Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Some of the Earth's largest submarine debris ows are found on the NW African
margin. These debris ows are highly efcient, spreading hundreds of cubic
kilometres of sediment over a wide area of the continental rise where slopes
angles are often <1. However, the processes by which these debris ows
achieve such long run-outs, affecting tens of thousands of square kilometres of
seaoor, are poorly understood. The Saharan debris ow has a run-out of
700 km, making it one of the longest debris ows on Earth. For its distal
450 km, it is underlain by a relatively thin and highly sheared basal
volcaniclastic layer, which may have provided the low-friction conditions
that enabled its extraordinarily long run-out. Between El Hierro Island and the
Hijas Seamount on the continental rise, an 25- to 40-km-wide topographic gap
is present, through which the Saharan debris ow and turbidites from the
continental margin and anks of the Canary Islands passed. Recently, the rst
deep-towed sonar images have been obtained, showing dramatic erosional and
depositional processes operating within this topographic `gap' or `constriction'.
These images show evidence for the passage of the Saharan debris ow and
highly erosive turbidity currents, including the largest comet marks reported
from the deep ocean. Sonar data and a seismic reection prole obtained 70 km
to the east, upslope of the topographic `gap', indicate that seaoor sediments to a
depth of 30 m have been eroded by the Saharan debris ow to form the basal
volcaniclastic layer. Within the topographic `gap', the Saharan debris ow
appears to have been deected by a low (20 m) topographic ridge, whereas
turbidity currents predating the debris ow appear to have overtopped the ridge.
This evidence suggests that, as turbidity currents passed into the topographic
constriction, they experienced ow acceleration and, as a result, became highly
erosive. Such observations have implications for the mechanics of long run-out
debris ows and turbidity currents elsewhere in the deep sea, in particular how
such large-scale ows erode the substrate and interact with seaoor topography.
Keywords Debris ow, sidescan sonar, turbidity current.
INTRODUCTION
Submarine debris ows are important sediment
transport mechanisms on continental margins,
1389
1390
M. J. R. Gee et al.
100 km
CANARY
ISLANDS
Landslide
1
4.5
2
3
28N
El Hierro
Landslides
4
Hijas Seamount
25W
20W
15W
Saharan
Seamounts
Madeira
26N
Canary Islands
Saharan Debris
Flow
22W
Africa
25N
20W
18W
16W
Fig. 1. Location map showing the Saharan debris ow, Canary Islands, Saharan Seamounts and the location of
landslides around El Hierro Island. The thick dotted line shows the location of a long prole shown in Fig. 14.
Contours are shown every 100 m and annotated in km.
2001 International Association of Sedimentologists, Sedimentology, 48, 13891409
1391
sediment transport pathways. Numerous sediment ow pathways, originating from the continental margin and island anks, converge on and
pass through this gap (Jacobi & Hayes, 1992;
Wynn et al., 2000). It is probable that the gap has
been a pathway for turbidites and debris ows for
at least a few hundred thousand years (Weaver
et al., 1992). The Saharan debris ow owed
through the gap at 60 ka (Gee et al., 1999),
interacting with and eroding a series of local
highs that form a 7- to 30-m-high, EW-trending
ridge. The Saharan debris ow directly onlaps the
distal part of the El Julan debris avalanche on the
SW ank of El Hierro and is therefore younger
(Fig. 2). The new data (Fig. 2) show that this ridge
deected the Saharan debris ow towards the
west, whereas turbidity currents appear to have
owed directly over the ridge.
GEOLOGICAL SETTING
Sediments on the NW African margin eastwards
of the Canary Islands consist mainly of pelagic
El Golfo landslide
San Andres and
las Playas landslides
Ch
an
ne
la
xis
Fig. 11
4 El Julan landslide
Hierro
Fig. 5C
28 00'N
Fig. 10
Fig. 8(A)
Fig. 8(B)
Area mapped
using TOBI
27 30'N
Fig. 9
?
Limit of basal
volcaniclastic facies
Dividing ridge
Fig. 7
13
20 km
g.
Backscatter lineations
Fi
Fig. 5A
19 30'W
19 00'W
18 30'W
X1
27 00'N
18 00'W
Fig. 2. Data location and general interpretative map, showing locations of 35-kHz proles (Fig. 5AC), TOBI 30-kHz
data (Figs 611) and a single seismic reection prole (Fig. 13). The Saharan debris ow was mapped using EM12
multibeam data and TOBI 30-kHz sonar data. Locations of Figs 711 (TOBI 30-kHz data) are shown by thin dotted
lines. The location of the Hijas Seamount was mapped using GLORIA sidescan sonar data. Contours are drawn at
200-m intervals and annotated every kilometre.
2001 International Association of Sedimentologists, Sedimentology, 48, 13891409
1392
M. J. R. Gee et al.
(Fig. 2 and 3). EM12 multibeam swath bathymetry data show the surface of the Saharan debris
ow deposit to be smooth, compared with the
rougher seaoor directly to the north. TOBI
30-kHz sidescan sonar data show large-scale
erosional features interpreted as erosional scars,
which link with a channel observed on EM12
multibeam data extending to the NW (Fig. 3).
EM12 MULTIBEAM BATHYMETRY
EM12 multibeam bathymetry data allow three
seaoor regions to be recognized on the basis of
their morphology (Fig. 3). The rst region is the
anks of El Hierro where slopes often exceed 30.
These anks are characterized by numerous
pinnacles, irregular ridges and gullies. These
ridges and gullies have an amplitude of a few
hundred metres and a wavelength of a few
kilometres. Pinnacles are typically 24 km across
and 150 m high, sometimes elongated or aligned
downslope in groups of two or three, suggesting
that they could be related to dyke activity
radiating from a central volcanic zone. Large
areas of these anks are affected by landsliding,
resulting in the deposition of debris avalanche
deposits on the submarine island anks and
related volcaniclastic turbidites across the continental slope (Masson, 1996; Gee et al., 2001).
The second region corresponds to seaoor
covered by remobilized pelagic sediment derived
from the NW African margin and transported by
the Saharan debris ow (Gee et al., 1999). The
distribution of this material has been conrmed
using 35-kHz proles, TOBI 300kHz sidescan
sonar images and piston cores (Embley, 1976,
1982; Masson et al., 1993; Gee et al., 1999). It is
characterized by a smooth morphology with low
relief (<5 m), downslope-orientated ridges and
lenticular-shaped features (Fig. 3). These lowrelief features are best observed on TOBI 30-kHz
data, which show them to be surcial debris ow
structures (Masson et al., 1993).
The third region lies to the north of the pelagic,
margin-derived part of the Saharan debris ow
and consists of a channel separated from the debris
ow by a low ridge (Figs 2 and 3). The channel is
30 m deep, up to 8 km wide and over 100 km
long. It extends downslope from the topographic
constriction between El Hierro and the Hijas
Seamount from a point where the seaoor slope
angle increases from 01 to >03 (Fig. 4). The
low ridge to the south of the channel is 10 km
wide and 20 m high and has constrained the
1393
Fig. 3. Grey-shaded topography of El Hierro and the surrounding bathymetry. The edge of the Saharan debris ow is
shown by a white thick line, landslides on the anks of El Hierro are shown by a dotted black line and the Hijas
Seamount by a thick grey line. Note the narrowing of the Saharan debris ow deposit SW of El Hierro between a
topographic constriction formed by the anks of El Hierro and the Hijas Seamount. Note also the location of a
relatively wide and shallow channel oriented NWSE. Contours are shown at 200-m intervals and annotated every
kilometre.
1394
M. J. R. Gee et al.
Bathymetry km
-3.8
Profile C-D
-4.0
>0.3
-4.2
Profile C-E
-4.4
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
Distance km
B
Channel
Ridge
NE
3.4
3.2
28N
-3.9
-4.0
L
K
Bathymetry km
3.8
-3.8
SW
4
-3.7
-4.1
4.2
-4.2
-4.4
70
60
50
40
30
Distance km
20
10
J
K
km
-4.3
10 20
L
M
27N
19W
18W
Fig. 4. Bathymetric proles sampled from EM12 multibeam bathymetric data. (A) Prole CD illustrates a prole
down the Saharan debris ow, whereas prole CE shows the Saharan debris ow along the major channel that
originates SW of El Hierro. (B) A series of proles sampled at 90 to the downslope direction (proles FM) that show
the geometry of the channel and adjacent ridge. Locations of proles are shown in (C).
1395
Fig. 5. Echo sounder proles (35 kHz) showing the Saharan debris ow deposit. Locations of proles are shown in
Fig. 2. Prole A shows a thick debris ow (>20 m) deposit with a relatively smooth base and upper surface. Prole B
shows a more irregular seaoor where a thinner, more irregular debris ow deposit is separated from an erosional
region by a dividing ridge. Prole C shows a broader debris ow deposit upon an irregular subsurface. Note the
buried channel that correlates with the channel shown on the SW part of prole B, located upslope.
1396
M. J. R. Gee et al.
1397
High-backscatter lineations
North and north-west of the high backscatter
region, the seaoor is characterized by more
moderate backscatter levels with a fabric of
high-backscatter lineations trending downslope
1398
M. J. R. Gee et al.
A
Local high
(low backscatter)
X
Lineations
truncated by
debris flow
Edge of
debris flow
Edge of
debris flow
Lateral
facies
Lateral
facies
Y
Depositional
flow lineations
Debris flow
direction
2 km
Lateral facies
Debris flow
Y
Onlap
1 km
40 m
1399
Fig. 8. TOBI 30-kHz sidescan sonar data of a serrated, erosional scarp (A) and very high backscatter and lineations
(B) associated with erosion of the seaoor in the northern part of the TOBI survey region. Light tones represent high
backscatter. See Fig. 6 for location.
1400
M. J. R. Gee et al.
SUMMARY INTERPRETATION
OF TOBI SIDESCAN DATA
The different types of seaoor outlined above are
summarized in Fig. 12. The depositional part of
the Saharan debris ow is restricted to south of
the dividing ridge, although there is a minor
breach by the lateral facies through a low, central
part of the ridge (Fig. 12). The debris ow can be
mapped from EM12 data over a much wider area,
although it is only possible to differentiate the
detailed ow fabric and lateral facies using TOBI
30-kHz data (Fig. 6). The low-relief topography
(20 m) of the dividing ridge was able to deect
debris ow but not turbidity currents, which were
able to overtop the dividing ridge. The passage of
Fig. 9. TOBI 30-kHz sidescan sonar data of arcuate scars on the downslope side of a local topographic high. Light
tones represent high backscatter. The low-backscatter areas to the S and SE are local highs covered by hemipelagic
sediments, and the very high backscatter within the arcuate scars is rough eroded seaoor resulting from the collapse
of the local high. (B) Deep-towed TOBI 75-kHz proler images a series of scarp slopes within the main erosional scar.
(C) A 35-kHz prole show hyperbolae and little subsurface penetration associated with scarp edges. See Fig. 6 for
location.
2001 International Association of Sedimentologists, Sedimentology, 48, 13891409
1401
Fig. 10. TOBI 30-kHz sidescan sonar data of strongly lineated fabric showing detail of blocks and comet marks. Note
slight divergence in the lineations towards the NW. Light tones represent high backscatter. See Fig. 6 for location.
High backscatter
within channel
Downslope
Channel axis
Depositional
flow lineations
Lateral facies
High backscatter
lineations
5 km
Fig. 11. TOBI 30-kHz sidescan sonar data of the northern margin of the Saharan debris ow, high-backscatter
lineations and channel. The high-backscatter lineations between the debris ow and the channel are interpreted as
low-relief depositional ridges that predate the debris ow.
one or more turbidity currents through the constriction is interpreted as being responsible for
most of the erosion observed. Erosion on the
downslope side of the dividing ridge was caused
by the passage of turbidity currents accelerating
into the constriction. The area of `turbidite
1402
M. J. R. Gee et al.
Channel axis
Channel
El
an
ul
landslide boundary
27 30'N
Blocks
?
Dividing ridge
Pressure ridges
?
?
KEY
?
Isolated high
Flow
Area mapped by TOBI
10 km
27 00'N
19 00'W
18 30'W
Fig. 12. Interpretation of TOBI 30-kHz survey data. Thin black dashed line shows the location of the Saharan debris
ow mapped from EM12 multibeam data outside the area mapped using TOBI. Thick grey line shows the location of
the El Julan landslide (Gee et al., 2001).
1403
DISCUSSION
Large submarine debris ows and turbidity currents are able to erode and mobilize signicant
quantities of sediment. Turbidity currents that are
sufciently powerful to erode seaoor sediments
can experience an increase in ow volume and
ow velocity, a process described as autosuspension (Parker, 1982). Erosion of the seaoor by the
passage of a large debris ow can increase the
debris ow volume and also create an efcient
shearing layer, upon which the overlying debris
Fig. 13. (A) Seismic reection and (B) interpreted seismic and 35-kHz prole S of El Hierro. Note the 30-m
erosional scarp, irregular lens-shaped Saharan debris ow deposit and the `double reector' between them. See Fig. 2
for location.
2001 International Association of Sedimentologists, Sedimentology, 48, 13891409
1404
M. J. R. Gee et al.
1405
Fig. 14. (A) Prole of the Saharan debris ow from the continental slope to the lower continental rise. The prole
shows the failure and initiation of a turbidity current and debris ow above 3000 m, the generation of a basal debris
ow facies and substrate failure S of El Hierro and the nal run-out of the Saharan debris ow with a fully developed
two-phase ow structure. (B) A three-dimensional, grey-shaded image of the margin shows the debris ow outline
and pathway of turbidity currents through the topographic constriction SW of El Hierro.
1406
M. J. R. Gee et al.
1407
Summary
The Saharan debris ow was constricted through
an 7-km topographic gap SW of El Hierro. A 7- to
30-m-high topographic ridge deected the debris
westwards, while turbidity currents appear to
have been able to ow over the ridge without
experiencing any discernible change in ow
direction. The volume, velocity and thus erosive
power of turbidity currents owing over the ridge
are likely to have increased, as a result of ow
constriction, resulting in erosion on the leeside of
the ridge. High-backscatter lineations extending
from these eroded regions represent reworked
local sediments. Flow interacting with blocks
10 m high has formed large comet marks >2 km
long, which indicate the ow direction of the
turbidity current.
Around 5 km3 of sediment has been eroded SW
of El Hierro, associated with the passage of one or
more turbidity currents through the region. Seismic reection data show evidence for erosion
directly related to the passage of the Saharan
debris ow, 70 km upslope from the TOBI
30-kHz survey area. The erosion observed in the
study area SW of El Hierro accounts for <10% of
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank the Captain, ofcers and crew of RRS
Charles Darwin cruise CD108. This work was
funded by Southampton Oceanography Centre.
We gratefully acknowledge Tim Le Bas for the
processing of the TOBI 30-kHz data. M. J. R. Gee
gratefully acknowledges Marco Ligi for advice on
seismic data processing, NERC studentship GT4/
95/252 and the research facilities at Earth
Sciences, Oxford University, and the Southampton Oceanography Centre. The gures for this
paper were prepared with GMT (Wessel & Smith,
1991), PROMAX version 60 and ERDAS software.
REFERENCES
Allen, J.R.L. (1971) Transverse erosional marks of mud and
rock, their physical basis and geologic signicance. Sed.
Geol., 5, 167385.
Belderson, R.H., Wilson, J.B. and Holme, N.A. (1988) Direct
observation of longitudinal furrows in gravel and their
transition with sand ribbons of strongly tidal seas. In:
1408
M. J. R. Gee et al.
1409