bernini's colonnade, and the papalpalaces, the magnificent works
in the VaticanMuseums and libraries,and the delightful gardens have made the
Vatican, and Rome, a magnet for artists, scholars, and other travelers for
generations. Michel de Montaigne wrote in his travel diary of 1580-81 that
Rome was "a place where foreignersat once feel themselves the most at home,"
and he set about "studying every part of Rome in detail." He found its many
attractions"bad for the feet and good for the head"-an antidote to "ennuiand
idleness." Montaigne viewed statues "framed in niches in the Belvedere, and
the fine gallery of paintings that the pope is collecting from all parts of Italy."
On Christmas Day 1580 Montaigne attendedMass at Saint Peter's and he
mentioned the basilicaseveral other times, but unfortunatelyhe never described
it. He called Pope Gregory XIII (1572-85) a "great builder," which he would
be considered today had he not been succeeded by Sixtus V (1585-90), the
greatest builder of all the popes. It is tantalizing to think of the observations
Montaigne might have made had he been in Rome when Sixtus was pope: in
1586 when the Vatican obelisk was moved or between 1588 and 1590 whenat long last-the great dome was being raised over Saint Peter's.
No matter. Montaigne gives us the flavor of late sixteenth-century Rome,
and contemporary prints and drawings display the architecture.In conjunction
with The VaticanCollections:ThePapacyandArt, the unprecedentedexhibition of
Vatican treasuresat The Metropolitan Museum of Art, this Bulletindescribes
the history of the building of the Vaticanthrough prints and drawings of the
fifteenth through eighteenth centuries. Much as the history of the papal
collections can be traced through works in the exhibition, so can the building
programs of the popes be traced through these prints and drawings, of which
some document buildings now destroyed, some record projectsenvisioned but
not executed, and some show buildings very much as they are today.
Of the forty-nine prints and five drawings selected by the author, Suzanne
Boorsch, Assistant Curator of Prints and Photographs, only the drawings and
three prints come from other collections. Her compilation in its comprehensiveness truly demonstrates the universality of the Metropolitan'scollection of
prints and illustrated books. Among the sources used for this publication are
the NurembergChronicleof 1493, Antoine Lafrery'ssixteenth-century Speculum
RomaeMagnificentiae,
Domenico Fontana'sDella trasportatione
dell'obelisco
vaticano,
and prints by Falda, Vasi, and Piranesi-all of which are distinguished works
of art as well as fascinating documents of the most dynamic centuries in the
creation of the architectureof the Vatican.
Philippe de Montebello
Director
www.jstor.org
OLD
S
SAINT PETER'S
&?
r"..
...
h^--4^~~~~
?1^,,
VL. W. 6f.
6.
IC*OeRAPSNIA
zav&o
Aaw*f.. d
?I
Ne
www.jstor.org
c.
1684
Atriumof
of Old
OldSaint
SaintPeter's.
Peter's.Martino
Martino
Atrium
Ferrabosco,
c. 1620,
1620,published
published
1684
Ferrabosco,
The Dutch artist Maarten van Heemskerck spent several years in Rome in the 1530s, producing a notebook
of topographical sketches that are among the prime
visual records of the city. The sketch shown above is a
copy of one of these. In it a feeling of the dimensions
and a trace of the character of Old Saint Peter's are
preserved. Visible in the foreground at both right and
left are four columns of the nave, which support an
entablatureand a wall above that has painted or mosaic
decoration. This colonnade and wall are interrupted,
however, by the huge piers of the new structure-only
as much of the old basilica had been demolished as
necessary to make room for the new. In the center of
the drawing is the structure built by Donato Bramante
early in the sixteenth century to house and protect the
altar of the old basilica.
Dr
of
rawingsspecificallyto recordtheappearance
Cross-section
of Old SaintPeter's.
MartinoFerrabosco,
c. 1620, published1684
Foundationmedalby CaradossoshowingBramante's
projectforSaintPeter's.AgostinoVeneziano,1517
of building activity during the Renaissanceand Baroque
periods. Alberti had a plan for remaking the city of
Rome, with Saint Peter'sat the center. Saint Peter'sitself
was to be enlarged-the nave would stand, but the other
three arms would be rebuilt, of equal lengths, and a
dome was to cover the crossing.
Nicholas V had Bernardo Rossellino begin building, and in 1452 he started a choir at the western end,
outside the wall of the apse of Old Saint Peter's.
Unfortunately-as was to happen again and again in
the history of Saint Peter's and the Vatican-when the
pope died, the impetus for building died with him. After
the death of Nicholas, although some construction was
done under Paul II (1464-71), anotherhalf-centurywent
by before major work on Saint Peter's was resumed.
Julius II (1503-13) and Donato Bramante were the
8
Bramante'sdesignforthedomeof SaintPeter's.
SebastianoSerlio,published1540
SaintPeter'sfiom thenorth.Anonymous,1540s
Bramante's final ideas for Saint Peter's will probably never be known. But if the details are uncertain,
the audacityand scale of his design are not. The grandeur
of Bramante's conception was such that, even though
construction was barely begun when he died in 1514,
all subsequent architects were bound by what had been
built. On April 18, 1506, the foundation of the first of
four colossal piers was laid, and twelve impressions of
a commemorative medal by Caradossowere placedwith
the foundation stone. The print by Veneziano(opposite,
above) reproducesthe medal and its inscription-TEMPLI
PETRI INSTAURACIO,VATICANUS M-and
Peter'sby Antonio
da Sangallo.Anonymous,
published1548
Planfor SaintPeter'sby
Antonioda Sangallo.
Anonymous,published1549
10
Opposite:Longitudinal
sectionforSaintPeter'sby
Antonioda Sangallo.
Anonymous,published1548
F O R MA
FOM
P E T RI
'T E M P L I
IN
VAT
ICANO
i
u'
,t
t,~,,:,!~
.T
A-4ToN,
'
l~"'f
AANTONIVS
IV
INV EN TOR
I
VS EIVS DISCIP
EFF EC. OR.
S G ALL
LABAC(.C
=_z_
'
1_
*
_-
.-
G RAT I A
"
ETr
Bramante the following year, and after its extraordinarily fast beginning, work on Saint Peter's slowed down,
even coming to a virtual halt, for nearly two decades.
2_ b_~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~\a6
P RI V
___
' _(
L EG I 0
PlanforSaintPeter'safter
Michelangelo.EtienneDuperac,1569
of arms and the legend CUMGRATIAET PRIVILEGIO, signi-
fying a copyrightprivilege.
Sangallo'splan presenteda major cross and four
lessercrosses,all surroundedby domes. Threeends of
the crossbecameapses;in frontof the fourth,flat, side
Sangalloaddeda shortnave and a faqade-his planis a
compromisebetween a Greek and a Latincross. Bell
towersat the ends of the facaderose to the sameheight
as the dome, and therewere smallertowersat the four
cornersof the square.The main body of the building
had three stories, the first with Doric columns and
pilasters,the thirdwith Ionic,andtheintermediatestory
with flatpilasters,all appliedto the surfacerhythmically,
eithersingly or in pairs,giving the structurea busy and
bewilderingappearance.The entireplanwas extremely
complex, with three naves, ambulatorieswith chapels
throughthe apses, and numeroussubdivisions.
Sangalloconstructedthe barrelvaults on the east
and the south, and he finished the outer wall of the
southernapseup to the top of the firststory.His model
would have been relativelyeasy to follow to the basilica's
completion, if his successor had so desired. But such
was not to be the case.
After Sangallo's death in 1546, Paul III asked
Michelangelo to take over the architecture of Saint
Peter's. Already seventy-one years old, Michelangelo
protestedthat he was not an architectand that he wanted
only to be allowed to finish the tomb of Julius II, begun
12
13
MICH
bI
C4ann 1o
.-
?~~~~~~~~jp
SouthelevationforSaintPeter'safterMichelangelo
andothers.EtienneDuperac,1569 orlater
14
TEMPLI
DIVI
PETR
ijj^^^r_^~~~~~~~~
~niches
_ n _Hds
1
|1 |N
a
I^Bl lthe
...-..-"-~--"'
?*
A>
-ei
-^
:-
Ch
bdr,*l B
4,
l,
s imwtm.
Hit Dewrin
kvrs nu'nmi
SaintPeter'spiazza. Anonymous,1570s
16
I'Be
Methodssuggestedfortransporting
theobelisk.
NataleBonifacioafterDomenicoFontana,published1590
1 NA 1
17
r-
Nn
theobeliskstanding
The obeliskstandingnearOld SaintPeter's;its transportation;
engineering feat the best documented of the Renaissance.
Various methods of moving the obelisk were
suggested. Fontana charmingly illustrates (see p. 17)
some of the other proposals: B shows the obelisk being
moved by levers, in C it is on a half-wheel, and in G it
is lowered in a cogwheel. In E the obelisk is to be moved
at a 45-degree angle. The letter A represents Fontana's
own winning recommendation (the putti, of course,
are not part of the means of transportation).
Fontana's plan called for first encasing the obelisk
in a wooden sheath and then building a wooden tower
of scaffolding around it. The obelisk would then be
lifted by means of ropes and windlasses onto a sixtyfoot-long carriage, upon which it would be lowered to
a horizontal position. Finally, the carriage would be
rolled along a causeway the 260 yards eastward to the
chosen position, and the obelisk raised.
By papal edict, Fontana was given the right to
gather materials and raze buildings, and for several
months he made his preparations. He received permis20
in thepiazza. NataleBonifacioafterGiovanniGuerra,1586
andwedges of wood andmetal.All was finishedat the 22nd
hour of the same day and at a signalfrom the Towerall the
artilleryfireda greatsalvo as a signalof jubilation.
FOOM
a~~~~~~~~~Ka
I
DAM
;O~~~~~~~~~w
k ?r(~~~~~~~~~~~
NOVA CSAUJCr,
ATCM
AIF~~tf~
~~~
~~VIONAER
rito
peam
~~: .?;..A.riSco
AWOLVEM'Wa~~~~~~~~~~~~
PWO
sl
sa
~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~?~~o ;:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i
if
!1
DL
Jj
,*1
ii
'
5~~
cAlts.
,i
'?~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i
!1
-rr'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~A
'~~~~Do
SK4rCnz
F;auunavrrHaraE
DParrHauvAncrllyp~~O
r-
Irr~~~~~~bA
-?
gvw aalE
r~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I!
~F
Erao
rrxnANw
GlowWK
- J~~~CMNYIP?LIUQT
Q)
XXCV
a. unzk
77-'
VWCIT
F-=7EM
--,b
ibm
X
I
Consecrationof the crosson the obelisk, with Saint Peter'sprojectedas complete.Natale Bonifacio after Giovanni Guerra, 1587
22
Paul V (1605-21) made the decision that had perhaps been inevitable for a century, since the foundation for the first of Bramante's huge piers was laid
on April 18, 1506: despite the objections of some cardinals, he gave the order to demolish what was left of
Old Saint Peter's. The principaljustification given for
doing so was that the old basilica was falling down. A
competition was held to design the new facade, and
even at this time the question of the final plan-whether
the church would be finished on the plan of a Greek
cross or whether a nave would be built, giving it the
plan of a Latin cross-was undecided. Reverence was
still accorded to Michelangelo and what was assumed to
be his intention to finish the churchon a centralplan, but
to do so would have left some of the sacred areaof Old
Saint Peter's uncovered. Paul V seems to have favoreda
nave, and finally the decision was made to build one.
Thedomeof SaintPeter's.
HieronymousFrezza, published1696
The engraving on p. 25 shows Maderno's facadeas
he completed it in 1612, additions that he was enjoined
to make, and other additions that were never built. In
1612 Maderno completed a facade seven bays wide, the
portion that carriesthe inscriptionIN HONOREM PRINCIPIS
APOST. PAULUS V BURGHESIUS ROMANUS PONT. MAX. AN.
PONT.
VII.
23
25
SaintPeter'sfiom thesouthwest.GiovanniBattistaPiranesi,1748
_
_A*
'X'
X
7;t--
_ral
'xf
I,
'l I,
II
''
-?
=
I:
I
I.,,
f-
I,,
R6',,,
,;,.,/,
.
.-.
I I
I,i:
..
:;
i
,.
I
!tll)Yliirlirlr;lllrrliilllliirrrvurr ?ulllllu--Y?'rr,-r.
_-
r.-cY--
?r
:-
ice
;4t
r ..
_,k-h-
'?`?r
--e
L-,
IeK-<
cBFclr
V;l U'lA DE
'ESTERNO
ft reg ,le e
r'reow ivmied
.1 C.AAt.-.^..
>/A
'at
,c^
- (<'e
rair,,e,
71"
acn
.u/
.fue
NO.. A,r,,eru.'l,a
JiNI,A TICA
,ro
,ran ut,o. .
i .eer r 3.[,a
-(t
,
,r/er.m,,r,,
,ft,,, , ne/i'
,/,{
Ir:
i ii
;Iiii
?,
Il'i! I;
i. Ii
1,:
' illi
Ili
iI.;
::
;i
1I ;1i i.II ?I'
1
i,l
i
:i II?
:I:
;i iii:
,,
,i
,i
,
i;j; .
i;iii
;tii!::,
('I
i ?;i:I
Ii
1,
I!
,I
.,.1s
:1
.,
ii
DELLAPIZZAr
POtiCI
3_-
fI
S-PIETRO DI ROMA
? ?
Planandelevationof thecolonnade
in SaintPeter'spiazza. GiovanniBonacina,1659
SaintPeter'sBasilicaandpiazza. GiuseppeVasi,published1786
_
_,
___
_
_=
_:
--
.;
___C
--------
.LL-
--- -- -;---
_____
:
-----
__
--
__
_--
IC-LL'==.?=----=-r
r;
-LI-
s.
= s
_
=
,
_
_
-----
".- :
- , * .:*.
._ _-.-_' '-~-?-_->.
_- - - ~-_.
--~~~~~~~~~~~~~*_.~,
~~--,- .
':
-----
=c:
,?r
r;I
I.-- /-- .
? ...
{ ..-
Cs,
.-/ ,
-:
a
---
j.
---,
---
--=-
-.1'
;5?- -
4.
I
--?---ccs=:
t
*
1?
I
'_
- _
__.__
'_
..
. . - .,,
SaintPeter'sBasilicaandpiazza. GiovanniBattistaPiranesi,1748
30
?e
;rc?
-;-- -----
I
:
--;
II`
i i
'
Illll I[11
......
faith." In a line are the obelisk, topped by a cross symbolizing the triumph of Christianityover paganism;the
door to the church commemorating the first vicar of
Christ; and the dome, with the cross at its pinnacle
dominating the entire edifice. Better than any other
artist, Piranesi recorded Bernini's intention and his
success-the creation of an immense space that is
nonethelessenclosed and orderly,a vast and monumental
space that is nonetheless subordinate to Saint Peter's
itself, a space that in fact adds to the grandeur of the
building and in so doing enhances the power and
authority of the Church.
31
THE
entrance portico to new Saint
Peter's(below)providesa transitionbetween
exteriorandinterior,an interimspacewhere
pilgrimscan preparefor entry into the sacredbasilica.It also servedas a passagewayto the Scala
Regia,the stairwayleadingto the ApostolicPalace(see
pp. 38-39)-to the left of the equestrianstatue of
Constantinevisible in the distancein this engraving.
The portico, 162 feet deep and850 feet across,is reminiscent of the narthex in the Constantinianbasilica,
which had been among the partsstandinginto the seventeenthcentury.The five entrancedoors to the basilica itself, which correspondto the threelargerandtwo
smallerdoors of the facade,are cappedby the alternating triangularand segmentalpedimentsas firstseen on
Maderno's
INTERIOR
OF
SAINT PETER'S
SaintPeter's.
Entranceportico,
GiuseppeVasiafter
Francesco
Panini,1765
33
&?
K
"NO
.;-V
IC
s \11 vs
II
%;
2 /
N,_
.
I;
',
1I-,
rL
--?t
?
i'*t
t
???CI-i
;,
?tci?
tTf??
'tf
? ?.???(li?????i
r''
i...?41i.?.??;.
t?
fI:'F' -L.-+?.i?
)Lt ?-1??1(????1.
(;' ' '? ' ' !I
i' C' ' 1:?
Ir
it' ''
N.
^-^""."'
?)?
ka
M----nI
II
.I
I
CP-c
:?
I
''
c
...,
?1
t
i',C
?
??
iIX
??
i;?
:i?..
!l
I:/
i
r'.
I-?
:I;
;;iI;
Ii
-. -.,
,i
Ir
4^^
ItIfI
L
--:
t" 1
;
LI^ii? E,'
I.I1 .
-zo
,i
I :.
m
i.^
,
ii ..
il i I;
L.
1 i.
.-t'.
I i.,
Al
Ii
;I I
I.
i
I
.1,
I
I
17thcentury
TheBaldacchino.
Anonymous,
+
?
The CathedraPetri.FranfoisSpierre,17thcentury
36
:?- s**`*
*?*
;x
-:S ~-Ih r*z
`4v
T 5::
c-?
2
a
"sr
,2**
s,r
?2 c
-u
c? ;` U
??*
CP
"sr
a-
C7
THE
SCALAREGIA
VED UTA
iaan CO^rv
onduv
dAIPsBMInta.^cAIOJ{('
The
Scala Reia
Govianan
SiJ"ta. cPAwonia.
iWWAotWVu.
Otauiai
aiercu .
38
ceea'U//a;
Rra ? etwcenowazza
eua
6Camera
oratolaDorf
*rus
tdi44wU6j.
TRANJVEJSA
SCALAJRVM
DtINWATIO
It
CVI
ICBNOOGRAPHIA
EARVNDEM
Planandelevationof theScalaRegia.
FilippoBonanni,published1696
ti I0
irotA
suctmtoBernuu
ntynofattal
AM
c d>er
o,,,ero
/rce/ra For/c,Ir.ff Do tSonsw
miJi
cA<,-oInn
M 3CjruO ^ef
3// Corur
dJnf^t.
m/fncr.nJJ ttfta de/PArdAto .
THE
APOSTOLICPALACE
_.-.
F.-
-,
O'l
'
Ato
,i.
Pa
Pbl
"
-
..-
-- -
According to Vasari, Bramante had a plan for totally remaking the buildings of Saint Peter's and the
Vatican, and along with his design for Saint Peter's Basilica and for the Cortile del Belvedere (see pp. 48-57)
Bramante most probably had or was evolving a grand
palace
formed
scale and
Bramante's ideas set the
bythe
elargely
our time, what
of the Vaticanas it hase
plraan
he actually built is a small proportion of the fabric
today. One of the few structures he actually saw
finished-or at least almost finished as it is said to have
been completed by Raphael after Bramante's death-is
the new facing for the eastern side of the palace (the
Barbazza
The SistineChapel.Francesco
afterFrancesco
Panini, 18thcentury
The SistineChapel.
AmbrosiusBrambilla,1582
42
stretching farther eastward from the corner of Bramante's loggias and with a faqade that matched
Bramante's. In the view looking north across the piazza
(a detail of one of the engravings depicting the moving
of the obelisk in 1586; opposite, below), the wing of
Gregory XIII is the large building just to the left of the
obelisk.
1'
I.r
;t.scjeccl-
'CC?--
r ?,
7? I?:
Jrc,.
r
? c
rSIdt,?2j??"
rrr
--jyl--f3--tP
:1.
IAok
i:
45
t
^~~~~~~~-
---
I- -
--
-'
_'
*
;r Jlr?-
r?
C-l
-
- _
_si
---
-n
A;A..
.*i
i'.-?.
- --
-~~~~~~f
~~~~~~~~L~f
""
;pc
_ .
-,-
r ?
I-----'
?I?r
LI
-C
??
lr
fZC
C
-t
c ??
,'aLI
? ''
??C1'
Ai*
;-1
CLIPLlj,
LI
-~~~~~
c
_IrCC
--PL_
?
..
-e
ew ~2?-),
4J-
AO..-,w
~
_
'b~c
46
_
I_?--
~ ~ ~~
*:
.
-r
;---
- ---;
tsL`
-41CedaPlriQI-_
i
__I
i----l---..Lcrx-------c--'
-=t.i
--
IE;------
_---i-r
?IZr_CP- :_,
_ _-----r--:---
----
--.rC
i-'
.-; _
-
-F-....
i:
-- -
-_r-
----
iII
r-
-r- --T .
SP"
--e
a
.J--.
rF
--
'_a
s'4
I_ICIL-?I-LI
-----r.
.tr
LrES-"-
----","trr-=-
t
I---t;r_-;-=r.-------
--I----
-T-
t
--=i
u p;
--fr---h
_C
r=
r
4
e -gs
iLte
L~~~d
~
-
.r
~~
--I
---
SaintPeter'sandtheApostolicPalace.
GiovanniBattistaFalda, 1667-69
Detail, ApostolicPalace,bird's-eyeview.
GiovanniBattistaFalda,published1670 (?)
1
47
THE
CORTILE
48
.;xu L
?.:
r;j
LI??.. *
fr-C
,:?J1
c.
L-?i
c.
r?r?-;
...
,,i?C??
c: ( r
jEcs
'jp:
.?
rr
?r
?-
,t
c.;
i-b,
tP
4?
" ? CC
r.'': ` ?
ri
?'
rcci?.i
\
.)*c
?:
4
114
r?.
.i
?.
C,
r
'?
.?
?r ,
9??;5i:??
.rr
9?
..
rg?
i?
-?
C??- ? .:,
,? ,(b \
'-X?1
''
:r
,
?* L3
,
'C
c?
:.TC-;Ly?
5?
.L'"
:hV_
f
*r
,j
..
?? ?)'
'
c
?t r
_.'?.C".
?if:? .L
.L
?:
4r?:
.rT 'dC; i
?.
?I*?,
sc,: ;iCII-? t,
?:?L..i?1?
1:
I??r?ifr. ' C:r*F
? r.?.
:,
??t: ?..'t:.
J5
r??
?
r,
?:, ?'
?.
.r.
?
?,
"Pic;l? ??-.
?,
ao` L
???- ?j
.?I. "
I\
P.
)?;
?. i?2'.r P_ ?'
)2. ?.?t;t.???3/ h.1,e
..i;
'?
F-j?
i
:
"
?
C13
i?lt'?.
rr
Y1 ?c`'i
(4
t ?i r
jE
c?.
iii
r` :
l?:i?P?
r
ce ,,
;CII+L;
,,
1
"
- '
??
4
.?.j
6b
uta uvvp\
tfA3143su4WdH
SJOl aflJSumVp
II
.1*.
..
-AZI,
-i
.:.-
'
i_
**-
,.
~.'
'-'
:,- ',":,l s
.,
<'7k.^>
....."'~~.
L. ^
-t
..
I -.
I~~~~~~~~~~~?
I,,
I
*
'
''
N
.,
'^^^..
...
'-'
:.
'
~~~11~7~':.-:,?
:.-.!.,'?
'",
..FPt
""
vC
'"
...,
.;--: .,,:.,.
" '
. ~ "
- 'I E' UW
E
-'..
-.
.
?4
'~' "ic
.-
^t
^i.^f
ai^..
--o
,
.~ ,'
..-.
..
.
.....
^1
-4+'..
.. ..
*;
'
''
c
.....~:.........,
....
=,
'.
:.;
10 ,~:..:',~,. , l~~
*
'.- " ~
..
......-.
,?,;
(;
?
-C--
--
-?r
--C-LIiF-CC?h
Le rL,t'L
_.SEr
.
s;
!,?rlLA
?-?-?ll'-i
C??i;l?j:'"
h ??
?I
?? ??
-51k-
?? c
.. -t..
??
"
.F-
T I-?
ICZi
r -'
.?.
' -r?4
iLIL
iSz
---;--r
T-;C.
,irr:.nwanvcragm
-iY,
..
??
rabu?l??l1?II
;;'-:i''oWLhSBa
?
:I
?-----
r?..??\?cr_
- -L
?5,
.?
i?:
SFFRrii
I?iiJfLI
;rZ?CJVdlll
"
FILl'itY;'
'
??r
'-4
r ?
"II
15"
r&?
--J
IC'A*-
--
:;?r?J?
?'
..
i.rll
.,
::r:
?"'
??:
ICJI
.
I,
i.?'
r'?ii"??:
r
?:.
..
::
i:??
Y..
;?'?
r'
,?
::r:..
??
??
., ?::?.
?,r
''.??? '???
.???': .?
.???
?;...
-2'
?.?
r J
-.....-
?*y Xti-t
..
?-?
?.
I:
r;
i?
u? ---
;r
C
Ci;
. ??
I
C
F
L:..., J...?-
?-
:
:z ;t
;:iT.
???rc;
?r
'
.?.?. ...
?
......
r?
;??
II;
I a_C;LI??
-n
=i
L'? ?.
?:-?;
--. r
rLI(
:r???- ??
.r
r, c?..
The CortiledelBelvedere
fromthewest.Hendrickvan Cleve, 1550
TheLaocoin.MarcoDente,before1527
-'"'1
The CortiledelBelvedere
Ammanati(?), 1552-53
fiom thesouth.Bartolommeo
.?
, -a-^rr-'-r
BB
B----~~~~~~~~~?r
^r-"'
I
4
-d~~~~~~~~g
I-4'.*
51
-~~~~~~~~
r
- ~~~~~~~:
- _ =!
-~~~
The Cortile
delBelvederefrom
thenorth.
MasterHCB, 1565
53
--N\
lt4
.i
-.
*^
,p
I
c -. ;L
c,1L;
:>Id
Il
//',
V1.ati,j
Ir
4i:
"'
`gp
? ':??.
':?
.:
ii.
Is
?B
?"
I.
j.
i\ i 1
IIAIJC119
's??. ??
'-? ?"?
'' ?.'?:? ?
j.
:
1:
t?
?;.tt:Y
:?
.
'?
1
?
/?1FiiY:.
??
37
.
',uM :f
The1I,
Cotilel
elvd
r i' C i mme n
M.i;:AJ'l
Eti
eD
TheCortiledelBelvederefrom
thesouth.EtienneDupre'rac,
1565
2Lkn
s
md1sL
-r
r.
"
.
-
fimrifimi
/j:
..
........
-i
IMIAINIVM
.HlKAPV
',{
R
RG IO
NGGMA
.HORTORVM.
I'.T.
.VATICAN
lKI .SVNISITRVCTI)NVM
l?A:::Sl::
E.
. X. 1
MORlM.OMNIA
5VM.A.
L0M
'
N-r-.' NI
.ORUS. TE RRARYM. AEDIFIC I h.'(ANIFIA(
MAIISTAS.POSTVLAT.LONG
T'::~l-V:,~~:
...
R..IPTi
rI.
DIC
O R '
OPfRE
A.A
.....
^. A
-l^^^^
r
F.IX' .PRA4I.V..
'^
'?iB?
T.iri^w,4M?Aw
f<%r
_
.-i-
r h<?,*
56
TheNicchionein theCortiledelBelvedere.GiuseppeVasi,published1786
fore the fortifications were built was an entrance to the
statue court. The statue court itself is here seen from the
opposite side and more accuratelythan in the van Cleve
print of 1550 (p. 50).
obelisk, the completion of the dome of Saint Peter's, and the building of the final block of the
Apostolic Palace, also changed forever the Cortile
del Belvedere by deciding to have a library built across
it. Domenico Fontana was given the task of designing
the building, on the site of the colossal steps and stairs
between the lower and intermediate courts. The south
facade (left) repeated the orders of the corridorsbut as a
whole was much more cluttered and fussy than anything Bramante would have designed.
More important than the departurein surface style
from Bramante, however, was the repudiation of his
concept for the Cortile del Belvedere. The theater, the
pleasuregardens, and the harking back to classicalideals
all seemed inappropriatelyworldly and pagan to Sixtus
V. The library could have been built almost anywhere
in the large expanse to the west of the courtyard, but to
do so would not have accomplished Sixtus's purpose.
By the one relatively small addition of the library, Sixtus V-more effectively than if he had torn anything
?-`c+=PQCt;"",I-.
i.
r?-
41c
L'-
THE
In
CASINO
OF
PIUIS
IV
-~-
c-
--
Battista
1670(?)
Falda,published
cGiovanni
The Casinoof Pius IV. GiuseppeVasi,published1786
59
! .A
-r~p4'
I6~~-#
'a'
\ ,^
>!
*A !-I^.-j
tI
hA
/~~~~~~~~
-L
II
Mg
'p
IA :
.i - I
LI
a
I
I
L. .'-.'
.t
-Omt
f`
Jc
1j
rI1
FOUNTAINS
TheFontanadelleTorre.GiovanniFrancescoVenturini,
publishedlate 17thcentury
the fountain, and two more sit atop the towers. The
papal coat of arms, surmounted by a putto bearing the
papal tiara, is within the pediment above.
The designer of this and the other fountains shown
here remains unknown. The inscriptions in the engravings attribute them to Maderno, but it has also been
suggested they are the work of Jan van Santen, called
Vasanzio, papal architect after 1613.
-L r
TheFontanadellaGalera.GiovanniFrancescoVenturini,
publishedlate 17thcentury
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~I
--
_T,
-C
FONTANA
lkI. ,,m_
62
eit.
DETTA
_
.
-*
.--'
ANA
L DET
'
G.X..-
t
bre
i.t.in
.o uce
di Carlo
GIacBo.
offi IFstmpra in
inc.
PONTIFICIO
Madernti.
onla publ
ah
ctn
FiP
TheFontanadelloScoglio.GiovanniFrancescoVenturini,
publishedlate 17thcentury
engraving, p. 55), it had existed in the first half of
the sixteenth century, and it was probably remodeled
underJulius III (1550-55) to look as it did in the Cartaro
view. Under Paul V, it was remodeled again, giving it
the appearancerepresented in the engraving opposite.
This fountain has been delighting visitors ever since it
was built-in 1622 an Englishman wrote in his travel
diary:"Thereis a rareship at one of the fountains which
has twenty-five little ordnanceson a side, and with turning a cork do discharge water and make good reports,
as if there were powder." The eagle, also a heraldic
device of the Borghese family, can be seen crowning
the rockwork. Under Pius VI (1775-99), considerable
changes were made in the part of the fountain against
the wall, but the ship has remained its prime focus.
Borghese heraldicdragons, spouting water, are also
seen on the large Fontana dello Scoglio (Fountain of
the Cliff), which was formerly also called I1 Diluvio
(The Flood) and is now mostly known as L'Aquilone
afterthe Borghese eagle that tops the fountain (see above
and "12" in the Faldaview). Made around 1611-12 and
set in the wooded area in the western section of the
Vaticangardens, the fountain with its rough rockwork
aroundcavelike openings is completely rustic in character. Quite overgrown today with mosses, ferns, and
vines, it provides an effective transition from the manmade architecture of Saint Peter's and the Vatican to
the natural beauty of the gardens.
63
del S. Pcrt.
NOTES
P. 9: Vasari,G. Delle vite de'piu eccellenti
Florence,
pittoriscultoriet architettori.
1568, part 3, vol. 2, p. 726.
P. 12: Ramsden, E. H., trans. and ed., The Lettersof Michelangelo,Translated
fromtheOriginalTuscan,EditedandAnnotated.2 vols., Stanford, Calif., 1963,
vol. 2, p. 69; Vasari, G., Vite, p. 751.
P. 15: "... . evidence was published...:" Millon and Smyth, 1969 (see
Sources).
Pp. 20-21: Barr, Mrs. Alfred H., Jr., unpublished translationof Fontana's
text, Print Department, Metropolitan Museum, pp. 42, 44-45, 55, 71, used
with her kind permission.
P. 25: Translationby G. C. Bauer from excerpts of Bernini, D., "Lifeof the
Cavalier Gian Lorenzo Bernini," in Bauer, p. 28 (see Sources).
P. 31: Translationfrom Wittkower, R., Art andArchitecture
in Italy.Baltimore,
1973, p. 195;document by Bernini transcribedin Brauer,H., and Wittkower,
R., Die Zeichnungendes Gianlorenzo Bernini. Romische Forschungen der
Bibliotheca Hertziana, nos. 9, 10. Berlin, 1931, p. 70, n. 1.
P. 36: Quoted in Lavin et al., p. 184, n. 28 (see Sources).
P. 58: Document cited in Friedlaender, W., Das Kasino Pius des Vierten.
Kunstgeschichtliche Forschungen herausgegeben vom Koniglich Preussischen Historisch Institut in Rom. no. 3. Leipzig, 1912, p. 123, A. 1.
P. 63: Yeames, A. H. S., "Rome in 1622." Papersof theBritishSchoolat Rome
6, no. 7 (1913): 484.
CREDITS
Unless otherwise noted, works are from the collections of The Metropolitan
Museum of Art, photography is by Gene Herbert and other members of
the Metropolitan Museum Photograph Studio, and measurementsgiven are
from the border line.
Pp. 4, 23, 39: Plates 6, 25, and 82 from F. Bonanni, NumismataSummorum
PontificumTempli VaticaniFabricam(Rome, 1696), engravings, 12/4 x 81/4,
12/8 x 87/8, 83/4x 113/8in. Edward Pearce Casey Fund, 1981 (1981.1149.2)
Pp. 5, 7, 25: Plates 4, 5, and 12 from G. B. Costaguti, Architetturadella
Basilicadi S. Pietroin Vaticano(Rome, 1684), engravings, 171/4x 247/8(plate),
17516 x 275/8(plate), 17/4 x 273/8in. Rogers Fund, 1952 (52.519.173)
Pp. 6, 9, 48-49: Drawings. Kupferstichkabinett, StaatlicheMuseen Preussischer Kulturbesitz, Berlin
Pp. 7, 18-19: Engraving, 193/8x 433/4in. (p. 7: detail). The Elisha Whittelsey
Collection, The Elisha Whittelsey Fund, 1959 (59.508.102)
P. 8 (top): Engraving, diam. 75/8 in. Harris Brisbane Dick Fund, 1953
(53.601.184)
P. 8 (bottom): Plate 40 from S. Serlio, II terzolibro(Venice, 1540), woodcut,
11/8 x 81/2in. (image). The Bequest of W. Gedney Beatty, 1941 (41.100.134)
Pp. 10-17, 20-21 and 45, 42, 44, 45 and 52-53, 54: Engravings, Harris
Brisbane Dick Fund, 1941. P. 10 (top): 13/2 x 16/4 in. (sheet) (41.72[3.20]);
p. 10 (bottom): 223/16x 167/8in. (sheet) (41.7213.28]); p. 11: 13 x 193/4in.
(sheet) (41.72[3.22]); p. 12:181/6x165A6in. (41.72[3.29]); p. 13:153/16x213/in.
(41.72[3.23]); pp. 14-15:13/4 x 185/6 in. (41.72[3.24]); pp. 16-17:157/ x 22
in. (41.72[3.68]); pp. 20-21, 45: 20/2 x 459/16in. (p. 45: detail) (41.72[3.47]);
p. 42: 21'/16x 15/2 in. (41.72[3.76]); p. 44: 14/8 x 193/8in. (41.72[3:75]); pp.
45, 52-53: 173/16x 227/16in. (p. 45: detail) (41.72[3.72]); p. 54:2016 x 145/ in.
(41.72[3.73])
dell'obeliscovaticano
P. 17: Folio 8r from D. Fontana, Della trasportatione
(Rome, 1590), engraving, 151/6 x 93/8in. Harris Brisbane Dick Fund, 1936
(36.15)
P. 22: Engraving, 19'5/6 x 14'/16 in. The Elisha Whittelsey Collection, The
Elisha Whittelsey Fund, 1960 (60.611.61)
P. 24: Engraving. Map Section, Royal Library, Stockholm
Pp. 26-27: Etching, 157/8x 24 in. (plate). The Elisha Whittelsey Collection,
The Elisha Whittelsey Fund, 1955 (55.567.1)
P. 28: Etching, 5/4 x 93/A6in. Joseph Pulitzer Bequest, 1917 (17.50.19-16)
Pp. 29, 57, 59: Plates 41, 181 and 182 from Raccoltadellepiu belle vedute
antichee modernedi Roma (Rome, 1786), etchings, 8/4 x 127/, 83/8x 13'5/6,
81/2x 133/8in. Rogers Fund, 1952 (52.519.72[1.45, 2.81, 2.82])
Pp. 30-31, 34-35: Etchings, 153/4x 213/16,161/16x 23/2 in. Harris Brisbane
Dick Fund, 1937 (37.45.3[44, 45])
Pp. 29, 36, 37: Engravings, Harris Brisbane Dick Fund, 1945. P. 29: 21'/4
x 33V8in. (sheet) (45.82.2[44]); p. 36: 263/8x 143/8in. (45.82.2[39]); p. 37:
31/4 x 205/8in. (45.82.2[41])
Pp. 32-33: Engraving, 183/8x 27 in. (plate). Rogers Fund, 1966 (66.549.4)
Pp. 38-39: Engraving, 193/8x 283/16in. Harris Brisbane Dick Fund, 1924
(24.66.1852)
Pp. 40-41: Drawing. Graphische Sammlung Albertina, Vienna
Pp. 41, 48: Details, folios 57v and 58r from H. Schedel, Libercronicarum
cum figuris et ymagibus ab inico mundi (Nuremberg, 1493), woodcut,
9 x 203/4in. Rogers Fund, 1921 (21.36.145)
Pp. 42-43: Engraving, 19/8 x 271/2in. The Elisha Whittelsey Collection,
The Elisha Whittelsey Fund, 1966 (66.555.61)
P. 46 (top): From II terzo librodel' novo teatrodelle chiesedi Roma (Rome,
1667-69), engraving, 77/8x 111/2 in. (plate). Harris Brisbane Dick Fund,
1931 (31.67.4 leaf 53)
P. 46 (bottom): Plate from Scenografiadeipiu celebrimonumentisacrie profani
antichie modernidi Romae adiacenze(Rome, 1864), lithograph 8 3/16 x 12/8 in.
Pp. 47 and 60, 58: Plates 4 and 3 from Le giardini di Roma con le loro
piantealzate e veduteinprospettiva(Rome, n.d. [1670?]), engravings, 119/16x
in. The Elisha Whittelsey Collection, The Elisha Whittelsey
113/4, 83/4X169/16
Fund, 1961 (61.532.26[4, 3])
P. 50 (top): Engraving. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam
P. 50 (bottom): Engraving, 181/8x 127/8in. (composite). The Elisha Whittelsey Collection, The Elisha Whittelsey Fund, 1949 (49.97.122) and Harris
Brisbane Dick Fund, 1941 (41.72[2.75])
P. 51: Drawing. Fogg Art Museum, HarvardUniversity, Cambridge, Mass.
P. 55: Engraving. Avery Library, Columbia University, New York
P. 56: Folios 97v, 98r from Fontana, Della trasportationedell'obelisco,engraving, 15 x 181/8in.
Pp. 61, 62, 63: Plates 4, 5, and 3 from part 3, Lefontane ne' palazzi e ne'
giardini di Roma, engravings, 85/16x 113/8,81/2x 12, 81/2x 12 in.
\%
'r '
I' Ik
//
*7I.
, -
?-
\\
d'X'"
I-? d 's~
---"--
I-
4~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
t'''
-__t .'
/t ijj
L/
_^
Y^ ^
jt
e - )';
va
I,'
*
-, , 1
.,
Il
'? '
Po
.?
''
.?,
II0^a-
'r
:f
/?'
:I
: ??
i
L
'
--"%
4-I
'4w
o-n
~ *c';
Q
11$
'L
F1:
*'
*
?.F
S
' -,~~--_
~ ~~~
-
P*
dy
*
^~
?*
'
?-
/CT?
4*
ol
;s@?. ^
Eh
I
'--^t^'LII
-~~
~ ~
r,
^~~~~,%i
r-
77
TC'
I
,
N,- :-
I ? I
4,.iL~
01
7' Q.Bkffiz
~-
'
Prm
'
niiactaus,w;rpm
?ontzes
.--.smrn
- pf^tjh
DLUt
vaffiwm^^
^tr Tf^mpl'"
ticommcidus
;,
s-
~ ol-rrad
b^c
@31,
ry
V-^~
trencmz
Portnvim
enn. ,bi
Sutnt
mm.
^wc
s,
I TI
bonilhdtd,
fix^odem ,uoblhci
R
ND
. L .xA
E PA rA VII.
.A
^'
b^~~~~~C
PiazzadWiun4tadal,t5c elj
Lep'ic,
hebbm in '4nrio
TenUpli auqrt,
t^"fiham
w,
Pitoruc
jnjnfWh
wW'fl dfr ht
2'tepU'
VI
Zelodel benpubli-.coe
dId0
&FtdQuI
talren^o
i
Hsw
cmnfulerr.
nmoditeti
ha,iiafrPdofrtintPep
-
,5j$4;natwnern
tIy~fSe.xj'r~'am
aUcupIenenim
*Jl4rzmuim
2 rum
-di
lon.t4
j
-1"
'tOtU1S
,,dldl.
-- _ 1~^
'.1
Nowir-~
I
u
tJ,
si rimcdiasse4quetfi1,,,n
VNg
PA PAALESSA DRA4
f,
as
diS-Pief,
l GChutfa
'
, -, L.
-I
--
'.
'
-_.
- -
-.
ccuno,w
dit^&
'--" d~-
o>