You are on page 1of 41

Water Contamination Research

CollectedNotesonToxicsLeachingfromPlastic,MetalandCementationsContainers,
BacterialRegrowth,andDisinfectionByproducts
May2005
ThisdocumentisdesignedtobeviewedinOUTLINEmodeinMicrosoftWord.
ThesearetherawresearchnotesforWaterStoragebyOasisDesign.
Thereisnoanalysisorsynthesishere.Thehealtheffectsdependonthe:

Material
Additives,moldreleaseagents,coatings,etc.
Contacttime
Contactarea
Temperature
Ageofthematerial(somebecomelessnoxiouswithtime,somemore)
Exposuretosunlight
Susceptibilityoftheindividual

Totheextentwewereabletomakeanysenseoftheinformationbelow,ouranalysiscan
befoundinourwaterstoragebook:
http://www.oasisdesign.net/water/storage/
Muchofthismaterialiscopyrightedbyothersandisreproducedhereunderthefairuse
doctrine.Thesourceforthematerialisgivenatthestartofeachsection.

Water Quality Standards


National Primary and Secondary Drinking Water Regulations
http://www.epa.gov/safewater/mcl.html
http://www.ehso.com/ehshome/DrWater/drinkingwaterstds.htm
NationalPrimaryDrinkingWaterRegulations(NPDWRsorprimarystandards)are
legallyenforceablestandardsthatapplytopublicwatersystems.Primarystandards
protectdrinkingwaterqualitybylimitingthelevelsofspecificcontaminantsthatcan
adverselyaffectpublichealthandareknownoranticipatedtooccurinpublicwater
systems.Table1dividesthesecontaminantsintoInorganicChemicals,Organic
Chemicals,Radionuclides,andMicroorganisms.SeeSettingStandardsforSafeDrinking
WatertolearnaboutEPA'sstandardsettingprocess.Followtheselinkstodownload

copiesofNationalPrimaryDrinkingWaterRegulationsandNationalSecondary
DrinkingWaterRegulations.

National Sanitation Foundation. 2001. NSF Standard 61 Drinking


Water System Components
http://www.nsf.org/Certified/PwsComponents/
Searchabledatabaseofcertifiedcomponents

Leaching from metals


Lead
http://www.denverwater.org/waterquality/pbwater.htmlWhere
Brassfaucetscanlegallycontainasmuchaseightpercentleadbyweight.Soldersand
fluxareconsideredleadfreewhentheycontainnotmorethan.2percentlead.Before
1987,soldernormallycontainedabout50percentlead.
Alwaysusecoldwaterforfoodandbeveragepreparation.Hottapwatercanleachhigher
amountsofleadorothermetalsfromplumbingorthehotwatertank.Ifyou'reconcerned
aboutelevatedleadlevelsinyourwater,runthetapuntilthewaterbecomescolderbefore
usingit.Remembertocatchtheflushedwaterforplantsorotherhouseholduse.

Aluminum
Aluminum Toxicity: Issues and Insights
http://www.bayeralbumin.com/web_docs/WP_AluminumToxicity.pdf
PeoplearecontinuouslyexposedtoAlbyingestingwater,food,anddustparticles.2
Estimatessuggestthatadultsconsumeapproximately3to5mgofAlintheirdailydiet.
HealthyindividualscaneasilyhandlenormalAlintake,sinceabsorptioninthe
gastrointestinal(GI)tractislow.4TheGItractprovidesefficientprotectionagainstAl
absorption,anditisestimatedthatlessthan1%ofingestedAlisabsorbedbythebody.5
Infact,healthyindividualshaveverylowlevelsofAlbecausetheGItract,skin,and
lungsareeffectivebarrierstoAlabsorption,andthekidneysefficientlyeliminate
absorbedAlbyexcretion.
Peoplewhoareatriskfromaluminumpoisoning:
Dialysispatientsandotherswithimpairedrenalfunction
Newbornsandprematureinfants
Theelderly
PatientsreceivingTPN
Burnpatients

Effectsofaluminumtoxicity:
Associated:
Dementia
Encephalopathy
Learningdeficits
Possiblyassociated:
ALS
Parkinsonsdisease
Alzheimersdisease

Report of the New South Wales Chief Health Officer, 1997


http://www.health.nsw.gov.au/public-health/chorep97/env_watalum.htm
Drinkingwaterprobablycontributeslessthan5percentofthetotalhumanintakeof
aluminium.Althoughsomestudieshavesuggestedatentativelinkbetweenaluminium
andAlzheimersdiseaseanddementia,theevidenceasawholedoesnotsupportacausal
association.Accordingly,thereisnohealthbasedguidelineforaluminiuminwater.

Copper
acidicwatercandeterioratecopperpipes.
http://www.boston.com/globe/search/stories/health/how_and_why/041596.htm

A Comparison of Metal Leachate Rate and Zebra Mussel Control


Efficacy for Coatings and Materials Timothy D. Race and
Mark A. Kelly
sgnis.org/publicat/proceed/1994/319.pdf
ABSTRACT:Laboratoryimmersedtestcouponsofconventionalantifoulingcoatings,
metalpigmentedcoatings,thermalsprayedmetalliccoatings,andmetalsubstrateswere
evaluatedformetalionreleaseratesovera2yearperiod.Identicaltestcouponswere
evaluatedforfoulingovera15monthperiodatBlackRockLock,Buffalo,NewYork.
Thispapercomparestheefficacyofthesematerialsandtheirreleaseratesasafunctionof
time.Otherantifoulingproducts,includingcapsaicinbasedcoatingsandabiocide
impregnatedplastic,wereevaluatedatthefieldsite.Controlpanelsareheavilyinfested
after15monthswhilethemajorityoftestmaterialscontinuetopreventzebramussel
attachment.Estimatedminimumeffectivereleaseratesforcopperandzincare
determined.
MetalSubstrates.Copperandbrasssheetmaterialswerecompletelyeffectiveagainstthe
zebramusseloverthe15monthtestperiod.Aluminumbronzehadalowcolonization
rate.FromFigure6thedownwardtrendincopperleachrateisfairlyevidentforeachof
thesematerials.Thefinaldatapointforbrassisprobablyaberrantandthuscopperleach
ratesforthe3materialsfollowthetrend;copper>aluminumbronze>brass.Brassalso
hasafairlysteadyzincreleaseofabout2ug/cm2/day,whichprobablyreinforcesthe

materialsefficacy.Thecopperleachrateforthesematerialsprogressivelydecreaseswith
time.Adirecttimedependentrelationshipbetweenfieldandlaboratoryexposed
materialsmaynotexist.Inotherwords,theleachratesafter15monthsoffieldand
laboratoryexposureareprobablynotthesame.However,thetrendsandrelativeleach
ratesareprobablyreliable.Theleachingdatawouldseemtosuggestthataluminum
bronzeandcoppersheetmaterialswilleventuallyhavecopperleachratestoolowtobe
effective.Thedecreaseinleachratesareprobablycausedbytheaccumulationof
insolublecorrosionproductsonthesurfaceofthetestmaterials.Ifthisisthecase,then
periodicrejuvenationofthesesurfacesbymeansoflightabrasionwouldbepossible.
ZincContainingCoatings.Thethermalsprayedzinccoating,thewaferborneinorganic
zinccoating,andgalvanizingallexhibitedrelativelylowlevelsofmusselattachmentat
15months.Zincleachrateswereapproximately6,3,and5ug/cm2/day,respectively,at
600daysoflaboratoryexposure.Thezincmaterialsserveasecondaryfunctionas
corrosionprotectiononsteelsubstrates.Evenatmodestlevelsofcolonization,zinc
coatingswouldofferasignificantadvantageintermsofcostandsimplicityovertheother
antifoulants.Zinccoatingsmarketedforcorrosionprotectiondonotrequireregistration
undertheFederalInsecticide,Fungicide,andRodenticideAct.

Fish tank zinc


http://www.zetatalk.com/nonproft/99001991.htm
ThefishtankswerecloseddowninmidJanuary,asayellowdyeinthefishfoodhad
cumulatedtothepointofpoisoningthecatfish.Thiswastheonlyadditive,andturnedthe
clearwateramustardyellowandcreateayellowfoam.Thiswasoneofthelessons
learnedinaclosedcycle,onemusttakegreatcarewhatisaddedtothesystem.(2002
Note:ithasbeenlearnedthatthegalvanizedtanks,whichleachzinc,highlytoxictofish,
wereprobablytheculprit.Anepoxypaintisrecommendedtopreventthisinthefuture.)

Coatings
http://www.epa.gov/safewater/tcr/pdf/storage.pdf
tankTurnovernostagnantwater
2.1.4ChemicalContaminants
Coatingmaterialsareusedtopreventcorrosionofsteelstoragetanksandtoprevent
moisturemigrationinconcretetanks.Throughthe1970's,coatingsusedinfinishedwater
storagefacilitieswereprimarilyselectedbecauseoftheircorrosionresistanceandeaseof
application.Thisledtotheuseofindustrialproductslikecoaltars,greases,waxesand
leadpaintsasinteriortankcoatings.Theseproductsofferedexceptionalcorrosion
performancebutunknowinglycontributedsignificanttoxicchemicalstothedrinking
water.Greasecoatingscandiffergreatlyintheircompositionfromvegetableto
petroleumbasedsubstancesandcanprovideagoodfoodsourceforbacteria,resultingin
reducedchlorineresidualsandobjectionabletastesandodorsinthefinishedwater
(Kirmeyeretal.1999).
AnoldgreasecoatingonastoragetankinteriorinthestateofFloridawassuspectedof

causingwaterqualityproblemsinthedistributionsystemsuchastasteandodor,high
chlorinerequirementsandablackslimeatthecustomerstap.TheWisconsinAvenue
500,000gallonelevatedtankwasoriginallycoatedwithapetroleumgreasecoatingwhen
itwasbuiltin1925.
In1988,thestoragefacilitywascleanedandthegreasecoatingwasreapplied.In1993,a
tankinspectionrevealedthatthegreasehadsaggedoffthetankwallsanddepositeda
thickaccumulationofblacklooseoozeinthebottombowlofthetank(68inchesdeep).
Athinfilmofgreasecontinuedtocoattheuppershellsurfaces.Althoughthismaterial
hadperformedwellasacorrosioninhibitor,itwasintroducingdebrisintothedistribution
systemaswellascreatingapossiblefoodsourceandenvironmentforbacteria.TheCity
decidedtocompletelyremovethegreaseandreapplyapolyamideepoxysystem.This
workwascompletedin1996(Kirmeyeretal.1999).Sincethetankwasreturnedto
service,waterqualityhasmarkedlyimproved.Therequiredchlorinedosageratehas
decreasedfrom4.05.0mg/Lto3.5mg/L.Thechlorineresidualatthetankoutlethas
improvedfrom<1.0mg/Lto1.4mg/L.Nomoreblackslimecomplaintshavebeen
received.

Epoxy
There is evidence that epoxy coatings leach various organic additives into water.
Permeationandleaching
http://www.epa.gov/safewater/tcr/pdf/permleach.pdf
The rate of leaching of organic additives was found to decrease exponentially
with time. Therefore, it is recommended that newly lined pipes be pre-soaked
prior to release to service. Normal hydrostatic testing and disinfection activities
will help remediate leaching. Extending the curing process will also help improve
the stability of epoxy linings

Leaching from plastics


Potential water quality deterioration of drinking water caused by
leakage of organic compounds from materials in contact
with the water
PlasticskeyProceedings,20thNoDigconference,CopenhagenMay28312002.
LarsJ.Hem,AquateamAS,POBox6875Rodelkka,0504Oslo,Norway,Email
lars.hem@aquateam.noandIngunSkjevrak,RegionalFoodControlAuthority,
Stavanger,NorwayEmail:skjevrak@nmtmrog.rl.noABSTRACTOrganic
materialshavebeenusedindrinkingwaterpipesandstoragetanksforseveralyears.
Duringthelastdecadeplasticmaterialsareusedforbottlesandcontainersforwater.
Leachingoforganicmatterfromthematerialstothedrinkingwaterisproven.Waterin
contactwithplasticpipes,surfacecoatingsorothermaterialscanbeaffectedby

migrationofcomponentsthatmakethewaterqualityunacceptablewithrespectto
aestheticeffectsorhealth.Leachingofvolatileorganiccompoundsmaycause
unwantedtasteandodourinwater,andpossiblehealthrisk.Organiccompoundssuch
asxylene,styrene,phenolsandethylbenzenehavebeenidentified.Compoundsleaching
fromepoxyandpolyethyleneappeartogiveunwantedtasteandsmelltothewater.
Microbiologicalgrowthinthedrinkingwaterdistributionsystemmaycausedeterioration
ofthewaterquality,duetoincreasedturbidity,heterotrophicbacteria,andeven
pathogens.Leakageofbiodegradableorganicmatterfrommaterialsusedinthe
distributionsystemmaypromotemicrobiologicalgrowth.Therearevariationsin
microbiologicalgrowthbetweenvariousmaterials.Inparticular,thechangefromcopper
tosyntheticmaterialsforinhouseinstallationsmaybeareasonforincreased
microbiologicalgrowth.
RELEVANTPIPEMATERIALSPlasticmaterialsusedforservicepipesmaybemade
fromPVC(polyvinylchloride),HDPE(highdensitypolyethylene)orGRP(glassfibre
reinforcedpolyester).InhouseplasticplumbingmaterialswillconsistofPVCorPEX
(crossboundPE).Epoxyliningcanbeusedonconcreteandonstainlesssteelinpipes
andbasins.Additionally,lubricantsmaybeusedforfittingpipestogether,aswellasin
theproductionof,forinstance,stainlesssteelpipes.
SeveralcomplaintsondrinkingwaterqualityinNorwayoronoffshoreinstallationsare
relatedtovolatileorganicmatter(VOC)leachingfromepoxyliningorpaint.Typical
VOCsfromepoxyarealkylbenzenesandalkoxycompounds.Inparticularleachingof
hydrocarbonsfrominsituepoxycoatedstoragetanksoffshoreandonshipsseemstobea
problem, with a solvent (xylene/ethylbenzene) content of up to 6070 g/l being
measured.C3andC4cyclohexanes andotheralicyclichydrocarbonshavealsobeen
identified as tasteandodourcompounds leaching fromsurfacecoatings.Inatreated
waterbasinformunicipalwatersupply,organosulphidecompoundswereidentifiedasthe
sourcefortasteandodour,andthemostlikelysourceofthesulphidesproducedwas
microbiological activity due to degradation of organic compounds leaching from the
epoxylining(Skjevrak,1999;Skjevrak,2000).
OrganiccompoundsleachingfromPEbottlesandtankshavebeenthesourceoftasteand
odourinwaterandevenaweekcolourhasbeenexperiencedbecauseofthismigration.
AnalysisofthewaterhasidentifiedlowconcentrationsofseveralVOCs,suchasketones
(Skjevrak,1999).
MigrationofVOCfromwaterpipesmanufacturedofHDPE,PVCandPEXhasbeen
investigatedusingstaticcontactwithwaterforthreesuccessivetestperiodseachof72
hoursdurationaccordingtoEN14201(Skjevrak,2000;Skjevrak,2002aandb).The
leachingoforganiccompoundsfromHDPEpipesshowedaconsiderablevariationboth
intypeandamount.FiveoutofseventestedbrandsofHDPEpipesshowedunacceptable
TON values (TON > 3) of test water. Degradation products from phenolbased
antioxidantsweremajormigrantsfromHDPEpipes.VOCsleachingfromPEXpipes
gaveanintenseodouroftestwater.SeveralofthemigratedVOCswerenotidentified.
Oxygenates predominated within the identified VOC with methyl tertbutyl ether
(MTBE) as a major component Migration tests of PVC pipes revealed few volatile

migrantsinlowconcentrations,andTONassessmentsdidnotshowsignificantodourin
any of the tests. VOCs leaching from lubricants used for joining of pipes included
componentssuchasC6C11aliphaticaldehydes,ketones,siloxanesandphenolbased
antioxidants.MigrationofVOCfromHDPEintonaturalbiofilmestablishedinHDPE
pipesatturbulentflowconditionsisalsolookedinto(Skjevrak,2002c).

ABS
http://www.healthybuilding.net/pvc/pipes_report.html

Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) is not


chlorinated, but like PVC has highly hazardous
manufacturing intermediates, including carcinogens
and is difficult to recycle. It is considered only
marginally better than PVC environmentally.
Recycling guide
Acrylonitrilebutiadenestyrene
http://www.grassrootsinfo.org/index.html?ce/plastics.html
ThefollowingrecyclingcodeguideisprintedwithpermissionfromTheGreenGuide
#88and#89

#1PETEorPET(polyethyleneterephthalate):usedformostclearbeveragebottles.

#2HDPE(highdensitypolyethylene):usedfor"cloudy"milkandwaterjugs,opaque
foodbottles.

#3PVCorV(polyvinylchloride):usedinsomeclingwraps(especiallycommercial
brands),some"soft"bottles.

#4LDPE(lowdensitypolyethylene):usedinfoodstoragebagsandsome"soft"bottles.

#5PP(polypropylene):usedinrigidcontainers,includingsomebabybottles,andsome
cupsandbowls.

#6PS(polystyrene):usedinfoam"clamshell"typecontainers,meatandbakerytrays,
andinitsrigidform,cleartakeoutcontainers,someplasticcutleryandcups.Polystyrene
mayleachstyreneintofooditcomesintocontactwith.ArecentstudyinEnvironmental
HealthPerspectivesconcludedthatsomestyrenecompoundsleachingfromfood

containersareestrogenic(meaningtheycandisruptnormalhormonalfunctioning.)
StyreneisalsoconsideredapossiblehumancarcinogenbytheWorldHealth
Organization'sInternationalAgencyforResearchonCancer(IARC).

#7Other(usuallypolycarbonate):usedin5gallonwaterbottles,somebabybottles,
somemetalcanlinings.Polycarbonatecanreleaseitsprimarybuildingblock,bisphenol
A,anothersuspectedhormonedisrupter,intoliquidsandfoods.In1998,theJapanese
governmentorderedmanufacturerstheretorecallanddestroypolycarbonatetableware
meantforusebychildrenbecauseitcontainedexcessiveamountsofbisphenolA.Other
sourcesofpotentialbisphenolAexposureincludefoodcanliningsanddentalsealants.

#1 pete
http://www.bellaonline.com/articles/art23142.asp
TheEPAclassifiesplastictype#1PETEascontainingaleachableformofDEHA,
classifiedasa"possiblehumancarcinogen"

Consumer reports bottled water


Source:ConsumerReports,Aug2000,Vol.65Issue8,p17,5p,1chart,3c.
http://www.angelfire.com/nm/redcollarcrime/tbw.html
WatersbottledinPETplasticgenerallytastedbetterthanthosebottledinHDPE.That
wastrueevenwithinthesamebrand.ArrowheadMountainSpringWater,forexample,
wasverygoodwhenbottledinPET,whichimpartedahintofsweet,fruityplasticflavor
(imaginethescentwhenyoublowupabeachball).ButArrowheadwasonlyfairwhen
bottledinHDPE,whichmadeittasteabitlikemeltedplastic(imaginethesmellwhen
yougetaplasticcontainertooclosetoaflame).Forwatersthatcomeinbothkindsof
bottle,theRatingslisttwoscores(andtwopriceswaterisapttocostmoreinPET).The
onlywaterbottledinPVCplastic,WinnDixie'sPrestigePremium100%SpringWater,
ratedgoodoverall.
BOTTLEBASICS

Bottlescanactuallyaffectawater'stasteandchemicalcontent.Hereareadvantagesand
disadvantagesofcommonbottlematerials.

PET(ALSOCALLEDPETE)

Shortforpolyethyleneterephthalate,PETisaclear,strongplasticthatleavesnothing
morethanafaintsweetorfruityplasticflavor,ifthat.Labelsforsomebrandspackedin
PETplayupthe"clear"tasteofthewaterinside.


HDPE

Highdensitypolyethyleneistheopaque,flexiblematerialofmilkcontainers.It'sless
expensivethanPETbutoftenimpartsaslightmeltedplastictastetowater.Tastemay
alsobeaffectedbyexcessiveheatorflavorsfromfoodsstorednearby.

GLASS

Chemically,glassisinertandimpartsnotastewhatsoever.Butit'sheavyandbreakable
andisseldomusednowadaysexceptforpriceymineralwatersandwaterbottledforbars,
restaurants,andhotels.

POLYCARBONATE

Strongandrigid,it'susedforcompactdiscsaswellas5gallonwatercoolerjugs.The
threewatercoolerwaterswesampledGreatBear,DeerPark,andPolandSpringshad
nofunnyflavors.Infact,thosewaterstastedbetterthanthesameproductsinPETor
HDPEbottles.Butouranalysesshowedthatpolycarbonatesometimesleavesresiduesof
aworrisomechemical,bisphenolA.

Consumer confidence report


http://www.rules.utah.gov/publicat/code/r309/r309225.htm
(30)Benzo(a)pyrene(PAH)(nanograms/l)Leachingfromliningsofwaterstoragetanks
anddistributionlines.

Building Green on PVC


http://www.buildinggreen.com/features/pvc/pvc.cfm

Greenpeace PVC ban program


http://archive.greenpeace.org/toxics/html/content/pvc5.html

Enfvironmental and health effects of PVC


http://archive.greenpeace.org/toxics/reports/cfap/cfapm3.html4.0

The most neglected area of emergency food storage is water


http://www.bagelhole.org/article.php/Water/104/
Oneofthesimplest,butmostneglectedareaofemergencyfoodstorageiswater.This
problemiscompoundedwhenhomefoodstorageprogramsrelyheavilyondriedfoods
suchasbeans,wheatandpowderedmilk.Youmayhaveenoughcaloriesstoredtolastsix
months,butdoyouhaveenoughwater?
Onegallonperdayperpersonistherecommendedminimum.Morerealisticthoughis
abouttwoquartsfordrinkingplusagallonforwashingpluswhateverwateryoumight
needforcooking.Thisisthebareminimum.
Youdon'tneedtogooutandbuyspecificstoragebottles,butnotallfoodhousehold
containersarefitforwaterstorage.Plasticgallonmilkbottlesaresafe,butnotdurable
andmaystartleakingifstoredforlongperiods.Glassgallonbottleslikethoseusedfor
appleciderarealsosafe,butbecarefulwhereyoustorethem.Probablytheperfectwater
storagebottlesarethetwolitertypesodabottles.Ifplasticcontainersareused,care
shouldbetakentoassurethattheyaremadeofplasticapprovedforfoodcontactbythe
FederalFoodandDrugAdministration.Polyethyleneplasticisapprovedforfoodcontact
andiscommonlyusedforcontainersofvarioussizes,including55gallondrums.Certain
typesofplasticcontainersarenotintendedforfoodcontact(suchasvinylplastic
waterbeds,ortrashcontainers)andmayleachundesirablechemicalsintostoredwater.
Leachingofchemicalsfromapprovedplasticsisnegligible.Waterstoredinplastic
containersshouldnotbestoredneargasoline,kerosene,pesticidesorsimilarsubstances.
Vaporsfromthesesubstancescouldpermeatetheplasticandaffectthewater.Thick
walledpolyethylenecontainersaresignificantlylesspermeabletovaporsthanarethin
walledcontainers,Becertain,whenselectingastoragecontainerforwater,thatithasa
tightfittingcaporlidtoprevententranceofcontaminantsandevaporationofwater.

Becausesunlighthasanadverseaffectonplastic,watershouldbestoredawayfrom
directexposuretosunlight.

Shelf Life of Water


Theshelflifeofwaterdependsontheoriginalqualityofthewater,thetemperatureat
whichitisstored,howmuchlightitisexposedtojusttonameafew.Many
manufacturersofbottledwaterwillincludeashelflifeontheirproduct.
Treatedwateroutofthetapneedsnothingaddedandshouldhaveashelflifeofabout10
years.Untreatedwater,fromawellforinstance,shouldbestoredwithabout16dropsof
chlorinebleachpergallon.Sterilizedordisinfectedwater,storedinclean,foodapproved
containerswithsecurelidsorcaps,shouldbesafeforuseevenaftermanyyearsof
storage.Replacementofstoredwaterwithfreshwatershouldbenecessaryonlyifthe
storedwaterbecomescontaminatedinsomewayorifthecontainershouldbegintoleak.
Becertaintolabeleachcontainersotherewillbenoquestionaboutitscontents.Include
thedateandinformationonthemethodofdisinfectionused.
Storedwatermayeventuallydevelopadisagreeableappearance,taste,orodor.Under
emergencyconditions,waterthattastesflatcanbeaeratedbypouringthewaterfromone
containertoanothertoanotheraboutthreeorfourtimes.BeCarefulAboutRainWater
Rainwaterthathasbeencollectedshouldbetreatedthesameasanyotherunknown
watersource.Rainwatercontainssmallparticulatesandacid.

Leaching from Lexan Polycarbonate nalgenes


http://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/200311/lol5.asp
Clear,lightweight,andsturdypolycarbonateplasticbottlesarestandardequipmentfor
millionsofhikersandbabies.(Theyareusuallylabeled#7onthebottom;Nalgeneisthe
bestknownproducer.)Sincepolycarbonatebottlesdontimpartatastetofluids,many
usersassumetheyaresaferthanbottlesmadeoutofotherkindsofplastic.Butnowan
accidentaldiscoveryhascastdoubtontheirsafety.

Normalwearandtearandcleaningofpolycarbonateplasticbottlesinadishwasher,Hunt
says,couldcausethechemicaltoleach,andtheamountofleachingincreasesasthe
plasticagesandisdegradedbyuse.AseparatestudypublishedinJulyinEnvironmental
HealthPerspectivesconfirmedthisfinding,andalsodetectedleachingfromnew
polycarbonateplastic.
TheoColborn,authorofthegroundbreakingbookaboutendocrinedisrupters,OurStolen
Future,callsBPAa"very,verystickyproblem.Thisisaproductthatseverywhere,and
ineverything."(Inadditiontobottles,BPAturnsupindentalsealantsandtheresin
liningsofmanyfoodandbeveragecans.)Sherecommendswashingpolycarbonate
bottleswithmilddetergentonly,andrinsingwell.(Thoroughwashingiscrucialforany
reusedbottle,becauseofthedangerofbacterialcontamination.)
Mostatrisk,saysColborn,arepeoplewithdevelopingendocrinesystems:pregnant
womenandnewborns,followedbyyoungchildren,andwomenwhomightgetpregnant.
Huntsaysthatifshehadaninfant,shewouldswitchtopolypropylene(#5PP),whichis
notknowntoleachharmfulsubstances.(Otherplasticsthatarenotknowntoleachare#2
HDPEand#4LDPE."Singleuse"plasticbottlesmadeofpolyethyleneterephthalate[#1
PETorPETE]arenotrecommendedforrepeatusebecauseoftheriskofbacterial
contaminationfrominfrequentandinsufficientwashing.
Oryoucouldavoidplasticaltogetherandswitchtoglassorlightweightstainlesssteel
containers.
FrancesCerraWhittelsey
November/December2003
In"HazardsofHydration,"wecitedastudyaboutsingleusewaterbottlesthatappearsto
havebeenflawed.Whilereusingthese#1PETbottlesisnotagoodideabecauseofrisk

ofbacterialcontamination,youprobablydon'tneedtoworryaboutthemreleasingthe
chemicalDEHA.Thearticlehasbeencorrected.

Safer Plastics for Storing Foods


GreenGuide|TheGreenGuide
byAndreeaMatei
http://www.thegreenguide.com/doc.mhtml?i=BGG2&s=saferplastics
Webonly|postedFebruary28,2003

Safer Containers: The List


byAndreeaMatei
Whenplasticsaretheonlychoiceforfoodstorage,lookforoptionswithrecyclingcodes
#1PETE,#2HDPE,#4LDPEand#5PP(onthebottomofcontainers).Theseare
frequentlyrecycledplasticswhichhavenotbeenfoundtoleachtoxinsintoyourfood.

On plastic water bottles


ByUmbraFisk
02Aug2004
http://www.grist.org/advice/ask/2004/08/02/umbrabottles/
Let'stalkspecifics,though,becauseyoupointoutanapparentconundruminyour
question.Thecontradictionsyouseeinthepressareamixofconfusionabouttypesof
plastic,misinformation,andbonafidescientificuncertaintyabouttheeffectsofan
entirelynewgroupofsubstances.Snopes.comaddressespurportedlinksbetweenPET
(#1)andDEHA(di2ethylhexyladipate),apotentialcarcinogen,linkswhichare
apparentlybasedonastudylatershowntobebogus.PETevidentlydoesnotcontain
DEHA,andthecarcinogenicpropertiesofDEHAitselfarehotlydebated.
Movingon,IwouldcategoricallyavoidPVC(#3),akavinyl,forfoodcontainersor
anythingelse.Ittrulyisanevilplastic,practicallyafountofdioxin.PVCcontainersand
PVCfilmcancontainoftdebatedickiesDEHPandDEHA,andsomecontainsoftening
phthalateslinkedtoliverandkidneydamageandtesticularproblems.Also,polystyrene
(#6)isyuckyit'smadeofstyrene,andyoudon'twantanystyreneinyourpreciousbod,
trustme.
Thatleavesuswiththewinnersofthisdubiouscontest:HDPE,LDPE,

OC&PA: What about cooking with plastics?


http://www.jhsph.edu/Press_Room/articles/Halden_dioxins.html
RH:Ingeneral,wheneveryouheatsomethingyouincreasethelikelihoodofpulling
chemicalsout.Chemicalscanbereleasedfromplasticpackagingmaterialslikethekinds
usedinsomemicrowavemeals.Somedrinkingstrawssayonthelabelnotforhot
beverages.Mostpeoplethinkthewarningisbecausesomeonemightbeburned.Ifyou
putthatstrawintoaboilingcupofhotcoffee,youbasicallyhaveahotwaterextraction
goingon,wherethechemicalsinthestrawarebeingextractedintoyournicecupof
coffee.Weusethesameprocessinthelabtoextractchemicalsfrommaterialswewantto
analyze.

PR its cool article


http://www.nalgeneoutdoor.com/technical/bpaInfo.html

EPAs Endocrine Disruptors Research


ForfurtherinformationonEPAsEndocrineDisruptorsResearchProgram,please
contacttheNationalProgramDirectorforEPAsEndocrineDisruptorsResearch
Program,ElaineZ.Francis,Ph.D.,bytelephoneat(202)5646789,orbyemailat
francis.elaine@epa.gov.
Sentemail10/18/04

Distilled water and methyl chloride


http://www.naturalms.com/newwater.htm
Wewouldn'trecommendpurchasingdistilledwaterfromasupermarketthatarestoredin
aplasticcontainer.Manyplasticsgiveofftoxinssuchasmethylchloride,acarcinogen
whichcanleachintothewater.Glassbottlesorstainlesssteelcontainersare
recommendedforstoringdistilledwater."

Bisphenol A Is Released from Used Polycarbonate Animal


Cages into Water at Room Temperature
http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/docs/2003/5993/abstract.html
BisphenolA(BPA)isamonomerwithestrogenicactivitythatisusedintheproduction
offoodpackaging,dentalsealants,polycarbonateplastic,andmanyotherproducts.The
monomerhaspreviouslybeenreportedtohydrolyzeandleachfromtheseproductsunder
highheatandalkalineconditions,andtheamountofleachingincreasesasafunctionof
use.Weexaminedwhethernewandusedpolycarbonateanimalcagespassivelyrelease
bioactivelevelsofBPAintowateratroomtemperatureandneutralpH.Purifiedwater
wasincubatedatroomtemperatureinnewpolycarbonateandpolysulfonecagesandused
(discolored)polycarbonatecages,aswellascontrol(glassandusedpolypropylene)
containers.Theresultingwatersampleswerecharacterizedwithgas
chromatography/massspectrometry(GC/MS)andtestedforestrogenicactivityusingan
MCF7humanbreastcancercellproliferationassay.Significantestrogenicactivity,

identifiableasBPAbyGC/MS(upto310g/L),wasreleasedfromusedpolycarbonate
animalcages.DetectablelevelsofBPAwerereleasedfromnewpolycarbonatecages(up
to0.3g/L)aswellasnewpolysulfonecages(1.5g/L),whereasnoBPAwasdetected
inwaterincubatedinglassandusedpolypropylenecages.Finally,BPAexposureasa
resultofbeinghousedinusedpolycarbonatecagesproduceda16%increaseinuterine
weightinprepubertalfemalemicerelativetofemaleshousedinusedpolypropylene
cages,althoughthedifferencewasnotstatisticallysignificant.Ourfindingssuggestthat
laboratoryanimalsmaintainedinpolycarbonateandpolysulfonecagesareexposedto
BPAvialeaching,withexposurereachingthehighestlevelsinoldcages.Keywords:
animalcaging,bisphenolA,endocrinedisruptor,estrogen,leaching,polycarbonate,
polysulfone.Environ

Leaching of mutagens into mineral water from


polyethyleneterephthalate bottles.
DeFuscoR,MonarcaS,BiscardiD,PasquiniR,FatigoniC.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=2137646&dopt=Abstract
DepartmentofExperimentalPharmacology,UniversityofNaples,Italy.
Polyethyleneterephthalate(PET)wastestedasasourceofmutagencontaminationfrom
bottlesusedforbeveragepackaging.PETbottleswerefilledwithmineralwaterand
storedindaylightandinthedarkfordifferentperiodsoftime.Thewatersampleswere
concentratedandtheconcentrates(nonvolatilecompounds)testedformutagenicitywith
theAmestest(statictests).Totalorganiccarbon(TOC)leachingwasdetermined
concurrently.Leachingofmutagenswasalsostudiedusingdynamictests;shaking
distilledwaterinPETbottles.Newmethodswerealsousedtotesttheleachingpotential
ofbothvolatileandnonvolatilecompounds:directlytestingthemutagenicityin
unconcentratedwaterstoredinPETbottlesandgrowingSalmonellastrainsdirectlyinthe
plasticbottles.Theresultswerepositiveonlyforthestatictest,whichidentifiedleaching
ofmutagensafter1monthofstorageinPETbottles.Thisactivitywashigherafter
storageindaylight.

Studies of migration of potentially genotoxic compounds into


water stored in pet bottles.
MonarcaS,DeFuscoR,BiscardiD,DeFeoV,PasquiniR,FatigoniC,MorettiM,
ZanardiniA.
SchoolofMedicine,UniversityofBrescia,Italy.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=7927074
Colouredpolyethyleneterephthalate(PET)bottlesforcarbonatedbeverageswerestudied
forpotentialmigrationofgenotoxiccompounds.Acombinedapproach,using
physicochemicalmethodsandabacterialshorttermmutagenicitytest(Amestest)was
followed.StandardEECandUSFDAtestsfortotalmigrationofnonvolatilemigrant
compoundsintodistilledwaterwereperformed,togetherwithmodifiedtests,where

freezedryinginsteadofevaporationofwaterwasused,inordertomeasurebothvolatile
andnonvolatilechemicals.Gaschromatographymassspectrometry(GCMS)analysis
wasperformedontheseresidues.PETbottlesfilledwithnaturallycarbonatedmineral
waterwerealsousedforlongtermtotalorganiccarbon(TOC)andmutagenicity
migrationstudies(upto6months'storage).TotalmigrationresultsforPETbottleswere
withintheEECandUSFDAlimits.Theuseoffreezedryingfortheeliminationofwater
enabledmuchhighertotalmigrationdata(higherthanthelimits)toberevealed.Some
potentiallygenotoxiccompounds(acetaldehyde,dimethylterephthalate,terephthalic
acid)wereidentifiedinthesemigrantcompoundsbyGCMSanalysis.ThetestsforTOC
migrationgaveamaximumvalueafter2wkstorageandthemutagenicitytestsonnon
volatilemigrantcompoundsgavealwaysnegativeresults

Aldehyde contamination of mineral water stored in PET bottles.


DarowskaA,BorczA,NawrockiJ.
DepartmentofWaterTreatmentTechnology,FacultyofChemistry,A.Mickiewicz
University,Poznan,Poland.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=14726281Aldehyde
contaminationsthatmightaccompanyproductionofmineralwaterstoredinPETbottles
wereinvestigated.OneoftheproductionlinesofcarbonatedmineralwaterinPolandwas
monitoredandPETbottlescommonlyusedformineralwaterstoragewereevaluated.
Formaldehydeandacetaldehydewerethemostimportantcarbonylsidentifiedinseriesof
bottledwatersamples,butalsopropanal,nonanalandglyoxalwerefoundinwater
samplesfromtheproductionline.Aldehydesarepresenteverywhereintheenvironment
andcanbedeterminedeveninpurewateratlowmicrogl(1)levels.Itwasobservedthat
theconcentrationofacetaldehydeinwaterstoredinPETbottlesdependedmainlyonthe
concentrationofacetaldehydeinPETmaterialandcouldreachmorethan200microgl(
1).Thetemperature,timeofstorageandconcentrationofcarbondioxidegascontribute
tothemigrationofaldehydesfrombottlewallstomineralwater.Higherpressureofthe
carbonatedwatersandnotCO(2)itselforlowerpHofwatersseemsresponsiblefor
higherconcentrationofacetaldehyde.

Evaluation of the migration of mutagens/carcinogens from PET


bottles into mineral water by Tradescantia/micronuclei test,
Comet assay on leukocytes and GC/MS.
BiscardiD,MonarcaS,DeFuscoR,SenatoreF,PoliP,BuschiniA,RossiC,ZaniC.
DepartmentofLifeScience,IIUniversityofNaples,Naples,Italy.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=12526902
Thisstudymonitoredthereleaseofmutagenic/carcinogeniccompoundsintomineral
water(naturalandcarbonated)frompolyethyleneterephthalate(PET)bottles,usinga
plantmutagenicitytestwhichrevealsmicronucleiformationinTradescantiapollencells
(Trad/MCNtest),aDNAdamageassay(Cometassay)onhumanleukocytesandgas

chromatography/massspectrometry(GC/MS)forthecharacterisationofmigrants.The
watersampleswerecollectedatabottlingplantandstoredinPETbottlesforaperiod
rangingfrom1to12months.Everymonthsomesampleswererandomlycollectedand
lyophilised,theresidualpowderswereextractedwithorganicsolventsandthenanalysed
byGC/MSandtestedforDNAdamageinhumanleukocytes,orreconstitutedwith
distilledwatertoobtainconcentratesfortheexposureofTradescantiainflorescences.
Micronucleiincreaseinpollenwasfoundonlyinnaturalmineralwaterstoredfor2
months.DNAdamagingactivitywasfoundinmanyofthenaturalandcarbonatedwater
samples.SpringwaterwasnegativeintheplantmicronucleitestandtheCometassay,
whereasdistributedspringwatershowedDNAdamagingeffects,suggestingapossible
introductionofgenotoxinsthroughthedistributionpipelines.GC/MSanalysisshowed
thepresenceinmineralwaterofdi(2ethylhexyl)phthalate,anongenotoxic
hepatocarcinogenicplasticizer,after9monthsofstorageinPETbottles.Copyright2002
ElsevierScienceB.V.

[Studies on the bottles of mineral water and the foreign plastic


like substances]
[ArticleinJapanese]
KawamuraY,SugitaT,WatanabeY,TakanoT,ItakuraT,IkegawaT,YamadaT.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=9641831
Thecontainersofmineralwaterandtheforeignplasticsubstanceswhichwerefoundin
themineralwaterwereinvestigated.Mostofplasticbottlesweremadeofpolyethylene
terephthalate(PET)andthecapsweremadeofpolypropylene(PP),polyethylene(PE)or
aluminum.PElinerswereattachedtosomecaps.Mostoftheforeignplasticsubstances
werePETwhileotherswerePE,PP,Teflonandrubber.Somebottleshadascratchonthe
topinside.TheoriginofmostPETfragmentswaspresumedtobescrapedoffthebottles
bytheloweringoftheinjectionnozzleduringthewaterfillingprocess.Thesourcesof
theothersubstanceswerealsodetermined.

Chemical and in vitro toxicological evaluations of water


packaged in polyvinyl chloride and polyethylene
terephthalate bottles.
SauvantMP,PepinD,BohatierJ.
FacultedePharmacie,Laboratoired'HydrologieetHygiene,ClermontFerrand,France.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=7589720
Thisstudyproposedanewstrategyassessingthehealthrisksofmineralwaterpackaging
andcomparedthechemicalanalyticaltechniquesandsomeinvitrocytotoxicological
assaysforthestudyofPVCandPETmaterialsatthemainstagesofthemanufacturing
processofbottles.Theseevaluationswerecarriedoutwithfoodsimulant(deionized
endotoxintestedwater)andwithnaturalmineralwaterinrealconditionsofpackaging

andstorage(from0to24months).Thecomplementarityofthesetwoapproachesis
discussed.Someanalyticalandcytotoxicabnormalitiesweredetectedinthefood
simulantaftercontactwiththebatchesofpowderedPVCcompound,PETresinandtheir
intermediatestepsoftransformation(PVC'paraison',PET'perform').Buttheseresults
didnotreflecttheactualbehaviourofthefinishedPVCandPETbottles,forwhichno
majorabnormalitywasdetectedinthenaturalmineralwater.

The bacterial flora of non-carbonated, natural mineral water


from the springs to reservoir and glass and plastic bottles.
BischofbergerT,ChaSK,SchmittR,KonigB,SchmidtLorenzW.
InstituteofFoodScience,SwissFederalInstituteofTechnology,Zurich.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=2223521
Quantitativeandqualitativedeterminationsofthebacterialfloraofnoncarbonated
naturalmineralwateratthemostimportantstepsduringbottlingatalargewatersource
yieldedthefollowingresults:(i)Colonycounts(on1:10dilutedplatecountagar,
incubatedat20degreesCfor14days)forwaterofthefivespringsandthemixedwater
werelessthan1to4cfuml1.TheGramnegativebacterialflora(n=50isolates)
showedaverydifferentbutconstantspringspecificspeciesdistributionswith
predominanceofeithereutrophicfluorescentpseudomonads,oligotrophicnon
fluorescentpseudomonadsoroligotrophicyellowbacteria.(ii)Inthereservoirand
immediatelyafterbottlingthecountswereintherangeof10cfuml1.Butnearly30%of
thespeciesofthespringwaterwerenolongerdetectableandtherewasasignificant
increaseofGrampositivebacteria.(iii)After1weekofstorageat20degreesCcolony
countsofmorethan10(5)cfuml1werefoundinplasticbottles,butonlyabout10(4)cfu
ml1inglassbottles.Besides,averydistinctchangeofthecompositionofthemicroflora
occurred.Inglassbottlesslowgrowingoligotrophicnonfluorescentpseudomonads,
yellowbacteriaandAcinetobacterpredominated.Inplasticbottlesfastgrowingeutrophic
andmesotrophicfluorescentpseudomonads,FlexibacterandAcinetobacterwere
dominating.Inmineralwater,bottledintothoroughlycleanedglassbottles,colonycounts
ofmorethan10(5)cfuml1werefoundwithin4days.Inbottles,cleanedmechanically
asusual,theincreasewassignificantlyslowerwithamaximumofonly5x10(3)cfuml
1after8days.Theresultsofinoculationexperimentsinsterilefilteredmineraland
distilledwaterledtothesuggestionthatthedifferencebetweenthetwotypesofbottlesis
causedfirstlybyaninhibitionofgrowthduetoresiduesofcleaningdetergentsinthe
glassbottles.Growthpromotionbydissolvedorganicsubstancesintheplasticbottles
onlyplayedaminorrole.Afterrepairingofthepumpatadepthof300minawarm
mineralwaterspring,thecolonycountsat20,37and42degreesCon1:10dilutedand
normalplatecountagarincreasedbeyondthelimitsrequiredbytheECdirectivefor
mineralwaterstoredamonth.Thencolonycountsdecreasedslowlyandreachedthe
initiallevelafter1year,exceptforthecolonycounts1:10dilutedagarat20degreesC
whichstabilizedatarelativelyhighnumberandasignificantalterationofthemicroflora.
(ABSTRACTTRUNCATEDAT400WORDS)

Dont worry about it-Plastics Council


http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/chem00/chem00959.htm
Alltheplasticscoded1through7canbemadeingradesthatareapproved
foruseasfoodcontainers.Youdonotreallyneedtoworryaboutthe
leachingofchemicalsfromtheplastics.Eventheplasticsthatcanexude
somecomponentsuponprolongedcontentdosoinsuchlowamountsthatitis
notahealthissue.Thechanceofbeinginjuredbyacarasyouareonyour
waytothestoretobuybottledwaterismuch,muchgreaterthanthechance
thatyourhealthwillbeimpairedbydrinkingwaterfromaplastic
container.
RichardE.BarransJr.,Ph.D.
PGResearchFoundation,Darien,Illinoi

Leaching from fiberglass


Leaching of organic contaminants from GRP
pipe
http://www.fwr.org/waterq/dwi0032.htm
A wide range of contaminants were found to leach
into drinking water from GRP pipe including a range
of phthalates and styrene. The leaching rates were
appreciable although depletion with time would be
expected.
Leaching off substances from products used in
contact with water intended for human
consumption
www.dwi.gov.uk/cpp/pdf/protocol1.pdf
20T20h20e20r20m20o20p20l20a20s20t20i20c20
20m20a20t20e20r20i20a20l20s20 20
20e20.20g20.20
20p20o20l20y20e20t20h20y20l20e20n20e20,20
20p20o20l20y20p20r20o20p20y20l20e20n20e20,20
20p20o20l20y20b20u20t20y20l20e20n20e20,20
20p20o20l20y20a20c20e20t20a20l20s20,20 20

21p21o21l21y21a21m21i21d21e21s21;21
21p21o21l21y21e21s21t21e21r21s21,21
21n21y21l21o21n21,21 21e21t21c21.21
21L21e21a21c21h21i21n21g21 21o21f21
21m21o21n21o21m21e21r21s21,21
21a21d21d21i21t21i21v21e21s21 21a21n21d21
21o21t21h21e21r21
21c21o21n21t21a21m21i21n21a21n21t21s21 21
21f21r21o21m21 21t21h21e21s21e21
21m21a21t21e21r21i21a21l21s21 21i21s21
21n21o21t21 21u21s21u21a21l21l21y21
21v21e21r21y21
21e21x21t21e21n21s21i21v21e21;21
21m21e21a21s21u21r21e21d21
21c21o21n21c21e21n21t21r21a21t21i21o21n21s21
21o21f21
21c21o21n21t21a21m21i21n21a21n21t21s21 21
21i21n21 21l21e21a21c21h21a21t21e21
21a21f21t21e21r21 21t21h21e21 21f21i21r21s21t21
21l21e21a21c21h21i21n21g21
21p21e21r21i21o21d21 21u21s21i21n21g21
21a21n21 21S21/21V21 21r21a21t21i21o21
21o21f21 21~21121c21m21 21221 21m21l21-21121
21s21e21l21d21o21m21 21e21x21c21e21e21d21 21
21121021021g21 21l21 21-21121.21 21 21
T21h21e21r21m21o21s21e21t21t21i21n21g21
21m21a21t21e21r21i21a21l21s21 21
21e21.21g21.21 21g21l21a21s21s2121r21e21i21n21f21o21r21c21e21d21
21p21o21l21y21e21s21t21e21r21s21
21(21G21R21P21)21,21 21e21p21o21x21y21
21r21e21s21i21n21s21,21 21
21p21o21l21y21u21r21e21t21h21a21n21e21s21,21
21a21n21d21 21p21o21l21y21m21e21r21-

22m22o22d22i22f22i22e22d22
22c22e22m22e22n22t22i22t22i22o22u22s22
22c22o22a22t22i22n22g22s22.22 22
22L22e22a22c22h22i22n22g22 22r22a22t22e22s22
22a22r22e22 22d22e22p22e22n22d22e22n22t22,22
22 22t22o22 22a22 22m22a22j22o22r22
22e22x22t22e22n22t22,22 22o22n22 22t22h22e22
22c22o22n22d22i22t22i22o22n22s22 22o22f22
22c22u22r22i22n22g22 22o22r22
22s22e22t22t22i22n22g22;22
22m22e22a22s22u22r22e22d22
22c22o22n22c22e22n22t22r22a22t22i22o22n22s22
22o22f22 22
22c22o22n22t22a22m22i22n22a22n22t22s22
22i22n22 22t22h22e22 22f22i22r22s22t22
22l22e22a22c22h22a22t22e22 22a22f22t22e22r22
22c22u22r22i22n22g22,22 22u22s22i22n22g22
22a22n22 22S22/22V22 22o22f22 22l22c22m22 2222122 22m22a22y22 22b22e22 22u22p22 22t22o22
22122022m22g22 22l22-22122,22 22
22w22i22t22h22 22a22 22w22o22r22s22t22
22c22a22s22e22 22o22f22 22a22b22o22u22t22
22122022022m22g22 22l22 22-22122
22d22a22y22-22122.22 22 22 22
A22l22l22 22o22f22 22t22h22e22
22a22b22o22v22e22
22a22p22p22r22o22a22c22h22e22s22
22c22o22u22l22d22 22h22a22v22e22 22a22
22l22a22r22g22e22 22m22a22r22g22i22n22
22o22f22 22e22r22r22o22r22.22 22T22h22e22
22a22s22s22e22s22s22m22e22n22t22
22u22s22i22n22g22 22 22`22w22o22r22s22t2222c22a22s22e22'22
22c22a22l22c22u22l22a22t22i22o22n22s22

23b23a23s23e23d23 23o23n23
23i23n23d23i23r23e23c23t23
23m23e23a23s23u23r23e23m23e23n23t23
23w23o23u23l23d23
23t23h23e23r23e23f23o23r23e23 23b23e23
23s23u23i23t23a23b23l23e23 23o23n23l23y23
23f23o23r23 23 23p23r23o23d23u23c23t23s23
23w23i23t23h23 23v23e23r23y23
23s23m23a23l23l23 23a23c23t23u23a23l23
23S23/23V23 23r23a23t23i23o23 23o23r23
23s23h23o23r23t23 23c23o23n23t23a23c23t23
23t23i23m23e23,23 23o23r23 23f23o23r23
23s23u23b23s23t23a23n23c23e23s23 23f23o23r23
23w23h23i23c23h23 23
23c23o23m23p23r23e23h23e23n23s23i23v23e23
23t23o23x23i23c23o23l23o23g23i23c23a23l23
23d23a23t23a23 23i23n23d23i23c23a23t23e23
23t23h23a23t23
23r23e23l23a23t23i23v23e23l23y23
23h23i23g23h23 23e23x23p23o23s23u23r23e23
23c23o23n23c23e23n23t23r23a23t23i23o23n23s23
23 23w23o23u23l23d23 23n23o23t23
23p23o23s23e23 23a23 23h23e23a23l23t23h23
23r23i23s23k23 23 23s23e23e23
23A23n23n23e23x23 23C23.23
polyurethane
Leaching from rubber
EPDM (Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer)
EPDMisasyntheticrubberwithgoodresistancetoheat,ozone,andUVlight.Alsoable
tostretchwithouttearing.Itiscommonlyusedforpondliners,andasaroofingmaterial.
EPDMiscommonlyusedforpondlinersandasaroofingmaterial.Pondlinerresellers
claimthatthereproductis"fishsafe",andthatEPDMforroofingisnot.Thereismuch
controversysurroundingthispoint.ManypondownerssaythatroofingEPDMisjustas
good,ifyouwashitthoroughly.

ThereislittledataonEPDMleaching.Itisgenerallyconsideredtobeprettyinertstuff.
EPDMisconsideredamoreenvironmentallyfriendlybuildingmaterialthanPVC.
(http://archive.greenpeace.org/toxics/reports/gopherreports/altern.txt)
ThereareEPDMproductsthatmeetNSFStandard61forstoringpotablewater(for
example,FirestonePondGuard).
Generallysummary:theredoesn'tseemtobemuchconcernoverEPDMbeing
inappropriateforstoringpotablewaterorforfishponds.Whateverlineryouuse,wash
andrinseitbeforeinstalling(even"fishsafe"rubbercomescoatedwithtalcumpowderto
keepitfromstickingtoitself).Ifstoringpotablewater,makesurethattheproductmeets
NSFStandard61.

Recycling
IntheoryEPDMcanberecycled,butit'snotaseasyasdroppingitoffattherecycling
center.Itisathermosetmaterialandcannotberemelted.Itcanbegroundupandused
forsomethingelse.Forexample,severalcompaniesrecycleEPDMroofingmaterialinto
rubberroofingshingles.However,suchcompaniesarefewandfarbetween,soyoumay
behardpressedtofindsomeonetotakeanoldpondlineroffyourhands.

Leaching from cement


NSF Certification Suggested
Checkhere:http://www.nsf.org/Certified/PwsComponents/
AccordingtotheNSF,noncertifiedportlandcementwhichhasbeencookedwith
burningtoxicgooisfrequently,improperlyusedinwatersystemsbydesignerswho
blithelyassumethatcementisusedincontactwithwatersoitmustbeOK:
http://www.nsf.org/business/newsroom/waterworks991/portland.html
"NSFCertifiedtankcoatingsarealmostalwaysrequiredinbidspecifications,butitis
muchlesscommonforPortlandcementstobespecifiedinbidsasNSFCertified.Yet
concreteiscommonlyusedindistributionpipingandwaterstoragetanks."
"Thedisclosurespecifieswhetherhazardouswastefuelsareburnedincementkilns
duringthemanufacturingprocess.
NSFtoxicologystaffreviewstheformulationofthecementanddevelopsananalytical
testplantodetectpotentialcontaminantsofconcern.Thisincludesregulatedmetals
analysisbyICP/MS,organicchemicalanalysisbyGC/MS,radionuclide,dioxin,furan,
andformulationspecificanalysesforcompoundssuchasglycolsandethanoloamines."

Heavy metals from cement


www.epa.gov/safewater/tcr/pdf/permleach.pdf
Cementmaterialscontainavarietyofregulatedinorganicchemicals,manyofwhichare
proneto

leaching.Guoetal.(1998)conductedlaboratoryteststodeterminetheextentofleaching
from
ductileironpipeslinedinsituwithportlandcement(typeI)mortar.Thepipeswerelined
and
curedinaccordancewithANSI/AWWAStandardC60289,andsubsequentlydisinfected
accordingtoANSI/AWWAC65192.Thetestwaterwasstandardfaucetwaterfroma
New
Jerseyutility.Understaticconditions,arsenic,barium,cadmium,andchromiumleached
from
theliningtomaximumvaluesroughly1020%oftheirrespectivedrinkingwaterMCLs.
Further,theacidsolublecontentsofarsenic,barium,cadmium,andchromiuminthe
cement
coatingappliedwereonly3,1.9,13,and6.6percentofthecementindustrymaximum,
respectively.Therefore,theextentofleachingcouldhavebeenhigherifanalternate
cement
lininghadbeenapplied.Additionalresearchisnecessarytounderstandthefateofheavy
metals
associatedwithcementleaching,andthedegreeofaccumulationwithindistribution
systems.
AccordingtoBerendandTrouwborst(1999),theapplicationofcementmortarliningcan
also
leadtoaluminumleaching.Thealuminumcontentincementmortarliningsvaries,as
shownin
Table9.Oneofthepredominantcrystallinephasesincementistricalciumaluminate,
whichis
believedtodissolveaccordingtothefollowingreaction:
(3)Ca3Al2O6+6H2O3Ca2++2Al3++12OH

Optimisation of industrial wastes reuse as construction


materials.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=12201684
Thisstudyconcernsthereuseoftwoinorganicwastes,foundryresiduesandflyashes
frommunicipalsolidwasteincineration,as"recycledaggregate"inconcreteproduction.

Leaching and primary biodegradation of sulfonated


naphthalenes and their formaldehyde condensates from
concrete superplasticizers in groundwater affected by
tunnel construction.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=12188355

Sulfonatednaphthalenesandtheirformaldehydecondensates(SNFC)areusedas
concretesuperplasticizersfortunnelconstructionthroughaquifers.Thispaperdiscusses
theirprimarybiodegradationingroundwateraffectedbyconstructionactivities.The
analysesofgroundwatersamplescollected5mawayfromaconstructionsiteclearly
indicatedthatcomponentsoftheappliedSNFCproductleachedintothegroundwater.A
maximumtotalconcentrationofthesecompoundsof233microg/Lwasfound,anditwas
shownthatonlythemonomericsulfonatednaphthalenesandthecondensates
uptothetetramerleachedinsubstantialamounts.Thedecreaseinconcentrationofseveral
monomericcomponentscouldnotbeexplainedbymeredispersionbutratherindicatesa
biologicaltransformationintheaquifer.Thiswasconfirmedatasecondfieldsiteandby
laboratorydegradationexperimentswithpiezometermaterialasinoculum.Lagphasesfor
theindividuallydegradablesulfonatednaphthalenesrangedfrom0to96d.Naphthalene
1,5disulfonateandtheoligomericcomponentswereneitherdegradedintheaquifernor
inthelaboratoryexperimentswithinanobservationtimeofupto195d.Thisclearly
indicatestheirpersistenceinsubsurfacewaters.

Characterization of the leaching behaviour of concrete mortars


and of cement-stabilized wastes with different waste loading
for long term environmental assessment.
vanderSlootHA.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=12003146
ECNSoilandWasteResearch,Petten,TheNetherlands.vandersloot@ecn.nl
Theleachingbehaviourofcementbasedproductsbothconstructionproductsand
cementstabilizedwasteshavebeenshowntobesimilarafterassessingtheleaching
characteristicsbymeansofapHdependenceleachingtest.Thisprocedureisparticularly
suitedtoidentifyingthechemicalspeciationofmaterials.Geochemicalmodellinghas
shownanumberofsolubilitycontrollingphasesinthislargelyinorganicmatrix,thatcan
verywellexplaintheobservedleachingpatternsasafunctionofpH.Understandingthese
relationshipsallowsthepredictionofleachingbehaviourunderotherexposureconditions
andtoimprovetheultimatequalityofproducts,ifsodesired.Theroleofettringitetype
phasesforthebindingofoxyanionsinthepHrangeabovepH12hasbeenidentified
beforeandconfirmedinthiswork.Theorderofincorporationfollowsfromtheratio
betweenthemaximumleachabilityatmildlyalkalinepHandathighpH.Increasedlevels
ofsulfatenegativelyinfluencethebindingofoxyanionsincementstabilizedwaste
throughsitecompetition.

Bacteria
Safe water supply without disinfection in a large city case
study: Berlin.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=11225280
[ArticleinEnglish,German,Russian]
GrohmannA,PetersohnD.
Umweltbundesamt,AbteilungTrinkwaserhygiene,Correnspiatz1,14195Berlin,
Dahlem.
Berlin'swatersuppliesoriginateexclusivelyfromgroundwater.Forsustainablewater
management,riverwateristreatedbyflocculationandfiltrationandusedeitherfor
artificialgroundwaterrecharge(riversSpreeandHavel)orforbankfiltration
(NordgrabenandLakeTegel).DrinkingwaterchlorinationwasabandonedinBerlin
(West)in1978,andinBerlin(East)in1992,followingGermanunification.Chlorine
consumptionforthepurposeofweeklyperformancechecksinthechlorinationplantsof
Berlin's11waterworksandoccasionalchlorinationwithinthepipesystemfollowingpipe
bursteventsamountsto2500kgperyear.Basedontheannualwaterdemandof250
millioncubicmetres,thisisequivalentto0.01mgofchlorineperlitre.Microbiological
monitoringatthe11waterworksandat383samplingpointswithinthepipesystem
showsCFUatlessthan10/1ml1andcoliformsandE.coliinvariablyat0/100ml1.In
viewofthelowAOXcontent,amultiplicationofbacteriawithinthepipesystemcanbe
expectedtooccurnotatalloronlytoasmallextent.Resourceprotectionmeasures,filter
backwashingandpipesystemmaintenanceinobservanceoftherelevanttechnicalrules
willcontinuetoensurethatthequalityofBerlin'sdrinkingwatermeetsstringenthygiene
requirementswithoutchlorination.

Water quality problems associated with intermittent water


supply.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=12639034
TokajianS,HashwaF.
LebaneseAmericanUniversity,Byblos,Lebanon.
AcontrolledstudywasconductedinLebanonoveraperiodof12monthstodetermine
bacterialregrowthinasmallnetworksupplyingtheBeirutsuburbofNaccachethathada
populationofabout3,000.Theresidentialarea,whichisfedbygravity,issuppliedtwice
aweekwithchlorinatedwaterfromtwoartesianwellsofaconfinedaquifer.A
significantcorrelationwasdetectedbetweentheturbidityandthelevelsofheterotrophic
platecountbacteria(HPC)inthesamplesfromthedistributionnetworkaswellasfrom

theartesianwells.However,anegativesignificantcorrelationwasfoundbetweenthe
temperatureandtheHPCcountinthesamplescollectedfromthesource.Astatistically
significantincreaseincounts,possiblyduetoregrowth,wasrepeatedlyestablished
betweentwosamplingpointslyingonastraightdistributionlinebut1kmapart.Faecal
coliformsweredetectedinthesourcewaterbutnoneinthenetworkexceptduringapipe
breakageincidentwithconfirmedEscherichiacolireaching40CFU/100mL.However,
coliformssuchasCitrobacterfreundii,Enterobacteragglomerans,E.cloacaeandE.
skazakiiwererepeatedlyisolatedfromthenetwork,mainlyduetoinadequate
chlorination.Asecondcontrolledstudywasconductedtodeterminetheeffectofstorage
onthemicrobialqualityofhouseholdstoragetanks(500L),whichwereoftwomain
typesgalvanizedcastironandblackpolyethylene.Themeanbacterialcountincreased
significantlyafter7dstorageinbothtanktypes.Asignificantdifferencewasfoundinthe
meanHPC/mLbetweenthewinterandthesummer.HighestcountswerefoundApril
Junealthoughthemaximumtemperaturewasreportedlaterinthesummer.Apositive
correlationwasestablishedbetweentheHPC/mLandpH,temperatureandstoragetime.

Septic System Density and Infectious Diarrhea in a Defined


Population of Children
http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/docs/2003/5914/abstract.html
Septicsystemdensitieswereassociatedwithendemicdiarrhealillnessincentral
Wisconsin.Theassociationshouldbeinvestigatedinotherregions,andstandardsfor
septicsystemsshouldbeevaluatedtoensurethatthepublichealthisprotected

Safe water treatment and storage in the home. A practical new


strategy to prevent waterborne disease.
MintzED,ReiffFM,TauxeRV.
FoodborneandDiarrhealDiseasesBranch,CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention,
Atlanta,GA30333.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=7884954Inmanypartsofthe
developingworld,drinkingwateriscollectedfromunsafesurfacesourcesoutsidethe
homeandisthenheldinhouseholdstoragevessels.Drinkingwatermaybecontaminated
atthesourceorduringstorage;strategiestoreducewaterbornediseasetransmissionmust
safeguardagainstbothevents.Wedescribeatwocomponentpreventionstrategy,which
allowsanindividualtodisinfectdrinkingwaterimmediatelyaftercollection(pointofuse
disinfection)andthentostorethewaterinnarrowmouthed,closedvesselsdesignedto
preventrecontamination(safestorage).Newdisinfectantgeneratorsandbetterstorage
vesseldesignsmakethisstrategypracticalandinexpensive.Thisapproachempowers
householdsandcommunitiesthatlackpotablewatertoprotectthemselvesagainsta
varietyofwaterbornepathogensandhasthepotentialtodecreasetheincidenceof
waterbornediarrhealdisease.

Do U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Water Quality


Guidelines for Recreational Waters Prevent Gastrointestinal
Illness? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/members/2003/6241/6241.html
TimothyJ.Wade,1NitikaPai,2JosephN.S.Eisenberg,2andJohnM.Colford,Jr.2
1EpidemiologyandBiomarkersBranch,U.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency,
ResearchTrianglePark,NorthCarolina,USA;2SchoolofPublicHealth,Divisionof
Epidemiology,UniversityofCalifornia,Berkeley,California,USA
Conclusions
Ourreviewsuggeststhatenterococciand,toalesserextent,E.coliareadequate
indicatorsofGIillnessinmarinewater,butfecalcoliformsarenot.Therewasevidence
thatriskofGIillnesswasconsiderablylowerinstudieswithindicatordensitiesbelowthe
guidelinesproposedbyU.S.EPAforbothenterococciandE.coli,providingsupportfor
useofthesevaluesforregulatorypurposes.Infreshwater,E.coliwasamorereliable
andconsistentpredictorofGIillnessthanisenterococci.

Microbiological contamination of drinking water in a commercial


household water filter system.
DaschnerFD,RudenH,SimonR,ClottenJ.
InstituteofEnvironmentalMedicine,Freiburg,Germany.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=8740859
Themicrobiologicalqualityoffilteredwaterinacommercialwaterfiltersystem(Brita)
wastestedinhouseholdsandintwolaboratories.In24of34filtersusedinhouseholds,
bacterialcountsincreasedinthefilteredwaterupto6,000cfu/ml.In4of6filterstested
inthelaboratory,bacterialcountsinthefreshfiltratewerehigherthanintapwaterafter
approximatelyoneweekofusebothatroomtemperatureandat4degreesC,suggesting
growthorbiofilmformationinthefiltermaterial.Insomecasescolonycountsinthe
filteredwaterwere10,000timesthoseintapwater.Thefiltermaterialof5of13new
commercialfilterswascontaminatedwithbacteriaormoulds.Nationalorinternational
regulatoryagenciesshouldensurethatwaterfiltersmarketedfordomesticusedonot
allowdeteriorationinthemicrobiologicalqualityofdrinkingwater.

Household drinking water in developing countries: a systematic


review of microbiological contamination between source
and point-of-use.
WrightJ,GundryS,ConroyR.
WaterandEnvironmentalManagementResearchCentre,UniversityofBristol,Bristol,
UK.james.wright@bristol.ac.uk
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=14728614

OBJECTIVE:Toassesstheextentandcausesofmicrobiologicalcontaminationof
householddrinkingwaterbetweensourceandpointofuseindevelopingcountries.
METHODS:Asystematicmetaanalysisof57studiesmeasuringbacteriacountsfor
sourcewaterandstoredwaterinthehometoassesshowcontaminationvariedbetween
settings.RESULTS:Thebacteriologicalqualityofdrinkingwatersignificantlydeclines
aftercollectioninmanysettings.Theextentofcontaminationafterwatercollection
variesconsiderablybetweensettings,butisproportionatelygreaterwherefaecalandtotal
coliformcountsinsourcewaterarelow.CONCLUSIONS:Policiesthataimtoimprove
waterqualitythroughsourceimprovementsmaybecompromisedbypostcollection
contamination.Saferhouseholdwaterstorageandtreatmentisrecommendedtoprevent
this,togetherwithpointofusewaterqualitymonitoring.

Can water go bad?


http://science.howstuffworks.com/question201.htm
Manypeoplestorewaterforemergencieslikehurricanesandpowerfailures.Thisis
especiallytrueinruralareaswheredrinkingwatercomesfromprivatewells.Thesewells
areuselessunlessthereispowertorunthepump.Ifyouaretryingtostorewatersafely,
today'squestionisagreatone!
Itturnsoutthattherearetwowaysforwatertogobad.Youcaneasilydemonstratethe
firstwaybyfillingabucketwithtapwaterandleavingitonthebackporchforseveral
days.Afteraboutaweek,youwillfindthatthewaterinthebucketcontainsmosquito
larvae,algaeandvariousotherlifeforms,noneofwhichyouwouldwanttobedrinking.
Fromthisexperiment,youcaneasilydecidethatstoringwaterinanopencontainerisa
badideaunlessyouhaveaplantopurifyitwhenyouneedtodrinkit.Storingwaterina
closedcontainerworksnobetterifthewaterthatyouplaceinthecontaineris
contaminatedinsomewaywithbacteriaoralgae.Youneedtoputpurewaterinaclean
containerandthenprocessitinsomewaytoeliminatebacterialcontamination.Youcan
processthewaterwithheatjustlikeyoudowhencanning,oruseachemicallikechlorine
oriodine.
Thesecondwayforwatertobecomeunfitfordrinkingisforsomethingtoleachoutof
thecontainerintothewater.Asanextremeexample,imaginewhatwouldhappenifyou
weretostorewaterinaleadcontainer.Leadwouldleachintothewaterandmakeit
poisonous.Thecontaineryouuseneedstobemadefromafoodgradematerialinorderto
avoidleachingproblems.Glass,stainlesssteelandsomeplasticsarefoodgrade.
Oneeasywaytostorewateristobuydistilledwateringallonplasticjugsatthegrocery
store.Thiswaterisinexpensive,freeofbacterialcontaminationandissealedinafood
gradecontainer.Youcanstorethiswaterindefinitely.
Inthelongrun...
Severalalertreaderspointedoutthatplasticmilkjugsmightnotbetheverybest
containerforlongtermstoragebecausetheydegradeandtendtoleakafterayearortwo.
Mostofthesereadersrecommendplasticsodabottlesorlarge5galloncontainers
specificallyintendedforwaterstorage.

Expiration dates on bottled water


http://www.loper.org/~george/trends/2004/Feb/977.html
"It'sroughenoughthatthemillionsofAmericanswhobuybottledwaterarepayingfor
somethingthatusedtobasicallybefree.Butevenhardertostomachisthemessagethat
comesonthebottle:Likemilkandeggs,waternow"expires."
Mostcommerciallyproducedwatercomesstampedwithexpirationdatestypically
withintwoyearsofwhenitwasbottled.OnmostPolandSpringbottlestherearetiny,
whitelettersadvisingconsumerstodrinkupwithintwoyears.MostAquafinabottles
sporttwoyearexpirationwarningsontheircaps.Ingeneral,thedatesonbottledwater
includetheprefix"EXP,"meaning"expires."Fijibrandwaterhasaslightlydifferent
approach:Itsbottlessay"Bestby"followedbythedate.CocaColaInc.putsaoneyear
expirationdateonitsDasanibrandwater.
ThemessagethatwaterhasashelflifehasbeenfurtheramplifiedinthewakeofSept.11.
TheU.S.DepartmentofHomelandSecurityurgespeopletostockpilebottledwaterin
theirdisasterpreparednesskits.OnitsWebsite(www.ready.gov),itinstructspeopleto
changetheirbottledwatereverysixmonths.
TheAmericanRedCrossalsoadvisespeopleviaitsWebsitetoreplacetheirstored
bottledwatereverysixmonths.Butwhencontacted,theorganization'smanagerof
disastereducation,RockyLopes,sayspeopleshouldreplacetheirbottledwaterbeforeits
expirationdate."Thewatershouldbereplacedifthemanufacturerdeterminesthereisa
reasonforit,"hesays.
Butdoeswaterreallyspoil?Despitethelabelsremindingconsumerstodrinkup,thereis
virtuallynoevidencethatdrinkingwaterbeyondtheexpirationdatehasanyhealth
impactatall.TheFoodandDrugAdministrationconsidersbottledwatertohavean
"indefiniteshelflife."Eventhebottledwaterindustryishardpressedtojustifythelabels.
"There'snorealrationale,"saysJaneLazgin,aspokeswomanforNestleWatersNorth
AmericaInc.,whichbottlesbrandsincludingPolandSpringandIceMountain,and
importsEuropeanwaterssuchasPerrierandVittel.Thepractice"isnothealthbased,"
sheadds.

[Bacterial regrowth in drinking water. I. The upgrading of


drinking water]
[ArticleinGerman]
JaeggiNE,SchmidtLorenzW.
LaboratoriumfurLebensmittelMikrobiologie,Eidg.TechnischeHochschule(ETH)
Zurich.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=3140535
Sevendeadendwaterpipeswereinstalledaftereachtreatmentstepinadrinkingwater
plant.Duringaperiodof7weeksthebacterialloadoffreshwaterandstagnatingwater
wasinvestigatedwithdifferentmethods.Amodifiedsurfacespreadplatecount(Plate
CountAgar,10folddiluted,14daysincubationat20degreesC)provedtobemore
effectivethanthetraditionalpourplatemethod,becauseitgaveconsistentlyhigher

colonycountsandhadalowerlevelofdetection(0.001CFUml1).Theenumeratingof
electrontransportsystempositivebacteriayieldedhighernumbersthanthecolonycount
methods,butisnotrecommendedwhenrecentlyoxidizedwatersamplesaretobe
investigated.Highestcellcountswereattainedwhenusingepifluorescencemicroscopic
counting,yetbacterialregrowthcouldnotbemonitoredthus.Thetendencyofbacterial
regrowthwashighestinfreshlyozonizedwater.Instagnatinglakewaternoregrowth
occurredafter1and3weeksbecauseofthebalanceofbacteriaandtheirpredators.

Microbiological quality of drinking water and using water of a


Chao Phya River community, Bangkok.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=7667704LuksamijarulkulP,
PumsuwanV,PungchittonS.
DepartmentofMicrobiology,FacultyofPublicHealth,MahidolUniversity,Bangkok,
Thailand.
Safewaterisessentialforgoodhealthofhumans.Thecontaminationofwaterwith
infectedfecalmaterialiscommoninareaswithpoorstandardsofhygieneandsanitation.
Thedeterminationofmicrobiologicalqualityofwaterisessential.Simpleroutinetesting
ofthebacteriologicalqualityofdrinkingwaterisdesignedtodetectthepresenceof
coliformbacteriaandvirologicalassessmentistodetectthepresenceofentericviruses,
especiallyhepatitisAvirus(HAV).Therefore,thisstudyattemptedtodeterminethe
HAVandcoliformbacteriacontaminationindrinkingwaterandusingwaterofaChao
PhyaRivercommunity,Bangkokwherecrowdedlivingconditionsincreasetheriskof
waterrelateddiseases.95samplesofdrinkingwaterand75samplesofusedwaterin
containerswerecollectedwithsteriletechniquefordeterminingHAVantigenbyELISA
andcoliformcontaminationbytheMostProbableNumberTechnique(MPN).Theresults
revealedthatHAVandcoliformcontaminationratesofdrinkingwaterwere25.26%and
64.21%,respectively.Therainwaterhadthehighestcontamination(60.00%and
80.00%).Tapwaterwas23.73%forHAV(14/59samples)and64.41%forcoliforms
(38/59samples)whereasrunningwaterhadtheleastcontamination(2.94%forHAVand
5.88%forcoliforms).Thecontaminationratesofusedwaterwere10.69%forHAVand
68.67%forcoliforms.

The effect of container-biofilm on the microbiological quality of


water used from plastic household containers.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=15384720
JagalsP,JagalsC,BokakoTC.
WaterandHealthResearch,TechnikonWitwatersrand,POBox17011,Doornfontein,
2025,SouthAfrica.jagals@twr.ac.za
StudiesinSouthernAfricahaveshownthatevenwhenmicrobiologicallysafewateris
suppliedtodevelopingcommunitiesatcommunalstandpipes,contaminationbyhigh
numbersofpathogenicmicroorganismsmayoccurduringtheprocessesoffetchingwater

fromthesupplysourceandstorageduringuseathome,renderingsuchwatersunsafefor
humanconsumption.ThisstudyinvestigatedtheoccurrenceofbiofilminPVCstorage
containersasonepossiblereasonforthisdeterioration,usingheterotrophicbacteriaand
totalcoliformcountsaswellasturbidityasindicators.Asecondobjectivewasto
determinewhetherbiofilminwaterstoragecontainerscouldcontributetohazardous
microbiologicalcontaminationindicatedbyEscherichiacoliandClostridiumperfringens.
Resultsindicatedthatincreasedmicrobiologicalcontaminationisassociatedwithbiofilm.
Thebiofilmharboursheterotrophicbacteria,totalcoliformsandC.perfringens.E.coli
couldnotbeassociateddirectlywiththelevelsofbiofilmincontainersbutratherappears
tobeintroducedintermittentlyfromtheambientdomesticenvironment.Whendislodged
withthebiofilm,thesebacteriacontributedsubstantiallytothedeteriorationofthe
microbiologicalqualityofsuppliedwaterstoredinplasticcontainers.

[Bacterial regrowth in drinking water. II. Drinking water


distribution systems]
[ArticleinGerman]
JaeggiNE,SchmidtLorenzW.
InstitutfurLebensmittelwissenschaftEidg.TechnischeHochschule(ETH)Zurich.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=3142166
Fivechromiumsteeldeadendwaterpipeswereinstalledoveradistanceof12kmalong
theZurichcitydrinkingwaterdistributionsystem.Cellcountsweredeterminedintwo
seriesoffoursamplingsinfreshwaterandstagnatingwaterusingthreedifferent
methods.Thecolonycountsofoligocarbontolerantbacteria(1:10dilutedplatecount
agar,20degreesC,14d)inthefreshwaterwasincreasingalongthedistributionline.
Initiallytherewerecountsaround1CFUml1andafter12kmbetween120and1100
CFUml1.Watertakenfromhousetabsshowedhighercolonycountsthanwatertaken
afterreservoirs.Afterastagnatingtimeof14dall40watersamplesshowedaftergrowth
from10(3)upto10(4)CFUml1.Waterfromthetwosamplinglocationswiththe
longestdistancefromthetreatmentplantshowedlessregrowthtendency.
EpifluorescencemicroscopyandtheINTmethodfordeterminingtheelectrontransport
systempositivebacteria(ETS+)werelessusefulformonitoringbacterialregrowth.
However,inthestagnatingwaterthereoccurredasignificantlyhigherpercentageof
ETS+unitsascomparedtothecolonyformingunits(CFU)withgrowingdistancefrom
thetreatmentplant.
BOTTLEDWATERCONTAMINATION:ANOVERVIEWOFNRDC'SAND
OTHERS'SURVEYS
http://www.nrdc.org/water/drinking/bw/chap3.asp

Bacterial Growth in Two Bottled Waters

QuickTime and a
TIFF (LZW) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.

Behavior of enteroaggregative Escherichia coli in bottled spring


and mineral water.
VasudevanP,AnnamalaiT,SartoriL,HoaglandT,VenkitanarayananK.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=12636308
DepartmentofAnimalScience,Unit40,UniversityofConnecticut,3636HorsebarnHill
RoadExtension,Storrs,Connecticut06269,USA.
TheabilityofenteroaggregativeEscherichiacoli(EAEC)tosurviveinbottledmineral
andspringwateratcommonstoragetemperatureswasinvestigated.Filteredmineraland
springwaterswereinoculatedwithEAEC(ca.10(4)CFU/ml)andstoredat4,10,and23
degreesC.Watersampleswereanalyzedevery3daysforviableEAECbyplatingon
trypticsoyagarplatesover60daysofstorage.EAECsurvivedforthedurationofthe
studyinbothmineralandspringwaters.EAECsurvivallevelsweresignificantlyhigher
(P<0.01)at23and10degreesCthanat4degreesC.Furthermore,EAECsurvivallevels
weresignificantlyhigher(P<0.01)inmineralwaterthaninspringwaterat4and10
degreesC.TheresultsofthisstudyindicatethatEAECcansurviveinbottledmineraland
springwatersforlongperiodsofstorageat4,10,and23degreesC.TheabilityofEAEC
tosurviveinbottledwaterindicatesthatthesourcewaterforbottlingindustriesmustbe
keptfreeofcontamination.Furthermore,therefrigerationofbottledwateris
recommendedtominimizethegrowthofEAECinwater.

A Randomized, Blinded, Controlled Trial Investigating the


Gastrointestinal Health Effects of Drinking Water Quality
http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/docs/2001/109p773778hellard/abstract.html
MargaretE.Hellard,MarthaI.Sinclair,AndrewB.Forbes,andChristopherK.Fairley

DepartmentofEpidemiologyandPreventiveMedicine,FacultyofMedicine,Monash
University,Melbourne,Victoria,Australia
Abstract
Adoubleblinded,randomized,controlledtrialwascarriedoutininMelbourne,
Australia,todeterminethecontributionofdrinkingwatertogastroenteritis.Melbourneis
oneofthefewmajorcitiesintheworldthatdrawsdrinkingwaterfromaprotectedforest
catchmentwithminimalwatertreatment(chlorinationonly).Sixhundredfamilieswere
randomlyallocatedtoreceiveeitherrealorshamwatertreatmentunits(WTUs)installed
intheirkitchen.Realunitsweredesignedtoremoveviruses,bacteria,andprotozoa.
Studyparticipantscompletedaweeklyhealthdiaryreportinggastrointestinalsymptoms
duringthe68weekobservationperiod.Therewere2,669casesofhighlycredible
gastroenteritis(HCG)duringthestudy(0.80cases/person/year).TheratioofHCG
episoderatesfortherealWTUgroupcomparedtotheshamWTUgroupwas0.99(95%
confidenceinterval,0.851.15,p=0.85).Wecollected795fecalspecimensfrom
participantswithgastroenteritis,andpathogenswerenotmoresignificantlycommonin
theshamWTUgroup.WefoundnoevidenceofwaterbornediseaseinMelbourne.The
applicationofthismethodologytootherwatersupplieswillprovideabetter
understandingoftherelationshipbetweenhumanhealthandwaterquality.Keywords:
doubleblindrandomizedtrails,drinkingwaterquality,gastroenteritis,waterborne
disease.EnvironHealthPerspect109:773778(2001).[Online1August2001]

Disinfection byproducts
Trihalomethanes
http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/docs/2003/1117/ss.html#shor
Theresearchersexaminednumerouspotentialconfounders,includingsmoking,alcohol
andcaffeineconsumption,pregnancyhistory,bodymassindex,age,race,education,
income,andemployment.TheyfoundverylittleevidenceforconfoundingofTTHM
effectsonmeancyclelength.Only3%oftheparticipantshadaverageTTHM
concentrationsabovetheU.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency'sannualmaximum
contaminantlevelof80microgramsperliter(g/L).Forthisstudy,highexposurewas
definedas60g/Lorhigherperday.
http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/docs/2004/6779/abstract.html

Chemistry of mutagenic by-products of water chlorination.


http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=2665075

Mutagenic activity and presence of the strong mutagen 3-chloro4-(dichloromethyl)-5-hydroxy-2-(5H)-furanone (MX) in


chlorinated raw and drinking waters in The Netherlands.
BacklundP,WondergemE,VoogdK,deJongA.

DepartmentofOrganicChemistry,AboAkademi,Turku,Finland.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=2672329
ChlorinatedsurfaceanddrinkingwatersinTheNetherlandswereanalysedformutagenic
activity(Amestest)andthestrongmutagen3chloro4(dichloromethyl)5hydroxy
2(5H)furanone(MX).MutagenicactivityandMXwereformedduringchlorine
treatmentofrawsurfacewatersandpurifiedsurfacewater.Mutagenicitywasalsopresent
infinisheddrinkingwaterswhichhadbeensubjectedtopostchlorination,butnoMX
couldbedetected.Itisproposedthatthemutagensresponsibleformostoftheactivityare
acidiccompoundsastheyweremainlyextractableunderacidicconditions.The
precursorstothemutageniccompoundsformedduringpostchlorinationofdrinking
waterwereefficientlyremovedbyuseofozonation/activatedcarbonfiltration.Onthe
otherhand,coagulation(Fe(III]inthepresenceofactivatedcarbonpowderseemedto
havehardlyanyeffectonthemutagenprecursors.Thecalculatedmutagenicity
contributionfromMXtotheobservedTA100activityinthewatersstudiedwaslessthan
20%.

Drugs in drinking water


http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/docs/2000/10810/forum.html#water

Water age
750,000*
800,000

Milesof
WaterMains
1,100
2,750

87,900*

358

>16

24,000

86

1224

PopulationServed

RangeofWaterAges
withinSystem(Days)
<13
37+

Methodof
Determination
FluorideTracer
HydraulicModel
Chloramine
Conversion
HydraulicModel

Runoff Quality
The influence of urban density and drainage infrastructure on
the concentrations and loads of pollutants in small streams.
HattBE,FletcherTD,WalshCJ,TaylorSL.
CooperativeResearchCentreforFreshwaterEcology,WaterStudiesCentre,Monash
University,Victoria3800,Australia.Belinda.Hatt@eng.monash.edu.au
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?
cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=15383877Effectivewaterquality
managementofstreamsinurbanizedbasinsrequiresidentificationoftheelementsof
urbanizationthatcontributemosttopollutantconcentrationsandloads.Drainage
connection(theproportionofimperviousareadirectlyconnectedtostreamsbypipesor
lineddrains)isproposedasavariableexplainingvarianceinthegenerallyweak
relationshipsbetweenpollutantconcentrationsandimperviousness.Fifteensmallstreams
drainingindependentsubbasinseastofMelbourne,Australia,weresampledforasuiteof
waterqualityvariables.Geometricmeanconcentrationsofallvariableswerecalculated
separatelyforbaseflowandstormevents,andthese,togetherwithestimatesofrunoff
derivedfromarainfallrunoffmodel,wereusedtoestimatemeanannualloads.Patterns
ofconcentrationsamongthestreamswereassessedagainstpatternsofimperviousness,
drainageconnection,unsealed(unpaved)roaddensity,elevation,longitude(allofwhich
wereintercorrelated),septictankdensity,andbasinarea.Baseflowandstormevent
concentrationsofdissolvedorganiccarbon(DOC),filterablereactivephosphorus(FRP),
totalphosphorus(TP)andammonium,alongwithelectricalconductivity(EC),all
increasedwithimperviousnessanditscorrelates.Hierarchicalpartitioningshowedthat

DOC,EC,FRP,andstormeventTPwereindependentlycorrelatedwithdrainage
connectionmorestronglythancouldbeexplainedbychance.NeitherpHnortotal
suspendedsolidsconcentrationswerestronglycorrelatedwithanybasinvariable.
Oxidizedandtotalnitrogenconcentrationsweremoststronglyexplainedbyseptictank
density.Loadsofallvariableswerestronglycorrelatedwithimperviousnessand
connection.Priorityshouldbegiventolowimpacturbandesign,whichprimarily
involvesreducingdrainageconnection,tominimizeurbanizationrelatedpollutant
impactsonstreams.

Tank materials for aquaculture


http://www.teamaged.org/aquaculture/ctanks.htm
glassoracrylicplasticUsedtoconstructaquaria.Whileaquariaareunderrated,these
areanexcellentoptionforteacherswithorwithoutabudget(everyonehasoneintheir
attic,garage,orcellar)oralotofclassspace(canprovidestudentswithindividualized
learningandentrepreneurialopportunities).
fiberglassTanksareeasytobuild,modifyandrepair;prefabricatedtankscanbe
purchasedinalargerangeofsizesandshapes;canbeexpensive.
treatedplywood,cementblocksorgalvanizedsteelTanksareeasytoconstructandcan
beacheapalternative;coverwithanontoxiclinermaterial(donotuselinerstreated
withfungicidee.g.,poolliners)orpaintwithwaterproofepoxypaint.
epoxycoatedsteelExpensive.
pouredcement(e.g.casketliners,oldseptictanks)Potentialtofindsomegoodbargains,
buttoughtomove.
polytanksConsideredshorttermtanks;good(fairlycheap)forclassroomaquaculture.
stainlesssteel(e.g.unusedmilkbulktankorcheesevat)Expensive.
porcelainbondedcarbonsteel(e.g.discardedsilorings)Niceifavailableforfree.
Q:Howdoesleadgetintodrinkingwater?
A:Leadisn'tinwaterthatleavesourtreatmentplants.However,itmightoccurinyour
home'splumbing.Leadlevelsinyourdrinkingwaterarelikelytobehigherif:

Yourhomehasfaucetsorfittingsmadeofbrassthatcontainsomelead;

Yourhomeorwatersystemhasleadpipes;

Yourhomehascopperpipesandthehousewasbuiltfrom198287.
Ifyourinteriorplumbingfitsoneofthesecategories,youhaveanincreasedriskifyou
haveawatersoftenerorwateroftensitsinpipesforseveralhours.

Q:Whatarelead'shealtheffects?
A:Leadisatoxicmetalthatisharmfultohumanhealthifinhaledorswallowed.Itisa
healthconcernindrinkingwateratlevelsabove15partsinabillion.(Onepartperbillion
isequivalenttoasingledropofwaterin55,000gallons.)Althoughitmustbuildupinthe
bodybeforeitaffectsone'shealth,elevatedlevelsattackthebrain,kidneys,nervous
systemandredbloodcells.Thedegreeofharmdependsuponthelevelofexposurefrom
allsources,includingsoil,windandwater.Effectsrangefromsubtlephysicalchangesat
lowlevelstosevereneurologicalandtoxiceffectsorevendeathatextremelyhighlevels.

Water Purification Methods


*
Boiling
Mostwatercanbepurifiedfordrinkingpurposesbyboilingitfor10minutes.Thiswill
destroythebacteria.Inordertoimprovethetasteitwillbenecessarytoaerateitafter
boiling.Thisisaccomplishedbypouringitfromonecontainertoanotherseveraltimes.
Thisshouldbedoneafterthewaterhasbeenallowedtocool.
*
Chlorination
Forlongtermstorage,watershouldbesterilizedordisinfected.Waterstoredin
thoroughlycleanedplasticorglasscontainerscanbechemicallydisinfectedforlongterm
storagebytreatingeachgallonwithsixteendropsofliquidchlorinebleach(Cloroxor
Purextypebleaches,containing4%to6%sodiumhypochlorite).Oneteaspoonofbleach
disinfectsfivegallonsofwater.Thisleveloftreatmentwillpreventgrowthof
microorganismsduringstorage.Afteraddingtheproperdosageandstirring,allowthe
watertostandfor30minutes.Itshouldthenhaveadistinctodorofchlorine.Ifthisodor
isnotpresent,addanotherdoseofthesolutionandletstandforanother15minutes.The
tasteorsmellorchlorineinwaterastreatedinthismannerisasignofsafety.Itisnot
harmful.Onthecontrary,ifyoucannotdetectchlorineinwateryouaretryingtopurify
bythismethod,donotdrinkit.
*
PurificationTablets
Tabletsthatreleaseiodinemaybeusedsafelytopurifydrinkingwater.Thesetabletscan
befoundatmostdrugstoresandsportinggoodsstores.Thenamesvarybutitis
genericallyknownashalazonetablets.Followthedirectionsonthepackage.Usuallyone
tabletissufficientforonequartofwater.Thedosageisdoubledforcloudywater.
*
Iodine
OrdinaryHouseholdIodinemaybeusedtopurifysmallquantitiesofwater.Add23
dropsofTinctureOfIodinetoeachquartofclearwater(810forcloudywater).Mix&
allowtostandfor30minutes.
Thispagecreatedby:
peter@coolpages.net
http://coolpages.net/2000/

Emergency Water storage


http://www.storablefoods.com/water_storage.html
NOTE:Theeasiestwaytostorethebulkofyourwaterisin55gallonpolyethylene
(plastic)waterdrums(FDAapprovedforstoringdrinkingwater).Yousimplyfillthe
drumsupwithyourowntapwater.Thedrumsofferedby21stCenturyFoodStorageare
thebestindustryhastooffer,andaredesignedtohaveweightstackedonthemwhen
filledwithwater,thisallowsyoutostackyourfoodontopofthemandsavespacewhile
keepingyourfoodandwatertogether.Werecommendtwo55gallondrumsofwaterper
person,thisalongwithcollecting"rain"watershouldbesuitable.Beforefillingadrum
withwater,makesuretheNPTplug(finethread;nonwhitecap)isnotpositionednextto
awalletc.Itshouldbeonthetopfrontsideofthedrumforeasyaccess,becausethisis
thebungholethatthedrumpumpsthreadinto.
Rememberalsothatyouhaveseveralsourcesofwateralreadyinyourhomethatcanbe
tappedinanemergencysuchasyourhotwaterheater,toilettanks(don'tusewaterfrom
atankthatcontainscoloreddisinfectant,itispoisonous),waterpipes,iceinthefreezer,
etc.Waterisrelativelyinexpensivetostoreandcertainlynotdifficulttodobutcertainly
thetimetostoreisnow.
Itisalsoagoodideatohaveawaterfilterinadditiontoyourwaterstoragedrums.This
wouldallowyoutopurifydirtywaterfromlakes,rivers,creeks,etc.21stCenturyFood
StorageoffersTheBritishBerkefeldEmergencyWater&CampingFiltertheoriginal
gravityfiltrationsystemusedbythousandsofmissionariesworldwide.Nowaterpressure
orpumpingrequired.Hightechceramicfiltersystem.Timetestedforover140years.
The"SuperSterasyl"filtersreduceupto99.99%ofparticulates,cysts,parasitesand
pathogenicbacteria.See"WaterFiltration"inouronlinestorefordetails.
DISINFECTION:
Forlongtermstorage,tapwatershouldbesterilizedordisinfectedinthoroughlycleaned
plasticorglasscontainers.Watercanbechemicallydisinfectedforlongtermstorageby
treatingeachgallonwith16dropsofliquidchlorinebleach(CloroxorPurextype
bleaches,containing4%to6%sodiumhypochlorite;donotusescentedbleach).One
teaspoonofbleachdisinfectsfivegallonsofwater.Threetablespoonswilldisinfect55
gallonsofwater.Thisleveloftreatmentwillkillbacteriaandvirusesandpreventthe
growthofmicroorganismsduringstorage.Alsocheckwithyourlocalwaterplantforany
additionalinformationtheymayhaveforyou.
Waterstoredinplasticcontainersshouldnotbestoredneargasoline,kerosene,pesticides
orsimilarsubstances.Vaporsfromthesesubstancescouldpermeatetheplasticandaffect
thewater.Thickwalledpolyethylenecontainersaresignificantlylesspermeableto
vaporsthanarethinwalledcontainers.Becertain,whenselectingastoragecontainerfor
water,thatithasatightfittingcaporlidtoprevententranceofcontaminantsand
evaporationofwater.Becausesunlighthasanadverseeffectonplastic,watershouldbe
storedawayfromdirectexposuretosunlight.Storeinacool,dryareawithnosunlight,
likethebasement.
Studiesshowsterilizedordisinfectedwater,storedinclean,foodapprovedcontainers
withsecurelidsorcapsshouldbesafeforuseevenaftermanyyearsofstorage.
Replacementofstoredwaterwithfreshwatershouldbenecessaryonlyifthestoredwater

becomescontaminatedinsomewayorifthecontainershouldbegintoleak.Becertainto
labeleachcontainersotherewillbenoquestionaboutitscontents.Includethedateand
informationonthemethodofdisinfectionused.Werecommendchangingproperlystored
watereverythreetofiveyears.

Good places to seach for this type of information


http://search.epa.gov
http://www.nih.gov/
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?db=PubMed
http://stanley.niehs.nih.gov/ehp
http://www.ehso.com/ehshome/
BIOSIS (www.biosis.org)
OLDMEDLINE (http://gateway.nlm.nih.gov/gw/Cmd)
EMBASE (http://openaccess.dialog.com/med/)
UMI/ProQuest Digital Dissertation Database
(http://wwwlib.umi.com/dissertations/gateway)

You might also like